New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-02-02
SCENES IN THE CHAMBER.

roar. The bill will be submitted 10 the oena'o
as soon as possible.
SCENES IN THE CHAMBER
THE VIEWS OF NJ. FALLIEREs-M PAUL DE CAS-
sAGyAC CAUSES AN UPROAR-THE PROVISIONS
OF THE BILL.
PARIS, Feb. I'm the Chamber of Deputies TO-
dav NJ. Falleyes. President of the Council being
absent. NJ Develle Under Secretary OF the In
terror read the conclusion of the Premiers speech
on the bill for the exclusion of pretenders from
Office. ,
NJ Fallieres argued in favor of the Governments
proposals that the Comte de Paris by recognizing
the Comte de Chambord, had reatfirmed the claims
of the Bourbons The Republic. therefore, was
justified in taking precautions. he did not ask ior
the wholesale expulsion of the princes, as SUCH
violent measure would affect some inohensive per
sons. The present measure did not threaten the
Army as it was aimed only against system Oh ap-
pointment by virtue of royal birth which was
derogatory TO the rules of promotion Ii was un-
necessary that the bill should provide against the
event of n congress of the two chambers eecting
pripce as the President of the Republic, as 1t SIMPLY
enacted precs cautions and did not ann AT placing
obstacles in the way of any manifestation OF the
popular will.
NJ. Nader de Montjau, Republican urged the
Immediate expulsion of all princes.
The general debate on the Governments proposals
was then declared closed. and the Chamber ue-
cided by a vote of 396 yeas to 1874 nays to pass 10
the discussion of NJ Fabre's compromise bill. NJ.
Andrieux. Republican, proposed an amendment
substituting for the first clause of the BILL deprlv-
ing princes of civil rights, declaration of the
rights of man procaiming that all citizens of the
RspubIic were equal before the law, and eligible TO
all Offices according to their capacities. Nj.
Audreux was loudly interrupted by members OF
the Left He declared they had no night to INTERRUPT
in the name of liberty. The bill, he said,
was merely an advertisement of pretenders, OF
whom tlfe country would otherwise be ignorant
He did not admire the little Robespierres and 81.
Justs vino parOdied the blo0d-stained page OF MS
tory. NJ. Andrieux withdrew his amendment,
which was reintroduced, slightly modified, by M.
Cuneo dOmano Bonapartist but the Chamber re-
iected il by vote of 2S9 10 90.
NJ PelIetan amid the protests of the Right and
acrimonious disputes, urged the adoption of NJ.
Floquet proposal The Prince de Leon, Legitimist.
said he wondered that general could have been
found in the French Army-The remainder of the
sentence was drowned in the uproar which pre-
vailed butit understood to refer to the accept
ance of the Ministry of War by General Thibaudin
formal oensure on the Prince de Leon was passed.
NJ Deves Minister of Justice, declared that the
question lay between NJ. Floquets proposal and the
placing on record the power of the Republic to pro-
tect itself without necessarily exlllng all the
Princes.
The frs. clause of NJ. Floquet's proposal was re-
iected by vote of 352 to 172. Several motions for
an adjournment were then made but the Chamber
BY vote of 2S2 to 115, decided to continue the sit
ting without any suspension until the proposals
were disposed of
General Thibaudin said the question did not set
precedent for depriving officers of their rank as
the pre enders would be placed permanently on the
retired list. As Minister of War, he formally en-
tered upon the engagement to carry out the law as
passed. No disloyal influence, he said, need be
feared in the Army, which was wholly devoted 10
its duty and would, if necessary, energetcally de-
fend the Re public.
NJ Ballne's proposal easmerlng 5 the 1 orleans
Nj. Fabre's bill was passed by vote OF 343 to 163
and the Chamber adjourned for a week
Before a division was had the three clauses OF the
bill were separately passed. The first clause pro-
hIbits princes from filling any civil or military
post. the second empowers the President to decree
their expulsion. and the third enacts penalty of
from one TO five years Imprisonment for violation
of such decree
Deiaiosse BOnapartist explained that he and sew
erai members of the Extreme Left, having them
selves prescribed, could not support the bill.
and he urgently appealed 10 the members of the
Chamber similarly situated TO abstain from voting
The debate in the Chamber of Deputies lasted ten
hours. noticeable feature was the Rights organ
lied system of obstruction. NJ Paul de Cassagna
tsunted tie Cabinet with having been unable 10
find Minister of Marine He objected 10 the
statement of General Thibaudin that the soldiers
were devoted tO the Republic. 4" The army belongs
10 France" he said. when you tell us to go get
killed ior France we shall go, but not for the Re-
public"
Amid a storm Of evaporation and disapprOval
from the Left, N. de Cassagnac declared that the
army was demoralized by the proscriptional meas
ure and that the turn Of the Princes friends would
soon come.
The Expulsion bill will be brought before the
oil lie
President Grevy continues TO chersn the nope
that he will soon have occasion TO dissolve the
Chambers. . -,
ST. de Mahy, Minister of Agriculture, has been
professionally intrusted with the direction OF the
Ministry of Marine. ~, "a,
LONDON Feb. "A Vienna dispatch to The Da,ty
Telegraph says that the convection Is gaming gio9u
that the French are the eve OF fresh trOuDie.
The pos of affairs is likely to grow worse before
II improves. The crisis has thrown Frances rela-
tions with the European Powers into confusion.
The StaadarPs Paris correspondent says that the
debate in the French Chamber of Deputies yester-
day was poor and tame, and would have been mo
nOtonOus, but for the tempestuous scene at the
close. an.
The Daily Nems's Paris dispatch says: " Diff
ferences between NM. FALL eres aud Deves
reading the remainder of NJ. Fallieress
Speech in the Chamber of Deputies yesterday,
a. was expected General Thibaudln explained
that the Expnlson bill did not strike the Princes
of the army roll. but removed them from active
service, leaving them their rank.
nup mn, .rD.D DTDE IyYESTIG aTJON