New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-03
HINSDALES AND CARLLS.
THEIR RELATION BADLY MIXED.
TESTIMONY or Mr.. AND MISS CARLL-MR. HINs
DALE CAUSES A SCENE IN COURT.

TESTIMONY or MR. AND MISS CARLL-MR. HIYs-
DALE CAUSES A SCENE IN COURT.
When Judge Brown took his seat on the
Queens County Court Bench yesterday. at $3.50 a. m
there were only five men In the besides the jury
men, the counsel for the defendant the clerk of the
court, and the court officers The plaintiffs counsel
In front OF tho Court House awaiting tho arrival OF
witnesses, whom they intended introducing in rebutta
General Tracy read from the Manhattan Beach
Hotel register that Mrs. CARL and daughter OF Brook
Ign, and William X. Hinsdale Of Garden City,
arrived at the hotel on August 90 1880
that Mr. Hnsdac registered their names that they occl
pied adjoining snd had their meals together and
that they sad at the hotel three days and lett the hotel
together
Miss Florence TI;nsdae recalled by General Tracy
and told about her father giving Willie CARL watch and
chain when he lived with Hlnsale family at Garden
City. Dr. Eliphaet Nott,' Mrs. Carps physician, said
that she suffering from nervous prostration and
could rot appear a witness before Monday
Miss Ellen CARL stouty built red haired young ~O
man, the daughter OF Mrs. Car was the first witness
called in rebattal for the plaintiff. She said:
| am 10 years Of age, and my brother Willie IA q.
have been at school IN Massachusetts. In 1879 was
Diobt "' "i'i' ndiiccd that Mr. iIinGsdale
cared much for my mother did not see anything
improper between them. went 10 E,nra IN 1879. MY
mother came to Ehnra IN January and March, lSso She
stopped hotel and stayed there few days MI Hlns
dale was there was az the hotel every night slept
with mother. one morning Mr. Hinsnale came 10 our our
card. took the card. Mother was IN bed MI Hlnsuae
did not come INTO the room sccomPameq my io'nef
there the day after did My brother was quite large
for his age NY father was a mechanic. We lived in
Newark, and while there occupied part OF tenement
house. My mother done the hOusework. we moved 70
Williams I'm Newark. do not know how mother made
his acquaintance when moved to Brooklyn my rather
continued to work in Newark and boarded there He did
came down from Enira for the HOLIDAYS in 1879, and
when returned my mothcrand Mr.. Williams accompan,
led me and went direct 70 the college ana they stayed
the ahburn House. The night Mr. HinSdale came 70
the Rathburn House mother and m self slept together,
and he occupied an adjOnin1 room. Mother ana were
at Newport in the summer of 1880 and MI Nl'hams
stopped at the same hotel with us. From Newport we
went to shelter Island aud met Mr. Insdale there. We
We visited Saratoga White Mountans Portland, Isle OF
shoals and Boston, and Mr. Williams or Mr. linsdae was
with us I'm nearly all those places
just Miss CARL stepped from the witness stand '" X
HIusdae looked contempuoIsly at his wife and daughter
who were sitting close by him. as he did 50, both women
burst crying Miss CARL approached Mrs Hinsdalc
IA il to speak her. and she too began to cry and all
the in the courtroom joined IN the crying ana et
the room II WAS with difficulty that the men suppressed
the tears caused by the pathetic scene, and there was
strong feeling against Mr.. Hinsdae.
Isaac ~ CARL amedum-szcd gray-halred man. dressed
in the garb OF mechanic the husband OF Mrs Carl, was
called TO the stand: He said
r.
to my place OF business in Newark, and told me that my
wife and ". r. lilusd.e were gong 10 elOe UP 10 lhdV
time had suspicion IL my wte's inhdcllty' was
aware of the that my WlIe ana daughter accom-
panied Mr.. Williams ana Mr.. HnSdaie 10 watering
pl1ces when Nr. Iiu-dd.c came 10 my WltcS mouse,
wear before married her. she worked IN silk factory
IN Paterson. she let there and went To dress
making / manufacturing tobacco when
was married After my marriage l
moved 10 Newark and worked "a a machin.st was
introduced To Mr. Whlsms by my wife IN Newark preF-
how long my wife was acquainted with Nr Nlll!lhs
first met bum tnat summer a. Trend or my WlIea ne
represented himself Us travelling agent knew tnat nc
was q married man.
General Tacy-Do You know how they first became
Acquainted or how they nrst met
Mir. Carl-Hell, guess they met by chance.
General TracY-Dm YOU know tnat your Wl,e went
West and where she Went tot
Mr.. Carll-i knew that she went West that was all
General Tracy--WeIe not you concerned .
Mr.. Car-Ncl. suppose was COnccTneu, nut ann
inquire where she went
Mr. CARL continued that he knew they were at water
ing places together but thought # OF his bust
ness. Mrs williams and her came to me and talked
to me OF the intimacy existing between my wife and Mr.
Williams and added:
Mr.. williams son tod that my
wcs cOnduct with his father killing his mother
first saw Mr. insdale at my wiIcs no in Brooklyn i'll
he was the agent OF the Stewart estate at Garden CITY,
General lrcy-Wcrcu't YOU led 10 understand that he
was little prince at Garden City and was glad 10 have
him for Il bOaIdpr!
Mr. Carll-Yes; understood that he had plenty OF
money and were glad TO have HIM "a a bOarder
Mr. Irtton again asked for postpouement until Mon
day, when Mrs. CARL VIII take the stand.