The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1877-06-17
SERTED nv RfGHE.
The Medical student who JiItrd n rrett,
I,ss My I.ud. In ~ Jocose Mood.

t'"" ~ h''"'n Ne"s
Tho cAeo ~ SrhoalNs w. Roberts came MP on
al,",! IN tAG uiTh Count OF Nppr'ls ON Nay 20.
gamo-, Btanwcll. ana Brctt on the bench. Mr.
eSrenei ,hot thus was an a al b r" ls
the dlul ht"r If an engineer tn recover damages
from mcd.3,l stud nttor breach 6. promise Of
nafrlnrc. Tho parties reside ai lluud4worl d.
near I}rminghnin. ana thee. .tiuu wa tr.ei h,-
lor" Justice DrnmNu and ~ common jury at tlc
Waiwiok ASSES. The defendant pleaded ii III
h was not oi arc when the promise was made
ant tine pia iutm then sou4it to amend her
atcmont " claim hy alleging u now promise to
axe. Ills lordshir refused TO allow tnc amcnd,
ment. hut res rVcd that and other matters. and
ley Two questions to the, Jury First. had me
d"i'h,lanl ON tn qua oi january lN'G. ratliin i
his promise; AMI second did he IN point Of
tact make fresh promise to marry III"
planting Tho Jury dd not answer tho II It
question. but they found Tor tine plaintiff on 80
second. aud awarded her 600 aS damages. lie
contendcd that there had hrrn no Now engngr-
duy Hltcr the defendant wrote to- the plant II
stating that Il h. married her agaiusi his
adding. " In my idea YOU. are a, perfect lady in
went go src her on til" following lny. when. ar-
corning To- hnr nTonnt' H. Wtnur," rs lott'r'
I'm" Lord Cnlrt Justice said Ii vt was true It
nnpuneh To ir'sh lr9hnS,'. iu' u'i nhdnht
nii' w l'.hi "I lt L. SUI NN l"'h.l Iloi ~,
VIZ '"' nh''lnE h""u7' N"S nv, o "s'i uuV
MY XXI ~, w ',t ,, ",' a'nuN 'lVmvw H. al
lnfh J"~''' bf'U ne N'Ni'l 10 nuke "
nv n.y., l'pn,ii LOW Wvu, nc 40 " cNo'p' oS S"S-
ny WI h|bbry you ,ui.,,..o,.. "ru.fu
i.,iu - u-','' 'rHlIiiW.l Al" S"e S"YS' iM"l
i'i'iS w. ~ to :, ,,,i,., ,,,o, n
49, i..i'i '-'i w. bI. iiy "",i u I'HuiI' ,''t y
woman @nni' -hy J. W." 81, ,.,,, IN '"'' he0'
"ih.N u' sun lncnvr1n l"u suVrl :, ......,. >.
. '"' i.V'Y III =" @ ''if ~ ~, "'',' 4,
N, U' u'l h'"h1 VIZ : d XXX ~, ",,
VIII WILL, ~ S'i.s ,, ',, H"' "o N''""'""7 anu
,rI I..f'n Ur.ttn III ms n,ueh os save
Mh'n ~ y, r,N, A"u W,'tL H., ,' .,l",I' y
" ". w, Mn'h u'u i'Vul" h"' hV'p inSS'n'
~ hoo, ,o~-
hI. n'iiHi 9alu ,t 'n' plt'i''l, ''u ,,'u VIZ
I','",I' ,'.u 10y nrI u"l'Ii Mo- vn h'I 'n- ~ r
VII risk ull AMI marry you' winnie lrf S'Ster on
S'r ""t,nl W. .,'''' "'"i n"' ''s"' IT, 1",'
ilom ~ rlain'fi 10 The dei'ndnnl ~, day after
We interview n QUESTION, ~ Wn,,vn S.r. H"-
,lt -1 " Ilih "S .. " own Hnriis "1'''I' LOT
so,u',,,. M .,, ~'t H. nn t ,r,..nt ,ieir
pnrtlns ~ oti'r Z" snow unt tl" d"i,hdaht
nae ON tn" OCCASION 'oiu h.r ne eou'u moi
1hn Lord Chief Justce-Did he give evidence
o. ,.";f ,,,,..r,
The Lord Chicl Jusuce-That Is II little
adv rs.
Mr.. NrVor continued the reading oi tho letter
IN Whish tue piaiuiin expressed the hop" ihHt
something mignt o.-ur ~ that they would mot
b" pHit"d 80 That they might marry wiyuut
ruin 10 his pro~p' IT'S. amt asking II II would be-
tI ANY avail " stu" wrote u MS nltluff. ana
" thor he .DulI not SUI. Il some means ~
tins fl.v should IA. hn u,,,t.I forever for she.
f.t "a. could moi xiv, hin up' rnnt letter said
H.. learned .ilis,,l wiis uuit, Inconsistent with
the ulniutifi'- story thnt the defendant snid hr
wnuli FIX MI and marry her. The pl.intin
add wien You arr, hurpV YOU viii never
know what IL cost nl, To- lart from YOU. Tho
d,fn,iant lad written IT, t. The piainiTs father
I the ,iuV after the Interview must break on
my engagement with Louie: lit is lar from my
WIS., tnti should give her up but circumstin-
COS compel No t. do 90"
Tn. Lord Chief Justice said the letter was