Daily globe. [volume] (St. Paul, Minn.) 1878-1884, 1882-05-04

to make about any member Of the COMMITTEES
on the subject i not believe word Of it,
nor that any Investigation Is necessary. For
one, treat 1T with utter contempt and oh.
ject to the resolutions. aN1 eai saasis{-L-H
Unanimous consent for its present consid-
Grafton being necessary the resolution went
over. IoIg3 - S@94IaG sas 3Ji ss24ot 2ssi1iiii
The senate devoted the remainder Of the
time reserved for the calendar to the politica1
disabilities bill repeating the statute prohibit.
ing the appointment Of ex coniedefates In the
army or navy. .2ia. 01iiilii 2 liiniL'
Ingalls, moved to amend SO as to continue
the statute, but confines its proposition to Of.
fcers who left the army or navy to enter the
confederate service Ingalls, moved to commi,
the bill and amendment. Hue2 ga'..
Objection to the latter motion was made or
the Democratic side, but the chair ruled 1t In
order. 20 a5-5sasst p.7 !lji2F pai3
The discussion was resumed, saulsberry
and Garland favoring the bill as reported.
ingalls,, replying to the arguments on the
Democratic side, said the senator's from South
Carolina and the aouthern statesmen who
were their associates had never Been able tC
understand that the war meant shytai1g. sgo
Butler retorted that he knew he much On
that point as the senator from Kaneas an d {
great deal mere. II he wanted inform tor
about it he would not apply to that senator
lOI Ii, HUE WOu1Q NC 6uU10Ib VI U6 l6CtuI eC
about what he knew or what he did moi
know.
Ingalls, Continuing first difficulty
with the senator's from South Carolina is that
they believe the war Was fought about q point
of constitutional etiquette and was to be ended
by polite apology. notwithstanding this,
the war did settle some things. The junior
senator from South Carolina (HamptoI) the
other day declared that God alone knew who
was right in that contest. Ny understanding
is that the North fought for the union Of the
dismember and destroy it. Thatwar was TO,
slavery in the South and 70,
universal liberty in the North.
The senator and his associates now having
again sWern to support the constitution and
its amendments, assert that, Notwithstanding
these four years contest and seventeen years
debate that have followed, God alone knows
whether it was right to fight for the union OF
against it; for human slavery or against It. =
Hampton rose to an inquiry. He under.
stood the senator to say the North fought for
universal liberty. BE would ask whether the
North took any such ground at the beginning
of the war; whether II was taken when con.
gress formally declared theipurpose for which
the war was -waged, or whether the North
would not at any time up to near the close OF
the war have recognized the existence OF
slavery If the South had returned 10 the union.
ingalls, replied that the Question showed
the Mmcntty Win 1le senator. was IN assert
Ing mat tneee 4lesaons arc 9eeo: Wnen the
senator's rom s . .ne SOUND oeSafed tnas Snefe
were no sucn tnings % f0yatty 70 Inc Union
sible for those who believe by.g0nes should
be by.gones to 20 with them in their attempt
to obIiterate The discussions, dangers and
difficulties that arose after the conflict was
CLOSED. II was nota9reeaoie LOT Inc men rep
resenting Nortnern consutue!cies 10 hear, as
ne tlngaLs) mad irepeateoly heafd, Sonlhern
senator's declare on the moor that Jefferson
Davis, IN patrlousm, ~ aevouon 70 nnman
hoerty, ana as fepfesensative OF al tnas was
gooo IN human nature, vas me peef OF ,Ionn
hampden ana george WashinHtona Within
the last forty. eight hours Southern members
had declared Robert n. Lee % pc the peer IN
PATRIOTISM ana icyaity 70 country, OF any man
who ever fought on American soil
Butler-Has NOT that member right 70 his
opinions s.ii.r,ul1. .f1. .,sts-a-
lngalis-!a am NOT Denying MS r1ght. H
were partisan on these matters would be
glad 10 nave sucn speeches. made mere every
Gay IN the week. Ord. 81,
butler-Then Why DO the senator's com.
pam. .,.. =. q, ,a;.. -. a...,.l
lngaHs-6ecause neither the senator nor any
OF his associates have disavowed In believing
In such allegations. ae.r.ya.
SALISBURY remarked. ne dfd NOT near ingalls,
dissent from the CONCLUSION announced Dy the
senator from nevada tJonee!, IN the Chinese
denate. tnat the recOnssructlon pohcy OF the
South was ialnre. -,
ingalls, replied that the reason WY pc DID
not olssens wa because ne nso never peen an
aovocate OF taat poAcy, ne ieRsraeo y as Y,
many respecn Ga; a. un!ayolanle pl1tnoer, an 3a
we had been paying the penalty Of It. ne did
not propose 70 discuss the question Is 70 thzt
now. ne would merely esy 70 me snstors
from the so9tnern STATES tnat argumepU, ior
the oohteration OF tne war stalntes py exciu-
sion, Dasea upon tne loea s9aL tnete Wa oil-
Terence De5ween Inc TWO sioes. 70 t1as con-
met, Wouio nna NO response 70 Noltnern
nealts, Ous mou.o % touo Mee Dy vino'ca1lons
OF those eC8Iule6 at bQe OallOG COX.