The New Orleans bulletin. [volume] (New Orleans [La.]) 1874-1876, 1875-03-24
TCoETINUED FROM FIRST PAGE.

eminent, being, it seems to me, the mo
natural aud obvious sense of the Lar
ouape and the sense in which it vi
be most naturally understood by Il
people, who adhere to the principles and cor
cluSions which | announced here in my n
marks on the 125h inst, and which hc'
adopt bv reference without retraction or qul
dcation; and while hold that recognitio
BY the Senate or by Congress Of goyernmen
thus initiated, can give it no greater validit
then it had IN its inception, still as domesti
violence and civil r, which may lead to
complete dissolution Of society, no
tue best remedies for getting rid o
even an iilegi,mate government | can ap
prove the action OF the President directed {
the humane purposes mentioned II N
amendment or substitute offered by the Hena
Tor from Rhode Island, and believing th'
recognition Of this government tor this pur
rose and 10 this Cytcnt Is IuStlhabe under
the peculiar circumstances now existing III
that State, until by fair election more
legitimate goyeIntne ut can be initiated, can
vote for the resolution III the sense have
aoYe attributed to 1t, but IN the
enlarged and odjous sense which
has been attributed to ii by some 81 the
speakers on The other side l could not vote
for ii, and most deliberately ayoW my con
victiOn that in such enlarged sense Or IN any
action BY which hat government was originally
set up and put iii power, 1t could not secure
theyotes Of majority OF this BODY.
Mr.. Wnytc, of Maryland modified his
amendment offered yesterday, 50 as 70 read
ResOired That the use Of the army Of the
United States TO enforce the uuwdrrantable
and void order o. Judge Durell, issued on the
9Th of December. 1872, directing the Marshal
TO seize the building occupied as State
House for tho assembling Of the Legislature
Of Louisiana, and the employment OF United
States soldiers tOiuvade the hall OF the House
of Representatives OF Louisiana, and TO ejGct
therefrom persons claiming to be members
thereof, are contrary TO the spirit Of repub
lican institutions, and cannot be approved by
the Senate Of the United States
The question BEN. Oh the above amend |
ment il was rejected yeas y. nays 33, Us
follows:
Yeas Bayard, Bogy, Caperton, Cockrell,
Cooper, DAVIS, Dennis, Eaton, Johnson OF
Tennessee, Jones Of Florida, Kelly, Herman,
McCroery, MGxey, Norwood. Randolph |
salisbury, $ eyenson, Thurman, Wallace,
Whytc, With.rs -.
Nays Allison, Anthony, Booth, Boutwell,, |
Bruce Cameron OF Wisconsin, Conlling Cra-
yin, Dorsey, Elnunds, Ferry Of Michigan.
Frclngheysen, Hamilton, Harvey Hitchcock,
Howe, Ingalls,, Jones Of Nevada, Lggan. Nc
MILAN, Mitchell, Morrell Of Maine, Morrcll
of Vermont, Morton, Paddock, Patterson,
Robertson, Sergeant, Sherman, Spencer,
Wadleigh, West and Window 80.
The question then being on the amendment
submitted by Anthony to the resolution of
Frelinghuysen, Thurman offered tho following
proviso - the resolution: provided that
nothing herein contained is mean. TO affirm
that said Kellogg is ds yore governor Of Loui-
siana.
ThurmpG said there We're several Senators
on tbs other side who affirmed over and over
agGin during dc debate on the Pinchbacl1
case that Wn. p. Kellogg was not Ne pre-
governor OF Louisiana.
Edmunds sad lac would vote against this
proviso, because it obscured the sense OF the
original resolution and raised a negative preC- (
uant, as the lawyers can it, on another part
of tho case.
Thurman referred to the discussion end
vote on the PinchbRck case and said he could '
' OF forget low tie Senator from Indiana {
IMorton) used the party hash over the shout /
oeEs Of those whom lac treated as recusants
He (ihurman) could not forget how they
were treated as little better than descTters |
from the Republican fold Remembering Il
that and very wildly, too, he could not quite t
see how the fact that they could vote for the p
was to settle the Interpretation t
thereof.
Edmunds Well. / will say to my friend
rom Ohio, |, for one, do not know of any
leserters from the Republican fold certainly O
lot among these to whom be refers; and sug- b
yest TO him, in the second place, We think we t
ire quite able 70 take care OF ourselves. II
Thurman Well, now, Mr.. President there il
, no necessity for that remark, for am sure m
did not volunteer to take care of them. Is
they are the last people in the world that I d,
would undertake to nurse and take care of u
laughter ii
The amendment of Thurman was rejected; ],
cas- "a, nays 33. Mr.. Hamilton, of Texas.
eng the only Republican who voted with
he Democrats in the affirmative.
Mr. Thurman then submitted the following is
: IN amendment to the resolution Of MIR tl
nthony:
Provided, That nothing herein contained so
meant to assume that the body of men pc
hch elected L. Is. S. Pinchback was the
gal Legislature of the State. II
Edmunds said he would vote against this 70
nendment on precisely the same ground Bt
Int he voted against the other. Tho amend hu
lent was rejected: Yeas a, nays 81.
Thurman then offered the following as an Fr
nendment So
" Provided that nothing herein contained cl(
meant to approve OF the Interference by
nited States troops in the organization of
le Legislature of Louisiana on the fourth
ay Of January last Rejected. Yeas q, 10
AVS -. OK
The question then being on tho resolution an
Anthony rs a substitute for that of Ere 10
nGhuysen, II was agreed to. Yeas 33. nays rel
J. as follows att
Yeas Allison. Anthony Boutwell, Bruce,
urnsldc, Cameron, W. F., Christiancy, on
onkling, Cragin, Dorsey, Edmunds. Ferry r..
Ich.l, Freliughuysen, Harvey Hitchcock, orr
owe, ingalls,, Jones New, Logan, Mcmillan. str
ltchell Morrill, (lle.l. Morrill, VIZ Morton 81,
iddock, Patterson, Roberts, Sargent Shcr-
an, Spencer, Wadleigh, West. Windom-33. PR
Nays Bayari, Bogy, Booth, Caperton, ne
,rkrell Cooper. Davis. Dennis. Carbon in
,hnson Tenn. Jones (Fla.), Kelly. ker-
IN, McCreery, Maxey, Norwood, Randolph, ter
Stevenson, Thurman. Wallace,
hite, Withers ..
In giving his vote. Robertson, OF South