, 1880-02-04

'pf M Sa4s Fl s%sY .s 'fy Se sGfss 9eass followed tho
precedent It had got THY n,ofn!ng,iii giving
apnrarasns ts AEFIann f G'ss c As,es ssHn as nySE
der III tic management nf pu,llc
aFairs, g., b1unler which. very few
s w" str,s,t f ,st t. ,s1 wcn IN ,c9 tS , fa1sit 1it
ctla,scu To scott nperatv. ThUte was bit nMe
remedy, and tint was to strip Lie Apprnpra-
tiDna cn1tlnttteo, Vt the t,lwer which 1t had
under the nist Enlo to le9's,ate 1,pon oRpro-
priatlon bills. 1,eavG tho Appropriations Com
tim!s strictly according lo taw. nil, lenye It to
nll the ntliur Committees 70 nifer md conduct
icEsatIol1. l. Il appropriation l'ills were ,lis;
but II what lie tfec,lctl 10 be +! Freat Il mis-:
take should bo mntto llu should bo compelled
to ynts a4afnst thu whole. III
Mr.. Frye-The lIonse ypster.tny,. deter
s sbe SE @ @sHy oyy* ot Il Y liz 't i % ns
Conr.lstM. Does the, gentleman suppose
refused to 4? collectively? -. nj,
!, Mr.. Hafaell--1 do. 1t has given us aIgn
Iii. Randalt-Aul tho gentleman gives ths
Hu1sr n ;a M snn sIx tl9t tho third c1"uso of suo el
M, NJ 1arf'!@I .1I;;[ offered TINT rs ~ sscapo
ltG.u tltis elt!icMity' MIi nctEhE LILO openk-
help him; but sny now that III my judg-
mel't thu only safo wny Is to remove tho
Iii. blackburn said II tic pending a,l,cn.l-
ttlistri6ate'i. il Dat WIS ~ Instances Of Of
cco,lo,ny ho WAS mistaken. 1t WIS II lnatter
Of history there never Ind been II case where
4 matter " which a. special committee wns
Inf
appropriation bill that the Committee hatl
not entteavUrgd to Increase the expenditures,
llo entered his protest agatnst tho distriblt-
tim of appropriation bills, mt IN tho Interest
fiji adnitnistratIon. iie rcmi,leti III. 'GaS. Jar.
fell, however, TINT tho power WINS not yct
reduced tn tho dire alternative which lie dr.
scribcd. t WIS mt yet forced to nXtricate IT.
self from TINT tli'r'ua by adopting Ills ,nnscIt
limitation which could put stop Of,
another cscapc. II tko bil is were tlstrli,utot,
md tlle only safeguard to tie Treasury
which the ll1nso If la,i was STRICKEN :lo,w, M
port n:l,lo BY tl.e C0nlmittee ~. Rules, with
I'LL Its slns, would bu rejected n1,d spewetl out
OF tho mouth Of the House.
Mr. Whlttl,orne tl'ongllt l'ts. friend from
hix inntl. Ilis i,aiai It'd ,iat Justify it. iis
(Whitthornc) undertook to sny lie eO,ild
demonstrate TINT nll the vicious legislation
which 'tatl clllracter!zed tho Government Ut
tllo country for tt,e lnst eight Or ten years Ind
Rrlatt9ms. tAppl4us,n, and laughter OH tho
Republican sttlo.l llo nssertetl TINT III tho
Forty-fonrth CoEErcss he la!l. ns ClmirlnMn
of tho Committee on Naval Affairs, heartily
APPROPRIATIONS Committee isamialD ii in re- re.
dlCiilg tho expenditures Of the navy,
4fr,. .Dlackburn-Wlll tho gentleman under
take to say how often have seen him stnnt
here anl offer amendment after amendment
IT, f nSy@i for eIaya$ EMANCIPATION bills always pr0sla
AIr. Wllitthorne-.Only once, and TINT was
when proposetl, III view, If the renewal Of
tho Navy Department tn tho new building, In
s'SSe SonIMk n Gso m saa i|frk h bievsaa assaiefn II TIM
thoary Of s1r. Garfield: 1Ie believed there
ought to bu 0ne Committee in Charge OF the
appropriations of tic Government, but hu
believed TINT TINT co,n1nfttee should By con-
lowed to ,s.rp Jurisdiction, ti!o .liscretio..
and work Of 81! the nthcr Committees.
Mr.. Randall Thought tic House, OH reflcc-
t!on, would regret Its action In giving tho Ag-
;ot pfStnfa fo Co. Gonittss faTFH Of tho pror1
re,ne1alors.! WY wsii t& history Of si tHo 1nls
to which Afr. Garfield had rrferrnti. Tho
policy anl principle Of t WIS TINT whenever
by leEislation thc pgoplc's expenditures weru
t"t ~ rinfo,,' IT. /. n'tu @ " uu,.o Wy sGM.i
+, t.tv -, rE.s'.n!; a. os Whtia oRteSS uesret
II NY WY ~ MeeIe.se lug GSpeHultlltea OF
tao .i0sefieht ~ taefo snou!;l 90 swlit WuS
t ~ m4Ffn ios miu Mscoinpttislnteht y tnat
ncroi,n a ,ortw T ,a a1 ,neo1 rx oh sSif WH'c I
sn ~, nv .t.,t ~. M fH1! iGsn!a. 1mstk
s tbat s Ws ta r"c Mr @ 81 on ae n
of'g Y me qrnn o. oysry nsnarelt
= y ~, nv 1ao Etese s'e TEoT TS%n
fo,v, fcn St ~ Sa ILL., 4te,oorMasiy 70 w gG1iiem1ia
tsom @ p, rs1 tnt H. ns 'ne'atHr OF to iaoiso ~
Wohn! Teslst III esery PoSSlMn Wy Known 70
silo rules e repeat Of tl.at rtle, a1,d use
Hg;fy fa;'y @Igt t tn 10 pre;sf aG aioaSG ~ rem
Of M ~ eo h9 poWef at any
eflitilent: t, H. ,ihore %9s ll'le OF cniliG!aint
ihpn%a, i.pa%S Sana 10 Wisir 'lH eos!M utvlae ~
netWeon. WlNt W cn!iea ne econo'Alo eS-
peses o. ano Hqyerelt ,n @ tl.1sg 'e't.
% ,Ha ap pee!, s!,tiao, III me mgpohs'aIIaon eI,s
Eeitle1nelt troin Dnlo eo'll;i never SECURE the
V,sc1ne1lt V ,e, e .he peeho py syg 10 tcm:
INC expenditures, teea!sa tllat p0wnr !Rs been