The Centre reporter. [volume] (Centre Hall, Pa.) 1871-1940, 1877-02-22


rlurta There Mr. Tucker who followed Mr.
Field un tbo same slide. argued that tho judi
rIart uf Florida and ltr Legislature were part
1T lha lraal machinery FOR determining tho To-
-ult - c't,,iuua. aul that their action must
u,rbtfuIs lr taken lntu account
Iiu twu Hprrghpa far the lirpuhhcaus were
nlaap ln Mr. haaruu nud bir MrtrHry. Nj,
haa.au aaii that thr arguments Of thc Demo
Gratis raised thlyc quvsllaua llihi, ia thu tgin-
mission o. general ruuNgsaiuE board 81 rrcAufaaa
tho vote ~ Florida. Second. b. IL a national
count Of app,n from the board 81 State can
yasaria Third, be- lt Judicial court nt appeal
fr1u the Slate uuuItH uf Florida iu guH taHI-
f.a#. uar,yluEat Tho Democrats had as-
saHrd su anir@autr ausuyr 60 an thrso quoa-
tiuaa. Mf haH.uu maintained Chat tho come
u.sraiuu bad Hu power o. inquire bow TIE ptoe
plr had voted lu auy State it b. NOT popular
votes lut electoral votes that tuuFuss has
power tu count 30 u should Do h,ii however
that tuu commission could investigate thr
vuyHty CANVASS hHi lhr voting in ihr precincts,
hu would De- prepared O. prove frauds lu the
interest uf thr llisn riygtbfu uf thr pTussrst
description llu hastily faH over number ~
sauuii,s- rl.,u could o. hluuaht up 90 Offset
t4e single ui.r ..iraied py Nr llrid. Ma
Mslup followed uH u4r argument against tho
power uf tuuEfgaH f# go behind thr returns
,lsa4. auiHrut.s q. aHau tI4a, lAr proceedings
aH q writ uf .a.a t#.frTBHta Ia uut mNalldsta uar
acts - q ruile uHe,r done before the case ia
i, ,trauHgA.
Arguments u,ra nad. ly Me-srs. OCanuf
Meffsa ana EiaUa iH behalf ut TOO DemurrAt-
aui STANLEY NauAea7 ami air NtuuEhtoH tu
behalf uf tAv L#Uuh.rau- uu tho question oi
EuIue behind tar Ilaflda ,ylllnratr-, aDd all
mitfI8. evidence. Tile Husf notable arFu-
ma.i. were uu-g uf Nr MvfrgA Hui Judge
uaJatHs
Mr leu... Doc IshaI uf tho Democrats
o.4asel pointed uul HAT lhtTe were two prupo-
H J. a q ..I aH1
t.ealr4l,l r,iGgI ~ q state. one wac HAT
lhu Ielu.al government could uNHGds1e The
g.fafa. u. iu other words reject vote uH its
uHu motion. without tIr consent ~ the
State. Iar -os.4l proposition Was altogether
different. IL I- tHaI state l,-e!f may under
iaE. FT.ryH5.u.- O. lHH.Htaf, ta, ,oftAr-te u
tie governor. Ait.E State, ~ lis uNn alll,
HAS m.r.arh,i IAr governor certificate, the
Federal government MaE go behind d. This
Ns claimed had hysu auHr lu the case ~ lluH-
ia uLtIr th, State had Laly everything lu her
power O. u,,TtaI Iae Hayes certificate, aud
has made % tl. tulf af The commission % y1In-
pIgts taaI work 81 MrulsA claimed tazt tsr
power uf cuuLllu1 votes. granted iy ihe ,uH-
sutlagH, carries tAa poser 60 determine ahai
sy, votes. all tAat lils determination ls the
a.#I uajg ~ thg commission.
Charlie ut.lar l4d. al ufyT tJ produce
evidence before the commission. bat this nAs
objected On O., 5lr IfaIls.
.ef.ss ai s-i- hy vh.ra electors aTe spFuutrd,
a--g.laE taat tly aaa4 declaration ly tLr ro-
igrHu. hrsl i- il tLe enup'ruaL q the
appointment. That a#Hul4tIgat CHmplejrd.
e=HHal le r,t aside. except ia tLr interval II
uu, bslHr.a tae lN.N a.i uf apau4uuneat .ud
l8e dan uu ua..-. 4a-#. tAr iau. tlg electors
peri arU JH..I functions Ns casting lArlf votes.
The authority ~ tlr State over jng electoral
satr closes. Lr sali ga.l tag r.eriur- have
voted NlafatE Is done Wlla The votes after
th.T ti4t .- all, Id a.rIl .ure With tiIt Federal
Constitution and Federal iaN. ia respect o.
counting lHy Nulr- t-s question Do ulj Who shall
count l.gu iat LHa rAa4 ilyy lr counted.
Naf .t ull-. bee taI,f4l Aa, Ca undertake judi
e.aL examination #4#4 zz E- g.. paired .a t.tluE
wit UI ..l. .HGrrE...H WL.eU llNalN.- going 20
tho yr.F bottom sad aserEia-l.lg tie number
af legal Ns,e- e-el ii tlg cluTi attempted 10
SIT Tic facts rulaeruug tht StAtrs submitted
81 I4uI ga tho N,rF bottom. how luuE q time
aua.d .u lgHul,A lie declared that This
paH.r ua- uut conferred upau Congress The
ua|F aus i..u i.l t-e commission iu determine
was. N .4a wen. Gle s.r r.l-a y.urtHTs 800 Florida
aa iss -.Ata aay % .aat ura,lu,s.
SIR -..u-at.H -aale jog Llf au hour fol
lsHlH- HE. Matthew, aud declared that tile
f.slIa returning board MAS l-r laAl authority
rsg.ll-lrI ty t.lr legislature of Florida o. de-
..aTe uLa 1rI. tlr ,.a.tHT-. all tar Tribunal
aal uu paatT lu 4. bH.4a she appointment iy
tisa ~Gala As a,e..l,d lE .A. provision. ~ state
l4H- The ruau.e- e-.u- wAs appointed 10 euuat
electoral NHt,s 4l4 fag tu aa.lt Do, sates ly
Hhlel yl.e, ar- utsl ,auetUL
b,r I,ag;- usay s .aHH'ly arsumgEt. tie
-ui tal.. ,t vl... Hss 81 follows TIE oA.y
rg.#ra- ..g I... commission g. gula der that
rAleA goes tu illr l--5s gt fact alI record oli
aAaeA 3D., raNt.s.rs e,lt catt ls founded thv
decision AZ tlf etatr aAufarsyrs. ltyuad taia
&. HaUa.t gr. tag u la.s boundary ~ uuAl de-
H4H Esa z -..fH y d. Is
4uli ta Il, .4ty.,-- asl.a ulil! 10 a s-csTtAlueti
h#u ,ttIs l.au Fuial lf iAg governors oeTtla-
e-t. Do forgery. 50 = & a,rt4los o. taiseLuol.
tar ..au.s-l. 4 ga. 50 latk ~ Sd o. thv fact O.
ae logulya tlai fat .s ,a, aul-ur .! iAs law
t.l t4lNar--a- authority t4r N;ai,s uHA re-
cord - thr y,-.h ~ its election 4s oouc.us!yr
.0eH c.a4 rl.sy ua at,8uat, power iu "a D.
t.a4 t llat would aut " Hverr-ly hy Judicial
.l Us laflr.. su4 aH pacuaTy judicial pOaer-
l.fs ieus conferred lE law urou auy trllunAl
es-#Ht llH-g ilf0Esu. ia fllv -uprgus court tie
commission d. luI r#lFt. and has An power 81
a3apt methods of TRIAL iur determining the
rslla Hf individuals q gao f-s~rGf'n fFacued-
las .aEalFcs g ifsal HN jury. and the common
ias .aE.rpu.ys larfirF o. tAr commission
assuming O. E. iala suaA au irsgr Or % tho Al
legged .lga-It4Ets ~ NlmWhEes, one 90 tAe
slla s.vgiugs, thar lsas rcrl looked into ts
Gee state ga-t ssH.Hr board, Ul.eG has ~
aHiHyj hm uldeE uath sud found him g. he
I..~..+t'" 't''- ta .'. a't hi N.'t"' ~ 49,
i.s.-.- whether 20 '-n.'"i 4e 4aALA'A oI 40
'-...' ,'4', tA+i' i".' ..'-ir '+ lf..t
q a.' ..~'.,4 s-.el.5 l-"','' ,A, '..'l 'A.'gi'
e. lA' '.ifF" ai.4 iaH -aas ~ Nl t4, N'Ai. 4AN ?
tts '.'. '-a-' .-'.." "'-. .".' '''' So " -.
.'.+'' '. '-- 7-' '.'-' '.-, '.'-'.'a -,
I
f ~, ,5
YOU n.'.+ '' N'' No. .'1' ~,
-
--A t. '', ',.'+''t +.
'.'- -.
..t ~. ~. 49,. /.
..-..' "'.. '..'. .", y. ". -, I.
,. tJ ~. go ...., 49,.
~. -. ~. -. .....s -. /.
- .t+f5H 49,,
-
-. -
'+ ~ .-5. n. .i -, '..'
...., 49,. -.
...f 49,. ii!.i1 ~
5...t., ~. ~, l.,-.. 20 -
ti-' ,f, A. -. s
.' '''' - 90
81, ...-..t. r..
- ',- @ a. - - -
- -. -. -. -.
80 ''- ,. t'" "-', a. -
:" go VS. Wv ''-...' - ''.'
'N"gN .5' " 80 a.. y, \. ~. ~ !.
~ 1t'.' "..'..'' ,''-',''' '''A -, :, 4
lsgssossod q al The power ia the matter invest