New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1874-12-29
TyVEEDS APPEAL.
TIE RETURN TO THE WRIT OF cERIloHAhi'
Wi lard BARTLETT and District Attorney Phcll

THE RETURN TO TIE WIKI VI tIhii"i'''"
Willard Bartlett and District Attorney fhelpS
caue Yesterday ueIore Judge Barrett Ill o!'r anu 49,
.r 10 selte tie Iorm OF the return 10 the VIII vi
c,rtlorar Oh which appeal from the REFUSAL " U
e,sr Wilil,m NJ Tweed hiUeas corpus I'LL III tno
Terms OF his sentence expired toiDc carrieu " h
Court OF Appeals. After some private uH'u'''o Wv
return WAS made in the following form:
The OF the Court OF Oyer ana Iermner ~ ".
"a, n uf ,crilorIrI Obedcn'c the sald writ ~ Is
hereby cer,i. ID ana returned 10 we g., Inr l. Nv
on C. 49, 1874, pciltlUn WAS presented 10 Ju,c,
l,.c OF tnc oLprouic Court or winch copy - u.o
uuc x; uIaracd "a" That thrreupoh WIZ VI hape.
,'r,,. ruluuue IN the Court vi Oyei ana lermiher,
* ao " ed uuu Issued, OF whcn copy Is hcVo a
ucxcu, inarKed L." Tuat At the tune ahh plcc ~ SUN
wr iullrd, 10 W.T. Dee II, 1874 at the new Court
uvisr la tnc cl,y the MarIen came lhto court hnu pr
yucca llie uouy Tweed; tue Disrlctht'0ine ,o ~
cvuuty tarn aud there appear, ana tnc W.
A lei urn to writ, ui wLich copy ~ hereto a, AZ,
marked &c" That tnereupon Iwceu iniic anu i,ioi
E,yer.p 40 Aba -It return, OF when copy y heictU an
w,lu aujourucd uni Dec. 81 1874 at the now Court-
nouoc, III he cly; tue W.rhcn produced aEa tne oody
vi before tue Court OF oyer aud Terniner, ana
DstrctAtorney aiso came, and tho loiOwng pro-
were na.:
A motion made by the D!atrct-Attorney to
third, iOdr hftn, six h. seventh, eighth,
tenh artcrs Of the traverse lac Court, witd0ut
pasblng uenhteiy upon said motion, suggested lhdt tue
proceed iortnwiih 10 OF PROOF III support VI Inc
SAID traverse and tIcrcupon the Court pro-
cccded niially 10 near the proofs ana allegations
were Produced relating To the ihprsonnieht ahu
support an tue urticcs OF the reverse. lhtrc.
upon record vi JUL 9mcnt was put III eva ce OF winch
copy Is herewltd Produced indrhcu Il. ana slgncl
fur Couit Tile fclitOr
upon oil red In evlLencc the original minutes OK
proceedings before The Grand JdrS, by wncn the
luc, iCtOu Wis toLnL nj wuich minutes
COP, Is hereto xc marked r." Tue evidence was
uJ clcd irrelevant III lsc anu incompetent 10
prove fact thereby sought TO Do established ana tue
o. clIUn Tna relatUr then offered III evl-
nnu,cs OF the Clerk vi the CJurt Ol Oyer ana
IcIniner o. wnlcn lnlnuics copy 10 nrrrio anncAed
marked &C." Verdict OF the jury as rem.
ny III Dcng me minutes taken az the tie ol
tue IcuItiVn vcidct, and Inc only ehry made IN
tnc nhu;cs OF the cour' cohctfhins INC sdine. lnc
oVldcca objected ulclevat aud incompetent,
OUiccio SUSTAINED. lc reator tlicn olaicl III
u,i,rx ii n.rneL d. upon a motion to correct the
verdict aS r,nicrcd aud entered. Inc evidence
objected to AS Irrelevant and lheompeigin tent
offered IN evidence the bli OF eAreptinhs.
,aAcn triu or the criminal action, or winch
copy Is herewith prOddceu nidrked -, ana slsDcd
tnc Clerk Court The evi-
objected 10 AS irrclcvant incompetent,
proved that Inc ne OF $780, mentioned III tue irSt seu-
tcncc cUItaned III tue record, paid nv Wiiilam H.
Taeed Nov. Is, 1884, anu 1t was adI ted tniI he had
ucen Imprisoned uuuor tIe SAID commit
tnan Ono year prior 10 the granting OF tue
and aujuugcd by Tue Court that William NJ Tweed
entitled TO his discharge, tina. the wrt should
from dc han been tihen. ana order was made
words ana f.ures loio@us Upon hearing on
tine return, aud after hearing me proofs
parties, ordered By the Court That the writ OF
uucr Is reuandcd to the PenteutirJ. Aud 1t is FUR.
her cerdcu obedIence the OF ccrt0rarl that
the PAPERS hereto annexed, marked f." o. and ~,
und produced, marked l." and l." are true
copies VI Tile record Of Judgment III sdld CRIMINAL ac-
ton, Of the VI verdict rendered the
the criminal action, Of the pap rs on tue mo
Ior tue correction OF the Judgment record, and
or the bill OF taken upon trial OF tue
crimnal action, now being aud Remaining OF record III
tic said Court OF Oyer and Termiuer.
We ccrlliy under tne seal OF said Court to the
Justices u tine Supreme Court within mentioned, in
cer,un schedule 10 tins writ annexed as within 1t Is
cOmuialiued. BY the Court,
JOHN SPARKS. Clerk.
The papers referred to have been already published
except Judgment record, and the bill Of EXCEPTIONS
wnicn two largo volumes OF nearly thousand pages
each.
the issuing of the return delayed till tomor-
row, as Of the papers copied. The argu-
,nent has been noticed the first Monday OF January