The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1874-03-06

feat OF the Measure-The Resources
and liabilities OF the Governments
The Roseate Financial Prospect Pre-
sented by Mr. Garfield.
WASHINGTON. March g. 1874
DEFEAT rRANkING BILL.
Mr.. SHANKs (rep) of Ind. called up his motion to
reconsider the rejecting the bill the dstribu
ton of public documents, &c.
MI CorroN rep) OF Iowa. moved to lay the motion to
reconsider on the table.
Mr.. Cotton's motion was reected-yeas lO2 nays IA
Mr.. SHANxs, OF Indiana, moved the previous question
1t seconded by 2l to 90 and the question
ordered by-yeas III nays lo3. The question then
taken rscOnsidering the vote rejecting the bill and
was reconddered by-yeas 12l, nays l06
Mr.. sHAsxs, Of Indiana, then moved to recommit the
bin to the Post ONCE Committee with instructions
port back bill substantially similar to the bill intro
dgSed last Monday BY Mr. Butler 2: MASSACHUSETTS.
a uneon wa e on the hi,
origina reported and the bnIwas rejected Dy-ysas
The following Is the vots:-.
SsSSs WI SsSs1
ss%s5s .f;sSs
MeusSton o~e ' unten, 'q Harbu aS Kendall
PsSsas
ham Perry Phillips Pat. Of Virginia; Plat New
sa.k; sawyer, sensr: shsnts sioss smith q Norm
Maryland Woodworsh and Young OF kensusky"im
sSs snE a.'sT
ss;, 81 s5 Ct
q nShs henaee ke,,s HSar Holman
ssS.ssFS Hse Ct 1ss.
P5eT pIss Es% SsSss sd5sIss Il +
inoi. Ross savior Of Indiana, ssyer Of Ohio sscdsid
ssosE n SSse $ s%2
Ct lilnqiss Ward q New Jersey Wheeler W1ithoTns
%a ss
The House wsn no Of Ss Who'll. on
I'm %soateTd
s s' ~ :s'a
He n::ss.' .;asa
ing The cloth aid not subscribe to thai doctSns
To
for os s wa as
money it necessary to expend to carry properly
r. ss
q n
surplus was and they had been sO!d when
eminent forced 10 tAe necessity Of laying
as he
Congress 'o'n aen'l' 'h' ~ha' was the duty
THE ACCOMPLISHED REDUCTION OF TAXES.
On the first point he explained that Of tho
the @ s Tho
IN. eS.s Of the .s IF mere 1na y A.
Two ss
ne which cut down rsyenpes-and the only ques:
ssa Sssss
S o sa ssa
to the reduction Of taxes particularly those tea
st is
Il o be that doing a pS cream s
United States would 60 9at despoilsd and like Lady
GO. asked Mr. IL. what he to the
ss replied he wSua sTnaps glad
and despsed company OF against the re-
ss Ct % sS 5 The not
which should have followed that action
as msas IL SsG hh s
the reductSn ne o taxes sncs 1870 when there
not probably account for deere the surplus lie
de aet a o. thu Of s
sssh dawn sss 10000 since Is7S that
Alright
He to the Clerks desk and had read an extract
s ssf sinSns Eu%a nssasa,
cause the fact that MI. Dawes had frankly and man;
III e.
The asf been se. SsF
:ss' s5 as a as had
cshsT nc nsf
ssa sSi
ms Mf Dawes? statement e make It cor5sSh nQ P
But sSt S
70 Il %as he the Sy s
Garfield criticised some Of Mr. Dawes figures especially
ri. aaaSSeS Continued the country under
one IN one de to the House the
% rs Principle hes
Of sy d
belle Sslisysa
ss Il the
s''Ss Ways :na :A' no%s the
s.an vnsn IL u sss the s sse wh sSs
Committee on Appr9prstions proposed that whenever
that q n ep
and when an expenditure could be postponed year
ern@en to Postpone Il When the COMMITTEES had Done
other dollar nywhere.
He then went into de. q 6s estimate. and .oc,
praCns for for the next asesi and stated
mate, .s and his asSTs: were liable sSarss
IN he pnfa