, 1875-07-03

spoko 1ory briefly and cautiously. hfr. f1.latosd
w.s TIN mnht roacrvei man Of tho lot. Mr. Nc.
tls trial. and
ApuskD r111ox AND Kou1roN
"a untrust~orthy witnesses. Mr.. Davis. who
vo.od for Ttlton. raid he did no beceuss TO ac1nit
guilty Of ro, ,jnry. Mr. Flate voted for Tllton,
But wan willing to voto for Doccl'er to SECURE N
agreement.
liz. Jsi1roy loft the city Immediately on sd-
Tlton aud sioulton retuse to 10 interviewed,
but Noutton il ont In 4 card daring Plymouth
Cnurc1, to arrest or indlct him.
THE CHALLENGE WILL Ii AccK1TED,
tho laWyors Of no1chof SAY.
Sir, beacb. Tor Tlltop, says tbs result ia satls-
factory. ~ only. 4 disagreement Was orer hoped
for lie sass TIlton IN restored by tho result to
hia old poeItion, and this WAS his chief reAson
for hoginning the suIt. Sfr. Beach rotiEes per-
bo tried again io any form. Mr. Morrs and Gen.
prGoF lefs town ~ soon % tho Jury were dis
charged.
(xpfhs Aassttdked FYt4s.l
THE ANXIOUS CRuwD.
new YoNx. July 2-Eariv t1lis morning tho
Jury. In the caso Of Theodore riIton aga!nst tho
noy. f1cnrg Ward Deecher., breakfaatod, and
thon sont note to Judge Nelson, stating that IL
returned m answer that he voa1d be ut tho
Coutt ~ 10 O'Clock, aud would then sand for the
counsel and communicate with tho jury 1t that
hour,
His Honor stepped into his private ROOM.
Thcro were then assembled In the court nearly
tho same group Of Plymouth Church people al
"erc there yesterday. MIR. Decchsr camo In
with Deucon 1iowafd. All tho stapding.room
vaa occupied by II o'clock.
Ten minutos Inter Judge Neilson took bin sent
Hill, aud Tracy for tho defendant, and Morria
md pearaall for tho plaintiff.
TIE JuRT ENTER.
At seventeen minutes past II tho Jury f1ed
Into court, looking Al il thoY had passed sleop-
lens night. In reply to tho question, "Gentlo-
men Of tho jury, hhvo you agreed upon q vcr-
dct?" Foreman CARPENTER replied "We have
not, your Honor. We regret it very much that
NO fad 1t impossible to agree"
REMAHKB or J.'naE NEILsoN.
Judge Nel]son stated that !lo had learned by
note from tho Jury, earlY this morning. that in
tucir opinion they should be discharged. as tho,
suffering IN health. lie experienced tho force
Of thht application vary strongly. and had called
them in now, at tho earliest moment, giving to
counsel and othcr8 m opportunity Of being
would like them 10 carry away kindly rccollec.
lions, and 30 far aB they could, remove wha!eyer
chaRrin they felt at Loinx detained 40 long.
Ho wished them, 10 rocollcct tho fhcs that
not until yesterday did they suggest that
they could not hgreo, aud that suggestion came
from thoir foreman. signod by eleven. and ao-
cou1paniel br anuthor from ono juror, who
thonghe ~ agreement possible. Whiio he had
porfect regard and confidence in tho opinion Of
the eleven. and tho explanation Of tho foreman,
10 thought something was duo to
THE TWELFTH JunYMAN.
His Honor had tho same thing Oh his mind vos-
terday It 4 o'clock. and ho allowed Jnrynlan Tay-
lor to devote lis t'mo to bringing about an agree
tho note that they woro unable to aeree,
and that the disagreement WAS founded on their
inability to decide upon the weight OF tho testi-
mony and tho crodlbility Of tho witnesses, and It
appeared to lila Honor aud e7cty person con-
yefaant With the case that it whs impossible for
lin to help them by any suggestions; Not
means Of helping thom on that point;
Tho weight Of the Testimony rested
Whit vi wtn]aasos ] Tho, eonid bolisve " md nj
what wltnesneB thoy could not. Tho Court had
no right to interfere. 1lo WAS GLAD to DO assured
that The disagreement did not arise from anv
want Of attention on hts part. and God knew
nothing.
10 which bis attention had bean cAlted. aud hs
would like to learn from thom explicitly tuht tho
any way ctouded tholr vision or occupied thoir
thonRhta directly or indirectly.
Foseman Carpenter assured Judge Nef1aon
that hc was right - ho hsd questioned rnans Of
the 1"!5' nna theY ~ to'a niin tnatthey had not
Lac a.. u 10 49 iae'f tiS tnonEnts A. az;
1oo o1uso SAL w "a1 Mca Rtasniou ~ oos!
tnn.' A,a n!uu1 sapf u@.1 WY n.'lt sot cuu'u Ao'
AErue' me ~ Moa ~, ui7ena'Eo .ue!.
!no G''3A 'ue" @'s'oo 'A"s 'aoS "o'e oo" o'0-
cn9iee9. n ,s
tsnaa - :, J." ds.+;na,1r ,,,dor.tana t1'"t .i,o
inrx Iii nj n, stsod % eiavcn to oms ~ n~mhsp
bnd ~ ~ "F' ~ o' ''
A'1 ~ M p,c7rny w.xrrn.
tFhntk Il to In
fs, t,nnsmt. .a - ,aoe.sn,.r ;a.o3 ~
tato iikennss but - lursman J Jcff,ey ohsectcJ' d.
.nd H.. 1r1"a .,'nm,J thnn' ~ fesrs IL. Cc,r,
~ 1a ap oo 70, tb" =, rnn,o,an evore
or,vne o to,mspd ~ .vo ~ mr1% ..,.h * mrr
na."'1s NJ" AoA "A41 " A"'o "''o "''u s1' '1''
MI, H.. n.echc, v,nt tn III, ,.,1,nc and .hoot
,mds ~, asn,, ,,rv,,sn =" IL ''..,s a'''
"1ra Tha " ;,rv ,*cra ~ .nntsn ~ ~ W. ~ 0'o" ~
no 'o'' ""' :: ,,an r"vv aroon.%
-. h,,s .h.. t.,,,;.t .t,.t t1,a,' .tooa r,, J.,
ttrso ~ acGntttn b,,. H." nac. ~ H. i,ro.o
lsG 1or III. .as sn 1 ~, Luz
s.i Its11' "@- '"o' "-~ '~'&o' '1- o"A "S' W ~
Mr. Tt1tnn ami Mr. MouItnn enternd thn court.
room a fow ninutcs before tho iury. but wefo