New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1881-04-07
A LIVELY DEBATE IN THE ASSEMBLY.

A LIVELY DEBATE IN THE ASSEMBLY.
rwO HEw pLANs PRoPnsED-FARNEsT ADVOCACY
on ALL sIpFs-FINAL ACTION DELAYED
lFRoN THE REGULAR CORRESPONDENT OF rue TRIBUNE.
ALBANY April 6-rhs discussion on the Street
Cleaning bill awaited with Vr' at interest 10
dav. Toward noon the excitement vlslbly increased
clond of w York politicians lowered about the
members whenever they stroed through
the open spices back of the seats
There was much lobbying ADD tbs pro-
posai to substitute soma for Prof Chandler
had led to a test which lasted nearly all night
and was continued ull the Assembly met. One
party. led by Mr. f. A. Carpenter and MIR. Hamil-
ton, would have Mayor Grace apooiut tho Su-
perntendeut subject to conformation by the
Board of Health This was generally regarded
as surrender to public opinion, as ex-
pressed by the Committee ~ TweDtv-onA Support
Of the bill as It ca from ths Senate 1t was de-
clHred might be expected from these men in the end
1t ~as arcued N their ehalf that the supervision
over the MAYORS appointment by the Bosrd of
Health would 90 merely nominal.
Opposed to this party was ore sd by AsSemblyman
brodsky winch was in favor of Governors
Commission comp SD OF one Democrat and two
Republicans. Inns would insure, they claimed Re-
publican con 'rol. aud probably satisfy the pubic
demands. Both those rvh schemes came be ora
ertul ruAusrl os qnety at work in Ia
vor of Mayor Grace. Th-se chiefly
the exp an ,uons If tne weiny RaDu Iliean m-n-
brrs of the Co nmittee f rwen'v-Onc that they ed
gwen time IN mo ief t. bin II IA, Dlrtv at each
| election aud Ind now somc 81 i'm TO considerations
J. P,erpont Morgan sad warmly 10 m"Inb T:
What want to protect IA the heilth If nv fam
ilv; | don't care ANYTHING ab1ut the Mayors
politics"
At the hour of nom Speaker Sharpe
announced the special order. and called H.
F. Baker. OF Sar tOta Comfy. TO the char
f. A. Carp inter at once oI'red as a substitute Tor
the Scnatr and Assembly, bills new one authoriz
Mayor Grace Ia appoint sahject 10 the approval OF
the Board Of H. i,th. superintendent. who would
mold III g for two year. sui c' TO removal bv The
Governor upon the CON iIunt Of erher
the MAYOR or the Boud of Health. TINS
su1ariutendelt. il was u~pp'-ei. sIpuld 60
81 10 900 Yearly clean the stress AMI have foil
aui .iur.tv 40 fke co &. lC .tiY ev'rv of1"r
Respect III" b % Is s.miAr 20 ma "mch iech,N
p ,ss,d the S'da 20" Dt ] Us real thro'Ih i'r
tn" IN oruIsliI q the Assembly, ] r"Hsh mis-
tax of the prut-r tn pa ~ been g'v~n the - ne
uu ,er the senate hi!l. The Democrats ih"ntht
th, they stw au ,p9n4iuutt 90 n kr uattY pniut
IA thls c. = mace. II ssius ooAs std INA
he would l;,, o. call attention che llri that
the bal carried a. cruiiou on iiS Lace. Mr. Up'u-
ter Nifn some warm % II manner, >alh o. thrr"
had been No. Intentional de- pton. >pe k'r Sidtpc
Is 4 tf
their were 10 b. veto &C., 'tain.d NOR today
by smaii practices AMI p1rts 90 orirf. lhiS Wa
Of iuan> e. rhces ct the niru-" mtcft~ Irii 10y
the members. Nj. carp % er tIru exp avn ,teiN
the ,onts OF FERENCE between TVS bal ana those
tnat nad preceded %.
| Air Brod Nv followed win an amendment provid-
M ior tie appoint trnf 81 a StIet'-t cleaning Com
m,ssion colsi-ting or W. liam II ,wd. A Ian CamD-
bell aud II IRE e. Van Wick, Who @cie 10 nav
l puwrr 10 app INT sup. Tluic udruL VI. BrOd>ky
sad hat be u rTci tie au,e udmtut hccau-e hc wa
| unwilling L. give fhc power 81 appointing the
| entertainments 20 N lyuf Grace. IT, VAS h'nazfl
10 the ScLitc cohhdo 10 q t"nritatiVeb uh'
known fDsn sucH val p0w'rA hey Wcf" powers
never beior- gwen - "a man ." "" i'tA stare ne
Mayors ~ were not fictc a, thry onsht -
IT,, ~ the mater al mixing can'rict~; altnOugI
some person. d,s ut"l %. lac tb0dsnt bc Commission
coulI bc nppinicd under tnc Constitution.
Mr.. ilu-i rd -aid:
T,e Court ~ Appeals has rxpf~s.cd a different opinion
hb .ut power 81 tno l-g 80 ar" 10 ap."in r"rin'
- ~ from tnai Hca ~ NJ. bruusky. t"u@l tnt'o'
p-rm,s b" L'g-"'orr {" hcs'g az CERTAIN 'i'' 'a -
to n tnr Otucr oib oncrf- 80 Uig iai pOsu"ns ht M
Hen a. Detar nent properly, ami you propose tit toe
Mayors oud be- c"up bow d.~1 To- ,his creature
I'' cont %g -V ,in. Sir BoG ID CiI l. worm
murn. II 81 "a Constitutional IL pr vdes
summ ~ power 81 removal. icOie 'u-i cnDe 10
AtJdny the removal 81 au lucomp" ont man
an II q. M a. The Do sci - tue r,-tClc,n ug Depart
ucI, | am AS r"est q K pa" ic'n - anf hrie Dut
al OF IA 90 ah anirIuDeIt
Toe EeUuDlic.a part, la. charged with 10 NJ too
u,ue, Of A r.ier ii carry: " 10 Oo vng IN c-uir liz o.
sdyen ncoU. Bus - g no. mater Of u tory inIt
Ice safety ueUpir tue relc u1eci Il not
20 win w.lora CV now car, nj Aoom
aces polic'. hc - 'ap"n.e man: az
Sew.York Il tne leope 81 New York are wiling 70
Z tnis power Z" thcif Chef AtSi,.tat" AN S'Hms
II toe Mayor Of Now-fofS not q be ta-'el non l'e
puDrau government nds b 90 'nc failure. Way, sir,
he plrdg . mn''elf t. ~ fhlnll d-clerrr % t.",o
auues II h. "ins u assume nat rep ,n,ibl"y ""
csuuo nBDrd t" dsny han toe power
Mr. Hamilton replied:
I hay. Lac he II to .lif1lle A of
dir a tT,Iug pTrsent the securing craI
10 New.YJrk Idtn, that statement. pn opposed 10
tOuaL I tnink - o'n never brco ns law. Il VII
that dr prnt,r's b Will ~ ,De n 10 get he sire"L
Cleaning dOIe. Tue Copper las ate people HuNOcatei
a separate strcoi-cesuius parm~nt oeneye
the bin good Que. Any Dau appoI.tcd IN tbs way
ma a lair aud nest man lie viii be rrsponsiDie
be vernon and 10 toe Mayor aUd ~ The BOari 0i
HEATH. ! wish call youf att ntlOu q" A. Important
axe OF the Dill rneie Hil De no on9 tr.n OF dem.
qurut supeun cndent When Tue cnafgcs ar pfesentc
To The GoyctDUr De can sInDarily ronovc thr mAh !
DeheVe nlverlsin2 the contrasts. IL scem' TO nc "e
are adopting lar aud ho.e'SOio plan; ana
thst no nau wiL og.o-e u except be desires
use II seai ~ tnr R'pnoicag parry. Mayor Grace W.
were told had PROMISED cue rc~Csaniug pArtment
suOu d not be used ia partisan s~nsc Can We trGs
Ipau whO toid Police CoWmssOper mat hr dld not IN
tend prefer Guar ses axain. hlm aud then DID 50
of NeWYork In tus year 81 Grace ISL Il ~ not 10 ue
presumed should adopt such plan Thee" men bad
tGrOuIh Every true Republican Will vote against the
senale bill.
Mr.. Brooks-A mans intentions should be con-
sideIed. This a twelfth hour repentance. | said
% my friends III the Committee Cities that the
president of the Board Health would not accept the
appointment Mr. Hamilton denied that statement.
Mr. Hamilton-l SAID nothing of the KIND.
MIR Brooks-Of my own best knowledge Of the
Board OF Health Assert that rs members Will not
accept tins service # you impose II upon them. Is
there any gentleman here w.io "lil say that they
eopseutf Silence shows that no gentleman rs
author zed To IN axe such statement. can under