, 1875-05-26
And that Bililngsgate Will Soon CIh
Place 10 Argument.
The Remains of tho Blac1z,
mail Theory Resur-
rected.
Porter Gets $4,000 for His Haraneu.
.--Facts and Gossip.

ueAr conclusion, hts venom against nlton os lr
lug to increase A. hia fund OF abuse bocomos e.
llauatod. His speech hAn bean d n,oet aluR.,!ar
one, almost wholly without argument, aud flied
with abuao OF Ill tho principal Witnesses. llo
nil conclude tomorrow morning.
t7d tht Assoc,af<d Pffssl
NgW YonK, May 25.-Ex-Judgo Porter, bo,ot.
resumng ls argument for the dotenso Ia tho
T!ltou-Decchor suit. said ho would close to4lar,
and Mr. Evarts, on tho samo aida, would i'm.
medlstcly follow. He then continued Lie I'D.
dseas to the jury. md bata If Doeeher Ind d..
beuched TlltonB wife, do you think he (Til. 5n}
could aak committee OF Christian men 10 &c ,aa
Deocher? He makes m utter recantation Of
ttta charge Of adultery, and then comea iuo a
court OF Justice and asks for verdict. This
paper could not hAva bsen prepared to protect
hin wifos honor, becauao silo had lafs hs roof
threa days boforo this papor vas prepared, and
| nas living IN the houso Of HRS. 0yinRton. Tho
| accusation Of Bunday was false, and on T lcs-
| day b. ratrActed 1t, because he kna* It uss
falsa.
| N.. Porter then spoke Of Indy who Ind 1etn
MALf0HAfTLx TnAnucED
| by tic man who lad not hesitatcd to falsely A..
| cu4s hia Own Wifo aud bis lonored pastor, nss
| 1loruo bad no advocate, and. therefore, bhe ~.
| tho violin Of this leader Of FREQ love but TIL,
lady commanded degree Of respect l,lc:l
would nevor be obtained BY Theodore T lsof,
ns,ther in thta city or any other place. Tlmls
tho man uh8 was endoavoriog to keep hs
wife'a disgrace from becoming known, and I'll
hc had to do was to keep biz Apo'lo;liso lips
loved to thi. day. Vas It for such mon o. 'aera
| the LAW interpreted aud sustained Ia tho cosstH'
Francis D. houlton Was QUO Of c1aaa Of dsu-
ge,ous men. Two yesrs ago he mas = lcs slas
inomber Of ono Of tho Trustworthy frma In this
city; today, through sone eAuae, that Sssst
house has mat with
| TIE p18AsTEn THREATENED PLYMOUTH Cru. eli.
Frank Moulson WAS eariy brought into rel stiop
| with penjAmin F. But!or, from suit In .slr1
hiA firm was engaged: The prosecution ln tia:
caae sas pushed by lnformcr Jayne. and oddly
enough. tho prosecutors counsel ras BENZ sam
frionaship i sprang up up between those par1ies-
A1oulson, tho infosmer, and tho infor1scr'e
counsel: Tho p!aintlHs Eafty bad en1ea7 red
by fraud aud sfrasagom, to secure TEacY'!s heF-
vices. When Butler vas 5oiocted "a ono Q; t1s
counsel for Deechar. ho dtow up QUO OF thu ncsF
Adrot and abba pApets ever published. vii lc:. RI
intended to kill Raocuer at ana blaw, aud a.~a
| was put forth 1t the Time al
HouLToNH own pHoDCcTr0x.
hfoulton wAB eikhcr true man or false Or.
J In tho middle Of January Noulton awofs thu!
on tho Int Of that month there was p.!t1.t
separation Of the trn, sud ho WAS III tlt tl.m
with Robinson. That was either truc OF ia1re.
When AoblnHon was on tho stand. 10 Has
} asked when Mou!ton ooased to be mentsr Of
, tba. hsm, aud auawored: "our. partnership
| ceAsed On the LIT Of January, In pnzBu apcs
: Witch q these two mon ilsa' No nan csull
: doubt It was Erancis ., Mouiton;; Tilton aui
Moutton had conveyed to the jury the imprsc aim
in their testimony that tho claim of t .0E'
agAiuat DoNon waa ths clasm which Dowoo t.s'sr
t douied. There MAS good reaBon for thf, TT
| right behind It 1ay tbs Glow to
TIE cuAAoE or DIACNMAuLN1.
, Tho tripartite agreement would have bound al"
pordou but \ bafbarinn. Il was Important t., La
i plaintiff to avoid uo charge OF backmil, u
. boing dangerous to beechst. and Monlton hsii
0 sho wa dangerous person. Hor sanding away
: was moan coat1ivaucs Of Tilton aud Nou!top.
sE te5 to asa snHo 81 81
si:ss sss espr..soa: fsa,ai tsads. hsrsby n;
j. raslgnntIon ot Plymouth Church" Th.s
means Of = s.paroxysmal kl.s."- During al tbts
T. tIme, when these partios wsro writing latter! II
ops a9othes there wsFs no eapros''oa'. ass "
:. but Deeehet'a wsrs thoss Of Christian r. 20
y man aud yot, when thoy mot 1t ia atAtsd Il It
TuZsE TEnAB wEaR Used
q in their conversations. This man. Moultop, wbt
Processes to belIevo thae Henry Ward nes; ;l&'
vaa An adulterer, liar and deoauohoo, Aks. lln r
J. Into LIS own bouso, and tella bly, wife o. ~, ~
y (Decohsr's> onense. Ae hangs Deeehes's pc, pc
psrlor, to bs sosn BY ht4 own boy, md co.a'at:
!. this man to ths charge OF BIZ wlfo. whan .Is n
- leaves them togeshot. He permite this sdulscte
pormltted hifn to ktss biz i5fonlton'a) wife ln Iii
preaeucs. francis D. honlson does not 2 2
that when Beecher crossed bss thEtahold b
y aalutod Hrs. Monlton With kiss. Thsod r
10 Ttou who WAS thero many times doss not dcn
A thai the pastor Of Plymouth Church
aALurEp HouLroNs WIFE wlTH x1sa.
~ What lAy behind and beneath Ill thlsl connas
Ieulton. il the charge Of aau1tesy "ste tr'..,
y. Mr. Poytsr then referred to MouItun's mi .
rl,ea hs lasrnad trosn Tracy that ths latles y,
Il +. Tie sa.sss 'sd sa
- beoaius known The public WOULD wiah to Asot'
~ tain Thy sho payment Of s3. 900 WAS msds.
Ihe Court hesa took the eus:esnasy zsee<a
ID. Afser The recess, Porter continued bis adits
or to tho Jury. IL spots Of tl.s extraordinary u
~ that = man hke Mouiton. according 70 bin o*
Id ssatemeo. delivered over als r'fe to sho CO.,
'a pantooship OF man whom ho knew 10 10 Ayl
r. oc1itical dobauohso, and that ls bad the 20,
Est trat of sbis hdu}terer hanging 70 BIZ asaN;nt
room. But wherever Frank noulton 2 nesded y, J
oxplAuetfon, IL was forthcoming, and. II no otA'
,.. WAS possible, hs had
4 HHAH9.Roh0Ep LIE.
-! Iza tss.iaed that tlts portrait "ks hsns1ng 70
o9se for ony t'e white sttsf i IT, nsysr y
w,s in n his hoase until be- moved to Remae
Z. street, In 1879. When b dld 90 - J
oa; forgot that Tlton Tor anosheT petPoso H. .ta
!4: teatad that thoy lad soon It III th.t house II
ss1 point itself waa Of small tmPofsancs; s na.
ns, Mou.ton sxors that 10 assumed no attitude
IL llostites to Deecbsr until tho latter accused b!
nd Of bsos mail iu biz ss.toncns published on
x; th.t neioro ttat Frank Moulsou refused to
y. Beecher sven 800 the originals Of the do 4ineu
sss ba posse..ion %ho Co.. Tssy s'tsd .stss
asy, Hnui.ou dcpted that hs h&d permitted Tilton
"a q. copy thstu. Although copies had s4ea
ilil. boen publiahed, and sea.tered hoados.
Fol- Mou}top y9fnBad u sven rsHm!t ni2 n'
nd clsrk 10 copy stass papsra on the p!es ID
~ ha w&s going to hlragansetk but When 20 u
w. w. he took thsso papers in hla pocket to show
1nu. 1nn. Repismin p. Uut3or. md to b WoTsn taso
ord. atstornont which wAA ...
!ioa, pNl0hkD TO CRUSH bGHcA1A- .
mo When be returned With this etatomeat i9 !
N. POCKET 10 found lstser from Deecher Aakll
~ psr1u!aaion 10 &ss tho pApsss. ua tlan NE9
~. 10 bin lstte1, Or rather copied lesssf WI
rep. Butler wrote for him, declining 70 lss nln
~. $hnAN Ia hall haN1