The morning star and Catholic messenger. [volume] (New Orleans [La.]) 1868-1881, 1872-08-04

n. !s;; .. :ss ~ sT1rs mTAIis]...1. y,
~. .n i, T. the s. polite proposition Of y
,us a. H tsmporsry to, take up at this time =
:ho ouestion Of the superiority OF Cno ts,s
hc,ty g the ReT ma G sSsS sia 0 nes
btsoe th" opportunity aAfpsAed by our E @s .
piy to them not very long ago: ! Ana ~c
bat We are growing interested 10 the qIWS1 W.
ton now in hand, Papsl s.te .,,n nrssent fix
prefer that they shou.a tei /. ~ nrexsented on
The main question. It would nave 0o~,i3
indeed. gratifying, for instance, II they SvS
Rave. stSstohsA their courtesy tas e. .ssss. 7.
to have made .sOune aneweE N W s and
~, sa9 ths Bi,hops who seeded from the xana +
can Eonncii. relative to the fslaeeooosusC. +
IN .snurSff Of the dogma BY IL defenng..
E0 Our Contemporary .a.ks Wy, cOn psossst
tie 5di66rence Of opinion 9etwe ee.,rat.tion
auts and Rounanists on snS me-. 70 accept
kfths es timouy Of che Fathess In fa'os Vi
i,papal infallibility = 4'-' ''''"
| f.Thsy gropossaato prove papal ini AM
biiity fro@ scriPsurss 400 0Ss 1o" '''''o
a .aThs rsfusasasn of their asg1msnt
| from Scrfutnro has got sboen quoeed ~ W
FROM Protestant, but from Roman Cat0E..o
writers, and cannot be imPugned - p1e!u 's
's s. undoubted. lnes tie !ishest snt t ri.
:" tie: in their own Church, declare that inc
s.riv vriters ON tho Christian Church 40
:. not advocate ,paRal iafallibilitX. Pa so sne
AnS thf st,s sas used uS ~ tie "a
SEes OF papal infalhbility, are spurious ~
~3aorreries anS -frauds; a1aa shss: nc
Ssnsn Catholic. teacher; can claim tna,
&c thcse writer's maintain this dogma "''no~
peEjuring himself. ,a ,;.. q. Ino~
what reply our contemporary mas 20 "sA'
to these grave charges. ...+s
ar But as our contemporary insists that tn
~ quotations they have pa6iished are i lact
q; q! and not foEgsriss, Ms AZ - NO" s''' s'
id i. They tell 10 that 81. Augustine mad
be use of tho expression Roma iocuta, caus
til We demand that they point ont in wis
TO- part OF his writings that SAYING S0o tsng,
h. that Rome was the source Of authority
Ao matters Of religion.
cy- .1srtallsan,-He speaks Of Rome as the Caur
~ " whence authority emanates," ana 90 o.
. Pope Is Sovereing Pontih.-s""e"a' '"'''~,
VI We demand that the whole passage
J. produced.
our 3. They tell us that 0rigen dsesar
Peter ma exclusively the living rock !
Il" which tho Church was built. !
nen Orioen.-He says Gan $3.50: Considsr w
? Of must be the power and authority q Feser.
=: I;rino rock upon which the Church was 20
thnf her decision should be s. unaiteraoie
AVE though God had spoken through nef.
wedemand that the passage be produc
q l.. They tell MS that 1renaeus SAID
n, 81. Irenaeus, disciple of st. Polyoarp, sa
- SAl the Churches must depend uPE -,
go Church of Rome ~ ON their soufco anu ne.
at is. necessary for all Churches 70 CONS
un- this Church, i'm which the Apostolic trgai
Erato has always been kept intact by those VINO
cat. in all reepectes faithful
T. l. We demand to know III what part OF
49, writings these passages are 20 &c toano
snois In fact they tell us that the ques
10 9TH rests On ouch a0thofities.- Let chem .
70 toll verify those qaotations, tea Were
i. s Of are found, and give them comPie.e, OF
AVd Shall be compelled to agree with the ~ %
,.y beers of the Vatican Council, who deci'
three that the Supporters OF the dogma gu
.,otsa authorities, " CARRIED, interpolaSed, sp
-. Gus, and.twisted out Of their proper M
new Most of the Other statements, in
street. article we hold to be contrary Weil-k
CLOCK facts, but We will be sasishea as pre-
az q with an answer 70 the point we have
Q held sented. .i.x - $500 - = 80