New-York tribune., 1877-06-12

WAS so PEoNS0Tl @l1 Alc2il & l,H hsH9pI E T3rE OF 6s
roros GlAupN. lzmO. pp. o. Lockwood biooAs az
The Rev. Mr. Cook. whose mns'r,ions are
now attended with such brilliant picst -c among the
Boston cluicAcoCrs. iu addition TO hl- rcnown aa O.
pulpit orator prOpouuccd a ucw theory ~ lhr
atoucmcnt WI ic f. Submitted to stringent citital -
animation m the present essay. a. tie opinion oi Mr.
Gladden. the rosiotmcnt Of the doctrine oi thc atone
1nent though REGARDED by author as tis theological
Io.tcrr &C. k essentially defective IN principle feeble
IN treatment and ost.urtNc m tcntcrcy, oatafnG
from ,hc standTout ~ philosophy, Whatever reputation
lc la, Nod hy lns popular cloqn'ncc hc has FW''.t
brushed away by his dou.lis the doctrines winch many
Christians Vet believe. with thc iatcn' 60 suhsuti
some hig more rational n ircir place hut Eir ccn'al
nre moro effective than his ahirmadous. Tie h"-
shown that some things which layr hih't'o been
believed can be- believed mo- longer; uut hc hrt
failed to show what We are % Pehc'e n lDc"
stead The structure which be has attempted 20 eoct 20
place oi thc theories of thc ntoucmeu Wiic h' DISCARD
l. so hsIi, planned and so poorly built dat tnose wlo
lad lnoi To for Ic.ues viii bc Surc before lJut o
fud IL topp lug down upon their heads. Nr COO. h.i7
I'm analogy % The doctrine o.. the aon"m,ui in ti
prn,uic adopted bN tho Concord d"l.iai hi br"""ih
Acot for the government 81 mis- once occh"tcd school
on Beacon IiN Boo Boston. This pruciglc b. o." r.wo'
OF iie runishnclt ol tLe guilty by tnc sulsuuI"n oi
the souatsry sac1hcla ca,t.senrnt OF toe n"oc,hl.
MI Aleott seems Lave said iu eioc to hs ht!c h"e1
Rows gou fausl uCt vhsIri, bat II yOg d" %haptt
sbail .t ,sLip yoa but small mai sou Whip me- 30
g. TIC % lccui revived Of tie Grcum la"R.vcr.
Z-iier- o u. Id to have pat out one Of hs oWntyte
I'm mace al bis ,,u's who lad committed crime that
ephi.ctcd Lin ~ tnat punishment. MI GLADDEN. argues
both seiret the incpo aad rs application. The EcorJ
OF Nj Cook Ec maintains, coniiadicts tic Brt principles
% morality aud tuc example which hc presents ln
ilu,frt on of the prucpl, of the atoncmcn s pa pai'
al war with his theory. ia tic remainder OF the essay,
TIE gtor presents lucid exposition Of his own views
Of the euelect denying tta, the lnssare Of SCRIPTURE
which So ak OF The suhrinSs Of thrst as Judicial pun
isalseut are to bee construed m literal eense. lno
Ble lie gire does not always stale the truths OF rc
Icsn viii scientific precision htny OF Tie teztG "hiei
nre made hc sul,c. of 'uinUatical ard logical andy
e are siinfy tue expression OF deep religious hobnf
ereh sionf viii alNaf taEe highly objective uud
u.etcai foitn. Tho passages, accordingly which 81 PEE
sent tist as suloDg ild,cauy ld The place Of me sn-
nor and COD as bcng uol itlacd hy bis -feugs. need
ue he interpreted 10 u.uner To dcuy the first prGcrs
of morality j, is possible tlgt these words MAG be-
frI.s But il is not possible that the penalty al sn
should cttarsfcIIfI from -. ult, 10 ti nnoe"h,, ht'
tlea.vu. wrath against tlc sinEcp stoad bc prtsed
pv ihc s,ra rng ct q suoss hclr, or that any rH.-
httuton can be made 10. tic sp.rtJd d'ath
witch follows the violation OF spci,'l tw. 81. Glad
doa's uuur,tcnllas cssay cannot bat bc regard os
scaslanlc publication. 1t discusses "1 Intelligence
and ability grave tncrue o. general religious interest
Hs work is rmu.ut1 temperate iu IFS zone, c f iu s
ft oaot with no tracoo ol c0rCscrs.a uuiaratag Hr
yc.mcuce 1lI cut,cy ffec ir0m the not ylt que oo-
solo.c sl.i4t Of tloOlcgict nate.