, 1874-10-04
,,..;,, 10 Place the AtfidaVits Oh
File.
,x<rnrnts by Mcssrs' eanlacld'
r. ,]oync, Smith, aud Nni'k-
erbocker.
,,;,,,;ors to Filing on Account Of the
wy scandatous Character Of the
Testimony.
onnr+ Orders the Afdavits to Be
12S vs caa,ea and Placed On File.


11s 1sa caa,pa and Placed on File.
~. motion Of alr: Page, solicitor for or Ar
.:,. 1ao ouo Of tbs dsfsn'ant8 II 1ne sun .s ol
I'1A4-s, F,r,ell, for rule compeilng tue
IAas1 ,.:s,n, 10 he derosit'ons was argued oa-
e7np:a'a'Aw. wi),;.a.. in The Circuit Court, yes
fsro 'o'oe .;,c There wero present Of coun-
t1!ca: 'D'I = cac!icld. who represents Mr.
ssi' ~. Geo, Smith. who is looking attcr
EEsa -A'.s. ~ the Hon. Charles Z. Farwcll and
t1e 'n'se, .ticr,: :al 2i-. Ic Noyne, 1lz. Page,
ID 10 " ", Er;ckerboc':er. Tho represent AF. ief-
-. # will re remembered thas the apphca-
t,o rule was E1ade last Neancsdag' a.
~ 49, t;mo liz: r.go gave his reasons for asking
.a' ',1,r,s Int flat, owing ~ the absence OF Ar.
.,:a,5 tbs Court deferred actlon uutH he
t.:;i To heard.
,s+or ,nc motion had been restated, Alr. caul-
800 ia had no particular reason for object
."-,, az. rule OF the Kind; but he Ind had his
,c:sc1s for ,
vor FILING The DE2os1T1oSs.
m. ~. that he felt that it would bo for the In
t-s:+s of his c!irat that they should not be
f.ar,til tho case camo up for hearing. The
e=n@cseE ol 'ue ea7o vac ea ..,t - 49,
f,rr.: the object i'll taking 1t being that out OF
s.-rn chau 5ov grains Of wheat might be
,..,,i: aud me question IN his mind WAS
t1ata5r oa77s ctieo'NssAn.
E.cn he icl! '.4a' A117 e'2eA"o r,..,.,
rase-taefe "as 4us Ns-e'7s ~
rsz!::o2-. nc eon!eosea 'ha' ~ n -,
r-.soD ior IT, aho IL Was ''''s' 'n~s'oo u4o ~
fiA1 w 70 p@N 49,
u1ai, u a11ssapN'35 -
AA1l's THE enAH"e4t tN VI - -1A'
fa Eere political purposes 'e'ree 10
Id beea ol'oSeu ~ 1li1a - '''-''@s
la1Hei4 aao n';nse'4 n14 10y. .ol.o l H..
t7se: IN theif 11Fes' anu sn's 'esl1aio4, ID
+ to bElag h'1n ifat"eh} Flo'n'neoA:s o7t''e 'ao
e31taus's' as LUG es30 usu NAAoo' ~
I22e as.ea'1o'' Ill etlo no"e:apets uo ~ 49,
Is De'"eon llaa '1i''' ,A.1 'n'.s - s .oa.;
i:'eoec' o1 1ne eas9 o"t11 eet.'cu' noen '''A,-
n2uF probably ought not TO 60 upon Inc reco1os
I; the court. That vas the only reason he had
,,not fi,ir.. il AMI If tic Courx. sav ct to say,
y. bo ong,,t n fila thu da.
1.74 7,s:1.-t,,.,,,
Eth over the question whether there was any
rrorriety or improrr;etv in his retaining them,
tA..-se the ccrtlcr,cn fconnse11 knew he re-
.s:-.s ..ono .r5 .,,ot h;s ,,,i.c. ,,d @,,rnoso
e'1ea .aeA'' 0A4 "AA. 40 f1'l
Eas. LIZ cGoe.e'ooo 'nes IIa eoEies' 8uu'
therefore, did not thina there was any necessity
10, cuttiag tne originals on file until it was ao-
.,,,,e1r certain that TIM caso vas 70 ba tried.
,.3 ,,,.ro ,~,,,,a ho .,,4;,,e
EtA tu-4. -1N A--AA1AA. ""NN~ "S>~-- 49,
r'1s = test "netner tae oepoS'''o"s Ut Fott'ohS
Ct :he.u, at least, could be used IN the case
l. fvr
Any 1;,rpoprR MOTIVE.
!, ,.a Ill E;.pon,r c,n1, ,,,t. .,r
Il ua4 no'.o - al i'' .AoAo4 so''AA A0"Ao 0"s
rio Ao p:e2seo regarding tne HasteF' AS
eae:!lcn of practice, he did not know that =
re!t7 vas compe!!cd, il tie gaze notice to
-, o.bar rsrtica frat 1,e wa'a cojn,> tn
o'0et ~.
Ut eep's!sAoHe- ~ t41'o Anoeo W t'osstoH0 "0n
's1ly tie qusst!oa was "nesheS they apper-
;sned to the case, or whether those who under
t,,k to insist upon his fling them were to be
,<actcd hr Tho daacsi+,ons There wer. certain
tr,acts ~ - 1he c.!sa .iat Wou1d mi he ,fracted
sae ~ xaT o. The M osLer b7 the derositlous in his
n>ssps.;on
;. 49, 10 .to.ac eslu I'd qucs.'ou y. psae,ise'
usn;- 4 rafp,cn.r uay made a,r}in, ;z;ur M,
aA;.1, tn t.t. +..;,r,o,- ~ y r,. t7ton hefora
yot,rx ,n-;,or:ya%l ~ 1,,v ~ +aEa y MA
t.noositjoo ~ tho ]ov Irau tb-, In ~. - ds;n-
srrsted n7,tv snd i, ~ 1va- ,,.ar -, .,c,troI
If either Of lie no-t;as 1r,3 tcs.;,nnnv h,T;nc
tern ta.tn bv IN nacor - 49, cha,ao;or af.e,
tha na-ty Hho h.s e;ra-, ~ >otiea has sn-
nonnred th,t hi. 1es,;,on1 = c3oea1 ,;,a+ ofSca,
has notIinc furthar ~ - dn ;>,,t ~ ~@o~'
rET;,pr 49, rre7,.,o.v
which becomes n,r. ~ tho rorer,t !, H.. c,a-
10 The c1s:o6r of ,ha C,o-L ~ 80 c,,'-t ~
LeT 1ere NJ tbars ss sn u H.. .e +1o @
pt one Of tha rartisz sGta,Ii h.. roon;Tai ~ sur.
reader to The cn,rt ~ ,a,sara 49,, Iaia,,-cd n
tse co1r. Thst v,s H.. -,,e;,o., +a,, lc9,,,.a11
we're in. II VAS enooestad hv ~ rc;-l;ic,d ihet
tc tsl ret.ined the toat;~nooy Cof corraa ha All
t.; a:cr7la IN imnro,,or -1.et;- r. ;;,,i hon;ns,
ta1t :tere MIGHT he so,,e c,'n,,rrn;.n suTnose
N.-c yas. Uss .hnrs a,17 1,o-.a- ~, 1ta T.!r+ ~
Es gentlemen ~ of +i,a cp,rt p - r'@''
Suppress 7H.T Trsr1.soxr
10 hare it hnrnr1~ ~dast-a-a.;3 1vl,+ oor,3 r.
d3ae u;f;, Il: Eo,T r. H. at;e oe
nil. be- ysrr n-o,'.r Us ~; H. uau,o .4' ln.r,o
n1scs.ioa 'e.i 80 plopsr III nav'n8 me taSt1I:o11s
lsoald rsnarl,air nsie 9n 5e nes' nn: to oouls
F,' '.1 'ook the testimony. 1t 1t NaB iTzcie-
telcrecd-on r. W. ~" ~ "He1. 49,! ~
h:tzoonr7 1e>o'"' "i's o4a 10 N'AAo N'1o
liz I:,l,ie,d ,o-o,-,.o,, .,ot ~ a;a -. .or +.,a
ses:mony va ;-ea1a.&',s -: ,n.. 80 -
VI. IL s1oT,o .,,,,us It, fco,,sa,a,
tsa thst cucs,;an ha3 ..e,,, .'1,. ~ 13a+n,.'
c;aar r5,tj.s- - 10y at - ~,
r.orjs 11o.- .,,,,, e4a ~. ~ !s ~. ~
sse7s2-v .na s,,~,,sa.'. ~, e'ss 80. 1n,3 49,.
10 p5rnr to e,1,n-;a sao stut IL - o ~ -
BE- Should ho,d H.. i ~, ~ ;s..1s'o,'4 haco,so
- IL u = IL.