, 1877-10-04

1,at hren esuc., 10 rorsythc as witness, direct
twR. admitted that they were IN hts uosacssion,
| md the simple question Wa whether lio rs a
! witness should Obey tho mandate OF the Court.
Tho question cnnlA not be presented At this
stage, hut the tlcfenst waa anticipating qucs-
ttDn whhh might atisr-wlicthcr
| 1E WOULD CNtMisATE ntMsxLr,
4 o. whether fc would he erfmtnatc.1 II the books
! themselves were ln.roduccsli That question
were oGeEe', In evidence. An!! then there must
l,c something else TO exclude them, or suth Nr
tonl Of them M the prosecution desired 10 Use,
,a,, ss nrre statement Of the ssc , Tint
aMtnGd concerning tl,etn. What WIS wanted
was lhc books IN olclience TO the subIxrna.
/ They wol.ll he offered In evidence IN proper
shape and y, legitimate season. When they
| wcrc thus offered, Forsytho must show to tho
| satisfaction Ut the court that their admission
| wp,ld trs,l either to .lsgracs or crimlIate him.
II his 1tunor desired authorities on tllIs hraell
nf the application lAtle time would be required
10 prolucc them.
After sorno talk, itras Decided 10 tako recess
fur an hour anil u luaetc7.
MF: stilta notified The defense Of three ht1dI.
ti,t,al witnesses. whose nnncs were mot on the
inlistmcnt. .-ticorGc Buckley, ]. W. Doan, and
j. W. Ehenhhn.
Mr. Heed conceded that, although the statute
Of the indictment nit the names Of witnesses,
!ltNlcr tf,e construction VI the Supreme Court,
4 wna settled that others might be called; but
IL half never l',cn held lint that might be done
a!tsr the. 1ary lla1 % nesn iMpansie'! nna TUG
were KNOWN to the prosecution prlor to that
time. 1t bad ot,fy hccn done to his knowledge
o,'cc or twice IN twelve years, and then boeniIso
so'nethInG Nas ulscoSefea III t''e COURTROOM
The objection of tho defense vns oycrrulcd.
and exception tnkcr.
Upon fHasseMbling ct ] o'etocki statc's-At
tornsy M!lls submitted ~ that TIE only question
lnfolvsa Mae ~ whether the subpoena should be
tt1icc tle bot'kH 10 oytdcnce mas ono that might
arse hereafter: -
If anv mint TIE GogsF 1sKen r. ,,e.t,or vbctn
81 tio ',ooKs 9nght 10 70 ofoaght INTO court.
ne saprosea rsa MI. tors{tao wouldn't sase Wsett-
an c 81 ooGKs M were ~ us % or ~ soaf. as
Sms rs,a ~ sne p.oseGuoa eIa ~, noa seG tG en-,
r1ent 10 een the booRs oefofe going 1urthcr
was sely a!iiefent ;'fie; sfss;. ,..,, A., ,-
rs,,.t,,. ~, aa.'s ussfeu IaG 9noks
prous. .tr hot re e1fs; on, ot an natory %
sofy. o,.. ,.,..x x,..
Mr snth si alt not aisputo that.
nh A. Mais saMa lho subpoena sannla be onesGd.
,ense TO DC tint thcy eopld MT be compelled to
lct Ing prosccntlon see the GooKe. me QUESTION
"ns Nielhcr taley naa rsLlt 70 gee tict';
~, AZ. Mlsa re,narKea tna' ae alo not ADVANCE
Is Ceast ,. saln that FoIsytl,o M WIS not obliged
70 bf1ns tle BOOKS N II my prosecution linl no
ElE'lt 70 veg tie1n. 10 nah no riGht 10 innko M
ulaea ~ belhE tteM ~ MGIciy peeausG the
IT, i rn,s,T rssIt ~ cn., sEa M os ,en
70 90 something which clearly tho prosecution
haM no ri1he 70 insist upon:
~: st9rfs tt!en proposed 10 put fofsythe on
0s H. f.Iu sh IT, .a vS ,n books h .n n,,ec IN
tug tanis wa.e, q bis sttorrcys. ". .
M: Mr' Aeea remarked that thcy were IN bic
FAu4t' - -.---...
JAMES poRsffIfR
is Mas tnen ea!led cry sworn: l aM doing moth
I .mX noH. III loa4' 20, anu ~ ! was IN Tho
MMnoiEsa1e ~ ~ RsoeHs1y NJ eas!nets. NY 6lofe VIVA at
10: no: y ,a ana .sn1 = sonta M9.eF greet % le Ar!
lne fos 2. several years. Andrew Hogan think,
II 1871. Us, atad 'ig know William Ckristopi,;;
iii n ricrK T. uf harns ~ ku Q. socgtos an1
p,nE, ad ID, receiving clerk. Beardssy VIZ my
easnlsr my 6tooakeepef' 10 not Know TINT
!, !,an ha'noa creary was n my employ During
ta9 tose & sGa1s We nealt t,,n III groseE1es not m
see9n4 el1 i oooKkeoper W. oosah MeGlosy' Chris,
ttopn Espt ihcn awll!lei 30 dll ny son.
nm,e flw Wa.,u mutt sGfs.a' yuare no Mo hot knew
,, ss,'t 1 Them r. to ton, about week ago-Abont
eno s.p sne ts. nueprl.a t uusss tecum Was served
~ Nv ~ na1G4t Hnsu peesi aites y Wns heFTGu.
ian ~ nos ~, n, M'tow "ias uoAs lhey WGfe 4he
Ite"s1."v ~ r,st knax H. t.an osn 1uty ~
nSal1siey' ~ not KNOW thclf contehts-hut
a!i o. at. te'l.pat do PERHAPS OF PORTIONS ! Do
~. s.I.t sG!9ee. ""'s1el t1eso "AS a11 aecount
WIZ MSi,ti ep,.,. Ill.,, ,ro- ,oo ,.o NV ~ ,.,.
Q'TnM n"i,y wv esei hee tho "A" aeeouht'
Al a;n aesi,te 'ste. 70 a1',n answer; ~. A.. .,
.,,Gt ,t,on 49, % ~, y hs. ~ ., stse t.uuIu
sn.s1f ivy NV ny oo'"e' ""o hA's"s e''"aato
5nWi,,, ,,o,, how,
,oifaI II !, 11n ,aa,..'n.1 It W. euv ~
s.as ~, -, =, sso' ,,'.s A~A uu no'- Il Ihe!u
WI W.nas. suus a.. IT, aoegit. 9'ttoa y, w.. ,.,,
,,a..t,a ~, ANY ~. ,en W asMsa so loAo"'ne
qua qM"Ja w .t ~ ~ saut ~ anu.h .
oc,,n,i ~ un E,,. ~ y" . VIII t1'as
H. .,.',. u ~, Juu Js naum fiR apouL ~
~, ~ n..on. esae %"e ,V x 'a uM yo1 eses sec
'"u nOlv.'ro ,,,,, % t..,P 49,, I'M sss1utt1
eio you oe1ose sao aF'A'a ou1y' a.