, 1881-12-25
Egg
tn nE~TRlAL.

made, - - =, ! ,~. ~
1.,': = =. =, =
- --TH r E=>TRIAI- III
:. -. t." .pnoCEEDINos. .-%,~,~~- .~.
.-w4sH1scros, D. C.. Dec. 24.-Mesas Reed'
c<o,-,1,o ord T. " 1ss1itEuu were In consultation /
80 49,, ho,,r I,efnre tne opening of the court
n ~. Henry r, stcarns, of Hartford. opnn., took
-ha rtana and ScoyiiIe resumed bis csoss-exa1n-
The wines. stated that the faculty OF memory
xyas ocncraily the first to show itnEatrmcnt III /
,7,ast all forms Of insanity. IS: -, .:
scnptlie-Do% you aeTee with tie 1asr witness
thu. .tusuusty is always the outward manHesIa-
,don Of diseased brain? .s -
Jidce Porter objected to the 1of7n OF tne ques-
lion. and insisted tnat the defense observe The
same rule the prosecution. had aonefeo TO-
letting each witness testify to what ne. Knew,
snc NOT found an argument UPON Inc ef4uenee
of another. @~&* g. "7
.Gu{teau-, II, - ~ F." :t@. |
you ARE GETTING Exc1TEb POINTER
SeoyiEe-i must cay that Judge Porter eau
maize the most Of nothing of any man ever
met. T.. %>@:: %>@:s & ~ -
af,er further questions re atfve to brain dis
oose scoxI,le asked: .Ia it true thai such DIS
ease can always be detected by an examination
~ rha, orcanT. =. /: =. j.. -. - Il
.Ansyer-I can only answer that there have
hce, t.ases Of brain disease where. upon c1aut-.
,stson altar aea,h. no lesion OF the brain WAS
,ctnctfsd : <s.:: .*z.,.5 -
TIE witness was about to make further ooser-
,affo;ns Iusr ns Scoytlle proposed u question.
1udra P.,rter 10 witness,-Go in, .Doctos, and
,n;eh ,.o,,r answer- >.-*.. d. :.
ccc,:il,cEWetl. hold On q minute. !. -.
'E~,M1ai.n1 n;1r11G ,.t T,,ls ESAM1xA11oS, :.
~; ~ ~ ~ .@~:>. >-: :'s~a
p,,fcr--1 assume the Court is conducting the
-i.1 ard - the Court i shall always appeal for
;uc enforcement of rules OF practice The Wit:
,nss 81 onc of the most learned scientists Ut tho
r,,,,,. a,,d ve,, n,ust not attempt to treat him
- .t.,.,,,t, ia ,rer3, your scnoolboy. will ul,t
.:t'.t ~ -i.1.r
sa.,t:;a ~. + some W,11armth-Weu, ~ let MS see
;s.,t - ~. 1,,dp,. t,or,+,r -, --.
a;,1,,,..1 u; Win a hit at Porter. but
,rs,t.,nr raising his eyes fron the pamphlet
.rs,r., ,;c v,s nretend,ng to rc,ld A broad grin
-, arsnread bts features. and he seemed 10 enjoy
s.,es,i.; .,,s sIor1n or angry words, -. -,
100 80. i1ternnsed with q few smooth
,r,.,s nd rha examination proceeded for some
49, .ss..-.,,. .,,o,5,n, -. ~:
Whsu ,udge porter again protested that SEQ
mi, I.,,,,a -, t,a ne-rnftted To rehuke Witness
soar;fIa s.;d. - .e.......s ;. 49,:
- o;-<, e1o>~ rnR vnrR SPEECH
1900 .I.h,rad rbe yritness NOR had oc-
-. :; ~
C.,t-.,,-y yrhat,e rtt, matter viii, 1ou Porter.
,.nsrs .y.,n ,nnsr mare tontracted Day,dxe's
sns ,,.,.,a -. ~ ,,,,-n, - :
s.,s,',s 1;nees,, fo rest1 fron 1nanuscript what
annentpi II, be a hypotnettcal proposition.
80 .s@,,,,e ci,,ne scovillel + can't understand
+s., r.: *1". ~ f."...;.s ~: =
soo,-,,,a ,ro+,n1,--we1i. don't understand It
mvse1f Mr. Reporter; please erase that, and /
will mt anotber question. !: 80 -. +.
. Rood then nut few questions to the witness
,n-,n;a order II
par+a, a,,.;n ;nternosea an objection, and de-
.naaa mar tha witness De allowed to finish his
ansyqer and not be cut short by counsel
80 1,e ,.;,,,sxs h.s mn ;ntitnated q desire
.a.ov .,r1htr,- furr,,er In reply to that oues-
rim yo, y1,e tne one that appears to be anx-
taue for 1nore ITO the witness1-Doctor, do you
Iss,re -, aad anv1ntn9 to your reply? p.
Wtt,ass-No cir:
- 1,,orcur ANSWERED.: -: 3.
49,, .,o..to,, a.ra<,r,C . nd sutt1cIrn,iy: =
Recd-As supposed. Judge Porter, you dis
80 ..a,,r 49,, 4rtrnesss Ne usu.1, 1t;en-
srss 1.,,gh,er Il the exprnse OF Porter l. IKeed,
aesd -, ;ccvii-l-aa.11 ret ever it after awhile.
:1h, ..-.1n,,.,tor ,r,cr,.ssc1 witt, frequent OBJ
.acr1nns an the part or the prosecution requir-
tnr the ruling of the Court AS the witness was
!, ahuu1 to set,re Guitcau sad: :: Allow. me u
ask. If you hold the opinion that a man cauno
be insane in q SPECIFIC act without having dis
esse of the BRAIN: " -
.scoril,e assented to she question, und the Wit
~,asr -o,t3od..-A 1nsanirv means disease of III,
1,s,,r. =. :: :--~ =
cv,to., .esod anorhar question, but JudR
.,oa +,-rno .rttr,ess rf,a1 he mold n
's,,''-... u,e@. aaxs 80; 49, ~,,,n,na1 80.
enouas ....e..,,.,N:I4 49,. -. "s ---
oa'te'a "ene- -A'' - =,
I'M NO CRIMINAL AMI MORE Than 1oo AnE
Tn, here as ms own counsel ana nave Us Us uuc AZ
right 70 speak as sou have "a1t nn1't - a.
convicted before yeu caa, me cfinna, ,s,u.'. s.a
great deal better outside tnan you 40. rlen, y.
or.people Will say I'm o'saee: n'an 1tl1n ~ %
Porter: ..~.. :. 80. -; -,
corkhil suseestea ae tn,s ,s,as aoase w ps'
mitied me psosecunon woa.u :a, 4ns's' e'e'' =
prisoner os Impsso % 70 'hs ~ uoia oon,,arf
suoss S911 se3,,,,,r ~ s,,c., . co,,rse 49,,