New-York tribune., 1871-03-30

during the progress OF treaty negotiations with the
United States Was there any crime in this ,, o,.,
f Mr. SUMNER to Mr. Sherman)-I can answer that
Mr. HARLAN denied that any one had complained;
except perhaps, Cabral. Referring 20 the precedent
we had been cited for tho Presidents action, he held
that IN the Nase of Texas, solemn promise was given
10 the Texan Republic that the moment they signed be
treaty ard before II ratified they should be pro-
tected by te United States Calhoun though poor Se S
man. and his spirit t0day the very soul OF the Dem,
ocratic pa. aud cah0ws srgume1t On the he'd aispach
to Mexico already quoted, was that nav n, n.
cSi yaGeS wSc Negotiations we're pendig r HaFSn 0
conicnded that there eecs from ts p9sl,SSn ,Sn
Sss Snotd sdG o Bcntons T y Years on and
concluded by movipG 20 lay the resolutions Vi 'i
Mr.. sUMNER<I hope the Senator viii allow me an op'
portunity OF being heard I'm reply % orostion."
The VycE PRTIDEST here stated the melton, lana ana
then asked the Senator from Iowa ''di' H'i'"H'
Mr. IY must insist on tho motion The hon
oabe Senator r samue mas peem ~ nj hs
ing a1y question and have attempted to answer all h0
mas put cos for the question by Hessrs. Conkling
Edmd and Others during which sg ta sHhSI ba
TO get the floor and continued 70 aSoreSS 'o
me- I VICE PRRsiDENT-The motion Is not debateable
he bn 9neston must be decided by the Senate
Thc question being put the CHAIR declared 'na' lno
'Sas @r. SstIjMNER~I cali for the Yeas and Mayo
Mr.. EDMUEDS Q2ep. VLl-Nes, let us nave 'he 'c"s
The Veas and Nays were then ordered and the socre
tary being directed by the TO can tue
promptly called the name OF MI Anies7 "i'o '"S''
!" Mr.. ir' THURMAN TiTi' Dem, oho) Mr. President
Several Senator'S" Question! Question"
AIr. THURMAN-I ask consent to put one question
fCrCs OF No NOp'l
The VICEPRESIDENT here raped to order with ms
gave; but above the noise and confusion Mr.. THUR
know II there in the Senate before where the
resolution was not allowed to close the debate
Mr.. CoNKLIYG CRep., N. " objected to Mr. Thurman
The vIGEPREsIDENT-Th rules prohibit debate on
Mr. sUMNER-weI. Mr. President
The VICE-PRESIDENT-Th Senator from Massachu-
sets is not in order Objection has been made by several
senators TO debate and the rocall has eonnenceq
and the Senator from Mississippi has answered TO MS
. .
MIR. SUMNER tstin on his feet)-I did not know that
MT EDMUNDs QRep.. vt)-I object to debate Of any
kind.
The VlCE-PRESIDENT-The Senator from Massachu'
sctts OF the rules, and the chair trusts the Sena-
tor will not inct upon the char The paiul uutJ Oh ie
Mr. SUMMERTIME at all; 1 cid not know but that the
Mr. CoNKLING dnterruptingl-Io object to this.
The VICE CEPRESlDENT-Th chair asked the Senator
motion and he said he would not He said this TO the
Chair in the hearing OF the Senator from Massachusetts,
The Clerk then proceeded with the roll call, when Mr..
arlans motion 10 lay It on the table was carriodHeas
S9 Nays IT, The negative vote in detail was as oio"s
ss ss:a R;si R:tss sT 'aai ys2 s...:;... s.:?ss &
cOogT yo14soa SIaktery SgmlSr T ,e
on s table was paired with Mr. Car
dsGac hlssFt Fa5i.S FFS% Sc'''r hS MS' t vs. h@sS h
Mr. Sheman's resolution, iustructing the Judiciary
Committee 10 report bin TO rcpreSs disorders IN the
South was taken up, and the Senate then, at io ad-