, 1880-12-05
DOCTOR EARLL.


Inc 1ntru da} u LIS u 44"' " ~ coai4e7 11~.i
interest. most If tho session being taken up ii
+.,ah,,;1.a, o,mm1nat;ons IN medical nointe. tn,
'''~' ...... 49, -, t.-t-a -. ~, ~, ,,-o3u
two days, ret there were lnrKe number o
medical :mcn inside the bar. wh'
were apnanentlv yerr much intcrcstc,
T., ~. +1.l.,..on,r 49, .~,..a n,,t+o = WIN
III tne aesu!no"e VI 'ne 4PeE'S- Vultc q nun
ber OF ladies were present when the cour
opened. but as soon rs the nature Of the exam
,,o+4on ,xna aevoloned thav ,,rocofu,,v retired
r. r,,-, ~, toe;da ~. -:.,ta, ,,.,+h +ta e,,,t
" E-ar' sa. ot'e'oe nus eounsts', win ane eau-'
indifferent manner that has marked hts appear.
xncc ever since the trial began, and WAS, Of
course ,ho centre of attraction for the gaping
si,,ht.eaa-a W. ho-o ~ r,,dar rh;s Continual
s.en,:seer ne ne. ooie up unoer ,n's .ns sod hora
scrutiny Win tne u1u1ost sane 11olu' A!o oo'o
himself with an air OF q man who was belng per
secuted rather than prosecuted Ho Is quite
confident 1hat he will be acquitted
The 1trst witness sworn was Dr. J. r.. Hutchin-
son, Who upon his direct examination. simply ply
corrot'ofascd u b'otna1oI testlt"1, a. " ~
symptoms following water infections g1ven
whet: the girl wnG treated By Dr. Earlt. anu tnn1
hc believed Eta Carli died from the eject OF
shock: -t., -. u. u.n p,,ro,
hai I1 died Cd from the effect Of shock
fsd s3 ID nexc BIZ th0 sueh ;h'eGon 10 be the case
Witness stated 1nat 1t was generally ocicveo
aiming physicians that II the search WAS P1r-
bv % Sudden M % slock could be found in every case
The witnc$s was asked It there were uneqnlV-
ocaI signs discovered after death that WILL SNOW
ply. tho witness said not always. but tho dlsscc-
ton nf ii body usually developed some sign or
sIcrIs that tend to show that the subject
i,r. Itt'' H"tchinson at great length with
f"r f's* 1!1e* @ to adv:ss Re use
WIS tho case, bnt he thought it dangerous
prnctite for women during the period OF gestst-
ton Wltncks WIS nware tnat Nina many women prhc h+
he difi moi consider Il physician Respectable who
w"u4" use toesc ;.1 ] ~ n.e p. ..a
,,,ar ;tT,1,ncn,s ,1se1i IN destroy evidences of
.nn,a,,n, ,r;tr.ss 90 II ha had
se"'auon' "11assSo ".s.. sa.a 41 ....n. nau
OF such matters. and again reiterated his opln-
1on ttat he considered such usaxes beneath the
practice OF any decent phys:cian. witness
described the effect Of chlofnform and other
Rnasthctic5, and the probabilities OF death from
t'ivsc drugs when administered to patients I'M
der circumstances similar to those which oc-
CURED in the case OF the dead girl. The odor Of
ch:or"Eorm wonl1 remain tor several hours
yet the witness was not prepared to say just how
suffering with acute peritonttis could
NOT walk about Chlorotorm would pro-
ducc death by sudden action upon
the heart when administered to women
suffering from diseases OF thar character, and
the only way to discover the presence Of the
drug wns hv the odor. In regard to water .in-
1cctions. witness thought cold water the most
fntnl in its results: No reputable physician ever
n used anythin< Of the kind during pregnancy.
Mr; ynn Hurcn asked the witness It during ttc
history OF medicine the Practice had nut been
general. Witness snid it had never been done
when women were pregnant.
taken sick with cholera norbus, and the
examination was temporarily suspended.
Judge Gary Raid in reference to .procur-
In. medical assistance for the sufferer
tl,at he believed the unlettcred man always pre-
1errcd brandy and sugar under such crcum-
stances. and DR.. BiuthArdt being present. that
gentleman mixed decoct5on which brought re-
Lief TO the oycrcharged stomach.
DIR. w1LL1AM II, BYFORn.
<,,, ,,a,,. .,.,o,,~,, ,,h,.s,o,a, a-,a e,,~s,..
t au t W. ~ oclat. atta ~ 1aeuIe1l autuoE
;n1rrSi,'ti }p to dcfonse ,Sas 20 +,at aua oGa
4tt!M1ucou y! LIZ uctet,se. WAS ueH SHorn. ne