, 1879-05-09
1.o,vinclne Reasons for His
he nccisiop on This Point.
saourea without Much Trouble
A' Course Of Quoation1ug.
uoutpIt Makes q Very Clear State
~ nent Of 1'hnt tho Prosecution
Will Show.
~ Mr.. Hoyne Begins Fills Ar
"' uument on Behalf OF the
Defense.

1,.or,JDt1Bo case On tue tWG nQtlou6 ~
he eas,. .ss inatc,mcnt IN bchnlf Of some OF tho
quisn u,, ~. snl 10 furnish bill OF particulars
dsteaa'..' I.h.r. ;1mleo Dyer yesterday morning
70 o.n. so.,,ion In TIC matter,
fsfe d" nvyun,11aso no7u MOTIONS,
do,uo demonstrating tl,at nthe
snd, 10 ~ ,,',a !, a. thc Indictment has been
newspaper article "s tno .,.".ss. n 49,
,r.tripcly termed, was "oF'h so'ne1nlne a'tef
~ .ud tint iIle gentleman VINO ure~ IL wasn't
w. As,.d{orly 49, fresh, not to say ycrdant, young
the eAeeso ~ IN. praylcartls at tho Iar
vquld make him out
After setting out the substance ot the mo-
49,. ,rt cnm ollr,0ntLng counsel on tho abio
Iohs' ~ H., yhict, thry had arg,1ed them, Judge
nsonef ~ -. witt" ia m, ,,ccm n necessary. in py-
Dyer ss'a ,.,ons ne u,I nv 10 m ycry far into ths
.nb,ert Of common law conspisacics. Tho
.a ln.r,o IN this easo was statutory one, thu
eneDso ~ hnIny nlon,r drawn under Ser. EI4C
!ads'men. o.ns n ena ha.c1 ,,non the riou.r RI,
Rey!bed alaI"tes' a''" oNse. np 49,. 49,,
e,rdlng couspsarlcs 10 ue'rauu ING QnHea
ss,,,c.. II was charged tint the defendants
s...,,,cd tn dcfraud tho United States IN
eon>p.'- hr f,,r,Ixhtnr .oor ston. for
ttyetli "a'e'A, ..,a, n"r,n,,t NV nnor s,ano
rood stone, al'd getting p"s ''cn' iot pool hlo'e
!. for rood: BY getting payment Tor unneccs-
..,r saving: by gottIng payment for
hbof mol pe'AosAeo, V
double payment loF hauilh9' ana by
obtaining payment for falso or oYer-tneasurc-
psO'e. ~, oro.c,totinn ,,y Mueller nnl tfilla Of
ah-lns p'ess .,'o a"r,,tvtnr NJ t,,oso elaine bv
jllko clallns, .uo W. "' y. @'AV'e ~3s'''o ~
buFling md I'LL, 7hlcn cla.Els VERY ior pay.
neRt for bad stone. UNNECESSARY @ Haml'R, laonr
ut,et peFloFGa, &C: amn Hsers ,,t t,s ,s,o %of ~
touplcts. and III ctrtceponaencc WIN u!e 9lic-
ebuon Of means. Win one e1ceptlon: a c1neo
eramlnatlon disclosed some iinperlecttons ~ tue
Indictment. but ny ques!io.l WIS, nasi y ue-
tect1yc IN materta! anu lata' respects; "oalt IL
hsreice.cd aa fntal and badt Whcrc On int!!ct,
Tue plaintiff OF tlle charge nsalfss MN aha WHAT
b. had to meet, II lad beeh ueeidca lint
The object ot thu pleading hau been
obtained. Tile glst OF tie arguments III SUPPORT
otthe motions seemed 70 20 LINZ Z, the oltcnscs
charged were not cfsthea persc. lne Coust pIo-
rreded to real home o. uc decislons ~ eotlspt-
ny csses at common law, atiI the aehnitlone OF
Conspiracy as lau oo"n ~ ac uese Gu1nut1s, ~ ',a
suass sa; o ,tis.c '.l,arHen In thts cnsa waa
y, .s, a''.,,mnn law ronsnirncy Init m alrvrI
.'.tn,orr % ntrcn.r WheiLer il was nnccssnrS tn
us'. sss e. oo ,"on. or not Il waa oonorrns ihnt
an mehs IT,, a ,sr srsc "s w.
.nm,tsn,e.. n~ was aniiicient. Taking tic whoio
~ H. s,iic3,nant t"oc,hr 4 uns nin"nd
~, ,herc ~ ~ was am anrecens m lie nart of nil
tI,.o jafan,,nnfs IN I1rfra1,1 the Tiniial Ntnrca
tss xosol .u,siaJ ~ txnra o nm"st,o ,sss
ha.sss w ss'I. III. ns not ~" ,,a~otton ~ nss
s s.o ,,,sinu1' ,ri,o,, th,s n..eo 10
1ua Dstao ta " nSr,,,1i,,, H. iS,tod ny
s.us s..,s w. s!to nH H ~ ~, .tat,1H ~ or.oc
Ees, .h spS'n ~ H., ,.",,,,s,t u - ns..
..a ". ,ot q m. i,,tnn ~ n,t ~
~ -. ro.sro,v v"o 10, roIar ~ r,.o,,,s
Naas. " ~ n,,,,s Wd,,t n,,,- jntn
saasr ..I son,'hoM y, ss, LaS' M mi"ohG toS Ilto
~, ~ us tst N nar ~ thc snIic,,n ,yhtrf tu'
,as.a ~ uat H. .a. pats ~ III s.. us,ens m.ei ~
Iuuee ~. 1ae eopep"at5 e4aoee p'opct ""e su4'l'
nsa'. .-.-.-......., .,-...-.,-.-
BUT THERE MAS 4 FURTHER ob1RcfloN,-
taat!t did not appear TINT any Of the overt nets
were criminal or unlawful. It had been rencat-
idly held, however, that nn act dono to carry
Into cf!ert a conspiracy need not necessarily be-,
u itseli, eyntnai anl ,ulawfu In Its character.
The language of the statute Itself would seem
10 answer tho objection: "That II
ny ouo or moro OF the parties
lhiE do apv net to cl{cctuatc the object Of tl,u
toreptracy,i' Acts which wcre n1leuci should
ks such acts as IL might he Hpcu wo1lll tc nntl1.
fally calculated to elect thu object al tilr nj
1etcd cousbfrncy. This very n,iuatlon Ind hcrr,
psspd 4pon by Judge Hio,lrett. WIN. unltmu
other tbnus mi saltl: Il 4 cf5ssnirney 81 ftseI1
4crinc, il docs mt. hnweyrr. hrT,,nn MIN.
4bable. unrss ANN ort IL ,'nne In fnrtIera,,rc
Of etfcctinr INV Of thc nnrnnses. nj tn, rf1,.
lplrtcr. Il ia 1iot nercssnrv tiaf Il sho,iid h.,
Ii and of usnIf n rrin,fnol niYrnar n mrv h.
10 entirclr jnnncrnt n"t' II r. IL t.onn IN f,r.
ue,aucc IT iii. tminwfui ronsnirnrv q T. s,S,,
- w. ai,AA"@ut ~oH9I"taGJ3 ~ ~ hthi