The Hawaiian gazette. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1865-1918, 1884-03-19

tSSSrssN Jc,sS T. Rss&
MiasStsr Il Ne Ia.erfcx.
ThlS defendant tker wrcte ard sent h.
ths, SSs3 JeAR L. ESssA 3 ietser N he
vcssss sRd sSeres hslts~Ssg, tAss i h.
ssS>
heNcartS, luiv = ISL
HIS Exesilsecy JesS 4. BIS. Minss4er
q he 1atsrser. ese.-Sa-s I have he
ho0oy y eesaeUAeSaye reesip. Il war
letser dssed Jsre ~ granting per-ass
ssoz II uaake sssrausys n lbs city, and
tAask wa tx we kin& NSsAes hx tke
saccesS q the enSseStskSnSe
I leave ter San FrsnesSc,, hy tAe rsSit
Steamer, ROW dss and sAsn raske Tie
neeesSs-y arrsrgsEssnsS tyr proeseSing
uyith this undertaking.,
I have the ksser t. Ne SSg, y0vr nscss
ehcstsrs servant.
tSlgnsd W, Fle~rKrEw
Szrst That tbs defendant seeoryiSaSsy
prvcesSiei H. Saa FrsnesssCA sna iresrTrd
Considerable expense in the pcrehzse u
material and cars fcr the purpose Il the
SsiG Undertaking, and e1SsSed an enSs
neer for the purpose u SrpsrinsenS6rS
ths lSying OWN u such trarawsys, sctinS
upcn the hshef thSs he was properiy
authorized BY the SAID john 4. BsrSk. bv
hSS letser q the thlrtSeth dsy u June hsss
AsSt tbs defendant, acting Rpon the S.sae
be6sf, caused tie Plan nsezsScoeSi in ths,
sSlrli paragraph q the Plaintiffs sSid bill
~ b prepared and forwarded 10 the plNin,
tfG- Ard this defendant submits that the
sud John I. Bsssh had god and SufS
cleas authority 10 give the permission
contained n kiS sand letter q the thirsieth
6tv " june, and h. denies that the carry
irs cat u the sad undertaking. wOold
BE- IN contempt u the plaintiffs rights n
liz Msiessy's Minister q the IrterSc-. 10
co1trOl sud SsreesS, " that the same
wUUli be q violation u ether puhfSe ard
private rights Or testr1ckiTs u His
ALsiessy's highway, Y pr~icdSciL to the
dignity u the law, " ! menace 10 thu
pG66c peaee.
>sasasi-Ard this defendant further
ss5sh thx- h x ADVISED ard believes that
should the plaintiff SG1cessd in preventing
tins defendant iron, CARRYING cut his SAID
Undertaking. according 10 the permission
granted ~ aforesaid. the Hawaiian Gov
sruaens : and VII be responsible 10 this
ttsts1tsnt fOr damages sustained by hun
II Consequence thereof
E'pili- ThSt this defendant admits the
several aLleSatfons contained in the 9Th.
sixth En6 seventh paragraphs Il the sud
bill
Eaai- That the plaintiff well knows.
and az the time q the thing q his said
b5lI u complaint vel knew. that this de
PENDANT held the said letter Il the thur
tis5h DIV q June. And this defendant
Z. l. =. 4. L
have the eject stated to be claimed by the
defendant IN the eighth paragraph % the
sud bill
Fsasf-Th1t. On the I45h day u August
last. this defendant received letter truu
the plfInsif IN the vOryis and figures tOl
llElns- that l. 10 say
DEPIErsUSr 0E rEE INTENUS-
H1SuLULC. August Il. lSSS
lIr Nm FLCEERpEw. Hawaiian Hotel -
Hosr Sir- In reference 10 the scheme Of
laying down street tramways IN the city
Of Honolulu. for which yUa clRim 4 min
1sseriIl authority. and which yOu desire 70
inz1,y1rure. and which hAs been the sub
isc5 Of our late conversations, wUuld say
thIt our laEs are quite clear in defining
/ ths powers u 4 minister. and especially q
[ the Minister q the Interior, IN any work
| Of Internal Improvement. distinctly stating
/ that k1s 1ctlOn must depend upon the
Consent % the King N PriEy Council
/ and does not confer On him the authority
/ to act Independently. consequently HIS
/ NEiss5y7> Government feel. that n justice
| 10 the interest yuG represent. a. well a 10
eu1bIs them 10 sustain yUGr enterprise 10
/ llivaE5aEg. they must CONFORM strictly q
/ the spirit OF the l1v, which requires chat
| your proposition should be submitted fJl
the consideration Of HIS Majesty IN Priv
I Council
hzvs tie klnor TO be Jun Obeiient
servant.
tSizus,it CEIs. 7 GUL1ck.
( Minister Of the Interior
I Which letter us answered By this De
/ fs1d1Et On the sixteenth u the szij
month Is follows,
/ HlyULrLr. August ID, 1855
/ Hls EzcsIlslcy c I GCLIck. Minister
/ Of the Interior. ste.-Sir- In answer Il
I yuUr cuumunicati0u Of the IItb instant
IN regard u permission granted ne b
his Msjesty's late Minister Of the Iutsri1l
81 lay down tTauwJys and run cars II the
streets AMI ruatts Of the city u Honolulu
and IL sTIb1Etls. beg 10 say that | have
I M objection whatever to yUur laying the
natter before the PrIvy Council IL yuu =
wish
I have the honor TO be. SIR your NOS;
JbedlsEt servant.
Si-usif " FL0EEznEw-
And tins dsfsnizut / informed and be
Ilz7zs that tine ssii natter has newer bsru
brought before tie hunorahls ths Privy
I Council
E-rgsl-TEa5 On the 9Th and Psi
dfE- Il August this defendant wrote and
sent % tEs plaintiff letters II the words
and figures following that L 10 SAP.
H1SuLCLC. August - ISS:3.
To Hl- EzcsllsucE c 7 GCLrrk- Min
ls5sF 4 the Interior stc-->lr- Having ~
csived report and Outline Of street railway
fruu the engineer l have the honor L
hand yUG cupies flr TUGr information
TCu vii observe that the rails VII b
md frUu the EatEr front at bottom o.
Fort street. I'D 20 k1kui street IutO MN
ann street. also along Berstaniz stree
from Fort street u and Up Suazuu stree
and al0Cs King street frul1 beyoad Oshr
/ prison ruaf % waikiki
Ii ! intended 10 laE a single Iins O
rails Only. three feet 81 inches =ids- iusf
L SIN aL-- -LLAa-E u IL STEELE tLE car
drawn b. h1r=e pozsr OILY
Ihe cars after sunset VII carr tn
usual li-iLts Of street railway cars OF an
uantiI6cati1ls that nay Be desired b. yu7r
dePaTsEeut-
| 10 insure thzf ths Undertaking /
carried CT II proper manner, 1 have -
erred the Services Of Mr. Juli1z h Smith
q San Francisco. IN engineer Who L EsI
sl1En f1r ms capacity and ability. an
wnC has laid several street railways II Szr
Francisco and elsewhere
l have tn k1nor 10 BE- SIr. yoGr ms
1herIsut ssrTznt-
fSignedl " FL0FLzDEF-
E1eI6s7-g=- FE-s. Euginesr's report
ssalF- Nap Of H0noIzia- with Orztline O
street rzIITsy- Ezrk=i n red
H1sqLrLr- Azgzss u 1883
To Hi- EIcziIelc! C. l. GrLrcz- kln
l.stEr q the InterI1r- etc--sir- RsfsrTiins
% nv Letter q the 5lth instant coTsrIrl
engInser rspurt 10 1e, and flzz q H0rO
Ill1- I wish 10 say that tkz statement an
report / relative - tx work intended 4
Be proceeded VIII II present. and L I'D.
VIEE1ur Ersi1S1ce u The rights zrzzEsd t.
re b the lzte zffizzis5er Of the interior
uElell rI-zEs do Mt EzITe= and onIJ
/ f1CWzEd the report and statement for yOgz
Izf1rulz-IQ1-
The eEgI1esr advises re that Il NAY 3,
fund d=sirzhIs 10 20 q rsszrn b. Bere
tzzis street. b1t II this Is decided upon