The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1877-12-15
COW N0DORE WANDER BILT.
MI, OPINIONS or CORNETTiS y. AND
uJIyItU N. As tsINfSs MEN.

"e"' NV" ~" 80. -,
Upon the rcop'uinE ol thc N"nhcrpilt VIII
.,,, s,,rr,ont. Calvin -cstcrdny Mira
case j. 'o'' "a, 49,. H., ,..., -, r, ,,,,'
Jennie panior'n ''s''''u VIZ" S"o was "' ''in-
NV Ne. Vanderbilt f,pourn,ly willie there
an saw y" 70 ''" -. -, al. A.,
Tic first three ngn'7 -h' WIS N"ho WIN 'o
r..,u,,i,r. almost the whole time. aud Hftcrthat
,,.nti, nlnnr with him. At other tines
wa IT. '''' ,.'. ,,i mi NJ m.
SIR D. Forrest the nurse LiNlV' "ud MI' Dun
o.n who as..stld ia the magnetic treatment
49,. C,mm.loro
v,r' WIN '"' oo''' '''''''o ,,,,
M,--rs Lord and Clinton enjoyed a protracied
.,,ollle ns TO whether evidence could bo adj
,,.l,i.h rossfJv Ind "A medical bearing
or which might have applied to Me-. Vanderbilt
influencing the Commodore ut a period remote
i""' .,lh,., 80 bfs ,viu mud ,hs c,dicu
rom NV "'''N".s ,,.i'.,, ',,i,I r,,, ,,.,1onco
thereto Surrogate CALVIN ruled that evidence
.neh n- proposed. tending to show influence.
- .t,.i.siiJc anil nvcrrulcd Mr. Clintnn's
direction. Then cN-Judgc Comstock and Mr..
r,,uton both argued that In the cont e-tani-' allie
O'n''" ,'" . 49,, ,,a,,,o1 no y,
cations MrS' ''n was "1' "'''',,
~. ',,,,,. c,,,c,,. cor',rniny her wa. in
ev"S' "'" 49,. -. ..,',,,.,.o1 ,,r.,lI,.
admissible ana the former cNi''s7'u 'l.''p
his disgust AT the constant attempts to force in
.,i.i,,o, ,,,of.,sa.dlv c,rroborntiye. when there
N'''''.S ~. ~! S,,.r,,o,, - lyin
said he hoped counsel did not propose to play
.t,t,, t.,. -, introdu,.i,., this sort Of owl
.n' p''"ui '"r. .,,,,,'I,,,J ,,u,,in I'm
dence' without they rVhV'nhp'"'." '""'"h :"
other evidence OF which II should u" cprropO-
.s,i,s rv,dapce concerning Mrs. Vanderbilt.
rauNe' H'''o"Vv NH, ~,
he decided would not be admitted without She
WAS mentioned If the contestants allegations.
Al. t,,l commanded TINT If the contestants had
WI H''' ~ - =. - -. -,
known, Wh'h the ull'~ lNl'H0 N'Ie vI ""n' WI"
they now know Mrs Vanderbilt would have
- moi. a., marty 'rhov unw nronosed ne
"n "',' 49, - ,o'.1 -. ,v..,
sac '' SnoW u'a' shv N"s H"n"'n''u " VIM
H. Vanderbilt 70 influence the Commodore.
!, 80, al, i.a,,,.,s T., ,ri,,, .ho UNA o,,i,l,d
"'', -,
10 under inc VIII anu 'oul'il "uoruruhh opp"r-
mnty for protractcd wrarglc between
"'se's O'''.Vn INV w ~ w. W
"m'h inc 'a',rr c'alh'u .i'e ilsn' 10 "ii'ehu ',e
'.,,i, rhn't,,.s M, 80, -ir,,,,, AGO.
un' ". ",n. ~ N""'n',is "V' V" ~, ".N ~,
tbs 10 hNry three-hanl"d game OF dlit'r'nre OF
,vinions was played between the Surrogate and
- III AL rD,,,, ,,.,,.. ,,h H.. nj
nv ~''''','' "a ,'..',,.
dne an'cthS clr'ums'ah''s h'teeh mohths
uost. rior to the maxi ing Of tho codi1il was not
hoo remote TO proye IN, exercise Of undue in
e NV ii ~ t,o W. ,,'nJ HMM, ,rhr
H "gI,n,,n b.1 cl,ar,,,,,,i1.I NJ ~
w., ~" IN, ~" ,l ~, h. t,.. H. hor.
Irt'W ~ tu,uhE Xxx fa,t H. ~ p ME y,
anu ~ iN,1 nau ~ ,.' ',V,'' n., Il
t,rr,,lot C.,,,n ininrf,rnd bv NC ina, ~ 4 sci =
slr2 sS SHvn h ',os pg Ss 1cI
,, lo,b sii s,t.riJ inrn,ai eS'aertinr.. Ia IL
i.i H. ho .,t ~, n VI flniin, H.
st,, ~ ynnjarhiit's H. ,iu.noa over IA" (',m
moioS xrpied to ny SIR { inioni AMI would
9,rn ova,. hie dongh,nr taVi- hson k.tt IRON,
KIN .'.v,.i,,j =, bv Mr. Tamil MI '''"'
rrp,1.,~ 80 t'n''s ~, GonnininrN vas rnr,-eI
H. ,,t tbipgs H., ,.v,,nss,.l hirns,iit v,.rv
im a.. IrH ut'nEI, ne ~ t'ss't ",, Nit ky
81, r"f,atn {, ,ivin1r1n, IL siri.ken ont.
n'.' I't,t',, it,, W. IA 1t -
- ~ -, j. .,. ,.t. ,,ni.r ~, NJ
VI3I'reilt Iii III" must carry ONT in" doafnr's