davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
, 1874-12-07
CHICAGO TRIBUNE: MONDAY DECEMBER T.

..n, 1T, =. .,,,u ,,..,...
i,nI,t ee"n ,, ~ aSu r. NV ~ euester esias
& u uur S ~ e,,a U ~ s ,,,,t,,
tibtai "a It III u ,oa, u.,olJo ~ ~
ti,rouH, ~ rnih, t,b to,aoanb b'f1 farn, ~ "a1oatai
saERm saiam ~ nai.s sSloscopo" loi'a " ee''s'a'
Oh. fro,m'ss s of irnmnnuot will havc IN done
In NM, yonr ,nfuo,n,, ai,, rn ,,an,n II ~ vo,r
Mf,atnr s.Tin ntorrn a,"r .a W,o a. ,ro,,1r.nr
~ dn vlr,t nv ho,inhfed ryorta ''' A' =
Ala thcrn is vct n,,ntHor .vondcr or .,,o ,norn.
inr atnr. Whcr IL ia ,,ausirv t,s aim r. bornnna
tho day's Larbluuor. it onnn In n whiio oona d.
footIv ncroRa lin sn,,u ,iac M rnuuI hincls ant
of Von,in; md il 10 n,ost lmportant and imtor.
cstine phenomenon, I}y menna of thIa cvont
when Il takes place. tbe tr,,o nistnncn ami ma.
tons Of tho llo avursly boloa aro cncl1lntod. aud
tho fncss Of astronof,y and tho r1lloa Of unyirn.
tlon aro fxoa on t1lolr exact and im1oynllo bass.
Aud yot II 10 m ovont oxfromo1v rRro. Il cont,ot
occur Moro tlan twfce in tho )onroat fifcs stitnn
and It nay not como uyon ouoo to q man OF 100
yenra
.flloao transts Of Yonus ocour In palre, at
rognlar intervals, thus: First III 1aIX yaarg. md
olght years afterwards: and 10 on, It wns not
until tho Inst two Tara Of tra1,stts tho oup uar
occurring in Tho seventeenth md tho otbor In
tho cightocnth century, TINT human attention
was callcd to tllia interesting phenomenon. lilo
first transit calculated was III 1851, predicted by
Kopler, but not soon by any ono. Tho firat
tfanHit soon was cight yoarB afterwards III 1000
slnce thon tho only trnnsita Tint havc occurred
in 2a5 ycara wero tho pair iu 1101 and 176o. bp.
foro tho "Rovointionary War;" So that tho olds
ost man now living has novor had chnuoo to
sec eucla an cgcne.
I,nt now at length, on this 8th Of Docomber,
1874, thai iH, Tueadny, tloro is to occur tilnt
notable event Of thu coutury, transit Of Vcnus;
with stiEl cnother eight yeats afterwards, III
1882, hfter which, no such ovcnt will occur
again for 121H :yoarH. Unfortunately for ua,
this transit vii! take place after sunset In this
longitude, requiring expeditions to distant
plaoes In order to scott.
On. the lust OCCASION. 10511 years ago, such
was tho interest beforehand in the anticipated
orott that expeditions for observing 1t wore
fitted out. and cent TO romotoplaccs Of the oarth
BY several Europoan eovoreigns. Tho worlds
best aatronomers wero stationed IN Lapland and
hamhohatkn, ut bt. Holenn and the Cape Of
, 1874-12-07
$3.50 y, tu., srrirs at Magnolia By pt m. hona

= ,;:--, rona
':;i3 T: -: .s s, iss,.:S fss
tssPs nd siasi ss9f hessG %
SS 4 MI r. SsT S5s's0 as osav by 7Isp nj h'nd f''''
sss,. sos s b sss sss " 2ss, gts
sss; ssss xssy e +, 1i;"s
Fl II n ;;;; 5s!:s !;ss;s s$ss$ 3 :s
T. T. ssaise !ssHs n!of u y @ s aay
i sf1 p'sssss; s,4,ss c5sso sss
1ssss M ss
ss,! ss!, :, ME-, ,s
,s's TssT M fsssos .sss ts
:sss;s y S s$ f'"sS'Ss Ssad
;s, fss s
sS ina .,, ,.sss
s,E es se tsssS =
Sssa fsS%!sS III d SS Il asa's
@ :; : ssES;; *
: ;:.s;;ss i%; *;y &;
ut $50 i. h nrrftn nt f,urden by J. m lnayn fIom'
hdGs daily, pxccpt Huntny II a. MI nrr w It Inn.
csno BY 1a:Ji .. tn, Ilont f0niircd Win hid anm
~ 172-Fron hndpyer to Gambrijxe. inos Snd back
six times wock iohsn ndnrnr iii IL srEnnt H,nt;a1
sx sr, q H.: a,rlso At Caabtjdso by sp NJ. oavo CAM
AZ Ifa T. E,; q; Ut I,oat hoi,d r. re1ui[ed NTH BID %o
*{f 'ss ss ss sssS $s$s ;;sa 5ss
inayn fratn tsse a. =: NJ arriso NJ Aledo by r. M;
WasG hisun tts aa akoor Sundaf, at srrvc at
baak e5q tre5 re5S p5fs'Ans ns,xs
HI atar,aS n ri; ensa M rs;a,ant Hi5go Wednotday
H. nrryo n risaaaniu @ @mSutsdny aud SATURDAY, nt3p:
VIII AZ t7sl. ~. tn4ns5.. tnivJ. vs ,,ru,,n ~,
rsnr Ttnsl u nMnalo PFat3 Ferdinand
bsck tSIao n',ncP ts1a. e new otton, p miles and
t,rtas ~ y, ae1se y haEagon tuesday and Sat
EeW 3astnn Hondnv an aw nestou " p eavo
Va ia ~ tfrn, u, y; tfnM nu ro1ulr9a @ with htd $lu0
Aft.eni3hr T. " nnia Gtty aHd DrurJ,
fdrnrtn, r. .n III H. caGe. tRice wcok. Leave
hjnsnaitnn ~ y 49, @ hnu 'H1suay at a, arrive
a. ~ nrrxa ~ III NonhLy and Thur
M,ra Nh, IT, Ha3s' ~ 1ostn8t9n bT 8 p m. Bond
! 81: III i:rntn ti,yrrr.z f,.,r. - r..- a..
Far s a. NceE, !sasS ovo ncsIaJ aud
rnrsn,x nnj ~ ti. - Isss " ~ p H.; loare Caas
frurn ~ III ~ ~ ~ J.. T. arlTs ht Duwnnts
M ;a Imm * if nmtn iia9nreH ~ nn9t VIZ N. NO. Floo
Knnin ~ VII ~ u utlo y Iiow and
| - 4ulcs Guu pAck, thron t1AOs
, 1874-12-07

Is L; 81 se ri i ssss{ssa a /, S;: =
y: e? .;;s;
SsS:: g. and 3D. aI!'s %
ss!s Ss' II 4 q IA d 80 4 H. + ss;.
?1 Ssssr!i s%?s5; s % b !Ss @ i
ia $ s i + :;;s
ILL., ks s, yS sS Siss s,.l1s 1sss e. 1lST a
%s sss 81 s:'',s At l'sa At p
$: 's =; &: :1:s:; s;
4 %:sssss, 'E $ a;
::s ;s.:,!s Il: &;
Kns'sn INIT 12s, Ns, ps,en sE md md
SsiysS sss;5 IL qs5 as5 s' a. nSss
S!;s;: ;s!!; s;; ss;:
s1s;'5Ss 5sa a. 9f3S!ssa sh 'st.s' a. nono' w
n} Z, ,dss hs. 9ssei' ss Rss's;
Tuesday and Tr,lxy at MI afrlvo Poplar Grovn by
r. 'ss inaa, ips j go9o m mu'a ags a ay &
FsH S4yss@2' 4s! Ss asSs ssss ess R:,s 81
;!fye Il Pasts ), p y. savo w. pSssn 4assdny I'D
wv, sGsy 5 psn G oa}n % p afS
sy e'52s t. Ss.ep
ssssat ;a "a
bask t, b NY K
Il ssssS ssS i
h.Sa hSfs's s
ss ss1,sn sss Rss s2o z Sss ss.ss;
$sssls ss
e!a E!ee ettem Oregon. By yrou and lI, to rockford
T1s.s, S5J.:Sss
isoaEiof Sy$ r! iesvo kosttosd Monday Mcanos |
At oss'1
ssssk = ,I%s. SssS; Ef$ss iel!asso ,,ay ssssS
o. uao;o @ oses asny TGss W ~ T.
@?s ss1s-r,om Byron, sy Fit. Henry, Hail., md x,,,
a{s s9ts, ISfs Il R5sSis y
n I'D
ssfse n,ss' ", p e. bond
ts 5i!s; |is: 'sssS so{G; f:
s,a,,n n ~ ss a m,
siss @ y
'f$ sf
s,'ss ct lsss .s.ss, ;, wssn,s, ssa ,,', n 1.
, 1874-05-15
SILK MANUFACTURERS,
MuotInE OF tho SILK Association
AT1IQrlcQ.


Amortca.
New YonK May 14.-The Silk Association Of
Arnorica held itH second annual meeting yeeter-
day, At which tho 6ccretary's report was road
and tho officers Of tho preceding year s#ero ap-
pointed. Tue report gave review Of the opera
tionB Of the first year, and said that while
many trades aye langtlishiug, and aomo in ruin
GUS disorder, it is apparent that The silk trads ia
we'll In hand, controlled by conservative coun-
ao!s, Watchful for first awalseniuEs which only
legitimate wants should arouse, md fully con-
tent to bido a time which shall give to patience
and wise Helf-relianco their su1e reward. Thu
replioa to the requests Of the Association
for etatistics arc coatirmatory evidence to the
gratifying fact that the operatives in tho silk
mills throughout tho country have thus fur been
very generally maintained In thoir regular viei-
tations, tho percentage Of reduction from tho
usual Aoura OF labor boinG. in a.l tho mills, only
u por cent III the past yenr. In New York, tho
Rtlk operatives hayo bonn employed "a por cent
Of the usual hours OF labor; III New Jeracy, 8015
per cont in Ponnsylvanla, SO per cent; III Mas
99115 ror cent Tho report reviews the statistics
Of the ribbon manufacture, the trade In ladiea'
dresa trimmings, fr,nges, gimps, brads, etc.,
upholstery trimmings, aew1ng- -sitk aud maqhiao-
twist. or diesB ailks, the report ,ocords marl-
cd decrease IN the production, owing to tho Sep
tsmber panic. III conclusion, tho report sayas
"All considerations lead to tho conviction
that the natural facilities for tho American man
ufacture Of silk goods are becoming more widely
The American ilk.induatry iB d power in tho
land, and must be respected. Tho mills do an
annual business Of nearly III, 0,o000 0oo." In the
evening the Association gave its second annual
dinner, at which addresses we're mlde by VOL
kuoWn members and Otlors.
, 1874-05-15
o. both proach from rqanuseript, or aro both
eloquent mon.

1ouA1 GOSPEL.
In like mannor, tho proBecutor'a comments
upon tho words '"1oca1 Gospel" groaKly pet
yorted Prof. swing's meaning, as IL ho had sad
that tho Gospel waB ono thing In PittHburgh,
end another IN 81: Louls, and still another In
Chicago. I submit that no fntr-mindud man,
reading another for tho sole purpope OF getting
at l1is mIoaninR would oycr bo In danger Of mit;
thling tho meaning Of these words. He would
understand them as referring to tho differont
modes Of presenting tho Gospel nud not aa sig-
n1fyinE different Gospel for oach. In this
aanBo tho local Gospel whoro proaoh, aud the
local Gospel Whero Prot. Patton proaches. arc
vsI! t! d,aorent ,n from m sa9h oshor. and snnpose
they Always Will 10, 'lnlesa-whlch IL exceedingly
nallKdiy-tho prosecutor comes to adopt gub-
gt,t,antaaily my methods OF statlng and
illustrating truth. lApplauso. Mr. Modcr-
ator, 1t IL hard to bo patient With q critic
80 nnroasohnoly chptious. 80 groasly unfair,
80 nbaurdiy whimsical as the framor Of this In.
olotlnoat haa aAoWn hinlsolf to bg. say un-
hcsitatinglg, anu rovoront!y, that It he wore to
subject mo langaego Or uhrlst to tho ssn1e tor
ture that no aPPaas to the language Of Prof.
swing, ne Wonld haso no difficulty at oil In mix
1ng ntm omt M teacher OF false doctrincH. Jap
plahse.1 Iaolo -, eaof, nos4lng IN this speclli
csLh snhS ~ ~ uoa!utp, eXcops ono act aud ono
Hayl1g, mo aos ~ tnat ffoi. Swing gaTa n
LLo1ohE ~ Aln qf UNITARIAN CHAPEL
anu TUG SAYING Is Ehat no considered religion .
h!oao " v.sae' nus nul!nef aho acs nor tho say-
uH M nao1nia ~ tain eoaatataa W an nasnso.
by NJ 4hH cunhsfuUtlDn eau t11lS aet or lQctnrinE
, 1874-05-15
TEMPERANCE.
| Movements at NItu00iEn and Nor
r5k, ELL

movements ut N19N0QKn ana Mpfa
rih, Ella
Correspondence Of 4He Chicdao 1r.buae
Nlon1us, ILL.,, May 13-Tho Village OF aIinonka
voted ''No Lioeuae;" and Yesterday twelva suits
were commenced, III tho County Court, BY A: Il.
selling without lioense. The Hon. P. A. Ann
strong tlelo1ds thom.
Last evening, petition Of over 400 ladies' was
presented to tho Common Council of Morris, ro-
a!.eBting item not to grant nny moro licenses, or
was presented by Mrs. s. H. Dewey, in 3 very
eloquent mud foroible address. Tho Council re-
coiyod the petition, and d. referred i to tic Com
their regard forit BY rotus sing toallow transfer
Of iicenao to an applicant, aud alsn in refusing
to refund the money for the unexpircd term Of
another dealer leaving tho business.
Tie Hon: A. II. Jordan. tho present statoa
Attorney. who has boen very aolive ip prosecute
ing liquor-doalesB, waB elsotod by the Couuoll as
City Attorney over tho lIou. p. A. Armstrong,
bis competitor, and tho Herald and Adrertiss,
designated as the papor for city printing ovca
the RGfo,rner.
Everything now indicates TINT tho laws IN
favor Of temperance will DO rigiay enforced.
, 1874-05-15
to ahow bnuao May 90, and provisional warrant,

70 ahoT s, beuse May 90, md provisional warrant,
Cooper, Jonos 4 oaabury fllod petition
agalnst Wilmer 8. Bhopho1d, on promlesory
note for SiC4.l0 duo Oct. II, ISIS. busponsion
Of pnym6nt, and tho giving Of o Judgment noto,
or warrant to confosg judgment, a,o tho acts OK
bankruptcy charged. a rulo to ahow oaxso May
% was made.
SUPERIOR COURT m BRIEF.
George and Hiram WilAon bngan suit agninat
A. A. Ellsworth, TO recover 5000 worin Of
printing g,1nat presse' and type etc. at 1oe Clark
Tho Central National panl. began a suit againss
Horny Il. Plokot for $4,000.
samuel Z: Bailey brought gnit for $4,000
against .: II: Lincoln aud Ell 4. Doach;, aud
Joseph E. Bailey suad tho samo parties Tor a like
amount
The Illinois etone Company uuad E. F. Dore
for $4,000, mud Samuel J. Walker for e10, ,o0O.
CIRCUIT COUNT.
Jnmes Matthews bagan All action eghibst tho
Wllliamebprgh City 1nnuranco Company, tho
Mechanics 6 Tradors' Insurance Conipany, mud
the Drowera' y; y Maltsters insurance Company,
THE COUNTY. CounT. =
In tho mattor Of the estate OF Sarah r. Dar-
kenbilo. grant of administration was made to
Emily s1a IN T. poynon under an approsad bond Of
Tho will Of tho lato Jnnes Hart was proven
ny deposition, and letters parliamentary iworo
isDuod to Terence Hart. Executors bond Of
% goo wa8 approved. The renunonton Of
Mllliam a1a.1 burns' executor named in THO wll"as
Arthur Dur1nan was appointed guardian OF
hliloh tu1man, g. minor, under an approved
| bond Of 500.
Tho following persona wore ndiudged inaano.
snd sfY ban!o fsitS5 6ron x5sl o'sn' a'Ao'a' Anz'
In tho mstter Of tho estate Of John 9. oran-
dali, tee1ecutor's first annual account wcs ap-
proved.
TILE GALL.
JUDGE pnuMs1oNp-4Q. and from GO unlimited.
.JunaE ,AuaEns-Tax appoals B37, $50, $40 to
342, 3G2 to 805, 422 to 420, and tho call 8d8 $50
| 381. 800. and SCI.
JupoE Dooru-17o to 100.
1upGE TRgE-2,7 ,7G7, 1896, SIT, 101, etc,
| JUDGE GAnv-lU7 TO l30, oxaopt lbs, 112, 113,
| 115, 1lS.
JunaE 'JAmzaoN-2o4. 2o5, 2o7 to q21 22s to
225. ~' 41o ~
| JUDGMENTS.
| UNITED 6TATEs CIHOuIr CounT-JppqE DHux-
| MoaD.-united Antes Of America '. Electric Match
Company, $1,000: samo Y. Sumo, $so760I.
UNITED STATES D1sTR1Ur CouHr-Jupa BLopuEyH
C. ". Upton, Assignee, =. a. ii. Dawley, $1,057,ya
bUpEKlon ounT-QoNFEts1oNH.-Wiam Dsniols
:. William Pate5s, t2l7;ao-Eaaar Ioomis Of al, V.
Smith, samuel smith, and william T. Wndlaio. 500.
Illinois Stone oonlPany y II. Il: Honore t,eA.43,
JupoE GAhY.-Wuiat Kerr " Il. Il. Honoro, $685.
II. T. Barclay ct al. Y. ]. E, Young, $l8l.4B-Aex-
andcr Beal v. Lewis Jott, $56.82.-rown Of Cicero "
s:y: Walker $d7s.5o.-Jqmea Dsstno '. R. II. Housh
JuDoE Observation-Disclosures City National BANK v,
John Mo1ntyre, Frank Price, and John Hogers
$97e :73-oha1lea d. uronson ct NJ. '. IT. Z. Wood
c1nourr counr-juDcE pooru.-E. 8. Ireland '.
| Skinner, $jG5,G7,
, 1874-05-15

Quo OF our merchants WAS at the White House
the other day, and stated little iucidsn nj
that shows ono Of the many annoyances to which
the Executive il subject. Troops OF pcrsUns
call on the proaluent daily to log or borrow
monoy. Among thls number was a well-drtsaeu
woma'i. sho cauo into the antc-roem aud asked
well-known oniolal whose name was on tho
nppor lett-hand corner Of the envelope. Pro-
snmiug that eho had Important business, tho
usher lnylted Aer to ba seated. "When can
see the p1esident2" Hes, with tho Cabinet,
nnd viii be engaged for an hour" "Wo!l, a. I
have oarrlage, aud layo to pay by tho hour r. /
may al vol ride. will rolurn aoon," p,omnt
on lime, the laly returned. she was introducetl
to tho President. Her business was to obtain
nlonoy to pny, hor lotol bill Tho otlcial Who
gaye her tue letter Ia indignant that his letters
to the pres'dent are not moro promptly attended,
to-" 1urleigb" in ats Boston Jos.,nal.
, 1874-05-15
PHILADELPHIA.
Report Of Mnyor StoK1oy-Tho Oley
l EJnuRotcs.

Report OF Mayor StokleY-Tho Cley
ElnnslGCA.
Special Dtapatch to Tho Chicago Tribune
pH1LApELe1l1A, May l4,-a1nyor Stokley pro-
scented lis annual message to the Councils to-
day. It gives the total liabilities OF tho city rs
eS5,SG4, 17l.6s. Balance in tho City Treasury
Jan. I, 1874, $2,178,399.us. Tho valuation Of
real eetatc furniture, horses, oattlc, mud pleas
ure carriages on which taxes are laid foots up
s548, $50. an increase Of 21 ,0782 2G7 tho
previous year, to which must be addcd 1915, $685.
G97 money ut interest at snhiect to taxation.
The police force, numbering 1,0O2, iB admitted
to bo insufficient to afford propcr security to ifo
etc., owing to tho immenso amount OF Territory
tioular reference ia mndo TO tho evasion Of tho
ordinance prohibiting tho erection Of wooden
buildings withinthe blliltap portions Of tho oty.
, 1874-05-15
TIE COURTS.
MISCELLANEOUS business TRANSACTED
fEaG l1n1r

miscellaneous business TrnnsQctcSi
Yesterday.
| In the diyorca caso Of Harriet Wisner, COM
monced short tlmo ago, threo judges were en-
ployod yesterday afternoon In deciding whether
the complainant should have any a1imony, and,
it SO, how much. Judge Farwoll presided.
Ex-Judge Van Buron appeared for Mrs. Wisnor,
and c1-Judge Knowlto3, for tho defendant. Mr.
Wisnor hlou an affidavit etating Tint in tho fore
part Of 1870 ho was obliged to leave his
vito on account Of her chickering's
and i'll tempor and had ever einco
lived apart from her. Soon after ho decided to
leave the greater part Of Ills property for hor
maintenance aud that OF her children. She had
also property Of her own, including tho house in
which ahe lived, tho latter worth about $4,000.
john N. WlHnor, who was also nlnde q defendant
to restrain him from dispoaing Of certain prop
erty belouging TO Henry, flied an answer allog-
,ng that tho property which Henry sold him was
transferred BY bona dde conveyance, In which
the vile Joined, and that the injunction which
was granted WAS seriously inconyanienciug him,
and preventing him from making \ sale Of any
OF this lald.
temporary alimony, including aollcitors Iees, as
follows: $3.50 to bo paid within twenty days, and
$100 June l, and every moath thereafter. The
injunction against John n. Miauer WAS modified
~ hb to ouiJ EbhtTalu AlUl from conveying any
property or valuable thing Of Horny WiBuer, md
to restrain him from conveying anything to
third party to be hold ip trust for Honry Wanor.
The motion for tho writ Of no exeat was ovcr-
ruled.
ass 1000 INFANT.
Jnags fognrs u engage;u a. ~ try1ng tue case Of
DaYld CAAWBll aSRlnHt William r. bunting. Tho
plaintiff claims that tho defendant had i. large
hole or vault in his yard which ho neglgenty
loft nnopencd, and that bis {plaintins) ohlid
foil therein md was killed. For this loss ho
brings suit, and claims $4,000.
"A largo number Of witnesses wero introduced,
tho defendant oudeayoripg to show that tho
plaintiffs cows had troddon or torn down tho
division fence, and that hs neglgeuco CONCUR
ring to produce the ncoidont, llo could not ra-
cover.
$4,000 L1nEL SUIT.
A few days ago, a bill WIS filed by Il. J. uitz
and D. F. Eisenhart against William Hopknson
and Thomas Dartoe, to remove cloud oil the
title to certain pieco of land. In tho eo,'1no
Of tho bill, it was etated that tho trust decd
which created tho cloud WIS n1aao by William
A. Travis. m agent Of Z. 4, Travis, but tliat W.
a. Travis had no written authority to act ae
such, and that tho echeme was conspiracy DO"
tween the two Travis.
W. A. Travis, not waiting to a0o IL tue plll was
diBnf8Bad or not, began Hlltt Tor Abat yostof-
day, stating tho shove ALLEGATIONS OF tno olli.
md claiming that they Waro malsolonay mnao
, 1874-05-15
EDITORIAL EXCURSIONESyS.

CINCINNATI, May 14.-The New York stata
Editorial Excu1sio1.lsts were to-day mot by tho
Presidents Of tho Board Of Trado aud Chamber
Of Conlnloroe, aud invited upon Change. They
wero met On Change by the Editorial Assoc,e-
tion from Indiana, ami speeches Of Welcome
woro mado md responses givon. Tonight both
assocations will have reception at tho residence
Of Richard Smith, the oditor OF tho Gazette, Tie
New York delegation will leave Tomorrow for
LouisyIlle.
, 1874-05-15


by tho unworthy mud extrayEgaut laudatiou In tho
pulpit, and through tue prcss Of John Stuart Mill, a
nnn who WAS known mot to haSe believed III the Chfs
tlan religion.
Ii that the setting forth OF q fact Pot au nat
winch clearly royeasb and 1nanifebts to this Court
the gull Of tho rcapondant7 On tho contrary,
it is tho setting forth onIy OF conclusion Of tho
prosecutor hiMH0lf.
In tho sermon aforesaid l1ngnngc u employed
which Is dsrogory to ths stundafdso of tbs preabys~
run Church.
Again IN exhibition Of tho prosecutors infer
ouCos.
spgclfIoAI1oN NINE.
1Io has given BITS approval, In tho pulpit to tho doo-
trino commonly known III Sabcliapisn.
Wha.oyer hq may haye dono in tho Judgment
Of Prof. Patton, corts,u]y there are mult'tndes
who have made themselves familiar with tho facts
of this trini as thoy have been developed, and
sproad out before you, who do not ut alE agroo
with him In tho conclusion wllicl, ho Beta forth
hero, that Prof. Swing IL q Babellian, and that
a a' fvaa fs hs p ropnh aphf9vs sarv TO 1 s Of Gs %
specifications which are Bot forth unlor these
ohaygos, aud show that they are all, no Far az
they mnko out anything oulpablo simply the
judgments aud Views OF tho prosecutor himself.
TIE sPEols1CAT1oN.
come next to 6peak OF tho specification.
And llore III defining what tAe specification is,
and what It should embrace, follow tic highest
authority (O'Drlol,-7a Hillary Law and C5urts
AlartIal) lilo prnolplos to 10 esated aro am
sure, Hlloh aa will commend themselves TO tho
Judgment mud reaaon ot every member OF this
body, The specification must always oharse
tile accused with having ut such timo, aid
ii suoA place. dane aertatn ants wlliql, amount,
or witch ars thought to amount, to thg oHeuAo
atatod III the charge. ".l'ho faat or facts ought
10 30 vory tllht!n9tly specliea Or allogod in ach
p,ooiae object Ut inyeatigatlpn. Every faot in
Tie specification alould DO such pa, Ii proved
would convict the ACCUSED ot tho' charge, or At
least might convict him OF It," But does auy
taase aae speqlaostopp gan b. regarded IL meoting
this 1easouahle requirement. -" Any allegation
, 1874-05-15

formed too favorable an opinion OF the man, and
Of his general work. hs view il ono with which
with which members Of this Court, worry possibly,
may not coincide. But what then /? Is it not
better to orr on thu sido OF charity than on tho
| side OF severity? Prof. Swing did not fail to
slly tue defoot in Mr.. Mills character, Upon
his life, so abounding and 10 magnificent In its
labors III behalf ot philosophy aud reform, le
wroto the word vanity" NJ his hnal verdict, in
broad and lcglblo characters, aud oyen though
you suppose that bis Judgment Of him as phi-
| losopher, as 70 'isfcal economist, and as a re-
former be d too favorable one, arc you going to
| regard this rs an ccolesastioal misdomeanor
which requires formal censuro2 layo not 10
poor IN oplnion Of this Court Us to belioyo that
they will for ono moment entertain suol d
thought. No, Sir. Trof Patton IN wrong. He
IL wrong In thinking tllat tho religion Of Christ
is to be commended and advanced by treating
principle OF refusing to commond what IL oonl-
! nlonulb]a IN another, simply beoaNHo he ia not
all that We know ho should bc. Not so did the
Savior for he commended one, alpoat warm
5ss.sssa y ss fAs but soSsd 10 aa''ss ot e asi s
Jay, "Ono thing thou 1aoloBt." LackIne
TINT ho lacked I'LL things. It Ii not in any ini-
portant respect different from this, that Prof.
not therefore, done In this matter what amounts
even to an indiscrosion, leaet ot all to m ofon6o,
and llenco all tho prosecutors ingenious and
slilltul pleading does not deaoryo, Us mn por-
rious consldorat,on
PATTERSON AND cotIXEp.
PROT. Swing ia uoxt charged With having said,
in substance, In tho L0keside Monfht9 thpt
Robert Patterson and 1sobor. Collyoy pioacAod
tho same doctrines. This alao iB q copnluaion of
Prof. Patton, aud one Which dcps manifest
yiolanco to tue language which tho dofenlart
employed. Ile sald that tho two mniators
preached practically and to nfor from tis that
t4ey pfeaohed tha sumo Gospel, and tAat the
sumo that two mon alo declared to pTeach tho
samo 0os2sl because they both preach earneztly,