The New York herald., 1871-10-29

put 4 at certain percentage or At another certain
~ %sn s COMMITS
q little high may honestly thnk se Bas suppose
be were u1 1acsd for aSSs 50 would
tina, be the sr s oo o. hs
comes 70 questions Of p " how much nut "rs nrsy
the considerations weighing both upon courts and upon
When the time shall thA. nan can intentionally
men Sae.msni can Ss ssqasssd Jury because he
men we reached the q civilization tSen we
EMERGED sa soaSa %Ss TO
know the law and every man Is bound to obey the
"n''A'' - "Afi HAWKINS ms AND HIS WOMEN.
prosecution came from Enganatha, lani
e IN hays Sra ens w and war aed
al owed TO have only one husband am where he she
they They Dss' ssms 's from ~ irni
na s aa oa cgan 'hs n he aS
which, IKE England requires one man to be true to mis- one
they both shall and requires that y the States and
we welcome them Il Is optional with them
away leave after they have come but wnen they
particulars with the laws OF all civilized
Now gentlemen, from the evidence you believe that be-
tween ,wentyone and ,wentywo years ago Dc the same
Harriet Hawkins as his lawfully welded wife, did
mony which she has testne ha. The pr,..
A. the S ss a Seen Aa%
here; that they thereafter lived together ,, Inc,
vi we hes the prisoner at Willingly
ssY Sa.na a. Ss @ ns
he % sase y " n es n
are proved s Tor yourselves @ 70 say Va,
You eara e aya eso or not
they impeached themselves by their
that You snow~and Il is not dicui to rccalaii
in the s m TAKE ~ @ o.se wn
you into Court and render your
WHAT THE JUDGE WOULD CHARGE.
s But ySs sa
I'm order to lind verdict OF guilty the jury must neeve
Harriet Hawsins a. the time SCI forth IN the indle.
men the lawful wife OF the defendant" ies, gentlemen
IS sssd-That the with whom the defenaan. is
of the cohabng the lawful wife OF the defendant" ies,
lave but one lawful wife say you that
believe from The evidence that he married the prnc
quent marriage with any other woman WAS nun and void
in he Indictment have actual carna Intercourse with
beth Sarah Davis" Yes gentlemen, charge
unless. the satisfied s beyond
Ing propositions, they nnd the defendant not guilty.
aseasas iA to say am TO yo
the jnry believe from the evidence Defendant
with Elizabeth and Sarah Davis either hem
II the sae Or sna sf we're eevs M
to the Isl q s neT m%ss a na the DE-
The council further ask me to charge that il
marriage OF the Hawkins according
shown to have been soemnized and the jury believe from
the evidence that the prosecution has failed to
proof the jury in this case must ind the defendant not
have substantially charged you that doctrine in other
Words gentlemen, ami repeat it, must believe the
that they cohabed together as husband aud wife as
she related must believe from the evidence there
Further, say by the counsel ain
ee hn ,a e Ici ID M @ von e @
] le ies neate sD harue
And further Tha jury that proof
has esta hed by the evidence beyond reasonable
WHAT iiE WOULD NOT CHARGE.
rhat unless the jury satisfied that proof OF
mission Of an act Of adultery by the defendant prior TO the
cution beyond reasonable doubt they the
iendan. not G guilty" No. gentlemen refuse SO to charge
FlTonaas Your Honor finished reading the instruc-
The GouRT--Yes SIR.
its motion and the refusal OF the Court to give the IN
sructons asked by for the Defendant to the action
verbal adena the Court exceptions
given behalf of the defendant desire
v '"''' The vERDIcT OF THE JURY
The Cont convened a. ten ooSk A. on Saturday oc-
| The Jurors called and found to be all present
The CLRRK-cntemen Of the have you agreed upon
The FonKaAx-we have.
| The CLFRR-How do you find
lhe sealei verdict was then handed up by the foreman
In the case o. the People United States in the Terri
tory Utah Hawk.ns We, the render
as unanimous that the defendant Thomas Law
kns. is guilty OF adultery charged In the Indictment
JAMES II. CKUUCH HENRY u. PRATT,
WILLIAM II. LITER, JACOB OkNSrEIN,
ISAAC r. EVANS, HENRY GEORGE,
JOHN III, LATEY, CHAS. d. TROWBRIDGE,
GEORGE ii. KOUGHT, SOL SIEGEL,
JAMES l.. MATTHEW'S, Foreman
SALT LAKE CITY October 20 1871.
he n. 70 s s &. S ss s
prunouncng sentence.
Hawkins sentenced to Three Yenrs' I'm
prisonp,cut in tho Penitentiary-NOtice Of
Appeal.
SALT LAKE CITY, Oct 2s 1871.
Chief Justice Mexican this morning passed sem
tence upon Thomas Hawkins, the pOlygamist, as
fOllows:-
Thomas Hawkins, l am sorry for you, very sorry;
you may not think so now, but shall try TO make
you think by the mercy which shall show you.
You came from England TO this country with the
wife OF your youth for many years. You were
kind husband and kind father. At length, how
ever, the evil spirit OF polygamy tempted and pos
0eDarfeQ