New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-01-19

Garfield II ls not for the purpose Of doing Justice But
~ it can made to appear by the verdict OF uy ,
this act the act OF sane man, q man WIZ ,,n1
responsible for his conduct by man who conl1 W
his actions, who should be Judged ny sno thnm
whv these men can saw and will say: I've are not
responsible for what sane man mas zone We t. a.
responsible for that 1t ts true we had lu9IS ~ibf
true had n difference, but no sane man bau ~
because of that to shoot the Prcsdent Anu ma m3
reasoning Is perfectly correct IheTei"t, IA !ro.,rS
this prisoner guilty, these men are Sheltered ~
almost vudicatcd from public opinion. be i ~, bv
reason OF insanity. what Is the result The ptop;e SS
This is the man whose mind was lreEeH uP1hb a tnero
vas another war coming and that million VGS ",IF ~
be sacrificed Under that delusion he Sho' INC
That win be the first conclusion 10 what III n0 Tla
be the next slept Somebody must hc 10 p MI
when an act OF this kind has been zone. We
induced th' poor Innate to 90 ', aSd stot
ug what Con Killing said what Couking did what Arthur
said what Arthur did; what Grant said What Grant i,
~ the boTe so,9ewhere where viii it rc.t but upon
the heads Of and hearts OF these men WHO "aRu Io
men viii rest forever with that opprobrnm upon them.
and they viii down their graves Win tS co t6c
only thing that can be doue-Wh1 Grant has dohe IN re-
"a Ion ~ w. "a wrong" Let them write letter
IN the dcsolate widow at Cleveland and say TO her; II
il rno we are sorry 81 is true mourn with YOU hut
we feel That tns terrible calamity was ia some degree
the outgrcwth the legitimate result OF th9 unjust name
war which we wlred against your dead husband 9nd
they Win show thcr claim 10 the regard OF the American
people and the ouiv ling they can 60 to save 'heF
names from .ner!lcd oblivion.
Mr scovinc then resumed his review OF DR. GrayS
testimony ana commented upon ~ 10 the hour OF re-
cess. lie wa, interrupted 10y the prisoner once WIN
remark That 'ar u Try o; thg eX4ei'S %' u" H4@ ed
first and d'sscct MIN att!Wdfi Nj 9ro' ,.,o r,y
that ne would probably close his address 'oiu'IIo"
The C"u,t then. At 10 o'clock took recess Tor one
lOur After the recess the prisoner opened inc p'c'u
nTs with &'fe 10 5Sr tN t or tds crank news.
papers I'm the country. to-wt R,ds ItIBi ~ l'W.L
Medlrs Ciicago Tribune; to-Nit Iiasteds c,"c'".Hl
Commercial to-wi,. George william Curtis we
man lni!l,ue.. The weather has been rather cool
and cool eff little. The only crnnks In the country are
tlese fellows. They had liter join the GRAM m
Arthur coluAiua On and get into good company ana DC
NJ Scoye HEN proceeded with his argument and com,
~ Dr. R@5rd Of Ne7-York tc-tfying surrebuttal;
U vs. h0t 70 statc tho opinion Of The which
6@id Inv that gentleman when he intorruptrdby Mr.
Dayilec with objection 10 his going outside the eN
The Court declared that it not proper for Mr.;
scovle GO so and the latter promised hot &c oenu
Tie prisoner again broke in -" want chance 70 say
that tho NcwYork Court Of Appeals yCsleINaH HrGueu
fIiscase Thank you. Nj Jdd-c'
MI scovilc resumed his review Of The evidence as
every mind TO the conclusion that the prisoner was
either fool ur crazy man. ana declaring lna ne con.
gcf we're Inconsistent with the idea Of the mans mind
elal Reynolds had with tie prisoner lWruIne az some
ian IN on the statement made by the latter tat wien
,G iu ~. insane man could believe chat after killing
VI. Prcsia.n De youd not have 80 undergo long ana
tcdior tria for his ne.
GUirEAU CLAIMS TO HAVE FRIENDS YET.
The oncr denied ever having used suca an expires
sion and made his peatcd declarations that hencycr
lal any conception the removal Of the President as
murder and that Grant and Couklins were his friends
today, and "don't Won forget it,
Mr. scoyilc. having quoted from a newspaper inter
view with General Laga1-cydcuce introduced by the
10 ti. of. t,f