, 1880-03-08
rL. Case of Fitz John Porter Re-
w. Vowed by Senator Car.
penter.
out,ino Of tho Agreement Finally
Entered Into with tho
Utcs.
=. 1esseps Finds O Cool Reception
~ for His Canal Scheme in
= Washington. :,
~, Sherman Remains n Candidate
Boston Republicans, Opposed to
iirani and lslalne.
v.va of Interest Regarding Affairs
wv in tho Old World.
rrrz JOHN i'o1.rEn's CASE.
ttt....tnk BE T9S ftkttn an TA.ihst<A

In tho Old World. |
:; ryrz JOHN I'O1tTEl's CASE.
spttta, ni,pateh 10 Tho Chicago Tribune.
v,.u1sorux. d. O., March 8.-Sfntt Carpenter
..ac mo Of nts notable tcgnt spcenhcs on tho
~, 1obn Porter cas6 to-day. Mr.. Carpenter as
saebstcr on constitutional questions Is not sur
ss..ed Ia mo 8enato. lIs arguments aru utways
Iii .rrangcfl, cnroful, mud stuttcd and ARC de-
S,crei viii, tho grncu Of nm accomplished ora-
~ Ills opponents nro rs nnRcr to hoRr him rs
80 h|a friends. Democrats who for tho mtMt
All had vncuted thcir scnts during Id'gan's
tc.,bug auntysis 'nf tho Fttz John Pnrtcr tcstl.
.noov, to-t1uy returned an1 listened to
rsrpcnlor to tho cnd. They derived no
snmfo,t fr,nl 1t, Their bcst lawyers secncd.
4 faces in.ltuato nnythlng, TO ndmit tint Chr
nentcIs argument tint Congress cannot reopen
he decision nr tho cnurt-1nartinl, or cnnt,0t, In
s.ct. under tho Constitution grant n pardon.
WAS uHANsw EnAmi.K,
.l,bough IT Is tisi1nRtct1 that ns good awycrs ne
n,yaul and MuDonal1 ,nay Try nuxt wouk 10
answer IT..
,uony. md III un eloquent porors.ttou olcarly
,aoEctt why, III bis judgment, tho rooplo whom
il represented do mt taro for any analysis
n Tint testimony. Tho Irnn Hrignt,e wRs
oouposel IN gr0nt rnrt Of Wisconsin
tnnDs, Tint brtgr,le WIS cut down in
thsbatto Of thnsc terrible 13uf Hun days, losing
hundreds Of Wisconsin yeon,anry. These neIl
=. NEED not HAVE FALLEN
had Tlts Jnhil Porter o1,eycd Ills orders, and
hen Ioy,t 70 his commander and bis cus,Htry.
Tto grlrcs OH every wooded hill md grassy
ylsE,o through tho great Northwest aro all tho
EVIDENCE which Mr.. Carpenter Thought tho
pcype Of WISCONSIN ncetted to authorize him to
REUSE 10 cast h,s folo ~ pun'o.' 80 Jun
g,':I 0 dopn rortcr %%s , @ been III bis corno at wos
roin' a" o. 0 ,rnntor esa nr tho o.,.
unth tha war; ehrt'en'o' 'nlp.oseu a1 ,,.' W.
casfon, as tho clergytttoh Hay' u thrn ING cIhHA
Of his pcrornti0n With tho prophecy that tAo
Democracy werc likely tn - ct'1stl'tct them-
telycs rs to innkc It necessary for tho loyhl
North to nI "snln II, the wmo aehT ,o, to t%o
, Dcmocrats received with dcrls.on anti tnc he-
% and beon notuIna political in tue speech. Tho
sIu sIa.ten Stsu marrsa anf ,ho speccn. ;.
Suetory o ~ noritons Of Carpenters argument, alit,
then rotjred fron, thc se1'nto ohaml'er. ltpossI.
hly may havo been tH' hnri fur him TO l!ston 10
b!sown condemnation from tho lips Of Ill. West
TWIN 'o"''''''e'' THE sprecr1
:v4su,xa1os 10 ,ss % =. c. Mareh % a@1m tho Semitic
' t so ~ F. oSn perer md ID
carpaatcr addressed tho Senate. -.
tho tendencies Of our timc cannot full to SEQ
nn,n as IN .ts tos,p ps ssa,,Ia,nn md contrn1iza-
iuan'nS !o"atas etlnho'"attoh ahu cot,.Ni'A'1
ton Of power ana TINT inside or ehe tosos'i. teo.
~. .ro,+ro,,,otto,s .,f ,,o,vnr IL, f.oreyrnas