The New York herald., 1876-11-22
TIE NARYINEZ-DEL VALLI TRIAL
Conclusion of the DEFENDANTS
Cross Examination.
TIE DEFENCE'S SENSATION.
What Two Bell Boys Say They Saw at
the Hotel Royal
CELIA RAINBOWS TESTIMONY

The proceedings At tho trial OF the suit OF MISS
Martiucx agans: Mr. Deivallc yesterday invested
with than usual interest. from the fact that some
rather startling testimony was given by two witnesses
produced by the defence the girl Celia, whose
name has figured prominently the case. also
one OF tho witnesses examined Tho court room was
crowded. the audience being composed entirely OF
men, which was = litlc remarkable. iEasmuch a. ~
nearly every scandal trial that has been neId in this
city for years past there were always 10 bo found
among the most eager listeners In court
scoro or so OF females. Either tho women
who generally attend trials iiko the present arc
out OF town have OF ate adopted new standard of
propriety. No matter what tho cause the result Is
gratifying, and The fact that the absence Of the
class VINO used the most attention in
to the parties interest has created considera
Bile remark makes 1t all the more Tho plaintiff
was, a. usual, accompanied by her mcshcr and sister,
ooxcLusIox vALLE's TESTIMONY.
Mr.. Beach began hts days work by showing tho wit
q diagram OF tho rooms occupied BY him and bis
party at the Arlington Hotel, Washington, which tho
witness declared was apparently correct Mr. Beach
then offered the diagram In evidence. Tho witness
then with his testimony saying son the 2sth
ofMay sent $50 TO plaintiff at tho Hotel Royal;
hx the date from tho TACT tina. that the very day
when sho went to the hotel; know tho day that
u
message from her and, BECAUSE inrthcr she told me
nftcrward the date shc there (rhe witness
here corrected himself, stating that when he said
Tho 2sth OF Mny he should have the 2Sth of Apri
The money sent tho plaintiff, about $50 in bills,
and was taken to the hotel by messenger; cannot
recolect the language Of the recelvod asking for
thc money, but remember that sent no In
ply, SIMPLY enclosing the money In an envelope aud
handing II 10 Celia to give to the messenger; it was
about the oath OF Juno when rst demonstrated with
the plaintiff for going horseback early in tho
mornings whether she used 20 riding before tho
new side saddle was bought do not know, as seldom
went 10 the stables whlc ut Saratoga learned
that she continued her morning rides; when tho
versalion between and tho plaintiff took place re-
lating to these rides and TO her dressing
with her open | do not
think any third person present; there
two conversations between tho subject, the lrst
taking place in the library whether any pres
ent or not cannot say; one, think, present
when spoke to her in the library about tho HERALD
advertisements on the 11th OF August told her that
had found out all about her family that her father
not named Henriques shc had told mo, and that he
living rregularly' with her mother, and that she
should have been moro frank with me; she remained
In the parlor after the conversation and went up
stairs; returning l found her writing letter,
which when she me she folded up, acting as though
she did want to bc seem thinking she was writing
10 her father, l."
Mr.. Beach Qntcrruptine)-Did l ask you for your
ir rasinasons? A. am not giving imaginatons.
told her she could write to hcr father If she de-
sired, would toll him his what had said
her II met HIM, aud she tried 10 mako me tho
letter, but would not look II, and learning
house, Eot 70 minc
hat had IL Aox ~
HERALD advertisement3 A. 1t shows that after tho
conversation that had had with her she could
sec that she could not stay any longer In my house
Mr. Beach moved TO strike the latter part ol this
answer. Mr. Choate protested, but all OF that which
referred 10 tho perception OF the plaintiff was stricken
out
THE PLAINTIFFS ACADEMIC MANNERS .
The then went The convers tson OF tho
l1th of August took place IN The afternoon; do not
know what my household expenses were in August
while the plaintiff at Poughkccpsic Indecatc
language ever passed between us; ! always spoke TO
delicate lang uagc IN speaking 10 me she ccra,n
ways not becoming young LADY, ior instance, her
legs too ireey-(laugher her postur,s were improper
and thought It wrong Tor her to sleep with he'd
room door open; for her postures could not por
tray them, as am not a comedian : -taughtcr)--s
showed her legs when the aud on the floor.
q. Did she lift up her clothes with her handss A
have not said what she did whic standing
Q. Then it was when lying down? A. Yes, when
lying on The grass tho sofa.
q. Ind you see the pialnun immornly cxhibit
her pcrson2 A. said before and repeat IL ain
q. What did you sens A. saw her showing her
legs, in the house and on the grounds, in academic
Q. What were you doing Ut tho timer A. Playing
with my children.
A. She was looking
Q. Lying or sutnss A. Sometimes sitting and at
other times lying down.
O. Did you say anything 10 her at the timo abou.
IT. A. On The 24th Of Junc-t was my patron saints
day demonstrated with nor
q. Did you the plaintiff dressing or un-
dressngy A. did not went TO bod as a rule before
her and got up after her
0. What do you mean by her door being open A.
mean that according TO Mr. Alvarez, tue door was
o when you spoke to her about sleeping with her
door open what did she say A. Il on inc 18Th OF
Junc spoke her; she answered by saying med
strange lha. should be afraid OF sleeping with her
u hat then did you mean little whiie ago by
laying she never addressed 10 you any indclicato
hngusgcy A. gave my testimony on that point tho
O. Did you consider that vulgar and unwomanly
remark A. considered It an ind,scrction tho
part Of young girl inexperienced IN the ways Of The
O. Is that the only reason you givc for your tes
timony that ponts A. inai is all; did not CON-
sIder IL an Insult TO me.
O. Ind you, as . father OF family. not consider It
insult g,ven you IN your own houses A. ! havo
already said that considered u tho indiscrcton OF an
inexperienced girl
O Did you not think IL grossly indecent remark Of
q girl OF her agcs A. have said before only con-
sIaercd IL ind,scrction, not sign OF pcrvrrs.y.
20 you know Michael Meyer an attendant AZ
Iheir names, as do not need them.
ALI ABOUT UNKNOWN LADY
O. When Michael Meyer went on the stand did you
soi know him? A. do not know who Mr. Meyer is,
you refer TO servant Of So'ars who was on the
nnnd.
o. DO you remember having visited Solari's With
a,icrcnt American ladies' between November 1874 and
January, 1873? A. Before and after that period
there with both ladies and gentlemen.
a. Between these dates did you visit That place aud
nc there with single isdcsy do not rccol Get pre-
:sciy havire thcrc between those dates
q. DO yon remember visiting there before January,
S75y A. do not remember
O. Are you able 10 give the nanc 0i any lady you
allcd with y SoIari's. A. think not
o. Can you give me the naino oi any lady Of known
espectablitv whom, prcvions 10 Jaunary 1915, you
ook 10 Soluri'ss Ladies and gentlemen OF respect
ability have been there with me; could give their
names, but will not
q lady who went with you into private roomf
A. Yes
O WAS she single or inarricdY A. Single
~ na.r arcx A L recollccl m y nxn