New-York tribune., 1871-06-24

avoid don't understand IT IN view ol ,n wnor =" " m
sad na 10 his right a. Agent and ae corpohto
has been said that the motives Of Dr. Lanahsn must oe
his protection Sy ssy Dr beter
his motive There man who once SET no ~ 70 a0 an
Temple Of DIANA Diam fnhs do mot not SUPPOSE any such
70 one here Some has said, The worst madnan
- a iiye bich forms part Of his very life, 40 that
he ats nothing else drinks nothing else sees nothing
else SeSn better for the Methodist Book Concern
for religion and better for that benevOenee so In
matey tst Which could never benefit the Book
Concern or the Church; and, even ne undertook ,bs
on some else and turned his aten'i'"
90 his duties as Assistant Agent . ,oet
This closed the case and the Court adjourned 70 no.'
in Executive Session at O'Clock this morning INC
dict will probably not be rendered for severai u'o
the Committee propose TO have their senosi"p"o a,
all NJ the testimony to them before deciui"e I -
That Dr. Lanahan will be deposed Is deenieu pio..
tain and the important question u'ouo u A., 80,
the verdict shall be rendered at onoe, ~ "o no hos
he can have chance to sustain all 'no ~ NV"
made. ~, .o,o,,
uDGE BARNARD DENIES DIX. LANAnAN "oiio'
-. nodo on behalf Of Dr. Lanahan for per
-no Janus to compel DR.. Carlton to show him
80. q, the Methodist Book Concern, was denied
.sav by Judge Barnard, with costs In announcing
M dclsion he delivered opinion 40 pages in length,
,tplating the statements urged on both sides, and
t1eS . DO but little more than state conclusions which
rived after patient careful ard anIiou consideration Of the se ana
such refusal the part Of the respondent 70 permit bin 70 eI
am Of The opinion that the retoTs dcuy that he
claimed the night 70 ssS Pr;'GM control aT & Ci f% @ S h
properly the respondent for which will be stated
be msde in the building and place where papers
dna kept and not elsewhere and such eIS3a9n $ should be haa
their resolution Of October 1870 But Win such an examination
Besides been unable discover nee Tor er
@ % a ,eSp. s @ % Seo h 70 Oot % sought GR an e
PLANTATION from the proper officers Of the Book Concern before making
dend how careful prudent Christian gentleman could make the
TssIgs % nsnu,GSs ana a. PO TO ne ppd them Tfe
not only unsupported By edsoe but sre gns and Over Sns %
tie laiOr is hostile to the respondent and 70 the hes, neIss %
hostility and its injurious results The rsat9r
udse from Ae papers before me- makes charges S Sa SnS %
without proof evidence called for bis eOuds
SsISs S 70 S % ssSs be Ss% he H % % % am unSns
sanction such conduct To me surprising indeed h't socn clan, Nm
the reo surprised that he dd not make ne
and then justified in doing the charge Fsng to
going through She books and hoping % find ;oTsIsS son sSos shS % s
has hitherto failed to dscoeE sST OF oss or WHO"
'A As 'S S.foe stated the Peicr another ground
@ SS S%se 5 bct BSo Obvious from The Whole Act
I s O ne4. 4sG eoDene T did % moi Stead Pace The Gssa
respondent and The Assssn, Agent the Taicr both & &ipRd % the be
power ana authority and in the control and Inagenent OF
trusts ,Ss Ss r sH'dS S.cs % '.Es .A ''1 was ''s' Se
sign and intent It neither proper nor lavinl ana
Cor will unless statute has been accepted by the
General such TO nvahdae most nnm mkaoY e
abcatOn power authority parties 10 tins uuiOrtuna
and as thirk wholly litigation By common 9ge Pc
ce understanding subordinate and under the con-
troll direction agent think the show the esto
inferior and subordinate position to the respondent and wholly sub
iect bis control and direction OF Dr. Carton ana
that books papers with which the respondent OF
the Book Committee 90 voluntarily furnish him ,
Without having applied against relators case well settled rules Of
law have examined with little and labor fact bearing
upon question he should be permitted matter OF night
again examination such he seeks this apheo
HAD the question: should direct the wit 20 issue
Bu have that this controversy should end II tends
TO bring into scandal disgrace not only the Book Concern but e
made The Concern as the
papers show uneIampd prosperity It's profits for
u II vea were nearly What the effect Of these charges
continued repeated although examined and rfntes not stated
hat can be readily business IL will be surprising,
indeed much longer shall be disastrous TO the
Concern 1t divided against ITSELF and have il from high authority
that division shall the Book Concern cannot stand
The motion mus, be denied with