The Petroleum Centre daily record. [volume] (Petroleum Center, Pa.) 1868-1873, 1872-01-08
iOPlNlUN Ok:JUDGE GRlER

As write with ditl'culiy car only .,,, III. =.
clurions 10 which my niihu las come ai,rr ,',
examination ui this case.
ihc o"ul iuiuthi las exhibited y patprt A,
18th OF April 1870. Tins /. PR tin lacir .,J.,
Il gu"i tit.c, uni puts on the g,.p. nivut. ILa M
ncn oi pro"i that the patent Is VOID " WORLDS.
hteu hut rel" u ;hA ,eniaIks III ia. ca., a.
YEAR ". Da, " Wall, Z. L. kep; 80, BAT ~
'I,pi them a- a'iurInA arueu, uevlsluhvI Nh.
ptI.' Cie. |! To the PRESENT case.
A, tile infringement Ut the pal, nj 4, umh,.
tho ON, question will b- as to thr ,aliolh nj ~ Y
piNll"ii ta,cn, oi Apiii 2l,lsjs.
~ wos Ml,r -,Nculnti II had been td,a
p:Ielice anu HtrI icp,aed cxperim,lt. ll,i n.
,u.upaihnn suCCcod, ia over c,ni 9 Nh, u,i1 A..
"nd ig"o apee tf leuple uu The sub,t M
ter u al III, lslI 'hc TIA his ltru uuuf
ai' rsic iaa c-t'b' sheu its yret u,idty aua ,.,,
an, when : SvHii- .ud p tici.t pv.>r,,ruo 0. nj
l'.pu -tec!. ~ scoa-, We're onipl vi, ~
GO "a, ilat IL "a, wiIu had bttOie Ia d. ,ir
Iut nt- uu Nr 'HiiI sub, Ct anu was ul.uec ,,v
AID a. rr iuu ha,iLL me IT nor. &, M ,inaui n /,
| ic-ue- hv nppi d on l. elsi Of Nov,L ber Nj
ivr alnic IT,, aub,tU, TALLY tie .am, ou,M !,
'ns ui devices aud hlaciin. con ain.d in cmblsI
ants /. t'n, On he L1tn the sal. u,ont N.
ie uLd,lts fHni, d then>e YES ipio cuuuau, 4,
c ,iat.un oau,d IN ICED ior. ed mon
he iulo-o' p1ating he con pu iu.il,
y,hnon' a. d u ioith & TIE eApe see 0i Ii, gA,v.
,,ila "a. GGII. I'D h,tu VI tie f. uis They u.,s a,
u
irnp, .ly riaIit'u hy Il, i-iivi jude
Let l. Dc gree b. ,n.,i 4 H. cvuiI ism II t M
pViGa ihiunui'; AID MASTER pp me title
All acS'n u a''.'uii.! 90 III. payer vltdr bill
Il. Z. GiuEl. Jaln
NoTx -Ihr pssssse referred to bv Judge lrr d
hl> iurIneI CIV IN, u Wallace, " ~ Adoplec 10
app icatI. 10 ihi- ease Was us iu,iuw.
III l. u'u.ill the c'rt. 1h.u my valuable dha,.
ClN - gur, ul any II'" xc iue uf n, Ut ui It's ID
| NV nttd. Lat tca tvniion Of the public lEs NJ
ur q IL That subIest previously, uhG that nI5
1'r-un- have he n making r,praiele. abd tlth
.LruI- Il i"-pp Z, ana hi.chauiclans niay ltt
',s',ae lat s-ur, algJcils,,d IN lisir sp Gu utupr
-" ppssiOi H. or PROBABILITY Vi suth di,enai a|
E.,utioA; many experiments lave bsvI siCCr'.is.
, u,d cuiuiIY vcs! Lear. YET failing .h,rl d a'l
'circd result They have produced uoll rg bat
lie ~ IN, iuNci.liuh Hhe. perfected ma! lTuy I
Aid 10 he the Gu u'minsiny p'iut oi n'anv era 1
n'cn =, net on b! tn. inventor. tn BY man! v'r|
ur-, may hry, jT,iited irti4rtcil) by The usA
re.-iu experiments and failures of f,ibtr'. bs VI
-nNc- them no IlEit to ca N n shatp ihe h,pu
O. q ,,roiii oi the -a' cc-sfil inventor Il Il Nhu|
-pc, alton has heru reduced Ia practice vist d.
| p-tiiucnI III resulted III III i.co,-ry ail pbh US
discovery ha- b- =, RI, G,cd ny piiisn AID 'vs'a
Ued cxp-r m,.fts When srhie lie" ooEiiOdiG
'u,nulictnlr or inHrinlc ha- hesn hn' neft,
Ahch 10 uscful to t,e public, thr' thr pan! hap..
Dei Umer npubic b, II factor and ,ntt.rI mh tsH'
"an6 yet ~len .rniu- and patti Ut pr'es'.iI.
iavc ut length sucr, eicd, in s,ie Vi '''t'' sls
COTS. snMev luabl, iLNcltnnur GiT0e e!, ryN
seldom l. IL followed hi reward /! Envy i'b' n,A
Of the honor. hnv s,,eCuaOrs, sw Lie ala Il
-aI-s rob him oi the p'ui.t-. Ever! un,IoeA.
exI,crim nier who did Ur did or diG iat cone w!
| near making II discovery now claims Il. hH;u
WIN can nv.nt An inpr velneut or vary !" W..
Claims right To iIa,r the Origii nj hiscAni.
u I'd not -umiAoIa U'-e Or Rlihchnd ~ wv"
worth to prove NJ ti l. the usual hi,tol! Of 's
~ yr.at uiacUvrry of invention. ..l
''lhc present c'ste aGdS smother chap'e, Y !. i.
long ana uniform history" ailacss|
polls y. ~ e'-~. r'5.s.., -