The Petroleum Centre daily record. [volume] (Petroleum Center, Pa.) 1868-1873, 1870-05-19
IORPEDOES.
THE ROBERTS
PETROLEUM TORPEDO CO.
Office At the
RED PLASYNG MILL,
Corner OF Pine and second Ssreets,
Near the Raiiroad,)
IITUSVILLE, Pa.

q pa.sn, I'd t'z dsei.i1a Q, Jl1- 2 g t,r,1, -
'..p.;l- liz = se'r:, Fiie16ssy lave Lo"EaED
TWENTY Ha CENT.
- -. eTs-T Ov=ra,o- ein .-1- 70 ~ Io-ve-o
belyrg so,-451ius Well
The s1,sazin. I. he 6Aci.i5n 5n'reris-si By Jzd-e
CIR % the t.e-ry-econc f-1 cly Of s=,-sl1fser.
I~E. n re United >tste- Circuir C01E- 81 Pa l1cs
4 E-iie- a Ne- Tc-.- B p Lsra. ani : A Par I!
vlarce n. I-,t-h--xh for isf-I.tAr--. Ent George
E..sin- II Paiia:eiphfa, sat George II Ch-i-;y.o
P.i-sar--h. for plainiIf-
OPINION OF JUDGE CHER
nI=H,e with diEc1lty can ooly safe she con
clE.io-s n which my mind "A. eo.ie zfie- ea-.;1
e1sIa.ni:isn Of this cse-
= The cryla1Isinsnr Ia. ezhibi'=i-a .pa.e-i iaise
sJ;h Of April. ISIS Thi. !, y-u.1 l.ci- esidenee Of
god title snt pltz On the r--2or4=n;- the bGr-
den OF pro1f that the patent i void OF worthless
Iee1 not repsslr nv remarks IN The case 4 Good
ger =. Da, q w.H, c. { ksf: -zeJ bot n0S
sA1p. them s1Ortin- r1- o. decision Elicn iI-
pics ciez.,lv 70 r5e p-e-~1i ei-=
AZ ik= infriussDeu; of the patent i a1-aIi tai,
the nuly question viii b - t0 the validity OF cr1l-
piairsr.s patent - lArTil >. ISIS
-, n. Eft-r specul1sion hit been rcilcei to
rr-r-.. enc si-er reD>a-ed experiments that The
oor1ri.i1.nt -ecr-zis in overcoming he pre'ltice
asd ixuOrance Of tue people On tie su3.eri- srd
rer--asin- the p1ic that his inveotioo WAS r-e-E;
.f,e- he hid established ia great utility anc value
anc -wh.n bl. ceH'u- and ratien' perseverance, in
.5s-s o. =aeer- and -cnr-, ~sre co-npieiety .uc-
rlen-- "a rhe same sIhje-t- ard WIS un.tfe.-iIl-
i,i4e -ha- he had i- s, ri.i 20 the iIv e.liiOll,
I'D sfsr p1-rAlsin- one o. more CoH plah2ni y:
--.io-. he soUlisi 90 the i-t Of November, ~
~ 4 -yY-a-- fpr Substantially the .anie conbia.
ii.E- oi e7i-=. ard acine contained IN complain
ant. -.-enc On the 18th o. the same month the
--.-y-,-rl-- formed th IVES into company or
err-5rsii0a called .-The Reed Torpet0 Company,
rO- ~. ps.rpo-- Of rira,in- The cJm3aina11's in
Te7ti5u Ard sIgpr-1inc IN. expense ot litigation,
ard th1- t-frauf him Of the frlli-. me! pave Pc
.--a-- avn ii
o.--e-iv c-zn-e1 by the District Judge
Lad -rra.,he entered iev Ipiainlnt for per
cerEaI snj1acTiou- ard 4 Master appointed 70 take
a. ts.,J..l. ac:aGiinz TO the Drsyer ot ne oi.L
2 G. GRIER, JEt-.-
Sg-r-The ra-.a-. referred 70 b7 Judge G-ier il
IL firaler d.c5s-utI- Nalaee, ? -Ss &fclte1 a.
100 tsaAta to thts case VI. A. follows
III :. E-rrsIly the ci-c- v-r any vsl1Aale clscDT-
- :. s.e or ary u@v ularhin- Of er-at utility j
Invented -slc rhe n .e-Ei5r Of me p.bic h- nesn
--1st. rr +t.. s-1fee1 pr-vi0usiy- and rhz- many
Fs---71. hrve he=n rIdklnc Researches arc eIp-rl
.e--s PhsIos-lpner. ana tl=eHaIiciar- 1lAs haye
- slrl,s 1l.l-lre anticipated n tEer CT tlon-
ti Iry o. prDnithtllrF q --ea G--cot7ry %
"A IN Boz rziaT eIp's-Ir1eaI.-a;tse 9fst- -l--
IL -uI-f n-- very u-itr >s = --l --ots q lA-
s.--p.. -s..1lr TEeF kIv. 9rT.-.-,- ansr11- oeT5-
..frF Th-- Invention viel perfected Hay IN 7 le
s.fa ~ vi. re Il mining - n5 % HlllV eEef-
r,.fl a. Eco On p By the nTensor hu5 y Iliay a1i-
Cr- -f. nluV iiIru- prNt1sc- ntarrY ~ aa an-'H;-
ea=-irf e.:)erin.anrt ln- Eilifhs ci et.tt+- 'N =
r-.. -r.u7 M rrlE ~ .lr. 90 -l+ nc ntr 90
rl, ElBrin Of rfa .II.,gissfill mT-rrar Z L. Wien
.re,,., s,. l.is rt,-Icet ~ Sricrlca Wien x
ur-n,-rr H. -i..,!lfa.f. .i.ctlvsrY ant Nh'r 1la
i-e,,r-y ms. heed Seres:fet ~ paTlrln mi iunn
lril experiments. visl slmt. ieV rnltnnl-- t'l
n,u,ilicrlili. ~ mIefili. ii hean mn Dmicinhf,
wiifn i. rs.. ~ the Duniits silnu rie litN n'iilnr
H@a,lIps nilliiiG iene.icfnr ant ilr7r Ell ~ u su
.alf r..r Hen -eriils ant 1niltnn prf-e"eisiiiri,
,vE. III l.ng..I silcrnefir N ipue At +neerf i'lit
,,,nf, .,mi, vn,I,,h, invsnrnn M tiHiaT aiTr nlW
..,,,u il, n lnilf,wf.i NJ IT.wart Envy rn'is srin
VI me- ruur Niiit. iiIpriilagdrs 81 a. inn ~
ri.s Tin iiiu ai Jiia pi1ilits trtrY iihiaissi.l-
.r-11r-IprnI,,- VIM did dr I'D lii mt cnIne VERY
,-er lrni;.ilg tiscnvei-r iiasina H. t'srN ine
win a,n invent an Improvement dr NirY "a Mrn
,,liIn,. -,i1 IA lli,-,, lie Gr-,rinni f's.aury W.
,r,.i I,nr- .,nmpns Nn,se ir aihurilnrt. or N1ccr
ysJ, N ,,'s, tlia tiiiit y tie iiln. lirT az eve
~. 1-f.tl discnvg.,-r iliVr1Ilnn.
i,,,,-,,,,n init,,y-n history -. NAils, - - -e-
ssTs D. 9a