The New York herald., 1870-08-09

hno k~,,i
nS =, ~ you eaanne ine aoa WIN tue viow o' ,S so
ongh,v T Nr o'oou ""s recon' VI our A. "ao 'no'-
dry on an inst Wstmwent q, tnst %sn%p Xhont al,
hours time q; cnmraa r. ,nn va haan longer than
that; i couid not have been less in my opinion.
n X was iroa S , oS Yes sir. INV theory
or the case 10 hSa NJ Nathan WAS awakened by the
nofsa %, ,ha 10 aS s, ~' ond tha~ vher he cot up
~ so ~ ~ ,t t,o sase, , ome no s,~s %o. "ASA ~
w =" !" 'io oaoA iooll no "os
and was struck by this instrument over the head,
eneSng me mrs. wo"ha a'a sSe ur
skull this knocked MN down, .ainn NJ tmS hn1 ur
derer then passed over nun ana aea. .c o'ner oo"'
WINS mn Satnam Wa ,S y,nS cSsr o ne sn fon IN Tho
Dd you oDserye Tue CHAR ,"aS s "u ~ ,aien ~ .e
nnsd a y on the cromnG am mite nnsvs
cS that hi ~ was NOT wing down WHEN when I
ers there. one ~ tha nniicemen t,mnea II ovar ro
show ma and said n was fonnd in fhat nosition.
don,t remember II the chair WAS covered Win nnho
sterv ~ f
O. How-do Won account nv vour theory for rho nre.
sence OF HOOD IN the sfndv The moi NJ Snnd
Directly s0uth OF the chair the small one hot ween
that ana the aIil and the other stsns NJ hoo foun1
In various nosttjons9 A That waa tha oniv rnar,
which Confused me at ALI h was hard TO account
for the blood in that nosltion. tS nresancn CON
hardly be accounted for nv anv theory in anch
ouantities nness Inc tamporo, artery aS ont n, The
first blow and the rnsh nj hlood wac ca rraot ,nat
II spattered in thar direction ""' '' s''"' 'n''
By a Juror-Wben Won went into tho rom, ~ no tho
gasil9ht burnIneY a. Il was ' '''' '0o"' "' '''0
o. And ma 70 the nos,tion or tho hodv wo. t,o
hand ertandsd aa ~ pSn,aSin, - ow o IDLY n0y ~ WIS Wy
WING DOWN. II wss ynn ow c'qws or was WAS ~
that hut r. NAV h,~a baen H. sd a sur sure @ ol
n Xa' Sus Ra{ M nNys oeen moved py some one be-
n Was thare enyth,rr T., .to ,,rorr,,t.roos vor
ohserved ~ n ~ se ,S YOU ~
ora Ss ,San ~ On uS ,"uoa,e tho PfeSgLe -
nUy w c n, vt0 nn s a, No, SIT snlnS tae
o noSng 10 nn,. Veem aone D enc a; ere
pi Won sec tc cnhag or ho
az tyo {uu s1y y th te OF tne deceased wncm
on Inc chair directly ar The toot q, rho he'd st the
90 ost sda NJ the house. d,d pot ,nsnan3 ~ uor1 ~
y so,na anots S s speo % IL wv th st
hosom saw nothng ~ M Naho oToa Uu s1 si'
Was tns So re omsn or The ,,na un ars =, Tho
stn,vv II Voc rot" n"t "' '"s ''A'0 w" "0'o Al '"0
H'TIt =; ~ - y. N|2 y ,.' a.. ,. - g.. 40
~ nv o. ~ ot inc S Se was on ~
a. my 10 )" es NV. o'a MY hVSio9 any
papsrs p, ci,s ly,ns apy;.e.. pyI..-. - s''., -
Tne I12fQneF- GU mace thorough examination
OF the INJURIES received ana you loand Two WOUNDS
az tue PACK OF tne neat you sald, Denevef A.
one onyi AT tne occipitai prominence ! found l0nr
severe wounds ailogether there were three or Tour
other smallwounds right In the immediate vicinity
OF the severe wound which Fractured the skull.
q Ud you notlce II the TWO eyes were blackened
tae % ewes yonId be accoun,e for by the seyerty Of
the blows. srol
The Coroner showing the .'dog'D--You think that
this instrument iu1icJcd all the wounds? /? A. Yes
sir certainly; the instrument NAV have moved a
little when the blows were struck, and this caused
the long incsed wound in the forehead.
Juror-Do you think that there was necessarily
considerable struggling or was Mr.. Nathan stunned
Of tho tlrst blow 4: think there was no strng.
bow there were some marks at the side Of the door
which suppose were made by AIR. Nathan,s right
hand as he tried to get mn ,e
O. Does that sccount for the presence or blood on
both sides9 A. That on the o,her side was made
entirely by Mr.. Nathan's fingers. was ''''o'
o. You think he was siruck unawares nv some
blow which prevented his CRYING ont OF giving gan an
alarm? A. Yes, sir
The District Attorney What wac the nosit,on NJ
the gasight how brightly was n burning when Won
went jn A. The qasiiunf was at the window nayt
rss te 6 IN m args % room that ns
partay back SO that n emf of the gsre Of tho iiUt
through the place where Mr.. Nathan himself W ,Sas
lying; it was turned on about third OF the usa
force of gas iet. Ifhnk n corId not bao, saa
rom the street because r. was NOT nnrpre sm
J1rorVT6e Window was o5e ~ yen .,e ro roUI se
was il nota A. Two windows in the large room ili
were omen from the bottom, ana tha .v,ndnG ,n TN
o, Was there light sutljcIent IN the room for the
murderer to hit Mr.. Nathan each time with Ger
taintys A. Yes, sir; especially II he had been some
Anthony Ruppaner sworn-I reside M the Fith
Avenue Hotel; was called over to IL West Twenty.
third @ street on the morning OF the 10Th OF July,
aoOut quarter TO eight O'Clock; when went in thu
nall met Washington Nathan and went up stars
Win MN ere witness described the position Of the
given by the previous witnessl.
OroS5-eAamineu py DStricC Attorney fellows-l
Hoe the Naan Os
day before the murder about four O'Clock; when
Wehs up stairs tne mdosn was iying directly near
tne noori tne biood was d'y; the gas, think was
not burning w1ea @ d was lh ,ne n9use; there was
i n " n S1 t oct"g 9 NJ, e "tnaow iseii
nr,Ur - on IN. W,a vi HSI @ sou tIat
hn aSirt Saw SAWS o U Oe s, n @ Natnan ne
u @ sum vamss anu s,lpeFs o'i' 1ii NOT examine
~ 49,, = 49, ~, 80 W 20 .O 1 az saw VI VIC
i9oni Oil" ,,iU & pV1..Un M y, & VI, ooy .linh there
., r.reon rooa,vaa snSS, nhSS ti .
c,tn oS tb HanS OF o9aun a, SIom M e MINUS misnt
ov nS e " Sas 1ns ~ d % Naaa werei IRON an
boSv had been acaH fouy o Eve nonS ao Say rme
SovSS raSnteG vev snad W ye W. n aeatn must
,,;s,n,. rtnor ~ Nv, ."u mounus We.e
HiUcm' r,sot o's M 20 s "yu mot set 10 80 quioKy ID
%and &c hr. a. ~ 80 on,, s 10y y nisnt mave Seen
Hoa 'AA "ou's' ~ 10 poeSio'o 'na' IL couia nave
oeSu pv Afr prssou \, ,uror, oo,,noros .,o
i,S W. sn a w jns tn oo,npaISa .Ie WOUNDS
asmon1on H n Sh ,h Io stn so mu tney cor
ha'Ievn al, nS ,heu cnnd haya ha % taat
s.Iom !, al VI '"'AA 'ou'" ""'o oeoh oone Wy 'he
TUSi Do NJ r,o,a ,o ,nror, snor,d M. ,,,.s
a,I or cbam,ca anavs,s want ~ gvo "a'ous me
answer 90 70 whether Ihe hlood stains ON germat
were or not coacnIated or fresh when thsv cot ON
sbnmid hana u hoon ""S "0o'''' A"' 'ii0 nu'oefer
''-o"'" ""'
A