New-York tribune., 1873-01-23

@ You did not deliver the certificate OF stock 10 him
A No. SIR he said nothing about that.
O. Why did he his cert6catei A. do not
| know.
| @. Do you remember any conversation between you
and him on the adjustment of these accounts A. do
| not.
@ You Understood that you were holder OF his ten
@ Did he understand itt A. presume so; 1t seems
| to have gone from his mind. however.
@ Was this the only dealing you had WITH MN In rei
| ercnce to any stocki A. l think
| Q. Was it the only transaction Of any hndi A The
@ Has that $3.50 ever been paid to you A. have no
! recollection OF 10.
O Have you any belief that it ever hast A. No. Sir.
q. Did you ever loan Gen. Garfield sS00i A. Not 10
| my knowledge. except that he called this loan
| PACTs ABOUT GEN. GARPIELDs DIVIDEND.
O. You do not call it loani a. did not at the time
! | am willing 1t should go to suit him
| O What VIC want to get at is the exact TRUTH A.
| have told the truth In my statement
O. When you paid him sS2 did ho understand that he
borrowed that money from you A did not suppose
Have Won any belief now that he supposed sol A.
No only from what he said the other day do not DIS
o. We want your Judgment Of the transaction A. My
Judgment Of the transaction is just as told you there
was but ono thing ABOUT II: oon ,onoid n von Won
did not suppose tbat you had any right to H. or any
claim TO i'll A. No, Sir , - h,,, o,,or
| the stock was paid fgri A. Yes, Sir In, ,,.p.o.s
@ There were dyidSneS Of WI 0nsh Sir racine hA'i'""
q Did Gen. Garfield ever receive thesei A. No, Sir
| he never has received but s529.
suppose so It did not belong TO me; should not have
| given il TO MIN II 1t had not belonged to him.
o. Yon did not understand 1t 10 belong TO you as
loan you never have called for it have never received
O. Has there been any conversation between you and
him in reference to the Pacific stock no was entitled 70
| o. Has he ever called for iti A. No. Sir.
q. Have you ever offered 1t to him A. NO, SIR. -,
q Has there been any conversation IN relation to III
/ A. No Sir.
q. Has there ever been anything said between you
ana him about resembling the purchase of 10 shares OF
Credit Mober stock; has there anything been SAID 10
you Of its being thrown up, or abandoned, or sure
deredi A. No, Sir; not until reoently.
O. How recentyi A. Since this matter came up
q Since this in vestigation commencedi A. Yes, Sir.
vestigar0n that You held these other dividends which
you say you did not pay TO him in his behalf did you
regard yourself custodian of these dividends Tor
himi A. Yes Sir he paid for his stock, and is entitled
to his dividend.
demands A. Yes. Sir. as this suit Is settled .
@ You say that sS29 was paid 10 hun; how was it
paid A. | presume by check on the SergeantaI
Arms; ind there are some checks fled without any
letters initials ndicsting who seey were for d,y
dend was paid with him, in regard to this matterf
do not know what matter you refer TO- so.,oo, voo
would like to see iti A. have no copy OF It, c.o.,.
a Have yOu the original I a. No, Sir; Mr.. Garfield
showed me letter which he said he intended to incose
with money sent me DID not know VINO aI9 ths
he Intended TO put in indorsed on the back OF
that letter my reply first turned over the letter ana
o. Your answer fndorsed the back OF the letter was
published in the newspapersi a. Yea, Sir he published
O. A. pnbhshed did they correspond with your reco-
lection papers writteni A. Yes sir; wrote It
Guessed Of all kinds OF crime and msdemeanor; told
him had made no such statements as ne repIesenteI
his etteg which be said intended 10 have ncosed with
the money aud wrote on the back of 1t that maze no
O. The published correspondence in the morning
papers Of the next day your recollection OF what oe
he says he left copy OF hR letter for me at the Ar
ngton: received that letter; only sa" the le
o. Did he inciose the moneys A. Some money came
20 me ineIosed in an envelope which had sent
O. How much money was in that onvelopei A. Four
hundred dollars.
ACCOUNT WITH GEN. GARFIELD
The following memoranda referred to by witness is
staternent of his account with Mr. Garfield placed in
evidence:
- O DR.. 1885, To 10 share. stock c. N. ofA siS'a
19Ssir': Toti ) j7s '4-' - " '-'''
1858 by dividend bond, p R.. per les,
June 1883 by dividend collected for account se'o
CONGRESSMAN KELLF's CASE.
@ DO youtdesreito make any additional statement In
regard 10 Mr.. Kellyf A. No. Mr.. Kellys transaction
was about the same that Of Mr. Garfied's.
O. Give the details Of it, and whether he agreed to
take stock A. Yes, Sir.
O. What amount1 A. $1,000
O. Was that about the beginning Of this same session
OF 1867 or 1868 A. think 80.
O. Did he pay you anythingi A. No, Sir IL was the
Mr. Colfax; the same transaction precisely he
was 10 have 10 shares.
o. You received the bonds and sold them. and did you
receive the money dividends also A. Yes, Sir, and paid
O. Thes transaction in the amount 'and in its detail
was the that Of Gen. Garfeldi A. Precisely.
cheek tbst with the intais W d. X" written in the
sergeantatArms' room put in the initials in his name
In the check which s dated the 2d OF june and 1t was
for the payment OF that money dividend.
@. ,He had the money tor 1t A. suppose so; !
found there taken up at the sergeantatArmss and
o. You delivered the checklto Mr.. Keleyi A. pre-
O. when he received that check you did he under
stand that that was the balance Of his dividend after
paying for his stockf A. suppose gave him state
inent did the others.
Q. Did you think he he understood that that was loan
from you TO him; that he borrowed 1t OF you do
not think so still have loaned money TO Mr.. Kelley
several times ne saia the other dAy that loaned mn,
think probable he put that with this $500 to make the
1900 think he has in his 3lnd that he has my 1900
this transactions Is as follows:
To 70 share. .toei crSHt ~obiisr of Amsric. sicoo
jan is 70 cash, s3ss
1903 BY dividend of Q. P r r. $1,000.
June Il. by dividend collected per IOur account $500
1853 sept gs 70 cash loan 500
O. Do you think MIR. Kelley understood when he re-
ceved that check from you that that the money he
was borrowing from youi A. did not think se you
O. Was ything said about its being loani A. Not
that know OF.
O. Did you have any conversation with Mr.. Kelley
after that in reference 10 this transaction in Credit
Mober stocki A. Yes, Sir; he inquired about the
dividends, whether there any mOre told him that
there would not be any until the suit was settled
O. Did you understand from that conversation that he
considered himself entitled 10 further dividends there
were any made 7 A. suppose
O. You continue TO hold that stock for him A. do.
and all Mr. Kelley has received OF 1.-THE 1929
BY Mr.. McCrary-DO you remember the date of that
cash dividend A. About the middle OF June think.
deposited the money with the Sergeant at Arms the
nth OF June which drew this check
O. That the June dividend OF 60 per cent in cash,