, 1874-05-15

| retention Will moi V1tiato bhp charge, but y ts
thnreon. Il ia always botter to rotect s,cll mat
tor at first" Again 1t is said 10 bo "high1y im-
proper that the tnteronces Of the prosecutor
! should appear In tho specifications. Tho facts
draw tho lnforonco. Buch inforoncos Of tho
prosecutor would, howover, bo moro snrplusnge.
anl no ovidonce should i'c received on them.'
"There SHOULD be ',o uncertainty Of vaguoncss
Theha principles, embodied in rules, aro 80 OBJ
vlouBly sound, md tho construction, in atrlct
| conformity. with them, Of any indictment which
H. TO bo trlcd in an ecclesiastical court, In no
clearly important to protect tho interests Of "a
| commanding them to avnu. And yot tho int1ict-
mout beforo this body. md on which your
brother presbyter has beou arraignod, han boon
| framed In
! CONTIGUOUS VIOLATION
Of al these principles: Tho memborB Of this
Court have been, onveloped In great cloud Of
words, words Which state next to nothing as
regards actua1 facts, and WHICH insnuate noxt
cutor's inferences,,-rand through such d. =
| hazy and distorted medium, as this
they arc asked to look at their accused
brother! and 500 II le do not appear hn l!nfaith-
ful mi1lHtcr and g horattcal toacter. We have
involntion and conyolution illustrated before us
| hero to suoh bowilaorug extent that this body
! might we'll bo adjudgod Incapable of tlosormjn-
Ing tho degroo OF guilt Which Should bo attaclad
to him who holds to the dootrino OF "ovoluton," !"
n aGgnus R hrogtoss anI growth D. ny Mor aoos II II
| tnls naze Of lnaonniEonasa, whion, hke London
log, enYe'ops uB all, that tho prosecutor comes
aMa PIotesla IL open eonrt IS he ola az enn oiit-
seoo1 tnlb tlal tnat ne cannot maRe tnese cnaf9cs
anu speolhchnnn5 hnY moro dohnite; iof,thtB is
| tsntasnouns to . confession on bis part that he
uas no ease: lhpp'auRo.l 1t man were gallty
OF MuIaoIt u "onid, suppose DC posaaole TO say
30 eb uIstinn!y no Welo guilty o. J., ialsohoou,
tne Englten language 1s rioh enough IN resources
70 enaolo one 10 chargo tpet hlao MIN 1enalte~
ness Pseclslon, anu even emphhsls. ana II luis
responantls a. your par, haa oeen guutY or any
Wpll-oonneu anu unquosionapio eco'eaiastiea'
oMenso, l ~ o"ehs ! noe 70 10 anpoas',n,'o 70 say
W mnsS s onun1o @ u,u .ro e.ase'oos suo"lo oe one
VI 1ae' aua III aos ~, VI 4n,otonuo' Ill., .,,...
oat tnat Ino chaf69s IN tD1s inaictmont
w i nos Rlye ~ ahv !!Sne upon tn.8 polh;s
a,,tia Havo a!teaa3 = suown. Ina. tne bnoei-
ia that ssr !" o,s w d den a. ~ Inc oath
1eb!uuluH WIN tne uesI oI lug Approximations,
anu 'I assuming the onafge 70 be u proper FORM,
sho opject ot 5ue aroclncasona IL 60 polht oni
faithiunsss, and diligence s as t minister. a Ths ea
poi;e;a a's11mees u woa tao taeR OF snose
qaiull!es Ahs poon Man'los!ea hnouta % e4-
Hull tpteoau .he bpeeiacatioas. We iooS 20 SEQ
saIoi' t;e'a s'aseo sneto' anu hna nosn1ng OF Inc
- SPECIFICATION FIRST .
is no specification at all. The substance Of 1t Ia,
tuAI e4Asooa s9nENa8o neH Deeh lisea ~ Hot1nons
PElntea III tue Vni;ago 1n!Ra tho 1datgnoe
M anu III INC volume entitled truths Tor io-aay.'
IN thoao aertnohs tue rotero'lces to cardinal doo.
trineh are doulared TO he vague. and 4 is CHARGED
spat lucy nave not peen nheqhl4ocalV 9inrhea.
NOW tne object Of specialization fa 70 tell man %
~ VIM l'a[teIuar aeronotloo ne Ii aaouaea. that
o my & Geny nn gat. ~ rsgana e tnas parsGa
10 seek ms oxluonoo IN any o. sao soumes oi
sasinuns alluueu 70, Wnito u glves tae accaReo
~ no.ce ag 70 We PaIele.a. u'to1anoe VI "oas
~ Spoeon ""tun - opJooteu w.
~ amas tne naecI vi 1so.; nMmgs onenso naa
i hpoH " oouots ~ wy nnuh - suue " uls
~ ~ nua .s ~ oauno Ips H. ~ o4Ia n.
- - 80 ~ tao. Aeeaiteu s1he Ut: oM4uS, AuowMk
LUZ ti.as ~ ""a 5usPuetGn " uoynal unsono
ma1 ~ n ~
ean a n.', ~ ens pppno' nua ~ IVY
1u ~ "ay, LIZ sieuaulion a ans..s
t"niy os "lnS aas aiaSs "ouia oaat ~
nra,o h,+ e1,1 anar .,r ~ ,,n'' Sn;s ~ ~,
Jntat ~ ~ ta osfont nt.s ~ An R, ~ ~
ns,,aa ~ = .it ~ ~ w.
asota,a1 a "'. 1 3nt ,n;.. =, n.s
nauso'nnnoos .,a a., ,eat raenst, A0o"A"o '"so'
Nn r. ~ on,,an5 uu uI' a H., ,,;,,, ~ ~
IN oeao In n0s aond a Sergad ~ a
SnneiHnsiv ,,itI, H. ~ .ra tioa nn1 ~
sp1 nn, ~ 10 haro oSt nnI,utfv ,' dora IL ~
raiunoI' fnr ~ - ti1a o,nannunncea ~ "o nrstsnaad
otfenss. and for mt rofprmi,'e' thonab kno,sinr
thnso cnuaoono.,.cn 'AN"o'~ 4"'4e
!. sPEols1oATtoS THIRD,
~ aa a u n.s' @ nHe,ens, oeflares ,nas sne aoousea
r1s s.xon ane "eisnt VI ~ ,naonee ~ iaVot y!
oau uaisa1an'sn'. s NOW an anhuenee grows OUT o.
@ once aai il " I'm sa a "cn "s, m M
s.uau " eaaI 10 snonu n9 enaaGed VIII cortaln
spee'c aetS ana , no sa9na 10 punished lor these
aets' ' u na " Ral9ty u snom, ana II they consG-
thae H. ulsoapu'an9 W.; oaonso ontn o'nerW.se.
:-.,1! nc is n noxt sad to 90 gallty OF IN.
1o, Mortny aha eAtraVagant aldasoh o. Johh etusft
alau. nls thls Is conclusion Wnleh Iho proso-
cuior arrives as IN hIs own mind. 4 the 20; g;
oe'sea haa extrsVagantly lauded Mr MIL, he d.d
u , ny inc use OF CERTAIN words, Whleh ought TO
nave M peen quoted ln the specification, md y on
.heso ne onEns to DO trloa. nnt Instead OF thls
nc prosecutor has h1wn hs own conclusion
1o.. IRON tno Woras when he = DOES not quote. ana
enen sseKs s1 Tue ootenoAn' Oh INC
conclusion wnaoh he usaws'
~ .his, therefore,, tho specialization Is defeotiye
III 1oa ~ zets lorsn tno Vs. cGncson %9t1n Tue
prosecutor draws from tho language Of t1o de-
Tue court 70 draw the conclusions. Bnt may rot
man '; eneak words q praiso ct an atheist2 Not
OF Lib AtlG16, t0t Will doug this. Prof. Patton