, 1873-10-25
Arguments Of Mr.. Church and Tho Stato's atfor.
:. ney..'Tho Jury 10 Bring In Sealed
Verdict This MornIng.

n Nn
statton Agent At Lockport. ami hv lin, H.. .s,,,s M
that tho defcnaont M 49, aua " aam No could prov
!nto tho station and compared s watch with tsa etoe
.ho Telegraph ONCE Mr. Reed requested The Con,
70 HE S.s him ,lns to produce The Witness ''N
Muliu. tbo annoro, oss'ea 70 any deay, but Mr. Nc
nnoI ,.sM uo oalointendont Of the Chicago h Alto,
short no BY sending ,paes, ,o ans,n 'ne witness in
ordering all otler trains to eeor ~ ,raa aee nl AM
NJ nan. oesss 70 avail the arrival Of tho witnc.s
-. msa, sl'ed at qusrtcr bcfors Il O'Clock, ane
he 7z111F1rp "A rror,o., -.
Mvnnma ~ w. AZ sohIo"s:
Alton nro.d a aI Ts 1sna1. An 'gsnt Of tho Chicago
Seemns.5n n:, g5s,sstsnsa 5sss
sn pneeS ia sh tttnh ha he took
Carried tho watch in ia overshlrt pon tnn ,no ose
% f1mS 4 ny oee for Compared ta coeS Il Sss
uEosa-o1am!ued 1tts my duty tn renort ,-.,a
arrive and depart. Tcesraphed tx az
departurs sent the dispatch ~ rna after tIs
looked tho clock .nd s
gsr came the puTposs Of earrSe Snqw hst ph1snte
Thnk ho came in 10 correct miataFg. has m watch.
sngns DOM Know tbs Color Csme ~ g, here on specia
ahirt. -uA'Aoefsafs ovor''
Tbs counsel for defense desired 10 r.c,, c,,,,.-
bpear ana Edward Boune Gy whom thaw soaa E1lleh
provo that Pufienbergcr, On the nollt IN mnea 70
not wear IN overshirl The nu1nes ~ ueat.nns s alo
procure them. ''o hof TO give counsel
hey uaabe Il ssepo tsa Tor deesnso stated that
were ready for The arguments, "'sAes'ss' ano they
.5t 70 "a eed waived tho first argument m
: .,,o.,. - -, a. CHARLES ". ooNsrAsr,yu
opened tho argument for the defen,oa. IN
uy opinions aa 10 1e 5aT md read tehe
easo; tho rat ho would ieaYe to hs mpon tts
t2aos GagSsh ns tnsn roseed resd sngsy % oa
Inv, and s Under tSis fSss law WI \. only
sSsa tSs3 nS. nS, IL IL a. ss
.ssey W. aa e4ssas
Hawas followed by +
Who said that It no small matter II, hin, - n,.
at hls persuasive ho 6erty Of tnas sn
but when Tic oost of human hssaon
YES at stale was qus different nattar 7hsa T.
I was for them to c.re,u1ly rel II" reas Tas, Pns ts
TSo!ps puneo TO- r. s opening
hoxn st R eHT 1opsh s human lo betngs" as
ecklessy, but ho himaof was at The oraa no;n sno
namely wSora everyone pe'as esespt
ss aeeeans esa 1R's1 u aa IN II s.s. 1t { s
49, al uAAok IAdCh tG4AluB toWafu ~
omMon aenAd are ]uau1able Inst as we'll THIS u.a
ne Of the other The public prosecutor ba ns
!ertaken 70 frame an Indictment whieh nr chn1nas
bat. ,, defendaht mn hia train into anotSSes
7illfuly. There waH not particfo NJ praof
show tnat defendant aillfu!y Committed s,,ch uct
low could defendant wilfully commit sacb sntY Ho
ould there be any guilt In that mans hsart9 TSfs
Il danger where tho chancea we're len 10 nne ri his
'etng killed himself None Of those on the enrfue viii
I'm ESCAPED and he only saved his life BY miracle.
10 was likely 70 bs ktlcd even IT none Of tha passen-
0f vi md IT.
sg smcs p0 mas no" sng by us side to dis;
toae whs could testify Ia liz nrisonora Hit M -
ense were either dead Insane, and the one witness,
Mas so.o 70 e1cnpate him from the Charge Of
royonted rom snoatne M OF ~ Hain-wAs
le st4tas Attornsy whom hranoht na'' unon rn1
H., ~ stand. A:r.. neaue, who could md
aaoS a toa aory waa prcvent
ra,9 ao'nR 90 ~ The States Attorney, as be
oad save lie foe eaq @ Eos 3. his onh has
NV ,,eat at ~ %n himself rods on tho engine
70 @ Eot =. create doubt in thcir mind.