The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1875-01-26
'.Bnug on anorner witness or shall perspire."
Tue Dg BlAcK-bearded man sleeps like Preciosa--
star over BROOKLYN Heights
Ia in vuur azure deeps
Hide. tide veur siiver( light
ale sis D, NV Juror sleeps

Hc sleeps
The two gentry. Flemish bearded. who wear
brown ci'flins Ola worn que ana appear to be
demnre srd commonplace working citizens. lis
tened nke people already old. growing Older very
fast ana tie bi--aeaded young man with IKE
transparent turrets. VINO sit modestly. avoiding
a. much OF tue evidence as possible. felt obliged
O. 'isten Gus % sheer WEAKNESS. on the whole.
thel iooked nke twelve men pursuing knowledge
7 unacf Ga. culties.
rnR EVIDENCE
~ eitNco ec.ock the proceedings were begun
III o. wbom answered % their names. Aiter the
witn-~@ FRANCIS ID. Mouton. TOOK his usual place
f ,s anu 49, ,nas sie ,r ,oy on
NJ. shearwan read the following extract rom
WI Noodnuns paper, relating 20 the Tilton-
Beecasr scandal. % November. 1874 -
~ gnenuy l plsii.hed icuer IA both the World
~ ssra, f enin.n nee ,n Sont yn she lives
% ln, u1inass vita ne VIE another man Of eapal
Ne pres. sspeslaiy mat eot1 o. Them bad refer
.a' sl.pecisd thai was eeer iniorned o. the facts
pabiety ofmy Enowie edge 10 a convenient
Mr fuiertoa-rnis as as far as you eau read
Mr.. shear man--we propose TO read the follow
ms aopor-Read that separately under the
Mr. FuIlerton-so far as read.
The Judge may be necessary 20 read 10 In
order q tx bis exception. no Ar. sAearman.l
Read tiat separa'ely.
DR. sncarnian lreadlng,-
rhs sas9e,oa Wa hsigh,saei BY the conviction that
OF my radical tleores, sppears ln his iar-fsmed
IL re So3fsa ~ and elsewhere Mr. inioh's ~srmSss
ircnds When they looked az has remarkable proceed.
ns ~ h onliaai "a voc sey % Ne nam aeSres that
OF ths nost radical OF al radicals
No OBJECTION.
Mr. Fullerton SAID he had no objection 20 admit
she part reaa. Argnment followed on the cues
Mr. Sherman insisted that the article. wnie "
charged Nr. beccher With adultery. also charged
Mr.. Tilton With conuivance af mat adultery. The
counsel Tor tue plaintiff would have ~ that be-
cagse MI. BecCber dld DOT deny the charge Tor SIX
guilty, And tue oiner party was prcsumptive ~
/ inaOcent because there was no denial at AL from
l M Morris SAID this was a specioas statement
Every man IN the community understood that Mr..
beeeher Was tae mAH ana tie sole man called
Mr.. shearB,as, proceeding TO read further, said
by MIS- wooanaii into fnles specisc. dlstinct. un-
| connected charges against these three gentlemen
respectsey Ina s4nse' ?. lone u ~as sin .e
adultery VITA the vile OF ar. IL tou, ana that Mfr.
luton. AZ nrsi indignant about mat not oily be-
"a. 0ut approved o. q and relolced Ia q; aud
tn charge Ilat M. sOgiton weat VITA pistol
I zoe paroTs IA the ease, aud anerwar1 stood ~ as
mutual .Tiead ano approved tae wno.s thing
beclass n Toe EVIDENCE o. tse siiaess reierenee
j. made - tne articles sinsle eiause. y there
reIeGeuee - made 70 the woodhun story.
AZ EXPLOSION OF wUEDs.
Shearmaa allbiy setted on this series Of inslnua-
toas watching both Moulton and Fiiton. and ms
small stature. quick. suarp. glrish voice. English
accent and American nervousness o. uuerance.
put q new feature into tn tri4L Ae exploded
B ike pack OF nreerackerA
/ Frank Moulton. stroKiag has long, red tnustache.
/ smiled with about Lalf eenng, a. u saving sHe
Irfl TAT asfs
where MOulton had RAPED saesrman hard an
the course OF his evidence, saving that Beecaer
Z called him a mlscaief maker ana otneF~tse
litted nina. Sherman has yery great capacity
for HsUlium d pGrr0 Tie esa rattle OF Ike teie-
graph Instrument and ne - The only counsellor
al the trl@l WHO has strucs per nsliios from the
outset He SPOKE OF Mouiton's pistol act A. a vie
crime; OF Tilton ~ welcoming adultery into hts
family, &C.; whereas the only SUBJECT UNDER dis
cussion was waeihcr = newspaper shOuld be read
aloud.
Fullerton stopped sherman ana raped HIN
smartly. Morris sad he IalslfFiag bis open
ing speech; Beach said he was getting insin-
uatons The htsie msn ratified on usalst roed
and appeared 10 ike his coasplcuIty.
MR.. TUILEEroN
could not see the application o. the art Gle ne con-
corning Messrs. Tilt0n and MoulioI. Ihey were
not cailed upon 70 deny a.. There ~ 10 occasion
: 70 DO that except 20 Illustrate tue adAge t8at
! Mr.. shearman SAID Mr. Moultou consulted Mr..
Beecaer as 10 tne best was TO meet me story.
J. Mr.. Beach SAID the charges that publication
against sir. TAton and Mr. Moulton had no othcr
purpose than to insInuate pteiudice against these
! two gentlemen 10 admit such ~ evidence would
| be grave injustice ana he hoped would not have
THE SANCTION or THE CDgRT
Mr.. Evarts said-we have not been the drsi 10
! bring IN this publication, tue other side have
already referred TO Il.
Mr.. Fullerton SAID # they had the right 70 bring
IN the oecal0gue ana read the commandment
( ''ThoD shalt not commit adultery 10 does not
Justify the other SIDE IN Offering 10 read the story
Judge Nelson decided to excuae the paper as
whole.
INTERVIEW WITH wOoDuULL-
Mr.. Shearman proceeded 10 read tue interview
OF reporter win Mrs Wo0dhuh.
Mr.. woodruff 60 ING reporter,-lis relations were
frequent conyersauen when We brought hs sub q ~
note o, Il, 6u the eonyersauoa va, % gsm9sksse mar
can dlstcty remember M remarks Tor i4.cY made
seporter-You didn't pit tlem down. The IMPRESSION
Mrs. Woodhall-I ddu', iesl anything Of the sort.
knew this thing some tnle. thai I
was wng il saogld a, once haye beea charged with
attempts al backmail bat tell von az, there y not
money enough 70 !nese two ees 70 pnreAa m
mission ns On 70 esTry TO orch 90 h ny and e-e hs
ana marital relations pass as liz .ociai svsfet,
know there are other churches JUS a ial-c snd oiher
beacon IS fred on tho mountain D. itile hills are
called CONSERVATIVE society.
The Judge-same rullng and same exception.
MI. Snearman-lhc next par Az aph oner a. ne
folow1p9 words put INTO tue mouth ol Mr.. Tllton-
If Your honor Will pardon mel vii not reao az
orally. because wound nave 10 put 10 a great deal
which We are AL endeayoung not 20 do. We want
TO put in as little OF tins tntng possible. now
put Mrs. woodruff into the mouth OF M I1itpn -
l have friend who Il like a brorher-Frank MoGl.
ton went to him ami stated the iuily We we're
both members OF Plymouth church Nv friend sPos
pistol went TO Mr.. Beechcr demanded
OF airs iiiton under penalty OF instant death.
The Judge-That will remain Ia. All or that, 10
APPEARS. Mr. Mouton denlcs.
FuierfO0-AnQ a
The Judge-fhat may involve question.
Mr.. Fullerton-They have proved themselves ~
was untrue.
Mr.. Shearman-The next paragraph.
MT. BeaCb-Ne except TO IT,
Mr.. Shearinan-I propose 10 read short para
graph, and though no name vas mentioned, % re-
iers TO MIR. IiltoD. am doing RMS because vc al
OBJECT TO q great deal OF THIS gong IN l0uT honor
objects, and II they OBJECT TO my doing this sinai
nave TO read the whole paragraph.