The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1870-02-23
THE FIFTH WARD MURDER.
,rry cO,TrCrED AND TO DE SEW
FENCED THIS MORNING.


ward WIN >"-tnIn-.", """" N"''' "
Move for q" thn ArFs' So~naI%, % aiia, nv sv,re.,or
The VI" VI 0'"" - ,r., a, ,,..,.
nan the murderer OF WIN. IownSen1, IN huuson
..., on tho evening of the 10Th OF January last,
.,.,ini,d Yesterday boforo judge Inzraham, in
6, Court Of Oyer and rermin T. Az ha'.pas' ~
" pr''onef' nEEn'' .s % Con,, u,. a. Sorc-., ,rr.o,
rdr'n'c entered 'ne our ms Sen.'M app'us
ri ri N. hair had been eonoed' hi, face washed,
SHIRT vas uSsr,' s," ,'' ss s q. IU,. v
rc'n' 'ip..'',on N"'e" %. ',,.u ,a",,a. "' IVA
Hf'' n'u. we ,O,aon OYn,S', .sH - r.s r cn',na.S
ThS "ipo" AND hsR CHILDREN
sus il The Vour' room ana were "'e oOJeo" OF
rrted sympathy. They were accompanied by sew
r. srn'lsnen, who listened to the proceedings with
yriound attention. Inc Oour' room was eroWdeu
.,h Al, glasses. and the utmost interest was eyinceL
rhnfouinou' 'ne "ia'' on Tue opening " tne
s s HOVE h, W. ln'1odSsSa = Me Tor the defence Inc
shmouy oi d. Mm' l. Neals,
ruE roxns PHYSICIAN,
Dr. Ne.li. te.u6ed that hc had examined the IRIS.
,~uns; tbs, be cor "a discover no trace o. insanity
sso,, nav eIst Sitbout devston, sniieptcs some
,.T% W.. bs sn nna ,ae ncs et,soss shrss @
.S .fsst he murder, and wa. tod Sy nm ,Ss, he had
"a neas no ii rse.s ~ sosss, r sSse,a .ne
p.rns vane. .g.npy a. ~ ~
~, mns, ahoronss sIsmns,,sn us n. assmsS y Ray
sss, nan Of vssr And unosltiya,ed lntslleet but
....or.u
hoS''uhAi eAN''
bnnll vm badly formed and vi, would .erioS.y a.
ean mental povrh pat Nouid not neeesssIily nro.
" lnpusiye lrsani.y The "oShhslmoseops," an in.
wvnsnt used IN ths examination OF insane subjecs.
ais hut ts .s,ss me esss q ssy m no, N,
nisSes asso To: S5.a Sf S' .D1 pr1,on .s Y ,o,
o. b. y.nss W ns.t severely erO..,.mined both BY
81 Jsq.@iss Psl, ,nS Ss1nf H p~s ssso recalled
Asis bad yl,ted keypolds amer the murder IN his
B. ssd % sss @ :.s. house
rs.., and that v.s the eri.onsr h mao one 0'her
.,, -.' os Tn. STAND
tss the Bible bat on being in,erfossted. ansver.
4 calmly and clearly too questions which ver, mt
h him BY Juror.
,r,o. wh.,a 4, n. a., u,...
". :, me .hqelnak.rsp mai
va >0" '",' "A'o'er 10 we gro
EIIssLps"I Sont a fnoW weep the night oeforef
Sv,ss@TSs aisSt bs!oSc iA., then,
lrson-Did you have any 6rsakfast that day
hrrsoLDs-l don't know. suppose l must have
NJ. -. ....
k.t.9
RsYsoLps- Don't know.
turon-Did yuu not steal o kniie from there1
mINoLp.-pon know,
The examination OF Reynolds by Mr.. Charles
Jones TIC )urynan, created STIR In the court, and
rn the ocen'on ot his counsel making q strong ap-
pal to the sm9athies OF the jury. Tho tcstimo ny
jsry ior The sl,nee' '' "'"e Aeui.s'ea tue
-
I've counsel admitted the fact tha, the murder had
e,.S somm;I!el .nier the niost revolving elrcum.
aririei vdoS and unfor nnate children bnt that I'm
Proportion to TIE horror Of the crime was the psanty
sine nan h. ,5 " bays ba sSaty p,e6ed would any
motive, and what. he continued Could "SS, hSys
Prompted Reynolds TO the committal OF this
adses N is I1e % sS'ye rb ".r aSns VIC &
,tcbssi- -i.' .,1. 80 ". ,a,. lA ll. hand VITO
s0ne p,,a w.1d bsys az go. tHe M, ~ m pl,e 20. o.
Song. caorl lem Proe ,, ~ 80. - 81 81
.sAl Instances oi ~''- i'0'
a.. .-,,,,,. ,,,,I,. IHrrk;iV. ~ Iss,SIT
NV ree LANA b oBdns a9Te ahen admonshed the
ol ,'e v.e, sap justice ior ne poor
tae 2 ne o to dcsnd He breS 9e s4H eersra eren G 10
ts lfi,, VrsrcSr,nsd q nan 1 Ins neStes 81 nnr
s.i, y y P'i' ' ( nus nstnta fe The pitlful etieet
~, ~ '"el' N'u'i oe where their lives ut least would
NJ.
suea' AMI W.. senod to with attention BY many amy
,,'ro. .,u,...
a.. MI. 49, JuDok oAhNiN,
rent very h. fy ia .,,pke oT ,ha -, ~ a.,s ~
ton or m ap rrane-ty IN ,So ei,v ~ Ncp %,
alleging thai n EeYnoio. were ,n,rd "a sr,,,v aStn,
estnc,' or g-' ~ heSloIus WIZ l0uhu suuy OF an
,vs,v ~. ~ ."ihyr ueIee " "ould give license 10
s'ev seoa u ut IL runnins the streets 10 coin
itg5,s' WIZ IMMUNITY ne SPOKE mtlinsly Of the
s.t t,c M a tl-ir sorrowing motl'et and demanded
5 90 I nSSa M SaryS
III v T T'y Vsh t'neT OF Jsek ketnods conversation
w iy"LStd N pIo3t Of his sanity and reviewed the
iufS. rensrsd tsat baS ne cnn on ,hS ni,riit A.
ss,r s Maa t. shonld never have brought am tr6
. At The conclusion OF Mr.. Garv,n,s rem,,ts Jrd-o
Lgal4m NJ 'u's'
cu,aopD -ux ,rpv
neah'ialy rs follows:
mn dS'y u GS e thz roa have
fIu-s He and well oeins but ~ eI ords e.
he yours is tho solemn re-ponsloiliiy-and It "a not
y ?. tI.aed th-to discharge your whole duty. No
I'm h matters sh9ulu lnhnence you. Your verdict
N.,.r ~ IHI ynn 1.ny N.Y. ~ nr, ele et t'usnc.
topqInr cinwcr ar snv o,e, cnn Inssion, rear OF
Jour Iecisior Nor s6oSd YOU ,peT te da0hG 70 hsneG.
eaf mind In regard to capital pnn shmena ~ ~
glf judgment. NJ you have 10 do IS u md The YER
M .S sceoidins to INC evidence; avn called upon 70
'yyanines y the synience Of TIE law.
he poof ,9efe d f,e 9l.n douo in regard
tn,f to tho prisoner The crime cbsryea n, the
Ne hrst degree, There Is no doubt sbout thS M
.s n ara the person who committed the act these
Te Sa y, are nndlrqted. '"'''
.sisnce %oaiS ssx my tnsen oy We counsel for the
spousl6ity Tic law n,tner Sncrm ,gnT. msn Al
fled " published Who is insane The Snes ~, - ~
asaH,y 'ne man was lAoorihg under any degree OF
Tue law does not con.lder n moron.n,.c,n ,n..o.
iAn sho knows tho nature OF the set he is commItnF
'nl knows Al the lime that he l. dong wrong h. in the
ls " ,ng sW re,ponsite There nothing shown IN
hnaons n ,Sssnty sna Ihe rnd eve, naa hreyions
Eho tran ac I al III ,he ~ thIougnoul the
There aIpeAis Indeed slicSt motiye ~ ths n9,nu,,
a OF he crime to which the Distinct httorney hss moi