New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-04-09

went with her to Pceksk1u; renamed over Mohu'y
night came down Tuesday afternoon, getting In just
in time to marry Mr.. FINLEY Tuesday night; LEFT the
house at half past six the next morning. went to Boston
and STAYED there all the week and the next and LEFT Fri
day. and came home on Friday night That Is the little
history.
O. From Friday night Of the following week, which
would be the 13hi A. Yes Sir was gone at Gov Claf
Inns house the whole time.
O. Now Sir look at that paper and say whether that Is
Mr. Tltons handwriting. Handing witness paper A.
It's
O. Whether that ia the card that was proposed to you
on that Saturday night to be published by youf A.
think this is 1t, Sir
BITTER FIGHT BETWEEN THE ATTORNEYS
OF RECORD.
Mr. Evarts ITO Mr.. Morris]-Exhibits 1O7
and 1Os please Mr.. Morris.
Mr.. Morrs-I can't find them.
Mr. Eyarts-We certainly need them; they are exhibits
In evidence, and would like to have them at recess
MI Morris-You are entitled to them can find them
Mr.. Evarts-we entitled to have them found.
Mr.. Morrs-I can't find them.
Mr. Eyarts-YOu do not mean they are lostt
Mr. Morris-I don't know; can't find them.
Mr. Evarts-we must have them; would like to have
them and have the testimony proved upon that basis
Mr. Morrs-I understand you would like to have them
say can't find them may find them after more
tho, examination. Those envelopes have been out
and passed around so frequently
Mr. Evars-we have not had anything to DO with them
at all.
Mr. Fulerton-n they can be found. they will be, and
produced
Mr. Morrs-And II they can't, they won't.
Mr. shearman-We asked for paper yesterday, and
Mr. Morris said could not be found and just as soon as
Judge Fullerton asked for the paper yesterday it was
found.
Mr. Morris-Mr Fullerton didn't ask for It, and such
thing occurred you state.
Mr.. Fullerton ITO Mr.. Morris] -Don't say one word
Mr. Evarts-we want those papers, and are entitled
to them, they being in evidence before the Court
Mr. Fulerton-After the imputation OF Mr.. Sherman,
have nothing further to say about finding papers.
Mr.. shearman-The imputation is known to every one
who sits here.
Mr.. MOrris-It is untrue.
Mr. Shearman-A paper We asked for yesterday was
not produced and he Mr. Morrs said it could not be
found and within few minutes afterward saw Judge
Fullerton lean over and ask for that paper ana IL was
produced instantly.
Mr.. Morris-It ia not true.
Judge Neson-One moment gentlemen; they will find
them during the recess probably.
Mr. Evarts-Your Honor understands that we are en-
titled TO those exhibits. They their prop
erty for the purpose Of this trial than ours.
Judge Nelson-still there is liable to be confusion
among so many papers.
Mr.. Evarts-I understand that.
Judge Nelson-They will find them II they can during
recess.
Mr. Morrs-I have found every exhibit that has bcen
called for readily as could and counsel has put me to
trouble in calling for exhibits here when
they could use the printed exhibits we'll but they have
not used Them seemingly for other purpose than TO
give trouble and when the counsel undertakes to make
any nputation that we have withheld any exhibit we
repe it. 1t is untrue
Mr. Fullerton-The imputaton ought not to rest for
upon Judge Morris because yesterday when the
aIled for foupd
stated Immediately that it had got into the wrong en-
velope with another exhibit-an explanation which Mr.
Sherman ought to have accepted at once don't know
why he should attempt to cast any mputaton OF that
kind on the gentleman who has the charge Of those very
numerous papers and who has produced them from time
TO time when they wanted with the greatest posi-
BILE alacrty, although at very great Inconvenience.
Mr. Morrs-The exhibit which was called for, to which
reference made in the envelope with another
hbt marked In the lower part OF the envelope and mis-
placed In the package. as your Honor VIII see, not
marked the others and there were two IN the
same envelope and didn't find 1t at the time looked
over them again, and found it, and when Mr. Sherman
makes the imputation that he does 1t is utterly and
absolutely false.
Judge Neilson-In other words, that he Is mistaken,
and ought not TO have made IL.
Mr. Morris-No. Sir; I say 1t is untrue
Judge Neilson-well, we will leave 1t there
Mr. FullerOn-Counsel clothes his language 80 as TO
make IL offensive.
Mr. Shearman-It cannot be blotted out.
Mr. Observation-Disclosures we cannot consent to be put
in the position Of asking favors when we desire original
papers put evidence against to be present
| at the trial for use by counsel.
Judge Nclson-Some one must keep the papers, which
are very voluminous There well may be delay In finding
for them given paper The counsel should do all he
| in that regard and that is all.
Mr. Evarts-we be put In the position Of asking
favors.
| Mr. Morr.s-And don't want you to ask in that
| offensive way, either
Mr. Egarts-I have not asked for them in offensive
| way.
Mr. Morris-Yes, you did and you have been offensive
I'm your persistency reference TO them and casting
| mpu,aton that | didn't try TO find them. l say 1t is
! offensive
Mr. Evarts-Have you got the papersi II so, let me
have them.
| Mr. Morris-I will let you have them In due time.
| Mr.. Evarts-I will take them now.
! Mr. Morris-You won't take them
| Mr. Evarts-wcll, the Court will direct you, then.
| Mr. Morris-wcll, the Court will not direct Inc.
Mr.. Fullerton-Ths ought TO be enough. stated to
Mr. Evarts that courteous way always try to address
him tiat II these papers in existence doubtless
| they We're they would be found and handed to him.
That all he could ask II Is not extraordinary
thing, IN handling many papers as have been exhb-
tied In this case that some OF them should 10 mo-
mentarily displaced; and after that said way
which certainly gave oensc, and when ii was given
as an assurance good faith, Mr. Sherman saw IT. pur
posely to make very offensive remark entirely uncaled
for which did not facilitate the looking up Of the paper
| or It's production but calculated to annoy.
| Indeed, 1t insult, because the explanation
which have already said that Judge Morris gave yeser
day. when that paper found ought " DO Satisfactory