New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1877-11-29

obarre Judge sno ford said the facts had recentv
TO his knowledge He MT HUI appealed TO everV scna
tor the door 10 sink the partisan tOr m lment.
and not deny the right 90 this contestant 10 tax bs
mony which no court 90 earth would refuse him. Mr.
Kellogg here to claim the price ol his fraud
he here 20 ask that this Senate would give eject 70
that fraud. committee had been appointed 10 * lin
inc an such cases and Ibis committee said 90 We have
taken 20 much testimony about Returning Boards that
Mr WADLEIGH said the Field committee took tesd
Nr NIL said the Field committee took testimony IN
regard the Electoral vote thar closed and so ar
as he was concerned 10 should ne closed forever. .
Nj MCDONALD dem, ind.l inquired 0i the senator
from New Hampshir Mr. Wadleghl II he did not know
that the members 0i the - e'h hetu.inHs LoaI Ic
fused to TESTIFY before tAe hou7' commute, nun '
not summoned before the Senate committee last winter
Mr.. MCMILLAN said hey were examined 1y the field
Sir. NIL, resuming called upon any Senator to Pn'
bis hand upon any testimony already taken AZ I'd sr
Kellogg completely with tue Returning Board, as Judge
sp,',a on reg - prove, ~, eo,,, % - fact
M HILI-Dd anybody before ever hear nudge tel
cant prove ina. even il give VOC perm sson"i Address
ing Sir Mem Ian. He said; How d. you know 20 never
Mr. NcNIILhN-I was there for n Iona time
Mr. HiLL-Wol, did not know that before; we VIII
REMARKS, he sal senators should NOT Pm a. judges TO
decide the rehts between uarlies aud say they "oail
noe let tem take proof Mr. kellogg d NOT prele hu -
ms Board lie admitted that three Of the mem beers Of
the STATE senate, rctlruol Is elected by at ooa " w.
elected hy ne people II tAs should be proved was
lie iii fora senator in tlIs body. Would senators sa{
q Returning Board 90 elect himself 10 thr 1endlti
Would they such man in this body 30 certain VIC
ire committee FIRST that % wOul have 10 take 'esllno
That the chairman applied 10 the senate ana GOV au-
"a oin issue 10 refused TO tae testimony. II Governor
kellogg should bee convicted OF these enaige' u @'e
NOT ouJ close TIE Senate % hm' nul "o.u .l 10 tre
peni,eutarv 20 him. Tie cases were referred 10 tue
committee for the purpose Of inquiry mo Az ne lac
tora count: he did not want one particle OF
testimony ON that Subject but me- aia VANS ' ,c
aided countug in three senators AMI ten ntnnerS 81
pres. purpose Of aaknc him senator The LEGISLATURE
which elected him did single sct for "LcE ihet
disbanded and some. Bat oh! saio his fr,nl on tne
o.her sac OH ,Le NnanI.oI - " w. ,s e,r
cocred by Governor Ke iogg for the purpose of trains
plu ing him TO tne senate, that he might msroirrsrnt
take man 300 With the CLARKE ringing do thei ear. thA
Le Was llr author OF tlc fraud wl-cu cent nun 49,
H. ro,id p1l he frr.i H. was tie frt r.me that
he tNr Hui ever heard thai "a man .Ec heior-
S.u- ne. I'm. lI JILL & fr I mere VAS no
concentration. sna Tor which .her' WAS no excuse lie
-Iet. cald. fD hrcth through ii- on. stal.Iei
crust of NV his, and e.t to the sound honest truth
90 ask t.r ~puf.t give AIm hisT Ndf4 Al li- IH>lf
ina the kellogg case was never made the comm. ttee
lui alr q certain motion had been made in tue senate
When direct char e. of crsoua fraud D. mace nJ one
of line contestant. m the presence OF the other Eas
tie duty of the senate o. allow MIN % take testimony To
Mr. WADLEiGH sad he had listened 20 The furious
appeal O his friend from Georgia. with good le1i oi
interest, because Dc showed how great NOISE cYu- Doe
made abuu; a small matter he drought rLe senator
from Georgia vas not Unsettled u stating ai thai hc had
taken 10y the Senate committee. OF which senator Howe
chairman tic Citizens committee, of which -ena-
tor sherman WIS chairman. and Ac Field anu Morrison
committees OF thc House 90 Representative. y! argued
that this testimony covered all The essential pI2ts i the
case, ana T mat reason Tie committee i-'i-Ht ii "ehl
not 90 consume the iiine i hearing more 2, ia -,.
Mr. HoAk hep. Mass also spoke o. iHe ''est- ga
t,n made ol tnese comni,let ana ,ia ta1' S"'-g
~.ohor himself so FIRST was mot % favor on iaAlS any
more test nnuuv, dnd lie ceIuilhb l-ilHai WIN "i