New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-02-01

PapaI Church. In recent lecture before the Clthoo
Union OF Ireland took occasion, among other exraVa
gauces TO set forth with all honor passage from q
speech OF the Pope delivered on the 2st OF July is Ia
which he Justified explained the doctrine OF the de-
posing power According 90 the version he gave OF tho
Italian discourse. this power was an authority 10 ao-
cOrdance with public right wnich was then Ng',o''
ana Win the acguiescenoe OF si Snrsuan ia noc s-.
n writer, who signs himself c. g. d. assails LORD fOberb
Montagu for erroneous transation and. Win nnIe-
niahe Justice points out that the WORDS s,c2"do
pubJilco dHora gigens DO not mean " ID accoiIahu9 pc
force" He also quotes words not quoted BY Lord
the call Of CHRISTIAN nations (chiaHGh dai Do) de-
poPolD which as he truly says. Hye very d,hereot
The Voce delta Verid Of 22i July. 1871 the day follow
ing the speech, confirmed by the Ci11Hd od"o''oa OF
Amid these grave discr,rancie' Of high authorities.
ourtreadrrs may desire know wha' SIN higher an
thoritg the Pope himself really Oil say and We have
happily the means OF informing them from the youm.s
boiore ms. which contain the sole authentic report
The speech was delivered. not the 21st bnt the 20t
OF Juy and Will be- found at Vol D. 2J We neen not
age as Gaoted by Lord Robert MontagI, viii be found
IN Mr.. Gladstone's Vatican Detfees' ~ ~"
essential point is that according to {. :. -.
the Pope justified the dep)slnZ power on
this specific ground that they were called TO
exercise by the DESIRE or voice. or demand OF the ma
them that the pagsag given BY g. y ID IN tho ldlrt
callrd by the voice OF people" ehaDaH ddt rot,
del pOpoip not in III Wh'ther they were slO"eh Or
not another question, winch we cannot 'ecue "n
IL material Is that, from the fixed dehoer ite ana ohb
authentic report they have been eXcnd ana tna tuo
Pope himself su'talns, ana lhrrtuI' cI'ltu5 ~ 70
ug power. not On tho ground Oi any demand o. t' pun
c opinion OF the day, bat a. attaching To ms Once -
And now, IN bidding 1aIeWeIt To Don rdslua,e, ,
fer him best thanks or hs two volumes ffooIoy
this acItnowedgment may heEcr nj ~ , 80 ,'
st. IN the case OF Its reaching MN, II Should ctu," ,9
surprise sereprOich tnat he should nave Aofel
give lin the reason why" We hld already and ottrn
Infa bity IN full dress, IN p,acocks phmes IN
fabiity fenced about with wei set hnrs OF thcolo@lh
phrases, npenctruble by ~. the multitude the unln
uated. Boo Don Pasquale mas taken u. Dehnd ~"
fanibiity IN disnabe InIabitv able to ~ capert
NJ viii. 10 indulge in lis widest tomps VITA lac 9Om dh
mpuulty. Aud surely We have now made COOL the 49,
suraDce WIKI which we began. II ever there wa -
spectacle, strange beyond AL former oAiti,'n' a',
1t j.
THE POPE CAUSE or EUROPEAN CoEyUIsIoNs.
Il is but fair toward him to admit that his prcicccs-
sors had bequeathed TO him temporal poty rotten
and ecte IN all It's parts as the wide world could show
At the outset OF his POntcae he attempted 10 turn pop
uar emotion and tho principles Of freedom TO accoun.
the interests OF Church power. As to ecclesiastical
affairs, he dropped at once into the traditions Of the
Olola. He was and Is surrounded by nl,terers, who
aGroltly teach him to speak their words in telling hun
that he speaks his own, end that they the most
wonderful words ever spoken by man. baFinK
essayed the method Of governing by LiJ-
crai ideas aud promises, and having by sad
ncompetency control the chargers he had narneSsed
his become ITO the ieasD one OF lhc udln
OF the European cOuyusio4s or loi lie rushed
from the pole OF politics to the sOutA, aud grew
to be the partisan Of Legitimacy the champion OF tho
corrupt and perured sOycregntics or italy That
is OF the whole world Had he 0nly had the mo-
ntions Of free press and OF free opinion, yaulO 10 as
OIL but to sOYeTs absolutely priceless, ana the lnds
pensaDle condition Of all their truly useful ogledge It
might have given him chance; but these bo
dcnOunces impiety aud madness. AZ tho
age grows on side enlightened, and on another
skeptical he encounters the skepticlsm with
denuncialion. and the eElghtCument win retro
gressiOn. higher and higher into the Regions
! la
and wider spaces fTVm the living intellect OF mani lao
loses province after province, lac quarfos viii Govern
ment after Government, he generates scLlsm aiIer
scnism; and toe crOwning achievement OF tic vatican
Council and its DEGREES u followed, IN tue mysterious
OF Providence, Oy The passing over Tor the ht
time history, Of his temporal dOminOnS 10 an orderly
and national Italian Kingdom, and OF German Imperial
Crown the bead OF Lutheran King, who Is thc sun
init and center OF Continental Professionalism
But what theni His clergy are more and more an
army a police caste; further aud further from te
Christian Commons. nearer 10 one another, ana IN
closer subservence ~ him And they have made hlu,
The InfaiDle :" and they have promised be shall bs
made "The Great" And, IL to complete the irony OF
the situation the owners, or the heirs OF handful OF
English titles, formerly unreclamed, are now enrolled
upon the list OF his most orthodox most ODseqliJus
followers; although the mass oI the BRUSH nation re-
pudates him eagerly aud rosClute!y tnan II has
done for many generations.