, 1877-05-01

tree. tree: WsRt This p WEAPON @ poody Struck oErie,
abont thc heaif pie men thcn aenarafetI ant
aesjn ciinchcd' when O'I3rien tircw a knifc md
I Stabbed lis onponrnt. then unarmcd in the regIo1
Of the r~oin.
ense n wond Desn tsa ae th knife
self-defensc. On the contrary, the evidence weni
to show that he was vas tue assrcssor. and that he
would be chilled rs to character Let the iuFy care.
fully weigh this evidence. In conclusion, he had
only to say that he wanted fair trial for the de-
Mr. Carlyle, on beha1f Of the defense argued that
o'ricn was IN energetic, hard Working. and quiet
aule to thrash anybody around The stables. Ie
Of ok osSn I'm yoaS in The stable
sci contended that Doody commenced the attack,
knocIed down the defendant with the whiiletree,
To p1
vokcd by the deceased, who struck defendant with
"a terrible whI1etrec, and broke Ills arm. As
0Isricn lent tint to Doody few days before, and
did not it a.ain until it lay beside the men on
! the sidewalk: The probability was that Doody
used the knife, and this view Is supported by The
| fact that the defendant received bad cut
CHARLES BLAIR
the rst WINGS s salsd by iho prosecution ns
es s rs' &c. SSs
i've wears. Deceased WINS at wort IN thc stah,es M
Scpt rs: 1876 dcfondat1t having left there ahont
The Court decided that eri.icncc n, tn wbv de.
fcndant icft wns ;na1Imissihe '''"1 - ~ ""' u''
The examination being resumed. witness said
TINT ubout 7:0 ~ M, Scnt v5 he sn,u n'Rrcn
outside the Palmer House tohiecon " nv to tnsta
i,1ony with regard to O'f;rfcn's anncarnnce ana
barn where Doody was. rio latter nasscJ h. hscr co
but afterwards cam" mt into H. frant nR,iar
called deceased coward, and and eaallenged HIN MO to
noolv nns,yrred ANA air inn,t ,vsn+ ~ ~.
ANYTHING to do with you" o'Briensprang towards
hin, and Doody said, Don't GONE near me, or |
proach. and Dooly struck him with a stick 70 Or
club. This weapon Doody afterwards threw
away, saying that he could lick
effect OF the blow was very great TIs men alter
wards clinched and fought IN the rear part of the
is.;9.nd ha5n for r. few minutes oBten got up and
1 n nihsa "aS'5 ieS ob4sa sa
cut anybody. o'Drien walked away ind passed
Il ;ss:: :s
vas "; bareheadcd when he came up to the stable.
There 3I1; was blood On his face. Messrs. Tidcn,
r@1eF - ana Mo95e .,', were present when onrlen
out out as to the fight except that during
lhe course OF It Doody got OBrien down. !
BEEN asorsa H~e1 a, nat nstv hs hd % twice
ant: some OF the men entertained hard feelings
alAfnst y tficn, but ttero was 10 scheme to put
=, n,m ont ot tue barn Or to get Doody TO whip him.
ruttner witness testified that he said at the time
lhat u the blow with the whi1letree was struck
antd tt would have broken the mans skull,
IN reply to some questions pnt by juror, wit
iess saiu 1iat Doody was stabbed in the left groin.
". ill'icn threatened to call policeman il they
nun qnlt Eshtny, and 'Brlcn said that there was
10 OCCASION r. DO SO. for hc would not light any
nose. frooably Doody did not know thnt he was !
at until witness noticed the fact aud pointed it |
'nt'
C, e.. r11nny.
Of tbe Palmer 11onae s+.h,as
orrpboratcd the testmonT ~ fin former ,s;,"ess
. to the fight Ifn sa,v iioo;lv str;,e VIZ" ,t,
he ,yhlcfree. HearI .n,n" nrrtn erv ,Sa+ "aso ~
ther was coward Sa,r thc i,9bt oftar~srd n"t tTh
ccount given differed in M ,e9rce frnm thn+ fnr
ishcd bY the witness BiaIf ''AA 'u'' 1o' I
Dr. nlnnrhard xns cnlInd !, ora fo,,a n.a, | :
wing on the loor NJ thc xtnhia VIII h,s ia+as4iy
rotrudino. Thcv wnrc ~ ~ ~ H. htaa a.I
rom au arterv Wttnnss 1850 r,a ~ - ;t ePsa'e
hcir nrnncr nos;+ion .rd I've ~; .t @ ~ u
ham arriycd 1nnnr ,ros ~ 3y,Idi, @ aaS;; -. .sAe!
.nujrej fraan ro,,r - 's 49, n,: ~ 1 anu ~
he ,ronnJa rn-. aea aisn ~ neiu MN.
dm;n;strrnG md thn cssea 1a "nu u. sllmulants p
, thu Conntv Ho.ri,aI ~ srs. ssmossa t | e
esrrhnd ~ .oantT .aJTt., Aotpitai; me w!tness I y
' tha rost rnx, % ~. ..tI useeaTeu ~ sHo~n j.
led fron Va ahsrt. sa"a!'ss.uI. - ~ 'anlcs Dooay
'mmon pocket-knife. Death wns caused by