davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
, 1874-08-22


eondant, disseminated through the country, aud
insisted upon ~ 4 baais OF pnlllo policy. How
much this accords with any systematio s'.solence
Of political economy" taught IN tho collegea Of
Iecogn!zod maatera: OF that acionco we may loayo
for tue reader to Inquire. Such philosophy
WAS mt in harmony With tho common aensa Of
Northern agrioulturists, who wanted m open
market tor their profll,cta IN, foreign countries.
and merchants ana shipping to carry them thoro,
n,oaisleB IN return. Nor did it better accord
with tho ''' - ''
coMMua aEysE or NORTHERN MAsurAcruaEns,
who wanted al opall .co1n1nolce to bring them
leirraw materials fronl allY part OF, tho world
whence they could best be procured, and to
transport their fabries to my pnrt Of tho world
whero they could bost find mask0t.' They did
not wish to .bp .t}gbarrea, - they we're ny tho
lords OF Protective 1ariF, from buying tAoir raw
cotton from South Anaerica, nor to ho zoAtglctea
manufactured goo1a. They did not aHk for the
exclusion of foreign fabrics. Nor did the lm-
porting merchants ask for any legislation against
oomeatio manufacturer.
All caaaeH, ,Were content that Nature with her
law OF supply aud demand. together with in1lyi-
dual entorlwiae aud Hsgaclty, ahould be lottfrce
TO adjust Tho relations and proportions OF ,agE1-
cultural manufactures, and commerce. % az
per3enco might dictate, without perpetual Hquab-
blos " IOongress for tho -"prosectson !" OF ono
favorltn tntereRt from honest competition with
anolAer; determining beforehand, In Tho light
oi ignorance. or by the impulse Of solhsll''oss,
What .Gomin1aitlea tho peoplo should bo permit
ted 10 import Al>l what tlIoy should be compelled
20 tnant'faotnre; and detofmining also whataer
loft free to distribute itsalf In QUO proportion,
botWoon agriculture. manufactures and aoamau-
ahip,-between telling Western forests, cul-
lystlug cid Or new Bolls, peopllnR factory vi.
lagos, and ploNlng tue .oosan. or whethas.
, 1874-08-22

Nathan Sargent, author Of tic "0llyor Old
School I4ettors," and formerly Commissioner Of
tsaoSa ta@ n s 0o ooe 81 oi 1S aSo @
dropped from tho, roll thls weak. 80; ~.
, 1874-08-22

tha IHe, rscort W ,a si';o1 srH;,,o y
caamitnua u ,,aa Mu'sI atrs,teG ;Io .to
nav Nct;vitv hu to nros,o"t m.s ond M a.o ,
tho enactment, Of 1ligiTayin, rio mania odf
faot,,ra a"naa m9' "0aiih vi oIsaaou auo
n,on notnrs ,a n,n
ioota or uhaw1nnc t%a;, % rrotosp;e;'a ~ t"rn
cntto,, iao.mror. '@o Wn,opoio and rasa;
de,era sofd ont ti,o;r ,ara,'nJise ~ s,roat =;
unnfcs on1 ns,oo ~ anttn,, Tss,,,o.a ~ .e1T 80
Tona ,g;dora sv t 'a1s tai loi tnG sams paposos
uantlicraft mechanics concluded to letwatorfals
dnd nlaehlnory supply the place OF muacuiar OK
erton. .Sailurs and day-aborers, witAtlor fam.
illes, along with h,rel lnen,on farms. and I,ouur
servants. 'a)lurod by tho .nn,r de,nonTl ror
onorativeR rnsl,oa i,to H. ~ a++a,, Haa"as ~
, 1874-08-22

OF tno hnaas, WilcA presently feachGQ TIC All,
nirals ears, WHO sent for the Captain, questioned
him, and. andsag thu story iruo. severely repri-
manded him for Lia brutality, and ordered ium
buck to rescue the man.
Tho ialend upon Which Jeffrey lad been so
harbarously lott waa oae Of the Lcewsrd group.
q deao!ate rock called 2otubrero, and the Recruit
got back to it just fortnight after tho event.
A,careiM saasch sTna instituted, but all that WAS
found was pair OF trouaers, not Jatfrey's, aud
q tomahawk-handle. VIC trace Of the pnlaslng tnall
being dtscoyeratls. -, ,: =.
Yhla result being reported on the al,ip'a return
to l,arbaloes, Sir Alexander Oochrane felt aatis-
1led ,that tho man had bean rescued BY some
passing veaaet, aud lot tho matter toat for tic
time. But good many formed di iaesent opil-
ion, and suapaeted that Jal{ray lad come to some
England tho affair waa taken up by tho people at
homo, aud mado 80 m,uul noiao that, aftor two
yeara hal elapsed, tho Uaptain was brought to .
uourl~msrtia1. coudomnod, aud dismissed the
service; TAla however, instead Of eppousipg
moro, BY the authentio "details which were
brought to Light in tho eauruo Of tAo
court-Iaartial. Tho ileRality Of tLls mana hay
Ing bseu pGesAod at all--the ventBlity OF his Of
fenao; especially, considering tue circumstances
90 hot olimRte, aud tbs ready tomptattonto ap-
peaBe 1t PLACED directly In Lis way, combined,
with tho inhuN,hn cruelty OF hia abandonment,
to htr tlie nubl'e indignation. .Meatings were
halu. arslo!os written. petitions algued, urging
the proprtoty Of endeRvtrlng by al moaay to
discover What hal heootne OF tho mlasiug mau i;
aud Sir lFrauolB Durdatt loat no oppoI tauity OF
keeping TUG question betoEe dqyoFn.peut In tho
House of Commons.
Illegal preshiugs, keel-saulings. Aosgtugs to
death, were not 80 uncommon In tho navy at
that tlmo 90 to account for tie uaaally tndlKer-
cut Iubllo'R eHpouaing Robert Jelrrey's oause 70
warmly but It did Ao, and made represousa-
tive lnan OF him. D..
Ths- -ds4t eutAepHo news came tram George
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
The we st,

A FURIOUS bull recently attacked Mrs. Love,
near Elk Rapids, Mich, throwing her from his
horns distance of twenty-oue feet. one horn
entering the stomach and the other entering
her mouth and tearing it back nearly to the
ear. The injuries are said to he fatal
The Headquarters Hotel at Fargo, D. f.
with the railroad and telegraph offices. were
burned September %. Loss over $50, 0G0
GEN. BRIsBIN, who was sent by the Omaha
Aid Society to the grasshopper district. has re-
turned to Omaha. He visited Dawson, Gosper
Furnas, Harlan and Franklin counties. and
found more restitution than lie expected. The
provisions on hand in this large district VIII
not last more than ten or fifteen days He
estimates that $4,000 people win have TO E
supported through tie winter.
JUDGE FIELD, of the United States supreme
court, sitting with Judges Field and Sawyer. at
San Francisco, III the Chinese women habeas
corpus case, has decided that the state law
under which il was attempted 10 send them
back to China is constitutional. Judge Sawyer
OF the circuit court disscnjed, but Hoffman
the district judge, concurred.
TUE three parties are nearly equally diyidedin
the Oregon Legislature, tho Independents hold
Ing the balance Of power i'll either House.
REPORTS from different portions OF tie ives
say that furious storm Of wind and rain
visited the localities. Sept - \ church at
Rock Island, H., was Totally destroyed, and
much damage was done at other points.
A WOMAN named Jackson. accompanied by q
boy who answers the description Of Charley
Ross. has been arrested IN Harlem county,
kph
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
OHIO RIVER IMPROVEMENT

The commission appointed TO decide
upon plans for the improvement Of the
Ohio river held a session ut Evansville
Ind, September %. The commission
approved of Col. 1Ielrills plans Of i'm
proving the river by movable dams.
Pennsylvania, Ohio, Illinois and Ken
lucky were represented.
The commissioners adjourned that
afternoon to meet iii Washington Oeto-
Der 1G. Resolutions were passed asking
Congress TO take decided action for the
improvement OF the mouth Of the Mis-
sippi 50 as to meet the wants Of the ae-
rieulturai and other industries OF the
country; appointing q committee Of two
from each of the commissioners from
Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana and Till
uois, to obtain from the states the pas
sage OF suitable laws ceding to the
United States jurisdiction over such
small tracts OF land as may be needed
for the erection of locks, lock-keepers'
dwellings,, abutments, ect, and con
domning the construction Of another
bridge over the ONO at Cincinnati, q
short distance below the present bridge
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
THE Nr]H POSTAL Ivy.

The following is a synopslsoE the mex
postal iawwhioh goes into effect January
list, 1875, unless the law be changed 1T
the coming session Of Congress, Under
the new system, postage on tie ordinary
articles carried by mail, and which Ii all
eases it viii be necessary to prepay, viii
be as follows.
L. On letters. sealed PACKAGE mani matter.
wholly or partly Ia writing. except book manu-
scripts and corrected prooi sheets and local er
drop letters. three cents for each aei.
ounce o. fraction tiscleof.
=. On local OF drop letters TWO uts Tor
each ounce on fraction thereof
3 On daily papers not over four ounces ~
weight thirty five cents per quarter, ftLtaa
m0utis:( the same six times per week, thirty
cents; tIi-Weekly. fifteen cents: aeMi-WcuilIv.
ten cents; weekly i've cents. al tie above
are for one siGar,eI-t!lree months.
] On monthly magazines weighing not over
four ounces the rate perquartcr Is three cents.
the same. over four ounces and not over eight.
SIX cents.
j. Or quarterly magazines the postage for
the above weights Is respectively two and three
cents.
g. On pamphlets, occasional publications
trancient newspapers, magazines and pencdi-
Gals haudbilis, posters, sheet music unacaled
circulars proepeotUses, book manuscripts and
proof sheets, printed cards, maps, Autographs
prints, cbEomo-lIjh0graFhs and englavings
seeds. cuttings bulbs, roots. and sciona, the
postage is one cent. for each TWO ounces or
fraction thelaof-weigl.t Of package limited 20
four pounds
T. On flexible patterns. samples of ores,
metals, minerals. and merchandise, sample
cards. Photographic paper. letter envelope
postal envelopes wrappers, Imprinted cards
plain and ornamental PAPER photographs and
all other articles foE which other rates OF post
age are not prescribed, and which are not by
law excluded from the mails, the rate is one
cent for each two ounces or fraction thereof
weight If package limited TO four pounds
S. On books the postage Is one cent for each
two ounces or fraction thereof weight OF
package limited 30 four pounds.
8. On uns5aloj circulars. newspapers. and
on periodicals not exceeding two ounces in
weight, when any Of the same arc deposited
in a ictter-carTfer Office for delivery bE the
Office or its carriers, the rate l. one cent each.
TO- On periodicals eNcec ling two ounces ia
weight, when deposited in a ietteI-cauier Of
fee for deli cry 10y the Office or its carriers
two cents each IS charged.
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
The South

W. p. JONES United States commissioner at
Demopois, Marengo comfy, Ala, and the
Republican candidate for probate Judge writes
that not man has been killed, nor q single
outrage committed in that county on account
OF political feeling and free speech. and Re
publican principles can be INDUCED III any
where. The best feeling prevails between the
colored Republicans and Democrats.
JUDGE A. A. ATocHA. of the superior criminal
court of New Orleans has rendered his resig-
nation to Gov Kellogg. No reason assigned,
as no action by the state authorities against
the leaders of the recent revolution would Ice
brought before the court.
CONFLICTING reports arc in circuIa ION as "a
the condition of affairs il Edgefeld county.
Ga. The negro, Tenant, ring-Ieader of the
party, was not arrested as reported. Latest
repor.s state that all is quiet
C"L. JAMES @. BRoADHEAD hitherto 4 CON
spicuous Democratic leader in Missouri. de-
cIines an invitation to speak for The Demo
cratic candidates. but will oppose the ticket as
a whole
The fall meeting of the Kentucky Racing
ASSOCIATION closed September 10
THE Democratic executive committee 81
Tennessee have issued an address to the pub
lie, condcmning violence. and citing the civil
rights bill as intended to bring about the state
of affairs now existing in the south
CORY f. WALLER shot and fatally wounded
Robert Geschoft III a saloon at Little Rock,
Ark, recently.
THE kellogg administration was reiustated
in Louisiana 10y United States forces. Septenl-
her Is
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
INSURANCE IN CHICAGO.

r b,,or+ of Tho Ma
l. A. holi's''iiLei = 49,
tional Board OF flfe ohoei"Iltsi' 5''S .
that the recent action e1the Board re-
commencing the withdrawal of insurance
1---, -, g-rI,;oae,o vas absolutely
,'''-'--i'-'''' -,,.,.,,ro III
necessary iiS q pio'ec'i's
authorities OF Chicago had III some IN
stances utterly ignored the requirements
e ~ po,r} md IN others they had
80 ..fo,.,. TIE
lnade sp't9iiiJulc clloI'9 90
Fire Department was sadly lacking ~
7ioa;,,1ire and zyaa controlled by politi-
80 = 10 t,,.-o the authorities had
a 80 COCO 600 for the construc-
e.l, o1,5 ,lar:,,- ~ ,,te, mains md fire
II - 1..e Ill.,. {E-.+e, Euoneer 81
~ - ~, Cbaeahro7,~b a4sGIts that
230o 006 CON he axrended on that work
- oyea
a. - L., 0al.Iev president Of the
ID l,.ee3'l-;,,l, -, 4ha COMO
-5-E.,. 90 i, -.efaFa,,ef
~ 1IIllee- e H. 7,a,.,,,g,z.,,+
- 'iie e'7,,''i- 1a-,.i ;Fl, fba o,r,o,.
~ - - - H. -;t f7,af line common
ls,,,,,ail - l.},icaoo md ,.assed ma ordi
- =, tI.st at5,ecs Int +he updal,vri
ta,s Eo,,e - 1,+tla confidence tbqt Il
Iii I've ca,.ried ont heaausa the exeau-
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
THE; & 8; W s.
The EAST.

Il the practice shooting at Creedmoof be
tween the Irish and American teams, no scores
are kept, but the Americans excel the foreigners
III almost every instance.
THE Fall River cotton mills companies have
decided, it is said TO run their mills on short
time. some reducing to one-haif and others 10
one-third.
THE Representatives OF the transatlantic
Steamship Companies have failed to agree
upon passenger rates and their late rivalliea are
renewed. tickets to Europe selling al SO each
Mn Ross, father of the abducted boy, has
commenced libel suit against the proprietoIs
of the Reading Pa) Eagle, for an alleged de-
ffamatory article in that paper
s. g. BRIGGs. OF Chicago, said to be default
er in the sum Of 100000 from the bank Of
which he was cashier was recently arrested in
New York.
Ohm CRAWFORD, propristorof the Malable
Iron Works at pittsburg, while returning with
his wife and daughter TO his country residence.
on Sept 18th. met with terrible accident
The barouche collided with a coal-wagon, tear
ing off the front wheel AID throwing the
daughter and driver to tile ground The
horses ran of, and 1Ir and BIrs. Crawford were
thrown out. killing Mrs. Crawford instantly
Mr.. Crawford his daughter and the driver
were nv,eIoIy u5uteu.
THAT unmitigated fraud, Weston, has made
another failure in attempting to walk 500 miles
III six days He gave it up after walking 32(
miles in New York. recently
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03

Throw BIZ the trappings of thy tinsol rhyme
Hush the crude voice, whose neyer-endins
wall
BHghts the sweet song of thrush or nghtiu-
gale,
set to the treble Of our tinsel tine
Is earth grown dim has heaven her grace
sublime,
Her ponip of clouds and winds and suusct
shoWTs,
Merged in the twilight of funereal hours,
And Times death-signal struck its iron chime;
Oh. frail false dreams not the tiniest note
From yonder green girt copse but cries thee
shamei
Love. beauty, rapture fill tie Warbler
throat
The self-same Joy, the passion bitiic and
young,
Thrilled by the force of whose immaculate
dame
The first glad stars, the stars of morning.
sung.
-GGlarg.
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
Wa shin gton.

HE New DIRK bank note companies have
been awarded contract to do part of the
government bank note printing. Three COM
pauies competed, and the compensation for
the work that they have contracted TO dc VIII
amount to about = 50o, 900 annually This
viii necessitate sull further reduction in the
bureau of engraving and printing.
GIN. SHERMAN has sold bis Washington resi-
dence on / street to eX-Mayor Emory.
SECRETARY BRISTow has gone to his home in
Kentucky, TO be absent some time.
The national bank redemption agency gives
notice that in consequence of the exhaustion
OF the five per cent. fund and the failure Of
national banks to make a prompt and general
response to the request for additional deoosit
of five per cent. of their circulation. it has
become necessary to stop the redemption of
national bank notes for a short time.
THE President. Secretary Belknap and Gen.
sherman have signihed their intention to be
present at the reunion of the Society of the
Army of the Tennessee.
GEN. SHEARMAN will leave Washington Octo-
her to make his headquarters at St Louis
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
The EEGLTaE cELa1 i y. rIIlLnEI


On the revival Of the channel tunnel a
recent correspondent says that hitherto
the French have been only playing with
it, but the Northern Railway Companies
of France, afraid lest the tunnel should
some dag be made by rival company,
is now anxious that it should be attempt
ed at once. 4 company is to be formed
under two Boards OF Directors one
French and the other English The
Northern Railway Of France, and the
English Southeastern, and London.
Chatham aud Dover Railways are each
to contribute to the scheme. and the
Parisian Rothschlds. who are closely
connected with the Northern Railway,
have also promised to support It, The
French government. which was opposed
To the project when NJ THEIRS was In Of
flee is now favorable to it, and bill on
the subject viii lie laid before the As
semblg IN November. 1t is estimated
that the total cost of the undertaking
VIII not exceed ten millions sterling, and
that El60, GOO VIII cover the preliminary
operations which are To test the feast
biGty of the scheme There viii be
thirty miles of tuuuehuo through the
chalk under the sea. ST. john Hawk
shaw and Mr.. BTamdees are the pTinci-
pal engineers. If ever this tunnel is
made. and it now looks more hopeful
than 1t has ever vet done, the govern
meuJs OF France and England viii have
to come 10 some understanding rs to its
being closed OF ueutraEzed ia the event
II war between the two countries.
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
IoNATEAN NFWH0UsE.

English newspapers express discredis
of the story publishedm the \. Y. sun,
concerning the fate Of Jonathan New
house. who was frozen to death on q
hot day in a Nevada desert through the
evaporation Of moisture IN solar amor
Of his own construction The Enter
prise, of Virginia Cjty, Nev., to which
the Sun credited the narrative, brings
forth additional proof including the
statement of Coroner Baxter, who held
an inquest on the body 1t the northern
end Of Death Valley. The verdict rem
deryd WAS that Newhousa came to his
death by being frozen in sort of
sponge, called n, solar armor, Of which
he was the inventor. and in which he
VAS tightly laced as his own request.
said arnfor being moistened with fric-
critic mixture. The carpet-sack found
with Ncwhousa contained various
chemicals. with which he was supposed
10 have mixed the water which was IN
iected into his armor. The remarkable
fact is added that the men WHO went
with The Indian TO 'tiud the remains OF
Newhouse had their hands nearly frozen
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
sER-CEE NIUT.

4 serious riot, attended with blood
shed, took place ut AspnwaII recently,
between 1taIians III The employ Of the
Pacific 5Iail Company and troops on
du5v there. 1T appears that one Of the
soldiers, unarmed, wason the wharf, and
was chased of by some Of the italians.
who threw stones at him. On arriving
at his quarters he reported the case,
when an officer and SIX men went 1T
once to the wharf to arrest those who
had made the assault. On reaching the
gate, one OF the Italians fired two Di5-
tol-shots at the troops without result,
when "a volley was lirodin return, which
mortalIy wounded one OF the Italians
and seriously wouDdcda Jamaica negro.
The excitement was intense, and addi-
tional troops have been sent for to keep
the peace.
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
GovERN15ENT EXPENSES.

Estimates Of the Government expenses
for the next fiscal year are IN progress
IN ali Of The executive departments, and
a few Of the bureaux and divisions Of
the east have already submitted their
estimates to the respective heads Of the
departments. Tie most important
branches VIII not have their estimates
completed for several weeks. About
Ealfa-d dozen Of the latter class cannot be
finished upti within a few days Of the
the assemblingof Congress inDecember,
when I'll reports and calculations must
lie submitted TO that body. Ia The
general aggregate, the estimates viii be
made Tor about the same expenditures
next wear as was allowed by Congress
for the culrant fiscal year, but IN almost
every branch increases Of various kinds
viii be recommended, on the ground
flat BY lhe legislation by Congress in
it's last session q too great reduction was
made. and the clerical force and funds
intorded for yarious purposes were left
inadequate to the requirements OF the
service
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
Foreign.

GERMANY.-Th Official Gazette says that
while the expulsion Of the Danes from Schies-
wig was a legal measure. it was only adopted
in a few isolated cases The Gazette SAYS
relations between Germany and Denmark are
friendly
RUssIA-The French newspapers publish
St Petersburg adyices confirming the report
OF Bismarck 5 overtures 20 King Christian Of
Denmark, looking TO the incorporation Of that
country in the German Confederation. Cor
espondents say that Russia is greatly Initiated
AT the attempt. and will never permit Germany
10 hold the key to the Baltic Sea. The same
papers say that the opposition Of Enssia %
the German policy in Snain is due to this cause.
GREAT BRITAIN Work has been resumed IN
the Bolton mills, pending arbitration set
tlement is expected about the end of October.
The cooperative board resolved to invite
Wendell Phillips TO the annual cooperative
oI.gress in London.
DENAARK.- Post positively denie7 tnai
the Danes have been elected ON ScslesHiS-
Holeteiu
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03
$agaCiCuS Mules.

From the Virginia New Enterprise,
4 gentleman who Is too modest TO al
low us to use his name, furnishes rs the
following instance Of sagacitv which he
recently saw displayed by a pair Of
mules, those curious spotted fellows
belonging TO Hank Blanchard Hank.
anQ john Pagan wore seated in a buggy
behind the mules, driving along South
& street. near the Divide Suddenly
the animals halted Whipping and
coaNing were alike IL vain; they would
not move What 10 make Of tins Hank
didn't know, is the mules have never be.
fore so conducted themselves. Seeing
that the animals constantly turned
their heads IN one direction. Pagan be
gan to looh that way, to see what it was
that 50 strongly attracted their attention.
In q moment he dropped on H. 1t was
"a single whitehead, s. Hay S23 per ton,
the regular retail price being SO. The
mules had observed this, and could not
be moved beyond Il until Hank got ont
Of The buggy, went INTO the place, and
came back, pretending that he had or
dered 10 toms Of the article at the re-
.ducad rate They then trotted of per
fectiv coutented
The Superior times. [volume] (Superior, Wis.) 1870-1912, 1874-10-03

Judge Wheeler, Of San francisco,
has revived the old English rule that
fraud in procuring a marriage Is good
ground for divorce. Mandler Yretsni
complained that his wife Eddel had
pracGced fraud upon him by falsely rep
Teseuting before marriage that che was It
sound and healthy woman. when. in
fact, she was subject 70 insanity. Judge
Wheeler remarked that that lac supposed
the husband was Il sane person, but the
TACT Of his marrying after only one DAVIS
acquaintance witt, his wife lift daabts as
20 the condition OF his mind It seems
that immediatelyatter the l1l..gri4co Mrs
lretsH became violently insane. ard has
since been m inmate 81 q California
asylum. During a lucid interval she
admitted that she had been an inmate Of
al insane asylum IL Europe, and as she
had represented herself az a sound and
healthy woman before marriage the
Judge ruled that fraud was established.
and divorce was granted Oh Tia.
ground. He added that Yretslli ought
20 be punished for his haste In MARRYING
out four years Of such life had been
sufficient punishment