The Wheeling daily intelligencer. [volume] (Wheeling, W. Va.) 1865-1903, 1875-04-15
VATICANISNI.
Dr. NewtOn's Second Reply TO MIR.
GlaIIStOne--'TlIe obligations Of
IhG Syllabus. .......

NNR. NRNNNnnhT ~ kANAEAhNNNN UkhUNH 10 NlEs
(iInIlStOne..'The Obligations OF
IIle syllabus.
DIR Newton's fresh pnmphlOt in reply
10 AZ. nInI,,or.,, K,I;.,n;s, s,oruv Lc.
% =" I''' w. TnDI;.L amJ Tsi.r Co,Lolic.
IT., A., ,Lo,,,, ~ ,Iaoo;.ino ,hn Gov
's"''' Wv .''' ., o. -, y, Ii ,,. 1T,
t,t,',, n '',o,' ";s,H .IIo,,iano, =,
" '" "r T. w." |'' ' 80 .I
Wv .''O" W" S ''' r''i"" |an '
ivy, ~, "sv =, WV r oo, ,bo ,oaChin,,
'n"' 'no ""'FV'''" "'t"'V" Wv ''"'s
Oi the bishops then and now is IN proof
that thu Church has changed its doctrine,
anI ,io.orv forro;,oJ II, clo;m N Lc
wi" "'V'''y ''''" =" '"'" "
scmper oadcm"'
"llut II is no change surely 10 decide
between two prevalent opinions; but, II 1t
Is to bG 10 regarded, then change has been
the characteristic Of the Church from the
earliest times, rs, Tor instance, ~ The
third century IN the point Of he validity
Of baptism by herCtiCs. And hence such
change M has taken place (which should
prefer to call dnclrinal devclnpmcnI Il
in itself Il positive argument in favor OF
the Churcl's inJentity from lirsI to last;
for II growth in ils creed il law oI Its
life. 500.
"Illc IL il to toll u.s." said Mr., Glad
,na DIN, ,,o po,o /. hon,l Inv the
'"" ''", Wv wy ,I.,'.,,,',,,,,I
moral anu olNlhe 'aW' ~ wv t"'''"'"'
mcnts oi God, by the rules OF the Gospel;
for Of these one and all, tho
pope himself, by himself, Is the Judge
without appeal TO this DR.. Newton
replies
That Is, Mr. u'"aS."nS .nI,,Ss '';"s ~, Wv,
n n"pe ,5 "TIor" il M" ti"I" and NAV
rrm,eeI To circulate by Cardinal Antc-
aclIi whole Syllabus Of kindred "erro-
neons theses Tor the instruction OF Ihe
bishops. ,, om"'i T.; mi"i, s pra"i"ncc
aver c,y' 60 exercised aver The Church. but lot
liz grant, for argument sake, that u Pope
could commit so insane u violation OF the
natural and revealed law; we know what
would be the consequence tosllch Pope.
Cardinal TurreCremata teaches, as lhaye
quoted him, that "wcrc tho Pope to cont
mnnd anything against Holy Scripture,
or the articles Of faith, or the truth Of the
Sacramcnts, or the commands Of the
natural or divine law. he ought not to he
obeyed, but in such commands he ~
nored. tSupr., p. Is. Other, and they
are the highest UltrAnOntane theology
ans, hold that Pope who teaches hereSy,
ipso Erio ceases to he Pope.
la ,,,,o. n nassure from Mill to show
n.a, ell non wri,nr. vim maintain doc
UNIV '''Vrc "'' w ''.'' WV" ' "'.,,..,I,.
trineS which, carried out consistently
would reach that dclinmenium Chat II IL
ihe riUht If nny one to have liberty to
80 ii..,.... e., o,o.y nossiI,Io
give PiO''o "''''"" ,', ~ . .sm,,,,,,
Shape, by every possible cnaU'e,' "''"'"'
any let or hindrnnce from God or man,
In nil his notions whatever,) which the
u,,.oai. ~ n ,tcv hnve mt already
FoPe Slv"H' w. wy ~ 49,, n,r =,
reached H. b.t ny l'oSi l", :" a ,Id "i
81 inc pahipIS. Y; G' ti"t ie,"'''S w WV W"
igasloIlS " ny ~ , ,I,n la ro.
have said mat lhe Syllabus d ~ ."Hv
ceivei from lhe folN WIZ p p',,no"o y
snbmlssi9n anu ~ IN ny o. o. "? !, ,a 70
hdd bnt not OF nun, W " Iii III ~"
dogma lorce. ! maih'nin '1'Is " sui ,,,a
say, IN spite OF Professor ecn'l..e wv" Az Nv
English CathOllc writer 10 Whu.l NJ ~
Gladstone refers, have as mllGh right 10
maintain that the implicit cGnue!nn '.'la,
with which it VISITS lIs e,gm ~" FT ,Lp IN.
lions j. not et nera OF u" , nss % a, '
hlIible CHAIR, rs nave , ln.Se s sn"SSs
heologians, us blshop rea.et sptH;N"'
VI O call Its doEma'ic form " IHys. ao,..
! do not know what fessler hl I,T sh'
Of It more than y y 10 De rg gp,,", JOnv
submission my "Ve'''cl'eS: v" /, "" /. IL
anothcrs right 10 conslusE ttt;i,;i;i"
private conscience ah nct VI i !a..i. M
Nr to say, In MIR. HlaustoIeS w w s' a .s,
"utterances et e'lihc "a, nfe nov 'Ile o "iES
form In which ih,alllni.''y ~" ,h;,t
] only say that nave " ,ls ia;i"s
otherwise; ana wieli lne Lulv, y ~ W.
approves Of one wrller VINO MrI ,.'a,t U".
way, aud Oianother VINO WEl"t ~ a Iii. "
he makes neither uOSm"''c, ""' ""'' "''
Iowable. ,,L,.,,L.. 1000, .,sos.
grant ihe fOIe mas i IVY. W En-" ~, Lee Ia.g
Oh the SYLLABUS nc issulu i iJo .. " y"
spoken Of II as "a regular u" "Oey !" welt
cannot tell wR ,i {''u a t~i .,nrtors viii
ing; anyhow Ihls ny 40 no. IT, isCi c6S,
tesslers grave t 5neo'"R EI @ \, IN !, ,SocI
Ilderlng ihe . nSSPGi .t"ii;iIy At",enyer
nOsmatlC'l'I w" n.tSu,,,',,"ns;b"i ,ronnsitibn,
now gun y 'is. u. i'IiS ~, i"s";hg ir,ihc al
he rue, EXCEPT y I ill., q" o,;,,,,,,to,n
l0G,itlOhS, e'VI III "' miino",;.ns when ",
Su anu III 'm NV Gn,i H. wboi srnsr NM
m ,n 10 'heI, W. wv" w f H. " "ovorniiy If