The New York herald., 1876-11-22

my papers about thc l-iu Oh SShtcUVef, P'cct's'"
them because they IN my h.use; us 10 whether
II was honorable TO publish them or MOI IS question
for nv lawyers; anu gentleman. pui the question ~
issue lust Is not whether ! am or
not; did look Them up 10 give
my lawyers; had them ana gave them as
found them; | understood yer, httle Of their con-
tents Adele visited my the 18th OF July and
two or three other times; never seat any presents
by her 10 her alhcr or moihcr did not request the
plaintiff to give Celia music lessons; on the con.
trary. she wanted TO give them, and ioid hcr
dia employ her 10 give lessons 70 my servants
objected 10 the plantin Is giving me English lessons at
my house New York because u was inconvcnien'.
did not want young lady sccn coming in and
oui OF my house, as infercnccs might be drawn
q She asked you to 20 10 her home 10 take lcssonsf
A. She suggested such hing.
O What ~as the Inconvenience to you that you did
not go2 A. Well, because u was inconveuicnt
q Distance too srcaty A. considered - better Tor
not to "a.
q WhyY A. Because I understood Il TO be So
The nation came to close nj this point,
when tn answer 10 Mr. Choaie on tho redirect, tho
witness tcstiiicd as follows:-
have ed from the planta hty more
letters oni- received two letters roE her bcfore
going Poughkeeisie-the note she lett at the jew
c!ry aud the asking tor money was not Ia
the habit OF kissing her nj Solars any other place.
kissed her; there any talk
rooms at soIar,'s Nc used TO occupy we're Two
chairs, the table which took lunch and small
table; wnen SAID her age was ory-s"a on he cross
examination, yesterday, meant 10 say that when they
took The census NJ Poughkcepsie she gave her age ms
iorty-i~o tlaueh,crl
70 Sir Boach-l was present WHOM sho ,old the
an act Of childshness
WHAT Az kLgvAroK BoY sArs I'm SAW.
wi.linm H. Gicnnon young man about nineteen
years Of age. was tho next witness Hs said he re-
sided at No 20 sullivan street, that ia The spring of
boy; was there from tho .'31st" of April and left on
the 5ih OF july tho plaintiff occupied room No ~ and
by the name Of Miss Livingstone she came there
before ho did and lct in Juno. he went To her room
one day with parcel; the door was locked aud she
opened and stood between him and the door nc saw
another person IN The room whom he recognized as
Frederick Hammond, ntterwurd a clerk In the hotel;
he sitting on the side OF the bed; she had on
light wrapper ut the time
To Mr. beach, working In restaurant as
waiter. OF Great Jones street and broadway;
have been there v, weeks when left the Hotel Royal
went 10 fifth avenue ana Forty-tourth street; ran
the elevator attended the door; went last January
To work IN carpenters shop IN Mercer street, when
out of work stopped ~ a friends house, Mra
Kahns who lives al No 102 Eldridgc street. and keeps
a boarding and lodging house; paid 81 30 week.
taking my meals IN restaurants; roOmcd alone; IN
January took care OF my uncs's horses kept the
place clean stayed therc t three months ago, when
went to stewards Hotel, in Twelfth street, near
broadway, as hail boy stayed thcro month, until
The place bustcd up; II about the latter part Of
MAY that the occurrence spoke OF took place; tho
WAS No. g9 on the fourth floor, on the
Forticth street side; tho elevator opposite
the Forlcth street sido the package took up To the
age: IL was on tho desk, with the number Of tho room
marked on IL; when took IL up il was about nvc or
hn-past five ~ the evening; had not been running
tho elevator that afternoon; the clerk ut that time
AR. Swift; the 0ico was In iron. OF sixth avenue and
the elevator the Forueth street side; the door OF
being on the side; think the plaintiff was IN the
habit OF taking her meals in the rOom as have
tue waiter taking meals up there met no person on
The was opposite the door; there was bureau,
a washsland and small table In The room and one
chair; the room was oil from the main hail, which
should judge was about tour feet wide tho head OF
tue Enrtict street and the foot toward
the door; there but one window tho ROOM tho
bed was up against the side OF tho WALL tho cast
side; did not 20 into the room, hut tho door was
opeucd about Two and hall feet was spoken to about
Las nv Mr. al Vail in
room IN Fourteenth street, last Sunday night was
FIRST spoken 10 about he case by John Manning, who
was hall boy In the hotel at tho time there;
the room had to look over her LETT shoulder;
Hammond had his coat on and was seated ON the west
bed observed hc bed clothes, which looked
us though somebody hal been sitting thcm there
being Other disarrangcment; utter leaving the
package went down IN the elevator; once kept a
diary, PLAIN account book, In which ! often
wrote; made note among other things
that the hotel the s.3lst OF Apri' Of this
nm certain; hnd lost the book discharged from
the hotel because stayed away all night on the 5th
OF July; Hammond lett the hotel about two weeks
after the package occurrences never was indicted
never went under any other than Glennon. ans
never arrested; when went 10 Mr.. Del Valle's
room the evening previous ! mot Mr. Dc! Vale and
walk around the block and camc back, when met
two OF Mr. Del vallc's lawyers
A juror here asked who was accustomed to take the
plaintiffs meals 10 her room, and the witness replied
that there no one ~ particular.
10 Mr Choate-f drst heard Of this case By reading
last Friaays HkRALD;s saw Mr. DEL v allc's address
and called To see what he had to say about 1t; he
never addressed INC tho subject; u wss my sus-
gcs,ion that returned tho second time 10 Mr..
Del valc's when told knew about
s.Miss I.vingsion;r knew that therc wcrc thirty
days in April but when the notes in my
diary ran them all down 10 thrty-one; am
sure, anyhow, that went TO tho hotel on the ast day
OF April
that determined 10 call on Mr. Del Vale; 1t was
MunniDg who spoke lrst about the case to me.
BELL BOY TKLLs ms STORY.
John Manning, tue next Witness who was young
about the same age us Glennon, testi d that be
employed IN the Hotel Royal from the l4lh Of April,
1875 he 1lth February 1875 us hall BOY that .siss
Livingston" he bcicvcd came TO tho hotel about the
2Slh OF Apr and stayed nearly two months; that
day gentleman called at tho hotel Tor Mr. Hammond,
aud ne lMannng) told the clerk that Mr. Hammond
was 80 that he went to the room and Knocked
the door, when Miss Livingston opened ~ and that
he saw Hammond sitiing the bed the door not
locked when he went 10 the room
To Mr. Beach--Hc stated that this occur
renee in May, aud that no fch certain
.'Mss Livingston" cans there on the 2s,h OF
April. because she came two days before Gcnnon
was employed; he did no, know y Was tho slst' Of
April, because hc had always understood April
had only thirv davs (anghtcrl: spoke with Gcnnun
about The first on Friday evening; the occurrence
In The room he testified took the middle
MDy; he testified That hc bad been employed III tho
Deavan House. Union square, nficrward ut The Evcrvt.
House and Fiiih Avenue Hoic; employed a Sec
ond time 10 May al tho Hotel Royal and stayed iii
Scptcmpcr he irst read Of the IN the HERALD Of
FRIDAY he then made up hrs mind 10 see Mr Del Vale
CELIA ox THE STAND.
Quite ilutter OF excitement occasoncd after
Manning had lett tnc stand by Mr. Choatc calling tho
name Ut the next WitucsS-''OcllH rainbow" dcr
has been mentioned SO often in the that
examination has looked forward TO with consucr-
able interest she Is quiet neat looking little Dody,
was drtsscd black and wore PLAN rouna nat and
had her hair done up III net. She gave her
in quiet tone OF voice, never getting excited,
when tho counsel for tho plaintiff became
little violent The way OF putting his questions.
Her scif-posscssion was remarkable, but II
evidently not rcshcd by her cross-cxaInncr. who,
despite LIS Ucst endcayors was unable 10 "trip her up
sayIug goes, IN any ono OF her statements she
testified that she twenty three years age that
she is chambcrmald and waitress in Sir. Del Valics
househod that she was in the Clarendon Hotel, Sara
oga, before he employed her; that went with tho
family 10 Poughkccpsc IN 1918; was al Poughkccrsc
Introduced To Ter aud the other wants the
huusckecpcr aud govcrness She tscn went on with her
testimony as iuows:--rho plantn seemed to be vory
friendly with Inc and took interest shc often
coavcrscd with me IN her own( (room and oscwhcre;
Sunday mornings waited on fhc table when Mary
the 0rRl The