, 1879-03-14
Liability Of Hotel-Keerers---suit
Against Potter Palmer.
Leasing the Ogdcn Ilouse.--A LaHser In
Search OF Damages.
Record Of Judgments, New Suits,
Divorces, Etc.

."I =. ,.s,,n .n1 '.''oh ',a eo"s'sieu
y" .o"es .aaag @ =. Msraa"s eonea spsng mr.
raneeu On analt or ro!ler maoe smallest IN i''r
%Ss ors,ea ID a1 at n 9 sp'G 1G1e, s'
ates'a. .'.a' WI, , s'elu .sau'y 70 .e article to
w sluee@eo. 1ne of'ss,a' ~, l'a'snt only maae
claims Tho grst clai,n was only for ro,,cr In
combination viii, wclI-kuown mechanical Dr.
v,cns ,vhI,o r., thc reI,.,,cs A,on,a. ,,ha w.,
,..'' ",n.s ., =" ~ 1setue'' WIG "an
been acaa fourteen years. was allowed
to claim an exclusive right OF any roller
for washing OF wrIDnlng machines coy-
nrcd Will, vnlenrizrd ruhbcr ,- auv ,t,a,
elastic .,,nst,nco ~, ,,o,vto,. 4, ,,,,,. =:
e'astle auns.aAes anpesf'ohe lo water IN eono''
adjusting the pressure, and the c1aim had been
sustained by judge Lowell, IA sIassach,,sc,,s
fir t)cfcnso wn.. ftrat wnnt nj novcl,v mi
secIn1 , ',cn,o, o n % ,nfr1nr'mcnt m "o'''''' ""o
Judge BtodEctt* attcr describing The patent at
rscat longs),, SAID that II the claims hoi, unt
bpen nnssea On by n Judge. he won,d do,,h,
t,,o;r s.,t,,t,v y. In hal u,yar. "o"n'
htnntton natcpt wns only ,nfrinvrJ hv In eI ,so
o.o1 =. a." ,np, ,"s,na,,a. ~ ,!e aee
could only claim those coniessedlr old parts IN
combination with The peculiar roller he claimed
l9 layc Invented hS ~ae 4.t nGs TIC first Inventor
e eda a3efi esaas "tn a e fotG a. n % or o
tlon of'infrlngcment, the dcfen1ants, iii their
n,achincs, used no sriEal springs, the lower
roller was Fixed, nnd tllc pressure was applied
ny tho ioot ot thG opcrator. Tllc Ole.
Mepts OF ad1ustab9lltY wtrc obtained
Nv an entirely different mccllnnistn
from tho eonlp'ninant'B machine. TIC Alicndcr
machine was automatic; Tue dctcn.lanta' was
not; Md the one was not the equivalent Of tlle
Tlln. bllI would therefore b. dismissed on the
ground TINT no Infringement Ind been shown.
IN TUG other ease 81 tic Bailey WringtnE-Sla
chtne Company Vs. .. R. Collins 1nti others the
patent for 4 washbcnch, on which wr!ngtng-
machine Wna H,0de to stand. and WAS part or
division Of the patcnt to Altcndsr for improved
rollers. The Judge sa!d tue allowance Of this
nllowlnE reissues. II It he sustained at oil 1t
must be strictly construed And the patent held
to cover only the precise kul OF bench shown
IN the plans aud sDecillcattona. But the de-
lenders, and on attcnpt' by the hitter to cover
any kind Of Il bench would not be allowed. The
bill would therefore bo d1sn,ibsed.
A AHorELrKEErkH's Lr4ntLirr,
Yesterday mor,llus bctufr judge i,loert,' In. IN.
y9ynS s the aty 51nrpl 81 M1 ar1t t. ss It,
lsine aruimst Potter PAIihcr. urouriet1r of IN.
Tuimnr n, rernvcr tt.mvti,Ir II snn,n 1i,,,no,ie
ami o,hcr nroporty al ,wi,ci, aim fih"o had l"co
rubbed while staytnr ht liz hotel, Ehs cntnc
hcr, In h,ist. MT. Il, ylsit n snn nn,i ~ rn'.
rrsrntinr ti,nt shr ,yaa ,infni,r n stny n IN.
hart,inp ratss and was dsl }rne ,,Iacr It lahIa
uccupicI Gy bpartlrra. T}Irn,, her stay at t ;hc
hntci h1ir,iur nnter,rl .hrr r.,o,n MI cnrria,J
on Rptne diamond earriutrs anfi nthrr nersnunI
recovered everything ustcu, her enrrintss ,,n,t n
i,onunt. md ale stctl .,n,ner tn rrrt,vcr ihs
vain, n t1rse nrt1rips Ginninr t,c wrs HnG,s M
ul, jnDkecpgr. A3r, Pa1t1Gr claimed lie was not
responsible, because. tR-t'le first place, shc lind
lnAGc special nrlnngqMrnt Will him for regi-
she was going to stay, but leaving lin to be-
lscvc u WIS to he considerable ttmct and hc
enye her spccial raics.s lte also alleged thnt he
was protected under tDe statute OF Illinois for
that j. was neither ssstal common, llur pr,s-
dent" for quest 10 rotatn lu altr room such
yaluablcs, Whon due NOTED was posted up IN her
room nrid all over s'sa'c hotel. us required
W law, Informing guests tnt Il safG WIS Kept
III the office for the purpose Of accommodating
guests III dcposltfng SAluablcs or money thar
they fn,Ght hafc. Sarh contract Tor hpcc!as
.., ~ "uo , d,. t, u.' nn"s s sat" 'nG
,an.nr.o1 Il ,,,t ,a - 49," ,n. I- a
and boar.1cr. i, ''9 "~~'~'
.,aro W Luz o,s' .a, sne u'a.. ~, vavu .'at
tuoro r"s M"s ~ @ s.esy ~ I uc'Su"mI ',t LIN
hnnr,,nr ff S as NJ r,i.r n NY .,,,..
th", roint,o Sa @ No 10 frrc a f. th fnH
"uont .'s "1sm ei'ttG WIS ~ eon.'ofetsy. actu
VIZ. "u.os ~ ~ ,,,tif ~ Ian W. " NY u!.s II tt
III w ~ Jns5 haune .i,a' 1,, ALE. Isskae
H.. ~ ,rnG ~, a"u sp.e.t aa asss
,ord ~ scSE nt NV not ,sa M,'.Hu ,,,. p 'efuf
.JiItjre l,Iolrttt. ut ,i'.. rnn,tisnn of IN. mr..
,iuisiltx, took III. cuse ut,dcr adyiscnct, say-
lng ho iud never llad Just s,lrl, cusc presented
lriors him ID thu present o.e, mud l,u wished to
ryail,iuu tic law on tho subject,
HEAVY .u1r ron pA,s.ors.
1,1,, 1...'a.,. s1.a ,nsa .,,,,..s'., j.,
,s;,iEss ~ navnua @ ~ unEaGs" yesieIu"x ~
a,A htnrA t.s emsG o.. otnar nasuuh ~. Vs. losn
Hlorai, ha!oi1.ntepc1; Tx ~ "Aleli tnG uansages
aro sa'd as slOo,o9g 1of ntceed assault asI INT
ssts. ~ seelns 1''a. nus'oei!, lawyer, nau
r",I" ,i", s,th.no,. ~ ~ IN, ~ Nur M,a.
ncfi tnatls somr REPRESENTATION ninut t,,eir re-.
Hucctiyu liens To d third nnrty In November.
1877, wl,,rN Moran inturpr:tud ilto nm attemnt
10 rcut HIN INT OF Ills money ntlll urrtin,. thu
LAWYER oi the strcrt. uttgn,,,te,l r., thrash lin
T,'e lccaI Ecntlcuap retortrd In isral wuy.
and t]c iury rutsrel plout j v'clock to dcciiu
huy ulurj, III Ind been l!utlaryu.
rur nnnvv vvr.rr
A. hn vu"ha u|s .s,"I'
!n .ns easo o. Gasetnosa " y. y. ogaeg
lLIlCTRs lllS bII1lE8 NGftuEI tltStl