The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1875-06-18

The Lawrence Smuggling Case
It's Legal Aspect.
A DIRECTOR IN THE TOLLS OF EQUITY
Decision Against the Union Pacific Rail
road Company

making i've cent pieces He was held in 81, 900
bail for examination,
A oil m equity has been died In the United
gtates Circuit Court by James Il. 0sgood h Co.,
publishers OF Boston. against Frank Leslie and
the American News Company, to restrain them
from publishing 10 Frank Les!te's Illustrated Netcs-
paper poem by Oliver Wendell Holmes, entitled
"Grandmotner's Story OF Bunker nm Battle"
rue Messrs osgood claim to have the copyright
OF the poem In question. The bill also prays Tor
an accounting
Yesterday, In the United States Circuit Court,
before Judge Benedict. Vincent Pamero and
Joseph Garbriese, VINO had been indicted Tor
CONTRIBUTING, pleaded not guilty 1t is probable
that they will be put on trial to-day.
The case or the Emma Silver Mining Company
limitedl, OF London, VS.. Trenor w. Parke has
been removed from the supreme Court o. the
State TO the United States Circuit Court.
In the Marine Court yesterday, while MIR. J. 7.
wnltlegg pleading case before Judge
McAdam, he used language for which the Judge
thought Mt to rebuke him. He again repeated the
offence. for which he was arrested and 1ned SOS
BY the Jucge Tor contempt Of Court. The pugna-
cleus counsel put his hand IN his pocket threw
nown the amount and went on vita his pleadln0s.
In the Superior Court, PART ., before Judge
Freedman, suit was commenced yesterday by
Doyle AdolphI against eX United States Marshal
sharpe for the recovery in value o. Sc, 200 worth
pf goods. The plaintiffs set up that rhe goods
we're sold by one Lagraye 70 Mr.. Lands, a clerk
Tor II. b. Clanin & Co., and by him sold TO them,
when they were seized by the defendant as n por-
tion OF Lsgrave's bankrupt stock, and that the
seizure was violation OF their right the goods.
An order Of sequestration was yesterday entered
in the County Clerks ONCE against the property
Of the New YORK, West Shore and Chicago Railroad
Company. The order based on an unsatisded
Judgment Of Marquet j. Courtney, and oy the
terms or the order Livingston Langston was con-
armed as receiver OF the company.
Judge Donohue yesterday approved the bonds
Of Mr.. Jewett, who was recently appointed
ceiver OF the Erie Railway Company. Messrs.
Homer Ramsdell, ). L. NJ Barlow and Francis b
wallace became sureties and qualified IN 100000
each.
THE LAWRENCE SMUGGLING CASE.
Under date OF the 18TH inst. Mr.. Bliss, United
States District Attorney, has addressed letter 10
the Hon. S. +. Phillips Solicitor General, refer
snce TO the case OF Charles L. Lawrence, who has
been indicted for completely IN smuggling. The
following are the principal points Of the letter.
I have received rom you copy or the addl-
ttonal argument submitted In behalf Of Charles l..
Lawrence. IL is not denied thar England received
from US Hebron on charge OF forgery, aud
when he was acquitted mat charge. tried and
convicted him Of larceny. IL rs not denied that
Van Aernam was extradlted to Canada Tor f1r-
gerT, ana Eed Tor false preences. A 10
rms case Van Aernam was never tired
Tor the offence Tor whi-h he was ex-
tradlted, out was tried and convicted OF
iase pretences aud sentenced 70 seven years i'm
prisonmenr / state TINS on the authority or a
gentleman who Was concerned IN Van Aernams
defence. II L. not denied that Paxton was eX-
sranIted for one offence and convicted Of another
ana that the convection was sustained by the
highest courcin CANADA. Nor Is IL denied shat
Carpenter aud others were extrodited 10 France
Tor one offence anu tried and convicted Of an-
other. The cases refer % are disposed OF by the
cavalier remark that THESE are feeble anu un-
1aNNA Il a
Others quite a. respectable" Why ieeoe To
whom are they nsatis'actoryn except 20 Grim
inals seeking 70 escape puniShments Where are
the judicial decisions taking contrary yiewg /
have iaied 10 md any IA which TIE ONT was
directly at issue. The nearest approach
the CIVIL OF Lar ave, anu IN that
the opinion 20 literally quoted by Mr..
stoughton was as be himself SAYS, reversed on
appeal. Nor does Sir. StougntOn meet IN any way
the authoritative declarations which quoted %
government. Wbne constituting himself the
CHAMPION of tine British ! government he cooly
describes rs views "a ABSURD auu childish Mr.
StO0ghton enleaVors 70 snow ina; TOOK an ln-
correct view uf the decision OF the English Court
or queens Bench IN Bowers case merely aha
the assertion nat when the couusel says tuat %
was conceded IN rhar case What BouYIcr could
not DC extraolted. unless ~ ar angcmeni Or me
la~ 81 France u was provided thdt nc coaid NOT
Re tried upon any charge except tnat upon men /
ne was extradited lis remark seems 20 me utterly
~ variance Win TIE truth. Mr. at9u-hioh seeks
90 tnrow a doubt upon the Freucn decislo > ana
quotes at length IRON a circular oi the French
Minister o. Justice IN ISL lie safs that
Mr. Clark IN ~ work On extradi-
French courts have settled down on ina
view tnat a msu may be tried for crimes Other
tHau those on winch he was eNtradirsd. aud tnat
In dong 50 ne Golfers from the conclusion 40
winch the Q9cen's Bench arrived Il BOWERS
case o. The most satisfactory prooL" ihese asser-
tons must nave been made Win tue idea that you
would not examine Mr.. Cisrkeis nook As 10 tue
'nestati0u," Mr.. C.arkeis language - a. follows
10 l6sl :-.snce the nrst EDITION 0f tats w0rs was
puDnsned three very important cases have come
before the FIencA courts. They were fnig dis
cussed and reported aad the DECISIONS mas be
e. r 1T b