, 1880-03-30
diSgatohed 10 Portland, Nc. Thu shipper
RnlNs " crl1lftnt DfTord 10 En1lif i,y ynl exon

reacl! lorf. and: although you Will Insure my
freight alltl give me hetter rntes I nm com
pgIled to scnd BY tlts .Englisl, vessel, brcal,se
TX knnw .a. sl!n Will not be disturbed" And III
!ho iace OF tilesc 1Acts, everywhere ntn1tlcll,
the honorable Senator from Oh,o says nll the
n,nii Ind to tto was to clargp It In Ills ucroll,,,
;, AZ. Thurman sAitl tho Senator from Mninu
=! nnd mot met The point t. Ills satisfaction.
cause British ships could carry goods, there.
fore the A'rlcricnn owncrpni.l war premiums,
and thoreforo llo Wns ttninptest out Ut exist.
e',Ge. II 80; how i It t!Mt they have their
Siali,,s i.er9? # they DID not snrry on the
o!t inc hlFh seas,-if there were Ilo American
rtsks, Inv comes this mighty class Of
MWHa.prGl1ll,lnl M men, far outns!'Mbcrlug all
were not, driven otr tho sNa? ii Is BECAUSE
thalr business was mot stricken down. Tl,uir
prHatS may lMvn l,reh l..ssnl,rtl, Int, II tElpy
liNu llot lnnia profits, they l,cr1r wnllll l.ayt.
carflctl u, tho business. Here Is onc, for ip-
Sle ls lost IN her tentti trip. 1Ior I,lno trips
ilaye brought pr0tlt MORO than sufficient Ia
indemnify HIN for | Afs, nlsllanccd nre-
lM''!lns. Aru no pe9n!e Of THO U'tlted Stntes
yenr aftMr 3car they carried on this business
IP1yyay I|PGylnyg these war risks and iosl''g I'LL The
A[r. ,Dlaino-Docs mt tho Sonntnr know
enough &C navigation Il, know tllat TIM s!ltp-
GWner i W!lt Keep hEs vessel nIlDnt ratfet tl,uli
tll'is giving employment tU tte sailors alul
l!elptng 70 continue tho commerce Of
the country? ail only pleading tho
tra md q ta} t5S %o' o as"Fnst is q n ,dls the
boldly ,and sleiEnntly Aaiic.l their sllipss
DURING TUG entire period Of tho lvnr under
tho projection ut tho American INK, Geliry.
!nE ~ tsley .litl every day TINT they put by
rGic,cipt iar lns!lra',ce paid. tat i was
lsrltatn, Which the great Government which
They wcru serving would III the end 500 was
Mr. Thurman sald that IL sl,tp-owncrs pre-
iaa psrnt ta i 70 ri L Ut ts liz with %inryas afe 5
did nut seo wllerr tho patriotism cl,lle III.
a wliilu ngu these s4lts smiled tho ocrnn
Witll the Stars aiNl Stripes At their sast1cad!s
t,. n!la Of patriotlsn;., They, woni not phil
tlat i'aE on tho broad sens, and III tic tace Of
n! e'lcllss, out ot pure patriotism, uloy kept
niloas. Now thu Senator says TINT WIS not
IT ut nll; i wns becanso t},oy lnai1o
n %s eslsIet' t s brsans nFot 10 anl r, IGfs ts
risk Of destruction on tic sen than, await
Gcrtnln destruction at the wtnryes. II that
y 1,"e taklnE lmtrlntisnt out Of the argument
| lo nut knuw ,What It ts. hut wlsnt Of tho
iiercnnt TINT did that dill it l,osa,tss % tlcru m
Wns ni1il0y ~ H.. as lla believed, and lll
wUilhl lnye sl0ppad It the moment llo fou,dl
there WAS not.
Mr.: BIalne-I AM nrg,,ing for the excul-
natctl eruIscr cl.piins jnRt as earnestly NJ fur
the War pr9tatuln elatnls, ard ,IIu nrR,tIur
Inf tlo Insurance G9ill'1l!it,s us earnestly ,ls
tic SrMator from Ohio, II he will put iii tic
tiese otilers-tIiat they shul| show thoy arc
losers.
1T. Tllr1nan--Now tho Senator from
Maine llilS iAI4 down tho principle ttnt ven
tl!re 70 tell him le vii! nGt: stick to II wpelx
ta he1of% f%at 70 @ bnck put tiow s We gst at
II 6l f'S IL 1877 Fl S! Sy sayus Ms f1t iat at ts y
illsnlnMce company should only clalm fur
what It hal pAll aitor Il fill exhibit Ut atl
Whoo busess. # was wit VIII s stos% sstor !'s aIY ~
that 70 ti!e ,lnh WHO paid wur premiums, it'd
require, hin to furnish oil exhIbit Of liis
mip!o ,nt te,D n1sliesa to w Wetl!ar 9 M.1c or
atr. Hlalne.,Vo sliall bu Willing 10 fo1low
tho rule rs far M practicable, bit these H.
s,lralicu companies essential. to commerce
were not pl,rs.ing tho sniMa kind Ut Il bust
men took ulelr risk III tic Legitimate @ pur.
slliltcH nf their buatnexs.
j., alr. Thurnlan-'rhe Senator Inns doubtless
heard OF such thtg as the right Of aubro-
bfr, Dlalne-Ycs; and heard It demolished
Mr. TlillrMnIl-rhb bulntnr did not Ilenr
i de'ilol!ahe.l. Whull tho Senator clInes to
~ Dp 1lldgs IT, WI! learn to haar both sides
Mr.. Thurman here stopped. rnised his
haul to hts foral,eat!, US II in pnln, and
steIYetl about to full. Soyer.l 6nnat0rs wullt
to Ills assistance but, after btthIug lis llea.l