, 1880-09-25
UORSE-BEATING.
Conclusion of tho Trial of Dunn, the
Horse.Pouuler.
Son1o Very Weak Testimony Offered by
tho Defense.
lers Says Whips Are Mado Tor HoFso.-CoI.
Van Arman's Closing Speech.

van RfMan's CLOSING Speech.
Tbs Defendant Escapes with q Petty Fine
Of but Sas.
Tho cnsc of Jero Dunn, charged witt, cruelty
TT hhltuhs during tho recent tHnn.liorau contest
on tho lAko Ahnrc, wns realitnctl before 1ustIco
snnner1eA yesterday nlornIng.
HIt II. r. f.EitICKsON
was cnllc for tho proscctitlon and testified TINT
lle went to tho show n1,put 1a:D Wednesday,.
Ills attention was called to n horse by Dunn
urging tho rider 10 9ot awNy from the ono tnl
me1tatuly following, nnd he became satisfied tho
horse hadn't tho atrct,AtI, to do it, Whou he
tnt11e nrnt1sitl "gn wItscss observed tint tho
loft heel III tho rltter wAs bloody, and TINT there
WAS bood nn tho side Of tho horse. place six or
eight nchs:s long, which lDokcd rs II IL had been
wiped or with wet CLOTH. On the driper's heel
was Il brad ntoMt ve.ciHhths Of ut Inch lung.
Wltncss nskcl Dunn If he was the ownpr
Of tho horso. IIe said he was. Wit
ness tulh him that he hnd como tteto
rs tho representative Of tho Humane Society,
hut Ind no disposition wintcvcr to ln anything
that would cMtlsu my 1Isturbat,tc,-thnt his n-
Jcet wts u call his attention 10 tho f1rt that iie
WIS cr'lclly treating his horse,-vtont!lg tic
Inv; and witness asked him to stop 1t. Dunn
nbrnpty replied that he w0it|l shoot my tr,n,l
who attempted to Interfere with bis business.
Nnl repeated this when tuld thut ttut WIS not
proper tHk. Witness askctl him II hu wns Will.
Ing to hhvo twu cxln.rts examine Ills horse to 8cc
II hb was mt crliully treating him. Il0 snd 'ic
WIS tlot. Witness noticed Iurge wclts OIL tito left
fiarks Of tic horse, which seemed TO be over
worked.
On the cross Dunn tried to draw out that Sui
llvan md 1,nth.nRn had been promised in-
1ut'I'ity to testify agai.st him. Witness, tow-
ever, Knew nothing OK my prOJntsps. Ii0 WIS
within Six fcet Of tic hurse. p.. didn't hnyo his his
pn Sry 1 ctwsen t9ste ~, 9 was pTnss%
"otss' 49,. ~ ~ns III
AN EaAc1ATEn AND sopsE'tfNo coSnlT1nS.
showing signs ol distress FROM tho way n which
Ind u ;sssse.l a, ~Slppe Se . sei s i'iai 10 70
~ to Tho striking by Dunn und suvernI boys.
yG rn,1 th f.S ~ twa hours "nd as
ii a,,swcr 10 question ~ on nj tic cr er,ss, wtncsa
| sail thu hDrso wis i.ntacrcifn1ly whipped.
..,srlt .wba. t.! t. 1"erSyi !',I asked & Jrre:
| which yOsl would like to hn trcasel."
| Jcro drew out that witness WIS Within throo
ient q ntin Wi'dl. nc struck tto horso ~ sygrI'-
,omg, g r',t+ W. d ,os ht slio Witness I1e was q.
sma,,, tau t'Hn' s'oo VI Dunn' "no uSeo us right
'''!Sd; &S'a closed tue case for the prosecution.
snting what ha wuttlll prove, ind pltrhlng Into
er,,r en to sat IT, au % eSK. il" WIS M'i1 rrose. &C..
tey y wp @ not S @ng tse ss 'xT snno show
III. was thon swarm. ind tcatifei TINT tic en-
tered tho tlorsc, whoso hentl, Hubs, nnJ wim,l
tlmt klMl having been previously trnineti i' ir n i
wlloln aeaso1,, nnl for sx weeks for ths spcstai
stDIora aa sofweo Witmess Witt s;sS oxa9lMe1 M
tho horso uvrry tInlo It cnno vi tho truck,
] Erunt dIBtrCHs In nerves or MUSCLES, Huf-
| 1lcIont ,rost ,yas glvc,L-twelyn hol,rs in
twenty fntlr. It wis rested oyery flftcen
oveFy twoaty:rar ha'irs; s'n,ak VOL @ and m sept t
hour nl'd hnlf 1T tno tl,.rg tho wiiolp r,lcr.
lt9 is !nt Srealy strike u. The nnlIlnl Wns
aa an 1t ps tervas aI'y WIS IN s,cae t stD e te
Sas spy; T. proyens mt soroness n tho muscles u
rG Go,t fso re- WY n "fh'niilo nah aott'r"-lnla
inv horse wo be- nft"r S 'II tys wurk te'1 rhnra I
W. wsFs 81 no %sits Vt, T. on its h!ns but Isl spot'
srES IT, lit pS stesE 9 1F r 1e y nmnogr vtH no, 70,
ono to str,ko It. Tho "'eans employed 'eore to
EScoulAnE, rIt10MTEN, AND gxclrE
fr tho horse ws . Us @ stronE 81 is thnt of TIC ' Ir!b
Gf tho desoFt for his stcc lteould not he OVER
drvcn ,on nccsll1,t Of Ita temperament; it
10 xs. whipping Or l,o WHIPPING. Tho is,tso c" bs
| lnngsd 70 II. ". suwclt, t'f l!oston, md cost
without my bodily Injury. Mono Of mo rI,ivrs
Worh "spsti" nl't !lt'ho OF them hasl blond on
%ss ats' ise s s sir wS tnS
I',it It WIS useless. ~ the boys Iegs d!dn't so
wS wv; Sss snxsrr With rel A. ms 1a let sxssS
| eItota. ,Ttu.nttlp horses w,s hts bsinrsS. liz,
didn't thrcatcn e s''.ot euy QUO who inluriered,