Daily globe. [volume] (St. Paul, Minn.) 1878-1884, 1882-03-23

Office, and that it was competent for the sen
ate to fix any less punishment If it though
best. Finally Senator Castle withdrew hi
amendments.
Senator Kinds then moved that the cour
vote upon the proposition as to whether tn
| Judgment to be rendered by the cour
should embrace the respondents removalfron
office.
Senator Castle offered the following as
| substitute: Shall the respondent be removes
from Office for the causes stated In tn
charges and articles on which he was fount
guilty.
Quite a good deal of discussion, or rathe
talk, followed this, Mr.. Kinds taking th
position that the proposition offered by hin
was the proper way to proceed. 1t was onl,
step towards the removal of respondent
The removal itself should form a par
OF the Judgment. Senator Castle argued
in favor of his proposition, and did not agree
with Senator Kinds at all, as to the legal effec
of the two propositions. He subsequently
withdrew his amendment but it was renewed
and on being put TO a vote was lost by the fol
lowing vote 80
Ayes-Aaker. Campbell, Howard, McLaugh
lin.
Noes-Adams, Bonniwell, Buck, C. F.. Buck
D., Case, Castle, Crooks, Gilfllan, c. D., Gil
fillan, j. B., Kinds, johnson, A. NJ, johnson
F. l., johnson r. B., Mccormick, McCrea
Mealey, Miller, Morrison, Officer, Perkins
Shalleen, Simmons, Tiffany, Wheat, White
Wilkins, Wilson.
Senator Kinds proposition was then voted
on and carried by the following vote.
Ayes.-Buek D., Campbell, Case, Clement
Gilfllan, c. D., Gillian, J. B., Kinds, How
ard, johnson, A. NJ, johnson, F. L., John
son, r. B., Mccormick, McCrea, Mclaughlin
Miller, Morrison, officer, Perkins, Peterson,
Pillsbury, Rice, Smaller, shalleen, Tiffany
Wheat, White, Wilkins, Wilson.
Noes-Aaker. Adams, boutwell,, q. F.
Buck, Castle, Crooks, Powers. Simmons.
An order was then adopted that certified
transcript of the judgment of the court be
transmitted to the governor.
Senator Kinds then offered an order TO the
effect that the judgment of the court
shall embrace disqualification from holding
any judicial Office for three years. An amend
ment was offered to make the time of dis
qualification seven years instead OF three
Col. Crooks gave notice of debate, but the
order, as the proposition was not q resolu-
ton, and on a vote being taken on the amend
ment it was lost. The vote was then taken
on Senator Kinds order and the same was
carried by the following vote of rs to IL:
AYes-Aakers, Buck, D., Campbell, Case,
Clement, Gilfllan, G. D., Gilfillan, j. B.,
Kinds, Howard, johnson, F. l., johnson, r.
B., Mccormick, McCrea, Mclaughlin: Mil.
Ter, Officer, Pillsbury, Rice, Smaller, Shalleen,
Tiffany, Wheat, White, Wilkins, Wilson.
Noes Adams. Bonniwell, Buck. Castle
Crooks, johnson, A. NJ, Mealey, Morrison,
Perkins, Peterson, Powers, Simmons.
Senator Kinds then offered long document,
which proved to be the judgment of the court.
This recites at great length the history of the
case--the articles of impeachment, the organi-
cation of the court, trial, arguments and the
result which disqualifles the respondent from
performing the duties of Judge of the Ninth
judicial district, or holding that position, or
that of any other judicial Office for three
years. This was adopted by the same vote,
which closed the trial proper.
Various other minor matters were at
tended to. It was voted to pay the counsel
for the respondent to the amount of IS per
day, not to exceed $3.50.
Senator Gilfllan called attention to an ar
ticle in the Dispatch in regard to q caucus
held in regard to the result of the trial, and
denied the truth of the statement in the ar
ticle and 1t was agreed to expunge all that had
been said about it, from the record.
The respondent is to be furnished with The
proceedings OF the last day of the trial.
Some other little matters were attended to,
after which the court adjourned at midnight,
till 10 o'clock this morning