New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-02-10

times renders her objbt Of peculiar interest to her fellow
citizens and whose character nasmuch know her we'll
can portray without color nge from other partially
save that hold her In uncommon respect"
q Did you write that. Mr.. Ti,on. A Idid Sir.
And did that a have thus read II 10 express your
opinions as then entertained A When wrote that biography
believed good portion Of It, made exravagent state
ment of 1t with view to conduce TO the purpose
q For rhetorccal effect No. Sir not for rhetoric.
q For what A. have already told you that Mr. Moulton
Mr. Beechr and / set the enterprise Of
handling and controlling that woman, and believed to con-
siderable degree during early months Of acquaintance with
her. that she much trsduced did not believe in her
travagances.
q speaking Of the period when you wrote this, A.
wrote that in the first months OF my acquaintance with her.
q You wrote IL In September A. Yes Sir; and had been
acquainted with her three or four months
Mr. BcaeThe gentleman has succeeded in inerupng the
answer Of the witness.
Mr.. Evarts-That is my right
Mr. Bcach-No he has the right interrupt the wit
ness's answer
Judge Neilson-n the answer is rcsponsivet
Mr.. Beach-It responsive
Mr.. Evars-Thst Is q matter Of opinion.
Mr., Beach-Let hear the answer OF the witness
THE TRIBUNE senoyrapher read the qucCon and answer
Mr. BeachTo the witnes You had got so far now finish
your answer.
Mr. Eyars-We will about that Ny question IL he
that and IL these his opinions the time.
Judge Neilson-He stated they wcre in part and in part
they not.
Mr. Evarrs-Thai a certain point Of time Now how he
those opinions nothing do with the ques-
ton The point is whether he held them when he
them.
Judge Neson-The witness has answered that he did part
and in part he did not
Mr. BeachHe went further the witness said that he wrote
extravaGany with view conduoe to certain purpose
The question counsel then presented him with view
to hetonc and he answered. "No" and he went explain
inoh hSh no in
ing question put by the counsel
Judge NeilsonI think that is proper that have down.
Mr.. Beach-No. Sir; it was interrupted.
Mr. Evarts-That is down, and then was going on
Mr. BeaehThis is most astonishing Your Honor heard the
question and the read and the interruption, and it
right for the witness to explain
Judge NeisonBut st the question is he has not sub
stantially answered the question; think he has
MI BvartsITo Mr. Beach, You draw it out further on
redirect examination.
Mr. Mors-Bu not the right OF the witness to answer
fully?
Judge Neison- believe he did believe
it part and he did not believe in the extravagances
Mr. Fulerton-He further and said that himself and
Mr. Beecher and Mr. Mouton had agreed upon line Of
duct with reference this woman and in making the eKpana
ton he interrupted.
Judge Neison-He said that and 1t is down.
Mr. FulertonOnshalf OF what ne said is down and the
Of it is not down paper.
Mr. Eyarts-Tha only reproduction of what he said
examination lie
Now Twill read this extract. beginning TO read:
Judge Neson-Turn a page or two Mr. Eyarts.
[Laughter.l
Mr. Evarts-Oh yes Sir have but very few passages to
read and this quite Please listen this and whether
you and whether expressed your sentiments at
that time. Reading
lone OF her is I will lit up mine eyes TO the hills
whence comeh hepmy help cometh from the Lord who
made Heaven and Earth"
The Wtness-I believe in that.
Mr. To readl
She reminds the old engraving Of St Gregory dctat
ing homies under the Outspead wing OF the Holy Dove
Did you write thsti A. did
O. Did it express your sentiments at the timer A. That
was not sentiment "reminiscences Of picture that
hangs in my library; that Is TO say woman who had
this text (she had it written somewhere on card
over her e and it reminded of that picture any one
who could habuay live with such text that and whose
life whether truly falsely preends TO be guided by such
text reminded of picture my library of St. Gregory die
atng his homes under the Oupread wing OF the Holy Dove
@ You knew thu lady and had known her for months A
Yes. Sir.
Judge Neson-He says that reminds him of this picture.
Mr. Eyars-That is what he aid-tat 1t reminded aim OF
the old engraving of ST. Gregory -
Mr. Fueron-It not worth while to let have again;
there any other question put let have it and mako
progress
Judge Neiison-He has answered that.
Mr. Evarts-Pleaee listen this and whether you wrote
IT. and whether expressed your views concerning her and
her opinions as you then entertained them:
On social questions her theories similar TO those which
have long been taught by John Stuart Mil and Mrs H. b. Stan
and styled by as frceloye doctrines,
while others reject tins appeaton on account OF It's pop
r assocation with idea Of promscuOus intimacy be-
tween the of her stem being that marriage
is of the heart Of the law that when love ends marriage
should end with it, being dissolved by nature and that no
civil atue should outwardy hearts which have been
and finally in religion, she is splritalst
Of the most mystical and ethereal type Dd you write 1hat
o did that express views concerning her opinions as you
then entertained themg A wrote THAT ana think ha Is an
accurate Of her opinions as se Then hed then that
* moi an expression Of my opinions, but OF hers
O That is statement Of her opinions as you understand
ncn,q Yes sir; when made she had
made any exavagant uerances the subject Of free
1--we she always quoted Stuart Mill and Mrs Stanton IS her
exempars. .
Now please answer this which am happy to say is the
loo, e,tence Of the biography well rs Of my inquiries:
Known ONLY as a rash cOnOclas and ranked even with the
,o uncouth nOsenakers wac are waxing sleepy
before time she beats her daily gong Of business and
musical but stTug yer eiO"s me Out
ward rudeness Of the rhythm by the inward anu u"Nout sony vi
% - the sncerest most reyeTeat aud dfnely OF hui
man souls
did Won write that and did that express your opinions
then wrote that that part of the extravagances
in the sketch it eliminated in that
And thatis the end A. Yes Ihad not so high an opinion
of her as that, Sir.
@ But still your opinions were IN lha' uleoto o"s" '"''
did not get 80 high A. What Sir 49,
n Your opinjons that direction although they did
M, reach 40 hchs A. No Sir that part OF the design
that as mart Of the little sketch make it thoroughly accept
table 10 her so that it might accomplish it's service
COUNSEL. MAKE A CORRECTION.
Ti,oro 10 ono oupGtiOn here in ref