The Petroleum Centre daily record. [volume] (Petroleum Center, Pa.) 1868-1873, 1872-01-03
iOPlNIOst of:JUDGI GRlEn nr

As wlitc with iinicuty can only state the con
clu iions 10 which my mind has after cartfu
cAam,n1t'on OF this Ease.
lhr con, .lainani has exhibited n patent dated
t5tl oi April 1855 This IL pr MA iace evidence VI
a good t,tlc. anG prta ou the respondents the bur
de-, Of ro'f that .hc patent is void or worthless
necd not repea my remarks in the case Of Good.
year v-. Ia, q v all, {. c. Req; .>9,) but now
lhop, tAe,I IL AZ, ntins arue oi decision Which ap-
y lc' ciea,ly 10 ia u . esent case. 5
A. lli> Infringe n,ent Ot the patent 10 sdmted.
thu oul, QUEST will be to the validity OF CON
piail.iis patent Oi Apri, -, lsbS. 4
Il Wis after sp,culaii Il had been reduced 10
prrIicr and I'.r repeated experiments. That th-
,vinp.sinan, .ut reed III over conf tie prejudice
and iguo ance II Il people OH the subject an!
-. u..ciI Z tn, IIupctna his iIyrntrn Was ustfl
a., he ha,i t. tatished lis gre utility anu yalns
anu wh,i, his sriiUs aud p tIcIt perseverance, IN
sp;;t u ,iierts W.. SCOTS, wer. onp tely sue
s. sui that g, who had before IN d. expen-
mrLtS oil he. fmc subject and Was un.uec tsiu,
sLu after hur,l i1.ing unc - more q mplaIauts to,
be .Ue-, he fDb,I On t.el III of November, 1867,
ior u pa,e fl Substantially the ssme couibna'
ons Uf deric, IAnu n.achine con aimed In complain
ants pat.nl; Op The 18th II the san.e monlh The
ie. pvndchts T. lined then> ives into COMPANY .,
cor ,ration sii,d ''1he ue,d Tor, edo C0mpar,,
tie purp' 80 "f iat,Ls the con plinanl in
vsn'ion ard ,ul loriug the expe see OF litiga'ion'
aud tnus dcir sud him oi the fuiis They have per;
5, we'd eve 'fer III. prei.msly injuueti- u very
iroptiiy g'at I'D hy Il, Is rict Judge:
lie, Ge.r - BE enier'd for CONF ains for per-
petua iIjuu zion; and Master, npp.inte to take
IA ac,"4nta ".iding 10 The payer Of the bill. -
L. c. GklEk, JuSss'
NorE--T he passage referred to by Judge Gner u
his former ir,i- on, Nasce, p. 2s9 adopted "
a. icab'e 4 this case was rs follows:
81, is u iiy the cusc, v hen any valusble dse'v
IL Uad' ), or any new niacnlus OF great utility 10
luv,nted. I.a, ieattn,ion of the public has bsta
iurucd To Lat subject previously, ana thxt mary
person. ~ I've hetn making researches ana expeii
meuts hlusopArs ana meCAaniciaus may nave
some N . asurr artcipatod in their spesuauons
-t pIss' ity or PROBABILITY Of such discovery o'
nseI ,lom many experiments Lave beeu slccessnt
/, 50 uu In very near. yet failing short oi ne
DEL cd ,.ult. They have produced nothing Dene
hc A. , D. inveniiuH vile. perfected MAY uu! =
s.', to + HE Gu uiGa'ing point of many expe,,'
men =, l ony BY the invfutor. hut BY many on'
or-. i' ,4na, hay. prnited ndrcc ly BY the ln.ae
ec@-u' r.p,lAeuts ana failures Of thtr., ou1 =;
g.yc H. , j right tu cam share ottle b no, y.
r ..ol OF the successful inventor il Is WEE
s1r u.t ion has been reduced ~ practice, Wien e..
dis eoi" ry ha been perfected y patient ana e9s
Iel oNl "rlinen's wien some. new COMPOUND, ".
mauu'r ciue or A.ac"ine has been ibu- proaaes,,,
Winch 8, Useful to thepublc, :hat the party mskink
be- ON 90 apubic be nefiy tor and 10 pssn,
Am yet when venius AID patit1, pesSvs'A.I'as, .'s
have length suCceCdrC, in spite OF sntsit ~. -
coils. ,s,me iIatl. invention or clsco"ef!, " "
sr'doI IL II followed b. Ieward Envy Ioos NJ, u;
Of the honor, hiis specalaior3, swindeIs, snu k
rat-s NIB him OF tne = Ats. Every unspeee,s Wv,
eJ pei iai nisr who dia on did or did not come va!
n'if s,nking discovery now claims 1t. tvH! ,,m. %
W 10 fi,n invent an improvement or vary ls w" W.
G. II, ~ right 10 iraIe the o'1gi al Cisep'a!u Nd
! n a. not sumpons dorse, OF Blauchards or w. ~.
~ 1rtal discovery or invention r. 4, ,,.
| "'Che present csse ADDS another cbapie. " H.
long and uniform history y: " sllacsi v ~
ports p 2s2