New-York tribune., 1879-08-27


interested in the subject of vvsecon Is called to the
announcement OF the meeting at metropolitan Tempe
S. DeYoung scapeD, will be there, ana theh
give exhibition OF this interesting pfauch
of scientific experiment which will be highly
entertaining aud instructive TO an VINO may De 50
fortunate admttance TO the Temple on That
subject Of the doctors dsseotng knife on this occa-
sion thoroughly detested by the human family
for the Prevention OF Cruelty to Animals Will not
feel called upon to interfere with the operation. No
commence promptly AT o'clock.
"In the number of The CAL for Thursday also
written many hours before the dispatch mentioning
Kallochs father was received or its contents known
at The Chronicle office, is the following paragraph.
showing how mlnutely Kalloch had arranged his
plans for his Temple speech and how he had cata-
logued its contents:
"As the Temple Will not hold one-hslf of those who will
desire TO participate IN the meeting tomorrow, me
crowd outside viii be addressed by other speakers while
Dr. Kalloch is dissecng the DcYounes after which he
VIII speak to the street who are unable TO
obtain admitance 20 the Temple.
"These paragraphs would be quite sufficient to dis
prove his statement that he wished to defend his
father but this is not all. Not satisfied with hav-
ing all the advertisement possible IN the city
through the medium of the newspapers hostile to
the De Youngs he called into requistion the assist
ance of the California Associated Press, whose
agent telegraphed to the interior journals his
slanderous intentions. The following is from the
dispatch to The Sacramento Record Union, Gated
August 81, and penned long before the dispatch in
which Kalloch's father was alluded to was in the
hands of The Chronicles telegraph editor:
"FUN AHEAD-KALIOCH PROMISES TO FIGHT THE
DEVIL WITH FIRE-THE DE YoUNGs To RECEIVE
AS GOOD AS THEY SENT.
"sAN FRANCISCO, Aug. 21:-KallOch will. tomorrow
evening" he come back the De HOun2s IN KIND
giving them good as they sent he proposes to read
the story OF Napthay published IN ne san some years
wi Il AIN
reports say sent Isaac message with nOtihcs-
tiOn that II he read that Creed they would
shoot nm sgnt Kalloch. it is further asserted,
notified the DE Youngss that he would read
the article tu question: and immediately semitic the com
m}ttee 10 obtain copy or H.
"It would appear from this that Kalloch had
made MP his mind not only to read the article from
the old Sun, but he had decided to read it with elab-
oratons His father is not alluded to in any OF
these paragraphs. and whyf Simply because
neither he nor any other man IN San Fran
cisco suspected that his fathers antecedcnts could
be in any manner connected with Lis own mIscon-
duct. His fathers memory an afterhought,
supplemental pleading to the terrible indictment
brought against him by The Chronicle 1t was not a
happy afterthought being so inconsistent with his
numerous declarations of intention, advertised in
every conceivable way.
NAPTHALY's RETRACIIoE
"B. F. Napthaly confirms all that is stated herein
regarding Kaloch's intentions. He says that a
year ago he retracted all the statements Of the old
San article IN an affidavit made by him. He adds
Kalloch sent for him and asked for copy of the
article. Napthaly responded that he had none, and
that if Kalloch found one by chance he had better
not use it, as it had no foundation on its face He had
written and published it, he said, in moment of
anger and frenzied rage at the De Youngs. Kalloch
again sent for him. and he called desired. Kali
loch again asked for copy Of the article, and
when told that it was not accessible he exultlngy
announced that he had one. He was once more adj
vised not to use it, Napthaly having acknowledged
the falsy of its statements and declared it to have
been written in a spirit of revenge Then Kalloch
declared that he did not care whether it true
false. Napthaly told him If he used it he was a
dead man.
con Saturday. when the news Of the shooting
came Napthaly was at the Sheriff's office. There
were present number of well-known gentlemen
As soon as Napthalv came in they reproached him
with being the cause of all the trouble. He
velemently denied that he was to blame, and
asserted that he had gone to Kalloch and
had marked a copy of the old Sm, and
assured him that ITS statements rejecting on
the De Young family were false and that they
were written by him in a spirit Of revenge to get
even with the De Young brothers for injuries which
he had fancied they had done him,
"Regardmg the Boston dispatch, the prescent
Kalloch declares / wrought him up to the
requisite pitch of oratorical madness before it was
recsved Neither the managing editor any
one in The Chronicle office knew anything about
Kalloch's father, except that he had once been
clergyman and had lived in California. 1t was
presumed that his record was spOtless. The dis
patch came on the morning of Friday, August o.
the date of its publication in The Chronicle 1t
about / a. m. Al that hour everything is life and
motion in the Office of leading newspaper. Mails
and railroad trains are lneXOrable they wait for
no one In some haste the telegraph editor
looked over the dispatch and got 1t ready
for. the printer. The managing editor was
informed that KallOchs father was mentioned; hut,
not reading the matter himself, he presumed that
the alluson was simply 10 his emigratmQ 10 CallfOr-
mia and mis- residence on this coast. Mr. DE Young
in later, so late as to preclude close eXami-
nation of the contents Of that days paper lie asked
regarding the Boston dispatch, and was informed
that it simply Tehear,ed the facts of the
Wednesday article on kalloCh, with some addi-
tioual information respecting kalocRs ant-CathO-
lie and anti-Irish record. Mr.. De Young then said,
If that Is all let II CO." words t. that effect.
The standing order in The Chronicle Office has been
never to attack mans relatives III connection with
any cr tlcsIn made on himself
9Ee Chronicle has, therefore, shown by indis-
putahle proof that would convince any jury, that
long before Kalloch knew or con- Id have known or
could have suspected that his father was 10 be mem
toned i'm Tie Chronicle, he had resolved To attack
the venerable mother of the De lOungs; that, be-
fore the dispatch winch contained the allusiOn 10
Kallocb 0ere was received at The Chronicle Office,
Kalloch f1s had already declared his intentions to
make his slandcTOuS Speech-in articles written by
himself and published IN journals edited by hnc
self, IN articles possibly penned by hlmsell
which appeared in the columns OF journals hostile
to the De YOunGs and placed for the time under bis
sociated Press dictated If not written by him.
These dispatches wele already III type in distant
cities at the very moment when the alleged article
on Kallochs father was coming over the wires from
Boston.
THE SHOOTING NOT cowARDLY.