The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1877-02-15
TIE VOTE OF LOUISIANA.
sYf,IIT VfKE 4 PRESIDENT BY TOR-
GIRr md TR.fID?
un,tcriy Presentation or the Democratic Cnse
to the Electoral Tribunal by es-Scnnt"rs
carpenter aud Trumbuii stoughton aud
shriilbnrgcr for Hayes Arguments

,,.-.....,... -. A.. v,......a....,. s,....
hn"''N ,',.c,o,,, ,T,,,,,n,, NV .,.scn,,,,r.
,r,,,r,.r and rrumbuI, stouah,on ,na
.h.i,bnrucr for unye.-Thc a ruument.
-,
Wl-HiNGVoN, fcb li.-lhcre was more
'N go, - =.
tau i'r several Gays past' chi'hy oecaus' II
was Known that Mr.. Carpenter and Judge
,..,..i.,,il ,,..rn g., arsok Stp.a tbn onnniny dn
IN IN .,' ',',.'' "p.,''i'''
lU 10 lh' lorlua 'uSo no such uaScilninE's
Of miics and Congressional celebrities have
~ ""' ''H ' '
90 interest wis malh'aiheu' Mr 'arp'h-
tr took up the thread OF his argument
I,.r, 4, ,.l t.,,o 1,,,,,,od ON ,,o ,,r,,,,,,,s
N"''' "", "''" "i'iP'r Vn ''v y, ''v"'
.vcning, and in a speech oi forty minutes re-
lf"rnlnE .., Board and overwhelmed the com, NJ
A -iD n with logic and authorities TO sustain
iiy of the oaso as ndyan ed 10y tho Demo
.... ,i,,+.rs 1n1,o T,,yiuu ,h,,
'"' .' us ""uHo ii"iii"un 'r'n
oHtit'd TWO hours IN re'itng What
. l.mp.r ratio counsel were preparcd TO
II th. onr,rtuni,,, WA ,,ivan ,b,.p, ond
al l.- .i~-,n- the unconstitutional character
and .uui. tfon of the board. their violation of
. .r ti. ,,,v,ss mad. of ,bc ,.,,.,
" '' "'''"'7 "'"" ~ NV wy .
lN. HliNN il' ln"lgihilily oi TWO electors. In
tu4-, oi his long and mastcriy
..t.. .,,,nt,,l Ia II -,
TOO %" 9P'""'t S"S'"'",r HIS 'l'"S va
.ri .-.li government which had boon set up by
... o.. irut ny freely from the cDulcmua-
..h. ,..,,,,,,,,...I la. S,,,,,rs IA
y" ~ '."'''Ois ~ 'u-
b. Hui Morton and Representative llOar.
f Uu..u,-r was re.itel with gront
-, II had boon given mt n Time
.n ELECTORAL Commissions were un-
i-it Of and there were no partisan
..-,i'r.tons 4, prevent their cXurossIn n. nm
t..-f fUiIniuu of Kellogg himself and the Rn-
,rf o.. HtrJ nnI tiin '.urfs from which ho
trt,I his rr.t.nied titl@' Judr" TrmmbmIl
,.t ,,n,,fi ,iv ,,.r thr ,,rr,,nT ,vhich h"d
IN covered IN recent inSestigntions by the
III ,,n. tr r',,I, ., h"nr "n Tho Nrnhler, IL
,runnr'.I TINT Morton Ind branded ,hn derisi1n
81 'rtI,i,i Ilur.u a. MS 81 ,,r,ss usurnn,i.n
NM E,fmnnd- hni us,i NH his nn,vers ~ inv.','
-,'i,,,t ~. n.,~rni,, iairJ Min ,,,,
sr' n .ltr in MS t1sk.t had knorknI f,-
., .'fl. nt tho door nf the small .nI ha.r
~.u.,i uinlitt.nc. hy the le"d"rs n1
. laliv: That Uoar Ind nronoin..i
E .urt. ur E~nrl uurhinnrv IN, I an is9ana
lU. ti-ituiiomal: ami. in brief. that the Vital
t.. ms nf i,rpuhienn CLAIMANTS fnr M,
,,on n', III n, h.lu ug a,,,, yV,i,',Issi@ ,,
.f.., af,.n e,i, .ietl.nni In uni1ansnrnI
''' ia "'''''" "a SN
T.i.-;nnn question. rs Mr. Stoucb,on
'c .I,,, if.,lt Al thS H.. ..inuin, - liz
al.i run-l-.nn So NH n So that ths
Ia counsel -e.n tn realI,,. me- Iuri.,n
80, .lrt,. In tt..,,'tting an, br,n..si a i.I IL
N- iii D.,t'.,.,r,ti Ia. ,,.,nr al liz,
ID 'f.-,i.Ir sflt.r. IL. r,i "A I'M 80,
r...ri,i -i,l, which Is nj w,'il iakrn
..-f .tt4 r.t e.l'-,if itinnni in tb~ nr.t
uDf f,.g.l rnt,-fiti,t ..t,t,lIy -
...f -t,f.i.. .,. tI.. ,nnnr.r nf ,,n, - - -
p,Iff,-. aai If IN. thr,.., rsl-
-.t'l ar. mot str'm, on'ui,h
90 irurn iI.ir a. iTn iL@rs
-. t.,.. ..0ar... 'nf Lru,Drv. II is .i,n ih,y,i,t
.IIl ...fi .a.in-rl nr, nj n loss how H.
.f l nIu..tinn. They ,oul.i Dis ms !
rl. ..-. "A IA soma show .f .nru ~
..r tH. minority for Ild.n on the
.f III. T. '.lfus ,,n- ms nothing conn
,tnl With tie a.knowledsni MAJOR
rs in Lou -iann, and the frauds Which
un-.l lrunis. ro prove were in this ease
ID sf for
n ,y.- Nsrc evidently restless last evening dur
Leth. uo,vrrful presentation mude Iy Mr. Car
- ntrr. bat their iis anmlittre was more clearly
shown today when they attempted To- reply on
They rnuid not ailord 10 admit fraud and i
WIS out oi their power 10 isprC ve il or to show.
thai IA. hourd hid rrar he'd ain honest verdict hy
lrgal and honest means. All they could DO was
g. plant Themselves on the tcehnicality that
when "a Stat. onnirrs any judicial lO,y,.rS ON "A
-f Oi .m,n and provides Tor no alipoal from
fI..r y l'eI-ion. tho tribunal clearly had no ntl-
i.lr.fy tp Investigate much less t. reverse this
-.ou.
ilr - Ighton. smartirg under the iulg-
Z. .ft-N Nl4rh hi- own party leaders had pro-
tl...l upHu Kellogg and his Whoi" crew, fclt
l upon TO Introduce his defence with n
t.r. w .lN p.u"gyrir of Durcil rs an upright
d.. i-,-. nut uuting the subject wa, too grand
lHrN.- NNtrs lc abruptly shifted his linz OF
lf-.Il.Nt aui hrunrhcI On into a more gonrrul
f-. nf Rrpuhlicnn sm IN I0ui-inuu The