New-York tribune., 1871-11-21
rUu UrLTmA COLLECTS AGAIN.
IpLAS OF A EVGt> COLLEGE BREATHING VEN
GEANCE.

GEANCE.
70 the Editor OF The Tribune.
SIR: Nv attention has Just been called to
an article your ppcr Of the 10th inst referring to The
Phsdclph University OF Medicine and Surgery Tue
ssrluonis are without an exception, the D.sest tissue
Of fehOods prpetrated and that you should eid
your paper publication OF such ISLANDERS Is
beyond all comprehension II is the plainest case OF
blsekmai the p;t Of your reporter that ever saw
and my colleagues, the trustees, and myself have re-
solved that, unes, there is fdl rctracton we will
resort 20 such measures will expose the eackhcarted
bribery your reporter and OBTAIN justice for ours Ives
The facts arc these: do not nor ever ga own ne
Philadelphia University; Inever had any charters cob,
b up y the IL gisatuIc; there 10 not man announced
uhcr of the faculty VII" Is not engaged IN ,nCh,
ing; thtsc were any diplomas sold since nave
be, connected with the & hool and ueeNe not before
Tnc oor of Instruction l. more t."toHtn & M aG @ ~ 1
aai :. tilt number between 1000 aud 5"CN occnpy
Institutions Of learning and their attainmtts are ac,
knowlcdged to he Of superior character Inc sch0
John MCClt Toll, the father Of Gen. MCCcIl'l ana Is
rllty Of iu,dnran"r say" thai Of an opposition TO
TyIsy TS pFSGr St S M & GgSsi S. S F%f;
s es 1%4 SH|S ~n the or and
All Of teachers are higl9inded able practitioners
:. a'''TS '.rSo'TTsd "T% E-5ttood Inc aS S'G' III:
.' ,cy T e lSSE oc an purpose Of dedrvTe Students
and tarDsLn,, III" reputation "t IlNaI school WIN
xa g k Of l4y@t d , Sntoi1S 4 r" 'ry tsG triS 4nTS
ihat sfndG nj Gf H. Philadelphia University have never
i and jOil,d rotjon concern referred to; thai We
have row IN or sc,cIa, ,u:.r9ch VII" have taken
tber te .rccs i'll the Pennsylvania Univ'!i'v and are
pur,u- thor ',ur, "i >sdy fol Ne ltlpo OF Pc Pc
ceiying dclI,c ia the live, tnicilrslrE lHihido pit
Uniycsty Of Medicine AMI adfN: IAt vi! ltN IL't
yoa pnllh irchihi.uE n" sale Of acadcnir d"'rrt'
We were in.trImt uta' in cCttng passed. and Tie most
unk Ud Vii as nur-l accusation II tLat oi fs'Gei'
Eier, 1:ct.. iit We nv done more to expose and
drnounce ihan all the Other nedieai colleges OF tue 'o"
H5w re,Gcncp having long been patron Of yGaT
}Gana -. hh2ME H. "H lor h@Sf e. NV r
aud 10 IN" pressed feel confident that yo1 VIII a."
sprr,i Ui.',, int y0ti nav the fai- hood, furnished
by yoLt joIt'r. Iu1ccd. if avn ccrr'rtIH lni'i'tu
your r"t'r j. not ONLY relative OF these parties "u'
La J. III hr!ei, paid. Yours, truly,
Ph,j1G, ipi,G, Nov IL. ls7l "IlI'\" iA>t'
ANOTHER LETTER IN ANOTHER LINE.
10 ne Ed.tor Of The TrtG"he.
SIR: ] notice in your issue OF to-day you
rl continue to publish referring to the bogus
diploma sncs,, which my Maine il associated, hut
have omitted to publish my statement as to The truth OF
The slusions We commend our zeal in cndeayoring to
op truth and TO do all in your power toward pre-
yeniing the cIcnl ton Of Improper medical GER
incates do doubt Nat you have received all the
letters you refer To. But far tho o letters refer to
The Philadelphia Univcr,itv of Medicine and Fun ery
they entirely void o truth The statement that the
Phladc phia UnNcrsy ORGANIZED a. anegro school
l. .iiup ridiculous and amusing and serves only to
chow that s author could have no other object than that
Of taxing crcduy 10 it, utmost capacity 80 far
from true il this that there colored pysi.
eau or student connected with the Institution nor eau
there he, according to the present bylaws. Nor was
therc Yer dc gree itber conferred sold TO color ed
man The statement relative TO selling to an herb doc
corrtrtSld, or any one produce any paity par
tie vio have received degrees other than IA ieGt
imatc manner. from the Philadelphia Chverrty OF Mtd
and surgery. As stated 70 YOU ~ NY otbrf letter
oil the business connected with the PhlaIcilhia Ih
yersIty sranSactcd IN strictly pnslness ahcr, arr,
in aceoidancc with the usages o medical coeees any
fne M 1 Te EnSry iiS.f , with ini tGs
hon plIna concern on PneHt H. the dolhg Oh eTren'
~ well a, 10 and the community you sh9sld make
htte statements as public a. me srrors a,u
u AXE of so powerful means as the columns
otyour Eai impair the reputation Of an honorable n
under s,.n.alcd on Tor fairness Yours Truly,
FhtIadetlhid, Nov. a. ls'l "h' fAihb'
III ssary Ia say that thongh IN accordance
With uniform principle of giving both sides hear
Ing, VT pint Mr. Pane's general denial Of the grave
charges ade against his institution We do not repose
The 1Lst faith i'll his assertions. Farther inquiry into
ZOE conduct of the Philadelphia Universally of Mecrlne
'nd Surgery, andiUf the miserable Electe Ioiege
nave stsntd that bot equally corrupt Or as MI
Pa'ne Elegantly expresses rotten old concerns" The
etatisents made by reporter who has not rtia'
uvf IN PhIsdephi the authority OF eminent ply 81
e'sns. and We have doubt of their truth Addi-
eh~i evidence grdng the establishment Will soon lie
io'foIDing and such acs regard 10 bogus colleges
are to ie developed Will defeat the infamous scheme
Nbhh certain bogus phyncans and professors OF Phla-
oepsiS have united IN to influence the Pennsy vana
A1euissnse ths Winter, and charter which VIII
hsAhle the sAh {" diplomas every character 10 any
extent. THL TRIBUNE hopes " defeat 20 infamous all
eno' and at least Will NOT cease trying Ed
i"ishEsiN6 COMM NICATION FROM PROF. j..
DUNBAR HiLION.
ProPTtetor Of The Bep.York Cttv Tribune
Mr. DEAR SIR. In publishing nv last, letter,
which you call "fac-sime" of what s4nt you per-
n'e humorous errors IN orhOg Apply now tins IL caused
one OF two facts, either you wish TO lead your readers
70 thhk TIE suthor is poor p-ier w,ch shows al evil
nt ib you 10 try and libel him 10 this respect hen
s"u hbo" his has not the chance to he aud
hd ny tbos' recffrs what you publish bas and If
900 LOT Iive 70 far away you would rot dare 10 do IT,
ASh proves yQp w W q c0waIdv rascai.t 10 s&Y tho