The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1875-01-28
reason for saying that the OF moral unanimty
has not been made out.


has not been made out.
In another letter written at The time he says
Another ground for receiving the dogma SIN not upon
anee Of the validity ofts act pcr /, the ccnsi.ratirn
s ns p"T srs c Sa Gou Ss 10 allow
sne,r Sis,e head and such large nnber o. bishop. to
ors leads me to accept The m a.
number OF bishops.
The next chapter ON
THE VATICAN DEFINITION
Is ratner 100 theological and technical IN ITS char
acter Tor popular reading. After repeating inc
usual Scrlptural arguments employed by Roman
Catholic divines In lavor OF the doctrine that the
Church Is inialliply secured from error he argues
that such as the inlalhbility OF the Church has
been SO Will IN iuture the lnlallibty Of the Pope
De. ne states A. length variety OF consldera-
tons by which this AVAILABILITY Ia limited and pro-
tected from aouse. For example, he says:-
ina And IN S manner rssards the
siS Of @ BE- Ss
rom tine Apostolic o, IN order taT
IN The Pope or council So too preeept OF morals.
a' ,Gs sast place sSsl'aoH nu,s RS e.
rSSs prescribed yisr Tsysass his eom%ana
n Sas no over nn mo NO aw he M M
nock to eat ythins but ysgeabe food 70 dres
not cNmn ns into the neso ne would in ike nancr
o!rssis . mater IN Itself good bad. Ii sayss
~ the h ws or Ge me
yery hard prcve that wasconradicus e mosai
sM or wa n sc sS here be are s
Sai are nal Il a sna in d"s
fal mater the Pope Is 70 be believed and obeyca low
for for the If. Of as @ in 70 S
sary one would ' so SPEAK Oh lotteries
nor Of particular dress, particular Kind food
external TO the range OF his prerogative.
CONCLUSIONS.
Or. Newman, In his concluding chapter, writes
The main point OF Mr. Gladstone's charge against is
tps IN @ se s o. acts
!uqs Of the Church BY the third aud ourth chaplsrs
scrion consider he sivcn no proof at az; and my
this ra s s %s
a%sF n"'s s II he but M % ds
prsrosaye S aahnry 'ss%a SaS hs'
laws command. measures Ms inaliIOiy bears rs
while fairly exercise the ,hsoloEiaS pho'oehsr
Moreover whe,her the rccosnon Of his ,naby IN
WIZ MS ACTUAL me lain Of
by the !, ,Sr these are s large md
this and therefore insists upon the Increase made by
no real % lie has for b SS
centuries had and ro used that authority which the
core the Council there was The rule o. an
there were exceptions 70 the rule; and since the toun
iS be Objected that r al suc
10 &C. $ ' N ne vasn
ara 40 ns Sees on a hy should Dc
reproach against by ali Protestans that The
asspS,iS assrSssivs papagy, in which ilsodo
Exist course Prince BsMarcs and oshc sSS'sng 10
'st oa rps rn
y Srsa pq S, more @ ss' upon sooy and
pproba,on Of The russian acts against eVa e one s
win" ars
name To-
The country put does any one sGpE";s that they
Vatican DEGREES and not rather rom ilv prestige
inst sin' %SS sp.
where and how have they sgni,cd that tiey can turn
& q eses Ssca sa I'D
q tine !; WI Oh /; h.,
has of MS na big ssrSe
bat OF The politicians Of the day DO not H, c"a
party %a osnae in iSci
S on %sS OF % @ ess IS
apn @ Mr. Gf a ys ina" It not the
ne. "jcsulSsS who are the "S;staisn, party, but
OF aa'ssG Ss ses aGe
%ns a nins O. Of whs been
%rap ess o axe III 9ns e woSd ns
be said mat he5s esnsierahls alharsngas
hSe s o Mr. a me s Ia" III M
with the evident thereby made manifest OF
Gahoss they ali OF way ~! Of ' iSnkn o.
While Pr0testanS all 1T variance Win each
and by that very variation OF opinion have no
ground of certainty scverally i'll their This is
snowy and servceable retor5 in controversy but Is
nothing more After ALL the field of religious thought
which the duty OF faith occupies Is small indeed, com
pared with that which i open TO though OF
course TO revcrent and conscientious speculation
draw from these remarks two conclusions FIRST. as
regards Protestants Mr. Gladstone should not. on the
one hand, deciaim against US ms having 'uicm ntal
freedom" II the periodical press. on the other
hand, Is TO mock admitting a liberty
OF private Judgment purely Protestant we
surely are not open to contradictory nnputations
Every note triumph the differences which marx
to Mr. Gladstone Is distinct ADMISSION thai
eaptives and slaves Of the rope secondly the bcne
tit OF some Catholics, would observe while az
knowledge one rope jure dirt,os ! ACKNOWLEDGES
comfortably dwet upon when individuals use Their
questions, not simply 'Ttnaaare Il, sensu" but
the purpose Of anathematisins the private judgmen OF
others
say there is only
ONE ORACLE GOD
the Holy Catholic Church. and the Pppe her head
10 her teaching have desired all my though ana
all my words to be contormed To her Judgment submit
what have now written, what have written. not
only as regards its truth, but as to lis fence. its
abcness ana Its expectancy. think have not pur-
sued any end of my own IN anythina thag have pub
Ii>hed but know well hat i'll matters not of faith
may have spoken when ought to have been silent.