, 1875-10-20
.,..ripucctl Abstract Men Declare Them
slngularly Defective.
p.otd Of Judgments and New suita-
Criminal Business.


, ~. ,.onorary Injunction was gransod Mt tho
'eaftd ~ tndao rarwell, and yesterday tho mo-
Il, N Dissolve, which was FoBlponcn ,foh Aaat
: s's w. c,me up. htr. Appleton, of tho firm Of
ffaNs s" 1,,arra ! Arnletnn. on bol,a,f OF tho
s..,,,tnspt, read tho Dill, ana iAA1. iAacaheF'
tepPe .o,;c,to.s far the t]efoutlaute, read tho
Ne q the euHe ,,I. ~ AZ R.lo. ou
..sts 0b[eCtl01 was 1Haue ny shs' hs'ont ou
ss"a. thn complainant, to tho Introduction
behhl VI ~ ,n.,,r m III, nrcsent unotton.
n ttsdtnR oi tuo 1ts" "" -u.,,t,
:, Il vss not nWor1l to. btlt the JuuGo e'1u"eu ~
y" .5 stating al tlle hamo time that 1t was
nbs1ssa' i, -. ,,,.x,,o. ..t,, ,ri.
.t pleading, anu tnn'ssi no 1oi'opoias W
,an.s xas Offered to anppo.t It, nc "onta nos
Hsc'ff lne 'A'NAs'
a >,ntxtE Nts no1s
THE AHH"kH .---.
Wv =, ssli,or nymtt, H.. ii. se..e nj ths
uA laa hep!s III. ..,.o.r.,t - t,,n ,,s,truc-
!, Id b remedy *ne es'.' totssloe"' W '3' "'.s4
~ ii &ay pullc fecusos bf hfe or otAet"'e' s"a
~, h rey,pe tho law In regard to ftecordeFs."
" ,...rs.nts depy, however. t11at theRo were Tie
n dntaa'u'" ~ forrs Il the tins Of tue sale Of
81 ~. hrofn telsltng to the purchase
u ~ sbstrsct books or in regard to tho puwer
eHinns eILa, noIrds to purchase Atg.ract books, or
4 toau! ~ ~ natt They also Ntxte thnt tho tn-
aas ~, ~ the statutes IL . question cf Iaw dayoiv-
tt % ~ so'-''
ahas,.o h1,o admitted t},as tha County Commissioner
Aa .IIs-,ny thc nuestlou Of purcuusislH . set of
stn ,nfs anit that In Matyh tAat Otto PcItztr.
Rt7s. s.. "a ered 10 se them Let Of .ooks for
9ooe ous Ms casr wi scceute.i, aud tAesepy II !s
GSN. nt,Itnc ~ euntrhct v4s made by which tbs
tlmto 49,. Jist}o 10 pay the price agreed
nsitJ y. II ts,o books Ii! t,uestion wero mt ali
!aJ tsfn,n lhe f3p nnd they mt rofdcs Of any
hs hont, auatracs minutes, OF eztraets certified
!, nroYet b. the Judges. II n further deuica
q ..hfv,stt yoIutnes called '.fplI tract ILL
w. - ntnt af lis xy5 volumes purchased correspond
y =. r.ouiremensa of ihs lAw, or tatt oneh4K III
~ .sHtv s,x yolulncs are Iii relation 10 convey
~" M ~ IL SINCE tue Liking effect Of tAs ACT LII reja-
y" u f,outds TnrJ also Len5 that the countI can-
rIdmttt we're nus authorized to Gny tha ~ hooks
..s hs full tract inuites, OF that 80 ooo Wan M Ok
s ETsn r. 81 = fs,; wsIs sa o u IF pst
!. bceiI wele wollh ths snin latu the aaae wot4,u
b rid. The amount to 10 paia war 10 u iaea ohiy
ttht poa,d, aud no court tn tho alssnce at iraIa.
snsx cou,Ln .tiun be,wen 1citz,f and sno Boafd to
txay t1.s,, tus a4e Of Ills tuokH. .......
TpE cous7s cLEns AND TIE TnEanuHER
~, .a1 tonpccliou Win tho aitsr cxLoIt In their Of
seiap AZ. Iaeu alndta fhst lls was Instructed TO
Ky ~"1ruut for xA5,puU, a1,d Miller astatus HAT
~, n, ,lai amount ju the County Treasury, ~lta
81. ~, vsrruut could aud wuuld haye Lesu pAid
Mn Mn sot tst, ior Inc ,apjuArt,on.
49, THE couM,sslurERH
u,.t. they ,teypQ Il 10 b tl4elr tl1ty 10 proyids
iM. 1 ,tSxn NJ htsrx books Tor tne use Ut tAo
ss4s u .1se tor Tue ,urvusa 1t 1udiuH conve:.
ri i,nds and In pursuit. Ut this !auatlo tnd tneJ
H.u,J oil ilcIoqns pt utto te,l:er a,II Wiuuuus
s1txsts. xhi.h .pleand 10 t.te1n IL Cs amply
..sa,. Tuo books cunlatnua letter. pro.s oopteA of
,t tbey 4lsu tleu1ncu yI4l3a -U, they
srttofd rtcofds OF Csnyeyal.ces leltrs tue fire.
sjT. tha Coutnissiuaers claim that 1t wul4d h@Yc
~. 1uch more to have gop,cs nst!e proposed toau
Ea1 Ptn.s,,s boks ihul they usct tacir beat iulg
st.t: th,t the books compiy wttn the iaw; that nu
t,ta hs pesn pracitesu an1 t4t thcrufora III thslr
ss5an no court win interfere with tatlr uctlun.
M i.cinrr ihrn le44 4 number of kftuAstts IN
taort or he sueHer,
p, IL atday,ts Of
wt1w.Nya ANN Tu1gyckE
xo,t tb., .thhntv 1ere. mud i. ID teea for 1uApy
MI n 9,aet tuaicrx: tllst they had tuade the ab-
tntthoor. tn oljrs,jo,I They opened Tulsa Looks in
nsssiJ lsrk Of 1874 elnhouYinz shcreln n! trunsac-
,ne ' Ths peots wers hett ~ saowia
tnm,tt rhsin II Hts nrd were 70 Atyaupvtt a. u
Eas IL tr1a stata Of rc4-tst.o titles. 1netr only
sases lheg arer in keettn0 sucn books ~As 10 enaue
hon 10 compile 2ohtlR.ts, and their guicesB do.
ltdA On thar Accuracy. Their TeAulsa Aa4
ten Gsccesaful, md thuir abstracts prepared
haa their books. we're UNIVERSALLY admitted
ta.s dss.sis, loan brokers. taw5e1A, and b4nkort,
" 4ntns Lilo dsuy that ti.s books Nsrs nlAdo fof
a4pr1oss 0. selling than to Tho county.
@satj a tpt Hzty.sRht volumes cont*in1ng letter.
atspes IT Abstracls sre usceasary to suoH oon'
fa. saata ot title, aud werc conped In thu tchs nat1
hdks nd clas.itied ind!cts, together with tue orig
hIsntr7.toota showed by trucn avery o1uysYalN o1
hssmtrxnea recorded. the tlma Ut httng II, III
SlHaefI tht halIG 04 tnA H!AlSug Au0 E1Nuteeh
NJ At deacktpt&on at tho seal eatate. Iht
tsd tndlee4 do not contain The 1ats ol
:. instrument. bat that can 10 aRcertaintd by tlt
eay hoota. bsstdsH tha4a ud eas.Ty Looks they
In, Without s1ss1 charge, gtreu IL, 60 humber d
aAts tonnes, which sup, ismental to tue tract ID
kk aDa udll enasLtp 10 1u4ka thcln cumi.ltte. Tbs
Hkt iadcta alolo, II n thLrged aFa worth 34',td1
adths pur hsse was ruads, alter careful e1aIntna
ny u tht cutaty Conmissions7s. FmsitJ. t1e1 "
EtAs, shs itics vas low thu lut. haso ta1uo,iraI
Vi Gty Indignantly scUut lho ,dea thai kusre wei
nltsnnpt influence.
Orrp RKLrxBu
IN lid N afdsytt In Which ho s1ccfdc tho cnsrao
lasflhs tooks, ulr;r uuN,Ler, and yRiue IN nut
l4kn& RaY - uexcr1Ded iu ths utoyo sliadxyltt O
kAslap1 Tuteltks.
&C t}[anrs s,,d N,cho,.s 1,r1arp yah a,so awora Il
taaai xairn,snts
OK THE rAnr mr. THE cnMp,Aty.nra
IT, iputetor va. r..i .."a-,I .",'..,.,t. rie A.,
Nitn.roi r. !, 49, s,,a ,n.t "a ~ sr,t t,. AL
h,a-tpota dr',rar.t ~ r." s",,,s sar, !. sc",
tl,No rtJ,m.s lIvt,ot ,+ n,.i':y, s.',,,t1s I'm.
ID IN so,. ssa ~, h,,s ,,..n h,a 49,
ps.d tha tncn,nu, rn,ss ',,,.ix ,u Wy" ~ "ot
iNa IL IL III -. H.. 1aca5 10y s'e - ,,,1,t. ~.
1s ~ E,,,,o ~ san. = tos' s1o ~, o"oas M a9oa ~
ahas IRON ~, ~, =, H., vi ,I,,. w ~ tnts.
liA esf'. = Ao''' ~ 'n0 'eAa VI oe'ooE'
IAamd,,. arr n ,,.u,- - .,
ts4t tnst ~ ~, x. - .snnJ ~ a!ro tsaas ~ ~
tIssa 4 ma ~. naa ot staAuy' a.Anou4 -. ~
uusI i, t,"- ~ eae 'o' tsss4 'oa1ecs :" oe"'A'
Msss s,.rsst A. T. as saaasM taas rs va s'e.
AtA is1, III. .ra, ~ .'seS, eA1 ~ uss ~
144ki, N II, atytda, ,i, -, ~; ~ 't. ~ ~
tAsaIt3 Aitnr "r,,,x ths,n ~ ,,a t.a h..s
TAI found that w;ia = .rti ~ isSa.s at. "o",s 's =
EhGs s1s1tnt 1e.r ,t,ag 80 a,I.",t - - -.
}G4s 10 tn.t" tn,cs "up sSunAs", - ~
aas V,lmanns Th,sl te o,,.,s,sxs ,,.in,s ~ ~