The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1875-02-05
old who have lived In wedlock quarter OF century,
and have had x or eight children, Of whom halt sur

TIE PAINS s aso CARES or sA.E. ,s , +.
M II ns manly snS ana s1s @
for mental culture than she has and feels himself her
woSn not sc ch r.
Silh worldly wealth. who admires and Is admired BY
%las wss
rsnss%sn. whstev w'n you aaf please ssnie %
. ShSt ssssr,ie You 6now
9s nd ss Sas
the man who has sworn to love and cherish woman
nS Sss @ Se w e VIE.
Hence intensely hate 'ree love" and hate All ncu
ss asss1S' wS:
| Mr.. Shearman-f now read the third paragraph
| OF Mr.. Tilton's repV:-
Just rse ere from your ssssr Is that advocate
nes 'ove' On tue c, .4,rsiy o,,o.,
q so A. Pearl AnSrsw cas
samsnc supreme love Of one man tor one
ny s aSs HS % not SsySsS s o ohs na
& hs s 9y Se% Not Ss
bs s sa " n s Svs snd
."I' rec s 'G 1sisss
snEv fsa Ss a Il u ssss
al n S'A sons w s'si ws
on the few VINO, right from The many
. same 'ns "sSHs %sfa more Rss%
.a sls ws WIN n''
Mr.. Shearman-l now read the fourth and nfrh
| paragraph
BE- rishu!ly ais.oiysa ssSsc dssran ieI'i:!:
saaesy wpis nusoana ana WE r eoin ave- ham am
sood
DacSxTx AND pEAsrIY HUSBANDS,
sss rsSs iiyiae oT nS%sn snail you re-
nsS as sS es IL N
vess Thousands Ct women appealing 70 mercu ana
"a e q
yoa cruelty aagoni ali wonankind ~ SAVING q each
0Slo9uS because nave asked ne law: decars
FaaS you hays iastsHssS married pair who. s,er
n az. % w e. u hs .csy me
has alisi sphere ana sneysd better oppcrtun,
Sasf sasn ana ss
liz ana can 'lS
ssasss show %s i saa
years you and your fellow thinkers sentence her
h
Rss sss
q 's'y
rs WY S1 i ss oS S e as
s.' y's sas 'sxs
written and published your threats that even
RSaa s4y q ss
met, genius would Gown :e;foT
as er oon q s
s
isw''' '
MI. Evarts THERE'S another paper. 1t is an ex-
tract IRON the Troy Times, published in the Golden
a hov Io W., Il
IN evidence this copy Of tnis paper, Mr.. futon
thereby printing this 10 hls people, his public.
tlcles already written In the same tenor, by the
oral evidence OF TINS witness expressing his rea-
right to present to the Court the pub ioation OF
such an expression OF views, without design or re-
proacn, 20 the position Of his paper on that SUD-
Tho Judse-You cam. read It unless 4 appears
y vas publ,shed With bic knowledgs: Ny irisnd,
proprietor Of paper, because the article appeared
! IN the paper without hts knowledge.
/ TILTON SHOWS TEMPER.
| Q. Did You approve OF Its insertions A. Ineither
Golden AGE IKE any Iair MINDED or liberal news.
paper. prints the news That IL an extract from a
msnt, exactly as it would. in the same column,
pIinsan extract from 3ns speech OF Mr. Evarts.
mr. EvsrM makes Wy fsce ana sntvsrs, pro-
The Judge-l. think you cannot read It..
meni. a. nothing Of that Kind has ever been done
Mr. Beach-It proves how you cannot save your.
self from distinction, no matter how you try.
| (LaughterJ
Mr.. Evarts-We can hold the editor respo hsiple
personal them or paSsi they spp.as IL
another source as original matters.
The Judge-That Is q different question
Mr.. Fullerton-lt does not appear that IL orig
Mr.. Evarts-My proposition is that tue editor or
publisher OF pubic newspaper Is responsible TO
~nssher personas writes Them M
! or not. rne very essence and independence Of
Journalism, as now claimed, and It Is not lor me
to say not rightly claimed, Is that there shall be
impersonaltty as 70 what ne wspaper proposes to
SET iorta or to publish. Inc other question, as 10
an extract from newspaper, Is very different.
Mr.. Fuilerton-rhc proposition. then, Is that Mr..
Tilton snall oe judged by everything that appears
IN the Golden Age except trat when is an extract
from another newspaper. That is the proposition
from the other side. and Il Y an extraordinary
bic for what appears In that paper without Ills
authority, without his knowledge or sanction IN
perceive that correspondents claim to write and
TO be heard Ia the public PRESS and they are given
tmsnss are in harmony with that Of the editor i or
proprietor OF the paper, but they may Do admitted
TOR the purpose OF combating them.
TIE ARGUMENTATIvE EvARTs.
attitude in which MIR. Triton and his newspaper
occupied to the subject under discussion, and IN
reference to which the testimony Is pertinent. II
IT be pertinent at all. Having shown that Mr.. TIL
Whatever is the character Of his newspaper Is put.
forth IN Its issues 10 the public, upon which The
! public pass Ia dcnounclng his publications, and hts
position as publisher OF opinions IN this commu-
My falls upon him, not on the question or bis In
/ dividual responsibility as author OF this or that
paragraph but upon MS editorial, hts prOprietorfal
! responsibility. Tor oiffusng these sentiments
through the community.
The Judge decided that the mere publication OF
an article from another paper rests upon the prin-
tected.
/ wltnsss--ln regard to the articles expressed
good deal OF dissent; expressed my regret AZ
written by iavorte orthodox contributor to the
press, 2 writer for the Christian Union and mem.
Der OF Mr.. Beecher's church. (LAughter)
G.. We might as well have the name. A. ask
for Your Honors permission to s1ut out the name
lady
Q. Well, don't know who the lady IT, nor do
care; out It seems to be something disreputable
on the face 81 IL.