, 1876-10-27

indictment IT. fur murder, that. in reality. tlc o.
.onss asf "H'"s III. :Se" Ne%, IN ii. eass @
"S ~ "asf @ aa: T. a snsg e Gpa rs
A. appeared mt 0n1y between counsel on thts
eide at on the part o .e do'enao for that Is very
eofnnlon}, but ~ faeh! an" Wide difference be.
tween thu sInwx evidently entertained iy the Court
and lhe eosn,cl fot the prosecution. that W. feel
y"ur liunor upon Ills subject; and ali have to .ay
al this hsogc Of the proceedings ~ fsu far as ain
In2 osur san haay h9ve .t ! H.
listening to tho testimony we'll tlIc arguments
u, tue fe.pecsise tldc-. without having arrived a.
ercnce II Il. And II YOUR Honor Ia. aIrsa!y de-
termirs TIT: gaestion TINT ball raIl ie rralsd, It
:onid b. little worss THAI Idle for Us to Under.
tako
70 WASTE TINE
In d4cnsrfng It. And ! llaVu no disposition. II
or osIa ny ~ uwn ts!tics. ;Ss iIly. Al,i viii any.
therefore, at thn staxs q tlo proceedings 4. 4
md yonF 1pnor drAIses or even Il !inK to listen
so III nrsunnt tspon the question whether this tsa
ea,o s u murder "r Of sonc tower degree Of hotp!'
hut sc DO not deslrr to do 80 II your 11unur has
| already determined thc tnattcr.,
Mr. swett-.l wonla etu.n that Il your Honor
that wc l,ayc no objections. Nc Isndcrt tanl that
1a}l nnds, H., " pt.e'ee eomeA a' mas'o' of
Mr. tun Arinan--!ss mastcr o.. .conr.ef
Mr, swest-fes. know Of no decisions In this
"1y ~ a. to e lie csn
:'a's IT, as u s''Ss Viii iii tat IT,
shr state .incc tue Constitution Ut 1sls:
All pessuns shall he bntafIe by aut1ctnt suretic&
cArci tor raal otrnscs, wItse tIc prou' Il eslent
| Or thr presumption srrat.
| Sow thote expressions "whcrc the proof Is cvi.
drnt or tho presun,p,.un great" have, a. u.,,rr.
stand T. received Judicial construction. Whcrc y
T. nas,eo @ for af;1 @ IT,, EF!na iaeIs s ~ not
Hra'! Jury H. upon iFoof which Is ''eyldcnt,"
and nion th. indictment that tue P,ess99mptI"u
u /. not unfsclHeuty thu case that whcFe man Is
indicted f"r murder aud the n!leuee l. aHsunshtrr.
Sf bsitrss p ts 70 u9 e 20 " VII % s tsf
the, conrt. hnss that thv gtIenrr = i.
nrlofc trln1. uut II there itu trial, and the Jury
fail 70 fluid the defendant guilty, then, Us unler.
| stand, the paFsy IL
BECAUSE there has been failure the part Of the
prosecution u make out II cuhe of muEutr. do
mt say that that q rl4n that there fay not be
from Tit opinion Of Chlef-Jastice spencer in tho
rarc agulnat Goodwin. asst of Whrelcr's criminal
| cu.es:
The ia~s:ot every free Government catlmata per.
To- 5tf e b. Il M ' g. sSS 1nf: S!,;s n
~ sitn$u: ~ "s.:s AT & Si';'st ss sa!t
ssrr lie taspias Tie i shs oasn.. snas snisT lei in.S IT.
s:' WHY ;ssn!ssy !Ss;;ss, THU ii!
,.,, se AvI @ III H. !: III a. ss,Sry r.,
r.s,en,, ~ rn,co,lsnrss u suit woa t"SiIy
aanlI1tnK imli, tutreurr. rrgsri t
s II IT, sy L ~ ns r, psaEs s II H. r. ps
thH II rsni inss;t vi .et'iss e +. - u Atser
ME! s a .1 ta ,t i; "aS ea1 nc @ III n +
ag sua xha II .sSgttilEe X. n,t .esa .ox'! S.
S le ra~h @ trg" te !ast aat tnq @ @19fe!a m
iic Prisoner: aud i a,ay ac 6e tEst ,ai5rity
u ti,e JURY arrta u t1e verdict nhsa,ntd i5
~ /: 's:: s% s s
Il IT, m nr{ F,gs g 4ssy oa 9s H.. pse ssr @ ns
VI ssreeIca "ef pfoeseasd sttm @ lii ill., s so,ssSi. ILL.,
pfls3ucs's Eult; anL am thcrctarc. bound te c''
en1c las tas nt'sonsf ay o. innocSnt y ~ ofs"s
T. t. sS % us sa IL ea% IN ~ ad TIT t. y
iron sie .l.,ns,'s irritIfe ui tns fccor.aucS tat
| llr Will srrear stanu trial.
Nn,s l did not sur anything In order to press this
arsu.',cnt, III. perfectly wsln; That i. Gc sct
W. do that t.,e nriaoner ia "i rlIt now cntlsl 10
hui. We would ike 10 l.a.e tiv question Ist..r.
| I'M II your I[pnur would Ike. that Tho
argument By set down for sorne future lay. und we
n!rsrn nr. ti thcm: '''' ''' '''' N'' ''''S %'''4
Mr. Nced-Sow, II tho Conrt please, ! subtnit
that sttes what occasreI III couf. .hia ''ornis'3
II cbIuuI H. ',.,.d hi I'M y,r 1i,,na, a,I.rr.,
th!s Euur1 uMti TOMORROW tfrdnyJ morning at 10
s,a5Ied on nv way bome .ck aud worn OIL and
| went into tic I.alnlcr Nuuee to sec d irertl aud
thcs. met Mr. Norm. ouu 0f thu counsel. and he
fal 10 tic then tlmt hs WIS requested tu
notity nic to bc hesr this alstrnoon at
2o,caek' s2sd 70 him. -, .,Thcre "a no court u
socock, 1t adjourned until tof1uErow lLurn'ng. y
And IL thcn announced TO nc that yonr llnhur had
been pursued md brought b4sk1rcqae.,ct so en,o