Morning journal and courier., 1881-10-11
sournd altO Guurier.
Tuesday Morning, Oct. ii. 1881.
Jennie Cramer's Fate.

The DefenSe-Vhe COachman'S Evidence The Carriages the Important Nights-The Chambermaid'S Evidence and her Trials on Cross-Examinafion l The Court Takes a Trip to the FOote Building.
 The Malley trial was resumed yesterday morning at West Haven.
 James Bohan, coachman for Edward Mal- ley, was the first witness for the defense. | Have been coachman for Edward MalIey since f May 14th last; Thursday morning, Aug. 4th, l I saw James and Walter going toward the i store in a buggy it was about o'clock; | saw Walter that day at noon; he brought the team to the barn; if I recollect right he was alone; saw Walter on the next morning, Friday, shortly before s o'clock think it was s, as it is the usualH hour hitch up 8 team for him. I am pretty certain James got in the buggy with him; on Saturday morning Walter went out with bis own team and re- turned at noon, James being with him. I should say that Walter got home on that Thursday night between 1O:3O and II o'clock, and at about Il on Friday night I usually get to bed about Il o'clock retired on Thursday night just before Il and the next l night at 11:15 both nights before going to bed had taken care of Walters horse, he having returned; I fed the animal and washed it's feet; no one saw me; after get ting that done locked up the barn and put the key in my pocket; the horse was not out again to my knowledge; there is no other key to the barn that know of; found no signs of the horse, carriage or harness being out after left the barn those nights have no doubt at all as to the nights have testi- fled to; usually get to the barn at and 5:3O in the morning.
 Witness was cross examined by MT. Bush Witness adhered to his direct evidence that the teams were all in on both those particu- lar nights looked at the clock and was quite sure; Friday night Michael W. Malley had out the black horse and Walter the brown one Michael came back between half-past nine and half past ten; he had out the side box buggy and Walter new top buggy; on Thursday night my folks were up when I got home I think Michael also had out team that night, getting home about 9; Thursday night Walter took the team out about o'clock and drove down to the store; am positive that hitched up the team at 7 that evening and that he drove off in it. come to think it may have been Friday night.
 The testimony of witness regarding We'd nesday night excited interest also.
 On Wednesday night Walter came home between one and two o'clock in the morning. I sat up for him; he came to the barn alone or drove right down to the barn from the street. he had one horse and the two seat Surrey buggy don't recollect about Tuesday | or Monday or Sunday; but Wednesday. l Thursday and Friday night remember, and | shall for twenty years to come, and so would anyone that had MT. Bollman humping on him for about twenty minutes, as I did | about that time I know Charles I. Wilson I met him the morning Jennie Cramers body l was found.
 Witness was now asked if he did not tell l MT. Wilson in Lutz's grocery something | quite different from his above testimony, viz, that he (witness) was all played out from l sitting up so late waiting for the teams to ! come home. Witness answered emphatically that he would take his oath that he did not tell Wilson that.
 Being asked what he did tell him witness said: remember telling him that I had to work harder at Malley's than did at Nal lory's, where I used to work did not tell MT. Wilson or Mir. Lutz that I had been kept up until o'clock in the morning waiting for horse or horses; I told him was worked hard ; I said nothing to him about being kept up late, nor about being kept up till 3 or 4 o'clock that Saturday morning could not have said that because it was not true; I have heard from Wilson since through John O'Brien, of the corner of Grown and Howe streets did not send l O'Brien to see Wilson I met O'Brien few days after I testified before the coroners jury, and said I thought it strange Charley Wilson should say what he did.
 ] I heard the clock strike 1 shortly be fore Walter drove home Wednesday night, Au- gust 3d; saw him the next morning about 1 8 o'clock; he took the team out between 6 and that Wednesday evening
 | The witness was not allowed to state the conversation he had with O'Brien Mir. Bush remarking that it would come in later in the | ease.
 t'Were there brass hub bands on the buggy that Mir. Walter had out Friday night ?''
 s'There were gold hubbands on the buggy | he had out on Thursday and Friday nights T
 To MT. Fox-Walter did not have the Sur. ! rey-two seat buggy-out any night to my knowledge except that Wednesday night hitched to it were Walters horse and the l black mare I recollect the black mare had just before been out to take boy after med icine for Mrs. Michael Malley; I am sure ! this was the Wednesday of that week.
 Nellie Sullivan, chambermaid at Edward
 Malley's, was recalled; said she was cham
 bermaid; on Friday morning, August 5th
 the store watchman came to the house about
 eight or half after he wanted to see James
 Malley asked him to step out and the
 watchman handed James a telegram yes
 Walter was in the house at the time fixing
 new covering for 8 shelf; the watchmar
 came in and had breakfast in the kitchen
 Walter got home that Friday night between
 1O:30 and II know it is so because rec
 ollect that that day I had my afternoon ou
 and was delayed in getting home until lC
 o'clock; remember giving him the milk he
 usually drank at night that night shortly af
 ter got home.
 Mr. Bush cross examined the witness, who
 told further about her getting home, how sht
 had to unlock the door to get in, and ther locked up the doors again and then heard
 Walters footsteps the stairs, he having
 probably let himself in at the back door witt night key witness said that then she rar
 up from the basement and saw Walter stand ing in the kitchen; thought when she got tC her room she heard Walters door shut don't know how many beds were disturbed in the house that night; think I only made up Walters bed Saturday morning 1 I think that made up two beds on Friday morning, and I am pretty positive that made up two on Thursday morning; I don' know why I said moment ago two bedi ! were made up on Saturday morning, but don't remember of making up more thar one I think James Malley was at tht ! house Thursday morning and Friday morn ing; have forgotten whether l told Mir
 BolIman that James was there Thursday | mOrnluS ana uOG on T rluay morning; WnRt l ever told Mr. Bollman was the truth, be cause could remember better then thinl now James was there when Walter was GOV ering the shelf on Friday morning; I an positive he was there Saturday morning; Mir
 Fair came after me to come out here to-day
 we talked about the telegram he asked ns if remembered calling James out when the
 watehman called; I cannot remember wheth , CT MT. Fair asked me what morning it was called James out; I had previously talked with the watchman about the telegram talked with him before he came out here cannot tell what told the watchman wher he asked me if remembered about calling James Malley to the door.
 Witness became worked up to indignation and desperation under MT. Bush's cross ex ! animation, and finally became so balky that she replied "I don't remember to every thing, until finally Justice Booth talked tt } her kindly and fatherly, with such good re suits that she told the good justice in 8 burs | of feeITno that sha IUonld him ba