New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1881-05-24


nip,ity with which the nomination was r,ceNou &c
supported hy the press AMI TN pSolio ,he m~n nv
conitrv resulting n ~ utter defeat ~ ! INC w., ~
whom and the me h0l, br - hici, c conn nm
that nomination was sought 10 pr u'i H. ren,Ic
cafes determined puri ssc ol me palt "l w en-,
10 t'te tbc control of the krpuh'i,an party li"nl
anlrhine politicians AMI pi'' h'l'CtN' al
rainrn tn the principles, and m th"dS 3l tue tnu,i
80 ., A. nf tii, party. When honest duirr-
enc,s of opinion 9Ld acton were rc,Fc''" l' .: W.
Grated and political conventions 'ud % %
,anr,s]nied The people and not t&rtlon oi a" "sS
fin That in opposing thc CohhlIna'lnh VI M
ncu,inotion for the reasons ari by thr me- 10 ~
odoptod the Republican senators "f the tili''I
States for this STATE have raised question oi W. a.
moment to the whole Ndil"n, f'I "', .d',,,t
they may. II j. no - Than i,lsn ni,'' rower of
ON the paIt of SENATORS TO uNiIP VA Sp~ ,,;,c
nomination and appointment 70 Itu',';;1 ; oi'
which the Constitution IA, VI. ~ III ~, ,,,, ",
upder a pretencc OF " courtesy Que u HNh - ~,
denouu.s this as "a m.on~tr0us d0cifihr HUDN'i?'NO
of ,he fundamental prime PIE 20 tI' I az
=; IT. ~ destroys tie equilibrium ana balance {"
IN ,i'' ,v,,;L The founders Of political system
wisrly proyidsI and justly con i't''i as 'i!t r.'"
cipai bulwarh and safeguard "i p'pu'"i I''j -
enJ th.t IN rccicuing their scat, bc"Hu~ oi idlIui
in This Internationally ah?uI"rinG their ,S'S "l
duty leaving the Empire sat unriTrccu' u ~ tnc
n,or IN - minority Of thrir and our political op"-
uentS-these Senators have been iai>e 10 tf' III
stituens and their trusts. ana nave justly i"i'lT''
the confidence and respect "l IN AI,l!y"t ICDiI.
And undrr no Circumstance, should ihrlr Uu'hte h'
coudoued BY a reelection to the position ui'\ nay
oLuao.l and abandoned nor should any HlSolN hc
chosen 10 hll their plac' Who are IN any lnaInoi
or degree in accord or sympathy WIN 'HciI ic'O-
iution1ry and unprecedented conduct. ,,.,,,.,,lo
IL That the President ha> given unm's'aNape
evidence that. while properly recognizing tn"sc
delegates in National Convention from ln'' ol',t
md their friends who favored ms nomination az
Chicago ne does not desire ana VIII no! ,I'' IL
opponents to he in any manner pros, rneH oi , I.
favored provided they give m, AdlnI,,,' i,,'
loyal support which u Repubhcan Admi.lN r a'
actin, in accordance with the principles ana tiaul-
lions of the party. has right 10 dcnad ana eNlct
of oil true Republicans We tn' i'l"l' can "P"ii .0
Rcrnblicans belonging to the Republican aSc3cla-
tion and organizations of tlS cltN 10 unite WIN us
In opnosing the return to place and power OF these
resisiing senators. who seek reelection WIN inc
nyowed purpose al making war upon an Auli,i'is =
tration we all helped TO elect Ana III cas- "l 'hcr
refusal 81 TO do, OT their encouraging these eN-
Senators in their assaults upon the ADMINISTRATOR
then il is the sense of this meeting that imlcdaic
measures should III. taken for the organization III
every Assembly District IN the city OF AdnlhlSlra-
ton Republican Associations am! an Ad administration
Republican Central COMMITTEE; ana We p'1fo
ourselves 10 USE all honorable means 10 defeat Inc
denomination AMI election OF any Kcpnhican mem
Der of the Legislature from this city who sustalns
or encourages these rcSlgnlng ScatoIs III 'hoh ""i
upon Republican President
Judge Fithian then said that the meeting had
been called together on short notice, and that. IN
consequence, several gentlemen who had promised
10 be present and make addresses had not been able
to attend. They lad gone to Albany on important
business and he knew that the audience would be
resigned and excuse their absence lAppauScI
MAJOR PANGBORN's REMARKS.
born. of New-Jcrscy. who heartily applauded as
he came forward He spoke in part as follows:
Mr.. CnNRN,S, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN; We live In
that is conspicuousy iconocas,c ~ Ha1 s mae nc
iself famous for thc rhcSSncss with when II mas uiS
perScd many OF the decisions ana fancl's ngcrcdu
Traditions and legends oi the odcn time The fragments
are nos beyond the hope OF reconsucton II IL so with
preudicos prccedents aud PROV s Tier" Wash pIoN'rD
81 oficcholders. that few died and none resigned
lanChter Well, although We know that th,y nave me
faculty Of resisting the aroach- Of giin dra'h YET
isa fact solemn fact Mr. Chairman ana icIowcl'lch
that two OF thenI-I think there were two great
laugh,crprominent "lhcGhodcr. VINO nave rCNiSmo1
10 the late distinguished senator tOnkng ana htte
Later to Mr. Plat ar "ss ." The VIZ" RE-
public has not tulnbed down ! Wa III washington me
other day, and the vacant seats were hocNeh ui"Ieu III
mourning. lLaughtorl
This action taken hy your Senators has been pull
We have been trying to find sufficient excuse for tr
Hr law HAT wa. tbc re-, ou for IT, said nc: do
not und, rstaud what 10 is all about don't see way
Garfield" said 10 him perhaps the reason was a.
O'Conren for accrtaiu proceed w Dhn vas M"
giving expression to the most awful inprtctions re
locked around, but could net see any body wh wac NE
object U her cdrSes liz went oS' ana s'u ~ & ny
good woman. why are yon inducing III slch we nan
guagc r. lie then looked little closer ana "a" that she
was heaplng hcr inairdicu3"S on a." 49,; i .g 49,,
"Fvhat am doing il for lCc4G. IT .,'r q" an 'tl
ling is angry that the President won't lie si4i to he
One Of their published reasons that the President
IN making the nomination 10 the Cole torsinp 0i che
nomncr should he familiar with the laws and system of
the revenue when read this wa astonished for 40
moe strongly than the senior = major o. le VI
Newly prk advocated the nomination aud continuance
In Office Of Murphy and Arthur VINO were MeNef ine
equals In the knowledge required iNi lat ONE VI I
Roia rt,on lAppause1 make no apology Tor benz h|r
tonight for We ON the othei H',e 81 '.t Hui7l &
tute integral part OF the l"it OF NtN-i"h ana
own just as much OF inc custom louse
a. any OF yOu. II seems 10 me that TINS controversy
brinss Us TO the consideration a. an exceedingly i'm
porant question, not merely in political hut IN gov
ernmcutal and Administrative scn-r Inc question
which has is tins hat j. the Legitimate mlta
of tie Senatorial rcrogativc ana power a. relating
fOf he
limitation of the Presidential pcrogaiNc II regard Ia
nomination for office al cases 0SfS an nc" %nIG
The demand OF these gentl'm'n, US uud,[
f fo1 the II PRESIDENT S Of the United scs TO select Tor an
office within State any person 10 whoa c senator or
objects. lApplaise.l This proroson stems to be an
entire! uusou.d uusalc dnd einic'0is one;
Another point IL II advisable or proper fora Senator
10 abandon his position and retire, TIE strength OF his
defiance To the Administration, ora rcinl3raemcnt and
swer should lie: Abide strictly by the Con;
nominate aud the senate small thcIeafIer-not before
advise and consent or refuse lAIpau-c ANY depart
Const iior al direction leads into officially. TO limit
The TX -cnivc in that manner J. compelling Lin I" a.d
folxS Thai -vclty i1nr or sercnt,-nve
ler,oi~ Of the Senatorial body must abdlraie
their functions and allow one or two senators
from paidc ci5 S'g be9 10 10 NOBODY "H raS
De nominated affirmed fow the state Of NeW-f"Ik
1870 ~ , . Nm W. f yi ,,sc are ouT senators
Illinois, Ohio or any other stated lAlI!taSel
Gentlcncn these our servants not our masters
(applauS, and this meeting here tonight shows that II
the selection made by e lrcsi nj DO 9t LliT 10
please or two Senators doe please TIE people vi
The state Of NeW-York. lAPplHscl
do not know that is uocdiul that should 20 any
further in DISCUSSING thc- pot nave tred 20 make
them clear, and think, as Tie lawyers say thry
astO my conception Of cNl service riVr; me I'i"'H
does lie with the COur's-incn or me President ~
lies with us II We insist tat our relnc7'hluteS sn
not beg offices OF the President then this eseing shAl
cease Applause am %lihAs l." u"i,uo ti"a -,