New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-03-20

nv immersion Of Mr. Hslldays answer The Impression
derived was that Mr. Halliday said--
Mr. Bcach-Does your Honor think II b proper TO state IN
the question the impression Of the counseli
Judge NesonThc proper question is did understand ~"
to say aud which, after ALL amounts to the same thh
Mr. Shcaman-Dd understand to you reported 70
Committee that Mrs Bradshaw had said to you ha "
Tton she would appear before the Committee ou'
would write the Committee letter. A. did NOT du HUI
mean TO say
Mr. Bcach-You didn't say soi A. don't think did.
that the report and the inconectness OF 1t In s
mornings paper. didn't say So
z. You said. did you
The Witness-Wil you repeat that AGAIN.
Was not your statement In that part OF your answer
where you said you reported to the Committee something
about Mrs Ttons Saving she would not appear but would
write the Committee eer-wis not what you intended 70
say that Mr. Ton said he would not appear MS Brad
shaw would not appear.
Mr. Shearman-yery well 1t Mrs. Bradshaw said she
would not appear.
Mr. Eyarts-If YOU will allow me- think in the same an
swer which Mr. Sherman refers Mr. Halliday did use the
words Mrs Tton" when supposed he meant Mr. Thton'
Mr. Beach-No he didn't
Mr. Eyars-Bu not in this part OF 1t.
Mr. Beach-IIe didn't mean Mrs. Triton he meant Mrs
Bradshaw when he said Mrs. Tilton.
Mr. Eyarts-Thst charge would not appear against Mrs
Tion
Judge Neson-He meant Mr.. Tion instead OF Mrs Iloh'
Mr. Evarts-Yos sir, think ] want that corrected
Mr. Morris-e Mrs. Tton. and he referred 10 the
fact that she suffered enough and he would not cause e
any suffering by going before the Committee 81" was
Mrs Tion
Mr. Eyars-Wi1 You allow have rightf 1t Is Tor
the witness to say which was right
Mr. Morris-H explained 1t in that way.
Mr. Evar:s-Can you find that question and answer
The wness-I did make aluson il the Court please, to
Mrs Tton in point; don't know whether inc geh'ean
has any reference to that.
Mr. Deach II gas NOT N
Mr Eyarts-No but think it is the answer in which
he spoke about proceeding against Mrs Tilton-
judge Nclson-He meant Mr.. Tilton.
Mr. Evarts-Yes Sir supposed So OF course only want
to make it straight
Mr. Morris-I take issue upon that point was against
Mrs Tion and Mrs Bradshaw giving that as reason
why she would not appear before the Committee She said Mrs
Tton suffered enough already and Mrs 1on asked hc
the questionable question was put how she could appear
against her-how she could appear before the Committee
against her, and Mrs Bradshaw said that che had suffered
enough already Mrs Ton had and that the reason she
gave why she would not appear before the Committee 1t Is
Mrs Tton.
Mr. Evarts-I is not in qualification OF anything that came
out from Mrs Bradshaw.
Judge Nelson-The question is now, whether the witness
will make the correction of the point referred to :
Nj Eyaris-Yes Sir; and say to Mr. Morris 1t Is not IN
qualification anything he remembers was repeated by MN
Gaday az coming from Mrs Bradshaw bu precedes it, when
ad-the point what he said about not proceeding OH
the charge and speaks Of not proceeding against MIS-
Tton when he against Mr. Tion suppose IL
was not part Mrs Badsbaws statement hen Tor Mr.
Morris has substantially stated that and don't ask that to be
modified.
Mr. Beach-Ohl not at ell.
Mr. Evarts-It has not anything to do with her
Mr. Beach, think we have got the answer.
Mr. Eyarts-We will find the answer when it is printed
Judge Neson-The right to make the correction needs be-
is reserved
Mr. Evars-Yes Sir will reserve that The witness has
q right Of course, to make se correction
Judge NesonThe right make the correction II need be-
will be reserved.
Mr. Evas-Ye will look at the record, and let the VIII
ness make the correction il Necessary
Mr. Shearman-That is all Mr.. Halliday
Judge Neilson-That is all, Mr.. Halliday