, 1879-01-08


Mr.. narr.son-I yielded to my colleague for
4 moment, sad think be has taken It. do
not object 10 The letter being read.
1upuH nioDaErr's LETTER.
The Clerk read "A loltows:
D1arn,cT counr ~ rnx Ur,rrn sr:1rs.. NonrH-
ems Dt:rE'cr Or lts.tsots, THE hoX. II. y: flnn-
Strr, iunnr. CntcAno, Jan: 4. 1s78.-3hs Non.
h. III hen v,dsz ss'sS ,htSoss =; S. .se pHh
ett't j. coops Sss sn, shsdoo ia n
ss eass s e sep{ t. ss eas
e.ndae i"t =. 1ase he Gnea s.tes b"es
hs e. zach ehsr' sra b. See
fnewsase q sss .ptec @ ereunas upon Which,
tueh spp1teatIon is tonght to be mnde. am well
a*arc of tho doubtful propr'cty Of = Judge Sub.
dcem!ng Il necessary TO ask for an investigation,
and the danger Of ea!*b!,.,inR g1ea!onae.e rrcc:
w.h ~ Whe H. r.sao a
E'ade that hare been guilty Of 0ncnse jnat!fytna
Impeachment, anl - Important Y t that tne cnar.
picon. that, leaving ont Of view the pain inflicted
on ne by allowing TIE circulation ot sueh ramo's
o,s s ! w a to ~ IT, m
tidne officer on tho anblect. and solicit the most
thoroush aud searching inquiry In tho fa,rnets Of
oi Representative take such oraer ~ viii ens5ie
nnr efInfreR titonnsen 10 rrtat IN IN ernnrht fnF.
ward b. these Or anY other pcr4ons anu rigorousIy
'hxsst,Rate ss,aa.t tho same. Respecttnl,y rnnts:
H. Hurch.rd-A von, n,o,c atr snn.,,ar
and will not then further trtspass upon tho
time OF my colleague. l hope my colleague
will not object to tho uousc voting upon tho
question. which It almost, II not invariably, has
done, AZ to what committee IL will send this
snbIect to. Let The House vote, and insist
rat. sha.,os !. III, ..s, s,',. "e p.,ast., "
,,,t,,a -. ~ a. ,,.., a.sa',t.s Hssa..,ss -,
tho Mn,,..N ~. ronsa,t,.a" ~ ~ 1,,S,o;.... ~ r.
~. 49, m aa,,ss..a ~. ss.T -" 49,. 49,, 49,.
n,non1n,nnt oorx G.rap,hsia.. : hnne .ho
rfa,, ~ ,rl,i rssr,,, ra.a ~ ts ,s,a,, hv ~
uor.. .t.,t.. H.. ..,,,,n.. .h.i, ~ -.f...., -
a.,naa,a~ ~ 80 .',D 18TH % so.aa,,.,ss aa W.
Mr r1e,,t.eosf. anan,,or ~ ,o,,o.,,,
,vha h,. t,,., ..,,a h,, ~, ta. rctorraa ~ .,a
n.a..a,st;a. t,'ss.,o,, ,,a an..,.o, ~ ..t.tas
~, sh 80 tnw h.,.,ra ~. ,,it,.- s..a..
r.,....,.t.. ~. s,,ss ~ ,.,,.I,, n.'.,..s', ~
,,ro.ac+ III. ..ttt1n, ~, ~ ~ ..r,. Nn,.
e,.,a,s,, ~. ,,.n..,,o, =, =, shan +. .h.,,'a ~
a.as.a.., ~ .,,ornfo-. ,,f,,.a;, - rsa..., :.
-, ~ 49,. ~ ,ato,,sra,.a, ~ :. =. ,.,,.u...
th,t .ror,,1 -, ,,,n,o .r.min. i,t,, H. a,,o.
tion .nn see n do,n1 nv ,1nty n. n Tcnrc.snts. s :.
t,v. w,uId n-c.nnt ,i,o natI,,or - rtror ~.
rs.o,nt,on Thsr. II now hcfora I'm 11o",s
nr,tt,on that IN shr.c ,,osa W, signed hv ncsr,.
IN nf NV con.,itro1t, Amonn ,non, 49,
lrodinr vho,e.n,a merch,ot. t,rcst ,nanrfac.
tt,r.r. ,as;,tno i,,onhr-,non .,,d -,"t os,.t.
mcn ..sin1 th.t - .nccinl comntttoa h., ~.
no,nted 10 m to t,htcaoo md thcrc sot,*fv
nv constt,uont. th,t thle man stnp1. unr,ri,,.
i,o,oro I'm c,,,nmnn,tv A. II t,o has Inn. rro,,
thai M, uouso ,so,,1 t,tc the ,r,,,cr or,tcn f.,
H.. noI,a, Now ~ III tho n..t r,oli-,,a.-r
.~sm,n.t,a,. ~ III. t,,r1 t.u. 49, n.o.. ,.,sa,
hr .no 1n.,Ir,nrv r. cono,n;ttco' 90 Thc Con,,ni,too
~ r,,1..,irnt,o, ,ut1 ,tn nFfor. ~ ,hu war n
ro,trcrt ,ntrotnro;1 ro.ni,tjone ,,or. ~ ,,,,
p"'tu'eus "'o1.u ~ ;, es,'Ho'9 ,'"' "s'o ''4 t'.o
impeachncnt OF Mr. beikhap. 1t hah been al'
most universally tho case that through Commit
To-. ntb,, .hsn 4ha .1pt1ir,rrr conmittc, M,
80 80 vsas. .uau .no vae'.5 eou'es .,N .,'' NV
lac1d naFo peen ofoaRht 10 Inc notice OF THIS
House. Nov, sir. tho Committee OIL tho
:1udicfarv +. coronotra NJ icarn.I md
suoe'at5 c'npo7eu 1ea'nsu hno
honorable men. No man htru holds 1t In
lghef honnf .hnb nrsclf. hut. air. thrco
..e.- d. C....i..
the'nbcfs OF tnat committee src alfcaay on IN
t1ntrn r71tt i,n