New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1880-05-14
xLyIth CONGRESS-IId SESSION.

REGULAR REPORT OF PROCEEDINGS
SENATOR HILL OPPOSES THE THEFT Oh khbIoSSS
sEAr-MR CARPENTERS SPEECH THE rhNsiON
.pevARs BILL IN THE HOUSE-THE LEGF'
I,r1vE B1L1-MR. sPRINGERs REPLY TO MR.
oKTH
SENATE. WAsmSGTOx Nay -. 1880.
In tia Senate to-day a communication was
rece.vus FROM the O @ Interior in regard 10
an appropriation OF $4,000 TO cover dehciences III Tue
salaries OF Registers aRh Receivers OF Lana 0mces No
ferred. . .ho
minority of the COMMITTEES Alleged Frauds In the
Int election on the subject OF NEUTRALITY-SUSPICIOUS. III
Island Laid on the table. =, .no
The Senate took mp the bill aboishng sn tOl's y" '
louisville aud Portland Canal after July l. Aooo a..
authorfz NJ the Secretary OF war 10 IRA '.;r Of
Treasury Tor actual pcnses Of operation ann rc'' "
te canal After dobate the OIL was o for the
IlbIsry Of Congress was taken up ano ai'ef "0O"''
a11 aStas orp resolutions were then taken up and MI.
HAMPTON DtnA e. spoke s6sre sny Mprouer mo-
IH!e 10 a md no was panied TO diff witt them
and with his party nssssite;s th hseE deEcnce
He could not admit the principle thai ssttIen ' - L.,
eeutesfed case its IN ts eond I've ovetnow 49,
The s-nase announced deliberate jndsmsht nS1
Mr. kellogg was entitled 10 is H o 'h;ndine effect
fa,s case can be reheatd now what i TO prevent ss
tSn senate would always decide rgntly but the CON
saomenees OF leaving titles u seats forever
1nen to question were more dlsasLLo"s ,, Ill.
~ hi svmnatbies were with tue contestant III tnls
case and with the State OF louisiana whlch IL u w. ~
- c-"at n wrong But the Senate had n power Wr,
,lress that wrong. Time, the great nel.tr cout
fSat State with whom his own people No 50 M ,Sn
~ sn"' eamu,o1 would not mscOnstrue MS action.
Ibe ncone OF South Carolina can best judge low 1'o.
t,anor IL guarded here, and shouiG IL ever uo NY 80,
having courage follow my CONVICTIONS; .noS uI f
at least say he bruvcd the shaIts OF cSns i%er's
SHAME and on the field OF honor peuSeo Soi"'i
fame" IApplauseI 80 r,. .-, .o,l, tho Amor He
,nnrstood tine senator from Georgia tMr llp 10 hae
argned tuat after the Senate hau s"d'eu beLs"ii
aId have TO upseaS him ii the Stnte
TeSslaIure. This would make the sates' u, , ,ne
senatce; .rpryter read legal decisions showing that
the dee,son of court of hnal jurisdiction was 9
sihle~though IL made black whlte ana VINO IN,
Mt Carpenter dsd not wish 10 De Dr. " ~ do IT
making Judgment nnai hu"o ~ 'SH'' ~
Mr. EkION (Dem., Conn., stated that ne ca no, ~
vi ~. Senate as goyernable by the rules observed W
fine courts. Il was an assembly OF anu 49, ~
nver,J9 States governed by 40 shch rety Tthh' ,,
MT CARPENTER said tue Senate was unoouDlo"F
body of great men. e.o. o,,,, yvbistle il down
'nS ~ ~ RPFN TER-If there is anything don't want
IN whistle down the wind II Is my own greatness "ns
that of the Senator trnm Conntcteut. Due >, ~ ~ y
s,ot the Snnreme Court body oil gieit men repTes
eli the ates aud Of great dignity anu ieSlectao
a. chow Change In the political uIJOrlty 10 arg "
corrunttcn in the acts of former lnJo1'S "ouu " "
Nexicanise the Senate Let MS have one pace Wi' H.
10 will he constant, respected, where Justce VIII NC
Administered impaltaiH A., ,.,oa +,a a,or and
Mt $50 p. M. the senate went into eXeeuNe sesSo"
and when the doors we're opened adjourned