Daily Republican., 1880-05-18
FIFTH EDITION
TIE COURTs

AcOuRTs.
.o 20. 'srron.oIas n,s ten Case
w.,r ~ r'aintih The Wages ,.o ,"a
{ Specially reported for the pvn,
. NM New CASTLE, May lstb
I. The Barron Clayton casa ~. -o'n
.slai. Thomas MoCraokinv tsstissa III stll
the wagonin it its general lS,',nsd snna
Wasdefsctive and was moi bIIp bppsata
A. ?; Carnagy recalled. rtTs sts,sl ris
2 dead look put on the peach 'iea h"S.
the cause Of pulling down t%ay yUay n
+, side; that he positively reinssS sns 81 y
: s ioSs upon the body simply becsu. i"
would inture the springs. Tbs bs'aas| snla
were Of the first quality NJ. ,nsspri
a clerk for the Kent Iron Car osin
testified that the company he rsUr sUnp
sd sold the springs to MIR. csr.ss p.ssS
that they were the best ussd. d.s,asg sng
Hessrs: -! ,C!arnagy and Barron naa naid
their bills separately; Mr.. css. Es,a
called again, said he furnishsd
same kind Of springs for 'TeI n \
WILLIAM Byard reecsllsd - ,.;i =; ~
springs went down the frat % ds,
used the wagon before the ,ooS sa !,
was put on. '00A on
Mr.. Rodney thus addressed ~,
for the defense claiming that 10
clearly made out his case. a., ~" 10
had to render verdiot'any how aIs IL
or Of the plaintiff he said for tbsss y
undisputed items on the hin % Nv
even the springs were not .poo5 q"
could only deduct the price of
springs $32.05. ' Vi
Mr.. Vallandigham ably aJd,o,I
the jury for the defendant, ss allsa
that there was partnership bs,yI
Barron & Carnagy which bs %
ssnted notes and bills to prove.
the Judges charge the iury ,ati
to their room. ''
The next case called was No. /
George T. Ball vs. Isaac Grubb, ri
for plaintiff and Rodney for defanSs'
The case being ready a jury was
paneled. ""'
Mr.. Booth opening for the ulaiJ
stated that this was an action of assn,
sit brought by George T. Ball to rseo,
for services rendered to the daienJl
while he was Sheriff Of New Ca,
County. The property Of James
Khowles,a a nonresident of the State
owning large woolen mill in New \
tie, was seized by the Sheriff on
Of foreign attachment. At the reo,
Of the plaintiff Mr.. Ball was emplol
by Sheriff Grub to watch the props
which he did with commendable idI
ty, and that Sheriff Grubb had paid
part of the claim but leaving sb
800 still unpaid.
Deputy Sheriff Morrison said ali
knew was that he had been sent to
Mr.. Ball 10 come around to the otfc|
Mr.. Grubb, but do not know what
Of q contract was made; do not ki
how long Mr.. Ball acted as ystchr
nor how much he received in the
of compensation.
Thomas Griffin: knew that Mr..
had been employed ty Mr.. Grubb.
the writ upon which the
tachment was made; he made the
dorsements of the costs on the back
the writ; one item was to pay
watchman; he erased the figures
cause Mr.. Knowles thought that 1t
too much; thought that the fgI
erased were $3.50; $l65 Of
costs were paid thought
the case was thrown into bankrup
Sheriff Grubb told Ball he would
him all he could get out Of the case
George Harris: know Mr.. Ball
Mr.. Grubb. The property was s
on the Oath day of December, i
Mr.. Ball or his SOD William
there as watchman from that
until about the middle of MAJ
saw them there always; they
here later than the first Of Mard
was in the employ Of Mr.. Knowels;
brennan in the mills and attende'
iring up, keeping the mill warm
he machinery in order.
Mr.. Booth offered Mr.. Balls b
'videnoe upon which there
.hsrgsd seventy-two days at $l.b0
lay, and seventy-one nights
200 per night making in all $2.5
which there was q credit OF $l52, \
ng a balance Of $98 unpaid.
The jury in the csse Of Barron
layton returned and rendered a
lict of $l42.52 for the plaintiff.
Mr.. Rodney, in opening for ths
euse in the case Of Ball VS.. CRUDE,
lot deny that Mr.. Ball had been
loyed as watchman, but simply
% had charged too much for his
ices.
Mr.. Jordan a watchman in the
10y Of Mr.. Shaw testified that h'
eived $l.25 a night for his ser
nd he considered that enough.
George Harris recalled: Was
loyed by Mr.. Knowles at night fol
month; wheeled coal, made fires
ept the machinery in order;
nd $3.50 would be fair wages
light Watchman,