, 1874-05-23
;. iaporter-Whnt do you suppose can havo
taduced tile Professor to publish, or writo that

neporter-what do you suppose can have
aaassa snstsh ' Professor to pu1lis or vrto' that
hfr. 1Iurlbut-Dfr. Swing is 4 man who hatos
| notoriosy: His position forced him into it. 1
think no Is tired OF tho dotracton which polomi-
quiet sphere Of action,
heporter--.1s tho hontimont Of Lila own church
strongly with tho Professor?
Mr matiFlbut-Vorg mitch 80. indeed. 1Iis
snS No a asi d tRo rresbytel1 sb 1
have doolarod him not guilty Of horeBy, 1 thinlk
that regard is MATERIALLY strengthened. No
doubt, Il tho Professor insists upon withdrawal,
general sentiment. I believo that worry large
numbor Of big people will bo with him. thinIs,
however, that his loaying hfs miBdion at this
particular timo u rather hasty, .unoHs, as hare
before aaid, no felt tirod Of tho long continued
nothing Of tho mattor except through the press,
but business mooting will aoou DO called, at
which future policy viii, perhaps, DO determined.
mr. o. Fl, Loo, anosler s5t ri Elder Of tho Fourth
chnrc1, was also called upon, but he utterly ro-
fuHod to haye anything to eay OH tho subject,
hecanHo ho had NOT thought over It, aud, nj Ell
yer. know +! nothing wl1atoyer Of Mr.. swins's fu-
tilro Intentions. all he knew about tho affair
was already known to thu public.
Nit. MOVES.
Tho Rov. g. g. NoyoB, who defended Prof.
Swing. during tho latc trial. was alBo inter-
viewed.
i;eporto1~What DO you think Of Alr. s"tnga
| :, alr Noyes-1 think It was most unwiso under
| tho circumstancos. There was no reason for
nan,rsor, ~ o.u,'sSla5 1n,, s,,'n,.o ~, ;rarooo
brnnr',t ~ oo soa 0upoSn ~ Hay an'Mencu M we
nnrtioaS W. oo"A y" WIZ A'"Ao''oA ~ o"'0'oo
pessTFsoaNJ sTr Novoa-1havo m ro,son n sun,ouo 90
IT, a,un. uasu A1 -. tu'1Gn ~ nalI,ono y. so'
co,,,t ~ ~, lug iuua 5e't , on ~
r,ot u IL u.p sa III; ~ S5 na oto
~ r. ~ In',, Tt,,ro ~. ~, ~
nraai'. " su 1 .nu I..ae
i .ol''An oot4n1't14ou' W. 1tl:.I' uoa'1 t"'9
1,e!1,,. naa stronger ndoraoment OF hls position
n snlh no WE ntaYon 10 IT, " the Appeal 70 the
nynoa. 10 Is realy tlrea OF ali tn9 lax ABOUT
tl1, aau ~ tnas .no newspapers p"o'lsn 1o'asl9e
'onno sJnsloge.sy. .,.,
III Meporaermn9nt yon n tn'nn n .nat the rroiesSor
~" gSs au n;,f ~ at5n aa1n nS H. noSn ~ ~
tt,et an,,,1 10y m,,t soa5'"ot A''n oelsen ~
M Hr W t1,im'. that ., ,orr,,o,,n
". Noyest-.A tnInA tnat sho , oVer"holming
majority TO- OF ha s9ngregatlon wil condemn io
np nsep m1 snoniu M ;. AnYe , .oomporoa nls tllcnus
prcshvterv v;ncatei1 " liz tooct;nra A6' "'u 'A'
| HonortcrIThon Won thiuI thaf' ont os con-
aidnrston for hia frianie mi fnr tho proehvtar,t
swpr aboud hayo @ tu6 a
| Mr.. Noyee-I cortninlv tlo. and nhoye aIi fnr
tim aato n the Glnrch' III shon,,1 h.vo hra,ved
Tia wnrat- 5nrod ,1,o .rorot 1"' ~ 9A~'~N
'AD RcnnrtcrW1VcIl SA ~ "o,, von nav h, da,t,foa
nntoriety. md mint ho iuirol in tfh.t hpht
sfr. Noyes-That ia 0 ali yory ~ wei we'll. but his
i;ahI n,thnnr,, hoi;ora na ,ated on,, ,S;.i H.
,,rn,t ,nn1;r5oa ~ "s''@ "'43 "A'AA ''Ao
paAo9S ''o'''o0'
.s.nn. anur. lntioS. ~ c,,..
OF re a
cnnvor."t;nn. "''N "-AoAA A~ A'>@ 'Ao A''4o"A"6
" Ronortorm mjyhot 3o vot, tb;nk of prof s,v,no,s
| -r;tnsrn 1r"t '' 0' ~" 'A''4N ~ AoA' '"4"@
| prof patton-1t ,s = ,rr,rgo
Inncrte ts1o1. 40, 10 saLptnv ;;',a4;o ,u,
praf nattnn@ ~ t,nro u tlm,' ~ a,n;sas tim,
bavc hoon ~ nrood ram nh, time e n timo 'a ad
no direct intiination.
Heporter-Do von think that uoH tbe nroner
| courso for him to tnke? fAo1oA
Prof, patton-That il q question I oanuot mn.
| awer it ia fnr h;Y conacionco IN scft,o '@'
| Roportor-WoIi. in. Wow Of the doctrines which
yom ba|ioye ho taac,,as can he consist nmt1u w.
main in tbs Presbyterian Church 49,
Prof: Patton-5fy oninion il thnt he cannot.
neporser-what denomination would accept
Prof, pattou-Tho Conrrerationalists. I
think. =
have unon tho presbyterian Ghnroi, in iii.
cago7 p ~ ''''N'' ''''' - 0'l
| Prnf patton-It IL verv hard to aav do r,t
! know: but do not thinI1 tho froubrtorinm
Church will be nffoctel boyond the bounfiH Of tIa
Fourth Church. ~''~ 'e'
! Roportor-Would not tho dofcction oe TINT
Church ho anita n hfow tn lin t1ennnima+n, ~
prof. Tatton-Yes: It womld ho ,,nfnrtnnn+o
nenortar-Ts if tr,e That yo,, hnya tl,n,,r},t nf
mi D nrotecntnr tho annnai '0D AA'o 'A'us"' u
prof r. paitnn2No. tF0"''
| nonortor n, 1,m ;,to,;, ), ;r,rao ii, 41 1,u.
,,,tor ~" '''o''" w. 4''P'ael4 tno itea-
"' ,,n:, ,,.4,o NJ r.,,zn,r,, <un, ~. -
irol. fattohIEo: SIMPLY appca! from their
oee.slon, Mn'cn tn1nN IL wrong, 10 eot tho
| Juugmons OF nl3Hef couit@the synod
IepDTIGf--f nut HkGpS Will you thHe 20 EoE tAat