The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1878-07-13
THAT FORGED CERTIFICATE.
rdcTS THAT HIyE 4 TERT UGLY LOOK
FOR UILLIfM J.. KELLOGG.

the '"m'p"s ',.,,,nsa In. a., k,.-ncr
W.. .I.nt. cor,r.d,c,rd-A Snug Ring.
,,. % t,u.,,.,. ,,.. 10
WASH lN"i'N' "", w., ~
fore we .'''' '','', 81,
VERY n'nIly u'lru " '''"' ''"'u Nv wa, yam
inrd ny hls'"'h' ""' ''''@ w Wv '""'", y, i0
Turns " Wv '' i l,,,t,',i t., Is,.ux,T
reior' 10 '"' N'n",' n"' ,'"'''vu ~ u'"n ~
logs oplnl"n "s ne, ", 'u,'uu.'"s ~
such p't's W u. W. W 'N'o.
IN an" w u" r,' no.
Whuo"'". D"' ''H w V. nN"'At
eNanhlh"uon M Nv" r''nS W .ouV"-
"a u.""' "V "a. ~, -
flrS' NE '''.l A.. , 7'y',"r' ~ VIM ~,
hr h"p '"",' - '"9 9V'o"u' "'o
money nus WI ~ ~ ','V'''-
Der "' NV ~ VIC oi,t',"' 'uo-
men'' III w.. "u,N'ou "'S Wv"
repeater u',''."''o"s =" '"o pus'' anu '"iru'
Inc 'o,t'u iL'ui"' .i ",i'Vn nO,'ohh
iosgciuness was M damaging IN the nrst IN
stance to his vcracity rs the things no remem-
- ia .he Inc, instn,ro ,roro 10 bIa couno.
bcreu u. NV "e' '"'"u'c "'io u" n'e .o",p'
sure HIS s'crc'hry' H. conquest 'inrke' hau
carefully laid tho foundation upon which
vauocc was To he clenred of nil knowledge of
he"vEA Voc -, - -, vs. wy "
the forged certificates and all interest IN pro-
vomiting the discovery OF the forgers. Potter's
..,'r.,od ,u.s,lons today lcI Knllo,c into
answers which summarly destroyed this foun-
dsion and brought home to Kellogg most dis
sc,esabc responsibility. He left the commit
hsfeeau'' ivsIO"s'D,'"'' ~ ~ NJ m'1,,'
tee room much shaken. Like all Hepubllcan
witnesses caught In some contradiction or adj
-, . ,i.a,,.o,ti. -. t,soro.ot,,i -,
mission oil disngreeaole or disgracclul sort
the first thing he did was TO hunt up Shella-
larger.
Uu.H,'' - =,
Butler began henoggs examination whore ne
dropped il last night In several forms he
@Aeu hri'oH" w"c'"ul p,o''p" lo'"k mum "'u
support from Hayes would have enabled rack
nrd 10 support his Government against Nichols.
Touo,c hos crown 10 no too good a U,ves
heiuES ""S si""n w w w" s''" ny
man to speak uncquivocally. even about this
e-s, nr,iclc in n Iouisinn, Renuhlicnn's crced
rh. -, Ia, ,,, ,,.iiiir,, q, 90, ,yos tho, n ,oio
Inc most no was "lii,hs 10 say was INA. 'e'c-
gram from Hayes telling Packard that the two
fHaves and packnrdD were elected upon tho
- -. a,,1 ,ro,,d s,,ra o. ,oil ,n,,,,hor
same Vo"s' anu Woulu st'hu VT IAN '"E''ne''
would have been followed bp some adjustment.
uro tho Who.,.r comnromiso between tho
cinip,s ~ penuhlicans n.d Democrats
putior tbon took nm Krilorrs knowledre OF
,bo Sbcr,nnr ic,,er "'t'ndar I1s omes,ions KeI
H. conii NO., remen'h,r from whom in August
is77 Tho csi.t'.nce Of Tho letter was then chr,
-, al ,.r.sir nrcorted no ali ,vnon, ba
benrh s,,,nt ~ i,'f'H cc,tain in,inn"v which
WINS nm drre,ool 10 Inv. visited hetveHn ID A
Weber AMI Mrs. Jcnks lSd To- ccn.
cr,i ip,nressinn nr,"n, Louisiana nil
,inpa,s ", H., lc,t,r ,r,s in i"r banIs
vvannns s wa hnarJ W" IL" -, H..
IN " ie,tor AZ, wrote il, scn,a,,Sor az ~ ,,oisr
nsttn, ~, ,i To- la Irn,h,. AMI frri,:
q, ,h -, ~; ,cnroi ,,rr, T., at,,i
her Ic,tar Kinos NJ ,h" .,.,ns,i H. 80 ~
n f.nJ r,r,,s a. ~ H. s'i W. -, i br
nrnI CURIOUS I n,i ,ie ini,',' nSNpu nei IL IL
snnten u, n,nn., ,,,Ii,ici,n. ris
ramrnber r nu ~ ,,a NJ w., W.
has testified shn hnd made n" oiusion ~ ~
lno aI,, H. iu ni'u' ~ nuS"n 70 uhl
10 IL from INV ono Jtnr i.,'rs T.,
and Andnrs"ns lat,cri ., hcr -, ~ a
H., n, ~" III, - ,uI XIV hh linpuru
s,n,or,cnt Kciing,'s ,.,i ,,"'1., ', ~, 70 .n's
direct conradct6n lie t"d OF fnr.hrr err ..err..a
~ ,be ,tnr inc,nin, tho ,, ns
already made public. and then testified to an
rem days h"fore Mr. Inns tsstner sha benrI
,bs nrs, ,cn'rol aiins;o 70 ~ i,,a e LII ~,
interview Mrs Jents ravo K"llnyg 10 ,,ndnr'
n,nd w. s'n I, n, r,, " ord hodin, s o,t,r
pnpap rcnd w Korg rnrnn nasn e II lelt n,
Ter. This testimony sirius away the las, uncon.
Uiscort NOV, ,oot Ellnr, IL hnrn msi;,, a.,
his Examination tn6uinted returns ro's' eiyinW the
,nc,So ~ ~',,,j h'' W y,nrS Wy
tho result prasaly likc tia, set for,6 IN Senator
y ,res rrnort Tho interest somnwhnt fns,,ed
lthis s,nrr IIisco. womb tnkr nm n mr. sh
which il was alleged intimidn,iSn nxistcd.
sad ask Kellogg wInj the vote was, Kellogg
voter ynrc irtimil,,cd ANY, K"iio~y de ,InI
inc tho Rsnuhiicrn vatns cnst from 10 coiorad
rat M would 20 al &c
This simnls nolitlr1l nrttn,stir K.,i,,,., showed
A lnrrr krpuhlirnn majority in Louisiana.
In the fail Of 1916. shortly after Tho elect on
nnd hoforo the Returning Bonrd made its de-.
cision E,lin,s. rnis.j 500 oOii iinnn " ~, o,,
dorsei iy g j. FarweIi one ~ The visitipg
statesmen. md John b. Lyon. and discountei
AZ the Union National bank uf Chicnrn. II Tho
close Of Hiscock'- examination Springer mes
toned Kellogg ~ 10 the cause Of This transac.
ton. He testified that about IN roe-fourths 81 tho
money went To his hrothcr-in- inv. one C. "
Wills engaged with him in managing n plnntn.
tion in Louisiana: the rest OF the money he
devoted To- his personal necessities, paying
in doing 80 some personal debts tt
this statement OF the cnso Kellogg nd.
hered through somewhat prolonged
examination. He denied having given
different version In n conversation with Sen
ntor Spencer OF Alabama last August He adj.
mtted that. speaking rs he did speak then 10
man like himself bitterly resenting the
neglect with which Hayes had treated
southern Republicans. he might have used
such language in reference to his own sHcri-
tie money raised on this note was used 10
elect Hayes, This was very skiful lodging.
hut Kellogg was equal to Il. Other conyersa.
tons with other narsnns in other nlnces To- tha
same purport Kellogg denied outright. ns he
did sundry particulnrs of tho story about which
Springer rynmined him Krllouv nrofesse cd
his willingness 10 nroduce hnoks ana nannrs
10 show ihe truth of his ass"r,inp as
10 the nrivote and ners"nnl disnosi,ion
Of the proceeds Of this note Fvidcnca
eXstg 10 show TINT he hns reneatadlv
said Tint This sum OF money was raised and ex.
pended Tor political purposes. part of il in the