, 1875-06-23

. criminal c~;--.. e.,. proo..d'na ss..uts e:f-
hit ths question Il ~hsshsr arty should l. com.
criminal case II not raissd 81 this proseedna.. Il
ta.as parties. ware indctsh un,ier the criminal
so s e III as e qssSs ~ as4s sA i. b s II:
No thsttt seems vesy cls.t to that tAes4 boots
which P,fs.in io tls nsn;F;m.n. = IN prop.
diss'ar ea' them biz pFirtts boats or not, are IN.
n!opss sas.cts Of ...Inns.laa end.s tha o,4e, Of
hla truth&uJ kert ,hs ioots which sht lax reaurfa
hin 70 kee: ant hA conducted hs buajnss. - dis
The set Of jnns n, 1914, Amending Tho ous.ou,s
psosaes ri ,s nh :eeos. Ts.'n III Iii. stf Id
s H. r. .onsy 10y y
representing tho Government, rhsntver IN blu belle
y 4: % Il: e. eGs Ss
Will tend to prove any allegation made By ths United
aiasea, may mate :, 7fltsea motion particularly
sstuug forth the alleaaoa wbieh hs sIpsc,4 10 roys
and oreupop II: oog.t e. n Eaeh sait or proeyss1!pa
as|sna.ns or sa.a. produce s sus eSot aSo;e
o. paper court II a.y and hour to b. specified ID
ssli notice. which. soassher WITH copy q saia mo.
claimant by The United s.es Marshal y delivering 10
him certiaed coty thofeof Of o,her~tss stsae Tho
selyei sn1 il e tofcndAht Of clan.nt sha iii Or
refuse to produce such took, insoies, os paper,
. ss1snss IL ssa 70 ss III. 10 ~ e tsn
fu4od unleas us f.'lusd or refusal 10 Produce
ss sa Ss1f1 n;ort.d 70 's9 IA
ai,a be perutd under the d1recllon ol tha Coue 1,
mnlr exa1nsuanon at which examination tle dotend-
ant elana, or or h!s seon' may oe present. et such
lie ,sme In evidence % b4hslt Of lhs Uad Satss.
II, ~ ;sa tsa
tho e.stody Of them, except pahd'ng .hs1f ss.mna-
M il clained ihst tho proys,ons Of this lsv e,,s
tht the control Of tte!s book that L. that
Il" H. nS gh y ,e,s shs ht
Iosss Spon @ lhs I: hs eouse..ou q u t. al sees
isons which iha DltlctAstorney says ths books 1il
10 MT constr1o this law 81 nsecss.rtly implying
that thd Govc.nment ay not examine these books
tho purpose of determining wAethsf thsra IL anything
Il slse. q s s
5s s sess 10 Il T. ~
teforo one Of aoo Commissioners Of thia Court a.
Ses Ssss tx essna1 sn s! ct 4sT
sssE|,;s;a is: ssssesy r @ H. ssss
sqs q hoseFntncI,t books os another vet Of books
srsnt y q oa Saas y ,0TnS ssa
u tho Government boots, Rhonld think II would 10
tho day Of tho court 10 treat tbom a. belhngna 70
ss tlc true Ijssillcry boois. an'"o no Sol"0ftea
THE ORDER OF THE COURT
will be that the IoYka IL question: rather The safes
nn1 vaults III question: lhal be opened In the presence
Of the MaEahaln sud Collectors OF Internal Nsysuus:
!has tue eeolz md parsEa thsron ts taken NJ
thu examination Of The DIt.r1ct Attorney snd sneh
S ~ s S :. hs Eess v
.a a sa pssis1 o
couAael during such examination.
Mr., Ward--At tho openlug Of tho Hafes d.
eiro also that tho EevoRuo ottic0rs 10 permitted
% t9 10 present. q !! my turn cut that t'4erq IL
,lro III thc ordinary sonso for tho purpose Of per-
fecting. that. I suppose. while they are not
nsmsa sxdaS BY your 0nor sho7 will be neaasd In
Iho court-ycry vol. that will DO proper.
the napo1s that tho motion OF tho District Attor-
nay does not sPacity tho books ns the law ro-
qsres. Il seems 10 mo that tho Court ought to
specify what books arc to be- produced.
The Cou1t-I think that ia to be determined
when We ABcostafn wlnt books arc In tlere, Tho
TACT is. these eafes or vaults are part uf thceo
promises which haTe. not been explored. They.
arc: like secret room or cloHot belonging
TO these promises, Which has not boen e1amliod.
and to Which tho oflcora Of the Government
lsvo boen denied accosa. thiut they ought to,
bo qponoa for tho purpose Of such examination.
Mr.. smitts-That do not dispute. Tho point
Is. what books elnll be produced before IIovno7
thosc saios arc 9pcnod aro to, DO produced.
coitaiu2 F'
This Court-Yes, sir. Tho presumption fl that
they holong to tho busine8a OF the dsatiIery. or
copFs9 hcEo. may 10 booAs thoro that 4svs no
application to u but whp can aQtormina. that
before they nro examined, and tho op]y place 20
examine tliom will bo bufore. the COMMISSIONER
Mt. JueBBen-Do we undcrHtaud your Honor to
bold that under tho. law OF 1874 tho Government
liza tho riulk nf. EA}Tunn Orr1btlu, Au{tfn