davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
THE TROUBLES AT HOBART COLLEGE.

On Tuesday. November Ia, letter from
Gen.va. n w. was published in THE TRIBUNE giving an
account OF the recent troubles at Hobart College Pres
dent hinsdale OF Hobart has written letter denying
the correctness of several statements In that letter
He declares tnat there bowling runlAns in the
co4ge. TINT tie President not grossly lnsulted by
any oue: that no member Of the Faculty WAS knocked
down and sat upon that the Faculty ana not Try 10
coerce the Freshmen into sending an apology that TWO
members OF the Sophomore class we're not caught
aud dismissed; that he students did not 60 out IN
body that the students have not appealed to the
trustees and Faculty expressed any inten-
ton of resignng; ALSO that the trouble is at an end
These denals without explanation woud not convey
clear impression concerning the actual iaciS Inc OK
act history Of the trouble obtained from the best au
thonty, Is in brief as fol ows:
In the baseball game between the Cornell and Hobart
Freshman mines outsiders were called in to make mp
the rt nne instead OF one, as the Cornell men sup
posed Toe day q ter tao game Tie hODuJ FRESHMEN,
meeting, resolved 70 send letter OF explanation Oh
Cornell Freshmen Iils action vas AFTER
ward Reconstructed, and the Liter, Whlch had Deeh VIII
ten aud even placed IA tho Ret ooei was S an
On the next Jay au O1cldl hoIce appeared on
the college bulletin board signed ny the Ifcslicnt anu
other officers Of the college, denOincng the gross
fraud" in tha baseball game qua lnStn- the tIeshlI"h
class 10 make apology. TINS noNce stated tnat tue
inactlOn the iOoart Freshmen mad been secured pJ IN
classes aud declrcd tuat unless an apology shOud Dc
favOrs any would be granted TO any class IN re
Carl any athletic sports rms nouce caused great
the Freshmen summoned before Ihe ffeslucht ana
Faculty, wmle tIus assembled the dlsturDihce
descri6ed in TIE TRIBUNE occurred. One professor Was
thrown 10 ne ground bat II Is claimed that this was an
accident On the following day Que student "as expelled
and nuot ter suspended months Tor taxing part IN
the disturbance. All tie mtmOers or TIE senior ana
JUNIOR Glasses hen signed letter 10 the Fdcu y'sathg
mat tuey were all equally concerned IN tue
a sturhnnce and would voluntarily take
upon themselves SD. pensi ID IN case decision OF
Faculty Overrued. Those two Glasses TOOK no
par, any college du les up to Friday evening IL was
intimAted TO mem thelr defiant attitude Precluded
the Faculty considering pardon OF the dismissed
SUDDEN a letter sent TO me Faculty from com
mLtee representing Two classes, anlng that they
did lot intend ueiy the Faculty ana mat the dl-turD
ance OF Wednesday was not meant as an insult DuI was
tue outgrowth OF u mere spirit OF mischief Inc TWO
casso voluntarily returned 10 their duties on Saturday,
and hterwaId the sudets seat IN petition that the
sentence OF Lac usiuIssC0 students be mIlStod No
lra was III de the trustees The MOZART Freshmen
offered u play the Cornell Freshmen win hhe hiaue ?
enrIy OF Hobart Freshmen. and again beat the Cornell
players by a score Ot B 10 =.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
THE UNDERHILL ESTATE DIFISIOX

Philip R. UndeIhill, OF Nev-Rochelle, as
executor of the estate OF his mother, Mrs Elizabeth
RhInelander Underhil through his counsel L. d. Fred
ercks and Francis Larkn rendered his final accounting
In Surrogate Collins yesterday up to the present
period The matter has occupied the attention OF the
Surrogate for about two years, during which tnc the
counsel engaged the have made fifty visits
to White Plains. Tho present amount OF undstribated
estate ia S36II9s Ca OF which the executor share Is
SlJ9Glg 96. The share OF Mrs. Deborah X. Ihorhs
OF the csarix and her child en- Is 1924 CaSsoi
the income OF which Is payable to Mrs Tborne dnas
her life The share OF Mrs. GuiOn, another 1anSl.ef
OF the testatrlx and her children Is Sl4I49o ~ the
income of which In the OF Mrs Ihorne Is pay
able 10 Mrs Guiop during her hfe Out OF the estate
about $4,000 will have to be deducted for commissions
and EXPENSES and each OF the legtces Is TO contributed N
proportion to his respective share In order 10 bar
monte all the different interests existing In the estate
b. r. Guon the new administrator with the VIII al
neXcd, through his counsel withdrew yesterday IN
favor OF the Central Trust Company OF this city Ine
nnl decision OF the Surrogate. based upon the opinion
delivered III July last, rendered. An equitable a-
vision OF the estate VI Mrs. Undcrhill was deceed aeA
OF the three legces receiving separate snare OF me
estate funds. -,
The retiring executor. who resigned his position
retains absolute control OF his share while The SHARES
of Mr., Tholne and Mrs GuiOn 10 he deposited via
the Central Trust Company for the benefit OF these e
atees during their lives and NJ their dent the prcps
is to DO div ided among their respective children.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
IRVING HALL REJOICING.

The General Committee of Irving Hall
held its lat meeting FOR year. last evening at Irving
Hall Luke C0zns presided. He congratulated the Or
gauzatiOn on OF the Democratic Party and
tneIr own candidates the election.
c. w. Brostne presented preamble end resolutions,
which were adopted unanimously Iney declare chat the
res at OF the election this city and State was largely
due to the efforts OF the Irving Hall organization fur
Their that Irving Hall will laoor to maintain the union Of
tue Democratic party; that If favors reconstruction
OF the American Merchant Navy subugatlon oil the
powers and dominons wise, just and equitable taTln
a repeal OF an especial revenue tarin; economy and
honesty in tAe administration Of the cIty government
Wis. le1satiye changes Huere thcy may D5 needed ana
promotion Of Tho clcuOn rights OF tne peJpe win re-
s 81 To IN Dortant offices nov dependant IN .heir coll
trl upOh the caprOe OF appOlntIye power Ihe CAalr
In n app jlnted committee Ga ave 10 prepare call LOT
urimaies Tor the General Committees Tor next wear
me committee inca IUr.uo1 III inc, thu neadeu Dy
band arcned resd OF ouerlnelect DaNldson
No. 7og Greenwlcu-st On the way tue procession "ao
iuel Dy the Assembly Dl,trlc Irving han organ
IL .iOn Fireworks AID calcium ngdts Combined 20
rsud. r the sctHe Drllaut one Jales u. dcCclldhd
introduced Mr. DAVIDSON TO the tnrOhs Mr Davidson
lnauksu tnBln for honor Conferred upon MIN ana
tuer support ia the recent election
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
ENFORCING AN Old LAW.

TIE CASE OF THE SACRED CONCERT SINGERS AR
RESTED IN NEw-HAyEN.
NEW HAVEN, Conn, Nov. Z0.-Ihe Clty
Court room tits morning crowded. The arrested
sacred concert singers Manager Peck, OF the opera
House, and the manager of the company were tired Tor
violation of tho statute Of 1884, which provides that
every person who shall be present at any concel' oi
music dancing or other public diversion on sunday or
on the evening thereof, shall be fined 81 Inc HT"h'
Opera House was crowded last evening iuIy TWO
thousand tOVe there and others had Deeh luIhe
away The singers had warbed down on the programme
10 "Tak About Your Noses" or little IurthetpGr-
hans dow u 10 A Great Day when Detectives kelly
and Brewer arrested two OF The male singers ald hdni
GERS PECK aud DWlnnel. This is tue company tWc
season. Manager DwiDnell said and none OF them huu
b en- arrested before. The Information against MAZDA
ger Cark Peck read &" That on November 10 ~ ne
Grand Opera louise he did then and there shHer anu
permit therein public concert, exhibition ana per
frnance Or gain, without license being Obtained thor"
for iron the Cnief OF Police" The complaints against
Roger Wilson Richard w. MarKs Edward a. Scales,
William r. Forbes and Charles > Dwinnel charged them
with taking part concert without license having
been ob,aiI,d" Clark Peck was fined 80 ana COSTS
and Agent scales anu Manager Dwlnnel were nhed
like amount They appealed to the superior 9oarl inc
bonds 500 The performers Marks ana forDes'
were discharged.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
,,ppvcu ANN AMERICAN CLAIMS.

WASHINGTON, Nov. 20.-The French anu
American Claims Commission met this morning VI"
made long order limiting the time for preparing o"so'
About twelve cases per week are to be argued anu SUI
mitted before January next ana S"ei 'u"s 80
,u,oor casas ner week Claimants arc allowed thirty
5avs after the United States has closed Its testimony
t,itan which to take testimony in reoutta i,
ALREADY closed by claimants the United o.,iony in
Eufil tIe Sd OF January next 70 take us ~ abr,,
M etner cases they win have only untli tue Oh "a f
Ay. ,,.-n,,.,t "a bound to fur
ssn at the request OF the Commissioners an he
s possession whcn may be Of importance In vi. or the
ent of any claim. short time ago the ~ for
United States called upon the Sr against the
artaI naners 10 be the case OF rear - "a
Seoablie OF France To-day the FTench ooH s
SSa, some of the papers will Oe furnished put lu
rannot be furnished for grave reasons Oh loi'0 -
Giplomatio nature - 49, ,,a.uovad Iouis
aInas AIT the United States Francois Sahuc ag t
xTntd states Stephanie OrODie aG the Cneu otd.os'
nioume Reandeau and others agt the Unlted slates.
Awards have been mado in the following eases as
Gheophlle LarrouK agt the Uhltei SIa'ee' W
Malice against the United states
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
FAILING TO GET PRESCRIPTIONS

Hugh Ward not long ago began an action
in tho Court of Common Pleas against Edward j.
Hogan to recover s., 900 damages for an alleged
brcncb Of contract Mr. Hogan IA physician. lilo
former, owned dug store which he sold TO Mr. Ward
promising to send all hs prescriptions To hun TO DO
filled Mr. Ward alleges IN hts complaint that Mr.
Hogan has never sent him any prescriptions at al AIR.
Hogan demurred to tho complaint on tho ground that
tho contract II made void impossible Of perform
anoo and immoral. Judge j. +. DAILY yesterday handed
down decision ON the demurrer In which he holds TINT
the contract Ia such as may support m action ana tt
tho demurrer must DO oyorruled Judge Day says that
there Is nothing mpropor In physician contracting TO
advise hs patient 10 with hs prescriptions 10 RAi
ouar drug shop In action for DAMASCUS Tor breach OF
such contract there might be much dmouity Ia got
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
THE VOrE 0FNEW- YORK BY COUNTIES.

OFFICIAL RETURNS FROM FIFTY-EIGHT COUNTIES
AND sEMI-OTFICiAL FIGURES FROM TWO -CLEYE-
LANDS PLURALITY l9t.444
The table of the vote of New-York for Governor Is
reproduced below from THE TRIBUNE of Saturday,
with some telegraphic errors corrected 1t now IN
cluoes the official vote of % counties and SEMI
official returns from Kings and New-Iork Counties.
These changes increase Cleycland's plurality to
1914. Ala, or 4j3 more than was apparent Saturday.
The vote for judge Foger 34l, 542) is 2l4OO2 less
than Garfield received IN $50, and 221279 less than
was cast for Judge Folger in the sane year. In
other words. Judge Folger lost this year little
over 80 Der cent OF GaTlieds vote. and little
80 Der cent of bis own vote in 1880. Mayor Cleye-
land has gained LAYS about .27 of per cent over
the vote for Hancock, and 1925 Ia little over
per cent over the vote for RlpallO in 1880
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
END OF A POOLING ARRANGEMENT.

The pooling arrangement between the st.
Paul and Omaha roads, easbound business from
st. Paul aud Minneapolis, has expired, and yesterday
the conflict between the Northwestern railroads be-
came 1ercer for this The has other cause
than the opening OF the Rock Island route to st.
Paul by the way OF Albert Lea The aggressive policy
OF the ST. Paul Company, which has extended
its lines IN all directions without re-
gard to the rights Of neighbor roads, has
made necessary complete readjusmcn OF railroad ter
rOry In the Northwest. In this respect, the railroad
not thing for IL has been recognized "a the
inevitable result Of sharp competition be
tween rival lines There Is little prUbabl
ity that IL will be enOed until tho territorial
rights OF the different companies shall have been
settled for n long period.
A direction OF tue Rock Island Railroad speaking
OF The said yesterday: Gnere Is really nothing
the mater to-day except the cutting In freight
rates which 1 have doubt. mas actual begun.
Tue persons who think mat tDis struggle originated IN
the stock sDecuatiOns OF the diroc vi the wO com
panes viii be seriously disappointed. so lar know
there Is no personal icelng III the quarrel Inc
81. Paul Company appears unwilling to give
line fair snare OF the business ne
tween 81. Paul aud Mnle ~ Ills All OucaBJ. l. has
refused In other words 20 give others the priv
leges which under precisely similar conditions IL LAS
demanded ana received. I tbnk 1t is HDOut time 10
thai what ia for the goose IL sauce for the
gander Whom this war Is settled something more than
right ~ part OF the st. Paul business wii Dc de-
termined,"
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
INTENDING TO CONTEST d BOND iSsI&

Arnold Leo, of Arnold Leo 4 Co., pfoAe,s
at No IS Exchange-place. has served a
officers and directors of the Union Pacific RaiN"! -
pany and Blake Brothers Il Co.. the o"na-s
with whom the company recently conclude" '' 80
action for the placing OF its ISSUE OF coslei
bonds saying that pc had been advised tIa' 'ue
was illegal and that he would take legal steps 70
II AS soon ~ practicable. Mr. Leo IN his notoe 80,
that he Is Il stock and bondholder Of the uuO" "a
Company lie says that Lie will hold all inc pi".s
whom he has given notice personally liable In an! w
that may be taken toward the issuing or neso'',-s
these bonds He has also informed the inter'O o,ton
rnent at Washington of his ieg con,pny
Sidney Dillon president OF the nloh , of nvice
said last evening that he had received 10 so ad
from Mr. Leo Tho sale OF the bonds, hSsshsd ard
completed last week The thing rs ling tlsl
what steps can be taken To prevent SOM onhf Is
oIready has been done There b. no doa' Mod
the legality of the collateral trust Issue ,n, JoAsf
mon by Sidney Bartlett, of Boston, eN I'd ra
Dillon and Artemus H. Holmes three o. ~, da mai NOT
road lawyers in tine country. The pon1s sr sue w
gage the property OF the company anu, anu
fntes no law or Governmental regulations
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
TIE BEEKMAN WILL CASE.

The contest of the will of Stephen F. Beck
man was again before Surrogate Coffin at White PLANT
Yesterday on the petition OF Gertrude BeeSman ioi
probate OF the will The examination OF Miss Mars
Emma See occupied nearly the whole day. The hFs'
will of the three executed by Mr. Beekman was made
in her favor in recognition Of the attention bestowed
by her on him during the eleven years she had lived
with HIM Miss see gave her testimony with great pm
ciSon. She gave "A detailed account or hcr htst -
0uaintanCe with Mr Bcoknan prior TO hiS SepnstiSa
from hi, wife. She lived at nome nearly OrlOsS ""
house of Mr. BcckInan. she subsequently ufed VIA ri
Reekmau Us his house keeper Mr. Beehnah sue Jaw
was Incorporate IN his habits, and for two yeaTs peoe
his death was inebriatcd nea ~ every lay he " ~
feeble ina body and mind and she had 20 care or En-
bv dnv and night Witness said that Mrs. Gerune.c
Beekman wrote letters 10 him and urged hia 70 ~ ~
TarrytoWn lie finally Went to larry town anu ~ Ia
her house. AfterWHrd he expressed las Ie2es lses
had done So for after he had made VIII N h'I isV,
She had treated him very badly. Mr.. BeeALau 80 80
time atterward showed witness what paiported wsss
will signed by him and Mrs. Purdy. as witness ss r5
Mr. BteGman intmated would rcctuy the errors 10 re-
committed in hi, former wills. but she dd not r eys ~
This was fourth Will that be had made IN tePg,1
questions asked her ~ Mr.. Lartln, tho wlthes ts
most soleinniy that she had occupied the sahc aim,
Mr. Boollnun That she Eat ever Ocel s.l.s gyrn.n
proper intimacy with him. he case As adlOuiheu ~A'
DO .embcr 4.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
FRANKLIN EDISON ENTERTAINED.

MayOr-eect Franklin Edison was given n
complimentary dinner last night by John b. Haskn. at
his home at Fordham. The guests Invited to m ct him
were the members Of the Conference Committee OF
Twenty-oue. made up OF seven members each Of Tam
many Hail Irving Hall and the County Democracy and
the successful candidates Of the County ticket On the
right OF the host sat Franklin Edison, on the
left John Kelly. After dinner had been eaen,
Mr. Hlskn as chairman OF the Conference Committee,
Ills cOabOrers upon the greatness OF the
victory Mr.. EdsOn. he said I'd been elected against
the greatest stock jODDlng combination ever ehee ed
Mr.. Cleveland had just resigned the MhyOrally OF
Buffalo In 1884 he mlgnt be translated to the WHITE
House. -
In response TO the toast of " The state OF New York
aud its & vernor-eect John Kelly said, IN the course
OF his renrKs Slr Edison mas nad experience as an
rdtOr. but ne Is apt scholar ana he VIII learn
readily Ihe Coufereuce Committee Will GiVe MN All
the advice he wants"
Responding to the toast OF " Tho City OF New York
and lis MayOrEect," dr. Edison, after tracing tGe
grown OF the city, said: AS Ale. Kelly has re-
marked | am not techuIcally familiar with
the administration Of municipal aHairs; but
think VITA of the Ze4t emen VINO dld me
tn, honor agree upon my name, shal DE able very
Soon 70 le RI do not already know. an sure,
at least, that [ snail have the assistance or the
twenty one grntcIn VINO did che nUnor 10 present
my name 10 people OF New York. VITA their coop
Grafton hope may your Congratulations upon
my retirement FROM Office two years ence, ana that
may from the people Of New Ork the saluta
ton, Well done, good and Iditufui servant "
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
SMALLPOX AT CHATTANOOGA.

WASHINGTON, Nov. 20.-The following as
match has been received from the Postmaster at ChSE
sanooga, Tenn, by Assistant Attorneydenerai ri00
IMAM: nh, ,+,,
. f,u.rr.xoooa Nov. 2O-SmallpOx here Inc cry
bo.nifI ia hled The United states barracks WeIo ~
Sese last week and the city has sjuce puenseI ' 30
ST,Idinys but they stand Government Srounu, I. -
rssir.d 10 u-e them hospital purposes Go
L. denied by superintendent o tno ,,a on vii,
an3.ncsT mo- one See the Secretary OF war az ohcei
49, 1nnr "a valuable telegraph at the request Vi o
government We have not Time 10 remove tuo
SniiJngs and want permission occupy them as tne1
stand. Acc promptly.
In answer the Secretary teegraphed this afternoon 70
,bo MAYOR of Chattanooga saying that he had been sd
SiseA by The Department Commander that suoh acuoh
would be an outrage on Mrs. Mcintyre widow OF Lieu
senant Mcintyre is residing there ana also upon
the suuerintendont OF the National Cemetery ana tee
mnovrs and i'm view OF these no was called on W
teDy the request
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
GENERAL INTELLIGENCE.

BOsTON, Nov. 20.-Presdent E. b. Phillips,
OF the Eastern Railroad informed the management OF
the Toledo Cincinnati and st. Louis Railroad this after
that he Will accept the presidency OF their com
pany upon the condition that the arrangements now
under way for raising additional capital and funding the
coupons for the next ten years are successfully
carried out. . =,
The Hareer this afternoon says: More than hall OF
tie esOJ,OOO needed by the Toledo Cincinnati ana ot
Louis Railroad has ready been subscribed"
CHICAGO, Nov. 2O.-It Is stated that c. c. Wheeler
general manager OF the AtcsOn, Topeka and Santa Fe
Railroad will decline the arDitratorship OF the three
Western pools TO which he recently elected IL Is
under stood that he will decline In favor VI George w.
Manchester, the assistant to W. b. Strong
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
POLITICAL NEWS.
COUNTY CANyAssERs EXCITED.

The Board of County Canvassers yesterday
canyassed tho returns OF votes In the XTXth. XXth
XXIId. XXITId and XXGyth Assembly Districts. Tho
Republican Aldermen were IN their seats and as soon as
the Board called to order. Alderman McClaye moved
that the action Of the Board Friday last be reconsd
cred and that the inspectors Of election OF the -FOUR
eenth Election District OF the XITth Assembly District
DC sent and questioned how II that the re-
turn Of votes in that district ransposed since cleo
ton night On that night the return stood as follows
Spmgue. l73 Bliss, 100 The supervisors return ana
tho County Clerks return agreed when produced and
showed that Bliss had received l73 votes and sprague
100. The Democratic members made several points OF
order in the enheavor 10 delay the final vote, while
several messengers sent to the homes OF the
Democratic members imploring them to hurry 10 the
rescue. The tactics for delay we're unsuccessful and
Alderman McClave's motion finally reached and
passed Then Alderman McClayc moved that the action
ust taken he reconsdered with tho intention that IL he
defeated. and the Democratic Aldermen prevented from
taking that course when they arrived later This was
done. when the Democrats arrived In force little
later they for few minutes parayzed by the news
which was told them. There is not much doubt In the
minds OF those with the subject that deDer
ate attempt has been made to count out Assembyman
Sprague and that the Democratic Aldermen are further
ing the scheme They are afraid Of the questioning
which inspectors would he subjected TO by the Repub
llcan Aldermen. rhe Democrats vented their ndgna,
ton In various ways Alderman tltLpatIlck aecIaIsd
10 was conspiracy, an undermined way OF getthB
the best OF the Democrats and that the hepubhcahs
had formally agreed 10 be present at the opening Of the
Board and TO take the course they did. Alderman
McClnve said that this untruth. There was no
understanding the part of the Republicans, aud no
concert OF action except In their endeavor TO right
wrong
Alderman Fitzpatrick declared that tho average OF
Republicans none too good to wayay messengers
and alter the election returns. lie ala not chhiSe
however that II done in this particular case
Aldermen Sauer. Kirk, Hall, and other Democrats
Joined I'm the discussion. Alderman McClaye laughed
the professions Of purity made by the Democratic
members on behalf OF their party ana reminded them
that the city had debt of over $lOOOOOOOO most OF
which the result OF stealing By Democrats when
they controlled the city government. Finally Alderman
Fitzpatrick offered what be claimed new res0u-
ton that the inspectors be not sent for and this AFTER
amendments by the Republicans had been voted
down, carried.
The canvas. completed last evening The clerks
will he engaged to-day and probably large part OF TO-
morrow In adding up the total vote for euch candidate
II probable that tie official result VIII DO an
nOunccd before late Wednesday aud possibly not be-
fore thursday.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-11-21
THE CASE OF CHALMERS.

JACKSON Miss, Nov. 2O.-General Chal-
mers mas died petition for maniamus before Judge
Wharton compel the Secretary OF state TO count lis
votes in Tate County. lie ohsrges that Mr. Myers the
Secretary OF sat allowed from other districts
to be inspected refused to allow any ono To 500 the
returns from tue Id District until they were counted
lie alleges that the purposey concealed 10
prevent any errors rom being corrected during tho ten
DAYS allowed by making returns, and says The
cer Al error As TO j. K. "Cha nDosS" would Oeen
promptly corrected II the returns had not been frdndu
ienty concealed. Tne Commissioners OF Election Of
Tate County have seat an ded show ing that
tue votes were for j. r. Chalmers, and not for j.
Cuambliss"