The New York herald., 1875-01-19
tiers excluded ana resumed the examination q

49, 49, -" 'S'~.f'u NV e~s"~''"" S'
a9 Un snG,s ysn ,,sssyss Sns s1sEsr ,s
Beecnsr terminaredS A. Yes, SIR. fI ifr
Mr. porter-1 renew tne Offer 70 prove that this
letter The cause OF the discon tnuance OF the
iriendly relations between toe witness and hr.
Beecher.
Judge Neilson-That is shown oy the statement
% After August did you ever enter Mr..
Beecher's house' A. never entered his house
| % Did be visit your house Alter that timer A.
No, sir; not after tnat time.
house q make New Years calls.
| O. Did you ever know him before that day. A.
I never met. him before that day. nor ne me 10
my knowledge.
q. understand that the Inception OF your
riepdship or Mr.. Beecher was on tnat stormy
night when you learned that he mad deeauched
sns ws a G II @ sS Ma
! .s, time when you refused 10 accord MN access
TO- the papers "a err ana documents N which he had In
/ O. wha; time dld you nrst become acquainted
with Mr.. filton' A. became acquainted with
him IN 1880, at the New York Free Academy.
z. AZ any other insututes A. At no oiner tnsti-
were there until 1854, and were classmates part OF
the time. 1i oe
9: We're you very. friendly with him shere' A. 1
q. D,i he do you layors while at schools A. I
dont rcmsmeer saas ne d,a me ,asofs fs.r. o,a
q. Did NOT Mr. Tt!tOn accommodate you and en-
able you to get prize'
When Moulton was asked by Porter II he had
not taken prize at the Free Academy by TuIou
Withdrawing from the competition, Qne OF the
Brooklyn reporters SAID, soto roce:-"Therei
wrote romance 20 that effect one day. and Porter
has been gobbied up oy It," .r fe 4rrr
This probably accounts for Mr.. Moulton not re-
memberng any sucn occurrence.
A. No, sir.
Q. Where did he go when he left tho Academy ?
A. He went into some newspaper ONCE as re-
porter lett school IN 1854 and went to work
win Woodruff Robinson as boy; saw Alr.
Tilton frequently, and our kindly relations con.
tinued: lived IN New York until 1SG3--4. When
came to live IN Brooklyn; had then become a
clerk In the ONCE, and had an interest In the
hrm; alter that time We met more frequently |;
Mr. IIrOn was residing In Livingston street; did
nOs visit his house, though we were. friendly until
1858, and he came 10 my house about that time I;
q. When did you first become banker for Mr..
TtonY A. In 1871 he deposited some money with
Woodrutf Il Robinson. rr
G. Had he ever transacted business with you
before A. He never had any pecuniary business
with me before: never lent HIM money before.
nor do remember doing any business with him
his house before that, and he had been to mine
frequently: he often ate hts meals and slept az my
house; II was about tine lSt OF January, 1871 tnat
he deposited S. 900 with me II was at his instance
made. ..E ..- sr..t t.-+...J d.. II b.
O. was It for any special purpose-tn connection
with any newspaper enterprise
A: Not at tnat time. He drew the money out
from time to time by draft.
Witness here requested Mr. Porter to furnish
him with the date OF rne letter OF Mfr. Beecner, the
original oil which they expressed a wish to nave,
and. 1t being tour O'CLOCK and five minutes, the
counsel agreed TO suspend the crosse examinar rion
lOr the day..
The Lourt then adjourned until eleven O'Clock