New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1882-02-04

a n f,o
states tina: he was OF the haihHs IN chaHt der
ury: thsf he occupied room No -. IN when ~, u1
ohasr a eonv o. me Egeniqg critic dnr'pe ne LA
that there never vas cupS o. me tt"t " ,sr mo-
five. ma; NJ @eoyils haa Seeu IN ,t' C'Floie
the hotel upun occasions, ana VIE. VIC % =, tm,es
thereon 70 be the signat,res OF I'M ln' b,,ii,T
Allan Il. searIe, another Oh '..1 tbrsr I,rr-
sons AZ lie National Hotel CA one occasion, T11sf az
lions raet. Ills Stteron 'h"s qey az hat tins
matter was tse ject Of criticism sui Quart aHn
i1at at The hour when sae Sa5S Una, ne T ~ ,bir
roOus. aud mat 1t VS. insst0it mtoHso'e La La .S
could have done 90 Tie last blnuaY - 10 ~
Henry Brasueu, enc OF the witnesses "boSe tYldehee
Mr. Scoyue desires tU bring IN a. newly CacOFereu eN
nc yb de, les ina; be over cav the prisoner except
one cay while e was being from the court room I"
TIE y6l lie states that last jane ne ud ete VA" VA
ia.ayet,e PARK vino may been the prisoner ana
fnat ne remarked thai he uusi be either GlspPoleu
oiicc-srrttr - luuauc lie Ithleu, nON'|Sl' INC
stataeu made by Mf, sc0vir III his aindaElt INA, ne
was frightened ol OF the park ny The czy c0ndtct OF
sc District Attorney tGeu stated that he had nothing
10 aad tc those ahdayiJs He Thought they completely
dIspOse4 0i mOtlOu Tor " ne" 1Iial. -, ,,..
NJ. ocUy,uc-i desire {" move "a eXpuhAt IRON
anIdayiis certain portions 81 them wier 10 D'sHe'
Attorney, Al seems 10 uc. must nave Aho"o "'i' ~"
Judge Cox-ihrfe Is good deal the afi avt+, par
ticnary IA rrs.rd "a SNYDER which Is MOI comp en-
evidence, and WllI uVt DC c"G"i0''cu ny ' it rae
M. ScuvIle-i THINK it no more tbah HSht va" Ne
Court should say NM eCoh 'iilr IRON, fhe record
saying th8t thcy should % 6NPhISeu uVn S,,.T ia
Tue only nah WHO raises Gs Eol,e a-S' - 800 m
az on
throwing "dt eVe'EihhE III LIS ,,,sh ~, RENAL
Snyder, cli0naJtS RON Wizard iiiouSh p'I~'nai
piquo. only Imagine one parallel 70 "a ga" ouV..
at,a thA is me 0f men sympathinhs WltL me
Di-trct-AttorDey throughout lac country "tV q" 90,
ing letters 10 me Med "lth 'he virus o s1npOA' ia,
il tine only parallel he drawn and thaS Is me
TACT. From this cenire come these death-auen
to me- ana tnis centre the gentleman lhehus sI
20 ont he GlSriyes wlcn VIII De uea'h-o'o" W 'Ho
character at tnls man. . -, ,r.. a. h. -
plunged eXrrp lar a. IL Inpeached the ciel' oil 0hF
der for truth and vcraoity. .,, ,,o,ti,, ~ the
afdav's MED ~ the defence he had n9 rg1 fo hun
and ne du not feel tnaI ought 10 act upon me notiU
vitnout ttKIng under tvist ntnt uAth 'C-hoII" a.
counsel had any question II law or fact winch ihey
wished to discuss ,e, it might be well To 90 -"
MI ScovIlIo inquired whether MS Honor would take
under consideration tAe question as TO whether NC
would allow evidence be taken as to the Eehhehess
OF tue Jurors signatures cn the arSin OF tAe
The court replied that lie c"uld not ADMIT auas y,
oral evidence tending To snow that the dispute" "Its
Was the writing OF the jgroTs by amply eoiP''ie "
TIE ARGUMENT OF Mr. DAvIDGE.
sfr Daviuge nen proceeded 10 argue against the mo
ton for new trial Tue subject of newly discovered
evidence touched upon briefly, Nj DavidGe houihg
thai the evidence the defence desired 10 bring
in was simply cumulative and of The weakest KIND AS
10 the matter Of finding Of the newspaper III room
70 which the jurors had during the trial, Mr.
Daydge criticised severely conduct Of snyder in
going into room which ne had authority 10 enter
and taking theIeTon an article which lie had no night
10 take Any fair-mnded man would concede thS, the
status Of Soy der of suspicion Even granting
thai tue psyei had been found IN room, II did not
follow ali tina OF the jurors had ever read the
newspaper Il remarkable bow glibly hal fact was
IL seemed most natural thlLs TO ocONIIe
that "a in4n WHO inscribed his name OD neW"
paper must nceesSit"c rel have re1d inc
contents of that newspaper. re tpaVugcl
ccniended the presumption Of law IL ihe other
ia he course OF his iHrttf criticism OF HhEntrs
conduct hi bavige sneerg! relerTen Z" ms thierihg
strange wneA the prisoner suggested that the
door OF TIC open.
Mr.. Oavd.e--Yes, auG many private doors arc open;
but what would you THINK Of me ii went moushg around
The pii,o:,r-If you had been in snJders place, you
would have tone what ne did
Mr.. ptytse tbeu commented upon the circumstance
OF the finding OF the newspaper I'D To- jurors quarters
hayins been known by Mr.. ScuVui, 10 beochhtl' ana
upon ,h -enonans failure 10 bring It to the attention
The C1Gf!-i is due 10 Mr. scoye 10 say hat no did
Of he Iarsha.s ,lG discovered that it error
Mr. Daudge-lhese papers do net show that Mt SEQ
vile brought 10 The attention OF the f0t AID jury,
bus nul ,he chance of he rial that was de
oiIed aga..ist hn feyampeGE - stou"1 ior new
Sir Davidse continuing argument, orterde'. that
It was evidence that the jurors rcat me htc"pg
Critic berausc Their names were upon II.
TIE prIsuaeI-lts very strong pTrsunpllNc evidence
Jug,e efrecilly m regard 20 grog Jury, and cigar
jury ana . lIry that Pi,,s cards.
Sir. Day1se obara,icrlrd The proposition for Tie sp-
poiitncnl q! o"uiis~oi impure into the mai, 81
" SIMPLE unqualified nonsense. dHd protested asaiast
ll actl' o. the jury being lmpcachrd ~ nls-r-
able d. spcable trick lie referred L. Sn} dHr Hs he
Ing apOtieG - leopard W TINS bIslrss. because man
cannot touch tth without being Iered IL c0ncidSlOn
NJ SAID II falriy tried was the case
OF the United states against Charles j. Guttau Ger
fanny be iJcr no com ialu aSai3sl the Otfahtl,
patience aud justice OF i'.s court shi huhbi summit
THAI punc pOncy aGd The administration Oi justice
alike demand that tins tTl sda CONE 10 al erd, ana
the motion iVr . new ulNi pr oNrTruioL .
Mr. acog.llv then indsuan 5 replied TO the criticisms
which had ncen naGe asa!Dsi SnJ hcf b"th ny c"oLsei
Remarks Al. ed uildaNlts OF the
Jurors uad drawn Ep under tie erection OF Mr..
Da silg". Lars the 'dtIe "'he ont staten IHa' VIVA
ever the jIIy s"cre 70 he ""Lld iud0Tsc,
The Dirflct AItoruoy-A1d the cOuatrY viii endorse.
mr. eoo,iAe-Oh. sontleneu, WI not be dn'e from
this oase by Cainesr gonss or anything else When
leave Inlz case
dr Dag:deo tdryiy)-Oh no! The ease vii leave YOU,
M SrovI-I cav teal snyder nad ushi % take tAat
paper. Aad say that ne.Orc We get through WIN tins
matter Court viii SIGNIFY from the bench that sU! Ger
did raht.
WI VIZ DnaI YOU forget 70, Corkhn. God Almighty
takes iOn- pui, bat lie cones ou' ahtad very une
r scoye pr"cesae" 70 argue 'n@' oA' u'i "''0' 'iN
The DisuIat-A ttoruey-iiow DO you know about thatf
Tue pr1soner-I never beard oi The gentleman before
the Affidavit appeared .
abe tnat sn had put MP lob IN tits matter, 90
IN, ground fpat there was nothing 10 Induce Lin to do
it, unless fer the purpose Of seeing that justice
%Se DistrctAttouey-Hc not say that he did
take the I,s per INTO tie room huuseit
The prisoner-The answer To C0rSblPs eur Is that
Snyder says walked iuI0 the room aDd "a thr paper
maj diseases nf ais wicked, dgibonraI sl1r.
Mr. scoye-Wueu this case COMES before the Court in
bauc shall make point whether counsel ioi the prose-
cution have right at every stage % 4. case TO
nounce and witty not only the defendant but the VII
Mr. Dasidge-I am doing all get it TO the Court
in Danc, but yOu VIII not lei it 80 thcfe.
Ar scOyine-Yes Will; after while; IRE arguments
OF the prosecution have been those o. VhAcnIoA ana
aspersiOn instead OF reason
THE ASSASSIN AGAIN EXCITED.
The AttorneyIs IL crime TO charge tuat the
5ury viola d their oathst
MIR Scoyile--It is crime 10 slege specific acts.
From the be ginning end IA these adsyts there
this sneakng nuuendo against snyder,a Is this
object.
tine table with ms clcucbed hand, ia order to
give emphasis his declaration And God Almighty
will In flne rain every opposed 20 GlYo the
Iord Dieut, II time 10 pun me tbing through
few minutes later the prisoner. VINO had been for
soe time engaged in comparing the names C the Jurors
anon the mar in OF newspaper with their names
1bey appra q euIautOgrSpb album, exclaimed Any
one can see trat they in the same hand writing
hurdrad oerfs Wouid testify |