The Hawaiian gazette. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1865-1918, 1884-01-02
rAs easvtts MAnda=sus Cas-.

A. : El-l'N~--s -asi el'clea y SaNl1s- In i
order that may he understood clearly ia this
1ase. ard possibly Evpcyssa eo-reesly. I viii |
-soi every roiu; which dsSirc to present IN
tbs ease, and Wi also stare tic position Which
.i2 'et take, and shsreby saabls ths respcua-
guss cguuSel u saw siase in ar.-uizz a.si-st
ylvsr.which I tc not a-s-e.
a statutes of his Kiasdcra make il The
chclL pallic duty & the Minister cF the IL |
leug- ~ scnc sssscaabis tiaaS, 70 lzy before |
ths Ezly1 Cc-uc1 al sppiicatieas fss eharters !
ul-cl zrs i- cc1tortnity With the statutes s-a |
vii the .zw, and are fc- cbjscts for whi,h |
charters -a1 lzwfclly &c granted
90 Is uci Ter hsra = ssy that he VII ebsain |
-1- H-ylce e the Frtry Council On cne charter
t5- val scs % Il IN another, providing that |
Cshe- : IN legal fo-rn and fog lesal cl;esss
To aclo that The Misister las discretionary |
power sc dcscr-ius whether b. VII u ~-Sfl |
re; present any such documents wculd be
s1cvsrs've Of the legal rights Of all ulea Sc
caret BY the Constitution, and Ct the Grtv cs a |
Aluls.e- q the lusericr &c perscrra isapar- |
11-iy he duties assigned &c hiu by isw |
he Puvilsse q rigbt- IS Il a,ay be. q cb.ais-
t1S tbe advice G. TIE Privy Ccurcil. Is q cu-ht
o oe vsrr valu3bis- Il tie Mi,iSse- a. Is |
ePsio1 car csry that rishs tc any spplicant. |
hs ea1 deny L q al. II hs car as-sit ssch |
ush- to scue sa6 deny II 70 c.h.-s. then Al |
Eanner ct abuse, pargla6sv aai c,-rur.icr
weuid be Pracscahly, al The sbISes ccncern- |
r1S SALTS CT charters which existed in tie tine
q he Cha-,es and lanes cCcl6 easily |
ereeP H. The Constitution and laws Gsav q |
a A--lSec- Sccl GaE-vrvrs discretionary p,ursr
Aae detenSzut IN hls demurrer takes the view /
th1i The Ccurt has 10 jurisGictsca. because |
.aere Is ~ law or ssatzse q this realm Is |
alleged IN The pe1tic1) by which lie Master 1
: required 10 presens such re6tco for |
casrssy q incorporation 70 the King IN PRIV /
Nelnc1l L = uos essential that every ces- !
clal GUY e. any cEsccr, hist CT Low. shan be /
-ieg.sly specified bv statute.
d 10. elEi., n this case. thai tie C,r-.
e1a Impose ey w. q Hzaz61z.zs, duty, The !
FericrriaHee q whieh is 6iscretcrarv With /
1e cccer- he gruEH5 vhich .ake = his /
else, ls .sas cf yesterday. Is, that wherever /.
: clear, impartial duty recrsrei ~ Law 10 1
1e performed oy n ofScsr, the Cczrt caa ecu-
ge- s1cas pertoruarce o. . pruper apVlicacscr.
II ne vles e tie defendant Is correct. tie /
saints ccUl5 read as fcllcwS, VIZ. " Il shall I
Be Discretionary url.b the Mizisser Of the In /
ie-i1r . .1y bs.rre the King In Priyy CcuucIl, I
or net, as he LIKES, any iavful applicatien fsr 1
1Wtel eharter. How wCui6 that rea6s
u Lee rsspoc3sns elains thai the petlticn |
= lnS11c1snt because It does not aver demand I
111 refusal The peEEcr does aver that the 1
respondent ~aas utterly f1ileG and refused ard 4
s-llL tails ard refuses, &C present The appEca-
uo1 tcr ch1rter C. the King IN Privy Ccan- I
81 There cau be 10 refusal e that whi-h 4
"a net bscn tsuaa6sd. Nsrecve-, thu cases 1
and ar-hc1Ees l-e. believe. culv claimed :, /
8 @ tie extent q resuiriuS thlt prisr de-
uauc Be made e cases where tie Gutv : cufv 4
a prrrale and net F1hlic dry. L : both 4 4
Ep1lr ard ass priyase tutr thai tie head /
lt ils La-ericC Department shah llv before The |
---1cIl al SUN 1ppla-a1ic1s. the slrls bsing, 1
50 .ssal fcrm and tor ls-1f ve5=eas.
bu- lie petEeu AYERS tha1 ths pstslCuers, {
AS April, fLed n she ciice Of the Department 4
Of he Lr.sClcr tAeir 4pPiicatgu tgr th5s char ]
ssr- That necessarily ieclu5es rg7zest &c d I
sls act ard al ctAsr acts which the l1w re- 1
sllres % oe dgue IN cr5er 90 sraus The appi- I
ca-lcu-
Mr.. Nhiz1g argued thas the petition bciu., I
-has cf PrIvz1e partiss IN their pciva.e iuser-
ests- speeiic demani should Be alleged. 1
rhas 1c demand Tor the performance of ! spe- I
ciic act can be inferred tTun anv ssneralf-ies.
The demand Should be made o. the incuu- I
bsns of he gfScs, the mar, uct On tls cfSce. /
Thls Pe1lcn Is against Z. 7. GElick Mi1istsr 4
q he Lusericr, 1ad be ciscd ease from Of 1
WlLilees Report. Pase sQt, holding thas /
ien=nd un n officer is uot sc0d As against lis |
s1ccsssor n Ctce-
By he CcErt Wcult yCu = e shc cztens I
Ct eilsulng shas q every charge q Cfice rev |
Peltocs wuuid have s1 &c fled u every maj /
rsr PsnG5nS
NJ. WhiEng ", yuur hcuor. Bat II case
sf ulalcamgs tie case 5 different. TIE de-
uEat being essential in such cases. The I
EuE oeIag against the alizistsr personally I
speciEr demand should have lesn Alleged I
aoW cuule q the nest important guest57u I
involved II the ease H1rs tie counsel read /
tie ssltute- ! zgbmis that the law n cases OF
ma1danzs l. that the Wiz does not arply n I
cases 1f Glscrgluu.
Judge Austiu ' The plaintiffs 10 uos deny l
this.
M Vhi5ag- No you- homer. Bur I NUS
refer = r Charters Of Incorporascn IA this 1
kingyicm % ucs issue gf right L Is uce 4 |
mater cf-ushL L does rot aHuct the nights I
: Pr1PersT. L may afsCt sle Eabd5-ies sf I
sas pa-ses
Does tie discretion suIy eaue IL astsr the /
Ans n FrlTg CUgucIl have given rhsl- cur |
sent Can -ae Minister Be pllcrd n .hat I
Fcs--innt Or has be 10 izsccsciuu7
exercised
The -a-hor6ez = 2 sh1v that T discretion
cuuIes 2 a. my stage q sas ease. -hen this /
WIZ WI rot Ee-
The eugrs have gone 50 IA as @ say Aas
4 snsre . EEas5ru as . the 5i--ress,n- ne l
presumption VII Be n .1Tcr Of t4s z5,--g5sp |
We suhmi- zla- MS na-1sr Is N laa i5-c-s- |
nuu Of the minister,
Ar- Nsunann- Z WI 1ElE add, Laas GU
pcsi1cn : aiis- The Court vii not taSe s1v 4
lcCcu wben thecz q. szs11ztzsn- rHar = I
discretion of aue ctzcsr VII not Be szhrn5t-ess I
&c ne discretion Of another tribGuaI- We ]
submit tla- ne >ilz1te gives crmplste DIS
crsCGn o Ssa minister n tins case.
Ikat tae wgris b and VIII she ADVICE Of
wIrTn . i1rr
Efhrulzve =ct1u cn taeir pu-r The niinis-
tzrsz dlcrgEun ulzst apply si-her 5ef5rr or
g--r lie acEg1 -f TIE PrlTv Ccuuca- Il cza-
mt 1e arr sEch lcrlcR. Gan he he-ia - e.
sruise his G5scrs1cu gf5a- s1rh lcf5qr ?
Clearly not e eazncs szzrcsse L aEt.- sAev
have lksu acGcn lie discretion bs-7ns Il lie
neule1t Of lie 6iiaE sf tie peE1rn-
Tie lLE : ciezr-1nG I % not see hLr
y1a- lancrs ca1 leEislate apsu n. suEisct-
- va : says IaG cAa 1ea2 ucs-ins sise.
&C 10. -a-lz y1ur 1Cuurs VII scr1rch -Gr
E1E Pz-- 1f Z
M Seuna-zs -stsrrsi Z the Ezrl7ur,.y,
case S1ers ne VI vas 6au5sd. On lie
-ru1nC tlas * was naEzsr ur 5i7sr-sri,r- ri
be claimed thar tie S11r1-a 4 tifs - = =
-laa- sa1s there . 10 1rEznenE
NJ EL-rEed II rspiy1 80 -aars j. N
-lspure eerwesn u Is % the lrr- Bat anlv
Is u he fra. And Is sass-nu Of -1r-
sL1clEn Il q lie .E4ElTles lie >a-l1e -lu-
nut be eansrueG Is claimed By the counsel slr
respcudent- WI-iGGr inser1n- sther w-rss.
rha s4Gzsel asks f me minister csEld ear
eiss his Giscrsesn as=.r atizlzaa-zvs actun Of
-he RITT Council Csrziniy-ie i ezzy z
snrrsEFs sf ease rhe-e rev cs---uscazrss
zlsh- zrisT Efsr he 1ccrn Il he Ccizrr7
E2sra vaulc be smizenEr proper f1r
tis A-nisfer . viiah1lG -hzr-er.
lie 7GIlE Is a La Eicr oE lie Pe1-
80 a1Elns seen lied .;1rin. .ae acuubenr~
q NJ 5I5cSis ) preaierzsar TEss ssliit r1s not
araa=nE AGAINST lia- sgssierszsaF. hu1 a.zsnzr
Ne pf-si-1E l-rInaznr The G11ea 1f ,hr /
eoe'i=-ss1alr ae-airs IN he suE-1ssur.
sHnnIE slas ne ps1.Enn saavs Ie-4I
1ul-rE % he szfsn,ftar- Ts a, mr. ssk ~.
e-azllsr be gz-1s.aL 6ur asar he ugr5uu be
sa1uli-iit = ne h5ag- N Prsrv CazncI.
5-r- ne case rss1s-i and tae matter WIS
llz=n Under srtvIssn.Br