, 1879-04-23
No 1NsANtTY THERE.

NO INSANITY THERE.
Mills shows The witncss tic "NcllEo' letter
at tho conclusion Of bis long clocuttouaEy c1cr-
else, atd asks:
I" Assuming TINT stAtcment Of facts to bc
true, will you iell tic Jury, Doctor, whether In
your optnton as a scientific man, on tho 10Th day
of last june, Peter E. 8tovcns this defendant, or
tho man referred to III this Hypothetical ssatc'
ment, vas SANG OF Insancl"
Trudc objects to the ,lse in fhe question OF
Stevens name, and oil that part Is subsequently,
stricken out.
Storrh objects on another score, "tn New
Yurk,'' hc says "tic Courts hold that the Qrrs.
tlun Of sanity OF insanity. cannot 10 addressed
to Witness. don't understand that tue co'i,',
a question, fe at liberty to assume hypothetical
case exactly the contrary Of TIC faets submitted
in evidence" ...-.-.., a..
"The witness usay oc examined on hyno.
In tho testimony, L hc has been present a,,s'
heard alt OF them The Jury nt last urc to deter
mine w'elter tic 1.ypotletical sase Is true or
not, asl whether, from oil tl laets ~ .,le case,
they believe tho man sane Or treano At the ttIna
Of tho killlng.n
storrs rui.s ia few authorities, and Weber
replies. ,.,. - saw, ~. c.,r, ..,s, -
iiowaTcr, is had better bo What was the mental
condition OF tho ,nan1 Think that is tho bet
ter foru, although do not sns tho othcr form
u sineotnpotghs ann. .,,,,t3,o ,.o rrcat,,r H.,
Doclos asks s alS' pti1 n yo,.r v onn"n ,aa NJ
~ acceu.a1po di,,, ~, ia vrnirr n III" soth
Of june, 1873, At The time II this homicide, Of
tlic man therein referred tot ..... .--
renas ssesa1iy te isyes. S's% aoedsa hSf ''' "'e
st'That Is all" says Mills, very much satisfied.
suow many cases Of treatment OF Insanity
hnve you ever had, Doctorf" asks storrs' Tor
, starter. .,,,, !, .,,o
Ihas "ou'" W p'o''s "1'0 :" W." - '''S
feH'y' < ,,n5,cdan
uW.lj. tlero arc 400 tn the asylum which
7ltitlh ,,.,.
"Whcn wns the first time 5ou eyer hearu luis
lonG qussa.2,h ans,. ae"r1 ,eau n rsod 1,cforc.n
mIIayo you discussed :hts subject with hfr,
| Mills before going on the Bta.,l!h
"Ycs sit; | had convcrsatlon WIN nlm."
| "Any1 you noS hoafo Luis 'e's ques''0" 'eau
! 10 g9ntt l., u. ,,,.nnt form 7ye hovc ,,oa Tim
subicct under Alscuestou.''
II want to usk you whether you think that
tic fact that the vile referred to hero sohoed M
any eiica tehas M ~ om ord, @ = ~, hynn rss
sno!eSt ..,1, u .a1 ''e'ta4 eo"13A'' - ~~ @'P~
thetlcal rartys'
mo CONF knoM ON, as T. muu9 ta a,oroc,or of
sf1ec W1s ~ ~ dsM n1innaf valid no to form anv
lsase httect W Enea.'a1. ~ .t, ~ an',,tin
p1ft ot yoat opI'.,p nartyi ~ " t' ''A'
oi u1e nJn9,t5nett.4 J,5 IL uaI ~, oo,1t,t,,,u
"it would as to ~ mora &c eonaitl9n. .'liI H.
sirposo II snou'o saIu "nt .',.a iscu s1 81
~ Clne,na.. IT,, H., sn1, ~ -; x, KY s,nn.s
proper strcet; tae SUMS o. lug oes. t pus'Ess
houacs IN the city were on ti,t strsst; thnt tils
general rcpusat 2. no st1sst VIZ I"u, ,,a Mmn
suppose NM ths nypHtMssMaa pIsay "a,, ~, nSs"s a
III tEe "ut!u stsaIa ~ t Ii1tS to+d ~ .'seo
street WIN anynoay; Mal S w"n.a ,cnu u e.,
move tfe 't'lplese'o" i WuGle ~ Eatnc'so "s ~
hls moral eonul!losl' "1a1I wv !. 'ut.
| NO, sis. y "oo'o"'' "a'a u's oaes'"s opo"
| Tue question:, a., -, H., u,,,,,,.to,, -,
| Low ~oulo INC nearhe o. tle Ieputatsun u
Race street 10 tlo hfss pace haVe any ocafi'e
on tho question: .-... .-..,.
"Race street may nave Good reputation, as
general reputation, aiM siMi might CONTAIN
some very ulsTepltab'e holes.
"Snpposc ihero was no proof that hc over
went Into disrcputab!o ho!c ~ ali, ana sup
poho TINT w ONLY ps9os 9. sIa ta, ma was IT, %
ness who unuertooh 10 aI1asm LUZ ., 70 .!'' a1Il
who was tic only one wso gver went t9 . dis-
reputable hole, then wouldn't that nodaiy your
opinion OF tue 1norn character oI lie parry hhd
attach It to the 'FitneaB n'lu hot TIC hSpothct-
tcal nnrtyt" .,,.,.u
Yes, sir, II that ~Qs IN tnu eS'aes'ce. n!
that a. Individual w1s called e tlln stht!d WHO
had lltnisei1 Tisteu otaleputao1o no'o. as you
rail- It, gu Race strcGt, mud flere waa no proof
whatever tlat tho h{pollctleal patLy Gstl VISIT
E$