, 1873-05-26


/, 'kron.the &e.u York ,tForld, llqy %.
Tho 1sibutle printed yesterday, y long 1ettor
fron, It's correspondent in Iondon, Afr. snialley,
consisting. in the min, Of tho writor'a personal
recolootionB of tho illuatrons philosopher whose
death hal Just occurred at tito date Of the latter.
must be satisfactory t9 NJ hille Ameriea, nd; I'D;
snoii h'.' unntintod warmth u praise IN IN tIe
2 Tribune, whono 1ato otitor underratcd. Mr..
Mills abltioB and regarded him with
from Atr. Groo1ey's writings. We nro glnd to
meet 40 cordial q recognition tot Mr.. Mills su-
perority in that uuexpcctod quarter.
strangely miaroproaents AIr. Min TINT We viii
point out the error, III tho confident hope Tint
our contemporary wil rectify it. This expected
loyalty to truth is alike duo to itsof to its read-
priatng pasaage to which We rafor in Mr.. smnl-
ley's letter is the following: ~ ~>
which rsthor @ dTese, ] but made haste to ask lin
ID hs 'Poical Economy" which Proteettonis& wore M
Tho habit Of qnotng@ @ IL heir own 1e aee,e; ;to to the
dSssas SIT Ii. II hass
hHs nasd !? ts, bs av e
prtsss stats Of derelopnent. do 40. trsn say that
e sdae tas he auite beovea se lest of to rrotse-
tioniss hold thet doctrine as temporary ono which
h y 70 w
European manufactures.
Now, 1t is absolutely certain that h1r. Mill
mover used to Mr. Smalley, nor to anybody, tho
question Of veraclty; but assuming Mr. snatlay
to bs ingenious, ho most certainly labors untlor
singular hallucination. It ia wholly impossible
that Mr. Mills language ia correctly reported, Or
not rot haye so 6atly contradietod ii private con
yorBation with . stranger, who sought the inter
! view with = lettor OF Introduction, what he Ind
] said few months before In b very om-
phatlcc letter written for publication IL m
| ey is undor hallucination. aud the Tribune
cannot nfford to lot its correspondent naislead
| its readers on point having SO close Q bearipg
Journal has so long been the foremost champion
Of tho side which this groBs Misrepresentation la
calculated to strengthen.
Mr. smalley aiirms that Er. Mill made the
in tic summer Of 1866, Now, IT 50 l,apponed
that, about three months earlier. in tho Same
year 1885, Mr.. Mill oxplicitely authorized tho
representative Of another Amercan Journal
mike sasss opssss asssr'sp sf s,s % As 5 7sTs pts
his mouth BY Nj. smalley About the middle OF
March, 1866, tnerc appoared IN TnE cH1oAao
sst2ad e tgS % ws oaens ns 1tss
takua a great interest In the Free.Trade diacuG-
sion which has been startod in tho Northwest,
have had seDfrul conversations splh him tlig
subject during TIC last fortnight, and an permit
made Of his argument relative 10 The advantages
Of Protection IL a young community is in:
proper aud illogical. Ho will shortly deal
xith this point himself in You; :; columns, Jor h
tic cause 0f economic truth. Tint aasno wrong
to AIr. Mills reputation, that same afrront t.
truth, is now repeuted by tile Tribune in Il mucl
more Migrant md aggravated form, When ho nc
| itaaf tar f3.ntrn frfn n
new refutation. by him is not NODDED for tht
formor waB usl1erea forth but littlo time in ad
vance OF tho tlnte assigned to this apoarypha
and impossible conversation. Mr.. Mill promptl,
lettor, which appeared in The CNloAao TRIBUNE
! about three weeks after its date:
DLAcKnEArI PARE, Kent, Fob %, 1860.
you, dated Fob. il, asking me- 10 explain passase
my :" Principles Of Political Economy, In which ex
9e onoR ~ sh duty for e,
means Of nautazing branch Of industry III itsel
suited to the country, bns Which would be unable =
from the atatc. This pasaago you say has been uat
use Of by American proocttonists as The testimony .
s5ni!y 70 Aiasrsa s ths sensr.i prnsipa q Ffe
Trade.. This paaaago has been used for !,
sonaoasy Il my u opnion t earany %S
rlausibty than can be tbs in the United States
sa toas w0,s s
tho United 6tates Now England, and pennRylvnni
mapntactnses @ on large scaio and Viii tho benet Q
high protesting dutiG for it least two corporations
saetng u NV weh M ose o had bad ' se
esds s hers as Ssen = eMpe ,4a s.ossnso
} 70 compete il tha American market Viii those .
Great Britain does not ., arise merely from th
recent IT,. dae n Of thsr BY
~ be ompysa rh tsStIs srs.ter saafs aSS
duction Of osAcr nrttcles hara ucper for no'aen
recommended or coanst'aaneed any prottetiny duty
] Sry eaass ss Z ses Gssa asnn
tnt ef Protection. TA9r MoDxnATR TIME N TIL
. TON AND IRON OF AsIEnICA STILL NEED pHoTEoT1os
! AuA1NRr TAosE OF THE oGHEA HEM1spAEnE, IT Is L
NY Efks ooAptEIx PROOF THAT Tl.*x OUGHT NO:
! THE GREATER THE INJUSTICE AND THE WASTE OF TIL
{ | NATIONAL RESOURCES WILL DE.
Iconann myself, the present occasion, to tho
ensr Into The fall.cits Of professionalism generally
you y no eo%psnt e tnng @ a
= n sad i.onyya ~ my M M o. rs Economy
tho Iast published Vle Pseros, sditlon of .t Work
llavs directed the publisher to send Jou copy,
u the important journal With which you connecot
pleased to attaeh any n.y. value to my opinion on u
plctely stated, with additional replies to protecton!s
n p 49, t. ssa Of the reop s'Gn
Having malo 1t 80 oyilont that Mr.. Ssualloy'
letter is calculated to produce totally falBo i'm
: presaon III the interest Of tho American pyotee
!: tiontsts, no wait to see what amenas the Iri1
une's gense OF joarna1iatio honor will impol 1t t.
make in the premises. We leave tho modo an
, mcasusa Of reparation to its own manly instinct
+ without any suggeHtions, merely roseryiug ol
right to Judge, with other American aamyorB @
; Mr. Mill, OF tie inadeQuaoy OF the reotiacatio
= = | when made.
= ttA Spartan nIotAor.ss
) A letter in the Now York Herald. giving IN &C
count OF the recemt duel at Richmond, W., snys
Y at iB relatnl Of tho venerable mothor VI Nc
| 0artv fhnt s}lA Fr0m fha nrtt of In