New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-04-29
COMMENTS OF THE PRESS.
er.rp Cg,pcI,s Fully MET AND OVERCOME.
. ----- l. Il In

STALE CHARGES FULLY NIL AMI w IsI'NN-tI-
The daily accommodating evidence of MIR.
Blaines strong hold uPon me mus p ana ~ warm 81 over
fe Stale charges OF eight years ago ana pace lhci ah"
H. tei'nS TO lie many VINO had forgotten he answer,
as wei as tie charges The Posts resurrection ana
TTess,'uni 'i inc proner that the memories OF
men should be reo>Led to the answer as Wen as 20
mi forcibe and conclusive rcoiuder found III another
column Of ne lress Of this morning am Is oy oS %n
Ycxt 10 Mr. Blaine himself most competent 10 make ~ tno
Hon william alter Phelps, Of NeWJeIsey. Nr. IAeIPs
doe not s,npy rTPe@' oT "vsdge of what he is
savug aud stakes his high personal reputation On il7
Sse to accent the word o. Mr Blaine VIII show any
more respect for that OF ms GnlVIl"G s
s ePIy sa truth aaS a6oat nam Bane position win
see that tho stale charges OF his en4Ss ave neG a S
met ANA overcome u rests WIN M biiuo D a,d
either 10 show that Mr. Pbclp, s sptols ptHueI am
81 el w. sf on Mr. Blaine hey ma.ou-y perverted
Inc facts or grossly mscon eived thom As Mt. BiGeS
tbev are compelled TO ask for new t1aI upon We o
charges whose hollOwness ana the large pIopoIon oi
which they are based. thoroughly developed ana a
,nirany enforced by MI Baine's trusted ireud ,I IN
innate associate, the careful pers VI WHOSE 4c''i
We recommend oar readers
ENTIRELY FALSE AND MALICIOUS.
Fr.la me baltimore Atlerican.
The old charges which have on several oc-
easiOns heretofore been made against B-lhe Dy MS
enemies aud often shown TO DC diSo haN( Oeon Ea
repeated I'm The her- YORK Eteat9g ISt qua nNS no"
been SO completely dspTOved by the Hon william walter
Phelps that thcy viii probably mover dLah SLOW toi
selves In the presence OF those who have the sghtest
acouainance Win the facts. There Undoubtedly no
man in the country whose statements IL lnls naIeI
would De received with such fesPtG anu DC
regarded authoritative as tuOse OF AI a, moao
mice sense OF honor and undertaking integrity nave even
him the first IN the cOnid nee Oi ne people MT
Phelps takes up the charges sei di an All 'u ~ ~
Ineniary and other evidence that all the ch4I9s bdN9
baen 1 our Of the whole cloth. and are entt} a'o anu
malicious These facts have al been bIonels OUT
but the complete, logical ana au way "a 49,
thew have been Ilade by Mr. Flelps VIII tel "''n crush
ing force
ARIY ANSWERED AND FULLY REECTED
from Tte TTOg TeisGTd1h
The stale ISLANDERS which have recently Deeh
reailed by me Acr- York EceHing Post regarding M
Rlsues official record both as member Of Congress ana
Secretary of state and the charge Of more recent 0n
20 effect that be has been packing conventions IN hls
behalf a Presidential candidate nave pten
Hon william Walter Phelps. Mr. Phepss Intimate
knowledge OF MI Biaine's business affairs for many
YEAR, and h, high reputation As an honorable gentle
man and VINO would not attempt 70 scad the pun
no IN any way, give particular force 20 his statements.
These statements are supported In every possible man
ner BY documentary evidence which leaves 40 ground Tor
one vii disbeieye the assertions OF MI Phelps except
MIR Blaine's personal and political enemies VINO
xTo,ld no doubt continue hT tie ola ahd oIttn e1-
ioded charges al bis head In spite or every sort OF PROOF
,bcir faisitv But Mr. Phelps further In this
matter than the disposal OF the charges against MT
paiue He states that Of his own knowledge Governor
49,, ard lsst but not least, Senator Edmunds, Whle
members Congress or the Senate were actusiy S
q offence Of which MI. Blaine Lao NS'" Pi'
Innocent
Dir. ELAINE CAN RELY UPON AMERICAN Ju7lloL'
Prom me inca HeTdtd
William Walter Phelps has reputation GER
family IN this state and doubtless throughout inc Union,
At least equal that Of any 81 the persons VINO III or
ASSAULTS against james q. Blaine He has taken Tie