The sun., 1873-10-29
criticism OF tougr, ssnan ~ ~

ihr uthu Hhu no representatives For two
man man who once % might move the world now none 90
Nn NAN howeyer powerful he may have been is re
cfosy whe he falls he ss 's ns ed pea,s ca n' .. sen
S f.9 s9 ns sSnt and memory o. those who have
no no voices OF the fricnis who once surrounded him
Soce Of Justice The jrry should see TO Il Tia, truth a
thc AlIllug OF james Fisk was murder
THE PRISONER HAD THREE prrrNsrs;
f,r;t lnshabe homicide. hecau.c he killed Jane.
LEX IN seidefence second that the maitreatmcnt or
,ause Of Fisk'sdea h. and wound innictcd ;hi
mind I y time be he con- hi ' the va. Sa @
b ii Tps "a III h't ~ mt',9nsihe for it Ia bri nrst that
sil,eH him mifd' tn" he was insane when he Killed
lie Sogld take these dcfcuccs in their propcr order
nm 1h'd dr OF hsaniiy Wcrc tle 9ccason not such
gS icT9g nar,sr "a, G wcnid sssn 10 be part Of
~ mlitrrs not before th,n Insanity, such the law
t,c"snil d. was disc - % The mind Mcdical men had
W.' m,i s9,h d.tr.eat ior ny reputation as TO say
thc hour " his hrth To hc present inomtn here Vas
,ot one sign, iarS, or symptom Of mcntal disease.
~ nat blood, irarcdy oyer instead OF prociain.
oncr's Indifference then that ll the nest Mr. I'M
Nhom even the ueccs' ties OF the could induce
Who had fred tie .hoi. ms dctcncc was n".t IN.
uush'ns imposition "pon tie judgment OF the jury.
TnE NEXT DEFENCE
10 order the that James Fisk di not die from
tne o9hd nicisd by the prls9ner but fron tn, treat
IN, rule of the old Apsiosason law hat Il one be
"Un.'d ahn ~ wound ee not prontry cared for, and
murdct or mansl laughter because Il the wounds had not
@ i' ce ae %fuRaS W Ssc woH@ IN no, han ssd
""i9et that u the wound be- dangerous one, caicu.
It'd 10 ndalgcr Or destroy Me- and death ,nsue, the
M 5cd. nnci9t y i %r;po1,e,s % Tough i ,pgcsr iast
n,tcr ur.tmcnt M hit have SAVED The patients ifc
uccl.ioh io the same tu'ci Was recorded In our
a. 'te' .,ungciy enough entitled. "HsOkett ast The
TIE QUESTION FOR THE jury
was. pi the wonnd coutrnute in any degree to the
death u James tlsS. JrP There not doctor ON
dangerous one, aud ouly one Dr. Cafnochin screwed
up NJ professiond courage to the opiuion that the
,nre forth as tlng Of wonder IN surgical Journal,
"ercd were prcsetved IN some museum In Italy. rut
thee wonderful almost niracuou. only proved
atal. As for the treatment of fisk's wound by the
nasuu,p After consultation they determined % The
most p9er measure for his rcicf the administration
!, did not make any dircre,ce whether the deceased
he Language q the od Wfcrs,n Il he lad not lad the
Wound 9e .9uli not have q d. nut hey nsd not even
ca ,d hy the def dared that Fsk dicd from
Sn P5 a de 1i IF Rcss s e,sae he ySio%. SS M.
me eAse-hit & ne puils % Jane, Fsss eyes con,
seniiemcn almost united IN saying was inemnpalibe
,accby ilas ins ihs suing ~ MURDER. w6a'Ser
death rc ulted immediately fr m tie wound or from
tAe rom dy emp yea 10 alleviate H.
rHR THIRD DEFESCE
va. hat &c prisoner believed hn,e to be IN such
mnea dln.er from Fisk that h was jpstned in siiins
Gus bodily harm Tosuppcr this defence they had seen
S G & aS S R' 'sS gtSs
n TI o. rGIad to spPrssnS mme
ounded itas~ere no ju.t.neAtlon. nlu.t nave some
,b e. 20 me common @ .enss Of ny fellow when called
BE- ain bound IN coi science hound In law TO RyoiJ
Y encounter u possible. Atin' the eneounter must
NY enemy fr .uea ~ encounter claln no Jl.tia
meet J,n,'s # he had reison to Sptiehend
i,9m such an enc unter ht j. suuhsibc for thc
ground to apprh herd oanger, snd that the encounter
10 tla hula.n NE.
nE MUST Satisfy JURY
- hs con trSucu tuat he as il.tinrd. Dear1ng u
a. case . GsSo.ed ~ H. 'S svdefce Sa 81 H. .'f' VII n
eln-acr IT, tacs admitted ny bntu lIe tdIs.ut,d,
y Il 4,l.o,,a,e, pfcmed.tat'i aarirr5' '' E'''
The District Attorney proc, cdcl 20 review the
relations hctv cen Fisk aud 'hc prisoner. from
their partnership In the oil refinery at Green
point.
TIE crst movement ~ hostility ono of aggression
90 o., PAL "t o.. gf.u.cT, VINO 's.ted NE property
vio ian mp 3 'Imi iula shared 1t sin rr.rlf Tnt
Vas iv.so"e. - Aostilitcs on the other size.
THEY EJECT HIN.
He 5 s ch9rrea ~'Ih r as.,raepF s money q M e9gps
u. f,r s5,n t,,i'c We md th,t ~ ~ h' u
uon proposed and carried ont by fisE. Iios iities
oa FISK r6en f9Ss se a5 i'5S b;%sen bSlSsn
tntn ana We have ne prisoner claiming that those
reputable meiubcrs u ne bar % III. iiy we're engaged
d an si!em6. q throw, abroad ihToae6 al enssr
snet sw'Ps' S pP PrS @ a Ia T naf nj & enssSsd n ~ ~ q
1he.vdence Is from the mouth of their own witness
Prisoner for the purpose " procuring those letters
Mr.. Treman submitted that that did not show
that the prisoner was engaged In an attempt TO
publish the letters.
The District Attorney said that an Injunction was
sr,,n'.d iesirainns the prisoner ana Msusned from
s9' ao' pr perry he called IN ltielap 70 bqcsmsii
United Ia thr testimony ahpSs that The Asgressor the
ho ota.r ,lde, * wss tudeiy1 rins t. procure
As INDICTMENT AGAINST sroAEs,
aod w.. eyd nt it on ne Gth q January l'12, he
Ana e w. Sas ase Ca bs6y s Sl9 Sce asy q e 1aSg ,.
cab tor te onman House, Is in hls room there mo-
nclt ant N'ter tarrylg aflc 10 The Office drive. o.
of Ja.s Jf o'wi 'i9'' Id soos tes oG,ss a,
ie 6m 10 he Grand ccr,r on estior ,ef as Far ,S as
Fourth str'tt sud lrondNny he gets out aud goes
ABOUT a mSatc. aiter ,t,ajs cf t"t cbimGeriS Gs'nSH
sG s d FaS Grars Vas o5Sa 'eGn 0R os aioF o P''s
1r ~ i2e nmn h',l Of st test 9oleL where he tsi
a p o % e, 5e. T af Ery@S s!'
Ell m NJ, carriage and going up Tie private stsrs
tne - pistol T hoard The prisoner
e rear ol lus house, which would have let him out
ie a o3ers asn ocfSrc F ana SeSsasa spss psases e,
90 uuttr fht charge of utl,,r as a crlminal in
ca 90 y for mu der aud during an that time word
hos &c n'd hIu which wouli convey n any mortal
nc he idea that he had the least participation any
which fwo shots have been discharged found near the
c.te Of The conflict. These the facts ask you
% can d. honorable men what IL the conclusion from
Aest facts. who was iu that staircase with murder m
h4- heart DID James Fi-E, weighing two hundred
mounds and W ward, ms aeaNy coak about hn, rush
ina staircase ~ muruer THIS young, athletic aud ygor.
o.s prisoner.
THE PRISONERS EXPLANATION.
Mr. IHclls reviewed the prisoners erplana-
tlon Of the admitted facts. There no doubt
that n meeting was to be held in Providence on
the following Tuesday stated hy the prisoner.
lie said tia he went 20 the Hoffman House to
get certain papers IA relation to that case. Iie
WAS rchcd on that afternoon after the
tragedy aud where were the papers Then
there was the direction 10 the Grand Central
Hotel lie SAYS that he directed tho driver
there as 70 a landmark. II he waited TO sec Ferris,
VII, not direct inc driver TO Ferrss place Of business
on tlc corner 0f AmN aud Mercer strrot2 Nhy stop
IN Four'n street before reaching broadway. II he
huielP Tine enough, FHks carriage wac not there.
Ilnc 20 go 10 bp4Fo N th1uuerln's. me next you
hear Of hlm he is Ntcpg Bailey, th4 Interest IN the
Per 10 AL forgotten and lost light Of. He 10 going to
got q trts Tor tnr ltra crook
The Dsthrt Attorney ask ci Why The prisoner did not
ave ih Grand Contra Hotel on nndluF that The lady
100 The par,OT was not the lady be uiou .ht. hut hs
thc ear of N,ugcsncc rtcpeulln the voice OF Fisk
Nhy uld he not then ayoll hls terrific foe VINO might
fuh on MIN with his 2 pounds Of rrhh He says when
e haS rke pistol lie had time " retreat No time