, 1879-02-01

ee"i1, "pld You ever know before thu. the Whole
s1aGlir
a.
iuat ";H Hot ~ uuost3e".r',nt y. J.. 30. ~
III Vs. n,arnn: W., a ,''t ~. h"a fo"nd an Il,
t1r tnk.ng ssa! laes' s 70 nses
coneloeshoie amount " GnnueJ. tnuusa"a1 & y!
aol.ass, PetHapa, tssInR ~ T.. oI I,,t enasn
| no figures OF estimate" .....-.
Tna remember wnat H. o'ssfepams;y "A "de ~
hctwcen Tue n'nnunf q Iees titopara IL, IeioItca ~
,esc .nsac yea.s ~ .n no sos.3,,, anT A' "Aa'
foa !onnu oo tlaa .c'uah! IGeeTeu s,. .,,,
naoc a,n ~ ~ :, my 'n'ho, ano "1""ys na'c ns''
hoont SI0,0U'
oEan ron tell the Committee "hetner 1r,a,
| ?lhVoo was maze Hp ot Icee esinso ue ,STGte9
IN sasss whi:h had been referred to Nr; ul6baEti
n". ~. tat.Mar yeat cs ~ ~ 'as Icy ~
n1 Wncihsr T. VIVA sfaas np o. ~! ICES easaeu -.
se'esea .'y nitn ss he9lstef' c'theF IN '"a' year
or n,f preceding ycart' , 49,,
~ IMPRESSION "hst ann - HoH, tnal ulat ~
amount wa received mud not reposaed.-tflas nc
naq fsf,s.N ie . .na. "ocn mofs ina" "e naa fe
por'H Iar -. .nr ao xo,, t.v. b.for.
you or fhIs question h1 thr amount u ices iIat
he ~ rr;e'sed during tlosv three teafs enE
efeti ~ nis report, and also upon toe "enstTue-
| t,on o. 1hr Ia"t'
| mcinter now-.erer11."
,.'I., nm' ,e 5ury reaolTS 10 lndtct H'ooa1u los
p'.IY pnY:,' sir. r.ar ,h. c,,.. =, orr ,r<,,on. 7
f,ru ~ w. S.,iI,Y Isa. tne aay-a nay Or W.
n1I. ,nn,,n ansnra ons 9us,ness, sns
| nt1a. % - "uI'o1 ~ hnu an inuiGtmeut' ~
yTr;ting II ~" ''I e"'1 ""c'"e1 - -
.Hs. ur p,,o. ....u. =. ~. .,,n. xo,,
pa'i" st,,I,,,,,, .,,Tt ,1soln',oni oI'. n.
!. .,n rI it.. .ut ~ gu,s frequently somst'%ys H
fu." ''"' ''' A''' ''''e'"''' VIC e@'e@ ''''
did nc, noT Intn1 s ste' M Tie re;ouslon "ai pasted
s.in,s ~ ~ M.. banGs!'
an Imi%t,n.nt J." Va, a. aogn as re haa iounu
Tia, III. was ,i,Tase,'. tos n'n; Sno" s
mcmbsr a,ou. , i'Ie'e'' Il :" ''o" o'"efs' ooo' re-
:. in en-, us t.,,,. ~.
nro."n, nt,o., 49," 'n H." msnr H1ana Jutate "rla
nranst iiith,rs -. '"se" 10 l,a al aape'"ent
:. th'n* tlcr', ~, ,.or'. pe'lnrs, iaa.!,.
rtrrn wa. no,,n ~ ~ III, .tI. htanf "ss 1osent.
wa. ~ r;st,,s no1e @ WIG Tpte!t aeast y. THINK
leet rvrcnt *. ,,., 49,, '1n~ ~ Ioss 70 'Is!I Ut
a I'M IN ,aM nctGTe Us a. to- Tue guy Of r hto
brr Win hro,,,hs n ,.rr ,tnv W.. nrnh ,ttn
.f,,dve nanps I, ,xs. s r.oi =, .n'aks p'ooas'f:
oycS mi fh,nG ,nn,t 81 49,. " ~, a.a ~, ,eao
1iud :irf,cn Hern. 80. w n 5",u.s .nn @ VIZ
of thr aw hst,r" ~, e., ~ W s Sa. y
III tSh r." oe'uss YOU soted 90 the snd1etmeatr'
outte nf.sn ssS,, r. I,,ds. so 'tE ~. ~
~ rs !; '''" es"e" "'e 'uoke 10 feao Inc u"
..
40 Tou remembcr whether fo told you yon
conlu or could not ind!ct Htboard under the law
nna lart.s"
ceat 3y t, hase soe trom n,p but we we THte ti
ban s!'ould be indicted, aud acted Eo.''
What lawyers had you had before Tou to
e1Se you opinions on tl!t requirements Of the
lay % r. to H.h!,a.d reoortin: his fsesa"
nnll' ihey were sworn u witnesses bc.
!ulc nIe JasF, ana JunTe HahEs asked
1. .'e., so'he question:. 5cmcmoef 2 re-
n'arK dudee lr'lnlbull mate. Judge
Bangs askea Judge lrhunu'' a1est'ofs,
ntiu nc tlect1n:a t" ansMcr II. 1t was relative TO
fnat i'o1nt; Aater Wait!rg tor moment. Judge
nanSs ma nc wotlta ss h,a & 10 ansrer % tA.f N
s 81 10 .a. ssc Att
lAa1 u what Is me mater VIII! me country
now caca mum constr'tIt'. the law Tor us own
convenience IN ihak'nC rcslorts hnd receiving
paT. lhosc arc pretty near tho Nosds-the
"a tl,at all tsc ads!cc YOU got rom JnaEc
lfumb9ll on stc 1acsiloh O. tne construction
OF this low. AMI tt'e rn'cs laid down VI tile su-
"About alI eau think OF now. 1'l,c Judge
statements w IND had. ! d. ilot remember
tl'etn now specially. ! Wns struck very much
"Dtu Judge Tr,'n'hul. WHEN on The stand,
conatrue flle law requiring IIlll'aFd 10 make re-
Turn. agrsesh'y 10 A'r. AtboaFd'a coastFnc'
| Ll4ut. =. ..
We thought That Judge Trnnbuli gave I'll
the law - nir read II. u agreed With mY no
tloD 0f thr law a. Aao featl II uc1ore ne came
III. He confirmed inc III mT Former opinion TINT
We should ith!set,"
TIE lid rot, thcu, eonstrue the 1aN ~ lib
bard dids'
~ think not"
"What construction did Judge Lawrence give
you'll"
~ cannot call now to mind ANYTHING that the
Judg. Instructed us In in rctattun to the law"
| "iuu l,atl this indlct.arnt prepared Ayuinst
Mr.. tlIhbard for perjury 10 making out these r..
turns of fees, earned ur received, ul,d your fore
ulan Endorsed It, and the District Attorney
signed II, and yt'u returned It Into courts"
'.Sn We could mt get u. Va ordered
Judge Bangs to draw tie Indictment, ~ In
other eases, un finished our business up 70 that,
u,,4 aljournca ffuul time to time, waiting on
that Indictment. l think We finished up or
THURSDAY evening, and had nothing on Friuas
but to receive tlInt indictment and mako 4 re-
turn 10 Court unl adjourn; but VIC couldn't get
Il either Friday morning or Frttiay night. We
met In 'c morning. ufd auIourned to meet at
our usual time, o'clock, Wc concluded taking
eydcnrc InArfday evening", ana No Here
5f1rn