, 1876-10-24
A Comparison Of tho Dead Man
aud OF Ills Slayer.
An Appeal to tho Jury to Do Their Duty
to tla Community.
A1r. Moran Bcgins the Talking OH Dclalf
OF tic Defense.
And Makoa @ Forvid Appeal In Behalf
Of H;a C1iout.

hl,ro ,,,,, l,oa ,,,t ,,a.,, ,o,, to.,,I.n ,. .io
III "ta r,a nus yss "ss o ,a,t ' so
the NEIL being driven from the scats heretofore
occupel by them hung u1t to the gallery rail-
inrs and stuotl on tho hacks Of tla bcncl,cs,
MI, .o.,nr tn,oro.t ~, ronnta M, nv ,nanr nf
uuen ., 'i'te'ts.e'' psople' "'1H '.' ,'a"y ~
tMct'' hat. never gathered III aconrt-iionsc III
sulliynn was seated bcsilc her husband all .lay,
md t. two were Of co,rsc Tic cr,,trn o1 ntt To.
tion. noen Ncl'e uu1nE M,. Mo1a'as auasess'
at'a not Il few among the ladies were moved to
tcnra when lie tnlkc41 atout q little boy clitglnE
TO 9ulIiya,,,s neck a,,l kissing 'j as In,,ratfons
.,, H. ~ 1r.r, .s aano u"u 'use.s e',a'
ac,cf," Mrs. ltnn1oru was present durll!G tho
morning, anl she, too, tremblcd with agitation,
and cried when reference was made to The
sc,ncs of ti,e truprs2v mud tl,n t.onscorrnt mia.
crv mud lopcltnrss ri 4lw f,orcaso,1,a famiiv
IT, W., r,,,,, @,,o,,u f.,~ tho ,,~rs ',.,,.,,,,
.ai. s.n 4.,a,an upxsaeu iol aae pfosceu1sou'
anu spoke SUBSTANTIALLY Us lollows:
Tho duty Of II juror, was IN asl cases m I'M
pG. @ a4e Se o It soa as Sn Ns1e e e Gs 1 Sp
thu most highly Intelligent, Tint the office Of
administering Justice was vested III tho citizens;
nl.d wherever illat w!s tle ease It ought to 20
segafJu @ Saa 9 h nesysd Kry y W. y W tel
citizen, aud one Which deInan,icd thu highest
md best qualities OF llcnd aid heart; and
where thu c'tlZcn was called upon to admin!ater
the lazy IN casc like ths involving on the one
6lde the peace ind safcty and good order OF
society, ald Oil tho other thu life or liberty
OF citizen, II r0se to its very highest possible
l'o!nt. II WY then TINT j',ror !,eeH;ne en-
phntically Judge, anl required tho intelligence,
parttnltty OF u Judge, 80 that he might upon
tho ono llana carefully conserve the laws a,l1
necessary 1ihcrttes OF the people, and
upon tic other hand guard vIeilantly md
rf.r
to bind this. duty moro forcby upon tho CEN
SCIENCE VI tllc Juror tho Inv Ind wisely brought
20 oil tho otllcr considerations tat cniorced this
high duty tbs sanctions If religion, aul Ind re-
thu responsible Ut nll offices, tiat lie should
swear In the presence Ut IFS Maker that lie
would execute that office honestly, fnfthiully,
legally, und according to the very best of llls
NOTHING COULD pr SIMPLER
or more cus,ly coulprcl,enticd tAA,1 this case.
There was nothing co,lrlIcetcti, nothing iliIli.
Glllt, nothing that required nnytitpr more thun
j,reliend beth thu low applicable 10 Il ai,i tic
iacts involved, The crimi,ml Inv especially III ths
country. wis uxtruu,rlv siinnlc. liz y:ntt,trj
to say that the wl.ulg mass Of wrll.fnfo1uci
statcs, especially In tlie % mora intelligent s Dor
tlons, where VT llail tile good fortunc to Hive,
were suicie1ltiv ncnni,teG Will, nil fi,c Tcnerl
principles VI tic criminal law to lw uIJiu to
decide suc!, Il question ns wus hvfure
tic Iuyy lust about rs we'll as uny LAWYER III tlo
State Ii was tho rood fortunc OF tic uCor,le,
TINT they were titus ule to thoroughly Under
stand u,iJ completely comprehend tic common
mud or1nary and daily rIghts a,,ll privileges Of
know how to nyDl being cntanrlcd in n ,ucus-
uro in tfle crimtnn1 law Nf ti,rh IjtilIru1Itv.
lnwcvcr, nrosu Will, any nun uf ordinary IL.
tc!!Iseucv. =.
,,o., tfsp ,,':s w" t,,. se " ~
Tie defense wctt) hn,l seer IT to tledrce In Ills
openi,v Ut tic case. which it wus NECESSARY for
him to alludc to simply TOR tho purpose 1t r1i-
bcca,lso thcy ilasl no sUrt Of rcleyn,cy to thu
cosc, All,tsfoM Ind l,sc,, made 10 ti,u
MANNER IN WHICH TJlE Ju1r VA. sE1,EcrEp.
rs fhongi, l.u iSwctt) had some iault to tindi
NJ - n ri ,,1urs II vas vrj H. Ike rhrv v' hs.1'
hrcu selected In precisely tic manner t.u
statute rcnl,lrci lIuuItrtls uf mel, wcre
icJjsent ctizes IN s thu "fty s Mem of al ss 'uss
cs, Of I'll natluualitirs Of every cC,lcryaJIr hiutl
a,nl dcsrriplnwuru ts,uiasc,; ,,ccu,lsu illcy lad
iorlucd u,ll exfrgsscI sorur kind III u, "IitnlHu
,St 4, ~, e. s.ssmst,; n olon ! ~ IN ~ Syss
S1s sessee x rntry 5 @ nf fGqc" t tse
wns sntistje,l. Ii s,,inr,l tn iim t1,mf ,rht f. e
Counsel cu 1 for ..t"t @ % ll tbink' NJ s.isS '@ II" @
,,rr, 1l,at tLrrc wns s",ur ,mSntrae n III, ~ ~
lcctio,I II thu iry II, fits .,st. r',tjI tia inrv
rcnlg;iy iii WSrS tlley iIununIe,i IN try 1I tI,st
iss,,u ,isy wcru sworn tD ,Ty wns tuiajv if. n.
irre,,t o., They wcre swcr,, IT." to trv In. o,,es.
tfo1, w,,cther the tcfrn1nnt ps,s,.;i n t,r tcr.
ribia rrII,,, NJ m,r;i.r wns ,,ntiv "r u,'t ' mi
tiat was tu oniy q1!tst!on M tar iscsu /" is try "
trrrstln,s ar,r,,,'t ~ 0S ''''N "''o s'e' =" ~
vAiiUt's rE1.sEcuTloss THAT u.u occrrncn
'"A os sctn.,nT ~. rn,,,s71sn,TT "u Veeo''"hn
liz fSwcti; hal mil t,nt am S,rr"t,,u i, .o,,
irSr 1T III" ataE. II, ,S ,',st trrt, 'u ,n,r
hv n Mr faivim r.. - t i,'t'n. ~.
IN rcv ,it,tn't inrm I'm ''' n" ;,I,"m t,r,'
hin, iii il mid then, i. 'In,crin,,". lin 't,,iit
nr i,,ntn'rr "T ~" "csmI. t,sr I'M ,,nre'., E""s
tinms In Sw.tt1 sa ho% ,e,,,rr'' t'Is IN .c,t
Of rr|.on liz ind rcml ~ so1.s ,rrrth1, m III 1s mcrs
sncmti,.'a u,t .vj"t ~ Il W,,,, .,,u IT,.
hrns,"ht l., i,rrcf Wnr., x, f,,nrin,, ',n mt ',
itrim,s nrsrrt,nsf +" ~" ,,"tiv ,it.n., -,
lin rtry ts,.rts ,Yere. sonc h,,t s,nt. .v.; ,,ai
ind til. .t.xa f,rue Ia ,rI,v,r, .,,rs"lv,a my,
tbtuo NJ rcfftriiv,s Irr,ntin' 1'.i i,,,,,,,. ~
snh,tr7v i,,'nmsshr ,, ,r,~, i,1" =" ~. w.
ha'n,ur,an ~ w"rs. va, ~ ,r,iI hio,i,,., ~, T.,
neither Uw. "r }uf,r|ty vet in wus ~ ~,