New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-05-07
AVER[CiN LFTERi TUKR.

AN ENGLISH DEFENSE or IT.
TirR ARTICLE oS THE sChn'rIN TdE "ENcfcio-
prpi> BRITANNICA PRONOUNCED UNJUST AID
DEFECTIVE IN kXONi.i.DGl-
F,r-t ne : ,,ctitor. Arrd2t.
II Il not Sir Arthur Helps, who, in his
Guict, pait.iOScL way. asserts tnd u SIS rr L, Ia
tos9, at dis nee than tlose ne. d, tn' - "~'
iurv the ~. Ter saying "a hn@lf; non '''e, tr tHil%
de-. moi .tsn tn hunan uIuc, rra.~sn iii err
Sryertne,,gs We hold lie Truth III A'tur's T.
mark We nsrd rs,and OF mis- rir alt our lrcld-,
t.l'>p Of tle, eli Nv nctarfc they are t'" d. ar ~
Hawthorne II I'll ah uiI theory tlt love = I"'t.'H
wcr the same az butt H. TIL wt~ III, rlc ground
for H. MIN criticism II L. esp cidv 'ci. Pr'iS or
hliI hcc..n se-,S'Nc ne Sni 81 on rt = 20 '' T.
tc eve and due IA TIM aul pos ce'iVr ~ lbst;
Nhefirr il j. "A ulu Or SAT-" u b. no hard fo tci
wlicr, the personal 81 meat has Ia sIIh'. y" u
vice viii hide IL; thin In of Isivate n'eFpI"L l'n
aud NC feel H. BUT ~ dc.ng wit' the rdc'> oi an,
otnc ointment, Ne -h".li iluty, one pow
.;c,rncss in TINT cdao d"S ~" ir'1tue or
distr,.ri, d"cs MI flect (he moral mpass,
favor tut rldgueat "r'rn "a.!H siEn1, ,l.,
Sc 80 dissatisfaction Wi ourselves Slt'' 'riVr "i'ce
al ra b1os, arI N SIN de- &c on.ny II.
ma, vim, ", ote IL .his t AMI a IA Lrr N'-~'n
OF t.if famous slyin; Of Adi' enough gre .tn,.
~ 'r,u's sent noes M, sirt t'-'Tl "''"',
reference in - c4,,plt KIM, and his blank Ncr>' "lt
from cnior of hts ha" I'r+r ~ : are Ven 10
ee terms ht not always 80 Hppir@cIh Ne ""f"-
Ir, Its vru ;,l es,ci, III stand oh il own tton
INV or cNnPe eond We G % 'R paGG vi. d,. r
wcr. not interpreted ire.Ni II We may -
Ileyo Mr. William BLACK, tAriF rcrye-ted a'p'i,
mort. lc-srfy z csc.,r ought not " ,',l"y
t.cu nero This owe cr, - TIE mare r":'srr WI, &C.
credited Judgments oi tlc.t Uit ui 81 gu N, - '''
III. roInlrteut Uoou-, 'isch AN N, tlit t'' iha'
OccV IN IA" ability al kilsh G l4ls'n 10 lLe ~ ~
.ti Sc ~ 7i 'ht WtA'h l"~t . : '"S'1 j." '','
tbos at distance tlnu those ,r at h'nii Htl lLe a.
can fi.ritnic docs npt ATTAIN O" Tag. th"nSh "a
u tu largely prais. l-l"rhai- 40" h'H OF III AIWh
IIel,s' rr,n irc For the IKE ct Ainr,.'"n i1h''.
rnrc lud Brit c1' u, II ~ vs." - "'':.r ing 70
,aiont poilH. IN Whcn lis writer las, In onf "iit,
con-, " ic oi Tie rak i .Ii'c "i f. cafenI ',sdtg -
pol l, and he air - hn~i "hi'" he t'H '"
n y Il % throw Over In. No" .
ot ht- .lbow that tn should srVc
ilv have r,c,Irr. nd l.''Un-> wien alsaI
hin T., 81 mort yo IN = viii. - Il. hut wh,' II
>ln .t u" 'o.r 1t n % tie, tie ,i'i VII! m'
h,rc !, "it,I ~ 80 =, f5. r',
ldr iiHOw 'pts'-r'shii i"'e "i ,;"i''h r.' -
turc-riliculed ms ~ t""'. . IN H. EH.t
Mtn ~ ~. ~, ,,ni ~ i,., AL his ,,i,.S fl:ta
-, nd fricudI, i,nI n. rc r, sui was 80, one
d. 1--we dedic.d tic AN from MS w'lti - 'etuIh
'I;i,uo. tri- thsi oc'd 'hoog ~ ere h -,
and be ro.i oi II cua $50 dFN- go |', 80 fei"iin
III t NO he, bal spectral n"ocn. 'r'| M. o.
,ic lad ,.t. cd dlu AMI rtR Il hay al s.Inn led .,r
horn 1t dd'hrrak. DC ,m..dfril y u'Iird L'p'
,Io.-rrng now rInm p'sictT c'P ricnr, ~ hei1re hr
had {, ~ IRON Theory. And NJ c0In,r Poe ~!i h!'
R,vtu" t0 ,.oik "hovcrmnlC!' ia ttor oi
81 tnc,c is a IN '-tci idea lial..i liz an e.~c,o
,lroHen h,- WIN: t. Peih.,'', na A., o.
n rrs: t,iry mind bs III ~ quot
comp ,nior assertion instead Tine great literary fnlt
uf lie Nm rl 'iIli- ci'es IA ie InIA'i DC q a"'-
il c. them have mi hHiI. tAai rn~ isic In ii.' ~er
Il d'Ily that %of'.s lone T., ri u. Ak N 10,
tim le wrote. tally q,ultcr of tntury nSn, Il
trlcr rhn IL T.. how, 'hoifa nn' ev.p lh:n ,h, VIII
il iir irving ond Pr s-otr all I,,i'a, Wills
iIawtnnrne had shown 'iHt rhItIan'~l i'r'.er'ed =
can lie hat stale ike suhl' ntoina L"und H. hir';-
tire, and rrn'H~ i'ecp.ihhlc n'm II i"c ~ 10
Tics" w" even lh'h d"iiSLi.hE ef'tr7 ana
slowly making ther NAt 10 iT@'"iht I1.re"
lcfuc frYr and c'tetTicAiiy b. Nv nrfe pi~,niei
U- with The HAT iic deeper,
couUcrncd hat ia4- 6" r''L,rA IHp; II i. surely
very Ia say al that eonn ry whrh IT, thI'e I'll
otnri.i prpne tni sHi rn froui y Rails
nm, -, exptucat Of ali k,is, hat ~ Gnrrir Il i.
c.cnt ui ,ture ,Lsi IL dwr ul"D the utnit, -uarr
rather tlau tie mi i;y at TIM. u o.lsel the hu,i,c
rather than Ia s' aScil oAlst nyc 81 man To" ~
this "a roiii0n 10 it, L. nla Q" ~t'',re With the
rt.n -. also suggested - Gri-woLi - tm "irr mat
iLo Americans had too Str.l my toiSht ti 'nctuiiT
of TIE A. arr IL. aid wur, bu~ 'frI IL drsc T.
ccilc favorable verdict, not t4'i" t"''u ~! ~ ihcit
birth. bnt fUu thHi ~ Hnr hlcfs'"F. No T Di'v ~
- O,s The tTah+c~iid M u nuN cincni
to b" distinctly Au ri'ln' ana yet ~ i"ti'iNeh tc,J
Bat fi0u rnn.n, IRE against 'oe.cralf,s. lrt Us dc
though h -tili living: III. w,llro1n "IILlard"
brcon.es lar'i; :" the Rriow raI cr>" on rlac
ns grcii ~'eial Az political sHsi,H fhc New
Wn,lI :" T.mrrau j. ,lriininct,l 1nTbd ,.-
tJry-whch IL tue ceI'u"n sbtw g. Lla Lil.f, how
mistaken IL may oSut wi" Ein >5ii! Iv.ug
i.HliLi' praised rir his phLsnrJpt IsA,r 1.,r,-ti
r,iistint,csdslih'H eh h" -uta>s,i hi- At
least tang, y'ts ~ rusr wtltrNrr MGai viii
Mr. Ene:s say ," ~ IL t"i4 Encyclopaedia
aware int rJorr-u. IN intnv waYs-iH hr
the hermit ~ W;Ltn W'nt ia gefsi'tnt ly
forth rss othcr nEierr h.Iir that ri
JOAN Brown ~ EiiFper- itrry Hut drovph.a rcfcr,
ltaC ticsc. udSIn+ o. oHr .-tI.
-Fo t-ns-:"nI This w'ier fl"'' ''rSS"d'e opinion
III +. T. Whpc Ia the effect i,t lie y uf the il,,st
si'lr stfin ma 1 aud profound ~ ciitc-, aui iyin
U'h~un himself uetly usVrtS mirk ~ rNc.aiiatl u
the .aS.ase might d ~ rifIId's tyUs ..li
.trd admiration ~ lrirn1. Well! an.d tint
iwn Whpilc 10 at the LtUN' sli.tg, -r.aiI
W. 'n pr"iniII OF cri ic' Iii cnni'~s tlf' Ii
r-pcIr-i ,r.o.t,,l works ~ volumes ana -.v.
njn ~ by this e re!oT'-t ine on Scrvcd 10 deepen
urr conviction Nor auurfu tut- OnI.n M is
provincial :aIr. ul"ISn a'"c!a crcitius iruc's
fmh hm l"iiS IA aitYi,c't- OF merely ueO Ii wfuiS
caulay sad thai shHr 81 " ilppic- -ssiy-
sHhtlrst aud ilrf nd cieir'st "a pa ssuu az al
read. sl,s M,,ri wrute that t,,Dy SsaLl t,r,.
Nith airy Ui ther ctL- in t.L' 1', eoaatry
f-"oi declared that nc c'1tIV uId ever tIrite1 is
writings nit-n quoted IN Fiauce a ~ the rrn,
Dict,Iairc uuivcr-ei lie. Conleut, ans" ~, y o. n-
spoken OF: "I<.s casts dV cr1ui,le It6...i!e ,.e
". Wuipplc. - 4 Cnnmrn'IB, laI IT, fireesr
d.s aarrus rtndepead.n.r d. pi.a,iu-uf- 81 IA
preOccup.l ton e"nst-nir Do n,riets ,l. Pmtei
,icc In rcsl, In vcry cilTUiis aim IT ngi.hiu-
to Ilud chat; whilst our ercy cI"szsI ogmfialy de-
eIcr POI, criticisms TO b~ H. ord rl.i-ir. sap
l'u Ti'"'s au 50 ts W. Ia" i'e nu9 le.sn" ~ ,s'ac
VIA" iEes seriously trIei Ia dciraet from ~bIpp's posi-
item. bnt mi. T. Ell; iiy atrouucd for by tn ,r ~
wnppics couucriou with The Worth sserieGn Ksca,c
tie inn VI which sainul aHfurt ste Poe
md. Pos deciartz tu-i hhlppe las bcu in.ct L
with TINT trunSpur nj her'sy-tr sanl ~ critical Bss-
wrIiirH-l, dut uf which Ia tlyt,
Ia all anrIai h,n-es and open them ike owls 10 nIl
auforiai dofests But he was eoIlileised =, il,t
,hni hi. lectures on me Eiizahctian t.an.i-
and could hot d'ny hin place ani.ris the
Lherin 81 srw-Y"rs.' AMI arter ai hie il surely
a.