davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

Present-Appleton, Chief Justice; Dckerson, Bar
rows, Danforth Virgin and Libbey Associate Justi-
ees.
ANDRosCoGGIN CUNTTY.
FRIDAY.-Everett G. Reed petitioner for partition
against persons unknown, involving title to lands in
Lewiston. On report. Bolster argues for petition
and Morrill, for Hilton.
Benjamin Pulsfer VS.. Isaac Pulsiter. Assumpsit
for money had and received. To sustain the count
the plaintiff offered two notes of hand dated nearly
forty years before the date of the writ The presd-
ing judge ruled that the lapse of time only pra
acie evidence of payment of the notes and would not
bar recovery. The defendant, the verdict being
for the plaintiff, excepted
Bolster argued in support of the exceptions and
Dunn sent in his brief for the plaintiff.
Frederick M. Pickles VS.. Levi Il. Coombs. The
plaintiff minister, the officer in replevin for
sleigh and robe attached as the property of his
friend. Defense-the plaintiffs possession cover.
The verdict was for plaintiff.
A. P. Moore for defendant argued to set it aside
and G. S. Conant to sustain it.
George of Stetson VS.. Albion G. Smith. Motion
for new trial overruled.
Frye Cotton & White for plaintiff
Morrill, & Wing for defendant.
Kate c. Henick ct al. VS.. John Marshall. An
argued statement Morrill, for defendant files brief
Levi d. johnson VS.. N. c. Estes Frye, Cotton g.
White submit their brief to set aside plaintiffs YER
dict; Hutchinson & Savage-theirs to sustain it.
Thomas Goss VS.. ID. A. Coffin, Exceptions. Dunn's
brief for plaintiff in.
Ann Shanney VS.. Androscoggin Mills. Frye, Cot
ton g. White ask the court to set aside plaintiff
verdict for $1,000 for loss Of two fingers in defendants
unfenced gearing on the ground that, though true
this particular gearing exposed on account of
alton, knew the danger and was cleaning the gear
ing out of and when in notion carelessly and
contrary to rule.
Savage contended earnestly that the jury were
right.
Luther Perkins VS.. Stephen Fogg. Defendants
motion for new trial overrued.
State VS.. Webster. Cotton's argument in support
OF defendant in.
State VS. H. A. Page. Briefs in.
HutchinS 81 Savage for defendant.
White for State.
State VS.. Leavitt. Briefs in.
Ludden for defendants exceptions
White, Co. Atty, for State.
j. L. Marte vs. Napoleon Cakes Moore argues
defendants exceptions.
YORK COUNTY.
Mindwel Storer in eq. VS.. Mary l.. Poole. in
writing 30, 30, 30.
Tapley for plaintiff
N. Hobbs, Burbank aud Derby for deft.
John GRAHAM VS.. Boston g. Maine Railroad. app't
Case loss of trunk and contents $66 and interest
from October 4th, Saturday, 1873. The plaintiff took
the train at Kennebunk for Saco. His trunk not al
irving at the Kenneblnk station in season go with
him he lett word for it to be forwarded by the Mon
day train The baggage master engaged to forward
the trunk as if the passenger was with it, double
checking it. The trunk delivered into the Gus
tody of railroad at Kennebunk, Monday, and lost.
Tapley for plaintiff Yeaton for defendants.
Susan A. Thorp VS.. George A. Shepleigh.
Yeaton argues defendants exceptions.
Copeland per contra.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

Mr.. EDIToR:-Hundreds of families in this
city are now, and have been for an indefinite
time, paying for water which the Sebago Water
Company fails to supply except internationally
and stintelly. Meantime, and all along, the
company knowing perfectly well that it was
not meeting the demand, has proceeded TO put
in new services, still further to stint consumers
Midway the town the supply doubtless has been
abundant but at both ends, the east end as
we'll as the west, the people, having aid in
full for water, are and have been previously
suffering for the first necessary Of life.
And now the company not fulfilling its agree
ment, not beginning to supply in full the Gus.
toners who have paid their money, has put up
its rates to figure without parallel. L say
that the rates of the company are excessive
beyond equal comparison with those of any
other water company similarly situated. The
water costs nothing. The work of transfer is
done by gravitation. The works, we have been
hundred times assured, though excellent
were cheap. Why then these monstrous i'm
posts? l challenge the company to give the
figures Of the cost of water IN other cities and
this and make justification for itself out OF
them for its rates.
But even if the rates were fair, when did ever
people have to pay for what it did not get
did not get summer or winter, by day or night
First it was ice, now it is water; but the public
will fiud extrication from the one monopoly as
it already has from the other. WARD SIX.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
Maine Business Notes.

The News says about dozen hands are still
at work at the Bridgton corn factory making
cans. About two hundred acres have been
planted with sweet corn in this section for this
factory.
The Lewiston Journal says the Auburn ship
ments of shoes during the past week ha We been
961 cases and the receipts of leather S5,425
pounds During the previous week the ship
ments were 555 cases, and the receipts of leath-
er 52,99S pounds. The manufacturers are bust
ly engaged in filling orders and the prospects
are quite encouraging.
The Rocklaud Gazette says the Bodwell
Granite Conway were the successful bidders
for the United States Custom House and Post
Office at Fall River, Mass, the contract amount
ing to $51 900. The contract for the grey gran
lite was awarded to Gen. Tilson at $4,000.
The stone is to be furnished properly cut at
these prices
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

Mrs. DIR. Devoll will give an address at the
temperance meeting at Preble Chapel Sunday
evening.
dust was not to be seen.
A young lad named A. Britt who is camping
Out at Evergreen Landing, drew the damp car
tridges from his revolver last night and substi-
tuted dry ones In so doing he discharged a
barrel, and the bullet took finger off.
AT the collation. given at Officer Bells house
yesterday morning, Miss Bell presented Mar
shall Bridges and Marshal Howe each with a
fine bouquet, which they carried all day.
The Reform Club will hold public meeting
tomorrow afternoon, commencing at CLOCK,
in Sennott's Hall, Kuightville.
A fellow affirms that it has been so very not
the past week that the wooden Indians at the
doors of cigar shops have perspired freely.
The telegraph indicates that wave of cooler
weather is approaching from the mort Invest
Don't interfere, Old Prob.
An old Democrat thinks one musician to two
soldiers is good deal of mesc to pay for.
The &c Zouaves with % musicians had Just
passed.
at half staff to-day on account of the death of
Com. GARNER Of the New York Yacht Club.
The hotel registers show an increase in the
summer travel of late.
Everyone praised Chambers music yesterday
A gate which is not fastened is not good
thing to lean against, especially if you have
been drinking. An intoxicated individual
tried it on Oak street last night, and it proved
very unsatisfactory.
A man from Hong Kong, China, passed
through the city yesterday.
Officer York lost valuable pipe at the clam
bake yesterday.
The steamer Tourist will not make her trips
as advertised until the first of the week, in
consequence Of slight accident to her pilot
house last evening.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

A VENERABLE PATRoN.-The venerable ia
cob S. Smith, Esq, formerly of Gorham. and
now a resident of New York, in making his
annual remittance writes: II have taken YOUR
paper with all its changes and improvements
since October, 1908, those good old times of
Arthur Shirley and Isaac Adams. At that
time took the offica recently made vacant by
the death of Col. Samuel Whitmore, at the
village of Gorham, Me- and was admitted to
practice at the Cumberland Bar at the Novem-
Der term at the same tiGe with Samuel Fes.
sender, then of Ntw Gloucester, and am the
only surviving member of all those then in
practice there. | continued in practice till
1888, period of twenty-five yeas, when re-
moved to my fam some two miles from the vii
lage, and remained there thirty-four years. till
1867, when L removed to Brooklyn, N. Y,
where have since resided, and attained the
age Of 80 years on the 2Sth of April, this year
of 1875, in the enjoyment of my usual perfect
health, taking my daily morning walk, PARTIAL
ly shortened by the natural debility incident to
my declining years. | am still intent on my
library, to which l am devote1ly engaged, and
until the last two years have made my annual
visit of five or six weeks to the good old town
of GoIham, hallowed in sacred memory for
nearly three-score years.
esteem your paper as ever, a candid, con-
sis.ent, Independent and orthodox Republican
journal, and shall continue as a subscriber as
long as | live"
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
-Four Protestant denominations-the

fold. -Four Protestant denominations-the
Methodist Baptist Presbyterian, and Congre-
acknowledgements $50 churches besides
which are Lutherans, Episcopalians, United
Brethren, the Reformed Church, Unitarians,
Universalists, etc. The Roman Catholics num-
Der 5000 churches.
The lions Advocate says that year ago it
called the attention of the Mirror to the fact
that but few infant baptisms we're reported at
the State Conference. In noticing the A9vo-
Gates statement the Mirror replied that the
neglect was due to the low state of the church
es. Now the Advocate says that the churches
have been quckened generally, but no more
infants baptized. The Advocate leaves its
readers to infer that Congregationalists don't
believe in the doctrine of infant tantiSm.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

Owing to the lateness of the hour at which
| the fire occurred on Union wharf, it was impos
sible to give full list of the insurance, and al
| is natural the loss was over-stated. Below WI
| give list Of the Insurance and loss, both OF
| the buildings and stock:
BUILDINGS.
Nos. J., 8, 4, A. K. Shurtleff owner In
| sured for $4,000 at the agency of b. Barnes
Jr.; Girard, Philadelphia, f$2400; Merchants
$250O; Peoples, $500; Commercial, $780,
| Loss $1,000.
| No. 5, R. o. Conant owner. No insurance
| loss $780,
| $4,000, $4,000 in the Franklin of Boston, at the
agency of E. E. Upham 81 Co., and $4,000 in
| the Citizens of New Jersey, at the agency OF
Andersons & Dow. Loss $4,000.
No. s, j. De Wolf Perry owner. Insured fol-
| 5000 in the Rochester German, B. Barnes, Jr.,
agent. Loss $500.
No. 9, Judge Fox owner. Insured for $1,000
in the Franklin. Loss $1,000.
Nos. 10 and II, Judge Fox owner. Insured
$4,000 in Citizens. Loss $4,000.
No. -, Judge Fox owner. Insured $1,000 in
Franklin. Loss $780,
Union Wharf Company, $500 damage to the
wharf
Insurance on buildings $17, 700; loss $13, 900.
STOCK.
Emery g. Furbish insured $4,000; $4,000 in
the Prescott with B. Barnes, Jr.; $4,000 in the
Citizens, $4,000 Peoples, and $4,000 Alliance
with ADdersons & Dow. Loss $500.
Freemans, no insurance; LOGS $780,
j. w. Whitmore, no insurance; loss $500
Waldron & True, insured $4,000; $4,000 in
Commercial of New York, Rochester German
and Westchester, with B Barnes, Jr. $4,000 in
Hartford with Dow & Palmer; $4,000 in the
Home with Dow, Coffin & Libby; $4,000 in the
Royal with Rollins Loring q Adams. Loss
$4,000.
D. W. True, insured $500 in the Niagara
and Amazon with Dow & Palmer, and $1,000
in the Connecticut with w. D. Little & Co.
Loss 500.
G. W. McKenney This is the stock attrib-
nted to f. A: Hamlin & Son; they were mere
ly agents) No insurance. Loss $500.
y. w. Jones, insured $4,000 in Citizens, New
Jersey, and other companies at Andersons &
Do~'s agency, $4,000 of which was for Wolff
q Reisen of New York, W. d. Little & Go. had
$3.50 on store scale in the Revere of Boston.
A. ID. Whdden, insured $1,000 in the North
British with Dow & Palmer Loss $500.
insurance on stock $37, $50, and loss on stock
$3.50.
$50. Total loss on bindings and stock $22,45O.
From this total must be deducted the value of
building No. B, $1,000 and the $500 loss on the
Freemans stock, $500 on Whitmore's stock,
$500 on McKenny's stock, total of $500,
which leaves total loss of $1S,950
LILO %io,sou loss Is uNlueu among nineteen
different companies, giving small average for
each.
The cause of the fire still remains mystery.
Some are of the opinion that the building was
struck by lightning, while others think it prob.
able that it caught from fire N the sto-e oc-
cupied by j. Winslow Jones, which had been
used for soldering purposes. Cinders from the
fire were found yesterday several wharves be.
low where the fire was, showing that large
amount of property had narrow escape from
destruction
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
Hayes Battery

Headquarters Hayes Battery,
July Is, 1876.
General Order No. 9.
Officers and members are ordered to
appear at Ward Room, NO.3, EVERY EVE
MING, at 2 1.2 o'clock, until further or
ders for drill. Prompt attendance is
requested. Per order,
J. III. B. MORRILL,, Capt. CONG.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

FRATERNITY EXCURSION Fraternity
Club with invited guests made its annual ex.
cursion yesterday to Trefethen's Landing,
Peaks Island. The morning was occupied by
sail on the Florence and a subsequent meet
ing on the island, at which Hon. 1. Wasbburn,
Jr., gave some very interesting sketches of his
recent journey in Europe. A CAPT tai dinner
was served by Mr.. Trefethen under the trees
near his house at 2 clock p. m. The weather
was perfect and the excursion was in all re-
spects entirely successful.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

ANNIVERSARY OBsERvANCE.-To MORO
occurs the seventy-ffth anniversary of the
First Baptist church of this city. The pastor,
Rev. DR.. Shailer will preach historical dis
course at the afternoon service, which begins
at p. m.-and in the evening there will be a
union meeting OF the First and Free street
churches at the Vestry of the First church, at
which there will be addresses and music appro.
PIRATE to the occasion.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

CUMBERLAND STREET is closed for repairs
~ between Oak and Brown. 1t is necessary on
account Of the blasting for the sewer. jy22d3t
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
Attention Pioneers F.!

All members of the Pioneers are re-.
quested to be at Headquarters. MONDAY
EVENING, July Gath, at s o'clock P. M.
sharp, as business Of importance will
come before the company.
PER ORDER.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
CITY AND VICINITY
New Advertisements To-Day.

new AdvcFtIstnitMts T0-DNy.
MISCELLANEOUS NOTICES.
Davis g. Co...
NEW ADVERTISEMENTS.
Maine Wesleyan Seminary.
Found-H. Winchester.
Partner Wanted-N. S. Gardner.
Wanted-C X. Chisholm Bros.
Notice-Cumberland Street.
Losu-Meerschaum Pipe.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

AN INVITATION To THE X. OF P's.-The va
rous lodges of Knights of Pythias in this city
received an invitation last evening from the
Knights Of PSthas Of Dover, N. H., to visit
them in September, when they promise big
time. No action has yet been taken, but it is
very probable that they will accept
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
From the 'tNew Haven Daily Union ~

DR.. Scott's cures in some instances are indeed
wonderful, especially in Nervous and Chronic Dis
eases of long standing. The "Famous Wyomoke
or Nerve Food,' with which he has had such brill
liant success, is the result of assduous scientific
search, and without doubt the greatest triumph in
medical science yet achieved by man.
lB In some cases only three days are required
to remove the cause of obscure diseases that have
afflicted the patient for years-recovery rapid thor
ough and permanent.
Consultation Free, iy1d &w27tf
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
[From the Boston Transcript, July 10, 1872. !

Standing foremost among the most liberal and
most successful of American physicians to-day, is
DIR. G. Winfield Scott, at the Asylum Institute Medi
He has risen above the narrow preudces of particu-
lar schools, and by treating patients their
demand, without sacrificing his abilities to sectarian
rules, he has achieved wonderful success and effect
ed cures that astonished of the ablest physl-
cians of ne dav
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
COMPANY A.
CONTINENTALS

Every member is requested 10 meet at
Headquarters THIS, Saturday, EVE.
MING, at O'Clock, for drill.
r.. T. MCCLELLAN, Capt. COm'g.
w. s. COREY, Clerk.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

ALLEN MIssIoN.-There was good attend
ance at Allen Mission last evening" aud the
address of Mr.. j. Lemly of Illinois, was full of
interest. Tie warm weather does not seem to
lessen The interest Of the workers at Allen
Mission.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
Municipal Court.

BEFORE JUDGE KNIGHT.
FRIDAY.-Bridget Haney. Vagabond Thirty
days. Committed.
Michael Collins, Hugh ConIey and Patrick Sulli-
van. Larceny. Thirty days each, imprisonment
and labor
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
iy1d&w27tf
Notice,

WHEREAS my wife, Abbie Daman, having left
w my bed and board without Just provocation, ]
hereby forbid all persons harborng or trusting her
on my account after this date
SILAS III. DAMAN.
Southport, June goth, 1876. jy19dlws
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

WE open choice lot of Hamburg edgings
this day, at popular prices. Our goods are all
new and fresh and are selected with care, so
that we offer the best patterns and on the best
quality of cambria. Davis & Co. jy22-2t
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
Opinions of the Press.

IMAM Meuoai hecoIu, N. l., July lo6o.J
Many diseases, considered incurable causing great
suffering in countless thousands of our fellow beings
can in the majority of cases be restored to perma.
nent health under DR.. Scotts Scientific Theory dem
onsratng the fact that his mode of treating diseases
of chronic character is unsurpassed by any method
now in use. All should consult with him who wish
for speedy cure and thorough advice as DR.. Scott
has had the most remarkable and gratifying SUCCESS.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

AT 10 o'clock this forenoon f. o. Bailey &
Co. will sell at salesroom IS and 81 Exchange
street, new aud second hand furniture, carpets,
&c. &c.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

CELLULoID JEwELRY. perfect imitation of
the coral. We are having very large sales on
these beautiful goods, as our prices satisfy all.
Davis & Co. jy22-2t
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

THE TILDEN ZoUAvEs.-The Tilden Zouayes
turned out last evening. They covered as
much space as it is possible for five officers, one
band marshal, forty privates, and eight drum
mers to occupy. They marched in the most
open order. A skirmish line might have occu.
pied little more space if men were scarce
The young men seemed to think that they were
a good many. The Portland Band was the
chief attraction. though the uniforms of the
Zouayes were very snowy.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

BASE BALL.-A match game of base ball
was played yesterday afternoon on the horse
car grounds in Deering, between the Dirigo
and Forest City clubs, resulting in a victory for
the Dirigos by score of 8 to9
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

FRESH supply of Thin Clothing for Men and
Boys at Rich's corner store. Also complete
outfits for camping out parties.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
KENNEBEC COUNTY.

The Journal says patient at the Insane
Hospital, Watson Gould, escaped from the in
stitution the other night in close imitation OF
Robbins. He has not yet been found.
The Journal says Mr.. J. B. Wendell and
wife, florists in Augusta, the other day made
up fifty elegant bouquets and presented them to
the female patients in the Insane Hospital-a
beautiful act. which deserves imitation
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
To Let.

Pleasant Front Rooms to Let
with Board. Apply at this office.
apr29 diff
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

The GEM Fruit Jars are the best in the
market. For sale by Kendall & Whitney.
jy15 eod2w
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
Vessel for Sale.

Erig ''MECHANIC,o now at this Port;
1917 IONS register; single dec X; built in
1852; is in good order and will be sold
AT n bargain. For particulars, apply to
CHASE, LEAVATE 4 co.
jy2l dit
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
PENOBSCOT COUNTY,

The Lewiston Journal says a reform club
was organized in Levant on the 10th by Mr..
Walker from the Bangor Club. Fifty-six sign
ed the pledge.
The Wing says that an old lady, Mrs. May
night by stumbling over granite rock on the
sidewalk near the Bangor House, which is
placed there with rings to hitch horses to.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
THE FIRE.
A List OF the Loss and Ensurance-The
Loss Nearly $4,000.

Owing to the lateness of the hour at which
the fire occurred on Union wharf, it was impos-
sible to give full list of the insurance, and as
is natural the loss was over-stated. Below we
give list of the Insurance and loss, both on
the buildings and stock:
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
STATE NEWS
ANpRosCoGGIN COUNTY

ANDROSCOGGlN COUNTY
Mr. John Perkins of Mechanic Falls, had his
teeth knocked out by kick from horse the
other day, so says the Herald.
The Herald says Mr. Charles Y Pierce of
Mechanic Falls. received quite a severe sun
stroke Thursday and again Friday, but be is
now convalescent.
The journal says the body of Freddy Thorn
ton, drowned on Satui day, was found in the
RIVER near South West Bend and brought to
Lewiston Wednesday.
CUMBERLAND COUNTY.
The News says John Mills of Pumpkin Val
ley, lost very valuable horse Tuesday, in con-
sequence, it is thought, of eating caterpillars.
The News says Johnny Gore, a young lad Of
Bridgton, son of Isaiah Gore, while at play
Tuesday jumped upon the end of a sharp stick
which pierced his foot, severing small artery.
The News says Thursday Henry S. Buck Of
South Harrison, fell from a scaffold receiving a
severe cash upon his head.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

A PURE. safe and strictly vegetable medicine,
of extraordinary curative properties, is DIR.
BULLOCK'S KIDNEY REMEDY, NE
PHRETICUM. Bright's Disease, Kidney,
Bladder and Glandular complaints, Diabetes
Gravel, Suppression and Incontinence of Urine,
Female Irregularities, &C., are relieved at once
by its use.
14-29-4 jy18eod&w1w
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
LOST AND FOUND.
BOARD.
NOTICE..

DERSONS wishing board for the summer at the
Il Seaside, can hear of good location by adj
dressing j. A. MCDONALD, Knightsville, Cape
Elizabeth. jy15dtf
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22

TRAVELLERS visiting New York will find no
better accommodations anywhere than are to be
found at the well known ST. Nicholas Hotel,
conveniently located on Broadway, between
Broome and Spring streets.
The Portland daily press. [volume] (Portland, Me.) 1862-1921, 1876-07-22
Supreme JudiciaI Court.

LAW TEhM-WESTERN DISTRICT. Il
Present-Appleton, Chief Justice; Dickerson, Bar
ows, Danforth, Virgin and Lbbey, Associate Justi-