Daily national Republican. (Washington City [D.C.]) 1870-1872, 1872-01-16
THE COURTS.


surRExa oeuRr o. rHn USIrno sTArns-
moaday, Jsnssyg IS isIa5on motion q NJ. ?.
PsiP, pssns e. I,,. MAJ ' Ss,oTnes
No 10 q Dec. tern, ii1o. VIM b Knox, plain.
90 n esror, va Phses q, lie and hTSn CHI les
the United states for the Western District Of
No, Il q Dec. term, 1870. Thomas \. PsIt'r,
he supreme Judicial Court Of tho Common.
wealth Of Massachusetts.
Mr.. Justice strong delivered the opinion Of the
court, afhrminE the Judgment In those causes
NJ. Justice Bradley delivered eOncurrlns
Nj. Chief Justice Chase, Mr.. Justice ulinord
and Mr.. Justice Field delivered separate dissent
to oiy % ioLlrxS-rhs following sa.e, viii
Abraham Morfeli, ", WIN, J. Pattoni ee, Henry
II. Clapp; %, Geo. NJ. Fillmore; 100, Arson N.
Thompson; iol, Obas. II. Adams: io2 Joseph W.
Parish and WIN; Z, husei lbs, WIN. 5. shreWs
scrREss oouRr % THs DrsTmcr or 90.
Court room yesterday, ohiei Justice Cartier
aud Associate Justices Olln, Humphreys and
Macarthur on the bonoh, =.
The court called the calendar Of tho torm--t1
cases In alias follows
THE Casa ron HRARiNu,
Bounty claims Of farragut 81 ali United
ao.: " y wii.on @siSosy u. %as: Gsraasi
Green; sickios 4 CooE vs. Bsiilmors steam
Byfnes Va. King Supplss ys, Bohrsr; Boal vs.
Cassln, EXECUTOR Dyer ". Jackson 81 ali Onuu
Va King Of ali Work "a. Secretary o. Treasury
OF the Lake; Laderer va RuadlettJ Jones vs.
StronEfellow; Oroplsy Va "copper" Trumbo vs.,
DOweni Durant W. Conner; 0arnett "a. United
States; Alexander " District OF COLUMBIAN Gas
rldyjvs Frsd. VandorsnsS; Hsssier Homilisr va
Poor; MoHowArd %. Va Poor, In 70. Amss
estate; Willard ". Willard faalts "; Brad.
Elles 81 A. Va, Bell, Douglas, admir-, Va Doug.
man; United States vs. Rsssn 1 HisT,
Mossrs. N. Wilson, W. D. Webb, and Perry
| were appointed a committee 10 examine Appil.
eanls fJr admission 70 the bar.
Tho following casss were then taken Up!
Joseph Gardner Va. the Nationsl Freodmen's
Saving and Trust Company. This case comes
up on an appeal from the Circuit Court Upon
ooToG aSs ssIs D own ns P show
| that On tho 10Th day ol September, lses, ho do
posted with tho defendant $50; that Afterwards,
the he sum o. Cs that soon man ssr Y Ss
discovered the loss Of the pass book which had
been given him BY the defendant At the time Of
SsHins Sesn ssolsn from Il. trunk hat he
| shortly thereafter went 10 the defendanrs place
Of business and notified the defendant Of the loss
=, ING poon MI aseqI .hae " Wy WI uay
sit on Proclamation q the boob, aud had
/ charged the same 70 the plalntin, whereupon
Tie Plaintln demandsd ~ rum the defendant,
/ the plaintiff testified that when he made said
/ deposit he gave information to the defendant
IA b,n,hsrs -. s,L.s s,hsn ~ 49, 49,, ~.
defspdant he aid sam Of ais in January. issv.
~. oh,.Inst ~. mnnax Hvn,sasn,in- Ht. ~ ~
49, ~ ~ ddes'jyg ~ ~ az s,,, ~ A.
80 80 sns.s,in' as.,,Ia,y. nsosonntn ~ ~
hin In r..nsct ~ 80 ioiorms, ~ Ia M y,
=, .i0rlssia p,evioas Ssn 70 me ds,esnhanS a
,s ~, ~ ~. ds,onaan, % III ~
svid.noa tba chariers Nv law ruies sni reySla'
sson ~ o,sa a,,nn ~ ~ hsgsnJsn, .nd ~,
hcsdnnIng ~ ~ husInss, n had bcsn n, eSs,nm
AMI usage 10 axe Al ne lime Of rceeIyipS = ~
~ ns,nsc n ~ eo,Id III. ~ ~. 49, Z, ~
sniJ nv, ara No. ~ ,,ixs bi,n 49, 80 ny
Al the tIme OF maiIns a naynent 10 reanIss
~ .,oh Ssscsnptnn an n s,s.,st sns,srs ~
Ia SIYsn Sn5 1bs nass'hoo8 hoins nrsssntsd
ana ssymspt oi A meslne MIN beins PeoIs.tsJ
70 make sISh payment 70 he Per,Gn sn,wsrins
os,I n,rthas -, ni,p,nan, ~ ~ ~. IJon,i,s ~
shs ssnosI1a,, n ~ ,hs J.no,to,s 49, na,,. "
GU; and mostly rssdmsR' Whose IDENTITY could
sr ,hs as, .ecrs, mi ennns,in
snlJ mode Of tranSscting bn.ines, dspositor,
| 49,. ais.t -, ~. dada,ss,. ~ u, y. ~, ~
making ,hslr deposits mat the pialnun lndl
siasn ~ nisin,Is A. ~. linz ~ w Ru,ILn
| ~, II. J.,as,, .nd ~ 1htnh he h.a $500
~ ms,S. tha7 al ,sid tims Ia :, s.iysd :
pas. book Of the hind given 70 ali dspositorsi
| Ia, NJ. ,s.v,a.o, ~ Al ar Fahrn.r. ~ ts,a
M mae upon me demand ~ sSns Ons snS
nresentsd ne plaintifi's paSs book Md snsverrd
M d.sc,tniicn ~ himsaif Nrnlshr.I srr.ssi n
~ ,hs ,itInIia h.1 ma isf. M :, = y. sh,.r 4.
| nyy.ar1o III .ha,h.s 80 nayman, -. ras1a !,
| Shn M. in,,sr ~ 10 so,nrs me ss..nsh,ias bt,
| Az. phasa Ihs dsSsnJsn, ss',eg Whsvsan o,
M ,ns,ins hssy,ns ,hs cansc hsx,ns ,nnnd ~
slc,J ~ ~ ~ vsn IN sSisnsa VA Shov. ~, .n,
tsTts. bsid ,hat op Inc ali moi. N. ol"InsiG
Mas spiiaie.l ~ sesSIer a. I'm ~ tram
| ,he lima n onsht ID hava heen naid IA ahs1
,adginent .hon1d Ia Sntsrnd ssci,riin III, tso,r
Shieh ruiIng AMI me tnJ,rman, ,hs.angg,,, - -,
tered the defendant anpesied 10 tha csurt H.
| generaI tarm. which appeai now come mn 10 h.
kesSd N'~' ""'N" '''o~' NV 0O"' ny I" "
The case was arsn,ed BY Mr.. stanton FIR IN.
Trust CImuany And by SMr Rarrott for card,
| ner Tho sonrt Maid tke easa undeT adyisemsnt
whitnev Va Ames neaIh IN defcnda M m =
| ge.tsd AMI caaa oontInneI
Dnrant va Ijonnor. Juivm.nt FIR nlainlIn
in,vaII Va, Volani' Gase dIsmisSedi
The court thon Adjourned until this mornInR
EauIrY CovRr-Judgs Wylie.-ThIs court
| mala thu fOllOvinp 0r,iafE VeEtArdaV.