, 1873-07-18
THE COURTS.
Interesting Suit on n Produce
Transaction.

Singular Action on Cheok---A Cof-
fln-Maker's Suit for Injunction.
Criminal Court Ncms---Bankruptcy Notes
1.-The Courts III Drlcf:.-
Now Suits. d.
A case that will interost Board Of Trade mon
vas tried bofore Judge Booth, tho last few days
past, In Oulbortson, Blair l. Gov. johnson, Mur-
ply d Co., on action brought by complainautst to
recoYor from defendants balance Of tho pur-
chase money Of, lot of Shoulders, stored at
Delphi, Ind. Tho defendants, Il, P. and 8. E.
Murphy, in their plea, denied Joint undor~
taking or liability. The evldouco showed that
on July 10. 1871, Uulbertpon, Dlair + &,Oo sold to
johnson, Murphy l. 90. tho shoulders in 1uos-
uon, receiving over $500 az margin, and agrce-
ing to carry The etuT for intorost storage, etc.,
disposed Of; that on Aug. 8, 1871,
hHs' bookB with $4,000, thorugh an
srror Of PLAINTIFF bookkoepor, which arose out
of tho fact Of plaintiffs rocelving that dato
check from defendants for that amount.
but which check was made payable to tho order
Of @. spear, and was iudoraod by him to plain
eifs, On Ills account with thom. In the latter
part Of September, this erroneous .crodit ntlll
standing in tho books Of p1nintiffs, who remained
ignorant Of tho error, they presented an account
to defendants showing balance at their crodit
Of e40.O9. which defendants paid by mems Of d
check OF johnson, Murphy d Co., and
the transaction WAS closed on plaintiffs
nooRs' very snofslS thefea,!of' 1onnson,
Murphy & Go. SOLD tho shoulaers
through tho agency Of tho Delphi house,
and TIM proceeds Of the Bale after dcductine
.ss..oa .n,a,,nt;,o - a. 6o7 NJ ,poro ea,,t ~
e,a1eos as n,a.. a. -. ~ hn ~, % ;n5oSnoa ~
CuAoeftson' oiau wy ai4u ~ 'no1,1 A4uot W
defendants. About tho latter part Of October,
or early In November, tho PLAINTIFF discovered
aasuss.oa - ..ma 11 rrod;+;rrr p,oora mi
correetea ~ sAo ~ saou,tg ppsais, ~ ~ nil
eaneo ~ @ IN ~ nver a" GO 90 I'm
hon siey 4hn thia timn ta g Of Sohnaon RufnIv
~ Wssoeu ana .no plenens m ~ ~,
aisos IT, anlnS tet s us atau ~ H. H.,
tars areont md thet tbo i'm ha M
intarost inteol tharnn Gha defond.nts n1a;m that
10y taof IIu ahnrtv after H. an1a ~ Tho shon1dora
as. Srts tat 4hn tpananct,on wea ~ 1Oct
y a. daaI ~ 3i,o 1rooaa5a - ~ H.
si as asadisaI ~ i,;r j. IN hnnIe ~
-. t,,Ax x1x ~
"n ~ ntaroJ ~ - tha ,an;fYa ~ afnndnnts md
W. entSio4 ~ w a.1n - oanr t1ns' s1r1
.nas ~ ~ snu W. ~, taS,it ~ ~ ar, H.
posua ~ m"a n g;+bir to or,.r, aon,o ~
tha 1rn, hna;nnaao snI Jnhnaon having charro Of
sne urn @ ama h',o;asa ths ns r.
Hues y. ~ - ~ .nnraotinn LII ~ taots
a.an1 y. = Warmly mi nnon tha booEa of
ony ~ Ii 49, M rosaaaa aaI ~ +i,o o.1na Va
Geavca sSpr soco,,t "1se ~ tnt S.to ~ ana
Dolphi sn9uiuos acGohns, Nv r.;tt NV IHso .r u
nos n,;, s,or as tIs ,rat =, Nou"nhor Ta
M non3 ,I a,1on,dor ~ nccnmnt .nnonrod frum
o h fp @ nave .a hson
asadi4 .ets anss, a. 1ahnsnn snhatntod
ores w. Gn AZ hasnro ~ "1 n,tnr t1n nis.
M acnvo1ca nv fo a. Zoo error as not eear
sne vn had tho rucipa chsreo Of TIC
nrn1isio1, bnaineas wns II tho hahit Of sIne The
9rO msne ;n transant;nns msao hy him fos Tia
mr.. ncconnt md thst tho othor menbors Of thc
nrm sas acovsrea y onts If Il Tes
ca'faa to the attention Of dofendanta. bui
.Sn9I nn oanatmant conld bn had with thom Or arly
~ ~ tham tbat on lila lat Of Noyembor. 1a7i.
@ oss %as n aeas " tat tbo % aa
~ ~ Az hin n ahont e25 10O tint r. p Mur-
IL hsa hod % nh,ree 90 nf tha nsaes of tna rm that
pay nau - ta a. 5a7 n haa heon mid to 5ohr,.
een y Inc nr to nsses - nhnyo @
IL ~ bn rou indahta1 tn the Arm ,,nlasl
ana osnors ~ mss os, I'll - ~ ihar saaaia
enoy ~ snomI ,.hi.h 1ara cc,a;derod do,htfu III,
sone " wv 1,t, e,o inrv for doc;a;on VIM "a
tusn %as ssaIea wv verdiot wch viii be- roal t
sunrr;ns sunmeH 0oA'o0 '0os' "''''1
aoentng. s,,nrnrsr,,,. .,r,o,s ou . curcr
c,nosre;a1 7nan csuaois1y Sanora md those
aatsd T., the e' mnnoy and its casual
+ns 1s;i Ia ;ntorasta in oca;on Tcn1ara
soat'ord.v s.op' ~ 'morn;nr hv Glof Tuatjca Taryel
ne asoada5 ~ tho c.ae dsc;dod srn =.
9,1osa III n1'stnIuar ~ ~ tho Frat Natinna Ronl
auao"a; a4 80 - ooo,ntn5 and nrou;n,a r. % i.a
t,a,a,,r v ,y row bia chact againat fs balnmce II
1 ~" Nv % AZ ha,1nS p,av;o,,o AZ ~ ~
1rooanta+on ~ % nf tho chnct thu maior Of II.
Lsf W. ,at;t;o,.aJ an,;no n +ho hontrrnto,
cnoeA Wao % ps.io pa ~ H., - a,,;;,nt;r ~ II!
Sohss' nG Ro,r,,nt i,n "insl ~.
~ t;a han1~ ,r;or ~ fba rnat,,r;t,
psesns.ao M at a. Wv nat '04h 4lo hans ns;ms IL;
sa,t ~ os oy,at | rai,n;no that 4 noa
saSsaa5 = tte r;nht ~ nrsot lie !mmatnro nj,
s"s,ua. ~ tha xas;oneea noina or that at tn