Arizona weekly citizen., 1883-12-15

out when got there; saw them by gas
 light and light from other lamps in the
 hotel; did not see Mover tIll the next day; heard Levy say to Murphy and Mover Tn the Fashion two hours before
 the shooting you have been making a
 talking fight, now you've got to fight"
 Peter Gabriel.-WHs talking with Dr. Holbrcok between 6 ana o'clock at | Meyers drug store; saw Murphy, Mover
 and Gibson; tried to pursuade Gibson
 Co go to bed: Murphy, Gibson and Mover went up the streetat pretty fast gait; Saw Murphy grab Levy by the
 cout as he came out of the Palace; Levy
 did not grab; saw Murphy and Gibson
 shoot; by the way Levy staggered across
 the street he appeared 10 have his death
 shot; first saw Mover coming from the
 the center of the syeet, be said to me,
 "l shot him. they kept shooting him,
 and shot him after. he fell down; about
 3 or six seconds saw Mover after shoot
 ing; saw Gibson and Murphy s4oot;
 Levy fell on sidewalk across the street;
 Murphy fired three shots Gibson fired
 at him after he fell; did not know Levy,
 only by sight; could not mistake Mur- | phy, Mover and Gibson, did not see any
 body come out with Levy; was standing
 at bootblack stand north of the hotel,
 and was step or two into the street. A. G. Buttner-W8s city marshal m
 June, 1882, of Tucson; was not present | ct shooting of James Levy; saw him | dead on sidewalk across the street from | Palace hotel little south; tt was about ten o'clock; was talking with a man
 named Livingston on Congress street about Court street; heard some shots l and ran as fast as could into Meyer street; heard about seven or eight shots,
 not less than seven; first met Murphy, Gibson and Mover at the fruit store north of Palace hotel; Mover and Gib- son were walking on the sidewalk, and Murphy was in the street; arrested them; took Murphy's pistol away, and took them to jail; Mover said Il finished l him. Gibson "No, l did it." Murphy | said "I done it." each claimed the | honor of dong 1t; by the tune I got | hold of Murphy, Gibson and Mover | were gone; arrested Gibson an hour afterwards, and Officer Newoome ar- | rested Mover the next day, saw Murphy | and Gibson on corner of Warner aud | Congress street before the shooting; | saw them previously together; they | were talking about James Levy; they | were talking with Levy about some | trouble; tried to pacify them; searched Levy and found no arms; instructed Matt Bedding not to let Levy have any firearms; Murphy's pistol had two chambers discharged.
 Chief Buttner was subjected to short and hot cross-examination by MT. Fitch, but was not confused.
 LewIs Le Page Reside in Tucson; am miner; was here in June, 1882, when James Levy was killed; heard the shots from the Fashion saloon, some thing over hundred yards; heard five or six shots; saw Mover after the shoot ing at the corner of Meyer and Congress streets, at the Elite saloon; Mover was there; he said, "I put five shots into the d-d S. of b-.' 1 was not present.
 Cross-examined-Was working for Murphy; kept cases for him and dealt at faro game; he discharged me about week before the shooting; he said he had five more bullets.
 W. B. Hopklns.-Keep the Elite sa- loon tree bllliards); was clerk at the Palace hotel m June, 1882; knew Mur- phy, Mover and Gibson; knew him by sight; last saw Levy June ,, 1882, after 1ark; WAS opposite Palace hotel at the Maison Doree about dusk; saw Levy and another gentleman at bootblack stand; saw Murphy and another man pass up Meyer street, going south on Palace hotel sIde; Levy was at a boot black stand just north of Palace; crossed ( he street and went into hotel; Levy and i he other man came up to register, and asked for John II. Campbell; saw Mur- { Dhy return from the south and saw them oOk through the window; saw Murphy C top at the hotel, and Gibson stood in C he street; told Levy not to go out: ( Murphy was at south side of the hotel ioOr; was talking with Levy; Levy t Isked the man with him where his pistol vas; he said he had it in hIs Lip pocket; a old them to go out of the pack door; they promised to do T 10; they linked arms and went [ ut to the front door; heard c be report of the pistol; heard Levy say Oh, my God; stepped to the door; saw T he flashes of Murphy's pistol; saw Levy bread out his hands and run across the sreet; after be fell I saw Gibson shoot Ievy three times; dId not see Mover; he shooting took place as soon as they from my sight; saw Mover b fterwards ID the Fashion; stood by the ( Tindow while there was shooting; did Ii ot see whether any other person fired r not; Levy was slightly under the in. .uence of liquor, but not much; Dun- a an was on the right side of Levy, next t 0 the outside; Levy had hold Of Dun- il ans left arm. u Cross-examined-A person can go out U trough the billiard room the back way; O sevy's rght arm was linked with Dun S ans left arm; did not see the first two T hots fred; saw a revolver iu Murphy's ands. The witness WAS questioned c as to the exact number of J hots and the distance ID feet of each Il ne Gibson fired into Levy's body c fter he fell; think Mover was the thIrd lan who was with Murphy and Gibson a then they first went south on Meyer L treet; heard David Gibson say, II tl filed him." Murphy contradIcted him nd said, No, did it"
 Recess till half past IS o'clock. n
 AFTERNOON SESSION. T,