New-York tribune., 1871-03-29
,.,.l, 4 d. eapp,p, ia rhIeh hsy h.l a.

% @ F'%'; . . ." s Sp%: pSss % SsS
has pu ase b Conn m % ~. Ers R,Esy Company Mone Of the
6Tp cnsp has been expended IA e9S1 & gops T ws bo t
lesns 1 or of s COMPANY her eIcecde Anse
@e3 55s Osebp COMPANY p which Could f and Len,
are iaerc the prejudice o The oia, & s va n.s hs .S
Va, roi made by Board in existence whom the law
g,s t. M21,y % 02S o. s fS1 o WA .e b5 he ,o persons
% s5, sni Il Is in the Gould Fisk aad Lane The de-
uts r,fase to tsnsr lO shares Of soc hone Of he
ing fees nauns public elections And in preventing The
o se'Ss o. ss capital durns 1855 Is not sooounisi Tor by
annual report the Legislature for that year lh net eaInns OF
have dmnhe IT, stock and bonds have ALLEN market
value ADD has become impaired Gould Fisk and Lane ore not
sSoasR sSSa l1s property '11 .i the s made .n.' by
There ,veneui the b Of any demand male noa the directors
and the onv vents BY way OF excuse for emitting such DE-
AMI upon Their Information and belief your orators alegs that The
on Lane october 1862 constituted and dosnei made
trolling the said Could Tsk ard Lane but board IN 50 far
said board has sei at ALL has acted sni does SCI n
% ClJ Fst nd Lane m thst abough il NAV he ,ruc A. nov
legged by Gould sk and Lane that since ihe election Of sach new
during the preceding year When The Penss holding directors
board in October 1852 ef he said Gould Fss sud Lane have
hd still have practically the absolute and gnh esd control OF the
said corporation Its funds aud property. aud all IT, ars
And your orator. uron no and belief aleg that the
said William Tweed ful aceor with the said Could Fish and
Lane IN Their private and peoasl ig and advsn
expense Of the Ee Railway COMPANY .d 70 The utter d.
and personally interested many Of nc eeTe and s tst & the
Could several Of the said directors salaried EN-
poyes o. th. Enc R'Say company "a aShg ing 'os[ % % s S
GOul under the influence sod control Of said
&iu n as .soicr. the Fe Bsilwsy CompsHy they anJ
such ,nd that among the & Po3S % tins s s :: Tq TreI. G.
Hilton the faer q the Transfer Clerk asd himself ek cr
q Hail. the suppl Agent Erie Railway cOPaHy nat ~ r.
Of the said Directors is In Substantially ke po ION or
win The said Gould Fsk and Lone except that be is s.rsl %
npoy6 Of the Naragsuset steamship Compapy T6cl Is under '
3ssG'' sss.s direction and control Of tue ' 'S ' Lane "
the si Board The said Hoaer Ramsie Alexander Dyen
John Ganson md ohers who are ee Of character ana o
for such Compan under Ordinary ccanes TIER independent ac
lion as suh Directors believe aud charge eompro-
% by reason pledge b.t they would either
support Iorey ssd Could resign and il be not 20 tae
check to the plans operations Of sad GopG III end
their end at they are in rch relations per,nai or
with tue ad Goa FA ana Lane as ue's Gt'eI snl M % ,5e
Ehe Railway Company 1ns The sHl Gell E ana ln, G %
NOUS amount. which e have wronF AMI faudg W OBJ
tanned nom Tie gr-se the sai m tS1Ie 1a @ ' gh % M en-
iaes hel DO not ate-i llch ueeti1se
claims ni as49 10 5ar Of ne Ere Railway com3ay a
S tFe ise , aai i oS icf s c@PaHy for DE
and Lone AM orator are wholly mani. 20 Iaf Ia' "
u the E'H, Of "a Cooai o. pa , 3u ' Es l and Ian.
lie became rector an of ai ther ma3ageuea Of the Cigsn
oussd from Once tH th, iyue Of or' e5nYel u t 10, 's
Company e appointed arl that preliminary injunction be e7ned to
Tie ic Following are the grounds OF the demurrer:
Irs: complainant have not in tier b s;aie u c
ougi, cnte them to any snl .o cry or -
plant John iig, Henry fhomison lev Iniers o. JOSIAH
parties TO the bih OF complaint iha.h1,n IS - -
Herein stated all Of them c'n!rerated 70 tecue
control the Erie Railway COMPANY by HsihAlr Htli'
md r made part Of grounds Of the Bin Third That ht 9s-
ton fond aHi Ere Railway tomany a neees parry 70 e l
insruch therein stit~i LAT TIE sd 'onp,ny el Aif1
amount Of money the Rssay Company, IN 'osCn the
corporate powers The latter Compan7, br nsol With Coal Lane
and defendant fOrTht That Ecari semen anu '"iNI
Wand ler.ii
slated therein they received large srnunts u n nom
F~ Compsn;ie fraud aud combination Wh u1 Lane, ana
tt isceit fnh that Nsrrigln-e Steamship Company Is a
perss,,ry party h ilagml is slated therein that s
Cn,Ty has aegriiei wrongful gains the Bie IA J.
deeu4apt Of which gams acrourt is demanded BY tbs
tl Hlh Tbat William ~ Tveei Alexander = Deyu, Jusi n
- Nhi,. J"'h "1l',i' " ". i,,- IIt,
Son, Ahsm Goull Homer k'ms ell, ienf in"hpu Jon
Ilcnr. smith and George G. tl necsii pafs To th o IS
s stated therein that he ioee lrr VIII 0oid ~. sIl 5 W.,
elc-ei directors 0 the Erie Railway tomlat ~ Oor @ ana
divided Eve cfs, holtng Ofc' for dhtrt term >
which tie b ask 20 tav r aud u & shorten r
o. ~ of the DTetfs ana that te p,I-,h - hl
b, the lin still Directors of tie Lnr ailuay Com
rsnr and n a. resPc VIM NJ Tweed is aDgl 10y the m that
he accord with the dendins G"ll iNA shl iAe ~
schemes of private gain expense Of the E N tomn ana
u,ng interested SreAN That The bill expressly waves
an answer this eui r slch manner an form s. alone Is A""h
I and rc br the aud practice Of this CDuri ar at Were
his i boaad t. answer IT. "htr-oe lold Ie u.s.
missed with costs
In the course Of his remarks Judge oar OF Massachu
sets who opened the argument In behalf Of Heath ana
Raphael contcndcd that the bin Of complaint contained
enough ALLEGATIONS OF fraud robbery, and corruption to
eutitp some one TO relief, and stgmatzed the high
handed actions of Fisk and the proceedings In this case
In the state Court disgrace TO American justice ana
the American name The Court then adjourned till TO
day when Br. EyaIts viii continue the argument Tor
the English stockholders.