New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1875-07-17
THE INDIAN RING.
COMMENTS ON PROF. MARsB'S INDICTMENT.
A VERY SEVERE ARRANGEMENT.
From The Boston Adrs,ifssr tRep.l

VERY sEyERE ARRANGEMENT
From The Boston Adreytssr [Aepl . .
The letter of Prof. Marsh TO the President IL
Of In liam affairs sOne worst charges being those
against Mr. Deono and Comnii ssoner smith: Bur al
remember that they are not proved. However strong
may be tho presumption against INC sserely or iv
Commissioner, on the theory tnut 'ho ," a,,
bad infringement ccrd lot have pcon c,t r,,ci
to lair hearing. and we have no GSlDt
they viii get IT, There seems TO he an eSetcnt ~ D.
pect that shall at last got thorough examination
nfo one of the numerous swndes by which the inans
have 81 greatly cred There has been enolh o, ss
ofcers who may be very guilty, but who arc not yet
proved The searching me inYe.iigluon tnG
we know who the Indian Iilng and no mas Deen zen
tug rich on the pande. OF cur syaSsh proonr
toned 10 the meaRncss OF Their 0n,hsr'
LET TIE INTERIOR DEPARTMENT BE FUMl-
From, Tie Bo.toa Globe pnd.)
Prof Marsh does not mnce matters. An
G.siOrns faces than Lo eau possibly nav 80 t D.,
credit mas representations ana hc s"t' 20 ; M 100
REPRESENTATIONS are based lilo stat his reasons ior
submitting this TO the President instead OF we @
irankiy Ploi. Marsh is equally candid in stating
In short me indian service saturated with fraud and
corruption an, tie Indians AMI Ia" Go'cfIlehi are '.n
cncatII f0r The profit OF agents ana cOntrnotDis Now
b1e i, at east lrud enough searching invest "a
ton. Tue Indian service certainty heeus oltiHaIInS
oaSiy he can gain much himself aud justly ais
PROFESSIONS in brtaf oi consdrHe ANA goneSt leaa
Junt of the Indians. Lat this department. oil Tie sei'"e
Ice iImigaIed-
NO FURTHER EVASION POSSIBLE
Iro.t me EOsOH rot q M
| Prof. Marsh speak, 80 very plainly III ms let
c4 Pres 'icnt or ~ uon thefu.1 :" tdd! "a Iii la,
supplies lhat 10 Is npPIS"e 20 S,o Nn,,ips les than
alsnic certainly If dr.uUnsirido cou" induce man
OF sicn ,ir1c.y scientific lotOis OF ihru- To- pt ioit
s, remarkable propositions. II Is ey' n' na' lal
D.auo j. about toica. phi'e clearly Mhp i', .''iaH
j. ana wat Ms ,iscOyori's d" a" lt-cr.',oy.
There 4. further excuse i"r utAhte or evasion
ON he part the President. shrh arcu. "h' aS'n,
t.e officials whom he has Hppoh' Il ahl comm" 81 u,
oGiee and to whom he h $ Iricued al VINO nave tpN'
COMP it-. must 1oiCe IIc LA'cd'e at i"s'" 10
AN INVESTIGATION UYtvODtBLE.
f.r.i Thc BD.'pl J,ffl't ,"t..f -
! "Mr. Marsh l. plainly MOI 10 'e eNtihSIiisiiHd
br an, ..'.oo.il OF ou 81 81, ~. "a ncy.eci. ~ arpc'is
t. ieadrmrtcs. Drin brctu,e ne mas PROMISED - go so
! tIis matter and bcc,use P.of Mash himself plainly
vov, Ida, o has confidence IN Inc present sccre1r
~ the interior Dcpalui, ~ aud IA i' commissioner 81
/ ind M AnIrs. We Shall want clear eNidtNt" 10
/ ,jr,.ucc a. that the Luter-,"c ~ j. T. Nmiti'
1 q tia.uafc ut Prof 5itt-h, o,n college anu = Ger
,,,I.i OF Eudl,s ored STANDING Hitl rto-iias been
deliberate participant IN THESE ltah '4''' W. hj lJ'
,rc how possible - avoid any i"h.'r lur iht'NlSi
uan a,! 'laeht OF tiis matt l. - n, oit'h 80
na t"" r. Dc NiI.' Lis 49, o. "i ,'i-. -, J'
ci unI,r In eyes. II, t-c.ti1c, hS charges te
r;nac out o. si-l or On any privn,e lie is dchi'd
! a.. t,,,ls -.tfu if @. llat groill Ui SUI
rrion ., our Nnoie iniHl roiey a. at pr
aduH sce We are sure mot Itc'iuei' N'''A' ~
| ,.i,s IJ a.lcn result.
COMMISSIONER SMITH uAs. NoT WEAKENED THE
| CiI Z Us.
F,Of ne SD5tnG1,,d ts,' bicdh (fnd) 800.
Prof. harsh. lclier 10 Inc President, and bill
Of Pal. mt '.ic iI "a 'r' CO i'.e h1l'tf
INK i,i. loo. witilout Doilz able 70 overthrow or
even M,Aati thcn Prof Siash. ~ the course Of ms
s,lJl worm cOIs,s on evidences 81 Curfuit IN
Tie innlan aGinl>t'aton and ,he a. h'a,,' tit/.m,
/ eO,- I'D A,aG iu4r".s with 81. Niu does "a" 60" IN
d. nj dvi II >ns Ou C"ni'nsti1n "i o'-chitcs l" $50
i, si.,f iioi. Ai.l-l h,, c o no. "liihh il"' III '
of iise wide ii-c P.ol. Mr,As c--r5's cover d"d al
vcU .ae irt Of eiHdlI li'"' 'ii, ~ S-n'f t,,-
IN or widely d -tant -c.ri~ '0iniS rom iar-'
MANN" army oc,.s an al JiS. - in'if 5"r'"is,
t.nt. .,oul hiS~ b. tAe Pres cent 20 itNe il-ctt
.c . hole iiiJIOn udia Dits ~ ie'lst, "H'i
i-ls .Ir ""c lh.iIi I-0''.i' A''df t'' '' N''.-'.
D,noi c'ui"-,.on ".oso el.'lo"ee would have e''eh
! ttilr - tACF ia ilu-s.
mn nLLGAlloNs SO SPECIFIC ~ TO DEMAND
AI1HAiION.
I.Jn, The ii1Il n d., ...st tffi)
The accusations Of Prof. Marsh call for IN
iu,,,..tIo4 .utv IN 'Hcnl ot, Indian ila.
indeed an ingry hat already b CA oi'i,icd ana N""i'r
@. Icr esi;rn 70 come whether me eilaSe' are
vel l1iIci VI not, much baS Den sad IN one qitr-
,i ii aio. her t,.li examination wa Inevitable. His
spec. &, gc,Iic Ioh. IL bc -iIrr thore
tnu-s bout Proc.,'n %hich arr stfan@c ara PurS'
ptr cr inc President al IL" United States. n" snOuid
int publish them ~ L"s &c hr%,i,'oT' IT, Is NOV
VINO ~ "ari"hel Ia l"Aih$ m' own Wy .@t
toh,ii.ry, H. has h,ru intri,tcl w,tn special
aud oi.ah, SOME sense la an oit'ti cl"tciJ
corlu inoAs 49, tnug IA ais intop .>lDe wa. IN,
stead u alin. iA'ni Gr"-t o. t' frtid'iii and
~, b., ',.'r t.'i'iI' ,. md. the Iisflii-
MIND. Np'.. i,,,.,v.. i.s,.lif. nj, iuIg.
't 10 ss,nr c,trlt II do..s mol aii,t Tue c,,tutia
,,., a.. M. t. ,. toy. c 81 c.4-.t! d.. must rr ,.-
,-..t r. A. ,.o H. know 5 al. 4. D.. natter o. r.H.t
i' f. '.xt.,.t, comes DN j., .ii oi tllt
,,,icl vii. 10, ,,i.., nest Winter la ii, event We
l,ue me .a,!, .uh u., D. speedily brua-ht oar.
.r.rc,,,S, ,,,c,.rpv rr,r,,-,rD
u Ni'-h' l'i',I 80 H. ~ -'-'i'-''>'
, g, ,'".r - i't - l-' 10 -
. ilOf. N:il~h 90 Ia A'4it-' MS ItN'"HNi"
60 o. roqut. 60 ;ir C'Ei,.l,ltt"". +t'.h AHir "f
'tt'i'mrht" -, Us c!'I-s .''' 'n'''' ~, ~, -,
.'i ECU 'i''' ''.'''i -,-'h ~ 49,. q" 49,.