, 1875-05-12

RE9uTTAL
HRS. 1IACuoHALD'1 Ti.7f1NoaY.
Ngw YONG. May 11.-Mr. Docchcr nAa absent
when tho great Ecandal trial vas resumed today
in tho Drooklyn City Courtroom. l1sa. Uoocher,
however, was In court.
Tho examination Of Mrs. 11acDona!d nas con-
ttnued by Mr. Sforrle. and Sue testified In sub
stance ~ followa: think HcEsio Turucr went
TO Koypors Tuesday. shn LET. TiHon', ahout
noon IN Monday. remained u. Kcyrort four
or 1iso weeks. Do..le returned stous reeE
Esto'o did. think Mira, Tllton had returned
from Monticello whca Bessie re!urno1 10 urooi:-
}yu- The foldin1-doors on Tho arcon,! floor wcro
generally open: nerer HAT thrm locked, and
could not SAY tia. thcy nero eycz locked rhrn
pulled together. When tho toora vera cloaod,
the top part did not come together cloHc}7.
Cross-exdminrd: ! l:ayo been in Tilton'n fnr,-
iiy for ostr twenty-five roars. livcd with his
Parents 1t EosEost. I cau.c TO work for Thco-
do!c Ti1sou at BROOKLYN for ten OF twelve yca.s,
and vent backward and forward betunor tho
tHo places. When waa Ct Tilton's tho frat
tiue. tbeY wcre living with Mrs. iAchsrda.
AfIar tacJ ment to lousekceplnG.
AEorr FOUR YEAEs 400,
went to TiltouB 10 live. I wns thoro mlIou
3.a!p. 'aH born, IN juno, 1860, but 70: .loag Lc
fora tbEt. Hrn. Titon generally paid ina my
wages, eal sonc.iEea atr. Tilton ttid. I1ltom
paid rao my wage. al Of tho rcar 1852 although
] wils not there oil tho Tina neyorloft Tl:ona's
family altogether, and was living thero when
MIS- T1tGn Hent array. 1as ultimate mud
confidential tczms with tho family. When waa
down q: kcypor:., I was trchtad ae ono Of tho
family. ! saw yi!tpn givs alisA Turner money
to 80 to Loypor:. 1hers arc two front rooms,
connected b folding doors, On ths second 1ooz
Of I!!toal hcEgc.
1!et:.rrc4 examination: Ralph wen about
yeasa old vhan i:7:. Tiltnn "eat 10 Iorscelio.
| TlLToS NEcALLEo.
| Theodore Jilton was recalled. uo t.e!iled:
! novcr 1t MtB. Wuodhula housa while Eho
| Iivc4 in 1rring pace / ueset sALl to N.s. Wcoi-
| bull, A. any time, OF in any uorsons r1eaence,
"fictor.a, you publigh this Rnd you arc nado
woman" Qeferring to tho ec4a;.a!). I neyor
calloa Col. Blood ss:ds Ut tho Eroad strne: onice
aud talked to hin aIou: tbs scandal. Hn neTur
| DO with tho publication. lad not tpo.ian to
Doui Einco the coonth oi April, 1872. ueroE
! g. lhe of.co iu Which thu scandal Erttcls vas
| published. / MAS ue1cr present whca any proof
BlipA Of that article wcto khown, aud uevar sav
Ruy OF the s!!rt.
1he ui.uces hero read frn11 lit tic rIacos
at which liz had lectr:ol out.iie oil brooklyn,
{ from Oct. ], 1G7l 10 Nor. s. lSi!.1
| In answer to Mr.. Norris. the w,taets said TINT
on April IL. 1877, ho terminated his aequains-
auceship with Mrs. Wocdhul:
Tho witucaa continued: hcguu mr. political
campaign July g, 1871 It Datimore This IL
t
The cflcc No conversation mas ever bad Rboyt
| Bcerhes'u congregation paying 9lo0, 00o 10 dup-
pteso the pnhlcation Of the acaudal. on tho 4th
81 July, ~: did got stay 2: Mrs. Tooahuil'a.
darn When YEA confined to my house through
iilnoss. 1
x.Y1 s1Rrr OK AsoFA-tcp
Il a1a: wooahul!'s. but have :. my Own houso;
| tlrs. Gia.s never matted gu 1lrs WoaAuti aud
myself when We wcso At chicken aud champagne
suppers. I never SAN champagne in tiset house.
MrH. Woodruff and wore uoyer Gorved with re-
frenhn!enta IN hor bedroom. never rode out
horre. 31ra. Woodruff ne:cr said to mo that
Doocllcr had better prcsids at the S!cuwny Hall
n,eetinE. or Aho would '.n1cko i. hotter for htu,
than hell VAS bolow.8 I Was uoyor In her Office
1t NaaliKht. / mover went to Mouitous III q car
risGe with Alrn. Woodruff. 11r. Cuolo mover waa
| nsk.I By Iuo to joiu III tho 0odrn Ayc. I de-
! cllncd to take Cooke on tho pkpcs WHEN he re-
qucstod me to do 10: becsu's acquainted With
Mrs. pnfmcF about three months atie. tho Golden
dgt Wna asartad. 1t td1z. Woodhul!'a office. Il
| Naa inpoGsiblc that nl.e cou!.l hnSe heard con-
veraation about starting luis paper, as It wsa
started lonE be{o!e becatnn acquainted nth
her. The sltps Of tho scandal
| wLRE SkyHh hHuws 10 MI
In Mrs. Woodhu}ls Office. iu Airs. PAlmer'A pres
cnce. in tae spring Of 1872. or Of any other time.
~ TINT time ras somewhere betwocn the Ohio
| lliycr xnd tho Mississippi.
Tho witness was asked to t}K tito precise To-
cali.y hs waA iu ti1 weeks b:ioro tbs lit OF May,
tile data liked ty Mrs. Palmer for thin couyersk-
Mr. E1arts objected. aud long discussion fol.
lowed.
Ths mituess then continued: did not rido
with 3l1s. Woodruff in tho fossol procession,
nttcf Il lad broke up, nor Was IN carriage th.t
moi sco 1lr1. Woodruff that dIy. At tho inter-
view iu MollltonA n:t.'Iy, In tho earIy part Of
November, 1872, when Woodruff and 1raoy wore
pre8ont.
HAD xor WRITTEN TIE "TnUE sToaY,"
nor a.y- pa.. of it, It was nos written in De-
cember. rrtoIlrct IT by my gung to DR.,
6torrs about it At tint time. I lever uncovered
manuscript, btEan "a read 1t. at TINT inter
yiow. ubTer heard the letter al coutrltiou -
spoken Of b. Moultoa 1t that inEe1visw ns a
! 1ncse memoranda.
4 loug argument e1sued batween counsel on
tho subject. and the Testimony Of Tracy waa
TLs Court iInally admitted tbs .nsuer of .as
witueas.
Tho Mitnesa t1,en testified: mr. Mouton did
not lay 1t wna tlln memoranda nr uotan of tho
conversation hs had With beochar, uoE anything
tu that et1oct.
Ar. EvArtB
! oaJECTED TO TH1s LAST n5ATEAEST
Of tlle witncsE, OF: tic ground that, according to
Gen. T1acys oyldenco. 1ilton waa not present
whenn this nl+morsndum or "letser of cop11s"
Tho Witness was then askol II Mr.. Tracy raid
to him last summer that II hs madu charge y:
ndultery againnt BoocI,er ho {Iracy) wonld not
feel Ais oath b!ading on lin. aud would bo ro-
loasod fron liH word to tl.s wtsness.
This was objected 10 BY sfr. EyuTta, Who asked
for time to look ut Gcn. Tsacy1 testimony, aud
In tiIe meantime tia hour for rocoEs Lid arrived,
hua tho Court rose.
1tr. Morris Ito TI'ton)-I WAS asking you bo-
foso recess in regard to As. 11acya notification
to you OF hts iuto,ston Ct foeing hmsolf 1T
liberty to act for alr., Meycae1. haso the owl
denre hotorc mu, aud will read i mud, call your
! Ill l. inf ftrnu
tion by 1fr. EyartH} =
"Whoro did II occur. tia. tntoryiow-that co.,.
| Yorxutions AL think it occurred ut the Glib.
"Q.-Tho brooklyn C!uh2 A.-Th6 brooklyn
Club. Il may h,se oeoa # NJ onic'. 3lr:
Triton Nas in '!e haI.t IL Of dropping iH S,. q ny
dropping in 1t ils Club when MA taklus
1uurh, OF At 1Iruor. aud NC. him III the street
often. W. lad cayuAl conversations.
"Q.-Hull, what passed. bat"cc.a you? How
usa tho matter introduce17 -l:eferr.nS to
Ito conversation In 1877, said to h1n' Nr: Iii.
tor, ~ long As you alheto to tho csro that you
t4on stated to me. Bhall