New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1877-12-01

NAYS
nm PACIFIC NAILNOADs

I ftrr mn MsfTt4s0n, NtthefS--O
1IIR PACIFIC RAILROADS.
Mr. PADDOCK tRep. NebJ su6stiiut'1 the follow ing
rrq. II - ALLEGED that The Union pacific RaifoId Com
and Is hrslc = have negrcei aul ri u DO
t acs o. eng ss under when their construction "a' Or
a Il is alleged that by reason Of sail default and on
account oi Ire stne Ia yeflA nt OF M, i ,I, M
mys o lacir i1, and lawful 1guts and nnvi r., as siy
ate defnei aud agreed upon IN "a" "c4 aioi'''' ''
Ttj, Tia, the President tho Unl,ed states b.. and lac
mem. II am. ca-s Whch prevent rim from eNecu is as
by said Union Paoac .alroad cou,ny aaa or,3se5 WI
Tie aes stipulated aad agreed upon III ''e several
Ordered 10 he printed aud lie on the table
Mr.. PADDOCK gave no.cc in.t AZ "T I no IN. an
submit substitute lOr the resolution 81 Mt. W
t. suiici n0w pending Several DIS were lh'io"io'u
Mr. CAMERON Rop. PennJ presented a rcmonstrance
Of All tie National Blnss o. Philadelphia, cN'ap on,
aud several Trust Comp1nie "slii Tue ",, IT,
bH authorizing thc com Se 90 tilFcl u "u ~,
extent a. TIC Oinettic legal money % inc eoua5'
Ol tEe Pttshurg Chiinnef oil Oomi'Itt III .''' ~
fepcal ~ or amendments 10 the bankrupt !i" Ieiesfu
to tine Committee Un the JuhclalS'
TIE KELLOGGsFOFFORD REPORT
Tho scua.e then resumed consideration ol the res'u
ton reportcI by the Committee Privileges and Elec-
tions for tie admission Of William Pit h Hrgg "a
Senator from Louisiana for six years, from rch 4,
1877 the pending question heng on the sunsiiul "f Nj
tee on Privileges and Elections, with INSTRUCTIONS to tkc
certain charges preferred against Nh Kellogg by Mr.
Hr SALISBURY DeIn., Deli resumed the floor and
continued remarks from the poin. whore ne sus-
i.ceu members 81 The L. -isiaturc which elected XII
ogg scniOr, had not been elected ny thc people, Luz
were rsiurlcd elected by thc Returning Board. fuu.
ycns age, IN ia contested case oi - hc'
~ ~, D., iia,ts and Elections said II could not
rcide adverse to the VAL of tae people expressed at the
Gsiot-hox: but now this committee reversed that de-
risiop II wac necessary years ago hold hat
CoctlAe order to give seat 10 Mr. spencer, tc pres
cnt senator from Alabama and 1t wa, necessary 90
reverse mat docrihc tpat MI Kellogg might take
seat on tins floor. Senators The other side Oi tEo
country and Justify tncnseivcsl WHAT would I the in
mont oi tllo country NJ. Kellogg himself admitted titt
thirteen members the - ElsaiulG wneh tcctrd nm
were elected by tc people, and that was au adn-
SION winch carried upon its lace evidence oi naud Ec
DIR salisbury argued tnat the election III Louisiana
was pcacCablc and fHr There was 40 Interference On
me part any Democrat Win the Registers of Elect On
all 81 whom were republican, ana appointed by Cover
MIR. HOWE5 ARGUMENT.
Mr. HOWE CSep Wis., said tue work II reconciliation
did not seem to 90 IN this Senate Chamber In the
volume Of gs which be had listened 10 IN the last two
or three DAVIS IN THIS chamber, brothery love seemed TO
have a email part. Nj. spohord made no charge OF
,,,, AGAINST Keiioes aud the Returning BOaId before
lie Committee ga Privileges ana Etecl Ohs iH tr "a
-, S,v.u,,r allie. 81. the world had been advised that
~ rider ~ ucly the Butler c'se II was necessary to
$ir M tDen, ca said Judge sp Gord presented
his cuargr. aud oii,r,d TO prove them 20 october
ap,al,d go me record. Judge sPonor ia hIghne his
cie before cJ.nmiitee mlde cerh a. o
iaeis anu a. "yy Item Mr. Howe thea referred
10 the action oi the hc'mh'HS, "oSid ana s~ld
.IIo SV"rogI lad had ayundint opportunity to
make ,uc charges oil iiaud as1s. Ini' T''H ions De-
IrG and lid DO was more possible Tor that board 10
bJl ~ . .,d when It examined ,hr returns Of tie
peI,i", I.1G tlat II vds possible for the supreme
I'M nf lie CLcd states 60 terpoda'e rdud IN gay
.oi a., NOON a cau.e which had been argued. IL
~ t,s.iDe fOr the Returning Board IA ~ secret
! ,'-s,nn 10 blind the whoe "of,di an tue Noiiu
nov what IN figures were III Irs"rd 10 the lou'>lna
hf', re,rus and ever! body knew ol every vote eX-
! inI.i by tins board. There hdd Oeen good deal OF
tIC altiut GuVefuOr Kellogg haNlhS entered INC room
.'ls 81 nv tnc board, through side door lie tAr
/ Unyrl lad entered the consultation room q, t'e
JH1sJ%s .. s1e door, too lIs would be 1ttle
SURPRISED To- Lave anyone ni'ue au 20 'L"t V'i;t
,, IN, or some cnc else htd gone into hc room b'c'l
~ ',rat di.fiaucuiscd IN Louisiana Ma instantaneous
| n, Tie Judgment oil lrlDuha' tn"tse' ~ 'nS S
| 49," state warranted H. E'e5 D'mo.ral was us
il.ucAised account Oh ei, on' ~ ,
VINO WIS d.siranciisvd IN LoiH"Hi vac 1 ' ~
No., ~ ,ul,,tnce oI .aw, bat IN defiance oil Law 10 on
pc''Iu %, az crime he nad committed bul ~ cs'me
ana ~ , s,!I, iDeu. GaJ asked If dsirc.e-
uirut o citzus cd Louisiana was ot III Elt,IVI =" TIC
inely-iouh a.uct oi IN to'''i'H'i' OF ne S'''' in
fIrfHOWE ,.td tine is"laa cAa'eu ~ s'"'"'' anu ~
IL, "rutHI n,rp. Gal arsuod that Judge sponvId
made certain charges a-lu,t ONerhos he..oss IN" OF
f.r.d 10 prove tntin iA Octoncf' ne Zen u"u i I,
lowing tecSfaII, which he s"ii hau o,'h n'''u'u MN
Today NEwORlEus November 20.
~, ION J.. JOIN LIE: ,epce here in Kellogg. Office
UFEl
| sponold. iN""i - MIN MIN
MIR. PATTERSON on TIE sOUfhLRN FoLICl'
Mr. PATTERSON Q.cp. :. CO said Ia maintaining
the title of MI Butler 10 seat In this body only 10
cogizs the logic political events. Those events
were not the result OF any act OF mine. Thy were
mould by the hand OF another. IL IS unnecessary Tor
me To review ia detail lie causes tnti cd u iht as
suned trunph OF the DC nocraIc party IN s'uia Caro-
| Lima az last general election ~ was, III NV
Judgment. triumph OF might over right l. WAS ho'
won by any just and lawful methods Known g. AN
elective system OF government To achieve IL Htt
crashed la The NON grasp Of armed Ioicr.
This " A. NY Judgment February aud March i's ana
blrcd upon testimony srt FORM IA mtinDiai sem ~
| Congress : gucd by tue kriu' lean state tnclal-
and senator. ald ReTpSt natVrs ia bcHcfai Assembly,
That memorial Wa, aio before tie President immediately
att MS iu .ugurtUl GuFtrhor Chamberlain htl III tAt
Executive - .lartIcit abOc argument IN -utlhil
of ilr Drnp sIUu thai It contained, uud NiuMhodr a-
mOiy 10 sutiu iis allegations a. 10 matters oi t''
When Il became Known that thu President contemplated
fuc removal Of the troops from the stat" iiousr, Il
Thrill Lorror went thruagh tht hearts o. tbt
| Republicans Souin Carolina, ana thei tioMuou
| the National Cpuol To make solemn lIo', !
| ana earnest appeals again an act Whicl
they were bound 10 hihd as tho foniast behyhel ana
most uudcstrycd aud untuic{ wrong OF NAlrh ir l,
foiy of political parties furnishes any record lMit hhn
ignorant and uulrtcrc ~ the graf mass =" SUM" Ho
ina pubican. may De- they yet loyal aud true Ia
principles OF the Republican ptly, hd III war
and m peace thcy had gathered around the nag o TINS
All the den OtOa Win Whcl thc dtNol NAll
Il ton clings To the cross o his keueemc ~ i'op"v
cans tbey had never ed their trust and they dd
not xprct themselves tO De betrayed through t'sbi
Ipne wears they had been hunted for their opinions
sake but tncy held their faith unchanged, nnd asserted
it nv their ballots with ine Xibe ndcy To their party
Tney know enough love their Government ai aust