The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1873-02-05

ley Alley got more shavings than anybody else.
MI. Schouller was then shown piece OF moulding
said that he had some Of that kind OF moulding In
ne upper part Of his shop, but had not used any Of
It for year.
THE WALNUT CHIPS.
Michel Schouller. son OF the last Witness testi
mostly used at his father's Establishment; Mr..
Alley used to take shavngs away IN barrels OF his
bedding: the rubbish IN the Shop sucn as was not
Mt for bedding, Mr.. Alley dumped occasionally
children TOOK away shavings, and on the Monday
saw Mr.. Alley In my shop Cd the Thursday after
election; ON wednesday saw him there In the
neghborhood Of eight o'clock, when witness gave
him directions to go down town and get tools for
one OF his workmen; ! did not know Mr.; Abijah
Alley took away on tuesday, whether It was three
or more or less. The witness was then shown the
which was s alluded TO- ana
the soth 81 August; these amounts were marked on
the outside Of the wrapper, 9. o. d. alter the pack
ages were opened the wrappers were thrown
among the shavings
didn't remember whether or not on the day OF
election he had promised to pay Mr.. Alley bill Of
a billiard table away; at Cambridge / saw some
pieces of wood, which said didn't come from my
place; also saw piece Of 2 pocket from billiard
table, which said couldn't have come from my
place for three months prior.
REDIRECT don't remember having any con-
versation about money with Alley on Tuesday,
election day, nor do think paid him any money
on Wednesday.
Mr. May then proposed to show to the Jury the
piece OF brown wrapping paper found among the
shavngs in of the barrels, ana also Mr.. ScnOul
ler's bills of $s1 each 1.-THE same as marked on the
brown paper(, bearing date OF August 80 and Octo-
Der Is respectively.
Mr. somerby objected to having bills shown the
with the Identification Of the shavings The Dis
trict Attorney abandoned his proposition to oner
the bills, and the brown paper was only submitted
TESTIMONY OF ALLEYS Transfer.
John Tebbetts was the next witness, testtfying as
follows:-Am twenty years old, and have lived IN
Boston since last June; came from Ohio, town ad-
l him since nee in '' boston; drove team he
had four horses; one was red, with black
and tall the he drove was sors an
had the horse disease; at that time the stable was
divided into stalls and grain and hay bins; witness
was produced, and pointed out different parts Of
III the barrels were exhibited; don't remember
that I ever saw these barrels before; they
Mr. scdonller's for shavngs on the evening
Of the election ,, day. took away three bar
the other a larger barrel took them away about
six O'Clock, and carried them to Alleys stable, on
would be made In billiard table work one OF the
barrels, the large one, was emptied under one
done a little after six the horses were fed and
the stable locked; he then went into the house;
WHO LOCKED THE DOORS;
there were five carriages belonging to Alley and
carriage belonging to Mr.. Kelley, in the stable;
washed and ate my supper; think Mr.. Alley went
out; at the table Curtis Alley said he had left out
a. h Mr. Ay s he
was then near eight O'Clock, think; didn't
see Mr.. Alley that night again went to the stable
about six O'Clock next morning; Mr.. Alley and q
Mr. Baker were there; Alley had hold of his black
horse at the door Of the stable; the horse was IN
nor very fat; Curtis Alley went with me;
Leavitt Alley fed the herses; usually they had
wagon Alley usually drove was there ana had two
barrels In 1t; they were partly covered up with O
horse blanket; they were lying lengthwise of the
light; was not there when Alley lett;
took a horse to get shod when re-
to the stand where Curtis Allen was; s soon alter
took load OF WOOD from Harrison avenue and
to Hyde Park didn't IN sight of the
place there was no team there in the stable there
was manure heap, quite large; the pile was about
two feet high; saw the boards near the manure
heap on Saturday morning after election
WITH BLOOD ON THEM;
these are the boards to the stall where nv horse
stood; the shavings were piled upon the manure
| heap; on Wednesday morning saw some blood
| the blood came from; he said it came som a horse
which ne had struck; his bosom was spat-
tered with blood bloc" tr saw no ,n Indications Of
| he didn't say which horse; made particular ex-
animation OF the horses; on Thursday evening the
was discussed by Alleys family; Alley said he had
better put down in writing where we were on
shavinss billiard pockets, barrels, &C., might
make 1t go hard with us (hOrse blanket shown;
TIE en the was used Ay TO
whether the manure heap was the same
Wednesday morning as on Tuesday night; worked
for Alley from the 7th OF August to the 9th Of
November; on the Saturday before election Curtis
Alley
ASKED HIS FATHER FOR MONEY
| for me; he replied that he couldn't let me have
any, as he had paid $50 on his house that day;
didn't succeed in getting any; the memorandum I
| made as to my whereabouts on Tuesday was given
to the Chief Of Police; there was a new light axe in
Mr.. Alleys stable; | call 1t red In color;
| day. AXE shown.) This is not the axe, out may
have seen this before; have not seen the red axe
ton it rained hard; one Of the teams went out at
about three P. M. but none before; don't know
| that Alley had any business with Ellis. except
| what l heard him say; he said he paid him
$50 on the house; had seen them together few
gether in the stable rear of Ristuns store; don't
know what they were talking about; they appeared
on E g?
| Ellis was walking and Alley and were team;
have seen Ellis at the stand when he had inquired
in them in the ends towards me; didn't see Alley
after left him Wednesday morning until the even
30 NEW AXE IN THE STABLE;
several days before. The further direct examine
| ton OF this witness was suspended until the
memorandum made by him could be found
Crosse xamined-Left the stable election night
about six O'Clock and went to the house about the
| time Alley went out went to bed; when got to
] the stable next morning l helped get out the
wagons, and then led lame horse to the black
smith shop half mile from the stable; can't tell
| how long time it took TO do all this: don't know
| what time Alley took his breakfast that morning;
can't fix the time arrived at the stand, but think
1t was about seven o'clock; Mr.. Alley Curtis and
had keys to the stable; Mr.. Kelley had key to the
stable some time before
Redirect-Heard nothing said in Allev's hearing
| in regard to liking the time Of his coming home on
election night.
AN IMPORTANT WITNESS.
Ellen Kelly testihed-Live in Spring Court, No.
6, close to Alleys stabe the house and stable are
| separated only by q small aeyway; remember
election day evening; went through the aeyway
to a store think 1t was about seven O'Clock; there
was noise and men talking In the stable
when was going out when returned heard
| man say Good d-n you - there was q light in