The Petroleum Centre daily record. [volume] (Petroleum Center, Pa.) 1868-1873, 1871-04-13
VWaNft PR CGNT.
oP1Nl0N oF JUDGE GBIGR


a, write VITA 81 icaty can c,.ly state he con
cl,t.ion Ia which my utiud lH- cOue after ears,u
e.aii,i,ia;lon Of tl,i- Case.
inv c,,m ilu,lit hrs cNhib!iei II patent date
.jt. I Aprti. ipib. ti.s l. l'lui latiy evidence
b, .j,d title Md puts on IT," respont,uts the nt.y-
4'n uf 'tor' t..oj ;Dv piIsm is sod or wo.ttl,ss
rcei uu; 'ei'@' ia. e.natk' '.ile case oi G"od-
.e.r ". ljts e H4u {. {. Rep; -:AJ bit nos
i,'u thea ae s.lur'ii!i- ru -. LoCisO vi icli T.
- ic. tlei " 10 t. . itrseEt csse.
A, tAr Infringement "a tnD patent is aliuhtvt,
thJ nut 4u' -uon Mil ne i's 10 The validity vi com
yiI'nsird patent Ui ,iri +',ioJS.
1t Wa nt.rr speculation hsG been reduced TO
Practice AID g,er iei.t.,t4 experiments, that Tue
cOm;IlrrnI succeeded IN ~ NefvOD,;hg ne prejudice
ana iCnuiun1C %; the people the subject, and
cr.ualing the pupiic ,aat his invention Was useai;
amer he EI established lts guat uitnt, aud yHiur,
ani when ;ils gen u nuu patient .Ance, in
suite o. .ilccrs and scul-,n CON ple,ely snc
ces,fnl that Heed, who had before made expert.
lenls the same subject, aud was Unsuccessful,
imagiuei thai hc had tie Dcst si.ht e. ueinyeniun,
Il, L after purchasing "nr of hsp'o ooupia.nani-to
peGp,.s he applied on The ist al November, 1851,
fer ~ tt,.ii ior Substantially the cumtiua
tull- of devices and alhihe contained in comp ai
aui', Id,cnt. Un the ivrn ui u.e saist inon,n the
r-iui.!.n fu.lilel ~ t,usrNea iutuu Cu'pnuy or
colpOli ion called ir heed i"rptdu Company,
for r.e purpose u! rr,;nis Tee C,lu,. ,.lanttis in.
,ei tiU. a.L -ErpJriiu, tne eNrerse VI litigation,
lbd thu- doiau,. MA, fl Ia. irui~. They have ier
seyer,1 even aiIur tho pre- iminnly Injunction VERY
properly gtanlc! by tie District .u'i.e.
let Il deere hc CATERED i"rccnp,annnt for per
petuai ,ujiinciio. a,ld CHESTER appointed 10 Jake
AZ account according 10 lAe prayer oi the bill
IL. I. GRlEk, Judge
NorE The yassage refs rreG to BY Judge Grier IN
hi. former d,el,'uI, NaAuce, p 80 adopted ns
spp irs,blo to thi- CHS. wa Tvs follows
'ii Is u-uaiiy The case, when any valuable di,cov.
cry i vildc ur any new nuciue of great IL ity |.
invented, that thea teiiton Uf The public has rctB
lur, II To tlt subleet previously. and that nai,y
,pr.o,, t,n>,. BEEN makitg RESEARCHES GLi cApari
,nents, tn ios'p'ers ai'i incehanicias may i'av,
~ some aturr anticipated N their spyculNtions
..il v,,.-p ity ar probability ol such discovery or
tnvrntio.: many experiments have b' suCc,ss ful
~ .,., cun.iii very near Yet ilin. short at t,r
-if,,i result. pney have producer n0IniAg bruv.
fcipl. 'ihe inyrutipn ~iei iictcctcQ may tnliy he
-4id to be the ci'rinA'uy pn,nt OF lnAnv cyIrri
iuen = II. pnty hy the inTcntGr, bll hy many 9th.
r- te Iiiy hiy, prutc,i indirec l., by the ,lr-ic
cc--il!l experiment. and tiiinres ii u,hrE, but
i've. them ri.it 'u "A N ~IlC Oi the hC nor Of
ire prod, Or the sit. It'll inventor il is whpu
.,,tcu lauM ts been IeGuccd 10 practice, when cX-
etiiltrt tn resulted Va 'li.C Uyory aua when tLNt
ia .cuy,ry i,r- h-n perfected iy lErnt ant rOn'i,-
urd e e<p-rimcnts wbvu sr'e new c,n,lOdud. ant,
,,,,nutcturn, mncnc has BEEN ihu- pruducrd
l.ch /, uspf,l to the pHtc. that the patty IFiugii
b.run.1- apubic Du,f ficlur and emitted 10 Il lH eut
md I.L ,ici. y,iu7 and pail " prrrcve!.Ii,ct
have ut length ~uccrcdci. Ia spite OF -ivtI- rnd
-vOil- me veiunbl, invention ar Cisco'e y, how
seldom il IL iolluNe'! by reward Envy lub- Lin.
of the upnor, ~ hiic spcCulStO.s, swnr :, and III.
.alrs r.D tin I'll TIC p-nfts. Every Unsuccessful
* ,erntn'er who did ar did or did lot come very
n,s,c making discovery nrw ciaiih- IT, Every ona
who can invent All npr''N efncat or vary its :urn
claim. ighl Ia iiraie 1lic original nisCuNny VI,
need nor summons OrBe, or Blanchard or Wood
worth u prove tat this ~ the usual history OF eve
~ great discovery OF Invention.
THE present case agds another chipic- tn th.s
i,ng anu ,iuiforn hiotory."-2 Wallacc, Z. y E.-
ports ~!