, 1875-05-12
BEE CHER,
The Plaintiff Takes a Hand in
the Game Of Rcbutta1.
Dcnlals Being Trumps, Ho Plays
Them without Stint.
Contradictions at Wholesale Roll
from Tilton'a Lips.
Be.th.r, 0li7er Johnson, and Sam TilLtsen,
Come In for ! Share.
wood'ey, Tracy, Hrs. Palmer, and Bes.
.slo Turner, Incidentally
Sque1ched.
There Il Plenty More Of Perjury to Bo
Accounted for Somewhere,

Important Statement by Bowen
rs to the ,rripnrtite
Agreement.
NO.
7nrox UNEXPECTEDLY 7Es7,T1Ea 70 sorn1sa
UHE1TKC1ED.
5pt.fe' Dsratth to TIA tal+d7s Trfoane.
NEW York, Nay u.-CouHee1 for plaintiff yes
terd:y surprised almost every ono in tho court
room by esddun!y recalling Sir. T;lton to tho
witness-cLair. lIo WAS called by 31:. Morr..,
wlo turned to him af:cr Tho l,rief examination
Of aiite Mcdonald Was finished and said. In I
low voieo l.rt!ly audible beyond ths circ1o Of
cc:1nEcl'8 chair, " :.lr. TiI:on, ul you take the
ul!ne5G-ssenl?" l1r. Tilton aroHe, aud, walking
forward. Eas down in The w&nass-chair 30 quietly
that 1nEn: in the aud!oreo 1Tero nnararo that tLa
plaintiff hicaz:ll was upon the stand.
H1s 21A:;sEl.
1t nrat Mr Ti.on'a tca:iuouy WAS gren in :,
lor tone that it 1nust hayo been tuIuliblo IN
tho btck rarts OF tho room. Mr. 1lton appeared
very calm. tol gave hin whnle attention to tho
s1a.niu.::oa, leaning forward in hin clair, witt.
hin, iips half pErtol and his eyos 1i=e1 on Lii.
3Ior.is, lo seemed TO catch tho n:cn. Of tho
qu.Lttona before they woto uttered, and an1ncE-
ea vcry promptly, beginning to apca]s homttlmca
a'nloht bofo1o tho words OF the quca:ioua lad
laft ths ucs Of lie qucst:oner.
Hts ACo1EScE.
Tho members Of tho Plymouth delegation
smiled and whispered toEetler, snd in The long
pauacs Which frequently interyened betveen tho
questions mau7 III tlls sudlencs couro.scd in
lou tones, caa,!ng tde-glauces It the witueso.
atr. EeccAcz wau not prcseut, bet Mrs. Ieoclcr
MAS, acd Eha looked straight At Mr. Tilson With
4 EliGht ftorn uhi]o lo waa tostlfv!og. Several
jurors connutted together While tie examination
Of Mr. Tilton raa going on, and by uods and
eisnifcant glances indicated that their interest
vsa fully aroused.
"wELL VI" NJ TIE SCANDAL.
Iilton had l,tge package Of paFsrn aud lat
tern, from which ho readily aelested documents
which ho Nas asked to produce. uo seemed to
b. perfectly familiar NTH the testimony which
he was called to rebut and onco or tuico assiat-
el his counse! in finding tho particular pABxases
about which they decided to question lin.
When discussions between council wers going
on concerning tho admission Of Ills testimony
Oh certain points, Ar. Tilton 1istonel With fixed
attention, seeming to b. impatient to Join In
them himself, md to chafe undor tho gcst9an.
which tho Law put upon Lin utserancea.
EhE C0l4UNAp AEST4AEAAN HuUNOESCLp l. Il.
31r. Tllton began u long aoEiez OF DENNIS By
declaring that ho Ind not visited Ltrs. Woodruff
in Irving Place Is the colorad witness N'oodlny
lad asserted. Then lo said that he Lad noser
called Mrs. Woodruff "Yickoy" in his life, and
publishing the Cca1la1.
aha' rA11za trAsT. PRESENT, Ero''-A.2 ~ fa0-
SouSCEp L1AA. ~
l.J -. =.
by Hooa!oy. Mrs. palmer, ous OF tta defend
anita witnesses, had testified that in the esriy
part OF 1872 Mrs. Woodruff read portion Of
the proofs Of the acapdal article In tie pfesenco
Of herself and alr. Triton. This
Mr. Tilton denied, saying that q.
the date Unsigned by Mrs, Palmer for this
interview ho WAS absout in tho Northwest lectur-
Ing, Mr. Triton el,onel whcro 10 was In 1871
and 1872, prior to Nov. s, 1872. By rcadinE Along
lint Of plnces in various paris Of tho country
Uhcro ho Ind lecss1od during TINT time.
oEs. 111AcY PRONOUNCED LIAR.
He denied that 10 Lad had uhat IL known Al
tho "tsuc story" At tue Sunday evening inter-
yen At 1Ir. Moultou:s houso When ur. TRACY.
Mr. Muulton, aud himself were present, Th.t
document had not boon written theu. He nlsa
contradictcd Gen. TrscY's statement that, It that
Of tho manuscript which Le had brought viii,
hiaa, and had begun to road ths statement. u
several o!hez particulars tbs witness contra
dlcted tbs testimony Of Gen. Tracy, a. vol a.
| the evidence Of various other xi.neasos for ths
/ defendant.
M1ss xEss11 TuANEa PRONOUNCED LIAR.
! Tho llvetiest intoroat waa shown by tho au-
diencs In tho plaintiffs ntatsuautu In regard to
| tho sccne at his house, when Mi,e Eessio Turner
assertol that aho had l,een kuockeu doNn by alr.
! Illsou. In very decided manner tho wisnosa
denied that any zach Ecoua had over tako,'
| place. uo wa1 asked II Lo hEd nad0 certain
statements to Eesslo Tasrer-among othors thai
| It wua no wonder bis gray lh!rs were golng down
in sorrow to tho graye. Did you aty that ? u
asked Mr. Morris. mo- sir" replied Iii. Til
| tou, and then added, without smiling, tn 4 Ion
tono, ~ had no gray hairs At tLat tinao." Ms
1il,on ven: On denying statement aftsE stato
mept OF M.5a Turner M tAoT wesa road to hin
from her testimony by l1r. Norris. These 10,
nInls, which woEo listened to In perfect silence
| by tho audience, xcro made without hesitation
! "a promptly ~ tho questions weEo put. Mr
| Tilkou stated that ussaie Turner WIG absent it
KeYpost dur,pg tho Hllolo tirao af Nr. Greeley.
atay At lid louso In 1860.
Mn, pYccHIa s'orF" ON THAT sLoBnxn1xa scrxE
Mr, Tilton denied tlat tic tntosvtow lad takez
place. which VAS spoken Of by Mz. Doccher 4,
occurring In 1871. when tho defendant said thai
lo u. on Mr. Tilton's kaees. and thRt'ho ant
| .l.s. Illton Kissed ono auothcr. Als. 1iltos
said. however, that ho remembered scens soluc'
what similar, which had occurred hbons ter
ycars axo, md which had reference to Ano!Ao!
matter.
o7uGn ALLEGED DIsclErAHcll1,.
31r. Tilton further denied that hs laa ssal tt
alr. Dccches from Nip OF pala1t tho statomou
Of Its ~ifs concerning improper advances mad;
to her by Mr. Dcecher. lilo said tbat DO la&
read . very uiGereot paper to Mr. Becaher. III
lkowse denlod that aaything hAd been said a'
the tins Of tho arbitration in his presence about
burning papczs. Mr. WlkssoR hsd nos sug'