The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1871-04-23
he Asserts tho Right Of Questioning the De-
cresS Of the Ecumenical Council.
TIE BISHOP OF MUMTCH's REPLY
"Bs Who Will Not Hear the Church
Iat Elm Be Unto Thee as a
Heathen and a Publican
DR.. D0liiuger Sustained by the Uni
yersity of Munich.


ilnger Dean OF the Chapter OF Vienna, to the Arch
bishop u Munich and Pressing, IN explanation Of
hts position with respect 10 the decree or Papal
tniallthutQ;-
xour Exceeacy has asked in two letters expair
ny ro..en VI respect 70 the Roman DEGREES OF july Is
Aa rsesrred in he circle Of your Cathedral Chapte,
pens sre used against sch priests s saSt
been guilty Of sross moral crimes, aud even bat seldom
sgnss these This is TO occur do not, within
period, snhrnn myself the articles of faith as K
Iiea 4 .. ,ims hat council meeting of German
Il q, es la when meeting al the German bishop
was hs.da Al ssrzburG the honor Of invitation
1a Ra1s that II 81 BE-
take part n the proceedings. but have audience
prepared prove before this meeting the follow.
ing hss & Of decisive importance for The
The Holy SCRIPTURES ST. Matt, is, and 81. John xx IL
and far nialibihyn concerned, the text St
npH sIand f,i: But We bound By solemn ostl
sea myssn Ave twice sworn to aSsep, and to explain
hs he
s I s.sfRsa ;s'
found sngs At an inallibiliy given to the Pope There
sssola soIaai' perjury And, have said am pre-
so,n ssyt al episcopal pastorals and notices which
have @ay Ared the assertion has made
hsi5rcA proof sought that the new doctrine proceed
.ss M hs rGg. s
ssiors IN the Church matters Of fah beginning
roash ~ sns md forever has been generally at least
s I ss9 Ssssq upon s an ss5s
20 s pisnssi facts and estiinones m 0i'e' con-
sss eia spse Of a' Ln
resy q a b. eassbocks from WHICH ae they soS
the aeas during their seminary educaron since proofs
"a these books the invented
..ss,se .As prov. ,1. aas, WIN the two principal
.. Lguori''
sn w s ss Hs.osss "a ,ss
%sp 81 caaon and ss ssso wns Of the
dI.treuiea curing the coSae.I and snslg
rs a:
s y s s S x. ons By the
bis insaibiiy that 18th OF July 1870
are IL the mos saring contradiction % these resolutions
~f ssiicss that shall Sc abe 70 prove that the new
sa e. he D Of sna .sSes. hs S thai
an ssans an o. thai to as Ell
...sly sw m my admission to tae Chameer Of the
nsssss.ry esn.esasnss; me Ba. Oman ssnss.@" and
spa and whh are
. y sccspses lnfalibe decisions ami are
81, e g me , opinion ssen By the ega faculty in
ernsa Iss ssal,J which your Eiceency may be pleased
only ASK two conditions for tn. conference which hav.
Dropossd % r.ser prayed ns that my assertions
view 70 their subsequent publication the second thst
man culture chosen by me- shall be al
Should ths be German bishops
Ca NAV pl.sss your Eieeiency to form ont OF the mem
5e Of ysa caihsdral Chapter committee before which
sss aos gentlemen doctors, and formerly
seo may hope thai it would be more agreeable 70
SEN e uts VII me in Guiet argument to COMPUTE me- II
yea. O. sas7 criminal sentence assn: me and to
saying !. il your Esc.hsncy, VIII consent to pre-
file - this conferences and win condescend to cor
rerta int wi I ma have
explanation Of testimonies and facts. shall
profit And you place before the prospso.
zoe g % - se , a %sy : sePs that
iness, rnoss noble, benevolent and mos, Christ.
s s. 81 and
nssr % reseNe publicly all tas, have written 10 th
the p.ao.
q the Clergy hsnGreds Of thousands Of the ay
think a.. All ind impossible to accept the art
o. y us day no. single even Of those who have
r,sy q the Of these All my friends
single person believes what hear day BY day from
MI bps soieIence such ss have proposed and The pub.
iaslght Witch 50 many long for
M er @e rs 90 ss
sy .slceai ..tfue.icn correction Of my opinion.
eject aPoa and am ready TO prove that there :
ar.nlsa .rsimouies which taken together with the
NC, se mos, important fact, ana counerproois
90 ss' - erson TO whom your Excecncy ntrusted this
Ss work az q. pfopossa eq.
hours or ssoid doing So to make public
lees p ne mser~vin, tina, the
5ssrnent DO requested to allow statesman learned In
e TIC case is one Of the highest importance for al
Sovetnments may be assumed that this not
srs Tsut presidents in the past history Of the
well as WIN he chars IL
cishops hed us sessions under the presidency OF the i'm
csoe bishops. In the year isss Boseman cantinss
.sasa q sss Mosnci o. basel and decree which had
= mes "a . me Communion in kind was now sub.
.enowsassd Ss s see P ,ssa c SSsanS
,sh ,ssa mpoa,.a, . and
ccra ssi greater similarity with the transaction pro
q Teh history between the Bishop DS fer 70 q
RyrsaA and the Protsstspt statesman , Pessis
sdsr s sasp.oss q K'Sg Henry ~ asre que.
. q S 5SoE sDo
b. Hacnsr.s, nenU himself presided and the most
wa wa nisap;.d s.f few day.. ans AFTER
eer q sosssys quotations had been Examined by h,
elect for the Catholic In the excited minds
os yspsrsss Archblshog = leave entirely to your owl
casholos and what psrsons you win invite 70 at
s yo1 wso n Be sss 70
f nsuon The practice OF the Church proves that u
sea .as 80 establishment Of the tradition whicl
~ Npe ard lheOogians have acknowledged And in this
natter for historical proof lam gladly 1ess e,
NO aasion and Of The Catholic faith. such men
'sv, heameni Hotter Arneih, hampschulte, Cornelius
90 a.ioricsy rant or not ""'"e' my ''0'''
fNf kAesency was pleased formerly 70 honor my book
snn was generally considered among German
pGss q &, g s %s 2.
~ ~ y, hsw assnss contain the truth then have