New-York tribune., 1884-11-14
r. william !. Winch, Of Boston,

.,,,,opat,on. Mr. william j. Winch, Of Boston.
s,s heard for the fret time IN many years. "o
Asve had occasions In the interval I" oePio'e
IN. shsence for with the present scarcity In eooa
sopcert tenors have not often been privileged W W
inch smooth and graceful singing as be generally p'es
% his account when the music In hand Is mol
Aomewhat restricted horizon His voice Is betiu anu
sven In quality and almost the only disappoh'c% % ~
ssuses grows out Of his too sentimental s'!ie' ~
death OF Miss Emily Winant's sister whlcn o
on Wednesday, compelled us to forego 'no a,oo,.
which had been anticipated. OF hearing as'n' - rast
liant singers lovely singing in the " ih"a''. ,ro
April this was the most delightful feature oi ~ % vis
ance- Her place supplied on sno., ort from the
Hattie Clapper who familiar Win 'ho "o" a., ,ho
Co., tbat she had taken part III ~.
,,,ormance Of Mr. william Courtney p"f'f ~ future
spring Ii may not he ainss 10 eothcr with a Latin
PerfoIman wouId be enhanced greatly by an agrge
incni between principals ana consistently TO the
Continental method OF Latin ;,h tHe nsuai Ro-
solo singers gave as the Cs and I" s WIZ" '"'
The Chorus societys concert took place IN n ra
, HaiI, 20 sac,etv sn performed for the third tune
since the choir has been IN ndS,pm rrogrcss in
rcai TASTE has left this beautiful work behind III INC
isi of ora which, To large poTm1n on 1l o Eevcr
seem slightly archaic. or at least oldas,%hcd que damatc
sbeess The Vigorous and healthy beauty Oh the sil
climax Of the work. the conversUdni % smdi.rcc % that
sIed the academy Dr. Damroscs vocal forces 0u. out
,,nmhored those of Mr.. Thonass, ana lh.h w"
by greater vigor This was ontalnou ~
s~ar si,ce the comparison viii intrude tScHJ 49, q"
cost cf refinement in expression anu NoDai id
,ty Neither OF the societies hau ico.' i 20
t,;ilvR from the duness whlch Is az. y,
res1lf from long vacation in which All tnous.s W
sSnoine are abandoned. aud we can accept uV le i,
gTat.flly as indicative Of the performances WnlSm wa wa
Se Gwen later in the season. after dllgcht stu3 h
nrsctice The solo parts of the oratorio wele ~ LII
fands OF Miss Charlotte Walker, MIS- oai"1 a
Earron- Anderson Mr.. Theodore j. IoeGt @ a,a
Mr. MAY Ienrch-a capable quartet as our music ioves @
lnow Mrs Barron Anderson took the pace VI nhIic
CaTre Morse who sang the contrato solos nj me M
rehearsal The change contributed naIslaiH ,aarsnn W
snccess OF the performance, for Mrs barro, was
sang we'll Miss Walkers rellorn"nSso oaoT,
marked nv a common table seri0uSiit,ss vi ,,,oss
ts,s and jntengence Her voice is not OF aIEe colp
h,f it is clear true and we'll sust ned IN o, ~ r,
ton and dramatic intensity Mr. Helnrlch
,'arts and makes the demonstration anew AZ Ncls a.
pasrnnre MIR Toeds singing effective 10 'hoso "ho
fike hs pefsisently lyric style ., sooot ~ the
second mart Of the Chorus societys concert Wch WE
male mn OF BeethOven's minor symphony ule
recjtative aud aria " Don Ottavis! son MOra i'1n 5
:. Don Giovanni, by Nine Fursch MAIL anu W
Festival Procession and chorus from G Gonnhlh
"Onren OF ~heba." Among the hS'cnei'
was Mr. Joseph Bennett, of The London ,Iu"y
Telgrolh an eminent musical critic ana the ooilhc
The boos for Mr.. Nackenze's dramatic ora 0rlo lnc
Rose of sharon which the Corus society VIII peiioi'n
for the first time IN this country on February D.