The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1872-01-19

bs, certainly Is not CONSTITUTIONAL or wise NODE OF ap
s he had oseS S1%es as S. s the
Turning from the rues to the report Of the Commission HI
public servants Ehl Ss Or ssSa
government bot i had been rejected
Be made paepsnaen oi the popular win because qaes
TO ie %s
n .ha 1ses OF the army and navy should hay
ssssa!sa y sa Their q seist ss
intelligent man could %as.s
public servcs no law could prsscrS,
Se hsse S and EYE s
me report was that party the bane Of this government
LABOR FOR THE spoorss OF A PARTY
oash to disqualy for public once ln AZ free conn
ss aas ya
aseo ns w s s service REFORM n
sS:S!, h ~ aesss:.IsS p
hs Ss Sss K. mr.
that present sv.em the appointing power Sp \
Sep tsta and The ss.s
malignant lDs! The Isad,ns members republican
dcsnaes a apoa,m ns%
s SSoa hs aea s' Of ss
and @ mad @ so
relations q the applicants they high shampions
sss e
.% I.
SsoHsss
- Ssrs position
fore an s1amnmg hoard Of turn of mind should
copy papers great speed and accuracy know no
81 ss % sp
mean never expect to know chemistry l do expect
ad's eG
nye examination" (Langhter In conclusion Mr. Carpenter
81 not tn
be adopted 2. this time Al the brsakn:
less PATRIOTS sent theirs school and now this system
cssss public once ' .Ssy
near the moon come: TO the the
Mr. fEuMBULL wished to say few words on this SUBJECT
witch SS 4. se% ss from s.sss:
nsa ss nS
Mr. CAErEsrEE denied having SAID tnai the
n & b: s1 80 as % THAI s Ne
"n sS ms1 0s "a In ether TSr the
hope hope that hat the ciS sel,o. re-
TO Ss S a.
certainly Understood them to be devoted almost entirely to
ana are 70 Pc shsnssd :h. ste %s attempting
i st being
=, ~. ,oS 0sslog Ts or 1Is .SrIn. srvtNuS
from Wisconsin takea position against parcu-
S but p 1 The h. Of s n tina:
pared and conserste friends Of the sdminrs-
entire than ninety dollars i ~a ss
nes Of wa'A the
" sTIsnMAM' trep Of ohionWhat document is that?
Civil Service Commission. y ''''
MT. TnuxBull.-well we viii see what they say. am
aior from wisconsin. who had the part The opinion
Of the A S m upon another question
concluaon which condemns the whole of H. Nj. Trumbul
81" to complete in figures the exact economical
aaa oin . OF he s
pari:on oe,w cen the probable operation OF careless and
z sSss rS1 haze he
on h Ha' OF the
which is fatally unsound reasonably held response
ss Of IF. wish to =. The
reysnge internal and ss.erns les. Than
h ne nom ramr OHIO % biz
1t Be WIN sna how WI ss
only yen .,e nj TO ns' So" but
Senate IN lew days, and which
WILL ENTIRELY CURE TIE ABUSES
TIT MBuLL-I shall be very happy to concur with the
sss h Sic h s eS al
high eulosum upon the character OF the President
same rSsss1s had S Ss
& ing them oHa the that
Of United states than 10 SCI tina, hat
e ADEPT be- ssss ,ps s res
Mr. rsUsSU here contTo1ers% s Mr. Garpen,er views
As TO the extent and importance of the Presidents powers
pointing power belonged to The Executive and great evil
eminent had gradually u.ped the power assumed to
aoT and the dm Of sy
s g. o% sss Does The
and the law vest the appointing the Executive
m the nsss Sr Ae sn that
kspresentativ's ~ o9pgressy
illinois, INT as to that of the patronage Wisconsin, Of
which have any knowledge answer that not know
Mr TnuxSGLI.wel. cannot speak as to the rule in
tee and The President endorses this report and sends
our public oer. il arises from the o Dsnp OF
coSrEoLLED ny ooNenEssaES,
tina; sy Th; report he work Of gentlemen high
inquired under the present system
and have SET them forth here with
eompc'ivs examination =. system let Ms apply other
comes us eaorssd BY he s0''''o ms report
hat M eoa nS ns 81 Mr.
for all the statements of the report as In hts
Congress the recess and ,ha, he had
sspS 20 ssH me fs % pres
ent advised fayoraos to ,ome civil service reform
dent az not resa 5Ss report he
MI: IIrNnulL-To examine q. for what purpose' To
Jersey Mr Frenghusenl impute 70 the President ny
az SEM US important
port without having read without knowing what state
ments were In M The idea 10 me IL lnconceivabe'
Mr.. FRELINGHuysKH-I pould not mpute Presl
dent any ignorance neither would mpute 10 the
IlnOis purpose Ia make the President appear
different light before the people than that 10 which
puis himself
Mr.. TRUMnuLIwcl, let see what the President does
lie says, -" have not had time examine the
PAVING report sufficiently 10 suggest definite legislative
aeon the support which be
s,pessg a policy sy neeae H.
saws that he had examine
ne able TO ct definite legislation but, OF
e iea II " ne could not have said that embodied
policy long needed. lie had read understood H.
anu the report here endorsed ssentlal facts
50 ar as hcy relate 10 the OF appointments by
the iresitn himself, who has for neaTy
20 POSITION non. " KNOW what the present system H. Even the
'hr from Wisconsin himself endorsed the statements Of
hs report wien lie said that persons high in the iegsa
tive departments NJ tho government had
INbuJTEn THHF .rrs M rur
M ,h NC ~ make certain appointments dictated