The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1884-07-20
s0Ms NEW 1OOkA
ASeuaiSso.

all sffeS ft.sas-
Hned ~ So' ,',neS,r anoS,,,sn IT "
no"'ofu " Mi, ,,,,,a .o,rmo ~ .oms 600
bnep"'u" ,a.,h ,,,,h sdmiroh,o c,rcIso,ss.
pas' s. 81 nj, tbo ionJing t.na,o a ,h.,
hu '.,n .'.t,o.o,,v and nnli,,c.i aconom,
toc"n,uo ~. in,i.i,i,o ro.d,r hn. h.a, mr.
oi WIZ. si,a,,a rons.ck n multitude q, hoot.
u'1 ,iio,s Tor ,he most part prin,ed In the
snu ,an,u.yo Whe,bcr one ia diaposod
,n,. ,nnorulIv or iistrustfulIy MT the nav
~" la formulated nv Carl Mary and ali.
soo... , ~. sss,Ilc, no American reader who
,o.n ~, ,o ,yelI informed can AFFORD 70 mao.
,,,,1 ,o,rn,d and oftcn eIoouont e,.
wv w.. ,,hich Mr.. Groniurd ofr.rs ma. ",
po, 4, ,nIi,a,e tho scope and value of tbia
pu', ,,,o,,no hook by showing how tho anthor
NJ. a,,,o ,yr,rlous miscon ceptions Of tina
eolle,v. n'a,hnd. or tho coming revolution In
.,.a ,s.,nrI,,ion o, production and dstribu.
.1U .nd what, In the Judgment OF the
''vn. uI ho Tho effect upon tbe manaae.
-, ,n,irs u,,n the nosition Of woman.
nion ',',, ,ho oducaton and morals NJ tho com.
,,i,v
IT, ,ho orst ,,acc Mr.. GronIund ia carssul "a
,a.,'ns.rato Tim, tho oo6n,rativo common.
.roaI,h contaminated nv German sociaIists 1.
=. w., sonso communicates. 7. "a natural anou1b
a., >, .uy nsonls .houid confound socialism
-i,h communis,n. aimee evon An Accomplished
s,nou,dsr n, tina orthodox noliticai economv
oapouhoe, VI 'no o''uouvA pU'a. .eonoS
INC that the socialists nronoso 10 divids ali
.r,n.r,v intn eou.I mart. m communism In
.his ana. ,he shaker. .,o an examnIa Tat
-. ..., bov tha,r nr;nc,,ioe arc di.t,nyush.d
,r,m ,nos. ~ socisIism In the hoot bafors ma.
"cnr,,nun,ata mate an nronartv nomnon
.ron.,.,v uh,,o on, ,,r,monuooi,h iii, nI.o.
property' ~hiie QUE eommon"eaAsn wiz p'soe
only Tue INSTRUMENTS OF p'oa"cnon-iaho. ma
chinery' raw materiais' anu 30 iortn-uhoer
coheetiVo oonIioi. Ahoy 'eQu"s overy ono "
90 his snare Oh 'aooi' anu a''o" ninn W CON
sumo as ne heeoss oul eoihnhoh"es''n 'e"ves
everybody al peIt"c. hoe''y W WORK ~ niucn
Or as Hue 10 no pie"ses' .. hot ~ ALL out
makes MS Consumption eA"euy oommehsura'e
with MS performances. In snort tne
motto OF socialism ID. everybody according 20
his deeds: whi!e that Oh communism ID. Every
body according 70 MS heeus. Mr. otoniuho
admits that tho com muhis!ic motto Is the more
eoherous. ou'ho suphi.e .ns. Jul TUG soel.r
"'..' "o'lo u. 'n1Io 'ue'' .aAi"S .1"n ns.a
" anu 'ue 'aes 'na' no'ian,s a"A1 HUMAN
h"'uio 40 'uss ."o,I =.
Oh 10 aii"'su I'n . .,. oos"use. nis'. "
MEANS W aoo'eA .no =. y. piopeis'
ahu oee"uSo seII ~ nus IN '.usn-
'ns oa' III ihui'iu"ais' ooei"aan' no' ohiy
reverse ins'oaa ' W '"N'nk pr"per,y away run
eNrsoou'' e"oe .'a o'.aS W ".alo
p,Cp',;. :, WI uu,, '"n.',on .no
VI hu,N'"uHi WV, y. p'"sS popo,' w
~ un.uipe"en"n'o ''s'' 'ua, vi oo, ,r 'n' TO
sui. .. Que lNu'viuua' eA0i.'o..' n'.o',"
w,i ai'"tu INC 'ory ni'sn.'eS. s',siu'"S '"r Ia,
s'"u"i', W ""io '' o'o" VIZ.
oeiohs ~ Tvs posSosso. Wy ING IVORY s''o"sess y.
An '''es' 10 10 eh'oyeu as ne 'n,nAs plopo'. pu'
Ao' 70 w uSeu Az "n ihs'fuheh' iof hoec'ns nAs
Eo''o" c''l%ehs'
II Will already have been made evident that
Mr. Groniund and the German Socialists 60
much further than Mr.. Henry George. who. by
the way. has never professed to be Socialist,
Mr.. George would nationalize the land, but Mr..
tronund would nationaiize, a. We have seen.
Oil the instruments OF production. OF which
iAna 10 only one. Inc latter acknowledges
mat eithsr OF the two remedies proposed In
Progress ana poverty'-confseation OF land.
.! that iess violent expedient tho eonhscation
OF reht-wou'd nave TWO results hiahly bene-
ncta'. VIZ. the revenues OF the community from
lana womb 10 largely Increased. ana the vast