New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-04-24

M Morris-Bstssr rcd 10 IN sranalsssoa.
Mr. Rvarta-Hls Honor doubtless does. II shers y my
one that docs not understand he esn raise HE hand
Mr. Pryor. an willing that ny classical friend, Mr.
Evsrs should interpret II; win accept hi rendsrfns
Mr. Evarts-No, you may give the direct reading and
viii orossexamine you upon r. tLaughterJ
Mr.. Pryor lrcsdngl; po.rox 1874
To Fl. ". BErcHra, Tcin Mountain Houss, N. H.
Ves, ceni ct sf0tim. W noHans pohS
Licef n,agnuw perieuiu1s aeersi. .....,...
guam icneo diem s.wm solam We ~e fTas6ss 'se d.o'
MARRIED Exhibit l24l
The English Of 1t, believe, We are agreed, 10:
Come come, and in the name Of the Father 70
have iaborsd for srse year. might obtain y an
thorty which hold for day only. Do not frusuats
me by your doubts, or suspicious perhaps -,
Mr. Evarts-" Duo;sstione fyour Honor please means
"dubiafon" naturally, hesitation, uncertainty, or
doubt
Mr.. Beaeh-Both doubt and hesitation.
Mr.. Evarts-Doubtng or hesitation, suppose We
have an English word "duDitstion" that comes pretty
near "dubitanoae."
Mr.. Morris-(Readlng:
To JAMES RrDpArH, slobe 0rics
Cleveland win come with full documentary power TO act
leave before Monday, 4 at all Hws
Marked Exhibit 1851
TWIN MOUNTAIN HOUSE, Sept 3.
cannot come Meet Cleveland on Friday at Lowell
He leaves on $50 tomorrow. u. " B.
Marked Exhibit 1875
TWIN MOUNT Mn Housr, Sept T.
JAMES REDpAIH fremont Ho,lse: MI, o.,
him at fremont, but send messenger TO Revere House
Married Exhibit I27 II.
TWIN MOUNTAIN HOUSE. Sept. L.
Cleveland left Twin Mountain House at $50 this morn
ing and will meet you Lowell depot al go ths ttr
dayl Aftermath Ia that plaipf H.wB
Marked Exhibit 1881
Now we win have these marked
Mr. Besch-well, they can be marked hereafter.
Mr.. Morris-You, I think, said yesterday, Mr. CIrve-
land that You that telegram before you len the
Twin Mountain Housed A. did not so testify,
think
Q. I 40 understood you.
Mr. Evarts-whch Is That's
The wtness-I did not, think do mott knew OF the
kilograms. could not that read one or Them
Mr. Beecher told abOnt them, and possibly read them
70 me / 10 not recall that.
Mr. MoIis-And when did he read the kilograms tn yon
or give You the substance Of them A. II you will allow
me TO explain that
O. How long before you left the Twin Mountain Housc
A. A word OF explanation, II you will Srecpt il.
O. No, am only asking the time simply. A. re-
turned from Mount Washington on Thursday evening" IN
the evening Mr. Beecher said he had had dispatch from
Mr. Redpath to 20 TO Boston. said, Are you goiDgf"
O. Well now / sm not asking for that. A. thought
You asked for
O. Now am asking FOR The time when you became
aware A. In the evening OF Thursday, the 30,
think.
O And YOU did not leave until the next dayi A. left
the next morning.
O. At what time In the morning $50 as stated heref
4. could not have told Sir; that IS
O. Well $50, it says here. You say that when yon
Tod Mr. plari ne
NO Of course mott" A. That is hat he said.
@ Wa peremptory about i'll A. Peremptory.
O. Well had he spoken to yon about this dispatch ia
which he says he cannot leave. at is impossible for me
to leave before Monday, il at all % A. He had not.
Nj Evarts-what is the date " tbatf
Mr. MorTis-sept ,.
Mr. shearnan-Mr Cleveland ought 70 see the dispatc
before he
The witness could not tell anything about that !
think nv irsthe arst statement OF Mr. Beccher TO
was that he had dispatch from Mr. Redpath.
O. That was Thursday, the %, wasn't III could not
i have recollection.
@ You left on Friday A. left on Friday.
O. That was the AM A have no recollection Of see
Ing dispatch when he stated to that he had had one
from Mr. Redpath.
O And when was II suggested that you should go 10
Boston A. Friday morning.
O. How long before you left A. An hour, or an hour
and half.
-.
House on Friday When you went there Thursday A.
was including 10 leave on Saturday or Monday.
O. On Saturday OF Mondays A. Yes hid not de-
termned which.
o And what induced the change OF your purpose' A
The request Of Nj Beecer 70 stop in Boston and see
what this
O Well but Won could have stopped there Monday
or saturda, "a well couln's you A. hadn't the time,
Sir; my plan was To-
NJ Eyarts-Mr. Cleveland. vou were hah through an
answer: will you he 50 good 10 complete II.
MIR Morris-He was through all want OF il.
Mr. Evarts-I know that
Mr.. Morrs-It was an answer 10 my question
M Evarts-But there Is no right 10 stop IT,
Mr. Norris say there is. When witness hss an
swcrcd question: and then is going Oh 20 state some
thing else beyond that 1t Is proper for counsel 10 stop
him.
Mr. Fvars-You ask another question, and II stops an
answer and then witness is reported as making half
snswArs.
Judge Seson-The witness must be allowed to answer,
Of course.
Mr. Evarts-I did not observe your Honors remark
Judge NeTson-Of course. he must be allowed, and
then IL II ia a wrong answer, Il may be struck out.
Mr. Beach-If your Honor please, do not assent TO
that rule OF examination.
Judge Neison-Weu. we don't take 1t as rule-t Is
suggestion; aud may often be proper suggestion aud
the proper rule. but not always Of course
Mr.. Beach-Certanly. But submit 10 your Honor
that t Is the province only Of counsel but II s the
duty OF the Court when witness has fully answered
question: and proceeding to state mmatera and irrei
evant matter stop him u is not bound TO be received,
20 put before the jury and the public as portion Of
the evidence.
Judge Neison-Undoubtediy; otherwise the examiner
would be ct the mercy OF the witness.
Mr. Eyarts-That agree 10.
MI Beach-It is what sou are dispnling
MI Evarts-No; 1t is not. But in the midst OF an
answer the witness isstopped by question: that Is
what 1 complain Of