, 1874-05-06

sop s No3 Rosts I'D I n eb tbst sssS
ho ussa tho torn oo1octicism, tho eolooti-
olat of t,so Of application, not in regard tothe
3:=iH ?fssasa I'd Thu. p.ft u trs ola rstt.:
was something worse than tile cruelties praotiood
Sg 5g IT, ss t5ai M MgpSH ps4bt tsaE sss s I 6a
in egsm t. shs nha sssstds 81 & s: :rasi n Nv I'LL
reeed saan2 tl4gatlbn II aly mind ~ f. whit 10
SsS "a ;ksSsS ksS6td a 1hsa eSa,9ea 6 h VI
hns s; sE fsE;F s s S'2t or E. s f1gsfsisa rgs.s
II IL 3 4 4, 4s$ i qs: S si|'5ss ~ ~
sTsa Es III s hsai ss; ' Il ftsss s s 81 s ass q ss ss
word "ropcalod," thought hsH idoa was SUBJ
s.antially correct
,tdSy ny s Prs ARM IA S aRyy WI y Hags agaS
I'D yo snd @ srstaa{ ha HIa u III h5d t5e saRsiaan
dh sts sdsasIsa @ StpIis(lS steut thht. He it'd
he did not hold tho sabe!llan view that It was
alnystcriona subject. aud be did not undertakes
pdaob H. IL .he b5 D stafs for 'asfi aiassos M
d1sDIa % i isiasrtts!'d ths thss eslaet!9n 10 b.
taogely modal oas, ef F6ia6|isl 6fis All
nature, and not nierait III tho fotta of 1anlfess
eAtiph.
ByW.F. woud-Q.-Will You stats whttnsr
Jon hayA lid any donvorsatioh With Mr. Iedn-
ard, An elder Of the, Ninth presbytorlan Church,
tious with him, but do nos remember any con-
vorshtibn With references to Prof. Swing.
Q.-tn hiA Office, In which tho point oonosrn7
Ing ths impttcAtofy Ptaaha Mefe spoken abohe
Al Mny hato lid stich conversation, but
1.-Two no Recollection of 1t ndn.
mn. TAownrsfbdt.
Tho Rov. h1r. Trowbridgo Was the he1s Wit.
moss, and was examined BY Prot; paston: .
O., [HAnding ,withess d lottor)-1s thaa your
handwriting A.-feh, slt.
Prof. Patton thon read Tho following:
orrtoa or 1lIs 1NTEh1oA,l
lBl Wear WARRINGTON drnEHT,
CHICAGO, Oct. 2, 1s72)
DEAn Dno Yours containing 81, IL received. II
to pre swng =, s nos ,a ., y s ~ aassa
: qaeor genius. liz probabiy would not let u. hsrs
at reht 1T rottcm and yes 10 ttonbioa IL sroas dial
by his dubious or oncsided ktatctnts Of things. But
he gots hold of that easo can roach, and
unless ws ars compelled te. 1don't know but b. Will
force tho preabJtory to cali him to account but ow
]. u. Tnownn1paf.
Tho reading Of tho letter oocaaioned loud
laughter among the spectators
Prof. Patton'-"Ihat is al" -.
Prof. Swing" Where do you reside, NJ.
Trowbrfdge7" lLaughtcr.J Al reslao ~ NV
oraide. at tho present tlmo, sir.
Prof. bwing-Thnt Is al. L..
lhene"ed leughto5 in Which everybody out
Prof, Patton joiuod:]
Mr. Noyes did not think tho letter was eF1'
denoo, or that 1t ought to b regarded a. such.
It was simply personal opinlon-a crlto1sm q,
which might hare been made from Eory partial
and inadequate understanding o. tho faats:
Prof. Patton re1oned thnt thoro nad been
good deal OF personal opinion III n me oroah.ox-
animation ot Dr; PATTERSON. the aileea.ion ~
tho second specineateoh aeaof tns n,ss ehareo
pct torth tnat the aHeot OF nls tsmlng y pleacn-
ing had boon to cAuae Bfhfo aoupts 20 % q en-
tertained ~ hia minis5eiaat nsetnIon ano 1na
object he lfattonl nao ~ VIEW N eaA1ng ~.
patterson 20 tos,ly' sna IN proaaelnG .ne .ostoE
OF MIR. IroWor1dfe. was 70 sahIain tnAt specah..
cation: Ino esioenoe "as certainly ooaapeteas
to 20 tnas. u-,..,,
Mr. Ifoworidge aeKou whether wltness #oala
oe perm3tteu 70 ma1e an ,G1p!aina.aGn.. .0.l.
Dr' Pattoroon--1 YOU'D ask "hat no mas to
~ ~ ~ aaalnon: lGanaat9,s.l t,t .,,. ,a H..
Ile hotio1asot 5utea saat Wltnoas naa tuo
r1ght TO atato enytnhe when 70 coneluored o.