, 1874-03-11
Coobrook, n Times reporter, In roforonco to tho
sounonu rroaccd by Mr.. Mccarthy.

H1tloftt though th0 NltncB1 tcu IL WltIlout llce-
itaion III tle prosouco OF q largo number OF
latfeB.
,fr. Gordon demanded to know what this had
toao with tho charge Of trcats.
.tr. Harry eatd 1t was tho worry key to tho case
wlicli hold tho revolver.
Mr. Drnyn,er vent OH to Hny that he relatoa
refused to allow Mr.. McCnltl to baptszo hts
wfe. llenco tho threnta.
AIr. MGCnrtliy, i'll ernHs.cxnHtnhtlof1, hBReo
II, wituess II ho tltl not ronaombor t1as ho gayo
tl,Ho rumnrks Oh lnying boon lrst maae ny ALL
Wikic.
Ar. lIraymor Mt first doniod,, but aforwart, ,1 r..
numbered, that tho pastor did quota AIR. "1'Klo
Mr. AlcCnrtliy-Did you not express The same ,'
oinon oil thu occaHlon thas mr.. "nA'o "o'
Q-Did Tint concurrence on your pnrt imply
tkat you woro immoral aud llcentlous5 A.-No,
rrof. Mitchell urged tint tl,is had gono tfer
cough It wns not roleVahe 10 commune tnla
Bbject.
Mr.. Barry Baid that it was relevant to show that
to pontur went out Of his pulpit bunday aud
itlufgeI In H,lcll talk as thH.
Mr. Mccarthy dunied that 1t was Sunday, but
Ar. D1Ayinor stuck to It,.
Mr. Wagner waa recalled to show how tho
trentA clllo about.
Several delegates objected to It rs Indecent
atd oiroBive, mud IA not relevant to the Charge
q making throats.
Alr. Wagner was excused from any dotni's. =,
Atr. Barry saisl thoIo we1o many other spociti-
otlo,s which rcnainod 10 ho disposed Of. They
mre equally objectonnble, a.d !l;.tl thG t uoancn
Alr. larry presented q printed report Of q SER
nu,, preached by MIR. Mccarthy Ia Haights bill
i:rd hall OH Sunday. Feb Ii. and 1t WIS vcriliod
iy Mr.. Jonhon. who was prosos't.
at'CARTltYB LOVE AFFAIR.
Mr. shoaror stated tint, Ia 1872, the pastor
bid lin, about a lovc affair, and reforrod to ar.
1cLeaull, saying that lie could, and would, take
liz !.cart nut If he persisted In this matter. At
n,u'her tino the pastor rslerrod to Mr; sham nm,
ut layiuE bcon guilty OF number Of ind'scre-
tons. anil threatened to tell something which
Would injure tho ponec Of big family:
Alr. shunror oiforcd to toll sonlething about
t,e 1nstorH rlltrt1tlfulneBs, but was oxcuBodt al
tint charge waB not pondt1lH.
On crols-oxamination, Shoaror atatcd that tho
tirent as to MIR. NicLeiscl WIS Oh account Of the
1n-sol'a love affair. .,
Q,-What did Mr.. AIc1.cisch haro to do with
lhat A.-You know more about 1t than do.
Nlr. Darry snid that he Ind how come to other
charges nnil specifications Which should not bo
iced befnro Il mixed nssemblngo.
Prof. Mitchell thought it beat to proceed md
ltubmitted by llo COMMITTEE boforo othors were
taknn up.
Nr. Tl,,ar1o moved tho reference Of the new
specifications to d committee, but Withdrew ut
tho b'lyss' stion Of pr. Gooihpeod, who thought
NUMBERING MCCARTHY.
Mr. Mccarthy thought this WAS adding insult
to injury. 1o had not received copies ct tho
charges anI specifications, md he va. not 1caay
to 20 forward. Ho naid they wero numbering him
III lnslir:; OIL with tho trial.
The Moderator called hlm to order, but he kept
on il, MI excited, yiulont strain, saying that thoy
were numbering him.
Mr. Kernott moved that tho new charges be
referred to tho Committee.
lror. Mitchell said that If Brother Mccarthy
nectlcd III, hour or two to prepaid himself
Mr. McCarthy-A what? An llonr or two!
You ought to 10 ashamed Of yourself
Tho Moderator Ordcrl
1iuf. Mitchell HAid that ho meant that II
Eroli,cr Mccarthy needed MI honf or two in
which to make up hia mind w1at 20 ask tho
toruscll in tho way OF delay. ho would favor Glv-
ing 1T.
with copy Of tho charges md specifications.
THE SPECIFICATIONS.
hlr. McCar,hy-1 layo mover seen tho apecia-
cut:'lls.
draw up tho full specifications aS to immoral
talk.
Nr. Gordon called Mr.. Barry to order, but tho
Moaelntur overruled the point
Mr. Barry new grew excited. and declared that
Mf+ 1flfut1H b4tHA HUI NEllHuA VI LILO A4EIt1s
lIo aou,i4tod thnt to had full specifications in
lAH r.'u'iet, which hul not been Furnished to MIR.
hlrEaith:.
Nlr. MCCARTHY nrose a1,d protested against pro-
cecdinS fs,r.l!or, but "as roughly called to order
By tho Moderator.
SECRET SESSION..
Mr. Gordon moved thit tito Council 70 into
necrct sessien 10 determine whether any furttor
testimony WIS necessary. and what action should
be takcu Oh the additional specifications. II
ftut,, In dat hnN Int1n tImA tlIa n,
cllscd noctel to prepare his defonBe.
A delegate asked il 1t was contemplated to 60
into secret session aud decide tile caso without
giving tha ACCUSED u cl4anco to offer rebutting
Testimony.
Mr. Mccarthy said that this was just what
they Nuiited to do.
Dr. Guodspeod saiil he should be glad to know
whether Brother Mccarthy desiol u defend him
self Oh ali tho charges, aud IT ~, huw much time
hn required.
Prof. Mitchell aad that il It waa necessary tt
proceed tur.her in tho investigation, Mr. Nc.
Cartly must first bo furnished with copy o1
tic n,uro detailed specifications, and then given
time to tefend himself.
The Moderator nBked Mr, MCCARTHY II he Wn
ready to proceed with his dofeuae.
Mr. Mccarthy said the gag law lad pocn On
forced upon him, aud he had been refusod por
mission to speak. llo WIS not really to ontoi
upon llis doIenso. They must know that.
AlI, Gordon'B motion was laid OIL tho table.
lie CANNOT READ IT.
3Ir. Mccarthy asked permission to reaa pro
tcst and Btato lla griovanoos.
Mr.. Larry moved that tie permission b
granted.
Mr. Goodapeed objected to 1t, Mr.. McCarth
llnd talked moro thur anybody olso i'll tho Couu
ell Ao Lau boon treated with perfect fairness.
Tle Moderator said the motion to grant poi
mission was out Ut order. Brother McCarth
should not read any protest Or apoak at all, 9,
cept IN his defense.
Mr. GoudsEoed said the accused was constant
~ charging the Council with unfairueas, aud b
rendered it dllilcult to treat him without prej,
d.co. Tho only thing for Alr. Mccarthy to d
was to state whether Ae wished to make dc
fouse, and, II 30, how much time ho required.
lie WANTS TWO WEEKS.
The Moderator asked theao questions OF th
nccue' : who stated that ho did intend to make
dofen =, asd would require two weoks.
Deacon Hoard suggested TINT, in order t
facilitate business, copies Of tho new Hpecif
cations should be furnished tho accused.
h1r. Wels submitted that, until tno evidonc
for tho prosecution was all ia, it VIVA impertiner
to nsg Lie accused how much time he required.
.ilr Mccarthy inquired II motion was n<
pending to graut him permission to present Ii
lMotoat.