The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1875-01-16
NEW SATURDAY, IB75-TRIPLE SHEET

M nEhAAO, OAJ ~ MIA 1 ,
person allowed tue ismiis; Of his chu,cn
would BE- the only one Of the three nyovsd would
Be unhurt by it and that he was silently suffering tor
witnessHAndre~ Bradshaw.
II s q sy u rSeoS.
nc s Ms snd
q S that 10
the accusations which ne had formerly made against
wness-Mrs. Andrew Bradshaw.
believe q reply to these charges was prepared
by Mr.. Tlton, and " as afterward published; loo
neve spoke to Mr.. Beecher on the subject
MT. Fullerton then asked the Defendants coun-
sci for the charges, stating that they were en-
braced In the PLAINTIFFS notice.
Mr.. Evarts-Plymouth church u not the defend
ant.
Mr.. Beach tsmil,nQ)-l don't know about that.
Mr.. Evarts-Neirher Plymouth church nor the
Christian religion is defendant here.
The Court-lhat Is my view OF the case.
Mr.. Evarts-Notce 10 produce any paper we
nave Will be obeyed, but to produce the archives
OF Plymouth church. we cannot
The Judge promptly decided, at Mr.. Evarts' tart
suggestion that the defendant would not bring
into Court papers or books belonging to the Ply
mouth church which were not his own, that the
counsel was right
"very well" said Fullerton. ~ guess Wen get
them In here some way"
every well, then," exc aimed Evarts subpoena
your witnesses In the proper way. We shan's
assist you"
The object OF all this was to put the onus on the
church 0n1cers OF talsfyIng the record.
BOUQUET FOR TILTON.
At this instant an o11cer OF the court advanced
through the audience with q bouquet pinned up
In white paper, and It was given to Ttlto6. He
blushed and put II into his hat, on low chair.
General Pryor turned about AMI asked him to
open it. Tilton shook his head. Pryor tntimated
that it might conceal q note. 1t was then opened
and proved to be modest collection OF apparently
garden MOWERS. put together BY other hands than
florist. The bleeding heart, red roses and red
buds generally relieved on white ones, with q
single sprig OF evergreen, composed the Offering.
There was slight effort to applaud in the gallery,
Triton, without looking up, laid 1t down on the
naked table and resumed his attention OF the case.
1t Is 70 be observed that every night TlltOn pre-
pares the schedule for the next days proceeding,
and II he and Judge Morris should both be taken
down with sickness 1t would be next to impossible
for the plaintiffs case 70 60 on.
SUBPOENA ISSUED.
Judge Fullerton caused subpoena for the origi-
nal charges TO be prepared and served upon the
defendants counsel.
do not remember anything growing out OF
publications. the New York sun that spoke OF ex.
pelling Mr.. Tton from Plymouth church; re-
member a meeting at Plymouth church to consider
me GnaTge ao MADE against mr. Sy mr.
corning what had been done at that meeting;
said to MIR. Beecner that thought the proper
from the roll OF the church; MIR. Beecher
agreed to do that; said he was not
not be investigated against INN, and consequently
there would be no exposure Of the facts between
ton on the grounds OF non-memDership; after
ward had conversation with MI. Beecher about
Mr.. Tilton had come ln and. In the presence Of
the congregation, stated that II he had slandered
his pastor he was there to answer for 1t; Mr..
Beecher said he made as generous reply as he
could on the matter; That occurred a short time
after the meeting in Plymouth church, within
day or two, believe; recOlect there was to be
COUNCIL OF CHURCHES
had an Interview with Mr. Beecher IN regard
to It; Mr.. Beecher said he did not want Theodore
to take any part in IT, that II he could keep quiet
until after the dissolution OF the council the mat
ter could be orldged over; he thought everything
could be saved; after DR.. Storrs had made speech
before the councii received letter from Beecher
on the SUBJECT; had said to Mr.. Beecher that
understood Dr. Storrs thought It necessary 70 be
severe.
After a little skirmish between the counsel Mr..
Mouton resumed--l said to Mr.. Beecher tnat
pursue, and l thought It was not ingenious for
him TO 90 1t; that was before the speech OF DR..
letter followed; Received this letter that YOU
have just handed me about the time OF Its date.
Judge FueIton then asked 81, the opposition II they
Evarts answered "None," Judge Fullerton then
read
BEEcHKH DAMNs sTORRs.
storrs course has been snspeakabie Outrage
has turned against HIM in the most venomous
,on iSf are hollow and ia!lss1 They merely
INA rs gam y
has am In hopes that rhsod9re who has borne .
strike at friend. There are one or two reasons EN-
phatic for waiting until the enc OF the Council before
fTa-TRat the attack on Plymouth church and the
the public mind likely be absorbed in the eccleS
Seoond"if Plymouth church is dsiellowshipped IT will,
constitute blow at me and the church tar severer
Thtrd.That II Council does not disfeowshp Plymouth
sn az ne so Sou w go on brs
in his speech and, in that case, the emphasis will be
t0urth-At any rate, whie the fury RACES in Council
so 70 @ sha g
the battle over one can more exactly what ought
a mas' run Se FOR S anS ns na
yours, ,s,. H. W.
Nc tell under frst impressions what the effect
OF such a speech will be- l, ought to damn storra
ANOTHER BOUQUET FOR T1LTON.
While Mr.. Fullerton was reading the epistle end.
a slight laughter)-a letter to which the church.
men In the jury box listened with close atten-
tion-a large red bandbox came up through the
audience and was set at Mr.. Tllton's side. He and
General Pryor looked at 1t doubtiully, and Pryor
jerked hrs head away with a toss OF contempt.
Being opened the box was shown to contain
magnificent bouquet, arranged by hand in slen-
der porcelain vase, with miniature nags, GILT
stars, DC, on blue ground. large white lily
dominated this bouquet; orange blossoms tube.
roses, vlolets and neartsease made up the body
Below were ivy leaves and ferns. This graceful
bouquet stood up high and conspicuous, and
card on 1t said: -
Theodore Tilton-Compliment OF his friends.u
"wAvB TO FOLLOW wAvE.n
Mr.. MoutOn-The letter you have handed me Is
from Mr. Beecher TO me. received /. about the
time OF date.
Judge Fullerton then read:-
. SUNDAY NIGHT March g. 1874
MY DEAR FRASk-Ts there to be no end OF trouble, II
To- a w n