New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-06-14

JAMES MAILEYs SISTERS on THE WITNESS STAND
CONTRADICTORY STATEMENTS OF LULU NAL
LEY.
FROM sPFcI,L CORRESPONDENT OF TIE TRlBrNE.)
NEw-HAvEN, June 13.-The delay of eleven
days has diminished ia the least the interest which
people here take in the Malley trial At the opening Of
the morning session the denomination Of Miss Lulu
Mallcy, sister OF James. resumed The questioning
OF the witness by Mr. Bush thorough and even Sc
vCre The counsel for the succeeded in involving
the IN several Contradictions but the discropan-
ces between her statements made on the direct
examination aud those which she uttered to-
day not Of very serious nature. There are also
several points Of difference between her recent tes
mony and that which she gave before the Coroner at the
inquest asst summer -.
light when won had suppor Friday night 49,, ut:
Mr. Rnsh read from the testimony ut the inquest IL
was qnte light when we had supper There was no reA
why were late"
Odd You not 50 testifyi Al did not as remem-
ber
OWN Won swear that you did not A.-Yes. sir
I viii. We usually had supper between anu o
Q-Dd you not testify at West Haven that James was
singing upstairs while you we're in the orchard ana tl
he called to you to get towel Al tlinA not "'''
James singing while was on the porch. -. r,os
Odd Won not testify before the Coroner maj james
went to bed about o'clock that night Al uiu ou'
ODD you not testify tina: after Mrs: Malloy went
away YOU and your sister went up stairs ana Huuu
James in bed IN his own room with the door open A
Mr Buah read from the written reports o' the te-ti-
mouy given BY the witness al former hcarngs to sho"
that she had testified his questions ind !te'i
O.-Was James at home on SATURDAY. night. August v.
Al don't think 20. He home AZ supper time Dut
don't think he home at breakfast time sunday
Odd You not testify at the inquest that
YOU were home Saturday night "hen jan m
he AZ breakfast sunday morning with the rel OF the
family Al don't remember. don't Trims dd. ,h
The testimony gwen Nv the witness in regard ~ me
ride she took with James on Thursday nsht was the
oW6ich Of these accounts the one You gave before
the Coroner or the one yoI gave the 9thr u Is
rect; AThe last testimony gives the correct account
ODD Won MOI testify at the Coroncrs nquast that
! Won saw James Friday morning. Al am sure 'u
Nr Bush again read from his notes to show that she
Mrs Lizzie " Wolfe James Malleys oldest sister. was
called witlc---St tam T. Hoy testimony was
substantially olows: Lat Auenst &c va uvlnt 81
home. on Friday evening, August D. Ihii, eli'L q
dinner IN company with MS Iath' lne VII ~ ~. :
not him before that day. she next sa" MN tt
0'coc that evening when he-camc 20 he hcuen uor
and asked her when supper would be ready.
| $50 afterwarl Jaw him IN the dninsroom, me a-se
him 10 el his sister Kate to tea. lie went Hp tihIr
after SINNER The rest ~ the family and some friends
who were there went into the pAror JA,Il-7 - ne
shortly af.erward If the wat-r was warm so tli1 ne
could Io.Le Al his request she lad ont some ~ Inc
undcrc otlGC FOR hun aud later hraIu nm asl . id
! towels ms was "A nttle before o'clock About 10
o'coct the wines went up 10 her sisters room ID
which sbe fnu,d her sister Katc. James ant Minnie
Gujo" LANES was standing BY the gas jrt booking At
al had gone 20 b.d she heard James cans i2r mos
quito netting. That was anoat 40 a ne ,i'ck
He alto his and The witness 81" MN 70 Out u
/ the gate. ~, go. -,.r,,,,
! her ANYTHING else thar happened At nome I,a' W. "A
The examination very lous and severe Pht thri
the III the Cross examination u tue previous VIZ
! ness. t.... si.c tasti
fed that ON Friday August >, she was al nome eH u'
! Jane. was at nome AT the cNruiN-'