The Grange advance., 1874-07-01
The Beecher.TiltOn Scandal Re.
viVed.
(From the New York Sun, jane 22.)

The Beecher.Tilton Scandal Re.
vived.
(From the New York Sun, jane 22.)
The offer of Mr.. Theodore Tilton to
waive the privileges Of uon.member-
ship in Plymouth Church and appear
before its Examining Committee for
trial on the charge of slandering Mr..
Beecher, was announced in The Sun OF
Saturday. The proposition has been
declined. Mr.. Tilton's letter was ad.
dressed jointly to Mr.. Beecher, Mr..
Halliday, the assistant pastor, and Mr..
Shearnman, the clerk Of Plymouth
Church. II referred to the fact that
the Rev. DR.. Leonard Bacon, the Mod.
orator OF the recent Congregational
Council in Brooklyn, had said
in published articles that
Plymouth Church had thrown
away the opportunity to vindicate its
pastor by allowing Mr.. Tilton to retire
without u trial, and had laid especial
stress on MIR. Halliday's letter to the
Sun to the effect that Mr.. Tilton was
dropped from membership without re.
Election upon his character. Ur.4 this
showing Mr. Tllton offered to .es;ore
to the Church the lost opportunity of
trying him, and to do that his plan was
for it to bring charges against him
just ae though he was still q member,
he promising to meet them just as
though the Church still had authority
over him. This letter was not brought
before any meeting of the Church, but
was the subject of private, informal
conference among the leaders. It was
decided to decline the offer, and MIR.
Shearnman, as clerk of the Church,
wrote reply to that effect. Mr..
Shearnmau and Mr. Tllton also talked
the haatter over. The ground taken
by Mr.. Shearnman, who is a lawyer
and has all along had much to sayin the
conduct ofthe Plymouth war, is that
MIR. Tilton's plan is not feasible, even if
desirable on the part of the Church.
The only way, he thinks, of putting
Mr.. Tilton in a position to answer a
charge of originating the
Beecher scandal would be to make him
a member again by the usual process,
and that would involve Inconsistencies.
as Mr.. Tilton's religious belief is not
now such as would make him eligible
for membership. Thus the negotis.
tions dropped, and so quietly had it
been begun and ended that the rank
and file of Plymouth membership knew
nothing Of it,
On Saturday Mr.. TTton and Mr.. F.
B. Carpenter, the artist, returned from
New Haven. Their errand had been
to lay before the Rev. DR.. Bacon an
elaborate written statement Of the case
from the Tilton standpoint, including
the last offer and its rejection. The
document includes a recital Of what
Mr.. Tilton says are Inaccuracies and
injustices in the proceeding which
have incidentally involved an asser-
ton of his willingness to meet the
charge of slsndering Mr.. Beecher and
a request that DR.. Bacon, as the &C.
knowledged head OF Congregational
ism in the matter of polity and usage,
will consider the subject thoroughly
and render decision in accordance
with his convictions:
T1LToN's EXPOSURE.
ASSOCIATED Press Telegram, June 23.)
Theodore Tilton publishes in The
Golden Age this afternoon seven COL
umn Particle touching the Beecher
scandal. In reply to the charges of
Rev. L. Bacon. Moderator of the late
Brooklyn Council, that Mr.. Tilton has
been = cowardly slanderer of Mr..
Beechei, whose magnanimity alone
saved him from disgraceful exposure,
and having suffered in silence four
years from these and similar misrepre.
sentations adroit]y put before the pub.
lie by Plymouth Church, Tilton says,
neither patience or duty will permit
him to longer conceal the act7al facts
from the public. He then goes on to
say that he never slandered Mr..
Beecher, but on the contrary has sac
rificed his own reputation to suppress
the truth about him, and that he never
has refused to appear before the