The New York herald., 1871-11-20

llchooriie what ne AZ. w0sre no went, anu sa
on: Lnere was not mach III icui.y Ia recolccti ~
aoout Mr.. Tchborne, as tue amount was serl
small We were nearly an honr discussiax II
ma or v no conil give some good evidence. tinf
corrcSpO .Ieacs arranging Tor an appolntinenf 0l
Identification WAS real.) Bef,rc weut 70 CroydoI
on the 2lta OF Marcn, $685. met james McCann al
the Nes.minstes hospital, where am aow engaged
ne was men servaat 20 ar Roger; we were IN INC
lsol: be ore tnat h.d MOI seen MN to'
fourteen ,ears he said, when he calIei. trat nc
be company ,or each other, had not Iorgoti Ell
McCann; bur we had not communicated a. ALI
knew wnere was; ne waited at the Victoria ~ia-
ton ME. aud we went down to Crovdon together
we spoke auoat the plaintiff ana dcCann said SIR
Roger mad grown very soui; lie SAID he would rather
net tank about Sir Roger III haa seen him; we
spoke aoour reginenta af'als. Tie ram waS uil
ot passeners, and dad not want them g. hear wnat
We saiu. AT q uydon sa@ Mr. Bal2ent and u dark
cOlored man, whom | did not know. fLogle was
here poin,ed out IN conri.) l daiesav that h the
man; Carter was also there, hai known hin .s
groom IN the regiment ana McLann was servant;
there was hoy ,aere-aogc,s son; al least.
kitchen. with the otner men. 1--WE or six mlnutes,
when was taken ~ stars. ano ihet ar. Baisent
on me landing ne wcat with me into rron,,
whcre | remained lew minutes Mr.. Bal
geat went 'hio another room ana sad
! was ta~en into the next room, waerc saw sir
Ro.er iicnbornc; 4 beileve Mr.. 8aisent remained
outside. Dul AN not quite sure sergeant MAJOR
McSourt was IN tue loom wnen | went m
] had last seen hin IN 1857; McC0urt would
know more aboat SIR Roger than ! could, "a nc
was his drill sergeant, aE,i nad To drill mn every
day; | Recognized McCoutt more easily tnan sir
Roger-dec'de,iy he vas man o. iorty-ave. ana
men do mol cnange so much at thtt time oil ire
as younger men; had u doubt aDont Carter, but
soon recognlzei hun; ne has very peculiar
face. has Carer: IL was eeitiug dusk In the
evening, aad candies wer,' brought on the taoie
shortly after arrived; | ana not recognize tne
taav h va a inc AZ nsst vew nc na n ao.
under the Impression thar he was n The man, and
should have sworn that was my impiessioni ne
nck sitA kp..Uv ,
said ne did not wish me 20 say All unless was
sure saii there WAS no lear OF IT. he said we would
ter ter Of an all hour began to percslve a
trace OF cir Roger there Is meauingies
looS about ir kogs r; 40 not mean ,udd.ng
asked Sir ROGER II ne rememoeied oelng at squad
ron drll outside ci Canr barracks, ana he sai0 he
did; asked what ne rememnered II ~; he sad on
account oi having severe ali from mis-
horse; recognized niln on that occasion;
tnat was in aoDut twenty minutes from
the appearance and the conversation; wnen
looked AT him, and removed the moLnta ns OF tat
from aDoui ms acs recognized the feStu. es or
Young Roger llchoorne; tGerc was no Otner pecull-
arity ahoat the laco. EXCEPT look tnaL IS not easy
TO deh,c or d, SER re tners was peculiar iip ne
apparently lame. as tic always dMa paralyAed stAp,
as IL were; here wa, ecuiar look auOut
tue eyes; there was peculiar accent IN the w ce.
but not so nucn when III the regiment III the
regiment lie wJrld say, "vab or you DO wrong ~
he always commenced win vat" | attempted
TO induce III To ue those woids again. but dih not
succeed the tone OF me voice was nearly tue same
when he was IN the reglMenI.
Re examined oy Sergeant Bdlantine-The peou-
harry ni the e. eS was mat the nerves SCENE To pe
constant In motion-a twlcnms; | recullect the
same a ection n nr iiChborne white IN tne reIl-
mcnt: before the plaintiff read me alndavit. do
n0 think had expressed any opinion To nlm, but
had cone 20 fne conclusion that ne was Sir Ro er
be ore he be2au to rcal; Mr.. Tlthbotne hau trem
hIng IN one leg nc ere pnDting IL to the ground;
have no reason what ,ver to mod fly the conclusion
came 10 Oh tndt evclsian
You believe Tim To b. t e man2
WEness lcm nalicalv - es sir.
To the jury ca. not recall 10 my mind any occa.
sion on wnlcn ncala MI. lIchborne lead Whie In
the regiment, although ne would cad the reallnen.a
orders.
By Sergeant Ba,lan,inc II remember the fall from
the horse.
IL was proposed to read McCourt's affidavit IN
Chancery, he uelng nov dead. The Attorney GEN.
cral 90 &c ell on the ground Of no op orJun ty Tor
Cross examination; Dni, ter some discussion, MIR.
Giiard read tie allidavit
rne carOinecrs when Mr.. TicnbOfne was IN It; ha
saw the piantItr and knew hun AT once TO he tho
carDneers: there could be no mistake about his
identity Whatever.
ANOTHER WITNESS DECLARES TIE CLAIMANT TO BE
raE NAN.
william Andrews sall--l was the senior partner
In The nrm OF Andrews & Co., Pan Mall. helmet and
July ls2, aud had ten years experience before
that; ! retired IN 1868; ! produce tue oraer
brother's handwriting: knew MI. 1ichbvrne from
lSl9 TO 1861 I saw him frequently when be had
leave OF absence; l cannot swear was pre- ent
when he wAs measures Tor q helmet, but know
he was measured, ani thai mat entry 10 his IN ..
n naye gTSa Tor aaa
the claimant, an5 nave no hesitation IN dec aring
him to % ne me same person ny, we attea out m ls4J
by Mir. Sp0fortn how |, was that we had 10 make
his accoalre,nents; ! sad We wdtciled the
Cdzete for those re- eimeuts for Which we were
employed, ana iound ous hls address and wrote "a
him; the plainln sail II was not SO. Dut that ne
VINO Greenwood was he said Il was Colonel Gcorrse
Greenwood who had been In The Second ttfe
that 1t was 80: meas arei MS head tien, ana was
cgnt nv six aud nal; the accoutrements were
made - t3ls mcasurenle T.
fttug Of helme's is matter OF great n,cety:
heals do not run pretty much inc same; TINS Is
III my hundreds; 1t Is very common size indeed;
any one OF the helmets OF the many hundreds
would II any ot The ner hea Is: was much
friend: nc was bigger; could not recognize the
Frcncn accent, our do not remember whether ne
bad u French accent in 1853: he spoke iaIr En2isn
then: I remembered the vaice; | have
good eve for photographs; gramed daguerreotvDe
Sir Roger Iicnnornc, bui do not think tnat ~ ike
him; before saw plaiutia IN NJ sponorth's office
nad recognized nortralt SHOWN @ me ne ~ Mr Spoi
witness, who Iailed to pick out one as that he
had seem, Mr.. sponorth told me he had got
mach stouter. IA care de pisite was shown.D
though; | saw him shortly after recopnized the
purtra, within three NceNs, ! dare say Mr.. Holmes
had been at our once In 1867, and had seen the
entry IN the books; got Il note rom Baxter, Rose
A Norton IN lsi1. and II was q. Ter that saw the
plaintin Tor he drst time since his re1nrn TO Eng
iand: nave no doubt NJ is the same hrs Roger
Tlchbornc whom hted out.
AND STILL ANOTHER
Micnael Carroll sald:-t was formerly private
in he SIKH DraIOnn Guards: am now servant 10
Colonel swInien, VINO com anauded the Fiith Dra-
goon Guards, INTO whicn regiment " " transferred
from the sixth: rememper Mr.. io-er Charles
Tcnborne on,ng The sixth Dragons IN SO;
was a priyatc IN the LoOp to WIN n
he was All ached, ] am q CathOi @; he marched tne
Ca,ho &c soluers 10 church ON SUNDAYS; knew nim
well; have seen the clana"t and he u the same
man; Lave no doubt Whatever ABOUT thai; saw
hun at Corydun In Daceul,cr, 1897, and at CoicheS
tor IN 1868; had conversations with him Oh bOlh
OCCASIONS, and II IL now my Judgment that ne B The
sane person.
The foregoing ~ pretty tul rtsnyae OF the testt
mony OF the witnesses examined up 10 las night
MARBLE HIANTELS.
KLABkR, sfsAA MAkoLE AND MA1sLnZlNo