, 1874-10-20

| brtery 10 tnko hdvanthEea OF TIER own wrOni,
MIR. Noyrs uitl not think IT wan competent for
Synod To act upon report Which contemplated
tho arrnlgnmollt Of man bAfoEe tho body viii
was not amouablc to II. 1Io (swing) was not
member of my OF tho prenbytcrieH. which wa
required, In ordor to arraign him, by tho dcosBlo,
OF tho GonorNl Assembly. =;
Mr.. Sfeklea moved to stri!so out that part Of
tho rsport woh ro"tod to ieponaing WITH read
lit. Noyee begged lcavo to remind tho bod,
TINT Prof. Swing had ITO representative on thu
Noor, and that tho documentary ovidbnco WAS nj
essont'al part of hlb casc, and ought to bo rcatl
It WAS not safo to aEa,lno that oycry member o
tho body Init road the testimony.
Prof. latton did not Hco that tho case wns
materially changed before tho Synod from wha
It vas Doforo tho rrcsbysory. Mr. NoyoA know a.
ncll as anybody TINT tho cydenco 1aa not road ir
contained q stipulation betwoon himself and MIR
| Moves wlioreby It wna agrecd that tho doo,l.
menthry ovldonoe uhould not bo road, that il
should bo waived by both parties except 80 far
caso pro and con. 1lo could no! 500 by Win.
aght QUO part OF tho Testimony should DO read
rather tGal1 another.
Mr. No. es replied that the stipulation expired
by Limitation at tho end Of tho trial, and ho had
no authority to mako any stipulation with regard
to tho disposition to be made OF tho eyldonco.
After protraolel discussion, The motion Of
mr.; scklcH to st7ko ont was agreed to, thus
making tho leading Of tho testimony necessary.
11R. NoYEs' ARGUMENT.
argument ~ to tho right Of Prof. Patton to tako
an arpoAl. and, being allowed To do 10, Addrosaod
the Synod ~ follows:
Mn: NtoptnAroE. Before vote q taken upon thu
consideration before this body desire to submit aons
rcaaaFks III nupliort Of tho minority roport.
| NO APPEAR ALLOWED rAuF. PATTON.
II NO nltpti to 10 gOyctncd ly Tho law mud by tho
prcctlcnts Thlrh tn conformity with tls ln,
S han ~ t. ha
nsss es0, 10 ats ,na te St !.
readily takon Il for nr.ncl ,hat M" rjMt nF ancsi IN
cssys lise iii,, anaats!ane. aid tsae!ssst1s.
fnr ssrrsy ,nys ,cn,, 1crx ;mfrnrcnt ~ h.r i,,In~r
vary seldom therefore, liza Tiers bee any OCCASION 10
apca Or to search ont yory carefuy thu nrsceJeuta
WITH Iayo Lss,I eataplrSeJ In.r t. IT, Aupejlants
The 10y oTe5 courts nayo urs.fsa before
Taarity viii theso taes has rcr,nps D led s1;
nny n carried In y 1pbrai at thc instance or cithrr
shs prosecutor or III daten'ant. propose to SHOW
Patton cannot appeal hs caas to higher court, be.
causo a. tlo iaw Of t.,e Church IL agast lin: bc.
SAWS there arc 70 Iresstlsn,s II l|s ayos; ns:ase
ay ~ e r.r a maasa r. ta
'01 "'>O'' ,.,1a 1apv', 49,, 'Is1' .,nr.I
,, lam - W. Wno NAY ~, ,,,. ~
DO ,o To yho sos. ts Law sssera s4's ony
~. r. ~ .' fu, ~ t Roo, ~ nis",Sn. Hhs
Sc declares it IN apt,oa sali in no ca,o be- IN.
nIsi ..tja; ~ NJ ths ,a4' anra m snsi l., "a
hs tf reaxs M o. tas .. ~ rea fr ~ 70 q
~ is rbt n aunaa Il IL nj It5 ,! i'm
thnt ono should be- an vriansl party. In 1u,sI II,
tha bit he nuat Ss iose than that. lie must 10 az. g.
oassos sSn 10 or sn ~ ths case Si prp9s
ps ths ppusecleu av snnea III hx Me0 dSsn,s
be sIono Is iae to j., aaar,a1c bS ts Scs1on NJ fha
court. fo man oan appoa mulss, BE- hns hoen i, o..
wro,,rnl by Tho ecisn,, nneair1 ron, rrnr WINK;
cannot claim .t La ns been wronHnd bv tho deririo,
III Which ali VIC yo;ed to yusa,n his inIcl,,ont NAV
at IL sss 1 61t as sss,9n a. inflicted gsTos
III @ ana Tas @ tey ~ ys h + massy p:
sy u, erreI fy" ona " v a M INV s sS
h'5 r. H eg gn' afs H., ot II .
,o,icrs Quiy In o,o rtnrcct fie IL an o,irlnai nnrv
and 10 lar ua iii gocs, would Io cntitlcd 10 annea
nerso With ii,,s rieht In or1er to tSis n i. .t M
Essential that ono sou bo an aaprs1a T pary ~ tha
by scslou ous ,nst tcy ,raona, inry sr Isn
nsc from 1t. 10 This Prof.. Patton can y 10 r.im,
lin ia urctteyctf In 1lo otlicr ,rnv anil tn mn
rrc,lrr or;nit thsn ali otlcrs ihryni,Tlhnut tho
Shoss Cnnrcl, who sro itke-,nim,ed viii htnaclf
sru arqricyel. liz Inn urosccnts Psf swnc mt fnt,
m o,fsnso S9,,ns, n nersonsii1 int n, ~ nocns
asaut u Church. Tho uittai Of swnx cu,n tsn
mplt be ana in lin yfcw H. tn H. !rrl I1snrn rs ~
Il ,,nt r"sriry.i and therr;or, cannnt aneai ~
That ha1o I!iyen a rjsht deiimitinn IF thc tcrn,
1mrir anorscfsI u NAV IL rcs iv patcrn,cn @ to H.
cisnus IN Evil co,,rts for wi'aro ;o,i eoI ~ ~ "J
IN mn 1tnos ~ DiariI,s .itnut "Far.s. Ia un'v
IL 1roncr n reaort To- s c,tnorf;a n ssrarnt to
rrecap scnac in With, t,sy ara ,,sen ~ 'o
II, ia IEtH nn"n ion ~; .ae o H'n 70 d,,h ~, n,o
state w. 1own tho snnes cou Of I'm III q .s
Wills holding tir Tho neoIe hare no r;o1t n ,nnsai
liz stat,o Of conneet,c was naysr itsSsa ~ IN.
vSs Iis can,,nnn i, hv ;si ~ H. a.1 ~ o ~ ~
" n a1S ~ T W geng 10 ne .a.o ho
tho .a ofenss ster a fsir stoulttal Il nroydes @ ie
n, 'up 80 aaa ~ e. pa
1orsn Sarsr.er NM" n1t thn n,, II uu nv ~" ,.n
- ~ ". ~ .Tn. ~ T! ~ nv I.oI " ~ tu9 !so.s
cuat sno am e11 ~ .nrana mor " "
snx 4,,E .tbn H. .It ~ tIt s,i t
E h. ~ - .aIus nt D. ~ o ~ LA otae RAse TUG
; ~ o1ISts .ne pasI ~ !. n9seI "as