New-York tribune., 1871-01-10
REMOVAL OF MR.. MOTLEY.
cc-.,rres cron scccea pasr'

alone nominations r'r office considered Ic c,rS'o ~
1hcse sccct proceedings With IN apnorcnt c,E'1,Se To
crs6int OF that ~ y elan Sc allowed b rules -sey 10
cie ON NJ. NOticyfs cCnilm'noH. t'S-.'H crr
o. 09i' rnas s,,oy TP ~ ,sS sS'' sc5e,c 5l been
unaimpus. lIy coRnlcrce a-d li4ne '' H., ,'r bCW.
lears lc O tb c.c1ivln 1tr. Motley no-l IL %I,o
ever also ys that pon tbs question of ASI l, ,lle %
ttv: tl't onlv fns, votes were recorded Eaihss
lis rcc,n, and that an-'ns me sa',, s1o tor"
~sl M. , ,"..e hc .r'scquc.ty secs e. dci ufy me
cag' o tigt lcesc S tiS,i .y gefcrc. 10 enate
ms ;,, or ej.,'y uuaniui6as in It's coEeai!en
with tl.s Iieiiclt.
TUE HrXOyAL -'JT WITHOUT rtCtDANIS'
A. =, ,t'oy ss,s that so flras je IS aTare, no reg
B,a,fr confirmed Minister 40 this Court d.ondonl has
,crl.cu removed i TIC sideni who cIp'.i'e '
To-. uIy tis may ne Ut may also 1e true as ' s'e
o.uor Court than tat ~ London. There nave pe'n'
asc,cr frequent in-tarces OF successive .iS'.S o ~
-suloi Gs ven gS Osavhere az "httu I'LL l.. M le p.'.
81 dn but have no Nhn.1 a. t, anu ~ "', 80 a"ertain
viter t Hl.t 90 Tie succession was removed or hhu ~
-e~i :4cd. Oh M ease e.. Nm o lie ta aes,ne
aaa boehl garJ so 60 60 H. l |i N tIc frS rs ance
a. fhc try q, ta Gsvarnmont of munster ioliSnE !
lis ic 'l ri en- u ; U el iis aUr0irtuicnt More
- 'o[ ,.,.. d, cysve that the Cove nlarnt 70
- if.c Minister. can ind other means oI Gplhlnhg
Iar nr c..toqiuga Va ancy IN the oaic. tnan
- n,, li.i s J. - 1852 quoted by nm ~ on ne ne
~ .. t,t il 90 .ta.s The Only exception tasep ny ny
yc. ono - any expIt sion OF tainc llisl uuiint & @
;Ips course ny ;s MISSION nc i5 5g in IShith,
afer .cr.n u)uv not having been aWae tnfo on on
ssrteuoI.t o- Is coi YeIsDon M4.h ioiH ,ti f9r
81, 10Th J,. rad heg sapI'Ied u HIS lo4''4NP A'
. -, - Sr B.. i5rlp uoy ratur,ly be sqsea e
.-@t ' .ierl % iai;d yoa Jsrs hs Iron,
-, ~ @ & @ citation nd a;s,n. Of lie subject dis
t v r 10 part lg1Ja Dy ne N m! eouIai-
.i.-,i',, b. fb. .5t!. ,f Yr3f i.s;. . 49,.
% mon the Minister to state TO the Gov
49, w f,. M to Ike Jews OF the Power which &c rep.
:.sctc was inaccurate ana is disapproNed y nara
o,e nu. IFS lccesy in tlis was ugn,staha3e IN
MS ut.cH OF Tins requirement, NJ Ny,le& cS IA
{'& on E %ly & Ref'ty to- m par in ts inter
of tic fg of Juqc. II thought BEST ogeEeT,
T. raa~ a. l over fOT reasons the general hd'tiS Vi
Tllch Las t-ou already Indicated
Mr.. MCILEY's NEUTRALITY-SUSPICIOUS. OF TIE PRESIDENTS
VIEWS.
lie treats ;s serious hope not intendona9 oe-
rerr. ficu his IN n5tructiOus o diplomatic incident
sad dcsigu.cs almost impercoptible variation in
-se verbal rendering Of single paragraph in long as
patch what had been, in fact an entire msTeprasena-
t.on both Of ihc time temper aid object OF ms IN
srrtrf ls ana IN important doctrine OF lublc law. Mr
Hnticv sr,s 10 justify his presentation On Jnne) as tho
Yiows Cf Tie President oI inal NIeA ne Mss NO. 'n ~
authorized present 10y reference tc tIe stae t anu
fbe 25h of September There WIDE differences 9nd
broad distinct tons between those >tIecIois anu MT
N0tcs paper Of 2oth Of june although he states
hi discover TIE .e Syr h 0e eSi e s
POI, hSm 20 TO- pc ANTICIPATE the authority Of his
icnt in the prcsentatio Of its wishes or opinions.
TIE sANDoyISCo COINCIDENCE.
II remains only 10 notice Mr.. Moteys adoption Of
-,or which had its origin in this city in source biz
tesy personally and vDdctiyely hostile to the Pres
den Mr. Motley says it has been runored that he was
removed from the post Of Minister to England on ac
count Of the opposition made by Sentiment Senator
Who me" lhw) with bis friendship TO the sen
DJ treaty. Men are apt to attribute the causes OF
tier own failures their Insfortunes TO others
than themselves, ana 10 clh assOcltio OF se a Ps "
nersbp with real or imaginary greatness with wlleh TO
can lie no question as 10 the idnt,ty, q teo
md his REMOVAL but nc ~
en;irey mistaken in seeking vicaIiors leave ot ms ms
60 N @ t iS ard ebtvi and an Injustice to the
venerable Senator alluded to, 10 whose lhnu1nce ana
urgency MIR. Motley originally Indebted Tor his nom-
nation 10 attrbrte him any share in he cause Of his
rymoyal MI Motley must know tor II he does not
lac iu 13ct tu6t
many Senators opposed the san Domingo treaty openly,
.eerolsy ana with much efficiency as did the dis
Engushcd senator to whom lac Teies' ana nave never
teess continued 10 enjoy the udininlsheI confidence
s,vjps Is more tolerant OF bonest and manly differ
rces Of opinion; is m6Ie single OF sincere M ere N N
a. gar less Of what concerns Himself Is more nk
and conf ding n his dealings is more sensitive 10
D. tlaysi of confidence would lock with scorn
and contempt upon one who uses the words ana the
Hssurauccs Of friendship to cover secret aud deter
Ged purpose of hostility Tic President has not with
hold lt confidence respect, nor has lie Withdrawn MS
TORS Gd renee with hin on tie question Of san Domingo
q 9pv oCer subject on question of publc policy. 10
scc give credit 10 the suggestion that he hos done So
Vr that he would visit upon third panty retenttsht
is unworthy Of Mr. Motley, ana WI douGuc,s ne re
gTcttcd 10y An " en- the moment OF JioGEhus5 eNC.Ce
"HIsroE1cAL FAcTs."
Il conclusion MI Motley collaes the dates OF the re-
tct0n % The san Domingo treaty the 3Oh OF june and
tnt Of nv letter requesting his resignation, tho 1st Of
july which he places On record" a. on " historical
fact" To minds post hoe propter hoe is conclusive
OF eausa aud efoct There is tradition in Eng md,
believed by many that the Goodwin SANDS OWED thelr
appearance to c fall q certain gtGepl9 IN TIC pre-,
redug year. Inc coincidence which 5Ir =. tity stsnps
a am listorical fact" j. not the only or inc not re-
markabe one which bas tcea the suJect OI hsloy IL
guth0r Who tells us Of two old women MAO, "u"cllS
tdurs beck from effects 10 causes naturally IcFc4C0 70
taei deceased husDahts, Tciet tlns HIiG.o IC %
and buiias they compared notes ana dSc0yeeQ sludy
eirCuWs anCcs that tailed win WOHd~ilHI cAar-hesS,
such q Bagbara's father having been e1actiy iOus
wears aud ten months Older than KITS father ana one or
ihcin having dicdOn Wednesday and the other on u
Ihursda aId both Of them having been OF very me
make aud Icmarkay good locking, with otlcr extra
How Mr. hoticy, Who in his paper the "end Of his
mission" denies hayng ever expressed any OPINION on
thc subject Of the san Domingo treaty, seeks to connect
hs recall with the almost cotemporaucOus rejection OF
that treaty except by process OF reasoning similar
that which occupied the heads OF the two worthy Old
women, by placing himself under the shclteriug wing
of the eminent Senator referred to, II is difficult 10 see
IT wore useless 10 attempt to rcfute such logic. But
kr; Motley and the world knew that the nostlhty
Tao San Domingo treaty had accomplished
All thai they could accomplish toward its rejection
many months before he WAS invited 10 Iohgn, lie
sreQty was admitted TO bc practically dead and was
and before the GeceaSe of the iusriOus states
Of Great Britain This event, which took place on
Motley 10 make place for successor, who might be in
trusted with tne negotiations IN case disposition should
20 enter tc discussion aud adjustment OF the Alabama
HAMILTON Fsu.