New-York tribune., 1874-11-09

ringtop Williams and Whitley was resumed Saturday
morning Jddge Hnnphrevs said the proper orders for
paving witnesses fo7 the dcieuse wOGii be ma lie when
the Court was satsn,d Of It's daty IN tue premises
When the public put persOl on trial, WIS tRht tha'
the public should bear the expense OF such rii The
orders would be tTaDspTc OGd sbow tho
necessity for It, III should turn ont the iIal ad-
vaDced that some witnesses have been summoned here
TO testimony wholly Inecvdnt 70 tic case. and
which entirely unnecessary. 1t will be ainattcr for
sidcration by the Court regard expense
All parties be satisfied for the present with tho
order and with the in which the Is con.
ductcd.
Mr.. shiveler recalled for the prosceuon-Wit1ess bad
brought the letter press OF the missing dspltch as
1t was delivered NswYor. The copy was produced.
and the witness said it fac-simile Of the message
as it was delivered the person TO whom y vas adj
dressed. Witness also produced a r,ccptDop5. aud
showed that the message recepeJ oT by A. B VIII
lams. per Gill; witness also produced press copies OF
other dispatches and showed fro the eipooa mat
they delivered a: No 90 sixthayc., N,wY1rk TIE
dispatches were sent 10 Williams from Washington, aud
were signed Harry"
The Court directed Mr. Riddle to read ths dispatches
to the jury, but Mr. DavdEe objected. sas t1at tho
proof not complete
Mr. Riddle claimed time to l1ish the proof BY other
witnesses, which was allowed hun.
Jesse Ward called for the defense and swora-Wtness
lives at Newton N j.; keeps hotel. and formerly
n
for truth and yeracty; was bad witness would
not believe him under oath. ,,
in Newark, and knew truth had heard many persons
that z,rruth was DANGEROUS uan: pope wcr: al
they are nearly all AFRAID Of Gm; there had been several
fires about there and people Thought rrdtA Aaa soe
Mr. Rddle-Wnat has that to do with his telling tho
Witness-well, not anything n parhcIllr.
Mr.. Harringtol-Spelk little louder. Nj. ward.
Judge iiamphieys.We!l, pthSe itinst, c,iIn,
the rules. One Of the leading counsel must eonduct
Mr.. Harriagon- am one OF the parties to this case
Judge Hnmphreys-I know you arc. ana you or your
counsel conduct the examination. foa can do IL
II YOU want TO- bat not blth OF you az u,4e, 0,o.
Mr.. Harrington don't think your honor uuuer-
Judge Humphrey do understand your position
Mr.. Harrington-I want the Court to understand my
Judge Humphreys-I do understand yon' Just slt
down now. Mr.. Harrington, sit down. A.. -. .
Mr.. Harrington, sitting down. want the Court 70
Judge Hamphreys-rhe Court understands your posi-.
tOn exactly but your position does not prevent the tnes
from being carried out One OF the leading counsel on
each side will conduct these examinations Now 90 on
with the case. -.
Zrruth; his reputation for yefaciy Is 9ai wona % hos
believe him under OATH CrOssPxausiued Oy hr Rldde
does not Known that he would know him now; had not
him slnce he came to Mash;nsqn Irratn h va; m,o
ness witness knew his reputation bad, but did not
know that he would know zrrdth if lie should see him;
H narrison W. Huseiy sworn-Is Deputy Collector OF
the Port of Boston; knows Col Wntey rem tnoers he
IN of April last knows that Whitley gave GiDner
party taat day which witness was present witness
detailed some occurrences which enabled MN 10 nA tho
date -, ,,,uo H., or ,,nod n,
abont lie matter because he met iady the next Sab.
hath, which the l2th OF April. ana he remembered
ness was not able TO tell the conaeeuon be.
MEETING Sn 5 e aag Sa s ana day Gs met s
lady was the I2ih because the Methodist Conferences
met there that Jay witness q; not & Iang Sne
was subpenaed to here because he o!l chandler
he eeoeeeG about the m G9neg AK s Somt
the matter, he not willing To come mere ana
swear TO the without heng more sure about thcm;
witness mad talked about the case consdetao Since 10
Wa "aWTIioIn f. Bates sworn-Resides in CnbrigepOrt;
ia employcd at the CusOm-house knows Nlntey' ana
remembers that he had dinner party g Ets'er sun-
WEI were pTesen Caoss-examined by Mr. RadeRrmem
bers the day he apponteI TO the position
on the 9th which tue following Infsddy was MOI
invited to the dinner party but called tmcr 10 Sc @ oV
theie persons there Whitley Witness
James Tilly swori-ts u GetcciINe oDIif u Dostobi
Whitley Invited lin TO q dinner party ana be was
unable to attend; was invited the Gay before when
II. F. HUTCHINSON sworn-R,sles IN sprl-fed met
Col Whit ey the 9Th OF April last ia the depot NJ
Springfield, Mass on the arrival OF tue ot.o'A tram
from Boston; formerly u constable; mot Whitley
by an arrangement TO see him about an appointment;
eximined by Mr. Rddle witae,s likes the date.
because put IL down III Ills Gir5 G''13 CAhIOIteu
' w " hnnegite sworn Has charge Of four dif rent
lines OF horse cars ia SeNi kCJ "n" Ft5s ih Ne"-
York; before That was ID the SeclI, | & ~ 10 s,on' V
the 9Th Of April went TO the Bloeckers i'r 20 ee hr
Whitley. found he was not lhore tAd Gay ABOUT
l:3O went down the depot where tue Boston trsln
came in with Mr.. NewcO3D; whitley caue .h on that
train aud witness and Whitley were together som time;
went 10 the AstOr House, aud there sepdTGed aud WIT
ness went Boston witness fixed The da.e y ms mem
orauduubook he remembers about thc Dispatch which
Neteshp sent from Toronto Gy Pr Jison ~ & snyng, a
Johnson who had jumped his bail and witness and Net
teship were engaged in turning hla up ;og MS bo1ds-
men witness had not then ascertaned whtthcr the
securities the bond were good, ana this dplteh re-
oied 10 that Whitley did not know abOG, ta TaBslc-
tcn did not tell because witness thought b. would
h1S Tropspexanined %pp by Mr. Ridlle-wacs5 was
arrested; saw NetteshIp about three months ago; dd
mot know where he Is now witness begun 10 WORK for
the "a. Company on the O.h OF seP,emper had made
oTrancemcnts with Ncttleship TO hunt up JohnsOn's
bail, aud was TO seud Word u Ne'uesA!p aooat the
secnrity. . 80 -. g.. ...,,,
Boston, where you lived, aud where The sccGity v,d,
how came Netteship to telegraph yoi igoM Cdnada.
where neither party lived, that the Setur-Y was goOdf
Witness-Weil, l WAS to let him kuO~; was 10 see
about IT,. =. -. 800 , hon,
it, Mike Hayes was TO have nothing to 80 aooat ~
Witness did not kaow Hayes; Net1esh!p ntver spoke
to him about Hayes.
At 1880 o'clock the Court took recess.
AFTERNOON SESSION.
On the reopenlng the Court after recess the cross
examination Of Applegate was resumed. wines met
Whitley at the depot; thinks the train was Oh time
took lunch with hta at ST. Clair witGcss had just
turned from Cincinnati; had 70 means OF remembering
except bJ referring to his memoranium-hook.
BY Mr.. Henkle-W.tness was shown paper In several
pieces pasted on to brown paper DaeI and SAID he
recognized 1t: first saw it when Col Whitley was past
ing it ogetner in the Office IN BOston Whitley picked It
out OF the wasteblsket.
OTts TGo Judge read it, and asked Mr. Henke to state
what he desired TO do with It.
Mr. Henkie replied tnat he proposed to show that q