New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1871-04-15
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES,.

Mr. HOLMAN Dem.. Ind.) renewed his prop
ostion Of yesterday TO allow the of the hail of the
House on the Path Of May next, 10 the Young Mems
Christian Association.
Mr. WOOD Dem. n. " SAID he would object, unless
,bere WAS an understanding that there to be po
tcal sectaran proceedings and he was AFRAID there
Mr. HOLMAN replied that the Association had no con-
hg MI oMc TSIs dem, M objected.
Mr. BEATTY rep, Ohio, from the Committee on
printing reported the Senate concurrent resolution
10 pit on Education with substitute reducing the
lumber to 5000 for distribution by the Commissioner
oosit6n' il being sustained by Messrs. BEATTY. H0AR
BURCHARD, DUNNELL, DAWES, and TOWNSEND,
sbhdpSSssW0RTH, and f. II. ROBERTS. The substitute
was finally rejected and the Senate resolution adopted
% to62. .,o,, n, pp,vuvcr
mrncKEE Rep. Miss called the attention ofthe House
20 hen made I'm the House by Mr.. Garrett OF Tennes-
see on 9Th Of April but not actuay lo h5S To
Nv. 10 senator AInes characerzing him as "a shoulder
strap puppy and potroon most 5efnre t6e House.
% a. Honse might visit on the author OF that speech
such condemnation such gross Dreach oi prNnese
Mr GARFIELD Rep Ohio offered resolution reeit
ing the offensive article and declaring that MI
nS Sd ne He and should therefore be repmanded by
the Speaker and directing the excursion VI 'ne SP'
Mr. cox Diem n " stated, at the request OF MI;
Garrett, that, before the mater nao yarninS the
IIn,
ons which his speech bore TO the rules OF the ouse,
songht 10 strike out the obnoxious paragraphs iO e
GioL, He was member, not acqualnuu WIN ' ~.
rnles and he Mr Cox thought that ANYBODY WeIe "
he selected for cenEure In such matter u shVuu 20
Older metnbeT for he could pick out dozen oluer i
hers who had frequently transRessed III the same Ie0
ton A.. ..o..h.x tr,r,,c..ed
Mr. GARRETT Dem, Tenn)-the member iinpn.cateet
std he had moi Intended commit any lnracuoh OF
the rules He had his speech written ana II ne hau uS
lyered n ne would have had the Objectionable aftce
read from the Clerks desk. If objection had Deeh ede
10 H. he would Of course have excluded u from us
speech He was willing now to have IL e4ciuueu Hoh
The GLObe. -, ,,.. Al, -.
Mr. DAWES Rep., Nass) expressed the opinion thn
the apology hardly went far enough. -.
Nr. ELDRIDGE Dem WIS., thought that tne gentle
man from Tennessee had made " "A clear thlng OF u
Mr. GARRETT said lie was willing 10 apologize 10 the
House for publishing what IN violation Of the rules,
but further than that be could not 60 Ia the way oI
apology.
luton that whenever leave 20 print speech Is given, the
member shall be pledged In honor that nothing personal
or unparamentry shall be contained IN IT, or any AMI
adyerOn any member OF the executive branches or
Tie Government, or on the House or Senate.
Mr FAKNsWORTH Qiep. III objected.
Mr.. BUTLER remarked, that he thought that member
would object.
Mr. FARNSWORTH-Persons matters are not always
supplementary. IL Is often necessary 10 DC personal in
order ~ speak the truth.
Mr.. BU1LER-Then let IL be said, and not printed be
hind mans back, like the act OF coward, IN the last
moment Of the session THE conclusion Of the sentence
cut on by the Speakers gayel.l
Mr. GARFIELD modified Ills resolution by providing