, 1876-10-24

There must b: ~ dire Mcef.ity,-ft't nrrcasfty
tn Eart: ln'lnr, q save ws''illrl prIc' not s1he
t"fnl!nrary qualification: III vfLity To ln graft
N"1c nt tlIrlc, t,cfnr" tho lar, were re"ng';lz:1
NJ nj ttn al.llt"st weight u consideration.
Where II man wAs tll1 n%gressur liu WIS Lnta-
Hac!'atc'! tr,'fil setting up stl!Iefthsc Ut all.
Ec aakeh tilr jury
WHETHER THIS wAa 4 GAZE or ICsrIrlABtE
HOMICIDE
whether the 'leferdnEt was compelled bT atl!Tc
'eeGssltym af protecting hts owI. t!e Or d fas.
tflg 1ttc of Mr. ffaufhrt!. The question n!,-
swercs itself, Sullivan tlti not cvc prcttn'l II.
BY tho humanity II llc law he wns permitted
l'e believed, tia. he reallv thought. III tbs titu
a1inn IN wllle hc wts's liAra, t!at nothing hut
taking the IIlc Ut 'Ian!or'l wnu1l sayr him from
present tlcnti, or great umlitY hastn. The flt-
llnnlord's l,use, attaskc'! lin. Md kno:kctl
him down. II Ilnusor,l linl ttcn risen with Il
pistol T.! his hand. u1nl Sullivan Ind shot him,
II woull still E,c murder. The young mat,
upon himself aa MI excuse for tile h,mciir.
lie vas dlsIuolet from EcttlnE up tho Plea uf
sclf-lciense, unless after the tight had pro-
grcsscd hotle I Inc n1rl he abandoned 1t yolItl-
tartty aud notified the othcs side u his intct-
ton.
After reviewing 1Ianfurtl's letter, claiming
tlut tho extent ul The charge was that there
wMs 4
nIsG tn T1tE noAEp or Ei'pcArioN,
ring md with Maynr colvln, tIr said The clurEes
could mt hayc been rroyclt even II the Cuurt
lad permitted proc! to be Uttered. did my
Dnc .Ruprose.. Il there were men IN tho Boas'l
making list 0f tlttr positions ror sinister u1ul
iinpro}'er purposes, Tint they would conr fur
wartl lind fcstily to III Wouldn't every onc of
tflcm leny IT. a man who was hase enough 10
lcrvert lbs Office thus would l!t base enough to
llehy It even u,sder oatil. T'iere was unit
versal suspicion all oyrr tie city about
that time that tic ntllccs wcrc full If
rings, anu that opinion Is ~ weft-funtlcd now
III then The defendant was well acquainted
with the Enarl, and had no interest In nssa,'lt
tg my oilc, lis only interest beinE the ndyNn t.
1ncnt Of the scElouls. Counsel lid not k,ow
what grn,s''tls OF hcllef lantnr had in the trutt,
of the statelaenss b: mutlc; bat Iinpfnrl l!al
said to Sullivan. "1yhcuever yon CONE to tut III
!S!<al way viii either lnakc then, true or
Will take the let,al consequences" ffc dill not
know liuw much oppression, wrong, and insult
hc Ind suffered Mt the hands Ut the UOnrd. What
he fiad said to Sullivan was all ht MAS bound 10
sAy, h'id nll the law compelled him tu say. Thu
uly Incl, who male any fuss about being called
rln5sttrs wero members Of this 'oas II counsel
latl done nothing wToiig, atId Should bc charged
to III hut II n,an told the tfllth about him he
would bc apt to make u fuss. The must clam:
orous lnan was the rubber when eaught, Mem
hers nf the Board had bccn called TO prove
That there WIS no SronE,--tle same ones WHO
Ind l'ccn accused Of being iu It,-anl the vaiEs
u their testimony was ii he determined By The
Jury. HG insisted that their testimony was not
reliable.
IN COMMENTING uroS scLLlvAs's CONDUCT 1T
HANPOHDfs HOUSE,
le said there never was cuoler lnan than Sui
liyan,-Ae rttitng verbatim long spuGtalt t hat lie
inate tn 1ia'1fofd, MD telling ex!etly what thu
reply wes; never wis \ more akil!ful md alroit
slut n.at!G unlcr tho circumstances.
a recess w4s then taken until = o'clock.
Upon rtasstmbllnE, tho attendance WIS as
/ large Us IN the morning.
Col Van Aruan resumed lis argument. lie
said he desired next to allule to u subject upon
| which considerable tiIne lad been spcnt by tic
| lttensc, md tlat was tho
rAisT WHICH THE DEFENDANTS WIFE TOOK IN
THE OCCURRENCE.
lie believed nil tho interference un her part In
| the homicide wus fnr the purpose of humanity.
lie lu not the slightest itea that any wultull-
much less II tady VI her accomplishments urd
| Etotf character -cuuu lnye inttrferch III such II
lie lcgEcti to he unllerstunl to entirely .ruu!t
| her uf The least possible blame In connection
| with It. But that WAS not a!l that was claimed
oil tl;r othcr stdc. It was urged that tltc jury
Tiny Ind taken great puino t. prove
that scyesa! years ngn she had received all III
Jury, undoubtedly tlt'Fe or less scvcrc, III Wis
tlot aware TINT Mr. 1Iuniurd wis accountable tor
| they wcre utter strargcrs,-that linilforl ki,cw
Mrs. Sullivan nlcrcly ,ts public writer, nnll II,
Tint hIcf,n rtHyn n t1mf 81. 4,
~ mt"s,s sppMs ~ Gs, a.ai Guy,
md tv ,'..r ,rsnni & '.rot n1
~ ~ ;t.oi ~ ~, p' - ~ u III
m IT, a1 a"io,a ,"t =" iu tai ',u th s,,t ~
iar hn"i,,, -, H.. 't.' ~, mns na nU ntatc III ~
,uss"i H., ~ ,.su.si'n+,a,, e ~ ,. ~ W."
.,ra ~ '''v ,r,',a sfn,sa M Us to o'1 & u.s. ,.e
Iinnfnrd,s ,vrs .n,,, 81 rhtialnn Sseoss sv,,. y.
,,nihv ,Soa " nas,1 a fr cr elute, ,ens,,s SYN,
% the following cycnn., ] 81 pbysicau l ioun l,cr in IN
sla fy ~ i! III th t'rf,nan. ha ,,,|'nht H. ~
taks la wife ,l,crc. .oud Iianfor] l.aye nr. ~
III" enu'iiton ri iTarfnr,,is xfn, ~ hrr orni'an
chi,t]rr,I irsI,s fl" hn,1v nf icr ,n,sand nm fnI;v
,uIr.lrrdi Wus rI,c rtt so,mewIat ,rrvas ,y ~,
tint ,vtri,,or M,,,bt i, nj '.ian "s s.,n',a,h~
fnr her. ~ So,,sri lid tor ~ ' . wIf4. # ti! ~.
fmlant Il neit ' h ~" so ~ VIZ Xxx H. u h Luz ~,
rcccivn wo,,1i nI.o,,'. for hrr ci,ul',io, iii w"r.
ths INV GU, tsi" thnt H., rns str,,., 1 11on.
f'r, ntsnfIoneiIsI Iii H., am.
for kmScd ,15w,, nsosa Il e lis fset .s h,s,.rr. .a
ri nn,,Hcnt hnf'M" :" hts t'",,ti' mi
struci; Nrs' Sullivan Mr. va, armam ,,'".w nw
It lmd ieeu sworn to by the brother Of, Of thc .ic.
Wns yrry W tcnyr, til Nh sli..iItest ruI, @ wo,,hl ]
IH"t'!st u iSA 74!Ns. 41"aiolNs htltAiuH WI Iia-