Grand Rapids morning telegram., 1885-05-09
NosAN-scosT sxaMlsATIoN
TesnH1Onf Ta<sn- Osfsnsiss fsctcs
Adlosrnsa Until This Morning.


Tie sEa1lilatsoD of Deleesiss CaarLsa l.
Moran and Poileeul.A Herman Sae5s
ckar zed Sl1h a4a1sla y ,flLef -sbooung Hll
lala hsart-<as partially eomplsled ~
F0hes Colrt yesterday. The proses,u -ion
sas eone1ets1 - Assistant Froseeutlug As
tsraeg Carrall. and ne defense Is :. u.
clay sno Is a.ssoclaf.d SlIa ~ A. Earle lu
thi- case. n. Earle ~. not gressll. 1-Ils
car oI rhs eltY- The only witness ssoFu
other thar L4o-e used before ths ooronsr's
iaFy E4s Superintendent u Police Fsrry,
sh1 sald lhaf Ca TIE eseElEg o. shicb rie
sn1olinx occurred be detailed Detectives
Moran AID Cast ~ ~ sIlh Polee COnslaDle
So1bs and arrest Heart. >eoDs haFing IN
foEnled him ihat be thought Heart eould BE-
found "a South Division street The var
rant zhlcn a. issusd several weeks before
TIE arrest va gwen ~ Detective Cast. and
the three started ogl - different goates -
meet al -he corner Of south Division street
and Wealthy asenae Later in the evening
L. b. stanton drove - headquarters and in
formed the Superintendent that q shooting
affair had occurred at the corner OF Lyon
and North Division streets. Mr.. Perm vent
- The scene and sas surprised u md Mr.
seoog there, as ns supposed no va IA
another part N the city. Tie wltness
described the seazch made for Heart
about the eh1rch and under the sidewalk
Substantially the sane a. other witnesses
When he met ScOby he asked hiul Il hs shot a.
heart and he repled that he dld, then ASKED
him him II he bit hlm and Scoby said No
1 didn' shoot At him. / ured GA the ground.
Policeman Wiley who vas ON duty 80 Gre
ems Park va present during the search, hav-
in- heard the shooting and left has beat
I Scoby said that Moran hred Ina the AR. The
Officers concluded to abandon the search al
though Scoby wanted % continue and
thought Heart might be recaptured that
night. Moran vent north On i0ula street
after the shots we're fred but returned and az
ssr the search at the church va. abandoned,
! vent south with Scoby 70 notify Cast. The
l superintendent returned 10 headquarters and
/ soon after received telephone call from
I Cast, saying that the three were together on
/ South Division street and hat"Chsrley and
/ scoby suggested that they get a rig and
/ drive out to the d. & NJ. junction. he re-
I plled that be did not think It best anu moth
M more vas done that night lie, the -u-
i perintendent, had the revolver used by SEQ
BY but had not asked for MOrn's From
has own knowledge be could not tell the ca
hbre Of the weapon.
Al the close of Mr.. Perrys testi-
mony, Mr. Carroll announced that
the prosecution dad not wish 10
offer any more evidence, unless that intro
duced by the defense made II necessary.
Mr. Clay insisted that the prosecution should
call All the witnesses expected 10 be used on
the trial, and should certainly introduce the
I ante -mOrtem statement of Heart, and all
the evidence obtainable TO show which Of
the accused fired the fatal shot Mr. Car
. roll remarked that a. be had offered evidence
enough 20 hold the respondents for trial,
he did not consider any more necessary upon
the examination. and "a to evidence Ia re
gard to the size Of the BALL ne did not con
slider II material The respondents acted
jointly aud It did not make any difference
which fired the fatal shot. II IN acting to-
gether crime was committed, both We're
equally guilty. The Judge made some re-
marks indicating that be did not entirely
agree with Mr.. Carrolls opinion. Il was
finally concluded to recall Superintendent
/ Perry, but "a ne had gone across the river il
was decided to adjourn until this morning,
when for the satisfaction of the Court, the
revolvers and the bullet will be produced by
the prosecution. II Is not probable that the
defense will offer any evidence, but Will de-
pend upon Justification by law To secure a
discharge at the close of the examination.