New-York tribune., 1884-12-11
r., sTEWART GETS AvERDICT
,,vr,NcroN OUT OF POCKET 100000.
,,rs,oS OF Mr.. cnoArE's ARGuMESr-rhk
.urRY OUT AN HOUR AND HALE.
= Aox

urRy OUT AN HOUR AND HALF.
,,h II Choate. as the result of SIX days
'o f,rt obtained SlO2.o23 ~ yesierda! ior "''
',, Dayid stewart i'm his action against =. =, ono
. - "a recover the difference between tne r.'0 r,
' - entral Pacific stock. for which NJ h"'''"so"
"a 800 a share with interest ana 'nc a" 90
P''. rois In the Contract and Finance Oonpa"' =.
sn"'o nart suit Mr. Huntington. II was alleged
se"o me stock under agreement to pay any a'
h"' ~ rts which he might pay to any one else 'or
stock. , w cnoote tnok M the sub
S, Mr.. uansiugtons letters to the admission VI
iec' a., evidence mir. Bangs had obected IN the 'riaL
who" " ,,nlereT runs away" said nc, " he generally
"o ~ rs,c leaves something behind to explain the
'n y" :, MIA aicht When Emo went away, ne ieii tho
s c" =, the second National Bank; when mo'ner
s,hau,n departed shc took her Jewels out lc't ner
-. hebinl should like to know why TINS rnoiisueo
- 4, COPY OF which have seen containing '"e'7
-, has no, been produced" Passing to the ques-
-, ,, IN the Jury regarding their acquaintance Win
-, pnsse sage aud others. Mr.. Ch"ate siii that
% Joy .,,,,,d rnonarchs hoased of their power In con
lin, newspapers aud legislatures. and In p"ss'ns
,,s bui he was In this instance that 'ncy eo',
-, c,,t,o the twelve men of the jury MI '"o''o
-, s,rnrsiun cane about upon Mr. tohs'lne io'' ~
- :, N, alleged nortrait OF Mr. Chcac that haa oeen
.,si,sheA Mr. Chuate. with suppressed emotion WI"
90. t,t a,va, lnah IN his eve. said: WIZ h"' f'F
- .,r s,rh neans of ,or,raitnre for the ieatnen
,a,..sl No mo- TN paint his picture az raih'eo "s '"'
immortal baid' ,,,.t
sse ti,at grace IA seated cn lis nrcw , ,,,ss,t
t,snetln,s enfis lauehtrrl TIE ioni ui 3"'e "i'9"
Al tts ise aiais w. threaten ahl tufmanu
ti9niHnaii9n ait iutiil hltth ,,
Nhe,p ttpif eti ih sttis tH So his spaA
a. yits ihn AHA assurance ~ . niah ,,,.
A, es.a ne.t ,.k ap ST. cahbilnss ehafer tha' we
ia.,pssi sa,i na whleh hsihhpl h""Ht '",' W., =,
tieea ana iaa,haf,i 90 siaehhelaefs' "''"-'' a"'
,afor.,a aasips, tue Contract ani ilhahph '""'r''
tiops,ns, was Matchmaking sehene sn' s.ee esaa,,I y
tisa he aplleai,9Ia 2, s i' bs 81 G bs osa o
iuniigions lees TO tauIe on We grave ~ III iianr
hs h"a s"' i've wond he have taken that hherUt " he
weIe now sitting CONGRESS, ateI Tue Ieton :" ~ ,S
ie.rei friend aughterl. wonld he have taken @ th,s
innrtTt Gentlenon might there not be honor even
among Congrossmena Laughter. n%"mu,' % ivna wa, v" a
Boson bosau, is said. hiaeknail suit W nav y !, -
hIaekn,a suit one without foundation VINO say ~
was nni founded IN facti Docs Mr iinntlsloni 40, 40,
lis oblcct 10 call theso Tour grcsi shos w az ~
and compel theIn to disgorgo No. gehtclhsh % u"u'
pay TO call names We must stand a. "n, on "S Governor
did these four men pay Sloo saIc OF nor, ,r, ,i
stanford said that he negotiated for st. Inc pu'n@aSc @
xac stock owned by each. II this not far pur-
chase aud fair sale Mr. Huntington oaud nave SHOW
rat the stock worth 800 The iauloai SUI. sun
re"r,sented honest claims, honest parties la tue
Brannan snit Mrs Brannan, who Ia consequence vi "
nos,tinn of her rights received $4,000 for her STOCK
which WAS bought in order 10 settle the SUIT my
ry never have accounted FOR IT, and theN expect 10 ger
through this world without acconntinS loi III anu INV %
fore the jury. They say this Is tremendous G'i sm n
that MIR stewart should be satisfied WIN MS IA pcl
cent Yes II that is all that belonged To him. anu II e!
had not bagged 400 rcr cent that belohgcn ,o i @
Our cla ~ klsed upon tho difference between the sum
paI Mr Stewart 300 shares at $l3o AZ saIc i',o
that paid Mrs Brannan $425 share Is 81 1oH
with interest from April 2l, 1870. makes - Voo NJ
based Oh the SIO0a share PAID 10 settle IN" ihihpu
suit the sum Is $4,000, which with interest nasos
SlO2023 81 These are not large ilgures cohilateu wiz
the SIi 900 dividend pockoted by the defendant an
those associated with him" Mr ChOate cou'lnoi
with calling attention of the jury 10 the moral eie''
OF q disagreement , 4. a.. ,,,., nm,
Justice Van Worst gave short charge IN Tie Jury hh
then Mr. Bangs presented twenty seven special points
upon which wished the Justice 20 charge inc Jury
The Justice charged about half or them fhcePl"hs
were fakon The jury. after eing out an hour an ha
found for Mr. Stewart basng tie amount on lhr SUN pau
Tor shares II, The ianbId suii. Mr. 'hoate was glNe,
M extra alo OF $1,000 by the Justice VINO g"hru
Mr. Bangs stay Of forty days n which I" prepare '"S'
Oh appeal ,,., a., ,.t,, 81
Mr. Cloate moved to Iroceed to-day win the tfal o
,he eases OF william Patton aud the Asnc~ ana hHlh
wall estates against MI. Huntington The t1h wi'
finally tot down Tor the FIRST MONDAY IN January hr
Patton sues Mr.. Huntington on the snc of 2sI s"los
Elizabeth Paon cxccutrir. on 100 slair thc Anew
estate ON 30 shares tho Aspnwall estate on 900 Sii''
ON e basis the jufys verdict ths wonId maxi w" 80
aidfIonai ciaims against Mr. Huntington amount 10
ln. no