New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-01-20

he didn't want 10 tell Well said "Why did You send
the letter through Bowen, no party to that demand
why didn't you get his signature told him he fool
sending such letter without the signature Of Mr. Bowen
Was that your conversation that he fool for sOnd
Ing III A Yes, Sir; without Dowoa's signature.
Q Go A And he said that Mr. Bowen had promised 10
furnish him the evidences
Q On that occasoni A. No Sir wheneyerlt was necessary
to enforce tho demand Of the letter.
q lie did then he told you that Mr. Bowen In that into
vsw had promised to furnish him with the cvdonces A. Yes
Sir he gave that to for not having had Mr.
Dcwen's signature when that is IL.
Q. AL that occurred al the interview A. And took
memorandum Of what no told bsicvc the memorandum
was published in my statement concerning
Mr. Fulcron-Ncvcr mind that statement
The Wness-Pardon me.
@ Was that the day which you noted the precise hour Of
your entering uponof your bocomng connected with this
CONTROVERSY A noted the precise hour at which Mr. Tutor
gave the information that he gave at that interview
@ What did you note In A. Put on piece Of pspor.
@. Have you that paper A. 1t lie here.
@ Was 1t detached slip Of paper' A don't remember;
the paper will show for itself wrote it down.
@ Have you Il here A. Yes Sir 1t Is amongst my papers
think
Mr. Porte-I ask for that paper.
Mr. Blackwell you entitled to see unless you want
II for evidence.
Mr. Ryarwe have right to Ii 10 determine whether
want for evidence
Mr. Besclr-I submit not
Mr. Eyarts-Weu, 20
Mr. Beach-Yes; Il Is hero
Mt Porter-Is 1t at handf
Mr. Morris-I may take me half hour to look through
here Unless it Is for purpose don't propose TO do 1t
l don't wish TO-
Judge Neson-M Morris desires that oandum should
be made Of particular dates Of the documents desired
TO look for them
Mr. Beach-No this presents aRothOr question II they call
for this paper evidence why that is thing and II they
merely want it from cuo-Ay 10 look at IT, that quite an
other, and shah not furnish it,
Mir EvartsWe shall raise the question until the paper
is here.
Mr. Blackwell, the paper Is here. and when you call
for evidence will look for it, and il not shall moi
Judge Neison-Wol. think II yoa would give mcmoran-
dam of the dates Of the papcr DO prodaced would save
time.
Mr. Beach-It won't any time 1t is likely.
Mr. Fullerton-wc. all suggestion upon that subject has
been wasted so far.
Judge Neilson-what could be done II the paper were
brought here Is quite another hing.
Mr. Fueron-Wcll, tne uo Of evidence is very clear II
they call for it 1t comes
Mt Evartsn would to be very clear from the witness
that he made memorandum the time that have right
look OF for the purpose Of testing his evidence nothing
else.
Judge Nelson-I don't need to pass upon that now.
Mr. BvarThe paper is not here so that we cannot raise
these questions.
Mr. Porterwhst the day and the hou OF the day when
this communication made A. 1t Decenber tho 2Gtb
Sir think, in the afternoon.
O What was the hourf A. Some way around three O'Clock
| think
O. When did you note the bouri A We'll, It was pretty
important communication and made memorandum Of Il
that account,
@ Important your A. No; important to Mr. Tilton.
O. The memorandum made 70. his convenience A l
made memorandum OF because thought 1t worth while
make memorandum OF 50 important an occurrence and as
his friend made IT,
O. Did he ask you to make one A. No. he did not 1t
my own thought.
g. You have vcn all the conversation that occurred be-
tween you that occasion As al present remember the
yes Sir.
O. Did you sec him afterwards before the aotb' A Yes
Sir. did.
@ several times, A. Yes; think him two or three
lines,
O. AZ your house and at hs' A Yes, Sir think at my
house and at his.
O. Did you him on the 9th A think saw hin on
The eth; yes Sir.
@ VIVA, occurred between yon that occasion Where
was that A. Idon whether was the 9th or
not but the interview that remember with him can give
you.
o Where was it think it was my house-Ithink Sc
i think II was at my house.
O. Did he come Voluntarily A Yes, Sir
O. Not in pursuance Of any agreement between your No.
Sir.
@ Nor At your request A. No, Sir
O What took place. state fully? A. At the interview am
speakng OF now told he hal sent word TO MI Bowen
that he asgong Mr. Becch5r within short Time ana
wanted him owen) furnish him with the evidences he
promised him 70 furnish him WITH and that Mr. Bowen had
come into his presence and told M tOn that he told Mr.
Bchcr that he owen said he would dismiss him from the
papers,
@ What papersf A. Dismiss him from his employ. rather
O. What did he that A. lie sal he would not be IN
6uenced by any threat he would do Whatever III ms
hpet
Did he represent that at an interview A Between him
self and Mr.. Bowenf
O. Yes Sir A. Yes cir.
O Was ANYTHING said in connection with the presentation Of
the letter by MI Bowen to Mr.. Beecher' A No. Sir
O. Did you understand the interview after that had
been done? did understand whether was before or
after 1t was the subject have here spoken Of
O. You did not know whether had had not been
there' A. No, Sir.
O. Had he said anything you about it on the a6th'
Mr. Fuleuon-About whati
Mr. Porcr-Abou sending OF that letter to Mr. Bowen
ITO the Wnessl My associate and | don't understand
you right Was this angry interview before or after
YOU understand the had been Mr. Beecher'
didn't understood anything about the note having been dev
cred TO Mr. Beecher at that interview.
O. Was anything further sa1 upon that subject then or
upon any subject A. No. Sir not that remember Of
O. What was said that occasion at that interview A.
That Is the substance OF II
O. Do you say that you have already told all that
was ssid A. Yes, Sir all that said with Mr. Tiiton
O. Did he consult you TO his relations with Mr. Bowen
Did he consult then his relations with Mr. Bowen
No. there was consultation to his relations with Mr.
Bowen.
O. Was there any conversation about the probability OF the
term nstion Of their relations, A No. sir.
@. Aud about the probable dismissal OF MI IlIoh a.
Nothing further than have narrated.
O. Was this short interview with Mr.. Tltonf A. IL WAS
not a very long one ; don't know how long II lasted