Arizona silver belt., 1879-08-22
'FerrttorS of rszanA ys. Jehn kt. tsab-
 bous-. berxe A nrAer

of tae testImony, although very vol umia0us, had ve the space, there fore are eonsrainea 0 gee brief summary of the most important part of it
 A. , Bilderback testified that while working on top of 5 bnilding at the pinal Brewery. in the lower end of Globe his attention was call ed toward the roadi, saw O'Neil ahead and the other man ride around in front and come back faelng O'Nen when .hey commenced pulling at each other and striking. Buth wsze on their horses, saw 0'liSeil try ing to pull thls man from bis horse, 0'Nea then jumped to the ground. eaughe this maa by the right arm. aud again tried to pull him from bis hpse, but the man broke loose from him, leaned back in his saddle, drew a pistol and shot 0'NeiI 0'Neil then lodged under his horses neck and ran out the length of the rope, turned and faced this man. He stood there one-half minute, wheR tllis man said .Take that God damn you 1" and then O'Neil feIl, as he was falling this man turned and rlie of, driving some loose atock l was the first to reach the place. caught 0'Neil by the shoulder and turned him over on bis side. He vas breathing a little, breathed two or three times. Did not examine the body, ssw no weapons on his per son
 CROSS EXAMINATION
 The exact q stance from where | was. to tue place where the shooting took place. IS 155 steps. Whsn l first sas O'Nen he vas in front. Do not know the man. never saw him before that I recollect of. Do not know that l would recognize bim. Do not think I would know him. Do not know what transpired between che parties before 0'Neil passed this man in front. Did not hear them speak. only what this man said. 0'Neil jumped from the left aide of his horse and came near pulling this man off. The man broke loose, leaa- cd back in his saddle, pulled 3 pis- toi from his pocket and shot O'Neil O'Neil could have had arms on and ] not have seen them. The mans horse did not jump and run around when he shot, but moved back step or two. Will swear positively that the man made che remark, "take that now. will you, God damn you. ? O'NeH was falling as the man rode of in q lope. O'Neil was not pulled from his horse, but jumped of.
 J. ". Read testified that about five o'clock in the afternoon of the 18th of August, he saw Mr. Gibbons going past his house driving some loose animals and very soon after, saw 0'Neil coming by also, rid ing quite fiat, both passed out of sight Directly afterwards heard 8 shot, rose to my feet. saw 0'Neil stagger and fall, then walked across to where be was. He appeared to be hfeless. Did not examine the body, saw no weapons on his person.
 CROSS EXAMINATION.
 l arose to my feet es soon as l heard the shot, saw O'Neil stagger ing Did not see Gibbons at this time, the first time saw nm he was riding by ny Aoase, the next time he was riding down the road about 50 yards from where 0'Neil WIS. Did not hear him say anything Did aot hear q word. Could not see Gibbons from where Has when saw O'Neh staggering. IL is about 70 yards from my house to where O'Neil fell. Do not know Tho shot 0'Neil.
 Frank Bissig being sworn says 1 was working on building at the Plnal Brewery when my atssution vas called to 8 fight. l looked toward the road at the same tilae Q shot went of, there were two men oyer fhora ssso ore hnra-ha..k and tka of1.