The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1871-04-15

fieloS 6uggosn0n-HoW the
Democrats May Get Out
Of Their Difficulty.
Albany, April II, 1871
Immediately upon the opening of the House OF Assembly
this morning Mr. FREAR of New York, sad:-Mr
Speaker rise to question Of privilege. present
the following privileged bill at this time.
Mr. ALvoRDI protest in the Of the parliamentary
law Of this House and OF this land against the introduction
The sPrAKHs-Ths Chair win accept tho gen.leman's
protest
stoned By NJ Ts:gn.iloa q the Sixteenth
MT LIITL being precedent in the legislation
Be- entered one on tie
The spEAEERThe Chair has announced that the gentle
MI FnEAE moved that the House go into commte Of the
Mr. ALyonD raised the point of order that required
The srHAHEaIae Chair viii decide that this being pr
veged bill the motion may be carried by the action Of the
Mr. ALvoRp desire TO tina. win not under the cir
& but DESIRE ao ba of S
protest against this invasion of the rules be entered
into he Whole cali as Sa's
ayes and ordered before proceeding to
the calling q roll TIE Chair ordered the door be
Ss:;Ssn csisd ,5s motion into Com,
then went Into Gommss Of the wSoe Mr. Frea in ' the
Mr. WEED asked that the bin be read through which was
done,
Mr. wEED moved III committee rise, report bill TO
the House and recommend IT. passage.
The and mad. their report and the Speaker
tie report Of the committee and orderns the bill to third
Mr. GoopR1oH called the ayes and noes thereon and they
eadns and sd o q &c
in The negative The lin therefore ordered to third
Mr. FnEAn moved thar the bin have IL third reading
and desire tina. lie Speaker win that requires TWO
'S TIs s sSpr.xrl-fhe Chair win no. so rule
MI n addition 70 my solemn Hsoss
q res -
s II s so. 3 c a; & Il me
Ss 8sSoaD cS dss sSs Speaker whether
r Hgs1 & s ITss a..s. :! ~ sse.s
s 81 S,aDsE dIm .ss ss Ss. y. appeal IN
NJ GHnAsox call he aitsntion Of the Chair the for
y s
Chair 81 s: w s e. s
orH a th nov u be third Fading
' Will Rs' i'ss Drv
Ey. GIE1sos-Thsn appeal from the decision Of tho
appeal Il not in order until Of this
noanced The result may be that the motion may get two
The srHAKEn-Ths Chair decides point Of order well
sir as n .ss
sa 's rules
b e r journal Of the House and
eRs s Il
appeal must be taken now or not q ALL and As one OF the
m MaSis 1eaI Rs q he rule: q the House.
without feeling and in oil Kindness and without further de-
H.. e
% s . when
IN tha fla h m
say this the nrs place let me that te accomplish
sss s 's
% during my
he House ju;ssd sr y Re pIosPss, q
"4 s aS.sa
resolution adjourn There . nothing sst requires this
as sid ia 'S.a ss' %
P ss s
S s SCS1 10. a.. AND 4: pp 1a and
issue and trust ina. she Chair win ali sood nature
s0Sq am Clearly he opinion SIR tina. as
seea saas n 80 81 & % N
terms that rose % point Of order yet was in fact
Garry H. understand the Chair 70 rule that il requires only
s
&c h: Be at 5 M
Mould not s ns or vote of %
suggests there Ss sSiFS vote o. The House
% sas %aeas a he be ' Be-
p ods, e Sng This mater "a close
ton Of the gentleman from oswego In the position Of
M TIELDsi suggest tina. th. House ha. no right
appeal from mere opinion expressed BY the Chair
Si;A e .,l q: gentleman from onon
ps,n; q orss, ...ss ne Chair
did not require twohird vote The Chair has stated that
ss s yo BE
h wf RrssSso remind my friend tina. IN.
much stronger one than Be states T. The ssnsmsn
S% s.
NAY his sd question nS Ss s
TO order The third reading require
sa: .pe .:f
sSSn s Tas Who " S
Joke upon every Ssc..Cn however solemn 4 Be, that
ms whether or republican
pna ss me oa..
p hold WI e. % 1. from allow
ss q Home SIS
s ss $, ss
Pss's sas y y.r s
S resy on The 'I previous
-fh the spss ,s Sss
CHAIR NOV. F !: Sshs -. So s''a.' w
Mr.. ALvORD--The CHAIR mas sOmeWnnt amplfhed my
swer upon that occnson has fully ataed the case
s:-That there very distinct
Lyon and that made p the ethsrgeneman the fol
through everything my friend from New York, the
gentleman Onondaga did that however Char
had the Chair emineny right
to-day and therefore ruled A. he did But have dstnct
that there dssmfarity between the
| lions made upon the different days.
The spEAKERI will simply state that the gentleman from
Mr. FTELps-T have no doubt that the gentleman from
| OncndaQA thinks he right IN both his rulings.
MrALvoRDT always In favor OF bringing In for the
jury, akd may that am always right do not DESIRE
Of he oiss through s Speaker that we may put upon
cord our protest by or appeal from the Speakers dec
upon mater At ISSUE before the House, and that
protest might wv come a this time as any other stage Of
jhs pSseednxs