The New York herald., 1871-03-30

" upon Congress- The Senator Mr Haran must either admit
that the hsa as1rpea this pcwsr or else blot oa
bad been shed in this unlawful desposm did essen the
Mr. HARLAN sontinued he said we had always treated
with the Indians as NATIONS and had carried on
%sS isaia% isss. S9s Isss
Se assi q
the Sao 'hA'
Mr.. HARLAN also heard Of the bombardment
S s RGg s'
sSf IS Y s.o.:sa
Summer ss%ns .g Ss. tn; s ss" All s sss.s
ss x rs
o, % s wa, siS s sSs
ali hoaors should % ;Aowsrsd upon, hin q
n. Sna I ~ s1 ma'
Sefe. his and to secure the Executive choice
of Missouri friends Of Senator Sch had been
Mr. soHUnz nterrupsing stated, with much warmth
and emphasis that this the Grs tims 20 hs knowicg
desired ssy charge was absolutely unioundsd The
h 70. ss ss
and po'i9n ~ Of Senator Of the United States
raSs oS aur%a.s o. approval % IN the saiispe
\: as b had bis
and that the senator from Missouri had too hastily jumped
i deny y .ucs charge IN "a
Se Senator pretend tina. hi. conclusion
Of ra SSs s as ssr ders. TO say 70 III.
MT L. was M to say he chesru submitted
ne HHhIAs prefsrred % tbs. the Senator should u.s
e'0 but
had right 10 Judge Of the Sincerity the Senators ooarss
M s nG aaS
shuseis claimed TO 10 friends Of General Grant but
summers Speech President Grant the head
Gained sy kF srIs Nj s
Ms ss 81 aSs %
night and to devise for whose suppression Con-
s s s s days &! and s
e rspae @ a q Rs
T1s the srs in & with the
s.s Mr. sIrHnAs eD Of ohi0 any one COM
NJ to Mr.. shsfnsn- i can answer f that T. '.
ses s;s
ne S e n'
!hst he moment NY signed The treaty and Ssfsrs
United states: Calhoun, though authority aus:
S sss ses; c% .S hts %
houns argument on the despatch to Ne1co already quoted
permit Texas invaded while negotiations were pending
Mr. Han,n contended there was no escape from this
lie quoted from Bentons Thirty Ysas on the point
and concluded by moving to lay the resolutions Of Mr. Sum
MI SUNSET i hope the Senator win allow an oppor-
as gEyfsss ! ss.ss ss Question, Question:
asked the Senator from Iowa lir. Hsran whether be
Mr.: HHELAs-I must insist the motion The honorable
Senator (Mr summer has been heard all the way through
ton, attempted answer ali be has put s.'
s ss 70. s wss ny y Ed
the noor and continued to address the chair.
The WOE PnEsiDENTThe motion is not debatabIe. Tho
!. ns " scat
The question being here put the Chair declared that the
Mr. EpSusDs !rep) Of vYs', let us have the yeas and
@
called the Of Mr.. Ames, who answered in ae anrma
Mr. THURx AN-Mr President--r sE gc rsTsg9 ETH
SEVERAL sE sEyAToRs-Questiorl Question: -.r -.a
The vIoE PRESIDENT hero raped order with his gave
but above the and confusion Mr. Thnrmans voice was
Senate before where the of resolution not
Mr. ceSSLISe rep) Of n. y. objected Thurman's
The VICE pnrs,prsr-TAe prohsei. this
The VICE PREslDEST-The Senator from Massachusetts
moi in OBJECTION to- has essn made Dy n sena ma
senator from Mississippi has answered to his name.
Mr. sUMSER (sdl on his fect-l did not know that the
Sen ator- -
MIR. EpMUNps-I objec, to debate OF any kind.
Nr. SVM,'FR ircpeatlngl-l did not know. -
The VICE Pre- Senator from Massachusetts Is
of the rule and the Chair trusts the Senator will not
the painful duty reminding him OF IT,
Mr. SUMSER-Not all. / did not know but that the
Senator mi ght withdraw his motion.
me- me- Chair s from
expressly whether he would withdraw the motion and
he sad he He said this to the Chair in the hear
ing of the Senator Massachusetts, The roll call win Le
resumed. .
Clerk proceeded with the roll call when Mr. Har
an motion to lay on the table was W nays
only republicans voting Messrs Patterson,
Robertson schrz Sumner The negative vote in detail
NAYs-Blair Casserly, Cooper, Davis of KY Davis Of
West Va, Hamilton OF Nd Johnston. Kelley Patterson,
Roberson Salisbury Schurz Stevenson Stockton Sumner
and Thurman-N.
table, paired Mr. Carpenter the other side, who
absent.
Absent not votngMessrs Bayard, Caldwell CarEen-
ter, Fenton, Ferry of Conn., Flanagan, Lewis Logan Nor
r Of Me-, Morrill, Of w. Scott, Spencer, Upton, Vckera
Mr. SnERaANs resolution nstrucing the Judiciary Com
mttee report bill disorders In the South was
taken up and the then forty minutes past four
adjourned.