New-York tribune., 1875-02-05
e,hticmen quite suf.
TUTON'S FREE.LOvE DIscUsSIOYs.


O. Look at this article, Mr.. Tilton, the article
which contains the parts pencil marked there and say
written by YOU and published your spaperf Handing
witness copy of IAs GoldeR Age A. Yes Sir beg yonT
pardon Nj E,.s Did Jon call ny attention to any special
srticlel
O. asked about tho article that bas pencil marks
drawn against portions of it, A lcs sr wrote that Ny
name is signed 90 H.
Mr. Beacll-WA1ti,u' IL
Mr. an article entitled NJ Tltons Reiolnder
to Mr Greeley"
Br Moris-Nr2f f. The date Of it?
Mr. Shearman- Published in The Goiha Age of September
9Th ls7i qq- g.. long article constituting st paragraphs.
A. only one OF them g material TO this po.nt-
Mr. Eyarts-lnc others relate 10 other top.c-.
Mr. shcarman-Ycs, Sir, they relate TO o,fer topics
M Fullerton DO you read the article to which J IS repy'
Mr ShearGau It Is not published n this paper
The Wilnos.-Y,s. Sr. 10 j., published there
Nr Shcarmlu- -u2
NJ, Eyars The rcio.nder published here
Mr. Futro, II we have the sermon Do u- have ths tc1i.
Mr Beach ne snail have 70 read the whole Of thai
article.
Mr. Eyart, W.N. we viii read our part.
Mr. sAearm4 read The third paragraph Mr. Ihton're
ioindc-
Mr Morris jus, read Mr Greeley letter ai't
Mr. shoarmu 40. DO is not necessary.
The Wt.c.s- Won't you read the whole auDe'
Mr. Beach huk it the rule Sir that whore answering
letter read which it Icj should be read
also.
Judge Nelson think ha the rule P-rap- II counsel
will look at 10 tcy can judge whether It is material
Mr. Eyar,s-Y Your Honor We und,i what the rule
is Al that en- Dee claimed by out clnei .nd- is that t
gives item @ 90 rad any part Of ,he paper 10 which 1t
reply, Il ihc. dL They cauuo. u.asc n- read IT,
Mr. Beach. .I.r with my lclEcL l,uI 90 regard to The
rlc
Mr E..r-Ns lad The opposite ,co ate carly part Of ths
trial
MrHcl.a--N..,. Sir IN tLis ts'G.
Mr. E,a--.-I ,iHua SO.
NJ Bca,h-No. >.r Yon are m.-.4a.1.
Judse %e..-l Hs,c bad occasion 'p -y 'lt where one
party put, a.,- .n they were a. i.! .l c part o.
Mr Bsacu.A. NY.1t Sir
Juo,e .-,u. lja, .t vac dcrmcl 30 pst U by Ncm and
the other sd. coda ,ld an, para,. o. t' bought proper
Mr Fu.,.j.u -fnHf doe, no. pIcss' tIt- cl.e
jude Nc.-4a-No. Sir
Mr. E,ars liaN docs fail t0 PFC I- casey Slpposnc
itisa are s., o,, ,cd to s,a4 Is ao tu4t precseiy
the question .id n accordance with u'l-, tat parry
read, what D., Lak b. Important h.,l f 'nc other soo
have right 20 .,it w.aat ,hcy t.uk pfoiert
Mr. Fullerton Thea his answer IL ncuuY, Y,,noHslbc without
wc have the ar .clc to which u is reply.
NJ, E,art- I.I- is misfortune
Mr. Fullerton Want to mend your mi.taunes as well A.
can by that whole article b. rad % ihe first III
stance ana ,nc whether tinA tn rpy appropriate
Mr. E,art. !o not understand that "" lrt obliged 10 rad
tie whole article TO get the pon, which Important TO a2
Jude Ne.ln-l think the whole deemed pat IN by
you.
Mr Eyarts That may be
judge Nc,ou-Aud you read such par. You now think
prpcr and , Afterwards call attention 10 other pari..
Think that DO answer ITO Mr. Fuller on may burden
yon With subsequent reading perhaps
Mr. Fullerton 1t won't be any burden for 10 read any
thluc thai NJ 1llon has written Sir. lLAu,ltcrl
MIR Eyari, This h-cusson between these gentlemen
Mr. Greeley sud Mr. Tilon-Which somewhat elaborate
represents oie. subjects understand / have
the letter subjects than this. and we have found
graph Of NJ Griey that relate topic our
learned rfi,nd, po.cr-
The " Mitu,~-. Ilc whole subjec, is
Mr. E,acb his = offered ada.--.on statement
made b., M 1iou Mr.. 1l,ou says ta. II person In
maAns a pln., against his interest refers TO w
ten paper wlolt which the admission T. not complete the
contents of c paper ought to be shown before the statement
can be u-cd o., e., ienoc against the parry.
Mr Eau- shown 10 the wltnessl
Mr. Beach Shown the witness! No Sir; shown TO the
Court and Ja Who understand this admission and
strae i..
Mr. Evars-Wc that Is the rule Of evidence that your
Honor has pssc upon that gives the h To the other side
20 use IT, There any rule by which are obliged "
read thing that they right Il certainly has ~"
been applied ~ ,hls csss