The sun., 1870-02-19
THE PuBLIC scHooL QUESTION.
Has New York CITY any Rights which
Country Members Of the Legislature nre
BoUud 10 Respect f-The Birht at Albany
The Hon. ThoniarJ. Or, amer Rebukes
the COuntry inturmc ddlers

bound 10 RtspeCt S-Thc Bight nt AlbaHy
The Hon. ThonnarJ. Cr~ amer Rebukcs
the CouDtry IntCrmcddlers.
The Legislature in Albany has been flooded
With petitions for the repeal OF the law allowing New
York city to make appropriations for her ragged
schools. On Tuesday bitter debate occurred In
the Senate a motion 10 refer .he petitions to the
Committee on Municipal Affairs. Mr.. woodiu Of
Cayuga county, lasLcd the appropriation without
mercy, nsting that II destructive Of our Com.
mon school system, and movement really In the
exclusive interests OF the Roman Catholics In
reply to MN the Hon. Thomas J. Creamer made
bitter sltcc', Us follows:
Thought that reptesentnt YES OF the state OF New
thai senator. could look liue oeyd tie uowngs OF
nS out 'Stibhe and ooian peuuon,. and send tlenl
hunir 4 u q Jusond OF Ioor chiiroa who have here.
one tcln over them TO look alter inc i1tero, - have
to I1S @ Ne aTd sy IyS c ss1 e
and stNe 10 give them.
Why ~. what question for theIeo ie OF this state
zcn. q ihS city >cw oIk shal. have privilege
,asssa SlargE t.t 9Le in thslt Ifess WY soni
eAor slt hundred thousand dolaIs 4year tba, W.
saye ,, Why don. tho people Of a. st'ae afons Nod
t,s hs s i or,cr uL H.. ~ uIUn L.f Felt1en'
aon oy wacS marry ali lie coutte; 'caS Of TINS sste
Ps gTSs' 'eGc s sac sHS Sq Spa RS5' 5
eountic. Of Sew ork and Kings, Why, TASK. 40 90;
ION tSe Siy yos % SSh nj @ 's
ehoS ,s o. at I GanS H S ySS 10 aog q5geT S 9qr
msae Sq 70 2h w you ra,s y'gfSvs- sursy We hays
year 10 sess TS snd a cS a4S senss o ss @ 9
emdren u our city, when We nave peop ticf@ Who
are SihnS % d. IT. sna TO DO q al one thiiI the ca
orss m S.SSS SSreps. foq9 % sss sss1ry S nays laws 70
nave NJ such l-ws lere, aud IhcraofS In our lsrs.
. u a. GeSessary 70 have epen some avenue to edu.
,e.gg.i Si - - c.iii VA u-terA.iy shrns
t' ~, 80 "a II .ls, M s ,' hg f.s',s' ~ .t,ie
&c tnE y devote @ sves 'S a,I Z sS GS ~ isss seo 20
ene nu la c4re and siudHr,s 40 70 s,.ueAto Elan
& Tc oHs s, c,I, to be allowed 20 interfere sutha
e AZ u Ne ~, N Ply 'Osf5l' s,s few gert,men n
about i uAr We are oursc!vcs-to satisfy n, yiews and
iAr cuar MOTIONS Of these pco c up1n ths qncstoI-
tucse thousands 4 poor ni.d,cn by ,a-rincac ani
6F a. Wy IN isngrSEcs ' ga az . g9yeT ana einca'cd
oL F,ntcn ~ concerning h1w oJser pcop,o's ,nuGf5n
ISwTs y s, ., .aoI.qEn ,r.tautas IN e Com.
t ~ T An IN ~ c", y'"F ttn n r,ir
ehansGi - "a. - iyA. " an amount qua 70 tsenty
lunl Of - -. @t understood fu vrl Ia nat Commit
c, IN dc Committee Of oiicl,nce 1lyns Oh .is ~
erg diy rrlps i5e amount Of h4 soy S,a . a.
,Vs would oe % reluccd uat tvent, per cent OF thS
i.lsN amount NNN a &c n mere naglttNc. Sir he
amount UI -rud ill-t these schools done caIDOt
stc l,e.e. IT sun.ccnt i1eaoc ss TO ssr that
ElrHdy i Lrrt Ytar 10, annual cNptL Lss CT suppgrtg
oar pu.l lC -choOls Il- D~ca reduced q. arly fgO00
ahesv schools cui cXsi, 10 Cefail eNtcnt Without
tupru it ifJu. llc Cit OI tie stAtc-l oul on,v sty
rom the cy, OF uley asa no sLDpIt irjn the St,5.
~ aat % NsE asUith e aud tris year hUye said
Tie current expenses uy Board Of Education Of the
cN an' county of New YORK have uotn reduced
tstlQy tu LAT on ma! Ndd q a. JtgJ toi wnat.
cv.r amount cqIt O. % er cont OF he Excise nind
pl L1J, Al stl te SApen,e O C1uCAtug our cai q. on
poor ant l'rI Hu !, Wlll amount Ian mi.
Lon G,.a les than wa. for the y! eccdnr yoa'
co. -i0rf tbs q matter Of purely lOeU lc-i-iaton
u , O,y g. rrp'ai section that EuIboI Ics the CIV
Il srw H 60 Tax ~ ctiZcns for a lur,y loca
tut.i ii.u O. hH.r sn- le TcpreseLtauvs IRON tlnt
- 4 uUrt o' "a tlt3 Assembly, Tor the repeal
Dec D'. "a senator believe AZ east ltle ssitgoy.
illAtts pf. lSu4 X NcruututS Are we VI New
torN ~ ldd ta ~ 10 NhHthsT Oat people slould ns
lA~id IJ1 i- ku'p2r' ~ uJts We are WlH- To take
Vac ltsPoh'I9iA,y b. are yullug lace m pCopO
i1n bis tut, tI.eA Ing hat ara rrkt aud A. as
.'iti-ur U1d fna Ioufd ia. sald, we Aayi aire4d,
as avtoc te people u tAu y aud of tie STATE
O.! uuotrit"IAs our views upO tAis su0Jtct 10
No. GTa VIA p1i'y Or NhAi members of UaJ pu,v ~.
~ ucns'lNr- AtAist me On tins question IstanI u
.'{eI OF eeIcAusn 1hough oNely ctInasi ~ SbichII
1T re Fta n . no matter whether Il it "a tdr pfe
diceE oi -ght4ciCu ia ay parry IA any ~ tsru of
Duc, ali VII itaIuty no plEly tLaI d.os u)t laiu
tan tA.s IJallyl.