The Hawaiian gazette., 1880-12-01
cWa csrx nlrl judicial cirruit 10
rsnbt- Tern. 1880.


-, ~ Nh. Tern rsmr.srssd nj Wal
uuu anuEa uu Tau-~aas tine sth day % Noren- l
Ruar suFu-r sat HuE- A. ". JE1d. Fifta Associate 4
lusrrv uE ttr Srrrune Cuurt- Irusii irRs the Hon
C n Es-- olrr1i sudFes Mr. Preston prosecutor
ErznEn CtEzzs
~ = = T. Lz-snda--MAnsiauchter IN the
II tsls-iae rsaslsnsz vs-e impaneIled as
s-- Mall-s A. G. Bond 6ied1tochr 9. Holmes.
ChzsHaa- ~ Wnnas- Patty and Rirknrd-
E ". Esarkur1nz and Va. G. Jones defended the
r-ruunnr- Lmn rrrnunrr w1a rhArred with the man
al1urt.rrr ut T9hErAburz. . uz1lSs cf the Gilbert
- N1lraET - fshAia- han, On tie 10Th day OF
azras- - 81 ular6 Iiz.Et4tSon the Frlsoner was
- Isatr-s Islarsz uassres e1uployed ca, the
ranrra-a1 usrE sEns4lInnd and thear testimony was
wtarlrrlalir uE fnrtrwH. On the morning In ques-
lnns az aSuua q o'canrk- thh aieisndant went into
Ahm rrnn w-inn-u tire dHcHRsad and living
maA ANN ms vie and other couples. were
uleerEr-- 4Htu1d1It r1iied the covering from the
&-ca1saL md 1H wusuzn- ezFosI1g them De
uae.z E-s g-raced and tcok I'D billet OF wood
80 - rsliru ard srrurk c-t Etrli1uc the door.
r1lnsses -rcr-nei and sr-nck doceasei sifh stick.
As-uzzis sus.-d and F-isonsr goi away and ne
So Ulil cane E-llsH ulIh Winch he struck de-
raanan1 wirh am AA1 saari the head Another
$3.50 anEumd and tine drcunsed got into the
rlnnr-a w1Ia lhe FrrsurnHr and they ctanched
-rrartu- The Entuur uarTreE Ertertercc and SIP
1-szrd rI-1srE1sr ard dsce4s=d- Deceased returned
~ -eEz and rlt o. his Flants- Prlso1er re-
tzszmg -slt I. rGu E,odured Il at deceased, who
lalla1r Cd nuEt ANS and uttErInc CIV Of fear.
- - rrt-ul-rr. $40 REFRESHED followed ty de
60 uzarrse4- Atler re1re1tlnr % OF 30 yards
w-sara- l-ra az decuN-rd- who reorivrd the charge
ms 1irra1z aa1 tlA Enur1zlly wuuurhel. dying al
lu.zzr.alE- The Eir1so1ler had been uniformly
Arms ra s.unaTzu1-
~ nj pin7IzcT. srnrninsd for the cruun. saids-
Fr1z.rr uas ny oTersee- On The lCra Il August
lnz A. ~ a Ettle hefoTe started down 10
80 l1lzu-s - uurE- I eac tee7 eosls about 5 OF
= UDzlss Enen 6iibc-- lslsnder cane rushing
e. ~ sd .1ii thcrr . disturbance at the
tauas cnue tark and en.e-ed The house lot and
uzG rel@ln-r -sl1E1E alu-lE The wall from native
hamua- ruurwnnG " a Sorth sea lAsnder. Saw
cauaaM-z rnlns frasz native hnuse- Prisoner and
uauual mtuuf . &C p1uss apart prisoner turned,
asnrA rar1r zi sui s5cd- Prisuner suddenly turned
anz r-sa a. thc 1ztiVe. hiitlns hun IN the throat;
49, SCI lls kIseS and hands and rolled
49, ~ ~ uruund vzs q bad wound and nor
a. ~ 1zzlses cllisc-ed aruuId the body and
nutr-rE q a. ~ tzkcn INTO the house- he was
aszz ] had di-rc4ed these Feople where 10 sleep
EE--lr1 FeoFls II une rooIn- The deceased was
maE unmrrraa MR. did knUE he was sleeping with
Hhmrm uumnl- Tie uec-asrc had his pants on
wrnHm shot. ] kaW ~uApor IN ms hand If be
dad 1ze suzla nd have seen A. Was about 100
te.l 90 Ana The hody was carried m searched
fE sa1rrlr- Ind Ia Aud any Searched for
~ tsdE al thai rrme--Iross caAmined: De
49, WaE st1ct and yuunG. weighed above 10
49, nai hce1 ElcE ruo q three weeks de
kn1 -s-z-ued o. trs uu-i Was passionate man
SEQ hr-r In n Fu4sEian one OF two occasions
~kmrm ma1mm aa1l uE Tor cuty- dcducttd - Tor
-rEmu@s and - for clothing and Fala hum VI only
H. E-sr1 a oae ;g7oe F1i hira ert had not
eee. tr1zhies,1as pzrtIcuiar- Prisoner had
r.r-szI-Isi 1iIa1 Lhfze natives were very NOISY
a. uocld hzrt noclced II deceased's hands
wz - ~ siE1f A. cetec-IFe saw the man
Fre.a W-tisnry. lsou q las; witness examiEed in
hala-l 81 tlae CruUl= / szw deceased chasing
rrlal-ar- and be 1hen SHOT HIM Prisoner vas
Mimut lN feHe fruut CT decreased and close 70 the
rm1H III pm4 nr ssln- ] use X every week. had
ms ua-a n Lsat morning. never keep II loaded
a1u 7.-lsaa-r load H. BE asked sae for car
80 an gaze x 10 hin a No. Shot be asked
~ -1.I-aaa f1r .he gun and she gave II 20 him
80 1..a 5a,1zz-i c..suIuC ro1nd- saw nothing IN
~ kznis- ! EIighi have sen = pocket knife
Eras "a me rcEzuazh- The prisoner vas gong 70
rr~ -usn-n H. s4id tte natives were after him
LunE znlnk lues Ellilf 81 hiEa before he met de-
unaaaa- EE half rurned -urnd and shot him. There
ur~r auusnl nat-r-s standing about was excited
I'm. esd the case Tor the prosecution
- Il Ssnrie. examined Tor defense, said; 1 was
D. >saa-zf II Angus iAst- Prisoner came TO
Ra.d sd b. tzc shSt a Gilbert islander and
r1rc Eill=s1f Up
- ~ BsaraAn- Am acquainted with habits
81 sz1s-z IsiA1iers Saw the natives s1tnessesj
&C Sz1nrdzv aud sFoks with them They are
rwmmraair uhnf NE call the heAthen natives-lg-
rnnm-n MEd uurrwlllrs-d-
IN E Iarrndsr called and examined Oh his own
lunsrs- On the morning OF the lVth OF August
~ n ~-l1 Eeut - the rooms OF the south Sea
1s.1n1r-s 7 Nas late Opened the door and
sa-1l-L Eetarncd - my room and put on pants
- - m Diseased and wife sleTf next TO the
e. -lrse5 the blanket fnom his bead and
r-a@uua auy fass and be RAISED a ballet OF wood
- -arrw Il AZ nar with fun force. lodged be-
- - 5nar and 1ise bullet struck the wall There
-. a war af crutchcs In fny room. Lex sfie
1czaaand toll=wed me be was night behind me
a. sd Lal5 q NJ ] dropped the crutch and
I'D ! arsans znys-if. and - pail away from him
50 t-rs talo ms bedroom and four or i've
s..r a. ~ hack and gathered hold q me Some
= tt-r sui ne uricer he arm. IN consequence
url-- / lrrr 10
frz1sn and asked Mrs Whitney for something 20
ts~.raE lnraelt Wlth asked for a gun- thought
rE- wuzAd ALL mr. i 4 not true that TOOK a
rA-se iuaiic- 4 INC no hat o. cost went back 70
So RESI- 20 e. 70 work looked into my bed
rslrl &c - Il deccased vas there; he was not.
So nztire sanding and ordered him to 60 to
- Il-csz-ed Eas scar the steps (of his room
- -,s1uIzr Toe Eris EIth jack knife In ms
hruL -na rucnd the r1se bushes he was close
~ rne. Itzrss6 and s.lot him Han - or % steps
h-rn-a Fred- I szE him down steps and saw
krsfe IN hls Enmd- He vas 80 close had 20 treto
rurrm anraAnlF. Ihr evening before, after supper
rzaHd rham nl IN 90 marx days work All went
e. IL nv room except deceased i was sitting
aa-u D. sli- table smoking. he WIS angry and
szs1s Ena.i1as- Il he Uo1ld not 60 de took his
tift ort and said bv motions that he would cut
- ops1- I did not pull blanket OF his body l
stI.15lt - uas GONG 10 murder nle-eross e1-
- 2 Have been IN euploy OF Nj. whitney a
Isfir orrr ~ months Have been IN theSe Islands
umm wear last Sapaember. Am not IN the habit CT
Vr.rnr anita Hnraae Gilbert Islanders was afraid
fh-r urrr ousuirr 10 Nhitney's house. don't
hr-1rw rizt ASKED for cartrdgs- went back TO
~ hAa and co4t, and 60 20 my work Twas
----nslrd - drtead Enyself II he attacked me.
In1t 50 nv ccat and hat BE vas not IN my
- -.r-. cot as far az Hoe6y lone Of the ma
sfr-~s md thcn I szu The deceased coming down
r.. a--ra No knife f0und- Looked for Il a dozen
rfrsss The women came 70 deceased, and one OF
riuu ruut his head I'm her lap was cool 1did not
nA.1rsh vi rusualimr for Mr. MaltneE-
- EirRartnn addressed the jury urging that
sar rsiturr Island natives were not 20 be beEeveo
~ .hzs ths 5risoaer shot the deceased beng m
e. ri r-1unda6 fer fo< hls own LIE and tnat
si..-rfu-e az sho.sinr wes fnstihable.
H. Fresloa. 4 rtEly- c01tended that even set
49, rrfse the eridenoe Of the Gilbert Islanders tht
rriezusr shszld BE- co1victed- When he got 20
Mhfeurr's house he safe and the lac. Oh ms
rersnsnIrur she cun- lnadinC i and going back 70
hms mnnan nv NE Hid Got ms coat and hats and
rua uurnr enc anrpased- then going With the load
garm 3 thr natives quarters SHOWED DISPOSE
- % ssuk for an opportunity 10 cause disturb
-.-u-u nd ~ rereneed 1pu1 the deceaseo- de
.-utz tare SKI fer his employer and should also
k-re fuFa--net hin q he alleged threats on the
rrrsiurus arr-inr. There could be no 1ustinratlon
Ehn rrunainc Usage summed up The case 70 Inc
7nH nmf cirur1rd them TINT 70 justify tne killing
XII ahr rinnuaAad- thrF must be sai1s1ed that tnt
rrHrmnr DIM Inns OWE ll9e- fnas the PERI
snum he lzmlnrat, such that nsn o. ORDINARY