, 1874-12-14
THE CATHOLIC CONTROVERSY.

,n,.ror., nv ,ru,, ,1.,,on ~, n,n.,,r,,,,.
pastoral OH the subject Of tho Vatican de-
eynra hv Dr. r]Ilntho,ne, Ro,nau CathoI;o R;x1,o,
ot B1rmingh mn, WIS road in the various 1eoman
Catholic churchos OF tho diocese on thB 2ad ol
Noyouber. After doscriblu- thu ]oc,ral shaurfli,
tics OF tho position OF tho Old Catholic party,
tho Diallop rorerts 10 lIr. Gladstone in tho FOL
lowing telt8s:
And wo havo scon Within THU fortnight marvellous
iers,nost rro.esiat il oyer mum MAS Trotrstap
suntlo u thu rheoru Of arecch beyond tito totro oi
logic. planting himself on tho aldo OF thiS un,ap,y
aoc taking his esson from Its iuohberu, nd stopping
i9ra III nost slnKular production to ntorroSate Her
~ ~ ,ai ,a m E ascsaw %
to s,to but et Air. aadstons md NJ Iii ali mpn Kmo
that We Cathocs,-you, brethren, your priests an,
your Dlslpls,-besllea tia motives common tn oer
inc, Lnve notiye FOR Obedience 10 tho civil power
HAT is pdsisr to ourselves, and that IL the hxed aud
Gn!smaneeagS ,s Ioc'sns anM enforcement OF tGs
src Int n.cI ,nrc for f,oIs .oEn nh rs u'f rnr ~
our reitron, wo should bc luyn1 AMI oluIicnt to VII;
ever cly.i government II constituted and es.a ll,u
over thu society in which No lyc Need loin; IT.
ntlor proof beSond olsr own habtual conlnct? ILL.,
assS We hayo neen 9ten rsproaG;hea .; " loliiSan
s soo .s an @ e ; ~ tno eaasng % sta 0i
ng a NJ Mr tGG s aan @ n s - p ny
niet ConBcepces antl WHO Gaze u,0ro f0r The fulure
hau for the present world. Whnt would 1rcllu have
ta:oic. with a her grievances. Ind nut ler biAhos
aud clergy nces ssly 1cuGated tho Catholics duty Ut
oaeying tho evil authority II Is wel-1uown
i.ct that tAe Leafs OF tsniHhisn na1ntaineA aud
successful re1eon aud reSounn WIS tlle influence
of thu Pope a',1 tho c4hoiic Church. eyer ilcucatln
to '!aty of ciyal eoodienss. Tlat sostety Va con-
the 1rs Calol!o pfcatca. II tho records Of the For
en olec ioil all tug truth which III very much to 10
doubted, they wdtiu show how ofetl Instance has
heen nate at Rome TO ondeayor TO obain sono teca.
ltion from this or that Pope to this OF that portion Of
sr M o. @ tno ~ aocafH o. inc M
n1wrr. Tl!usa rseords wuud Iiknwlse teI ar At ass
has been kept up, not now eaAt until recently III
Catholic States, the chief Obstacle TO- bo oycrconc
nhyng @ ~ laen t TO e, tue '9ssy 70 ho constituted
OPINIONS OF oruEn PROMINENT CATHOLICS.
| Several communications relative to Ginaatonn'B
pamphlet appear III tile Louslon Times. The
national lcaacfa' ous altefwIld lolio"ef ol ar
Premier, aud ''rorios III procaiu,ing " hiu !" Gu
tro submission to tho authority Of tho rope."
a,mrovos nv nf Mnnn"nnr t;anois atntemomt :, linz
ane eseaa..s.'.1 y & ~ ~ tno % Sts;
~ ut oo"o,,.s .sa u tcnn Sncroos ~ toc-aoa ~
t"";t;,n.In Gounc;i I1o"rv potro win IL cnns N
sa,a .;,1 ~ T,ti..I;n Jro,;;, ~ Tao,,a
rnoa;rn,a lis nnprovsi " a,r 1:Ia.t sn,,so
| IN thn,n ,vn1tn.
- .1,uso "u.ua ,a.s.. ..o r.. ua. .,..,>
,ae ~ s " n, au asS .tBrSs ~ LINZ % s1rtu III
iniuus discussion tut tho resonsiLity must rest
olI thofo who wou..I ,sl eaccfdotuI supremacy uul
authority to an extent gaiuat wlic reason an con-
ssso must rotost The - ata M tendency Of o
M S rd ins 3ro o Has 10 'y
m ns'o III ,na yas % o1
UItra1nos,tano rrcss may utter au.tlenla may acc
nnlato yltuperiou, may cndeayor to aIgnatize What
they pleased to deksglatu IN Arossts Trlulnyi
rAo " Lit they VIII Aot sacnee tho voice of truth aud
reason. .
Lord Arundel, OF Wardour. q mo1nber OF IN
English Catholic house, differs Gil soma points
mi