, 1874-11-22
Church ~ 41eAH5 eui1otaSso1A 10 LIE

" 1nat any other religion than the Hopa.u reu
~. or tnat IN "counEIea called Catholic" the f.e
Of other religions may laudahly be allowed.
| Ia. L. Or that the Roman PoauI ought to come tt
| ton. = -''N AAo1--A $4,000
He observes that recent uttcrances have but
conn1med the strongest interpretation wnich cur
| 9 10 put upon taese anathemaa, aud he adds that
Upon ha.ty refus.l, that neither The intlicion O
penalty In lfe. limb, loslty s. goo1a Oh d:sobollen
a1a members Of Tie chrisdan Church tie tto t
been here reatfiraed. Ii terms 1hcre is 10 mentor
asfy asy thss ssS ssys &C. SS a s
" Rome; that is to ssy, by rope4 aud Tapl Coun
els and the eondemnaona Of the Syllabus include
declared eeumen:eaD hare trlnsgresscd tie Just limits
q tneir power, OF usurned the right OF Princes
secadon1 need hardly say; and Indeed The right tc
s1mpoy RhSs!sal @ foree is even hero uudisgllsed5
:, But the main attack of tie pamphlet is con-
eent1atea ecu upon the third. proposition, THAT nc
ona can now become q conyert to Rome wittoui
1or1catlnE his moral aud moutal freedom, and
placing Ills civil loyalty md duty at tho merry
Of another "-ttlat other being tho Pope. That
al converts do this deliberately be is. indeed,
fur from asserting; bu: he maintains that they
are inexoraoly committed to it. For this pur.
pose he recalls eone ipoldents OF the CONTROVERSY
winch preceded tho passing Of the Catholic
Emancipation act ia 1879. He observes tbat the
strength ct the opposing party lay. IN the alcga-
Roman Catholic to pay to the Crown IN entire
allegiance. To answer this allegation, measures
we're taken to learn from the highest Rpman
Catholic authorities IN this country, the exact
tposition Of the members Of that communion with
respect to some OF tho moro. e1ornitalt Papal
assumptions. Something more, he says. was
necessary than tho remuneration Of such extrava-
ganoiea* as the right OF deposition aud pesseou-
ion, or OF keeping no fsith with horetics:
AZ to the individual loyalty Of Roman Catholics
State dispoeed to generous candid Interpretation
to 1eIuisiton., which might b mads On them from
Wa reasonable hat Eneinnd should desire to fnow
not onIy what the Poln might do for himself, but to
ts Mnas .n .nS o. their
such demands could touch their civil duty. Tho
theory which placed every human being, in thinga
PontiN had not been an idoluu srecus mere theorv
of the chamber. Dsuin-poweE never SURPASSED In the
political history Of the world. had been lsvoted for
centuries to the single purpose Of working 1t into the
practice Of chr1stendom had in the West achieved for
AN impossible problem partial success aud had
dcnce Of the Church by that Latin conquest of Con
atAuiinope which etectnay prepare tie way for the
downfall q The Eastern EmIiro and the establishment
Of the Turks In Europe. What WAS really material
therefore was not whether tho Ppai chair laid claim
to this or thas particular porer but whether it oid
claim to some power that inc1uded them all, md
whether that claim had receised such sauct1on o1n
the authorities OF the Latin Church, tint thnro
NAMED within her borders absolutely no tenaeae
from which ~ar against It could bo
maintained. did the Pope than claim lnfallibihty?
g,.h Il ~ mich the nr.sl satm ~ nn,xrrss, chs, M
ence from hisaocE aud were tnese clat,ns cit1,er
az botn, atltued In his Churc, by authority which
even the lest papal Of the members Of that Church
must admit to be binding upon cunacinnee7
he SHOWS thar not merely Dsshcp Doyle, bnt
the collective body Of the ficars Apostolic, who
thon governed tho Roman Catholics Of Great
Britain. utterly repudated these claims the LAT
ter, for instance. oec.a1iug-
that neithsr The pono nor INV oher nrc,.. or rc,.
;.; na - ~ p nur -! pnG1 rI. e1e
hss 10y gat M to interiors directly or ndrssly IN ths
snv m.nnsr ~ neTfor7nauce of ths c;x,l n,a e, ~
~ due 70 1ha Sinr ~ 'A' e@''' @ot''e "aA
white the Irish Roman Catholic hierarchy pub
tlth an address containing the following article,
Of tteir successors
..
On Tasa f, e;, tnas 4 - not IN
q - eae a ,a. an . neoss ae tneseos
1el111oo W pttteFe' tos@ ING Eopo ID 'u1an4o1e-
h1r. Gladstone then observes that
since that tina an these nro,os,f,,s h.v. taa, ~
xrrsed Tia pones f,fa1iihility whe, he snsare -,
rnthtrn IN fuif1, and morals haa 1aen dccarrf} v
ne assent q the hshos OF ne Roman Church. to be
~ ia itt ~ i W ad;.a ~ f ;e ~ exe1y
subjects has Lam deciAred In ss manner thant INV
practical limit or rcserEe aud his supremacy without
any reserve Of civil rights, has been similarly affirmed
any ensesnsni q. '1a InaFcn LINT re- world
tho1tv Il IL al necessity for saIyatton tn be;rsr
~o1,''' - :. =. A.-1"@' ~ ~ "e''
de proceeds to expose, one bT one. tho subter-
fuges by which roman Catholic e1posltors en-
deAVor to aetenuate the stringency OF this claim,
such, for instance, as that the Pope is only in
failble when spenhlue ex ca1edJu and in Tho
fotfnu1n1' fua nassare In axnlodcs tla most
tssc,arf ~ thasa ovss;,na @~ ~4o4'
Ae4uons ~ @eoo s'0s0
VIII ba Eald hnally that the 1nfalllflity touches
only natter Of faith and moras7 Only matter Of NOR
als7 viii any Of the homsn casusts kindly acqua,ut
ns what are the Departments ana functions Of human
e which do not IND eanuot tAu within the domain Of
morzs7 -". 40! Snoh distinction would be
the unworthy device OF shallow policy, ratnly used
70 hide the dafnA OF mat ~!id amot1on which ut
Rome, not from tne throne, DUE IRON behind the
throne, prompts the movements Of the Vatican. I
dAre not to ask there 10 dtes Or tattefs o. human
Life, such rs e&n escape from the description and
boundary OF morals submit th:t duty is power
wh1ch sases WIN Us ~ me INCOMING anu goes 20 rest
VIII us az n6nt* u soe1tans1Ve Win the acuon Of
~ ,aea E ma shirh ouv ,s,nes us hs 70 an
ieayo the light Of Lie So then Il is The supreme direo
ton Of NJ il respect to Ill duty which the Pontd do
clares to belong 10 him, approhate ooncia md
this declaration he makes not as IN oiose opinion Of
ne Schools but eaAsfd at''0u< efeaendam ct ft''e-
1o"'
Rut be- further insists that tho 1Ounci1 has