New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-03-24
@ You have no way getting at the line, them A. No.
THE STORMY INTERVIEW BETWEEN HUSBAND
AND WIFE.


this Jury in relating the interview between Mr.
| and Mrs. Tltop when they were In the pariof' ana
just before you entered, a. You have descnoea
you said that Mr. Tlton observed to his wife; You nave
brought this girl here against me- do yon remember
that that the language that he u-edf A. That's JUST
the exact language lean just him with MS hst near er
saying damn you have brought that girl on here 10 use
against mel" remember it well a. If 1t was yesterday
O. And you remember very words. A. Those are the
very words he said.
Did you state those very words before the COmt'ee'
| cannot say whether stated those words or not
q They have always been in your mind have they no A.
OH they have been my mind when have tried 10 tnA
about it.
Well did you try think about when yon were before
the Committee, A didn't have time TO think about IT, gave
my evidence just as 1t to my mind according TO my De
recollection.
Well yon thinking OF 1t the time yon gave ~ A.
suppose was but did not go into details before the CON-
mittee.
O Did you not profess to tell before that Committee what
Theodore Tlton had aid his wife at that interview A.
Yes Sir and told just what lhongh wac hen to the best
Of my recollection
@ Now, refer you please your testimony before the
Committee upon that subject and tell whether you used
that language thenf A. II knew what, SIR
@ Tell whether you this language before the Com
In stating what Mr. Ton said TO his wife: "You have
brought this girl here against me" think testified
before the Committee he said You have brought this
girl to testify against me-"
@ Look and see you did, A. Yes, Sir witness reading
from book
"Mr Ton got up at once before finished my breakfast
door and tried glass folding doors could see
him through the crack and could hear him talk very loud to
Mrs TiltOn; the alert and going 10 watch him.
went to the door and listen and saw hm with ms MT IN
her face and he 10 her Damn IT, this girl shi leave the
house, then went In and sad You shant damn Mrs IEon
on my account"
@ Then you omitted before the Committee these words
"You brought this girl against me-" A.
body that fixed this all up, left 1t out; don't know.
Do you remember whether you did did not say that be-
fore the Committed A. Oh could not tell you what said
word for word before the Committee could not recoect
@ Did you remember the time you were before the
Committee A. remembered it just az gave It before the
Committee. What before the Committee was just a.
came into my mind then.
@ Did you remember when You before the Committee
the language Of Mr. Tlton you have brought this
girl here against me A. No Sir il had rcmem-
bered II would have used those words probably,
q You would have used those words A Yes sir-uness
did them, and put in, az have SAID don't
know which til
@ You thought ago that you said before the Com
mttee that Mr. Tion said his wife that OCCASION lyon
brought this GIRL testify against mer A. Yes Sir
@ Well did M Tlton say SOP A. Mr.. Tnton said You
have brought this girl on to against me-"
O. Did he say: "You have brought this girl to testify
AGAINST me" 7 A. No, Sir.
O. Well why did you think you stated that before the Com
mee A. Because have been refreshing my mind, and
into all the details Of this testimony That IL the way
think IT,
O. By refreshing your mind did you come to conclusion
you testified before Committee that he said You
have brought this girl testify against me A did not
think anything what said before the Investigating
Committee just all over it, and got it in my mind the
way it was-the way was sure it was.
@ you able how your reflections upon that
subject induced you believe here to-day that said before
the Committee that upon that occasion Mr. Ton said You
have brought this girl testify against me' am able
to say to-day that said You have brought this girl TO
against me-
O. Why did you use the word testify" moment ago
instead Of the in that connecticut A Well be-
ago thought that was what had said before
the Committee.
O. What made you think so' A. Well, it came into my
mind We think great many things and could not always
tell you what makes me think So
@ You thought a ago that You did use the word
testify Commttee' A did Sir but looking in
the book. see they have got it
O. Do you think now' A No know that he said
O. No mo- Do you think he sad that OCCASION
"You have brought this girl to testify against me =
Nj Porter-I object TO that question.
The Witness-I know he said-
NJ. Porler-SloD; object 70 that question.
Nj FulertOn-StOp her II you can
Mr. Porier-I object fifth repetition OF that question.
she answered every time very promptly and unequyo
caly.
FulertonThis is the hrst time tAat mas Deen pH ITO
the witness DO you think now
Mr. Porter-I object the petition OF the question.
Judge NesonThe inquiry 10 be 70 est her recoee-
ton.
Mr. Porter-But the inquiry test her recollection should
not be by way repeating inquiry that has been exhausted
Your Honor will find that that question has been answered
again and again.
Nj Fullerton-No, Sir.
Mr. Neutrality-suspicious. have repeated times the
other side.
Mr. Evas-on our side have not repeated Mr. Morris
Mr.. Mors-The record shows quite differently
Mr. EyarsWe will talk the record a, the end Of the
Mr. Moris-we will talk about it incidentally before
closes
Mr. Porter-Let rs have this settled let the stenoapher
read the last four or five questions.
THE TRIBUNE stenographer here read the testimony az
follows:
Did YOU remember when you were before the Committee
that the ancua@ Of Mr. Triton was You have brought this
r here to use against me A. Sir II had remembered it
o You would have used those words Yes Sir-unless
did them and put in, as have SAID; don't
q You thought ago that said before The Com
mes taat MI, ,pn sG 70 70 ss mi w a me Ye. Sir
q Well, did Mr.. TtoE so' A Mr. Ilton said You
| have brought this girl On 70 Use against me. 49,.
against mey A. No Sir
q Well Why you think that YOU stated that before the
Committees Because have refreshing my mind, and
al the details Of the testimony that is the way
o. By refreshing your mind did you 70 the conclusion
thai YOU had testified before Committee that lie said lOu
have brought this girl testify against me A. dd
not think anything about what said before the investigating
Committee just went all over H. and go' II III my ihc IAe
way II was-the way was sH'e IL wHs
Are YOU able now to say your reflections upon that sub
ec induced 70 believe here to-day that ad before the
Committee, that upon that occasion Mr. I1on said You
have brought this girl testify against me A am
able say to-day that he said You have brought tbs CIR
| on 10 against me-
q Why did you the word testify moment ago, in
stead Of the In that connection; y Well because
moment ago thought what had said before the
|