New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-03
NETWORK DAILY TRIBUNE 1ssLTwELvE PAGES

court next day as he know, TO communicate the
sentence to the prisoner at the bar BadgSn T9' tn me
went homo 10 his house and found reporter OF THE
TRiBrSBf there This was Al . O'Clock lie knew that Lou
notice of his expulsion until after Mr.. King got
up. and 7 don't believe that MI KING gets up very
early he knew that TIE TRIBUNE came out Or vent TO
press o'clock IN the morning aud that Tond spread
this stigma upon LOubat among millions ana unions OF
him away that he might wake upln inc m2rhInB a."
read m fHE TBIRUSE the first knowledge o. MS disgrace
Ml d inc ha3o f ben 2lf r i Of hat strict
guard over himself and his conscience when the law
cx1cts and which natural Jl'tlce eAact7 ITO" c'oiJ
There arc therefore scren persons to scrnle closely
ont OF the eighteen VINO sat upon ms committee
and who pronounced this extr1?rdn 'fy JI tnen e&
ing the wrong man, AMI ccuslllug te Wroi man, "ncl
rroSsiy pati'i juIgmsnt. Tthint I have pointed out
the thlncs which tend to account for Il, and that
the integrity Of purpose % any Of tho Governing Com.
mittee. know how imRercePtibly 10 the party hmict
FOR william Tnrpbai II" "a worthy ofit Tie is man
whose mere friendship might naturally warp the WDol'
Mr.. ClriorIThcre f. no proof Of that
Mr. Choate-ProOf! lie has been In court All tho time.
Look at ain and him Who sly that Cldwal der,
counsel for william, dining companion Of Henry-who
say that ne nis h mse BIS nave been warped
Who can say that King 10 spite " Us rob convictions
Tie ' Wrp SSdI s" OF ne" course. ' BIT It is
unnoc'ss.ry for your Honor to account FOR IT.
enough that cahs But you can also say that there
are indie atoms which for the partially. II is
impossible to draw ont much IN the way o. expressed
way he Winds Of friendship blow And there straws
In respect TO s,rfn ont ~ the eiShle ID.
WHAT THE PLAINrIFF Is STRUGGLING FOR.
Ihave substantially finished what have to say in this
case They ,ay-and that struck about the worst
part Of my learned friends agsaent for II showed the
most IN his legal logc-thcy say Thiss court
Of equity send him TO court OF law to get dam
ages he Is 1gItng Tor mere shadow; the Union CluD
will never let MIN again; il you vacate the expulsion.
they will eIpl him AGAIN. ! douot IL me Union
Judgment that they have made mistake. They VIII
see by the proofs the case, II they diligently
unheard and allowed a guilty man 70 escape.
it does not lie in the mouths OF their conselt TO come
here and tell Won that they viii SH refuse 10 do him
justice. what kind Of argument is that TO address 70
your Honor, sitting here as Court ~ Equity az Chll-
reiiorl You are to do justice, though every
member Of linton Club came before You and vowed
that the plaintiff should never enter It again " we
have made ont you are bound to set aside the YER
TnIess Won can overcome the decision made in the
Hutchinson by your assOciaewhch Is on all folr7
with This ease except that mi ten times sronser for
aside II yon pay any heed 10 the dictates OF natural
Justice abou which my friend has been Growing all day
long yOu bound 10 set that verdict aside IT, Is me
only remedy. Why. what is this man struggling Tort
Forced association with these scntlemenl No. They
may never OF them speak to hn asalu II They see NJ
Forced enjoyment OF the pleasures of the club house
Never what il it thcni Why. II il the greatest and
can ask for What il III A stigma has been
mn upon him by 4 company of gentlemen wirh
whom ne used to associate. II has followed
him around world. II meets him on the streets ~
NeW-I0rk when no IA walking with his friends II
meets linn on the R0uevauls OF Paris when every year
he zoe, To visit his aged mother II hlunts him By night
and 1t follows him by day everywhere. No man can
eVaggcIste the extent OF the mischief and damage
which he has suffered
nat does ne shy about iti Why. that 1t was inflicted
upon him huughtlcssy caIelc5sly by committed 81
gentlemen in whose hands he had placed himself without
hearing had In his defence. or whether he
had anything 10 say they heard lS HcruSeT turee 81
them. Those three made "a charge against MN winch
gentlemen might well consider whether II was ground for
cXuul>lOu or not. And without informing nm what II
was of whur lad said. without giving rim
chance to snow IT true. ami 10 what he
NOT to say against it, they east htu out upon tue worli
and simultaneously they published upon the million
WINGS OF Il press all The world that nc Wia 10
longer tit tor the company of gentenen
Now, II there il cau,e IN which man may WoTthlj
invoke aid Of the Court Of Equity. II there IL SUB
iect on which Court OF Equity may Wortnly exercise
sublime power, IL Is exactly mere aud Tor TINS man Il
lac has been charged with Offences Whch uhnt am ior
tho society Of gentlemen. no wants an opportunity 10
meet charge hc wants II 10 Toe proved and i"unL lie
knows That has committed any s1cn offences lie
knows that no committee of gentlemen, hearing the
Whole rasc can 10 such conclusion aud that te
Governing Committee only to u because they took
tnc evidence bcaild his bacL II II on these grounds
aud great and sacred object that he appeals 10
your Honor ami know that he Wil not appeal IN WIN