New-York tribune., 1875-01-23

not choose 10 make any should choose TO make any 70
anybody Beecher said to that he thought would Do
s cSnVso and dfD tod Kim that made such
% a. 5 that hS s Gy S,5 s pa ss% Sy one Or
and had denied that he was an Impure man-hAd uo '-
o We'll want to a.k you whether in this article publshed
by Mrs Woodruff Illicit intercourse between m beeche' anu
Mrs. TltOn was chargedf'
Now that raised Mr. Bvss to objection that hey wahted
the paper but all that preceded that in regard to the interview
between this witness and Mr. Beechcr was entirely competent
and proper in the absence Of the article itself II was the de-
csaon OF Mr. Beecher that conversation that character
lied t. by asserting probable effect it would produce
Then air. Mr. Evars says the article should be produced
"Mr Fulerton-Wcll, II you want the article
Mir. Eyars-We don't want the article
Yet the counsel says undertook TO produce to em
and are bound to produce when they discamed all de-
sire for the article. [Readingl-
"Mr Fueron-You can the whole Of 4 m or have Una,
part in propose to leave ont II you wiz ADMIT ai "
Mr. Evars cannot agree to any substitute for
Mr. Fullerton i propose give that @ IN nsasfy that we
should produce II here. $4,000, .,.ra ,no n the oh.
Judge NeonDocs the learned counsel sana upon '' o'
lection that the paper would best show'
ndpe SeI,on~Thcn you cannot do it. You must produce
the paper"
Then Mr. Fullerton says we must 90 on with the evoence
What was the precise question before your onor' That wn
WAS nut by Mr. Fullerton whether the particular matter ne drew
attention to published in that article The ooeeon was
10 that evidence Mr. Fullerton then says II VIII go ON WIN
the evidence and did with their evidence not as 10
what the article contained but the transactions between
this witness and Mr. Beecher in regard to It, which were
entirely competent in the absence Of the article.
Judge Nelson-Sh it is not TO be denied In view OF that
evidence that they would havea right to putt Ia
Mr. Beach, did not object that but when this gentleman
Mr Evsrs rises and says he reads this as our evidence ana
that assumed obligation legal or honorable
produce that paper deny and the whole effort OF the gens
OF
this extract from the article.
Mr. Evars-That argue, to hold you to your promise In
is my purpose
Judge Nelson-You can read the article
Mr. Beach-W ysu permit me to say 10 the counei lhat
think have the support OF an objection to this question and
while it is always very great delight to me to listen TO the
gentlemen is difficult for me to reply to him. and DO mo-
want to be called upon to reply TO another argument ehcep
| as matter OF courtesy.
Mr. Evsrts-Now l will make proposition OF my own
have resd to your Honor this evidence which followed Wha
learned friend has said When said, "We don't want the ar
tce meant to say ave not putting in proof here
you continue to put that proof here we want the article yot
were after putting in proof" Sir understand, th
plaintiff and his refuse to produce that paper ACCORDING
to that promise to strike out every particle OF t' VIII
ness evidence relates the subject OF the Woodhu scan
| da from beginning to end
Mr. Beach-In other words II your Honor please when w
prove upon auson made to that article the declaration
Mr. Beecher-" that will ruin me and when he enters int
devices with this witness for the purpose OF avoiding t RUN
ous effect upon himself that must be stricken out unless VI
| produce that paper
| Mr. Eyars-That was my motion
Judge Neison-I could not grant that motion without select
ing the particular passages which, perha in the paper ough
10 be stricken OUT but under all the circumstances regarding
this as msappeheasOn the paper will be regarded as Deio
the Court and you r Eyar read it and II they DO no
produce Il, then you read II from the printed paper
Mr. Fullerton-I hope your Honor will draw distinction be
tween the article in the paper and that part oil II 10 Whch REFER
| ence was made by me In this examination.
| Judge Neison-Yes Sir.
Mr. Fuerton-It don't follow that volume shall come II
| evidence because a paragraph was alluded to.
Judge Neson-We he will first read that paragraph tina
points TO your evidence and he shall exercise his judgment
regard to reading the whole OF 1t.
Mr. Eyarts-We shall read all that which relates TO your story
OF Mr. Beecher in regard to the conversation
Mr. FuleonYou propose to do i'll don't understand the
counsel on the other side shall determine what he shall do
Mr.. Eyars-Of course.
judge NelsonAs the paper referred TO- story was re-
fered to- he may much OF it covers those two con
siderations think itwoud be very pleasant to hear that
before we adjourn.
Mr. Eysrts-If your Honor please reminded by some
Of the jurors their hour Of adjournment has arrived
Judge Neilson-T TO the urors The jury will return al
quarter after two O'Clock punctually.
Nj Madison Ohe CerkThe Court will now take recess
until dfteen minutes after O'Clock.