Daily globe. [volume] (St. Paul, Minn.) 1878-1884, 1879-03-28

Let me here say to the recorder that do
not wish to contend that there was not a
battle, or that there was not heavy fighting
or hard fighting, and that some of the fight
ing there was probably as hard as was ever
known-I do not doubt that for moment.
All that we mean to say is that there was not
general battle, continuous battle, battle
from morning until night.
mat we have shown, we think, that Gen.
Porter did not violate any duty by failing to
come upon the battlefield, as charged
against him.
That he was not guilty of any military
crime In not having attacked, as charged.
That the 4.3O order of the 10Th was re-
ceived by him at too late an hour to have
been carried into effect
That by its terms it involved an attack
upon Jackson's right and rear, and this could
not have been done by him.
That throughout the Doth of August, 1862,
his conduct was that of faithful and zeal
GUS commander, discharging his duty dis
creetly and wisely, and so as best to serve
the interests of his government, and aid the
army OF which his troops were part.
Now, the question may be asked, how it
came about that a man who was so Jealous
in the performance of his duty, and, as we
allege. was SO faithful in its performance,
could have been convicted by this court
martial OF these otfenses. I was asked that
question last summer by an old lady, for
whom I have great respect, sitting upon the
piazza of the hotel. felt little perplexed to
know how to answer it. She asked ques-
ton further which relieved me of my diff
Guilty; how it happened, if they thought he
was guilty of this offence, that they did not
find that he should be shot. Well, said to
her, that that reminded me of what I had
once heard in reference to an Arkansas jury
who tried murder case; the evidence was
submitted, and the judge charged the jury,
who then went out to consult. They finally
came to the conclusion, and so found, that
the prisoner was guilty of murder in the
first degree, but with slight suspicion that
he was not the man, and therefore they did
not think he ought to be hung.
l rather think that is true in reference to
this petitioner; rather think the court
martial found Gen. Porter guilty of these
high military crimes just with slight sus-
picion that he was not the man. I think
that is the reason they did not sentence him
The truth is, they made several material
mistakes:
AS to Porter's location.
AS to retreat
AS to the presence of Longstreet.
AS to battle.
AS to time of delivery of 4:3O order.
Now the time has come, as we think, for
rectifying these mistakes. We think that,
after this long period of sixteen years, this
investigation can be conducted free from any
bias or prejudice that the circumstances un-
der which the trial took place and the int1u-
ences that were then operating, the infu-
ences that then made the minds of men in
famed, made them ready to receive extrava-
CANT statements, made them susceptible to
influences, to prejudice, to bias; influences
from which no man can be free under GER
tain circumstances, have passed away. We
know that when there is any great national
disaster in any part of the world, when there
IS q series of defeats to an army or navy,
there must always be some one upon whom
the popular feeling can turn, aud upon whom
the consequences of that disaster can be WIS.,
tied. And when the feelings of the people
are aroused, when one of those popular COM
motions sets in, it ramifes, and extends and
selzes upon all classes; then it is that it is
almost impossible for the Judgment of any
man, 1 care not how calm and deliberate he
is, L care not what his experience or integ-
rity may bet is almost impossible for the
human mind, frail as it is, to resist those in
fuences and look at question which in
wolves such issues, calmly, candidly, unbi-
ased and unprejudiced.
Now this record, as it seems to me, from
the beginning to the end and speak with
due respect for the court martial and it's
Judge advocate-it seems to me that this
record, from the beginning to the end, shows
the influences of which have been speaking
because while the results were produced in
the main by these stories of Gems. Mcdowell
and Pope, yet those stories had degree of
inconsistency and contradictory about them
which think if they had been anylyzed as
they can be now, it would have been seen
how unreliable and contradictory they were
But it was time when the minds of mon
did not weigh with the GOODNESS and deliber-
alton that t can be employed at a period six
teen years after the occurrence of the events.
The examination of the witnesses and the
opinion of the judge advocate evince the
deep gloom and distrust that had seized upon
the minds of those who we're conducting the
trial. Some phantom, not an exhibit in the
record, seems to have been constantly rising
before them to disturb their reasoning facul-
ties and unsettle their judgments. The
simplest truths we're ignored. The grossest
exaggerations and misstatements were be-
AAoYoA' AAo Juo5o auVOChtos WHICH, CdAloO
upon for an opinion, uttered lamentation
and pronounced a philippe.
NO ray OF clear sunlight could penetrate
the murky and dismal atmosphere in which
prejudice, distortion and exaggeration had
enYeloped the case.
Sound reasoning and even-handed Justice
were almost moral impossibilities under such
circumstances. Men are mortal. They are
sWayed by passion, by the excitement of the
hour, by the moral forces that press for the
time being upon themselves as part of q
nation. 1t is too much to expect of judge or
people that they should be lifted up into
that serene atmosphere where these earthly
influences cannot reach or affect them, when
their country is passing through the trials of
such a war.
And then the man who from his position,
or from accident or through malice, incurs
popular hatred, and becomes the suspected
author of misfortune and disaster, is hunted
down with such eager thirst and such blind
rage that even the strong arm of sovereign
power cannot always protect him from the
avenging spirit that seeks his destruction.
But, when the producing causes of these
disturbing elements have passed away, the
facts can be examined into calmly, carefully
and justly. Then the errors and injustice
of the past can be retrieved The man who
has been the unfortunate victim can be re-
stored to his good name and his rights.
You are called upon to review the proceed
ings of the court-martial in the aspect have
thus presented to you. If you should re-
verse their action, it involves no necessary