New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-07-09

with WhOOpS ana Nellh OF Delight Ndultu i'hAb
of delegate to challenge a vote recognized in the
convention. If the delegates from State DISC
beyed instructions given them, that was between
them and their State. This convention hal moth
ing TO do with it. He took care to explain that he
might he found voting against Mr.. Grady on every
other question before the convention SenatorJacobs,
of Brooklyn, announced that a. good Democrat
he though Of the minority, bowed To the VIII oil
the majority. ~ III
sat quietly IN the midst of his associates his face
uumnVcd and grim, like sphlhN. II IS arising y"
speak was the signal Tor great conm@tl2n, nt5,
tapered OF INTO shouts of " Platform inc hlu-
tude of the convention was one ot eNtTaoidlhalf
deference and until The tilt between hm ana Cor
ouel Fellows. which followed later on. WIS
over the ordinary rules of parliamentary proceed,
ure were auucated. Ileasantries were exchanged
by the two men. and both took pains to Iecali 10
the memory of the convention mar IN 9'u az ~, 'n
cinnati they had mounted the platform 'lahrn
hands across the bloody chasm and p's'h lt''n-
selves for the tablcau ON the co1t-oi-aIms oI h'ia
tuckv. The h1c xpoue of kelly's argument vas III
one of thc mattef-oi-fact statements with whch ~
opened. ! biz VAS that there we're siNt'-tWH c,Uu-
lies i'm Ncw-Yotk State and only ten oi ln' il
,vore Uemo.r,fic Now the effort was making q"
disfranchise " the great democratic counts oi New.
York. which elects your Democrat, IlrNu'ni.
ilp spoke btioh, and quietly ANA appeal'd TO 'uo
nbrslitv of the conVentlon
r.r,rt>G REILLY WIN GHr,r rt-rrcr
Colnnol Fellows closel for the majority ~ the
Nev-York delegation. llis treatment OF h'IN wa
rvtren.ly reapectfil. II say for him' D." san,
"na nav for uiysnlf that wo have hui oh" common
cud ~ gain and that IL the same ~ ihni ol r'etF
delegate on thi, npor' Calm attention :" the
fact thnt he aud Kelly cnmo from th" Haiu" di"ii''
bo asked what dolcHntcs had oho"n lh'm'
Mr. kr1y snd that the t.r"" prnortnii'
,rp,til,tion. had done H. hccnu.c tnc' lnd Hhnh'n
hnud. M Cincinnati. fclloWs urged tlhl lu'H
rre,lrutinl- had I,,me Iom thc ttut' '"hN'hu"h
Kelly. The great thmg tor ihl. ION ION ~ ~
consider H thisi thI7 gentleman WIsu,- p" t,U,'"
mc. tle won't Notc for me-, AGAIN, Una, Pl'''','
,y '''IS' io TIN! Obligation before l9s; con,
ventiou ndinuru4, aud Mr. Kelly IN
the majority Ihen he viii yot, for me-" 49,.
General Bragg of Wisconsin, and Major
Burkc, of louisiana, ra.cd the Po,,ni
and not Congressional districts. lie con
cluGcd hls speech hy moving the previous Vu' ,l"'
ihcro was sigh of tcl"t, and crir- OF Pu'''l"n, !,
question came from patts0i tue hHll' fN-0'uu'"
Wallace OF Irnnsyksnih. Aaid lu Nthlollau
voice; Mr. Chairman, does the gag lan cA'7t mere
m the form of the previous question , ,,.i
Go,ermor % Ain66.r. and then swiftly
put the prc,ious question and declared 1t cariir!
amendment ii was watched with keen interest
Roars OF applause were given aS the ch"lmnl oi
the several states announced tASI N"t'', lI'I' liI
was tremendous applause when Thomas A. non
drcL, ta4t tAc 30 votes Of Indiana IN IhNoi ol
destroying The unit rule. The vote IN the southern
etate- IN favor of the motion, devoted ~ they are
'A'''A''Nf
sous. Bayard delegates it was aiterwaId
said although feryent for states
RIGHTS voted for the molten In the hope of killing
cleveland of as q candidate. When Newton
was called Mr. Naming SAID that the vote hAd not
been taken. The ANNOUNCEMENT Ol the Fole oil !He
State was therefore postponed until all the oihrr
states Lad voted. Then Mr. Manning SAID New
York casts - votes IN opposition 10 tue MOTION 81
which Is were against the motion, ana 10 III
favor ~ >,
Il challenge the count" screamed W. Bourk"
Cochran. Tammauy was IN great comn"-
to, Mr.. Kelly -t impressive, But ;le o'her
delegates were tossing their arms anCrly. Cochran
and Grady -au down The aisle nearly 10 the Lnaf-
man : desk and demanded tina the vote Of Ncw-
YORK should bc poIlcd Nj. Manning stood oAt lh
the aisle. pae but firm. New-l oGk.' he again
said ia q ringing voice, "New-l )rk under nsti1C-
tious Of her state Convention casts II votes
against the notion
Governor Hubbard said "The Chairman decides
that Mr. Nanuiug's statement - the chairman OF
ths New. ork delegation must be taken as p''ha
facic correct
Th.vorr ot New York was then recorded 2S12 iu iic
Eca.tirr The secretary sul'uI eel ti1i So votes
had been cast FOR tie motion and Ib3 4&'ui-I IT. Z"
majority of l3l votes. iiert was large majority
az. ..it the motion. therefore, even n tue hIt"rh
negative votes n New-l 0fk state lad been ie-
corded.
The committees were then announced ald the
convention Adjourned tll Il q. ILL., tC-norIOW.