New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1871-05-16

might BY opinion the subject matter thai you
o Did ,cu comment scitse rsm,rt observe upon
NS' EsS Ssss TO E siS Won IA or noti
Did the reading Of that leave any opinion on your no e ume
n 20 ~ ia S' rou believe vha, Won readi A. No, Sir
dshsEeve IL" untrue or false all that you re'd
'OSU sd Tu no notion as to whether you read
fslse when ycu read the accounts A. No. Sir
DID you tsR to your friends more or less about this re'
| Sir; think did, somebody ssd something TO me
6 6S you .' sS SI' You ss S ,., or.
o Did What be said about the matter concur WIN
We're those view. in accord with your they different
from Won enerained A. They little dhsIeb
Wso nd ! ySs ssf p5 A. SS S, i'0" did
not see him m ,. William Foster wa. arrested upon accusation
o. VIA, do Won believe about it, asking y0n S"'
b r FS' believe any one Was arrested for killing MI
A. G M IcD srs , Ts III. part. who arrested Killed Mr. r'oan
That Ir TO Be ;sa the information have .e.dy derived
t9s nit va. &, ' S., C. he william FO''er not
inS~ fir ,, from what you read, that that was the man arrested
SRI was Po X. S n srre,tcd party who did from
neyI, % POSTER Of Whom the newspapers spoke and
whom @ FcS %, y the ToS SR about A. Son think
p0th1g Won an, prejudice against policy Of the Law that tales
hT'S No f so fSs %SHeS. .c!a consideration. .srq about
further isI ,t s a. Of NJ mr. PSns sn,I a. No. Sir
Do * NO about lSU hun S% or his friends
by Judge GsIyn on The ssS SSS Sr P Of rn in case
where The and the evidence would justify such YER
@ None whatever, A. None whatever 49,, ,-,.. p,o...
What is buiressi A. Brooms and brushes F1onsi
'e y Judge stuart challenge for vOD Have you family
O. Do Won think do you You could hear the evidence IN mi. case
s s, sn &c, nEH the law from Tie Court hearing
s s s s5 1sr esf before nc Soa ' &
| Mr. Martin was thereupon accepted and sworn. Ed
| Alfred Redlich, Francis McSwcgen, VIM. A. Stevens,
| Nathaniel Esser, Chauncey Bernard, Hyman Morgan
| w., l. IIu1fuU
Robert g. Ennson jr., and Patrick Anderson were an
rejected on the o Gnd T9es and opn
The examination of Mr.. McSwegen occupied cOhsluerdpe
ahG wS %n fS judge saar challenge for principal
cause that he had formed opinion and retained IL
would NOT like to find verdict of guilty where
the punishment was death; would weigh the matter
JHdre Stewart then withdrew his challenge, and under
GSIvn oanoae9 i To- ana pnn
ment and thought better could be made OF people
~ The estmony he would do his whole duty the best
of his ability understanding and according to ms
he Governed by the law as laid down by the Court as he
did he had any option N the atter ~ nc ha ~
the opportunity he should alter the law reatVe 10
Inde Cordozo-Does your objection to capital punish
mcnt rest upon your consclencef a. we'll thhA ~
Cordozo directed Mr. Mcswegen TO stand aside,
and the defense exception TO the ruling OF the
The original panel having been exhausted, and the
clerk announcing himself ready TO- proceed win the G
of the extra panel of 500 Judge stuart in'eposed inc
iV eog%1 q S9aE g % u
ham ~ FC Sn The @ oU Of the said Court also come there
spop The sd William challenges the said panel be
he ~ r , Ta a the % GSi Tn The ps fTSa ~ a Be:
and drawn and arayed and have been BY te ssera OF the
uhy 9 and without Sss any G S lawful md 'PS
he A, the said term e., Of M GS Of SaT
9 G 9S d ps Re s e d9 $751; which va e P.
term Of toe sad Court mat on C ,se sa addition, p ,oTs
said Court for eIts panel Of Jurors 70 be drawn y SAD
t Ts IN md The C and Ccunty Of NwYork made any
directing the Clert Of The City and County Of to draw
Court thereo but he that the Jurors dsyn and
the Gty and County summoned said
d Court made IN open Court thursday day NAV MI
the sane beng the fourth Gay q " term ~ s7 6 ne fourth DAY the "
SoS Of Oyer snS T G .a Id on TS s e Rs
81 Fay NAY a HS He e Alert f9 cfGSo justice of the Supreme
NewYok Justice the Oyer and Iermner ~ , a..
& Of S. S S County S9Ss S Iss
his Office GG 1s, and ni s0sS s az % SGocs
from the T1o S rE Sfo to s drawn Sy said
Clerk and attend the sad Court mas been made By s
was srfsye g. and the said jurors summoned BY ibs
sRen Sn% Snf Y sd ne authority IN law vsst9 premises
d except as cO9frfd upon them S 6s m1 q OTsT we're
attendance said drawn asyei and .ummon to attend the
Jurors Of e number duly drawn nd .rmsG s sre, o5 y
ballots the names ouIoIs tn s''.ndng Sd SS T,HSd
which jury o the tra 81 The sa indictment msm
the said 50 attending had not been n IRON iar'1s
spec Competent juror, the trial Of d Indictment Third That
S sad ID o' s1 above ST. Tefs .u s to The ck the City
and and Va. Gent S1 duv Of the d clerk to draw from St petit jury
biz o in the %aIeT m gSgd S x T Of p'% Jurors and %
@ certified copy Ue5 gIs' had NO sd sSsr % ANU
sad boz snd certify as aforesaid greater number jqTo
Jurors that the S ' C Sy Of May H GG a from 5
P 4n p 6yD Dt % drawn ih SO juror. Illegally
nure prejudice the said William Foster IN DIS ssd cause dgnsd
a 10 5eveY the SD copy to tie and d aewar
On ihe Gay bs ,e box ance Juror Wit Graham YOung
Illegally and vita the intent enter as oeh tne zane
SO jurors the Of the 800 jurors Aforesaid 50 Inst draw"
And the said minutes containing the names O. sol jurors the said
Cek dd then ana SsIe T e sB and With the intent soc
ss deliver sad Sheriff CERTIFIED copy Of minutes Of tse
.s a SlsS$ T EaSs '' Nth SIX i
ersapc1 Proceeded % &c
.b by law said sol seil certified copy Of the MINUTES Of
such well tue ssd Graham loun as the w others
AO ISS Ssi he said Sheriff aicrva wit the 18th day Of May
1871 returned into copy certified Of the drawing and
as 1t ss es s and that he same Is the ss panel Seh
here hath ehalnge and tn the ad panel nov
drawn an dfrsn panel to wit panel Of so qo
warrant order other authority Whatsoever mat tn ss
erlef aO SCI ' SrrsJ s 20 avn and ryc as Aforesaid and
Graham Yoqrg' drawn .m s'@ i'd De' Jury 30.
aforesaid certified copy Of the SAID minutes Containing SOL
sheriff and Young and the 500 others In said panel
attend the said Court and each and
of the illegal done without he kDowg
pryy consent nnance suggon or sanction Of h the sad
for Inn or with MN or with
his pvty or behalf any whatsoever b. his author
that done Aforesaid against The VIII lo
| protest him the said William Foster. ,,
And that the and County Of NewYork said
order T,qurd by said drawn from the t
Illegally and desgned omitted
with the int aOe drawn tie
panel here and has thereby Illegally design.
dr and with the intent copy with the Of
specified snd form toe above set
the great 1de Of him. the said Wlhsm Foster
y WbeeupOn he Judgment that the