The sun., 1873-11-17

IL tI,,
haIlues' 'e"u'hs !" l'u'c "'v.'", - -
awkwaruhess OF ga'', ,he r'su, ''s ooi't M i,
hheeu anu '"c 'Mi'V"''s Vi '"o w NV =,
t"c i"'l'''"''S 7"o'.' Wy NV '''','''''''' ,i
'ne "n'''r r,'"'s "'" ,'''v ~, ,,n 'r'.i
feHlmeptal me- 'aP'' piOohe Ou''l'ue' ""' i'u
neeh pr"'her ""'.e' VI n'E'I ~ ~
'""n'noers' E"No "'S oN'u'"'o ~ '"'V' ,',.
''"'nan'' ,o'' Nul""'s' Nv" " o,,','.'
,''' '' w -, .r,,
sN"ic ''"' "u "o'o''N "',''
n''hc. M.hS "l",Ss'' "u"" -
.u'"''"e" VIC "''e"""''' ~ ''''
'',cs Ivy i"u ~ h'''"" w. ,,.. :, ,.,. ..,,.
ny ''"s'' '''''' az ''o'' wa, ,,''
' ,, ,,.,
49, -
US ',,',,, ,o, ,,., ., ..,..,,., ,,.,
=, '''', ''''''' ~ | 49,,
~ ~ ~r'N,' en- -,
',a,.a, -, T., 49,. no ,r,,,,o, a,oro
- ,r,,otto,,so
~ '''''' -, ,a. a., ,,a,a,oo
,'''s.,,,o, ,,.. pn,a,iga mt o,tion,o
- -. -. -. -. ,.,t
n,,, ,,.a,,"r r,t,,, s,ro,i
~ ,,.,.' ~ ~. -. -, ,,,o
''s ~ '"' ,,,1 -. -. ,,.ti,i,,,,
1, ,,u, ',,.,N. ,.,, ~. -, ,,.,r, =,
-. ,,'., H., 80 u,o
,,, -, ,,,, t,,..,.r
"'''' "i'.,'N 'o' ~ ~
"''U '' - 49,, -, ,,',,,r,,t,f
The defence may fairly be said 10 have shown
that the claimant Is not Arthur Orton, and TO
have brought out great deal In his favor from
the numerous English witnesses.
We now come to consider the testimony Of
the two South American witnesses, James
Brown aud Jean Luie Tho nrst-namcd swore
IT,. .ta,.,,,... ,t,a, ho 10, Lou
"a a., -, , ~, 4, -. tt. 81
nhath on two occasions when hc noticed brown
mark nn his side and "a scar on his left arm aim-
l.rtn those now To- bc seen ON the claimant. lie
dc. .iar., that lac was on board the Bella early in
! the morning uf the day She sailed, and that he
then .nw Cant. uurllctt. her comnandor. with
! Cant. Oates and Can't lIoskyns and Roger Itch
borne. come ON board. III Of them being very
drank He asserted that IL was currently re-
purtcI iu RIO I'm 1854 that some survivor. ~ the
Bclja.- wreck had been picked no 10y "a vessel
/ called tho q .pr.y and cnriied into Mrlhntrne.
| Ar,aur tho witnesses produced o., Mr.. Hawkins
| ina rchrtt.l we're CAPT. Oato-. w,I hnown as the
| Capt,ip ofthc Northncct. who vas prevented
! H. ui h.iue IN command uu the fatal might IN
| which .hc won't down by the subpoena ia this
! GA o. md can't. Up.kyns. Both of tlcsc gen
! u.n,.t ll,c IA uoirt-hl.ul denial e. tle-t.te-
ipe.f- Of pruvti ,. far Old. tlI.. ,yor. concerned.
I, Y IuIo. the steward of Tie O-urrv. about
who's. narrative there .. an almost rYwanti. in-
tor 30. b.. described o.. o. ir. q man of int, .cit
/ c.t,t,t,nfucc. n little under nfty Years uf a.r,
with o. Lald head. tN.nklins ewes. aud gray
( l,,td. which dcsrends anon his breast. lie tcs-
tiaed that in February, isit, he sailed from
staten Island A. steward In a thr,c-ma.ted.
bari<-ricged vessel called the Osprey. when
some ,ol miles from land III the coast " Brazil.
iu the ApriI following. on a very hot morning. a
boat was i.irkcd ur containing six mcn. nll In a
/ a., -. M ,.. 49,, 81 ~
80 ,.,,... ID, ,t, ,o,.,,.
...',,.,..'.,. .,r.,,,i,,., ,icir t..,. i,.t..,rl
.,,i ,.,,,,r, ma M, hoo f,,r ,,.s =, .,,ug
..'i.r onl u,,ti cha ,c.s.l ar,
i,' >,.,I..,,r,. IL, I,,i, III. ,.,,,,,.. MAJ, v,,.
-, i.,,... .,..,,.i ,.h,~.,o a. bc so,i,o m
,,t...',., ,.,.i ,,,, ~, ,t., and ,yo. Il, ,rc
,...,.,..,t.,.,,a,~f f.,.i,,,', I,,,,, ,,i n..b.
49,. t,',i,., ,,, ,..,,,,, ,h, ,,,,,,, maj,
lh- h'i" ""i'"- Wv ''''-'' ~ ''"'- W.
told Luie hc could never remember any Ailing
| and W. alWn,s dsrnuycd. I-pou Li. -ilc was q
/ , a.. , q. -. -. . ,r 40.
Drown hNh' ana ilS l+' h'l" "''' 9''' h"''
! rnn away t. the lialiaia' dEline= rs soon a. tie
I o.nrev reaci,.d N,l,nt,rue nud s., lost sight of