Sacramento daily record-union. [volume] (Sacramento [Calif.]) 1875-1891, 1885-02-21

TO the doctrine OF eminent domain, were The
Coiistitc ion Makes, that they ssy tii.e even IL
property is damaged i IS no. s,3 be damaged
w. S'ttOu' !, (. elisa lot, Siding new provision
80 ~ ~ az 5s 1oh,,ti' Stion' ahu Fh<e e 'ferts dam
Sfs,es pi ,, nay T - SgUl;i..uea by Vsler T
feern IL siiss,el 7-Tte;,S., ,I.Ie Pof iss'si'-
sptr 10 tt,e water to,, ,,,;a, ~ ~ - y,
not be taken rr aslnaaad trr ,,,,tIi,! use with
out ,lst cornDarsation HAVING been 6rsr naid
into Court That is the Irov;Sion 7 bbnra
been Speaking of. | come now to anotber MO
vision in rasnect to water Article Wv Cantidp,,J
The use OF ali water now annronrioted o ~
may hereafter be appropriaItd tnr sale rentsI
or distribution is hereby DECLARED to ba a ,,1b
lie use and subject to the rfo1Ilation and ron
troll of the State in the rnennSr to ho ,ras-bI
by law" Now what orn tbey, talI,i,-S 1h,,,t
therep They sre toIting ahoSt - ''Do.. ~
not talking about eminent domain nv o,,, nv
thing else That section is HEADED - Vyatcr "a
water rights Thev Snci,re tb,ro 49, III ;'iiT
constitufe nuhfir uSe ana 6,,lISI,i 1'.'';
whether tbis eeyis isIot11 ro 90 sa, -h,t ~. -
else shall consfifute . 1mIiis @ 1"' ri
there in Ianm,,ase th p,,,,o+ ~ i;C3 sas
stood that the sF1se Of oil ,',.tar -,
uroted ar thar M her a. - nuM aPpi4
for sale rental or diStribntio bpt a.,
cIrreG I'm ha n,,,i ne ~ - HeicpS he
is pnbIic ,,sa sc 70 a,er .ii's 60 ,. mii,
diffarenIIv9 fson we s, fii U1ii ue''lie ~
exhe1Ista tb, S,,h;enE yyts,, iiot . the!
shall constitute - nt;ic ,s, u, l,:,ter5 .J -i'' .
It is proposod ~ mste mora IL cr3 r,,a5 Au yer
non fasd ~ dii "a a ii,0-e cata ecu ueu!
m fC Afa,, -, =
nroy,isior ~ ia Ci,t,i..i 10 ~ : li 'i'''
n ioI. y, ,bt ,.,1 IN & o
is well settIeJ i, tb S.yt Of f;i "a 's1its s1t
bo,,e 80, 49, " '. o ,[.,t ~ .44toiiLH: Nc
si,nTlv daoS.,rat ,Et uee4Slon' Mlicl Is
T. tae ri - = Si+lt tIt !;tm nls beel
ever man hnrlr. o 'm ". tie otte ott
owns the streaHn al na $50 @
nriator beIn, ~ titI7 ~ l. Nei4 pro
sbove s,lbe,t to raosnnHh - NJ NJ ION
cinlss Of tbo con,or i' .i, ii'sSe PIN, PIN
and are declared by our Courts We find no
decisions to the contrary Of coIrsa the
decision which NAV he cited il, 1,jtb Wal
lace. Atchison ys peterSor Is .haScd on a
different state of facts There the S-nrer,e
Court saws: As respects the use of ,Tater tor
many ui,rnoses tba dorfrine NJ n. 'cou,", iO
law, decIaratory of the rights Of rinarian own
ers was Al nm carly day 9ffor tho disn,nr Of
gold. found to be inapplicable or anuIic1hI
only 70 a very limited extent. to the nere.sitiaS
of miners and inadeouate to their nroterfi6,,
That is in reference to mining. These mineral
lands are EXEMPT from sale they lfo not co,cti
tute q situs for a setfiement TEnv arc oyrned
by the paramount mower of the irnifed StaIes
and that Government has the right To saw we
viii protect those miners, and we viii foster
that Industry and the Government has done
50. 1t has seen the vast expenditjlre of MONEY
and il has recorlizef the claims Of those rnirerS
in appropIiatiug water on the cronnd
that the first 7appropriatJr is fist in
law thus recognizing the princinia that
peryade5 all law. that to the yigiIant
and not to the sleepinp does the law Give rs :
sistance This is n different c,se Tnfhet coee
OF Atchison VS. pcte5sou there .ras no rino
rian proprietor The fee was in the Govern
mcnt; the title had not PASSED and the Goyern
menC had the right to impose lis own condi
tons and to saw whether or not the man who
first appropriated the water TO work his own
claim should be protected or not II has nothing
to do with riparian nights Finari,,,i ri%hfe9
YOU know the derivation. il comes from
ripus" d bank Those " no live ON the hank
get certain rights and those ri,ats are 2 rareal
of and incident To tho sstste u-Lor.,,-tt,r ~
r..
foamgn Snd tbarn ore Il, ~ ~
land that tyatr hrroT,cs .art md orI "f
his estate II is pr0terted nv tho SANE Grant
and no same notant fbGt IroIac+s fbN 7a"d
Snrh has haer tile rr,,e =; rat -,
rort;es and Tho S5o1e r,,Ia LoiSs -, -, ~
fhe I;,yernrnort cf tha I-,i.ad c,tns ~
Son, ~ 1,,atte ~ 49,. - 80 49,, o,,,,,
nrrar" fr q ~ & ?"t 1"li Coiioeiii III
I 80 ~ q pG3lI 9se, uIs ilot PllN&te use,
Nit; - bt ~ r'e ,. ,i,,-' @
~ PiE oe' Lti' tlle 2tp.el-e Nouit "ouid say,
- - 80. 80 lUe No G9ii9Ti'rse " Ii a pioIlI usvIt 10
ol,i ~ - f. 20 90 80 ~! - @ ,oilie Co-!!St VI
tft , !dit 81 'it SUM
,.itt Tho ito - = ~ - t,' 1c,,e,y
,yii e1+-,iS9 ,',,,-i 80, ~ 90 - - ' :. S - y 10 70
S , r. y, = - Po.' ei oEel y, anu eLe
Ei i VI LUIS 2tatc y A. t'Aei !il'.t view,
- t'i - a. Se! S"S i lg. "ileu II appears
80 - - 60; Ptopet.s 40 oousiit " pS t5 te1Aci5 toI
H. eso ~, Nquts aIe n9l @ oouIu ps
~, @ - w tIo.l u tIe @ 9,tt' i III @ % tiiat II
oaMe ere anu ne tse Is Oily pr
yiate II iiiS'it ~ h1tltIis "iateNer.
- - VI tiie suPpvsltioil VI tiIS maintenance ol
81 @ ~ IiSl5'S. lllc "llotc dVc'!Ie
" m PuiiS USE - lolteu o1 neces>.t!, IL Is 70
pe StiIctl4 coustIueu anu the property IS 70
"e t'tA 81 oIt.t ,.iteI pr piope1 coli peilSd!oh
-t ~ Ie tiia' 5!iS provision on ouI
~ "a - iiftri - is slIiipl! GeclIat9Iy ol "nas
~ ~ w " ~ ~ nithts nc" NV sIloIlu
il 'tiluNS sii'tt tiio .lSh'S " ilPaiidA PiO
@ =. lee'i2 snouu pC pIosecteu W.! 90 they car
4iiein u IittlIan an, PropIletoI3 II the! are hot
mo1ri " :. 80 70 eau te @
lIPaIlah P1r1gpiletoIs P1g "tet 1t Is INSISTED tIey
+ az @ no', -, ne Ilslts VI tnese rlpai+au M pro.
az W W pS P!p.eetC,i anu II HS lIau uot
t.a'' &c i tI I e "%Iiu pt0o"pS
oe paII u tEe laW qi CalIlornla, oe-
pIenaiis paii Lm s, tiits ett State a. Goes
PIeHaai prev ~ IA aliiios[ M every olate III tLe Sllon.
ii,Ii t a. ' sI ny oT Il cOGl! mas yer!
l.s1G III t5I9 rlattei DSt @ sun We sit ere
~ ~; te iiotI VI ne iietIts " eyer!
fit.i FI 80 ~ ~; 4 ~, w .ioS4lG W o
lIstiT ciu ~ " t tiaIl icostItute d
RuptIG usc, @ lien ma uei i3 opeIte 10
@ Ct,s i ~ u, ot an! N.i1en 1 i'eiVL? VIC sNc our
sant.lol tiat sucll anu such tillg shau COIL
stItute d Pupilc use III Iesaru 70 wafer We
stiouiu nS eaIGlll anu looh aii over tls broaa
STATE anu see now mitils idlnllleS such definl-
t9 tioh NAY eliect even II tLe supreme Court
ShOutu occlue II was cousIitutlohal. 90 not
beieVe III gTahtlhg a"ayAthe properly OF any
Gitlzeh. All want 70 kiiqw IS Whether II IS
ms pioPeleii 'Hu WI uo my UTMOST
10 Pi0tect mn III IL, Wlletuer ne pe man
oL t tIlIlolls, @ VI moItLless pesSr, reeolect
t:iat ; O ~ u 49,, ~ a. ii a'o W ~ d
tiie @ u s.s;t ~ tliis country stateo
that ms pa!TIotlc deNotoh was Sqch tnat ne was
enIlfely "lliliig 70 sacf-Hce an OF MS Wlie es
Ie!aIIftS Oh nAe aItdL oI hls country buI
enllh n NIX y II wen Su1u9n IoI Us 10 I9ok over the
otlDe EIui see WneIheT OF noy we are Wiling 10
sCIIC9 me !ISiIs ol any MAJ III efuGF 20 etiun-
e!ate Eoihe PaIgleular HosLht. mere N the senate
as CONSTITUTING Puohc use. IN making these
renlaLks i am iuIly aware OF the great peneht9
Whlch irrigation Would Con!er upon LIie south
eTh par OF ttils State. peileNe II WouIo make
the Wli9eFIless hIosSoln IKE the rose. peieVe
1t woIld PlIt Us IN te EausuafG OF prosress, ana
SSL , HoS% az ,-' = tiie tg-1ol
VI tis 7it''e Is "sos' It, l. loI oiie' "ou4u Ao-
support IT, -. ~. c.
p IN this case a.s OF Lux Lux VS. Haggin the supreme
Goult 3 say me; G f@1gn4 @ 70 nave ihe Wa.ef Mleh
n%p"e' % ~ oNe. SeiI 'iug, AT vac uttte oI tieT Puf
CiSe eoitIIgu nue. to no" ~ cuiTeIe So.eo5i-as II
was actussoIieu 10 tun-maS COT Iporesll heIe9-
.tahieht oi Ml4cn tne! coulu li9t pe deprived,
AhogheT LhIhg; nave not our supreme Court
ueCl9eo tnttt these riparian proprletorS are en-
tlseu 70 Watef t9r i tHe!I cattle Is mere an!
pIopoSltlon IN thls PHI t1at water snail De fur-
nlshed 10 their cattleY why, sir, tins is a nee