, 1876-10-20
At him, The fatal tfot wns ntcd, and In few mo-
INT nts fihnford was dead
,n app!y'ng tho law ia this killing, let US lint

HuHElflNlH 30:
WHAT BORT or CHARACTER HANroRD WAS,
for ~hcn the inv il presented ynu will nec that 4
Isn ilas tln ahnc ti3l't 70 defend s wife t:!at o
fenl either himself or wIfo when threatened n.-
:Sns. !hst s and
GsG!slGn no nay properly consider the feeble con-
dls,Gn h!a vile was In. both from her acute attack
who was aasafllnE him.
ldan!oFd ana Sullivan Hesc entire ft!angcts and
sn,!sxan only knew him ft.m his con4aes md l,ls
sna .,s Thether s 4 wers ttuo q not 4 wholly mm..
t;u't; md reduced I gtfi, VIC was liz. pnpii.,
tas 1iaa besn A. told. and believed, that ne
ia1n, .an ''oiateo tie hactcd rolstions or MS
ir,frst. iSt any ,tSe" gully theEe OF lmptoFot
'hm.,tasiGy ha 9ai:y %'1h S,daaa tencheE fie knew b.
I'm f'nn ~ snH III sns Shatncsst q memoeis oI
Of s we not open t ~ ,as
ls ~ts't + s,l.l va, s! X ss r. Ss1ei
1tnss desa1 en1 e,her ne o. hs % Mh
knnw th.,n ios hn ,ssa ~ h,4 A1e nAn, nc as1 hot
the sitntes Id ecen adsi asts.s 70 T.
t%s ~ ai ri ne,n nc.n no ~ ,nls sask9 a
fnstian4 n i,n,oxtn ,,nt -, ~ v,. ne was
ss:t!oy II, sls,asif5 @ oi so%sn il d! nst ass''
efusx Or 90 @ 81 he T. ,IS 1 s
A'eu' ,ar my ~, r,my.,, n ~ ~ ~ 'Hn. n.p p9sse
III ,yns fustIHca ..th ~. -. ~. - 80, -.
iian;ord md ,nakinn him c.ttt IN Y. NJ
arn apon iii vito md strEpr "tn hrr sal agan r tGG
in m it,snnt h. conjd hnyc dana Ae' 'sa'u' ""e1
mo law fs2;G;; nn stsska 70 retreat md
Enr II. n..niiant III "a sxa, f ng cam neioio
Ge cou,i mt retrrat mi ih,,cforn IL wn St ,aa
csfac. bn ~ a. s rt any e. no tele
II h e"ula hres"a M nm, n ~ n ~ 10
sare hse en ense III s % IL aneer ~ an
ban ws. KY n ana s VIE Io IT,
ua no. boun even II hc couI to rnn arsY sp ~ III
Win ha cn1esxn,c ~ .esret atiss y ~ nan
her carncssr and wo hi tnst sirne ~ H. ~
VI WHEN @ g ls]isysd had 5a.t .t91sE het Ssx:
int aec,as,,,,,x oSc1s,os' Sc!; ,sns ,,.,n - ~ ,,,
ss s sa 81 sstH etsfh h.s n sFss
aG T. besaa,s Gpo ons OCCASION whs r. NV
h h. a1 bss n a so %
n,e,ts5 ioF tAs 1..ts qna IL going sIout tae cty
sias,ss s o. pcople s"d; az most reportcrs d. hc
ias ~ rct.ant Iy u s IN atenasng tha
aaw. NAV ns,oesX ~ e see,tugp eafe'
snea nc nse az te means n his power 70 snvH Ills
ts 15 p,cycnt Fc to rs intended stn such A. re.
st ri H.! ~ ~ w; " 4oa9nx HE h!seFeafJ
~tsnHIs snSs.n xil,1nE n hlm; u 70 IN i, s pHwsr"
ony o ha eyer VEN hsn was ' mna The
,r,., on3I;a.n 1IsAnLIso ING. LIS s ApvERaAnT
na toia l su dan. e' sa kuT ."
IL kasw stasT Of T. ths% @ had oys1 aene lin sSy
saek sd oensed e IN seno ,nnE
Ts;s'S5s Is fhS"s1t ~ Z I sa9!d sssx yhss
wad IN aaH 49,, 1cen m pns nPoh hs hc
one, pesseeaby ana s unsTaG
a;ar ient ~ at'acx 1sd @ 9esn coss.ned to mean an
n cyc nfnr s m Ens f. ot Istraet.
It, 10 .ald ae wonld p!oye It. When a:Esd for hls
dsmss r .Hn nc sau ho w1nia glse none: When asked
prsven @ So pn5eso IN .s Wosp papeIs saaGs hs
tors i'. Sullivan; tue yeung husband, a. The wllfal
refusing M to say anything which would In any man.
nes htH!t or Lessen the injury, or even pre-
iIeaton' a' Ee Grre,o5 "nsng injury .,e ~ puS
= .,t"S. noS. al ahe IT,, no.a mSea thciI hands
10 amacE. anu snii'san Enocsed him Of threw HIN
nor io'ow IT, up or attempt TO-. ltanfoIl did not
rlIie ia .;,na ,yn. sue ,li1 epa EenE ahd
mullen and Sullivan, unnford mnde an nttnrt nnnn
the wife. When he left the wife and bcran a nav
attack upon sullivan. and when Sullivan was held
90 that liz could intepo.c other defense, hc says
he thD1ht Of his attack upon his wifea character,
nis a s,fehg w. OF ns Wo, ana seolng the attack COM
INK u''o" MN, ~ ae va,', .luuEnt !, ,r,,,,, ,,
md Tim. a!.o',o ohI h;a "uGan adyst,, nsA' ,.,r.
q rawnn ne es excf nso ~ hnk o. lie
remember lrne il. lie ts not eonacfou. at anT
Intention Of drawing 1t OF nrlng Il. All thc
thought he can recall Is the thought that he might
lawfully disable him, and thus In tho
sea'ao = ne rx u'a oa.,. asaw u without knowing
r. nn,t a"! coatS'1heaess III IN regard TO
nim ar witb,t anv @ msq boxo Mnoat no. ,y nny
which be aJs, From III. SEot tic III Iilinr wa.
necidcnta! How cusiiy il, thls seufc tGete nicat
have been deviation d! an eighth Of q sirtsenth
part Of MI inch md Jet the deviation OF lesa a-
taneo than thIs Or the muzzle Of tts pistol would
havs 3niysed iian,orl Altogether. The Thought Of
rs nst Z, afn waa wo ssy la"fn thought
hetus rcmoysa .gas tnc ~ otsr defense
Il nst foiow that icrnns1 uiis. ,~e. uo. e. & t1sn
man whom he supposed 70 BE- m encmv' aud ~,
tackled, iii rights Or lf-defensc were t5tcn swny
by his enemies. lilo was bound 10 stand still nnl
Lo beaten. The reaeou killing Ia unlawful when
itls ualawfuf. IL because tho defendant had othcr
moaes =. 81 eacare, and other modes Of dsfenao.
~. ~, Savan M VA NOT pound 10 csGapo and leave
s,o H. ,sa H,u ~ hr ~ ~ eacoPe ne w1uias and
fense possible. '''~' "''D ~'"'' '''N' ~ "'
Mr., SWEET then {1Iscusscfl
ruA LAM or sElF-pErEssE,
c0ncedng that tnn N0s not Justified In lt1ltnr