The New York herald., 1874-08-17

M. DE GAvARDIE-I maintain them for HIM
are iiar tExplosions s1s or Indignation from the
Right aud Centre. Loud cries Of "Order ofderr'
with "hearl nearl' on some benches of the Leit.l
The PREsIDENT-I cannot allow one mehpeI OF
tins Assembly to address another in such Terms; s
Monsieur schoelcber, call you to order t"hear"
NJ JULES sMoN--Why, NJ ie President, did you
allow one-halJ OF the Assembly to 2e insuitedY
can sSe sne %
aud mnrmurs on the Right; general agtaiion.l
The PREsIDENT-lt can never be admitted that
IN an Assembly member may say TO one OF MS ms
colleagues, You are lar t"Hear, hearl You
n. scnoEIcnER-l beg your pardon was In
NJ JULES sIMoN-words which were an outrage
on the Assembly. ON history and on public morals.
were not repressed. 1t was an insult to which We
could not submit. tMurmurs.)
the PRssIDHST-lhere was no personal offence.
forward IN this Assembly and, whether they were
JUST or UNJUST tney were not personal insults.
loud dissent on the Lefty But wneI outrageous
language Is addressed TO Deputy cannot tolerate
NJ. sOhoRbcHsR--M. de Gavardie used offensive
words 10 me, republican or l848, and one OF the
prescribed OF the "a December.
NJ JULES SIMoN--I repeat that the words uttered
yesterday are an mdignity towards the country,
history aud morality. Oar protest will be entered
on the minutes. Noise.) IL would seem that we
are IN the Assembly only to be insuted. IL is
time for that to finish. Increased agitation and
murmurs.)
suspend the sitting. .Nosel
M. DE GAvARDIE-l ask, gentlemen, for a mo
ment's silence. l am anxious to explain the
words which escaped me. ("Ah, ahl" on the
Leit)
Nj. JULES sIMoN-But the language against which
we protest was not uttered by you.
M. SCHOELCHER-IT you withdraw the words
there Is an END To the matter.
Nj. DE GAvARDlE-But l do not. tExclamations
on the LelL)
NJ. SCHoELCHER-Then I maintain the lie gave
you. Increased agitation,
NJ. DE GAvARDIE-I am anxious TO explain the
words which, repeat, escaped me- loud inter-
rnpuon on the LeftJ It was under the impres,
You. r'Well" on the Left.l Hear me out
M. SCHEURER- X EsrNER-We are listening to you,
| but 40 not give yourself those airs.
NJ. DE GAvARDIE-It Is you who give yourselves
airs daughter and noise.) lemployed Tue IAN
guage with which am reproached under the EN-
p1re OF painful sentiment interruptions on tne
Leit)-caused by the recollection OF words used IN
the previous sitting, 1t was then said TIE ;,
monarchy leil under the public reprobation."
VOICE ON THE LEFT-Certainly
NJ. DE GAyAEDIE-what does that meanS
SEVERAL DEPUTIES ION the Leit)-lhere IS dll-
terence. That is not ''the contempt oil ali honest
menn
NJ BRIssoN you allow me to say words
The PREsIDENr--No; cannot permit discussion
winch is quite foreign to the minutes
NJ DE GAvARDIE-Dd not the monarchy also, in
your opinion ial beneath the contempt Of all hon
est men?
! ON THE LEFT-No, M. BrissOn did not say that.
NJ. DE GAvARDIE-W e maintain the words
used. (Murmnrs on the Left.) say that they
escaped ape yas yet p Pesss M IN reSn
M. SCHoELCuER-I maintain also the lie gave
! you, and which did not escape me.
/ The PREsIpENT-And maintain the call to order,
! Great a2iratlOn)
Here M. GaIloa d'Istria entered the Chamber.
! NJ GALLoNI D'IsTRIA-I was not present when NJ
Schoelcher entered the tribune. am informed
that he asked whether the words uttered III re-
ply to NJ. GambetJa were these :-"The Republic
! 1ell beneath the contempt and the reprobaton, OF
| horror, OF all honest men," And whether
acknowledge them. have nothing to withdraw
and maintain that remark. loud protests on
the Let)
| NJ. SCHoELCuER-Then / declare that you have
! uttered an infamous iasehood. violent uproar.
| MN. Testelin, Ordlnare, Jules Barnt, Lockroy
! and several other members OF the Lett rushed to
the foot OF the tribune and apostrophizea M. Gall
lOn d'stria IN words which could not be heard in
consequence OF the tumult.
The Observation-Disclosures, return to your
seats. Sucn scenes are deploraole and compel me
TO suspend the sitting.
The President then put on his hat and left the
chair ana the business remained interrupted ior
quarter oil an hour.
When the sitting was resumed the bill to better
regulate the organization OF the Council Of State
was read third time and adopted.