New-York tribune., 1876-08-04


10 postpone on the part II Nj. Blaine; The tesiiio
not being all in, have come 10 no conoiu'ion 0N
MIR FRYE- tNat is true do you Justify the chairman ian
of The Jndicary Committee in bringing that ai'er pc
Mr. HIiNFoN-I have nothing to do with Il; Ihe
Chairman of the Judiciary Committee acts ior hl'nSc"
'TJ Mr. FRYE"Answer me categorcay now. DO you
Mr. TUCKER Dem, Vail call the gentleman TO
order lie night 10 address my colleague u.ree"s
MR. HALE's PROTEST.
Mr. HALE Rep, Mel said that this Winter there hau
been much Of fair combat the floor OF the ohe' ~
foremost in those combats had been his i"rmer
Mr. Blaine lie had given aud had taken h"r" u""'' ''
he had never given blow in the back Ills 'onp''S n'
always bcen ouen and manly and everybody opposed 10
him kpe his ground and had fair chance TO thrust ana
parry. All of this matter by unanimous consent h','
been considered ~ far this session was coh'e''"'
n matter of the past. The Judiciary 'o"''rn''''
had agreed after fun deliheration III Wni'h ne ma, , in
man, Nj Knott, had WrtGlpN'e' ,at ,.a frnl in
which Mr.. Blame Interested Sh"uiu C'i'S ~, ~ u.s.,
vcstgation should cease from coihcu, ~ ,h" ncSt
from discus'on ana sh"uli ~ W i inv .nurmnr
session He hgd failed to near n,"' ,, 'r 1,n,uil,e
of dissent 60 the conclusion oI tlc JH''I' ',n,
for az the time IL was 81, ~ knrss AZ the
time that conclusion was reached II hl nrui " N,r
mined that. in consideration of all tue in
Blame should have the brnchi 1I M,'' I'M" subi@rt mad
court would have alwHy accoTdcd hlll i,. ,..t ~
been opened again by the gentleman teh =, ~ FScnds
by thai openng no had gained anytl = u @ h.s .',
had gained anything II Noiiu o., 49, ' ,,',,I.
House nau MAJ a ltiIldI hiNi'
drnb.rafiuu and passion; passion Wi'h "d no. ViOo %
lfs words; dclIncrttlon which iald III "..'' ,ri,
,r, add enemy had disappeared, before II stlu'k iot'
TN, House hat tine two combined N ul'lHv @ ~
nd never seen before. IN lnNt'lS''@un on Nv o II
trr,.rd to tc Judcilr, Committee OF the House. anu
ha, been pvucl, that the mihs' OF IN 'h,,,cr
mi nassinn a, that uf u iui-c; bat tnc Ohhrn,u
nf tndI committee (Nr. ku0ttl dait5 10 come 80 .no
Hosc and not only to- discuss sac matter cn'rH w '
rTrt nm Ter consideration but u 20 into Ar Bllo ~
ia uus 10 toe mater. II Is breach o. 'i lii'n, ,
ms mo member 1,or has ever htct ul,kl.'e' Wy
participating iu lhcTo y 40 nan H. "uu.ai fo
ieen uainrI by the exhibition TO-DAY nc "Pp. ~ ~
botu sids the House to vote aainst thc rtpoii eN
crttus Mn Knott Tnc report l. made up, lie sa prih
cil on tccu3cil grounds but u Eoesiutt"rr. ~ u's
ihe TT, heart OF Mr. Knot, and no nan who H.. h..s
is.cu,d MS spera VIII DOUBT tntt il. 's VIM i
i. ,unylu. him to-ay q ud.Ic. W.rh IA, ncr li-
bcGd IN uis heart iOr weeks ana m"h.t'' iS nI'y
wA.cn lie, IN IiL la conclusion h' aiii: IL ny yUd-
tucsy tir Kno,J would have no more cared 10 maze
tnaj Srccn than nosrs owl af,s u" s'u'.,C -.
when '!le eagle Is abroad soaring III hlS l'"'' 1NiS
on tue Republican ''Gc.I
OTHER REPUBLICAN EXPRESSIONS.
Mr. NCCEARI t.ep., iOSJ)-de.hDer o1 t'e judiciary
Committee e. pressed his regret ina TN CHAIRMAN o INC
ud!ciar, Committee had taken advantage Of the orpoT-
tuuty afforded him by the maSnanimity oi MS col
leagues, and ndd discussed the whole subject oi h'e'u-
,otiou lie compared with the treatment received by
Afr giuc the generous treatment accorded by the Re-
nuIican ,iqc o the House 80 'ir hcr aud declared
that Mr. K,rrs yndication Was ot Sd complete nor 50
thorough nor overwhelming a. Vas TIE Nihd'iph oi
Mr. MOAE RcJ, Mass). auo'aer member Of the Ju-
dietary Committee, sAl e.t ~ Htd ds>,h''i i" -,
rrpo,t not on any technical srua!, nut hcr"u'c hc i'
It,.I tl, Gentleman from u4..ay Incapable uI Ia"
net of .uur,ssuu charged AGAINST in li' hdi th'H-'
20 Ia.,i,te fu1t leuicinau- uI-u pusiti a. r'prc-
~ ,,. ,,.,,,r.,l -f.f. ,,t k,ultci.y and a.
intrliau 81 lhc Juii"ry Com 'iicr OF thc House ma
oItycieHcd any susp,iou proving ont facts before
fbc tont;rc lie bed i.,I,n & t. tac speech oi mat
acna,Icu ius Liorniug WIih Tue Moss I"""hd n''Iy"
auJ shame, ant ~ ho "aa h-d u "'!o.' ''aH"H '' IT,
r ar he -ifBiit not nave --t.tHl Do.
Nr. LAWitENCE uirp., OuipI-anothcr member ol me
Ja!c.Iy Commit,a,-a,so cApIg''rd hs tc-r,l at IA,
',lI...I5n witnessed by iEr H.u.e Jo-lr, aHd s'il
That he WoGid nos insist G1t iUc 'c"r', MW,H ~ I'.'
s.-ned, should be rcrUhni'tit" 10 t"' J'''''''i! ''
Iu!JtC iur review.
DEMOCRAT MOVES EECoMU Tru.
Mr. HURD jD-m., Ohiol vino presented the report
said that the gentlemen Oh the minority oi tie com
mtcc VINO bid just spoken did not regret more than
hc himself did hat had trdnspired to-day lie h'i pre-
s,cd TO the House the report which had been uiuli-
f,ou.iy agreed 10, and ~ 10 which he mad snPpos'i
there would be no discussion or debate; nc had IN con
vcr.;iuu. glyca ui, WORT q! EDuor to hr Ft!" tl't
sti.rd that al tlat was intended to De- said w's that
which related IL tnc Cuauau OF thc committee ahl N't
he r,.rriteI the debate because II compelled ihos"
srut.rn, VINO id Aiudly and generously ssncd the
to withiTaw tnrir approval fIom IL. lie wIs not
here 10 express an opinion "a, To- "nal h"u p,'h
or as 10 tuo different propositions winch n ha 9'',
cu-scd. A report mad be- presented Whth oh'Il'I
& , ss, ly iui.,rliy oi Inc Committee with cnccr-
iincss ana ircnIlIuc>s lie wOmd rthl nhindh that
rl report Vas tuc, aud tnnt the PROPOSITIONS IN IT,
1I,n % @ -, ~" tcrc tn s5y mat there was NOT the
lie was mere W -, ~ ' or ti, t,r, al IN,
| CHAIRMAN OF tic Committee clthu a MlIul pui-
ms 10 ,,ithnoid m, Caldwell dispatch, or disposition
10 inufc any person lie therefore prepared To vote
IN ynl o. report as hr had Not'd Tor u wien III aN
" ,,f ir f,r ,.iuIit.c .cc: but six members of the
lrdr., Committee having requested him Ia have the
rrp5t withdrawn Tor furtGcr action, lac ROW uidt iHe
ncs,esry notion 10. tbat purpos- lie moved hrt the
| t..r.. |.sH. - tltt. al tIH.
EXCITED REPLY OF MR. KNOTT.
Mr. KNOTT arose amid great excitement and said: one
by ono the roses fade" lLaushtcrl Aud for what
Because they nave been touched by the frost OF truth
After the ship OF the lue struck is coors lttle eN
pected that would be compelled to continue the conflict
with the yawl yet, nevertheless II seems that such
the case As to the speech which have delivered and
which has caused 20 much pain TO the gentleman on tac
other side have to sly that would not alter single
word which | have uttered The man who suppo'cS
that ! will sit talncy by ana submit 10 , D.u
tai, outrageous, dslngenuou ana iaise .ssaa'' t !,
sucn as has been repeated and re;tclitei !
i'm ten thousand dhercrent shapes ana IN Ten Thousand
different channels throughout thS country, anu m ttu az -
ill NOT say word In my own defense or IN NY own
yindcaon. mistakes tho man lFurnng around 10 MS
side ui the HOusc WIN ErI'' I laiit," % ~ ~ ~ u "
spirit Of defiance lac continued: y Abandon me You
Mnon MON every Htterance Which / made, and / ret
crate a; much h Of the may gS1tlcnnn from Maine
Alr FrycJ who could sinder II on sIcn sglt , ta
must say that il certainly was uO very strong litbdslp
and that II must part, VIII 94'N !" H"'
veil and If forever, stll forever Ia e tnec we'll" Zap
! nl,use and lailgIcr Now what u the mead OF my
nI.ndiugl It il said that have prcludged the ease
mere trust that such iusinuatiOns were inadvertently
| made. because lhcy not lusthed py the facts
might even say that such lnputation Is absolutely ana
uuduillHcdly false. have only brought 30 the atten
tio of The House certain facts In regard 10 the Caldwell
tel gram without expressing any 0ilion on thosc iacts
at all or without having pr,JddSed the mater under
| Investigation , - .... II, =,
| Mr.. Knott continued: But now DO THESE exceedingly
| yrtuous gentlemen dcpOrt themselves. Ihcy are as
uc iud cs subject matter ol the investigation as
| rils IA
say tt Mr. Blame is immaculate, ana as chaste "a the
ccc that guarded by the irost froh pIest snow and
| hangs ON DIna's temple; and ironically there Is no
harm There Is prclueging tho case IN tla
| | nave not said tIat he Is gniity or Innocent nave ~
| IniIAr OF lne