Daily Republican., 1881-11-29
Fifth EDlqlOl
COURT THIS nORyIxo
Mr.. Lore Opens the C,o.,,
"en' " ""d Is FOLLOWED b, ~'s! .

Mr.. Lore Opens the C,o.,,,
Gray. ny M
Court met at 10 o'clock, and NJ
commenced the closing arpuma, nf, Il
the defense, and reviewed tho S'nent
tha' had been produced by ,ha 'iaeu
lie said that Mr.. Davis had VIC sla
issued some order that was ip,,,al ,usal
prevent men from using that sh"a ha'o
passaee way to, and from their
that was the Interpretation ~. "ol
put upon his orders by BraJi"a
Hazard comes here and ey,
swears that Mr.. Davis told him r'a,lv VI
must stop the men from passing ,S ia'
there, and be replied that fha na0
way to keep them out, would hae ae
a man at the door all the TINA u "a
tells you that he was djscbarnnal1l lag
canse he could not keep the N, msH s"a
that department, and what is mn,o NO "u'
sonable than to suppose the sa,n" oie
were issued to Carberryo In e 1ea. o'a
Davis himself told you tba, no ,ao'
same orders to Carberry, that I,4 dt ail
the other watchmen. A' ail
Again MIR. Davis tells you tbo,
day watchman had no right way ,"t
the pistol. and yet he admit ~ ~ na
saw the night watchnap sevo,ai 'Hat
hand the pistol to Carberry in tba m ~" :"
ing, and he did not intertrro. ~ u n9 u.
goes on to say that ii the pistoI we. ne
in proper hands, it was hi. Sa, Sa
take 1t from whoever had il MY
Wis says that the proper place M 70,
pistol in the day time was in a j.s ius
IN the Office, and he tells Won ,h't @
frequently went to the drawer 'na ua.
con.d not tell you whether h. h,ii ~.
that pistol in its place In three n'"n.
six months, or in fact ii he bnJ J"
seen Il there. Now was it no, NV w.
ty of Mr.. Davis, as superintendaD,
'see that the pistol was in jts ny,
place, and nov that Il question r ~;
sponsibility is raised, MIR. Day, y, w.
take an equal share with Ca,baa
McCatferty has testified that, he ~.
not recollecl that Adams hadsrs,
in that way before. Samuel H "A.
~as standing in that shop; he va,
even passing through, when Carba
came III and saw him, and in oLp,Is,
to his orders went over 20 him Ard
him 10 80 ont, and Adams repej
cant 20 out. ,arhsrry then ssld
must 20 odt, aud lh,n the answer p,
won't 90 out; what was Carbprry,n
a watrhman had iust been dl,cm,
tor Mt keeping II, IA Jut aud here u
man II lhd1nS up aAd deiyius hi,
thority.
Morris Carhcrry did no more II,
tine circumstances than any other Nd
would have done hc was eudrsvnr
10 carry out his orders and WAS rr.i,t
and in the encounter thai falIo,l
Adams Wa, killed No one regrets
occurrence more than the prisoner.
he would call Adams back if it yer,
his pp pwtr so to do.
This case has pressed upon my mi
for months, ami { nnOt think that
man is TIL" cold 'biuo led murderer !,
the S'ate woud have You believe
have known him for years, and w
recoIiect the time when he alone st
up, and attempted the capture of sd
OF the worst thieves that ever y,,l
your State.
Mr.. Lore closed by hcSeechiug
jury to calmly weigh all the ey,derI
and render their verdict acc0rlna
aud he said that he tLolght and
ieved the result Of their drlbcralit
would be TO say 10 this old man,
home your family and spend your
remaining days in pace, Mr.. l..
CLOSED AT 10 o'c Cck and Mr. Cd
opened the closing argument tor
State.
Mr. Gray took exceptions 70 seyel
prop SitionS that had been submiu
by The defense, and said that a md
trespass upon property 0ld hot JUST
the taking of HE, or even the USE Of
deadly weapon. The prisoner cau1
a 'all himself Of the plea Of self de:els
as has hacn shown that be himself pt-
vuNcl the fray, and man to ca;
that plea must come here with cI
hands, and show that he was a,A.a
aud his own life in danger bsiyrt
used the last resort; and even th7l,
not justifabic homicide, il be .Ql
have retreated ut gone away from
asSailant, unless the assault was 1il
in his rwn house, then he has no 70
to retreat, and he would be ju'tlt
killing an intruder, to save his 0Gl
or protect his property.
Tue States Attorney ci'ed q NUM-
OF authorities on sell urtelsr, to'.N
the Court and jury that the lr'olr!a
10 clam To that plea,
Tns Court at - ~ O'cl9ck'' 'oOha
cess until 3 o'clocA this aNerGJolL'
Inch time the States Attorney Will
sumo his argument 10 tAcINT