New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1885-06-17
TYRANT BADLY BEATEN.
NOT PLACED IN THE TIDAL STAKES.
cv.n uvAr errwEEN PARDEE AND JOE COTTON
....., xv,vs THE sURF STAKES


- ,.-oot ;maoe before which turfmen
go A. Liberation has tumblcd IN the dust The winner
=, tbe whers and the Belmont Tyran the great son oi
rsat Tom the colt that had mile in trial IN l:4o
en- nz,ng star that had out Of the West to daz
xle all Eastern lovers OF sport s's
beaten in the Tidal Stakes ana uiu
not even Get place. After wandas collapse last Sa'ur
Nav and Tyrants utter failure yesterday are there any
.sure things in racingp Tyrant was great I"'ofo
as he was entitled to be the merit OF MS
ming Joe Cotton, winner OF the Kentucky Deroy' wa"
ridden by Mclaughlin and was second choce' Win
Commododore Kittsons fast colt Pardee rluoen ny f
patrck third in the betting Tyrant was sluggish anu
1acked life He was extremely slow In moving wheh INC
starter dropped the flag, and the other colts instantly
opened such gap that the spectators thoush' tn"
yrant had left at the post But omcers Vi .no o
who were the starting point say that wneh MI oa
well gave the signal Tyrant nearly even terms
NTH the Others but was reluctant to move on that inc
4he Others were many lengths away before ne WAS IN Kun
motion Duffy, his jockey, struck him WIN the "np i
peatediy and Tyrant then showed some Traces VI sno
epeed which startled all behoders at Jerome fark nu'
he did not keep 1t up long, and was hopelessy oea.en
,vhen Tho race was half over. laboring heavily
while Pardee and Joe Cotton left MIN IN
the rear. These two colts maze Sp'o"..u
battle OF it to the last stride, anu 'ns
Judges decided that 1t was dead heat. DfooA"oo"
was third Tyrant and Grenadier the only
far back. ,,, ,,s.
Tho .iuplest explanation of Tyrant's pitabe pngnt
Yesterday in comparison with his really admirape run
ming at Jerome Park to be that his owner anu
trainer have not worked him enough since MS beimoh'
victory He looked high in flesh and moved as II MS
lungs were clogged with fat. At Jerome PARK ne ran
after the manner Of Hndoo, Luke Blackburn MISS WOOD
ford Falsetto spendthrft and other turf champions
Yesterday he after the manner OF Brlghtoh pe""
selling ola,er Bnt he IL great colt still! Like wanda
nc is now shut under big black cloud ou'
both Wanda and he have better days In store.
IT,,tl,o ri
stable thought that he had great racehorse
IN Pardee Yesterday thousands OF people agreed
with him nas Sd an hm BUT he ran
great speed and courage Tayns ,he as s, aud
s w1e eTcry stride to the end Prdee Cotton and
Tyrant are all in the Coney Island Derby = i h,i
ie RIM on Saturday of this week. Tyrant can naruiy
recover his Jerome Park by that ume but Pardoe
and Joe Cotton will make ne race OF H. insr 81 the
turfmep will prefer the chances OF the winner Vi ue
Kentucky Derby the longer distance. A., .u ,,,
oS and stayed there until 20 get
near the leaders. Feakes rode the niue pacR coI 70
the 'front.' and kept him But Foakes felt sad and
Of place all the time HIS dss sn 81 he sS riding ' tho
most brilliant style. He is nervous and III at ease when
II x l9 n a en- 70 nc ce to win would throw M
Mclaughlin is by no means faultiess jockey pu' "0
can iIs Time 70 sell renadier for cavalry horse to hunt
Apaches with. He will make his owners oahAr"P' "
TSe " Dwyer Brothers' fine black colt Portland re,
deemed his reputation In the surf at me
start for the Foam stakes last week and cut his leg
TIA, was Ss % w Dew ne Drop got off badly
seemed in mood for running, ana MS oois o"'"""N
Nor one sSorte was successful Here is the mean
choiy st-Dione Dew Drop. Iyrant Royal Arcn' noa
and Endymion. all badly beaten. Ihree VI '"e' 0"'
from Pierre Lorlard's stable, Oh, s.s M. ,ke IN
Bria the first race easily she does NOV "No "
run beyond three quarters OF a mile ~. .,u
Electric catching Portland at the close OF inc run
for the Surf stakes Portland is fast but Is not sayer
HseLand-Toe won the handicap at 3 Ini4s by mead
only from Euclid both running Wei @ maa"bars
asssa Royal Arch heavily The arch however was
badly sprung. IL was mnch 700 ias dS, o'"N A'' w
William Donohues colt Elgn with his owner e IN the
saddle the fourth race with SLOW nc nr every
u me Selling race fell to Bill" Daeys Lgau. though
Manitoba was beaten emily neck; ,., am
The attendance was large ard enthuslasuc TIC , 90
breeze tempered the heat and the afternoon was
extra racing the benefit 2, t Ss gnf sisnd
Hockey Club Wednesday OF next week.
DETAILS OF THE CONTESTS
The first race was for purse Of $780, Tor horses tha
had never won special weight condtons' INSTANCE
a mile Three ran-an illies-Rancocas Stables Diohe
r. years 10Y pounds, ridden by Olney); snedeKer 8
prta n lo7 W. Donohue); and Dwyer Brothers Luiu
20 o. Wethers Pools-Dione 800. Brita $50. Lulu
GAO Books-Done 6 to 5, Lulu to D. Brita ITO l.
D,oue led for half mile and then Brita passed her ana
won in a caner in six lengths in llI, Dichc seoo 0
lengths before Lulu. French pools 81 H.
Tho second race was the Surf stakes for two-year
old. s25 each ST. 900 added 800 to second distance
Ave furongs Six ran-Raneocas Stable pair, inc co''
savanac q Is pounds. ridden by Hayward), ana the my
Dew Drop al2 Olney; Dryer Brothers pair OF cots'
,r,,and u,5 Mclaughlin ana Buffalo Q15, Fihpat-
rick,. G. L. Iorillard's geding Electric az Blay'
lock,. and r. W. walden's FLY Leterla az, Le"isl
Value OF the prize $1,000. Pools-Rancocas par
&l5O Dw,er pair $llO Electric 500, Leterna ~
Embellishments pair even Dwyer pair 70 o. heo'r'o
Ito l, lctora 10 to l.
pgao was a little in advance when the fag fell but
mclaughlin got a winning start and was far in the lead
in an instant Electric also moving well wheh inc
signal came and two left the others 30 last tha
thev had chance Dew Drop seemed to stumble Mt tho
start and did get under way until all her chance
were gone Portland led throughout though NC
yauehlin had to drive him In the last hall inrions a.
Electric was getting dangerously near Portland won
nv length and half 1904, Electric second dozen
lengths before Leterla. the others pulled up. FRENCH
pools $40 o.
h roa, race OF the day was the Tidal Stakes. one
mile for tbree-year-ods, 500 each half forfeit bu
oplv $40 declared ont by July l, 1854 $looo aaaea
5000 TO second There 80 entries and the value
OF the stakes was $3.50.
Five ran-ali cots-B. A. Haggi6s Tyrant (Duny)
flames r. williams's Joe Cotton tMcLaughlin) keho'
rrootwood H'eakes); sncdekers Grenadier wv Dono
huc,: Kittson's Pardee q1tzpatrick). st. Angus
Poois-Tyrsnt $40, Joe Cotton so5 pardee $50
Joe Cotton ~ to 5. Pardes to l. Brooxwooa "
(3renadier to l. .. ,., ,.so.o Ton ro,,op
who was little before Grenader Brookwooa next an
Tyrant last The avore was so slow in settng uhue
-.v FIAT in 4 fyinki six lengths behind an'
DUFFY hit with the whip OF course Joe Cotton wa
~ sneed That's the way Mclaughlin almost inVarlaoii
Gets start Joe Cotons neck was In front OF faruee
In few yards and he kept the advantage uhti ne en-
tered the second rurlong Then Pardee maze tne p2c
40 fast that he got length IN front OF 10
Cotton, Tyrant now taking thiIa pisnce WIZ W.,
great burst OF speed under the iash. "he'
thew had run half mile Pardee length and hal
sesors Toe Cotton with Tyrants head at Cottons saddle
sTi,s Swinging down the long turn Tyrant lest gronn'
and already the stable boys began shouting that ne VIA
I,csten They were right. The colt that was Iohui,
the champion the year could not keep up w