The sun., 1873-10-29
THIRD TRIAL OF STOKES.
,to.TNG ARGUMENT ny DISTRICT
ATTORNEY PHELPS.

.NI
,.n Yesterday. after talking for nearly ten
.ur. several of the jurors were moved to
,..r-t, iI4 allusion to the sad midnight scene
vn,h ended the former trial. Tears. however,
a.. t,t sure indications that Juror il IN favor
- ,,alittal. for among those who wcpt when
,i prisoners life was at stake before were some
rbo strongly advocated verdict ~ murder In
.t, first degree. The twelve sovercgns, as Mr.
r-enain called them, listened with interest To
,.. address. and one, the second. nodded ap-
.r.yney The same Jiror nodded whenever
lie District Attorney made apoint.
Vr pl.it-'. argument, 50 far as delivered, has
,.,n an annals -is ~ tho prisoners statement and
u.te4tim1uy supporting It. His comments ON
Witnesses were sharp and often witty. Even
,re frdcc md the counsel for the prisoner
COULD mot refrain from smiling AZ the District
Auornry's remarks about Mrs. Barker, the aged
" sIcrNoman Who heard fisk threaten To- Kill
sps and heard the Nurse girls cOndVle Fisk
On the IHs- If "hls colossal beauty
w,s sroKr' irsririLp IN KILLING FISK?
Mr. Ticma.n said:
,.yrirytlaf.t. prisoner lnric'ci the w0u7d from
V.agc m ',,g, ,.i, Nai !"rr i'',ga ,g a. ~ 4 aea
-,sf. % f-1n fle g. h,.t tu f'' l,sc-t. TIE virst
vg .. 'h,, S' vi ". ,. Ef.i ga,iiet o G',.'-S
k.tt, .atlr.s.tr. tn' t''i ~ 4 Tag state coul
.,..f ... fl Ir lc fnlf tHc prsu. ti'- ttrtlut.iN
,.'i rl, t,c 81 ,'.ns was ih .clf dcfcnce. Tie
has. p. O .tfiI uc -1.c .ai i.cotri tlat Tie isci
- 'i l 1884," '9as tes 's.' '5SS. %'a ihs iary ay
VI. ,, ",i1 'p ,'.l %, &C. Bt.trici
tpwHNs %, VIZ nv 'iSS k1aM mai H9'siss f,ss
"l''' , n, ,na n,, S,r a tra..et 49,, 'i" Sis raa S
found 10 -,,ts b. 90 ''Yaris. lt lrrs"cution had
~ en.io 'i ,, t,. ~, M & ", sitre ,n,S oyrr ~"
!''iii.r ~ ih rio,c, aad c4ro. : dnaius the ,dy
.on N Of, ,,G t . c,r XIX i ,. 'c cne,ny nTl,
i..f ln, rir'. m rr cries. Mont frc," H. enemy
- 900 f.m. OH. lr..iftr fIA = ont ft. rlst5t
ri f-.. twice. Ih,l At darn. away, cral,d Ani be.
'''' ''' .-.
rur rHisoNrR'' STATEMENT.
,lrras. alr.il' or utira, IGc reR, aue,t,"n ,,'n
teinvi. h ii a dtrrerois man Mo w"uld tShs his
ife Tie, rrd beard The tc,tlwony II Commodore
1 ~ p',1 + .s a9s a. man ~ c""'aIni "a
srI '.., ...', Mons ,,,rc.Is : r, = ,serG
'.rd' ..as,. Il, .Sa.s y y MN Will ltsGsis. 80
,e o, ,ruasnrcE H. Ia ' ", y,t ~ "a ''v
cf0 N.u ent. llc sa- the luan Who mt gated me
a,t fb sgS rg uA'iI m No NJ na. ot ia h.
rc,., fa.s, rro ophctc word. MI iisI. thrre /. no
2 i'tF & Sasr.e @ to nay that na. he & a;@ sGmG sS
=, o., q, a,4 i'r iae slee4h ior r,hg9r or ay and
% rom @ pufot r pg-tp-. gT M Shr9 s TT9i -a re-
s, e. Or ,o en- Poy the Judicial achin'ry Of tlc
RISKS 1St1rrxcy.
r.y g-s irnuo'.a win the men ma, had more
l.-,' '.", u ~ Uon t'"t n.s eAistel IN th's " any
ttf vi h or Without pstol 20, ke's according io
, 81 S ,,5s. "ii',.hn al5 H,ti .H attended
p Ic awe carriage A. Il went in if roush tie
r. sr. If. GlGe' ,.,rc. ,qri % % ss 990g ,S 'n9.
'..'' u WIN filiei narot Nv ms sue ]. pstt
iaow hcni. Ihrk he ought to make hiu al al 0 og..
NJ content WIN r9llroad he rnns Inc q steam.
t"y 6v etsd V AZ s M nv % ih ne & VAN
t .1v comes @ m.1e % @ nun ,Itc ptttict Attor1ey
& a %, the Sss sss5 cg"a e. ara Tsld e @i SlT'oIh
Hrr I'VE. sccotdiaf % NE hgroism or, ,cownrii'" q
,tl, 6Sn eSi, 3 in our ci,S III dat man srouid
x1b he su et tHS o.. n a. & i'n' Wac fa4 a""y
Mt Mr Trcap asn Sst "a, canfaSt ea railroad
toais ana military BODY saa,d G ip,a. hi. at,caaa
ers b men 70 70 sh2w IN N n % ga-rn 10
rr'ane m nv rtencn & ne &chn.ey, 1n Interpreter to
-.,. Ihh OIL i.l.-, htflSEHi, l'',t.i
,lt - y .-,n nv ubirb hi. nome oW,.S ',4c iii
i .,1, ~, linn anI at stir he r@r''iti ,'G gtiy I,
tT}fns , ~ s3nis s fiiied , ry ogt
- t Pr. ,harc he mother any ,6n \" XIV \ i,. :.
. ... . "a 80 ,n,i or ~ - f, 49,. = 20. 80
. '"Sr,. @ -, u.,ii'' ~ 1a, No. ~ 'p'', p,,
-.r. r.. ciarei thai bsv,ng rnhhed hii,, oi
~ ''''''' "'-'u wipe MN IRON '1e lace VI 'Ne
ri.A,s '-0m college In Philadelphia 20 ihis
fr At a t t.i iNr city. , .sk ueht iis Hcqufint
'4rr it. , man N.n.eG v,. f. tr,.i,,''- f, ". .,
t-..ro. ttfo-'unrtcIy the ~aI.u., ~ Fisk s-.
srous and t, comm nee hat ~ ~, M OF p rsacu
d '' 20. nre hu' PARTIALLY revealed 10 ths case
.' r.' ,.-,N, uIL,,.Ii,r. .iN.' i's A.t te'A AZ
'N'' W '''"'"@' ''''
THE WITNESSES.
a.. r...~.t, -..,o,.., =, ,...t,,,,-,. -, a.. A..
Is ,'eTyp grri n. ,' Is'r ',sS,i,' 81 ~ Ni'
N ID 70 =. 'N'.'. i"' j" 'l' '..'tt.. .t
.. . - ~, ,n,.. 80, -, ',.t a" t.' ~ '''"
OF, - IN FisE Ana 4, ,,,',, ~ ~. .,r Ns Ss ,
M III anu , H. M ~ ~ Tx ~ ~ wa. =.
"a. ,,,.,an a.,s ~ u usl 80 H. hlN'
N"ie Ky net 81 r nlsUanu , Has flss'. tuphs .Li
. M 90 ,-on ~, ", p,, u., v'N, a.l i-
nr,t m a., ,t' 'U,Sst S ~ mo va ith
!. s ~ u, P.@cN' ~ oi -, NJ ~, st,,
H.. ~ IT, ~ ~ unVS hilu NAs stut pY nun t9 pr
.....- . -, a.u 81, " " r.tI' ".-
' "a by ~ 1V.u % M@.vre @ si' 'imoh!
- = ,i9nor1tt1 , oy .hst OF lr,ls, ana q. n
900 prose. ut nrst trial, but had strangely ds
3D. az. !' 49,. 49,. 49,, ~ ,,-.
.'" L'f' ~ lnt CLOAK. Ihe or ner found bnt
''' is y. ~ ~. NoN mere were tlsnt; IN ehnl. lloh
Nhtu silch wa poNel throuEn the hoIer
, \, u, w cuLl -'.i- st ~ poo 70 q fINn
g. e....-- 80 10 ou nr sand anu 80 10 eue,srg.
100 '.' lurlhtss ~ theoriHin- - a. too que anu
.'4' 10 Oe made tnr 10 oi conelu ron 10
VI yer "'o IN. ne OF hu.r ~ be ng. Mt. IRE
ie-t t. '.I pr1 s,s' heunohn was 10, owing tl.k'
f.r 'u d. aulr' re auutI nave o. shel thls
..t.,. ~. .,' suumtt ~. W Ile e r'Ah4H
t.. ~ ,%"t w l'"s"i Nop a. a oi u, slAtc, thnt ne
1.t D., o.. r .iaei suouu NV nu' W. ~ r. !eoleq hhl
' W s.ltr : " pistli IrhN d on nuu ana '-A
Al ,. ,isl Nv l'."hr "hr NV unliF,N - r', ip ih'-
''l '"''e Was biVuaV4ii'5 3l A4H Dihs -lNt
-
INsANITT.
tf.t.|.. ,.,... o., La, o. ,'i'',, -, -
l-,.i , .t, ~ " ~ ~ '".',n ,ita' . .'''l g wa u
u" .'" the pIl7on't n'pl II" t'"~ 10
.'t' l'tt h" saw pistol, he was Insane. d.
i D. Do 'lAlt lstf If o.