New-York tribune., 1875-01-23
PEACE DECLARED BUT NOT PRESERVED.

PEACE DECLARED BUT NOT PRESERVED.
@ The paper that have presented to you is
what known the tripare agreement snti A. Yes Sir
q Were you present at that arbationi A believe was
present at that arbitration yes Sir
Q. Were you present when this paper signed was
not present when il was signed.
@ Did you ever it beforei A. think have The
paper beforeyes Sir Mr. Beecher not there Sir at that
interview; so, therefore did not see it signed
O. did not ask why you did not see t A. Wen was only
telling you why.
Q When did you see 1t nrst do you Think A. When did
zee il hrstf
@, Yes, A. That paper think saw the time that
night, Sir.
@. Was the printed paper attached to it at that tmei A.
don't remember whether It not, distinctly.
O. Didn't You examine that night az carefully az yon have
here today Ny impression is that the printed paper was
attached to it, can't swear whether examined specifically
not.
@ Don't You know ii attached to III A. No; could
not swear that il
@ Didn't you furnshit' A. Didn't furnish ~
A. Yest A. don't remember that did.
@ Do you remember that you did mott havn any rec
objection as to whether did or not.
O. Do You know where that article from that printed
paper that s attached to the parite agecment A. could
not swear, Sir, as to where it came from
O. Do you know whether the plaintiff furnished i'll a.
Whether Mr.. TltOn furnished III
O. Yesi A. don't know whether he did OF not
O. Did you ever this printed article in anybody es
hands besides Mr. Tton yourself unattached to this paper
A. That printed artlclef
O. Yes A. can't swear that ! ever saw that printed
article.
Q. Did you what is known as the G6!d,r Age
Artice"i A. Yes and have jus, had heI have Just pro
duced the one that saw.
O. In anybody eses hands besides yours and Theodore Til
tsnsf A. Yes in Mr. Beecher's hands.
O. In Nj Beeches hands A. In Mr Boechers hands yes
Sir.
tbotv bavn
you ever see it in any eses handsi A. cant
whether it was ever in anybody ese's hands or not
@ did not ask you that asked you whether you ever saw
t' A. In anybody elses hands'
@ Yes' A. can't that ii in anybody elses
hands
@ You have no recollection OF ever seeing anyone el-es
hands, A. Except in Mr. Beechers Nj TOns and myself
Q. Yes' A. think in Mr.. Claiins.
O. In your presencei A. Yes; in my presence.
O. During the arbitration? A. No don't think during the
arbitraon-before the arbitration
O. Before the arbrationf Yes, Sir Think Mr. Cafn was
given On article by somebody.
O. How long before the arbitration A. Oh some time be
fore the arbitration
O. BY whom was he given the arcef n don't Jecolec1
by whom il given TO him.
O. Don't you recolect whether you gave il TO himf A
don't whether Mr. Beecher handed him copy Of H. or
whether Mr. Tion handed him copy Of IT, whether did
O. Were there two different articles printed from the office Of
The Golden Age embodyng this letter Of January lst A
The article Sir that remember TO have seen s this proof
which produce here.
O. Answer my question: A. viii try TO; am endeayor
ing to want TO answer you courteOusy.
O. Now ak you there different articles printed
from The Golden Age Office embodyng this letter OF January
lstf don't know Of any two different articles except this
one you your possession and this here which
seems be deen cannot answer the question, Sir with
out answering it in that way ntegenty. submit 10 the
Court.
u-Il thatpa paroyf A Yes sir Mr. Norris
has It, Is there any other way your Honor IL Which can
the question ?
Judge Neilson-I don't think there If, Sir
Mr. Tracy-Now MI Tiltons signature this paper isn't
it, A. / will see, Sir. Paper handed to witness
Mr. Tracy-You connect this paper with the arbitration
understand in all your questions TO me
O Yes, Well the arbitration before this paper
submued-I would like TO make that corrccion- the
evening Of arbitration that this paper submitted but the
arbitration before this paper signed money
Mr. EyartsThe paper was present o. TIC aoFatoni A.
Not at the arbitration; no, Sr
Mr. Tracy-The arbitration was evening and A. No
Sir 1t was the evening Of the arbitration after the
arbitration, on the evening Of the arbitration.
@ But after the arbration' A. Yes, sr.
O. That this paper vas submitted A. Yes Sir by M
clahni
O. Yes, and signed A. Yes, Sir.
Q Now did you show this Goea Age srtEse to M Beesber
at any time prior TO that arbitration A. Yes, Sir
q Wheref A. At my house
@ At your housei A. Yes, Sir.
O. Do you know whether shown 70 Mr. Bowen by any
one prior TO that arbtratonf A. think M Cafin told me
that he had shown 1t Mr. Bowen won't be
that.
M Evarts-Wel that is hearsay.
The Witness-I don't
O. Well, was Mr. Clafn Bowen's Arbitrator A. I don't
know whether he not he Of the atbra,ors
think he WAS however.
O. You think he vast A. think 20.
O. Do you whether the article also thown 10 Mr.
wilkinson before the arbitration by Mr. Ttoni A. don,
know that, Sir could not swear that II was.
O. Whatf A. could not that was don't recoeet
having seen 1t shown to him.
@ How long before this arbitration his shown 10 Mr.
Beecher and given Mr. Clann How long before the AMI
tration'
q. Yes. A. II was time before the arbitration
z Well, can't you approximate the time? A. don remem
ber Sir, how long
q Wasn't it in March, 1872! A. II after Nj Tltons re-
turn from the West, whenever that
q Well what time did he return from the Vest A. don't
recoect the month, Sir; don't recoect the month.
O. after you showed that article Mr. Beeoher
gave copy Of to Mr. Claim the arbitration agreed
upon' A. II time before consented the arbi
traiion; we consulted the lawyers first about it.
@ Did you give the article to Mr. Cahn with view Of |
having shown Mr.. Bowen' A. don't remember whether
/ gave 1t to Mr.. Clahln or not
q How many talks did you have with Nj Call prior 10 the
arbitratoni A. That, really, don't Iecollec,.
z You lad sonnet A. Had oDe Two guess