, 1873-02-19
\ 0benge Of Tactics in the Ror-
fumery War.
Hyde Park Anxious to Fight tho rortiiiters,
,. at Common Law.
A Sweeping Change in the
Mode OF Paying Jury
men.
One Of uyde Parks Insurance Agents
in Trouble.

a Ten Thousand Dollar Malicious
Arrest Case.
The defendants in tho Northwestern Fertiliz-
Ing Company suit for injunction against Hyde
Park, yesterday caino before Judge Farwoll with
tho following supplemental answor:
Northwestern Fertilizing Company Y. 0haun-
coy n. Cady OF al Supplementary answor Of
Chauncey II. Cady, William Z. Halo, Z. g. Clark,
l.. Bradnor, Jr., L. e. Fisher and H. Wander
bit, Trustees Of tho village Of Hyde
Park, and tho village Of Hydc Park, to tho
bill Of complaint Of tho Northwestern Fertilizing
Company. These defendants, by way OF supple
mont to their answer alroady hlod. say that tho
President and Board Of Trustees Of the eaid vii
lage Of Hyde Park, did, on tho 18th day Of Feb
suary, 1878, pass M ordinance in tho words
Ind figures following: (Horc follows tho
ordinance, already published, Of Fob IL inst.)
And these defendants say that said ordinance
has boon, since Its passing, and is now, In full
force and elfoot, and ready to bo enforced, rs
soon as tho timo of publication provided by law
shall expire.
Counsel for tho defendants asked permission
~ nlo Lib nuppAelnontaAS nna"ot "uu aAtoi
some a!aousa'on' Oh W 'no oneo. ~ "oulu ~ nAs"
o., On .no m5uneton, sno ooust uloc.uo W W
Mea' misuoue pto!euseo " tno n1unot4on' y,
following motion:
The Northwestern Fertllizin8 Company '. Tho VIII
lago OF Hyde pnrk, aud others. And now comcs tho
court to 40 iar modify the function horetof0ro uront-
cd IN this cause, that any suit or proceeding which
said deiendants Or either Of them may heseaftor COM
1nse o. prosecute in 9ny Court Or oonrts 70, Of w
ngaanss tne 4cotmpn9ne hSren or ohsGs . 1or the
3nnaSnta Or r. phc nar ths ordSnnces ~ aoi5
Village st forth In the supplemental ANSWER lcd here
~, shall not DO construed violation Of said injunc-
ton Or subject said defondant to proceedings for con-
Counsel for tho village OF Hyde Park having
spoken In support Of the motion,
Mr. suott ahfoctoa far IN Com,.,o that +,o
rananaaa - tho s,;,;.an .p,';b;.a s~' '.a w
otuuances s'N, " tno v.ilase Wero plomp!ory n1'a
unreasonable, andthat thoro was no good ground
for asking modification until tho matter should
come up for final hearing. T1o urged tnat tho
L.--: - H. ...I,o o+1,
noaelns u tne 1no1'on enouio 10 SGT 1or 1no zasn
Maroa' .he aay aos lot .he hna1 heaflng' 10 that
tho whole mattor might como up together.
n1r. Smith said ho did not ask tho Court to do
cidc on INV suca question "a to whothor tho yil-
Inn ho5 ~ saod roosonah1a or,,;noncos ~ othar-
!age nHa M pasaeu loasonaolo ordinances or otnor
"lso. "Aat they dld ask OF tile court was to
give them permission to try the matters Of law.
They surely entitled to do that. They believed
thoy could show that tho Cornpnnv wns coro,caa
~ III oasino77 'nas tno lnoro 1ac' o. INC oom,
pans nelng nuisance was not oil that
tho yillage Ind to complain of, but
thss it ".s Of easssss"sss
wus matter OF fact. and Inv and waa nat for
tiis Court to paBs upoD. It was for e Court of
law to dccido, It was lust and NECESSARY that tia
defendanta should havo an onnort,1nitv to nrove
,t
soerfect rieht tn nix tba Court for tbe moana ~
doipg 90. with the Injunction Weighing over
thoir heads, as this yas. thoy could not tile INV
suoh step; No one would say, 10 matter What
the Logislat,iro had giyen t q yesiod Hill to
carry IN jtA hnsinoss IN such mannor M ta ms'so
Il d nuisance. # thoy lad askod the Court. hy
this motion, to decide tlat the Company had yio.
the Court TO adiuficato unon any ouast;on IF Inv
ar fact thoy n1rht be ,,Tanarel for o},eci;nn ana
refusal; but on tho contrary, ali thoy sought to
obtain was tic right Of trial ~ law on auch nues
tiona- -" O a00s
Tba court amid II In undoratooa H. orioh+
th1t the oh;cct ~ tho ,not{nn ,paa ~ aht,;
mobilization Of tho irimncton AZ ~ von1d aecura
+ha nart;oa nnin;..aS f.se t; ~ MouG soeMto
naapptro .saa r1,t sa pi4R mr4a N sno
and mss mon aol nntion o ho fouo1 - 4Int tSn.
= stcn15 15 hpLa+eo ~ ~ s9Vn8ns Ina5
~ a H. aH Una oI tne eauae
ronrt shnn1d t%ini1 ~ tLet ts " ,o o1oh, she
Is Lop1o 5;a anoao LINK tnat tae injunction ahou5d
tuS 70 d. tAo ugtcn1aut Noli1o hui, a1tel gu,
ssSa ~ .aI ooont ~ sno aeclsloh oi me Court ~
whici thu comn5a,nn oeytoe ,'a snoula Dc e maae
tHaa aou tuo Go"plAl4snt sAou4u appenl 1r9m,
~ :nas I'll Mippeat p,n mou!a keep tno Injunction
~ tuH 1clce ~ now was. u
Rdareu 5a n % IN n!m snas TINS as tho proper May OF
ora H. ~ tno nsto ~; &. omeLt snoaa Pto7
p5 pa.9 mn sa%ESss % ina t nosty .ne o.nes s.ao wnea
aon13' mu "!oh ~ WI naaes nong E1eKase1 tneY
e't e11a NY Sput. t&oseapy & :na eu4ls 4,
ma}inn whon ca4oo M ~ " ba ~ asrd !. s4a
ataot,,, W ~ a4.at ~ ~ ~ ne naa no
nnnnrtunu ~ tost;no the;r ~ ;r hasnR a IN
HEe'1t aa1a ~ xt n,n sn1a ients ~ lnM' 1Ae
selvas ~ see an en and max T. } Wan snv u
o,,ta +hnt ,nu +iro.taaeJ hott J 49,. VI
NJ gmith aa;d thnt 4bo dosan5".,t. oo,,,,,.
nnthing Tnnrc thnn thair r;ohIs enIa, M n9uSnt ~
nronnss - ~ nnut;n1 ,,t5a t,1 10y ~ ~ ~
EnpnonS ~ vnctnns6 - tho .Hn eonsioe tne