, 1873-03-01


ground. Tho question Of joindor WAS MI imlno
!iatc and lnimrortant ono. The Mayor might
havo powor to appoint Mnson aud not Wright.
Tho Court might ho1t, TINT tho Mayor copld
granted to flo an information against tho ro-
'spondonte. It was easy to eny thoro woro
doubtful questions. But ho could not
that pefson gt contest tho rgat to eo Or,
ton as to tho juriadctlon Of tho Court did not
ggo,oo goig,o q r'shs to question mAno, title to m
0'1sHs %ho Court said tho ouo,tton o, jurisdiction
could only DO rnipod bv thn roanon{enta. The
ap on tho arn tn ie1vo tro 20 a,o ad oh
H. Tnay sn II I, 4" to gou aa roso u
It was not such doubtful nmoation NJ % r. 1 sncno
~ ~" TtH 1Ynnrt ~ a. s,+hs taomn1't ,oG'p'
~ 1no H;'sIa.s Hon.t =. 20 ~ 5I9uRnt: ~
oaao ;or Han u md Winha sor9 "ah Primo iaSo
aonlI,,,I no,nt % az Hn, or taero was really
sne oon5t ni,ould grant lowe
H. nn,, oeau Iniso uo9os as 70
ntorrn ~ 1,r a. any !aw. mr. aonay haa
a. Tlcrn xcaa .,othinn pi%osIsio % agaans g,a ~
t;t1, ~ hnJ, ~ ~ TIN %Haonf Hr r9teu, nus tn
QUESTION of oonetroton f aroy ,vo an, ~ @ Tns
Il wsa for thn 1n,5rt ~ dncdn ch a" nns
sos ""s an4, ~. ~a..e,"r. Iue'oo Mnetnor !neIe
lin, ts7o .gna m ouht lin p,1,an nns,,,,,,oD
aIonora oamo nndar to h ~ Tho gvo iax I"a nnsm
r1oIc whnr Il aaid o,ta -, iaw ~ WIS w oo-
ar. ~ boor1o .snxo ,a ,,t aot @ ~ Ms
and. inoimioi nj hoarsjs orrsr;x"5 " nnior IT.
Rnar ,a ony dor ~ Mas na .ne
amendment. As for A1r. Gnndy'a romarE nt,out
thc nocosatv ~ auhnfitrfip1 L sotin@ nr5"r' "
far % organizoG d nntlnr" 4 vas % MT seceaaorv
Int II nsnoaanrv tho nonrt von "a o ogont IL snes
It waa The truo ono. Oresuizod under y With
ont :. nnt;aU nndor. nr inv authority nf.o
It A0 exfstod' @ tif not "a 1t il Wv wag rsa oroatoda a.
As for thn aot Of 1905, .a.e would sa,, il naa
boon dooi1sl ssat II m not amended or altered a
oliartef, i was held to DO an amendment to tho
city ehnrteF Thu ao w9s loSai IN It's ttlo
the City Of Chicago. Eyofy section q that Aot
to ths dooaion r. snar caao N Te1ssenoe Sna 70
ths charter Of Detroit Ihe aet 81 1sgs Tedqc. I9
Board 90 tnat aae eho aot Of aooi mas plotted on
and that OF 1853 bocamo the original one: It did
not IofoE TO the previous eeE, e. o4s mas mauo new
board y was % aDsura 70 aay inc noara a"s W. not e
0on@isslonera vero 70 % elected BY &c county,
and hence ?, vsre excepted hy tue Mayors bill;
bat tnas Dill mhoa one e1nopt1on nna tnat served
aa ~ e1oluslon oa ~. o'ne.s: anas e19op'aon 91
others were subject TO- to tho Mayor: Tho law gayo
Il. The Mayor then, fuu power IN the promises.
Tho question WIS beyond dispute; tharo WEB no
reasonable doubt under which tho Court could
givcn sufficient reaaons7
The Court thought tho fact Of removal did not
appear. .".77@...' " .'~'@7.'~ :
Nir miey boiiovad i tho m"' sacon9 3 s'1srit ant
thai ont
Air. Goudv ani3 t}e f1rst nfidav;t aat IL ort
The Court s,1rceafol thn ins1,ffc;ancv NJ +ba
renaons OF removal WAS not alleged.
E1r Tnicv t1,nnclt Inv hni - r;9ht r. troot
tho t,ret af}dav;t a. tha nniv nne Ia5i hu hs Ta.
iators and TINT It failo1 70 nonta;n
several msterial avermontg, Under It tho
Would say % the ianguage @ Of Of Tho Msyors @ Iii waa m
oeor IN ss tSe n
forests OF the city REQUIRED Il. He wss the soio
judge, and it WAS discretion eonaded to him,
whether be notified them OF tie ro1.,oYal. ana
sent LIS roasons to the Council. II ~he' toid tha
Council tho interests Of tho city .rgauirsd q "a.
moyal, that wan sufficient. It'was onough for
him to follow tho lava. Tbe Council
other. He would sa7 nothing as to
that part Of Mr. Goudy'a remarks where ho had
hintcd that the Mayor dare not give his truo
rcaBon for removing tho re1ators. But ho would
had hot been gwen in full. K tho timo should
como, and the case was fully gone into, It would
be 4 aorry day for Mr.. Klokko.
All Mr. Cloudy wanted was chance for full
discussion Of tho subject;
Tho rolators, said MI. Tnloy, had mado their
could rot rot paos On the Eea and
snele.ggo aag tNa,, coloniisnra WITH III tha ro.
oemann o. ~ tug ta ,ow nh ennnph for thn
reiators to oiaim standing upon IN alleged
;tss ~ ao,,ths ~, Nomrt 1vou1a ioo1. wiz
Wy ~ ~ a'9.,, ~, ann1;ca+,on San ia of;ca