The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1877-09-11
MONSTER DOCTOR PlIELAN.
TRIiL THiT SHOCKED THE FIRST
CIRCLES ~ ST. LOUIS.


saturday evening previous. Thenfrair created
,n,rs, ~, i,.,,,.,, IN, H.. l.rhool -nvnrv
aristocratc part " the city. The Justice stated
60 tho Doctor the nature ol The charge preferred
,,i.. No.. eliza, ., t,,,.,,., bi. ,,if' -.,.l IL,
hehlhs' MN un"' v' .le ms W'l'-"hu Ill
hnsw'rto the usual question the prisoner an
nouuocd his plea Of not guilty. Perfect silence
,,ro,aii,1 IL, n,, cr.,,.,..I ,.,,,r, roor, ~ IN
F''"'' -, w "'' '''"' 49, III
answer 10 the Marshnfs "nll. lady " nrpa-
rently between 40 and - years " age She is
orl,. ~, ,i,d - , r,,h.r ,t.ih,. and, - ,lo,i,
'''' "'', ~" 'i " i''n 7n"""F 9"'. W "'"'N'
haggurd II face. the deep lines Of which wcrc
sunk ns only lon,-cYniinucd hardship can
-, "a -,
marx ON on" ol h'r u-'' pul'tN l'l IN" centre
OF group NJ ladies and ecntl men and took her
son, I'm tho Witness hnx
-
IL "'in w. '''i' I''l'l wei H"'iS'''" III '""i'
that III defendants line was ~ allege the in
san'y o' ms w'l' a. u"l''",l'n oi MS on'h'"'
bu' u Single ti"h'e at 'l" ,alm ih'' oi inc VIE
ns she stood the ordeal # submitting to the
.a.r.biu,,,v.s, ti,..,,.tv bu,,ir "A sp.,t,tors
....,. ~ ,t., .. ,.., H..
convinced all di~int"rosi't persons thn' she
was as sane as any in the room. When she
gave hrr testimony ie 'o' sympuhc'l' ana
-, H., ,',,'' - ,'''
s"O"'" "'"'' "'''V -" ""7 i'"'"'
ing 10 make rs STRONG ciS' against IN" u'-
PENDANT rs possible She made no attempt to
eolor nor cnse in nny ,vnv
M, -,
The plain story. as told hy herself ana reit'r-
nted 10y her ninet,cn-ye ar-old dau .htcr is q ter
rihlv uyiv nm. ,nl r,,r, ti,an ,n.., .lnrir, i,s
.ao, W. V,'' ,''' ',''' man ~, us
enforce silon when tine expressed indignation
of the listeners made l.-olf so apparent that the
Th "l 'f9", W,'u'pr ns ress,on'
IN" s,uiy, hS lii ,N Mi-' lh,iIn IN lhc fouf',
may be condensed into the following nara
ny, .,.,.o, ,,,. al, ,..,,.n
TWO separate sssnulis w'r" mnd" ny me Doc
tor, W. nftt III ..." IN "" evening" ne sec
ono nv" u,",S Nlt.; ~ w. even hS IN" 10 MOTOR
wrht 10 ~ !'i-'' s. lnt anu MIs. Ih'lah
iomow \ MN ,,',"',f' "n Wii,M ne slar "a l"r
hons g., at . and ON reaching the eate was M, by
IT In"inn Wi'o '"u-"t h,r Nv ,iii urn tnt."
hlr Town. a.; ana n71"i n,r t' -ir'h ssnH Hyr w"
blows on thc parN 81 h,'t mex. one ~ which I'M,
m"uinltrrly pr".ur'H a lnnI as mrio as small
nous, anu tn"rr met h.r uhushtrr. ~ years 81
aRci VINO to4A hcr.m INTO hrr own room and at
tended to h'r. Ihrre th"y sat together iHr
about two hours, Th"n they went 10 III" bath
room t2sotncr' ~ ~ TINS lhcy mn to hns-
through the Doctors room. which they
did WIN great rhre, 5" as not 10 awake
MN. In tnls they, were successful: but
not 50 on the way back. when he arose in
ms Dcu hhu ,lieu "ul. Don wwm' thtouyh nay
~ Mr. Tr p IL iiu'mer ywu. , n'h snn h.Hlu
LIE bI7 Mrs. rm"l'h run lr3ui IN" room me '.at
wui'n III n'N ~ ii..'ItiN 'i't,i ~ -! t'I
IN ~ M, hr,,,'i , NJ. b. b. i ',' ", ,
III mo-, Hru'',i lin,"r Mls rnrlnm "wn
MuIuT, al u l'''ii'- WV '1nnu "SSHui' "it.
.,ir M 49," III" u, . 10, "i',' IT,, n' II, '''i
orn ,s , n W. f,., .nl 80, T., ~, mr., .r
,ii "s nNns 'i"''' 'l,' ..l. -n ~ 'ii, l',u'
Ii,,,'' r tr.'' a., MON, III, a. .,i ~. ~ -.
,"'l, w. 80 ""', "',ta. ''i.,' w
''''
nm IN W.. "a mn su'il"h' W mn nus "i'1
k1lhf IN ~ uhu-0l' y. ~ u" IN. N'hinW "hi
n,leu i"I ,thN l3l', u'li vruWh sMh'rrH.
mn III. i...t i.,,' I,.' "li WIZ, a-"lh 10 HIS
oM,,i '., IN, i'' "''H az ~ :. "a , !,
ny ~ '"r. WI" WE ~ pit :, Us IaWy'r De.
iptr u" n,-"h we s'u'N "l lu'uie,n"' WIS nnl
NrrN nnllN IA ,l.s .-Nih'ii hs 'h' wan. - l"r
en- slu d u, LIE S'I'''- s'"tN Pluh", l'u.N.
nn i.N,,,,.' Nl'h ~ ~ s'li'iis T"N' i.tr we
opno.lunhitS, a'i1 sippe'i 'mt urlnl's 81 u. n
III Mut iii-s '' ''' H. ' lu1 1 ""lu. IN
III ~ III. l,i, ~, IT, '',,u n'..ln'' nNu-
a. iNH ,,,,', ~ NJ Mi., L1mE l" '"urch
~ H. 'i.i'E ',,Ni :, ~ ~, ~ a. Xxx W.T.,
I'"~ W. VIZ +" ii 80 d, tv mui,H nln
nLLnprGi ui'Ss -" ,ou "e"i ""sn d" " uifS
W. az w. n " ,rho1n
s,,,, ~ ,.l i ny, ., ro,y ."
"Wh-tI -, , ,,,'r ,r n.y. a." H. rr.,,,,l ,h,s >,
i,',, ' ,, y, 81 L. ,, II, ~ IN, ~ WV, a. ~,
Thrr ~ ~ ' n.y., "a, II ,sui H., ~,
,tii ~ , ~ a. v ,, w, - ~ w.. "S"cI
t'I ~ ~. f', Nh r ~, 'ii..,nJ INV.
self IN @ Ri ", W. u'., i ,'i, i'' r.
81 81, 'u, nU.n M'"t H'Mn', N""iN, W,l DE
e' sbrcs l' ~. ,. H.. IL sr,,,or
'.L'Ni a. IT, ~" 10 "''' w. lnI -ihMN'r'
al ul1 con ',us''ia HI h's rrn11s-"A"ih nation
hSN'n ,l'', ~. ~ W.. uN"N." ,.i' l'"oN'h|'
vi IL I..oo' u''u L",''''ii" 7.h9H'iih' ,,.c
IN lon' Soi thtrW me upon inc moor anu lvlt
M, Sf'l-''lf