New-York tribune., 1875-01-15
uch case but has he no, proved himself capable Of

him towards me OF course can speak with her
again. except with his permission and 40 no 10 SnS% % ;as s eTe @
sympahy Of her nature him. and to sec him once more
ss her and 0.% sn thoughts e'Y is there sS way out Of this
niyht May day star arise
i'"' w. csispedl HENRY WARD BEzCHER.
1etter marked Exhibit No. 10Y
You have also spoken Of letter written on that day
by Mr. Ieecher Mrs. Ton Ilandng letter to witness
Look at the paper handed you and say whether that is
NE letter that that day that LADY, A. That is
the letter
@. That is the one you ssyi A. That is the one.
FulcronI put evidence the letter Of February from
Mr Beecher o Mrs Tlton:
BROOKLYN, February T. 1871.
nv DEAR Mrs TnToN When you last did not expecs
70 me than wrs INV own houehts The friend God zen;
% (Mr. Moulton) has proved above all rehds una Of
my HE m ham, was tit tied up The that was TPsGy
burst upon head am not the less c and iendcry
At heart; You have no friend Theodore excePeal VINO
so ss s Z do in sO si p much lcscy honor Of
Sou, my wishes have ye. any nee % & e. my my @ Seat
ooa 10 Nouon an unfegned respect ana honor Tor
rue resd 20 your honor and happnes as brother could be
TO sisters In him we have common ground You and may
%S @scs x hgheT Boer faSrc May not this friend stand
pnc, in the new sanctuary Of reconciliation and mediate
and bless yOu Theodore and my most unhappy self do not
e my earnest ess fail OF IT, end yon believe IN my Judgment
there you = is is with Theodores consent
but he has not read it, va y rsiu 70 by his ha"dsr
very in this wish for all sakes such letter
ough, not to subject chance Of mcarriage.
Your unhappy friend, - - ,
@ what said anything, to you with reference to
permission to write that etterS A. Mr. Beecher wanted me TO
get Theodore's permission to write it.
@ And did your A. l did, yes Sir
q Aud when you conveyed to Mr. Bcecher the knowledge
that Tn odoe had consented what was said between you
A. He said he would wte the letter.
q How did get into your possession 1t got there' A.
was sent 10 me by Mr. Beoche delivered personally by
Mr. Bcccher don't remember Do you mean at first now od
1t get into my hands, or how lastf
@ How first you have answered. A. 1es Sr; certainly
O Now Mr. Mouon, prior to that time, had anything been
said about any between Mr. Bcechcr and Mr. Tton
or Mrs Tion and to be brought about, at all'
A. Oh yes, Sir
@ State, if you please, what that was' A. SIR
Q What arrangement made with Mr. Beecher, il any,
upon subec A. The arrangement between Mr. Beecher
myself this that there TO be no interchange
Mr. Eyarts-Stae what took place
Nj Fulcrton-Yes state what took place.
The witness-Itod Mr. Beecher that thought he had bet
hold any correspondence with Mrs TIon without
Theodore consent and said he thought that would be
right That Is what there about that
Q When was that arrangement made? A. Sometime an
terror February 7th in the early part of the controversy
O. asked you how you obtained that leer-frOm whom
How afterwards in your possession A 1t was re-
turned by Theodore Tilton to me.
@ Do you know whether Mrs Tilton received it ? A.
don't know Theodore Ton said he delivered it to her
@ What did you do with the letter : a. gave it to Theo-
dore Til on.
O. For delivery A. For delivery.
Mr.. Eyarts-lt OPEN supposed
Mr. Fuleron-Sealedf
The Witness-It was open letter.
Gctcr marked Exhibit No. ~
@ am requested ask you when Mr. Tlton returned to
you the letter addressed by Mr. Beecher to Mrs TntOn A
Shortly after the date OF ii.
O. Handing letter to wituessl Look the paper now
shown YOU and say from whom you received it A From Mr.
Bcecher.
q When A. After my return from the-afer April the
18th time think that the date returned from the
South Itwas after my return.
You may when you left for the South and when you
returned from the South A. think the date Of my departure
March 3D. 1871, and returned April 18TH
q During that period where you A In Florida and
Georgia generally South
@ How long after your that this letter now in
your hand given you by Mr. Bcecher A Not very long
don't remember the date.
q What did he state when he gave it to you A lie said he
lad received 1t from Elizabeth.
q Did you make any observation at the time A. No,
don't remember that did think made observation
this that Of good faith his part give to me-
Mr. Fulleuon-I offer the letter in evidence
THE clANDEsTrSE LETTERS
Weiaesday-MY DEAR FRIEND Does your heart bound
fo,cards al a used So does mine am myself again
did not dare to tell you until but the bird has sung
never sgin 70 leave spring has come" Because thought
would gladden. you 10 know this and not 10 trouble or
Ike 70 YOU my JOY wait for the BeyondI
When dear Frank says may once again 80 TO old Plymouth,
Ivy! t6gnk the dear Father
Mr. Eyarts-T There is no date to that letter,
Mr. Fulerion-There is no date to it,
Mr. Fulei ton-In whose handwriting s that letteri A.
Elizabeth Tnton's
@ And do you observe there words the head Of IT,
"Receiycd March 9Th ?" A. Yes, Sir.
O In whose handwriting is thatS A. Mr.. Beecher's.
he Lotto yVhp hp hand Tn Won A
Yes Sir.
Mr. Eyarts-Is the letter signedi
Mr. Fuerton-Thc letter is not signed.
Mr. RysrsI your Honor please all these letters that
have seenare obviously letters that contained envelopes
can see by shape that they complete sheets
that were folded and addressed envelopes have
been introduced call attention to IT, and Of course would
ike to have the envelopes,
Mr. Morhs-We have them.
Mr. Eyarts-We we would like to have them.
Mr. Fullerton handing envelope wnessl-Look at the
envelope now show YOU say whose hand the super
ecripou is : A. In Mr.. Beecher's.
O Handing letter to witnessl-Look at the letter
SHOW you and say in whose handwriting it isl A. Mr..
Beechers
Mr. Fulerton-I offer this in evidence read the letter
Mr. Hvartswe understand this letter Is offered 10 be
read as having been enclosed in that envelope.
Mr. Fuerton offer it having been enclosed in that
envelope now have proved the envelope to be in the
writing Of MI Deecher aud have proved the to be In
his handwriting also.
Judge NesonYou didn't inerrogate him as to the connec-
tion OF the two papers.
Mr. Fulerton-No, sir; because he does not know.
M BvsrsI asked for envelopes that accompanied the let
ters to parties and want the envelopes and the letters
go together.
Mr Whenever the time for me TO prove
that sent in that envelope shall do do
It with the present witness
Mr. Evarts-You proposed IT,