davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21

The transactions in State bonds amounted only to
$4,000; the feature was in the bids for Arkansas
Ia to the railroads DEALINGS in city bank stocks
included forty shares of Fourth National aud I'M
porters and Traders.
The market for railroad bonds was about as dull
and featureless as was that for shares Texas and
Pacific incomes rose %, but frsts Rio Grande divis
ion declined 1s. Fort Worth and Denver hrsts were
strong without further advance. Missouri Kansas
and Texas general mortgages were 4 higher. Erie
second consos were dull, but sold up 80 per cent.
Chesapeake and Ohio frsts series Is were of y,
Canada Southern firsts were 4 lower at ooA. New
York. West Shore aud Buffalo 5s were 4 easier ana
Northern Pacific frsts aud New-Orleans and racine
were steady. New-York and Texas land scrip sold
nj 81.
The Sub-Treasury to-day -ained ON balance
1922, 1872. made up by gains of $276498 coin ana
$40 226 currency but Its cash balance was reduced
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
COURT CALENDARs-MARCH 81.

SUPREME coURT-CBAMBERs-Hed by Lawrence. J.-Cal-
endar called at IL mNosl3 10 ~ 49, ~ la6 d4s %
i5e 1877 1855 1871 22 22z 225 226 $780, 1885, $780, 24s 252
253 $50, 264, 279, 2s9
pTsdY and Da"el. j. Nos i46 6S 1914 les iG Gs
10 s5 1907 III ia ia, l76. l7d. l7s. l79, l6 $780,
1870 1888 1874. lsj. 1856. 1877. -
SUPREME CoURr-~PECIAL TERM-Held by Lanemore. g..
Nos 1855 1865 65S 397 ACT. 722 $50 1885, 25 5C 1853
69s 2s1 1885, 243. 100. COS s76 6is 45s, 022 o12 4S
054. -, ,,.,,,- ,o.....
Nos 1882 1898 81 81. POSI- 2245 262a 20os ll2l 2g2
267g 2G86 26SS, 2760. 229 235l 2665 23l0 goo 419
% a 28eO $3.50 1887 26i0. 25g5 esq., 25oi 1851 263s
268e 1888 2fO3 27O5 27O7 270a PHO. 27l2 27l5 FIG
272O 272l 2f25. 2720. 2727 27Z9 1880 Z3 2f"2 2fSo
P3Rr II-Held by Barrett Case on-No 1926. People
agt the Metropolitan Telephone and Telegraph Company
PAIR IIf-Heid by Worst J-Nos. 1925, 2t09 248l,
767 1873, 374l 800 2476, 25l5 40 AZ p
2ls2 25O9 25O5. l157 PAPA 1887 $685. 4OS5 24lS 242O
suaRooArEs CoURr-Hed by Rollins s.-cOntested will
of James Stokes at IL a. III. , ~,
SUPERIOR CoURT-SPEcLAL THRM-Heh by rruax, J.-Cal-
endar called at IL a m.-NOs as. Al, 63. - 49,
SUPERIOR CoURr-TRIAL TEgH-PART I-Hed by Freed.
man JNos 7s $40, 7eO $780, 696. 443 6o4 $685. e9l w.
PiEf iIf"Heid by Ingraham, Nos 7o7, 7os. llol.
1853 1863 ITO iii liz ii7S liz. Ii75. l76 ll77
li7S ll79, 1880. 1881. 1882 -
COMMON PLEAs-SPEcIAL TERN-Heid By Beach J.-No
CoSnox PLRAs-TRIAL TERM-PART I-Hed by {. ?. Dali,
C. J-Nos. 2440 24lI. lSI9 2ll 1863 1882 81. 2llo'
PART II-Held by Van Brunt, J-Nos 27ls, 2772, $40
26ls 1863 2s7O 287l 2s72 2s74 2s75, 1910 2s7 2s7s
2879 2sSO 285 1882 25S3 1884, 1885, 1885, 2SS7 1888
20oJ, 1880.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
THE COURT OF APPEALS.

ALBANY, March 20.-ln the Court or Appeals
today-prescnt, the Hon. William g. Ruger c. j., and
associatesthe following decsions handed down;
Tag axt Kettetas, Motzser agt Hermann Noyes agt.
RaiIsy Cosle the Cornell Steamboat Company Lanetot
agt the Troy and Lansngpugh Railroad Company Fish ag
coster-J M gnent affirmed with costs
In re- application Of Thomas W. Church-order anirmed
me People agt the and Traders Savings Tnst
,pon-rder General Term reversed order OF special
Term affirmed with coats -. >-ux,., ,s.,
r.yeysssd New trial granted Costs to abide event.
uunter agt Herrck-Judgment aihrmei and Judgment
absolute on the stipulation. with costs
The following motions were made:
NO 1oG-The American Hosiery Company agt Thomas NJ.
Riley thsri-On motion, action rc"'oa IN name vi JUN w.
Naomi s. maris executor. agt Horace Hiscock-Motion
for reargument subuited - n r.oxson uo,,on IN
In re Mary Clemens agt Theodore r. W
advance submitted -. ,,a.,.. 90 ...o..
MsTy Reid McCunn and others-Mouoh 10 amend
remttur The Court took the papers; IN, cr. toni nh.
eOrge Crawford ag West Side bank-rhe court 'ooA tne
papers. c.r...or %. .r, rra,c,s IL Huber-Moton
10 dismiss appeal
Appeals from orders:
No 4s2-Jsne Vanderbilt administratrix, etc; appellant
agt John schrey ger rcspOndent-Appea dismissed uder
twenty one
NO e02Edwsrd Freel sgt Thomas r. Buckley aud others
no. Foster and others respondents agt the
city OF Buffalo. appellant "A igued - No., ., e,.L
6l3-The People, etc, agt inc open boaru Vi Sto0A
Brokers' Building Company Argued, ,,, ,... IT,.
No 624fns People ayt the Mutual Lie INSURANCE CON
pmg s,aIn re- the opcning Of
No 6lO--In 10. William A. RICHTER. TO yaeate assess
S 1i si1 re- Caroline C. Bishop to vacate-Argued.
No 627-Rotert T. smith and snoIher' ApPeoan'S AZ"
Johp B Davis respondent Argued. -, =.
No G3i-In reio Leake and Watts orphan hohe'o ""cso
assessment-Argued 1900, 49,. =, ...o,- No. al
The following IL the day caicndsi of tom"fo"' Eos 90
"a, ~, 81, 10. 81. 100. ov.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
CIVIL NOTES.

The General Term of the Supreme Court
yesterday handed down decision reversing the inunc
ton obtained by Leonard Grover, restraining Garry
Swain from playing in " Cad, the Tomboy.'
In the Special Term of the Supreme Court,
before Judge Larremore yesterday. Giovanni Grlone
was married for the second time at the OF forty
seven and Maria Klein for the third time at the age OF
fity-fve years.
The counsel yesterday summed up the evil
dence in the case Captain Irwin Archer whose e1-
tradition charge forgery is sought by the British
Consul. Colonel 4. t. Wood argued for the deendanl
and f. +. Marbury for the British Government Com
missioner Osborn agreed 10 render his decision to-day
Victoire Sevestre recovered in the Superior
Court yesterday verdict against the city for $1,000 as
damages for injuries sustained by her through falling
into an open trench in seventh-ave dug for ayng
pipes On former tral she mao recofereu S<VVV'
but n new trial was ordered
Judge Brown, of the United States District
Court yesterday rendered decision In the civil suit OF
Simon scneur against the Albany steamer Drew for the
loss of goods delivered TO j. Kastendike OF Albany,
presumed swindler using the reputable name having
bought the goods and received tnem The Judge holds
that the ners OF the were not guilty ofhny
negl gence delivering the goods
In the Supreme Court, Chambers, yesterday,
Justice Barrett made IN order directing James NJ Van
Note TO show to-day why he should not pay TO the
attorney of Henry Cooper money TO enable Mr.
Cooper to defend himself in proceedings instituted
to declare him lunatic. Mr. Van Note was appointed
custodian OF Mr. COODerb estate, pehulDg the
proceedng- aud the appointing him custodian con-
famed an injunction restraining him irom paying out any
money except for the current expenses OF Mr. cooper
business.
Judge Brown yesterday gave his decision in
the case Of John A. McCaull against Lillian Russell In
which temporary injunction was granted restraining
the actress from singing under any management except
that OF Colonel McCau The contract under which the
Injunction was obtained expires on May l. Judge
Brown makes the injunction permanent the following
conditions: That the defendant may not be sent to Cal
forna without payment OF salary for time spent on the
route: that the defendant may not be compelled "a
travel 10 distant points while she IL not In good stalt
of health and tnat h to be paid 81 so week Tor each
week after sue shall have given notice that she IA pre-
nared 10 act under the contract II the provision FOL
the payment salary is not complied WITH th'
defendant may Two days notice, AJAX for dissolution
of this Injunction,
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
vLUSlHG PRICES Or BOSrOY STOCKS
BOSTON. Tuesday, March 20, 1888.
CLOSING PRICES OF PHILADELPHIA STOCKS
R.aarL.d hu InnN IL DAVIS & Co. u WalLK.
TUESDAY, March POP. ".

TUESDAY, March 20-P. ".
To-day's markets at the Stock Exchange make
sorry showing for the livelihood OF LOO members
of the board The total transactions In stocks were
only 1913 400 shares and Of that total five stocks
contributed 55, 500 shares. The remaining 1890
shares dealt In included transactions in fifty -one
different stocks Prices, however. were fuctuating,
but with droopIng tendency. Buyer three days.
purchases were again conspicuous. Except In the
points named the market was void OF features and
the last prices generally were the lowest of the
day.
There were no transactions in Government bonds
at the boards. and they were dull outside; bids for
the CLOS are a and for the Is ls lower Annexed
ara the closing quotations:
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
MR.. sToKEs's GENEALOGICAL HISTORY.

The cross examination OF ueLIy NJ Ddie,
the husband of contestant in the Stokes VIII case
was ended yesterday. Mr.. Dale was shown paper
purportng to be genealogical history of Mr. stokes's
family He said that the paper written for the most
part In the handwriting OF Mrs Stokes In this paper
Mr. Stokes put down the of James Better as that
of his great grandfather the fact being that James Boil
fer was his maternal grandfather He also oonfounded
his father and grandfather, giving the same name and
dates of birth and death for each In enumeratlng MS
randfathers children he mentions himself and In CIV
ing the names of his own children he mentions those OF
his father Aferward the of his children given
boye are stricken and his children are enum-
Grated except that no mention is made of any
daughters -
The witness then testified that on one occasion Will
tam did something I'm my Judgment highly improper and
Mrs Stokes rebnked him." The Surrogate ordered the
words expressing the witnesses opinion stricken out
Q-what did william say 2 A. He was defiant
This answer was objected TO by Mr. Evarts, ana the
Surrogate said that 1t was improper; W.,
o.-What was the nature OF Williams answer was
q, dsrespectul A-Disrespectful would fall far short
of proper descriptions it would do for beginning; II
might lead up 10 II.
which Impressed his mind most IN Wllhams answer 10
his fathers rebuke was the utter sneyersion -
The witness not allowed to finish the sentence
Mr. Dale then described scene between MI stokes
and William when the latter tried get the former TO
sign checks. At first Mr. Stokes refused TO sign
six months of Mr. stokes's life William with his
father much than formerly At one time Nj
stokes and william very little together Mr.
Stokes until within comparatively snort time peiore
his e. 4th had always objected TO the Introduction OF
business matters subject OF con' esston -When ne
was at home evenings. - ,.
DR. John II. Douglass testified that he had been
personally acquainted with Mr. Stokes although ne hsd
met him several times On one occasion Mr. stoKess
daughter helping him 10 get out OF earIage' MT
III ,ace had vacant expression. The witness said
that from observation he was OF the opinion mat MT
etokes's mind was very feeble The case VIII Do COLI
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
A CLERKS RECEIPT BINDING.

James Gordon Bennett short time ago oD-
tanned a verdict against the city for about $11cOo
balance alleged to be due for printing and publishing In
1871 the Mayors message The established rates OF me
Herald for publishing matter not considered as reading
matter was 40 cents line The Herald rendered Dill
to the city for S4s24 go charging at IT, rate OF 81
line the rate charged for publishing matter as reading
matter. The Board Of Apportionment and Audit cut
down the bill allowing only 40 cents line. The bill as
thus reduced paid, and Mr.. Benefits agent gave
receipt in full. The General Term OF the supreme
Court Yesterday rendered decision overrung the Judg
ment In favor OF Mr. Bennett holding that the aware
of the Board and acceptance of 1t by MT BennetV
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
THE RIGHT TO USE ST. JOHNS PARK

John w. Green began some time ago an &C
,ou in the Superior Court against the New-York Central
md Hudson River Railway Company to recover S74ooo
for the alleged injury done TO his property In
uudson st by the conversion OF st. Johns PARK into
railway station and by the practice OF the company OF
storing and running trains in Hudson-st He seeks an
Injunction restraining the company in the future from
continuing It's alleged illegal acts He also began "a ex
ecutor of the will OF his deceased wife, similar action
AGAINST the company This action came on for trial be-
fore Judge spcir year two ago, and the complaint
was dismissed on the ground that the ca1se OF action
any existed was barred by the statute OF limitations
Tho t,1al Of the action brought in his own name was no
eun vcsterday before Judge Freedman and a jury
The period for which be claims damages Is from 1874
% the time He alleges that the land now occn-
n,ea Inv the defendants station WAS formerly aP1Dnc
art dedicated TO the public for use as PARK ny the
F}tv Church CORPORATION. The public thus acquired
,sght Ia have the park remain park and 10 nave huu
remain a public street unencumDered Dy any
nrvate nusances He asserts that the oeendaht ioa
and unloads cars the street. and TO such an e1eht
~ nreises practically inaccessible The noise ana
smoke and cinders from the engines also make ne use
h. nrenises "a 900 year less valuable than they othe
s.,sa xouId be- Punitive damages 10 the amount OF
Srn 600 are asked The company In us answer ses
nm mai Trinity Church conveyed the land IN dudson
iect 10 right upon obtaining the consent IN writng
~ ,h,rds 81 the property owners to sell the land In
81 Johns PARK any private use. The Trinity Church
did obtain IN 1865 the necessary cohsehe VI
H. ranery owners and sold st. Johns PARK 10 tne ran
90 c,,nnany for 81 900 600, about half OF when sum
as s;vep r., The property No testimony OF gen
eral Interest was taken on the trial yesterday.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT.

WASHINGTON. March 20.-The following busi-
ness was the Supreme Court of the United
states to-day:
No le0-wllam and Charles Ludon plaintiffs In error.
agt the United States-Argued -, ,-,,
ton and Missouri River Railroad Company. and. z,
No I92-Mills County plaDtin IN error agt the Chicago
Burlington and Quincy Railroad Compa1 y-Argued .
I93-The District OF Columbia pantn IN errorakt tno
WASHINGTON Market Company-Passed
NOlg7-Johuatnan KirkDrde paintu In error, agL La
fayette County-Argument begun.
Adjourned until tomorrow.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
H.B. CLAFLIN g. co. AS PLAINTIFFS.

NO Lrldl vi Une SUI Ol IL. De Nioiiia ~ wv
against Joseph and julius Levy to recover $4,000 the
value OF certain goods sold by the firm to the defendants
occurred yesterday in the Supreme Court before Justice
Van Worst The plaintiffs had Julius Levy arrested on the
ground that he had procured the goods through fas
representations in regard to the financial standing OF MS
firm He appeared yesterday that he had not made any
representations the time OF buying the goods put na
said aterward that statement made by his Drother was
correct The urys verdict in favor OF the de1end
ant. AS the suit was based the alleged raud OF
the defendant the verdict does not affect the plantn
81
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
REAFFIRMING A MURpERER,s GUILT.

Edward Heney in 1882 was convicted OF
murder in the first degree He lived In West thirty
eghth-s where one night while his child lay dying OF
the scarlet fever he insisted that his wife should bathe
his feet His sster-in-law demonstrated with him on
account OF his uneeng seshness, at which he became
40 that he shot her dead The General Term OF
the supreme Court on appeal from the conviction, yes
terday affirmed the judgment Of the lower court III
said that an appeal will be taken to the Court or Appeals
and that the prisoner will be rescnenced-at least
not until after the decision OF that tribunal
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
THE PARK COMMISSIONERS SUSTAINED.
A CONVICTION REVERSED.

Henry Boas was recently convicted ana SEN
fenced to imprisonment the state Prison for one year
for violation of the election laws In preventing .. f.
Gerdes from voting at tho November election In 1881
knowing that Mr.. Gerdes had right to vote. On tue
trial appeared that another had already voted IN
Mr.. Gerdess name when he 10 deposit his vote
Mr Boas refused let Mr.. Gerdes VOTE aud after con-
shifting with in authority again refused his de-
hiard to DO allowed deposit his ballot advised Mt
6erdcs 10 apply for nandaDus telling him that nc
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
DISSOLUTION OF A MINING COMPANY.

Judge Truax, in the Superior Court Cham
bers yesterday made an order appointing Franklin H.
Smith receiver of the Columbia Consolidated Gold ana
Mining Company and dissolvine the Company. The
trustees company had applied for dissolution on
the ground that the owned by the company cOulu
not be worked prohtably The value OF the company
property is said to be not more than $1,000 Among
the creditors is Edward 5. Stokes for S51,357 ~.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
THE PETROLEUM MARKET
NHw-YokK. March 20.

There was again active but irregular specu-
lation in pipe line certificates to-day The recent heavy
adv lnce Ia the price carried sn further hence the
final results VI market were the natural
OF "oyerdoing good thing" Heavy sales to realize
nroats were made nc the advanced prices and In the
afternoon the weaker bulls discovered that they mad
greater loads than they could carry. After early
excited fluctuations between 81 O7a and 81 o6a, the
pree advanced TO- In the afternoon the course OF
the market rregularly downward to $l Oo@Sl GOA
and the specuaon closed weak at those prcee In the
sst ha hour there fee sales Tor the snort
account -, - -, -. .. FOL
lows: po,ra,.
49,. ~ po,,o,o,,, F,chanra . 3.OIO.Ou0
Now- ~ III o. ,1oion,n n, cbange l433.0O0
Salous a'n,."a 800 Es.hana. O3S,OU0
~, . 6lll,O0O
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21

had plenty of time to obtain An appeal from the
conviction taken to the General Term OF tae ~
Court which Yesterday reversed the conviction on tne
eronnd that Mr. Boas had not acted malciousy. Nal
Zee was q part OF the offence under the statute
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21


EEw;YoHK. March 20 -BEEvEs- Receipts were SO cars
DAYS head against head for the time
20 direct sIaugherers ~ the 40
No. his
follows IA Illinois Steers 7cwtat IL &c, 81 0 l4s do
Dressed beef dull reported sales of Western at
siae9tc, and Common to Prime City Dressed sides at
sa ents to-day Quarters Of Beef and 1875 esrcss:ss
shipments for tOm9gTow 2z7 Live Cattle the Romano y
Kennedy and Acer Price Co Ihe last named steamer may
mainly
. ss feeling Om%o as dS0H' ssdy erse S
Ve%s were At with sfew Choice at and head o.
S ass a9%
ye II too sqgp S and
was the top price for States Washington Market with
oG cOs sIs aG Il jersey vea, Oos25OD csoAc
HVcyiit Co sold. II Jersey veas sOSl0OD. esloc.
| 3 head at the latter price,. Vt. ,.o
sic do lin 1t 7'.c do lie b. at7i.ci q do. i27b.
were cars Of s2t hssd
for three days sa head against 1887 head for the
ing in he ma keI today and number Of carloads changed
bands rather stronger prices than sond been
sellers demands Fair to Prime Sheep sold at La e and
Spring Lambs 0H were s'D in moderate supply and
a%y6iDsp trs better Than ssr oi. last
with most Of The sales Today at sJds7 so each A few
Dressed Mutton slow so59c. and Dressed Yearling
sales Newton dilett sold 800 Ohio sheep, 1s2 D. at
TIC; J6 do % d. at 1913 do lO To- ut 7c 100 do 30 ID at
67sc; i42 Indiana do, III 10. at &c.
SIC. -
Evertt Co. sold IL Jersey Spring Lambs, at s6as8
W Applegae sold. Jersey Spring Lambs at $6Gs6 80
each. ana, - Co.
head 10 do CChoce). at 81 each.
HOGS ReceiDts IL cars Of 2$9 he . RIO, cars az
Alb head against 4O6 head for the corresponding time
last week The arrivals continue zht and p1ces
sIight upward tendency Dealers quote Common TO Prime
Hogs al " 6OG$9 10 per Ogl1 one for SAFE alive ne
supply OF Country Dressed st so9u, squas tne enad am
Medium at 0Si lOc Light states
l0h6lO2c, and Jerseys at lOi2alO'Ic
LIVE srocR MAR8Ers-BY TELEGRAPH
BUFFALO March 90, Gtie-Tecepts o-lay. 500 mead
, %esE 'o zoe T bso 'n eopne through ~ ears
duh God 10 choice steers - 20
50 800 Good shipgers . 4OGsO - Light butchers 81 oo"
ShecD-I{eceipts today 200 head for the week
consigned through III market eady with fair ae
mand slles Fair Western sheep - lO6SG; Choice
Fancy 81 5e6 75 few loads Of very Fancy SOFA d.
20 gOGs7 3: Western Lambs sG9S1 o.. .,
Hogs-Recepts to-day, 800 head total for week thu. ar
th0ng, market steady aud unchanged safes GOOD
Choice orkers 81 9OGs 30 Ils1t DO 80 e Tpoa
sT TO- i61s March 2o-Care-Receipts 500 head: ship
stron Exports Is % 9s6 ~; Heavy 9hpphs SO@
81 Is Sj 80; Good COWS and Heiiers - 70
a sj Common 500fi stockets and Feeders - go 2o
Corn fed Texans Of 900 to 1880 a, s. % SO %
hesp-Recepte 800 mead: snipme s 800 head market
active gOO grades Medium TO Good ii 80 zo Choice 10
EHsf LIBERTY, Penn March 20 Cattle Receipts. 342
head and prices shade OF frOm those Of yester
Hogs- Receipts 1855 head; market firm Philadelphia
81 s5dss 20. Workers. ~ 1Ods7 80: .o, "A,
Shep-ecepts 100 head market dul and prices Zoe on
those OF yesterday.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1883-03-21
THE COURTS.
x,,ss ,z,pUs REFRACTORY TOOTH.


~ faouRIR WHICH II CAUSED DENTIST wEsrBAf
AND HERSELF.
IS...,. M. lizard began some time ago in the
- =, Common Pleas action against John westbay,
x.t,st "a recover $1,000 damages for injuries al
6..6 tn have been sustained by her while under
~ attendants professional hands She al
Ssss that In March, 1882, she visited MT
Gestbay at his Office with the purpose OF having MIN
tske out one Of her teeth which was not behaving well
Miss May Gray a friend, went with her to ENJOY tne
pleasures Of dental operation performed on another
bersop Mr. Westbay after securing his victim In ms
chair administered gas her. which partly or entrey
took away her consciousness While sne Was ~ 'a''
condition he tried to do his duty by the uhduu oo"
He put plug" in her mouth and began Operations
He was not as skilful as ne ouen' " ~,
been for he fractured her jaw in trying 10 extract 1e
tooth and damned the plug down her throat the result
be,ng that she was caused to suffer much more future
main and ANNOYANCE than she had suffered from 'ne
tooth before she went to the defendant ror 'u0 i
of twentyeight days she was unable 10 eat ioou' no
was kept in her room for month"; curing "",0n
she was unable to attend to her business BE-
.,das tho main which she had to bear,
.he was also ompeed to bear considerable expense
The defendant in his answer denies that he was I'M
S,Ifn, in his treatment OF Miss lizard On the contrary
he treated her with much skill. He attempted TO take
out two teeth for her One tooth was decayed con
tiou and broke of Miss lizard refused to allow him to
remove the peces If she had after leaving him. taken
proper care OF herself her jaw would never nave
troubled her or him, as 1t had done. .,. ,o,oro
Judge Van Brmt and Jury. Miss May
GRAY testified that che was standing near the
plaintiff when Mr. Westbay tried TO take out her tOoth
Hu began by selling the tooth with some instrument;
then he pulled the instrument The tooth resisted
beroicay yielded to the evening only by breaking
of. Mr. westbay attacked the rest Of the to"ta ne
ste Vaantly, but instead OF getting the oeter OF
the tooth he Knocked the plug down Miss Yards throat
Wien he saw what he, h@ C5os, SSpS' HE he
Rounded Miss lizard on the back and inserted his finger
into throat AT length he got hold OF the pug ana
hauled il out instead of keeping II threw II away
When this was he left The room Miss lzards lace
was covered with her own blood The witness washed
her friends face aud aferward took her 10 her nome
She subsequently observed thai Miss lzands Jaw
was swollen. Mr. Yves bay, in his own behalf, Genleu
that he had Knocked the plug down Miss izars throat
The Jury were ordered to bring in q sealed verdict