The Hawaiian gazette. [volume] (Honolulu [Oahu, Hawaii]) 1865-1918, 1876-11-22
WEDNESDAY,, NOTENBER y.
Supreme Coart sf1he Hawaiian H.
lands-Sletober Ecra, 1870.
P4AHASA Is BIL4,
Msssrs Hszris and Jaaa. J, J


OriNioS By Jrpp j.
ms i su5nissioa ur3sr thv Ccie il Which
K spDctrs that On the 27Jh September, $50,
a pise~ u hasd 90 Peneh Bosi street. Homo
lsts. U.s. conveyed oy Que Nz,ni 10 heaae sud
As,4ts A,s ul!s that "a the 5,h January. 1875
Ks-so Slei. lsayirg wi,I 10 uhieh nalata his
@ife sBd tNo ebiiarsa. Pazhsua 1.-THE plaiuti3).
ard Nieia are szstsd ; that Hs,aia aud Nina
have Sines died. sB3 that Hahata lsfs oy val al
her property 70 BIZ The dsfsniaBt) her sseoud
husband.
TIE e0crt is asked IN the SUBMISSION 10 eoa-
strus The all Of hsass The plia,id. PsAhAna
eit-zns that it leit his propertv Of ksczos 70
the dsriSses rsued a. j1igs,tsosats, ard that
90 the decrease Of Ealiasa and Nina toe pro-
psrty vested 10 Pk4h8Ha as the S1rvivor The
Defendant ciaitss thss BE wil OF keaao leit the
estate 90 HsIata il Zee. With IA estate tor hfs
Ia Pz4h4Hz and Niut2. and thai Nina having
lied BY The uili Of HsllIt4 The tee Is uOs 10
,be defendant saelsei ooly % the life estate Of
Panama
Al Tie las, tern q this eosrs uhen this sub
a-issloa was 6rst presented. 1t vas suggested to
eOaossl. that The fact. wbsea appears ia The
aSresd statement. that the real estate. the sub
ieei a4stsr q this controversy Eas conveyed 10
A-1ao ant HallAla hts rife, nig55 be decisive
e, the Rights u the parties 10 this case. But Il
: urged oy the plaiatEs coaussl that the sub
mission asked sJc ths construction Of Henao's
sta 0Bly AMI that the court iS limited 10 tbs
question
Section Tao Of tie Civl Code authorizes
sasIies 10 a GassEioa "a difference which might
q ths gaes,iJs u civil zetio0 10 the Supreme
C0urt 20 agree upon . ct$s containing the facts
gpoc ~baeh the controversy depe1js. AID pseSsal
4 saesolssso0 o. The sane. etc, etc The qaeS-
tioo IL difference u coarse : the rights Of The
parties To the Submission 10 the property.
Nos u seems 10 - that where the Srbuis-
sion q e. the GcIs Of Tia eJSe' diSeloSsS fauja-
ris1t4i q1esslo1, decisive Of the rights Of the
parties 70 the qzsSglo1 IA diSsrSnes. the court
aust consider it, notwithstanding it may not be
tue particular Gasstioo ~bich the parties have
pat AZ issue
lo The Submission before Is 1t would De labor
eSsiss>,y eIpsoted foe The court to eonstfue the
81. u hsal5 sigh the liability OF being obliged
ess soou a. the case could be brugSh,) 10 decide
lhat 40 estate vested 10 He0ao capable Of 6eius
devised By siL We consider. therefore. thai
sbs tItls of hsaa0 Ia the properly Is fairly
rsiSet oy the Sgale-1ent 10 the Submission, that
the premises ~ere e01vsysd to Heuao and
HsllAua bis vile
To washbern On Real Property .. 2Ts. the
s1ttoc sSyS Ia consequences x the tbsorstie
lrlaF arc entirety u TIE uEuefShip Ot uuSUdll
4El si.s IN respect 10 their Interest in tsnds.
they cannot take By purchase 10 u0istiss, aud
where llGd Vas eoaveysd 10 bold IN common aud
g5s 70 lJilt tsrlEcy, thsy we're held 10 take az
entirety Of estate without regard 10 the latent.
IEsy -re. uos properly j5iuS tenants OF such
lands, since. though there i q right Of Survivor
shfp, neither eu1 convey 50 - TO defeat tbs
right IL the other. E1ch taxes A. sntiety Of The I
estate
See aLso SehogIsr Dam. Rel p. ISL
The view that eoaveyaucs Of lad to hus-
oau5 a1d wife and their heirs. vests The sutisrty
70 each d them and 1Don the death Of one tie .
s1rviv0r tzSes the whole estate. i aoanIsHtly I.
Supported b q Blackstone Coz. lS2; c.. Lit. I
Isl Wight " Ssiden. 20. y. \. so Jaek- .
son rs S-svsns, Is, Jgbnsou's 10; Barber "
Harris Is. Wsud. 6I5; Doe ~ HoxIlrd, s, .
Coz. Us
The death Of Ksulo vested the entire estate
2 Hal1-1 The survivor, Eh0 Is GOV represented .
b. Bib the dsisEdant, Psahaoa takes uosLiug
y AslAo's VII f1r thses Sls nothing foc him
10 devise.
Jgdgueas for defendant, bat costs to be paid
y him. A. be might have taken this position
arder and saved The plaintiff lie expense Of %
.cgigg.
CH1s- c HAzz1s.
i. FEAScIs JCDD.
s B Dals. Esq forPIlil.iE; c. BrOnu, Esq,
% dsfendlas.
HoaoIela. Nov- :. 1876.