The sun., 1879-02-08

NN lhhhs bcc D.
VI @ ,, snni impo',ai, in oncc he concert conrr. and
hotter u trust Nru can done time him divided nct
on, Bolivia with and consult here. iNo siguaturol
discussion WIS here. raised ns to this de-
snatch and Mi Marble finally said:
~ may set thi- right hy stating that never got
nd.spaich which. as the Ifinutc euys. had four
words out makug II unntolicihlc. i got no
dcsm'ch oi that Kind. This stems to be- a copy
O. -. CT which lls boon rcld.'
Mr. iiiscork-My UNDERSTANDING Is that Nos
60 and ca arc th" saWc thing.
Tho tnrirman-lhe are not identical: Go
has four words irit out.
Mr Narhio-Ihgt is part Of tho ingenious
relation ~ thc Tribune. / know perfectly well
received NO unutriigible despatch that my
keys would NJ; tefiphrr. II is quite possible
thpt this may huyc been a hlundcr cOrrcc,rd
before tie dospn,cn reached me. suppose that
INV No. What have you to say to that?
Telegram as tollowsl
~ r,iss. l., sam,r-g rart Nee I;'f '''
iniehsihlc. M,NfoN MARriE.
A.-Nr woolloy brought me despatch which
was uninicigin to him. and asked me II |
could read it by my cipher. /: was unntelligi-
bic g. me, and IN order TO accommodate him |
telcgraphed 20 Col. l"lton 20 have the message
repeated In my cipher and that is his despatch.
o lEy Mr.. Eocdl-Thcrc is no mention made
ofMoolev In that dcspatehY A-NO sir; spain
was tho signature Of Col. pcitons dcspatch
which Mr.. Wooiley had brought to me TO have
Mr Rced-IIe has already testified that spnin
was Potion. Surely he didn't send a despatch
u. lBY the tnhifmNnl- l--1 I on knew NJ the time
you sent this despatch that spain WIS Mr. Pol
ton? Al think SO.
Q.-Whon YOU sent this despatch. which hns
been read. % was With un order 70 repent tho
message to You in your cipher? At was not
10 repent The ncssaEe % me, hut % another
Mr. Reel-Mf. Noonry's name WIS not IN tho
despatch There is nothing said about his mes
q ,iy the Chairman Did you over receive
No Number 60 did not; CT distinctly re-
memnsr. Imam, ,,,,.
n rcmurk WIFI regard o. that despatch. II am
permitted. II r perfectly obvious from this do
srt.u a- w..u az from other DISPATCHES. both
from mr to Nuolcy and from Noolicy 10 me.
thnt tlis despatch could not have been sent by
me W. bad u' eonversation nor cooperation
Whatever aud such Is the fact simply want
10 call attention tp it, and il it (. obvious and
the despat % itself is conclusive evidence.
REFUSING 10 ACT WITH MR. wooLLEY.
..Q.-Now le ns when YOU sot this despatch.
No. "a. what dii YOU do
iTt.cs.am ana translation as follows:l
NFw YouK Dec 4
tstcr ira., ," ,e1e ,er, NO WsT.aw ran ry dome e
tmg hn diyiicd act only BOLIVIA with ant consult here
80 signature
Telegram here P-of,,.t.nn acecp'c b. done only once
rrcr cor,nt Win wdolcy ana AT in conccrt Yon can
uu.thm Tine very important and there should be no
Al ! q nothing except 10 throw It in the fire.
Q.-pd you not attempt % carry out the in
strurtions OF this telegram AIN no respect
Q'-You took no action in regard to the promo
eiuons which were tclegruph"d after getting
.Q.-Did you talk with Dyke about Il? Al
did not; l never mentioned It TO human being.
Q.-Do YOU know whether anything WIS done
by others in relation to tin regard 10 carrying
out tho proposition which was made 10 you 2
Alan quite certain that nothing could have
been done. Intercepted the proposition and
destroyed the despatch, and never communi-
Gated 1 e any human being
.. tBy Mr.. needl-What do YOU moan by " in
terppTteNf' How could lufprpppf do
spatcn addressed to yourself; A.-Oh. YOU may
aulbhle about words as much ns You please
Mr. Springer suggested that the witness was
In the habit Of receiving dcSpatH hes for others
and Mr.. Reed sarchstically thanked him for
q, tDy the Chairman Did you make any re-
Ply 70 this telegram. No "a. Mr.. Marblef A
.Q.--The matter dropped at that point? A
Precisely so.
Q,-Nothinc was done or said' Al have
enid nothing 20 any human being about II up 10
this moment that nm now spenking.
Mr. springer read from IN" Iifbnne pamphlet
rushed out referring 10 Mr Marbles nilceei
action when he got one Of these des patches. and
continued as follows:
down there, Did you rush out. and into what
did You rush A.-No. siri think the despatch
went into the IRE or III q cigar which smoked
all went 10 bed. That was the fact precisely.
Mr. Hiscock-Nou didn't forget your deyo-
tions. did you? A.-Oh, no.
TIRE SADDLE BLACKSTONE" DESPATCH.
R-NhW lNilh ~ NO tus INEf II A.-lnNL . Is
not nay handwriting: that is my despatch |
want 20 state that sent il. 1t must be subsian-
Tia .y ac urate.
Telegram and translation as fo!lowsl
mo- rei-r. IS Gramer-v rri. Y !
tIiy yo.cs Lastnlght FoS iouud me- ana .aid he lad
nnhins which knew already. Tell Russia saddle
p-..,. ,.,., 'rrsnsapon .,..-.--.
wonsb.ly as Mo.es' Last mshi Wooiicy found me
~ .aii hc bad nothing, which knew already. Tell
n i a H
Q.-What ia your explanation OF that? A.
IN he first pltre. should like 10 observe that
ne Ilhune, IN printing that despatch on the
sth - Ofohcr prluted II as II there We're no
dolm Hh'ut Tint translation, Buttheirtrnns la
uou D, wrong; for, upon calling your attention
70 u. You w. u see that they print my despatch in
the .siual as IL their translation were indis-
They ggye ID as though IL were in cipher II ia
the bass of their whole accusation. They
guess and they make wrong case and the
tuosianr' of ihe charges against him Is founded
upon TINT wrong guess. In the Tribune cipher
extra, see they continue the false representa-
ton. ana thoy continue their ruh-a-dub over
WI business, anu they nnniy print mo original,
and IAN 70 put the translation. after having
ma thelr guess without disclosing that 1t was
Aguess.
Mr., Hiscock-Do you moan that the charges
are All oased On despatch No. Giy
Mr. k'"t-l think there are some other de-
sphtehos besides Ga. upon which tho Tribune
Q. y'he airmanl-Can YOU translate the
lhcorrri dr-pni' u and give the equivalent
could hut am perfectly sure that their trans
bllnn Is inarcurate. Laughter by Mr.. Rsei.l
Intt evidence is found In the despatch itself
without trusting 10 my memory exclusively. il
j. quite evident from the despatch itself. and
oven the I'ilrme translation tuHt ii is innr'u-
rate. II states q matter Of which am perfectly
well aware ! believe M that time / was foolish
enough 10 thinks TINT the Returning Board
would declare and certify tho result in
Florida correctly and in fnvor of the Demo
cratic party. | had rensons for tha' nellel
which J would state. II the Committee would
'ar" tl hcur 10; and on ac'ount Of that final -es-
honoi tho Returning Board Ind teiegraphod
T. Mr. Tilden To- "suddlc Blackstone" which
was ihe name Of his iavOrite horse. meaning 20
lntmnc 10 him my hope that tho Returning
board would decide correctly. II Is perie'tly
obvious from that last sentence THAI tho Tribune
inference is wr0Eg.
Q.-l Hu stat" us "a matter of memory that YOU
: hi ne despatch lr Col. Potion in which you In.
iit'l him that any proposition had inlleI?
a. sent no d"s patch to Mr.. Potion telling him
my proposition had failed. aud mad no failure
u report.
~ DO you romemhor a despatch from Col.
irion Of Dee. in which you used the words
,,nnish"d yesterday - Al don't rccolect
TIM G.spatoh.
Q-b' You know 20 whnt that refers Al
nin sure dlut remember, Int probably the
I'' would Indicate thai The Canvass lgg
l,"rl Went into session ON the morning ~ the
o'h. NN4 iti- WAS the last public session. II was