New-York tribune., 1875-01-19
TrLroN TEMPORARILY MOLLIPrED.

|
make their statements.
| @ What statements, A. Statements OF oGcnse
| q Have you reference now to- the pro-
| posed statement by Mr. Bcecher just read in
evidence the reply which he prepared to- IL A. have
not any reference that That which have Just handed you
was report prepared by Theodore Tton Mr. Beeeher
on that day and said Mr. Beecher This will show you
the mind Theodore has had upon h subject aud II had not
been for the publication OF correspondence and The
desron OF Theodore by his wife he would not have been in
the angry mood he to-day, insisting upon the publication Of
the faces"
O. BY Judge Nei-on-was that before oraer Mr. Tltons
statement had been gwen the COmmttee twas before
| Sir.
@ ByMr Fueon-I want you 10 state whether at the une
Of this cosversaon the which respective parties
to make before the Committee the subject OF conver
faon and their character then fixed to 'aie what they
| to be, A. State that again. you please.
q You have now identified proposed report that Mr. Thon
! prepared for the Committee TO makcr A. Yes, sir
| q, And you showed IL to Mr. Beeeherf A. did.
@ And he asked you Mr. Tlton would be satisfied with
| that A. Yes, Sir.
@ Upon what Of what that proposed report to BE-
predicated-in the shape Of Of parties1
Mr. Eyarts 10 the witness)-what passed between Mr.
| Beecher and your
Mr. Fuerton-I asked that; in that conversation what
said on that subject between you' A. ad to Mr. Beecher
that after Ton had made her statement to the Com
mee Mr. Tton very much incened and that Mr. Tracy
in subsequent interview with HMM interview subsequent
TO Mrs Ttons report the Committee, statement 10 the
Committee presented to him the influence which her
had had upon the Committee that ed the gers
ont Theodore TtOn and he perfectly willing 10 make
statement TO the Committee which shon contain the fact
of adultery between Mr. Beecher and Ms Ton that he was
perfectly wiling Mr. Beecher would tske great blame upon
himself and Theodore Tton from dshoaoabe con
duct towards himfrom any injustice towards hini-thAt
he Theodore Tlton, perfectly willing 70 settle the
matter without making any accusation before that Com
mee and that he had prepared such a report for tho
Committee to make and that he had shown General Tracy
and General Tracy had said TO him. the night OF the eonver
which refer that the Committee seemed now " De Oh
opinion ofcnse and that he thought would
not hard from that Committee report unfayoable,
Il true 10 Mr. Beechcr on ground Of the oense bat
which would really sete whole business and all the
parties concerned dhOnor in consequence Of crime that
| Is all.
O. And this report that you identified the that
you now speak off A. That Of them, Sir There
were two One long and that was a short one
| BY Mr. Eyarts-Made at the same timer A Yes, sr-two
| The short submitted to Mr.. Tracy.
| Paper marked for Identification " No. JO.'l
BY Mr. Fullerton Handing paper witnesslLook ., tho
paper now shown you and cay whether is the other report
prepared by Mr. Tlton at that timer This is the paper MS
| il all here.
| Mr. Fullerton-I offer the first report in evidence:
Report The Committee appointed to inquire into the Of
fene and apology by Mr. Beecher alluded TO IN M m4ns
they find that an Cfsnse OF gye asG Ta on o1 rS
he suitable apology TO both parties receiving IN return
the forgiveness goodwill The Committee further report
settlement Of difficulties and reflect honor on ai The paH@
concerned"
The paper heretofore marked identification No 30
| here marked Exhibit No. 5D.rl
For fear we may not distinguish between those two
ports want you TO repeat Mr. Beecher said when
showed to him. him, the report have lst pn in en
denceY A. him that Theodore hd been in that frame
| Of mind, and hoped
By Mr. Beach-what frame Of mind' The frame Of mind
| in which he wrote that
O Well satetr A. said to him that that what Theo
dore had bcening d. expressed in ho statement and
hoped would still consent to act in that way and hr
Beeche said "We, do you think he w' hope he VIII
he said. That is all.
By Mr. Fuerton-Now this frame OF mind Of which you
have spoken on part Of Mr. Ton understand
induced by report made to him OF the effect Of Mrs nloDs
| statement to the Commiuee' A. Yes Sir
O. What statement thatf A. All that know Of thss
statement was what Mr. Tracy eadthe statement made TO the
Committee Mrs Tton statement in which she had spoken
| highly General Tracy said, OF her husband.
O. Not the long statement that published A. donr
| know that it was
nothing
| O That report was not made, as understand you'
Mr. Eya-rhe witness has said there was another sate-
ment also there
| The Witness-Another statement also wherei
| Mr. Eyarts-Bcforc you at this time.
The Wituess-No Sir don't say there was another ate.
meut also before me at spoke TO Mr. Beecher Of
report which Theodore Ton had been willing TO make and
didn't show that report Mr. Bochcr did not have with
me- happened this in my pocket which submitted
| to him.
Mr. Eyarts-I misunderstood you.
By Judge Neison-You didn't have it with you No, Sir;
] didn't have IL with me.
By Mr. Evars-I think the stenographers notes will show
that there were two reports IT, the witness You spoke to
Mr. Beecher the LONG statement' A. cid speak 10 Mr.
Beecher about II at that time
By Judge Neison-But you hadn't it with your No Sir
O. The pepper you had with you the one that has been
read A. Yes. Sir.
BY Mr. EvsrtsLrhs not shown TO Gen. Tacyf
A don't rcmenber that 1t was | could not that h
O. You said something about paper having been shown
to Mr. Tracy A Yes. Sir; twas The long statement
O And not the short A don't think the short one
was shown The the substance Of the long one
| but don't think il wa- shown
THE long statement referred by ,hs witness marked
| for identification No. II. !
BY Mr. Fulertoulpu have ,p'Sn Of card IN Tht hr5"
published by Mr Tlou Handing paperl Look al
the pauer now shown say whether Bat Is the card re-
| fcrred to- A. Yes tbs, Is the one
| Mr. Fullerton - oncr II in evidence.
Mr. Eyurs- We object this RAoaf Honor please We
have had no evidence tL. Witness connecting Mr. Beeche
| with this article
| Judge Neil.on-Thl- irhe long statement.
Mr. E,ars-No sr. newspaper srticle rom Mr nlton,
published in newspaper whether had Other authenticity
than hat kuow bgt nothing h. been sad by 'ho witness
| which connects hr Beechcr with H.
judge Neilson 10 Mr racron How haycyou connected
| Mr BcfChcr with il ?
| THTON AGAIN ANGERED.
| Mr.. Ful.erton-SOmcthng has been said by the
witu,. With reference TO H. and make il ciear will AK
the wines. question in regard 10 IL 10 the Wines: