The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1879-04-08
THE TRIAL OF DIR. TALMAGE.
THE pIFFNCF pEu.tNbING THE MONT
10 DISCRIDIT ONE WITNESS.


The Brooklyn prcsbytcry mot yesterday |
800. i, thr S,.ouI prrshvtprinn Church .
,n clinton street. at 7. NJ. nm hour earlier .
tn'n "''',.' ,..i.,i,ns h.,,veor thc Rnv los
iug tie pls'"I" 'i.''''' '"''" Wv ~ V"e'
DuD'n anI me .oSS.'l' 'N'.''u, y.e.iah
Church mat pr '"tl'" may "'''p' ,',o pus'or-
ne ol hr C'''r" '"''-' Ra''Un" Onurvn III
Boston Ih' T''''n III N"s "1'u w''n c'oseu
doors ana 'h' W. W ",sso''o ' ~
Duryea's r'l"li'HS WIN ''o oo.V, "',o "VIo
many cNi r.ssl 'hs o' ''E,'' an. " purSo'
VIII ahc.''u ~ o"'s '' ''0 MN" "Oi"' VI "'e
brethren
The doors were 'p."'u "' D l. VI '"r ,n' Iti"
oi Dr. IlW"E'' ul.' '"'l' WIS " ruSl ol .he /
throngt th"' l"'NoI 'l.' pl.t" '' INC 'hurch lor
seais Women pushed rapidly through the gallo |
ia, On ! t,.n i.L ,.,-l vrr ont has Ian ai fnll
10 -. No. ,..f. mi .,r,,.,,i.,I ,,,i,h ,, |
speed "'hE 'ilN "9.'S' "l" s'iu-E'ou WI" 'lo
obstacle presented 10y the old-fashioned pew
49, I, nvo minutes every sent i'm tbe house
u'O's .,, - ,., A. '..,''.,1.'i'
was hied. and. uliT tho Mod'ralor ORDERS,
ihe iapifors closed thc doors while hundreds of
s.,i.,.,,s ,,.,r, sian ., IA. o,tsidc
,rl. w,tornt,r NJ once ,ollel nm ,hs opcs,ion
vh,ther tho drfenee was To be nllowcd 10
-, d, ,,,o,..s lif, e., .bov. tis cnaroct,r il,
u"'''' ,'" "'9 D""' W. i"
the event OF lis Offering testimony against Dr.
Taimase. DR.. stoar of rcd the following:
R'.''"i l,iu T. :. 'nolt ,t iroluccd erd OMITTED
sI I l,,.. ,., ,i,. r,,- a. ,,Ii w ,,t
nl Jon. 81. na'i.,. ni..9 tn. accused Nr iilus.
permitted turr'Nr.i hc cnn ihat i be- dd ACCUSE Mr.
lisesHn, i'i'lyn n,.- ie dd not io 80 i1l.ei ~
wy, ,. AK ,..'f, ,,' A. f,,,,,,.s.,.., .. I, a. az,
ust asiisi .i,,st tne trutii "'"'' Nv -
"r,. ,,,,,, ,t.o 49,. -, ,,,, ,...,o,,,,,.,,, .,
..,in. So. .. -, -. .,.. n. r.t.,.,
-, ~. -, t,..,.''.' - -. ~,
no, speak tho truth when he dcniod that he hnd
done 81, II ho p,ade s,,oh a deniol or tho whole
a., t'ra =, ,,,,. -, ,rtis ,,,,., 1o,
not know beforehand what the proof will show.
All lthnt IL knovvs lofor,h,p1 d. ,his eoup, ~ tho
o., ''"' N"'"s " ""u' % ''''' N'"u' W ,'v
Indictment ana us plain duty Is 10 see TO that
DR.. Talmnge il tried under this count II tried
:, IN - r.. t. i..,,. 49,. -.
~ "'' anu .i"' 'i, 'N'V'"'c "'ull''eu II I'l'N"'
thereto; II this Prcshviery will give DIR. Tai
mage ne assurance thHt when he comes TO
MAKE ~ defence ne VIII no perml'tel To- Justify
We cohuuct hHegrd AGAINST him by showing
mat ne ala not IN ihQi conduct speak falsely.
out ulu spennk trnthlulyi promise you tha'
pose the slightest objection to any proper. proof
specln.huon. Mhen the tlme Tor the defence TO
snow us case comes. thny VIII present evidence
10 prove that Il Dr. ,Talmage accused Hath;
away as hlleged ne ,ild not do SO falsely. and
thAt II ne aiterwnrd denied that ne had falsely
accused MN ne spoke the truth. II you REJECT
ms resolnuon. you cut him on from all possi-
bllty OF ulsproQi. even II ne were as innocent
hs thh' hoy, hhrnlIessi ,WohueriuI man OF
uaallle,e, VINO never slnnel; n .,.,-
=
but was hot n accord WIN MN when, In re;
spohse 10 II butter question 1T, spear salu
thht ne coulu not Know ,whht dlshonest prac1
tees thoy would accuse Mr.; hathaway OF nntil
M w pto11i was oHereu. Ihen Dr, van Dyke
[ snenrs '" resointiHni "s al amendment 10 Df
tis understood that in adopting this resouton the
resS,kry arssei 70 allow the seeused to imIeneh ihe
srsetcS. when Dr. faimass Il ses ~ s "a INV, @
FUSED him wa" "''" D' i A'Ee' 70 nave A''
N. c.oo...oti ,ho, 4. .. .,..,i H.. .A,.
Ut; SPear said .na1 u was Supply ansurd %
Pit'9iint Aht AtAt't " An' ltltH't was
"o "'O"eN ~ p'oNe -"i' h"'n"""' eIouIpA-
Tho p,v Arthur croshv ,erad no,r,bov could
trnu S ,hara, ~ ~ ,iins ~ 'Yuig %
t1 w." H. i nr a gn,t =, ,, ., ",.vi 1 .c5
sss g sluls .Ip t uoi, m "a ss s' ,nrr,it
~ hv violent hissine from he rall"ry. NJ
maioy so sad 3 HAY T the hGdahS e1a in
very lew minutes cause the Presbytery 10 de-
ride ~ ~, Vriih closed doors ~
,,ni HIo salu r." s .ay ~ " mn ~ the
Ui,n"a Tbe d"fnce iid moi obi,,ct I" nny vii
rnss to meat ch arcs baipg bro1rbt aftrrward
5y ths nrasecution.
rms was tnen nllo"yV 10y EenSrui ass@,nI IN 1 70
Smear and DR.. Van Dyke Withdrew tR,c resolu.
,pn r"s nj aprend NM M '"S
I,d iss, on i M wS hn, ~
Tina,1.'s rourseI ma tbst H. should max il
In ~" '.s,'acitv ~ pr'sIvt.r ana r0t ~ n vi
M nass Va Th"n he went down TO The and said
-" Aftrr So many imnutetions sgainst ma /
never should rest without a thorough investl.
ye,ilr NH IL 4, 4. not doua hero II eLaU La
a"ne IN "a N civti r"urt court ana demand a
mii free and thoroTgh investigation OF my
absrae,ar 'hut ei,i@ "ia IN, ~ ri,,bt 20 In,
sch ,' pue s,I W. S ,o y bnor .U i Iho
Gitm',v ",ainst item II IL tlE - il simmer
Kesnn,i1 nc, tbr ,titness stani Mr. Uatbawov
les,in,I tIot vbsn h., retUTnai H. prcotiv1
from prinn.ton Coiioee in Dsnen,ber 1870 he
n,uccd atrsn,,a trnst mont on tba mar, ~ Ls oid
friends. On Monday following. that being New
War; Dav hs went ca lltny On his friends Ue
& onl iii iai ne WIZ III VI "a ~. ~
luuhu Nhit tu'Ir W.T. IuHpls Hhou1 ~ iorI.
thce 70 ils lnucutrdnfhs' tnnt IL was sdld thNt
he mad gone away and left his creditors in a
dshonOrable way He said before the scssio ion
lhat he owed from sitn 10 S0oO md ha chal.
lenged any man who owed lrss to stand up. He
denied that he had acted dishonorably. He had
lAb0rei gradually to decrease this indehted-
ness Notwithstanding the fact that the Taber-
nacla did not keep lis pledge 10 help him with
bic college expenses.
Q.-Do YOU know Of any dishonest practices
with which you have bcen charged? A.-No
sir; no ono Inns ever 10 my face charged me
with dishonest practices.
On the cross-rxnmination. conducted by Mr
Mnlard Mr Hathaway said that he did not
know to his own knowledge that DR.. Tamage
had ever said anything untruthful about him
lMr. Hathaway.
Q.-What is your age 2 A.-AccordinR 70 your
Psychology don't know. Ny mother told me
that was A.
,Q,-Did you not use your official pos ition with
he Th'crnHcle 10 obtain credit A.-No. sir.
Q--Could you have obtained credit except for
your Official position A.-That | cant tell
al my creditors were and are my friends, MS