New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1884-05-03

Wffee may hnTe boon q 1ITTe pT7ITT ANU WTTT T'TT
your Honors attention 10 what as 1t seems TO mo- de-
enraes that they were partial You Nl 1 @aap 10
commit any crime or offence ls BIAS tlls 9llln&
impercepthlc and unknown. mfclt aud unrealzci foi
put partial committee man on the stand ana ne Wouu
swear that ne Wit' not partial Tll eEe{ one vi -,
fourteen Governors the stand, aud they woum 7N
they had only the lofucst and most sacred jndicai
Now lei ne soc-and here f. where The merits OF the
Sf S drF reeg ara the 2ny RGa Fl
Governing Committee ofhmsercs shows That they turn
mcut Of the Climb 10 Jay although this IS outside of the
record AID have no rg GIT to speak OF IT,
Your Honor has heard the story Let me- read II as
appears n evidence taking that which they had no
right to consider bat an by mistake c,n.l lex i'Ens
Taking ultlgrf,r a. limited ct iu the report ana
would he stated by my learned friends on tho other
made. the offensive rc,art-wlch apparently never
T geo qo Mn y , ly N y o or Tor mans H. THAT
dd not increase LoUIat. offence, dd IT, or4pon Ir Car
Mr.. Louhat goes 20 California Turnhul publishes the
romarh and mis- charge nude IN cons l'ce OF IT, oun
the further accusation that Loubal hd run away I2i
bat hack ienouuccs it false, gets the WHINE
letter. aud sends proof Of the fal'ehood 80 i ~ ~
would ~ Then. II bong known a. !e' abPrtnt,H -
ONLY twelve fifteen persons Tunbull and HeunoD, ana
Trayers gc tocrther and concoet TIE eirc1r h -, %
tribute II hroadca- through the boxes 81 he cp y" @
thoutand members and the pcN week u gets out ''o
Tirrc Is the story Here vou have the respective c'c
mons ~ offence side and on the other IouniC
made The remark which ought neycrt' nave D'cn I'-
Wr. Clrtcr-Ought never to have been made, yon
Mr. Choatc-Yea ought never TO have boon made
Bnt the PT5he eeecr in respect {? ~ consists - WI
Mr.. CIrcr-Don't commit me to that opinion. go
MI Choa,c The public repetition me sGheri pull th
greatest offence that has come into view ia the case, aud
almost the greatest offence that one Gentleman cOIh
commit In betrayal ~ another. loublt singing under
the whirlWnd Of passion. which must naturally nave
been excited by the charS' OF Iurnbul writes nm 'l
ter and gives him the ie-unreaSon'by II You please
Then Turnbu 1t being yet matter within the control
o-I nr. lp 4.
not by whom. 10 publish to the word. Ihere, Il an
other very great ofencG me case as 10 mos Two
fore the Goycrnns Committee who cXpcl Lpuolt am
mHdiy ceisUe Tumbu. Guided by the moral STANDARD:
whicl says that TTEhuls offence only deserving or
Cen>urc. Whrl would never 40 beyond hlmSe ana lhc
connitiee-mcasurcd by that moral standard tel me
how expulsion could bc visited upon the minor Offences
o. Loubal wonld Ike 10 have any gentleman OF inc
WV the Parailty is Of tic srosseSt possible kind Your
Honor Is not to pass upon nc intrinsic merit OF me
ceuslre. or on tho Intrinsic merit OF We expulsion Oh
Will look TO whether the committee was partial or
They all agree to that.
HOW THE PARTIALLY - ACCOUNTED FOR.
call your Honor's attention to those in-cnsihe
influences that work upon the minds OF honest men
meaning yet to do their duty How do you account
for that partially. how do You account for that
unequal, that grossly unequal result keeping in
Club the who had been guilty OF the greater ana
cNeilng tie mon " 40 MAJ cOmmt"i the MINOR offence
WELL YOU find thai gone o judge, "ae ahoar relhfG?t
Iurnhul ana tidl no hS'd tuc olH'ts 20 cAPIi us us
enemy To keep in lis knsn Tuo lac certainly d, Tor
he seconded the motion. You hnd man sitting there
as Judge who ought a. have been there. not only VOt
mg himself but urging Ills n-ooc t1cS ny lhe p weight
OF us personal authority lou ma hrothci Of iur
bull on the committee man conc r",% ni9'i' III az
the Investigations Ot this case nothing pat g"Cd APPEARS
a who appears 10 have been cAceedlh-y aytNe' am
his Associates -a an cNcctuhsiA llHI ~ % W
committee What l. the situation IN men no was pbtu
saw n word 10 him Bui anybody who knows william
Tirnbil ~ well know INN, knows that ma as,ocl-
atcs IN thu committee would against themselves almost
against tho e9''ltnces' nr ' , ll' ,i 'iC '' D
coma 10 he'P i"'' mp 50 go r ofi'r y,trb
Gcy would not ind Tor IOdnat. And then II YOU ina
thaf. three night, before Henry lHmb1l had been
tins Governing Committee. aud that another OF mo COY
ciuinI Committee was fellow guest al mar lS3 na9
hcir legs under The same mahogany nom clock utu
~" u a'n,T N6nid t,,,. NOT bc y ma lie involuntary
IuiuteHdcd bat inevitable inclination IA IaNOi
oI lulub.u and against LoaDai I1cu You und
hing las been sid and Justly said that might
.o'' va ~ iua1su.i in lie committee and in tic club
the ,,Hlm T., pUrc0 o. uo Union Club itself He's
the Whole ncorpOrltcd Ia one body mean Tor the pm
pn.os oI .Oycrnncnt. Tor tac purposes OF influence.
Ga, Uuou Club. VINO upon Tue atah' a3It, 9',"n&
lrSr.i bus against Loubl Nontind his relation, I" Lou
bat little str.uc and H. Rotations 10 iIulli li,t,e
l,G,,; To- ioina " men TO med part
laloU came he carry that! N, H ne lciut-iei df
King himself aIr. r.nunt Is probably tne mort inhn-
entmi iac,or IN tIc CnoL Ciui Bhh"hl' 7,f iGfhon;
rin5 of sci ctr,,c c,, Belmont aud Lo
j. it authority on tc sub ec are not 10 Dee trusted 10
Non't You tai- ~ Wei. King lakes up The lcttcr
lie d., not hA. tie looks 81 it. smells Ok IT, doe rot
orl u although il j. uu,ealcd. Sad he: j. 10 Eo,tiel
No. no. .as Iumbui, 10 /, mot hostile II Is merely DC
W, IL IL i, not hostile. if it don't reJu me o barh II
up Iwil take H. u b, J. no. o-.,i Ae "'il me- IT. Oh,
e implied be would mot IaAe ho;Ji ho,e one l''l Ae
would L.lo To stand by and second b1t Doc Eold C0Me
a- near colt tat iu Tie service 81 las irhd LGihou
lc -ayo hr Was h' l-i'ic.,". iitAd anu nc only
I1Jacuof l0 be t.crr. tat "as all
Iie ,ouh-Was not u..t heut''. l'I iAe next "'y ~
his tal me-.lgc nom Fir lou'li lo inc oiHti -nt
Af. tuuate-N0; rccti-e tu1t s what Le wa Sent 10y
Iuu'dd 9" set 1h. N.a 5'i ' D br iii
completing lhe ln'4i- n'7i,' I' Bay -.I ,
NOT get ipub.t out @. bed, Dat rcc04tc'Io9 might ul'eI
VII inc letter says. oliver X. King, my friend tins
lotion send yoI by tlc hands OF o. r. KING my l!rhL
bid nr,sat II ont alG asked hu E" dcit-r i, In lea q.
cLS.r boy. brc"aie &c h1t itI 10 H!,ot 'il, am
y , o.H nf ig'iIr ""' 10" '' Ny '''0' - ~ 's'
Mp. RI<G's RELATIONS Win MP. LorHAr
Then Mr. King says he was a grcat friend OF William
TlrnuH Let tba. 20 lOr what it s worth VIVA. werc
hi. relations the other side, with Iou5a that saw
were stlaincdl he SOY, they not lie says. we'll
he Vas ON about rs good term. with one with the other.
Let us see. II appears that IN March 1850, Mr.
Ioabat wa. permitted % give dinner al tie Union club
ia . private room 10 some swedish officers whom ho VAS
entertaining. \ gentleman. another member 81 the
rooms vc'e separated by folding doors each having
door LEADING into tHr hall While LoHpils IiHnrf "a'
progressing there was noise oi -houuhZ ana ppoAr III
,c other 0OIn. don't aupw hos II arose Mt tttItr
SAYS il one Of the features Of the mon tnp 10
have me ih'-' iliIl- 10 WV 'id thN t'ii'''
81 any rate tine uuruJr arUsr. Mr. IoHba sent down,
u.dut that Mr. I'm; WIS ~ the room below: me pune
r1o 40 dinner ant a-',rl mat the door of Johh-ph7
room might be closed. 40 satisfaction Is obtained al
though King agree. tiat thlt wa nc only remedy posi-
bir fnr the Orci-uu THAT LrJhat had. 1h'tc VS. an
active man tho Governing Committee. secretary ol
a.. ami Inn mo lori-c who had authority t0 Afford him
t remedy that hc ought have hal Mhcrcup'u Dir
Ioubit goes down and appiolcirs NM nl WIN Et-lcn
i,fi,,. ami with .hru-s of the shoulders, aud with
i,lpu1frun, of tIe eyebrows aud all kinds OF maurc1-
ttiput irn only % frcucEWan can produce he Irtht-
e,.I 7Tr ug very uIcl aud SAYS that il ne does not
order tu, door shut hr viii hold hu personally tr-ponH-
bia Now yoI get Mr.. King twice over involved lu a
,~ rr.,if, .bity. One, when ho WI5 TO carry tutt
i.ft,r Vncn ne found NOT hostile, und then hehh
ti, threat ~ I,uh3t 80 hold him personally ft-pph~e
Tor not dong his duty, as iaupat Thought We'll, Nl
KIM IL very indignant ut that, r very angry anu con
ilIu.- ifi.lv for - NrIr VItn loubat 1ut DE admits
How doe. ne prOcrrti he b, one oi INV House On
uI.ttrr. Hive The House Committee any authority To-
rru,.ie .uoIy} no They Wc ctpccLulv restricted