New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1879-04-05

OF 1873, elected an elder III tue spring Vi ~
was employed by the trustees in 1874 10 Porlor" "
| Tor which | received compensation
resolution of the Board Trustees was put IN ~
,oc md aud ,dcutitled IL was the effect that the
nshers he instructed that all negotiation Tor III @
To- be left to M Hathaway exclusively, anu Inat az, r.
picatlons for pcws should DO received ana releiic
| MN. ,-. 1900 Al re-
ccved from the trustees diagram II ihc chuIcu W.,
toe price marked on each pew MY ihsI ra %
reGI'e az LA, t 70 tke iess Circulars sent to
ali ders turn, requesting them T." can o
| i'm relation 10 ignment OF pe"H' wien me- nnb
tried every means in my power to induce them 10 SUI
scribe AL they could New appnesv1 tvl fo do for
my office, they were instructor d ~ ~
eighteen months from the pulpit was oSS,uned
! them seats which always did; and always asssneu
seats In proportion H. pay nenls. ,,,oo fran, tbe
nut thai pews assigned without reference 10 V
| dollars A-FOumerly frequently; ial'efy noio SCI
Odd Won ever make known TO him your method OF
asst ning seats Al reported to the trustees "i' "0
Several applications for seats were put we ie
eudence; Endorsements ON bottom OF hSS ne
TSey We're in the following form: The qnderssned
Wishes 10 obtain for the year commencing February J.
is75 ali the sttngs pew No; and hereby aSL oH
| Ia pay for the support or the Gospel, - on lo'' .
| of these we're ndoI semens, among which are ,nes,
III c,uo be granted for $780, IN justice to the chuen
Il must obtain 800" "Appli1ation not granted
| Treasury needs more money" III.
ODD Won bring such an influence 10 bear on people
who would not pay the required amount rs 10 aS
instrred TO DO 80 by MI Corwin, President Of the
Board OF Trustees. THE witness gave tle names y Td
| mn their pews among them l.. $. WttmoFe.l tn. .,,
O-iIave you any facts that lead you To Des|t ,na
Tr ranses knew OF Mr. WctmOre being obliged to give
| up his pew Ayes. He brother OF MS, 1 "a,
mage. and fell il was dcucate matltI, ~ hls as
| mhcy he iusfrnctions Of the board called at DR..
Talmages and saw Mis-. Tdndge' VINO Snip , tna.
must MOI 1pect any favors account OF Relationship
| now The WITNESS WENT TO PRINCETON
Counsel then passed to fourth specification, which
! /, TO the effect that DR.. Talmase charged Mr..
Hathaway with dishonest practices, and then dehleu
| tHat ne had done
Odd you ever seek tie advice OF d.. Van Dyke on
any snbiccti Al consulted with MIN IN reIerrucg 10
preparation for the ministry, "a dH VIII at,
mage Both gave letters TO professors al fI'hce"n
DE- faim.gt's letter was put in evidence and was
! read II introduces Mr.. Hathaway rs worthy OF az
confidence, and he had proved ms WORTH duu tu
Cheney IN almost every department OF christian Wora'
| Tnt witness (conuuuus) On jue last SUNDAY "a 1ane'
ton br Inlace into the sunday -@cA""i ana SloA
| in favor Of tuition, "hch was aigp,,a' lia ,
! Jvn vrars | received ina all only about 500 SIui
! tNu -, = lveut I'm PRINCETON ali nv Offices
in Inc church except that Of trustee Dr. Iaimite con
suited with by letter IN reference 10 ect b ei '
.oT me 'y hrr Nc rcicd: Ihc last Ietrr
wrote to Dr. HI he answered lusoeutiy ana 50 CAM
"to-Dii Won write TO Dr. Tamace about the loss Of
your edersmp while at PrinegoH A s- f %rs' so u
| letter written 10y Ms. Idimdge IT'D. D..
! Nr hard Il Is in substance ns follows: " br.
Iamaee wishes me 10 say that no unKindnes- y meant
bv tnr action of the Session. they wish to have some
one who viii be on land Tue letter closes Win oN'c'
.i,ns OF cordial good Will ~
| The Witnrss-ibis letter Was written abOu; October
! H. IS76 The last week December following came
| I'm RrnoElvn On J nuary o had interview with
! DIT Tamage az his house 1 had specinc purpose IN
call ng more Than an ordinary interview hau
| and was not pleased with my treatment went
to tod d. ina, t"i B Van bSe a0 had written ettr
TO The Presbyterian attscking the Tabernacle ana IN an
Interview VITA Dr. IAmdge had stated tat ne COY lhe
data for the article from me; TINS might nave mace
difference IN Tie way was Iecelveu' hrauV's' lr
| go Mr.. COrwlD and talk The matter over. oen'eu
the statement emphdtlcaliy, ana ahked MN 10 20 10
Or. Van Dyke lie salG We would n2t gee any ;I
ton from nim ana Declined 10 go ne lhieaEc" Suo
by my going see Major Corwln was deeply gilevtu
and said would meet the Session on the following FRI
! day He said this vas "mnentiy proper stteunod
| the Session and complained OF these sIaI, nlents.
advised M 10 90 back 10 Princeton attend my stud
| les and tnluk no more about the matter
THE QUARREL WITH Mr.. TALMAGE.
| Continuing the witness said l visited DR.. Van Dyke
the next day, and tod him that was indignant at his
charging me with giving away the secrets of the Taber
pacle which could ouy have known in my official
capacity He replied " I did say So" said !;
! "Dr. Talmage says you did" He then SAID Dr. Tai
mage called on him, aud charged him With having writ
ten the letter The Presbyterian told him had OBJ
raued them from any OF ms Official me,nners; ~, nc
Mr. Hathaway is entirely ununsI~ofthy ana - a Ie-
fiuer to the church denea thls and askGa Dr N
GO To Princeton aud consult professors dld go ana
| advised WITH d. Green and Or. LcGHI' came DdcA
lied o. T1eSd Nv morning bafore tho meeting
tid m H. Teln,s.e aud Jaw min, alone told him of the
interview with Dr. Van Dyke, and reported what he had
| said Dr Ia mage denied that he mad used TIE word
d1al,Ite~ aud biauchcd off attack upon DR.. Van
DyEe demanded that 60 with Inc ana see Or. Van
Dixie. lie positively refused sald: You must 20
win iae OF ,Iai nave this matter before tue Prgsby
terry" lie said 81 do not want to see Dr.. Van DYKE
uni. thc Judgment day said could not ana would
NOT rest under mis- charge lie ah7WeIedi belltNc
| iii AN uu,ruih, but Or. Van Dyke is a notorus
liar" Sensation ID tn COURT lod MN should Diihg
tins Iu. ctr before the Presoytery. He answered;
H'tna"dy' you 'AI 'Iolu =. - }ou ~ ~, "o W..
youu-y rt6c , Whole l,fe and not find any thing
mi ",ich viii am me ~, .I is ir s", uon
III. Hathaway resumed went to d. Van Dykes as
fast US could goi because didn't want to be ground
between Ire upper dud Tue htlHef hIANtouc
lad not been there more than i've
v 49,, be- il not Want to come in, but DR. Van Dy ko
said tim Come IN; The Lord has sent YOU He
hel'IaT a. h9 l1 ir u ~ maze e .o,id f h,I med
turned ana said: We have always been friends
td might as well h, ends st1ll." lie asked 10 90
with him 10 Hr. Co.wn. aud said We could fix thls
thing NJ in a Few minutes
Odd yOu 20 with Inn A.-No; dId no. want 20
! would remain untl The next FRIDAY, when / at
tended meeting Of the session d. I'imlse
aud what Dr. Van D. 80 had sud and demtndeG a
from the platform. Atcr debatr. resolution was
adJ pted which accepted Us ina settlement
MAKING AMENDS FOR ACCUaATiONs.
Tac following minute from the book OF the Session u
| the Tabernacle put ia evidence:
Tie following preamble and resolution, having been
ac0uirscrd ~ ana accepted by Nj Hathaway. were
unanimously adopted: Mr.. l. ". Hathaway having
! appeared before complaining of having been san-
dered by reports iu circulation concerning him, ana
that reports have arisen nom constructions ut
upon Ina lvcrtcut rcmarks made by members % this
church, and the VhOie matter having been inquired into
| and satisfactorily explained: ID rcicIc,
Ics0{rtR, Tint Session Of flil Church,
express continued confidence II Mr.. Ha.huvayfs
Christian character. ana declare that satisfied
that any and All charges when may have been floating
in Tie community affecting his mora character false
! aud sl.nleTOus.
This resolution beng passed by the session and ac
| ceptcd by Mr. Hathaway final and salts actCry
| adjustment uf the whole matter