The Evening critic. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1881-1885, 1884-09-10
1T WOULD BREAK SMELLS HEART,

1T WOULD BREAK SMELLS HEART,
Rut tho pu,,t,c xUo,,,a uo po,o0,oa
ar H,o,o. n..,. ysas,. I,,o,,. ..,a
poiIca Co., ce-,,, W. ca.,sa,, o,s
i,, so,,,a We "' O''" WV
""S'
MAYOR Dyes annual report suDm'ttel
and published in yesterdays CRITIC, con-
tanned very many good logical clauses. His
suggestion that TO- ou u,uoo o,nr,s ,;1,o
,t. -. W. v ''''0
'he Preseno romeo court, OF system Oh
magistrates courts, be created to transact
the business now done by the Police Court
meets with vorv general favor.
T. wolf. .Lno,yr foo. thot ,bo brs;,osa
- ,,n-,," S, nv 80 w
Oh tne fohce Court mas grown TO such I'M
mense proportions that it Is impossible for
one man sitting as the trial justice to prop
cry ulspose OF the many cases brought be-
lore MIN.
lHE CRITIC interviewed few lawyers
on tne sun1ect OF Major Dyes recommends
tion this morning.
Mr. Ibomas Il. Miller said The con-
clusion OF Major Dye that the Police Court
cannot longer be administered by one man
ls undoubtedly correct. His suggestion OF
return to the magistrates courts Is good
one. Inc cases to be tried would be so di-
Vided up and apportioned as to enable each
man 10 give them that care ana lnVostiga-
tlon Whlch they required, ana thereby tne
expense ana annoyance OF appeal would IN
great many Instances be obvlated. Ills
recommendation that the present Police
.ourt aCt as court oi appeal IS not ieasi-
sle, as all appeals must lie to court where
they can pe tried by jury"
Mr. Johh 3. Clarke SAID would be IN
IaVor Oh ,ecommitting thS Jurisdiction now
conferred upon the foilce court 10 ap-
pointees 10 rake tne places Oh the OLD po-
nee magistrates inc iacilities Tor dispos-
lng OF the business IN tho past by the police
magistrates would commend this action.
vi course, continued Mr.. Clarke, the act
estaDllshing tho follce Court providing the
rlght OF appeal from TINS court giving the
accused the constitutional right OF a trial
Dy Jury would nave 10 DO amended SO as 10
preserve this right Ihe only objection TO
eslaniishlng similar courts would DC that IL
wouiu enlarge inc hGld Oh Tue Already 700
~ Inv bo.oS 9nS & s.er eienuuv, ,,,i op,niou
nnt tOy ~ rao,iu upGn my Peii
cbarlos II povo az ~ Vs0 n.oo,t onrs,i
,,tad So ~. i'll. H. "s q. .,.1ya
~ a;;a . w .i 80 .iS 20
va P.oPsi r "v.oI'iv" ~ 'DS"p VI Nv W.
Jia,;a'' "rt.a oono oeioIo w. Vu1 jus
oc ,;oiations ~ n,1;o,, ,i",io,, sioai
,.,',,,id VI ies s.iSv'U,.s lt, III
IL t; I'M ~ u.sPoso " NJ ~
,o,eti,,,ia,.1 Al. A., .
iii 80, ~ lo'ou, v.av U.u 80 ".
H.. suali w ~
Ju,s ~ iLf 10 pos p,esol.Ir t pS Gno
Sfr NJ" .i 70 NV ",to"eu % iTI .uY ol'oe
wv wv W 'no Ni''niHai ooulV' II vnis pres
t tInS Ju.IiuiIt,o" l' iS 10 o9 Preserved III auy-
iIDn!, uou!, mneUner ii', III Ino iouce o3urS OF p'-
il,o ,atIi.E "Eistia.os, E, Wouiu mucn prefer eno
91;,nsn III u. on9 Ur "1o'o courvS W,
"iuin"So .i'.n"c WIN Une Ioi'Ge oou'0' as Ouo
iIIo , VI thc Justices 9I tho peace, II prop
i,i naeW .n eno aHu'i.iIeFa..on r,,., Gl y1e'r
''E,' W W. W. "ou'u 90 ,er lu'Iy occIpieu
.,, %, % -. "eTu' esi,' ~ 'uo o'u hi's'a-
''"tv sns'eti " pe n,3 les.orcu' ar ,..u
c,,, "u"ee ae i 10, ~. oltNer ,, am TearViiy III
M Va fnu sui uiResSlon Si VI 'i'1Ur .i1, Dye. ",
h,,s;,'ost W. .ho pIia J,asoSy e no'euset .,.
;,, Vt 'to o.,oo SouIS iu!u,res e9aO
mU.t .nda, Jms'soeS W nppotn'ou. m'Ior
..So"',.''n'"''o'. 10 gnu ouo'
why '"c fi's"ht System IL E""i'y.
Major Dyes recommendation that there
should DO more police courts VIII bo gem
efally approved ana Judge Smell could
very gracefully make similar recommcn-
datloh, SAID u iair-mlnded citizen to re-
porter
INC present system IS essentially faulty,