New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-06-22

was Mr. Bcecher from O'Clock until the peTlou' "V
ever it was that he went over to The ChrSta" Onlo"
Office on his way to Peekskill do not stop 10 cohsluer
AT any length the question to the time exhausted In
this interview with Mrs. Mout0n. She thinks IL con-
tnued until her lunch time, at IL, or l. OF ocloch
whenever 1t was She speaks of those hours ana Is OF 'he
impression that it o'clock, but speaks OF IL WIN no
confidence as being that hour exactly she says about
Mr Eyarts here spoke to Mr. Beach IN an uhuertone
ALLEGED AVAILABLE TESTIMONY NOT
PRODUCED.
Mr.. Beach, say she does not speak with any
confidence or attempt at accuracy as to that hour ana
read her evidence with reference TO That point
will listen to any reading of the evidence which may
correct me- but not assertion attach no Sig
nifcance whatever to that An interview OF two hours
under such circumstances. involving such intense in
terests mi ht well been enlarged by Mrs MoutOn
to three four hours, and she might nave very wen
imagined when Mr. Beecher got up to leave under those
circumstances that tho hour of lunch had come, ana
ask him to stay and take lunch There were
no indications OF 1t, as she says, anu
there was no truth in the lunch; it is a
mere impression the continuance OF an absorbing
communication which left its distressing marks upon her
apoearance as is proven by other evidence. But the
aueson returns Where Mr. Bcccher between and
IL or between IL and IL o'clock He says that one hour
at least of that exhausted in company with MI Kin
sella Where is Mr. Kinsela 7 Mrs M0ult0n ana MI
| upon that one point to the whereabouts OF MI
Reecber between and 10 or IL o'clock. Mr.. Beecher
savs he WAS at home in consultation with Mr. kinsela
Mrs says she in her paror under the cir
cumsances she describes. Mr. kinsea Is IN TINS clty
the editor of partisan journal in favor OF Mr. Beecher
though conducting it with great proprey, ana
against him his have no complaint
| TO make; but he was accessible wit
ness the friend Of Mr. Beecher, competent reliable.
| and trusty gentleman whose appearance upon that
| stand by his oath confirming the evidence OF Henry
Ward Beecher would have been destructive OF the prOp0
siton that Mr. Beecher at Mrs Moultons on the I'd
Of June 1873 He is in this city, repeat accessible to
his friend Mr. Beecher He is not produced witness.
And do you remember the presumption Of law as read
1t to you the other daya The presumption is as against
Mr. Beecher when this issue is fairly made between him
and Mrs Mouton, and he has friendly and trusty wit
ness by whom he prove his ab and tails to produce
him. that if produced he would not confirm his theory
| Ii is the judgment OF common sense Ii Mr. Kin
sea would have supported Mr. Beecher and cOntrdcted
Mrs Moulton, supposes for moment that the
counsel of Mr. Beecher would have failed to produce him.
And what Sir docs my learned and distinguished adyer
sary Mr. Evarts dol Instead of producing Mr. kinsea
he prouces his paper and ventures TO read portion OF
his editorial as proof that Mr.. kinsella was with Mr.
Beecher As my friends know, evidence III this case
"a nv friends know, no proof of any statement which
! NAV be contained in it, and we have the argument
against them only that they suppress evidence, mt
that a learned counselor against his duty and bis right
ATTEMPTS to substitute editorial written by Mr. Kin
| sella or somebody else, We don't know who, for
| the evidence which he ought TO have presented.
| Now, what says Mr. James on this subjecta
Did Won see Mr. Beeohcr the ID of June, 1872 A.
IrecOllect that dld. . a.
he was about stepping from little bridge crossing te
rOadway-carIiage roadway. which leads down 10 wall
O. From which direction was he comngi A. From The
| direction of Columbia flights.
n u1,or &c Nvb. Mr. A
a. No 1o4 Columbia Highss The residence has been
And when he passed the bridge which direction did
he take a. He took the direction leading toward Rem
@ Monta gueterracel A. Yes, Sir crossing Montague
O. Did you see HIN turn in Remsenst. A. He turned
o. And taat is toward Mr. Moultons house A. Yes,
q. Toward GO Remsen-st.i A. 40 Remsen-st.
O 40 should say. Now, about what hour In ihenorn-
ins was thati A. As accurately fix it, it was
shortly before o'clock think not after 1 tha,
ST. where you saw him t'unY
MI Beach-FrOnl that corner.
Mr. MOrris-FrOIn that corner. .
The Witness-I am unable to fix it accurately, but
should think few houses-fotr or i've houses
O. In that block A. Yes, Sir; it is in that first block,
@ From 124 Columbia flights TO Mr. Moulton's resi-
dcco that would be the most direct routeto go wouldn't
itl A. / should Judge 50.
O. Abont how far is 1914 Columbia flights from Mr..
Moulton'sl A. 1 very seldom pass through Columbia
Nights and l unable 10 say, SIR should think 1t
would be about ten minutes Walk, IL YOU Jill SucoS
Mr Beach-WeT, get It by somebody else.
MIR MOrriS-Nos; viii got that by some person WHO
knows better than you. Now lnen, stat me clIcn-
HAT morning thai impressc1t upon NOur nindi ~ In
order TO ca lain that snail have to explain my state OF
O. wen, explain that. A. Continuing When
started ont OF the house. Tho ri OF June IS very
pleasant anniversary 10 me. Ny custom Is always, If
possible, when business permits, TO make sen-hOlday
OF IT, on that occasion wasfet obliged TO 90 10
New York at earlier hour than usual; usually
H.. 4 -NlFk IA a.
ten bat tA1t uO.nins-Lfter few days about that
fine WAS OBLIGED 10 20 earlier, ana LETT the house WIN
the intention OF rcurlns possible earlier than usual,
aud king sort OF holiday OF H. and WIN yeFyLln
worry pleasant mood OF mind. On seeing hr Bsecher
rat ,nizel him al once, ana, perhaps egDtstlcaly,
tho ~, that he would recognize M when we met as we
did very nearly. Iut came nearer TO nun saw his
count nance la licate a a person who was troubled.
MI Esdrts-Weii II Is no mdVtcr ABOUT INC lnuca'On
II bis cDuntrnahce.
Mr. Beach 1T il some matter 20 us.
T1e Witnsss-His head was cast down. He appeared
to be IN trOlbe aud produced cht1gt OF my state or
mini that fixed itself upon my memory, ana up0n re-
turning nome at night repeated the incident 10 my Wie
O. AMI now near were yOI to Mr. Beecher-hOS near
dii yOa pass by hm A. should think nearer, or as
near rs am 10 him now. 49, So
recognize me- 1 don't think from his appearance he
would have recognized any one.
THAI Is struck QUIZ NOw, thai is the substance OF Mr..
Janes's testimony.
Jadse Nelson 10 Mr. Beacll-Can you suspend now,
srl
Mr. Beach-Yes, your Honor; had no idea 1t was
o'clock.
The Court then toox until y. Ia.
THE AFTERNOON SESSION.
The Court met at 2 o'clock, pursuant to adj
Journment.
Mr. Beach-Oi course 1t Is possible that any gentlemen