The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1872-01-05
UNITED STATES ciacuIT cuusr.
Criminal Trials.

Before Judge Benedict
Emmanuel Antoine, Thomas Roach ana James
Thomas, c00red, were indicted for revolt on
board the ship j. L. owen, at sea. on the Sd OF June
last while the vessel was on voyage from New
York 10 the West Indies. Tho mate Of tho vessel
proved 10 be person OF harsh anu cruel dsposiliOn
ana frequently, during the trip, III uset inc men.
called them bad names, and struck one or more OIL
them with ca p Oa Kind On ws ose sSSg on
on board, the captain intcriered; disturbance
arose, and In the melee the captain received dow
show that the deaIh ol the captain was wholly un.
premediIated. Mr.. Robert N. Waite defended the
accused, cOncnding that they acted IN sei'deencc'
Tine jury returned verdict OF not guilty.
The Case OF Charles misunderstanding Tes-
timony for the Defence.
The case OF Charles Calender was again resumed
yesterday before Commissioner Osborn.
The District Attorney appeared for the prosecu-
zion, and Mr.. William Fullerton and Mr.. Joseph
Bell for the defence.
Mr. John Knox Dunlop, who had been prlvate
secretary to Mr. Calender deposed In reference 10
a blank form pu, into mis- hand That he mad never
seen MIR. Calender issue report OF his examina-
tion OF bank on such form; mad never seen MN
issue report like that on page IN the Statement
book OF the ocean bank; witness idenlheu Tue
blank form Mr.. Uallender used In making MS TO-
ports; assisted niIn In making an examination
OF The AFFAIRS OF the Ocean Bank; Mr.. Calender
may nave made more examinations OF the bank
fnan one during the eighteen months witness had
been WIN Inn as private secretary; he nau
examined many banks during TWO years; ne eX, x,
amineu the Tenth National Bank, witness thinks IN
September last; witness was with uim In Tue OK
nnilnatl0n of mat bank; thinks Mr. Calender mate
swear Calender did so, but That Is MS lmptcssion
did not know II ho made an examination Oh tno
Elghth National Bank; he had not examiner tue
books of the Union Square Banx to Witness know.
edge, though he may have done So wlncss i ~
been present wnen Mr. Calender examined oem t@e
wealth q year ago the National Citizens
Bank and others were examined, out VIII,
lad been forwarded ny MIR. Calender To the Comp
tr0lier OF the Currency; thinks reports were male
OF the Fourth National and Central National Banks
ana also ol the THIRD National but he could not re-
member now positively; could not tell wnat &C.
ports were made; never iilled up reports,
Cuender did thai hlmse; lived In Dir. Callendcrs
house part OF the time as his private secretary Out
did NOT live there now; during the eighteen a
not remember MS examining any bank ont VI New
York city: witness mad made memoranda oi ,ue
o. anu REPORTS upI s anu h,,n re-
speak with accuracy.
Edward Bishop was the next Witness ne was an
officer of the Ocean Bank; he recognized The STATE.
mont book OF the BANK 1t had pecn In The hands OF
the receiver and had not been sent 10 washington.
Witness then stated that on or about the 3d or 4tn
OF October last, IN response to letter from the
once OF the Comptroller OF the Currency, he made
ocean bank aud forwarded 1t to Wash nutOn.
MIR. Joseph Iell, OF counsel Tor defendant, Odered
In evidence an eXempiled copy OF tus report stat.
Ing that the object OF oering IL was 10 snow that al
or about the Tune that report was made Mr..
Callenacr was engaged In an examination Of the
Affairs or the bank; mat he knew sucn report was
made 10 the government bv an officer OF the bank,
aud That, therefore, any report on ms part would
have been superifu0us, especially as he was aware,
from his examination OF the BANK That The report
The District Attorney ob)ecfca to the reception In
evidence Of the report, contendlng that 1t was
wholly fInmatcrial to the issue.
the Commissioner noted tho fact that such report
MAS made anu forwarded to tile government
After some further testimony the case was al
iOurucd 10 Monday next.