New-York tribune., 1882-08-17
LILLE rNDLRHILL VII CASE.
DscIs1oS RENDERED BY SURROGATE COFFIN of
wEsrcHEsrER COUNTi.

A DlCTSrON RENDERED. BY SURVIVAL Wa --' -
wEsrcHEsrER COUNTN.
PFEKsKILL, y. y, Aus. l6.-SurroSa'e Ooi-
a.. , r.dr.d decision IN the Underhln VIII case' III
which Eliza eth NJ Guon. one OF the her7 ol 'no e'
~ II,,b.th l. Underli, deceased. called Tor an Ac
o,rp,inr from Philip H. Underhn, executor. AFTER Tt
,ovpe The PROVISIONS Of the VIII admitted TO piOo't'
r. March 500 together with subsequent ransac uon'
4, connection with the management OF the estate ln'
surroepte -aysi
81 can nut regard his as most extraordinary case
Uer. i. "a vrrf lar-t estate lLN"l IHE a" "r "
atoui slOOOOoO. reatus 20 tI'iisa, ois ga 'f'1i- @
rer-ln aud be- gl.~itss' s.Iuil 90 man a.
aI,.,,.I wears. largely unl aunl.lAr WIN aHalr-
~ W" "a wlfness whose evidence can he
had A. to The history o. tc come i oohpie4 I
- n.o,.,. Ualrr tAc circumstances u bay DO RE-
e.-i-d A. llar,t.lOusi tnat no great ahgs|I uts
- -n tu, e-tat, While the business A'r zen con
~ T,e ~, fle iid of counsel on both sides. we sha
4 ~ - .i,uro,iulie a result more nearly Jn-t ihan.
- "1' o,,r To- -rate tna / nave been un,D., 10
pl.., much reliance upon the te'liul"ul ol ga,
tor save suerr he II corIoooiA''u - "0' '
Uap.. h. Ildrri4 was the executor OF IA. wills OF
r,... ...e .ndei. JACOB tllurltulcr, klLapclh X
f,t.rll. aud l-4ac CnirrhL All U, t1e esta.c. ,l
tlo-t iesaiors more oi less iuVoINtu euu ,,.
woven th tui- accounting. IL l. not reuaI AaDc '".
The executor wnel speaking Ol Iunus oi
eecuritlr- lervcd frum any oi thes-N etet is lll
io-. io .Ar estate Il seemed To- niin 90 make no
am r. o. AZ ur should invest nlr m0iDerS iills a. "a
- - filue 10 invest them .lfter her death,
ar ,rn - fuDa- Of aie aiter h,I death lh IN,
manner. u iherrni4!' ID 81! event. NV -
Ia, question here being nugated = NOT whether the
tut Dov a. has managed ii-wna ne ia7 on manu- Nn"
n slpoun what hc nar done III sAoi b, is :
So1St hat tne executor violated vel established
rules investing on ,I,-lN,.'., f
nIne-Jentls OF value and also d4-res uA- .ue eA
pres pro- IsIons Of the Will VIZ n Iequ.rru NE
rrffel !
sprugug from the effects " nnanci''. gI col-',I @
cla p.Ac, WHICH colii IOl VIZ" o.,'iN1.' "a
aruce Id, qua .dcd against, does uot ,erm u.
Apply ia tins cast, as u aPpca- 'nhl tAe alh'uHt
q tIe mortgages reached d" With eo'OoU w ~ ~
the value %. tHe PROPERTY byler tno o'iH1eo lo' u
ni nt me -Iirr .g.,t that the charges upon the
fo.t- Of Ia. trst4irl1 against Mr-. IbOrue ana Nj
Guon whether ia the nad llng oi tue iesiatr1 OF o
auy person. III accor.auco Win tht pam ad eA-
1Lo p.oys4Ou- Oi the VII, art Ydlu aud should Oe d
dur-rd from ten respective shares While the taXes
,.d nv lie executor OF the estate were assessed
think there ls mucu force 20 the phlcl-
80 tbat these taxes s.ou.d be dI-al.oAed
Ine oAcouiof" ne continues, uas treated tnc
on tue hpoa- against Mre IuOrue and Mrs Gulou
- t .,g .... al tue estate 10 Dt accounted lOr an
10 Objection Las been made BY Ia contestants
These ana aided To lie amount Ol TIE Lvtu-
toy swell ne "hOe una 70 9JV-'t - 80 IRON
which dcducu uOns ag.regatluC %-5,oOJ "a are TO be
o1f OF winch rss aeduc.lous OF book charges. airs
ThOrue and GuIOu respectively entitled 10 the
Use; G.4tiotug tnOse cuarscs reduces Ihe Iuhu 10
s36l -gY - and the Whole amount OI income received
by tur executor OF Tor wnlcu liable To account
a. above stated >4Usl Ills 30 sduJcc Ol cOursc 10 sucI
payncuts thereof he has maze 10 MS cOni-
ull-siuu- 10 The expenses OI ne accounting
A. Injured 10y thc surrogate, UcDit account OF
fhe r. follows: Amount o. inventory and
iutrtas. >.U-.7-T go amount Oi the increase Oi III
come $3.50 81 IOtaI. s96O,59o -. Inc cIeclts
are. D,14cD0us from inventory and increase
Ss5.oOO "a. amounts charged Mrs Thorne aud
Mira Guon, s57,l5l -; taxes, repalrs'
e. cet,ra, So 7JZ %; principal fund
S3Cl -g3 1Jt Puiup l.. UnderniIs eXecutOrsl
shar OF income, SlJ7,j25 paid Mrs Ihorne'
sl4S-S- l., PAID Mrs. GuOu, Sll6,l45 ~, tOtal,
Sy7J.-- d. watch deducted from tne total yalu. o.
estate, uulug inventory anC increase and Increase of
incon, ~goOJ9- 81 eayes balance due the executor
g. - 900 - 10 tu. calculation tie amount ONcrpald
Nre luO.nc u e-s374 80 the amount o'eIpald drs.
Gulou. ~. lOo -. making S14J4l 81 and lcay1ng .
TRIVIA error uuSccOunJsI iOr. OI Hl32 - But there
must Dr deducted frOm Mrs. OUOu's amount about
$1,000 taAes, and from drs IuOrue's amount about
TINS would reduce the
auce against Mrs. luOfne 10 about $1,000 anu the Oa-
aucU - ..lsl Mrs GuiOn 10 about $1,000