, 1875-03-25

TO Mt EdioT Of Tie EhicaRo Tribune:
et1fcAHot March 2i.-Aftcr aororal days' incu.
batiot'. Mr. Shntc1dt again strikes at tho rfo,oc.
| tiois Lille insurance Compnny; but hag lIe not
broken looho In an entirely now spot7 Sir. sht,.
| ta'dt would ignore the past issuos anil seeks to
| dispose OF tho question with thu assertion TINT
| ho las charged fraud aud aldl,ccd proof, Now,
| what arc tho facts? Sir. H!,ufcldt CHARGED tina.
the Protection Life insurance Company collected
! moro money by assessments than ii necessary to
| fay dcath losses, aud inBtaucad "how It migt&
10 DONE
n reply to this foul aspcseion, Oh tic 18th
| said: 'Ao 10''
Thu Protection Life Insurance ,,omn,nr I. ,,t,,
business far, hnucst. n,I legitimate urr,u Eouu,!
aFis md fnrnirAing indemnity for unc-lalf tbe rtat
y aly initial life iuaassnco company in the Uuci
na1ea 1bla rroiDstOu stand frady verify aud
lhe stockholders pledge their tetsoa1 honor atI rr-
ra Tste 1neans to "ubstsntlate tho proposition.
Iae eofnafy assessment close.l the lll inst
The s,ookh nsu halate. aud arr onon for insrc-tor
M Me challenge "ticorac a. Shu!cslt. Jr.,' or my
n,nes nun, u ret o! e to establ l:ah tho Charge
has snade or seanA convicted fals1er hafore liz,
world N Wal
Now what docs 3lr. shugoldt do? Does bo
ondcayor to set himself riyntf On Tho contra-
ry. seeking to reiteraso tho malicious fabrica-
t1una, Ae must stand in tho attitude Of one who
iallinE to sbstantiato falHe allegation, accepts
tho rcrerse Of the aptfthes,a.
or4tnarlly tho question Of personal character
%oa 9s, ase ~ 70 Part ~ tle controversy but when
Heeks to foul tho offending party by raktua
charees az fnsc Oh malicious, atld whom rroof ID
dea,atded seeks to hide himself bebnd ti,o fIi,n
~ reply. :, have falsicd. there is REMEDY"
WelE kliaTins that no corporation could enter
tho lists In aacl, controversy ucainat ~, nd,.
v!dnsl efenli ho wero Responsible, what cou.yo
| Bhall DO purdnedf
| - may bc," BARS Mr.. Shufeldt, IN bIack.
n,aser. .'nn,eE n 1fd my hc intAtic but Inv that
0ohoD9 OF fraudulent policies" etc. "is heyoud
my comprehension" Establishing tile fact al
hiS being "a blackmailer ani !uslatlc" q" had
| nothing 70 do with dlsprovinE tho other state.
] 18Th regarding the issuance OF fraudulent pol,-
! cie8:
assert that tlia Company ucycr wrote 4 no.y. or
covered ssk y o'lo. nr anywhere oIsc e1tept i,io
wrten application ou the Colranss h.uks. together
.,a M,au i1rsosss shan.a:iun an q r'p1;,le Ihss-
or ~ o fnn.,r ~ ~ HALO. ~ !hs Medical Direct
VIA, .,,,a 49,, ~ 10y .1,I. ao''ss ol''e.
~ the c,' M.S vau ~ a.spresel-ahd tue records
a ,;,,,o eo,,".' ~ nts rpe. uSs 'msecaon--t will
XII 'o n,e enough mn' ,ot ~; shaedi to symsashize
w. ra,,,,.n, ,, mnoH1 toaay na dehR nhtes ne
M Me.iv,o 1'nt Hno,s al'a 'aas wses said ho
lis,.. The rfotestion ,Ss Life lnsaranee Comp.nys
unsiehs aaS oeeh olosl 10 IT" po!lcy-,o!dors frvm
Ho IN nn ncn ~ o'hea coa.lAlY over tlld it. Tho
.u.otv u. aea9n ioahcs 1nonttoncd III tho letter
'a.', mn.u 'unas on nana "nen tho 1resont MANAGE
!HG"s aea1cu Hn cphtto's d1I!uE tna panic III the
iall o' 1n'j' una "efc pnla OH by tho mahngo-
!neIt tncn hla assessed for IN the carly part of
!ois' ooFegat claltnh oi donbttu caarncter being
pressod upon tue Company at tl!iH time (sono
Two years afo] were Bottled M the beat terMH
tnat contd be male, The Company holds re-
copss tot eeveral falE-naid clain,s, which havo
never bocn Assessed. aud nliclt tho membership
viii never be callod npon to pay. Ia not N1F.
shntadt ~ tho condition Of tlo othor party 1nen-
taaned. WHO, le saya, - weso rcd-l,ot 10 Eet in r.
I1o plat! Of the Protection Lifo differs from
all other hfo companies. Its actua''coet systcm
'.old liners, and demorailzcl thor tlock5. Take
tho year 1874. where son,e fifteen For moro
months mortality wna assessed and collected III
twelve, and tho ontise cost fur death Losses OIL
- 800 policy, ut tho ago Of 40 waS *3i.70, nara
bio In smali monthly assceHnesta. averaging
less than e3 each, while tlo mutual ratio, for Tho
sa1no ago and amouut, IL s79.15, all payable IL
advance. Now, II the Protection IL swinaltng tts