New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-07-03
pREpOSrEROUS CLAIM.

~ AMERICAN CITIZENSHIP.
Una rs N TUE DECISION OF THE UMPIRE
inA -,r R,-zzI cAsE-THE RIGHT OA Nl"'-D -,
IN I'M r,,r MOTIVES OF FoREiGNkR ~
nro>uSe NArURALIZED
rdttor Of TAe Trtonne' IL.
have read your editorial o. 'il's -
SIX ,ro ID BuzEi,' and Deg leave 10 IH'"''"
:, suthsntic copy OF tie oeclsio u wy ri.h
you ,a..nhsupt IN that case. when you pioU,N 49,,
w. ...soo Will BECOME historic lou VIII SO -, %
greal 'e.s h Swedish Minister, who happens no" !"
y, the umpire IN the United s'"'es an" ~, aimee
" r.n,ch has been sitting in Washington eve |
,a 81 Jasmine the rignt TO reverse any uec'oI "
,h. limited states IN matters OF hAtui"iN-
v. r. asvocat. for Spain is the one WHO N'' p
,s,aea that the action II the courts OF 'DiS -,
ho,ld ~. ,nvest gated by the Commission Anu ''1 -
,,,o- tor Spain In bis decisions Las gone ~ To- a.
declare that the action Of the courts u '
.hasty loose and inconsdersie' ~ .rtbor-
sncb ,dcas tending to give the Commission IN
Nt..r =. "a. nor ana cannot have under tne Inv"
y &c. t-siaent of the United states hlinaeh caAHo'
g. because what the Courts do ana ueci" "'''''N
,ns limits and scope Of their Jurisdiction re-NA''o
hoDa aud decided forever - couiu mo-
aocepted by any impartial umpire MI la" .,
-, md Raron Blanc who in succession hr.i
.,s, important position. did rot allow the sahcl'! " -
,dgment. Of the courts Of conpsient Jurisdiction % %
- nv br,rd OF arbtrat0rs appointed 10 as7r9s
Sages and for nothing else. who are mereN 'n' "'i
q, the Secretaries OF State OF the two Nations anu
- at here under all international agreement Hoo
.u,roitted TO the Senate. nor approved hy H.
v-lsp Count Lrwenhsupt was appointed ana ne H' ~
- nI aec,sion Of che case OF Mr.. Buzz, whose Aher-
CIV -, ,as recognized by Spain BY decree OF
>,.t.r 1s-3 he could not cut Guain ain the same
-, -. h,. nrrdecessors Mr. Bartholl ana Baron
Ilc and he said that could rot ma any authority
"a. commended By Spain. 10 examine "ho'her Tue '0
,,raucnr. Of the American law Of naturalization haze
heen m filled" But. while paving respect To pfihce
~ fhs way by means OF theoretical assertion H. pTao-
rcaIly refused Mr.. Buzz the recognition OF MS II- 40
a. American citizen. IN TIE JUDGMENT u the UMPIRE
A. A. ars eraJe- IN the ciuzenzuip. and be
ssVs that according To inIeru4ucua' law every
conntry has a rignt to eOnfer by General or special
i"in the privilege OF nationality upon person Do n
on nj own territory ," but be al that Stch az
.-aon has ,riihsn he limits Of ue country Of orgu 10
,bSr en- cf tam that ohtcA ne Government o. Sa'd conn
on chOoses roiuntdy1ig 20 eoncede- 49,. 49,,
Xo. SCI 1lat ths stion is iIn.ehabe, ana that MI
whine could not tolerate IL for ID moment NOI 90
mink that MI. Frenngauysen WILL How couiu ne per
mi the decision TO remain Oh record a. egal m %
Cent t6a the rights Of the Darurazed citzens OF me
United states are the mercy OF their former Govern
fnents and deprnd Only upon WHAT they NoIun.a.l't
oboase ~ ooneei 10 such proposition nation u
Sffy millions OF inhabitants so many OF Whom are nat
ur.lized citizens, cannot quietly uynli , -,
r. c,,rr's1.ndence between Mr.. Durant and Mr.
blaine Shows how quickly me eagle eye % NJ pain,
saw the wrong attempted to be done 10 the c4~e"s Oh
Aotns ai.der these ideas the umpire Count Lewen-
haupt could discover easily what hobouy, even Sti
Sersf had sus gected before duru'g eD years ara tGs
a tina; pro against spain vas ohy 20 DC sFeu 10
those Lus Of the Uuiteu States VINO nave Oeeh nat
urlzed M good fth ana not to others ana tAaI Ine
est M his good faJh Is to be uninterrupted resldehcc
~ I'VE or more years within the United states.
This i another claim which could not De toerale anu
which called forth the prompt action OF NL: b.sloe. i.
the dnty Of the United states 70 protect ls cleus as
SUCH cluzens and because they are cluzehs hre
snectly. OF any Otner reasons or circumstances.
Good faith is required in the naJuranzdtou IL ths
United states toward The United states themselves,
Aud not ward the nation whose allegiance If aufto
and tn residence years OF more, 4nlerFuP ou
uninterrupted cannot be made the TEST o. SUI soot
faith The faith may BE- very good under sloIt TOO
deuce or unuer q residence Interrupted AID very oal
under a long aud constant oGe .. -
When Martin kOszta protected against Aus1IlA D!
Mr. Marcy aud tue Congress Of the Uulteo o'ates
thanked Captain graham FOR his noble action on lhs'
ocasion nobody inquired whether kOsztA nteDueu 70
become citizen tie United Siat-s IN goa or IL pa1
faith AGAINST he Government OF Austria
have 20 dOub tbat the senate " tie OHIted states
viii ud some means 10 protect Mr. Buzz and all other
CITIZENS OF the United states wAo have ben Injured O
Buau. and who BY a combination o. accidcNJs almost
UcredIDI., have been augnlshiDs for more t-an Ten
years without practical results oi any Importance.
NArURALlZED CITIZEN
B0s.4ngtoa d. o.. June 20. lSa-