, 1875-06-24
BEECHER.
Mr. Reach Closes Ills Arg1l-
Incmt Tor the Iroxc.
caltiOn.
dnothor Batch Of Citations
from Beeoher's Ser
mons.
Which Arc Vigorously Objected 10
by Counsel for The
Defense.
Mr.. Beach Applaudel OF the Close
Of His Eloquent Per-
oration.
Tie Prosecution Submit Aflidarits Regard
lug Rewiy-DistoYercd Evidence.
And Make an Application for a Re-
opening Of tho Case.
The Decision Of tho Court Will
He Made Known To-Day.
Chtcagoans Who VIII ltclp Tilton DefraJ
tho Expense Of Mem Trial.
Tie Prosecution Submit Affidarits Regard.
lug Aewfy-Distoyered Evidence.
And Make an Application for a Re-
opening Of tho Case.
The Decision Of tho Court Will
He Made known To-Day.
chtcagoans Who Will Help Tilton Defray
tho Expense Of q Mem Trial.

eEAcH CONCLUDES.
WHIT Is SAID OF THE EFFORT.
Spectat Nspdteh to The Chseag0 Tribune,
New YonK, Juno 23.--h{r. Hoaoh concluded !lis
argument this afternoon, having spoken ten days
instead of tho threo to which ho promised to
conflno hlmsatf It Ia not generally thought
among tho profession that Beach has dono him.
solf full Justice professionally. Ills high ropu-
tatton has lcd the public to anticipate moro
passionate and eloquent presentment Of tho
caec, bnt the bad example set by Evarts and
Porter led him into di1fuBeness, which weakoned
thu argumont.
SUGGESTIONS AB TO THE JUDGES CHARGE.
On tho conclusion Of his argument tie plain
Til announced that TO had no requests
to Charge to oTer, and tho defondap&
then oiforod about fifty, accompanied by
hbont 200 opinions from various authorities.
Thor length and character led tho plaintiffs
counsel to protest against their being offered, ~
in fact q roargumant Of tho caao, aud the Judge
dlsmissod tho majority Of them with tho remark
that thoy vero divorce casa opinions with uhch
ho was already familiar.
Much to tho geuoral surprise, Mr.. Beech thon
made M oiIer to
nEopgN THE GAZE
to admit Of newly-found evidence Tho Judge
Instructed him to npply In Chambers, the proper
brunch Of the Court with which to mako such ap-
plications. Mt. Beach then haudod up num-
her Of afldavits, which tho Judge took for OK
animation. No action will bo taken by him uu-
til tomorrow.
Application to Judge Nelson and Mr.. Morris
for copies Of tho afiidRyita On which the motion
for new trial Ia to bo based was donietl. Tho
Judge had not examined them, and would not
till tho caso oa1no before him at Chambers to-
morrow. Lii. Morris refused to give the copioH,
ssying tho contents wore not to bo msds known
n;shsd tha, -. ~ ~ ma,, 4ssN nn nv 'ut-
nlsnea 'ae'a ~ sae AeFo'@' 'ooge Neilson lndi-
ea'ea .,.........---.... il
In rnnnen tbe rnsc hv .. vim I'm ch.ron u.v,5
be- tat,vcred to,morrov morn;no s,,a tbo c.aa
~ ae'.''so ~, to.uoA'o" Anos''A"s' @nu a14e case
given 70 tne Jury she eamo aay.
Thcre aoolns to ho little doubt OF yordict for
Laugh - IL. idoa nf ,ljs,uraa mani.
and plaintifYte COUNSEL vlo. fhron vnaks
AGO .a,d that a ,l,aor,oomcnt va ;nov;t~
~, s,n' .s sst,.' oos t "es 4"o' w
.y!1' ., a.e Nv" ~ ~ no@us sansa'nU " thls.
trial by reason Of disagreement. This d!strust
is general and lstlo oHort IL made to conceal 1t,
LII, Deach's ill-aayisod, jotouporato abuse Of
~. 4,,-ors a., tnsi,,,,.. .;nn. ~ 1'.,,.s' ,,,sa
a1sa''y inlotea tae ohaaces OF plaansln' Tor 1t
sppoars that tho action Of Jurur Hull In remon-
atrstinr wss previously spppoyed by the whole
tselyo.
INIT. "
1ap Iue " ,;1,f Aetos:a'fa "a a., trxas! nas
Nvv yopx Jnno - Isas.hor n,a Ria
vito caaa isIto to co.,rt. Az aIso ali qs IL
tnn Etro ~ .'ro.eer.o i.s 90 @'nH ~ ~ -
En-taS s.ot..r sas @ hhi. .i6 7" n"sA'
tHor H. ss.r, 49, 'aS sahn IL o9nat.
thn. T.; -n+as' -. ,n 1Hu9a' I.s G'at.e aa 1hAs
rao;scI 4ha3r "i,or1,a. .rd 3t,.t a{ naa
waa 1ci,vnrad tnw ,en',a s ~ 'uy
Sir' pcac1 ,hco cont,nnoa ,,,u .7aro.. ,ra
h,a Hrot atsoo. 1oa 1sa ~. e rot1ss, ana
il rnnIs ~ ha ;,v,t."o - " a., a neocus. t1
io1ai t1,a rora 1.ars s.,d hn 81. 49, VIZ
xith ~ liz, NY o4'u''" ~ eo'o'aano Ao 1o''o"sn'p
"''A LLAMA oor.nu.x ,.,vors
~. e,,,r,,ssa unIahnAS 4aasS,a 9HEot; IT, .u.,,.
s-or, AZ sa-."nrs ~ ,ant,,ts 91s @ t. nts.oua
80 ~ Hs.',S.s sh.t ~ - s'I - A.4' tseoottots
svi1annRo - s9an" '1~' 'Ao5 IN" no' oeea p1Ae"o III
=, H1 T.. ,,,,,,...a .L,. .
ans n,.do raw .rst.,,a III t4o Ieeo qn9sa
ss.donrn tbn irv ,,,n,t cn,syona NV III, ~
eouao u sns sestnony Ma'uh "As u avlaehee.
.rtdnnna IN ~ t eo,,ttr nos ~
vsncnd ~ iii. dato,5ant -' %Aso''os ~
Juf1a Neilson a,'9p"stad th.t Mr.. sbe.,o,r
coria U.Sn ohac5,,'a 1,,sa ~. nssah atau ~,
tntnuoh nd NJ no.o mnen ~ . t, eAoa Eos
tsu. sIn 49,. . u0or ot.An NY WIZ
s"d nS.,ianns EE;,r 4nosano4s 4a'a 20. s!kat,
4o ~4ona. sA1'4''"s' "s'4A - p'''e 'nA' 'ney &'o
| 1r,f.. NAEf.ar r.,fsI 41.A
Nesson ..xt 'Alas ~. nnehtn1An op
11ins.d -" s'1.ass - oA"oA "Aon M'' oosen
w" " a. phssrtnsr s.;d b. v,,,d .r. ~
@.aio, neaaxn eo o.su 70 "onla onef 20 o.
3sonnu ~ esely 4uo.a.'on laaos ny conosel 1fon
"A~' N"~e .~ne
w. n..,. ...a noae ae.>.i,..,a! r.,
III :,o ne@in a saSn son'e s tt nas unAuons, ena
w In T. neevaes EYE % .ns. Many Rafss OF shs
tNs9. N 4e.tsont uasn stu"a III ~; Auu a1a OUT OF
aaI eouhse. sa.u tnA., ultney eoaaa st1ike
W. mls&!ss' o. tnese ostaemeea G o. taa 4oahead
w45 aoe stHks Gus tne Setnlon on the Monht and