New-York tribune., 1875-01-23


3d. 1873 or May 3D. 1873 the 5000 which he didn't know any
thing about however
Mr. Beache is giving the capital instead Of OF
venue.
Mr. Tracy-He not giving the OF income ImoVe
that tho last answer OF the witness be stricken out.
Judge Neson-The words he did know anything about
Ii are stricken out.
Mr. TacyThat S5O0-you refer 10 the s. 900 which came
from Mr. Beecheri A. refer TO the 5000 that Mr. Beecher
gave for him; yes, Sir.
@ Have you named all the OF that he
had your knowledgei A. don't know whether the book.
Sir Issued" Tempest Tossed issued before May s
1874 or not-whether he had finished 1t.
O. Well do you know whether he had received any income
from before May 1s 1874 A. don't know whether ho had
received any income from that or not
@ you know whether he receives any income from the
Golden Age whether it failed 10 pay expenses A. J don't
know that Of my own knowledge Sir
O. Have you named all the sources Of income that Mrs
Tton had your knowledge A. or income-I think have
yes Sir.
Q. Does that include borrowed money! A. From me'
O. From anybody. Does include your borrowed money that
you loaned him A. Idon know have not mentioned that
Sir; there not 80 much OF that, find.
O. In addition TO what you have mentioned were your loans
to him : A. Yes, Sir.
@ Had he any other Of income to your knowledge
A. Not that know OF.
q, No other loansf A. From anybody eises
O. Yes Sir. A. Not that know Of.
O. No other applied the support Of The Golden Age
A. None that know Of.
@ What amount OF income did be receive from your oans
A. have had 1t examined Sir and l cannot
determine that had accountant told Mr.. Porertha
would have him look the books but there nothing by
which could be guided, Sir.
O. Have you brought your books here' A No, have not
brought the books here
O. thought you bring the books here OF Woodruff
Robnsons Do you OF his having any income from lee
"A ha hplia laYe n
from lectures which did not recall when answered
your question.
O. How much, A. don't know.
O. What years, A. My impression that he ectured in the
beginning OF 187 Sir and in the Winter OF 1871 aud the Spring
OF 1872; think won't be certain about that
O. Now do you know whether his lecture seasons did or did
produce any income! A. They did produce some, Sir
don't know how much
q. You do not know how muchl A. No.
O. Now have you named allg A. think have, Sir, far
as recOlect
O. Were your firm his bankers during this time, A. lie bad
money deposit Sir, with our firm.
q Had he any other bank account to your knowedge A
don't know that he had
q did stand in Aprl2d 5th is it, when
he received and deposited with you, Of s7,OOO'
Mr.. Eullerton-Ths appears by the account ITSELF Sir.
Judge Neilson-There both accounts there.
The Witness cannot state from memory Sir.
Mr. TacyI will show you the account How often had you
loaned him money should you say during this time A Not
very often, Sir.
@ Loaned it on his application A Sometimes asked him
II he wanted any money.
O. And if he said he did you loaned to him. did you' A.
Yes, Sir generally.
Q. What amounts have you loaned him.
Mr. Fuleron-That is all gone over, Sir.
Judge Neson-Yes Sir; "When he wanted money gave 1t
to him, )" he said, and generally in currency"
The WitnessMr Porter asked il exceeded 5000 and
| answered him no, Mr. Tracy.
O. Mr. Tracy-In the aggregateg A Yes Sir he asked me
il it exceeded s. 900 dollars in the aggregate.
@ Now ask you what is the largest amount you loaned
him at any time . A. Idon't recOllect.
Were these loans Independent OF your contribution A.
Yes. Sir.
@ How large the largest you recollec of ioanng
him any time A. Idon recoect Sir anything about
it, what the largest amount.
O. Do you recOect Of oaning him as high as 500 at any
one time
Mr Morris-Your Honor Is this to be gone over again 1t
has all been gone with particularly.
Mr. Tracy gone just every other subject
has been gone over
Mr. Fulerton-That is
Mr. Tracy-Judge Porter asked two questions about
the fact whether he had loaned him money.
Judge NesonOh more than one or two questions; he ex-
amined him much thn his judgment the point called
for.
Mr. Tracy-Our recollection is that he only asked him as to
the aggregate and nothing to the details That is
recollection our side.
Mr. Morris-It is q mistake.
Judge Nelson-He asked him as to loans.
Mr. acy-So Judge Porter tonched every point generally
Judge Neon-I said you could ask him this question Per
haps that will satisfy you
O. Can YOU state whether you ever loaned him high
$500 at any A. cannot, Sir but can state that
never loaned him exceed $780, think at any time
O. VIII you look the account and tell whether his
count with Woodruff Robinsons oyerdrawn at the time
he received the money from Bowen 1t would sppear from
this Sir that the account oyerdrawn s56i.3s
O. At the time he received the $1,000 OF Bowen! A. 1t
would appear so.from this, Sir
O. Now Sir from the account when was that $1,000 ex
hausted and the entire amount in your firms hands belong
ing to him exhausted!
Mr. Fullerton-I dislike trouble your Honor with objec
ons but it does to that this is waste Of time
the figures which prove whatever they do prove
and there b necessity for any ones swearing to them
Mr. Monis-The account has been read in evidence Mr.
Tracy
Mr. Tracy-wen but the balances.
Mr. Morris-Yes the balances every item OF the account
both sides
Judge Neson-You might substitute the word Withdrawn"
for exhausted"
Mr. Traey-Yes the senographer may change the question
The Witness add up your last question
Mr. Tracy-Yes fit will take too long. Don't it show
it show readily
The witness-what is the last question, General!
Mr. TracyWhen the whole amount withdrawn A. The
account seems to be closed on April 2lst.
Q. When the last item withdrawn; when did he draw
the last OF that account Sl7O4S to have been
drawn here April 2ist, 1873
O. When the next to the last item drawn' A. Decem
Der 2lst-December 9th, according to this accounts
O. Now will you tell whether that did not withdraw the
entire account A. The account eems have been balanced
on April 2lst, 1873.
O. ask you to tell US whether when he drew the 9th OF
December the draft he had anything remaining and, il so
how much! A. When he drew the draft the 18th Of De-
cemberi
O. Yes Sir? A. Iwish.Mr shearman would add this up;
cannot see my eyesight is not good enough.
Mr. Eyarts-We will verify IL.