The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1871-04-23

description the relation in which Paul and the o.heI
Apostles Peter-al fundamentally wrong ana
ought TO condemn own book and confess .nas nnv
neither understood Lukes acts OF The Apostles nor 'h
The new doctrine of the the Pope with en-.
Church. .nss syman p ,m. , be-
psSps
w 70 sSs M ws ssyss ons
the abore and can punish tina, no
ohs position and S'1SSp. ssn
that Papa or w church n history and
with the Fathers WIN .a ns m
:: e TnSS ann dn 'uS
For 10 possible thai there should e S ,wS
tune Ssns .mp ply ns rspa
OF the he may through the him
from Rome mighty long as hi. principal allow;
friar to whom Pope has granted abundance q rriv,
m has been hea
the bishops IN Rome sha. they have been told tine more
'ss power en- y;.,oa T6 !;
sap s %gGS asc;
that a. r. as Ssv ms
continue TO be aguaes Of the Church but no 10 Longer e.
which msss sSah
I; The pSps on the h o. a % By
aon We know that these were frS r..
p Of asr
in the decree TIA. the Episcopal power Is an s Rnmh
Sasonss are accustomed express. H. that the Pope
to Ss ss eu 70 uRs As s
s with had q, esn uGsd II s s
81 the seventh century pu. Away from himself win the
established, considering it a olasphemous asurpaion
and s0
venerable SIR took part IN the same by yorr The
decsraions Of the aGsrs Church. n. true
SELF presented the most serious asu,.s, opgo.i.on
discuss these difficult
ties prayed the Pope relieve them from the necessity
%hn the that sa
March exhaustive On the asson nsaoy,
70 De conducted by depuiaons chosen from both sides
with speeches in the Aa where regular discussion
As 10 the indspensab,ty urgent of such
ferences would ony quote here one instance consider
address hat fapa nia0iy SHOULD be raised donna
Of ana
these shining lights OF the Church has thus taught. Now
we'll y that ' 6sd
bis teaching in this instance almost exclusively upon such
ias,hcaons and never upon genuine PASSAGES OF the
his sualcsn, 70 conyince any prso,ced thee
Logan bis dealings With tased are stu worse
he later sSs had saocumbsa had Created
a
BEEN ndpensaSy to examine closely into hs
matter rs true that such an examination carefully and
suited proof Thai The theory Pipa insali6.y had
lated and and hsa then BEEN spread
and by force by the Of older eac
disposal Of the ruling power. '.oe
nothing Vas and YET the example Of the
sooen quoted Council OF Florence before their eyes,
the were laid before ihem led to
10 E1caeney that
.6e most careful COMMUNICATION Of .radon has In
about to issue resolution How great Inc
in ssS Certainly the rca..s Of Archoshop cardon
n s Ct s n
proof could not have supported examination for single
In the whole history OF the Church only know of
General Council IN which as IN hi. last those In power pre-
Second OF Ephesus the 49, there in the socaed
prOcesains imposed on III. s.s:msy The Papa Com
critical examination to be made Such examination
from state Of confusion which must appear pisiabIe 70
ssn.s s s ss the "9a
generally attach to it, council is only then ,heoioscay
free when free examination and discussion Of all objections
admitted and examined witt, the rules for
beginning was made in tins direction indeed the
|enae Z the bishops from Latin countries wanted
ssss.:ss nj; ana vi: s;:;.sass 4 Sss$:.;ss =
ss1;s those OF The Domncnn s,aSp Of Mondo Ghard
without pushing rest their case upon the unAssaAoe au
wen Known that The Jesuiis when they had conceived
the plan Of establishing Papa assoasm IN Church anS
The sc-caed saeTiacio dei inteeito and assured their
nnn s .c 81
adoraon OF the Almighty and the most noble Christian hero
light Of ,sifs.insd andsr.:sndHI di.csrnmsai
saoud throw himself with blind faith INFO the arm: OF
source Of religious fno@sdss And this Religious
20 The d9y
@ q has an
historical eannaon to abandon the same hut As lar as
no. YET descended 10 this poin. deiuson They s
10 human to human search and NINA
appeal history. does the which has
In pastoral letter has JUS. been Bishop
%
in lie Hog nna s IN
rs p"; s, by n, God and
ssd al other fully
these words But the question is then IN the presen, con
decided upon according % The in
e as Of e.ey
otsasS celons h.iors III. pc
.ss !ss%.s;s; BON Fsss and s.ssSs al:
themselves under he eomnon law co. Their their
Is:Sa.On; are endure they mus. ad. As.
nesses :, with the requisite sitting and critical
ali men Of capacity in historical matters able 10 give Us
ruth and certainty There therefore and remain
Firstly 1. the truth thai the three sayings Of Ohri.s
ali centuries in the whole Church in the which Is
given them namely that OF infaliby boundess
universal granted thereby TO the Popesl Secondly
that the ecclesiastical tradition Of all time In
h
these questions mus. be answered in the negative not
permissible to appeal Bishop kube others do,
the assistance OF the Holy Ghost promised to the Pope
the oDeds OF faith due this account to Tor
what to examine into historically Just whether this
assistance has been promised 10 him. And where this
Not in Council for there Cardons
cpal treatise proves Publications Stunned,
and entirely unreal picture OF tradition given
a suppression the striking and
monies And e precisely this which ready 70
And Excelency consider that the doc.
trine which adopt forms its nature,
by the declaration Of the Pope himself BY the
all infallibists fun damentai article of fahthat IL IL
question of the rgu id OF the rule which must decide
be believed and what Ia not In future
Catholic Christian could only query why he
eves this that follows believe deny
the infaibe Pope has believe deny
it, Nor this frat principle OF faith, the uoy Scrip
necessarily should most clearly show been
doubtful the Churchill must at every and
among every people have governed the whole Church
ike a brightly shining star--must have been placed
In the front OF all instruction: and ali wait
for explanation how is to cleared that only after