New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1877-02-06
PRICE FOUR CENTS.

] 49,
thereby makes II part Of the evidence b fore the COM
mission and our learned frcnd Jude BIlck ma, pro
their and efforts common law courts aud whom nc
has been good enough to designate as snapp"faloes'
this evidence s by authentic principles Of Jurisprudence
made evidence by tbi, attachment 10 the ceftsate.
| he instances bills in equity which m"y have
exhibits part OF the into the possession ~
the court n there were no objection the ease sad 10 .
provided for the OF Your authority is not pre-
duced. n The objection is made however lnarhcal or
Important tle ease has arisen but tue Objection hdt-
ami limits and provides the issue. aud the law upon
which your jurisdiction attaches Is pure fabrication oat
Of utterly unsuhsantial and lmmateral sa22eso3s IN
the law. Certainly II volunteer Directors on one se or
The other were permit ted - Law down the issues aud a-
duce the evidence aud make up me pack'2S o. te eh
dence IT would be strange commitment Of great a'i-
thonty to casual to rash 10 disingenous sngE sohs;
50 much. think. entirely dsp0ses OF the question Oh
! what there is in evidence here.
now DEEP INVESTIGATION MUST GO.
M Eyar;s said ne found himself then entirely upn-
peded the OF the question, open 20 him
as to the Commission, whether any evidence can he
cevcd, and If so. what He called attention
/ TO the memorandum OF Nr. o'COnor, presented
| on Saturday, and said that il excludes from
| tie OF consideration one OF tho GER
catcs to wit that which contains the vote OF the Til
den electors that they need other proof concernng H.
and it j. mentioned only that it may be excluded Sec
Cldy that proof in regard to the quo war;
ranto suit would need only reach the point Of proving
the precise hour OF day the 9th which the writ
commencing that action served, and on our part,
perhaps prove that appeal had been taken and was
pending from that judgment. Mr.. Eyarts then read
from the fifth point of Mr. OCOn0rs memorandum 10
show that the only exrancous proof the Tden electors
need RELY duly authenticated copies OF the state
canvass and the from four disputed counties
He continued:
Now it is proposed therefore the matter extraneous
that il is desired introduce and that claimed b. opon
10 your consolidation not that the eei Ga 10Y.
falscs the fact he has 70 certify TO- not that 10
a,cs TIE record that makes the basis OF the tact wcn
he % certify to. but that the record 20 The neo On
which by law he was to base his cericate departing
penetrated surmOuned by cytranc0us proof showing
that by matter OF substance in the progress or
Is say that somewhere IN the steps between tno
deposit Of the ballot IN tie boxes at the precincts ana Tue
original computation Il the contents Of those bONe-
- ne I,rsrii,ct. nm. cauyassed II their own
yas-ers Tie state caHyasers, or IN the action OF tie
Stgr canvasscrs in the h"al computation 81 the
rates 10 ascertain the plurality Of i0r or
the other cauGGeS and declare, and so make record
Of aud So tx the # thc Governor, whether that
act rgI wrong or their part, fraudulent or err
rOneous III law ar la tact, tAt somewhere Id 'A. rocres
matter OF ri4h and the question ~ rghiin ' or title
de JYc, there has cecurged matter i"r ldtc.d con
End how"ver Tented Tie step 10 be taken beyond The
record n c state canvas 70 seiFe me hl ana 90 ac
egmlsu the justice Po.ufed ny ihc learned counsel
or th- obi rt,s against tho Hayes cert 1caio,. the ID m
cplc upon which i. oacr, Ie occasion GCired il,
tolerated %. would carry 10 20 whatever point Ia, c3Ifec-
t.,,tG 1Il M once tnnrc rr, relieved from any dis
customs SO practical ~ tli- case except so tr ~ mus
49,. .iI,l I'D 'r,- m any
say, v-ej.er H'yrrn"Is caftli'''e c4'ud 1e ~
- fi,5 m r,r INC b.iia !, 4. ycrnr,', c.ri, i.
rt,l-...af IS coming n ra. u % Goycrl.rs carncate
aut .'cahl, down a- no Governor ctI .!c|c' 4-'s
j. !.. ,i 4.'. ',H !" ., Is, tt Ir.,Cr a. f,,qr-,
cert ics- Is rrirca or ay form or soatn.tv CON
Nenrss o. ar ucnucti" forged rarr should ps
,r ,'t eitot o, 5' =, ',I lr te rerti
eau. rs t3s 5ge.nt-', cer.cate tAat act OF 1872
requires. It's Neither es tAer proposition suggest
I .
Governor t,la substance tnaJ his certificate Is
Of tzirncols yg5nc5 TO sh'W that the TACT
to be certified d GiscOrtauL with tie Ccrtlu-
cate and tia tie facr must prevail over J.c iulelpo-
lated false ccfiiNct Oh VI. l-e 80 .il 20, i,C
care from tiat Pc 90 @ ft ~ ,, ~ ~ " ~ ON,
aek your assent 10 ts q mn ,l't VIZ! %, "
srgSS requires tlis e.rincae as 10 iEe ,i u le4s1s
"a .,rtic. tlt c,.i -t,4e End sep tie process Of
tie g rie''A D2 peer .. @ tat tc t 70 c cert
tii VA. m mo- a,g,rf-uty % introduce eytd.uce tho
e ~ ,... b'r, .,rt. .d without d.,-li.c. there
frr rc - tal vac ,r or 10 there might be
n ' ti 'z...Ieru, .l..of:o ialsIya Governors GER
~, ,t ,-'r an Il. r,i,d of MS spurious c'aracter OF
~, ... ,,it OF he falsely .oi u- tne fact pso.esscd
.t.r.f agultitug tie Governors cert dcato TO 10
, ,,.i,fii ti,, c,,y;,,. a. 81 record On Which ho
M, 40 Illr tbjs ministerial tac,ion 10 accord with
In. di,ai. oil H. and tat Won stage oi inquiry
ne. ' 49, ~ -,,.I,-r.ior . h. trcaIur IL, Govern
anu o.. 49, ~ I nal ut . l..f. on tae record
brflr. hiu-fo Wit the cumpoFcd t.ccuou-you are now
~, ~,t. .. a,err.r, i srl. "a, matter II PROOF. Oy
,ucn tet-oIS as 'Ao 80" -S-'H''' anu wan '' ''0
l0 rrsor.Arrr!C ,T!o-S OF ELECTORS.
t... in en-, I,...,t,, ma .l,ot
There Il, one G'Aer suggestion iii inc o' -'' ANA '"N'
Il, about eXiraueogs proofs that Nr Humphreys. one
~, 49,. .,..+..n. t.,l1 ,rl.o nuIor ID. Tpitad
"' 'l1o 44', = wv 81, -. -
states ana ID ol' D'l"'l il - '''N '"7- -
learned coun,c that might Introduce evidence that
NJ HUM trs had RESIGNED The i,terJasit!ou OF This
..... -. .. Co... ,. ,-.,. d., ..,, ~ IN,
Og-ciloh was sIriT'- 1' ~ 'V+ II "'' " ''''' "a "
dry before the Florida state tavaSsng Board On the
m dow f T,oca,n,ar = gn!cecdcnt 20 thpr ua and
t'N ''"' " ~, -. ..,. ? ,. al.
conclusive cuF lse' am i-' s.l'I ." W. ,i 80
20 read ltuil page - '. l'-e ' 81 49,. ' ''
polt OF lle minority y' .t 'V Nm