The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1882-09-10
HONORABLY DISCHARGED.
THE OUTCOME OF DIR. KNIVES AND
MIR. DAV1DSON'S ARREST
A Jury OF Homeopathic Physicisns Decide
that the Treatment OF Mrs. Davidson by
DIR. Kinne was What IL should Have been,

A Jury OF Homeopathic Physicisns Decide
that the Treatment OF Mrs. Davidson by
DIR. Kinnc was What IL should Have BeeA,
Coroner Brady held an inquest yesterday
in respect to the death Of Mrs. George L. Da-
Wilson's child the body Of which was found In
the North River last Wednesday. DIR. Theo-
dore Y. Kline OF Paterson N. j.. and Mr.. Da-
wilson we're present with their counsel Judge
Baldwin OF Paterson, Mrs. Davidson's father.
was a listener. Tho jury consisted OF Drs.
James A. Carmichael OF II West Thirtieth
street. Charles L. Campbell Of 314 East Egh-
teenth street. Edmund Carleton Of SO West Ninth
street. Francis Z. Doughty Of 46 West Thirty
third street. William E. Krause of 329 East
Fourteenth street. and Mr.. F. Snyder OF 303
West Twelfth street. The physicians are Of
the homeopathic school. as is DR.. Kline.
Garrett May Hugh Gaffney. and Policeman
Kelly testified as to tho finding OF the childs
body MS previously reported.
Inspector Byrnes testified as to the arrest Of
Mr. Davidson. Inspector Byrnes said he asked
him whether DR.. Kline was guilty Of malprac-
tice. and he said he did not know; that he had
nfed ns Ife to &C. abroad ad pear tae
Of mind, walking the room and tearing her
hair and that he had feared she would become
sons story ,of DR., Kinne's treatment Of his wife,
substantially as it has been printed. asked
ths sS Mr. f DAVIDSON sa Is
sent to Coroner Merklc's house; and he said he
late Then for cSrone aH Brady who
the t office With the policemen told the Core;
s"s ahe his w"s
Mr.. Davidson took a seat beside the Coroner.
ment to the Coroner"
Coroner b4saEy to read that
Hold on" interposed Mr.. Davdson's coun-
sci; now now enter protest against the reading
Il shall read it. in accordance with the usual
custom in this office" said Coroner Brady;
that You have no right to read
charged With b, crime and you had no iurisdic-
This protest was entered on the minutes and
Coroner Brady kr read the aepostion ,,n.
ady 10 IsTfa Mss B Sh
he said and believe it to be correct. 1t
charged pr Kline with complicity in this thing.
might need medical treatment"
II took III, the Doctor with me in order to be
Dr; I: Y Kline testified: WI Mrs D Mary David
son has been my patient for years. She was an
The first knowledge Ihad Of Mr. and Mrs. Da.
Wilson's return from their tour was by a telc-
Rte SR tkrd9 Sp saa r iSs
his wife had a severe chill at Saratoga the day
i4o; and partly deirious. stated. in response '
to their inquiry. that | presumed there was
spsd RI is hs r S.r
said would give g. ooof she was we'll Tiers
ed for any malpractice. directed Mr.. David
son to procure some hot water, which was APP
and that is the, reason | used lamentations
Or. Kline described his treatment Of the
and medicines used as he claimed. to re ie'e
her Of her pain: all Of which he declared were
my treatment was TO prevent MISCARRIAGE. On
Wn stated mst ,p pr1sysy NY opinion
eye her al @ r Srhs 1T Would SS nd
I neither be ri nor best unless to save her
Davidson dffsronlGd and found Mrs David
would have another congestive chill. Owing ing
to her condition, it became NECESSARY to relieve
ancee;" Dr. Kline described the treatment. He
shR n be Tas POSITIVE that there Vas not life in
du1ced by the fatigue of Mrs Davidson's Journey.
McGr1n saed brnj{ then reah deposit99n, Of Dr.
no marks of violence on i. At the request Of
kinne whether Mr.. Davidson at any time asked
him to make use of any treatment which was
He did not, replied Dr. Kline.
=, Inc Jury retired at ?. NJ. After an absence
| We, the Jury, md that the attending physician Dr.
mime or Paterson ~ j. throughout thr whole treat
mcnt OF Mrs Mary Davidson did all that
al skill and humanity Of kind ply stefan could suggest
for N" relief of his patient and that the child to
It's death from natural
Coroner Brady then discharged Mr.. Davidson
| and Dr. Kline from arrest and released their
| bondsmen.
| MIR. and Mrs. Davidson were still at the Fifth
| Avenue Hotel last evening. Mrs. Davidson
| was reported much improved