, 1874-06-20

a11,dta aIootinn .n SuIas fnptor 1po man9cr Of ny
formed thst tho aoorot servioo las boon
uBcd to send man to my district. under R!c-
ardson AZ Secretary Of tho Treasury and DAn-
no1l as Solicitor, oatonsibly to look after q
poso tho gontenan from ' Msssaehusstes SSs sap;
knowa anything about Il. I don't suppose l,o
knows anything about Jayne Sending anybody
tLoro, but thcy have boon tl,oro. Now, It sooms
right to say "old oock-oyo" now md thcn.
(Lnughter.]
Mr.. Foster thon gave history Of tue cana Of
Phelps. Dodge, s Co., aud said that q
n,0s s~ . TSa .a s d
! upon tl,oso gontlomon ho had never heard; nor
had tho House. Docs any man huppose that
Phelps. Dodge d Co. would rob tho country Of
Hir. DurLEn-No!
Mr.. FOsrEn-That vaa all tho unpaid duty
clnrgod against thoM. Wo mist cors'dpr lin
surroundings. II all ordinary vagabond should
take e1'oio IN that way we would call him
high oharaetor and standing Of these gentlemen
It IL highly improbable that they would commit
fraud Of that kind. 1t I Should invite tho
gentleman from Maaaachnsotta {l'ut!or) to din
nor, and tho next day. II should miss . apoon
TINT he had stolen It tlaughtor]; but ii should
find it In the pocket Of aomu yarabond. OF
courso ho would bo thiof. Now. I
Fiye It a., as c,.s my deliberate M opinion mud
psnmouS ns9se e 6e1e s o. Pe Msa p ss 1'es c
were deliberately robbed, and this Houso and
this country mover will do iuatico by thom until
they pay them tleir money bnck agein.
Mr. bUTLEn-Why don't you bring in your
Mr.. FOsTEli-Tho timo has not come for that
Jet.
Mr.. G. 4. ROBERTS also replied to Butler,
That gcntleman.. ho Bald, Ind takon an oxtraor-
aiaary re, course in arguing aEalnat mosa;
thia was moro remarkable bocauao
he had a.npo opportunity to oppose tho Moioty
bill whom 1t wna still before the Houso. Three
tin.eB consideration of tho bill had been post
poned to onablo tho gentleman to appear and
nick to denounce tho bill vigorously In tho cloal1-
room,
:. At tho rcquost Of Mr.. 1obertp, tho olork read
tho s!ntoment Of Jayne In his testimony that he
@ % easo aea 8 bsd sl'nrs pad ~ h na
a. foo,. and Roberts said tint viii show
why tho gentleman from Massachusetts
{Bntler) knows moro about that oaae or may
claim to know moro about ono side Of that oaso,
and perhaps It is q part Of the task which le haa
undertaken for tho foe mentioned in that owl
donco to asBnl 8 reputable lnercantilo house
upon the door Of Congress.
1lr. TRE1lAIN said tho time tor tho gentle
mau (Butler) to make his dotenso lad boon
lASoIa@AA
had beon invited, and had not come. He had
been ack, but ho would bo Bickor yet boforo
lie got through with his connection With
that infamy: Mr.. Tremain defended Phelps.
sSsasry RSsH md o. anans 1sd f 5 tf Il s sas
old story, dug up from tho gutter8 to sustain
tho rotten cause of Banborn and OF Jayne, aud
to bring dscredit On tho namo Of Phelps,
Dodge & Co.
Alr. BUTLER, commenting on tho attacks
mado upon him tonight and upon the attempts
to quote Shakespeare against him, nad he would
quote Shakespeare against them. "Tray,
blanche. W aud Sweetheart, little dogs
s sal #'e Docs tA'y s''& oer e. me-" our a%s
to Bnap7 tLaughter1 referring to Tremain's
assertion that tie atatuary story had been dug
out OF the guttors, ho said that he hal taken il
from the Congressional reports. whore Senator
whore EldredEo, Of Wisconsin, WAS another. aud
md whero TAaddoMs Stevens was another, and
tho hitter had charged it OH Phelps, Dodge i Co.
Mr. TRGsfA1N again took the floor ind spoke
for ton minutes in reply to Dutler's last speech.
Roferring to Buffers disclaimer OF personalities.
Tfomain sent to the Clorka desk and Ind road
80 extract from The debate OIL the goneva award
bill, on which he spoke of Tweod's boing hunted
By jaoEala. nat by lions, and ho said that tile
tlmo had boon when ho was younger than he now
WIS, md had moro imperfect feeling Of bis
duty, that pwlft and certain pubshmont would
have followed tho application Of that language.
But ho trusted that ho never should forget
that Bolomn injunction, Vengeance is Mile,
saith tho Lord" As Shakespeare Ind bcon
quotod so often tonight, he would quote tic
speech OF Jack Cale to Dick the butcher, Swift,
tho weaver, aud hla followers. The talfferouco
botwoon anciont mud modern Jack Cade vas
that. instead Of ti,orc boing no moro money, tic
modern QUO woulu have baakotsfull Of Kroau.
backs.
The House, At 10 q. NJ, adjourned.