The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1876-04-17
VOL. XLllL.-N0. 2i7.
WINSLOW'S EXTRADlIlON.
DIFFfCTLTIES TH1T LIE ~ IHE
UilOF ms SJRELNDiR'
A,Impsrtnut I.sue Bctween the I niird -ta,er
ans Grcnt Britain zach Go'rrn,ne"'' ',,-
eiiu,.to yield it- Ground aud tue
,,,s Minslow viii Not be 'INcn 'p'

An Important IsfuC between tue 49, a.,
aus Crent Britain Zach Go'rrnmen' ~,
.t,.. IN weld itn Ground. aud tue fuE'-
,t,a Winslow will NOt be tlNcn ~"
UAsrtSGrox. April iG.-The question DC
.., ,h t-,tted states and Great Biiidlh re''-
,,n. -, tho extradition of Winslow to TINS uo'-
.rnnient l. q fir more serious one '"H" - 49,"
.c,lly supposcd. and Il liScly 70 ls'd 10 'ep
r,,ve consequences. affecting not merely the ln-
tsrs4ts II Justice and good order In thls oou"-
,ry but the harmonious relations u the Two
u,v.,,rents. Ll.lc attention has been given |
lvt,epuHIi.t 10 the subject, the idea probably |
t.n,that one side or the other Will give way |
-. that some compr0 misc can he arrived NJ. |
qbe ,a.e does not secin TO present basis for |
c,npr,uI-e The two Governments ara at |
ss,I,oca, and ncither side seems ready ~ give |
wav.
The demand Of the American Government Is
frWu.l1w's extralition. to he tried for for |
eery England Is quite ready to surrender him
onnpledcc that he sht not be tried for any
other offence. and this pledge Mr.. Fish refuses
toeiyc. lie stands unon the tire ,ty II 1872. Tho
arti.l,lN,lD referring to eNtradiuon In that
tre,tyisi the following words;
rta.reaittaf thc United states and her Britannia
Ys, shall. upon mutual rHqai-i ions hy ih'uh 9r
t.s.. VI. '.er I'm io Justice an persons VINO oolns
r.s.-.I uIll the criw. uf murirr ur nsaui WITH m
t4DiI r.uii mu dHf oi VII g. O. ar. ln or !, ,o,rl
.. i,s1 i,'in tne tr,riterie. II tnc oihsr,
.Ir.ft Iss.t'l uui, be- dome upon such eviaen. G
~ .rNNfy rs according To ne laws ~ ne p1cr
DM..i, ii. 4pa-,8,1.ion or c5l,m.tmcn' ior
ti fffn. CRIME or offence bad there he' CONN ited
.lt rneet,ye Jq ~ aal 9,as msi- It,, o. .ae
..r upon crnp.sin, ms &C. undcr o.. 20 iesne q
,n4f ., tnat ht ma, bee nrou.nt belo fucl Judges
y, ,ieacc u triaaaity G,y ne 4 ard sal consiierea
s4lt uu such uearins, tle evidence De dccmei sum.
~. 'r air "a 'cutive sat1orW, tnat a ssrrAat ma,
,Gs,h ,r1rchen.ion and deivers -hau he borne snl
1,ir.t ty the parti wnJ masvs tae requsitlOA AID
tel.'r. The fu.iivc.
Mr. Fish stands on tho text Of the treaty, and
''s '"D'N - ." - ' ''' W
A.ainst trying criminal for different
= 60 ?, -
OF war; 'h'' NY 'h'e' 'no S'"'e DoP'''" 'us
alleges tnat since ISL 1t h - been common
,.,.ti... mn, ,.Iv f,r ti,. Tnited States I'm, for
-, ., -, c.,,.t, .. ,,,,,a,,a ,r,,,,,r.,s
luEland am l'F 'AhAiN u uehAhu cIlh'nila
upon one allie "a ION of crime. and then To try
tner, fn- other rr.rrs- IL 1. true that tho net
=,
VI iai''@"'c"' ga i-'' 7ils '''' V''"'"s 9u'l'
not be surrendered to foreign - ,te until n l.
srfanged by law or otherwise that ne snall not
be tried for any oHrnce c"mulited ureyious to
the ecX tradition other than The XtriditiDn crime
But,' say the state Depart meat, we have TO-
tNlug fo do with your act ul IAl'lfusut. We have
steadi refused to make "a now treaty with YOU
on tnat act as "A bass. aud ,oAr act g mot
change the treaty BY its IToNi-iuus " The Uhited
s.4tes Government ai-u rllcs tn 2.tn section II
lue aei of 1870 to show hat III. stafnte does not
.f,p,.s To- monty tha treaty of l,iy Tine seq
ton referred to reads thus:
w 49,. 81, 49,, 1850. 49,.
me acis specned IN The thrd schedule - tAs Aci ere
2 pnd a. 80, tH @ VIZ i2 81 XII ,ay y 'i ,'i & u
srfi@i "a n irtici :, iri'i ps H. ~.
',erret % N ths octs rep. dep snail apply (as
f4fds mes committed either before or af er the pass
~ ol ihe act ~ GA case Of foreign states WITH w.cn
srs, te''es & Sr' .rgsIg, ia tae sas msn.er as & "a
rede IN nursntno Of ms ACT and as sncb order md
rct Al every law ara ordnance when I, 40 force
an, i-..sh possession Win respect to such treaties
Observation-Disclosures rsIted on ~ s,pcor, ,ho
n' sa-e ltAv v'Seu y elteu "n =" =" lpolt the
'l". 'ir AZ uDe' ho' rlc,e'li ~ "Dt @ ~ r,
-. ,r,rs, w ~ ver, @ a,,,t in tts yi.,. ~,
'e Afpa' @ 'ue"s @ - W car 49, ~, ,,s we" ~ ~
.tfitnDs of tns uritish C"vrfn,nrnt i'm resneet
t'ttIur u '"1 ''i.i3~n ~ ~ tt,s ~, 81 80
80 ~ a." ,,si,a ~. s,t,ni,t1,n
t, tt''r ."7 ~, h ,rSt f1r sny ot hsr ,trence
the A,ner,c,n q eyornnent will regard the treaty
VIZ W. la s psr ~ rsint,
o. - a. ~ ~ a. ~ the,r M -ition
- ~ thv "a yy'u 81 co'ise mi an end 10 ali
sJ,, - " " ,.i,ad crin,rgls for the erav.
ertmet Speciaed IN the treaty, and ali that feIon
eii IA ,. ~, a., ttnr nam r,fing hi. rfIfn,. I'm
WI WI nns 20 ~ .v' 20 h -, ~, 80 t m s
Iii tou" ~ NJ, ~ ,,,,,oIse sn,oun, ~ criminal
and other interce,irse bet weentbe United states
- ~ a ,n,tntS,ns ~ a resf nritsin vould ren-
sn9 .ne & M ry Tr S ansd "nid h.
cone an AIsstis for of1nders ayaInst our laws
80 sta \ ntt'd - te. In t,,rn Tor tbnss vh n Id
violated the laws in Canada or Great Britain
but every s!o mas d is Two sae' ae Il al .9s I -
ernment has It's view t. mantain, wnich II does
EuceritV as the American : ate Depari
D,Wuiup street. Ike Mr. Fi.u. relies on the
tart ,f tne ire ~ Itself There ia notninr In IL
-, .rt,,.i, - sr,tt,r ,.N.,,',,s
.@a.",t u 'nE i.t'h'i 30. ~. , - ~
tan ne ex tradition cnarse' cry true, t1ey
ray. " but there ls nothing IN II Afhrmlng tina,
sUuf may do so, and the whole airit of the arti-
'Har r S,in Spu 81 Van ~ dn,nd nd Nm and ~ ~
in III - ~ lie artcie is sin Where
S'''l'. Us 80 -, 80 - -. , d. - ,, .,rr
49, ~ '"s No,r'rseu m s o''e ~ "u ~, do,n,t
o ~ % i t ~, r, sr nr ,n
uonre in tbe treaty that YOU may specify, and
- ii " ',rr.',,i ~ -, 80 90 hin In, ~ ha tr,sd for ~
bon asa for MIN on account OF one CRIME, and
ileu Try him for another. suppose we had
asked Vatl r an csc tped Fenian on some allie
P.tlnn. "a fnurr.r ar inrgerv or ,rsyn and then
,..t.. 80, ,r,, ,,,,, - -. 'utnr ,vr,,td -,
-NVr-tu w nm ioi io'', '. liz -'u VI y ~ a.
w. ~N"hitteH l" IT, anu My"iu PNnlle. oP..ni,O"
~. America h iNe brpukcd Sufh an injustice
The allegation that offenders have Decn tried
by each country for other Offences than the one
IDtlt.-d if Inc r,uutiitlou il an embarrassing
rra f.r f.r,,f Itt,t ir an ~ "a m. danied H.r
"'N 100 'A's. - s'Nf "a" - ~ '' -