, 1880-12-14
inE tho Trcaf1ent mny nppoiut John Smith u
C1ltonG! In tho army, for instnf.cn.
Mfr, lfHrnfflEtl-3NEs .of

!,"tf u nnNlh&mchts tho Othor IA merely
f te sas IT, Il P'Tef ,Se le.ssf e by a
with The naylc, mud cnflsent o. tho Bounto.
Kress c1n as,thorizo tho nppoihtinont of my
ss Nj hi sss sS H. sea e Ne cssn.ss ss s ts2,
,nuftn r., IT., , nI, no r'sht KIT g %i'npuse limacaton
yido TINT n tnan shitil be subIcut to military
.l!lsy: Thc s'owsr Eiyen Gansrest 70 tnatntnn an
power 10 aay WIN shall nr aha1l not hold olilces IN
@ the nrn,y ,ar T.. l. the NJ tn"per.tyo, It .1oes
q tho Cot!stitutlon providing That iaws ati,or.
izlng Pfekidontinl Gpponts.e1its .hall te general
cr1!l Hammond, who wns rostored TO thu Nrtny.
Mf. Gart,ontcr responded TINT tho flntutnond
edq H. iii Thran 1. ts ssd se rasc d, na
Ct.llInss. Maj. slnclair, and otl,crs.
MI Logan atstotl thnt tho inen mcstf0no1 by
aont to tho Sennte for confirmation. Lte p,ntett
out IN what tteir caaes were not like partcr's..
for olta4 eafSiS; Seo "f o hS sf Fy1nhy
tuti9nnl question inyotved. 1t was dangerous
to .lisregard tho Constitution, oven III suislll
inss MD T II 1s IL opin,S 'pS Ssn consress sft
H. sfoona ij @ n9Fnn I'D thiak so aS not only
oxeept mo IresI'Ient, its con,mnador: chicf.
was not ono of Tho oll!ee!s q tIo United status,
w!n Hy re y. GMnstituaon' tho PRESIDENT was
Nj. Mcdonald ciaitncd TINT ho WIS driven to
no such ground. Ills ground WIS TINT tho army
via provides! for III n'lothor part Of tho Cotstt-
tiitio'i, which KHvo tho whole subject 10 Con-
So. Carpenter said TINT authority was thorc
fh0rity WAs given It TO constitute courts. but
sy 10 at9r1y 10 vs s given " 70 ppopf scrs Of Tie
o aeSornmsnt f0 q tho asa but f"5 e
ws IL Sqyesa e esSish IL h'fx nStoas TT #
judicial procedure. but nnne tn d.csato judicial
af aots o. enurts. Or to say WIN SHOULD be Judges.
araaon WA # tho !csl.aslve, exeeatirs: anS jaaEI-
ter relteratel his argttnont TINT d suntcnco
passed by Il constitutional court Of ilnal rusort,
y re1s5 81 oeg 4s Ss "
tse psiyioso. ~ II I'LL iii prolose1 iss see e d.
Mr.: Voorhees, donled tho proposition TINT tho
Sentences OF conrt-.nartin1 was Il tinni judy.
nnont, tho effect ot whIet, could not hc cscapod
sentenced lie rcad bills formerly passcd Iy tho
ssnnto relieving persons from sentence, of
Mr. carpentsr as President pro tom. Of TIC Son.
| nto.
Mr.. Carpenter remarked TINT II he had not
- tH"sc oS1tt - kC'S1'
i ~. ~ Sn,., ep aeasF @ H. as. iiItn ls M
Sf signing iii wns nn expressiuI, Of unjnon.
lie nddutf thnt tho flct tiint severn, ilpcn,l.
atittiuonnl bl!a Ind slipped through Con
Sfsss Sor easrc5 for The pnAsiS AsS
anG sctiitfon nws nassci I;nnSrs.sa. fhM,oi, sSr
Cirpnnter supposed every lOcrnt yptllu iunr
out y h.s stockings NJ tho idea that thoy were
s vass,isas tnHntu5 ,,,.,,., "a
vjrtinr H. Ear1mtrr ~ s,,cnmsst"nnv ~ ei' IT.
point was thslt E0uKrpss had before thls seen it
70 lcRslate "a it ls now proposed to lcg!slatc
y IVY siIlEuiar tnat the nncvf;st!tusi9nnltty 0i
nfi lila nart|inr iii tn M peo III rlo f.
general ortier VI Secretary of.Nayy 1iorio. rc.
.yoklng tho senteuoe OF the nlvnI court martial
lpon Cnninlanaor Ilacne. oIl the ground that
scris ~ H. Msc,cs nuv ~ p 1ns.ea inc tne
aiso allowed lin. ''' o 0Ao'''t ''''
Mr.. Voorhees, olted this In connection with tho
cfatnor rtstd whon 1t was proposed tu pny Gen,
Porter for tho ttnlo ho WIS out Of tho army.
Mr.. Logan askcd II ilnel,e's sentpnct 44ti beon
| approved BY the President.
Nr, Voorhees, supposed SO, sinco nncho wns
Mt