New-York tribune., 1871-09-12

year 1871 arc largely or In any excess Vi LILO 'ui' "
oWru We % W coos TINT the increase In the funded and
tepornry debt Of tho CITY and County during the wv
and half years OF his MayOray yop 100 e cnmnter.
n ~, ~, r fnunty hond that did not appear upon
it face 10 have been authorized by an act OF INC
nurc, and which be personally knew " ,oTcs in the
meu no a ,.eo u"v,teS IN no sSI sl9 ST. and not To
S m hl6 "a, as act forth in the complaint. ana ihal %
taxes collected IN the nscaI year - VI nd that the sums
I ,Sr treasury of The City and County during tne
years 1860 and 1870 on account OF nod 10 and that
an9unou w. " ,o".J ueriod there was paid into
the trcs,ry of the City and County from the genera M
fund, $5374.3i 55 and not SSSoo, oo ,nnd the sIm
hicgatlon Inn uuiint WI WI "t the treasury is u marvel
ous Tho long answer concIudes d" o'
lows: ,,. , .,,,, i,s,roed and
Ano h anosn n u'.e .,scs v"a he formed aiming cripple
and emba CITY Government and tale dvants :" AM & h ss.
% IN ,Ss Roar, Of Apoionneut sdopt" and followed VIZ VIZ
the teehncAy aud particularly ,he W. .. hnnor
. o. -. which i, the vnt Of ali the numerous B9sfus
Estimate and oonmen ,hero ei.'ng mi =, q. the proce
n" md r oI this d,Gnsut As member h,ve been full acenrm M
regular respect Ooniomsse 70 n iha Of the p.na
m,pd for inrn h.s been already, and weeks BE- orr this action w.
laien BY ad Board Of 4 M % % ..e ior
by th. Boar. Of ApportonmeT ,nd To- I
tndsn tst rohos ~ anu ''' "N'e " '' "'
1n, d,,rror ~ the de,epdant, The Mayor, Alder
-, I,..,,,, -, ,ha fy,y NJ New.York i'm
H'"' ".u 49, .o., ,o,i ,hat tbe s,id de-
i ,, =. a.. aa,,,.,,, an tho crnunds
len'"n'' u."'"i'0u ~ % w ,",a, canacitv to sue
".'' '" ,,, ,, onnIoint docs NOT state facts suf.
a'. ,u' -. ..,I,,,o o.r.o 90 action Service of the
n..on' W. saoon,od nv tho n,aipt,a,, counsel in
.
a, a., ,o,,sior y, Nr o,cormon's reading OK Judge
- ~ ~ W. 80 ,.a, -, IT. o,ior ~ to ,ybctber the
ha''c'' as"in i'i',i '" ~ i .,..... ,o1 ,oo,
ehtiro 'hihueS vi thc bo"ru VI "Pl'' 4,
submitted, and said' "Ihe answer "h'ch n'' """ =, -
friend unable to make the affidavit ot mayor Han
supplies. In two places the answer speciray reier 10
acton having been taken by the Board OF Appornoh-
ment for which have information today ana re-
specting which the extracts from the minutes ano'
furnished are deficient"
Mr.. OGorman-It seems to me that all these questions
can better be debated when all the ailavits arc ILL.,
Ex-Judgc Barrett-Ifm my learned friend Will promise
that tomorrow he will furnish full and complete ex-
tracts from the Board OF ApportiOnment IL VIII Dc sat-
Them
Mr.. OGormanI am surprised at the course my learned
friend has taken II is exceedingly UNUSUAL and almost
yerrcs ON the confines of diourteousncss decline to
no interroc,td Inv bc learned counsel at this stage OF
tho nrocooJircs what Odavt intend or do not intend
.no '|.V's' "a' q, ,.. n
TO read IT, on finishing the reading OF the ahuaVs ho
finds he has cause to complain let him then do So
Ex.Iudyc Barre,t-I intend no discourtesy am eim.
ply here to exercise my right IA the advocate OF the
plaintiff and to demand that the entire minutes be fur
ed
,, r, r,,. A.. ..o, ,u -, 4,
Judge Barnard-Whrncver tho attorney Tor the de-
,h.,r ,,do, O., oo, s,,oostr,,,, th. a,ioaotiors y,
the compant and % thew e, sSa have omitted W to produce
that which is required by the other side If they give
reason for their failure to do so it will of course be taken
"a circumstance against them the decision OF this
notion the rule of law being as well known, that
whore man has tostimonv that he falls TO produce and
has an onnortunv 70 do so tho prcsunption IA that he
il throws him under strong suspicion.
MT o"orhah-"e Shali ac'op, ,ne reSpoS'o'''''' anu
shall satisfy the Court that nothing has been cVadcd
'o."i'e . ,,.., ~,
Judge barharu-beio'c .'is 'aSe IS suoi'i''ou WI
O'Gorman and Mr.. Beach, should like to have state
ment I'M to Thursday when the Injunction was granted,
:, A., 49,, ., -, ,,a,,,i,,os =, ,ho C,,,, ord ror,.,
OF the total amount OF ahtrS OF tne 'i'y ana county
of New-York. Court here adjourned the to this
morning at IL O'Clock.
.rr,n WIT OH coNrpo,Ipp covno11v
AFFIDAVIT of CONlhoLLEh CoNNOLLl'
,hmt.,od ,n tho 90 40 Nth otho doc,,ort. I'M, mo- No,
S""''eo IN ','' .aso WIN o'"e, out was no'
read 1t will doubtless be heard In the proceedings to-
day The specinc denials only are given
pio,ord u Conr,,,v hoi,, duIv s,r,r, 5o,osoo aud
,;n % ncb ~ and owSrv aiIeost,o ~ trnd cpsn;ron
a mo ncc in otco ser nmt r., The nn,;,It ~ ~;
actnn either NV direct cbarrc or nv ipnmrndn n
timaon nsnu;tion ar otherwise. He il not nov nor
ia1on' I'm h ~; r % Nav ", cv or ~ dir, ~ ioi hom @ i,or
manner conSected with or interested I'm The New
1nriut a,;n %, th W. wv Vr m t, C U
-, ah iners, C,,,,anr, H. ia ~
n, o t no nnr has he saJ anv vt or m
wsn in T5s Vc,r TorE Jrnder tlat Ec has yot oirnn
"r ",,sed to i've pivcn to thn NewYork Priutino Cam
pany or caused Il To- have monopoly Of the printing OF
The CITY and County (iovrrnmcn,s nor has fhe Mann
featuring Sutoners COMPANY now nor had H. by any
aid or connivancc his part. a monopoly Of all the
stationery supplied to the city and county offices
Nor has this deponent, in defiance Of any provision Of
law acting under Ot the other persons
any other manner. directly indirectly connected
himself with association with any object or design
of securing sum sums from the trensury of the
CITY and County OF NewYork nor for any other pur-
pose. has ho Obtained through any suc means any
sum from either of said treasures.
And this deponent further says that II IA true that no
has lately in connection with the Mayor the cy drs-
ilated The Ne,c York Ddiiy Trdscryi and the Seir-