, 1875-01-21
THAT Hs What MIR. lSccc1fcr
Vyns On the Brink OF.
He Told MIR. Frank Moulton
So in q Burst Of Con-
fldence.
Now Tho Whole OF Plymouth Church
Is In the Same Pcril0uS
Situation.
Mr., Moulton's Oross-Examination
Proceeding Slowly.
Ex.Judge Porter Absent from
Court on Account Of
Illness.
Gen. Tracy Badgers The Witness in
tie Approved Style.
Some Minor Defects in Moultou's Elem
ory-..Bcn Butler Author Of the
Celebrated Statement,

r,(< MI ~
o''o'A"'o" e's*'S'A''
-
NEW ouEsrIosEn,
ispertas Dispatch 10 The Ch,caao Ttioune,
New YonK, Jan. 20-Fsanc,a u. Moulton'a
Gross-examinatfon to-day was marked by an un-
expected eyent-the temporary withdrawal Of
Porter from tho condltct Of tho eroes-examnA-
ttoD, by reaaon OF illnesa, Gen. Tracy took
charge Of that part Of the caso, although Tiltons
counsel strongly objected. Tho cross-examinn-
ion WIS begun in = bland aud courteous
vay, but there was Immediately noticeable a
widc diversity Of manner and object bctwcen
tbs examiner to-day and tho man by whom tho
questions Of tho preceding dny were propoundotl.
Tho answers Of tho witness wcro not given
without dc1iboration, but ho had tho appear
auce Of perfect scIf-rossession. Tho contrast
between Judge porter's style Of o1amua ton
and Con. Traoy's became very Hharp aud clear
after tho flrst few questions werc put Tho
Generals queries wore announced in manner
and with m emphasis which placod thu wi,noxa
mn his guard iumediateiy. whereas Ar
Porter. in his quiet AMI ncrsuasivo
vay, inspired bIr, hfou1ton viii n
dogroe ri confldonca ,rb;c1, 1o, h;r, .,,,r. .,..
nnca into unw.rv ndm;ssio,a rtr,s 1ov,,o,,o1
that .1,e mennorv of Inn witpnaa ,v.a a,to,tir. T.,
regard to several imuortant oyeuta ,yh;c1,
came under Liz observation. To couI
nat recall whether Mrs. TIton vo. III
ar not when ho called uno, ha.
at tho plajntifr's houso To cot her 1ntter n M
nccc,,or ia d,l ~ 1rnt2 ,,1,at,,os ~. n.,..-
e.1taa ~ ,,,a ha,.a .,,.,, ,,,., az tAson
member whether Mr. Titon Vas in
tho house or not when he called.
IT don't remember" was m exnrrs.
sion which ho used frequently aressrs Beach peaet
fnllerson' and Morris came to afs. Moultons MD
Whenever opportunity offered. aud their sp,r;te1
objections to tho questions Of the counsel On tbe
,t1,ar aida b.1naa ,vit,o., .1x,.4, l.; - -.
osuo uaipoa "t'nssa efeass III nia efforts to
.pPoal enIte'y nnomnaf7assea. uon. Tfacys
tnto1roEatosies followed eacl other very rapidly,
but wltnoss waa not equally quick in his answers,
THAR moannc thro1,nt 1v,,on Ia as.i,.es .a.t
,,-. o .ousA "un4' ~ aoas'teu shhE
uo "ou!o nase de6tfoyed MfB' Illton's alleged
uouteeslons II Mr. Beecher had insisted on It,
so.racslop. tho counaets for TIM do,ersa
srot,a,,eod sm,tos. Iurinr ~ ne oss1nss at.ns
noon session Mr. n1ontton shou,d ,.s. "..s,- .a,f
sero given moro sharply, and indicated some.
gliug akin to anger.
pxa BUTLER wuorg uou1ros'e er.rr,rsr ,.s-
'-e@'>' s,,,,,,.n o4A AA1'fNf 1ASR
H. ..,.., Iii, SUMMER.
Ao testified, With apparent reluctance, that
Gen. Dsujamin F. Butler was tho author Of hss
hour l. of adjournment hi. answers to Gen.
t;n% tla1y @ m!ofa9gesones were given IN sullen
ia sna g. way "n'eh 70 c9ntsasteu strongly 9Th Ills
and liz W were 'a much s1atsa ri:h as'fs s
day,s developments. and made no atton,pt to
T,Taa.a I9nee1t tne. ea1siactloa. Mesara. Beach,
rnlcIson, ... anu Morris, on tho contrary,
suJ 4at.S Iaa'scta% mefSo4s IN their movements,
An ob,oatap Thsv ns,o no ehsnse an;s to mako
posits s'ae ssssnss shcE position.
n.a enni"s aaa, cortet OF ah EMINENT am AuTaonITT
mau - Gapitai tnin{ 70 got hold Of said Coun-
n1los es. GefaGs: ~ burst of contidenee TO his /
.a IT,; a.. ~ VIVA. a5; te1he1 growing more
iua..s Iionst Huacu; An4 a1acohtenteI or hungry
Ill., E'A1'rs AND COUNSELLOR fERKKn UNIT IN
rbtu ,,r,.r,,..,. or1hioS. l.sos a.,
NJ anlh aai.. IemarAsnie opnoh DID not appear in
for M oone 1SF s tho
stnVoIi"aee tant .'s. M 70 Il, se5 II is notable
~. ra'.+. as M1 Evssts daily nslsta that the
eeea atI,Yes. 4he Jury, as consequence, have
Eume SH, 10 'ook upon lin IN Very grateful WAy, |
i' mttn out ono or two exceptions, tho
1nrymen arc worry attentive, aud tleir
hs aydansa nrasootaS 9ar,t to we
AFTERNOON, one Of tho jurors indnlged In short
HaP' nut Yesterday they weso all awake, and caru-
tal 4!stehers.
THE ATTENDANCE,
r[ana u: caFpenser, tho artist made his Ap-
"; VIA Mr IIlton, and took scat Just bot.iud
slt' Fullerton, i'll position where
70 could look straight iuto 1Ioulton's
ta ,sco. Mr. Carpenter was quito palo, mud vas
mt and bis wife listened throughout to tue rro.
tceaings with tho utmost attention. There wero
10 lad'es In Court yesterday except tue four iu-
tcFeataa III tho case. Among liza sueo.
.stors were two Or three cierrv,nrn
fudge Tbbitts, OF California Ten'
iiieury ". sloouu,, Judge Moore, Coj. Beechor
,he Hey Edward BeecLez, and Francis D'
hlonlaou'k antagonist from Plymouth i,h1,cI
lsof. Rosaiser ii. Raymond, ~ 4"te"'
srEC1AL LEa1sLArtoy.
A bill authorizing tLo continuation of thu