, 1880-11-09


c,yeu yesterday hy tho Arppl1ato Court was tint
n rho case Of tho City va. ]. ]. Qarr'ty anil
utbpr4. n condemnation suit for widening Stnto
tfrect, an9 involving Il question never. bgrorp
ericd In this Stnto. Tho nnly property III tlttcs-
t,on on sip present appeal. lloWnr cr, wits Il lot
On tho so1lthonst corllor 1T StRtu md
TblrtY.Ilrst street, fronting twenty-five feet OH
yts,rI and running buck ltO feet Oh Thlrty-arst,
and improved by'A building pnrtiy wnol md
mrtly brick. Thu property wils owned by
t;afrity, and lr1,sc,, TO onc Cudncy frotn Jann-
nry. 1e;y tu Aluy, Iss4, MS sAtn0n, Mt monthly
ru1tal If <tD l5y tho condemnation suit Il WIS
sutyht tu luke tho wrst thirty-four fnet Of tho
Im. Tic Jury hxetl tho value Of ths lot Mt
s3.:sN, of tho improvements ut s., H0, nnu tho
Iamupn 10 tito rest If tho !ut MT $E0. CtItl,lry
ct md fixtures: The city app.sasel: On th9
iu Released frotI 1'nytfgt Of rent Whenever tho
they sh,n!I.l mukc, no deduction from tho
amount tn he ilwnrtle,i to tho owner OF the prem
iscs ppuaht lo hv cU1,'senlnrll ty rcusofl q the
1elsehold interest In tho sntli4. II they htl1cscu
that tbe rent reserved t tl'e lcslse ws equal to
Judge l!lfloy, III tlrciln4 tito caBe eufd tho
amount nj compensation which II landlord n1ld
tenant respectively were entitled to rccelso fur
Improvement lll,tst lcpGsl!, to y considerable
extent, OH tho elect wi,feh tho taksuH ns 4 u9r-
ton Of tho dcEnisetl rrcfniEes fnr puGlo ttst "
wouil pro,luee on tho tcnn',cy itsulf. il THO
lease was annu!lt4l and tlo te,lmncy tnr!ni,atei!,
r r. e'en aal i a rt VIII psnor1'tely lcfses ro
Mnsa.joa p on tam iA' II It wcrS "ii ica ott tiat
thd liability Of tho tcnnnt continued for tho
.prutIon by tho ety Of ,'art 1T tho premises.
There wis no tccis0n 70 Do found In tic 1llnoa
Eetssts sa tile po'ut. The WEIGHT of authority
for lAe cilsirp rent, Notwithstanding tho con-
demnntton ol l,art Of tho property for public
inliv to 10 takon hy tho plDi!a ~ vlrtlo Of tho
r:4ht Of etn!ncnt t,o.nAln, md t,rcu!sely tho
sane terms ~ which my other estatc IN Inu'ls
S pss be os ''' t5 ss pscriy Is ksn by he s
ssaIao s ott IL that IT. of which % iGo tenant
was depr!vcd-tsio possession for. the
compensation wis to 10 csii,nato1. M dhe I i,wss s
Ct enIl,ent dosliain took and subJcctes, tn pl,hu
rse, not tue eontruct BY ,Fhch nj interest In tho
s sas @ 5 Si &C. sss a s 'sss ws oss MesSs ts so
!xte', gtnor ntld Erutltce.. There could bo no
!ust ground, ho,,, for ho,ng Tint The conioulnn-
tio9 otasi Or rartof tbe smiscd premises could,
acknowledgment Of the Ie,,Hs elthrr III wholo or
u paTl. No such r,,lu WIS attempted 70 TO nl'-
plcd to my Other interest In laills. Az hctween
xHinGl, though II part or uilthe purchase n,oury
might 10 IN nrrenrs, A ulDriRn1p lib between
iAe parties thereto WIS nnt ,1vAlIdntcf, thGilgh
the money for which II was given wus uut,nfa,
oFhad not even MAtlirel.
tenant was eut}tJtait to receive from tho pub
t1c mi compensation for W much vi hIs Gasc-
n nola fTtato aA bod l'ecnfpproprlntul to pil,!to
ier ~ loss, and therc wus M ronst,n why tio
fnnal.! le exeHach from performing tho cov-
eaants 9f tho tcasc. lilo Wus deprived, IT WIS
itne. Or tho IosscksjGn Of the premises, but n.-
es1ged its equivalent IN nnpey, Al,d, ,lcG,r,i-
,,aRy. It WIS but llst TINT ho should
~ ~ helu 70 tho payment OF tho rrh,.
aae tnss'f1letlons Rs given aboye n,tlSt hMyo
tcsAlca ~ tue asseaatAalit Of Ii nrAer HlIm III
!st"s o! tho tant0rt hn1 smaller sim III favor
VI Wy tenant thnn VIM his tllIe. Tho tlAH,nErH
nHhf1edt tt'e laniiorl md tenlMt, respectively
@ S0A!u cach Secm to be tho result Of nlt isi,!I.
pSnuehs assessment. nIh t,cro could 10 no lH-
IJe9 st;ah tsa1 dantaEcs Ind INT f,tcu .tssessc
",,ts "nhn III INC aggregate wnntd not exceed tho
~, t,ne tn1h OF tile property taken, 1T long III
aa @sI. naasleflt WIS bilsel IN principles which
~ S,n H. r,,self Grrnncnua No proper duplication,
, tae principles VI tho iIlstr,inltDs IL tic uyi-
,lsna %e,en Wt hayc resulted III 1sloru t1n Inl,a
Rts s,R 70 tilo tc11ut.t for his lrilschn interest
ssUA !!lo 'rent reserved anu tho snnlIct was
1o.etos 1so. ~ u awarding him ElUW Tho judy
i,s,r i., nn tue Court Nl1w, Fur tho orrors Iii Tho
tAu3e fGuunllttti = - - = "' --