New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-04-25
otbor sooetv but whatever II Il, he wa, IN II M 20 nj,

other society but whatever IL Is he was In IL mp 70 MS
neck n tho committeeman respecters Of persons
and worshippers Of the golden CALI Mr.. Loubat was Q
object TO worship. MI Choate says they were
am moi Witty nor funny; but wOnld IKE to quote tho
answer old cOnuDdrm 90 the reason why Joseph
cast into the pit. lie was unit Tor the family
circle.
Mr. Choaters that the only you propose to maket
MT Lonba went into tho club on the night Of November
% 1881 and I'm conversation used language when W tne
report is characterized ne gross ana FOUL ar IDoae @
referred to the expression In the light airy nppant ana
graceful way OF winch he IL 40 consummate master,
and derived from Chaucsf We are not de-
man Conquest but what gentlemen use today The lsn-
euage used was such as gentleman, which trst am,
gentleman Ia his would use Mr TurDbull char
accrzed II at once; and the only difference as to tho
Kmba says that Mr.. Turnbu characterized Mr. Lou6ae
seribed the Ian gaen as biactsrdy AK your Honor
II the Judgment OF tho committee was too severe and TX
is a wife and a mother Mr. Loubat went away 10 Cali
fOrnia and then occurred what would natuIauy occur
made do not mean 20 say that q man Of tho highsss
type would have reported THIS conversations but that "a
Mr. Choate-You do admit then that he repeated H.
Mr. Robinson II he requested hr IIhDu 20 say Aosn.
ing about f. and lie had di-iegarded the reque3 ths
would have been legitimate ground FOR onence ne TO
turned from California, sat down ana wrote Mf. iiIn-
bun letter charging nm Wild mAl , 800 H. ~
dr Choate has said mat Mr IgInhu.s oIrLor ~ 10
than Mr.. Loubars offence IN making tie original remark
II 1t was 90 no was punished by the passage OF severe
ccnsure.
CONSIDERING THE MATTER OF BIAS.
Then, to the bias Of the COMMITTEES. When Mr. Con-
stable prepared bring the LOubat matter before tho
committee, Mr. King inerceded for him and begged tho
president not to prosecute tho inquiry Dir King said
that the names OF innocent parties might DE dragged into
the discussion. aud in This way Mt King interceded
second time for Mr. LOIDlI f4r'r report than the ons
which Mr. CadwalsJer wrote could not have been
written. appear, that the whole matter va. debated
There were friends of ,lr LOubdt present The session
occupied .eycilI hous and two-t rI. Of the
q
send there precnce OF any bias except what may
ne inferred from the fact that be Mrs. Iurnbufs
cousin. Mr. Kings connection with the quarrel begun
and ended with The carrying of letter abost whose con-
tents he knew noiYne Like sooa,na'uiea ieio" as 10
In conclusion, yr Robinson reminded Judge Van Worst
that he had already decided case, bearing some resep-
blance the trial, whore ho decided that ths
Court could not review decision of an organization 20
long as a remedy within the organization tsct had aos
been sought
MIR. CARTER on THE MODERN CLUB.
MI Carter followed ar Robinson, to great extent
covering the same ground but celebrating various legal
aspects of the matter Among other things he said
Mr. Choate has described the Union Club nsttl-
TON given over cards gambling and vine, as utterly
frivolous and unworthy OF con sheraton The Governing
committee am in ed not take this view. To them,
modern club OF which the Onion Club Is representa-
i've f. a feature OF modern cultivated NE IL Il place
whore gentlemen assemble Cor the purpose OF recreation
time, and even the fryotes OF society Games are CON
Stdntly INDUCED In viii not say encouage ~Ine cluo
il ef the instruments for the Introduction OF dlstln;
suslel society, and n u tns nome or
many men who have orhrT. where they may have
their meals IN the company OF their friends.
10 fact, all the comforts there except tic
domestic ones. II II BE- simply place devoted 70
rvolty and questionable l9nguage would any one can
the machinery justice TO rensate anybody lato
It's privileges d.,
Mr. ChOAte has tried 70 inhIenO9 your Honor with q
picture OF the paiutT figuring az a victim OF the 10
Structive influence brought TO bear by wealthy members
Of the club Even tRe honor OF the br became inyoed
said lawyers feared to take his case ms las
been ConspcuOIsly disproved when one or tho D1rs
brightest leaders has stepped forward aad placed al tne
gifts OF his genius and al the resources
" his art this plaintiffs command.
Choate says that We did not know what ta language
is which Mr. LOublt used Let In the FIRST place
IL was 10 lady. Il was known 20 the seu,lem-n in
whose presence uttered In the second ptcet was
OF such character Ia call tOg rcDue. There s0ne
difference of testimony to what form this rebue touA
but there H. no difference 90 tn language which was
used touching q noble lady when Nr Luu0at le.t us
city. Mr.. TlcnbuI repeated that language. think IT was
both improper and imprudent 70 do But what
Thousands of other gentlemen would have done under tls
crCuns stances.
Nh Garter stopped at this point the hour for adjourn
meut having come. The Will 90 to-day 1880