, 1879-08-23
THE COURTS.
Suvdan Makes Another Effort to
Get Out.
Voso, Mixed Up in the Friedborg
Shooting, Il Luckier.
Record Of Judgments. Now. Suits, d.
rorccs Wanted, Etc.

ABRAHAM AurnAM
.atno up yesterday bcforc .1ulEu bfcA,lister.
euytam, II will bc remembered, Wns discharged
on one hal.cns coTuGH baActt on an indictment
for ner,lry. Then he WIS arrestGd on 4 charge
of otlu'tery, hut again discharged. After d faw
moments liberty, he was rcarreatedton another
warrant for obtntnirg money under falso pre-
teptes under regulation. A third petition for
habca. corpus was then !llcd, md the argument
and hearing m the anne licnril yesterday.
Tic SlertN malo a return TINT the prisoner
vas held un'lcr warrant bnsed on All 'ntlict-
mcnt for obtaining money undar false protonccs
10 Pennsylvania.
The answor OF Eurtlam denied that Ia wa4 the
san,o pcrson as the 9uYdntn named In the rcqul.
si,lon.
Tile Judge said ~ tho name was tho anne,
4hc presumption was In favor Of thc identity of
euytlsm With tho person wantad fn PennsYlva-
nfa. ..
Mr., Russell. 5uydam's attorney, thought there
wns no presumption, but II was question Of
fact. ..-.-
Tic Judge replied tl,nt tho burden Of proot
Nas on tho nrlsnncf. The rrlneipal question
rms whether Suvdam was u fugitive from
1usttec 10 support tho warrant.
Nr. Gibbs, one Of t',c attofneys for tho prose-
entton. said that 5uydnm was resident of New
Fork. -.. ....
ehJoaE' t'c" wv" '.e e'"''' ',''' ea'o '1ns
vas born tn West Virginia, md went To Now
York in 1874, anil voted thcro In 1sT0. lie frat
came here In 1916 for the purpose Of selling
como West Virginia. lan.1, but neYcr had any
fixed intention to STAY hero Mntt become citizen.
When he got through Ills business he went back
IN Nav York III tho sprt1lC OF 1878, lnl lived
.us ~ .'e" 49,. .t,oa
thtEe c'el S'"ee'
On cross.e1amsna.lon tile prisoner said ho
boarded In this city a part OF tho tinlc
and ,,vcd in Eur1ewood part Of tic
IT,. .nhna IN th,s s,,,, ia Iac,,no,1
t"'o ""I" ;" ''H Sls ~ ,-.
to state whether ne l'Yca win any woman hcfe
ae hts wife, because his ariewcr might tend TO
cony,ct him Of b,ra,ny, fIo never voted here,
.n,1 ncvar had INV tvc,, iutcntionn of establish
INV do.,,,'.1s har. Whom In Nav ynr, he 81,
waya lived with his wife.
sir. Rusar1i mada another effort to show tho
g,,v1ori, romcd l,, t1,,. rroufsition vas mn. tbc
van IN conr, ,or In ,hc o(},dnvtt ottohc, n ,hf
naa !" eourt' ioF II, "c al''u',e a.'uescu ~ ..'e
declaration It was stated that Inc safuatn Of thc
rcqusltton had hecn Iii Colorado, and his client
had not been In that State.
u.-d.. ,,,,n. ,o1,na ~, =, ,,rr,,,,ro,. ut.
Sntunt. n1s ,i i.u ~, ~ -" tn.,as", ~ !. no.n.
' l, n;uIp1 ), hn i,, H. r,nrndn
'ern.' ,,n' i1go ,tm,.ht ,Iat iii nj amonrt r.,
nnrthlne, for It only Showed Tie o parties after
1.a o.,Han, ,sn. NAV 'seA '''0'N''''A - W ""s'o
enIi1aa; i, TnJ. ., .,,,,, n, r. f..x., T., ..,,.,
4,nt ~: snvIon had cstn.,1,ehrd a ontr!i" nnrr
Ta Tu ,stnass ' aatd r hrca,ne arn,,nincd Stt,,
"n"Sss g! ,h Sa s,,tcr w ~ ,rh"n h XII
e,.as 1in,,, ~ M Wnhss, .vns d.inr ,rns
,e !rm. it w. % a.t ~ ro.,r.s"".. !" "a "a
I ~ ,r wv uh., ,,;r,s, ~. IL ~ a ,sifc s"i ,,ho
n ~" ,.t,,a I4nina., co'r, ~ hts nrsscc.
h .s ~ ~, ,.it, 1"rs,n, n.',od ~ " c;ttro
pho ''"D wa NfJs' -'N,' ''e "
mos 'gss ,,n,' " 1 o,' o''' a''' "A' "afposs" ~
I3' x tsi,tIitas tc.,too1 tt,,t h, bod l.nt,rn
Surdatn sinre Isis. and Ind rnoncd with lin
here, Suyllatu l,ntl lived with wotlan here rs
his vile. and had t9ld Witness he tutcnlca 10
STAY hcre md probably practice here.
Auydam WIS reeallcd to tay that he might
hnyc alnittcl to Phillips thMt he Intended to
mako bis .lol,icllc here hut, if he did 50, II was
only mere passint. ih.cninn, nlnl not ATTY liked
determination, Bnca September, 1877, when he
3eft hers.
Sir. Russell then bcEtlsl his nrEumcnt. lie
claimed sslvtlam was not ttGttlye fsoi Justice,
30 TINT ttlc wnrFhnt ronld nut be supported.
Moreover. 9nysia.s had been discharged on The
charge Tor which he was brought here, und could
not bc arrcatod llcr" again until he had hau iii
opportunity O 30 back ho'nc.
tfr. slcDatd followed 0ls behalf of the prose-
cuton. Tlu' statute wns conclusive ou the stub
5crt. which matte It incumbent on the Goyernur
uf lllin1Is to grant thr ruVuIatli0n when the
tiovcrnnr Of renntylvanla made rcqussition
Anr marty MS ilLlttSt 1rlln justice.
The lntsge eniti tic nnls qHeslon was whnther
fnYtlam bud q. .f1omlc!le hrro whrH Inc rtiuisi-
lion Of ,hc unvcrnor Of Pennsylvania was issue,,.
>. Mr. Mc11ai1 cunicnlcd hut eyrn II Suylam
had dn1,lvile In New York IN ISIS. he
bad siuce o!'tai,letl one 1lcrc IN 18Th nml 1871
n,ul the presumption nt law was ihnt his tlall-
Gle WA still heEc unless hc pruyeh ronciu.
siyc'y the contEnry. llls0w1l afatanlent was hit
eitnuesf In The face 1T contradictory evidence.
The judge safd the questions presented wern
entirely different from my case of the kind he
had hsntd bcfofe an he would tnke thu matter
under adYtsemcnt for the present.
TItE yoss CASE.
A..o,, M t,,. suvj.u, cnso ,r,e df.,o.,, IT
.hn hshc"s,rnrn rH.c ~ n"nrv Wots a. ua,tn;
nm. ri" rtf"n srenrn rntt,rr rrt,,rtun, f., t,o
a. hut, ,yos nssnrcd il wn,;d nnIr taEe n fa,x
n,,n,',.,s ". ~" ""'u'1 "o'''o '"'o ta"' ~"
Vas, nttorn,y modc stutcncp, y. ,,,c ,.sx,.
Yo.s mi ,,tttt.rs h.t} hc,t NJ ~ trtI St,nSia.,
1,Iyht wi,n,n Vnss nn,i nnn f;rumroort mi mi,
an Alteration. I,,t wsro s,parntcd md nrr"rJ
r. !. sct1in r. Il nStrr thc tf,"no ,xns .,vnr
II hrnsn IN Voss vent nwnw witi, snit.ra nm. and
twn o.hcr cfnI,an,ns. mi .tnrtr, n"ross t,,s.
uratrfo tu ayufi having nny truubte. rhry vern
1mct' hownyrr, by i,rn1,nrart n,ai n ron,.an,on
nna ,hr for,,,rr br,,nr, htriuni1,r otf iix rnmt
nuj yr.t mu.I hrurr,,,. ,hat Il" 'nnIi ,sit, nmv
onp In ti,o trowd. Vnss wYs selrrt,..I tn nnnnsa
hn, mn, ,1,t, ts1, butl :, rt,g ann t,,,nh,t t,t,i,