New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-29

ma hereInbefore stated that the said sub
from said Turnbu oral replies 10 quesions pi,tes and
by the COMMITTEES relating % te ,J G,verning Com
mittee lccOmpa lied by all the evidence ~ fine
lore stated bus denies iufOrmatlon anu Dei' law the
plaintiff permitted 20 near VI or 10 con-
contents OF said report or OF sad or 10
anesfion them hut on The con rary AYERS ON I
ton and belief that said evidence hhu ~ ba
counsel IN case tbey or either OF them desired 70 80 t
same and further alleges on Gorinaun hen Al lin rry
the plaintiff and his counsel woud nave said Turp-
aud would have been permit ted to ques' Io ' ,n 'ad
bull the other Witnesses II they or siLr % ,yas ever
made such n request, but that no such request ifr
made The def ndant still further ans@erlns a,nt "a
ZION and belief says that tns6e intis conduct in
,be nliif nnself and The statements OF said IurnD
and me witnesses whose statements were akehp
such subcommittee, and tisdefendagt ssiI -
swering denies that sad resolution VI the Zotu ay ~
NAV 1850 was not passed and adopted by a wore y.
twO-tnrds OF said Governing Committee anu -
there was not at mat time any governing committee ~
said cub legally constituted 10 exercise tine power ~
removal, and denies th by the constitution On mem
Der This defendant admits that fourteen votes w.
cast in support SAID resolution but AYERS ,bir ~.
such fourteen votes were more thah t" Twin s1
Of the quorum OF the Governing Committee presels
such meeting there being eighteen InenDerS az
and more than twohlrds OF tue entire IN -, in
then existing there beng folr vacancies AT ine Inn 81
said Governing Committee caused DY tne - and
three members thereof aud by tue ctssatlo 80
in pursuance OF tne provisions of the constitution -
nbeOre stated OF the membership OF one ne @
SAID committee. all Of winch vacancies "e.o ' ~
and cold only be filled by the ciuD at largo a' '"'
annual
EigdM.~And this defendant further answering OF
HIS own knowledge TO himself anu on ~ ~,
forma ion and belief as 10 tne VtIer ! sy nen,-
Governing COmmi5tee, denies thlt thefe-"ore a r -
bers or said Governing Committee, VINO NOtei lu V
resolution OF IlslOn, 1n1 were dlsdutlno ~
SIT in Judg nent on the case DH reason o rSidon
Turn6ull by being personally Interested or scuy1y
partIc paling 10 said difficulties on IuruDdil soS VI
actvely aiding or abe, ting said Tu:nbull therein
the plaintiff. And TINS defendant Sun llI eni
answering OF his own knowledge so Iar as he 70 oon
cerned and on information ana benet so Tar as e
meiuDcrs Of The Governing Com nittee are coAcer
resolution did not ac IN good aud with ilrness
ana imparildy, aud tlIt said Governing Conn @
passed and aIoped said resolution II BAD lAi VI ~
Oias caproeOr from personal hostility 10 pdlu'lh "
partially rurnbuL ne defend tIt iur her Lns"e
any tine Resolved that the sdld ldruDun W
OF conduct improper or prtJudlciai 10 'no o.u
the acts OF said committee We're III any respect -
JUS, unequal partial or that tne same PfOcee"s
rom partisan feeling said IIrnbdl on the part %
i, ~ 1 tn STIei,, SO lar as he il concerned and
on III. OrInatOn anu belief far Otner members o
The Governing Committee are cOncrrAci denies tnu
any member OF the governing Committee nad resolved
and declared his purpose 10 vote FOR the pLdntI eA
pu,lOn prior receipt sad report anu su eNlocuOo
from sad subcommittee o. before sitting IN judgment
tho already expressed al opinion TIE va
the piaIutin. JlAt the acinn OF any
OF fae Govern - oniniitee IN voting for sad rssolu
ton was based personal Hostility ~ the ptlhtlA vr
personal friendship 10 said Iunodll Ana t1ls ueio
ant further answering denies said Governing Co-
had expelled. assumed 10 eXpei, Had pAulIh
without any heallu- or any opportunity 10 ueieh "
information as 30 wuat ne MAJ u"ho lv
Cause Of expulsion. Tuis dcirudant Iurther an
swerng denies any knowleige OF lnlorlna-
ton sufficient to form belief a. 70 WLat
injury or damage has resulted to plaintiff rom such eA
pu sion, said expulsion was JUS anu
necessary sequence Of tine acs ana thn2s mere
fore mentioned. AID ia discharge o. plnIul uutl
dcyaved upon said Governing Com nl.tee 40 4I'leal -.
AiIlfh-Aud tho defendslt iurih ANSWERING ~
eacn and every allegation IN said complaint not hee GIN
before specifically aumitteG or denied -. .,. elm
bhere0re. the e.dant demands JuugnenS la t n
complaint dismissed and that ue recover OF plant
ais costs aud disbursements Ior tlia ae1oh o+tore
Robinson, ScrOncr Bright, delen idnts attOIhe5 D.
ONCE address, NO. Iu2 Broadway, New-1Ork'