davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
Executors Notice.

Having qualified as the Executor of .. C.
Smith, deceased, his creditors are requested
to file their claims with me as soon as con-
vepient, and his debtors are requested TO
pay, ! wish 10 wind up the estate at the
earliest practicable time,
POLK g. JOHNSON.
Executor of o. c. Smith.
sept q, IS79-iw,
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
EStray Mule.

Takan M and posted Sept, ., 1879, by c.
n SIT h NV III dlyfl pistriet NJ, Of
Montgomery county, one a, dark az bay , hgrSs
i tsI No marks or brands. Valued
at tweil is1o 81 anu r, d. READ, Ranger.
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
BOOTS, SHOES,

etc. Of every class He will make to order,
or sell ready-nGde goods of his own make,
or supply a good custOm-made article from
the best Eastern manufacturers. All these
he offers at small margin of profit and
dettes competition if QUALITY AND
PRICE are considered
He has purchased this time very superior
of
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
Friday, October 3lst, 1879,

the following described tract of land in Dis
trict No, II of Montgomery county ESD
ACRES, more or less, bounded as follows !
Beginning at a black gum and pointers in
Nelson Browns line, running east 3l9 poles
to a black oak and pointers in Henry Croft
Zer's line thence south lo6 poles to a hickory
and pointers in Henry Crotzer's line; thence
2l9 poles to a poplar and pointers in lIelSon
Browns line thence l5G poles to the begin
ming.
Another tract of 1875 ACRES, more or
less, bounded as follows: Beginning at the
east line of the above tract at white oak
and pointers, running 81 poles east to James
Browns cOrner-a rock; thence south l37
poles with Browns line to a white oak and
pointer in Richard Browns line; thence
with said Browns line to a poplar and
pointer in Henry CrotZer'S line; thence
north l37 poles to the beginning.
Also one STEAM SAW MILL, includ-
ing boiler and the machinery of every kind
Herewith attached.
TERMS-One-third cash; balance on a
credit of one and two years with interest.
Notes with good security required and a
lien required.
POLK G. JOHNSON,
&. d NJ. and Commissioner.
Oct. II, lS79-tdS- prfSl0 90.
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
Saturday, October 1sth, 1s7s

the following ueSGribed property, known as
the Wisdom property; Begins at the SOUTH
west corner Of Il. W. MaOrae'S property on
the Port Royal turnpike, running thence
weStwardly with said pike about $40 feet TO
u stake at or near the Wisdom grove thence
southwardly 1000 feet ; thence eastwardly
about so feet 10 h. W. Macrae'S line; thence
with his said line about 1000 feet To the
beginning; containing about IL acres. This
land has been divided into five lots, three
OF which front on the pike, the other two
on n street that has been cut through the
premises. This land lies just outside of the
eorp9fatfHQ, plat Of which can be seen at
this once.
TERMs-One-fourth cash, balance on q
credit of 8, p Is and "a months. in equal
payments. Notes, With interest from date,
for deferred payments, and lien retained
r, D. MOSELEY, Clerk
BY c. II. Bailey, D, c.
Sept. 20, lS79-4tprfS 10 90.
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
To the Public.
r. @. Howell, Agt.,
BOOT And SHOE MAKER
CLARKSVILLE, TENN.

/ have on hand the very finest French
Calf and Morocco, and am prepared to make
when 1 say reduced prices l mean what |
say, and of n style superior to any ever made
in GAINESVILLE. Many thanks to all my old
favor me with their patronage. RepairIng
done neatly and substantially. Don't forget
the place, opposite ChaneeTy Building.
April 5, lS7a-ly
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
lake NOTICE..

/ have removed my place Of business from
First street TO my old residence, corner of
MAIN and SEVENTH streets where am
prepared 10 renovate Bugpies and Carriages
would have Il done. ] respectfully solicit
the patronage of my old friends and the
public. w, II. BRENGHURST, Sr.
march p, lS79-tf
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
Faculty and Courses Recognized.
Session 1s79-sO begins Sept. /, 1879.
IT E h MI =

TUITION Din advanced per annum, $50
INCIDENTAL FEE (in a,ivancel, per
PnnBf 20 20 e. 10. ,r,,,,,, - a., ,-,',.,.ls
except washing, payable monthly Ia ad
vance.
Especial attention given to English ana
practical courses.
Address the Chancellor for a copy OF the
Announcement" and for muller iniormn-
ton.
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
Boots! Boots!
John Rick,
~ Court House Block, Franklin St.,

having justretuFned from the Eastern cities
where he has selected first-claSS stock of
material and manufactured goods, is now
DPeDared to furnish
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
COAL! COAL!

Sc. Bernard Coal per car load, 10 cents pc.
bnshel.
81, Bernard Coal per wagon load, IL cents
per bushel.
Pittsburg Coal per car load, IS cents per
bushel
Plttsburg Coal per wagon load, 20 cents per
bushel
+. p. GRACEY a. BRO.
August 80, ls7s-tf.s
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
Monday, November Sd. 1879.

tract of lani in Montgomery county,
and bound "a as follows:
Regins at a dogwood ana runs cast 81 poles
to Hamlin's corners thence south TO Ham
Inns corner in Mrs, Pacand's line; thence
with said line 10 81 stake; thence north go
west lS5 poles 10 beginning, containing by
survey 73 acres, more or less.
Levied on as the property of Mat OvertOn
to satisfy a Judgment In favor of j. d. Neb-
lett, JAMES L. MOSELEY,
Oct. II, IST9-4tprfS8 90 Sheriff.
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
Monday, November Sd, 1879,
Sheriff. Sale of Real
Estate.
State of Tennessee Mont. County.
J.D. Neblett vs.. Mat Overton.

By virtue of wr.t Of vsnditioni exponas
to me directed, from tiIa Circuit Court of
Montgomery county. Teun., will $ II tothe
high st bid Ter, TO- ct;h, 4 The Codrt House
door in C1arkSVillc, Oa
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
Chancery Sale
OF
Two Tracts of Land
AND
Steam Saw Mill !!
Moses Smith VS.. Henry Frech.

Pursuant to a decree Ofthe Chancery Court,
at its July term, 1919, L will sell at public
auction, to the highest bidder, at the OFFICE
Door OF THE CLERK \ ND MASTER, on
Clarksville weekly chronicle. (Clarksville, Tenn.) 1873-1890, 1879-10-18
LadieEy Shoes
NOTICE /.
COUNTY COURT Sale.
Splendid Building Lots.
II. p. Wisdom ct ais. VS. Thos. w. Wisdom,
ct ais.

Pursuant TO decree in this cause at the
August Term, 1879, of the Montgomery
county Court, will sell at public auction to
the highest bidder, on the premises. on
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19
MoUNDsv1LLE.
The Preston County FIreIiuE-ThC Re
appointment OF Captain B~ridges-Thc
Safe Arrival OF KempIe.
NInnu..n.. Ali 10 tpsn

- ANsNVA SSAAtS "N AS
appointment OF Captain B~ridgeS-The
Safe Arrival OF KempIe.
MoUNDsvIlLE, April Is, 1879.
Correspondents Of the IntellIEcncer.
l stated in my last that our Circuit
Court had closed, but l find ] was mistak.
en-, for Judge Melvin has been with us q
good part of the week, SO far, attending
to chancery business. Our County Court is
also in session, and it might be said that a
joint session OF the two IS being held.
Our temperance meeting on Tuesday
night was addressed byJ I. Reed, Of your
city, who made a very acceptable speech.
The audience was q fair one, though not
SO large as it would have been had the eve
ming been favorable. Our next meeting
will be held on Tuesday evening OF next
week, at which time We expect as speaker
J. W. Thomas, Of Piedmont, W. Va, who
is represented to us US an earnest worker
and a good speaker.
From the appearance OF the weather
this morning we are now 10 have our Eas-
ter storm as we failed to have it ut the
proper time.
lsee q great deal in the papers concern
ing Elihu Gregg, the man who nine or ten
years ago, was convicted OF the crime Of
arson, and sentenced to be hanged. He is
generally spoken Of as q common criminal
SUCH US Preston Fire Bng' and other
epithets. Now 1t was my privilege to be
personally acquainted with Mr.. Gregg.
and my knowledge Of him led me to be-
lieye that he was then an intelligent, hon
orable and upright man, and one that
would scorn 10 do the act with which he
was charged. | may have been mistaken
in this, but / was so impressed that way
that | never have believed the old
man guilty, and hope that there may be
some way contrived that he may not SUI
fer the punishment prescribed. As a mat
ter OF course, | write this from the person.
q knowledge | had of the man years ago.
If he 10 guilty, justice should have its
course, and | suppose from present indica-
tons We will have Gregg as On inmate Of
our State Prison the remainder OF his nat
ural life.
The reappointment OF Major W. l..
Bridges as Superintendent OF the Peni-
tentiary, gives general satisfaction here rs
far as ! know. He is surely conducting
the affairs OF that institution in the very
best manner possible.
Yesterday We had the pleasure OF meet.
ing Jacob kemple, Esq, who has located
in our town and expects to follow his pro-
%iession. He has many friends in Marshall
county, and he will no doubt succeed in
getting. his share Of practice in our courts
Of justice.
Will. j. Mcconnell, the great temper
ance orator, commenced a series of meet
ings in Cameron on last Tuesday evening,
and we hear he is rousing up the people
to the Importance Of the great reform. He
can do it it any one can, and We wish him
great success.
The Reporter announces the safe arrival
of Mr.. Jacob Kemple and his purpose TO
make this city his future home. Y.
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19

Tnlmage and Hathaway Kiss and Make
Up, but Some OF the Counsel Don't Like
It-Moti0n to Dismiss the Hathaway
Specification Lost.
New York, April 17.-There was a grand
reconciliation in the Talmage trial to-day.
DR.. Talmage read a paper announcing
that his difficulty with Hathaway had
been cleared up; that he had never been
called a defaulter, and that he (Talmago)
declined to vindicatc his character at
Hathaway's expense. Mr.. Hathaway
read a similar paper.
Spear, Talmage's counsel, thanked God
that he had been spared the most painful
duty Of his life, that Of vindicating Tai
mage at Hathaway's expense. This was
glorious exhibit between the two
brethren.
Acrimonious debate followed. DR.. Van.
dyke insisted that the specification could
not be withdrawn simply because the de-
tendant and n witness had said that
they had no enmity.
DR.. spcar--This trouble was settled and
buried until the thing was exhumel.
These two men stand before the country
in an attitude that would stamp out n hun
dred ISLANDERS. [%Applause.1
Mr.. Talmage-Mr. Moderator. | wish nj
this point, before matters 90 any further
to offer Brother Hathaway the right hand
Of fellowship. We settled this matter Inst
night, and there is no power on earth that
shall stopit.
a loud applause followed, during which
Talmage marched dramatically down the
aisle and extended his hand to Mr.. Hatha-
way, When he returned to his seat Mr.,
Crosby urged the Presbytery not to take
any hasty action under the wave of ex-
cited feeling which had arisen. "IVhcn
the feelings have died away" he said,
stern facts will remain in your minds and
in the mind Of the public. It Is not a per-
sonal difficulty between these two mon
that we are considering. DR.. Talmave IA
not charged with slandering Mr.. Hatha.
way, but with falsehood, and that cannot
he put down by a personal settlement II
Mr.. hathaway, DR.. Vandyke and Mr..
Pearson testified to facts, the fourth speci.
tication has been sustained
DR.. Speer-If all wrongs which have
been buried and forgotten can be revived
and made matters q judicial investigation,
you would want the Presbyteryto be IN
session throughout eternity. Laughter
Mr.: Hathaway's motion to dismiss the
specification referring to this matter paye
rlse 70 a long debate, and was finally lost
by the close vote Of 15t to 49,, N
DR.. Talmage then claimed the right to
vote. In order to make It a tie, and Dr,
Nandyke commended that the defendant
had no such right.
Mr.. Millard said that this remark would
have sounded better from any other mem.
Der. Whereupon Mr.. Vandyke SHARPLY
retorted that he would take no such re-
buke from Mr.. Millard. The motion 10
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19

-Four years ago capital punishment was
abolished in Switzerland. Coincident
with this action came an increase in the
number Of crimes Of violence, and cspe.
cially of murder. To such dimensions has
this condition Of affairs attained that peti.
tons signed by over thirty thousand per.
sons, praying for the ~rcintroduction Of
capital punishment, have been presented
to the Federal Council. That body. how.
ever, after a series of deliberations cover.
ing a period oil six months, have arrived
at the conclusion that the statistics OF four
years do not give sufficient data upon
which to form a definite conclusion. To
show that Switzerland is not the only
country in which violent crimes are on the
increase, they have looked up the statistics
OF other European countries in which
murder is punishable by death, and pre-.
sent some interesting figures. In Eng.
land there were % executions in 1877,
against 4 in 1871. In Belgium there
were 90 in 1871 and 02 in 1877. In
France there were,Sl in both years. The
yearls72, however, when tho Communists
held sway, was an abnormal n in the
history OF French crime. In Austria, Ita.
.ly, Germany aud Denmark also the crime
of murder has obtained a terrible impetus
otpropression, much Of which, in the opin.
ion Of the couaCll, is due to tho increase
OF misery, an increased love Of pleasure,
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19

THE business men OF New Orleans are
dissatisfied with the city's Board OF Health
and its policy Of quarantine. They be.
lieve in making the city as sweet and clean
as possible, and then quaranining vessels
from infected ports for five days. This
would not seriously interfere with the
city's commerce, and would materially re-
duce the chances Of an epidemic. But the
Board otiIealth accept the opposite theory
that yellow fever Is alwaysimported, and
that local cleanliness Is OF little avail ia
keep out the contagion. They rely upon
a rigid quarantine, and have got Gov
Nichols to practically close the port for
six months by an order OBTAINING vesselt
from the West Indies and that quarter fol
20 days. DR.. Chopin, the President o.
the Board, has also retained DR.. Caring
ton as the quarantine physician, though II
is the general impression that he does mol
know a case Of yellow fever when he sees
It. Moreover, DR.. Darlington let in the
vessel last season which DR.. Chopin
thinks imported the fever. The truth o.
the matter Is that New orleansrealizes thai
this quarantine is going to seriously Grip
pie her commercial importance, and heI
merchants evidently consider that almost
as serious an alternative as yellow feveI
itself.
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19

and a spread OF intemperanCc. Finding,
therefore, that other countries in which
the scafFold and the guillotlne are recos-
nized institutions are no better OF than
Switzerland, the Council see no reason for
a returnto the old order Of things, and OPP
pose any repeal or modification Of the
present law. Thus, for a time at least
Swiss murderers will be protected from
the just penalty OF their crimes.
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19

WHAT arc the boundary lines Of the
clover middle class" in England, and in
"Pinaiore% A writer in the Pal Mall
Ga.ets throws some light on the subject;
"IIaving accidentally been prompted to
inquiries, | came to the conclusion that an
appreciable proportion Of women in the
lower middle class had at some time OIL
their lives been TO fortune tellers In
squalid streets to have their fortunes told.
more than half believing in their prophetic
powers. When | speak OF the lower mid
die class | mean to go as high as persons
who have been to boarding schools"
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19
Cos, or FOOD Now and rnen.

We find the following in an exchange:
Here Is a table Of comparison running
back to the year 1900 which gives a fair
idea Of tho various rates Of wases-oi the
agricultural laborers and the prices Of
wheat in the larger portion Of the farming
region Of England, together with the mum
Der Of days work required to purchase q
bushel Of wheat:
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19

With the exception Of the commence
ment OF the present century, when tho
wars with France had their effect in in.
creasing the price Of wheat, it will be seen
that there has been o constantly increas.
ing power in the weekly wages Of On ag.
riCultural laborer In England to purchase
the staff Of life. While this is true OF the
agricultural laborei, 1t Is admitted that the
advance in wages Of other classes has been
still mere rapid.
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19
Wsussal Natsr~e..
SEALED PROPOSALS
ctERx's orytcE BOAlDovc

CtRRx's oFVicE BOARDOV CouvDo,,.
WHEELING, ApHl is, IN
belIsd Proposals. will be rpcelved, At M, 4A
coSnt ~ ~ ~ o,sioek noon, for the ~EolGSisS ~
pd sa5s = Division "GreVpsVllls, Clutoa ,.A
Mp1.s-TS9 S9ple yAfdT Of nlCaIImidSS' f
taseT h9Ad,' IRON Glenu'I Hun "a A,Ah
second Division, $50 cubic ylrJS y eao1Oat
seeond el1S, and 500 cubic yards nm S,uss alsa1
"hAfer koad," iron city 70 Glenn, W. ~ ~
mixing. SuVe !ih hlaA
valley Grove aud Middle wh,sllD, r,,,.
IIST sSoiS yards eulVsrt masonry I'D IN ~,
second Division "WheelIar, West IIh-,,.n
Wy Ipfnptke," near brooke coupty In !SSH
yards tnaeadamiIIng. "1%0S
HMet Union and Roney't Point Rs,a - -,
nI 6asal wheeling ceeI,-SO cubic yards ~
Peninsula Road" extension tbrou,A y,A. .
sSeis ARDS eulvert masonry, 500 Guide ND M,
* s,,hiS !StaA sandstone paving, hIOa.ElI N
nuleadamiAnR. IEaa
ELM Grove Road" Caldwell, Rus,Lmu.
yards excavation and 30 rubie Jard, C1I,,1 -,
merchandising 10 consist Of The bal Sva.BI Y;
Limestone, broken TO \ S.i1Gh gauge. "
btl9ee ADD eulVort masonry 70 b hid dr..
Elipg VIII be measured Ia t1c1vGtIsa i'm ,la
Hds mnst BE- BY the cubic yard 10. u.s4,b,
neSsons paving earth, loose neE, OLD Nd n
and clearing.
specified above,
The quantities above given AT apsroIlnr, ri
liable % change upon GnSi location,
The Board Of Commissioner rSSer,, II, ~ I.
reject any Or all bids.
". G. SAITH, Engineer. ' ~
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19

allow no more testimony in regard to the
Hathaway specifications was also lost.
Just at the close Of day the Moderator
threatened to retire from the chair, and
DR.. Vandyke gave notice that be would
move to-day TO sit with closed doors. This
caused DR.. Spear 10 remark that the trial
was In danger Of ending in a terrible
iarce.w
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19

SINCE the commencement Of the present
year European immigration to this country
has been steadily increasing. The arrivals
at New York are larger now than formany
years, and the lists at Philadelphia and
Boston show the same tendency. The
condition OF things in many foreign coun-
tries Is such as to make America appear a
more desirable haven than Mt any time
since 1873. The social and political agita.
ton in Germany and Russia and the bust.
ness depression in Great Britain cause.-the
eyes OF thousands in those lands to turn
with longing to the Western world,
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19


FIGURES crop up occasionally to show
the tremendous price we pay for our M.
tional government. Mr. .Gorhaln, who
vas lately the Secretary OF the United
States Senate, has presented the expense
account Of that body for the eight months
ending on the 4th Of March last. 1t ex.
hibits the fact that the senate's expenses
for, The period named aggregated s6S2, $3.50
without counting the odd cents-a rate
ofabout a million dollars annually. Some
OF the items Of the account amount to
evidence that Senators can be excessively
free with the peoples money. Their sta
tionery cost athousand dollars per month,
and new furniture and repairing absorbed
over eight thousand. The Teller Commit.
tee, appointed under Blaine's resolution,
used up eighteen thousand dollars; and
the committee to ~reorganize the army,
which framed a bill that never had the
slightest chance OF passing, took between
five and six thousand. The salaries OF the
officers OIL the Senate and the committee
clerks reached the snug sum OF a hundred
and fifty : five thousand dollars. This
would give a two.thOusand dollar clerk to
each of the Senators, and leave some
money over. The extravaganza, however,
that existed when the Republicans were
in power has been added to now that the
Democrats have their swing. They have
made the legislative bill OF this year some
fourteen thousand dollars heavier for the
expenses of Congress than 1t ever was no.
fore, and yet it is a matter OF easy remom-
brancc that they prOfeSscd economy in its
most recent campaigns.
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19
Srsssal Nnassss.
"a Rn

To ali who arc suffering from the errors and indls
c%TetIonS Of youth, nervous weakness, early decay, los
Of manhood, &C., l will send a recipe that will cure
you, FREE OF CHARGE. This great remedy va.
discovered by a missionary In South America. Send
a seli-Rddrensed envelope TO the REV. JosxPH T., L.
NAN, Sdiion D, Nep York Guy.
dAi1LTfhlkw
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19
SATURDAY MORNING, APRIL 10, 1879.

A coon old lady desires attention called
to the efficacy Of brewers yeast as gargle
in cases Of diphtherla and scarlet fever.
She prOnOunces 1t better. than potash or
any substitute.
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19
DIED.

KIGER.-On Friday, April IS, 1870, a. X o'clock
p. NJ, FERDINAND DE- SorA, son Of John I. and Isabel
Kiger, aged 0 years, l month and IS days
Funeral from the residence Of his parents, No. a
corner Wood and Forty.aEst streets, at 1880 O'Clock
Sunday. Friends Of the family are invited TO attend.
Intermentat old Catholic Cemetery.
The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1879-04-19

On the occasion Of his induction into the
French Academy, on the Sd Inst. NJ. Renau
delivered the usual address. His subject
was liberation. The crowning glory OF
the French Academy, he said, is tolera.
ton; all other French institutions have
been intolerant, and have persisted.
within these walls every political, phil
osophic, religious and literary opinion,
every different view OF life, nc matter how
conflicting, talent and merit OF every kind,
nature and description, are represented
on a footing Of perfect equality" "Is
there a man now living" he continued,
that does not recognize the fact that Gal.
ileo, D~escartes, Newton, Lavoisier, La.
place have changed the basis Of human
thought by totally modifying the ideas
previously existing a to the universe and
the laws that regulate it; by substituting
for the childish fancies of non.scientiRc
ages the notion of that eternal order where.
in caprice and private volition have no
share? Have these great men dwarfed
the universe, as some persons believer
For my part hold u contrary opinion