The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-11-29
rnornr Ann cArIIoLlCls,l.
a Criticism on the Historians Recent
Article Oh tie American Problem.
WuvpttVa " VI Mo-, M 1879

, Criticism on the hlstOFlan's Recent
Article Oh tito American Problem.
WnRgLlNU, W. Va, Nov. 70, 1879,
EdIiO,, Ipislllr,nesr.
ansr.wey IN the ,,,trio vL,rh an.
- - -,e-,"'-,. "NA w
PeMeu III yesIeIuays lSIELLldENcEt,
copied from the New York TINES, on the
! the subject Of Mr., Froude's fecent article
In ,ha No,h Iw-r;.,n R.ris,r anolo..
Al, E.,,..ai.' T., 'y. ouS'V-s
you tue IolloWInB Iet'er Oh correspondent
Of the Chicago 7ribIHt, which recently
appeared Ia that journal, and which | hone
vnr wuI Iva all. 10 r,.La roo,,, I,,I, .o,,.
WV "''' w p".e W 'i'IA0 ,ON'A w VI yvur
paper, Is q mater OF Justice 10 the irish
Catholics land In fact all Catholics Tor that
malter), 30 uusparinply malipued nv your
Nsw yn,L non,smnora,v Ir.s,S.
~. 80 .0 I',I-'.. '''1NA'
s S,' I"s ~ ."'SI ~
u ,g ~ ~ Jew WoIus, 9nIy lew
Anu Il,O 'lT. IeH MnI w. ncCaeISsAL hurried
En- T IeP'y Wtno A mR o. SA1ea Anthony
EIUuIV ~ .ne NOlM IiH't,lca" KeritW,
SonfHtu mo IVu' 'sauo y oi1Ay, WIN the
m ,.Si' ,La i,,siiaS Eau tiE,oDieIh-ho-
uT TLs ~ Wy uIil seu eutss, &c
.i.st, u'S ~ w VoieL1oy SohLect
y, Wy uJhIets VI ne Aticlg 81
rIouue, inouE1, o. coStse, mat analysis u
h3t ~ lul! y " lllSnt % maue, Justice 70
10y nui iI, VI ~ ioIi I ulc-
N' S..,i H'osS S nSs' NY Insenu " WHle
Iu IeIu.s'n IuI review OF
J.osVa u u HS '' wi i1l n's9 ~, ln-
uuS'I,9GS, PA"aOAes, u'u s!AnueES. lhAt
mUu'a iv4"pso ..I n columns aI' OF your
PapeI I ~, aIucIe uIIS, anu IN
aaS Du"' " INV NV ~ "'' VomulAnu lu't
NY nT'th.,,.ro,,L...L ,..
- DI SDi,. LHHf Aunso ~ atguule1t'
tng ht PeEln nnPeaehlng Tue credit
T"tS III, H., .I..-i.. Lust h ,LLst.
EronJa ,Is,;,aJ Tbs r Iyw SnVS y nt t1
Antbonv Fsa,n :" nv ths mS,icio, T"" III
t nuy ItT tuo malicious anu
hn tn.Sni;ad III tI,Is ~, ~ Il now
i"I.sSnoJ a., Y,S,Sr onJ IT.t".iS,, y!
- III S,,I oa WV" y, E. au II I' Known
SoHI sSSi"h ~, b Tns ,a Macy mIse
III S,nhi,Sa, 'U ossn IN ti0 pos.Ioh WnIcI
Wac",,I,,, 80 S,Sor ~ o1 ve T tMe PeeT ~
;n%SSNS ~ i, U ,i'ss ssa Sat EsIsn aLs'
voi,,a Kim IT, H. ins,;l p ~ hIIt, u'snt
F,or, ,ho E. s1S ,S sT ~, ~ it ms
anil o,hsr 0 ,oSarIs tLe ~ SSInoIcS, Ltisn
tn,ioNs ~ III ron,t.s e iS law Inu inSuIu
oi ,Ss s;nnins ~ .ha oo IU.n une IlG I
VI tne sIsh!pk o. Ine ], Declaration Of indie
H. W. ~ iS,5 ~" Nv mS M tnuePendence
tSo w.. a.. 1I,a w HieAIV Nv war, anu
tsN, ,hoI, atI,tnS" .n'iL - tn hs {sry Gay
t;on .nT ia IsIa t" NJ tue Vons!itu'
III tha i nas t1 ' 'n;ah " as naPpy l9n1 IN
,nos s,'I IL, I E' ~ an'et what y WI DC
hSSinI rNv ,nhr.,,o sue Ias1tei anu lhIs,
sbo~ lie yrtarSS i"ra.. W y, tsCts, nignt
Non SnJ N" .,so,',,.IIS u. rtouue posi-
i tiyLuI snI tuo SIOu . Of the Eng
tntion sho Eat r. lest w AmeriGan Vonsti'
sas s I g.louIu ~ vlonteu And tue Ameri'
vSu a ooI =, n.y. PsrPsstuAli pat, Is nave
iSisnso q, i.o ~ sas .oet' nave not the
i''au,e, " iesE ~ present, 70 10 the latter.
rooan uot, uao' taiI, COhteht myself win
''I'U FLns = IUlloWs'
,oiI,,ian ~ y. Guy snns tn9 Woman CasnOIic
~ ~ 20 OpeT r wM witn Tue principles
VI I Tue IN. AtiS'iVa a SonSutItloh.
~ .N Mn' =. Iepiy; AZ vatnoltcs solemn
TT Smea' ~ suPL'TIt Ihe constitution Of the
.L n ie. o ~ ~ whenever called upon by
tIic AVE VI tne couhEy, l3st as DO other
H HAI 'isi ~. AnG lthe laws Of their
~ Snu .L ~ not pLoGlOiL their doing 80,
~ sAo ~ Sou I.,s.y LleLt Snutch enlolnS on
tho ' n. a. Sny ~ oDeyiny OF tne laws Of
I ae r " NV 7 unuet pam oil violating tho
'"n ~. " uou. ..,
cay,ai su !p,1i,g tnSt tne teachings Of the
Os JaI .eisioh G arc ~ c9nnict win the
H. u. tue C ~ then surely
sne I.nClptes ol tne constitution are 10
soI;s;os s WI" .aI 'TS 'cacnlnSS o. me Uatholic
ns,Stt.i, "nuI ~ ~ ePuAI nRht, the true |
;;niio IT, mus WIN, esp9CiAlly u me true
raomii In III 'e Ky U! oo,vVyVVV Of
IenlPnI, "Io .uS "sv nS principles are
a noS NOH tha my ovYy,VVo, anu thote |
E y0,SO ,onreson,H tGn f., trssh whicA
fa.' , ,ieoU ~ SiS lLisn 70 9e'
. conII;c %' ~ Hn " aoIue " tne decision 10
,ho aano,; ~ u1 Tn ~ Lhe principles Of
'r iV ~ SonsI2n, n conflict
msn SuS ~ tue Satnoilc rehglon'
,;-., Us H themselves unaet such
~ Ln.," - 10 an american citlEea
t;n MO ~ nA ~ ' TfDi y supPott ne Cohsutu
C 1Ion VI ane onlteu Sta'eS' say: Let the
' ~. T pvi.S Il. -, >,
r,;ir:1a ~ r suTe - VERY mucn AFRAID Of
con,,.,. "1 ~ PLGPonuetahee 10 TINS
S0HuIEy; 90 me oS Is altalI mat me descend
o,t,s, ~. PSOE'S nuI' A4t 81 HUE
Os5 ~ the aescenuants OF SSOO0O0O;
I'iI AZ o.HlR tle reasons LOT MS peliet
a lse n II,SI Nv eveIy man ana woman OIL this
oo,u0V,OVVUIIua eEety American man and
HoLnan. ne says; out now the Irish
H., n a,,S are m huepenlent o. additions
n oLo ,L mi'U It'll. mere are already b'WO.OOO
VI ttlem. 4IeyTeSTts Ne Gb@'netIee IRON
,eTuat t1e Whlch distinguishes them 60
hohoraoiy at nome; ana TINS Is favorable
70 large families. what does this mean
1ut tnat SOgVV,VO0o oil Americans, most oil
them NOT OathoIicS, are not free from
'eTltat rlee and that the cause Of the pro-
OaOie preponuerence oil Catholics in this
country ~ no very distant future is their |
%Tadt PurHy!
n greater alifont than this was never
ohereu Dy pubic writer to great and
vigorous nSnon. TAX now Of Dickens
american Noies SO, according to Mr..
Froude,, II Catholics shall ever have
Prep0ndsrance IN this country, twill he
largely u no! mainly, due to the relatively |
superior purity oil thelt wives, theirdaugh.
ters anu their men, Would he keep yir-
tue from reaping what It has Sown? Thus
does he lead US TO the conclusion that II The !
American constitution Is overthrown Il
VIII be IN consequence Of the sexual
wee o, 3O,OOo,OOO Of the American peo'
PIE Inc only moral l can seeto draw
from such reasoning Is: Americans. be
pure 4 You womb \, not lose your liberties.
trouGes Is; hill ouOVO9,OO0 Catholics,
americans anu; spite OF your sexual
VICE you WIZ always DC 10 the majority
ana Keep your constitution. :,
d. 10 preserve the constitution Mt.
FFOuut NOuIu give US series OIL "Falk !