New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1881-10-17
THE PERUVIAN RIVALS.
MINISTER HCRLBUT REBUKEs PIEROLh-HE GIVES
SOUND ADVICE TO THE PFRUYIANs.

D,,-,,,, Ootz TbcooI;t;ooI si+,otion l. still
PANAMA, Oct' ''-l III poll'lCdl h'u"'loli - GUN
unchanged along the coast of Peru although from the
cues % tn' INTERIOR particularly tno7e ocI ou ' w
u'rhaS' come reports OF lhe mastering Oh inc c"' ioi
another effort to eXpel the Chan', or "roto, ~ the
hated invader Is contcmptuousIv designated The latter
-. ,e.,, ,i. 90, . i,oroas,,,o t.
- to stro,t of tha or,ny
o occupation The Chllian army occupies the lines OF
,a'l """u' "l'' n'' UNIV u " WI WI ., -
The Peruvian forces are StronS enough ior e"ce' p"E
tccS;cg t,.c % +c dov IN linn, is some correl
- " -. - --.aa+ur -
ret ioG arcia Garcia and General IIurlbur the United
c,,,, ,,i 1000 .,,+ IN Pom, Tho Peruvian Secre-
tary writes follows:
THE hINIrRY, AYACUCIt0, Aug. %, 1851
STR: Tho presence in Peru OF an Envoy OF the great
American r. public is always cause o. pleasure to my
fcow-ctizcua whose sentiments 81 cord.ay and adj
Grpt,op1 - Iy o,tir ~. t,rrrc, cr Of ihese snonta-
uc0.7 and Taeabir sentiments, have to fnhl the
| official duty-o.rtaiulY n pleasant this
occgslo1-of concentrating. yoHr Excellency upon
Try. Unfortunately, the first gances OF your
Eycalrgrv have not fallen unon those signs progress
and TRANQUILITY which formerly met the eyes of the
vri.d yova erupou b, reaching the hospiiablr shores
q. Peru. The foreign war, into which mprcparcj, we
wore rn,c,d a. sr,l rlin ana dnsoation W Ierever
tnr 1v ha. pas>ed: whils as if such caamitios we're
not u.-furluucs enough, small fraction OF misguided
PcrIly ans are increasing them by serving the village
of Mlrlllcra as docc Instruments Of The conqueror,
VINO lends them his aid in maintaining this appearance
rom S'''ii iho Sh6c coal.ry. s''''
This act which our EXcellcncy VIII nave diSeoycfea az
by persona. examination ana Ine 92,eryaon "a 9 futLene @
events VII .e PgradcH your LISeamfy Ina, ,a JsG c
p vtgo,rt d,f,bt tfis nr,,si,n .yudsI yonr Excel.
i.lu "tLIu,' ,uu, ~ i'l,iii,' rith' tba+ re-
rnnf, "Id .cyiirti1iIy uraciicoI snirit which
is essentially an attribute, OF your fel,oWcong3- 3
ans was to establish and sustain VITA their powerful
, =
~. =, I'M l.. or 81, ,, ,rl..I ftf "on thi. Doiut
ISL wa" ''r. Il - ,io plrii,ii
I'M, - '' '-'
ihi- SOVEREIGN, juice ih r''u " 'G I,' liz ait, p
49, .,r ra.n"cts Inn tnr tvcI, drpgrt.ucuts whea
,,.',,., tE, Rru,,pIic ([yth r.ccp6u OF the coast
CI 90 ,i,I @ ~ h., fbc ti,iiilns iH winch transory
,'i, "y' i,t,r,, and, G,,.err,Iisnt ~ nor tl,11
th, ni his Eyri'uct Go'ontI nicolas de Parola WHO
M been progl5msa 4 Pre4snt ] 2caTesn Sy t9c
49," m ~, i t, nri,', mi t5n least trsm1,etd elec.
,,,r ~ fb4 co,nunic,fi ion cor,pela me 10 omit
al, '',,nil.Wt Ioply wish 10 draw attention to facts
and h.. these are aii clf-.yidcn, br, your Exc,lency
" i, tbc,n tte ottnptinn ftav desrTvc At present
,1y yiil he i5 uncr consideration by his Exccency
tbc s,cr.taly OF state to whose impartial and cir
cc,i,,s,.,.t ind '.,ent thcv viii have been
surirt. by tn Plrnipotcntiary in Washington, OF
ny tuc Republic OF Bolivia, VINO acting in the ah
-.pce OF oiir Charge d'ARlres in that Capita The
morul support mis- guided people Of Ma-daiena have
Thought To- obtain 10y cuyatus official relations with
iis cor,mn1ic.,o lon to yonr Excellence which other
,r,so ,g..I pu ,r.iGp t0 diuloullt, u43ge and the
, 49, + I.,ins r,e n,,n,rtni,ify nnV, ot,,rgiej
bad ma. ..f. yarff i bed.
M ' ,t ,,s,,r,ti',1 ami .., u,riD. I,iy.,li Your
}.,.saI,~y,s .I.eut servant
ATprIID AECIN Y GApCIA
,,,-,,.. ....,i., - 81.
Itut't' Ii'I''u' IT. 'P.'1'' ~ l'''o"'' -
LIMA, Sept' ~ 1881.
have the honor % acknowledge receipt OF your
favor of August ~ In answer you VIII aI.o" me 10
state tha % would not become ne 10 enter lO discus
sion upon the internal HhhfS or Feru' were
II not IN answer 10 an INVITATION from Hoi.
But in your letter TO me you aVeopched the ROAD 10
such discussion, | propose frankly 10 express my
opuion So wording it ~ 10 wound lightly
un.s,rl. Perm i, known 10 be Republic
-,.rr,,l bv "a constitution which should be the supreme
la, n, ss,ltus th, slprefur powcr and assuming an
artborfv unknown to the constitution, scnor Picrota
commit ed revolutionary and law less acJs. The orcbe
nr to.nt manner In which that revolution was carried
",t cbyr,cterlci il AS crime azainst liberty The Die
tor.bn MA. A tyranny. which was autocratc and dcs-
motto IN IN. cop.,rction tts title and its acts No CON
ititntnus government stes whc il waa supreme, aud
Inc simple will of one man took tho place Of
ia,r and constitufiou ODurcssed hy an
INVADER frc popultcc of Ptru submitted
th," ,nio,r,rv in tbe bcief thar IL would conduct 10
t,. ir.i,n ~ n1tiou. rrcoUuzed il as a Il. t,icto
Gycpnt but they never recognized its origin or It's