, 1881-11-03
Tho Daughter and Son Witnesses
Agninst the Father
Tho Former Asserts that She Was ILL.,
Treated ~ Well as Her Mother.
Tho Cnt-and-Dog Life Of q Diseordant
Household.
The Falher.in.Law's Dc1iaitlon'bt Hhai Con.
stiutcs misunderstanding.

THE ett,ss- examination Of ,MrN. Tlrmhn was
tukei, ny hy her own counsel alr. .1hrksnt. Tho
,es.Gn"'y Ut Mrs. sllfl''stost. The h"usrkct'@r..
taEcu Thursday urtcrhaIl., WIS questioned. md |
the asngrnI I,l,er rrul It lar tia iniur,nutiGH VI
si,r Iuslrt uni 1ury. Mrs. ilrlDnn trsti,tc tlnt !
Ut times fIiu iHtlty hHtl lIEttt tXtrtEit1Hhtlr
Supplied with tMMi Msl ut other timra hnl1 renlfy
suffered !ur wnnt Of It. l1urlit1 thu nuut1i nf !
.'uty. 1ss0. fur tho spnro IF clGven tnys. there
ha,, bnct, no halat II. tho hutIsr. They hull
s"ne srn and en!Tcc. bit I'D sustHntiIt fnotf.
They hn ackra! sufficient fnrl bnil' hsrorc n.il
utter nltn9 tho I'LL Tor .!tvn1ee. Sir. Jackson
sn'nfttc't twtI lt1tcs tnrn from Kincery book
til aIr4. Firi,nr, md sho stuis' tllat sku bud
tIkusi the;m frun, her Meculint hnok With lIcr
yrnt''r. It's thq pages enHtNlhed thu entire ne-
Gt,Int.
Urn. stiles aaitl he wu,,l,l offer tho honk In rvi-
lrl,ce, al,tl Mrs. Flrn,an was usscd n brllg It
i,l,u ro.lrt Mt tho l!rst opportunity. She toslAc1
tlat shr hul prepared the nlc!s f,r tho fhfn'ly
sce tlD tillns ur tic bill. Her dnl.ghser .l0-
sethinc did uot wnnt to IT, to sehnol after the
n!tns Ut the bill, bccusr Hhe was aIsnla IT wilt
,Iess' lersnnn' safety. The ushcr c!,il.
tlrrn werr Ut, anu h,,I not nttc,ltlr1
sct,t,nl sinGc tho tlne In question. f>tlrnE
Ann WINTER .,f ,sSa'-'Si her sr,l Aburt hat hecn
compelled IL wr1trvury dnptlAtcti slDcs, aisl II,
November. lss0, III 1luil UHly Il thin suit Ut
clutllts. Tho Ficil 4 t.cternccount wis brought
up und tho witness WIS questioned nl.tIllt tho
Items in 1t. She stnteh lhat everything 1tur.
chustd ut tho tiilc w,s MI absolute Necessity tn
rln,he the family. Witness hnt1 hecn told by
air. knIckurlsckcr thnt hur und WIS troubled
und t,rr husband hll toll her Sire w.s crs,xy. Anl
nlght to bs nn intatt: Of Mt tsIannB ,IsyHtt.
II, answer To tho nttoxuitin TINT size hut sent
sninIr nootls n,eny fta,Il thu !,ulisc sinee tho
1llnp or tho bill wlttess stase,t that shc nal Anl1
n, mid straw tick Anh wurthess lnit,tlry stove,
md bud sent nway SUMO hnoks, pictures, mud
rt,,Iu t,.1 r., h,1A.
tinrs Mr. t!rfnnn l'nl .''snrxetl her will!
knuwlnE nathIng nbant housekeeping. md
us !s1sns IT, +" r,ss,y ',"'1t rax n Aie o, 1tsh" , ,,
llnt,se aud pass.tl rh,l.rs beEnrs t>,nl rc!lgcI
Inv M her i. = s,onsckrclrr. she hull been IL
lrunn. th,s n,uht Mr. F.r1,,r, r,s,nt, ,,r viii,
fricmI III h!s cn',pAny. llr r1tgecstltI to brrnt
opr. Il 'i.~s in ~hrll shn hui. cnt te,tte1 sln,nl
st thrclM; lAl RNsH MS rGliEtlH Tar hts AcL!nn
.iai h" hui IN ut,ctroll,blr rilrlt,.ity lu ,lnt
.ut whAt sh.' bud cnslec.l.'! IL u" dusk. Wit
ness pretended I" cry. Ril'i Ar. FlrnHn
wt- llt:AlrrIl:s, ESutI;u TJ f.tutif,
and hIs frleiMI joi,Ith in tho cvtty. Thu salnry
nf s..a Yer mnnth recciretl ly witness during
the fnr snt'',th. shc wasumpJiynd in thu A,.eri-
:Ilas" clothing t0r ihr ch1l'Ircn unA hrrrntt.
1hring s',o tiny shy was c1nIN"yi III Thy oi'scn
upain ont Of ter s''i,ry. shc bull srt "csnr ,s
.Ml mrnns Il, het'i, tho ehtlirtn nwny from Atr.
Fr,nAtl r. M!1:xt hy "pp.'snR s...it1s"!. hui bud
msuhlt"i him. ns tsas Frequently tn. G3sr Shn
ta ;In t toh,a ''nI,y @ e., T. , th% H. ,rtI
'rv,'stn!iy iutn.el her, III preference to eating
with their fAtlltr.
AT thn opening ut tn, ,ltGrtintIl session Iudun
DHrulln MitllullI!.a tint Ilb h lust dIs.yeretI
thnt nne OF the j,tora IN tho ci,se Ind hecn
E'l ln"tt m.t!nt,tsl utter Il phrtial hcrlt1E. Tho
circumstance Mis- unllsilHt, and
rlIE .l'NaK Mlt'l1r COS >Ft.iE TIL: EvlpESCE
IN the Two c,.scs, aud brluK lna verdict III tho