New-York tribune., 1875-01-15
MRS. MORSE MAKES TROUBLE.

MRS. MORSE MAKES TROUBLE.
Mr. Fullerton-In the first place, then, Mr.. Moul-
ton viii ark you point n me that part of the letter
The whole Of the letter read. you understand.
understand the whole of the letter was read but point
ont that paragraph in the letter which made necessary your
judgment you state for Nj rton, order HE
attention might be called TO H.
Judcc Neilson-O Or rather which Mr. Tilton denied.
Mr. FulleF,on-W Sir il Is the thing
Mr. E'arts-The part that was readf
Mr Fulorton-He did deny anything that read o
him
The wness-You wish me to mark IT. Sir, OF read ~
@ Just mark it, so that evidence. A. hark
ing the letter. Between the first marks there.
Q Have yon marked that paragraph n red A have
Mr Eyars-I Will look a
MI FullertOn-Yes Sir handing the letter 10 Mr. EVarts
q you all the conversation that occurred be
you Mr. Beecher before you for Nj Tton and
also which occurred after M Tlton arrived there a
Mr. Beecher brought that eer from Mrs Morse and he
said 10 me- Here letter from Mrs Morse which would
like you read and read IT, and read the statement
which have marked well balance Of the letter and
NJ BcecheF am that THE cannot be true II my
own mind it cannot be true
O. What did you refer then A The letter or statement
with regard TO Theodore Tilton.
0 The statement that you have marked A. Yes, Sir
said There in the letter which know be
true untrue statement and Judge that the
statement with regard Mr. Ton quite untuthful ar
that Theodore and find ont from him directly
II he has done he has done wrong and sent for Theo
dore either day subsequent day at AL events
he came between M Beecher and myself and
he did there deny
Mr Eyarts-Welll
The Wness-Hc said Pardon me"
O. He there denial that you referred to1 A. Yes
Sir he said it was had told twelve persona
and he said who he mad told.
Mr. Eyarts-They have read the letter yet.
The Witness-I beg pardon
MI Fuleron- proper for him to state that whether
read or not.
Mr Eyarts-l think not
O What did Mr. Titon say He sad he had not told
twelve persons he told MT Beeche who he did e-who
he had told.
Mr. Fulerion-I read the extract marked know OF twelve
persons whom he told" Now your Honor WIN perceive
that without the context that las no meaning.
Mr. Eyarts-WeH read the rest
Mr. Fuler,on-That Mr TIon could deny but it ali
read.
Mr. Eyarts-Wen why didn't he mark it :
Mr. Fulerton-That marked in the arst instance
Mr. Eyars- your Honor please what we would ike to have
s distinctly the passage Of eer that read TO Mr Til
ton and thai he denied.
Mr Fulerton-I have read T.
Judge Neon-I understand that is the passage Just read
Then we have the conversation and You have the clause
Mr Fuerton-Yes Sir; and have read the clause in ey
dence
Mr. Eyarts-But do not understand have not heard the
witness say that the clause
Judge Nelson 10 the wines-lThe clause which was read
il that the one marked and that you say dened a Yes
Sir
Mr. Eyarts- the witness viii take the letter and READ "ha
was denied, then shall know
Judge Neson-yery we pass the witness the letter Let
ter handed witness
The Witness IreadinCl-
81 know the publicity given to this recent and most
crushing Of all troubles what has taken he life ont OF Lo
| know twelve persons whom he has told"
That" know Of twelve persons whom he has told was
the statement which Mr. Tilton denied
Mr. Evarts-That il all that said? A The whole OF the
letter read.
Mr. Eyarts-Your Honor understands sadistncty that
entitled the passage Of the letter that was read to Mr.
Tion before he denied II.
Judge Neson-We you have the denial and you have the
clause Of the letter you have them taken together
M Eyarts-Yes Now, have not the clause Of the let
ter yet
Mr. Fulerton-wel. that's not my fault.
Judge Neson understood the witness to read The clause in
question.
Mr. EvarsI have not understood it. He says that the
that he denied want the clause that was read TO him
before he made his denial
Mr. Fertone has stated that that Is the clause that he
read TO him. and the clause which he denied.
Judpe Nelson TO the wnessl-Now that that
we NAV understand you perfectly A. you viii give the
letter again.
Mr. Eyarts-we want what was read before his denial
!
the specific allegation Of the letter that he denied was
know N twelve persons whom he has told
MI FuIlerton-Now in making that denial what did he
say lie told Mr Beecher that II true said that
il that he had told twelve persons and he
toned Mr. Beeher the Of the parties whom he lad
told and l remember that Oliver Johnsons one
mentioned.
q Anyone else! \. think Mrs Bradshaw.
@ Anyone else. A. Don't remember, Sir
@ What other conversation had at that time? A. Mr.
Titon sad TO Mr Beecher Mrs Morse dangerous
wonan-a liable 10 come down 10 Plymouth Church
al any time and denounce mis- relations with her daughter and
that that letter ought be carefully answered the
ought well considered and that ought to be kndknd
could possibly I've made and the was written by Mr.
Beecher and submitted Mr.. Tlton, that interview
thuk-a al events il was submitted 10 Mr. Tton and
q Anything occur' A. Not that remember parcu.
ariy
Mr. Fnllerton-I offer the letter In evidence
Mr. Eyars-we object it evidence against MI Beecher
otherwise than az il formed part VI this ilIeryeT,