davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New Orleans Republican. [volume] (New Orleans, La) 1867-1878, 1875-08-03

The CatshOula News certains long COM
mpnication from Sheriff James N. Taulk,
his deputy. John 3. Boatner, and two ether
gentlemea, rsRsrdi9g the charges against
Mr.. w. r. Adams. a Winnsbofosgb, which
gentleman 10 accuEd of harboring uur-
derers, and assisting them to escape. The
Sheriff and his posse had 9arrant for tho
arrest of Rssves and McGraw, two men
charged with the murder Of q colored man
at Sicily islands, xnd went into Frankie
parish in pursuit OF the mufderers. While
in that parish <hey heard of The where
abouts Of one Irwin, said to be At the house
of Adama and - Irwin had been
charged with . similar efense t.ey
searched foe him also. Il appears
Adams HAD learned of the shetifFs in
tentions and warned Irwin to leave,
which be did. When the posse arrived at
Adams house that gentlemen net. them
and said, jocularly, "Walk in, gentlemen,
your bird has fowa." He also acknowl-
edged having warned Irwin, and said in the
course Of conversation, "No man should be
arrested for killing . negro if he could help
it." The sheriff says, in . previous letter
to the Franklin Sun:
fheard yesterday that the grand jnry of
Franklin parish had found true bill
against him fOf assisting Irwin to escape.
In view OF this l an sorry he has forced ne
20 write this article. II is proper to say
that neither nor any one of the gentlemen
Who constituted my posse, presented MIR.
Adams to the grand jury. At the same time
frankly confess that would have done go
had been in Franklin at the sitting Of the
court Such ofenses ought not to be per-
mitted to go '.unwhipped of justice" Grim
lstence and we'll being of society. is
tered. and NO sheriff can arrest .
criminal If the people, who ought
to feel in tonor bound to assist him, work
against him. IN times like these. good
men ought to be moro than ordinarily anx-
ious to assist in bringing offenders to JUS
tice Grimes are too frequent, and too
little condemned; our over worked people
with taxes levied to psy for prosecuting
criminals. If the offices of justice in the
two parishes mentioned were in the hands
OF corrupt men, and used to perveft justice
and oppress the people, there might be
tome shadow of ex xoese for refusing to ar
rest them, but such is not the case. The
most important Offices of these parishes are
held by Intelligent men, who are anxious
and willing to do right.
The authorities of many of the country
parishes evihce q determination to arrest
criminals and lessen the number of crimes,
but the citizens of the Democratic faith are
not yet alive to the necessity of bringing
murderers to justice. Many of them, as is
the case with Adams, still think q man
should not even be arrested for killing
negro, which doctrine is not good for the
best interests of the State.
New Orleans Republican. [volume] (New Orleans, La) 1867-1878, 1875-08-03
AIR btxe6.

Referring to the resignation Of Auditor
Clinton, to take effect in December next,
the Catahoula Nescs says:
Major Moucure, onr State Treasurer elect,
is supposed will be appointed to the posi-
tion. A more honest and capable man
could not be selected, but we think Major
Moncure should fill the position to which
he was legally and justly elected by the
New Orleans Republican. [volume] (New Orleans, La) 1867-1878, 1875-08-03
NEW YORK.
The Census of New York,

1uO CeuDU9 OI VeW KOfRo
NEW YORK, August 2.-The census shows
the population OF this city to be l,O5O, 900.
Sale of the Northern Pacific Postponed.
The sale of the Northern Pacific railroad,
which was advertised to take place to- day,
has been postponed to Thursday, August,
10
New Orleans Republican. [volume] (New Orleans, La) 1867-1878, 1875-08-03

AMUSEMEN8S,

AMUSEmEN8S. :
ACADENY OF MUelC.
MATINEE PBRFORNANC4,
Wednesday, august 4, 1EyA
Benefit rendered to the
A0C1sIANA REfIE1 AseOCIAYH0A
BIZ THE
vARI~TY DRAMATIC CLUE
a 6bisA occasion Vill be brIuonted - 1Rsnd
O,d romantic dHamA entitled
SEA o. ICE.
RBCkPrpoo cou1ifTu1.
Colonel ". J. Behan. P. 8. Nflts,
viniao A. Bel II. Dudley COlemS1,
J. N. Putnam, John Glynn, Jr.,;
6Ohn Adams, Thomas A. AdamS,
3. N. Harrod DR.. Beithelot
I. H. Oglesby, John J. Mellon,
Samuel Mullen, e.K Mi Ter,
s. J. Irwin, Joseph Mitchell,
George W Bosth MA A.COull
]. N. Norich, John n. CONWAY.
Doors Opo1 at eleven O'clock. Curtain rises at
twelve O'Clock.
Every chi!d attending will be presented With
book.
4 fine Cookine Stove will be presented TO the
Ver.on selling the gre atest number OF tickets.
Tickets Fifty Cents May DO procured from any
member Of the club or the above named gentle
Box office will be open TUESDAY,. August 3. at
ten O'Clock. jy25 % aul 4
New Orleans Republican. [volume] (New Orleans, La) 1867-1878, 1875-08-03
FOB RENT.

10 RENf................'..'...--Tok RENT
LARGE Ard PLEASANT FURNISHED DO0MS,
ia suits or sinRly in deslrable loc .ity. AL the
comforts of home guaranteed. Apply ct No. 199
Baronne street. jy3l6t
New Orleans Republican. [volume] (New Orleans, La) 1867-1878, 1875-08-03
STEAMBOATS,.
HO. FOR GRAND ISLE:

HO" FOR GRAND ISLE
ASAMHN h The steamer
9ilIy ya6E{ MINNIE.
q Drawing thirt-e inches light,
GUS RICHARDS, Mast r. A. P. TROUSDALk Clerk
VIII leave the head of Hatvey's Canal on TUES.
DAY, THURSDAY and SATURDAY o: every week
during the easCn at A. NJ for g. and lslt going
through in daylight Passengers will take the
Tchoupitouas street cars the ferry ct Louisiana
'srbss Tbe Minnie IN viii retur on WEDNESDAY FRIDAY
and MONDAY. arriving att p. II.
Fare each way - So
TIL Minnie will positively land her pasae ngers 1t
the hotel whaif
For further inf0rpation apply to
AITR 4 CARLIN, Agents,
iy3 Pm Nc. Thou upitoulss street.
New Orleans Republican. [volume] (New Orleans, La) 1867-1878, 1875-08-03
NOTARIES.
NHARLEs H. THOMPSON,

NOTARY PUBLIC
No. 24k Csrondelet street, mn stairs.
Makes sspecialty Of Title Neets for the purcnep
OF redemption of property cold BY the State f1e
other law.
Being thoroughly familiar with al details, AM
prepared for tho speqay dispatch Of business II
trusted to hip, vail guarantee satisfAcden.
iva I'm
New Orleans Republican. [volume] (New Orleans, La) 1867-1878, 1875-08-03

CMALL FURNISHED HOUSE FO
- RkNT-Three roOms aud kitchen, No. 469 8
And rev. between Rampant and Franklin street
Rent very low to . responsible person that o.
give first class security for the prompt paynenta
rent and cafe keeping Of the furniture. Non
other need apply. les
New Orleans Republican. [volume] (New Orleans, La) 1867-1878, 1875-08-03
XkTT

WANfR1 ~ e6RcnASE-A wooGb
'.s - s ssa TT: f. j. r. X, -: ,S:sss ss:s
New Orleans Republican. [volume] (New Orleans, La) 1867-1878, 1875-08-03

At : recent dinner in Paris, at the house
of 1mile 6irsrd1h, tho subject of the soul
came 10 be disguised. Each one present
,hel. u 1Sofd to eay, inclueisg the Abbe
En&6ms1, vhastHuiaa = fair neighhor,
~ lowing; saj. \ have seAected .
'qDuH sosGe . tAaEs auhaAy deliberate
0tqI0 b taak - 4Ght to live in fhis
VOID sIeaeAS
Su1enon s1a . M C.G ySS
New Orleans Republican. [volume] (New Orleans, La) 1867-1878, 1875-08-03

In the general fitness of history, Ne other
city IN this country could possibly celebrate
the event of emancipation as feelingly as
the freed people of Louisiana. Without
great display or ostentation, many of our
colored citizens yesterday commemorated
the great fact of emancipation from slavery
by quiet gathering on the Fair Grounds.
in . social manner. Hundreds of people
assembled, and quietly congratulated each
other on the present standing of those who
were once held in vile bondage. Almost any
other class would have glori6ed the time
with grandeur, but our colored friends con-
tented themselves with simply assembling
to indulge in ordinary sports, such as are
daily INDUCED in by more pretentious citi
zens. II is pleasant to note that everything
passed off pleasantly. Two companies Of
colored militia marched through some of
the principal streets before adiourning to
chs Aodezvous, and attracted considerable
attention.
= Upo orriving At the grounds speeches
were made by several eloquent speakers
The managers, Mesers. B. B. Colbura, j. A.
CrAig and their associates are entitled to
nush credit for - success % thesdemon-
atr<
New Orleans Republican. [volume] (New Orleans, La) 1867-1878, 1875-08-03

o West
pee $3.50
aa8 100
hg. ana
sterday
several
} $2s =
ads. a
} Ut rs
po& De-
black
ste &C.
80 y
sts 10
. fancy
. q Csc;
"a SEQ
N $50
! a059c;;
tens.
10 $50
styles,
BLES-
quoted
Cab
1krout
prices
10000
quote
D1SAc
l9Ac;
fuary
f9A a
with
y of
'hGce
hOice
) $50
9 de-
fst6rn
but
Ke IS
bury
et So
} sell
geese
siana
81 IS
5 so;
land. |
022o
duh. \
and |
It 400
hid; |
lanu- |
dull. |
J 0So |
sup |
are
$59
reen
de- IA
+ do |
ard.
etaI |
Is in
der I
l Is
[rk's
hen
lade
Iells
ted
nsin I
N. 4
Y
4
n
Es
<
of |
/
2sD @ /
ASoo Soa 4
IsS I,s 4
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-01-01
THE COAL TRADE.

PRICrs TO BE LOwERED-OPINIoSs OF OFFICIALS
The question as TO what course will DO pur-
sued during the three months by the coal ana rail-
road companies which bring coal to this city is as yet
undecided, but II O reduction shall be agreed upon 1T
will be only small amount The representatives OF all
the companies assert, and claim TO substana'e their
assertion by figures that the tariff Of railroad rates
is almost at the minimum, and the reduction
which 1t is possible TO make In miners wages
will affect the price only few cents o ton.
Mr. r. G. MOuton general sales agent OF the Delaware
aud Hudson Canal Company, stated 10 TRIBUNE re-
pOr yesterday that lie knew OF no business concern
ing Which such universal ignorance prevailed as the
coal business People, he said seemed to link that the
coal companies established for benevolent purposes
provide the people with coal at cheaper rate than 1t
can be mined and brought 10 market On the contrary,
they are intended 10 do legitimate business,
and earn fair profit for the benefit OF the
stockholders. He said that most OF the coal
companies had been able to do this that nearly all
money during the past three years and his own
company, which had been established 40 years. and had
facilities for doing WELL had only been able to declare
10 per cent dividend And this, he said, had been
done with advantages superior to the Other cohpahes
The popular impression IN regard to the exorbtant
price OF coal he regarded all wrong There was
no other article Of merchandise that was SO
cheap II was the only commodity that was
selling at the prices OF 20 years ago. Everything else
was higher The miners were not eX ravagdntlY pald,
but Thought their should be reduced 0nt sup
pose they are cut down 20 pei as ia proposed this
would have no apprcahe effect on the price OF coal
sgch reduction would amount to Is cents day on the
wOkmans wages, which would lessen the cost OF ton
of coal only SIX cents The question OF reducing the
reights this city would be decided in few days. but
IL did not possible he said that any great difference
could bs made IN the rates. The Pennsylvania Coal
COMPANY Mr. Moulton SAIL Tad sold their article at
much less price the other companies hut they had
not suffered from It, Whether not the proposed re-
ductOu II the miners would create strike, he
said he had no means OF knowing
George A. Hoyt. Treasurer OF the Pennsylvania Coal
Company thought the present the proper time to
make the in the price OF coal II th average
should kept that Of last year The officers o.
the other companies Thought that next March would ne
time enoug to make he reduction. be did tot apprc
bend auy general strike at the mines except III the
Schuykill region where 1t proposed to change the
Ell ire basis OF payment Tie miners receive certain
81 ice prop0rtonate to the price at which coal sells at
certain locality They cannot tell themselves what they
are to receive week to another as 1t depends
entirely upon what coal sells for in certain places.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-01-01
OFFICIAL AID IN REVENUE FRAUD.

The trial of Custom house Inspector d. p.
Harris for completely in the smuggling OF about 10000
cigars into this port was resumed yesterday IN the
United States Circuit Court before Judge Benedict.
Soon after the close Wednesday OF Ayeanets Cross
examination by Mr.. Courtney, the former was seized
with Of the braiu He being therefore unable
20 attend Assistant United States DlstrictAttorney
Purdy called Johu n La Du, Cusom-house Inspector,
a part OF those seized the steamer
Crescent City. The next witness was Joseph Roland,
spanard who is here in search OF situation IS bar
tender He testified that no was in the room at the
snap,ah Hotel when Harris aud Avellanet made ar
raugements for smuggling the cigars and according 70
ROLAND they were fOllOws Ayelanet was TO bring
the CHARS IN tine Crescent City, packed in dry goods
boxes contrasting 900 cigars each, and for passing
them free of duty Harris TO receive ESQ for each
lot OF cigars so passed long crossexamnation
elected nothing more from the witness EXCEPT that he
had someum smuggled cigarettes into this port and
that Aye,anet had told him lie would have to be WIT
meas in the case.
Joseph Forenier Spanish barber from Brooklyn,
testified that he had heard Harris ana AYeanet tax
ing together the Spanlsh Hotel and IN AVelanets
room asc, that he bad heard tnen c0hNeIeng AT tne
wharf when the steamer Columbus sailed on Now 10,
1917.
Arthur Gallagher, q hackman, corrohorated Avel-
lanet's testimony ABOUT trunk being taken rom NO
81 East FOurtn-st Sept go 1874 and stated that 20
the test Of HIS knowledge aud belief Harris was IN the
hack when the trunk was taken away. IL IA alleged
that the trunk contained some OF the cigars smugsed
with HARRIS cOnuivanCe.
Minnie Freepurger who resides with her parents at
No. "a East FUuTthst., testified that sho saw
Harris there sept ~, 1914 aud that he was In the
hack when the trunk was taken away AT the close ~
the examination Of this witness the Court adjourned TIL
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-01-01

from that time until his DEATH on Oct ii,
1878. He was engaged in the povision business,
but afterward invested real estate. Al the time OF
his death his property amounted 10 about 100000
will and cOdiei we're presented for probate by woman
who claimed to be his second wife. The probate OF
these Instruments contested by tho sons OF the
deceased. They charged ia their objections
that the will and eodic we're never executed by the
decedent that they were fraudulent; that the claim
ant was not the widow Of Frederick Rolwagen, land
that he was not the father OF LenaS ohd born some
two months after the death of Mr. Rolwagen The con
test before the Surrogate lasted from OCTOBER 1873 10
April 1874 The testimony hlls three large volumes
making about 2OOO Lages Nearly 100 witnesses were ex
amined on July Surrogate rendered his decision
refusing admit either the VIII or the cOdt
From hg decision no alleged widow Lena appealed TO
tile Suprvu,U Court. she argued IN OctODer
last diary L. CLINTON behalf OF the contestants
tine CHI IT, end grandchildren Of the deceased and
by william H. Armour Oh behalf OF appellant The bu-
preme Court yesterday gave their decision, Affirming
the decision of the Surrogate rejecting the Will and
cOdici.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-01-01
GOSSIP OF THE STREET.

TESTIMONY or IEGRAND LOCKWOOD, BROKER.
q Were yOua meuber % ,Ae LrLl u lockwood l. Co
In lt72 A. wac
q daVe you the books that will s60v the deposits OF
Sept. 1874 A. have not.
q WI you procure and examine the hooks. and SOC
there we're at that time any deposits o. 100000 or
bAVOO, male by the Presdent OF the Pacng Hail Com
paDy A. 1 will
q Are you the Legrand Lockwood who was evan
Ined some tins before the Committee OF WAYS n nd
Means Ia regard ~ transactions ia which Mr. sbe
hSa ana others wele afterward Implicated A. sm.
" won't you ten here oil that you know about those
~SAS~eIVhs A. know nothing about them except
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-01-01
CIVIL NOTES.

N
VI anu al''l Jan, io'D, anu "ii'n tNi'"
notice" the Chambers calehdar WI" nc caeu at O'CLOCK
D. I"' ,,,
In the case OF Alexander against AlPNdnuer
A., c,,,,,,o couct Csnorol Tart T,dOa Iavrance Oiv
"'o oup' 49,, go ~. Ga a ota1nn, ,rooaoIt,o
ing inc oPIuio"' 'io'u 'u'' ~ " o''"P. p ''s'
when 1t is case or ctuins contempt feleIece
may DC @ ~ aim nterrogatores WbGr the
proceCding il commenced by order to show cause aud
not by attachment.
Peter A. 1oungblood applied yesterday TO
Judge DOnohue for mandamus to the Board OF Asses
sors to estimate the damages caused him by raising the
grade Of hundredand-nttys econd-st. Tho reply
was thar the Board had not refused TO do co. but were
awaiting "A decision by the General Term a. TO their
richt TO act. Decision reserved Jas A. Deering for
" IL $50 &C Iop,oe = Miller oooinst tho
D." WV w. ---,-,.. -, -. =,
city 10 recover an amount for Dy e orucr OF
a former Board OF Trustees, involving an expsn1iturei
Of the amount allowed 10 the trustees Oy the Dy-
Laws ol we no' bi T nor tb tnstees bavin, excceded
htr authority he has remedy except against them
The representative one, there being $1,000 OF
slLhldr c'a'hIs'
Patrick Burns sued the city Tor services and
,rioIs furnished under orders OF the Deputy street
Ir'iai,nor N 1874 and recovered Indictment from
commissioner III low anu $500 J@' ~
which the city appealed. Judge Davis. giving the
opinion Of the GtAsra! Term reyrI.eS tns JUDGEMENT
of the act Of 1851 that the work should be certified by
the mead OF the appropriate department was not COM
plied with.
Tho oninion of the Supreme Court General
Term in Ino matter OF opening slxthayc, was delivered
Inv Judge Donohue. The appeal came up allegations
that those Directing had opportunity to the
port. The Court says that noGe 10 me u JSctOns was
lshU1i 40, tn rgcd The openino and
no cromnds for couceang the report were stated and
no fraud being proved in any way the Judgment must
be cCnnrmeu
In the suit of Kedtan against William H.
- president NJ the Roard Of Eiucation and the
Nehsoh' Ah'i ~ - - - -. -. -
Controller and County AuultoV 10 eOpe theh 10 sign
the proper papers the payment OF bill against
,,o Colooe of tho CITY Of York the General Term
Iho NVio t.. boiaa .bo, ,ho
Judge Lawrence giving the opinIoh' nYlus 'n"S w
Board OF Education III Io'1 was noG Vi o
city, its expenses were nO uhuer c conro Oh Ic on
trOller ana Auui'oI anu tho l'
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-01-01
DEPOSIT BY LEES & WALLER.
TESTIMONY or WILLIAM l.. JENKINS. PRESIDENT
IL

TESTIMONY or WILLIAM L. JENKINS PRESIDENT OF
THE BANK or AMERICA.
William l.. jenkins, President of the Bank
OF America the witness called. HE testimony
reserred Principally 70 check for 1880 which
posted iDthe bank OF which be l., President
q We understand from the evidence which has been
presented that check for t145OO drawn by Rich
ard Irwin passed from yeur bank through the Clear
ing-house during the fret part OF 1872 What DO you
kD9N about soch a checks A There deposited with
us on Feb q, 1872, 10y Lees & Waller check for that
hInOu1t.
Was that the only deposI made 10y thai firm hat
ot1 a NO II was among their deposits 81 mat day.
was tbtfe among their deposits anOta1g check for
tl4, 6OOt A. There was not.
Y. WAC are the hTm Of Lees WallerI A Both mem
b,Is Of she hrm are now dead LaGlaw q q are their
SUCCESSOR
q. Where Is their place o. busiuessi A. Somewhere
~ Pine'sts the Directory VIII E1CR where.
q WHO Vas Waller A. He ras uOt NS ~ the
t"e OF wLlfh spcak. Lees really attended H. all the
business and the proprietor although the gTa went
Dy Tie name Of Lees 4 Ma.i,r.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-01-01
TILE COERTS.
THE TENTH NATIONAL BANK CLAIM.
REVERSAL OF FORMER DECIsION-THE CLAIM


THE TENTH NATIONAL BANK CLAIM.
REVERSAL OF A FORMER DECIsoN-THE CLAIM
REJECTED.
In the proceedings brought by the Tenth
National Bal against Board OF AppOruOnment to
cou,pel IL 10 issue county bonds TO meet the
payment OF advances made by them TO the Courthouse
Commissioners amounting TO $9i25I9 3d. aud against
Controller Green TO pay that sum to the bank when
raised orders tor pcrcmptOry wrt as prayed for we're
granted at Chambers. On appeal 10 the General Term
both orders have been reversed Judge Daniels giving
the opinion in both cases. IN the first case
he holds that the establishment OF the existence ana
stce OF the debt was an essential prerequisite TO the
raising OF money by either taxation or loan NO greater
fund than would pay known debts was authorized IE!A
fact of the debt disputed by the Controller In am
davts ayeIring the moneys have been advanced to
Ingersol VINO was not authorized TO borrow the money
on account of the Commissioners
In the proceedings against the Controller, Judge
Daniels holds that the Courthouse Commissioners had
no authority TO borrow money be refunded by
of funJs which might aferward be set apart for the
compton of the work their charge. and persons
dealing with them must inform themselves, at their
perl OF the extent OF their authority. The advances
made even il the other three Commissioners authorize
the Treasurer TO borrow the money claimed 10 have
been loaned by the reatOr created no legal or valid de-
mapd which 1t could recover from funds Of either city
or county. -.
ives rise Judge Daniels holds fair inference that
no other proofs offered. Gu these considerations
he holds the order for peremptoTy mandamus 10 nave
been unwarrantrd. At most, controyerted claim was
presented TO the Court payment or which could not I've
secured by writ Of mandamus until the controversy
favor Order reversed with costs. John H. Strahan for
reIatOr; Henry L. Davies for respondent.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-01-01
A MAYORS TIME WASTED.

The am<JInt of clerical labor now imposed
upon the Mayor il signing warrants for payments OF
various kinds very great This is especially the
ease the end OF each mOutl. when several thousand
warrants for the employees the various departments
have 10 be ssned gthn few days. The manual labor
very great ntsrfcres with the other duties Of the
Mayor and sometimes unavdidably c4usesa delay OF
several days in the payment Of those vino need their
salaries as Que The Mayor has addSessed 10
the Controller muncation tbis subject, i which
b., EtaIes his objections " the system.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-01-01
DECISIONS DEC. 81.

Supreme Court-Firsi Department. October General
Trm-Noah Davis r. j. john Bral, sui Charles pals', H.
Cs. heretofore the sey~s t'utsi Temsohofu
agt Keech sbp-JudGnssi mrned glh ~ Lawfsne > Bart
McNIel. snuuei wh % COTS N arh ease sti s'
bur,ement n one case opuion DAVIS PJ satsa agtN er
Land Judgment reversed anj tsl granted CO.'S abd ''l
opinion bV DAues. j. IN. People fs. Alexander ngt
Aeundet-Orler affirmed. sih 40 costs snd d'o-iss'
Of Pilots al sP9aorl =. sl-OHisr r's,'sl' slou,
rem r,ystso Nth 81 c. The ce
directed Of the CONT II Appsas opno
by Davis The Mayor 6cJgdment rcIrrted. ari
grsnei. With ABIDE event. o,nion b uAu
Rasash agt Rolwassu Decree OF harosatv hfhsi HHh
costs opibsn hy Daniels Excelsior Puoeum teopsnT at lasf
,Isssr ct -he osI appealed bom sfrnsd siib9ai costs e's