, 1879-01-30
Dr. 1Siiinulrte md ft1Alkte.

q -, ,r,,,..., ru
Df' Nh''n"rte nhti h'a'Rte'
=" the Editor Of Thr 7r'bnus.
CHICAGO, Jan. 3s.-r'le Interview reported In
the Sunday T.,les with Dr. E1bourne. Of the
Elrn Asytum. IN re,xrd in the >H,otk,e rot.
o,,aa.. - ~, ~, M, ~. .o,,, o,,n n,.,,, srs
dismissal o1 Inc young man from the Asylum
after only two weeks observation was, under
the clrcuu,stunecs s,,f,irinntly rutnarkoi,lc INIT
,l,r rrasoua, a. given bv ,hc SUPERINTENDENT. oro
even more 70: bla'kle VA committed to the
Asylum on tic 1ndlnG Ut Court, from ample
Testimony which congincel tho 1urY and the ex-
merits who taye thpr ontn,o,, ,,uon i.-,,ot frofn
personal onset'at2n OF t"e ease,-oi tho iact
III Ills insanity. With these tarts, believe that
there nre very few Asylum Supcrnturtlents who
would feel Justified III l(scl,areIux d u,a,, COM
nftrr 10 ahnrt n ncrimi nf nt.erymtinn. Tlts1
d.. Kilu,,rr,e ahou ies II bis ,,,,tv ~ "a .inis
,,accouftnbIc, ~ il nlso th tntiisation IN t,t.
renort t,at he nusrs t}lc uatfents tfnnfoi III hla
j,ul, tu nc sure, r, sater oppurtlnjt,cs for srns
rt.nrc tiIo,, mn.1 nnr.f.Isns Imtt t%ia H. M ~,
eycnr, lint 11e hns i,nnrnyr, tIIrm' - "os 4''
Dr. kj1tmI,rnu tnny be nertectjy ..nrrrr. In III.
aieoats proois Of f. ami no i,as nnw mi II mn
f,f Tia uowcr 10 uiys' any. If in hai Fwated ~
ntonth eyen bciprc ,lsrfLinR. thcrn r,irbt hn
afijl sonla ni,cetn uM,ut II Int ti,. fact vo;,II
link t1tlEh batter for Tim fhnn t1lrv A.
present. Wv -
'The rea1 ot,estfon. bowrver Ia thla. Ia n
Gunrrnfcn,I,n Cf NJ, av,,tY, II, i,nva thas i'll
crelionnry ntwrr nI II ~. - IL i'm, irwin, lin
sl,,ity ~ "rtmc Thrill ,nssns 'a"' ~ 4ns.yy rsa.'1a
Court ot tl.s,trc. ind romn.lttc,i 10 the AsStt,n,
titnc Ut two weeks the Superintendent sattsucs
himself Tint lie ta.,not, and, II We correctly
understand Dr. hiltpurnc's remarks rs given
70 tne repottef,H nay not been ii!sano,
nrrst,mcI i,'snni.v' sts"l. ~ ~. ".s mnr ".s
a criminal trial at,.l coDylct!on. he turns him
Ipuhs upon soSiety " act upon hts own tleprayeu
IMPULSES. Masn his duty NJ good citizen to
~ ~ n,M .sGe "uMe 'to'un,a susn oPih'nns a. to
riyiiryrs tay hsx, Iecnf H. i, ,t M',t,a I
balktn. Justice, AMI pf uu artuaI, II not tccl,.
nca', contempt OF court ~ go uuiugi His con-
WYE WYE c.sta.i!y seens sniaelehtly sollen ptlons;
inaur .uistais was Il h,a @ mt9 ta @ sst h ~ an ~
frrs in 70 short a lima wtIh,,t ,s,r,,it, ,aian an
tic Itast, haye been more cuurteous to have
Eef n.y. sar ."ear ,ne nesns u ~ aohoI' anu Kept
f MIR atatn lara sr.s s,,", .. y, r.,,,r. TIN
unconditional dismissal, ,iI,dcr suc6 circutn.
sta'ccs, Ut !. easu like Blalktr, tl,cE, They ncud
revision. a sllperiptenaent whose faith In Ills
,,",snrs ia ~, x..l ha.. :! aae.s ,nat ae
~ NUM- .lc 'n!aHaks " q hGo1rt, oasGH trMn the
o1ter'a.n'!s y. numerous W,tnebaea extending
tfEr Much lo1lge: pertol, might perhaps think
lf:A stlll auortef tilc would sutce. III. XII
ooutns eanhot lhstlly us eoI.lnct II, this aIair
~ hscu!ea! men. 1ioE eau he. n ny opinion, Do
80 b:4ote ihe p1olle. 70 wh"LH Io IL respOnBlb!a
Us III oulc'a'. IL. II. hASs!sTxn. II. d. :,
.. --
a rlpJslcta.a Comea to Ue. u'Ungor.s Do.
'
ru,,.uo r. IT,, % ~ yoa III, 1a..; '4,'ti,
eo' w. -o'-ao" ""s oo''xo an un-
hlass4 physician ny giving pluco ih your columns
who ia thu rcripl.nt of somu untrten.Iir crIti.
,t.,,. ,-,,,,, ,,s,,.,.,, ~ 49,. IT. S'..