New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1871-10-19
s.. s.I, .As- d. Al.s ~ A..... ,A :, q. ..,,,,,

mi. n AsI ether seIcs,soe 80 ~ spe. npss e
yh pir = tse roads q tSs dsfsadsst. HsSs.,s. s =
ss a: aseoss ssd S Il rsS =. e; q:
AZ ~ a.: ssss ss, !, a., 4. &. s.s.. ss
q STATE b. enoae modern saeas 81 ssmr neisASor, -
Assss * oss sos..s.sa 70 az -. r,cs1: @
Countries lans and hrSues then Ties road, ~. -
together cessy via many common s ssS Ga': ss state
citizens q ..sy s.... Soly f.sel ether sass o. II. Ss.
e hsAsA' &, ,.eA ps,pe ahs Isqrs ...
!, ISr SSs: ~; s he S snssssios,s M asv a.
Cam. Co Ia R.r .sd Dsl o. c Gree" s s ~
FEDERAL Go,sIsni b, %, Sps1s md S so 70, fssk
sssi tSy ns.s:t ssnsss.. '''' sSsp ed =;
:ysS.s one s.,ss :: s:'; ~ = SSs, f.
an act doos II i .oTsres. syssiJ - =. lorsJ
c:. n s:SYs aai r. ,s.a .:.sn n
IT, u :..ER s:ss;i '' is- y s..f.t Ft' 80.
u 10 obliged 70 provide STEAMBOATS, n either eItrs1f, ,
is iI:s e 2 So sr S.;. a
Cor p:.:sss.s fright Z. .ny Pat !. y. State ssd VI
sSisa 9 provide Ti,ss: S,s: =;
r. ~. S' e. 81 PROVIDED S = I &
p.s for .bcsi IS niles tbrcugs ths scsAtaa soz
:a..as a. ss.sis. x ssSos.d 5. Morn c:s.
corporation vso:s .Drt yer: .sSy y ~: sat 70 s9N' s
Is proper q sniOen. domaDNeri. Cn, Co To-
"a g; % .: ST. Il. s q s
90 .s ess. = sss . s g, CITY !" gr
ate New York CITY The &c. give g0ss. 70 ecG9eEr
s.d: y .ssSsss E s e s
:: ;e 80 -. 30 ispss1 a. .sss Il. os r.
i ss;ss; ss.assis:a.. = along :s., A =:
: sS 3. s::. "a 8. .Ss .s%a.s Sss,
sant receive and send goods and passenger from and ph "a
e. s. sSsS,d sSS he o M
th. power public bsoea 70 The ctSens Of ih, sis W.,
oar own cSaHJ Tsins tie road Of tless eo@DsA = ~
10 clearly taxing them for public and for he a.
$sS".y Si Ssi Vii 70 pIsySsd y S saios q ep%s.S 81
d,,sd og%p.oy t:S d: PacS e q: :s A.oss for q.
TIE oEEEnD ~ who'll PowERIEss
contemplated BY eondemnson. But the act Of 1910 Id H =
n lie y 5 osic S AcS sss.ss ''i t s. = ola
tended the stock interest Of the ohe Who did -
tie owner Dat he power 70 condemn asuar vA And ~.
undyded share estate for yess ier ht rssa
estate DO se. I. t.ir .qdaS
:aeh prefer . t.Is The mac. b.
stock receiving sct1avs ue represented By the pV 49,
ssis t. And that tie others sboS receive what TIE sqs -
Of T ss SISs ,,as Of Ss e.
tue Determine that tie esss proper one 10, ,ns s, y ss
Of eninea. dom.in not 70 aS Ihefs arc On s np.as
those Of the defsnd.n The Legislature have dens sssS
dating business With eher ell Of these Is for public and srS
Bat %: only provide: ?r ,SS o,cS. e Hs o &
tOH, shall 40. b authorized % take phr,e properly
public without jG,t eonpen'ahon ~ made IL
"oO., "ud in several other s.,tac. Of t Sal. euacs a
present Consultation authorizing hLe cAssge TSo .aoes'rs
pOan. .ysn have been made woud seem presumption 1i
nv,hd add o. no eject even u S,i Va, ny opr 10
Illegal or Orchle taxing possession whOs. "
ven; Of The o.Ds doe, mot sso n & a.
lawful possession or having The legal sutonr 70 % ps
sSon Of the Land is rarOai
nDdsr vOuh be taxing the propet Of d. ,Sa
oenss.on 70 Sim must made thea before his etAe si T
directors these defendants In the possession sD coaS Ae
Dostcu not The oompassn have the titles the sOeLbOs Ian
seithsr TIE legal equitable title the night TO The
sS g. ,ss S@ S gia
tight to DO sS; q, .g'Ss the The $ 1,, WI %
snd compel lesser 70 surrender the lease obtained ba
:, 's M ssl's Il. So ss -S " hare si T
The breach Of tsus Their PROPERTY 10 the ''oel = !.
snJ rrres 70 which they entitled before it Bat upon pDA
mas prescribed By the act for condemnation bnr Bad and s.r cGa
any other redress thus the compensation Sr paid Oen
'- THE QUESTIONS OF CONSTITUTIONAL LAW.
Herr are unsettled question; e| S.s.rsos r
S S. ,.t for ~ A' s s'' 70 .ls .Ssoss Ss s
way you'd b against the settled rue Of eqs % graz.
S s. assI .:sss sf ss: " S"
ss;; sp 81. .sf;i &. 1i s ss :s:'
written Of hs lsPosea contsa ana s S
p ss pScs 20 III ss e X.
: Interfering where property toatr.r eOaso,l
ToSS ., . o.uSa Nv xs TS . ar
Here claim asAns AeiS partners or trustees Bquy s
i"ons TIE Supreme Court Of Peuasysss 10 hOs 40 P,s,na
lrOsd COMPANY Casey 70 r:sed un,s aO.J Pshn asI as
% b: 90 .e "a ssia IL. s. right. -rs 70
AaoS. question . 70 ; pS.: e tn: cO;TSsa T. s. 's
ISeSsr not MIRO vtre, and therefore all their uacarp t
he position Of the defendants counsel that this on ot'a:s
nd in which the eompAusbA have DO concern. I, Ho Hss
these directors deliver owe. to the iss'es all S.
nay take away and convert V its orn use without bring 'St
sS ;. ss ... sasSoro ana n -
n.s them 70 the preventive protection Of eOg1 o. sqS
&C. Ssi l1ssa sS Ssi. ~ ~ ). I
. too ven settled to discuss There = no s ,a
r. I'D .s;:S :,,:$ q: =, s;'i. ~
ss:: o. act. S: 3 fp 1870 Sd S IT, al
I'd "a. .ss .aS% - vi he dSsssisd counsel
gunent fer the cOmphinsnb be only accepted hTn ~
'ss soas.st sas "a. ''' r..tnetoS sF 2:
Dads embraced in the lease It gives aato.n.I e sIs
a. va I1eads 8 :lt yin ssA S e 4; ' s -
.ss e.. s.,s 4. r
u Peuusylyaaia The Philadepha and kne kAht1
rbe CataWissa Railroad Company, - Penn H. " ha
ID M The lease railroad ny another COMPANY ~
mother railroad leased the lessor aPp1itNoI -
nAnV decisions Of that Court beside that 10 Orsus ch -
md purchases made by these lessee Wth0u tie eoneh "
s0Asr 10 Be Tahd .
The conclusions thus arrived at are these; ,,,.. 4.
l. That the act gives authority TO the uni'eu
ease to a corporation Of anO;her STATE , line. via u
Thai ther works form connected and eouinuo0' n
SOEks Of the proposed lessee 49,. o... ~ ., o, Sba
x dnose of ali the property IL the eonDAhies except he
.Sd die franchises granted without the consent OF the
III the stockbodera , -. a.. .,s. ,nd AZ , msenyd
n. ,cIboers or OF any other proportion requlrH y Jaw
- oy oth,rss dispose Off works or 70 ,
rb.t leasr made By virtue Of such authority MIMI ns
"a the DIRECTOR that there Is IN their charF
, nnLel oosysct violated BY IT, and therefore the ss
lot unconsi g.0usL $50 =, a, -. ,.,uA IN. h,,eatt N
Of rItesded Pablo Highways controlled ana
..J toI regular ami Communication from ana
.S other siass-is evideav public use for "heh properly
Thai ryxn n the retors have not power 70 lease Io 1880
Mind the rkhoes their that the - a.. ~
h. ~rS, % the es,ecs With stipulation and ooas.os ~
stockholders valued and PAID ios so'
nv without hrt mailing COMPENSATION 49, .,o,o.ed Lessee Ia
m, Al. MA Railroad Company, tho Y
y, a. and snppemeu and the public laws OF - ~
sn.trurd nv the courfs Of that State power to nfe
sseh o all l.s snpalstOna -, lila. M, L.p uHed y