New-York tribune., 1872-07-03
THE JUDICIAL dALS'

JUDGE M'CUNN REMOVED uNAnimooo
VOTE--5UDGE PRINDLE'S ~ 'oN
ALBANY, July 2.-The See met at IVA n7
20 Senators being present S'o' D' = "oOe -
toned the propriety of going o''n 'no oase y.
McCunn until all the SenatorsIe present. ou' 80
decided to proceed, and the col lor 'no
there being no one present foIo icS n'en'
formed that II they desired toheaIu 'He' no" A"' -"
opportunity.
MI parsons NJ corrse, ,o,e prosecution, then iun-
mod nm After nottn ~, e distinction in this 'ase,
as compared with the othere citieseu lno "o'' "
Judge ncCunn's counsel in'ins uic uiai a" J."'nn
issue, claimed that the te'ony was oNe'"H'i'n"S :"
nroof of tho chore ,odol then briefly reviewed the
testimony introduced.
inst hefore the copcl,,s OF Mr.. Parsonss summing
up, Col Davis of responFs counsel appeared in the
Chamber. and had n cdtation with Judge Van Cdtt
Of ,ounseI for e roseon but took actiy, part In
tbe nroceedinos Tho iate then went into private
oopsultotior o,d n, rening the doors the Cerk was
directed IN road tbe cles. On charge rsr concern
ing the Ipdge,s action he ease Of Clark agt. Bnnger,
the President put tbueston' ~ loIo"N :" '
senator, as his name 'caiieu'
Senator, how say Is t" hrSt lteih OF Ohc onahbo
preferred against tic e'ueed prONehF
The following serrs, in turn, each rose and re
sponded, Proven:
Adams Allen. Baker slc; Toven ChaSei, cok Dehin.oP,
den Murphy Pa ner Robertson, Tmann Wager, Wesmann
" sow D. P. Wed .oes' Woodih
Senator Lord aI TO be excused, as be bad had no
opportunity to hche testimony or read It, ana there
fore could not vo,nderstanGingly. Tn" question was
put to the senate1d he was excused. Senator's Ames
O'Bren, and Tti are absent and Harden6ergh Is
dead
Tie arestion vtben taken on Che second chatge the
case OF Cary Love- and stood the same rs before
Mr.. Murphy anGing substantially proven"
The vote on third charge, Elliott agt Butler
stood the same no preceding, Murphy again voting
substantially ven" He said ne made this qutifca-
ton because bs not satifeG regarding the point OF
conspiracy.
TIE vote On Fourth charge, Brandon agt. Buck,
Duncan, shern and others, and on the NTH charge
OMahoney as August Belmont and Others. stood
the same as tbreccdinS.
The vote on sixth charge accusing McCunn Of issn-
inc order orrest when the plaintiff had no cause OF
action and fix the bail at an excessive and exorbitant
amount, stood toiiows:
Not Igore-As Allen, Baker Bovu, Chst6eh Cock DeAin-
SON. Pc Ter Gran HafrJaT LtV LoWcy, Mc6ovan, ha !.
Pa.ne Peyrr Bcisc-, Wagner ~esmatu nsow D. p "ooi'
frore-Besea Johason Nsdlea t,u5saa,iaiyl, Temsnul
The vote one seventh charge, Van Ness agt. Leeds
and Others. std q proven" 40 Uefore.
On the eighthargc-that the defendant had by hls
action brouelaho administration Of justice into con-
tempt, and cacd deCp-scatcd and general distrnst
and fear in reIi proceedings in the courts OF the
state-Messrs esedict, Bower, and Palmer voted mot
proven !" Me's. Murphy p rrV, and ]. Wood voted
acknowledgement" ID. p. wood essentially prov
en-" and the rtsiEder OF the vote was proven"
The vote wasien taken by Yeas and Nays on the re-
moval OF gud McCunn from office, and wac unani
mously carried sac affirmative, az folows
YessAdars. ~ 'ter ncdis', ogrn, Chatfeu Coo Dcln
FOlc (rahs nsswer. yoilsaa LSi' Lofd Lovsrr Ae
ssesmaua D =. wi, j. moOi' AMI Wooin--A
JUDGE PRINDLE's CASE.
The Seuafe th resumed the consideration % the case
4 Judge Pnndl
Frederick p. oates was recalled and detailed the
oarges i1aposehpon lim ia proving viii by judge
hindle.
Esther Russell a. similar testimony the charges
imposed in prove another VIII She also testified Il
selling 'Hl $50 in United States bonds he pay
I'M her 40 prrnm though there Was praminm OF
Than at tie time.
The Senate iheililT recess until pam.
When The benaeeassembled Mrs. Russell concluded
heI ,estiuE M cling bonds t. PTlndle he failing
10 pay her the pfiium ON them. She testified that
when she dseovsctthat she hadiaas d. foolish bar
gain she so ahand of 10 that she did not want Z
say anyhng abot y any one, an6 did not do foi
two year..
Albert c. Laihan oV.ectcd with tie bank in whic.
the bonds dcpsite terrified ~ 70 the transfer
them TO Prindle 10 his ,Ine. and Lssir continued de
post there IN hs LIME Lev ious To tGrusieT, PrDdl,
came 10 Use ithI alu caring th1t tho o0ud7 were
there, be asked fni lnue iiey were gGth he was tOlC
that they were woa that ~ los or 1ci tie bonds re
NAMED in fhe bankO PrG 's credit RON December
1868. to NGyembor' C9i hahen withdrew them.
Warren Ne won Osiut The banE.tsstthed that he
had sold tbc hOBdg JrHiIook: they yrcre dcpoSitrt
in the bank until tra'lerrcto Judge Frndle Prndl,
came 10 the,hauk .tf aEscowlat tncy ,,ere WORTH
,0id him ny huylLg rice wa 81 O, tSoyEcre worth IL
ts4 ed IN ret "a
par aud that prrf ah1N MS fignres. tncse bonds
were worth & IL n Icw moths; after tbc transfer,
heard Judge Iina.rlake xpauatiGu Of the fransac
ton, ia whien he 'l that h6Jncht the bonds Or Ira
DiLbe, upon who's" ropGtY V pHndie, held mort
gage; hc soil DiJe had plmised Ia pay la Govern
noni bonds, 30 lie h-n tLel from MIS-. ideok at pal
GOr Dibbc TO use 20 ~ him
In crosse xaUhnntr the w'tnss said he had taken an
actiSe part IA ofospn to TIE IclocfIon 81 Judge Pm
de his feelings gso now, MT very friendly Em; Eo
bad secured three afayits agdist him rever had said
anything harsh ana him Wliih was not true; had
D,Ver said If lac (wiessJ WAS appointed Commits
si0ner by him he Vcd never b, County JuGGe again
w ness was asKed h long the Unpleasant feeling, be
tvs en- Judge Printliud himself mad existedq aud he
could not say exIctlowlOng; IN feeling did not grow
out OF any private tnsscilOn; ht had considered MN
unit ior county JgG ana hene was uEIrendly u
him.
Geo. 6. Mason. wfwas clers in the New York and
MGltnd Railroad Or al Norwich 1853, test lied that
Prinole came theTehd exchanged some Government
bonds, in NOyemb, 1869, for MIlland bonds. The
premium, he thOUe, amounted 10 Tor lS per cent.
Austin BaIrONs ttih6d that judge PriBdle procured
suffered himself be employed as attorney 60 bring
iit IN the snprenCourt 30 procure an order 10 the
Sar Of real estatep pay leRaces Bemeathfd by Anna
Barrow aud proceed his clerk, Geo W Ray TO act As
attorney for the dcndant IN the case.
COuIss' for the psecuiiOn prOpoUBied q question 90
the witness cOnCrinR another A. which fhe Latter
was executor via was objected 10 y counsel f0s re-
spOudent as II winOt contained in tn charges.
The SclHtc WenntO private consultation ON he OBJ
lection AID. q TeOpcning Of the llOrs IL was an-
nOunced tl,at ticDieCfiOn sustained
james g. Thomson, County Jerk Of ClenangO CouD.
". was clEmine 10 identity orders issued by Judge
Prind!e an0 oth'papers signed by the latter ana Geo.
w. Ray, Pfindc clerk as attorneys for plaintiffs and
defendants. Fcsptiyey.
The Senate Ehradjuuped until .. n 70 morrow.