davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24
ALBANY.
CS-CHURCHM MATTERS" THE HOLY
CITY'-PERSONAL.
TBv TELEGRAPH TO THE tribune

Try TELEGRAPH TO TIE IitlBt MI
ALBANY, May 23.-lnterest IN athletic sports
promises to be keener and more extended Guln5 'u'
wear than ever before in the cys history The Bicycle
Cnb has roent ershp of l2O, and recently opened us
new club house The organization promises 10 oecone
the rival Of the Fort Orange Club the membership
which however, Is drawn mainly from oi3er men liz
Canoe Club has a membership of 80, ana VIII take p'rO
in the meet at Newburgh next week The Kidsehed
Athletic Association been Incorporated and recently
secured large tract Of ground on Western-aVe.' Oh
which a running track, bicycle course, and cricket
ground VIII be laid out
over 600 invitations have been issued this week by
Bishop Doane to the laying Of the cornerstone OF the
new Episcopa Cathedral on June B. The event Will DC
noteworthy in ecclesiastical celebrations IN this state
Tho First Presby terrain Church has raised the amount
necessary 10 clear its new edfce from debt Thr"ush
the exerons Of the pastor the Rev Walter D. Nclo'S'
who subscribed $4,000 and Dr. M1chmore OF mia
delphia Editor The Presbyterian, al but So'ooo was
secured last Sunday
tDudley Olcott. president Of the Mechanics ana
Farmers Bank has been elected president OF the PARK
Commission to succeed Rufus W. Peckham VINO assumes
the position of Justice OF the Supreme Court IN june
Trastus Corning was elected 10 MI the vacancy.
Commissioner Perry viii discharge nearly all of the
.orce of 800 employed on the Capitol during lne
next three weeks The conditions Of ithe appropriation
render impossible TO prosecute portions OF tAe WORK
after that date.
Dr. Gaurs sacred cantata, The Holy City was given
Tins wear at the annual musical festival OF All SAINTS
Cathedral on Ascension Day. airs. Garrt smith rel
dered exquisitey the leading soprano part Inc chape
choir was trained as a chorus for the occasion ne oc
csion is OF the year IL sacred music IL 'n9
DENNY state Treasurer Edgar X Apgan. who has been
sriosv IN for several weeks. was 20 r coNaesceAl a.
10 attend the meeting OF the Democratic 9I1'e OVln-
mlttee.
, The State Association OF Manufacturers 81 wraIIns
paper met here during the week and resolved 70 Ill
inlnish production, IN order 10 sustain prices
The late Horace s Taylor. of New-YorL had many
warm friends among the Masonic fraternity 81 ts Guy
a. Grand Master he laid the corner stone OF tLc NcW
City Hall two years ago.
Chauncey " Depew delivered the address 10 the grad
mates oil the Albany Law school Thursday Inc class
numbered A.. chapter of the PM Delta CA society," WIS
established few days before commencement "lth ten
members.
Work on the city water works has been begun
Ex-Governor LELAND Stanford. OF California VIII erect
one Of the most elaborate family mausOcdIs III IIe
country il the Albany Rural Cemetery.
The summer exodus has begun.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24
NEWS FROM STATE CENTRES.
SYRACUSE
BETTER BRINE-WAR SONGS GRlNNELL
ISLAND-COMSTOCK PARK.

ISLAND-COMSTOCK PARK.
IBr TELEGRAPH To TIE TRIBUNE
SYRACUSE, May 23.-An examination oy the
Salt Superintendent shows that the salt wells IN the
ssna district yielding stronger brine THIS year IMAM
they did year ago. On the Geddes and other salt reser
vations the brine does not any percepble change
The product, however, Is finding quicker and more
profitable market for several years preceding Inc
manufacturers all feel encouraged to look for revival Oh
the interest.
Efforts are being made for the production Of novel
musical programme at the Grand Opera House three
nights during the first week liz June The idea Is 10 pre-
sent chorus Of $50 voices, with orchestra OF lor
pieces, which will render a selection from "war songs
ouy The undertaking will be launched by several peo
r, uroinent In society with Professor Grove L. Marsh
musical direction.
Mr. Grlnnen. who owns an island in the 81 Lawrence
River bearing his name proposes TO sell bis properly o
$4,000, and to organize company with a capitu Vi
TO purchase the property build large no'el anu
establish park similar to the Others on the rl'er
The land ia desiraby situated between Round lsianu
Park and Thousand Island Park
Juce Comstock some time ago decided the city several
acres OF land in the With Ward Comsockaye lot
city park The land to revert TO the owner II IL wa"
not improved within certain time This time mas now
elapsed, and the property still remains unllnplo''u
Judge Comstock offers however, TO give second ueeu
60 the city, providing they will fulfil his conditions Inc
citv will probably avail itself OF the Offer
Howard q. White has returned from Oshkosh Wis.,
where he went from Washington with bis Wne' Tue
daughter Of United States Senator Sawyer OF that state
Mrs White is improving in health. and WILL II Is eA-
pected be sufficiently restored in few weeks 10 return
TO her Syracuse home.
Mrs James NJ Gilbert wife Of Postmaster Glloert VINO
for two years or been the leading soprano OF inc
Plymouth Church choir has retired, and will be succeed
ed by Miss Carrie Fry.
Judge Wallace has returned from New-York he taxes
few days recreation now in the North Woods WhIher
in company with q friend from New-Iork, be goes Oh
Monday.
Chief Judge Ringer and Judge Andrews OF the court Vi
Appeals are sojourning in New-YOrk
Miss Bertha Holden, daughter OF F. F. Holden saIle
for Furope in the steamship Baandan win q paILy ~
four Young ladies'. properly chaperoned Tor tour Ia
Europe TO extend eighteen months or TWO years
Asssmbymam James Geddes is at Mecham Lake.
North Woods.
ON lime 10 members Of the Caedonian Club viii attend
the Scottish festival at Rochester.
c The engineer of the New-York express on the New
York Central Railroad arrested and nned last II-'
for driving his CINE faster tnan the Ordinance PeIS
through the city.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24
THE LABOR BUREAU BILL.
A SUBSTITUTE PASSED BY THE SENATE.
THE BUREAU MADE AN APPENDAGE OF THE lNTk-
RGoR NEUTRALITY-SUSPICIOUS. OF THE MEAS

THE BUREAU MADE AN APPENDAGE OF THE lNIE-
RIoR NEUTRALITY-SUSPICIOUS. OF THE MEAS
URE.
ley TELEGRAPH TO TIE rRIsUyE.i
WASHINGTON, May 23.-1he Senate passed.
to-day the bill for the establishment Of Bureau OF
LABOR Statistics. It from the House 1t proViueu
for separate Bureau Independent OF any Department.
somewhat in the of the Department oil AsreuiE
ure. In the Senate amendment offered oy MI. Alu
rich, in the nature OF SUBSTITUTE wac
passed. This substitute makes the Bureau "n
appendage merely of the Interior Department
1t provides for the appointment Of Commissioners Oh
Labor, TO for four yearsat salary OF $1,000 year
he is charged with the collection Of information regaru
ing labor s relation to capital the hours Of labor the
earnings Of laboring and women etc The total e1
penses Of the not TO exceed $4,000 year
Messrs Voorhees, George and Call we're the only Demo-
who voted for the bill IN It's original iorih'
Mr. George felt moved 10 call heaven and earta TO VIII
ness and he wished put himself record at the same
time that only three Democrats In the South had yoted m
favor OF hin which had passed Democratic House
q practca lly unanimous Democratic vote Beng cIihu
10 order by Mr. EdInunds for transgressng pariae,
tary rule in referring 10 the action Of the other branc
Congress he sat down declaring amid much laughtetn a
he ready take back all he had said Explanations
between Democrats in the senate and House for showing
such OF In their treatment or the meas
ures OF each hOuse next IN order.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24

Observation-Disclosures
Observation-Disclosures.
TRY TrTrCR ,pIl To THE TRIEUNEI
NEW


UTICA, May 23.-Ground for the Eureka
Mower Works was broken Thursday Materials have
already been contracted for and tie buildings VIII soon
b. erected.
Work has been resumed on TIE West shore shops no
Frankfort The erecting shop boiler house and foundry
viii be completed within tx weeks This LAS revived
business again In the village
The urn containing the ashes OF General \. W. Gazzam
whose body was crcm1tcd at Washington. has been
brought to this city and placed in Forest lii Cemetery
The funeral OF Captain Henry c. sclradcr was held
from Trinity Church Wednesday, and WAS attended 10y
she military and many civic societies.
Edward Curran, who recently nominated as one OF
the trustees Of the Utica Asylum las declined to serve
ana Theodore Pomcroy. OF this city therefore holds
over Plo s Curtis also refused to serye and ~ tine
old trustee Joseph T. swan would therefore hold over
he has rendered lis resignation 10 the Governor
The Old volunteer fremen viii assist the Business
Mems Committee in entertaining the remen at the state
Firemen's Convention in August. Tie volunteers VIII
give the big excursion TO Trenton rails
The Utica citizen Corps has accepted the invitation TO
becOme guests Company d. CITY Guard, OF Buffalo, at
the unveilius Of tine soldiers. and sailors monument
July L.
One OF the heaviest thunder storms Of the season
visited Cuca ills afternoon. The streets flooded
and there was considerable damage To crops The
thunder and lightning were intense.
The Comsocl Brothers havcpu.cLlsed the old Observer
site Oh Genesec-si
At the annual meeting of the Uuca Mechanics Assoca-
tiou the receipts .he wear stated al $4,000
The entire indebtedness. is $500 All tie officers were
reelected
The Grand Jury has indicted Calvin W NcCarge, for
murder. causing the death OF Theresa Johnson VINO
was found lying dead on her bed Win D1e' through
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24
II QuT ON Governments
PROPOSALS FOR RANGES, STOVES, etc.
JgFFERsoNvJLLE DEPOT OF TIRE QUirrERMAsrExsl
DEPARTMENT,

JhFFttsONNILLE, Inu,, My IsNl.y
SEALED PROPOSE L. in trplicate subject 60 the usual
conditions viii be received az This Office until o'clock m
central stan lard time Friday June ~ 1854 which
time aud place they Will De opened In presence % bidders
furnishing and delivering a. this depot the following namei
articles 80 Afmv Panges, No l. 30 Army Ranges 2,
y Army Wood ~ acrs, No 80 Army Wood Heaters 10 J
No.
Bids also requested for 10 and ranges.
spending In capacity Range No and for number
above 81 other wood and coal heaters suitable for Army
equal In heating capacity TO the various patterns ot Army
Heaters
Bids also solicited extra castings OF all stoves and
ranges offered
The Government the right reject any all pro-
po.als.
Preference given articles OF domestic production and
conditions OF price aud quality beng
such articles ~ American prOuc aid
produ the Pacific Coast 10 the extent Of
the consumption required tho puDho there
Blank proposals specifications and full information - =
bidding etc. VIII be furnished by this ojee on appcalicn
Envelopes containing proposals. sboni plainly msysss
Proposals for Ranges stcves ETC. and addressed 10 the ~
defNgned- RSAxrON
Assistants Qasrtssnssss g6enssal a. q Ar
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24
ROCHESTER,.
FINE ART-ORGAN RECTTAL-THE BREW
ERS-A GLOVE FIGHT
lRr TELEGRAPH To TIE TRIsrNI

ERS-A OLON l. flNrn l.
IBY TELEGRAPH To THE TRIsUSEl
ROCHESTER, May 23-Thc next event OF III
teres IN this CITY will be fifth annual exhibition Of
the Rochester Art Club, which May % ana closes
lime IL The club comprises the principal professional
artists in the city, and their exhibitions have come 10 be
highly POPULAR The Board Of Control which selects the
works TO be exhibited, has completed ia work ana the
PICTURES are now being cataOgued OF the 2-l WORKS
offered 13s we're accepted The works accepted include
many examples from NewYork, Boston, Philadelphia
AMI other cities. The home exhibit viii be unusually
good Naturally disappointment exists at the re-
lection of 20 many works but the standard adopted by
the club admitted OF no course some OF the best
works in the DOusman sIe were purchased by D. W
Powers the banker this city and have been placed IN
his public gallery.
Extensive preparations have been m"ae dnilh- 'l'
past week for the celebration OF kochesters sem-Oen-
tennia June and o. The fireworks of that occasion are
.xpectea 10 be the finest ever given in Western New
York Mayors Edison and Low have promised TO be
present with Governor Cleveland and other prominent
officials
Frederick Archer gave an organ recital at the paata
mansion OF W. l. Kmban, on TrOupst., last evening
IN presence Of large number Of invited guests lie
artistic in which Mr.. Archer handled the inst
nent charming revelation 70 the local musical
critics.
@Cury" Hughes of Buffalo and Patrick Flattery Of this
city fought at daybreak Wednesday, by previous
Management, brakes Landing, ,rOndequoit Bay
Hughes whipped in the third round Nearly 300
Buffalo and Rochester sporting witnessed the affair,
which was not interfered with, though the Sheriff and
twelve deputies present the fought
pominsly with gloves. Hughes and Elattery
arrested. but subsequently released on $500 bail.
number Of challenges lave been issued by various per
Sons since and another fight III the future is highly
probable.
Robert G. IngersO delivered one Of his characteristic
lectures Orthodoxy 10 large audience at the brand
Opera House on Wednesday evening.
The twenty-fOurth annual convention OF the Z. :.
Brewers Association closed its session IN THIS city Ihur
day night with a banquet at Germania Hall, 10 winch
nearly thousand down. II was the most elaborate
and extensive AFFAIR OF the kind ever gwen IN TINS cy
IL brewers over $4,000 10 entertain
the delegates during the convention
Owing 70 the sensational and important evidence,
erfmin sting Dr. A. r. Sherman. which came out TINS
week, he to-day changed his plea from not guilty "
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24
TIE VAL sERYICE TO MEXICO.

WASHINGTON, May 23.-The railway mail
bureau nas completed the mail service between points ~
the United states and city of Mexico The service
will be- daily and the running time between NewYork
and the City or Mexico VIII b days 20 hours and 10
minutes. while the return trip Will De- made IN days
bo1r and 20 minutes The distance is 40 milos 224
miles OF the railroad beng III Mexico. Starting from
New York 40 o. ma the mails viii arrive in the City O,
Mexico at 1.Ip q. u. Coming nOrtnwaM the mail will
leave Mexico at q d. uI reaching NcW-NJrk at 1920
D. NJ The following named ces on the line OF com
nuuicaton: pttsburg C5lumbu-, ONO; Indlanapolis
a. Louis -eddlll Mo-; Kansas CITY, La Juntd. Col; Al
buquerIue ~ "; Renc1n, y. VI. and J.. Paso, Texas.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24
guilty OF criminal malpractice Louisa schaefer He
will be sentenced next weeS.
BUFFALO,.
BASEBALL-HOTELS-A BISHOPS WOkh
FOR A CRIMINAL-ASCENSlON DAY.
Inv TELEGRAPH To THE TRIBUNE.


FOR A OBSERVATION-DISCLOSURES DAY.
lBY TELEGRAPH TO TaE rRIBuNE.l
BUFFALO Nav 23.-The new Olympic Dase-
ball grounds were opened this week by the Bunao-
Detroit games and said TO be the finest Tor the pu
pose in the country The grand stand Is nan ocaeon
in shape and its seating capacity IL estimator NJ i
while two open will each seat LISA Inc secuo"
set apart for is provided with arm CHAIRS livery
possible arrangement has been made for the comfort oil
the spectators The grounds may be reached by several
lines OF street cars.
Harris & Lozbam, pronrietors OF the Genesee HOTEL
have dissolved partnership the former leaving " take
charge Of the Brighton Beach House. and the latter re
tanning charge Genesee and the Clarendon at sara
toga. Last evening sfr. Harris given gold Watch
and chain valued at $3.50, by Buffalo friends.
The communication of the sentence of Frank by Gov
ernor Cleveland does give unmxed satisfaction mere
where he was convicted of criminal assault on chll
and sentenced tO,fve years at Auburn Bishop ky al"
other Roman Catholic officials persisted IN asserting
Franks innocence from the first aud tried To get par
DON The Communication leaves him stu chargeu
with serious offence and the Christian Brotherhood OF
which he is a member cannot receive him back III any
capacity The Communication was largely due 10 lno
efforts of the Bishop. who caused evidence III fI"N
favor 10 be gathered and laid before the Governor
Ascension Day was observed with unusually elaborate
services by the Epscopalschurches this week AtKst
Pauls an orchestra Of thirty pieces was employed Inc
music including condensation of sullivan ; ft'tl'"l
Tedum of Thanksgiving ON the recovery OF the trncc
Of Wales and the sanctus" from Gonnod's Messe
SOenclle."
Robert IT. worthingon. first the list OF those ad-
mitted this week 10 the Bar Association OF the NY Oh
New-York IS son of 5. X. Worthngton cohinsSion
merchant OF this city.
The Orpheus Society which is 10 visit the Beethoven
Singing society in Newton next month, has voted 10
give the latter present worth @lOo
Mrs Langtrv gave two performances OF A NNeS
PERU th week Icorearge audiences but was unf"VoI-
ably criticised by the local press.
Colonel ngerso had an audience Of over 1000 az MS
lecture at HusIc Hall on last sunday.
Letters received from Lockport say that Miss Maud
daughter OF Richard Crowley is dangerously IL at Ier
home IN that city.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24
Troy.
DETESTED GARBAGE-ASSESSME METH
ODISTS PLEASED-PERSONAL
Try TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUSE.l


IBY TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNE.l
Troy. Nav 23.-Aluch excitement has been
caused by the indictment OF number OF contractors en-
gagged in street cleaning for dumping refuse near dwell
ngs and eudangerng health. The contractors threaten
10 surrender their contracts, owing to the difficulty OF
finding a satisfactory place to deposit saroase.
There is rejoicing among tho Methodist- Of this
vicinity over the reroccs~on 70 the Troy Conference OF
the large Burlington VT District cut of tour years ago.
and given 10 the Vermont Conference The churches in
the district have been in state of vexaton ever since
An attempt being made to render Round Lake again
popular as a camp-mcetuc and summer resort Several
large assemblies booked for that place this summer
eresting case will he heard in the Circuit Court
next week in which lawyer sues 70 have his taxes de-
cared paid. alleging that he paid deiaultinE Chamberlain
Church before the latter fed and credit was made nor
receipt given Church who il till in Jail, viii be wit
ness. Church was indicted to-day.
BY an ac. lu.t signed by the Governor tie Old system
by which the city pays for hale the improvements IN
many streets is .eaed great saving 70 the city is
elected The exueuse now be assessed on the prop
erty benefited.
This has been busy week at tie iron works; bnt the
irop-masers say the general trade is dull. An unsas-
factory feeling results romtne Wsl-strec crash tartn
agitation and the Presidential year It is probable mat
the works viii make the usual shutdown FOR the summer
July l.
It's threatened that the through freight traffic from
the Erie road by the uooac Tunnel route Will be With
drawn from the Troy and Boston road and given 70 the
Boston Hco,ac Tunnel aud Western. The Troy and
Boston officials sag this viii Bee 40 great loss ana prefer
the local traffic.
observation-disclosures Samuel Foster. OF this CRY. and
Isaac W Lansing OF West Troy left town to-day FOR Bis
arck Dakota to defend Governor OrdTaY. accused OF
using undue influence TO obtain legislation Tor the re-
moydl Of the territorial capital.
branch Of swinburne's free disTcasarv Of Albany
was organized in this city week ago. Already more
than 100 cases have been treated.
Father Havermans. patriarch Of the Roman Catholic
rest. I'm this vicinity viii celebrate ON June me NIFTY
fifth anniversary oi his ordination 10 TIE pIIealAoo"
Tie scm-annual ordination at 81 Josephs PROVINCIAL
Tbeolorici Scminary viii occur u u fortnight. Bishop
Mckinney, OF Albany, VIII preside
William T. Cramer Editor of The Ecen1g Wisconsin; OF
Milwaukee. after visiting leLlves mere -cl, 81 n
Europe.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24
HANGED FOR CAPIfAL CRIMES.

OAKLAND, Cal, May 23.-Lloyd l.. Majors
was hanged here to-day for eOmpcltym the murder OF
Archibald Mcintyre at lexington Santa Clara county
on March IL. 1888, and OF william F. Renowden at tue
same. Majors who liquor seller planned tne iuI
der then persuaded others to carry IL out his m
was broken on Monday night in an attempt TO escape
wAvERLEY Ohio. May 23.-Labsn stevens the thlru
convicted OF the murder OF Anderson near
Jackson, hanged to-day. stevens confessed Iha lac
planned the robbery Of Lackey, but not his murder
LITTLE VALLEY, N Y, May 23.-Charles B CLARKE was
hanged here to-day for the murder Of his Wife In MS
speech at the galowa, he attributed his crime 10 urinA
McDOSOUGH, Ca. May 23.-Leonidas johnson, a negro
was hanged here today IN the presence OF 10000 per
sons for a criminal assault upon white woman
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24
PROTECTION FOR THE GOVERNMENT.

WASHINGTON, May 23.-1he Senate to-day
resumed consideration Of the bill to provide for protect
Ing OF the United states in respect Of in
cumbrluce property wherein the Government has an
interest. The bill provides that whenever, in the opinion
President 80 shall De deemed expcdieut and neces
slry the Government 20 pay OF prior mortgages OF in
cumbrances property which It is compelled to buy III
seprotecon, the secretary Of the Treasury shall have
authority the direction OF the President TO pay OF
such prior Hens membranes, and the United states
shall IN all such become subrogated 10 all rights and
securities heretofore pertaining the en mortgage,
or ncumDrauce and the AttOrneyGenera IS authorized
L. take proper steps IN the courts 70 protect the interests
the United states in connection with such cases.
Mr.. Beck repeated LIS objection made yesterday mat
under letter OF the act the President could pay on the
Union Pacific Railroad mortgage He was not prepared
10 vest 50 vast a power IN executive officer
M Bayard did 30 that there was any greater
dangers under the bill In respects mentioned tnan under
existing law. M Alderman supported the huh He said
Instances had frequently occurred IN which the govern
men had lost large Of money because or lack OK
authority IN the executive officers 20 of prior LIENS.
Mr.. MORGAN moved an amendment requiring that If the
lien any be upon railroad II should not be pad
until after Judgment Oh court or competent )uris
dctlou declaring 10 validity After further debate the
question went over.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24

House Committee on Commerce to-day II wac agroeu 70
report with amendments Representative 3nss on
regulate the forms Of bills Of adng and the duties An"
liabilities OF shipowners.
CHANCE IN THE SENATE PENSIONS COMMITTEE
his request Mr. sabn has been excused rom ser'ce
the Senate Committee Pensions and MI Wlson' Va
Iowa. has been appointed 10 the vacancy.
For THE BENEFIT OF PRIVATE soLDTERs.-The HOUSE
Committee on the Judiciary has authorized favorable
report Representative Bisbees bill repeating section
121s OF the Revised Statutes so far az 1t operates 70
prohibit the promotion of any private soldier In the Regu
lar Army has served private soldier FOR TWO
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-24
A DECISION As TO UNCLAIMED BONDS.

WAsHNGroN, May 23.-Sometime ago a
trust company in one OF the Northern cities found two
United states coapou bonds OF small denomination the
ownership OF when it unable 10 determine. The
bonds wcrc presented mt the Treasury Department
Tor redemption with tine understanding that tie money
should Ue held bog the trust company in trust for
tine owner il ease he should ever present himself
SECRETARY Foi.er decided to-day that tine Treasury De-
partmenf proper baiiee Of such lost unclaimed
1w-l rzLt OF action against The Make8 Inc owner OF
the bonds obtain them or The price OF their redenp
ton al Treasury Department 10y proving hs claim 10