davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10

PrnLt affords much state that in July ls! Front
Knight No 90 West Lombard Street. and testify its superior
al dwelling
subjected the test undgoes this where during
applied
percepbe cnaci which and du!a
city believing will them satisfaction than
Baltimore, April 80 1872. Front Street Theatre
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10

BALTIMORE, December 10th, 1872.
Q-DEAR
Bradley Patent Enamel Paint far exceeds expectation in economy and beauty
durability.
el Mansion lousc with the Bradley Patent Enamel Paint
the Hotel
will
will be advantage liberty
Yours respectfully ISAAC ALBERTSON,
Mansion HOTEL n W. Cor Streets, Baltimore.
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10

A new way to learn calves to drink
is to nail the finger of an old glove in
the bottom Of a trough.
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10

The best bearing orchards We have
seen this year are surrounded on all
sides with forest trees.
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10
JACOB STOUFFER & son.

MARYLAND LINE BAlTINoRs CorS1Y Mn? September 2h, 1872
Bacy Paint BhmorelEARS
The which purchased from YOU has given entire much so : all
painted
have employed delighted with it, lie that he paint twice FAST
better job with the Enamel other paint he
the public of the
veb opante introduced
- Yours ytruy,
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10

Good vinegar can be made from the
juice Of watermelons by letting it stand
as if it were cider.
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10
NEW STiTIONERY uOUSE.
e. r. STOKES

E. r. STOKES
HAS just opened, in the new and hand
some building Immediately opposite the
Phoenix office, on Main street, q complete
stock Of
STATIONERY,
Comprising Letter, Cap and Note Paper, of
all sizes, qualities and Of every description;
Flat Papers of Cap, DENY, Double Cap, Me
dium, Royal, SUPERFICIAL, and Imperial
sizes, which will he sold in any quantity, or
manufactured into Blank Books of any size,
and ruled to any pattern, and bound in any
style, at short notice.
ENVELOPES
In endless varicty-all sizes, colorS and quail
ties.
BLANK BOOKS
OF every variety, Memorandum and Pass
Books, Pocket Books, Invoice and Letter
Books, Receipt Books, Note Books.
ARCHITECTS and DRAUGHTSMENy will
find s complete stock of materials for their
use. Drawing Paper, in sheets and rolls.
Bristol Boards, Postal Paper and Boards, oil
Paper, Pencils, Water Colors, in cakes and
boxes, Brushes, Crayons, Drawing Pens.
SCHOOL STATIONERY
OF every description; 4 great variety of con-
vcnieut and useful articles for both Teachers
and Pupils.
ALSO,
Photograh Albums, Writing Desks, Port
folioS, CabaS with boxes, Gld countless
variety Of
FANCY ARTICLES.
Also. most elegant stock Of Gold Pens
and Pencil Cases, superbly Rubber
Goods.
INKS.
Black, Blue, Violet and Carmine, Indelible
and Copying; Mucilage; Chess and Back
CANNON Men and Boards: Visiting and Wed
ding Cards, and everything usually kept in
First Glass Stationery House.
Which the subscriber intends this shall be-
lie will still conduct his BINDERY and
BLANK BOOK MANUFACTORY and PA
PER-RULING ESTABLISHMENT, which
has been in successful operation for over
thirty years in this State, and to which he
will continue to devote his own personal at
tentiou His stock will be kept up full and
complete, and his prices will be found always
reasonable, and he hopes to have share of
patronage. o.
Nov. Is, 4e-tf Opposite PhaniZ ofce.
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10
PRINCIPAL OFFICE,
Authorized Capital. -. .......S2, ,oOO,o
Guaranteed Capital. ........... 100000
Deposited with State Comptrollers
for Security of Policy Holders. $3.50, 900
NEwBERRY C. H.. S. G.,
n,,ox,l 10 1919

NEwDERRY C. H., S. G.,
December 10, 1872.
At meeting of Policy Holders, at
Newbcrry c.. H, Board of Advisory
Trustees of the COTTON STATES
LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
was organized: and the following Off
GERS elected:
THOMAS S. MooRMAN, President
WM. LANGFORD. Vice-President
.. l.. SCHUMrERT, Secretary
The Company is in the finest posi-
bic condition-haying SITS to s1GO
Of liabilities.
\ Dividend has been declared on
all Policies issued prior to January
lst, 1870.
M, w. ABNEY,
General Agent.
Feb. %, S-tf.
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10
CnAMDERsEURG, December 10th 1872.

CuAMBERsEURG December 10th 1872
Mr. SIR The paints We receive rom you have been applied
md
covering qualities adapIy kinds
Iuly especially class Of who have
We have
~ Yours, tru JACOB STOUFFER
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10
ESiH3'eAOszSc.
ES2y3'eAOsxSc.
S O UTH e r N
WAREHOUSE COMPANY,
Gervais Street, near Greenville and Colum.
bia Railroad

UeTValS otreeI, near GTeenVlue an0 ColuM-
bia Railroad,
COLUMBIA. S. c.,
Is PREPARED TO RECEIVE COTTON
and other property upon storage, and make
advances upon the same. Cotton shipped to
this house viii be stored subject to tho order
of the owner, and the lowest rates charged
for storage. All property so stored will be
insured in good reliable companies, if in
surance is desired; and advances will be made
at the lowest banking rates. Our store
houses are so located that drayagc is not
necessary; and no charge for handling will
he made.
All business communications should be
addressed to the Treasurer
EDWARD HOPE, President.
EDWIN F. GARY, Treasurer.
Mar. u, l0-6m.
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10
To Women, Both Married and
Single.


apply for relief before you become a con.
frmed invalid
l have been for years past attending strict
ly to the treatment of diseases OF women,
both married and single; and as the number
OF cases continues to increase almost daily
vii! pay special attention to those who may
apply to me for help, and may, if I should
get sufficient number of cases, make it 2
specially.
There are many women who are taking
medicines recommended for such diseases,
which are worse than useless, they palliate
and sometimes seem to give relief, but in
fact they postpone the evil until the disease
assumes the chronic form, and then they ap-
ply to the Physician for relief, which can he
given, but not so soon as VIXEN taken in the
first or early stage.
use no quack medicines, trea. diseases
on ration al and scientific principles
p. L. RUFF.
n. B. practice for cash only and promps
payments. Mar IL, 10-tf.
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10
U2eGe7'T @.
Fisk's Metallic Burial Cases,

THE SUBSCRIBER has constantly ca
hand fullassortment of the above approved
cases, of different patterns, besides coffins
Of his own make, all Of which he is prepared
to furnish at very reasonable rates, with
promptness and despatch.
Persons desiEous Of having cases sent by
railroad will have them sent free of charge.
A Reerse is always on hand and will Re-
furnished at the rate Of $40 per day.
Thankful for past patronage, the SUBJ
scriber respectfully asks for continuation
of the same, and assures the public that
no effort on his part will DC spas:t, to render
the utmost satisfaction.
RIB. CHAPMAN,
Newberry S. c., July 81.
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10
Free TRANSFORMATION,

WE are prepared to grind from one to
one hundred and fifty bushels Corn per day,
and will furnish free transportation of their
grain to and from CUR mill for our patrons
free Of charge
WEBB, JONES & PARKER.
Apr. II, l6-tf.
The Newberry herald. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1865-1884, 1873-09-10


1S73-Gly. W. p RUSSELL & CO.
, 1873-12-20

I Politiretterne paa de dansk vestindiske Ger ere
Parterne b~erettigede til, eftersom Sagerne ere ofentlige
eller private, at mode med eller we'd ~Sagt0rere, dog at disse
like oververe Forh0rene i de ~oaentIige eller Forligs-
megIingen de private Sager, uden forsaavidt Loygiv-
kostninger like derived paSadrages Diet OfentIige de f0rst-
navnte eller Modparten de sidstnevnte Sager. Naar
ikkun der, enc Part m0der we'd %Sagf0rer, Dor Dommeren
veilede den auden Part, og paaseee, at Inlet fors0mmes til
dennes Shade.
, 1873-12-20
Janus August Garde,

GouUerneur for de Dansk Vestindishe Ger, Ridder qf Dane
brog Qg Donebfogsm0nd,
TgJOR V~ITTERLIGT: Paa Finantsministeriets derom
VI nedlagte allerunderdanigste Forestiling har det be-
haget Hans Majestet Kongen we'd allerhoieste Resolution
at 13de October d. A. at stadfeste f6lgende at Colonial
raadet for St. Thomas og St. Jan og at Colonialraadet for
St. Croix we'd 3die B~ehandIing henhoIdsviis den 22de JUL og
den 23de Juni d. A. vedtagne A%nordning, hvorved nogle
B~estemmelser Low at 14de Juni 1850 ON Poltisagers
Behandling og ON Appel af disse udyides til de Dansk
Vestindiske Der.
Del Low at 14de- Juni 1850 indeholdte Betsemmelser
til de dansk vestinke Ger, mel de Afvigelser, der f0lge at
0erues Forhold, paa den det Folgende fastsatte Made
, 1873-12-20
Translation
Janus August Garde,

Goueynor Of tie Danh Wetidia Islands, Knight Of Dane
brog and Dancbogsmand.
uTAKE KNOWN Oh the most submissive representa-
ALI ton of the Ministry Of Finances His Majesty the
King has been most graciously pleased by Resolution of
18th October 1878 to sanction the following Ordinance,
by which certain enactments in Law Of l4th June 1850,
concerning the treatment and appeal Of Police Suits, are
extended to the Danish Westindia Islands passed by 3d
discussion in the Colonial Council for St. Thomas, and St.
John the 22nd July 1878, and by 3rd discussion in the
Colonial Council for st. Croix the 23rd June same year.
The e~nactments concerning the treatment and appeal
of Police Suits, contained in Law of 14th June 1850, are
extended to the Danish Westindia Islands with the devia-
tons consequent on the colonial relations, in the manner
hereinafter prescribed.
, 1873-12-20
ORDINANCE

by which certain enactments In the
Law of 14th June 1850, concerning the
treatment and appeal of Police Suits,
are EXTENDED to the Danish Westindia'
Islands. raosf9 ~
, 1873-12-20

I enhver P%olitisag tiIlades Diet v~edkommende Part selv
at udstede Appelstavning til O%verretten, dog at St@vnin-
gen i Diet seneste den n~estsidste S6gnedag, f6rend Sagen
faIder i Rette, indleveres Overrettens Contoir, og der
forsynes med Rettens Segl Og O~verdommerens Underskritt
imod E~rlaggelse at det anordnede Gebyr.
, 1873-12-20
ANORDNIG

hvorved nogle Bestemmelser Low at
14de jan l850om Politisagers Behand-
hing og Appel af disse udvides til de
danski vestindiske Ger. sea
, 1873-12-20

In the Police Courts of the Danish West India Islands
parties are entitled to appeared accompanied by a lawyer
if the suit be public, and to let a lawyer appear in their
behalf if the suit be private, which lawyers, however,
shall not be present during the examinations in public
cases or during the judicial attempts of e~fecting reconcile
presence is generally warranted by the legislation, and does
not cause any augmentation of costs to the public in cases
of the aforementioned description, or to the adversary in a
private suit. In case only one of the parties appear by
lawyer ystt. the sa 4adg &c shall 5atl;g guide t the other Sr party naty.o and see that
, 1873-12-20

Under Appel at private P~olitisager kunne, forsaavidt
Parterne like have m0dt we'd ~Sagf0rere foregaaende
Instants, nye vidner fores og nye Bevisligheder frem-
lmgges, uden at dertil ufordres Bevilling.
81,
N@rvarende Anordning treder i Kraft ire Maaneder
efter, at den har erholdt Kongelig Sanction.
Hvorefter allie Vedkommende sig have at rette.
Gouuermementet for de Donsk Veaindiske Der.
st. Thomas, den 22de November, 1878.
UNDER MIN HAND OG G-OvERNEMENTETs sEGL.
AUG. GARDE.
Il. So
, 1873-12-20

In every Police Suit the Party concerned shall be
in such a manner, however, that the summons shall be at
the latest on the last weekday but one before the case is
entered be handed in at the office of the Upper Court, and
be there provided with the seal of the Court and the sigma
ture of the Upper Judge, on the payment of the enacted
fee.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1873-06-07
FOREIGN NOTES.

Liberty Of the press has been proclaimed
IN Porto Rico and the censorship has been abolished.
NJ. Maximilien Lettre, the eminent philolo-
gist Was received az a member Of the French Academy
on Thursday.
The Shah Of Persia leaves Berlin to-day for
Essen, wesbaden, and Brussels From the latter city
he goes direct 10 London.
Dispatches from Melbourne report that a
panic prevails in New-zcaland over the frequent and
terrible assassnstions by the mountaineers. The set
tiers are organizing for Defense and another Maori war
Ii probable
A letter appeared in the London papers, yes
terday morning. from NJ Petri formerly private secre
tary 70 the late eIEmperor Napoleon, denying the au-
thentcity Of the appeal OF the eIEmpress Eugene TO
the French people, published in The Pau MAI Gazette
A dispatch from Fort Garry, Manitoba, says {:
"A large aud friendly deputaton Of Sioux Indians from
the West waited upon the Governor GENERAL yesterday.
to AJAX him reservation OF land large quantity
OF pro Visions clothing, and trinkets was presented
them. and after friendly talk they returned ONE"
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1873-06-07
SECOND EDITTON-Three q. m.
WHAT THE MoDoCs ExPEcT-rr Is THOUGHT GEN
DAVIS WILL SHOOT THE MURDRRRRs.

WHAT THE MODoCs EXPECT-Tr rs THOUGHT GEN.
DAVIS WILL SHOOT THE MURDRRRRs.
SAN FRANCISCO, June Ga dispatch from
BOyles Camp, Tue Lake. June says there has been
operations since the surrender Of Capt Jack Tho
latter says surrendered because he could hold out
longer The opinion prevails that Gen. Davis will shoot
Capt. Jack Boston Charley, and Schonchin without
waiting for any suggestions from the civil authorities
correspondent OF The Bulletin OF this city had talk
with Boston Charley who sail that the majority Of the
captives prepared 20 die like men. Capt Jack
for nothing lie does not speak to any person
cept his sister Mary. Charley says that twelve Modocs
are still at large Col Green's command is still hunting
for them.
dispatch from Sag Point, June 4, says that Gen.
Daviss command with all the MOdoc captves, at
Applegates house, aud TO como to Boylo's camp
that day. Black Jim is OF the missing Modocs. He
is the rascal who held Gen Candy while Jack used the
knife on him. Hooker Jim and Steamboat Frank are
hunting after the missing warriors and squaws in that
vicinity.
THE TOLEDO FIRE UNDER CONTROL
TOLEDO, jane 7-1:20 p. m.-The fire is now
entirely under control having spread no further south
ward than the Gardner block. steamer from Adrian
has arrived, and is now at work.
loss will probably reach $4,000, and the insur
ance $4,000 The retail Of Fred Easton Co. was
destroyed.
FOREIGN NOTES.
Special dispatches report seven cases of
cholera in Dantzig.
The Spanish Government will propose to
the Cortes that it choose Immediately new Cabinet
and the Ministers discussing the form Of cleo
ton.
In the Cortes yesterday Deputy Blanc
moved that after the proclamation Of the Federal Re-
public the members Of the Cortes place themselves
the head Of the volunteers their respective provinces
and unite grand effort TO exterminate or drive
from the country the Carlst insurgents.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1873-06-07
LONG BRANCH FROTH.
ARRIVAL OF PRESIDENT GRANT-TIT SEASON NOT
FAIRLY OPENED.

ARRIVAL OF PRESIDENT GRANT-THE SEASON NOT
FAIRLY OPENED.
LONG BRANCH, June eff misantrope
should seek harbor. he could hardly ialight on more
favorable spot than Long Branch is ut this MON mt
The season has not begun, and as one drives along
Oceanave brilliant eQuipage can be seen thaI
heavy jolting furniture wagon, or the hotel stage
with its two OF three dismal occupants Tho hotels,
with the exception Of the Rowland, Ocean, Pavilion,
and Clarendon, are closed, and although many
cottages are occulnl, the Branch Is az yet as
quiet as the I.notest fishing village In
the verandahs the ashlonabe obstetrics may be seen
beds mattresses chairs, and other domestic articles
heaped in the utmost disorder. Notable arrivals nave
not begun A temporary excitement was caused, to-day
by the coming OF President Grant and suite
The bucoio Inhabitants Of this place had
been on the alert all the morning. and when at 55 p M
special Of Pullman palace cars, which left wash
ngton at a. IN. arrived their enthusiasm had reached
the highest point The Presidential party, which con-
sisted Of President Grant, Mrs. Grant, MI. and Mrs
Dent Miss Nelly Grant, and Gen. Babcock, alighted
from the train In severe storm, and were conveyed in
carriages provided by Gen. Morris 10 the Presidents
cottage AT the West eni The President also brought
in special train siI fubloOded horses and several
dogs Gen Porter and his family arrived at his cottage
Parkave early in the morning. and cordially received
the President II ia expected that following the Presi
dents party the hotels will rapidly begin TO FILL but the
season will not actually begin until June
Goth. tho date named for the opening Of the
Metropolitan United States Mansion, Airing
tom LAUGHS and Central The weather has been chilly
toths date and has been stated, the avenues are
as empty as in midWnter Several owners Of cottages
have taken possession among others being Count Alb
basiss Louis Phillips, A. j. Drcse j. Curtis, Louis H.
Brown, George W. Chds, Nehemiah Perry, Wm'
Cavity, Thomas Murphy and family, Edwin Adams,
John Hoey, Mr6. James W. Walack, and Maggie
Mitchell AT the hotels engagements are numerous but
arrivals few The season is considered TO be unusually
hac
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1873-06-07
NJ. LUDoVIC VITET.

NJ. Ludovic OF Louis Vitet, promlneno
Conservative politician French, VcePresident OF tho
National Assembly, and a member OF the Institute,
Of France died yesterday. He bornin 1902 at Paris
was admitted 1919 to the normal school, and made his
debut in literature editor OF tho Globe In 1875 no
published anonymously drama called Les BdTT1eddes'
which was very successful The following year no pub
lshed: Lee Flats de Bios and two appeared
La 5ort de Henri III In 1874 these three dramas which
were OF a historical character and referred TO the
same epoch, were collected together and called Las
Ligue. Tho revolution OF 1880 placed the Doctrnaires
with whom NJ Vte night be classed at the head OF az
fairs He was then a member Of the Liberal society,
Tide tOi k cie fdiderd" and received from M Gulz0U
the position Of Inspector OF Historical Monuments
created expressly for NJ Vitet. In 1894 he was made
Secretary General Of Commerce under the MasGry OIL
NJ. DuchAte and In the same year he was elected a
Deputy. He supported the foreign policy OF NJ GuZot
and opposed all propositions for reform.
NJ Vtet continued his literary labOTs during MS pot
cal activity and published various critical articles, pr
cipally on Archaeology In 1899 he became member or
he Academy OF Inscriptions and In S45 nc entered the
:, .pch Academy replacing NJ Sonnet. The revolution
r ,s4s threw NJ. Vltet among the Opposition, ana no
o. ed great hostility 10 all measures that tended to-
a Repubcanism; but having opposed the c0dp detdi
s obliged to retire TO private life Having Deem
nto,d member Of the present National Assembly, no
~ - OF the leading conservative doctrlnalres WHO
mogored by every means in their power, TO restrain
NJ Tbiers from adopting the Gorms OF Republican Gov
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1873-06-07
AFFAIRS IN CUBA.

ENGAGEMENT WITH INsURGENTs-C.N DIrIoS OF THE
COOLIES CONDEMNED-AssIsTANCET TO CARLIsTs.
HAVANA, June 6.-0ficial advices from the
interior report battle in the Manzanilo jurisdiction
in which the spauiards suffered loss of 81 killed and GO
wounded and the insurgents had 100 killed.
The Tribune attacks and condemns the Colonization
Society for protecting the rights of the coolies. 1t
regrets that the Society falls secure humane treat
ent for the Chinese abOrers and better prospects for
them when their contracts expire. The cruelty with
which they are treated them to resort to suicide
murder, or flight. II denOunces the compulsory re-
contract system and charges that the present rules
were copcocted By mon whO finding that they cOud not
continue their illicit traffic IN human flesh, attempt 10
cheat the law by changing the name OF the traffic.
The same journal reports that persOne of known
Carlist prOcvities in Santiago dc Cuba have sent
10000 10 the Csrist Committee at London, TO assist
the insurrectiOn which Is now devastating Spain.
The DidTto opposes tue Federal Republic, and argues
flat nearly all the Spanish American Republics have
bepn because they srOye to initiate the
federal system Of the United States, while the Govern
mepta of Chill Peru endure because they have
iected the principle Of federalism.
The Government, yesterday released from confne-
ment the American citizen Augustin Santa Rosa.
New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1873-06-07
FRAUDS IN THE PAY-RoLIs.

Last Fall it was discovered at the Con-
troler's Office that extensive frauds had been prac-
ticed through the collision Of the superintendent and
tmekeeper Of the labOrers employed in laying the big
pipes in the upper portion of the city. The system
adopted was TO the usual pay tickets to men who
personaed names on the rolls Of aborers who had been
employed, and who either dead or discharged and
were no longer performing service.
The money received by these personators OF names
frauduleny retained the pay-rols by the supern-
tendent and tmekeeper was principally paid over to
them and the pretended labOrers received but small
pance for their share in the fraud When these facts
were ascertained in December last they were laid
before the Grand Jury, who found indictments
against four OF the parties who had falsely
personated laborers on the pay-roIs, and they
were arrested and imprisoned In the Tombs. The SUI
perlntenden John Noe was also indicted and arrested
and held to bail in the OF 5000. No proceedings
have been taken since until within few days, and in
the meantime the other men had been detained as wit
negses three OF whom have confessed their guilt and
one has been convicted before Judge Sutherland for at
tempting to obtain money under false pretenses. The
Paymaster OF the Controllers office, however, has again
made adayts charging these frauds upon Noe and the
time-keeper John Rice and his brother, Thomas Rice,
for whom benchwarrants OF arrests were Issued The
two former we're arrested by officer Sutton OF the Con-
trolers Office, on Thursday.
It's said that this kind OF fraud had been reduced TO
regular system, ana thaJ from nltY 10 ONO huuuIou
names were upon the pay-rols, credited with amounts
averaging $40 per month to each who had never per-
formed any service but personaed on pay day by
persons who drew their pay regularly on the pay
tickets given them by the superindent tme-keeper,
they having sworn 10 their identity.
Beside this particular form OF fraud teams we're cred
tied at an average OF $40 each month for which no
service had been performed making robbery from the
City Treasury of several thousands of dollars monthly
Relative TO the arrest OF John Noe and John Rice on
Thursday frauds upon the City Treasury, MI George
NJ Van Mort Commissioner Of Public Works, stated to
reporter OF THE TRIBUNE yesterday that In consequence
of irregularities discovered last December in the pay
rolls Of the men employed in laying the big
pipes on Tenth-ave, the whole force, In
Guiding John Noe, the general foreman, and Rice
the time keeper was discharged and reorganization
effected short while afterward Noe was arrested at
the suit OF Controller for fraud and admitted 70 bail
in $4,000 The cause OF the rearrest on Thursday Mr.
Van Mort could state the Controller has not com
municated with him upon the subject.