, 1877-03-07
PRICE FIVE CENTS.
he rome teehntts1sty. There b. some keen form
Of logic: which hare not .5es heard. and which

s ssshsfsy .ss sty. n;,. ;. ksen tes%
do no, mink shali evef Be abts to comprehend,
I'y which man who received re.rty thoasant
"a. sho,sn, aad i family Tspss. I'll I IN nos
!ide Of lhr thsniber e not permitted 70 donot
Se9 e.. r. 2es
aseaed x 70 hy the t5ibana' created b. ~. I'D:
son 10 nss Is nd a'o ;s sss
of that tribunal. ltaurhter.l iiu.siththe tiusIo
exception q tls sc9stot ftout = ConneeneI,. every
rrc.s jatt closed .otel to establish that tsE,,ns
ana enme y ws peon*: and ,ot. 1n sn
Ead u Isl fawned. sud hat " harc now osts".
ii'6ed 4 tribunal ais.insuished Shove ii human
decision ,vc woud all bow Y the sao4s ready ,rtss
nf cordial scqultsecnee. They tonls ths luctt!on
III des'Se lie a'a;a sS es
"tsi ;etet Of Lou'sans belonged to Hayes aud
NJ. 'T6utm.n-wfI tho sena,or a!1or M t. in.
X.. na!ns-ce,tss',aity;; ,.>t.
Sd :hat epald rot look behind tho dection Of tho
vi" III. Hi nia,nsHpseci.e.y, n"!; but It did aerisc.
was thst !. conid moi ink lehina il. tkefefors
,i sssss sSs sn.ts 81 IT, t @
rnado the Judrc Of The election. QUALIFICATIONS. AMI
H.. njaIne tintersupt!nx,-rhe Senator IA too
saH,d; IN soaa'ns 10 ia: point. ~..
M, Thurman tdis'esata'ng ths @nter1nnpslonfI- @ m
That Senate cannot look behind 'hat Eefa'n'os
Mi. Rlaine-1 an coming to that in duc tc,.on.
Fes,"Fa w % o Se xat ~
es q ses &c sa ss sis1
the Esestorai vntc Of that Stair: Am right:
H. i,isinn@t rsInrity - Hronsi}tutcs tl,n n,,,r3
6hio io ednlt .,at ths Electoral Commission di
what L did Do, aud that they. were un...
= s,me Soar careten to dce,sps
wno wefe Presidential Eletso!. q that st.te. o.
seTiai aaty. deeared who "a ill., Governor Of HAT
s s sss md n, ss. t s sGns ss .oay :,
lsan pas'!. Ii 20 fat =. The ese,ion oi Isyss and
hods =. shs sistsflsa. iiease o. sneser ths, s!ss
ths th,ons ct Ens!snd to asy Is IT. t an"9!ns .'!a
lula tnat Packard Is got ths legal e;ostsnos ot
b. .a sa' and ,he
who psts!det over our deliberations has 10
sses t. i s s s't httun ;a a. n st st Sa &:
f.om Ohio admts VI. determined by the Electoral
coEm1.,!on 70 bc eamrsssnL lessi; ani pH, son.l;
tbe authority of that hoard tes, ths Legislature of
Wilian III Keliogs ~ was duiy elected seaasot anl
eommi.aioncd By the Governor ii that statc. TINS
Senator bearing ihe grrst seal Of the State o. /
maintain. and j do MOI. unless CHALLENGED upon
that nont. tesfo 10 70 Into any OF tha details OF
Mf. IhH Hrmap-Do Interrupt tho Senator!
III. Thurmsn Does tho Senator understand Tint
The i;etasa!s hoard eownt she vetcs sos s;ovesuas
and DECLARE wno @ y elected taoTernos:.
Mr. Thurman-Thcn the Senator Is In great ef-
Mr. nlalnc-So. ncyss said any such thing; but
They were ha.ed On tho retuTns precisely. and
the samr Returning toa ri counted tho <otcs TO-!
M % t aos
! cEnnt.
dosceni y !: e 3ttfcrcnee between eon and esand-
iii Mr Fhnrs'sn1t ,ee to my To thc Senate, .ha.
q The Electoral Cemmis.on never decided that tho
y Returning noafd was = constitutional Hoard fur
tnytppE es ts Electoral votes for PFe'
!. III. 1tla!ne-no understand tho Senator from!
@ w. god enon1n ~ 70 count il ths Eeetot. "a. Psss.
i dent but not good enough to dsturmnn who waa
Q af. Thurman-Is the Senator oaks my opinion.
ray 1t was nut good enough for anything except
hSSf Lqfxs,ti !sa;'ssf; ;'sf Il; IN
+, ill ofnluns ll,a that tho Electoral! cnmnlss:on
dc'efre about the thing. or 1t least about eight oi
~ ~ them.
M An msehy hs H. Lspsa,s5} S.s;.}} ID
J. Legality aml their r!cht 10 act iron. thc same
sssasa Ia H. H.
ssa it,, .'ss'. f. ;,ssa.a & i9s n Psss
10 doubt IN that question: and It ID therefore that
maintain without any elaboration Of uExun.ent TIM
snip htts unon = tsus b.sis s.' upsa rsscise',
!. the eame foundation that tbs Presidential Eleeos
. he siss ss';.iet ttoa bs!swsss whom 20 al*sy
.f desrous Ut tscans with courtesy. that belius,
Ind ss ad shas
/, Was under Any obligation 10 yicd the ono to snt
y Sit. Nsyara-i DID not signify any obligation. /
nr va. mete matter Of practical conyenencu.
II i.te that sea,e arrangement bud besa niaio +
"a held; that hs was to be allowed to sllde BY au
Nleaol!* w. T. u aeeeptsd a. uostrnor Of Lou!sl
!. ~ Senator IN thss aoot wIiI .tate y ha p.e
e. 'ss:sa ss: ss%ss ;ss''f '"s liz As"s h.
.sSs s., ;ss ,ss ,::ss:"ss; r . s
for the AdmEnlstrat!on that now caist.. :. HIT
IN deny IL III tbs simple, hroA, Eroand that 1t u u
y Hayes could d. Il! Ideuy 1t on tha bro4d gsoun
that Iscsidrus l1ayes possesses character, eom
hs haA 10 Ahixh .neasusa snd ln Al cmlucas lie
gre. deny 1t on ~ grounds that t. ean tnauens
hefl 10 pcrsonai snA political aud oniela rc.ror.
.tIltly, dsny i ~ h''a .aa sh.l 1nd ny.sl
woarae % tas ana oe1 ~ Il
Administration. pnt whelhus Il ~ vfndca.cd, Q
whet.tt u bu nut, cS.o not Il is tlos The dnt
0f krnalot 10 tnVulsu what thr policy Ut the Al
n1,lI,.tratioh may le, bal what II ought to be, All
llopr Republican Bcnatu VII say that on lh'
bu,ht shrto shaIi be- authority III this land Ian,
cnvuXh ur sdsrntQr1Qs elioayh IL conpromtss I'll
hoGof Vt tl.s Nations, Administration 1t Yo1d nap
uatnlssfustou inu e3istrnce. tApptausc In tho 81
lrfles, which Was promptly checked By tho pEtstd
:. ! tAx ugfctE.
ID MI baya1d then tunk tLc floor, but, before pro
eccdlnx With kls remarks, yielded fUs M0lioQ