New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-01-21

$500 mo ~, his onsvcr- In making his charge the
District Attorney made the statement ol I'O' VIM"
had not appeared in evidence, and M scoVhe ""'''o
him TINT he would do the same If the act were repeated
Tho District Attorney had done the same thing |es''
dav in reference 10 the witness Moss who fe ASSERT"
had been tried in this very upon an niorna'i"u
He fscovile had since discovered that Coonel OoIA"
prejudice against the arose from the lac. ua' o
had once been sued by servant for - an" va" .
tried 10y NOES who was Justice oi the l''''' '"''
on record -, ,,
Tho ,risoncr-If Ccrkh wcre sued for all he owes IL
vo,ld axe ali the courts in this city to 90 the o'N'"
Mr. sco,ic continued and dwet AZ great length n.'H
tNc a,ym-netry Of the prisoners head as compare" WIN
other hcaaa and. having mentioned the D'iH''N''i
pcy amOuE others. the prisoner sitttu '-"' ia '
"CorkhinS is o sweiiAcad.'
The District Attorney once or twice interrupted 9'
scc.ic. oud. one Of these OCCASIONS MI I"''.
salcastic4ily exclaimed, Don't interfere WIN WI
Scoyine am afraid he viii stop if You DO Don STOP
lir. Scoyiiic'
NJ, s,ovuc ar,r,ciatcd the irony OF the remark and
cin,d IN The laugh that followed In pause IN the
argument the prisoner looked mp from MS paper an"
ead t was reported in the papers the o'her Gay ,n"'
Ispent three weeks my speech published last MONDAY
Asa matter Of fact only spent three or four days Fsh
along, morning ana night want tue I'D'i" ''7' N
that"
MI Scoyile resumed his argument cr1tlcISihs Tue
testimony given by Dr Gray, OF tbc Utica Asylum
whom he characterized as the big gun which he prose
cuton had reserved until the close OF the case supposnc
that he would carry the Jury by his grand round we'll
proportional. overwhelming declarations quoting ne
case OF AN insane man who thrnlcSs IN his family
cnrkhil wouid cali II a case Of devish dePrayity.
Yes" cried the prisoner, "Corkn.l is authority On
thc devil Gray is a big gun with biz mouth lwiI
marx hlm.'
GUUrEAU srRIKEs AN OFFICER.
The court then at l2l5 p. m. took recess FOR forty
five minutes. As GuteAu was being taken out OF the
court room he stopped TO speak TO Mr.. scoye' when
r. cd 70 him along. GultCdu
turned angiIly and SAID 10 Tall;
come, come" said Tall. impatently, trying TO push
''e Let me alone" shouted Guteau "Mnd your own
FAT having applied some pressure 70 Guteau the
latiet vita lis uanacod hands struck the o.eI on l9
breast when ac was al once sel1eu ~ 'n' o'e'' ''
n'iiieI % yS ~ rss Nh scoyi,c addressing the lnry
.a,d maj hr would dwell longer on Tie foc's Of ne
case b,t would simply mention some CONSCIENTIOUS
Which -4o" ne bS Committed mulacr Oh Ght to De
Iunsued n he were over the border INC la sel+
80 ,, and INST mat u was wha, God approved.
ts,y that the man who stepped over we o"I ''t .u
committed an act "i mnrl'i 2u2E" 't I" . I'
Ciscly rs the Vas punished when Ar STOOD on .Il
rsA side Of i4g .ae l. %a' iI'' I 'l , g
Should ,u.icr lie believed that II the c..ows vcle
HE IT, PREDICTED That Ju1-, Porer IN
crSuc address "oua 1' stress up'n thr 'ot tL1tf me
&c VA. .r,o.. pini.i d. Ms Gariri1 and w a.
tcspt 90 show by taU fact that he prisoner COCA. a"l
don on the pIrt 5f judge Vortermust be based on te
sumption rla' thc prisoner was man who. MG1 Eas
I,- muf va. li-,,,. Lo yiim or caprice ~ sp.ano o
'-,.r In !l,.. 49,. tc himself: Not now. The Lorj
waI,. mF work. the -eut "i lle LoIi can '. &c.
lay,d sc, lie c-iIent to-mor'" or 3D. iat 1eN
div and -t2t, a.j winch cod ne TO do r1A
az of me prisoner tt'l Ia'hhs .~ ".I "'t ~ I."'r
IN hc W., acting dude: q ds-i>'n. ioI Ed1 "I- 'ti
wouif i,' a,. needed suotlc, gLt TO allow that de-
prsyi,y O.. 70" jcye cpe1 ID bis mart
lncot n.ol " Sco,y s'u' pn E't H.
az il. ,o o9' not 5o b., job,c 10 maize
trruacoI- decisions; but when we collect twelve men
afirfcar..u nHin oT-cit!zcn- and understand
ali On relation, Of lie ana society w4o hnog the
value % property the value OF liberty the va ne OF
lfs, VINO have mad varied eNIerencc Who nave come
here mons tie Last nom me Vel ron on; jiSer
the seas, IN one common cIl],a-Ii2 OmialnS
institutions. !e. more secure I'LL the piOifl -iih-
ton than would under ANY oIeI hoae o. aiAutdljI
50 LONE a. the are ho1es, aAn ~ ~ .,.'D i, %
not requisite That yO1 have hsh deSfet 81 l Sehce
and d position to 10 what Is right But above all yo4
should have mora couiaec 5Hoi5 o' tl'ISc[i' mora
said lpu wiz do what i rght and 15 tG"ara your le.-
Iowncn. aad ~ ,ho sight OF gour G,I That Is "Aat
expect OF yod don't ask yQd now 10 End Tor OF against
tns doi,Etnt simply ask Od 10 take TIE evidence
srYc as what viii Ice the result Of your verdict IN
regard 10 loar position IN s'gr,y as 10 ] your
way cx,,y; that Nou should believe IL 10 be just lod
spS moye ousa. Of a rcerr desre 10 decide this case
aceorGug % law ana evidence. All ~HSh yen nave /
reG hed e1'soH y, 3i % nr iti61, none of of
" !',, rv,id and 1tieyc Gentlemen That you viii
Go g. Il~a,e tIc case with you, thanking yod oI your
A. 81 -ro,i concluded there we've slight manifesto
zion, 81 applause IN he audeuce, laey n.ued
atty ~dpur,,, eu by tie oIucio OF ihe Court,
attcnol 10 lie dec OF tine prisoner address The
jury. A. tl' tme ,L't the aEiA,ion "aH nioe .t Ha3
o. posed very earnestly inc Gaze L"dH'" occupied
seventy days and Ae dl not desire rcpetNou oi H.
H. iu.cnd thar my error shoud sct !Ao the re
cora up .u W.ca there was any p'S-..-} tu'l ant"
t..a. SHOULD ot $40" an ne II,.t e' .4 'eI'- W