New-York tribune., 1875-03-09

over here.
Mr. Fueron-when did she hear of this scandal was
question: and she heard first at the time
OF the Woodruff scandal
The WitnesstTo Mr. Fulerton1 DO you mean Is THAI the
first time ever heard anyth hing about t'
O. When did you first hear Of publicly! A. heard 1t aier
the Victoria Woodruff scandal was published
@ Privately had you heard is before thal heard ru'
mors Of 1t.
@ How long before that A. had heard rumors o-not
exactly that scandal but had heard rumors OF dicnJ
had heard II, could not
O. When did YOU first hear rumors OF dilculty' A. hst
heard OF the difficulty when Mrs Tton visited me in 1870. in
October.
Q, In October, 1870, then, waslt' A. Yes Sir.
q Well Madam had you much feeling upon the subjecg
Mr. EyasYou ask her II she had much feeling on the sub
Mr. Fulerton-Yes.
The Wnoss-What was your question.
O. Did you much feeling subjec' A. felt ~
VICE great outrage.
THE WITNESS ANGRY AT DR.. sTORR's ATTITUDE
TOWARDS THE SCANDAL.
O. DR.. Storrs was your pastor, you say, when you
were here A. Yes Sir.
@ Have you called upon him since you have been here this
timer A. / have not.
q. Been here eight weeks A. have.
O. Did yon find any fault with Dr. Storrs for anything
he did In connection with this matter! A. don't know ex
actly what you mean by finding fault.
@, Well Madam, are an intelligent educated lady and
understand the Of the term presume, as well as DO! a.
have conyersed with my family and friends.
@ don't want you TO give your conversations with your
family friends Have you felt angry with Dr. Sorrs! a
No Sir; have not felt angry with DR.. Storrs
@ Never felt angry with him' a. never felt angry Win
DR.. Sorrs.
O. Didn't you express anger at the time this Council was
called, A. No Sir; never expressed anger.
O. Yoa had considerable feeling did you, about it! Yes.
Sir did.
O AoInst DR. storrsg A. No Sir had no feeling against
Dr. stos but had good deal Of feeling about the matter
O am not asking you about that Didn't you think Dr.
sorrs was wrong participating in whatever resulted In
calling the Council A. thought Dr. Storrs was mistaken
and unwse.
O. No. am not talking about his unwisdom am talking
about your angcr9 A. angry with Dr. SorrS ID my
life.
O. Never expressed anger with Dr. storrs? A Never ex
pressed anger with DR.. Stcrrs.
Handing letter to w.tness Perhaps that letter will refresh
YOUR recollection Mrs PunamH A. that say here
was angry with the two churches
Mr. Eyats-No matter. unless he asks you what you see.
The Wtncss-But don't remember
Mr. Fuleron-Do you say you were angry WIN the TWO
chnrchesg A. suppose 1t extrayasant womans ex'
preston was never conscious OF any error
O. However extrayagaE may be, ask you you say In
that letter you angry with the two churchesf A seems
| said ~, but -
A. ~
didn't see it heEe.
COUNSEL. AGAIN GIVING AND TAKING.
Mr. Evarts-WelL
Mr. Fulerton-Wol.
Mr. Evarts-We have right look at the paper concerning
which you are asking the witness, and to read it.
Mr. Fucrton-And you may have time to read ii after put
it into the case
Mr. EysIts-You can put into the after get through
with it.
Mr. Fullerton have the physical power to keepis
Mr. Eyarts-I have a right to read 1t first.
Mr. Fullerton-No you have 1t is violation Of Ell
Quette and prOproty, and don't hesitate 10 say so'
Mr. Ey4rts-Iou c4n now proceed
Mr. Tuleron-And proceed because your permission Is
given ITO the witness Look at that letter again and see
whether you express anger at the two churches.
Mr. Eyarts-Wat Do you wish to oler the letter
in evidence ?
Mr. Ful!erton-When do viii make 1t known without
being nterrosatcd bu; wish answer to the question
Mr. Eyas-The of the letter you cannot give with
ont reading the letter
Mr Beah-The question is whether she expressed anger
Mr.. Eyarts-We have a right, after showing her this
letter, now to ask her what her recollection Is as
to her having felt expressed anger towards Dr. storrs
which your question before You never IAeu hef
whether she was angry at the two churches.
Mr. Fulerton-No because | know she never expressed
ANGER at the two churches asked her she expressed anger
at Dr. stor and her reply expressed anger at the two
churches her TO look ct the letter to see whether
she is mistaken or not.
Mr. EyartsThe counsel has right after exhibiting the et-
ter or memorandum to ask the witness thus refreshed what
her present having expressed 10 and
NJ Fucrton-Is that letter in your handwritng' A. Yes
Sir, it il.
Mr. Fueron-Then will read tho letter. propose 1t shall
speak for itself.
Mr. Eyarts-Now how is the letter evidence,
Mr. Fuleron-Afer having read it you ought to know as
well as do.
Mr. Eva5s-I was In a hurry
Mr. Fueron-No you took your time and handed it back
to me whenever it pleased you.
Mr. Eyar,s-I wish ~ understand what the evidence Is Oh
which ii is offered
Judge Ncson-lTo Mr. Fulertonl How is the letter ma
toriall
Mr. FuIeron-In contradiction Of her. Sir.
judge NelsOn-Wen.
Mr. Eyarts-We don't that is necessarily contradic
tory not contradiction that know Of Who was the
letter to?
Mr. Fulerto1-[To Judge Nesonl What does your Honor
decide as to the admissiblity OF the letter'
judge Neon-The learned counsel has asked you whom It
Is addressed to-
Mr. Fueron-Uc has read the letter. and ought to know az
wclasL
MIR Evarts-No, ought not
Judge Ncison-I You it to contradict the witness,
think you can it for that purpose.
Mr. Fuerton-Ycs Sir, think so.
Mr. Eyarts-f your Honor please it depends upon what the
witness has stated. memorandum may be handed to
witness whether In tho form Of letter anything ese in his
handwriting, aud after that the witness bc asked
whether or she has expressed the sentiments concerning
which she had previously been inquired Of and about which
she had made a certain
Judge Nelson-Yes Sir.
THE WITNESS CONTRADICTED.
Mr. Evarts-Now, that is all. l have not under
stood this witness after this statement after the exhibition Of
this memorandum have made any that this
randum will contradict
Judge Neilson- don't what the memorandum will do