The New York herald., 1870-05-05
THE BOHEMIAN SHAME.
Conclusion Of the Trial Of the Rev. Charles
n. Smyth-He Is Rebukcd by the Grand
IEqulsitors, bnt Hits Back-Ram.
pant Puritanlsm Portrayed.

Al nine O'Clock yesterday morning the inqusitors
of he Presby bcdy assembled in the United
Presbyterian church, Eleventh. street, 10 hear the
report u the committee appointed on the previous
day inquire INTO the charges made against the Rev.
lharies u. smyth and 10 continue the trial.
Moderator Finley occupied the chair under
me pulpit. anil The m embers OF the inquisition
ceeopsea seats Immediately An front and at either
side Of the papt The accused was cain and dsni-
nca IN mis- conduct and gearing. aud his good.hu-
fnofea face besmed with an expression OF
kindiiness which the sour.vlsagcd aspect OF
hs reverend inqulsiiors failed 10 darken.
10 Was q curious gathering for the nineteenth
century. Here were people who declare
themselves Christians trying Christian on pharsai
cal chataeS ~ Jewish iaw, for unchrtsttan conduct
In doing ihai which Christ himself was not ashamed
10 do Regarding the laws specially made for the
government Of the followers OF Moses Of more &C.
count than the liberal teachings Of the Saviour In
tended Cor all the world, and setting themselves
above pubic opinion and newspaper criticism, they
cut ~ pretty q nanrc as the Puritan who was re-
ported 70 have bcea caught
A. s.aH,ss s.ss 3, =: =. e., a. q sdssss ssssv
There were aoout thirty persons present, including
the reporters, and the proceedings painfully
slow. Rev. Mr. Anderson made the usual prayer al
the orenng amer which Rev. Mr.. Harper. one OF the
comnafiec of fnqaisstion, submitted the following
report. which he declared contained the sentiments
q hls eollesgas. Who was uaahe 10 De present. In
90 =. ~ VIA. .s1 sss !. a S'
as % ssns Ai sAs s $ s'ss' ssss us.r q y" inss. s@s
sss ssss ss sssn .s.. % ,Sgs.'s ,,ssa sss,sa
iast me aesassd y shai % sabeasa sEeaine and
meea w " ese tass besn exirests qm PAPER pab
.sss .sss. ,..iI@., ;s's:
srkss 10 ha ssi~ssa ssIssca, q sseusel ard ,e
screens a. sfsarh sasas ssedsns were tro z ss.~ n
t6e iss1esy sAh nan. usa % NE siasnsn, We
!: . g.s. .s =. r. =. 1:s
,aslns ~" '"'' Wv WV
n. N % < s sHs ,s,fA S, 4 "S "a. sa,'sss sss.3
tbem for As snl q fessarnnt aAch ksr, bar FOE
Es esss e the rspss the accused called
fGs as sns s,fst + s I. sss as. 'sss 'ss a % 81
ale the csh ealing for ard dsrosnt ~ pitcher " En
ealing araSs on us sa1bssh siaiasloh Of NE
fI, il., ne sI Incurred Y me sr.,.s .P.s.sin@ea,
room, 70 lsns sahsa, 'sasi sasy apparently.
Es,-fLa y. seea.sd, ). aessra.ass wrA s.oml..
as' !. css zoe q q AZ sSs e - s Ss AZ = ssw:.r
= b sss,sg e rss (. % c s q
rr-rha tho accused dh pot ash ether OF HE quests
% s ss ss Hsl s ,ss ~ ss.'issr
@ ATM G n, On sss TX, s ~ q ss a
s sn %, sessses AsrsAs 70 hass essn :, We
T.,IlIhs qsan,.y q sin asea by him 90 the
~ s.s; ,ss, ~ y. ssss % g:sss
tion any symptoms os intoxicalaop
evdence IL Ills case We cannoi ba titus hs ihs eclees
.ons r. @ extracted from newspaper q @ eiy and embodied
X. Ss @ as e Ss s se' on s .ssus 8
has been admitted established BY testimony 20 prove
on s'i Ao 'Ss as'a 4 %
also " nave 20 aesS sa @ or as s
left at liberty by Law account
Nnen as ai ss q
top we shall call attention 10 soms Of these "s we'll ~ 10 s
= ss;s ss ,s
did sp occasion ier cyl ~ san.ps mis- sna sa,pse., %
home for Necessary reiIeshpen he should have made
for taxing Lunch I - Where he wsss
isia q s.uTsias s.oet M in the he way % q o,ls,s ,,.
s.nsas ss.sara As s ss .
resong 70 % 70 S &ss.s may % ss
asSs sny a. 20 ss s. . ss s
for man 70 resort 70 such smasns seeorins " bic own
foafls conduct o hs accused was calculated 10 eoan-
es .peea .aasss sSs
which in.smg.rsnes causing 70 ne World rni.et o. toe
sanction 70 tue use Of moa stns liquors bsvcI.s IL:
aeSss q Ss AL sae ~ II: shaaa am es%a % csss sss
tons We recomend the adoption Of the following action,
DIs wns s sss. ne
particulars been proved, while there
sve that said specifications IN considerable degree
sie Ircsbyery The condaei q the which
saSss's With ,hs, cisss prassa sl ss.,ss
ssl;. aud w,h that tenderness oi eosseienSs, aud
1ss ssn qs Ssn won o o. ss
seeThat FER The nov ls sssse
to accused and .hs. he be sosas waned e aard hsre
his grave esnsre and upon tie cSnsh ana eaa.e y ces
wn Ssn s .s%ss spFSses but S sS cSa slns "
o1 no 90 the 0 sSpssSS Ss Of Ne 70 ,ss Ssss
Of God more ercauspecty 10 the fafas, the te cHe
1ismsssod.
In answer 10 the report VI tue collmittee 81 the
Pfesbysefy the Rev. Charles u. suiyth ASKED ire
privilege of making statement ~ sF'eytso ana no
objection having been offered he spoke a. ioiows:-
have o listened as may well ee ,errosss ws % maj
been struck yesterday, wah the very KIND and
I.S Spayea " every member he sc ~A sSs
20 eaps from Thai y wa. wa, MOI % % s
Of every minister and every member d ihis Prssbysy
os w:a msse asasl sss
s not s, e with mine The % .csa. g .s'm's <
condition as, ss TO REQUIRE meec,"s :. . s,@slans
before procuring remedy spd shs aryesss @ B.
the argument used aEainat the course purxuet. l
differ with him ~ scto. II vsrv seldom thSs sihsr
myself or family have Recourse 70 rroiessioIsl sa
atira. called in no medical aid, tn rryscr.hea fcr
her myself She is Low In perferi keAfh Immediately
after her recovery taken wife The disease bai
sti called no physician prescribed for myss and wss
perfectly cured. would submlt lulgmeni IA Dsd
cine 70 the tIst physician Ia Ne sna Although
have not the good fortune TO have rnehcs
diploma, has been good fortune 10 have s.nie uea
cine enough 10 tell mo when siana 10 s~~a Of rh %
glass to stimulate Then there apcthss
point "A vast difference exists between person who CON-
monty usea rtoxlcatng drink beverage and one Who
uses IL incidentally AS 10 the violation VI the satbsih,
sending my son TO AID the reporter irhnscrbn some %
the notes OF the Sermon wl rot that that mAy te
eonsraed into voai.95 bat question sueh resosiion
be wrong. question there member 10 ts art
who has NOT written portion OF l noe sAbtsih
day.
Rev. Mr. Armstrong here shook his lead.
Mr.. smyih resum,na, Yes there may
tons and very much asscnnas 90 tie efeaH
Of the members q his cours who would stena