New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-03-24


O 1t half past when they went into tAe
vital done whcu LIZ. Bates tAege' a. what was
GoEef
Q. Yes A. with NJ. Trtoa,
@ No A Why. Mrs. Tuton had been talking vi:h hi--
che had spoken 70 him lie making friendly cal,
think it q sabbath evening and s'ayed to snpper
Q Ana yet after he away, about O'Clock in the
afternoon NJ Ton took Mrs Tton NO the and locked
her upi
COUNSEL CHAEGED WITH MAKING An INCORRECT
ASSUMPTION.
Mr. Tracy-No, Sir, there is no such evidence.
Object 10 that sresoa To counsel tie Wit
has lot s4d
Judge N,i.son-I tAa,, 10 does.
III Fu.ler.ln-I don't taink DO Sir.
NJ Trscy-weu think yoa d. and therefore object.
joke NrisonH the question assumes what does rot aP-
pear al the Testimony o. the objection good one
Nj Fullerton don't I'D what does Ho; ap-
pear
Mr. Tracy-Ths counsel stated he testimony GSOut enc
o'clock which referred another occasion and then he tOok
the occasion WHOM 3r Bates hare and said for supper
lie witness .ns arl applied tae c1e Clock 70 that TIE
witness said
IL Fulo-ss-W4it a'momert. You need not state what
IA pose lave it TeGd That 80 .-iIsr
way &C. dot
NJ T4cyI don't know what rsat the counsel Las 70 inter
-. I'VE Wien ! al adj. es-irs "a, Court
NJ 3D. do AZ5S w-.cA SIDE os a-e " Just
NJ Tac7I III never on but Sne is-of CAGE aud that s
more .lal sone other .alcmea can say.
IT Ful crtSoS, vii your HoAos have the record reaGf
Juire Seilson-K,ad The record.
TiE TEIsUEE stcIoGTapner read Is follows
slfr Furerc7-Nov Mes Turre- vii Won sns1rer ruc
ton; a. remember rcy eatncIi sno,hef ecc@noA men
lev were LOGGED % Es together aud he WAC LA4AIs
y--v tr.r o. aer and nl, occasion when sAe sGid
why daring laSe every Goag 4s tar ss cs Aa4 SUI
W. cvay a ssI0r- knew t,at because tat day nsd
n aeied wy utcryl u hide cTo~s-an@ he.7ag nfA
i-u crya, cat 70 lie door a1 Knocked and Ms It'n
unlocked frs IT. running ~h'e'
e. Nr Tr0a s..rdug ng the burcen, aad he turned
anG iac J-st d. iead a. he 4Aa nc 'uea IS
% wcn was tsql' A. That was another occasion; can
4 -ac - -s a N can A u Hsy 1s'e go 20 u. ' ~,
year have been another year. J. NAY hAV' pveL o
So" & 1--WE rs no .ie, whether 3. was in ~ 1889 or
1sSt t. Nas curing to.e three wears; cannot give any
o,l,tc mc any iln that these seedlings or ocAHss
ny I'd H. ~. tssn ,fat f.acraber these scod-
ings 1in, pace IN ls1 1873 tao-e three ycars
tho o T. Il Won have spoken Of you now renen-
BE-. A. Another occas "a remember one f,eHligg ~
loetod the room oceher and nc was talking very loud
e You c5I le-r tie .ud talking again, al the crying tone
q Could yor hear what was snd' A No Sir was not
listening a:eney enough. suppose Il ad put my ear 70
Tie door 1t qOs1y AVE made Out Wax Aey were 80.
T. But you didnt' A. II hangry tone Of voice Tat
a.seG N, 20 be- around
q Wien ,oa knocked uPo1 the door an 7 was opened
q BIZ. Ton standing: A on ias oac occasion
he
and " zen mace nv appearance he turned around .
q You have tod abou; that de was Standing oy me
door Low lar he bureau from Inc G0or' a 01
u iTv far. A'wel suppose here wasthe door, dover
O. s.S or eight ce,, A. / didn't it; don't know
whether it was * or eight feet not
O Give as 20 = judgment A. could not tell you
lie dd rot prevent from opening the doorf A lcoud
MOI that: cdn Der until he door vas opened
o. You lidn observe he attempted 10 prevent her from
opening the door, could not observe sr eecaase ne
sus; all that Jaw was afer me door vas opened
Anq Ais face vas red Is he; Vii yfry as sq bret,v
very red you will they are as red as fire or " red as
4 Well which was it red as Gre or red as fury' A Well
Iguess, as red as fnry. . -, .. s.
Q What did you say? A asked Mrs TIton II she would
Yon usns 70 ret pardoned did you you knocked at
The door 10 cet adnissoni A. Well cannot state truly that
s e1 w" aSa s Hse my having been angry that day an
cus for going IN to see heard Mrs Tton sob6ng
q You Leard her sobbins and crying, A Yes Sir
q DISTINCTLY A heard her, and then saw her
q You listened hear the sObbins and cTyins' a. was
IN the front sitting room .,o,o =. 49, v.-.,
@ Yes A. vas MT sitting Standing over BY the
o How long did you remain tina, attitude A Do you
mean before went ~ and poke poke to PER- Tim.
4 How longi A could not state; perhaps h'teca minutes
q How ong they locked up in their at that timer
They been there for several hours three or four soura
Z Yesi A the afternoon, after dinner or after
D What time unch' A. They generally had lunch from
twelve 10 one. -.
They went directly after lunch a. remember
O. Then about ocockf A. TANK it was earlier
than that - 49, ,,, 49, ,-,,
AZ WAS about half past one, guess
o. IL was past when they went into the room; now
vh.t MAS done when Mr. Bates thcrel A. What
doDei
@ Yes. A. With Ms Titon' 49, .
q No A Why Mrs Hilton had been taking VIII him.
abe had spOken 70 making friendly CALL think
IL Sabbath evening and stayed 70 supper; -. =,
O. And asrshe went away, about one O'Clock IN the ar
te0n Mr. Mrs. Tlton into this room and locked
her upy'
MI Tracy-My objection s that after the counsel had quit
the scene which transpd after lunch and had gone back to
the scene when there and had the witness ten
what occurred presence he then assumed that the
witness had stated and Mrs Ton weni into die room
G one o'clock in the afternoon the occasion when Mr. Bates
there which very dferea thing from what ths Wit
had said.
Judge Selson- very easy for to modify your CUES
ton, Mr.. Fullerton
Mr. Fuleron-ohi Sir an strictly right about IT, Inc
witness may have misunderstood ny Questionable probably
did
Judge Eeson-n appears that the time when mr. Bates
wa there was In the evening
Mr. FuleonUndouhsdly 1t wss that did not prevent
IN from ayng tha tAy into the room q hsfpast