New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1872-10-29
CARNEY CONSTRAINED.

Mr.. Pcckham asked MIR. Garvey if he hac
cooked for Mayor Halls letter to him, concerning which
,e testified on Friday He replied that he had looked il
every place it where he thought would be Rey 70
be- but had been unsuccessful He was asked What the
contents OF were and swOre That 1t read; u accept
the hint will be less OF loA' anu ooA 'io "Oio w
the grapes"
Cross-cxamined by Mr.. BucRley-Q When did you first
besin work for the cityl A. over lOyears ago.
O. During shat period you constantly employed
10 an descriptions of city wOIki A. Yes
O. Was there final settlement or liquidation OF your
accounts with the city, A. No. SIR
O. Then IN the Fall of 1871 your accounts with the CITY,
covering that period, unquidated and unsettled
A. There was no final settlement
O. At the beginning off your cross examination you
made use OF an expression would Ike to call your at
tepton TO- the Mayor asking substantially whether or
not in any conversation lie might ever have had'wlth
Won Won did not always assert to him that your Dis
st he civ had been legal and proper. understood
u ~ say in answer 10 that question that you uu 80
claim Am right A. what did say Is ~ Is P nT'
there was another gentleman present. $1,000 a., :,
any conversation when there no one present you
ever told him that your bills were inSoaIeet or
of thar kind; may have but cannot remember
EANDOM FIRING IN ALL DIRECTIONS
n Won are under oath. / want you now to charge
your memory with it, You have spoken OF the contents
Of notes received from the Mayor; now charge your
ls,
recall one conversation but whether u pears upon thaV
poipt or not YOU can tell best yourself. .,s.,
% I mean any conversation IN which you told the
MAYOR your claims unjust fictitious or irauduiehti
A I doi,'t remember, Sir. .
o You remember there was partition IN the Tontroi
lers office Was not that put up Wheh the puliuns was
D' %. Are ~ YOU surel A Yes, Sir a..
q Was Ia not put up when the apartments were nrst
ocsupiedi A. After frescoed the rooms. 1t was sup
posed TO be part Of the furniture ,.s A.. r,o,a.
en mat partition was put up part OF the arrange
ments for his Oeeupationf A presume 80; uoh Z
q. Tei the jury when that was A. ] think It was
put into the Finance Department early inlS69: -,
O. You testified TO going over 70 the Broadway Bank
occasionally with Mr. woodward and certain checks Of
WoOdwaros being there that WoOd%ards tdy fi Tn
You got into the coupe A. said supposed lie was
o. lie came over in coupe accompanied by youi A.
Yes. Sir. -
was no one present 10 receive it, was Watsons desk
O. And the individual TO whom it was given was
always WatsOni A. That presume to be the case.
o. Don't YOU know it1 A. think 80.
q Did Won ever give it 10 anybody else3 A. never
gave It TO Watson at all gave it twice to Woodward
o. One of the Jurors asked yOu particularly when you
used the expression the rest Of Them whether you
meant 10 include the Mayor A. o0ht kho" lhat
@ Then you don't mean to include him A. No, Sir.
DIALOGUE IN THE COURTHOUSE.
O. Your conversations with the Mayor are matters Of
O. At the time they occurred you were very much
occupied A. ! was always busy those times.
@ And since they occurred very many circumstances
have combined 20 occupy your mind A. Yes Sir; /
have thought Of much else during the last two years
q. What did have the conversation
with the Mayor ia the vesbule of the COnrthOusei A
Probably the middle fore part OF August II was near
the front Yestibule in the rotunda.
q. on this GOOrf A. Yes, SIR.
Q. What errand brought you there that dayf A. I
can't remember.
O. Did you come suddenly across the Mayori A.
don't remember; cannot tell whether he going out
or coming in; met him.
o. was this question you asked him question OF
enSugb importance to induce you 10 seek him outs A
No; met MIN casually
M TIen OF course. this was mere casual remark A.
Yon may consider IL so II you choose; seldom hun
and thai day when met him, thought would speak
20 him. .--.--. - 49,, u :.
place he had come A. He may nave been coming into
HE building going out.
the Mayor-a couple OF mnutesf A. No, Sir; probably
10 n was mere passing remsrki A. You may con-
slider IL 4 you choose. . , go
o. Was Il after before the conyersatOnf A. After
the conversation az bs dwelhng 70 WHICH tesl-
FED in my direct examination. 10 =,
O. When did you have consultation aJ lLe mayors
object A. In August, lSV9