, 1870-08-07

bo1 contalntnE the papers on tho door, be-
tween the window and the chair, with The lid
upen- There were papetH strewa3 about the
table, and IN Overturned chair beside the
table,
TESTIMONY OF TIE cArrES1m.
Philip 1emaistre WAS next called for, He
came Being duly sHoIu, ha was aaked his
occupation md residence, and said:
an carpenter BY occupation, and reside
1t No. Gao Hn1son street.
Mr. Fellows then said:
Now. Mr.. lemaistre, Just 40 on aud tell ua
all yon know about thus house.
Nj. lernaistra then went On with long,
Irrelevant story, to which every ono listened |
xearily. One point OF interest in it was that |
on Thursday morning, July Is, he uplatched !
walked into the basement, Ind that anybody J
else could have dohe the sama Another po1ns
Wss thathe entered tue loure on Thursday and
called for Smith Ill the WAY up atairs 10 the I
third ste1y, at tho top Of his VOICE, but VAS
not heoEu by l.is fellow workman, although
the latter wss there at work in the garrett The
ison :. dog" With which tire snurres had been
committed was here shown, to tho witness AID
this question put to him:
Do you know what kind Of 4 tool this Is 4.
No; never saw ANYTHING Ike it; il is nos
usel ty carl,eatels.
q. Lid you ever wo-k Tor Nr. Nathan be-
fore last week? 4. Yes; worked for him
Ill the same house about i've or six mouths
ago. and also year aud half ago. l was
employed At that time in making some repairs
IN Ei.s stable, aud there We're cAulker1 at work
With NE At the -ame time.
z. Did you ever see tho servant WOMAN
Mr.. Ee!iy or her sou before this occasion
\. c,ei t..t saw the sons Of Mr.. Nathan the
arst time was at work, and also some Ut the
loE.t +tIcs.
G When dill you begin your job on this last
ocrnsi;n: a. began work on Monday alter
loon.
G. ril anytody witt you whilc engaged in
lie L,'1te: 4. Ycs; on Tueedav Mr.. Knight,
anf Of my friends, called t } see me.
O. uow dit. be set into the house? 4. lie
'h'E The bell.
=. =: "sre yea at wo:k every day since Mou-
i; 10Y lorg :ia you z:ork eacl, day 4.
tut 6 IN the evening.
l !. H"w did so1 get into the house every
nt1hnE 4. ! r>ng the bell at tho ba4s-
u1,t GEor-th1t IL, tho wooleu door. Tie
e'e with tlss IRON railing, whic', Is before tho
-, eonla oren 9sy putting my hand be-
| !. Vas tho house door locked, or oulv
vi4ti: A. 1t locks Of itself if closed, BE-
ea|c il has spring lock.
| At what time does tho in:lkuan come in
4.'mo,ring: 4. At about Aa1f-past o'clock.
{. Mho was in the house, usasl1y, when you
fwfe these' A. Nzs. Kelly aud her sou.
Y. What did sou Usually DO whon you en-
u0.k. ''e4' w
Y. Whom did you see there, ae general
!Mhs! 4. always eaw ,Irs.-ks1; saw
,ss 1snda .1a s1e door ~a.: Nathan there; .oa
!'oI5 SaA1,,,ch epor" asked juror. "Thss on",
rss:lct r.: tho wit.oss, pointing to III. Nashlug-
to,Sa,hAu. Il raw E:m twise OF morninSs,
,,.ssw him, tn, oil Wednesday evening. no
rs,.ilv car,e tlNp staira from his bedroom
Wien cntt rcd he llouse. lie como down at
hGi-rast one n2orning, hut believe he had
@" Yon snoto a:epl,ldcr in :he ouse
| Where did va, tc that: 4. There wcrc two
s..u1sdIe,s-opfof -. them In = clo3ct on tbs
| :reu1.d f,oor, WIRE I looser for my tools. a1ld
| he utl,cr IN c,set IN tue garnt.
L. What 10 on mean by the second floor
ne :I<or OH wlet dr. AAsh*n was k'l'ed: -
Yes.
q. Ve.c ~ closets in which these stcrl.d.
,.fs stood tstened? \. No.
d, You We 1t work while IN the lionss III
,sre Satl,x1t bedroom and library? A. Ies.
o. VIII, you notice il tho door leaainS
, txkv,l o,not? L. No, did nots don't
,, .r>m II ives loekel OK not.
q, HF long have you known Air. Aa'5:h,
, | sha ca({t to see you IN tue house on luea-
-,v. have known him about twelve
I .rer.tl. .--..
;: i. yhat ia his occupation? 4. Ha il var
rfh 1anpfacturer.
@. II what part Of the house were you wha7
le ealcd 10 sec you A. was III the cellar,
q | wer'ug at the coal bins.
s. Q Did you converse about the inmates OF
,hosouee A. No.
!. c You did not say who Tired thcres 4. No.
{. Yon had nothing whatever to Sly about
= Dtbs Affairs Of the inmates, or about anything
uat concerned theuls A. No: nothing what
ercr. ...
q, How long did yon stay in the house o.
Ihrrdsy: 4. Till about ten minutes to
('c,ock.
- o, Br Whist wav dill you leave the housa
!, y. We lett through tic basement door. We
lid ullE 1art work III the basemeut.
i Q. We're you in Atr, Satnau's room At al:
fine on ghnrslay: A. Yes: between ard
"rlocE.
| NY hammer.
I. We,e the wir .nws onen at that time
\. I don't know; did not take uotice Q
.. Lid you notice how the bed looked
! 1t appt ared made up for come one t.
ietl On.
6 Were you in the house tho next day
. | AZ E,i=!ed. but was taken there by = dc
-tt:rs, vino had been rent after me.
O. bid you Dee 3lr. Sath2n's body before i
! ad t. en- c,stusbed: 4. did,
I, Md 'he hcd-tlid you SEQ that2 Ho'
iii II look: a. did not notice it paEticsl
,, l:,,r. Int it appeared eighty mussed up
IL sEeet VAS thrown back
: JrEcEs QUESTIONS.
Here juror took his turn at questioning
@. Vas Smith with Ecu each day? A. Ye:
. q. Wczcyou tue onlv workman in the house
: : \. There was also aInason there. and labol
sr. Thtrc was 10 ane else. 1sa" no on
elre.
e q, When Tera the mason aud l4borer there
{ 4. On Thu, edaE.
o. Did you see them besore7 l. No.
, i. And 1here Was no one else theres A
, We'll, l saw two men in the ylrd looking ;
! the tagging hut eaw no one else IN the hou!
D except the master m1son-
O. We're there any plumbers in the house
i. didn't zee any.
a Q. At What timo on Tuesday did you see "
r:uleht in the cellar? A. About half past
: ! O'Clock in the morning.
e Q. Wha: cid he come ia. sec you about
4. About soue money AFFAIR."; some inve:
u:eLts.
'e Q. Did Eou 60 to any other part Of the Ct
ID q. Did anybody elsa vi.i. yon: l. No.
: 4. Did auxbody visit Smith. your fello
: ,sc worked together Ill ths time, and so
an tell.
be Z. lios often did you eee young Kellys
!. carly every day.
ae Q, Did you see lin on Fnday. mosni1
-;1er the Aody llad been discoveteds A. n
IT g. Did you. At any TINA. SEQ strangers
the houEe7 A No; nobody except the s1o<
lid md the ruilkman: the grocer received an
'et 'er for chop, l believe, from Mrs. Ke1y:.
= z. Did you cver So into The Te1t 81 :
be oIse-in,o the yard: T. So-that Is,
,e- g. Did ron 1t any time hear Mn. Kelly
mark that Mr.. Nathan WAS coming to toE
cd y iesi heard her sag he would stsy in
-oc:e On Thus.day night
,or O. Did you At auy time speak to outs
TeEos's about Mr. .satbans wife. a: No.
:: No: to nobody.
II, Q. When you called to Smith the day ,
s7eke Of, when be Va. At work IN the gsr
in Lie did not hear you, did rou call very loc
ell. L. called 1t the top Of nv voice
ust Q. At what iEe Of day WIS that
Abou: fifteen minutes past O'Clock In
Sc morning.
Mt: O. Were the usual day noises 1t that ii
ael in the street: 4. Yes:
@. Nov, suppose he had not been 1t &c
1t hit had been asleep, and i: vas in the still
the night, do you euppose be would haye he
aid yon: A. We'll, no.
O. Tou feel confident about that
Well, he couldn't have heard me unlces ca
Of 4: the top OF uay voice..
old g. Now, suppose that the rooms OF
ear aouse we're thus occupied: two rooms on
I third aonr by two sleeping persons, and
lay roon in the sarzet, and the rear room on
4. second floor: and 1t the same time it vas
hay sill Of the night, and the door to Mr. Ssth
socm, tke frn1t room oc the second doar,
the open-do you taink that nnder these crc
ont statees noisc in M1. Sathan's room VI
L. hsvs been heard By anybody in the house7
Well, think 1t would have been heard by
| he soma on tho same door.
Q. How many doors wcre there betN
lat: Mrs kelly's room and Mr.. SathAn'ss
:. Ihese weIeahree; but I did not notice Il
: II doors particularly
!. IT | q Wher t],c =, pJl-,,z ,rr-n nf yyr1Ff