, 1880-11-18
'TWlAT CUP AND LIP.
How the Indiana Tax.e,,.o
ator Lost His Expeota. ''''
tions,
His l'urcllnscs iii T,nroo
co'iilty Alone Over
$115,O 900,
10 VIII est Els Money Back, 1su u.
Expense Of Litigation, s' w


Judge DAvh +. vintt,n, Of tho Tn,,'lon mees'lon {.
cult Court. III reference 10 .ho xni"s iu''oe 1a cf
spiert tAxcs, continues to 10 tin t,o,, aeln'
ural conversation. und Is nttracttuv ..,see een'
attention, ns Inckos purchases ,ycrc ptead ,osa,ad
humber Of counties In this Stale, In ,h,. 'as
ula,ta hn paid $la40Vl into TIM Trcn,,s,. "'s c!H
tho COUNTY rot *soo0 llclow Is Judge v,s.* .nI*
dcclsun lit fl,tl: A'oai
Mary A. 1ctGr Va. .1osiah Locke. ,r.,,,.
htHtEnt To set t!st{o certain tax.sul". ut!
!s1G.i tscpalsty tlln !'so tac Ly Tho rr.ao.ss aos u
itrur Df this city, THE laIl,l jv.Ir:,' '9e ~ Ireas
u, this city, ri Tim tilo Of ti,e Is s.aas
nrnpsr ttrtif1Sates uf purchase wcss tI sy.a s1le!
x.ees nor s 'ins to o!s .i'I,G ye ws but q
o.its Of nviity il tic sales ~. u1e 4, l,4t.,!sat
'9 ge1fi ht tn a,' aa s t,'ey ro briefly thete 10
tiou which rru.ls: lh1xia fcui on s,l,,h u hsxsrlp'
sec. Il. ltnynsliinS', ltn,,Rc l.. >'''A "'eet'
hns resided a tho prc,,lsea !Y.rnSn,, Nv ut ps.s
scrEhc. nl,d llas Ind Nl that to ,d ~ nns 10 de-
On Rn PROMISES nt,!s!lace or pcrsvuaI I.yn ~, M
Hs Sfy I tt q ,t Mne' ,,rI, s1 aS.s H., 1sold hu es
c.y nor of tho city eyer n,ntle an erIa,, ~ 'ae
Gnlicct snLl taxes. nor Dyur ,na,lc etnan'tt %
plItlltin for F'lsl tnxey. 'A''a o
T. IhMt nS 10 Rlid HatN by the Civ T.,,..
the anl WIS only advertiser fur E,j. fos "saales ,ales
weeks ihstead of four wceks, Us the lar .stss e
Il Is further avcrrcl In Tho como,n1n. .,.,
p,nitiG, hofnre sfp cntnmuticc, hsr ri ,as, Icy
cred tu tho cnInty Trc!isrer tia ,,.,,rsss. %s.
money pull l'y leion!ant and !csa, philass in,eEsss,
ic t9fa',, ws sro'n Tfs. ate A f sS ,t to ,is o
1uade io tho City Treasurer, mi. Il ljkS ratnt,'
by him. Aud Lllnt II tender Qt TIM nrvrss,t.
Atno.nts ct tllc nire,nso ttsonry nnd intsfSts.tt
wins brought, anl refused. al thc,s tia uuas!
Eiis DtshHlt Into cOtrt, ssl,era Il now H. fr X
tefutIdan: lilo issue wits fortne.l BY rcaerri mi
.lennl 1" Tho soMplait. Thu evidence iuIiy Iss. su
hnve lnf1rc BntA. t,tx-dceds hnve rot VT IT,. IT,.
undo IT, tho tlcicitaAslt ,'r Is he Yet entitled ID
them. Uni. therefore. siot required 10 tltch,n
%hat Tux '' ssls. ss f'Eess Eess. q Ia M nrehs;si
ihc Guncrui Tax inv, whlclt pss nrescsbs ;s ,ns s
rights Of at,c purchaser. after he 1.p vt hi, ar
Hsetl, i,ayo n, sppiieat!on to thu ease III h.n1
question invalid hcGa!s1 Ut thu fac!s l!cY,, mi
proved? and .f nrnli1. Inns thu lain,f she hsy.
i,l,s w,sa ii.tn so,,rts ntter rruIwr tenders, to
tho right o, !Ee tcr ttle 4,llete, Us ugaissi ts
certificates held by tito ilrfGf,1anty Tint iii
snlcs ara invalid under The fucts rnnycd b.,
nt o,tS, ana, determines! W tho smprev eoytt
Isowcn VI. Donovan. Il: Ln'tIhtn!. p. :,;S:
1T .wns shown In csidcnee that donovan bad
abundance Of pcrsm,al Property on, Of wblca
during tho rcar Of tiin dcllsgacncy. ulna Hhkd
h.lI ly this Court, .soidcd thy tux tItle."
raytuE, or tcnicrlMg tl!o praner aiiossnt, could
t:nIilu intu tho equity sile Ut tho rourt to aats
lscr titt1 uietEa hs aAnnEt y certificate is4lpa
nsn,n I'M tnvnli;l tnx s4!o Ing ''to tecn {rcluet
tloIl, md i1idcotl all tht questions inynrtl IN
this case. nrutlctcrn,tic' II, tho cte Ut stcWhn.