, 1875-12-09
the COURTHOUSE.
,rrank Adams Cruslics Til1cy with
d Legal Opinion.
h+e Architect Is a Nero Emplo7c, and
Must Obey Orders.
Eran's New Elevation.

EGan'4 NeW EIHvdLIoE1s
Another chapter and now leaf were turned
...tatdsy In tho nav Court-Housp ard C!sy
in1{,dIoe rau]dlo, BY An opinion Of Ah'lasant
no,oorstion Counsel Adauls to tho Board OF
@ psh1Ia Works :!p regard 10 tho isgas points sub
s,,,t,a by Mr. TilIoy to them Saturday. 'n which
=. denied their or ths citys authority 10 dIscatd
49, y Eureka" plkt,. The document wao rs'
s.,,ad It 2 o'clock yeHtorslay afternoon. and MAS
snsrspsred BY Mr: Adamo, beca,ito Judge Nokey
nmoda,stood - lhat Judge Dickcy's ylaws are
o. e,..1iT sst forth i'll it. Tho following II
s'' TIE OPINION:
c1+ Iav pxrAnrnExE, CH1eAoo, Dec. s-7a Me
ss@,d ,f Public Horks-osNTLaaEN hs1o received
"a sop.id.rtd your muneatton u ped. q 1a7t
ssi,sua ths Communication u Mt. Thomas Tiley to
1.r ngsf uf dsso Doc. 4 1875. Yon ask tpe for my
ou!an - % your o~sr in tho r. m.'ssr of dressing M
3s,3 ~ .I1a Sfr. rillc1s communication !" yon
p.sss Isnly directed to proving that tho Eureta' y
ps lis tba sg1ocluen u Aug a. ls72. between tho
~ - ss.uv and ths subsequent action Of the Com
H. IN t,ys that tho action OF ththe bollee ia
.ss,fsre this rlan, tie Common Council BY
,+.olatiou passed. uct. TO- 1878. and tbe Board
GsaaT ~ Iii. psrt of .ho eontrsc. ,ct~ssn tic
~ nd county that ths R,rsta" plan should bs
a. aian Of Tho proposed now Huildngr apa ho s4J1
III m ltRtl sdvisers BustAtn him In this Wow.
Nhsatr Nj. Til'ey and hit legal adtaurs m right
or xrenx in thus ottton. consider imnaictta 10 Tho
Y,esat aaury T4e rssht ot t1s 9Sl1o nay be H. u
tnot be ersstul sl,t " Eursk4 piau Of whether
Soorsn. latwsen t4s tty and county OF Avg. -,
x Character as Al .rehs,es. ompoye BY she e, han
~ rght 10 hnyo tho - Eureka " plan or any other
ELI ao III paa ,doptsa. Aug. . is5, thu Common
nSrsa, Tint oun Rfchitot sals To appointed whore
aatttt ahalt b to prcpara tho necessary plana and
,ptasstSons for 10 sFocton Of tue etys portion a
GR ii tac Original Town Of UhicaEa, eontmuty
snnsn n ths Grurt-lIouss aquare anli tho general
s.t.iior 3ssgn ot tho sano 70 to ui uniform char
.,ssle4 sna Boata 1t ru,lao wbris and said County
Ccupislouora. ssil stehlteet, rlisn tbs plans and
eptehtatIous for sa!d building shall bare hesn pre-
NM b5 ttn ant agreed upon by Ratd BoArl 10 take
eLre>ct md aurortdtena tho constructions Of said
bpl!aiu& to jM completion undnr tho direction ana
toAoi q ~ Beard Or raba Wofk1 s,'d a..a arshl
hIaf cAsakry to hs dono, III mud about Tho oonslfup.
try nd erection. 9f tho Gity. portion Of s.!a
ot1I naus md performed by BIN u such architect
81 ehA Board Ut puEsic Works, and said srchitect
&ittce!e frt thu city Of Chicago - hls fnll coni-
natitn lot hA eniSs kyrvieea ~ such afc1lsce tho
ua al 7.$Sq, aait tun teng PIX csnt Of the sual
d;L2,s,Nn, which shall L. tia ent.rs cost Of tho
3tfpcrio1i of katd building: and kuch cotnFen.a-
Ia tiall b tfa for III services Of such sEelittct,
StNd ID him Ly said city. That Whenever aaiI
urSlect shan have bsen 80 nppointtd and the rans
NJ Board ot Pubic Morks shall, without uuucrea.
~ del15 proceed to advertise I'll tho manner teu ed
yLx gos proposals for cKtAvatinR aud putting Ia
Il fountsfion up to ths established gra1c-llue !0r
ha PARTON Of sid building to be oecuplel by the cy
irs,nmsnt. and situated ~eat Of the north and aouth
*aisstas Of .aid ll'es, .ud to IT tho eon,ats q
"a Hefk u4a board is directed 10 advertise in tho
aadbet fvqnfssd b5 inv fur proposals. for furnishing
Raa nas+tialA sud adn9 to- tslnalsdee q the ~ork
t1cton IT The c:t3s portion Vt said building, and to
nts coatraet contracts therefor, thu contract
n4s.sss foe e1cassnus 4nl putt ny in ss.d fuuutLs
sa ar Ls cily portion Of sid ouildlg III nlAo Tue
psns Or contracts for farntslHG tue tn-tcriats for
AapxiosmIngths reIna!ndar VI tAa work uectasary
r. obe lit In each instance Whenever Tbs uoard oI
oVAty Commissioners shall have el tho cuhtrxct or
paassa Ter doing like work, md fusnshtug hs naa-
t1A Gk lhs const1uenau OF the .cuuAty's poslGn Of
It'd tulttnk. TO tn.t ths construction sud erection
tskeey portion ct e1ld bEil4sug and ths eoiittys
<a tharaot shall 10 bKtui aud togrsss 10 con,p.s-
tea llptaneeugly, Or nearly III may w.
lnstsH artstF Ervrttfr That the vtone to bs used
hthse4nssruation of aard huldlug' be hsrtH ar de-
xnntnsa y !bs CITY ceuncll--tCaAmpn Counril pso-
iar th,s Ia o!ss 1,usy viz ehos.n a. arch.sc,
kas ceninon Gaun.ll. Ao Il si.apiy III ent4oye pf
fe w. % .psesa ~ taS @ ord I'D 10
1u1dda for ahh gonerA Il orior dessgn Of. tie build
seas Ypltatn shalaet.r anI appearances, - - alal
Etla and sald Eouhty q mnalxsiuntr5." Tie Couh-
Gl would hy, tutI urLes 70 h.ss put Il into the
cxE Of Mr. Tllley. ~ TT rs the Council was legally
ES1ri1ed 10 10 do, ID smbarraEs tho Bo4sd Of Public
T@h by withholding h.s us1cnt to aeeh : plan
T. sigAt Ia agreed au. by the board, end ths
ctaatl comnlsA4onrrs. sm of tue opinion tlat
Eaan1 = ehuditicu prpcaltnt to tho adoption OF !
tan, Tia Council, mjgAt have itsslf adopo1 plan,
tbiYs In tho adoption VI u Plan TO shs na4r1 Of
trtlsTas4ai tutI daubs tbs power Of tne 0oaneI 10
aakfsta thai Po SHr 10 msre culpioya uo*exsr thls
Ess ~ 3gEssptsus .1ion p!aa y t5e na.sd q q
bttl na4ur The cdutraot bstwatn tbs clty and tha
etstL Aad, also undef k4o or1iar pEovtdiuR Ioe sn
sfNttt; and, Mr.. TiiiDy cannot AEzeo watn u,e
sl'4; ot Public Wura.: then he .ean.o. d'.eharee
~ autca Of: arhitJat - prcscEfbe1 IN Tia
.ss 81 ~ ,ssss r. NJ .ss sDli Sessa: sss S %ses
EPsnFa a. go.rd. tho Council may. aithsr " orle,
stteaoution, dispense with the neceaslty Of his
estasa. nish tbs board upon rlau, nr may dis'
Nht IT. services Atogethnf. and pfotIIla for thn
HtI circumstances seou, to require It. .lshotsh ol
atufhtoh that ths Uon1d haA, without Ar. Tl4ay =
sssas, ns power ta sars, with ths board u Count,
earnHleper, npoa p.4u. aud that. In sYeA case, ii
sh ar Tile, "A duiy. hr dcsiEoa TO continue IL
eaNt!nE Of tho city - ths: preniteet Ut tho eitv'u
rs4ac,s tss 1s'Rs sD1ns, Attorney 70, .he City.
M tpinlon caused
L:5.'' MUCH RzJo1cINo
e0sPlsNQst2 or iuo Gu&tu. Hneto ina menu
Y 4ssmed to. tsal ~ though lhey hal beer
n gsatlamen thought that 3fr. Tlley was
lasasn 10 tho position he had taken, and, Il
a'tesd at sa,' ~ WAS Receiving bad advice. Vhs
aa;nt bly, ptepsSsns. another elevation plaI
~ ~; Eaan, they thought, would uot Lave
haaed Aaythlng, ~ II would hh'o to be ap
fefN ~ bdth uuuuc,t and County Conmia
ASE$, i niit =: y .. =.
, ,i,'.' NE. K.,Fu1nx
~ ~ Gat|s 10 sxy yest tssday., aud what tls vii
WOW 1emai9stu te Hoon. ~ thero Ia esAdsnuy
,,a9Ssnsnt ,n on foot " ouat hin4 entlroly. Witch
'sla leave ERan mtst0r Of tho BtuatIou4
~ Doa1d OF Pubic Works sake great dsa
asMef, 10 :totpeAk, IN Mt. EgAn, Nv they 81,
NAsafy courteous and obliytuE,, mud IL oyef,
Res ttsad. 70 Who = thst t.s WQss.A 10 anything
hh power 10 lrlnE harmony aluut DO
WV hinaelf and Mr, Tilley.
- '4' mi. EutN. = - ,
" t.peN elevation plan, which hs' or
70 hA1nusuf!eIautlv oomplesad BY hatuf
skta Ftasaut - tho beard Ut Public Wpxka
sstRAa st!ekA ia Tho lsualbsaucn styla. 10
NmA sehooi which gives = wldo seopa 4
~ 1caltect, md had grand etaulplea which
NJ 70 copiud after eu1 uuMovel upon. IT.
,s1s sa mat It IL the school more capable Of dc
tpmtnt III pu1er at; and, therefore, NOR
stsAo3A .s'ts 10 t9s, daep- -atuaytng arobiteot that
tsssr. sst Classical Of any utler style Of siohi
wv. 4he new deslgp proposed IL
eAaosatB one nod after tts French Nelais