New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-04-24
q When did Won nrst hear OF the quarrel between
vonr cousin ana Mr.. Loubat 80. -...i,
Mr. ROhnsOn-IIc Is not Mr.. IuTnhulI Co"S'''
Mr. ChOatc -Cousin-in law, then.
Thn ~ fnrs.-Mhen INan The crcular.

o.-when did you arst hear OF the quarrel between
E"Wi r ROW. RoSno i is not Mr Turnbus cousin
Mr. ChOatc. -Cousin-in-aT, then.
The witness-When read The circular
Mr. CUoArE EXPRESSES HIS CONTIpFNCE'
Mr. Choate attempted % test the memory OF inc VII
ness on this point and Mr. Carter tinaied that was
very strange to him how his learned opponent p'''S''
In driving nails into his own hin hour 'i''' no'i,
With the usual impcTt;rhabc smile MI. 'h"a'' d'"'V
Mr. Carter that he perfectly saiisea WIN '' W
deuCc already I'M. and shat he did not "ohef l' WI
Carter should chafc He declared that II Ills honor
vvoud only ii.ten IN .hc end OF the evidence, his case
would he found iiurregnalle.
Mr. Cloatc TO wimess-Dd you not tell George L.
IOrlllard in Florida during the Nln,et 7-li.,Ii
previous 10 Mr. Loubats expulsion; lnI III, , ti,at
had called Mr. IOuhat dirty low JlachSudru anu 'l"'
Mr.. Lou5at had run away
The tnC>~-Nut To my recollection ,.,..
o-iad yon heart that Mr. Turuhull had u'Gd ms
language aud Mr.. Lou'at had run away A. az No'
0nd it not occur 10 Won that in view 81 yogr rco-
in a case where Be WIS Interested A %. III.
QAfcr the meeting Of ne COMM ,1rfnti,
,-@ipe Al cannot eIy that ga not / uo No' W.
Odd Won not have a conversation with Frederick
Nelson before !hc meeting when you derArtI ' 40
your intention TO vote ior MI Louhat expulsion = A.
a Have Won had conversation with counsel as to
u, To- what yoa did not remember ,
Ola oa Vote for Mr. Loub1t's -,puaron and II favor
ol t,u>t,.r IN the OF Mr.. Iurphui. A-lrs'
CLOSING THE PLAINTIFFS CAsF.
Mr. TePoy was on the stand after recess and the carry
nr o ti afternoon Wa occupied by Mr. Choate read
ina ln- series OF ntcrrogations Nhah had been pro
nouulcd % NJ LcGo- on the preliminary eIan'AaNoh'
those Mr. 'Choate did read, Nj Robinson s"Ppueu'
and after few formal questions Mr. Leroy wl' allowed
10 retire Mr Hunter recalled. hut a. JldGe van
Worst sin ruled rgidy against the admission OF any
testimony l"udinGto show the participation OF hrSSrs
Belmont Traver, and tn witness N the preparation OF
the circular Mt. Hunter also relieved Mr.. King
again took the stand. Tie said that the action Of the
Governing Committee respecting incupated 'nembers
was communicated 10 the club ny individual announce
mcnt on the part ~ the governors.
Mr. Choate-Aro not differences made IN the Governing
Committee in case where OHe oI th'f Own meIi"oI' -
inrI paicdl
The wHrss-NO
Mr. Choate said that he offered to prove that Pe'eg
Ha member Of the Governing Committee, used IAN
1Iace which was unit fr repetition, III addressing m
other member AID nothing was done abont II. He
wanted to show that action OF the committee was not
mrartit The case 70 which he erred had enjoyed AS
much notocty as the papers possibly could give H. The
matter was excluded. Mr. Choate then proceeded 10
prove by the cu'. records tnat the practice I'D
prcviou- cases when committee sought to discipline
mciuhrr, o announce 20 him tue naiufr"i tAr 'A'' .'
against nm and 1--WE him 'ull opportunity 10 urW' IT,
III the ci-e Henry Draper evidence Wt- idA'u "fIWt
a subcommittee and the charge '0rmutted 10y theuI
1Lr cupou Nj Draper was cit4 to apptI! ~ orr tuT
Governing Committee Mr.. uotr asked thdt lIe Iut
records IN the cases No-ss. Elston and lcaVlu Dr
produced This morning After few unlnportant gieS-
oS Jonn u. Draper Nj. Cho5tc said thaJ Tie pam
| td's closed.
Mr after said tnat ne would have Etile additional
evidence of ana courScl agreed 10 he in sum my
m inst a. a. n ~ the evidence wa IN. II ,eIe.,'L
that the whole viii be given 10 the court before ms
I afternoon.