The New York herald., 1878-08-18
The Quarrel Between Beaconsfeld
and Gladstone.
PRINCE PATRICK's 100000.
Debate on the Third Reading
Of the Bill.
VICTORIA'S PRIVY PURSE.

has arrived NJ the letter writing phase Mr.
Gladstone made great speech In the House OF Com.
night before last upon the policy Of the govern
ment and as it also pretty that he wsuld
refer the personal matter between himself and The
Earl, the House crowded to its utmost capacity
Pausing after few introductory remarks he sad:-
al am extremely sorry advert to such question,
but the House will bo hardly surprised II
frankly admit at once that am Obliged to
ADVERT for moment TO branch OF the
question which Is personal to myself aliude to the
personal attacks which have been made upon me-
became this morning OF language used last night
in another place which Increased gation to take
notice OF this matter 'Hear hear ~ with regard 10
tho declaration made by Lord Bsaconsaeld, think
my shortest and sim pest Will be read with
out note or comment, short letter which have ad-
dressed to the noble lord subject Hear, hear ~
II is iolows:-
GLADsroSE's LETTER TO nEAcoSsPIKLD.
DKAR LoRp BKAcoSsrKLD- i fud you are reported in
the Times toaay have made last night reference to
stssss hat | assesi5sd daass,sa. and sy:a
G a M ON sn q f" mime he So Ss .
ment. You likewise reported TO have said ths.
gsd critcisms rcnectng with the offensive
sRaaes W soa saVs the 20 me- With
list selection OF those offensive epthets applied not
times places which they
having as' With hi: Vii
need hardly add, public
1T WAS WRITTEN
I wrote that letter, continued Mr. Gladstone, be-
If of epithets and tho statement Of
such facts he proved my plain duty Is TO make
apology Tor them ('Hear hear. ~ L have aad no an
yet my letter, and. indeed, could scarcely
have expected one Tor II has not been Tor many
hours IN the hands Of the noble earl to whom
It was addressed deny that the fact OF my
speaking OF the policy of the governments
disEonoring the country constitutes prov
ocalion or be rightly considered as personal
(Cneers) claim in the fullest sense tor oil members
OF This House right and the duty describe, If
they conscentiousy believe it, the acts and the policy
o. the government Of tho day dishonest and as cal
culated 10 dishonor tho country. (Cnssrs)
THE PRIVILEGE SPEECH.
Honorable members ought not to DO this lightly or
without having arst made iun examination OF the
facts; ought they to take this course except In
spirit OF readiness to confess themselves mistaken
upon proof given OF the fac but, subject 10 these
limitations, affirm that II you Tor bid members oi this
House to denoapcs when they cause tho policy OF
any government dishouor!ng the country, you
may as we'll shut doors OF the
Housc-(loud chcerst-bseauso you Will be depriving
members of Par 4lnent Of OF their most sacred
dulios-I Will not Gail II q prviiegs-And you will
likewise take from the country OF the best guar
antees 1t possibly have Tor the right adminisra-
tion OF public aniirs. Loud cheersJ hope tho
honorable aud learned gentleman, Of whom ! make
no complaint, will really understand that however
painful it isand It is painiuto have 10 resort 10
the Of these hard aud conde natory terms they
yet necessity OF Tree parliamen ntnry existence
and believe the liberty Of speech which enjoy is
q liberty whcn all other h bertes, and the
abrdgem OF which would render all liberties
vain possessions.
BEAcoSsFIELp's RLPLY.
Tue Premier, however, lost no time in replying TO
Mr. Gadstone's letter, tor tue answer published
IN thc papers on the same day. 1t was AS ioiows:-
Lord Beseonsed presents eis eonpiirneat. to Mr. Glad
letter tins days date referring TO remarks made "
requesting 10 be supplied offensive pithets
asrson rS, .nS and With note Of the times
and places at whieh they were used
year. and a" eSrias which NJ SadstoDs to use ais
49, AZ ~ s.s ~ ,e ,a an, v rnn.n, IN.
purpose Bsaconsaeid lord who is At
quest those who kind enough to assist hun
.ary re.t.rehss, which probably may require .ems %
delay in fspySs TO MI Gission.' may not srpsai w"S.
ing In becoming coureky he must VITA references
nvscve against the government that
government he mean, Lord Onshcid who Was alone
5esp9ssies and Sy ws%% fIo~' name OF hn sna
In the spirit few day. back. At southwark Lord
which every Enrlistman should he sshamsa act OF
aaeiieiy which has NOS been snsp.s,ed .na M Clad
aalions."
such an act, however. might be expected from Mnister
who according Mr. GIaasone, had SOLD the 1rceks"
10 10 ss .ns .s Sd G ~ m.s shs
not Mr.. Gladstone at Hawarien who compared Lord
.oaes friends knjy san1ns Of ~. Iiads;sns 5 hSw
eadsone proesesed TO explain tn. InodeprobaDy the
Imass.n :ss may sss..S' BE
~ DowsisG sTTuEr July ~.
The take sides, OF course some journals with
dhe ''sopnisLcal ruetorician, otucrs wth "Aephis-
tophces. out the opinion Is very gsesrai that al.
though Mr Glaaslone BEGAN u LORD Beaconsheld
llade error Judgmsnt in finally turning upon
him and opening mo uoor 10 fIcsh recriminations.
OF course TOO, there the usual cry that tue dgnity
oi the country 10 lowered, iesiing popularized
an tho music hall ditIy. "oh, hel nol ior sbame
What will mamma sayY wnai will papa
sayf' It seems to nave surpri.od many
oil The rcspoctaOIs eiasscs-thosc irigid. poker.
backed people who ,hlnk me sun Rises
leaders have SO much VI tie ordinary human being
An them. ''sueh bad form, you knowi' WHAT with
thc open hos ty between tn Parliamentary leaosrs
anu me iuss made IN Parliament over The allowance
10 the Duke Of Edinburgh on bns marriage the uppsr
are quite sosndaiizci Way, damn It, sir, talk about
Amoricanising our iesu.uuohsl tue country Is Re-
public already ~ heard an irsscible od tory exelaim
ihe other day. Aud II must be confessed that the
opponents of the Duke vi Connaugnt Establishment
Dii, II is called, have nailed tncr coors 10 the
mast anu fought The measure to The very IAst STEP
PRIScK PATS INCOME
The third readIng vi the bill the order OF the
day in Parliament last night, anu Mr.. Pnnso, the
msmuer for Derby, mcdiaiely arose to oppose the
ahrd rcadng and moved tnat mo o Oe read that day
three months when the members would be busy
pheasant shooting and st. stephens smut up) Mr.
Pnmso that the previous occasions wnsa these
grants came before Parliament hc had voted with the
majority III tner favor and consequently had bern
Obliged more than to defcud his portion
OF his constituents VINO preferred In tho abstract
publican iorm OF government TO any other.
THK DERBY REPUBLICANS.
on those occasions, sara Mr.. Pnmsol, no had con-
.ended tnat long AS We had monarchical govern.
ment existing IN England was nttiDg the dignity OF
M. nation as well us the Sovereign that tbs roya
state should maintained IN suitable splendor. he
had also pointed 10 Her MsJestys personal eharacer
her quick aud rcaay sympathy wan suffering At all
times, as was manifested years ago IN tue case oil the
Hartley catastrophe, when she sent a telegram
40 ascertain extent OF the calamity, aud more re-
Gently IA the oi the Pontypridd Minors but The
Instances were numerous 10 reIer 10 In DETAIL he
further SAID that under "A constitutional monarch ike
ahut Ia this country 10 his humble opinion, their prop
city and their lives were more sale than
thry would be under republican Iorm OF