New-York tribune., 1875-01-23
THE TnToN.BOwEN ARBIIRAToRs.

Mr. Tracy-This paper as ! understand you to
say pesent the arbitration the evening OF the
arbitration, but after the arbitration concGdedi A. Yes,
Sir
@ Who the arbratOrs tha. Occasion1 A. Charles
sorrs Horace b. Clafn and James Feeland
@ Who was Mr. Tilton's arbitrator A. really don't
know
@ Was /; not understood lat each party chose one'
don't how they chosen they agreed upon be-
tween NJ Clahin Mr. Tlton and myself way don't
recolect exactly how they chosen
9. Don't you know VINO named Charles stors1 A. don't
know.
O. Don't you know was named the friend Of Mr. Tton
On that arbitration? 4. don, rom,m mbcr That.
@ What the result Of the arbitration? A. The result Of
the arbitration might mention an instance, Ger
Tracy before the arbitration, you desire IT,
Nj Tracy-Please answer my question We VIII get on
more rapidly if you do The result .! the arbitration
that Mr. Tilton awarded $500
@ To be paid by Mr. Bowen A. Yes, Sir.
Q Was that payment madei A Ycs, Sir; be drew his
cheek for it there
e And that is the 200 that was subsequently deposited
with your finn A Yes Sir.
@ Mentioned In the accounts hcroi 4. Yes, Sir be-
Hcyc It is mentioned in the accounts
Mr Eyaus-Yes il is SO mentioned.
Tie Witncss-Ys Sir; Mr. Bowen ofIed 70 IGy 500 be.
fore the arbitration, Mr Tracy.
Mr. Tacy-Well, will pass that TO Juege Nelson
That take il stricken ont your Honor.
Judge Neilson-Wel, it is not a falsehood.
Nj Tacy-Did you witness any reconciliation between Mr..
Tion and Mr. Beecher after that contract sgncd? A.
don't recollect witnessing any reconciliation.
@ Did You witness any friendly act between them immedi
aey signing Of tha! contractf A. No friendly
than before-nohing distinguish the previous action
q Did you them together after that frequently A No
Sir them together after that frequently have
not them frequently together have not ever them
frequently together
@ Did you see them after tba, together occasoralyf A.
Not very often, Sir
@ OCCASIONALLY A Ircmember one occasion.
@ Not more tban Onef A. Il al my house perhaps
or three don't know don't recall them now Ifyou co.
recall them to me can answer.
Nj Eyarts 70 plaintiffs COUNSEL Viii you give Ex-
hbit No. 42f'
Mr. Morris Handing paper 10 Nj Traoyl-There .,is
@ Dc you remember your letter Nj BeecLr Of jan &c.
1872
Nj Monis-JaD % IS il noii
Mr. Eyarts Handing PAPER 70 wtncss-Iook al that E1hb.
IT," That is already in eydenceyor letter answering ths
don't YOU remember that letter. A. remembe it, look
ing over it to all that IL in II.
Mr. Tracy-I not asking you that Handing paper to
witnss your attention the printed letter shown
you aud ask il it your reply 70 Exhibit No a. z!
Mr. shearman-Marked in pencil Jan. 81, 1872
The Witness-I think wrote sa6h letter as that could
tell If saw the original.
Mr. Tracy-And sent il to Mr. Beecher? A. think co.
G. Do you know whether you have the original letter
copy Of it, your poesesoni a. think have copy oi tf
il was in my statement
O. In manuscript A. Yes, Sir.
Mr. Shearman-It Is marked E1lib. C.
The Wi,ness-t il quoted MY fret statement Mr.. Shear
man, is il nof
Mr. shoarman-Y.s Sir; .link 50.
Mr. Morris-What il the date Of III
Mr. sheaman-lt bas date Il IS marked in pencil Jan
uary 81, 1872.
Mr. Tacy-I understand you say You wrote Mr. Beecher
such letter Wa in reply Exhibit No AZ A think
il was yes Sir.
Mr. Shearman .Feadingl:
Ny DEAR SIR First with reference 20 Mrs Woodhuls letter
and your answer think that you would have done better 10
accent the invitation speak in Washington hut II lecture in
trces your reply good enough and will bear publ
cation. ..t... -, III. ,.,,>. A.. I'm ,,
frankly AZ your friend that ! am ashamed OF II, aud
would rather YOU would have written nothing Your
early assocons With and present knowledge OF the man
vh ~ hat pluer grounds upon winch you might nave 80
,, tat NO reader would doubted that IN your on
ion Theodore TiOn public ana private integrity was nPu,s
iiouab If the art had been written 10 compliment TIE 10
d.Jendfat il would receive my unqualified approval
Mt Fullcrton-ls that marked?
n shoaruan-The stenogapher viii haye to marx COPY o.
Copy Of letter marked Exhibit d, y
Mr. Mouon-(A Aside TO arporterl THIS 10 dreadful; wake
me up il 90 10 sleep.
MI Tracy Handing paper to witness is that Ihs Ge'@t"