New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-03

attributes put upon him In his absence by ts uah
e. he examined That is undisputed askel tnem on ~
the OF or side as they aIgungit II ne! M 'c'
mtce stated IT, Mr. Louhai II appear he1ri oi lS u,
California; lie was told that this story IN ~ is -l-
and he came home What did he do when he came home
according 70 his own story lie Went " Wbst id Io do
ncXtf Ny learned friend says on ne "uShl ~ N.Y.
arologized Good Heavens! ~ olosze 10 "9om Nt
and thereby publish the original remark J. that linton
Club morality That cannot be. Ap'o-1g 70 ,o IL
public property and public infamy That cannoi DE-
an apo'ogy How did lie como To apology 20
them Bl making the remark IA ne private ca, OIL s
II cannot b. lie owed them the apology because 2t ms
Infamous pVbic tim Of ne story, most pi'ul oIgl
CHARGED #. His apology was accepted by tue pdrue-
concerned Aud to-day 10 presents the wonderful spec
abiding friudship with every ono OF thoSc lerShS Si
posed to have been injured aud the GoYGrnlng r0,lI
tee Of the Union Club champions oil Henry lMhpi'
who bad pubstcd the remark calling him to account
TURNING 10 MEET HIS ACCUsER.
What was the next step according 10 his own story
Having doue what le could which Of course he ought
never to have been brought III the position " 10
turns 10 meet his acciser H. knew what Turnbuu had
said and hc got the report that rurnhnll was circu
laug. lie Incorporates that in letter all a'ui, "
To one Of the gentlemen who was present ana nc
his personal character not attacked h ne WIS Ivy
denounced blackglard or chaTg"n WIN rr rrT9
gvinz him the lie, ana addresse, ttlo ire ger eihh 10
whom. be understood, Tuinun iad to I We Sl%y'
Now that may have been offence IN somebody sNe"'
don't know whose. Thui, 50 narrated, may nave Doel
wrong on LDabat's part 49,, L.. ., ,,
facts OF the Because II your Honor Mas iooWct
me you will begin to see 'he gross nlquty OF tIs
admitted everything. your Honor please nc ADMIRED
nothing They say that there was notH III cO9nlGt re-
tween the evidence which he and That WHEN NE
Others gave. II your Honor please, the Two statement
wide apart as the poles You detected ny ny
al al NJ
needs deiectlOnn his argument putting u III ths wa!
That Loubat went to MI Wiling the P i, Wo ti s
he had not heard Tunbull dcnounce him aS hdcFghd0
but had heard mat the ep4r OF Lo1o' Ms i1 h hal
ever heard aud then, knowing that anu knowing 'h Il1
coHd moi answer an inquiry what lac lad AID or had
heard said without calling that out, he said 10 Mr. VIII
/ VIII write you letter putting inns iti''in' Is
stated by Mr. Turn6u, IN quotation MARKS ana asAliiS
You be said it, and you viii answer BY letter tLa you
did not hear il. and then Will have the written PROOFS 10
convict Turnbuli OF lying Mr. Robinson sau mat
challenge him 10 show ANY such thing. he could not 90
it, Now watch here and see how Our law applies 10 our
case. Mr. Loubat was examined hcf0re tue invest
eating committee and made has statement. He stated MS
substantially as / have fectei 10 your Ilolo!,
and 1t absolutely excludes the possibility ot an! SIcu
viii read it. At folio l2s lie say: This sienced Mr.,
I urnbull who broke ont rs follows; N"D'al p", u
Frrnchman could make such remark. Ara altcI lew
seconds more Of silence added l. Is the most unSen'a
manly remark have ever heard. ~ $50
Thtn he speak, OF hi, return nom California and his
writing his letter 10 Wiling AMI getting the answer oI
Willing a, appears in the circular.
Thcn on page 80 lie is examined by Mr.. Cadwalader
o. notice in this correspondence mere IS great
difference between Dir Vikings two letters; that in one
iettcr OF his 10 y0G ne says ccfIH
TO MIR. 1urnbul, he gives another CONVERSATION. Now
what want 70 ask Is tns: Was iAIN ieier OF Air Vii
inSs addressed 4" !Oi' i"t result .. . ~,
You and hn, OF does the correspondence Sho" the
Al tod him that he had msde mistake; he re-
manned IA king 10 Mr.. Turnhu after lett; cannon re
member anything except that those gentlemen remained
togct nor ana they uusj nave got the
mixed up Dir. 1uInbul sad 1t Was "a most unschie
manly IouaIk lac remained there TALKING WIN Nj
t{~Therc was no luminosity between You
Ave are not on speaking Inn, AZ present Az, VII,
Not an iuilnatOn 81 any ,Uc CONVERSATION with VIII
Ing rs MIR Robinson imputed to him ana found against
him II the Governing Committee ha1 removed MN on
his own statement would nave been ont IN the cold
ljut don't think there Is any man oi sru'r OF H.c-
-enOe that would haYe romo' ed Al on LiS own state
ucut, would convict Use Cow ilh% t"mhn,ite o.
being such >tglt brche1dH aa 10 nave remove ii vi
mark which had hccomc pubic by no net or nis bur hv
the lrcachefy and iu,ainy Of IurHnll ~ aurg L6n1t
However unrea> onaLiy, "a hn6- fhals ne cou 1"Fc
W6at happened They bowed him out; they bowed
,Ir Plltl O8t. Now tlcy -ay that M. fldit Wa ms
.oiod 10 mTcich lir ria;, by nos remembering
,-rqt ne remembers That 4 new WY of np'irlhn
ar,eT to say the evdcnceis overwnelnne against Mr.
Platt don't know what ne means 10y "NrrWHtIHluS;
ana remembers It wo th hI dozen w." d near IL
and don't remember, OF didn't heu II 400" "oh re
Mr. Plat -oy, tio' they told im: 'r Ioubat h'. asked
hot turn :.
van inst sl here ana n-tcu.
Mr. Cadp.1,dcr saws re DOM remember that; and NJ
49,. ,n ,,,.,. + r..u.r,ar trpt or aDvtrn. else
t hon ,,ri maj tool, .,c, Z. p ne remember.
MOI d1 ,lti W. 'ii' a. ~ ..ri,u.l,' saw tn tie
-n,. ti.t M l.. Sir sheldon, testimony
H. C90l.-SIr Sh, dion IN answer TO ms question.
n,, { win re4d il:
Cross ~ 5j,,lngt9n, by Mr.. Choatc.
O-Euai do you rcc1l'ct h-.ns -ld Z" Htr. fI''I ny
g ,,.,,i.c. nf III, rouf.f l,r,.4
f r"c,uocl 5iylns to lir Patt at he was sent for
~ ,, ave. 'nn.itiycy tlo' II We. NOT tpd him
in Substance effect mat hcoo Ilut'e "- NOT '"-iious
ot tc"l2ns a'Y . 45 , i,", ,, n,y'
- Vii t,I swear positively nom recollection mat 40
such thing wa- sl.d . Elias, ,. IL, ,c committee
Al could net e"e3t I'i , IN nm ID,l nom
,o,5 81 ttr slrt tool. place.
OWN you swear poSu'c! uEt I'D S''" 'i"7 '''
yqdi .,.. .. ,. ,r ,. ,,o,l
A-Yc, viii swear positively To the h'0i oi MY lccOI
lection aId belief nothing OF Inc Aiui 'tcII-'h
~