New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-03-16

,uhanop Of that couyersaon viii do it. bat cannot give
you the words
O ws start on as early yen can A. Mr. Tit'n came
m and opened The usp topic wheh was his Brooklyn a
O weH ,,op there What he ssid' "openea '"s
usual topic what he sayi A That he was senS seHy
wronred and broken down his domestic aud p0sH's i'
lions By this delay in getting this mat:e< settled
O Then you do remember tbst he came IN ana 'Ps
.ubec, in that wAyf A. remember the sae)ec' w h'
remember the language all, portion OF it, eosu NO. XIV
700 any word that he used; after carrying on Aa'
Tor q while became .,.
O asked what was sad' A asked him. 10 !'N '- .
AIR Beesher with hsvAg criminal re"us' "~A '''- ".''
lie SAYS my wife Is ~ pure as sn angel
understood yoa 70 say thai N nsng thai expression
thought you gave illustration a: I'd! Nc W =,
fwuAg his hand around and said "she s Pse az @ ~
Uwas his theatrical manneri A Yea Sir, thai Was lFe
theatrical part OF H. A., ..,,
o ANYTHING eseanyhiRg more said, then, that yon reeo
lect, A. Yes Sir; there WAS good deal
O Wen that you rocolcct asked you' A. No. Sir, not
that recoRcet
@ You have given row al Of that conversation 'ha' You
rreoneetf Yes Sir -,
n Hadn't yoa better tax yoar memory q little asar'
and see II ven have rot omitted snything' A Well yon
will suggest anything viii try and reeoset II III you VIII
mind me OF any idea
@ During iRermison, anything Suggested 70 yoa
N Mr. Ton stating that he eosid bio" hs r'' W
A. That previous TO that.
@ No. moi During the ntermission was any suggestion
made to Won on that subject Didn't you talk about that with
somebody A. With somebody
O. With somebody or somebody you' A NO. BIZ
O. Not during the intormissiOn A No. Sir; you mean the
internission here :
@ Yes Sir. A. Oh, no, Sir; no
O DlAut talk to Cen Tracy about that, A. Not about
that; No Sir
O. Suppose YOU do put mat conversation somewhere
that remark BLOWN. the roof OF OF Plymouth Cnufch
IL was in this conversation wasn't II! A. Yes ST.
here, 80 that we can see lts eoI
nection A. don't feel ihA, able 10 give the eOnnec-
zion. - 81, 49,. .o.A,n,
@ Can't give the cOnDsctsu' A No, Sir; he was speaking
OF his difficulty.
O Waltz minnie Well win you with that con
rerstcn and all tina; yoa now remember Of III A.
don't remember anything but these two
O Now don't ask YOU what you don't remember VIII you
commence with the Conversation and give all remember
A you Insist upon my giving the "eras cannot
don't
@ Wen do the best you can A. As said before
O. don't want what you said before want you TO say
something now A Well say anything more about 1t
than that
COURTESIEs BETWEEN COUNSEL AND WITNESS
O. Can't you state it to us now A. why,
o want you to state again want you TO give me now
all Of that you rccoheet' A. cannot relate
The conversation told you before Mr. Tlton say came
in my Office in his usual way
q We'll don't that; am asking for the eon'srsauon'
A. | can't give you the conversation.
G. There were certain
O. Wait one moment We viii get OF it, Mr. Schultz A
Yes. Ihope So
@ you give what yen recollec OF the converse
lion between yen aud Ar 1iton upon that oecaSoh' A.
rant give yoa al, thing bat what have given You
O. But that to question; ask you 70 give
me am unfortunate rs not to be able 70 gave
you anything
@ WHAT A. am go unfortunate not TO be able 70 give
you anything
Q. o. l guess will get answer. A. Perhaps So
@ Yos tell Sir what now Tecoect was said Re
tween yoa and AIR Ion upon that occaslon' A cannot
O Can't ten me what you rocolec, A Yes Sir can ten
You. told yoI what rtcofecied
O Idoat ask what you have done; ask yen now. A.
can't sn you anyt thing more.
O. Repeat now what you do recollecti
Mr. Eygrts-Now, your Honor please has counsel right
60 do that!
Judge Neson-I think he has, or cross examination.
Mr. E,ars- l. the second thai it has be,u repealed
Judge Ncilson-Withou success
Mr. EvarT have nothing s1y about ths.; that s for fhe
witness The witness answered and there an end OF the
,L NJ nnnry when N. witness fally answered He has
tl him the he reeoieced it-tod him ne
could not recoec any or AID now asked to reoocc1
ain aad repeat it sgan NOV, that submit beyond Tie
authority Of croSe examination.
Jalce Mellon The coanss, thiAk, Is perfectly regular
h cross examination.
Mr. Beach am Of That your HeneT bat you vii per
nit nc 70 say that having attempted 10 relate this
Conversation an having given in different forms II on OF
spirit entire farns-s iAs gentleman whom gresIy aud
personally re pec cannot make consistent IN some
wa ITO the waeesl Now Er Schn, II ia with tnien
tonal dislcepcc Gu sir but would be glad you would
state nowrepes to now all Of the interview between
YOU and Nj Ttoa upon ta occasion 70 far TeesIect
IT. Well Er Seaeh the difficulty betweea y0u and LIE h
thi: YOU want me 70 safe the language
Q Oh no ] don't hsv. di-c.imed hat and over
aeius A. Well hlt every tae und rtake to tell yos tie
substance o. you sop
@ You are mistaken IrAuGhterl A Wen, think 50
g You are mistaken sltog iher mistaken
judge NcionIe officer viii please see that orter kept
There r. occasion fox all ths.
The Witness ITO Nj Beach, That Is where we differ
Mr. Bcach-Well sir yol entirely nsa%ea. have not
stopped you all you attempted 10 give The substance
OF the conversations the contrary have asked for again
snd again and waiting for yolr narrative whenever
choose to give its given you all the taAt
can think Of, Sir.
O. Very WE'LL then we VIII p0ss that Sir II esnnet pet
anything more Did YOU state your direct examination,
that you talked with Nj Ton the subject Of what
Carpenter had said you Concerning this newspaper project
that Mr. Ton you that Carpenter had right to repre-
fout him A. No-to represent him a foreign
spondont
O. No Sir; didn't you testify your direct examination
that Mr. Triton told You Carpenter had night power
to represent him A think said that Mr. Carpenter told
me-he tod me Nj Carpenter mad right represent
him a 'oreign correspondent
O. understand you sad that, Sir Am asking you whether
you did not testify the other also A. / think
q. You think not A. think not In that connection.
don't rccolcet IL, Sir.
O Did not Mr. Tfon veil yeu that Carpenter had power
or right TO represent A. don't think he said that Sir
O VIII you he did say it to you A. No Sir
O No Did not Mr. Houltcn in the presence Of Mr. 1ilton
at the interview at the League Club which you speak
distinctly you that Carpenter had gla power
represent Tlton A. thnk-Ae may have said that he