The sun., 1870-11-02
TlrG RIGHTS OF THE STATES
- yEr EEDEEIL ELECTION Law
CONSTITUIfONILP

tr. tOustt'rtiOaulitb ot tbc LAW
T,.r.-..ri.tll cises were btiorc tie United
c.. ,..... Cont yaI,O.lIy upon mOHcns pre-
,t,.u,t.. uil o. tac indictments mon the
r.fs Tf,p eco. eiir Of the Court, the District
....... r.,gsi "a hd,c.m,nt Of Terence Quinn,
v,,s.,lt.c-.e .ei a.. ~, CHARGED with registering
t.f.r, .. H..rci .a oYc election district lie was
,.t.t %. g.. UI,.a ". s'ouShton. George
T,... ...r... alu Niutn .. DWtlcU appeared
t..,r..-.r,s. sal District Attorney Noah DAVIS
Tor t.. pro-. uio1. hfter tome preliminary discus
uo.. JuI.. W.uIiIG wac presided, expressed bis
,>i,vgacs- 10 ca o-ige 4tchfori to st with him
LLeafifnpcht upon ademnirerto the indictment,
N orlcr 0blt any questions In which tho Judges
lf .,o " Nery 10 doubt, might be inme !iaiels
,.f.., O., llo supreme COui OF the United Statcr
L,t...,t. Judge Blaici ord having been seat
nf. .H. .IL.8 ls sell upoa tue bench, Ar. stoush-
QuAsu ruE rvnIcrYESr.
n. t..sluu / VISA % present drst, Is upon
,.5. to lutsh TIE indictment as that one -
Nj, be- II ,.cltcd 10 this way w.ile The olh,r qles.
t.,'a cIr Ic argued upou tie dc Hurfor viii read
y; 'S g.-e prsia re1i an an syi, i Sy T TereSse
urn, a.tus on information anJ heller that the
daul jg. a. ho rrc.en1 term Of the Court, ~
NJ. tr ll. O.. Indictment vas found, wern OBJ
5rt' 90 q, following mann.r: Prior 70 the pre-
,,at tow. M,.s-s. Geo +. B,t5 aud Kenneth q.
Nmc g,,e. H t9s SCe't iogk iogk IA rat
t.Hs known l ihem or oi whom the, had infornl.
ton ulut. ol Iti-ota Wlthou, iuQuirut as To thcir
~ No .s . ans an sepii, sl'p, '. %. piscr, l,
t,cl containing nsmo were kept IN package uuth
TO- clerks dy.itel to uso .hen, when they sclec.cd
81 lcruns 20 Gtual a. grand Jurors; th.l 10 al
ucs. a,cr'. aud vcrr sworn, md tliat The Court
r,ulr,,,sI au a1duinnal uunret TO b. summoned,
~. mttt'J OF drawing is not in accordance with
rcW-su-- o.. df Win. Ju.o.s dudur tpe laws o! tie
s4,c OF Ncv YORK.
NOAH DAvis's OBJECTION.
District Attorney Div.t-T desire to raise the
eucsi1n hat uo motion % qulsh an Indictment cit
BE- p.tit.,,a upon such glvunds as tie counsel i1s
pft'cr'.I. r 'Hust have struck your II rors that
IN. N vt proeenti several questions OF lct, upon
WfIcu Wt are clearly entitled not ouiy t. be beard IN
arguu.u', hut 10 he heard by ur0ois. A contested
ir 'y "s 'l'f & 'i.. Hgn sf ,iii az m9,en c
t'u u'.un 10 qu.sl an 'adiemepi piaeed On
mat o. o' ,'i -G te"ii ,e.i lhe cue ion
c'ansl ct 10 r'se cIuuot tc rsi'rd except by o
pes in ahitrmcn, urOa fac,s prorvriy pr scn.ei "A
10 %, l.od, in I,n. he Grand Jury va, selected
lcs tie' .A 10 t"g TUE q un'e stand IT, in such
et-ts. 70 i4 iaii down b Archib4ld's CIi.aA1,
Prsc',cs ljd lc1iinls:
"ccut" ling. a.ertaia motloa % qnl,h AZ i'ct
retr.g ur.n isCc o. fua proceedings Tor fGr'i I.-
ter ra1 o' by way % defence On tlo ts'al uet,V
srlsr ". ARCHIBALD.
Mr. StrH i'.a-Tfe Ln.ulty With tho laarnea
eounsc's .4V BE- 'es is authority is ovcrrdden m
evtry respect 10 JulLe STORY In The Unied states
W oooll-' In tnlt case no.on was uod' 10
ne-s gave li- f' '-ncit before the Gr.nl Ju-y
WITHOUT rtu. sworn. AGit.Vi.i 9. aH4 Goa were
tr srntgl 10 g." ult. aai Che Court not oul. Aclu
49, ,'..'-' l-'1s' "a Iis.ts &c -; @ no
tfoycr, ,l, go. .,t,. i'm ms aaiavit' Jui,o a.
:, permit. rtc,.l.1.e of IA, Marshal M the
h'u,, a-. -. wG1 w.ro 40: aa4ldct - ,ur
Dsp-y - r' a. o. A'c lave been, "A oppo'iuon to
conflict ,l Q, uuony tLst the lu.ictmeLt lad
t..lI-..4o....g mlli
cr.rLEH,NLr SARCASM.
nsttr' Afusal, niss c.4.u1i tiai u wa npD1.
REM nu tu. zee O.. 800 case o. The Uuitcd Sutli
Nes or Was & ta- PFC i.r rtiA-I- was nc. r-s ~
og.usFr,'c'.
usaNr.
Mr DA'i.-.i an urt ls...ll h. slI,ns uiAt 10
hr. ston.a a-l li'f vr1A Won "irf Ve ~ ,-f.
"t.r ...'t '-', 't d. '.ft '-s1 i-i-i.'..t
Mr Davis D4.t4e,.ea'!j-I would o.at.oy counsel
10 du it
" iou-h tom la', 10 don3 foa Hcul' ave =.
nj baN- .is ID tl.t 'h,t' Nart De- n. c'l P,
N'rs oil Ul' t. VI ''.t,'Hh. ......,..
,d JgIse WOO -, 'l, .. ''.' ,' ,, o, '
tugrc yea DID, i". a' ..'.i ....,--
r. T', Ts,s w. SAY. u ,,',,.,. w., ,. ,,'',,.
n raw ~ ,,ra, vs.. a. t ,.,
an ,,,,.. l,, .ci'', 'l1 t.'',., e.,
not he made
u, rv me ,7.' ., ,. ,.i ''' ''''''.'' '-
NJ Sinn. .ltg. g. .,... ,.l, r.,.r ~ .,.r "a
,,,,i,n i' ,I - ,'~.-'.,,
~" Sir'| w., ni.t m ,M.'r M '.t, n I.,...,
.h,"b - s",'.,t , ". - t', a. , y. '''
" " ~
AGo. HESf troN rue pIMt RREu.
Mr. Curig4-Wr ffy. NOW q, submit A tr,-I. rel
o. M. trt.rt. ,r. q ne c.,u.It OF tn .,.ltit.i
Or, Grst tb,i ihe ,,t Cf t'.r.res, pl,sci N4, ii
is9O emitted Al .rt t9 ,l..ft, tic ritht Z ,,..
yens OF the Trit STATE. TO vote In the seven.
States Of t.e I,l .nd Tor other pgrpcst- % ip "a
f-r a. II purtor To- 90 ye tac oleute ciar,gl la Ola,
Indictment crime .-nIn.t 1 rt.d St,.s Is frpll.
n.nt to O., Coz. .!,.'si Vi tnt tul,d S.lte- nj -
tnercfore i.orvr4lNs and volt. Second, t.i.t "a,
said Indictment does not state iicts VI ch cnnst.
tute an or G.. .i,r tc .,i oi Congress linrc,ai .
Tne Indictment . ht,u ROLL w iny hsnl i- 900 boz
dlttmeut ur4U.. Itrsuee Ouiu ~ thirteen count 4
clarging In y.rs4s .C.rs, 20 IN Ier. t.n'l-I
have really hal Lp OULur.lu,t; to read i,--,er,a.1
ohinces against tc elh s.cuua OF the act o
congress VI MAJ ~, l5,J. Itcy arc Ill oi ucI
odences against or 10 reference - fcsisua
Ton prcI az ~ tp t' e.c-.ua IA CsriAii
eirtflcts iu us cts lur ntMltr oi Con
Frcss, and take 10 th.t ava t. ossgmo taat the ir
tcmtui is iorLut on tAia section a. set, VII ..
lHIteIred 90 lu De den uifcr that have sfsl.iu'.
~ lie CCmt AoN, tirs, TIC Nety ltss trns tha
81 kcs ut Nhtu Wc open .is oct oi Congress, tal
'sIecaly Wien Ne read tnis tscniicA section %
", a., iu tLe iti ll1.o, ta"t 10 Is iuposshr
tntcstrd ~ tt 20 aliiyc 20 any curcti iucn Of th'
Eesnlns OF ihe t.rinf aHi he nature OF the offence
against NLlcu D. Is aimed. wiAotl lo"tIn- ou'sie
oi ls ttrra. Fpi ,z-,7i.r: II fpy.af OF -.
Lauon o. voters 4 s!elks ul
.......-