New-York tribune., 1881-12-13

O.
as would say that this man has always bee" @! " 1'"i
o-By which you mean a diseased mind Al we're
to be very accurate shoud draw line c'N.' t.e
disease which attacks the brain after " haH e N'Ff
oped and the improper deyclcI nfnt " We D.h,'
should rather say he was brain noH-'ro'i'y ''Ns''
ital maiiormatiOn u! the brain. --,
,hS "a re1rh tE S and iSeire was that morbid project
a depraved A.-Deprayity enters as an e'emi"
O%Yon Thought mat the scheme was reyolHns that
1t could originate in dePrayity but was the Result u
a morbid disease A.-Ics -.
O-Wonld rot that depend upon the degree OF depaV-
itvl Al suppose il there extreme degree oI a.
pravy might coexst In the scheme. ne iia ,i,
Amerlcan people would Oe 80 gratei,L hat the. ", ~
flock to his lectures, which could only De baSed Oh an "
Q-Mght not that be the outcome Of adapraYea hear'
The Court then at 1890, took recees for one hour
As the manacies being placed upon tne plsOcn
he broke forth with a deuuncgtton o me prosecution Op
tae Of the word "depr'yltyi WIN tho id "i
OF committing adultery 10 get fa ol nus ti, ,rou
owing some debts, he had always hecn chris.ah 81 i m
And" be concluded violently. am not atrR'd 10 go
70 gullows if the Lord Almighty wishes ne me 70 t S
there. expect act OF God that VIZ plVu 's s
and the lury out that window u proItcI ne, II nVc
sary. want to thunder thai In tue cars oi 'no
people" .o, Ia, tto mis-.
oper tyHn t6nmning the table with his fist cried:
There are Good many poodle dogs in the newspaper
business and want toeXress my Itlfr .V at The
some Of those poodle .ugF. am glad 10 notice tht
hlgn-!Oned conscientous papers are saI 65 I65 Smer.
jury to hang man III my c0di'iUu ,1n
the 2d OF July, when | was rreclplI"ted upon 'I'
Hardly had he ceased speaking when voice IRON tas
most crowded corner OF the court room
him now The prisoner glanced around IN
manner while there was good deai OI sHplressbi en
motion among the spectators The d'pui! nsessfl
deavored 10 discover the offender nut was
0%TGn appearance OF mis- face Indicated moral insan
tvY Al made the general proposition that this mans
facial expression, with that which e kn9w 's tue % s
manner That, having some other eNiaenoS iY MUfr
have concluded that ne suffered from moral inD"'J
or moral mOnstrosity. ,, e ,,,o m
pcarauce OF ms FACET A.--les ...t., ,
Q.-What do you mean by moral monstr0sty "A A.,
Bv a moral monster mean person WHO Is poin WIZ
nervous ana defective orgaulznti0n one "a
prived Of that moral sense which Is an %oSih % hin" %
analogous In this sense to cOngenal cripple VINO Is
born spoechess with one leg shorter than tho otner
A CRIPPLE IN RESPECT or HIS MORAL SENSE
O-From that brief interview with this man you con
cuded that he was a cripple in respect OF his moral
sen-ei Ayes.
o-what means had you to attribute his cripple men
tai condition to congenal cause. and not 10 natural
causesl A.fhe shape OF his head ana race anu
physcal evidences Of imperfect ram dtNclopnlent
witch fonnd there being defective nneryatiou of the
facial muscles, symmetry oi cue race tnu , m %
deviation OF the tongue TO the Sit. loun ti' % o " o
born with "A brain two sides are nor SqI' ., 80
much unequal to constitute a diseased Drnin' lue
end of his tongue deylated onGhni or W ~ y,
an inch from tue medium nne. DO nor "iNh ~ W o9
understood thht on any OF THESE e'iushcoS s'"bH
The prsoncr%Tne doctors all agree that side Of my
head larger than the other Ihat may DC hS"u') vi
The %nc.s stated that fact hat the prisoner had
led concude that tho MAINLY oi the prisoner
~ w d, NOT b,sc ,oir opnIon on tho data you have
meutionedi A-Ths data only allowed me To FORM u
very strong suspicion. - ....-t.-
I'm the insane asylum from causes not congtnlta lh
Gates % cOngrniial defect In the prSon'rt Al inhde
IT these two COUSINS ~ came insane
from causes foreign their ancestry wodh not prove
any thing 10 this mans INSANITY -, -
Ir D.ygr iDuUired whether In the c1se or Mr. Par
kcr zone of toe If the insanity had Lceh brpu@ht
10y excessive drinking, there wonid ne any tii,s 10
unity II ne uTi4D "A
tive reply stated the of the other insane
cousin Amy Maynard, VINO up 10 her tenth year ind
h.cn a bright child but had become insane under
the influence OF n'smrrc -, lyt' "a az h "i',,' ir
whether that fact could throw any EH On the coh-'h
The witness repsd that it threw tho stronrcs, lislt
Ne one could become insane Of feeble mind RON mes
mcr,c experiments wh" was not already tainted win
O'-Yon think uoti Al may say know not.
6-You !rtW no difference between susceptibility and
insanity. A--Shc was susceptible, because She was
pr,t,pr-cd. could probably nr-nri ,e one 2nt OF
in,rtr pcrsoa, ~ thi, o-hndI' tnneH
gtol. affecting t5c nc1t1, unless thrT were "t an I'M
incrz,i frequently without being rjurci.
Q-1He drsroe of damaac would depend upon me or
gniI ,rr,,c,- r lra-lhic doub that ordinary
pcrsnn,. ia ordinary conditions oI hilt' D'cuH' Insane
O-iio% many nave become insane that You never
it,. and br stati tics ot u-yuin- that IL that fact
hli au' thing 20 de WITH the production OF isrhity
O. upp1.r ma; me idea u hereditary nslniiy hal
bttu r.uu, cd, wuad y"u si.H nave Ft4ch'd '' con-
cIu-ioy .ou dd i.uu tac formation u tie prison ~
neat his facial muscles and the deviation oI M tongue
Al would amount . no more iihn 7ir'ns -i,p,'on
T.e fact that head larger on "n" side Than TIE
oii.T J. @ @ az W i,c, ,a-f of .ha iid as r. In were
ana oil ,nGi ms, .I sort uI k.c.-ihc pr'uuftuOh ih
tIc udalc IIc extending along aoTn tAc u.cA ot the
| o|What In t.e Ecc'I A.-iadsr in the middle line
| q Have YOU cVr.unyd any more mouNicrsi A.
rhcy are not frequent tat anyone can etauVc any
large numne DO nos i-,aG nave nave , ever seen seen
! case cNIchy hh" tIls' HiiI @ h''r d., d.. @ 5,,n
more h.II dozen tla "ond belong to the same
Mr. D4yilsc tbcl wcnt.nro exhaustive examination
us tp tiir cEs difference b.i"rch lhr Wl''her" h,ti
ana the heads OF normal persons tue eT,en. o. thr
deviation Of ne ion.nc anu lhc 'Arel 81" iae ia,lAl
gct,ed toe pccujL.rcs. not always, however, To Nr
Diyidrts satisfaction, stating tIat d'nr o. them taken
lnGP c"ul" hr i"'"rl u'h ~ '' pi
insanity, bat that Ucing grouped ami takrn IA con
Htciun WIN the iart o. hcfrtar! INSANITY, tty were
| strong evidence.
GUiuAU \ CoNGEyITAL MOEsrEO,rTY.
Q-Ycu ha-e your opinion a. to nis moral mouslru'ity
on the shape Of his hcadl A-Ouiy incidentally. has"
itupou his expression taken In connection with the alb
normal shape of His hcId II proves tho cuugcnIt al
character OF he trouble. the only had thc
| facc ne mas / should say ne might nc dcprayrd man,
but when add 10 tlat TIC detective shape Of hi5 skull
ava strongly al thc belief - strongly as science per
mile 10 come To conclusion, ihai he Il confcnital
UYo rfcr 10 the shape Of tine head and the Unequal
ify o the facial muscc- and the dcNiaIu OF que
10 the left a7 in icdung nat the i3c"" moral sense a
ph, sca evilruc.s noticed vas detect In has speech
Q-Nhi o." you mean % & ,y In '"S,a % ,I M ,'oi'
| IAN hing, rose higher than ON the t.sr.
| Oils builc one sided sii4,o A lOp-sidcd
| smile.
Oh your practice have you met withmany lop sided
! guile-f At j. the Characteristic Oi those nsanc
| p.r.ou, whom VIC term pr,u lry nunuutiuItcs.
| O-raAru alone what would II a.nOunt tOl A.-AbsJ-
q When put out his tongue 1t won. to the left side
| Ayes over half aH inca.
O-Aud That was aaOther proof Oi CDnCcnital mon
stsy Al never SAID any ting remotely leading 30
| That conclusion.
AT ta pnin the witness asLcd permission 10 sit town.
stating that he was suffering frOn gHt af ctiJn In
! the heel oh, certainly" as-cnted Mr. DdVldSc, and
tucp Look occasion Tetuatc OF thc bitter
| marks made against him 10y the wines by adding
| siQuhcautiy: al thought II higner up"
| The Witness was not long allowed To be
| seated for in few moments the District