New-York tribune., 1872-02-27
DIR. CARNOCH1NS DEFENSE.

THE PRINCIPAL WITNESS, MARTIN WIENER
STILL MISsING-TEsTIMONY OF DIR. MOsHIER
COMMISSIONER BELL AND OTHERS
The Legislative Committee met yesterday
morning at the St. Nicholas Hotel for the purpose oi
concluding the Quarantine investigation. There ia niue
doubt that but for the efforts of MesSs ADer6er an"
Judd the entire affair would have been whewashng
lob" The other Committeeman have been present Only
n few times during the examination, and very ttIe IN
terest has been manifested by them. The committee
devoted the day to hearing the witnesses suDpehaeu ny
Dr. Carnochan most OF whom furnished evidence OF
their own Ignorance, rather than direct rebutng test
mony.
George W. Quntar President Of the Charleston he o. si@e @
teshed Uat M cnce Of yI% fever in Charleston year;
have experienced other quarhnaAS nave 10
Bv .gen. for the M, Steamship Company testified
We have never osTa The ports We have sailed from
Francis Macdonald agent for The Anchor Lne ., oHns oar
T have never detained Quarantine unless thsI had
So we We 9AS DC Hot es Whether the
owT Bsy; we fumgate vessels several times duns the
voR. G, Ksper Of staten Island tesfed boarding oaeer AZ
Staten the Commissioner Of u =, my uS X %
iii vessels bringing emganis and to report the condition o. n %
n do not think humane to send patients from f bay ~ TO
Of Of by the Quarantine steamers steamers ar 81
low ed to up sooner than sailing vessels els & @ 1 & we're 90
emgrsu arrived by steamer ana ony @ IN y psvsI hear. Of
@ nomnlaiat on the pr; Of the merchants Of New on
70 MI A6ge,& % & S1 s Justice Of the Peace Ird have
two assistants; my salary o this sAar' !, Iaa ] g ,l1 tt sH'
Cae s g w Of Staten island boarDgofee merely corr
rorais ;s tfSS1y Mo.% 1eSu, 81 Mt sS oae Vessels de-
& ~ t Lower Bay they IRON certain PoT. ,ne .
nation mi GGns to board ys.. At ag always understood that
Nj B5GT1 g. an fsH' m graduate Albany Medical College and
h1c been prac.eng physician since 1853 The boating hop % %
nav IN @ onop he eit the s' account OF the zee aho soD
S bgeen 2O and 800 vessels last season al Vstahuhei @ w,
emp companies permitted 80 take u heI n' IN % s Srn %
bvsI rarely ever permitted go into Quarantine limits We & ais
, ,ery anxious &c. vessels through Quarantine " Inc e'n
To Mf Aberge-I make written orders 70 hs
,boa the steyedoes do not know that thsy 60 % "a % % ,,i
eglaTlr; believe that would have hl choieia eP ~ ~
PsI md il the Quarantine Tenouons .,gssI
ioba q Fsy of the Grm OF Martin Pay warehou'enen shel
~ them 10 man name do not feel al Def 70 s'ne ~
waf confidential rdnsactioni would say 'ha' was '
% Chairman said that the witness did nojseose the nam' 10
would be eomPgTd to 1p % The T" witness prepared
NJ A5egrr-f shall have to insist on your n'" 10 'O'
| one,isn now or will give you until o'clock. ...,,A
Wtns viii make fnd out the man and converse "'a
m M Fy Subsequently the Committee and declared m Ina
whom he search o. bus eA2er.u ~
ngna 10 attend at Albany on any day which Tue 'om~
anAte c q, IN, Board Of Health testified; Dr. CAmoebAr
h, en consulted the Board Of Health and bis Aeohs nave
indoel n iS % he examined bat the Chairman stated
U he Impossible to-day and Dr. Ride would nave ~
A9sey then adjourned for minutes at the end Of .hel
time reas,embed at the rooms Of the 9uaTAnns tssd
EIebaego court Dr. A. n b' .Son' 3 @ % s. 81 and my .,
spec services" to The Board $3.50 at voc VIM hs Rn,d
nyd the set authorized the Governor designate one q % & n M
su1.tTing Commissioner under this clause , uIAn I'M
| second salary Cha. li".sl ws aPp@.e' ,As sTehltse
Lnsns55 b s NJ ma.a5n be received 'agse tao 90
Mr. Hasws receives .alnry OF "a 9 per ae y an bps The tw
nsd States Government vessels bono~e fei le Us" ., or Al 1
nci VIZ 1 p, CSrnoohso h JO CLERK Of h. uoH@
| souefs toeglTe, SslsTI 'i PAW V't J'ai' W