, 1877-11-23
THE CHICAGO
WHISKY.
Messrs. Ju.ssen and Bangs Clore The
Talking In tho First~Batch
Cases.
Judge I1lot1gett's Remarks to the
Jury---Tlse Twelve Still
Out.

The arguments Of counsel IN the c!sll case
against Noe3lc, Junkcr Il Co., wcrc resumed
yesterday morning, Col. 1uctsen leading oil for
lung n'ld iulty IS v'rofpns as that with which
hc onehca the case tic Other fiay. lie ffsEtcd,
Of cullrsc, that the Government lad pro,ntscl
ths c,uinnn,s absnlutc ess,, AMI er,u,tr.i ,r'.n,
u,,v A., r,r..~., :. -. ~. ..".s". ''''
nv" ."u ca y. 'e''et" 10 Lie testisn"hyo VI
nen aver u hiio~ t'lat n flupe waa held out to
the whisky incn oil throuEtI,-that in the end
they wuuld come ott all right, rhc Colonel
also toucbc1 an W1rt J,.rtrr. whom hc notr,r5
=. ~ unfur,,uo,a s,,,, s,'. ,"a. nv p..a 49,,
s,,.. ~ ~" "p''ftuoa.c = Roo sent eo~h from the
oIyl"h'an heights so dwell awhile With
If his nature and genius. The CO..
nno, had = crco, ,,co, -, eax o,n',
ns.a,,,. " +,.,. iii. s.'at .sa' W sa5 anoh.
.seas',,s s', 'a.n WIN tnc sluea1efa anu exposed
the other side TINT the Government had rjrbt
IN rcs,tnf1 n. agreement vii, ,ho.o ,,ht.Lr.
ncr rn.r ,.o1 10 IL, .uo, .,,t,.,. ~ H. a.m.,
1n,. w! .. ~ =, ~ a"." =. '"' astsm
LOUIS Al ,"neh IL was said LINT virtue and fattl'
might hc nstrf''utcs Of the people but were
wholly unknuyyn 10 Statesmen, and pultttc,sns.
l,ut vim wt,td rrncrt IN ,,n,1 s,,., n t,,,, If
moral degradation IN lie nineteenth csntury'
in this rrcst l,euubiicl ivbn c,,, eits"if1, III u.
slnmkc,l NJ nr.ariW .,,r,, a ,u.ittn a.v,cntn, H.
I,f,f, nj lin hivhcsf rn,tts in H., Innri ill.,, H.
CoIonci also t,alI ii. respccts 10 Cot. Motthcws.
a,y,,sInr lin, f,i In ying trnktr f,;t, viii. H.,
w}iskycn nTtrr i,o lad unitrn ti,",. ~ ;. c,a,,
IN. u nntt nitcr hr hal us,tl thcn, lu III, srtI"r
willie at, this smhirr;s thc f'nur1
even went NO fsr ox IN '" sav
that Matthews jad .rupeI tic defcu,,ants
in nu,i jf,rt n rotnt,,o,, ..,ni11emrn ,un,. i,"1
G1uk"cu @ ti,e ,nr,, ,sinm i,e iai homlwntaG nis '
Thu Colonel ,f,,st,i hr ..n1iin,r unot, lin. trr -,
deal fairiy viii hls tiI.ntx. "T' ''~ jay :"
1ttD0g HANGS
c,osr1 f,r ,l. f,,vrrn.nc,,t il .,,+tna ~ ,.,,t
-. 49, ~ va"
iust nu,l nft,:rw nr,ls trarkrtI hv ,n w,r Il III,
lied grass along thc wuy. TIN. ,i,,.lv. aisn ~.
icrre,l to tle power Ut Ayus.z to takc llIe lu,a
Vi q sii nl.d from It drsw n correct p:cturc "i
tI,r w;n,ln or,,nnlsu Whv In. ,nu,pnn..oti Il,
tb{s way, tho i,try were eynlrntty nj a t.,,s IL
rntrrst1t nui lie t,lfyo iii n,i ,nv it"n, ~,
Gy rnieayorinr to c1tiafr' Thr,. H.
ljangs alluded to Cot. Jugsscu ns "tnc
brilliant urutur yrutut.n i,"nnar,i swmi
wus described a. m t,i1y. wills. xIt,tlr ,ipl,.
mnt.1 Wirt l1e4tcr ~. !" NM, ~ cre,,s,'tp1;,r
i,I stau,itng, lie tfeti.al thai lI,1tsr hn1 W.,
ai!oat ti'c fact That lupe was hcli cut 10 the
torturinr Tic wor,1s .ti,. i,nr"rn,ncnt sI 1coi
ienen,lyr intn ,nroni,mr a ,1rs"t HAL ~ n."r'
than ti;cy really did incaf.. Tic Judge tnes,
sHt VI !! oysS @ sonssfIs ,.l S st il,c testimony u d.
entered into wn. tlpt n.mir viii, I'm f;nvrrn.
ment rnntrl nj 11.t,cr:r ufc" .nt ny t''st ~.
terms ii that nrtccnr,t nrnvi,lr,i si,nniv fnr
criminal, u,lI uot fur .iyit, Immunity. p' ~
,rt,ur n,.1,m,Hrr
III charging tho ry. sn III. .a,,sc TN. m ,1,f.
frrnnt ~ farm mi .nratcr na'i ~ as =" VI
irrs 80 ,,n,tsn that hc wu,iLI t,tvc nj lr,nf hja,
tury II I'll. err,,,nsa,ys tc.,imv r. r sn liz n,s
ctr.. Mi ~ whi'h hc ,r',,.rcttc ~ ~ ~,
claimants ,yrrr hnri tn ,,rrrn thnt i'm io.,-ato
srt mp Ia their rn tei:l u, crIIial @ I'm ;u,1lv'
Was IL TACT a,as On t!,o principle t!at .he narty
ngrrnnnt as lint ~. ~, T., i,,o ,,es ,,ti ,,i,
in tuutl, ~, I'm rort of tn" Hnvnrn'nnn, 10 ~,
Uoycrnu,rnt counsel. anu tl,o univ t,.t,nnv tmr
liz iurv Il, ..nsIirr Wa t,nt ,s,,i"i, sim'raI
will KorIIc. tinker 4 "a 1bctr o+,,rnnrs
i,nT nrr,nisr1 r. ,nnncr, rcrt ,;m "nt nrs ",'I
brinr lien fone to In. H'rermtnrmt ',",nsri aeA
n In shnt r"nsnn t,,r rnnrt In1 niireI INIT,
,attaaon. ~ ts e
so tu. Tjuc essential iuosry was wiIat wrr.. thc
M tet'ns oi .as asrse'%eat r.; !n.ly ma,s !s.Ssss
WA nroncr s,,],,rc. Tor rn'si,]rraI @ a Ill
nronntiinm. main hr nj WattI,"r. .Itit.. aI w..
W1su,,. anu Coirctor Webster were to il, .t,,.
s;,t"ycI s,nlv NJ, far ns thrv wrre ~ hrn,,.ht
mnic mari of lin attrremen1' Thc "T" ~.
trtnnt Ia r.sit,co In tfntrart T., wsi,nt
In fGe ,lncu1nrut tn whtrl werr atfa.hcI ths
awctt ami Smilh nllldaylts, rad been mails NOR,
currenlc. @ :han tis trial. AMI % i,t rscoecton ss 81
h" NJ tIS i,,rr.s inotrv n lo,a,,',
wrt:r thr a.rect,,,.t k,,sstn ntinilv as sei ~,
IN ~. n,cn nm ,na,i. ictwc TX nartc, " e. ,n ~
Il wnx f,1 tha iurv to sev whcthcr the fo.i,na, n
satisfied tl,rm ti,at ti'rss a,ifInyits ~ Smitt''
Sw"tt. mud ,junkcr iii or Iii raj f,,r,is1 III.
nn,t r,ehi" stsincnt -" ~ ~ ~ 'I" t.r,n. .',s
Of tic aercv,nc, /. Tho far, that
.rI,ntnnt ,n,mnu,tv l..d Icpr 'a. ,r,,,,tsm,t tnt
ra. f,ix c,rr,lrt hi; Inn tiev.rrn,..ns ~.
Mica any pro1,1isa Of civil in,r,unI,y. Whaicrsr
~, "rre.,mt was a" 'it xh.t, u, ,.rri" w.,
hui ~, a,,"st ~. mi ns ~ +bc ,rrx1 1u.t ;
nf tt,n seFccmrnt int I'm I.trrm.nstiao ~ int
w,,nt In upr.ea,,cnt was. II H." trx r. fa,mI !"
wv tnn ,stac,n"ot w,s ,,, ~ .o'n oa
f"ri..,r.x sn' a ~ H. ~ ~
IT, tSn ",,Inritirs nj Wast,ncsm, Inv, ~" ,,,.a
~ q" rrnn,,s. ~ ri, nut :..u,",..n I,Ii r." i
,",m,,w .ns ,,,,t ~ 10y hc rae ~, est,n,, W. w.
tmTy ,ntrGt bo sat,,e,, froIn tI evi.lc',ss tl,at
h9n1,,," w ~, .ne =. .sas
e thet t,". a"i% H. t"e tImo.
ram fn.i1t,or.. a,'i :ssc..ucn,s ths,,,,',,'
thn ,cnartmsnts TIns par;ics rmw., hn h.,,G,'
~ t." oa.t,,,, ~ ~ .'i,,e.u ~ .... ~
T., ~ @ ls -. ~ ~ sr ',ts-t,n ~ l"' .m.s
LII. "1 ~ IT. .'.,';, IL u', ~ E"n, mx fwra"n,