The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1877-05-25

,,x rUy yysTRY or 4 TNIJFRS3L-
~ Sr eJJfRoH ~ NEU lOHk.


., Failing the Other n Liar
,. brethren Appinnding and the bi'''-
,,,. committee Laughing The Anomalous
,r,,,i Of the Rev Charles \. Mccarthy
r,,,rial ol the Rev. Charles T. Mccarthy
canned vest rday before the Committee
r.,i,line OF the state Universalists' Con-
..,n. The Rev. Mr.. Mccarthy and his nc
r ths Ecy. T.. c. Swcctsrr again forgot
n.,..',es. The Rcv. Mr.. NJ Carthy called the
g., MIR Swc.isrrn liar. and the latter g"ntlc-
r,, rNalia,rd that the former had told false
la Some " the spectators stamped their
tarI 0lHpptd their hands. and wcre rcproved
II, ae NJ ,lerator. That gentleman tried hard
n -a,vl and look severe. but now and then
H.. .,un,enanoc relaxed in spite OF his Efforts.
Whenever the Moderator laughed the other
members Of the usually scdate Discipline Com
ml''.e laughed also
Tne Iey. Mr.. NJ Carthy charged that the Of
r.,l secretary Of the Discipline Committee had
Int an erroneous record Of the proceedings OF
v,ine-.lny and that this was part Of plot
l. make his cnsc NJ black as possible.
Mr. O. Ma Adam. having been called for cross-
examination .tcstinedthatthc Rev. Mr.. NJ Carthy
w.. dismissed because the congregation were
dissatisfied with his conduct as a minister.
The specification In the charge accusing the
p,v Mr. Mccarthy oftrying TO divide the Biceck-
r Ircct Univcrsalist congregation and to draw
~ mo members 10 the" New American Church.
& ph he had established in the neighhorhood.
,-tricken out 10y order of the Moderator.
Tia -pecineation was regarded n immaterial.
rnot frivolous. II WIS conceded that it was no
lr,'h ~ proprieiy for preacher to found a
'rn. Rev. Mr. Sweetscr tried to show that the
rr.i y the NV American Church - IL not
fual rnivcrsali-m.
i''r-i. IN alton In tho charge that tho Rov.
NJ earthly had violated the chr -lipn rul" in
9 NJ {, the courts Of law t. settle his gricv-
Gn - aeAlust the trustees of his church WAS
eir.. Arn nut ~ unimp pIrtant
s,' nm tones said II chargo h. l,'y Nlr M
tlr,iv with wi,k.dnnss and di-loyalty IN say
into me- that If the suit at law which he then
ipAt,nrd - bring against the Blccckcr Street
Church ilr salary which lie claimed lis tu'
81 Mi cone INTO court, 1t would ruin the
'Th- R.y. Mr. Mccarthy demanded iha, his ar-
c-or -p"liy il" language that was termed
Th4 Eey Mr. Swrciscr said: | am the only
witness Tn" Ian 'uugc WIS used hy tn" u'-
rl,,i ~ the door of ny house. H. nude angry
H. ~ how t1 make. II sMllns his arms Nio-
ln'y nnl -pok. loud lie said IN d, Threatening :
manner that II he sued the chur N the chur N
v.uldhr ruined Il was aderided threat On his
Iar. aul regarded it as such"
T4, Rev. Mr. tatny interrupted With, !
Eui tr- rhur d. would hc ruined. hut II wis "A
wrn'ns.wl ID guN. in "a spirit OF brotherly
I'4'. anl anl ID n, III .,rV -t,,t,,.,,1,ho,,hap, p,,.
~ ~ ~. ~ ,'','''''Vu ''''' '''e Az
81 ~ w Nvi' -. ", H." ," ',.,
~ Il s'.' -, ti''.f IL A., =, ,,. ,-,,, ,r.-,
80 ".N. W, n i.,," 9'' YOU were
III I,nr ~ II ~, -" -. Nv ,.o,, dil ,,I ali
AIN, r '' ~ r,r ,rJ ,,, a,' ,t., a.,
VIII u,,r u Ss. xr,,,,,
H. + >. H.. H.. :, ~ ir. u','i !. ,,, ",
- w. =, .',,inS !ar't'7S ~ ~ w.. '."i No.,
-l a,-,rl 'u,' Nir' Swee'ser mas i''u' ana
VI u, ,Hi nf.N' II Y m. ,,., -,.., =,
~" h''r'''9t Ahere' there' h0"-tnht Is
erru- Il. NJ .c..,,,. o,,,,-,-, ,o.
tnr !" ~ ir. VI. VI ,.y ny iii' 1 nu11r 1r a-
r1'' "' WY "''us "e "''''''' "i' Hr HAS
III D.. NJ NJ Ntc,..h. ,,,.,,., ,,,,h,..t
ntNh 'i ". rvdnrss anu ii-lpY"iN hc
s'lA. .u'' IN nhl alt.r h.cr1y dispute 'h'
s'r, Z. ., "n III ii w n' IL a, a, b.. N. .c,.,t.
t,i iD" ',''9 ~, ,n ~ ~, ~ H,,nS
tttrb , H. ~. ,, 'ii.,r. ~, H.. ,, .,
siih Ia bo f,,t" i,-,it,,' ,',,.t- ,.l., ~
ira. .io,yn tiat ,tul S.,i.L.,'- Win.