, 1876-01-03
SCIENCE AND RELIGION,
Eodgman vs.. Proctor-..Other Warriors
Joining III the "Shindy."
Tho Scientists S'lgnatIze Their Opponent
asa ycritablc Know. Nothing;
While the fndomtabio Hodgman Declares that
Proctor, TyndaIl, and Huxley A!o In
hn!a5on'sm 10 All tho Laws
oil Nature.
ANTl.HoooMan, to.l,


an1,.uonot.au no,
To he Editor II The Cafcago 7r,bune;
CH,cAGo, Dec. 30.-1'oor M1. Holxmau was
born too latol / pity him because he uoascsses
taent for ignorance which could l,ayo enrncd
him high apd respected position il. the limo OF
0aitleo. lilo could hAyo boca worthy Grand.
1nquisitor Of tho tribunal Which condemned
that great astronomer who was impudcpt
enough to teach Copernlcna' theu,y, aud to
cllrfsten IL Science. which cana IN M
| unrovcrent conflict with that Book uhicl,
Is supposed to 10 tho fountain Of all Tfu.t and
Science. Die not Joshua command tho suu 10
| ttanA e.ill bnt how could he command It to
| stand etiI1 II /. yaa mt in mntian ? 1'hcrc}or,
Gnliico vns An Atto;at. and {.oncrn;rn.' th,e,.,
'on;,s.t, 49,, .,..... ,r,,.. !. '.,as:.,'" ~
ussn'hp AnA an''"e' 1H"s !" HPeelae" ei Mf'
Hodsrnan'a Science. After roa1inS Mr. t'foctor'a
! lecture, t,e wont through tho whoIc r1be, hut
failed tn find nuythfnc a1,ou. tt,o {. Saly,,1, y
| .1cn ma,I, lin ionht n, onro tin ,r,.t,, nf ~,
| "A's. A10 ~" eo"o" =" "'ss '0' ''H''4 - a''
| new discoveries. -...
! les, 1t Ia " almost Impossible to kcop mp will,
tho march Of Science In our ta7 =" but II il e,,-
tj,c1y jmpossib,o to do 40 for this m31crn Omar
49,. ,..,s,., ,'.. oss I.a1, ,':, 1.a"a.. - 49,
""o ht'o"" nus o'e p''1' 'iia Ao'an. ~ ho
would kuo" llttlo moro nbont Natural filsloso'
| Phr, aud less Of the Koran. ho would not sock
| for ecentiic information in the latscr. anl, no.
Frffi ntt,s Il CtS IN EpS0
w.. ~ -. ,ra,.,,a,' ~, ~. ~. ..'"
Ao"' 't1' 4ionGsoah. 3ou arc hos sno 'haa TO
! commence var with Science; yoh haa bc:ter ant
your bsntu to work for nov Inventions, and you
will haye moro Aucccga. nj IL pfoycd by your fast
tnvot,,,1 :. ar;.uc,-f:n,,oo" ", ta.,o, +ri,,,,.
l'enNou ':eo i. w. ~
your own sc1ontihc aolAtacs, nhu II 1nnicasod'
| quito corrcctly,-Lcto!
| But you asked oucationa, az .tUov does le
| r,1r rroc.or1 knnw Tint fbo ca,t, cvr, ,ras II,
H.. ..,s.S;. -. 49,, .,a.t.s,t ...,n..s 50
tuas esoa1ns' uo'' aao 'l'e''su HAL
Ihat the earth was before III o melted. liquid
1art uf t)e ea-th liz still in mo1,cl ),oull 1,ntc
r. x,,i,,, r,1.,roo, o., t,,o ,-oof ~, ,o,, a,,a'
VI "n'eu 'o's"uo'' a.e ~ p''o, ~ soe SUI
nit 70 tlat, or 20 you nolieyo the Volcanoes 10
be- ihe c}li'n,'oJs of old sntans su!lhureoMs sao-
ratofyf lo''o 5o1 90 submit 10 y; wen, tneh,
tile inner part o. the earn u atsi 10 ineteu
steie u u pfis na1u1M tnai sho "noIo stono "aA
once IN that rtasc anu VIC aafo psoo1A ior tnasr
IT,: ~ oT fho spherc1i ehaio Q: our EARN !;
l2l by The 1act that the Elobo III hGtsenoi on the
loIes t'l W eoososlcal e"&a''na''o" VI 'ne sur
!aeo Of sIo garry. a.
should tAlak you would TO convinced. By
thss bf1oi eSplanatlo1, that the ehrta "aa ohco
| III melted state. bht you 4aso ono moro
scl1pie: ~ 'ne pooY o o@F s'ops WIS ot'co ~
asato or icelon;-n hloteu, h1uIa ulshs as tho
| tne3fT c91ns,-!ot too i3otessol oAlaa'u WY
IL tho process OF cooifhG, tho neaaet mate'!al'
| a. Eoa' h'l'c1' ieuu' oIc' ou Nv; netsie ~ tiu
bottom, III obedienco to the lay OF Specific
gravity. LII tne .sap9ia. ~; M nHl'oshSssAi y
III entire contraFeltion 70 s4ls laS; Iho heam- ,I
OF ma.soa aFo lonnd ..sas ihe suLaeo "a EoEl,
&C. Willie etahite-tock. "nlfii - seven ta1nes
hGn.or tlan so y fonha a ne,o,s .em ~ a.an a. r.
lhis 1uosI!on. Ms lloas,nan. % y u;,a fey ~ w.
awear. u th9 n1e. P!oeo' sola 4na sllseE. "naca
NO una ncas INC saslnee, ateL4 aai sotss 70 eas
very scarce coMpAseu "'st1 NV !ah's ot hlnHto
foek anu otuet n'ne1ai nnu s9e"; tuats9Ia M'ea
loln tne sur'aeo u % .1 h x;l, II Eolu "aa ~
plenty hs granite; "ou'A !se tlcner MN, ata
your DOUBTS won'u Hn'e luo'o ss3so ou'' M tso
pfopestsoas ot Eat1 e1,a stotsloa ase " sae
~ In'e' ~ N. 4"stei' oanrto y 20.
p'fnvnr esar Snrn Sereo1s nv vii nnw x',
now taat nts4o GoM anu s'1stt ea1's poas ~ tI tmo
sutss At ~. ua ,,,ot h -e.i,,:, a;,."n - LII
iatAons. II you Iaet M 'eauce aIi,eI i, u. snu
ese ~ ~. "ia~ eli oy % ~ H.. nv. o
tho potion. WHO .no VIZ W. WI , muT on a,se 10y
~. hcs -. sia a ,.' II ,o, sv.
cool ana examine the s!as ama yon VIII Always
nna Il 70 eohsa auu1o tnsas'u XIV " efef
81, ~, ,na ~ si'ii, ,Iino tc ua
5nn sstl tne n'oten 'ta ~ "'t' eois' ~ ~, e.as
VII conta''' " inuen 'abe1 1'eAeeu''%io " 'Ao~o
nS.as' sTs ,on, .;u ,ouovo r,,,r ,ro x;,r.rc
ms @ po, WIZ m ,n onr ioar .ns, ,s iis
ito euriaoo is ,,ot = a,y nofn-et yon would
70. 10 s1oaosea WILL 10 maus @ t ,,
the oart4 must have grown oooi. "'i inuat sesl'
on 20 coo4' eoo'' coo'' Wa ~ eoo'a "o"" " tao
se1tTs, nhs. H., ann ;. st;,, :, a c,osn, ,a,oous
lhat tao sun u stsil ~ l.a""its' 4..a GaauonS
esao eah po pIoseu "y .rs.,
tloii- Ihosu obaeIsas'otn Are psllotnlcn VIA
~ apparatus callca bt'ecttossoP,;; H.; W te.tu.
the FaYa OF eoioleh Aan!e' a!sos asse.
rnsa'n: tnfonsh Aatto" ,,!;, n!.. 1'n' ~
oree n1!sa't n..a ~ n'..a uns.s''rG ta;l'u tno
spectrum thus produced. ~ nisa,'s o. e- te!s-
scope. Each metal or eleons "en G.'es cutos
to the llhho PRODUCES : pccn''a1 Fl'os!tt1n'. .
iofmcd. IN some casss o. h.,y 'ss - ,o sns
sasno eo!os ~ o1s W '"w
Of different colol lhes9 tiee1fa h.e en1'nu1ea n',
tsslc I'll TUG inyhflaoo .e'ao ios1" ~. au"s W
cnsyt ana ~ tto 1onote coe W 'mo III
iicnlty all speatrl'il'-E!vlns cohb'ls'lo''ss o.
iluxtuse Ut QUO s!a", lne nnes Glataet",tsl!u
of each elcincnt appear III 1lso "tn'oas o1ae1''S7
and purity. ,.,,u ~ .,
but. " huaas ~ - ~ ~ ma
asc"1taln on!y to ch9ncaI eLaioahsyi o. II. 1ala-
toliaa. but also the r4yticai s'at9 ~ WHICH laoy
arc when oflelhatlog lSht. W. ~ ."o eipos;..
III continuous. tHo aupatance ~ ~ slo"nls'