The New York herald., 1871-11-20


the Paulne. ne ear sed but liule spanish, never
hea u hm convcr-ing 10 spanish; lie used 10 say,
~ wish tnat knew ~panish us wei as YOU do;" ]
di. mol 60 with MN 20 deliipila ne went there on
his way BACK 20 Sa ltiago.
rhe Attorney General reao long letter or the
witness 10 Mr. .osloTd, giving an account OF the
proceedings Mr ltoger ricnDorne aud then ques-
TONED ihe witness about \,
wines continued: w hen Mr.. 1ichborne returned
TO paralso he tod me tnat he htd rid len ninety
nne a,iies sht OH IN ten hours; he loo ked as
thou IN ne nad done il.
G. Dii ae look IKE The picture IN: .waterton,s
Wanderingsf' A. ! cannot say; may nave said
30 ! never neard oil the accident oI The mule
tumhirg dowu the prc:luice In The muuniailis. un.
t'l nelri oI II In this country; met traveller
| Painsas nm / auiit think mat he tod me Of inc
| q chem; was WIN run when ne had his liz cness
taken; nc did not say lhsl ne had it taken IN case
| any hing should lie all nm.
| The attorney General called the witness attcu-
non {. one oi ms letters wn,iea AT thc time. IN
whicn nc SAID, "A likeness OF hiin m Case anything
should befali .m9n
Witness lie did not have them taken; had them
taken aud sent one TO Lady Tchoorne and another
III Attorney Geueral-Iu one Of Roger Tchbornes
Santiago mad lwo vers Ia,r lIkcnesses taken OF
me- sen, one TO Lady iougniy AID one 10 your
Witness II was my notion having them done,
au,l, rs | eXpaine on lorfner OCCASION, / rot
then ny a rus ne did not know they were being
done
Tie Attorney Genera In letter OF yours you say
1 10 Lazy Doughty ''Air T. dresses a. sailor and
prevailcd upon him 10 ger has hkenes, taken by r.
4 Ayleseary. Tie da aerreotypst. | must realty say
pressed him much 10 nave II DONE" How do you
exptday
nltncss-Tneie mng mcorrec,ness IN express
sion. am stn urdcr the imp cssoa thai hc dld not
know that tiicy were lakcn and IuaL ~eat them at
nv owl notioa ana not at nss re luest.
the i,ord aici Justice Alter nearing his letters
and yours read 40 yoa adhere iony
Wiiness-fhc letters read impy that am wrong
now thinS tnat had better say that the letters
are correct ana thai what stated Is lucorrcct
TO the Attorney ucnefal-Wliat said belicve 10
pc lie positive TRUTH
WlLlless-I remember the sknn,ns or the alba
tpuIi iu tIlar
because M. Tichbulne forbade me putting an, tang
in concernirg hlu,; did MOI ooey MIN 10
the full exteL; | always remembered tnc hook
acetdccl; did nW rcme,ner the accident from
the n,batross striking Mr. rcnbo,ne with the wing
until ncafu II In ouri; hear piantirs exam.
nalion al the Jaw instii ution he spoke ABOUT the
hook accident: had no conversatiJ Jn with anvoody
at Inc Law institution abo II The al atross never
sad that he had MA e .'hash- of the alpatro-s;
read II the newspapers yonr questions upon it and
1t very mach uiprised me as lar as can recolle,
tie y aintn's account here ~ 10 The accident with
the atuatrOss's wing was correct. he book now
9sidca 70 me !, III "a, nandwrh,ng y IS my diary.
last, we written by me IN Edlnpurg IN 1866, the
pr vious part nav.n, been write, IN 1853.
To Tue i4oru Chez Ju ,tce Thls Is the diary gave
TO Mir. ItlilngtOn.
Exanna'oa continucd-n was then In its pre-
sent stale. inere are various mate that have been
added INC. is,S. There are cuttings from news.
pap"ra aud oshci matters there.
10 the tord Chief JusticeIhis diary was written
day oy day as The events occurrci.
ne Attorney. Cencrai IL Is headed "Diary Of a
Voyage from Hdvre lie trace TO South Amerca.n
Thai ~ wha, made me ask.
Witucss--l mi-ht have put he heading once;
never expected that tins book would come into a
cour 0l Justice | put down anytnllg tnat came
into my mind rs &c occnrfei; tie book was bound
IN dinbnrs m the beginning oi 1857 or the end OF
s5s IL had Deea pound oeOfe but was laillns TO
pieces.
4. You VIII see memorandum in pencil9 A.
Yes: twelve iiank leaves 10 ne Inserted;o here Is
another pencil mars, Twelve BLANK leaves tU be in-
scried AT the he lnDng and Gle end oil he book -
II its oeen reeonnd onv once, and all these leaves
weiei serted at one time.
1ne Attorney General Why were those leaves IN.
sertedp it lc 10 pieces aud had 1t repaired. and
aud these NY leaves placed i'll; afterwards wrote
IN i anything liked, anything that Interested mc;
there are Ieaves inserted between the accounis OF
the voyage nut and n Que hone this seems q
naturai place to put tnem IN: should never have
mad The book rebouud but for the excitement ol the
The Lord CHIEF Justice-The accident with the
aieltross "a on three oi tue additional pages. Have
you looked to ee whether Il is in the on II horizons
W,tncss-i am quite satisfied 1t cannot he; wrote
IL afterwards bccaa ie was t0rndden TO mention
an,t hing about It, even il u letter.
me Al s0rney t,cneral --iasen:--"I have let the
davs cfare tins pass without making any remarks
dentaIiy near lost an ecu
w:tncss-i am quite surprised to ind II there I
hal forgotten H.
There tnel follows long account or the AFFAIR."
Iae a Auorass soc ,,, Sra.saaye You ever gwen
o. M bc.ci, ualcs5 II nsnl nave been 10 Mr. Gus.
ford: the earlier part. as al as arriving " Fat
mouth, seat 10 nv father; burnod IL a ter my
j may have sent rorion Of the diary
TO Lady licnoorne or Lady Dournly; not tho
auanied win her I, do so. rne letter naudcd to
me- dated Aasust 10 = rom me % Mr. Gosiori.
Journai.'
The Lord chief Justice Looking at the two say
is the letter an extract from what You say Is your
orG'nal JoarnhS A. may nave done 1t from
me.aory.
to 9Th OF June Dnd you make ail that IRON
m mJry wtupul seeing yolr a arY2 A. MY im.
pres lou IS ihu wroe from memory nay by day,
wain.. III couln ger a snin. may have used q
wrong w"rh "a calling ~ chtr!cis'
The Attorney Gcncrsi--W"uia y9u say extracts
so; u white aae Thought hal made no extracts
from nv diary; "role TO Mr. Goslori a. mad
tiine but 'uay have made some pricf extracts
wine wrote the rest from memory: is II upon
Cnlleaa paperf II 80 mus. have written IL atter
arrived.
the AZ orney Gencral-t do not know.
hr. sergeant Ga.laniinc-Leti the witness look. and
ito G WITNESS read very word before You answer
apnu il.
altne.s-l could mol swear the diary was written
on TUE das eacn entry neafs tate; y migh be writ
ten twu or inrcc days afterwards tue entries also
IN ,he letter 10 Mr. Cos ori we're also made within
Two T turee days OF tncir dates.
The Attorney Gcnci al-in letter TO the 3otn OF
luae. issS. 70 Mi. u s!ord, yon say Il sana YOU =
very ronin sketch Of Journal TIA, You SUGGESTED
sh nld keep" A. " was y rough sketch; nave no
ier Ionrnat than that handed 10 me io-dny; may
have nJu memorandum Ks; I may have them
now; may have .wenty; your insinnalio, that
nave two journals Is not lrue IN 1867 was IN service
Win Mr. F.ccacr. o t.lingburR: | inca went tO
nv uaS' ~ Ar se se a a. nson ne ,s ~As rsa
son o his olsen rgInt me; nc assigned no particu.
lar reason ne inlilll nave SiId Lnai 9ot drunk;
had CONVERSATION wiin Mr. fitzgerald. relative
OF ~ raiupt. al,0ul This case Nj. Fitzgerald wrote
down saienleat made. and signed ~; was
trnc to Inc best oi my belief.
the aocancnt was read II detailed journey OF
w,ln ;ss 10 The piaintll'S ~ Essex Niil1 Er0yd0D
IA company win Mr.. Gcddcs wno knew Nj. Itch
hurne. IL also stated t0 witilss belle tnat TIC as
NJ Lhe Roger iichnorne nc had travcIed with.
Tns document was dated March. 1857.
Witness coaiinued--i I only saw him walk INTO the
house; Was most prciidiccd against tc painItf
nnll heard nliu cAamlnrh III The Law INSTITUTIONS:
] kn0w Ills. ssntehan's servant; net nm at
The CJburg IN Cnares -tre Z. Grosyetor square, he
thca N The service OF the p!aiDtUl: may Aaye
SAID to him, "Ht Is no more Rogcr tBan Won or me'
he might nave replied, but the od laay ac.
kn0wlcsigcd niin.v
The Atlo,ney Genera-pid you saw MY dear sir,
II they had scnt over an Egyptian mumnv and tick
ctc,i IL Roger Iicnburne' she would have arknow-
ledgcd ~ ncr sunY' a. ueg ner lady ysniD's par.
don u SAID thai, but possibly mighl auS Shier);