New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1871-05-23

Questions. n could have ol would not have
called you. WIN yon stat 20 'c cr Sii' PHinam.
~ will Won state what ~" Itc Wha! a. ~" %.
wcTg y9n P pre- ,c 4 lie la ~ S. Like Hos!ta
g On Whrt day it. a. T.c 4JtA OF April SATURDAY
mo 10 W., W., Won his wife3 4. Yes. Sir.
Cross y mined by Judgc 't-r. >,
O. Mad an were you acquainted with Mrs. Duydl A.
q. She never visited your famiiy' A. No, Sir
TESTIMONY OF MRS. ANNA DUvAL
Mrs Anna Duyal, the lady In whose company Mr. PUT
nam was on the night Of his death. was next examiner
by Distrct-Attorney Garvin.
Mrs. DuvalI reside at No. 7C1 Broadway and reslueu
there on the Goth OF April last that evening lett my
house in company with my daughter ana MI. futna az
four minutes OF ne' ana tOo6 ae - The Church Of the
Advent my daughter, who there singing OF was
practicing should say; my daughters name who was
With M IS Mabel Virginia Duya there were several per
in the car not more i3n nNe or SIX ON, , i
was n charwoman; when tho car was going mp mink
about Sixtocnthst Or scventcenthstI cannot he sure
man cot on the front platform OF the car but we DID
Not MT P anS t Were talking frs OF the weather and
then aerward OF the new buildings; the car went az
or TWeuty, sev;enth-st Mr. Putnam called my
daughters attention to the clock the Gilsey House. aud
she went to the door Of the car 10 look AZ ~ as she at
standing there said, "By the way will go ana iook ~
HelmbOlds store; have never seen II III up a. 90
passed to the other side of the the right side GO
ing up-and as sat down man looked III hV,octcd 10
AND sXcnGed there was man standing 70 the le S6
hand OF him the platform and as nc his hand on
Ss coat and the man looked around and mmed
atey drew the door open little WAYS eiSbt inchesl-
and he did SO May said some rude Reh Door S@
the platform" Obected TO ana eXoi' -. nne side: had
10. sbnt the door and drew her 10 one euO' ra,Tn
NO. sooner sSut the door than the door was GrwY Y
open again again shut the % the door was thrown
open probably half and this man pu' tho nstorm-the
doOThs man tR MAJ Putnam as he threw the door open
the third time Mr. Putnam rose from ms sea anu door
Wbat g. the meaning this g. and he closed Ihe Ioor
& tt his seat again; he had hardly sat down when
fhe door was and he went again 70 u b IN
and aid "sr will not allow these aules 70 Do ith
tad thew are I'm nv company; :" holding the door WIN
his right hand he went on the platform ana snuI ~
hind him. he expostuated with the man, but whaV ne
said could not say; the man the prlsOnerLsalu,
paid for seat and am gong 10 ava to
Putnam then came into the car Daek~aru ,he eSe
his seat and the man came IN ana hesate1 AT Ine 49,
OF the door on the side that my tonE INV danSh
ter with my left hand and passed hef 70 ny S ~ said
~ am her mother and you are very rude !" he SAID
"Hai" said, " You are very experiments" he SAID;
vii not allow them to be- nsuited' and he called the
conductor, who told the man 10 slt dOWn anu 10
alongside Of Mr.. Putnam and ne ana VIC IenaiH0U
O. state whether any conversation took place between
MIR Putnam and prisoner while he sat on the seat III
the car or If anything said whateyerf A. Inc man
began 10 eer Mr. Putnam OBJECTED TO ana as his
business why he could not sit down there or why ne
I've the because was very nervous and excited at
the time however there was no se p
and put his knee Mr.. Putnam SAID 10 MN, III
had known you in liquor would not nave sp3E zen
TO yOu and Mr. Putnam folded his arms ana tureu S
back to the prisoner sideways; he sat SO Few minutes,
and the prisoner took his hat and began turning ~ ~ HIS
hands and he said, GLOW far are you gong up say
How far are you going upG Mr. Putnam dld MOI turh,
o tbe prisoner puf mis- hat on his head stood
p close to the seat and said "We am gong as lar as
he'll p and he shut his hand hard down beside him;
that s. sir what saw; he didnt shake his st at MN
ne shut his hand hard beside him and Strengthened MN
self up out of the and left the door VIDE open
and stood the platform and Mr. Putnaih GOT up a
fha dnnr nd said moi
his seat and his pOsture the car went on al ABOUT
tyan cot oui bnt no person got in that noticed and
we reached the corner between Fory-tfth ana Forty
sxth-st there were words, and no more loOks
and no more doors opened between FOrty-hfth ana
Forty sixthsts the conductor began 10 smut up le WI"
PeaS S let e ms out at Forty he didn't quite
and said "What is 1t, madam ana SAID tease
stop at Forty-sixthst," and Mr.. Putnam sald IN tle
same voice. Fory-sixth-st " my little daughter got
and out of the first and Mr. Putnam got up
and went out Immediately after heri got up aso, pSo
had been IL and could not get on ITe b l and a.
Strengthened up saw a running my right hand
as came TO the of the running from the front
because ' that man might knock against me-" and 1
FASTENED TO the platform to get OH and a. got On Ie
platform this man come around the cOrlie thls
thing came down lcarhook shown so, so twice witness
mOtOnng with her hands as gVlhg 2oW kf Pn
MANS aud skull Mr.. Putnam fell Ike lead r5snt
the track the Of the dsher at the end OF
q. Now who was that man that struck It., that
blow That that that insulted my daughter
q. CBy Judge Cardozo)-who was the mani A. The
man that they identify and call William Foster.
Q Now, will YOU state what occurred afer tIat' a.
came down of the car benumDed 90 not tihh i h9
and saving Oh Mr. Putnam felt as If he was Killed
az i me ana nto Ie and stood there sup
pose Screamed; do not know that did; my daughter
stood screaming, and the car bell rung my gdueneI anu
myself took his head and feet anu moved MN lIo LA
track he lying with his head across the track ana
the mean time heard the bell ring was conscious
that the ear was going away ana seieaiSa ta ~
the drug store Oh the opposite side of the way.
q. Now will you tell the jury If you please wnGa tne
is that you saw on the car that night anu ihcn
struck this blow Foster directed TO stand up A.
This is the man. Pointing to Foster.l
@. And did you enough OF the thing that ne nseG
on this occasion be able to identity III Car hook
with which the assault made was here shown wit
ness.j A. That looks like the instrument, siT. .,
q. do you TecOllect what sort OF nat 9r' uti '
woTel Hat shown witness.l A. That is Mr. putnam
examined by Judge Stuart, have resided at
q. Ar you a widow ladyi am not. Sir
4 Al unmarried lady A. No Sir; married iTG d aay
suppose ne is at Bridgeport; he Is travelling lor our
@ Wa he at home on this night A. He was not Sir.
O. Do sou know where he vast A. He was at lndiah-
q. Wei you married In the city OF Newforkf A. Yes
q How long had you known Mr. Putnam A. -Four
O. Were YOU acquainted with his family-any Of themi
"a good many OF his famiy-but not intimately.
q. Did You know his wife A. No Sir ~
q. Had YOU ever visited his fanily-hls homer A. NO.
Sir. ,.-,,
O. Had any members OF his household ever visited youf
A. some OF his country friends had, Sir
Q. No, no, lady; any OF his immediate famyf A.
No, sir.
o. Has he often called upon you3 A. Sometimes once
a week, and maybe, hour OF evening, maybe few
minutes. ~,
q Ever call with Others or alone generalyf a. MOst
ALWAYS with one else
O. Could you person he has called with during
the last six months A. He called with Mr. Herman
Henniberger and Mr.. Kingman. .
O. What time did he call that atternoon3 A. knew 1t
was 81 O'Clock by the girls telling me and as he said
binsCif; he was only in a few moments when came
INF he