, 1875-03-16

,,stelorcd such slate al facts ns lnslticd mr,
believed, III what enhl. 1 told thcin They did
1,nt tun,w thc story Us told mo By Garrcater. J
thu !sloa Of turcl,aein5 tho New York Ejprcss
tnsninz 1t f,lo 4 n,orning Iarcr. and putting
1'occcr ut tho head Of it, and I'll tha ''aa 10 f,c
dono Gil tho strength nf theso papers. Hio,''-
ton then told m9 lint Hin was not all the htufy
At Tits roint tho us,tal rcccts ,Saa snte1,.
After lilo rccosH Bc!rtl.;'t droe: examination
was contlnrcd. l1o said ieucatca 10 I1ltni1
what Carpenter said aaont Aaonl:o', occupying II
medium position between the pasiien, and nc.ils
us friend in TIC matter. carranlcr, told I'll
ton had sath .InHltau was representing tho
]}7oo..!yn friend, Of Tii!on. Tllton did no. naaka
Eny ror1y that can reHemtcr. neyerrcee!sed
.riso or calling TIl.on matchmaker. haa
tam tam o.ton amt ncury Gtcwa nere
tl,on present. 1il:on Afterwards fkowsa
inc check for e7,no1 f.o,n Dowou as e:ttic-
,ns:lt Of his tliicnltcs with lin. aisi hs sl9wnA
tae etn:s,neu. IN be :ui.shed b. f'*Nl .lcH1nr-
il. tim. et.lp:nei,; lad l.cn H:!'. 10 alio
rlnlc.l
,owrs WOULD pun1.laIa srAr1:,u.s1
Of The aan,a clsaractcr T!lton eaitl il shslaurn
TT u,lc t,n,p that untas Justice val t!tTl. linn !ie
1lal tho power to bsuw tho roof Oh I'ymonth
Church.
office, think, nbont mouth 1ofte ho c1l.lp-
tied to mic tho E9won c1ecE. Do tl,s rc1lrmber
tho scar. Iharc cconycryed during lis iutoruiission
Of tl,o Court viii, Inv partner uMd II. IracY., Do
not seco'l:ct The tlao ut which Til.'1 showed MO
lii, check. lie raid: II hayo HI tied tito Whole
controversy with tlioso Drvollyi fellows, and
Thought thou1 down to thci' narrow" fie
tbcu showed n,o a rt1sc'ncut 10 nas to pnbl1ssl
III his paper, anti either bllnscd ms tho Uno
];owcn TaH to i,llbIlEli or Eelreu Its substance 70
mo. Tic iuscrylcw prcyiou.,t to Tic exhibition Of
sHe check vnA IN my ollicn. 40 Person wSa fires-
~: but Tllton mid ny,slf. Tho usual c!es!;s
employed III tho ollicr acss 'u tue outside pt1-
f,ntf t1tar k0trt tk,1
o>nlyc1satlon lcsai,. or how the subioct opalled.
1iIto,, came in alIl began tlis usuat topic of tho
E.aoksyn diIlic.sty, referring to lis bein,
s.uuged md hsakon down. / aAkcd him II lle
Ills Wife, and to loso up, and, swinging Lis arms
nrolal III y theatrical u,suncrt rep.snd: My
Nife 10 as pars ~ an angel" Tho reuark abolt
llovlu3 tho roof oil tho church CAME In In
fi.e ccnuoct.ou III which It wna introduced. Tho
witness wuS pressed by alr. Dc1ch Tor sumo fir.
ts:cr sehtI;aoay Of ills cunvcrsat'on but wisncas
replied he did not remember auytliing further.
1Aa wiincs3 then continued: I do not rcmcrn-
hcr at ny fist interview wits Tston that he dis
tai!ltd the li1lt Of Carpenter to lcpresetl, Inn.
Lu:icr aud Watson wefo present At tho iuteryiew
iu the Enicn League Club. Mpu'ton may hnYc
S'l:l that Carpenter hal no right ,to, REPRESENT
l.l:4hher at tho iutcryicw that Tl:cn refused 10
s,c connected with Tic newspaper cntcrpr1ae. nor
ho remember that he refused TO bo OIL any
l,eTa!5arcr with which Dccc]ler WIS connected,
Tie tutcrviow with Carpenter when Nr. 0tton
and alr. Clows weru present wns batwacn tue o0th
Ct December, 1879 md the lst Of JANUARY, 1a71.
after this Ind NIL interview with Tiltoi. nbout
tho c'lntee Of blackulai!. At almost all those
Interviews tho subject master OF
THE CHARGES or BOWEN AOA1SsT rREC1lEn
wcre 1lEclitsed, Itoy WcEG talked over onto ~
NY hoaao uit-r Woodruff ha1 gone awny. 10
hut ieMci1ter II they Wero talked over Ut tho
tniou League Olub wLen Watsun and But!tr
tsTfaf \ it3ftt fS Tfp&fh
Cie''s MAS there. Do nos rocolloctI II 1lr. porgo.
LIANT waa thsre, but Mr. Urton Vas. Wl!on tia
Giarusnon was getting bitter, I cntoayored to
luoicratp It.
TLia luie!,c,l TIC croes-o1aminatiou. aud
Tracy handed witness iI1wet'A check fur 5I,UgU,
Which lie statol ho cunld not ltlpntlfY.
Ea.irf:t: never tald Tlton at any inter-
v.o5: t!las Tho ilcws},aper cNterpriyo Nus good
nu;lc. ,n9l circulated through tho Ci"t, mud cra-
escd = great deal OF discussion. TE!s coNvcr.a.
t,Jsl Eaont tht newspaper tn.trp.iko was only
si:c:s t;lnc bafole The atar.tBg Ut tho H0!ien
-1:t.
i}"craaa: Tho ano1ogy mado for calling
~: II biscktnaiicr supposo waa also pIrculnt-
~ IL tho Club.
cHAi,tEs 8. .upsox
w:y mast called, au1 tcAlsltd: I reside In
Ser in1!:. aud have done 60 for twenty or
t"c,te-.iyc years. / have known Uoecher t"onty
years t.aA 1il:oa about fsf:een years. / am q
merchant, aad conduct business III Hosih street.
Lad cu.irelnat!on wlli. Tilton ii DclMonico'a
l'.oItl tho end OF 1tSl, wtaso No a,ncd together.
so hal 4 conversation abon. Beccher una Mcn1-
lcty Of Plymouth Church, At TINT interview
only remenbcv discussion about
Ecccl1cr, and Gad Ucccbcr 1lal o4caped
I'll charges, 10 far Ms wOHlot Tero cuHccs1.cd III
I'll tho sIsuo hc had been thoEc. Ifton said ho
had lost all faith iu tile man. said tis meal.t
hcIucthtns, md asked him fur ~, explanation.
Ir. lcuch hero nroso and ob1ec,ed 10 thsA limo
at examination as nat rert!uent and mnterial 10
III Nh Il in - n y
said tEiry wuultl olTcr soineli!ng lsero+ttpr that
world teTolop tho naaterlality Of this line u OK
pIniassion.
ondEo Seilaou decided o. allowing tho con-
VIBRATION.
Tho nltntss continued: Toall my inquiries ho
till replied: 81 hhyo lost Ill faith iu tho mat."
T!ton called on mo two Or three days after ti,at,
and asaod mo II saw beeehor. i batd I Ind,
dayn ago, and Tl.on asl:ed w!ly, mt! 1cpi.ed,to
put him oil his guard that would liaya douo
tae aa.ao thing b. linn, ant, llo a!:11 l,o always
conaiderca mo friend, ana left. This concluded
tho witucss' testimony.
Mr.. Beach moved 10 str!lo It out.
Judge Scilsola Haid he would Let it stand. IN
he thought 1t was about Ut hAr1utoes as u lamp
post. tLEushter.l
1lr. l.yatlH hero roso and t0ots exception to
tAc te1laI OF tho Court u:''| stated that before
they "clc throuI!l they Would ehDw tile Matc.
t!allS Vt this csidencc.
ARCHIBALD uI.ACX,
rth'len. Of D.ooilyn atsa merchant in New
iol4 waa then callsd, and rclsted :. conressa-
t1on witt. ,ioaIton at tie Exchange, In whcI.
tho ':ttcr had said tha& tho hesE conrnu for
l;.ucacr 10 purnno nisdcr tlIe charges would be
tu keep s!ont and that II Ills lie was not euf-
ilr;cns atls"er to these charges ho {Aou!ton)
ND nut know what mar. Tbs wtsrna Bntd
:" MoHston told mo that II tho story wna Untrue, to
publish 1t would bs dabollcal. Ho int.ulatoi to
NO That might uao this information ho had
l;,.o,l ,ne among my friends In the Church of tho
lrli;rilns." Al another inscryiow, 10 told hiul
that all tho clargcs esatlBt l3ecclcr
had ctlYnnted with ouo ludlYnIunl,
who had nikucd retractton ct them, At tho
tud ,n!crvisw At the Esrhuuge. t,o aa4cd me il
ltwas true tAtt Doechern hnnle had been ncraped
OF d nat!ce read in the church Of tho Pilgrims,
kaa told hsn, no. also told him tAat this
story was srrcading. anu f,o aud his !s!cnia wero
Isinx no afEor!B 10 check it. tlonlson pail l!s
Eau WA touched. uul l.o would toll suo vi! TINT
10 knew all about it, a.,!l that neech.r
WAS pure mai, asked lin did ilo
snean thut lseechor was nat guilty
Ut violation nf tho seventh commandment, anil
Ira replied, after d li;t!o hesitation, ~ TO-"