, 1875-06-08
the hnbband with an alleged adultorosa, after
tho alleged diacovciy Of tho crime, were auch "A

1SFAL&uAIk lHf tHtultf
lic said that to believe The c!nrgo Of a1ultoFy
vas true In thh case. iu Wow OF tue inferuourto
between tho parties after tho chatgo was sastl to
have been brought. Fss to believe fhat deecncy
gland II That ii. .hc<o people lad gono mad.
Mr. EyartA apo.o Vt the OCCASION un which sfr.
1'cccEnr kissed Tll:on. wbtca was admitted by
The latter. rase that Titnn said tie kissing oas
lono on tho forehead. Well II 1t Was. Daecnrr
rnuht taro got upon char III 1ilton mn.t havo
YIELDED lInlaol! 10 TIM embrace. [LauRltos.j
Moulson told Mr. Halliday that II lo tl.onR.t
Deecner bud man t,o would no: let lim nit ut
Mrs. slou3ton id iii !,lsT that l;,.eiler
HAD nHEx uEn lAsTan ruoM ofnt.ttaoD,
and that no ons coatd mako her belio.e cyii Of
linn. Halliday teaunel that when Mta. Moul.
tou attended, church. hho always went aftor tho
tersicn to thu pulpit Hlaira, in order to gst u
v0td from Deccher. and 10 mako nnndB with
him. Tho portrait of Beech +, whicb vas taken
70 Noulton's hou4s In ths f.ll Of $50. ronatued
hanging N tho pnrur Until sorno limo last year.
wiloa 1t wan folnogo1 to ono OF tlls bedrooms.
Thoro woso those facts Of tho conduat Which tl,e
Jury wanted to know AZ uetcrHliun9 tho aoi,ti-
meus snd feohnas Of pars'cs..
Mr. Evats than apoko Of tho echemo Of
FranH Carpenter to hare is2ocher aud TiIton
co-cditofs ou newspaper. au'i of THO opon ao~
tiyfty Of 1ilton tn bringing himBslf into ro1A-
tloaa witt, tho defendant.
The counael next referred 10 tho occasion on
1hlcl
| Mns. 7tL7ox AsKEp Mr.. nEycHER FOR coussrL.
tn har domeslic difficulties and Oh winch he
| ua'krd u passage iu tho D!blo. liz was de-
termtnel then lls would fulufsh no ground for
the charge q Interference aud he A'taply refer
rod Ier 10 tAs passage Of Scripture beginning
"Claltty BuGeEeth long"
slr. Evartu shoa tpoko Of tho publication Of
Mrs. Wooahul.'a carl. saying lAas tho evidence
plainly shoned tLat II WAS promeled by Tiltou
! hlmreti. The tchndsl proper was not mAds pub
llc until November. 1872, but this cara was pub
lt+hod Oh tic I'd Ut May. 1871. At the very time
when peacs appeared to bava beou rest1red be-
tween all the parties. lilo couatured The EAe-
| cnkoEoi iMto relations with MrA. Woolau, both
d,a:aBkofu! and disagroeaalo to Themselves.
| IN oRnEh TO CoScttIATE HER TO sILESCE.
Nov tho ecandst article Of November, 1875 70.
! which only tho parties Themselves had bccn
s1ou that Mrs. Wooihull's knoelsdgs Of ths
HITTER bad peeu ncfcasrd during his lutoeconrse
With llur, ilE. Tilton testified that suc had told
him al these iac:s at their h'st interview i'll
May, 1911. 10 hIa great assonlBGmeut. CunniMg
&r TlItoD hu WAS asked II ho Thought Dsecil.r
Or atoulton had told her. aud ho thought not.
come through Alsa. Morse. Whenever any
trouble eano np. Winch 1t!ton could not cou-
| venieutly attribute to anybody o!sc, ho laid II
upon poor Mis-: Morso tLutghIcr.I He was
asked II s'o considered i proper to communicates
tacso EEisntc couu'c!a to thtrl person When Le
starred with proposition Of absolute secrecy,
aud lls admitted that 10
| TOLD THEN 70 NILS MORSE.
Ti.on said that 1t aau from hor Open mouth that
tnese sectesH came forth, aud wero carried to
Mta. Woodhull. lfo MAJ Asaed II be aid not
know Mrs. Mor*e's ini1stuity whom ho told her,
anu he wRa obliged to admit ho did. BIT tin
enottn'ty Of thIs WAS too much for plaintiffs
caso, aud tue next morning TlIton mado = cor
rcctlop, FayIog Tint lie noser told Mrs. 3torso
about tho proceedings aftcf December, 1870. So
he could not have tod any OF the evtn:s 10 jan
uAry With which atrB. Woodruff showed such
familiar knowledge. Hero MS
| MEMORY wI1eM CAME AND WENT
like the complexion Of tho Indy In tho School
for Scandal" and wLicl. tho necessities Of coua-
sol could g fetch and carry"
The testimony Of hr. Andrews ehowod that
| Tltou wns introduced to Mia Woodruff early in
Mag. 1871, and there Sas plenty Of tina for him
to communicate these lLota to her before tho
publication of May -. lhs waa the lra. o4eu
tlEeat Of mating tho scauda! pubic.
1lr. Eyarts than road from the card OF Airs.
Pauline Wright Dav!s, and letter OF strs. S.au-
ton. init oduced III evidence to et1ov that they
tienied Over communicating anything to Mrs.
Noodhutl which could servo as basis for tito
tLeso aoleB' mouths, as be hnd shu. Mira M1orse's
car, Leaving Mr. Wlton AZ tile ouly source Of
Airs. Woodhull's information.
Rscess.
| nEEcnEn's FRIENDS.
Mr. Deecher was sutaounded by rotations this
morning, tha family party Including bin alhters.
| Mrs. Harriet Ueacuer Stove, Mrs. Perkins, aud
3Ilaa Catherine Deechsr.
!, After tlo seccAs. Judge Nelson announced
that ~; Beach had case in auotueE couz., and
wialed lii. Evatts to proceed without Lin.
| NR. EvAETs CONTINUED u1s ADDRESS
to tho jury, and sad they must bear in mind that
ang ef!art to suppress the scandal did NOT imply
fanlI on The part 81 any one. Who was not anx-
could II bo moro des4taple to suppreBs it
thau in tho QUO involving thsse parties
But tho couEse Of Mr. beocucr in this
matter. tnttsed Of indicating guilt on h't
| cenco. Lie considered the tLeory advanced by
a1s. Tlton to explain tho known faclB Of his con
uecl,on with Mrs. woodhull. The dofetso had
proeed thin intimacy, which plaintiff protonded
shown that it resulted from Al, enthusiasm for
! Mrs. Woodhutt'a opinions, and 40 iuSatuhtlon
| with tic clnrms Of tor society aud OF hor per-
sou. THIS lsdy rosuaiueda =
| vEiLRD FAlEarzss
| to our mortal glzo until tho cloatug days Of tllo
Testimony, but thers wAs no dAugar Of her beiug
| lninconstsued or misunderstood. Sho had vida
| public reputation. and 10 shodl uot DISCUSS It
ost Ill., Il ts9o 1t,, Of H.. the ddssasy Aa seass
courtroom in regard to the custody o! private
| letters bad boea possessed by tho modern B.r
phllIp bvdnos. theso would uarer have boom \
trial OF this cause.
alr. Evarts quoted other parts Of tho testi-
mony, ~ showing the Intimate aud atfes.ionato
relations between pI.iut,a and Mrs. Woo1nu,I
lo argued that al tho facts which MEs. Wood
hull published in regard to what took place in
the private rooms Of Sir. Moulton's ind Mr.
Boechef's houaes, after tho end Of Decc1nber,
1d7U, mist have Loeu derived from Tli.ou inn.
self. Mr. EyAEty said "t1o policy of slIeuce,"
OF nhlch Tilton'B rotations with Mrs. Woolhull
wero pretended TO have been a purt, Was OF 10
vAIuo ~ al element In this csso except
20 ths as 1t was represented 10 bs IN ar
gameptatiys conGessioo Of guilt On the part
Ut 1lr. Deecher. but the Testimony showed
that this policy was not Of Mr. Doeoher's adop-
llon, but WAS originated By thaSe who foArod lis
ffhnkncss aud boldaess. Tho point w1tl. Tt1ton
waa lhst he waa Eutued. and that ANY public
knowledge OF = breAk in his domestic AtY4ira,
eucA a. tna lght Of his wifs, would DO the TN
ishing blow to hla reputation. Lie urged Mr.
ueecher 10
LOCK- THE sEcnEr IN HIS nnAAsr,
avoiding dlscussluu Of tho ir1uhln o1en With
Mrs. DeocAoE, aud then they engineered these
elaborsta scnernes Of nuppsedslnR the scADlal
III order to deceive lin. while they themselves
weso arranging tor it, PRONUNCIATION. lIo por-