New-York tribune., 1876-11-21
DEL VALLE'S STORY.
JIs EyAMTNATIOy CONTINUED.

HIS EXAMINATION CON lINOED'
FURTHER DENIALs or THE PLAINTIFFS MOST IN
PoRTANT sTATEMENTs-THE DEFENDANT UNDER
CRoss-EXAMINATIoN.
The trial of the suit of Eugene Martinez
against del Vale for $50 damages for breach OF
promise was resumed yesterday before Judge Donohue
in Supreme Court. Circuit Part Ill., but in the room OF
the Court OF oyer and Termner, which has been
especially fitted for trials Of marked interest is the
only in the Courthouse in which there are facilities
for excluding the merely curious crowd after the room
has been reasonably filed. All the seats were taken
almost the doors opened. The plaintiff
her family and her counsel, Messrs Beach and Brown
were present early The defendant and his interpreter
Gen. Gonzalez, were in attendance, and the jurymen
were in their seats promptly but Mr. Ch0ate the defend
ants counsel, delayed the proceedings little
Almost all Of Thursday. the last preceding day Of the
trial had been given the direct examination Of the de-
fendant on hs own behalf slowly filtered through an
interpreter. He recalled yesterday, and testified as
follows
Ireturned from Saratoga Sept. 6; found the plain
tins mother with her at POughkecpslc; between that
date and the Sth the day she lett with her mother had
conversation with her; she did not come lht0 my
story that entirely false; u Is entirely false that
she forced her way into the room past Celia did not
say sending her away for her own good ana would
remain her best friend; with her mother at abOuto
o'clock the 7h, as was retiring, exchanged few
pay bills, including hers that was Sept. 2 paid
her her salary sometimes In cash. sometimes In check
expenses she deiaye them aud gave her money for
tie purpose when she asked 1t she gave mt no account
left in the morning with my daughters Tor the conYent
they LETT in tho afternoon.
see her IN Newlork. did receive from the hands OF
Celia letter from her on the dy returned to PouSh
krep-ie. 1 two days In Ncw-lOrk Letter shown.
TINS Is The letter thA AN sure Is III bri manu-
writing. From sept to Oct received suggestion
tnat anything remained due to her for wages did not
beief but conyetion did not at all receive from the
Dla /
Celia. | came back to New-GOrk with the rest OF my
family Oct. l. Telegram Was sent by her or her
mother 10 PoughEeepse, know from an explanation
by the servant Celia. 80 suppose she learned had
returned. got this telegram the Hotel Brunswick
the day after my return to Aow-York. Paper shown.
Ihi. Is the telegram: 90
loving to sickness IN my family am left without
cent tO pay my personal expenses. am Obliged 10 asa
you To give me some money at once. .. .HENkQUES"
IL on thc following dHy mat MISS Adoe caleu at
the oel Brunswick. received her card. did not see
her that day, oct B. on the same day received letter
from the plaintiff Letter shown asking MN iDf money
which has been already puDshedl sent her q ropy.
Before sending u lad rcce' e no explanation 0i nat
Blank demanding answer stating an alleged promise
Of marriage. / handed that 10 my lawyer. never
promised her marriage.
Tho defendant then repeated his previous dcnias al
most all IN the FORM Absolutely no." lie said he never
put Ing the finger of Miss Martinez and told her To
until he should replace It with another He ai-
soluoly never asked the plaintiff to go TO Europe, nor
aid he tr her that he needed one to watch over
his children lie never told her that no one was at the
house 10 love thcu only hired help He never offered to
,cuc her from the control OF her stepher she never
told him that her scpher bad threatened To shoot her
nd ncr hui band should she marry He never offered hera
choice between l. rope. Saratoga or to take house
wherever she wanted when she was at the Hotel hoy"
ho aid not ldyisc her not to 20 home
A paper marked Exhibit was then shown ani trans
lated by Gen Gonzales The defendant said he never
received such letter found It on his bureau and
taking 1t down found the plaintiff there; she
mover appealed him Ia June or any other time to do
her Justice never: he never called her Yankee or said
that all Yankees could DO bought; ne never told her bo
was wealthy and powerful and that lac could defeat her
ow; he did tell her she must accept the sipa-
ton aud make The best OF his hcndshp hc did not say
thai there Was justice for poor people; he dld not
propose t. 40 to Europe the Fl, promise to buy
property for hers hc dcncd that he had said any
thing her about his relations with other women or
had spoken lightly her OF married women or Of Ancr
can women All this story OF the painun IA these re
spocts mere romance. ,,
Alr. Beach began hi4 examination az noon Inc
defendant explained his memurunda lie sed ,hut W
discovered the pIiutn talked spanish inc INST zap
hC br lie met Lcr jan H. Dut mere Na' no Piul
o.ton her 10 teach TIL the 26th lie INST visited
America about seven years ago lie moved mere upyHl
two and hall wears agO. lie spent the summer urlaA
at Saratoga. He generally came alone but soheumcs
brought Of lbs children. Ho never tmpluycd "A uc-
octNc 10 follow the plaiutus the laWy la il-! nave
done sDy he understood one was employed ne uu i1'
know how long, IOr that 1t was over Two lnVuths ht
supposed paid hlm, but dld not remember lot now
long timc Part OF the payment was through Irlehu
while he WIS ILL., .,.,,,
together, In regard to which he simply sld she TOOK
what she lihcd eating WIN app'tit' anu ne pau tc
found her the Hotel Royal She Iequehuy spoke OF
her -tcpathc, cyi conduct lic learned OF her LEAVING
gave her money 10 buy trunk. AZ the Hotel Koya he
always mer her in Inc paror The cross examinntion
having arrived Judge DOnohuc adjourned tho ease 10
to-day. "