Evening star. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1854-1972, 1875-01-18
THE IRWIN NEAs CORPUS.
The Arguments 'o-day.
Decision of the Couft.
The Writ Dismissed.

hos fHF-f.1~ AtfNH W
ptr.,.....' - a -
4 ''--4--''' T. lT'F - '''' -, ..,.sf. ~
vrftr.~s - 49, ,r.,,.s...- -. 60 /
- -'l.'-N- ''''' ~ /
a.''i'-'- mere were F-t i-N prisons prc>eh- .
when TIE cOuT. convened. bat the room grail /
Uaiiy filed zap. The petitioner was in the /
saUTt 1r prompt t4m", accompanied by NJ
\. J- IuIAat- 90 Ills counsel. ami - itW min
Gtt~ afterwards the rriat0r. Mr.. Orjway.
v.tl his counsel. M.s~rs. c-e..a5aIseI and
4 .-ll.T. arrived.
7-T:. UT-FA~T's ARsvTETT.
At ie- O'Clock Mr.. brlrd1t commence a.s
ar ui1eilt- q LUalH- T. tir Ilrp}Tj'lt' OK lt-
"a 20 a"t 20 the RIGHTS of TIE people nm tIi~
country being superior L. IN government
which derives it, powers from the people.
Il i.f''t NOM story, Vol. II fiie com ncltS ni
Jefferson OH the ease Of Dune CGETS9l win
Huel. and said il was an exposition ~ what
ga, law should he. The prisoner stands IN
custody. committed for contempt, and there
- 30 Limitation. IL claims iHar t1g hpd>e
Was 'oi iE'.i'r z'i iott~k tf'Iu'-'5pli- " -li"l
'ra declined lI -l..~-E aF- and WuirI tpru.t .4-
HH~. -or sH' nap" cf contempt. To re'".1T
,, .ff- lisa. -Fs Hon - sol iIH-a of tra of
i-s-..T F. f- . r.EEEm ts.- the laws OBJ.
isr.tIa..f sF" Er. FOB b" g-e-. oHcI. alr
r' .- ..- 500 st.. iH-'. .sr ttt. '.t.~ aye sub
..el To- rH- Ear.-.1g og On. rudlCt5 ,-
He g.ag from IDrt Raymond. vol. -t. 3. ~
'-.-- and -t. "a 60.T.GL- .rf -...~ pax" tr as
rp T.a. r.rtri.r-e~ ~ t1r parl amen. IH O..
is.ft.l. ease. s' s!. The arIur..ra., OF Plrl.r-
THsHf IS acknowledged. -es lcr house a-1r,
.- .-iJa ce ledge tg p" supreme. he also
t.r ll.FE-- Hi t"lE-uaH~. t'ts f--ai was up.
uGH.- F#i DE o.r.sue tina taj~ doctrine from
-H~sl source WEES stronger Ur5"r the spirit
on COZ SD ar -.E ti-aI under the theory DI
ti5. government OF Great Britain. The SFtg
Common Law. seth PAGE was referred ID.
where g. is Helt that there 5s 40 power Gb7N.
tu-t UI HsiuG VUC~ti0l"f Hv law. ~ tsfrst
authorities. lIe~sf,i 70 was clearly shown that
even tu t-raat Britain the citizen gFf1,at
-Ttftsr rights than the counsel Tor tine gov
eminent (DvIrHJ he g. entitled q Uu...r
our republican form al ~4vrT.,-a1.
Mr.. Iurarf related Jh;f in r>g1 an o. lr.jr..-
man o. Michigan. WIS. prDugT.v hal been
DESTROYED by The enemies OF the cf4s-,ry
came Eerp with a claim and fif.s Fls- an AZ
was NJ. -~4rf ri ,s1 gf=r 81 Gul yvHst ! e. a.,l
the clftirmau q: thr COMMITTEE 20 accent 800
fer bf- services ar.i tor that ~ wa sent To-
ars.tF r.af q IRE f..r Of rE.. II14,-C .s.sf %,
INITIAL G,r. .,t-r..tf,t 10 s,,;...,,,,,.,t1-
GTg.sg..r an aatss-rs :irfi1-f fItr
:rrl> a..i ho r-.sI fIg,. f,f.nrs 40, rG.-t .ss. ,
.tu Wheaton. $50 Under ne d...i~i.,n i'm
lEsrt case The ,a,ypr az fbr F-Cy.- il ne
Je ie locke for in the cou.titgf.pn
tUr tg th. U-;is-,.- OF Parliament. d. WHAT
ere rho t.wp.~ Low of TIE Hons. i'm ~sG...,
c.,~.~1 Ti.v have, rI ,s,gr.-T T., ..,-,,,, q, ,,,
irr lor cyria-.rt ru- NOT .c morrison 81, j.,
th.. c~. ui Naff.rf-. cuHtusfttci b, mn I-.,,--
lI~N Pariamfur H. laid cow, a. "a ftrlra..t-
PIE That So lt.Tl tife common law and .7-r,ta
differs tn former gives pIa"s a. theIa:tar.alI
asked il Tire sta ura should 1nr vr.,fl I'm .ta
c.,~.. tie Tt--tI from, r~r pfcli.rI..,. q FL,
P.cl,trll1. i-. thar "a >ui-..urI...If ,r-fffr 81, D.
1lI- fHa sulfIfo,3 NORTON. rf Tl, form,
Representative hat power 10 punish for con-
!r.nt,. pNt epIH nor commit for
NJ, 81, . -. . .-'' ,'' ,f-i'i '-
I'd ot March wulllt 90 ouf on t.l.. -. .s
noon. INDIE. Mac ArfIf-.A ,i.,,rrr,.
-rp-s# Nh gurauf read q: number OF author-.
Ties a. 20 effect OF statute, ufDn fo~InpI. rt.
MI Uur-.rf f.--r.ti ,,, la ,-.tfnu Df -.
ir f--- i'm u.l --fsE Ia. .-- lin relation D.. .t
punishment ol eun,umaoiou> witness rs. aid
20 Ius. debate o that uc,-,t~i1u ~h3y-i ~ -f,,I
tia HOUSE hal .p power az thi~ TIM. -Ii.
act wa PASSED i,ttGu-, the IfpI~t. f.,lpI T4.t.
Rio, hsti uo ROVER 20 punish "a CORR no i'm
who Had charged tIaf f.Is. rn..ul:i...Ilre.s ,r
Massachusetts had sent money herr. T., flfif,
enc" tui-er.~~- ami Tal refused .D say from
whom Dr. -af hi Information. and o.. Thar
occasion Ji' %; "a" uip-t learned men 0T This
.tty hal made "a great speech
Judge Fi~H,T.-Who wa. it,,
NJ. bu.uut-K0Bert ToyIui> Of {; aor1f3 =
gentleman not unknown o. fame H. ,-.,r-
TirEed. saving that ;!iiS act was rrerl3.fai i'm
i~. iu fl.s f.r .~e1 cO,!e. at4L il provides int
tng ~p,akcr IF the House snail tarfir,- ~.
fact D. the district attorney. ami does n1r an
tuulfle i..u 10 commit him 10 iasi +, ~
vlu"~ thdt le shall 30 80 ia an such case II
HlaEc~ The 1ry e mi~sIam.auor. ANA mi, ex-
I4Uet> fEe whole nyv-cr of f5,e HI. ~
HUug.- then 7leefl~-e,! tine mower. rf courts -
punish Tor contempt. ami claimed -hat fhs
law ol ~. Tya.. acted iu -. The duty of Inc
court was plain. tir simple Jr;r.ijn1 n,i,i[
has tug hri!.- cf Representatives. power Owe.
Z, erItIlrna. lots VIII. ,-- derived -., "a ,.,
.Iellai Du-...u a. under t!,l Nv III 90
5.r-fI<,; an. Inn. 60
" sr..rr..!...-...,. -
'I''''- ID ''.t.'i~-- Ire
''I'. "'' '''ilti oi tiie rr>n"Ii"aj-
Tia. court .tir. --E-fp-. EGu rT,c.a 4 NJ
~..II..'...-E. sine Q, ..s r,t some -.f s--
t,f.- IS b a.. may. ua..st4- :li.fig Inc ,sr.r.,
Lr--- aNH. Perhaps. dispense with II. NJ
~u.-s. .rlt- fl 'le ease us~ y- tn preserve il
DE IH.. .Hfg.ffry and force tho trt il- Igba4-
corpus a.rs.u~.. next To- the Jury trial. / rs
gard .5a..i lie mos. tr,,5 ~f l-s
ass. rights ts'p-siu. to Dur-v~fru1 1| .st-rr5,-
fHsrs. ! I.Ne. therefor. listened with nd f.,-
yuT 1a motion 81 -l The writ i'm rff. ,...
Tho petition I.tOu which rr,. TvTfr il f,,.lf,IsF
was presented by counsel whose ro-ifs,u 80
.re t,.s ..t.t.. t.l.rp D.. most rs...,.rfrl CON
,lcrsl. ion. st.rl could -rr,.<. g. frii.is,. a.,
.6.g tina. frivolous Oh -rurro.--5f.rft anI,'rr4-
firG wauLt come FROM su.'. "a ~1.fg,.. an .fra.
some considerable reflect ION l5,,,Y ina sr..-
f.g'- I Concluded to grant if. writ Affprfr4
H.'. CD. HaHns- c5ruu. is allowed. tine -rlb,a-
OErrt proceeding are regulated by absolute
statute Isry. TIL, officer Ia whom IL il tlr...s-
g.. s~ required ip uie g return jp Inc writ. AMI
90 bring along Slth Ills return. th- body al
t." person ~ custody before tie officer vino
t-~.-.f '.fa wit The retaggI Is In-u secured
f.f- right by express provision OF the statute.
a. -"z.NIHg Iae facts >,:trs5 in t.taf return, ami
g. introducing geEr facts upon the record ,i.,f
f-aE le material iu tine case The further
direction rl .Ie Raw is H.af ts. fu.ia.s
... # ....r. D.. q.