New-York tribune., 1877-11-23
ACCOMPLISHMENTS

HOUSE IN FAVOR OF THE RESUMPTION REPEAL
| SENATE. WASHINGTON, Nov. %. 1877.
After the reading of the journal, Mr.. THUR
MAN Dem o. arose to correct the same, and said II
was error in showing that the pending motion, when
the Senate went into executive session yesterday was
that OF Mr. IIoar biass) TO Law the resolution to us
charge the Committee on Privileges and Elections from
further consideration of the credentials OF C. Buter
as Senator from South Carolina on the table lie quoted
from the record Of yesterdays proceedings and argued
that Mr. Hoar withdrew his motion 70 lav on the tahe
to allow the Senator from Delaware Nir Bayard) to
spcak and after that Senator concluded when he Nr
! ThurInnn) complained that the motion to lay on
The debate the Senator from Massachusetts mfr. iloa)
sid be certainly would not mako the motion aitr MS
Nir Thurmausl intimaiion. without MS hnyng IN on
noruritv 10 sneak ana It was then that the Senator
from Ncw-York tMr. COrkngl ma e the pont oi orufr
that fhe motion would no; he Withdrawn the yeas ana
! navs having been ordered a. Mr. Thurman moved
10 amen1 the Journal nv ordering OF
vcas and nays ar. Ioars motion. ana therennn Nv
Inarimous the senator from Massachusetts fdr
! IIoar) withdrew his motion" ., NOV, -
! Mr. CONKLING 0}ep. n " and others, " Oh no.
| tho record docs not show that"
Mr.. HOAR (Rcr.. Mass) quoted from the record. and
orqlcd that he had renewed his motion 20 lav on the
tablo when fhc senator from Delaware or. Bay rdl
concluded bis remarks but expressed hlnsef as wlng
o Withdraw Il for the purpose of allowing the Sthal
from Ohio (r Turman) 70 speak but ne pcnt oi "rhcr
was then ascd that it could not be withdrawn The yeas
Mr. TDMUNDs lRep, Vito Mr. Thurman-would It
be orier 20 move ~ refer yonr motion 10 the Cohl
| zee on Privileges and Electionsl
| Mr. TuTRN NAN-We viii never rot report. fLauchcrl
Mr. COEKIING sad Is there any prcterse in this
r,nted record or in apv suggestion The senate has
heard that the President submitted TO me hoy Wnlh
unanimous consent should b. given to the Withdrawn of
this motion TO lay the table and that the senate gave
| Mr THURMAN ash the Senator from NewYork II
IL ~ not the daY practice when no Objection Is
made 70 consid"r that unanimom9 consent IL event -
Mr.. CONKIINt;-I am compelled 10 say tfGt never 10
my knowledge. did occur i'm the senate or was II suS
Gcsted before that pumlns i senator % i IVY ui ~; il I
consent 10 make remarks not ~ lDe ioln1nt ~ T6l %
rcvoutic cnzqd the Journal ovcrthrew the rules ara SOD
verfed me orders Of the Senate Neverl Mt President
this proceeding yesterday WIS ."t ~ y, - & a.
am positive in affirming that was not hcedlcsS OF ac
motion Tho Senator from Massachusetts had, think,
considered IT, Oticr Senators had considered u also.
the motion wae made, in demanding the yeas ana NAYS
upon il. Ny purpose was to lt tbe morton w. aN ] OF g M
any body have hesitdt on in avO".ng my reason
for this. There had been II not ru,noIs Enslel' % %
,' .ti, for some time and which were yesterday
ptctcd 10 have ripcned into certainty, alliances relied
unun to transfer the Msicrlv from one sid' 10 nc
"iber sldei Of the senate. ! fclt it my right
70 ascertain hy tie earliest method who were tHc allies
the reserves and recruits and how mani ihey NtI. II
seemed thar a motion 20 lay on the tah'o, not being
cosiion and show how il was that inc control OF me
co"stitn,cG and ike TIE star Of Empire westward
fake IFS WAY" was quite particular ia ieioie 10 sci
ffih o. The Senate had ordered the yeas ana
uavs to De tak'n; ny Object Of course beng tn5t N IL,
forty-fouTth me cfhe nate mlghl operate Whch rue
l. u, these words ANY motion or resolution may DC
| Wit or
n decision amendment, ordering OF the yeas and
~ event a motion" ard = I speak Of my
in.a'e XXX ~" tiot f. is next TO Impossible that
such mistake permitted, rs he no" wants
D'lauere rose and asked to be allowed 20 make
some remarks and suggested withdrawal Of the mo-
ron ia l.y ON The table saw very clearly, other SEN
ators dd VINO attended to it, at thc nator from Mass
achusrs had not in his mlnd a the moment tue lolf
fluth rule nor tha fact ina; an impossible barrie, Aad
@ @r,cn Iu5 % ' brs"ary me- aIopted In reil to the SEN
Irfl Z
in,es 10 De courteous. dprb sni also Dis tuppO.
,; % 50 not NE Lad fe tIwcr 10 Withdraw. Nobody rose
infept i'm order G read rule of the senate, and every
body think knew that the mental operation ~ 'De Hth
ato- rom Nl.sac ,usctjs could not overthrow thc
,ri5s or unJo what Tho g nq'e had done. The
senator from Delaware proceeded subsequently
to Guard against thc possibility Of mistake. took occa
eon In e,ud the senate and the Chair ~ the state o.
me ouest on said: " When ths motion WIS made 20
Law tuis resolution The table senator was that
ecuatnl) demanded the yeas and nays Ine yeas and
nas were ordered Tie rule OF The senate declares that
ait.r mat no Senator can NlthdIH" moron 80 Int
taI hls Withdrawn IT, No senator VIII, think withdraw
t.. because It U be within the province 0 every oLeT
Eopo there viii be found some member OF tIis BODY
who, in the language Of parliamentary boief, WI
sbal execute it" Dl the Senator FROM ONO, any
DINER senator take ISSUE WIN thtt s,a,'eh iu any
senator set me FHht' or st Li' Nll' I'M, nv, ,.r
had ire acquescCuce Of the CHAR ~ the tlie Wien
asserted that this motion has Rot been Uithdiawn that
10 could rot De NlthdraWh tnth was lhe uhe i"f
the honorable Senator from ONO 70 insist, as he Goes
now os S'3,'" 10 act rid Of the motion to law
ON tLe table II canuot Zee amended
[ f.za
e.rotors I'm conversation. one saving " -n0ud ike
to u'ate remark" and the other saving " have oh
;cti., AID withdraw my motion for that purpose"
gy1r - litogue between two Senators actually ober-
afe ie Of the Senate. sp0ngos from the Journal
do rir has been put there by uUe-fh OF the Senate,
that the yeas and nays shall be taken aud reverse, the
III on r-ccoediug and ali UuOu the theory. must
,'nd,r.iiard it that what the Senator from
NJ, l,,s.tts Thought al fhe time, aud what
i Ia t the senator from Delaware. iS fantam0uut 20
~ Ciir ,,ro,nudiur 10 the senate another gursf,on
i cbetier i'm snite of the order f0r the veas and
@ ,,non shouid be Withdrawn bv u,Iauirnous
,i rd mon declaring The assent or dissent of The