The Iowa plain dealer. [volume] (New Oregon, Howard County, Iowa) 1867-1895, 1875-09-24

fsssAas - sAts sAlss sA#es sAs M
- II - - lAaaAst sawetsssA
80 u - t4v~ - - 80 ~st
i - $3.50 - So AtkA HAs4 $500
- - sslttls~a smtAtAAtA e. W tAas
sssAANa ssAs e@wsA sawa NesA
isAts y - t4Asa - ~ .AAAs " w.
- - Atas~a ~ essslssaw Il IA. 49,
80 = - #AA, sA~tAs .~raasssAr sAAA
- '+F ssst i 49, ts4e ". s~tst@s
's~lt 4 $500 \ ysf1.a ~.s sAmtAN
~ 49, 49, - \ shtse eH@tlsslss
4 talss Hslts ss#t 49, tsAss Hers
! 49, - t%~AttAN ~s.
<s~stks~v " W ssrls~+s
IT, s'tssH lasis i.Nts sAsapA
NV u Md sisvAst 49, shapiA
lAss ~tsts | II ueaAs ". lasr ~.
49, aststllnr ,ht irs sntfsmt
] Z ~ II sis, Il nAl# ~ H. " i
80, 80 - shA lA4a4stei nstttt sWA
Nth ~ sssla 80 eath hlt u 80
sAllslua t. tissre i he, ,ht
tsati IN - - tiiss sss Al ,iitittea.
iimss. stsaefsa aeeistets directs sN4
ssgshisiir h. sseh either The ,wa
tav. teTsttei Il ate, III rpsehal
hstsa enA .thrtt hNsiAN u u
l'Atil, and others. appealed frem ,he
,l,ssiie, rtnt " tas tnun,s, atrided
"A The March term 18Th, rrinica y,
Heck. Judge, "a, Jehn 4. Sihl~y
aeair., i,rsl llalli. anA another. ~.
rsaleA ffom ,hs district ea~st VI lte~.
esd reun.s, and decided a NE April
term, is1a, rpinion Ny Cole, Jaage.
HUH ~ere IN title rases. and N botl
.he original rarrh1se for 'assa VA -
samsa u b fsaudulen. and invalid "
shs hands u The purchaser, IN srnss.
qaence n combination " agreement
amsus ths bidders not 10 compete
With each ether. In both, The ccstiA
cate. u tan purchase, upon which th'
defendants .isle depended, had tccs
assigned n M assumed innocent rut
chascr, that h 10 way, a person c'aim
Ing TO hasc had M knowledge u III,
fraud, In both. tho iax title, afsc,
sha dead from the county, had beer
transferred to ths defendant by qui
! claim deed. In both. II was clainot
~ tho owners of the land---thc owner,
II .hc ra,en. .i,le--.l,at the purchased
81 thu Tax certificate obtained no bet
Ter right than bis seller Or aasi.nor Ind
and that II was N subject 70 nstnck ~
tho tranl IN thu purchasers hands ~ !
wnr III tho hnn,is vf the seller that /
quit eln,m dosl conveyed 70 The rur
. chaser .nly tho title owned by th'
maker II The decd, and, with MI III
weaknesses; or. IN other words. TINT ,
! person holding. by D quit claim ,lcc'
IL nv liable IL have Ills title arsailcd Il,
. his SELLER was, md for the tan,,
causes.
: In both, tin dcfrnlan. tho N,
+ title rlaI,nanl--lcniei ihefe rror"si-
iias. md a,te.ied their converse; iha
II 10 my. he claimed TINT KNOWN,
n,tl.inp al,out tho fraud when he tool
Nj. 1nit claim deed, aud tho purchase
II thu tar certificate from whom he In,
obtained his quit claim knowing moth
inp abeu, the fraud. l,c was IN no wa,
responsible for II, and II could not b.
allowed 10 impair lls title.
The ,leeisio,s IN those two casen. ~ M
> paren.ly rimiliai In VII essentials, wcr
somewhat startling, IN tho fret cnsc
In whiah Tho orinion ~as written \.
Judge Heck, II ii decided TINT nciihc
quit claim deed Or tho assignment b
a iax certificate conveys - tbe aDigcc
" purchaser, Il Luilcr title than hi
, seller had; tho title Ii ~ stronger |,
tho hands u the treoni Icrtpn than !
was III thu hanas II thu first, nna !
,uLjeel 10 10 nssnie,l ~ tho otipnn
ftunI; while In thu Int ensc. opinion
III ~ Cole, tho decision II esneil, ih
!. opposite On both questions Tho mi
ing |, TINT tho purchaser ~ q Tux ccr
iilsn,e ~ by quit claim decd may ~
Lellsr titls than his seller " assigso
Ind. aud that The sisls thus obtained l
tpf ,uljse. 10 b. aasailsd Tor The orig
lnal fraud.
!. We d. mol perceive. II the facis sv'
. ~ stated by our contemporary, how III
y side difference In The Two decisions o.,
!. b. sseoneilsd, and w hope 10 ses III
matter fully Investigated CessaInl,
. the eosss shssld hsvs decided tho sAm,
In both ssses, while - they stand, NJ
imposssnss ssn b. sltsshsd v sIshs1
= dseislon. IN Judge lSsst's rrobity VI
. have much eonklsnrs. and while u
= muel, eanno. DO said for Judge Cole
w l,ops. for tho saks u tho good fam
n Tho Hate, thst Tho charges brcugh
against tho court may 10 found 4
have bern founded On . falys conccl,