, 1870-01-27
TIE TRUMHULL-SUMNER DE-
BiTE.

&nt L. Il.
uD tnv q1es1lun OF the atknr OF tne stint, OF Vir-
{. IN to ,epr s.ttatioh n soDgEs.a ! hare a.
s.&lusd uu q suy tccstiotA Hneu hsVo beea
4 rUtat, IL upted. ffm EepIsi! 70 what regarded
~ uLn uca AIEun et,1 AID ialse assuDpt ons |
tp., hate Deen 1,ade cur4rg &ois dtscusason. Du1
a. e.u o. ~ III ~'in9ss it$Rl, 70 70 ,gn7 ,n hing,
oresel,. 10 tos .t:xs entefts.n I'd to mFaeu,
ftuu re, thas auolld tusAe soEe reply 10 asser-
Oh II door ia and Asain a:ter they have neeo |
CORRECTED and rEflteo. ....
Fur 4ou+ reason untuown To nc, OCCASION hsa |
ana lsst evening. tutt previous to 4dj ,arnnant,
SerA'or fscm Vermont tMn EdmQnds} and m5se4f |
~ 10 Whist had been re undertaking Ia Ent Sen-
= OF I previous pccssion in regard to coutog 10
! vote, W.tncrt soy slluAtao on ny pa1t TO the |
seLAtor mon Aaa,aceu.ct's tAr. sanneE, he
Thought proper 10 lllu,ge In tnta moss eI,raof- |
utnsrJ language. T13t MaY MAKO no mistake IN |
the lsoausEe, / shau 1taa 1t ~ reported oy the |
MI. srxxEr III. President, am asunlsned
II Ntal tnu sEuaso, from 1!Ana!s taJa rave sas
naky yetrs u this coAm0rtt and ceref hesrl ]
T. ia eiis eHla stis esssnssil, d!1ereaI" s
II ut m 10 uss pxtlsnentaty language. Will
LoG IrA tcepd that: cat go Al far a. can 10 t1-
s ane1 r. cone % asaes eunYeisson pe:Eeea tse s.n.
ktoe nom Vermont ana myself, nud Without a1y
alIu.1on Wna'e7et 70 the Senator frou n Massac11-
.enIton oi Inc Serata 10 Inc TACT tnst tue bill
wh'cn was pei ding IN toe senate At tne t1Ge tho
rnd.Istal1ng sns eli!ven At read II these
Ie1tez eLssEou Ia tne Congress OF tae un,ted
j atef," aid >tas The ptl waIcn sa4 hr01gnt orer
from the nonbe read IN theAe wofdt: !" Tdat tue
sid Staio OF Virginia Ia entitled to REPRESENTS
ilub IN toe CorzSess Vi the Ubted State@,' sne
tTo nI!l> beng loentcal u tetma, word sor word,
s1ta The exception Of The WORD SID !" aEd after
h4yiLE hhpHb lnAt the AUet dmeue OF tpn Senator
from Eesu Oht Vas 1tnmt diateIy offered TO the
house t,li tue uoment IL Tas taken up, tho Sen.
alus ltosu AaAA.chu.e.ta tctutus agatn 70 tta a..
ktt vi ftl ny ~ H,f0 0+.jf a
@ ss esnaa' as The TWO PROPOSITIONS gs!s a; e..
tnu Stta Of caao,d TO !rs.st that the.e Two bNis
a1e auAs: Tney are - dirsteat ~ two olts
The t~o bills read word fer WORD, except that
one ssJt 'lhr kasd state OF Virginia aud 1e osnes
"the Slnle Of VEkln!a.h EACH saying 10 so uaay
~o1d. ,nas The Stale Of Virginia entitled rep
aba JET tue Senator Asserts thxs they arc ca unke
ESQ o,nx can De- He sA5siniS0ef -....
~ ne.ef catered my head mat any ono c3s1d ,sid
non ent's cunaItetaton 1ha: nnJ tlRunent was
applicable 10 tne Hoato bill. Tae Stastnr from
ntnobon OF It; ne kept Ii Vii TO h,n,elf, mad row
10 see, 10 smPoAe It upon tne sebate"
lnpu1iog 20 me design 10 prncttse An tupo-
senator roae and cutIo4ora!ed my understanding
Of tLs sgteen ens, oid ,nn senator IRON Ma.sacha-
tt,ta sse ~ eolsrscten No: 1T AL
MT. SCNkER. VI cGufsS DOT. ..
Ms. TAEMHu1L- lie Bad mad q monopoly Of Il,
ard 1ept IL TO myself; was sIopa In the uadet-
nsaao,Lk auo "asa ), uNus' ~ ~ - ssars -
nas Icy ~ ,nn In a1 he ~ s.,er.
usue Lu t1ateC ioH. -. +Aln stnaa w u1s aAse5
I9n 1o ~ p!s!eA ~ ~ ~. ST.. o...,o
~. sUxN1M mA1 eoeGs sae ssn4'pa poia ,,.
~ In 1su4sI Ane Sene -. usg Iou n,s
ssssn nn5 e.. asse s9ooa os - assampna ~
~ 4 nn1rs IN sinurn. tf1sfn ~ no inns 10 noacs
sucn remarks, wholly u1calea TOR Irom tao Sens
tot. 40 not propose Aa. they enalt 30 nnap-
s,Ta,1 sas@o ast uss ~ IL
ls I ntn: hur tnrre "a, a mlsnr der.tsnnre. the
SctatoI irnm vermont nndo1s,ood il d,l1etrnttv,
An6 tho ssftenept was n3t enturce1. But be-
cause utrtreI. cd 1t differently mJ uuttVes arc
pracise 81 Imposition On rae senate. i snsil
take bat little time 10 show what the understand
lng was.
Tne txo bills, 81 have nlteady stated. the one
! that was urder confederation In the Senase ard
tEey related to tha recognition Of virginia a. q
vere alike. wbas vas ,he oblect of coming t5
Ills nndeHtAnoiug tnat ~e should tsse vote ~
ne,,n a!r,rt5 ,ne a,n.hs H"n hsre ~, ami
~. ", !e1 ana nn..a ~ n a,,
IA :, r,d ~ -. .n1 9 sa.a 1ra - .,rGs,sa,I Hs
hasn 49, ~ ,ne u,ns. hi ~ ~ ,n
a Ssh # lie 1se seests ssoad e,teur e r. tis tie
!. ssn,t,a ~ ne ns-~ 11cas ~ - ,ne - Snsea,n- Tna
r, T. rar, mn soma. n. enstSr. n ~ n,sc 7s,es
| 81. ,dsnt,,.i. srt IN s ~. Scre;saJ h1 SaS'te
en- the Hcusn tiiI in tee plsce Of lbs senate bill
N a. n lhss en- mrare Of. thouch thrra wers
SCI atnrs VINO nhnerstood tn2: tne agreement was
not e p1 e. a., = a'el SIT e y
ttat vas IRE view Of tome meuhers al the Sa1ate.
| 1it Eot attempt OF that occ 4son 10 force MT
particular yiexs upon The senate. So muc1 for
| that
The Stratcr then considered tho cEayge oi Mr.
snuntr the taya1 neonle Of y.rctn,a had aecn
-. - . ~. ~. ratnr. tnn rnaI,,sr. commune.
te'atee AeA11nR oe'eie 'ae 'ua'eaty eonit0'see7
erd dlsposed Of IL pf tne testlmooy OF oena1oea
Ednurus and Conkl1n2 and others, Hlsn this con-
| ror r,n.,nn.
&.. ...,s -
nnu 80 .o1 - q oe
soi9 " nse laeMpess VI tue suuelaly SouuNteeE
naa ptcn eos1ec1so ps n3AeH Hitniu tHo 1llo-
LIZ ..~..
Oo Tue SEDAtol t3LT. ouln1EI} CoE1ftt 1I8 9tA e