, 1874-12-02
raa hetwecn s. 99d AMI s3Eoo that 10 lFarwe' rat-


-. :.--.--. -
ysa s s' !; ap :soo a A., he , Tsrws rt
sGeye n9n w1s ss " % n S s e as,
stesss +, " lsns Il and lotsnang !o 1ssso Aa.
!alo VI for HIN. Farwo snys llo took Vr iho nolr,
h 'a!nS to'Ht IT. a sEol,son With Aler;on hAs
Eusluemt Of llleir jont iueltctl,irzs lint lilo nr
wclt for hla owl, benefit am, that Of Ans,wom lint
fund he 'IvIlcd lu thai Nnersna delivered 10 Ear.
wel o s!ote1, nn lnswell ci,ycrc, oih o ,,oies ls
rasw icy o s sr ,e M9. s to G :,e s
crstnn Of to hnt|ernon notes, nd dopa not roclncr
!" Maom pm "a eGy wcrs iayah;o hat, sfcr la,lg tc
nol, division was nnrcc oil, by syAiu liz tarwel)
tcok 20 1crss u poorest ta,d and gave anderson
co arres. lie snyn that bIaora check or 500 rrnro-
scented the ninonut Of bet which liz tEarwelD won
fEonsaaler nn tl.e clcSt!ol, Of L'neol', that the
undivided seven.h Of tile 50 acrea, bns In ronscra-
ton Of h'u having 1al tbs taxes iqt .o or three yearn
sca onesevcnh of The laid. III. Tarwcil further
pays thHt lo never held noe of Aaler'a for alollt
ss 'o It sso s u f 9s' sf d. By sssso
or Farwel4 tsttmou; IN reference tho character oF
~ rlnsaetloa sy Witch ho boean'o vested with tlo
"Ii.u prgas,ons in tlc second amendment nro s,,a-
famed neither by te setmnny ot rarwe. nor '!aher.
m.ney' wan '.pcsi Gettsug, both duo 70 arWall. mid
o 70 BE- pa BY Esrwo noa tue Aneraen noes
o OF s50u. mid Macr frequently, II not mora
positively aeules Aat 10 owed either Ia1wo or An.
hing wha'over except tho s., ;uo no:c.
"Yhs sesona "n.enamen, tho,eforc q conforms 70 Tue
r uyi.cnse # III. Two. and sho testimony Of flheso
two lasties in the n,,ly testimony ~ tho ease III refer
cnce to tho consideration Of the dees ai tr Two VIII
irnrty contradict cac o.,Cz In most es4en!ia
pv No nrrr Or o,tAvcEnz FRACTION =,
can this M,ncntlmcnt at tilis stage If tho case DO
ellnwItt. THO irbt amendment il frahesl 10 neel
part Of tito cydcnso giyen ty farweil. lat the bi
proroecd so Ia altered by kai amendment differs
la,wcll. FArwell sa5s Tho Conveyance waa TIL alnc-
ulo 1ae to n, 'nlas'nent Of h!. s5qo check, and 10
@ J, ~ s r aas, ~s II ss1 Il q t ~ m S svs
:l .i,o Erauseca ii .e ard we'll knew ut tho tinlo
whiel sai died as given to tai Farwrll by yo,,r
orator. nl that thu stine was intended merely
iii tilo nncrltimtiis stated The testimony Of rarwc
precisely c ga.o IT, It wod le dicilt 10 SEQ upon
what principle iils anwlneu Of Tho first a,ncrdmcnt
Mt tic final hearing hccnao the rlainttN has in hin
csd1nC' eTlfy r. Or 4nrsc insoFFscy sa'r m "N
FasSel rye $ss Tic illss Titnsas cn,ctl by s1ucr, and
after having teo examined nd cross-exc1:tEoa, ami
then recalled Gy complainant. adhered 10 the state
,ncut that the cuusltor0to Of tho iced tho 800
check and tho indebtedness Of Anaerson Of ntout
s3ouu ecrlan proissorS no!cs el Mahess held by
Inn, l that the aale Tas un abGolnte Gap for aeoue
% siaisr, sa Viii %l rarwen testimony prcsep. II, his
mcluory cnien Mrs!er oath repeatedly that he owed
Andcrao ing money at tho tlaa of tho deed, n.d la.
tile Gr,ly consideration of thc conveyance was the
Si,7uO uoto given hy him to Turwc for,n GalnbnG
debi, md ,at il not palo Of tho property, bus
only mortgage.
Of equity to as It to amend his picadlngs in order
that It may renlcr lm G ceree upon testimony which
o astcrE' aud ,easEcrsa Under tho solcnuity Of liu
| cath KS tElfc md perharA rcrjiircl.
| -. Tho complainant aud Tarwcll l,ayo <
! DIRECTLY AND ros1r1vELT CoSTAAD1OrED EACH
about sacs tcu,ifcd to by tl,cn,, md by no other
material witncfe.-Etcrial fnctu 1ta ,-aul vet
tho complainant aEksa Court Of equity TO reject his
s. ea If ns sta sns
tic complainant las 1lado ulNer oath :,I1 ncca tho
truth Of 50 much Of rarwes statement as n,i.t en-
n1o tho Court to raut ecrcD III the case, throwing
"i1ow can coMp!aiuant ~: tho Court to accent as
tic ace, s,aseu 10 bs iaao9 AND ILLS 10 the position
which tho complainant III proposing hia first amend
Tor IL after. tho amendment was. allowed. tho
Court could upon tho evidence grant no tseercc urcn
tho LII amended, then the allowance Of the a!rcn
amendment wero madc how wonld it be possible for
Chancellor 10 render decree upon t!s nllsndea blil
The oit III II Wolu 10 dei.te oEl-
tiyefy by a1ahcr. nn1 supported Dy the evidence os
f4rwel II IL oath against oath, both being conpe,ent,
though interested, Witnesses; nether wltteEs he!p'
oilcr wlrcEs.: Or by circu.nsnr!ia e:idence. 80,
'To Erecllt the Eta.cmcnt cf aIr. Tarwc as the
@ @aa @ nis ta eyeee rSsea eno Of M asMs rss q II
mind in reaArd 10 transaction Of which they ihe
euy twollving wcacca, about wlie, they bos profess.
hare each positively rcntr:4aiccd tlc other. Ioh can
not be right, Ono may he rerjurcd. Ii upon ruch
determine whether tho decree Ia based upon pcrjure
testimony. or whether arartct 10 perjured pary2
~ II clear that, nndrr sci crcn1nitanccs, courl
eoula grant no decree to tho complainant, a, there
OUGHT NOT TO onAa7 TnE Aursu,tEsr.
"The;o i a Snosr T tho h
ilo Court ought not 10 g.ant dcereo. Thu Original
hill s.ass III excuse for connlanant'a lachra that IN
sioul recoltycy tn him the land, nt offered to pay
hjnt tho amount, then due Elns. This allegation /,
5 9 ~ he rroosSa 81 nsn men s AZ" e
veyel IN 1sto. and for thirteen years thereafter The
enps'n9st allowed # TO ,s rsnan in, r. tho Ra-
complainant will! morbid perstrsy s!ll insists upon
h or oa u u to n nav M one ssn q
e taxes aud as,csancMts yearly levied upon the sand
In these yclrs THO lnr.! hca greatly appreciated III
raae md no Sad e.cusc Is presented for complaint
."ror tao: reasons above aet forth, tho first aud
| second amendments are both rc!c.etl."
III tho combustion Of the opinion, a court suggested
that It would bp better for HIN 1T 10 cnler TT
order diminishing ho!h tic origual md tlo cross blil
llr. Hunter, counsel on hcl.aro Of kr. Perkins. o.
defendants In lu original Buit, obccted Oh hegroMnt
that the evidence in tho case wonld stand as cloud oI
his clients titlo to tho land. Ie wanted affirmative
After aome little conversation as to when tho arg,l
nents Iii the suit should Ee heard, wna nGrcea h,
counsel that briefs he prepared upon which tho cour
| coull baso lila Geaision. '''