, 1873-12-20

her give mp Tho koys to lior bureau. So tried to
giyo an nlarm, aud ono Of them put pillow osor
hor faco. 'rLoy could not unlock tho bnroau
nnd mado her get up and do it. Thoy obtained
two wato1ies worth e225 throo ullaihs, worth
$500; bracoloiB, 9100 II diamond croBs,
$1,000; and two diamond t rings, al,oO0.
She Ind recovered nil oxcopt ono ring,-tl,o
watches and diamonds In April, nnd tho ro-
maindcr from four to Six wooks after tho first
lot, Capt. Hickey sent word TINT llo Ind thonl,
mud she wont next day autl got them. Sho know
Duncan very vol. Ono Of tho mon WIS Tho
aame slzo and appearance as tho dofondnnt Dun-
can. (Ddonlant's sttornoy objected to this
question, mud took an oxcoption.) lie did not
speak, but lold htr. Cunningham. who WAS
sleeping with her. Tho men wore not In tho
house over ton minutes. Tic small nun put tho
siolou prosperity into Ills pocket. On cross-
examination by the dcfonso, it was ot,aonyorcl
to Bhow TINT the man rho was supposed to ropro-
sent Duncan WIS really q n,nn named Dunlap,
who had boon indicted by tho Grand lury. Ihu
Witness testified that SHE WIS not acquainted
with Dunlap, mud that ho Ind nover visited hor
house, except cue afternoon after tho robbery.
penitontiarN Elmor Washburn wns never Mt
her house. 1lo had nothing whasoyor to do with
The caAo, 30 fnr ls sl,o knew.
CAPT. HICKEY.
E1-Capt. Hickey was called, and testified tlnt
ho Ind known, Goary twelvo or fourteen years.
1lo learned of tho robbery tho same morning
TINT it WAS committed. lIo delivered so,e Of
the stolen property to Lizzio Moors, but had
pledged llfH word not to roycal from
adto h9 he got rd,,te IT and e0%a I'd not not have
pledged Ills uora Tho question AZ to who gnvo
him tho property was thcn waived by tho Stato'B
Attorney. Ito ncyer had any talk with Goury
about 1t, md did not zoe Linn Ito anything with
m f,rnn ID f@ptr rnrI
for returning It, and did not eco auY reward. Flo
saw IL EaclsaSe said to contain $3.50, which w.,B
to 10 left for tho person who returned tho jew
olry. 1le did not have any conversation with
sou who turned over tue property only once be-
fore that ti1ner aua did not know whethar tilis
peraon llad nny acquaintance will Gcary or not.
a1ss Mooro cn1ae TO got tho property the day
after llo l[ickpy) received it. Duncan hal no
hnud in turning over tho property.
- On cross-o5u!nination by tho dofenBe, Capt.
Hickey stated that tho person who ga7o up tho
property WIS net Goary; that doay's ieputatiou
for honesty, 80 lar as lie knew It, was good and
TINT lie had neycr hoard Geary charged With rob-
bory before. Tho qucn.ionB whether It was not
practice in pasico circles throughout tho co,ln-
try, to receive stolen property from third partles
to bo turned over to tho owners forn reward, and
whether he had heard anything connecting Dun
can with this crane, were objected to, md tho
objection sustained.
CAPT. BucKLE1.
Capt. William Buckley testified that Geary
came TO nun ~ alo poi!so.stataon tho day TINT
aud told him whcSe to flud Nowlan and Williams,
and they were arrested OIL his information iii
Blooms saloon, on Frauklin st,eot. III tho
evening, Geary tuld whero Dunlap was, aud Tie
!nt&cf waH AGrGatRu 1Aoso men were arrested
because Goary stdd that thoy wero tho men who
committed Ito uob6ery. LILO tloionso asked
whether Gcary ~ atcl tllat llo knew anything
about Tho lobhory, which wns answered uega-
t'yoly, md tho teu'anng questions wore object
cd to aud objections sustained.
OFFICER isYnSE.
Onlcor Byrno tt*'tiiieu that he saw Dunlap and
Nowan drive up " pp]lock's Baloon, on Third
avenue and POLK street, lie morning of the rob-
bory; that they Inquired wloro 0eary roomcd,
saloon with dcary that Ao eaw Gcary with
Dunnp tho day .l1s.t the iattor was arrested. uo
arroHtcd Dunlap. howlan. aud Williams.
r,,,nn'3.n Il 4 cvsS1San44: ,:ss %n1t s,,o, r.. to-,
titled TINT ho was mopeey-loaner and stock-
dealer; that lio had known Duncan three yoars
t!at ho was sleeping: With Lzzio Moore tho night
Of tho robbery; TINT Duncan Tas one Of tho
chokod by linn tlxreo times; that Tho luttcr
wished to know whare llB money wns, aud tried
to nuke him give IL up. l1o lal =, ,140 there
that night. llo llvetl with Lizzie Moore. le
the latter would show any signs OF guilt. He
bud told Maggie Muoro, and perhaps soyoral 9TH
ors, that ho did not 'uow any QUO ongaGed in tho
robbery, but had doue this becauso hc did not
he r onS u ecnaso o T s
been subpnnac1. arxl lad already kept ou. Of the
way at the previous torn. a1r. Washburn had
nothing to du With htA appearance.
JANE' SowLAS.
James Nowlan was. tho next wltuoss. and tpa-
titled substantially III follows: lie camo here
ls:: january; had made Gcary,'s acquaintance
IN New York nld u'Hlo Duncan's after arriving
here. Patrick Conneaa, Joo Duncau, anl him
self committed tho robbery. Ho did not
hayo any conversation with Goary abou: this
particular robbosy, but Geary sa!d that ii Nowlcu
Geary could turn thenn into money In two hours
that II Nowlan intended going to Lizzie Moores,
l'e would Htay up all night at No. l18 Vest Madi-
Hon street to receive tho "awag." uc did Btay
up all night Two dnya provluus 60 the robbory.
but they could not at;seo to 80 that night. Two
AlBhta later. Nowlan. l3nncan, nad Cohners met
u'luor tha JFlBHs 1loslso an0ut O'CLOCK IN tho