The New York herald., 1871-02-10
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES.
WASHINGTON, Feb. 9, 1871.
PEriIInNa PgEsENrrn

PETITIONS PRESENTED.
Mr. wAaD (rep) of N. Y, presented petitions of the
homeopathic physicians OF westcheser county, Dutchess
county, schoharie county and Steuben county, York.
the incorporation national university
Washington, DC.
Mr. STEVENS (rep1 OF N H. presented petition Of the
Assstsnt Marshals OF New Hampshire additional COM
pensaton in taking the ninth census
MEMBER FROM GEORGIA SWORN IN.
Richard "A. Vhteey, member eect from the Second
onice.
MI EooPkR rep OF Mass, moved to go into Cemraiee
9 s s . H 70 s s with the object
a o se Of gave we notice .oI
bl " 'De 'AAe 1p 'ne naval Appropriation
srEaxrs stated .ha, q would in order for the
proceed TO the consideration of the Naval Appro
iha. motion would men s. he q the 70
stated that would be the right Of demand
the reading OF bill se as the laying them aside could
Mr. HOOPER moved that all general debate in committee
Mr. DAWES, !repl ., hs. appesled to Mr.. Hope. no.
could not be ID hs, way He should e, the regular
Appropriation 81 bills Be proceeded Win Calls TO
bate 70 one minute and was agreed toyeas los, s
mttee general to take up the bill to
repeal The income tax ana l ioS 50
The vote REGARDED question the .entmen.
TeTs great Of s4eile@en among @emssr ssn
after the roll ca and before the
the o.ass were made The o the
The following is the vote in detail
YKAEMessrs Ames, Archer Armstrong, Asper, A1tcl,
Aver Bailey Banks, Benjs, ain, Bennett, ethdne, Bgg
q
M Clara ao reIss csrfs h.n Gs,ead Cook
s1n.weh Ferris rsS ssaea de.s Gilman. Dsslasts sasG
oo1s h sss 5Ssi
kss osS G GGan q
Tss.y, Myers, Nbaes o'Ss orb Psrec, Peters Phelps
seos sssaoa ess La 0Fss sssa%
Tmss ss
Wood e sSd % Of Mass wes
s;s
6onser oopnor, Greos Dictey, lncknson. pox, Duke,
e.
ksy ks .sh hr
mick Xccrary MoGfew, McNesy Mercur. Mines Moore Of
land pomsroy PTOsssr Rainey Rice sawyer schamaker
S@h s q oIsssa ssssen., ssSs1 sssass:eD sss!ss
ws.sr Wbseisr wh.Ino5e, wilkln.on, Willard Williams
SaTa vi 1aa '0n Of oh'0 "'nAn' ""'Ae Won and Wood
INorE-severa OF the Pennsylvana members request
the reporter state that they voted because the bin
repeal the income tax far down the calendar
duty On sSes .Seis he
e on fan @ n % u 20 ss & the n Of @
this the bill itself could have amended BY adding
The resumsd the 1se OF
BILL 70 REMOVE THE BRooKLYN NAVY YARD.
mi.ne, opposed be BILL One Of The objections
In the deed conveying large portion OF the yard gov
eminent there clause providing that
s ns
of New York par, OF the property sold did
Of oesa.d e BY %
cents week being deducted from every person
e navy hosnef objection was the great i'm q
buis within ten years tor less than four millions of dol
ars.
vision made for the establishment of navy YARD
the vicinity OF New York AS to having the Of
enent done at private shpyard his answer TO that
that All the great private shpyards with the Morgan Iron
Works tbs Allsire Iron Works and ali the other great
chine shops Of New York, closed, Congress- having
esisaed away their business II would be little short OF
insanity to remove the Navy Yard from Brooklyn place
II al New London, leaving the great city couatry with.
out any means TO rely upon for of offence Defence
The debate further continued by Mess Starkweaher
an6 scoheid support OF the bill by Messs Cakn,
maker and Wood against II and by Mr. Ketcharn support
aaIo and establishing In the State OF Ecw York
poninent Of @ rep q s,nn, opposed me az.
.ne seestlcn OF locality ~ which The commits
aeh non OF the relatives might he interested
suns cut the names o. the commissioners lea wing
sIponrm ~, mr. sni q sae eoniIis ion e TIE President.
mind Ms . the mera question 1t L. nj IL,
dlAcntsoa b now he conyn that il wond be ey-
ceedingy se IN Btoogyn Navy Yar5 Th-re
was 70 Ste eher Long Issrd or on the Hudson
fver hes Lcnoou portsmouth, Lcage or any or cr
place more suary ADAPTED Tor navy yard the very
& sue reFe y: BrSokyn Nay faid located In his JUDI
Mr. ARFIgID lrep olo declared himself N favor OF
proyeins fo- commission TO be chossn by the Presoe
for the purpose OF nauirns ihe ,e o lie pronery
the Necessity sn Ps.r5s,y o the rsmoy. the neeess
y SskAsa ~ 4ylaG Alpa ri nN ha,A ~ p0piEiSs d