New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-09-11
TIE POSE MICHEL SUIT.

ARGUMENT, OF COUNorI-ci AIMS or y AiEitFt5
ND Drff> DANTS-THE CASE nor VT CLOSED.
Thu sui Of Sheridan Sho,a and y. VI. Palmer
agansh ;pstiu Dily and otlcr, wa5 arsi'. ygs fl.J
IN part before JaJ q Curtis In 9IpaI.o" Court. rp'ai
Torn The mails icston uude; the lrnoe. reported
ia r'ay', TKIHr>H. was az Ia the ri;lt whi'h u
contestants had d,cved from tho author. The plaintiffs
in thls they made contract AMY by
tc"gTsrh-jirocuy with Ernest Blunl, the author and
h., immediate agent, Micnaeis, about March IL.
1873. and that this contract ratified by
Il con, ey'Gco to them on April .. Tho de-
Z 1daU's claim th4t before thi5 date through sim
uipnDs & VAL. dan ttic s--w'O are de chdin5
g. III, .t-i 90 yes anco wac made by Nrhpc % 'he
ga 1.ist IT the p,y for bota England and America ~
I. M BAyIiss, ihe husband OF Mary Gladstone an tn-
@ actress ihn after this sale conpl e, BOY lies
c,op1 yed Wal. seil tae American sagc-rigbs; ~ &c
Wal, then in Epsrnd. ut once elera phcd To- al 's aS
the pay. following the dispatch Immediately himsef
aid that on the 1DN OF March sold Dir Daily the pay
Tor co., he paid the receipt OF tho manuscript,
anu 500 per week or the first So weeks vi the of
'le play tho whole amount MT To be less tlab $1,000.
Tie manuscript delivered April 3. fhe defend
ants s-erj ttit the plaintiffs knew Of this pIrohGa,
were in fact il. nr,otiaton with sinn'onis < Wall t.
purchase H. mi only 1'fem 1"i override 'hc \ cDa-
ante yhcn tloy discovered tha. the play had boen add
to- ,ir. Day.
o. the "trrr hrr D tho p' nr CLAIM, 'hat tie right
sold to Nh dy'ssOrrithc 10 MS wiewas sia"e1ight
re- England aipno; trft Ia. aCiOu ci simmJnds i1
holy unauthorized an that. in fact, tn plaintiffs
laI gone directly 80 the authorship whom Mr.. DAILY
II. gs have gone aud procartd real rglt-'' discoy-
,rlng that s,ninsnds 4 Wall nld fs!t 90 y.
FAe fneson eag thus sinly - fact aS to $40 gs
% j. yi,a TO convoy the s;aizii of the author ~ any
On, T., D.tcnh,c'es argued ~ great len ~ that ihs
.cn.r va. conclusive gan- g. 9 lain; that Mr. Os'y
W warren az t,icrap'"d - TIE al'hor, ana Wa "a
surcd - Telegraph Il It his ""icfendsats hal ~, .shts,
,..F. At ~ %
abide ris t. Counsel turtle ned thai an anlly
sis al She .to1c It appoar"l hri ie claim tha' Fay
..s hAJ r:ght t. convey Vic sias-r.gf ior America
w,s au thoa2 ht got ~ TO strengthen M ind's
bis, - IN a;a ,t ~ the 'ats sa.ei ~ %" ieon ants
onis .laougtcr to ti HAT BIS ss Hal tod Wal ne hti
.ris.lt :. hir' wss u,s d,rncd even hy him.
-, = Boon a. ~pqv ar ed p'cl'mnt lily H. Il no
.1u. IN "a, te,'n' Ny 5m n including d,fsrcnt
,,. l,a.ins cIr'.t defendants whose Interest, weTo
MT CON ,n. M. PAYS defense should not be mixed
W. yyth that ~ sirnMonis VAN lis frit.or argued
nat tho troor- wore insufficient and proved some
TIN, els. tan tn complaint. yf that Campbell Clark
Nas 90 o,vn,I 81 tae ruel.sh pay with Mohaes whlo
Tia complaint sta Iicnaelis TO Ice tie sole own'r and
,g,ir hat the proc. Na.tt Palmer tic owner ~
he "a, gn r.I.' ho me complaint stated II - 10
M 1901, =; = Pan ... A-ein i.- Ntry foundation o. no
I'll ir, IA i':ioi t3a The play tai neve Dee pm
i.'l; wit ut That 10 IT,, ',t ud b We 40 ilrs-
,,cl,, vet 'an,'r. "Irk's .t'r'Ti Introduced ~
- plr 's. thar ~ gc' ., 's9oe Nth El-il3, !'"
- PITS . ben ri,'cd 81 = l"ii So, h"4 "aoti 80
he 1urao-c - not D. " and 6y sDaa rpD'i "
tom
O. &C., Vt.n q es't. ST. 81 ,sh argued that the owl
t,rn.. .i ti.'t a. j. Wins Hiatt'l non To" n.h
lslit 70 80 il.h Ne,sinB. ~ cd Included TIE stiye
,.,t iag Srv York at :tl; .'le plaintiffs sh1Tod 40
.-At 40 t.' 0ut eng i'f" ZEE IA ila i,S-li
81, =, 1~"u luI thht tho aics ts'rl''.ltty
cvN,' ri.G. Vi I4N toe ~ L purrl2-er. Ia H1it
e." f.,"iu 4 at ~. '9V rad - crpla' iUric ii3
49, nn lni 90 'e Wmpfg ~ = spn"O. ~ lt-
or, mat Il n.,d become Al Oli- aa production oi IT'S
I3raf y. Clark ol Boston p;esen'ed '"' law IN be-
>, If ;le defendants ndt.tne fully re Eht oi iro
u t"tf rrur .,r 90 'tu .'-'I III n-ti ctriosfly'p.
BE- clsia fr";. warrant n i'iuut 10. iHai r.r'
rittst .lrr am c2nrDv' r'1. tnh nos, "a In by.
.r- IT,, ~;I.,'ot doubt fGi-rgC would work
! H.. nurrs IA ;.3 sLit shaved lOyal .urc'A %
br 81 D.; iileF IN apparent mt, all tia al ne
p,s wtt q ais0v that rislt lr well Otc ne.
ia,n, mai rnrhas. lee haj ncpurcd lhe pi o., title.
=. ,t scenes Hnd GrLleBts In pa il,fsiati sitia-
t,n5 " .ri v.r. r4",0r nd dr1Ji"g; n 4 i1cAte1
~ ~ 'rpur''y and S'a'e " s"ri"E Hni 80 Del y
r-sref Ihc lar en- -; arAHpTtefsc pi"yhty trfh
,.r, II. DsiY b0.sl; ~ pc! market 70. i.i '' sm
q. .lo..- tGn -; tn a. p''--d rHi" r@ins WI Tho
tr. q o. I ~.0ry-tii tJs r'st ~ RS l"iivhfs' %"
- sss TO iiu ti h,yes uc work id AZ > iu iiao
20 In, Wsg ~ ~ CREATION yhe 81 IN ~ soiHat ~
niunc,i Pre- h5 u b. own proper aDt -
r. 80 al hctr a.d ia hl5 .,is,ess hHd". esiih ~
ado y. 0t interior - Ia he =. sSe' - NJ - -
c..ion a.. ngiet to-day "a, Ia you'd ny1ye "''S III
rlry. ID -nk lao, tht j. Y,y OF Mc DIoshe i,s tAs
/ titintf W;lS deferred % tr,it.
IN. ar'yne"t ~ me ,it in,cvtngthe play n" Around
TO WGs.I EiSn, las "~' poo'pOne. aa u Is to 'ot
/ i,,y LIE .sDt - OH