Daily Republican., 1881-11-28
FlF''lb ED|?|0s
COURT JHIS MORN,>,,
Calling tho dtvtI l,.,
Number OF Gases Ma. Ls's|
ir'n'-Ihe Arxum.n, In thu H. y
perry Case Opened BY ne Ns1
Attorney 6enel al U.on.- poty

.,,.. "pened by Depu,
A'"r"eS S"nenal Cooper. '
| Court rc-aSsemhlcd AT 10o,o,,
morning, and the first business sVoh vi. th
cd t" was calling ,ha civil l.t ' sahn ".,en
following cases were marked f".1a f""a
Dertlnger vs.. Derringer: H. NJ - wrla irla
VS.. Enoch Moore Jr. Hollis ". WIN
tergrItt; David McConaughv's. w., Va
lstrators VS.. Isaac Dillon %Ql
Marshall vs. the Mutual Lon, "c4 .c4
Eel aud Bro, w. John A. Cr,,,.
John Little Va. William Rrivh,
for James & Webb; State use S'o y, "s'
Britton vs.. Isaac Grubb; A. B,.n,
vs.. j. 5. johnson George D1r,h'
Jr. vs., &. Dougherty's adminjst,s,",eel
Harriet Garraghy vs.. Patrick SuIIi1o
Jesse X. Holton va. John Pole. C,a Ch,a
jackson VS. James Dclaphln. .nd1 nIA'
case s.ms plaintiff, Va. Jamas "I "
phin and ID. j. Wilson Tbnn'pe, pe
Bowers vs.. William W. pri'rn.
Clement h. Snyth Va. Henry \ i"yne = ne
lin: Vincent o. Hin vs.. +. b Eias W.
y Co Charles E. McCarty Va J'bS
Lockwood; John Stark ", pr.,,n
Firth; State use Of Zadock A p"ol
William Il. Eothwell; WiUiam
Bush, vs.. Joseph Stoeckia.
thOny & Zohlcy, vs., M,,u 4
Weldin; Edward Tatnal, W Hen
Is. Courtney Enoch Moore, Jr
William p. klrr'- executors. Hshc
ham, vs.. Patrick Brogan; Aid Lo,n
sociatiOn, Va. benjamin +. Wal.
wife; Ann ID. Shaws cxecu,ri,
bert II. Weld and wife; paxo, ~
ioit 4 Co., VI. Thomas j. Gll,.. nv
liam p. Karr's oxecu,r,x Va
NJ Mnrray; SharpieS, q S,nS 7s slIapr,
KOb"len; Petiis and Curtis Va J,:,
A. Bond; Pottis aut Curtis vs. M Lr
IL Smith; G. II Buruharl 4 2,
Buckingham n Coz diamond \,
Iron Company vs.. jacob HardpriIa
same W, Patrick q. Briep. s}Ina
Patrick Newman, John II. Fr,i,a,
Peter Griffith; Ella EoDelrn vs.. NlIl,
Nj. ktAnard three cases James a
Mary Toner w. Michael Dorau', cxs
tors. There were alrOa larse nu,rt
OF eases ,"ut'uN,d umti the E.hrn,
term. Ca Ia" mo lull ut Charlie, ,
Esq OF rhn "Na'muluI rrmmitta
Charles iinsUoli>, - .ulr. Ii Fo,I.r !,
y. l. lrncst Smiln we're admu I'd
praclic" law IN Inv rou Is ot this :.
George v NJ ,eaa ) , l,G asked Tor +,
to III the goplr Ot ia. nUu miIce On
sessm"nt of dana q tor + Braav, 4,
branch of the +. W. y. railr,ad
Deputy Siatc'--Anornoy Cooper ON
ed the argum 1t Ior the Srareln The G.
berry casu. He cCrgr itu.a.ed the I'M
that this long ard TEDIOUS tria was "a
idly drawing 10 a c,csr, and sail nj
the pin ciplIq stipn Was If Morris @
berry Was In he discharge Of his dut
when h" rho: Adam,
Mr.. Cooper reviewed the evidence
the WITNESSES, ami showed that tn
he President OF the ,omrauy down
the cutored l,,toyer, ,Ary mad all tpntii
tEat they meyer knew Of any orlCr I'd
prevented men to pass Through that sll
20 their wolk. There Vas rule to pl
vent the workmen from lJafug or ID
leHrg III that department, but no;
single witness on that stand
A'NAiilu 'hht Oil NINb JAW y thl>l
Mr. Thomas :. Dall, has testii
that he had told Carberry that wh
he had any doubt OF q person right
he in that shop he SuDuld refer
matter t. the foreman, ilr. McCaf3r
for his decision. and even II Mr. DaY
had given him any srCh ORDERS, al
absolute aurh.ri'v 10 enforce them,
wou.d not hav" justified him IN
ing down any mdn tor a yiolaNOgi
them.
Morris Carha-ry shot him on pNrPE
and shot 70 xiii hlu. What DIS
per. on do when he sNo5t' .GJ,ti
and ki.ls hin by u r!e.e accidtIi
Why he goes 10 tue wUUu ed nl
! with sorrow and cOuultlon, aud i.s
all in biI power to alleviate ms sa7s
iuc+. Do Carberry DO tins No.
tue contrary he placed his lett all
arouni the dying man 20 hoIl hlD
and pounded HIM IN the face wItAh
ri sht f.t. " hal ,ind oi hear. "a
Carbprry to thus list ht, dying V,rilN
fla, he d heart of hrsh and blood, o.;
it made of adam anime 1t was ~
accat, nta., but VA, prchedNd''h
lit was committed WIN iuaIre Ia
heart
Norris Carrerrg had Aian' H7ln1
nd in the curHcr, iiDurhhug tht' d,h
" weapon III his t,s" D, and sIid y n
tnat f-arfIl expression, 10y. D.
& - You shat 80 or, and >aAl
II. Adams did jrs' shat you @
wuuid haze done uojer Ih7 H&
cum ,tancp, he pichsi up pre- In
10 def nd Limse!f viii, AMI I1E'o4
have Killed Morris Can '~'ry N '"
have been justified before the 'aS :
deing. >, ~,
| The defense has introduced he ts
of accideAtal sho)tnG; now ''S'
tembsr we went over t1iN Ga"
three days, nota word Wa slA hr
accident, talk to ma atoa' "'N','
there was 30 accident in tue 'u'.
The prisoners counse' has ai% ".
ed the plea Of self deienSe, there wa "s.
self defense in the mattcF' 'o ~. to
Carbelry was not in any DANCE :"
ins his life, it was his victInl' 1hal olm
II. Adams that was in danger; o''y'
could have let Aiam' alone, anu
ported the matter 10 Mr. DaNls su'
| lett the decision to Mr.. McC"p,'% y,
he had been told to 10 in Sh,n I hs
but no, he had the malice III .iII w. ri
a, lost tue deceased and II" 81 10" at
| Mr.. Cooper minded the li'f! VA "a
solemn oath they had taken 10 len'
verdict according to The e'iien'' in
begged Of them, il they la1 ',S
doubt in regard t. The guilt OF u,
soner. to give him the hr'leuI ,,J a
doubt. H.. said that be ha' i'," and
rs--ead the evidence in the ear r.y |D
could not see how they cou,H l'u n'
singIe doubt on the snbJect. !, ,,'iI,, "
going to acquit men W." arc tns
crimes of such magnitude % ;n,,
soner has committed. we lnign1O j., iJ
we'll wipe all the laws ou'' al" ~
do as they choose. .oo,;rp
Mr.. Cooper closed by prtsen'i.uss
eral points Of law that 10 .'| '' Sto
Court to charge the jury on' anu 'u,,;u
number Of authorities to s"'''
position. ,s,-s. ad
Court at 1 o'clock took rs''''
Is o'clock this afternoon.
FIRE AT kOCALAH''
1