Daily Republican., 1885-11-25
IF I H EO|1
This AOrntng,-

ing 4 "a
Court reconvened al IN !,
Chief Justice Comepys AZ
Justices w ootten and Hon..
bench. The case of Mar
vs.. Joseph r. Tantum. :.
and George Dyson, who
stand last evening when a.
ed, was recalled and cros. !.
Mr.. Lore in reference n
bought by him, which d, |,
from Mr.. and Mrs. Valens.
amount he paid for each
William W. Pritche,t
and presented the apprais,,
ecution under which bs
tines goods in 1876.
II MRS. Mary j. Valentino
and stated that when shs
the farm there was 4O3 ~,
place, 1000 pounds Of po,I
cow, which Mr.. Dyson n,
These things were raised
her husband on the farm.
calf costing $40 and a nj,
Tantum. had bought and
place and they were LEI, M
The witness was again :,
1 ed BY Mr.. Lore, with d,
showing that she was vorl
farm under an agreement hi
her husband and DR.. Tapt1
though the question was mi
different ways, she penil
hrst statement that she ku|
Of any agreement, until Ma
put of the place.
Mr.. Bird stated that he
his case, and Mr.. Lore opsI
defense. He said that aocs
evidence produced By Il
counsel they had shown n
time Mrs. Valentine was .
she was working for and
husband, and consequent
not maintain o suit Tor "
DIR. Tantum, Ms the owner
the farm. He paid Mn,
high compliment, and said
one Of the best and mos
witnesses he had ever
stand.
He contended that the 70
to Isaac Il. Valentine, and
ssizsd, and sold, and bc
Tantum. There had no,
dence b show that til,
part Of them, had evv N!
70 Mrs. Valentine, eoUs
were not her pro- .,erty
not make any cly Am for n
concluded by moving I.
(which was i'm mediateIy n
He then commenced
argument 70 the jury, and
Tantum lad bought tss
mrs. Valentine, with the i
that they were TO pay III
(which ls had paid ior d
lhe Eould give him the d
lpaying for them on, Of
1.-The place.
| But instead Of Mr.. Vsls|
Dr. Tantum anything 70,
doctor was Obliged to speu
the farm to keep II going,
lowing 81, 036. OF for the d
Mr. Dyson, 1t still LET.
loser TO the amount Of ST.
i He commended that v
shiftless, and that the fac:
being seized and sold by
for debt, established Id
Tantun allowed them TO 4
for four years, and when
they were running him 10
them 1t must be stopped
loft the farm.
L Mr.. Lore spoke sbcu
minutes, and when be Cd
Icsd the examination o!Ni
1 DIR. J. r. Frants w
shown q paper on Wild
his signature rs q vtza
; said 1t was an agreeasSi
K. Valentine and D.
THAT he intended TO ola
This was objected to b
was answered by Mr.. La
decided that the contrsa
United and Mr.. Bird lied
i DIR. FrAntz was cross
Mr.. Bird and said thai
Was not read TO Mr., Viled
did he know II Valendts
zant of Its contents. Thai
ment for each year, ands
alike.
II DIR. j. r. Tantum tesll
tho Fall Of 1875 lsisc
asked him TO buy his 100
Iconstable's sale. be
valentine much encolfss
. day or 30 Afterwards
called on him and beg9s
1.-THE goods for them.
Il She told the witness ID
ed TO receive 1000 10
from some property WI
left her down the State,
the sale and bought 90
STATED at the sale that %
the goods for Mrs. Nalenu
to get them a. low % POS
After he had bought
! wrote to Mr.. Smithers >
tperty which Mrs. Naisa
lshe had down the couu1
writing the second Letter
answer stating that thei'
more coming TO her.
Il Mr.. Valentine then cal
mess and proposed thai
the faI m TO her, which W
Remained on the farm iOu
had the use of the goods.
Several times during
had told Mr.Valentine
pay him the amount
cost him he could have
the witness, would pocAs
All the agreement be
tfarm was with ValentlDs
never had any azreemelI,.
MRS. Valentine. Az 10y
Journed until 3 o'clocs.