New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-04-24
CLOSING FOR MR.. LOUBAT'
rtr l-NIoY cLUB CASE NEARING ITS END.
. COUSIN OF Mr.. rURNBUILs WIFE on THE STAND
prr,sANrRIrs BETWEEN COUNSEL.

80 - ,,.,,,-,tN Cot.~SEt
- ~ =, - .,,.1,.od,d with mich
Inc Ohloh Ciup '">c .,'a e,nso Court bc-
animation yes''niay mo.'""s "' VIZ, -. n.,I i'm rho
fore judge Van worst Inc P'oD',u''' - enc
larger c"ui room 's'''.' u' ~" ., ,,,t even
Genera! Term. O"' '"' u" '''s''- -, Tho
las lA'i'"''' ''''','' ~, '1 ord ,,.cr.,I
chars N''''' '"' i"'- -, i,i,,.t n . railing
80, Ill, I'M. isi,.,,.t,, FROM the Union Club
'''' '' ~. -,., r.t.rNI,r.& Fred
wa ,, - p ropov tatcr IN ,bc
'..N - d, t,r f,v ,,,r,cs
" - -,.,,,.,s ,,-,,. hot .,
- -. -, -, r,,.,,s .ri,i,.r eve
' , -. ~ ,,,oI r,r... mat
e, ., ~, ,,,, g., r.r,,.,,,,.,s scco,,ron,,nrut 10
-. r,,,,. NJ, Gas, lo,,,,., s,,ecc.sou of
" -. tn. ,,1 NJ poaip.ou.. rosy com
- m, MITCH, ,,,,, .,,,,,, ,r, ~, through tile
t,,-s ,.,l, ,b. ,,,r. ,-,o ,,or. startling bri .ht-
80. ..,,i,t.-1 ,,, t,f,,,,,.,. ~, tha rotpl. acmmcl
go, ,. a,, a., -, s,,ord,r ~ n. own 10 the pie
s., a, ., a., 80 .,..,i-, fr,,ros NJ Robinson con-
t.urcd the series OF anxious consultations with Mr.
,.or which he hc,.an on c first day of the trial! and
Mc..r4 Cboa,c and Carter crossed lcga! sword, and
s.,,t.~ed wifi a,uutautIv ON every side.
Rcf,r. testimony was resumed Mr. Choa,c called the
o,r,top NJ tb Court IN m editorial " hi,h had appeared
IN The Escaiag st. ia which the facts of the he
so, had bc,u Grossly ,iystotel md Tie whole matter
rrcudcd He added that lie was sd ~ wishing 20
drag into the ease the language which the cause o!
thu quarrel when had sedulousy nan"uyred 70 keep
II OIL Mr. CAoatc asked the Court protect Itself and
the paijr. in tie case from any such proceeding. Mr.
Carter th,n.lt the request WIS an extraordinary one,
ord said that if There was one pont which was ndi~-
ritae IL was that the language used was such that
decent tongue might utter and no respectable pen might
write IT, jude Van Worst said that DE could not inter
eerc and remarked that The counsel should know him
better than TO think that lie would De influenced Oy any
such publication.
J. y P.att said that lie had accompanied Mr.. Loubat
when he went before the sub committee OF the Govern
tuc Committee simply ITS his friend and not rs counsel
Mr. Iou9tt hal a.kel him TO do ho afternoon o.
MAY ~ after he had received notice from the sub-con
I1fta 10 apror before them Nj Lonbat came down %
Ii. o,Src fine next morning and there prepared the
srarcuept which he aft,r,yard read to the committee
Mr. Ptt laid that hc lad not given him any assistance
IN IT,. prepar1ti5u but real over when IL was com
rlet,d When Mr. Lo.ba; attended he meeting Of the
r,,,,,,.t,a -ro+ a-oo,, Mr. p.tt went with him and
file witness Thought tia, the Chairman Mr. sheldon,
,,lors.ood ,s,- ne WA. There u, . ,I4cld When Mr.
Jouat mad re his statement he AID tlc witness retired
together
prC.rrrN- Nh CtDw.T tDTr'S pfNNTE.
Co., rtycs ss,l ,l,- lie wa. uo, q member Of the
,-, C1r, H., wa. nro..p- d, Mr. Clv...c,'- dinner
,,ntI occ,r,ol ,ho1, -l, lime q, Mr. Ioalar.. ,x-
l-i NJ cl,.,l,5or c,rl NOT reln.rllnor tl,, dltp
, ,,r al ,.. ...,.,s,,,, -,,~. s,-, Henry Turn
49,, NJ r..- sam, emo, ,la DINNER oc,,,r,,l about
- Nv, rf. Nv rorI,,,,. ov,l,i..e,, and that he
81. NJ r,r,n,u I.o,a. Y Parker wa. present. Nj
rlpITl
tbr occurrence IL s5ld thar he did not know the exlct
d,,c NJ tbc dinner nor The date az Mr. Iouhai', cx-
,i, b,, ,lt the lipner was o few d,y. before the
a,l.ia, ~ tba. he v-.s oDi-o clear Mr. RIvc- said
MOI b W. friend of Mr. Iouhat and had talked with
him. 9s 70 the tact fhst he was rrcscn, a, TIL, dinner
mn - ~ nv '' .''' -, ~ ,i -
Committee as constituted in May, I--- ~.id that nc
-. - ,, 49, rr,,~,,,,I1 f,,r ,o- ,c,-. pr-.,s-
hl'si' nave An""h .',ni! ''.',.',.-
ous 70 - ana ,a' us nIS' ~ ~,
between Mcssrs. Loubat and IuEnp" came uoi" "h''
Nj Choate described IS the celebrated circular He
had not declared his intention 10 Tor Mr. Loubar-
expulsion prior 10 the meeting whceat he had been eH
peIed After the meeting he had stated what mad III
e,c,s b,,, a.. ,i, ,,, ,,,t,, chat be should he *
Nv ~ ''- -. ,, 80. ncs,., n, tno
evident intention On Mr. Louaa'- part TO Secure letter
iron, WI ,, wing "''rH "0''-'
~ 49, ..-- ,..-.,-,-
NJ C,o,.a nm, ,r % COM. a, TIN Tp1nr<l. OF Ml~3
- -, - A.. MI, g, NE n,3 r.,.l ,,nrIar,
H. A.. a.. ...- s..I .,.., .n, l,d ,,,
"'4, ~ i, -, ,,,. ~ o,,,- ,tler
"'' '-', W ~. ,.,i ,s,, ~, ,iis ,r,
-. to,,,.o NJ Cbo,,o 10, This yv,v vosi.d get
',., ,.c which r radylc,p rr'cd olt.
Mr. Choa,e retor,ed that Il Mr.. Carer MOI good
friend Of his he would SIT under these constant dis
eovoe' OF bis motives MI b''3aen, 1'.,'
thai De remained at the clubhouse until after II O'Clock
m Clio NIGHT NJ the meeting when Nlr. IouDat Was
-, ,.I 49,. - 1.,r,.-. ~ Pm. ,I.,r NOR ,f
peicL lie dd h"' -'C any ''l''' ''l7 a. Wv ''' -'
H. way home. lie din give Information a- 10 the II sui
NJ r4o-t, IN d represent alive OF rl TUEUNr Ms
~, I..,, d. - ,... II mr. 20 ,',1o,L The interview
Ho''@'' ".'''' A'''' !''N' - w -
tllc' and simply tie Idrt oi Mt I-oupt '1pS""
nd fn.silr OF the ccLi.-c passed OF Nj TGruDuL
49,. ~o,Il r,,>'..,
S"'i'''' .'''''' a. Lee
Mr.. tn0dtc-lHd yon MAKE TINS '"I.A4"u4'"'''' IVY
Instruction Or the Governing committee
. The Wltuc-s-No -r.
Mr. Choatc-Was any O;hcr member present
Ibe Nituc~s-No. sir.
Mr. Choafc-Dld not know Il was a VOCATION or
your duty a. o member Of the Governing Committee
fOniectcd TOT
Nr R,,,i.o aati that .hn Covcr,iu. Committee had
-. ~. 81. .,,..,.., o.. ,,.. ,.,..,,..
never A~ue 4H! -1'cs'o'''-oi VI '-- 5'.J''' " ' o'