Arizona weekly citizen., 1883-12-15
AFTERNOON SESSION.

Lawrence Muran-I drlve delivery
 wagon; recollect the shooting of James Levy; saw defendant and Levy Tn a saloon the night before; heard Levy and Murphy talking together; Mover was close by; Gibson talked the most; Levy said Murphy, I've got nothin' against you, but if you want to fight, I'll do," they talked about going to Calsbasas; Levy offered to pay for hack; 1t would cost T30; they were to leave at 6 o'clock; saw Mover that night; saw Gibson and Murphy go up the street; was at Carrolls corral when shooting took place; could not tell how many shots.
 Dillard-Was rooming on Church plaza June ,, 1882; was about 30 yards from Palace at time of shooting; did not know the parties who did the shooting; the first shot was right in front of Palace hotel door; the first shot was fired a man ran out of the door. and they kept shooting at him; saw Levy dead: could not tell how many shots were fired; do not know Mover
 T.. J. Smith-Am an undertaken; the body of James Levy was brought to my place; examined 1t; one wound on one arm; one ball went clear through the body; another went through the neck; Chief Buttner brought him; he was buried from my place.
 P. DrachmGn.-Keep a restaurant; kept a saloon opposite the postofiice ID June, 1882; Levy passed me and mis- took me for another man; knew Mover by sight; after leaving me Levy went to the Grand Central; Murphy passed me a few minutes later coming from Grand Central; did not see the shooting.
 Mir Barker.-Reside in Tucson; am s druggist; remember of Levy being killed; knew Murphy and Gibson very we'll: was slightly acquainted with Mover; stood on the old Maison Doree corner at the time of the shooting; saw Levy ten minutes before the shooting sitting on bootblack stand: saw Mur- phy and Mover pass; they had no weap- ons that 1 saw; was talking with Levy; Levy noticed them; they said nothing, Murphy had always been a casual friend; had advised Murphy half an hour pre- vious to the shooting to keep quiet; think Mover was present; had nothing to say to Mover; requested hlm not to do anything violent; be was very much aCltateo: said he was not afraid of any thing; shortly after our conversation Levy went to the Palace; crossed to the old Maison Doree; as soon as l got there the shooting began; 1t commenced not to exceed five minutes after; saw three persons shooting; saw flashes of three pistols; could rot distinguish Murphy, Mover and Gibson, hence could l not swear 1t was them; should judge 10 l IT F shots were fired; could not distin- | guish faces, because 1t was too dark; | saw one man follow him across the street 1 and continue shooting; felt of his pulse; l it was very light; he gave one gasp after | I saw him and died; heard Murphy say l to the Marshal, "he needs box" did not | see Gibson or Mover; Dr. Holbrook and | myself took him to the morgue; he had | one wound on the right side, near the | jugular vein; another near the iugulsr | vein on the left side; one in the side; | and one or two in the side.
 Mir. Barker Cross-Examined-Quite | sure saw the flashes of three pistols, but it was to dark too distinguish faces.
 l.. Whipple-Reslde in Tucson; am dealing in faro bank; was on bank steps |