The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1878-03-06
BtNKING AND fTNiNCIiL.
IMPORTANT TRADE MARK DECISION

sprrcu,c Coirt-snccial Nv Judge Iawrcnoc-
inc am ,,isasi fr,n ic t,i'ncc ~ M ea' vat
the intention 81 tne ac.naAm. ia, W "a ' nnn. that
manuiact utcd D., tho pillniin, am ~ ~ ~ 1l u, M
,ic ilt"uiou 81 uc drcndaui in adopting me nln, and
nl. wfaisg, ana III p' n. t6nt cnpoyci
rurcla,,r, hc,yc hat ~ lursia-ns ine enaS,i
col ulc iHiuun- In I'm, conn, . 10, tee vi In fii WIFI
per u,td ~ the defendant Mn , p'". ,T,s
,., 10 mind Show, an ina ntioi on the part OF iae
1,,,n3sni vi a ,rr IN , isrAci ior eir .npoho ~
inr,, Which i.c, had made IN eA ~, ~, , ~ t,,un,
manu-, tha, the artcl lss acquired great reputauon
ant mat the pa.nin, na,r 'Nrl. VIZ 49,, y; a, fi,
io,uiaut after aualvtns can, 90 ,nto," ", ,, r,
similar M character COLOR and afraran,e "a that o. ne
'M"In n, v,n ' ,gg coa, nr,. that tie dc'Sndaut,
after h,'in- ,,, p'',,''S~ n. nWnr. ha. in addiuon
coned mann nn'n ''n'f ,n n,'ne InSln. o.,
closely rr..mGun- the riauun. both III meir >i,rH
ANA Internal appearance. q, to color. sn anu l"lliH
20 n'cnpuon Hnd directions iol i,, ,u, Inl' pa, IN
90, II, power Iii claimed iha, ~ @lni, , S.,,
laye an gAcn,,, r,n, n ~ m' nv NJ" or M a., sac,
llng colonel "l.' W Har' 'oi,mcicin n0rno,,.
don OF tie Iimnuii. label whether a, I" coio,
shape si.e or m,cumon. wingn inhts..'n 4 ,' ,al
,tl1t,t and intended Co. deceive the general lH
hr the cNi rncr satisfies nlr ini ave hu' MTNl' a.
u.,d lis the lcoulaui. !. calculated q" deceive uit'
,r amt thiuk That II l. very CLEARLY itoN il w.
d. diiar, purchaser cNiNed hA lt eiulailN Z" my
rr.~es ina which tie soap are pat upon tt MHfk''
| crf. al amt iNl tNANfiNaNNu ' Ult lMn lN'N"-
VII andoubedN reveal distinctions and dinri en,c, tg
tween ia, lahrs aud the devices thereon are Wu'l'hl
Int there ~ general ~ ~Whiahrr lnhi w. non "
thc liu-unlt u the Wee thHnetliuf al ldr~l"h 49,
| Wick sunra. the Court or nary NnNiH hr h""' "
presume that n WAS not a oriiiH> concur VA "V'
| Of events which produced tins similarity y
would he IRRATIONAL not To rest convinced NAl th'l'
mHrkahc coincidence of appearance, tNbthal "n" NV
nal Il the result OF dcsHn IN tie taH ~ A. ill ,t
| Hak,rs and Cuuvcuunrrs Tea Association Nr'hN
Nutcs sT2 D. 3l an Injunction mad c'nlasu'u l.-t w.
Inv die de- ndauts rom ISSUING rappors winch Mer II
Imitation at those O the planiti CA hp r' IN. ,.,
Chance or snd that though no one phriAul"i '',
Mn>rNHttlN initiated the combination MNs .'lN nun w.
and hN.N tutVcoiNr that n MAS True NAi u' va, w.
IN hat incurred ANY loss bat where itt 'lWi"l ~, =
ntNui.. that was Not o. mpnfihn" 'N' "Il,." H.
,l,r.fnr, Dismissed ease reported h'NN ~
W,,kiA Nui,s ISL @li lls last rhs' ST. ~ l
I.rk wool All RostWlck, nalN, y - ""ln"' *
,iltinn That the ulanun, arc eul,Nn a., ,
Nh iuuutuu restraint. the dri'hl"t IRON N't"lnm
III. ao not mean 10 understood a, hwlig lhhi VA
te,,t',ut has NOT the ~ nnuuiHl ur". ana hlso
Xii stnhn NOR 90 restrain INN from IN" use ol u'i
t.t, Oh q, tne n-lV device upon iir htleh hul
mt, ni that %. SHALL abstain from di'r.N- ny -N.s
wfu,rs .l clos N res uulius the Vuuuns a. tnrnah
nm l deceive the puulr auu lctifilN V ifnhl Vhl
.hull NOT sd N -tpht and tuf sapuho IN other wurd
ne must st under has NNn rulnrs, and not Hnrr Vust
the rIuuu1- judgment accordingly FndiNs may
! srtthr on nNr dave notice. john /, nry Hhl amt
seward Tor lAinuns, Ne ,srs kugtnmill stanbofou-
tor Defendant