The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1870-05-11

TINE ERFE-LOVERS BURIED UNDEH
TIE JUhY'S VERDICT

also charge the jury and that the jury would prob
ably bring In their verdict before the jourumcnt
OF the Court, the crowds In attendance were greater
than on any previous day.
The enemies Of the prisoner mustered strong.
The Tribune establishment was out In large force.
rHE SINCLAIR AND GILBERT FAMILIES
were numerously represented. the siar.hke eyes
Of Mrs. Calhoun-Runk blazed from a corner Of hs
bar, where she had ensconced herself seemingly
with desire to avoid observation. Mrs. Sinclair
sat we'll out in the group OF ladies, and bore ap
scrutiny with heroic fortitude. The husbands Of
those ladies' present but did not attract obser
walton. They all len In time to escape witnessing
the prisoners triumph.
Tho District Attorney went to the jury at tiOs,
aud SPOKE two hours and hall. lis opening was
follows:
JUDGE GARvIE's OPENING.
Ifyour Honor please Gentlemen OF the jury 1t lsnoi
rord 10 the tfN1sacton the Investigation Of which has
SSnaSSd II nIS e q te Ne weck Sm
three times the nmubor Of day that re are Jurors IN
long IS ithgs wopd have bGen yods DUTY and NV
to8 '3 3ur dsty bS o tSc psbe and 10 The rrisaf
To wa nay o AN rg ' camssn AZ mo
OF time required Ia tue Investigation Of case Of such
MoMCSToUs CHARACTER
Il, nPi BEEN Efr nan 70 a9 e Ta sg S
and no man has q rght 70 t9ke Tie lay Toto hs own
opir any case IS ,6is prisoner y hs 40 assumed
u be sen'at.onl Did I. ever occur To- 1o1 senlle-
been proved 70 the contrary, that
ALBERT n. RICHARDSON AND ms. MFARLsvD
wSTe eIt.ey r9o ,E o. ne charges that have been
In Nr. Ecntr son We see = man VINO when 'lis coun-
try was roct,d RON centre 10 crcul r"' Tbs
,ooELnE en- sar Sirgsgs' dor Peiicn1 va IA
wicked AMI 1rus,urai rcbe5" ns9ast II raj CIV,
ernment Here wgs man WHO occo.diTs 80 ne iosr:
Of ne reb sas nteoner and WHO, up TO The ime le
ro Syd IN h ETA tra y @ any root
sgalnst hlm OF 9i lmpropct conduct or any c2naAet
occurred ~ ne pres, Of numcrpua Wny't,. ana
yet he Ia chal gcd with crime Tor which l- r.spner
TOOK TUE LAW INro nIs OWN HANDS,
and sent him to his long account without preparation,
and wuhopt question. ard without trla. lscusioni
Gentlemen, put u 20 you a. sonshic men, I put II 70
word. put 1t 10 every one WAC hears whether
man ever
MiRRrEs A MISTRESS
exccpt mon compusion for he reasons, and vcrv
Justly, II size prostitute herself 70 'u sho may haya
a . q, Che 'gHG ias to hgcdT s 9 % P1 h.
rem. and TO be his COMPANION through .ng lt,tg,e.
woman who h1, been ~, be o%n stTe 81 @nS
IGNORED sSSS sGysay % says rHs Se proof
They say there Ta SyGSE sS sa %s 'sss
what object Obtained excsp, 70 glaee e rartlo:
n S WIN a S Sal ea1 a ey 2G q nr, Ts
their Intention by its contamination in
A MARRIAGE CEREMONY.
Is not that sufficient evidence in case mot he
sardcd her as pure woman and hHi -nc rcsar ,i
woman more than two years % ofo ana In lsGi had
aid to Johnson and .incair ana o,hcr. " ney's can
the world, and she had told HIM that sac woah never
Now. geutismen whether that be true. or whe,her u
be false, Is pot Tor me TO say You as co nmon.,en,s
your own mnds, and 10 say what the probahlte, lre
not kere to defend ad%lterers am nat here Tor he
purpose of,e9rng up the foundations Of sors and y
such purpose Bpt you are here for ne vurpgss g
ms community; as wen as eyer, gthsr yommunit
SSIa % not sy TOOK ~ we SSe % my
| Ia not for them to say he Old me deed, And
WE KILLED TUE MAN;
Wei % that .eFa sP and ms Gtsi
| he came didn't maSea MISTAKE In shooting enybody
rs Eri.GSs2 al q g' M sn, ~ Va; ~
once q frenzy which carried MN out q hm,clt ana
therefore he not rcspon.ibs for ie dcrI y nus
g 4 6scsas lily SS s't . na M p, Si d. a.
fe1ce OF insanity, while In the same breath iheysay
TnE ADrLTrRER MUST nIE
and that by the hands Of the dhouorel husband Th''
10 Inconsistent They must tax" one prpdlri
the u. GigSF 9h}n The ma act Snt 5' vas IS
insane and ,hIretorG n2t reTpS ,s e, mnn
mind Was Tn.lsw the Court wil GIVE yon, y thai
yG S1si Hit % Sc Ss WIS ff9S Ton V p r. al
be @9 me until Of 9t praH Mn IN fG ia T
tSbsh the tact OF an,y before thry on ne .nry
did the deed eshp The man his blood 3. On uir hl,a
but We are not gTy neeanta We av me-, r''n,n,,s
sanity, because
orR CASE Is MADE OFT.
We say. vou COMPUTED me murder a'l ro show ~
fact The prisoners counsel atteW' Is iH' IF. zee "
Insanity WeSn, Tha. r. 'gur rr.ot !, w.. 10 I'm, m,
'noG y6 ha Whit raa Ir 81 .racc to WI n IN
sau..y originate, ~ The llind or the l"'} whether
: cause We cannot conn, cnend. wu"iacr Die ID W.
! Diet .rugod ~ he quNefius OF ,he Ia, t,s .aioS o
, tue hands, the
MrNrrvl ANp TAKING
10 rmsC'G or o. orerr. as one waS,. na Il ~
together which uul,t constitute the !nd c,tl. 0, CON
ia 60 ierGcf Iab T. can , your ona ,at5ir
the rule in regard 10 ths subject OF insanity.
4 ELOQUENT PLRt oP FUDGE GAEYIS.
, Judge Garv.n tacu pIoroe led to argue What h
conceived to be- the law Of the ease, whch he d. II
. | - lucid and cuunict mtnner. After which, Hc ana
| lived the testimony, aud develope the III, ory o
the prosecution with such clearnc-' ~ s'',r unpl
tuiC Of ILLUSTRATION, and cOsency OF lo-ir %, proye
MIN TO be a great advocate aud daugcr 'us adyeI
| sarY before July. He made mnny telling IRE, an
evidently alarmed the prisoners irionl- az to III
result. Al tho close o. Judge Gsrvin's arsgneI
| prjtiOn OF Which Recorder llackeu rc"ppoared o
+. the bench, and delivered the following luminou
, CHARGE TO rag JURY
m o Sa @s el Sgh IN few Ga. me G%
10 eye during nyr Weeks. viii pass quc'ly from Il
gaze. only 10 n remembered for tue pIucC dent whic
may he established nv your verdict that thts has bee
trial invested with great public Interest you nopl
| only have notiCed from the eager thrOng dAily
sleging the court room may property be 0ttribnfed
notable persouascs have been brought fopSSid VII
public positions aud acts sayings IN conl ito
with the wife Of the accused for various years prior
the shooting, had occasloned extraordinary and dG ne
. | comments.
( l must now ask your undiyld sttenton wh.le e
: | sist yon IN holiday evenly
\ | THE BALAScE-BgAH
from which depend the scales Of acquiita and oony
tlon-tcales nll which such volume evidence III
| been placed. The duty Of judge ami luy ts AlwgI
diihcut al the end OF those ca es In Which ulANOdAb
attitude has been given 10 evidence his u'rn tAe
i ny the zeal OF counsel, consumed iH qucut a.
4 dresses upon either side Your duty bcroMVs cIr
ordinarily diihcult unuer the extreme latitude take
. BY evidence and counsel during this Til aud proc
u | lug from the pcculartes OF the defence. can pe
Y | lken your labor To that Of the god uIuer WI
10 obliged 10 st bushels OF sand IN order to obtain
PEW GRAINS or GOLD;
,, because really, amid oil these accumuoiiors NJ cv
y dence, the issues for yon e dclermne az lev ard
pable OF being simphed II thad been p.s'tu" At q
outset 20 have Known what circunstanc,s we're c ~
admissible in evidence as ditectly bearing upon VI
INSANITY defence, Ihs case might perhaps hA', Dee
closed within Neek.
This accused, let ne saw AZ the outset Of uy 'mtF