, 1880-03-04
THE COURTS.
\ Perpetual Injunction Granted
Against tho Metropolitan
Horse Railway.
Heavy Yersllcts Against the Illinois
Central nnd I.ako Shore
Railroads.
New Butts, Divorces, Judgments, Con-
fessioas, Etc.

New Butts, Divorces, Judgments, Con-
feasioaH, Eto.
METROPOLITAN CITY RAILWAY.
Yesterday morning Ju,1go tlarnum rendered
his ,irclsion 1T tho eisa nf tho City Of Chicago
ngninst thu Metropolitan City lutlwny Cnmpany.
Tho hill WIS tll,sl Rl,olt n year ngo 10 cntotn tho
Isnitway Company from 1ny!nR trucks and nl'cr-
ht1h8 horRc r,ttlvay Oh Lake, Cannl4 nn'l West
fourteenth strccts. md tho case wha heard III
December last. The Court Raid tho lnitlnl qtcs-
tlo1i wns whether ct'ltrt Of equity Ind 1rIs-
Setlon Ut thu c.so rs presented, 10 award relief
~ in1utctfon 1r rthorw1so, II tho ofrcumsfanses
.li =, rl;'Irc1 It w.ls very elc,,r that tue Gtty
Sbe sre.. es ts 'ssS r. " nf Tue
Ssts, sa Art; " Il ~; xSi srsxi;{cl tSat #, S
KrNnt!lg tho right to cnllstsl!ct and npcrHte Il
atrsvt. rlilwny within my city. town, or In
snni nf tho loeal authorities t,avlng coitrol Of
tno M sttnet , .r hiHh%ay 1,rolSsed 70 to g occupied
nnd t'nt It was tho constitutional pulley Of hid
!he strsts Of "wms. vi yitiagcs. a,si o!tiss h"t
lrgslat!yc anthorlty. i nlso rceognizet tho
s""staH ss casyg y nSofy # The t9 S"s .c9,. M ssfs
a,thor,tlc;;. The Iorse md Dummy ncl ai:ao
~ =. oily fis 70 tt's.es % o S!!t sSs H.
tff the : # Il ;a 5fs sircot4 sPS fGr eG
ancc of fis pr.wisfH,iS Ii,c city wis tic repre-
sentative Of tho state III tilo exors,iao Of tho
It wns fnic In tlnfnases Tor INJURIES that might
iSe T. r. =; t 'oS.r sSsr FIRM n ,ha,S
t!on whittier court of equity bud iurisdistion
1t VIVA conceded that II tho Metropolitan City
halfway ordinance wt,s ,nv,llld. the city could
IN tho exercise Of It's trcc 1N'wcrs. provcnt lis
powess m!sht lss,,l !" rot rho slne ,',ty tyt IN
tho rnrt ~ tho City nuyert,,ncnt 10 prcsrryc ths
ercetA for tho t'eliciitnf tho public which world
Justify tho llse Or the pulico furcc aiso tsttGi
annpprnl 10 court Ut .fn,ccry, which, lby o.
ont resort TO force, yiUiaucp, nn possible buoti-
| sind.
There must however. bo such an obstruction
evidence Of i!lcgnIity on tho nrt Of fhttsc t,tk.
Ing tho obstruction wuttl mt OF itsclf 10 sl,tli-
of I1fflrati II was useless 10 arguo tiut
1t WIS INT M obstruction to tho ordinary se IT
tho y en q + bS ss . ss,r t a. f ;Say
CITY. tlei,+ restricted to tio ,Iso Of the po!lce
Of cl,lccryY | liz con,ns, n inv sp1lycd l m .p ec
g,late remedy, md hc must thorofure hp!ti thnt
tho Jurisdiction nf tho Court In t1IlA fnli8t
supported, ~"
ob1cction nt,tjr y VII. so ~ enpainnns IN III" its I'LL I'LL
| th1t ccrtnin rrnt,r,.tnents ~ fbn ,inrsn mi
| Dummy net had nat bccn ct,n,I,1ict win.
tho act 10 bg t}icti with tf,o lti h,sf mi hct,,
filed, aud tfut M publication of nnticu or TIC
mudc, as rcW,,irnd by thn ant. Il was contcnde, t
Tint, for cyI.lct,cn ii tbesn matters ti,n EnIrt
c0uttI link nowhere but to tIu rcrurti ol tio prt,-
city rc1I1refl such rrrt,rt 10 10 kcnt. nnI i'm
pcrforinguco of This duty wins 10 bo rnt,cltsyev
is to thcso prt,ylsons Df ti,o not w,,a ui,sitrly
necessary IN or1ier 10 rtyn tho Conncl n,,v ii.
risIlctioi1 oycr Inc mnttor. md tiiat tho rcc0tr
f,con nFernti In tSbrncc VIVA thn sf,1c sMtrcn ~ nf
nronf m thn s,if,tcnt. Tmo mini hn,i imcm ~,
stntntl very ri rnn"iv i,v ,iNc Ilerifwita in hia
i,riof cxtr1,cts frnn which ti,n Cn,lrt ronr mnnn
lid tn,}nt. At,thoritt..s Ind hrc c,tcil witt ~.
| rnrd T., Tbo r,,i', ~ thi. ,oft,t nntn.t,sn T.,