New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-01-25

ta ai yonr daught.rs, What arcurity i. there
That il the license for whioh thIS bF'thtI--''M W
for rational men and that all of thee crimes "nicu
have mentioned my ho communion ny IL l''., ii,,,,s'
in defiance of the law and o tho Instructions from INC
Court Nay, morc the insane oi thit c'u i 49,,
the uudou6ied insane ar, inmates ol Nhl'lS -
uns) are 10 learn from the NtIdlct III ,it'7 "a f 81
theory Of the dc.enec shall VI. fH'l.l., r.stI.ns
him; that they all al bcTiJ lo coIIett'.'r !"
The 2a'es of nc asy iuns and 90 20 on amt " ~ ,r,
in Land. and spread ruin aud CoulI-rauOh III tN'l9
direction; au t. although the law io,pds -, an Ah'I'
can jury can Doe found That VAL sanction -H' ar;
Mr.. Por,cr-Hoie than tAat any man VINO Hi' I,
in any gree sl!tl Zoe ai hp.ii! 'a % ,i,nr.
none o. us ha- q. yet put 10 lun"uc o. }IHL ~
there is lot hannah being "a t.ls a., I9'',G @ M
the 800 o. 900 uuatic- ia sFiuu VIII 'r at Hii S
10 lax. on. IIycs II sucu were inc law gcutrarh the
mos. b,uI-u Institution iu tlc country ,h' 'ti'
of a-yluus Tor c lu,tuc-uu,t re abandoned Lti me
aud ll,lt the av l,, mo- Apli unon ihtm
order 90 Genera. sherman, uu troops tal may "t w
rard Am Iu can save tDc lives OF inmates or keep
cr> Aid hence }, i- as a glad To learn tLat MA.ie
is Gaze may WsI produce h1TiOr OUTSIDE "l I"it,iO
INNS. il produce, more horror inside OI them De-
lev. traf ii !: ur, couu Dee impIacllci ~ any unduc
asylum iu ms country they would ''} OF tI.+ u'u nv"
only thai they would be- endangered by Ills pitac-cr Di
founded on reason 1t is announced b. the hsh Ftdern
iurI, vino preside over tins tribunals ana hc law Us he
n1s uttered 1t IL your law aud NY Law.
TIE QUESTION OF INSANITY.
Was this man insane the ~ fJuy! fhc was not
you have but one duty, and tna is 20 con1lo, him. lie
was not insane Grant, for the purpose OF the argument
what not one soul Of you beicyes-hat his father was
insane Iii. father did not assa,s.natc Garfield Grant,
if you please that hi, uncle Abraham was insane His
uncle Abraham is not trial. He did not murder fF'
Garfield Grant the sam" OF each ana ai 81 tHg0c
he insane and insane on that day ave-, Mn@d 'ir9
PROOF indIr lUtably established, th3i ne never Ea7 IN
sane; and certainly not On the "a Of July. On inaI
point the principal claim by the prisoner and his coun'e
il the atrocy o this particular act do not deny his
OF the last six thousand years But he i not alone as
he VIII ind when comes to those rcaGh where
human race murdered the second born, ana
blood OF the second born called from tae
and fhe tIlr cr was condemned to live men punish
ment more terrible than death-with mark uaon his
years 90 there wa, Inscribed tables OF stone The com
mand 70 all people: Thou shalt not KIM bu,
OF his letters OF consolation 10 the widow; Lac
j. but fleeing dream. His death might have happened
field might have trod an Orange peel, or trol on
ra,tlcsnake. Bur the LaWgyer Of iAe universe enter
Uc sad: whose -hcdtcth mans blood, by man s4d4
rhe rr.sonsr-IIa was thrco or folr thousand years
Nj Pori.r-tnd tnaf man in me dccl, to,- Won thar
placed 10 value on tAe life oi Jam. l. Garfield ana
that as 10 tat hf, IL was bus of sIua Eauc; it
ana he ;hnl, tina, th, juy vii indot-e mia gospel.
r.1iiy "f Guicas .at.cr. and d.,,riI tuat ,1c dc
fence was lsc-cod and fabrication an M 1stuc
The pr.,on.r-You are telnig fl's hood
t,id,ic,. to insanity There IS one orier ~ Insanity
ca cd by m. prisoner Iamc, allied uy i'l ut oil ne.
unc, temporary mania, ana called by d. Hrl|ha moral
insanity. ilat mora, insanity, tr.nf 70 I'I ijaf-t'
consists WIcbcunC-, and j. Inherited not from "a
natural parent. Out Irois another toHrr'' tT- 7pr"h
to he THE s.ed o. Nbr.f rrare if '7 DOM act, of
tarqIa hIt yc are thr cI'Er.n of v'rr taiLei, tie
devil. wno murderer from me hrenn.ns'
TN, prisoner That iIar- Nol ill., l't.Ifi
Mr. PoIt.r-lhit j. the iu-nitv "Wch ts man has
Inherited. lnc ~ % T.. ar T.. well d. al o--t ing on
Tb. prisoner .IuIlng TO MI rert.- laa.. OF lower
dne jhlt cl.not near over hero TO" mad better DO
f. AGAIN. jude. ..-
.ir Putcl went on ~ IrNt" 'l' i'-'N'F "Hu HI7 .-
Of cHme,I ill wnich he included ai",ril. nile.
oftIti LODI up your record OLD man. CUES. yoa are
about as bad "a, tJrAniI. go.
Nh Porter wen. tO refer 10 th: prisoners iie ~
WAsnu DI Vn~ az t-cI-, 'a.' i. '"i., ai l.r'.
polsc al tac Keep rs OF tl" Iu-' iu' -' "i h'' M -
a. dinner aud U tea; c.rciuI 10 TAKE "'ti-; l"i'"h
s'cal.ug g., day 50 Llfay,"c ~ .:r,g i, milking
If..ar1fIJre 10 murder thr president len hr slotd
,"'' q mania " -,,c o.. tHe or.u
o nI.'. i.aI.ll' IN nary!
me .-or.r- For inc benefit of tle American people.
Ir,uo,, moi 4, murder. t,.- are very we'll eatised
- t,.
,,.- INV. ,,,.,,.,.,.,.-. mary ,,--.-,,,1
VA, III IJI''Ni'' h'''l' '-''-. ~
IN Porter G-rUrnrn,i went h) .uti4ri, do you
that ,i, man, brain was as,ascat deal with
"0''0'' go '' - ,,.,.,
nothing else now Vas ms ''''N '.7''' Anu wa 'l'
disease come AMI -o according TO whether President
=, ,., 900, r.-. zap wont ,,,,. with lf- wiz, ,r
""'.'' ,.,- 800, -. a.. 81 -.
went out win his children or "eH' 10 inc soldiers
Home. or went TO the railroad ocp'ti 10 you DelcYe
that ne IELt ItHtb Ioi "4-at W nv VI'iH ~ 10
make weeks preparation for az asaas-inaton and
that shouting another nan hrol-h ne spine is cure
Tor the disease I""t 10 TIE case "s 'Ac prisoner mAts
ii out ,....,
Tnc prisoucr-tfI we're the President Of the United
state and n@a rup9d tde i'e i'l.'n iI$ a. GivIu
and is the opinion o. great nany people, TOO.