The New York herald., 1871-09-19
TEE RATIONAL GAME.
The Goldie Observation-Disclosures Of 1870 vs.. The
Atlanttcs Of 1S7c-Defcaf Of the New York;
ers nv cf fo q.

The Goldie observation-disclosures Of 1870 vs.. The
Atlanttcs of 1S7c-Defeaf Of the New York.
ers by Score az IS 10 8.
About twenty-five hpi,dred persons. assembled on
the Union grounds Willamsr.-Is' YESTERDAY AFTER
noon, 10 witness The match betweel. 'he "uiuais
and Ailantics. as they existed last seas.rn The
game was gotten up exclusively by Mr.
Brodie. The eqisient aud energetic reporter of
Wilkes SPIRIT for The benefit of the family OF
the la;e John Golde, who was at one tune Tho =
baseman for the MQtuais, aitar - - nrst
same Position mo- muich he filled the
Aorris'" ..sG admirably for the Unions, OF
That the affair was success Is shown
concusivey by the fact that to-day the treasurer Of
the fund Will have TO perform the agreeable task OF
presenting to the widow and orphans the snug
little sum OF SLOT the amount taken in at the gate
twas announced that at the conclusion OF the ball
match game OF Lacrosse would be played by yhe
members OF the Knckerbocker and Manhattan
Clubs, but FOR some reason as yet nezpaned, MOTH
ing of'the kind was done, although the majority OF
the assemblage waited patiently ior upwards or
half an hour
As Tor the game Of bail, IL was, as whole only
mediocre, although at times there was shown by
both sides some really fine play Had the Mutuals
played as well US dd their opponents It would
have been game TO remember, but
as 1t was they, at least two or three OF them,
played In a manner that might possibly be consid-
cred haf way decent II they belonged TO some third
rate country club, but which was wholly mex
cusablo IN players OF their reputation and standing
IN the profession For instance, the manner in
which Charlie Mills filed his position behind the
bal the short time he played there was the worst
that has been seen on the Union grounds for a
long while. lie caught for VOTERS three
innings, and for Marn one during which time he
had tn ola nf
players their bases. Next on the list comes Swan
deil who made four errors, each OF which was Of
serious nature But perhaps they will do better the
next game they play.
to hS that pay ne m me ,es Aacs a ns wnsn
or the seven errors committed by them
five are chargeabie 10 Ferguson, who was in
q great measure eXcusable owing 10 severe injury
To his right hand which he received early i'll the
game. Cummings although at times q little wild in
his delivery was nevertheless very effective as the
total base hits by the Mutuals attests Start was as
efficient as ever at first base while Pike and Boyd
1lled their respective positions most admirably.
'Bad Dicky" played at short stop in real old-lime
style, while Chapman, Hall and Mcdonald never
filed their respective positions more to their own
credit ADD the credit Of the old club than upon this
occasion. Chapman was indeed particularly brit
nans 10 lett field Wnere he captured three flies in
WE We nave saia that some Of the Mutuas played
most most shameiuily This is true; but we should also
themselves quite differently Among those lat
Ger were Woters, who never tried harder
innings he pitched yesterday; T. Mills. who filed
his Old position at first base as he only can Gl IT.
way, Is deserving OF more than special mention Tor
the amount OF growing he did not do;
greater poTon the eame a0ofa1ns Eseer ho fse
caught for him most admirably ana Patterson,
a mn0 Playea m wen his old Position at lett field These
ton all Of them. but nevertheless well. Had O..
NILS ms and Swandeli done half as much the game
would have been much better one The following
Is The scorer