New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-02-19

Speaker, with oil kindness 10 every
party Whips hs or follow ont the dictaon. q Ta%~aDy
or Sy S5asr gss4o 10 as 70 pnp let
these gentlemen arise 10 his place aud te US nah IL
nns tor s biz S IN ; pus snss
and weighed and, II found to be xaa; t9n dasire
But these gentlemen talk about the people wanting
this b the people wanting that and ono O., man aron
dack region do not want bill passed IN the Cy o.
NewYOrk All cd eapandum tak and so lar ns s any
thing the BILL let us go down 10 n me
n part Of the majority this know
Intimidation on tie part Of Tamnany ha oh;eepioaSbe
The bill that they presented v ssTs
has been upon the files OF members iSr WSe 10
proposed o. regard !. as ss
isactory to the party but when the bill Is moveu 'os
gentlemen talk about TammaDy Hall Inc hson uys
gerel poetry which has been read here nst tSs
bill why should wonder is next Winter, On .h pe
strength Of the reception We have r SsssyaS sf from
steuben will ask that THE Legislature shall receive p,p
rising poet, while Mr.. Bryant is a setting one Laugh In
teri This gentleman has written speech w nic
pose he intends TO send around among DIS IT,,
and 1t contains, as have SAID, great many "
Mr. shattnck--I never paid out anything to nave
Mr. Maccuire~I will state that II the gentleman wi,
will print 1t free. Iaugter.] What was going 10 sg
this that the gentleman intends q, To- be has
made containing the statement that was In New fok
last Saturday and Sunday receiving Instructions irO'
Mr. shatiuck-I did not make that remark
Mr.. Magurewhat did tho gentleman mean 'T Tem,
He Yesterday made the remark ab0nt6ny Den2 ~ '"n
many Hall last Saturday and last Sunday. . -, nv
Mr.. Shattuck-I do not care wnat theS no WIZ, ny
Mr. MaGuireThat is not tine question asked ,a ne
question what he meant by anGnG 10 and ny receiving
Instructions from Tammany Hall. That Is the quesuoh
Mr.. shattucR~My remark In regard to that was that
il has reported that the Speaker had beeo III
NewYork several times during the making Up Oh ano
Committees of tins House, and since mat Hne upoh
questions OF this character and TINS Oh, III &
do not say that know this OF my own kno"ledse pu'
that is the report that comes TO me. .
MIR Maguire-And so the gentleman, IN his character
legislator. thus casts an imputation upon neUsp
upop mere report. The gentleman might easily ha'o
found out whether had been to New YORK OF nor a""
snppone was what has rnoor 20, 70 40 To-, WIN
that the gentleman went 10 New-forh anu cohsu"eo
Tammany Hail. have done him no injury. Ia main
Mr.. Magure-The gentleman told us that Ne wac III
his quiet home last Saturday and Sunday instead OF be-
ing At Tammany Hall receiving instructions; Has Inc
Mr. shaituck tsotto voce)--At Church, hope
M @ hope the Iaa un m ahe S s .,
was preparing last Sunday for INC acton OF THIS Legs
latUre.
Mr. Magure-And, undoubtedly then. il the gentle
fDds that 1t is Democratic measure. nc WI tnnK
IL n good excuse for opposing IT, because on that day
was in NewYork, and might nave Deeh re, re-
ceiviDg instructions from Tammany Hail bnt
do say Mr.. Speaker and gentlemen, that nn-
Democrats who intend TO vote against rms bil give
sfituents will hold them responsible for their votes
sna wait very ne re MADE ny to 6
pie OF local seligovernment. It won't answer
v io tn get up ibis long talk about the people
Tie of understand what the people want as well
%u SG as he does and take hs whole S.
members who propose TO vote for this blli under any
hnu muc w
from Washington apprehen1. Permit me TO gay, 10
whether It is passed now. or whether " Is passed
tomorrow. or defeated DOW, or defeated 20.
1E,s Si intend ses 70 %aniSy Il
Tys 90 TSey VIII Why not be- s%erSed from voting
bill under any talk about T1mmsny Han %, or
talk about ~ Rsat the he G does no, w
They will here stand and do what The people
publican expressions and Republican msrule, TO give
local scfgovernment TO the City OF YORK. and Tee
do not do that these gentlemen Will md ont
That the people will hold them responsible
of the people are upon and they are watching rs
agree with him to that extent and the people OF his
see that he has left his party become the leader
the Republican minority upon this l39r Inefe rs no
OF Tie gentleman from Washington to-day IN every
that he aes IN neger9 r To nv 1s Se S
friend from Onondaga Mr Alvordl and my good iriend
from @ ~ s nnry and aSs Eve place to
iIe gentleman from Washington. lGreat applause in
M. Wusted3Mr. Speaker, rise TO point OF order
II this applause IN the galleries u Cpeaed Ins 1dy or
any other day. shall move that the galleries DC eeareu
Mr.. m9sure-I agree with the views of the gentleman
from Westchestcr tMr Husted) IN that respect.
Mr.. Alvord-I rise TO a point Of order. NY point OF
that the gentleman now occupying tne Snau
Inc applause repeated the galleries would be ceard
ana call upon him now 10 fulall his promise lap
TIC Speaker pro ten,The serreantat Arms viii
that order j. maintIned aud strict order y hov i
tanned the SrrgeantatArm aud the DoOrkeepcr VIII
clear the galleries.
pose to add the name of Abram Hewitt OF New-iorK
as a member of the Commission, and further amend me
of %areH instead Of on the 10th Of April The honorable
gentleman (Mr mcGure), IN his kind ann poh.e way;
the House l. SIR wish 10 inform the gentleman from
Chemung QMr. Msguire) that whenever lead ID any
that 1t will he plain that good men OF both parties
Will follow it, III what have intended TO do hereto
tHc be, men Of both parties But Sir my reason for
this bill 6eeause y not ot Saa
home rule, as the gentleman has undertaken TO say
that he cannot Establish home rule IN this State
- single municipality in this State, without consulting
sI hers Provision in this BIZ that refers to the
wishes Of the people Of Newciosk ~ t5et rsspeHs
the peops Of as d sa d 81 beS S sy
ton their chosen delegates assembled 70 draft con
which should DC Dsss SS 10 t6s
people and by them ratified, iand their act
the highest act Of Sovereignty they can do
was to establish q basis OF local self-gover nmenf
Ana, Sir In no other way local sefgovernment DO
10 this any other State IN this Union, IN
the municipality OF New York, or In any other nuncl
paty this State. Tnis bill has never been submitted
10 me people OF the City OF New-YOrk.
Mr.. T. j. Campbell-Supposing the bill is amended 10
conform TO the views Of the gentleman from Washing.
ton 10 this respect will he promise TO for the Oil
IL Ia submitted TO the people -.
Mr. DavisI will vote for any bill which gives 10 the
municipality OF New-York local selfgovornmen1; but,
Sir local seifgoverDmeut must DO secured py tne