, 1870-10-28

Circuit Court.
yAraErAST nEc1s1oS-tEGd. SCALE or rR1cEs or
LASp FOR soC1u FARE rrRrosEs.
James Marks :. The South fark Commissioners.
THIS Is an appeal from, an award OF Special Com
Mssionrss, fol damages to properly OF appellant,
taken for park purposes. The cnlre properly
which Was condemned, consisted Of twelve acres.
assesscd to be worth s., ,3AsG9, md three acres
valued III q, ,0ss.s5 about. say $500 per acre on
tho the y OF appellant, that tue rise IN property,
owing to the Increased y1Iue 1y reason Of the
location Of tue park, would raise the price to
from SIX 70 eight thousand dollars rer acre
Tic cause was on trial on Tuesdsy, when Law
point. tho measure OF damages, was started.
Judge Adams adjourned over one day (wednes-
dAy) that he might cont.1er upon The question.
He cohkulted hts assteiat+a, aud the following
Nas delivered ny Chief Justice Williams In court
Ees1Ef11y, As tile uNauiMous opinion Of the Cfr-
cult Court: EH
appellant harns rnt to the .ssut+s eestain qucs-
tons asto II v:tas q ias rTety seasht Y Be- coz
ra1nse'. o. dcepd.n., bare eijrccd and tias i:ic
a + sSot q s s..s I'D j The
heeoun-el faf the rrpeise PARTIES have fully Iis-
sss 1 ID a1. 1si a I'D .aa
lave prreeutsd u the Court. stsststions and author
Ihc lassr amoun. lnsolrci IL she 90 :. h h.r and
M .vs 4 *. t' S'.ss
e y: q. Il y ,a 1ns
a:sai tine g i ss4.iasrs.;on 4, 4 ~ saIjee.
II,
ssmred bs e.n,rissa sa':' 'e"' ~ "e e'a
al :: ss H. se, 9 ND i n t. Eas4.st
= Ss TIL; I'll @ H. % IT. rs.ta ai ss Z: 3 ,1
AT tic time 1hen the laE& twrs,nr l.w. sav The
.ss 1 a rs. sl,s len
st % ts :: Ever rn Mh,a I'd
tlsia r:trs Win The iii .i,ls Il I,
::;,:' a e. II: T II
len; ~. nts sc.,. :: t.7s !; \ st,.i r t.1stcd
st.s Ii .s II: <:, :s ":ss sss Z
s s &c, =, 81 ss s, IT, IT, i.n sap = If r nd
.,;s: a:;:x;: ;S r, L: III: :: ,is iess.sa;
,hs sr IT, ti.ls ~: .:aaa y y a,s:s IT, esf
, ,s u. IT.. IT, H. se es5ae1 y IT, ~ e
tlsa5 nta,s Ere e Int I; d. 4. 4 .s't q 'hs
i; s i: 4i IL i Ia! % ss :s ~ s:s
t.s its r11..... !s't n, sHx particular tand. Ilr
t,t s'"an ID: s1s!'.s ass s' e
n.t ssrrei.t ri. 81 sssfea,s ear4
il 1fas e.. f. '1; 1e4ian s4a ,s stf +
H.; s,.Tsn n n. ~ - What rasty. sas. ~.
sea ''s,s,s t,s'is ~ ~!
ss.s y. Il Il; ,:s p :ss r. H.. tf 4 II,
A.a ina.,.sl, q ~ many u II tse,"i1n. tt, tararl
's' .4 ~ ":: (. IT. ..n r.
t"nns Al rr ,c.,:t-s ri: fcfrace to The aclHttttio
IT,, IT.; asies y Z: ,as I;ss sss. Il Il
E s:is ss:si IL z ':ns,;esi tss az 8
ss 's.' & 1fg5 . .se ,.!s Il
.sa ess: st.y esasn ases,. .5s d
r!,.-s. gshlis se.r. would ~ .1eh conduit On i,t
@ 9, s ssSs51y 1T, 4 Il e., .ny 1T which eaud E
.-et ts.n ianat ese1ii II she ss Ia
T;,..%.',oas5s ;ss 4 ,e ,hs rrs1:s.y i 4 y y;
nd ;is ,.i s'i. ssl H. aa ao,9gis1 e.
IS s' IT, ~ % II. Is e. ~ s.S6si asss
s "i si s'x a III IT, 4 that s 'bfs e .T;sP
70 ;,:.';sT; i|:a' s - 4 T. :! %o'a d
;Sa n ,t tefsn Il 6 &C. til; rsr IT. IL, ,sSis ssSi
ill., r. :s{eD !, ,s i.
T!s;a .c.ars:; !; 7: r. aaaEd ii e:of;,sied !.
;s Il e to t. |a G, fs Sv e
isesi e s s"s ss "a, uss.ss i @ ,s
ss nsa ses md Il s Il + s L hss*s H
ae 's ta to Of hay !ia TN rapsf3 sr I'D IL,
s, sss IL: t. ;s:st ;. s.st 8
e,drnn.ti:n e f.. =, ~ .c:r ~ - Toiant.
.tihd th1rrn 'sas takcn fully the Sta;r contd +,
H. is: s:;5 q II: ;ss:
ssy sf III n ,sy s'sf.: n lie ~ Ia.pas3 e
1,,e l'na: a.d :sy n.a.t p:xfor q u =. Ills ths,
ae u s. ;s e IN
,s "un:ts ~ r shs r. ny Is -a-a.ss against then
i:ut ssaisr q,'s;ts re,4:,. to he determined II,
I'll st ns Il ii l. ar.ne 9. Il P
;i1. wiz. ;As ais a, Mst i"tg t.re % r Nv. sh.l
tir r':+;s ss sa'r I" l'svra to land b5 the ioes
,:.l; 4 Es.s II; nd e,ud b benefited
six;t:;sis ~ essE: HSiss i.ai. s!suad ils es;,
] ~: 'Is Hsls + Ia 'ss,:s s:s q q
'sy e. :uss = = a5 &C. sIs $.:
Msd ,@ s ,ns:i. M 1sai.,o z she ID s1s., al
usisSs :vs rs.aia % S s1s ~ es,sa'
s' iii : r.s a :. tls atx
..st id Ts+ Ss I =. ~ mts ( 4, ,ac .ai1s r1psEt
: r. fsie II II sfs'
,es s IL .ss nsssssr ssrGs n ta tx
az c,s % %.a II IL ts,.ra sss r. Fl 1r IT, 81 ", r.,
whrh <uri, a us~ i !. ',sAI -nsrst il snd nc 81
III. = H. 1srf' II III H.,
II 4; Il rs:r ':es I, waS %a
@ ssfn that " the sle eA.d t}1s Ii the latter cz4o
ought t" also In thc fanrs Hut it i. applicable IL
D~&hrT.
Au+ta. quc-tfan p1rst ii W. cnnsd.r,l Shall III
vaue nt the sprltAat's ia,' h. aietts i the eatr
tTeTfy Wtta1 trr Tss ftl.it- u.ais to The Park C1
nllt+ancras 1.si1s.nfr rot. for two sref.,ns El.r
try n,a4te rHFs.,l..st l., the time xt,t for d.
trimatns III" yauc nt tlsr ars4llantt 1satL kcconl
tHy wrrt made Hs,asr ruc!t ~ to pTt
sales t. purchaser named ~ the Park act.
For tl ras0n fittf tRCirt'ea1l aIT'ilants psureft
might NIT 70 h. AFFECTED BY iir .ayp az property ind
ohtrtac # the ltns- and III the vicinity of tie raT
nrd iGs the u1trE that thr pri-c of auch a.l
was lafttr ly rsAs If the Vr,st tive vsluc given
lh~ latids In the rseiaitx hy the location and n
e1ertiTr improvement II the park; and Isetl
,ssFea@.si r., sa,,... =. na.Sn Of The burden
the ra!k Tlle trns rnE II sn1 s~s in thte Csc d
TO h. this: 1hr vAlur Of TIE land the lime the paj
hrt lrczm~ law. satA Ea." t., be determined hy Ii
9ah- naade nts dlatciy ytiur and ut tho iItnr j
law took strt aud by ltr .ntnfnr~ II u1tarsttr ~
t tr Falar- TlIr aIr~ Il t,e enhanced hy Al
rnsI-<tise Appreciation in er'nssaucuee Of The locate
nd ~ t.sres;s1snt ,a Of H.; ra.k how.ss
i<a'i ,,4sdr Of o:,.isc Of thr proposed park 1in
iFrarc tn ,ain psfot to, 1t the tir Of The Is
art ~ cGrct thln xny advantage, tht,s derive
atiarht tn the land. and rfulf be t4kru Into arrna
by tho Jury in estimating .he appellants dA,nAfrs
the ya:Hr a rntnts u7lr tl- p1nc rIts 4horr 1fStr
the Wtt rhsd 4dA nt-!rst. NJ rtx rcF cent ffpu ii
day o! the taking Until thr prrernt time.
SEE ErT-AcT1oS on 1nK CASE.
Heinrich L:nneHitter E. Louis Gstmmc Cas-
Dlm3C1'S 1Afl Il -