The Hawaiian gazette., 1879-11-12

cxzSs Il osSecsSal er an Azersosz HSrazl.
BIT Is ve have alTes3y sasa these Azerseaz
paxzs<-s d a< orz The SAa3rSeA Islands,
assthe- d thsr coz5-ol the gcvezzzzeas Of the
Kiayaoz-
Ar4s- TIE -@Co--s<Poaaeacs~ says @~Dr
: 2sckA7ssoz, wAo wSs sAs-s o. vssst, saw
Tl1zsssSc2 wAscA vss soaa h<Eoze the treaty
. ssr Sss.eaa. the SzssSvs3e3 AAis Il ~AseA
r-oapc%G asssz TIE treaty Sses.eee~ We
a3zz5s ,has = gA.zsssso7 sz tie ssssai q Maxi,
Tie CazrR<1l s Ts-s0G Es1zsassoSl TIE largest
and tess q sh,ese Ssl4ass changed A@zis >ho1s
sEe ySa-S =go. NJ, Ca-zVAs1 sos=e 0zs and
hss pazsasz Mr., Te-sos beoaaszg sSss r-VqzSe-
~ & sAe estate o1 Fayizs The zesirssg pAzsssz
Sse't ,sea, part casA and sAs hxs2aee oa zsozs-
gscss tGs n. Rschz7ss1S ssshsz so-cos u ssll
& h.e Ss5 ass k-sSr the s4cs<. sazzi The pl2ssa-
sSoz ali1SaS - hS5 hs<z e-Azac~3 IN vziue
wsshSz a F.s-sa3 q sss years hssose shs treaty
vrs1- MS oTx-zssoz. by sa< Fa;zs l4boz AID
skin a Aess-s Campbell 4-si T1ssoz. S2a a.
oztasy hy sAsz < ! large s42 q rao2Sy, 2n5
tA-1 soe> ~lshozs ReciT-oo5sv Treaty. Ths<
vas s5csssi ~ large a3asssoa< q sugar lands
sscz-ei hs leases Gu lops s<-za<. and sAe p1g-
cAssse q csbez LANDS whsoA s-lA-ss5 Tie &-sa
q The riaz=Ats0a 1log1 ssrss fold ovs- wAss II
VS. vbea ,be Sst.aas w&s paid. q ~hsch D-,
RSeAArizoz sreAks B1i this Is not al In @3-
6i-ioa u sAs Iao-s2se e ana. Nsss-s Campbell
s Tursr1 exE<a3e3 n the pazrcA2se Of sxv<a-
ssVe S1sz- zz2e1l1s-y. soc1S, sock and cher
appliances, xlrozi Ssea.aea. ard therefore. at
lie ti-e & shs p1Ve2.zss hy NJ. TSrsoz the
r-vq~-sy WIS vO-sA al Il sc15 fo-. FDr.
RScA2-iso1 kasv shs above fAo1s whs2 he
zS3s his vo15e-fEl <tzsszssai. be villf,lly
kegz tAsz t@,k 70 <ztsszvs his purposs. AID
L K GSs a1- know then. thea bs Is uaCss m
reliable so1rcs of izso-zzzsioz. 4ai hsacs lie
e-roz laso ~hscA the New Orleans Bee.' and
tie American Co-Te<poaie1os" have fxllsz,
sh-vzsa sAs v&zs q e22iO< q ignorance of
Dr- Rsc2arisoz
We eoass again froz tie zr1scle $ folloSs:
. TsS s5eoi q tie treaty has been 10 Eaks
9 tAs<e tEo dozen Hawaiian y70gzSe.ozs Al
@naa2l Fsessz. 0f 81 .gsaa.oea. he United
SAFES releases ;hs2 fro7 he p2yne1s of
Caster Ho1se dates rsprszszsiag larger
azezn; than tie vhale q lie 4-2o1-s os ihsir
= purchases frozz Shs United States. In @3ii-
. sia1 - his. ;he P-siscsioa q the Roa- NJ.
= Gitsua. Nezte- Cf Congress, has come true
= Uaie- The z1zs a Hawaiian SGsArs. more
~slEar Is Imported than the Islands proiace,
- Thai Tie prodoce-s'Of oshsr eo1asrses. O.
rAihe- masterpieces spectators, who calrr
. q ihls b1siz,ess by Ee4as q fr1riaIeas Gec-
lS-4-5ozs, gel the bensSs of the exemption
u lie shove ve answer. First thas The do
nestle exports fro2 the port of San Francisco
1loae u tbese isl4r,is II The ihres yeaTs since
ihe treaty went into ope-z.i0z, Amounts 10
81, 90, ,ezs, While the domestic experts frou
tie sane po-i 10 thase Islands II The three
yea-s before the treaty vszs into operation,
&ao1assd 70 The s1n a s, ,4sI. .sSs. thus shoE-
ing /. Increase q 6o@e<sic experts froz e1s
po-5 of the United S.@les N .hree years Of
Ss-zs0,I ,Iss. II TO This s &i6ei the ralzs Of
6o0=s5c experts froz Boston and New York
dIrec. 10 tbsss Islands, zni the zDouns paid
for -2ohs2sEy. steamers, schoooe-s, &c, Sc,
II The sane pz-ioi, tie statistics viii show
balance n fzyor of tie United States, which
5 s15cis1s zzsSve- 70 the assertion thai the
Cni1s3 S.z.es has Ez6e present of 81 l.oce,-
o99 pe- aaun 70 oo1pls do1za Of Hawaiian
pl2z-ers, II the rsnissio1 of Cvstol House
daiiz< O the article Of sugar And second,
Il svg The Hoa- Mr. Gibso1, Member of Con
gress, q &zy CHER bo1orshle member Of ihs
Uaitel States Coograss, predicted that sugars
no1 r4issi BY The planters of these islands are
tzo7shi into TIE United Slztes free Of duly as
Hawaiian sugars. We have oaIy TO say, thai
Mr.. Gitsoo 2ni tboss Who echo his pseiic-
E5aa II this respect. S-e false prophets, and as
se-z Al uniruth- his LATTER stsurdity We
hzre already exploded in former issues, and
shall Dot sicp row 20 re5ss-zts orr arguments
q that bad, L 1 50 supre1ely ridiculoas that
Il L waste q tine 10 toach Il At SILL Ii Vas
bo-u q the fsrTid inagin.tio1 Of soue wise
acre II New YORK City, wbsEs Il first saw the
light in the shape q lying dispatch to
Washington newspaper, sone Eoaihs sgo, snd
las teen fully answered by the San Fran
cisoo Merchant" well informed newspaper.
In answer 70 The lzst paragraph Of the zrti-
Gle 70 which we are replying ne have only TO
ssy, thai ~hsn the '.NsE Orleans Bee" and
tie American Co-respoaienoe, desire TO
speak ot the hzrdships Of The Raciprociiy
Treaty between tie United States and the Ha-
wziizn Kingdoa, IN the natter Of renting
CCsioa House duties On sugar, as being mimi
czl 70 the interests Of JOais;2nz sugar plant
ers. and disc1ininstion Sgzinst the latter in
fzvo- a The former, they should remember
thai the Louisiana sugar planters are n0t re-
gEirsa 70 pay duties On sales Of sugar in the
United States, and therefore, the charge does
III lie. q N ether words the paint i not veil
taken, and should be aband0uad once for al.
We oo0ozoi the foregoing remarks 70 the
@ADerican CorTapond@os" to whose co0duc-
tozz re look for fair and candid treatment OF
the mutual interests of the United States and
the Hawaiian Kingdom, in the discussion Of
al qusstiuns touching the workings Of the
Reciprocity Treaty.
We z-e fully aware that rivalry exists be-
tween certain persOas engzgsd in the sugar
refining business In SeE York and San Przn-
ciseo. With the coatrOversy besween these
rivals We profess to have 10 connection or
err--,s N s.a ---s-sz<s r. ----.L