The New York herald., 1871-03-17

s votes OF portion ,ns repaSncans gave seeming
10 sssich. which had no majority IN sac IN s f.vor 50
ss, the Of the might ss defeated By the
who did feel liberty againsi The
Ss'a $ 'r' a a e osa S1S s'
;n.ud Ss Th.. wns; mean sy Isss
sn ac
support asI wssS sspassss
ssss,iys rioI and Win full InoEeass Of
i Sc; H
and unSassd for By aid they receive from Con
MT KnIlEY- desire nssmScS as ! am simply replying
gentleman whether examination Of the record win
sS S Ses 70 rspsa @ G
against the repeal Of the duties tea and coffee which
he complains and whether he does not saddle upon
who the party the Aseendancy in this House
ae%an from Maine taT Hale in reference so. and sait
sirensih III: House: For one voted steadily
s sa net IN i : ps
party the majority 70 repeal the duties salt viii
p0 Do
!. In % our OVID @ good Time and and Tor our own purposes
X: " $:s; % III
1:,
continued to follow the aspoeratic lead and vote their
shape 80 % majority Of ia
me ss sfa ,s S
prepared resolution Of republican minority 70 do It in
Mr. DAwEsIs there better way than acQussCe IN
Mr.. BUTLrn-Ycs sir, always to acquiesce with the re.
publican majority ana M never Wn the demSSrsnc majority
,Mr. DAwEs-How do you cypher hfy-eish. to hftyp
Butt Ea cypher ai.y eight to atty BY who
selves That was the reason why this resolution
Ir: bAwEs-Thers does be anybody troubled
Mr.. BuTLER-I am not in the slightest trouble Think
somebody else wiz hnd trouble when they reckon with the
FOR thus defeating to give peace to the
S 1 The H.
The friends OF the resolution went about the House and
aaa ought 70
70
be given in the way be had Just mentioned It was also
NJ ssSTISs.W,S,si va: ,ae sasSs. =, $780,,
BuTLTs~Tns answer wa. .ha. on no condition could
Mr.: rErrns resumed. saying tina. 4 was stated in the
Be introduced leaving ali liberty they .hoash
proper to come to some action upon IT, There trick
whatever n the but acting his convictions and
strained hn from The right He wouS however, 60 into
s n bind himself O the Of the &
friends extent he was not 10 Be forced into
opposed gentlemen on oihsr side
the s = M or
with him when he stood his opinions and convictions
lated lie Aou.s that had been majority ali
of him ten of their friends who having attended
throw spsatership into hands Of the democrat
Mr. PKrERs-l should suppose you had some devsh de.
By1IEn1ws agree ss fully sush.sr ,..
the ehSir)pI desire TO ask the gentleman from Ma.achu
Mr.. BUTiEE-I made no assertion on that subject
Mr.. Bi.AISE-Did not the gentleman distinctly know that
NJ S &MsR-6ia not take to the gentleman and read
Nr sg1TEn-6Sss 6s SIR Iii .,ow ,,, >. :
Mr.. BUTlER-Yes, sir.
Mr.. BLAISE-in my own handwrngf
Mr. BGAisn-Hna at his suggestion added .hes. words.
contingent fund Of the House of Representatives." ZAP
ns he nnSe 10
NAV ask that no" the Speaker has come
che providing for the payment of the Of
mr.. BUTLER-what my ,answcrs Was II not that
under circumstances would have anything to with it,
was ha. under no cir
woua you sys serve as ~ ms % n.
Mr.; BLAINE-There are two hundred and twenty-four
&c ia can
His is essential to he constitution Of
committee
Mr.. BUTLER-why did you not find such committee.
Mr. BLAIsrBecause knew very well ,ha, 4 omitted
throughout the length and breadth Of the country by the
gentleman said he would with weakkneed republicans
would Tha, was the reason Applause SO the Chair laid
the responsibility upon the gentleman of declining the
BgT1En know " that s, was the trick Of the Chair
gentleman meant by the word trick am very glad 10
tins trick which places the gentleman
from Massachuses on his responsibility before the country
n. n. sT4I5I-TPolIS: sI4I X %SaS
Mr. BLAISLNow sir the gentleman from Massachusetts
made to vote for the resolution do moi what
gentleman who has given to the gentsm from Massachu
@ the ra aa ree ee s hint e he
speak, or 'forever after ho.d his peace''
Mr. BGAisH-The gentleman from Massachusetts says in
Both puy fsahs' s. M %s %
OF committee to invsstgae the state OF affairs the
earnes. protest Of more than ,wonirds majority of the
reggqe]sISsns g9 sS4s4sAYesi e ,ss aG2ss" sIi.
Mr. BLAINE-This bold groundess that
face the fact that the roll call hyeight republicans
resolution, and forynne, besides the gentle
man from Massachusetts against It, deny that the
gentleman has the right speak for any
gentleman from tennessee M Maynard voted for It
the purpose probably moving reconsdeyation-a
very and very justihabe very proper
whenever any gentleman chooses to adopt not crlt
cisng all If there be any of the ftye eight gen.
who voted for the resolution under coercion would
like gentleman from Massachus to designate him.
LER-I not here to detail private conversation
Mr.. BLA INE-Oh, mol buryou will distribute throughout
entire country unfounded pu-porng
upon made private conversation which, when
called for, cannot be verified.
Mr.. BUTLER-Pardon me- sir said there was caucus.
Mr.. BLAISE- hope God will pardon you, but you ought
ask 7 do Il. (Laughter.)
Mr.. BUTLER-I will ask God and not you
Mr.. BLAINE-I am glad the gentleman will
mr. BUTLER have favors TO ask of the devil and let
definite action
Mr.. BLAINE--The caucusl Now, let here and
that the chairman of that caucus sitting my right,
chevaer In legislation, 7eprote tethe gentle
from Michigan (Mr Blair stated, OF honor,
he is that he bound to say, officially from the chair
that considered, be considered