New-York tribune., 1875-01-27

Commitsee' A. On Sunday preceding the Monday which
had agreed 70 take the papers before the Committee Cen
Tracy remember the day correctly. think dovcnt ws
me TO the Fifth Avenue Hotel Gen Butler with reference
to the suppression Of the statement Gen Butter
Gen. Tracy.
Mr. Eyarts-Any interview Of that kind object to. Here
Is narrative that took paoesuppoed have taken plses
between Gen. Butler and Mr. Tracy. Now that not eyL
dence.
Judge NeIlson-Now II uponhs conference he rsfraned
want the result that Is all not the conversation IT, In
view OF that interview that he restrained
not restrained from taking the additional papers, he ma,
state that fact going to show the anmus Of the Witness
acting in good faith bad faith Now, get him to do that
ITO the witness You had a conversation A had
versation Sir Shall give il,
Judge Neilsonwlth Gen Tracy sDd Cen Batter. don't
ask what the conversation was
The Witness-Very well, Sir.
Judge Nelson Ito Mr. Fullerton Now ask the question.
Mr. FuleouDd you refrain from taking shose papers be.
fore the Committee In consequence OF anything occurred
there on the occasion TO which you rcfcrr A. Yes
Judge Neison-wel that gives It sufficiently.
@. Who did Gen Tracy represent on that occasiont
Mr Eyarts-Well
The witness-e said he represented Mr. Beecher Angh.
teri
Mr. Evarts-wer, objected.
Judge Nelson-Tase IT, Sir; let stand Take eIcep.
ton.
Mr. EYarts-Yes, Sir.
Judge Neilson-Go on.
O. Was with his appreciation that you wthhedthemf A.
With whose appreciation, SIR
O. Mr. Traceys' A. II at his request
O. that the why you did not take the balance
before the Committee Is 1.-THE balance Of the papeFs' A.
That Is one OF the will give the balance Of the
sons. Shall II
Mr Beach-No; have got enough
@ Did you have another meeting the next dayi A. Yes S
G. Whcre' A. At my house.
O. Who was present! A. Mr.. William C. Kingsley ME-
Franklin Woodruff, my father and Gen. Butler
O. Any elset A. And my wife
O. Was Mr. Tracy there, A. No. believe not he csms
that evening though after had been to the Committee
O. Did anything that evening after you had been 10 the
Committee with regard papers tht did not pro-
duce 2
Mr. Evarts-with whom
Mr. Fuerton-with General Tracy
judge Nelson-I think that sufficiently accounted for
Mr. Eyarts-Yes, Sir
The Witness-Yes, Sir there something
Judge Neilson-Wel. will let that stand then
Mr. Fulerton-Now Mr. Mouon, what statement was thea
consideration when you thus went to the Fifth Avenue
Hotel and had this conversation
Mr. Evarts-The conversation at the Fifth Avenue Hoelf
Mr Fullerton-Yes.
Judge NcisOn-What statement under consideraon|
Mr. Fulertol-Yes.
The witness-The long statement that prepared which
was preceded in the publication made Of Ii BY card to
the public.
Mr. Evarts-Ysu describe it as the first long one' A.
Well
Mr. Fullerton-Neyer mind mind
Tho witness-I can't help mindlng him.
Mr. Fuerton-I know this talk back and forth bet~eeH
You and the counsel is out Of order, in my judgment
The witness-wel. Sir, beg pardon.
O. Did you know, did Mr.. Ton know at any time THAI
he was furnished money directly indirectly from ar
Beecher A. No, Sir.
O. Did Mrs Tion that any money that was furnished
to her came directly or indirectly from Mr. Beecher' A.
don't think she did.
O. You didn't tell her, did your A. did not.
O. Your attention has been called your intimacy with MA
WoodhuI A. Yes. Sir.
O. And you have stated when 1t commenced and whea
ended believe! A. believe hsye yes.
O. you Sir what caused you TO permh
or 10 cultivate that ntimacy-acquantance or intimacy
Mr. Evarts-The direct examination has gone into that Sly
and we cross-examined him upon it,
Mr. Fullerton-IhaYe right to show Sir. what oojecs
he had in view
Mr. Eyarts-That he showed his direct examination.
Mr. Fulerton-No, he did not show it.
Judge Nelson-Partislly, think, not wholly.
Mr. Eyarts-Just far they it, 1t is ndr suoJect
and they were not unless have laid foundation
for some inquiry concerning the matters that brought OUT
but is this inquiry The question is what the motives
and reasons his acquaintance With this woman were whca
was the very thing wbch the subject OF direct exam
nation 81
Mr. Fuierton-You Honor will perceive that since the d.
o examination they put portion OF this Woodruff
srda which makes necessary that we should account
for this gen msn acquaintance WIN 'hA' "oan "u' P'
mugated those DO. 'fines \,