, 1870-12-05
Was Bazaine a Traitor2
Move nacnts OF the Armies.
CEnoM orA SPECIAL. oonRksroSpESI-j

.,t1,arr aoo .,.t,s ,,,1, ~ ,o;tr,,,1.use- e.0Do
.-,.a,,. ..,5 am IN rh,..enots wa rom
"ASoa 'ah. w." s'S, 7ee'
ptn,a n.e.ius u n.e;ns HI. n.,tipr order de- ,our
pointedly with the aseeEtion, "Vanquished hv
famine, we are forced to submit to the laws OF
,,, md tn rorx,i,nta onrsaIves nri.ouerp.-
"", c..ss.. - 49,. .,,s ~ ~, +r,s sa,t hv IA,
zaine to Bisnazk aud to London puellshes IN
the 1ndtpe1adonce Dtice letter in which he io-
dicu.ntiv refutta tho charges Of treason ~ in
.,o,,,aa IN c,,,ha,,,.a , nr[cj, m.t;nn and the
copcludinE x p.l.sraph Of bis defence is: ave
we're not compelled to capitu'ate eitneI "
tfon.~ -
Tie Tond Of prusse!s contains lo..es from
p:zaine dated c.sss,. November ., in which
he. IN response 70 aa@oeuA tnno.e'.oos y u
tIeason, proceeds to say, among other things, |
"that the French army would not have follow |
II , +r,,tor th.t tba c.nltulstion vns arrnsd |
N aps ea.h ri of Gc,oh@r thaf in at,emnt,no tn
a"to,,,,- .hs con,3nrt ~ The Commsndsr-ir-
Chief ~ liza Armv ot tne Rhine. ths delec.ta
~ tha gasernmer NJ ths na,ionay desanoe 40
si.,a - e. 40 -, ~ tn,r rh,t ha a,rs mr. r.
fsrn sny tnoul.d d,c ~ H. frre noe,rion of tha
n;mr' Ghich. afte9 ns.rlv th1es mnnths' h,rd
confn.ts scsinst a doub]a force. could, in
.sni,e Of nj eHorts. NOT put itself IN oommuni-
'csiion viii, i,it1. Thnt in this coutast OF
threa moutbg. Me1ehal, Il GsuatAls,
| Sf4n nf;rars and a. a5} sold,ern were
| II hv sha ensmy'a bnllatn- ia nyi,1enca that
| snci, ~ ~ s,,,r caEI not h.ve ham oomnnsed
- rou.rna IA traitors. Farnine afoue. and
~ 10 vesther wss the c,nso th.t the
1 the;r ha,,ds T4,e s,f1l1ery h,d no more team..
~ 1850. s.r.,- ~ rnnra hnrsts f,rnc a.fen
~ law E : nnr3,on ~ shem' Th,t w;,hnut il
encIrT I'd n+rseyerance. the amy would
hsSn tnccnnbea aireatly duripc tho d.as davs
~ octnbeT. sshen ehe was alresdy reduced to
IN, s Sran1aes .nd l.tsrs to 200 uemnss OF
had msad por day for eact, Individual &c.
Snch Is the qualification Of the chief
actor az the capitniation, Add to thia Ill the
Information rrca,.ed nreyious to the sur
Tcndnr frnno 7eserters and others. that the m
tinns Of horsa rneat xsro but seventy ars1anes
ns- H.. Ia as.h ;nh.h;t.nt snd fhtY fhe
sss1i ~ entirely isekinr. 20 tflst. dnfiur lbs
Ia 5svs ~ liz siece, eon,ds of desertars
mu9 sHe;r . 1one.feit xsnta b. sTaliox,nr sooous-
MI ~ tSis nrer;ons nsiina articlee and The
.rr-endev ~ MSt1 viii fse instif3ed ~ the
whole world. except by the enbrvo DICTATOR,
Gsnhctia. nd The unreflectip9 French, who
have ascribed to treason eycrs reverse they
! the csnitulstion Of Me.z,
:. Eox M c,nIrn. I viii give YOU tho othcr,
: or Gamfetta'a. side. Of The surrender, which,
: Nv the WV. il the s,de ceneralfy acc:ptcl q
l AitAt ttYn ma ht a
uG uuS ~ pe ,re.s,,. @ .nna.,at in ths r.ri at
a n V.l.onrt .nd nf,hli. had IN I rrnyinci,l na
:: rer. De- YsIcourt wss Adju,ant to Gcuera
= : }u.n.h.s NJ nd ~. ~ Mety mill ia surrau.
r Ma fsr.,s Hrm ~H th,t n.1,;na ;nuts,d of hms
as ne ~ ,,,a.;n;n,. insr "a r. r.rr;son w
y. dn1inr fhe fifrt few weeks Of the eicco yer
- n,a,s,,s..a xiti, ,hem' ~ nnch 10 that it Be-
It esma fhe thtme Of reusrks by Lis ipfo,i.
IN others; thst, although The supply was no
in | entirely exhausted, the ratiops were suddenl
l
a. October. md then again resumed to be give
A. cnt thst. sinea 1hs iii Of 6eptsmbes. 81
h. 7.;ne rnnio no earioua attempts to bfea
n fbrna,cI ,he German j,ues-{hat al at.omps
a were su, feints to cover up bis eecret negoti'
y. At INV Of those feeble at.ezupts ho Va
i. 1sror 1raaont I'M sent nne or ofher nj Iii
n Grncrsls With e1uress or,iers to 70 only 40 Il
=. and thcn turn tnck, That. for wceka befos
4, the csp1tulltion, party vas formed, nudt
r. ite leadership Of the Mnrshal, which system
q atcalls worked toward the Decentralization
to The Esr1isou, by making them uuderstau
'or | tint, ~ the Emperor il. now q pr,aoner, nr
u Inasnuch II there IL no regular government.
Of j. uselese to continue the defence any Long
IN tert,on Of their chief to be the bringing b.
~ the T'rfnca In,ptfisi. and With the MD
lie Armies of sedan and Metz, place him,
we!l ss maintain him, upon the thron
With tbe Emnrees aud himself al Regent
That III, nl.n xas ancou aged b. Uis1nar
th hnt onIr ta r.fc,, ti,s Ws,s in Iii own IA
he nsnrIy' to Iet him eonrnne lis proyisior
nc M. Wien that vas done. to demand his ~
rtpder- -,
Ihe Marquis do II Motte Fenelon, I d
;ho sceudant Of the famous autbor Of "Te]
ro. macuue,- tho has arrived here, q fsw d.
ass 1Eb, from Metz, coYrcbnrxtes; 10 the mi
xc- tie above sccus satiung Of II. de- valeourt.
sss have been shown a private Letter from
w. ,en tefore thn n.n;tniat,on. 10 bis slater !
"a s;f;nr he1e md uho !, thn nirce at GeneI
~ vne.eur. Ch,ef of D.xaine'e stafr. In which
.ar- c1prcrprs hi susrh ions in regard to the II,
- ei,s1s hnnett fntanttons. Anether Colonel
,ra- tLe Garde E1isea. ATE. tie c2ptulatiou.
his vie II ani A!exsnder fhis neobew1 ,
AZ ntii1 amnrr ihs liyinu. md on orr WV to a.
me many .s prisoners It is rumored That t
ing 1aine was torciely taken frcm his carriseo
oon Tho people Of the country and znassxcrot.
aed would be too we'll metited punishment
,oa. bis treason butt fosf It IL not true
ues could ci:e 10 you uany mora Iike pu1 7ori
ted eviilerces Of Dazsipe'e treason, but enou
al haye bern given to ehoE you tho d12f:
an French public opinion In regard to Tho carl
nm lstfon. q siiEe iii ereaf tatsetrophea OF
Ian ~ III. n ma tcn VIII T;l1 bs shrondsd in n,
sa. ta1r ,,t;, tfs rslrner and ,,nnreind,ced tis
t ti.23 ~ w., saan ~, f..tnre dsV li fhrnW rnt,re HI
sro- uren il; Although I DO not beliave II b
ute ful service to Lis countrv, would willingly
tha loss Of 1 fortrtes with an immente army,
Of do believe that bn fell in the extue criml
tai er,or his master did. ns,pely, 10 attespa
o1S e,yr fha d1n.stv before Franre racngnig
N.Y. ;n ,ha forner tI;c onlr r,1rst;on of the lat
- A. tnr4har i,ahcre fh.t ia w,a enr{ur.
~. /, ~ eahnv,rs ~ h,;rc;nr II, ~ M Tnnna
.;.s Tine. ~ ,1,n xsrr .,,s sp;,fn1 dfcjon. 4
4 whom a Berlin raper recently eAid. IN relal
old to The flilure ct poseo uago:istions )
t.,nr Ed h.fors the ;fn1orn.t., ~ ,hess A ~ ~
~. ~ yh,ef, hs .nnos.r ~ h.rn nfyeresl "a
Yer able conditicus, but which bore n'resdy
+h;. .nrr and vars rs,n.ronrntix reinctrd.n y :.
sssa T1,.t. thtrefora- H4zsins WA the uup
t. L. ,icfi+n nf if;nfomatic .rnn- in Which he c
;.am ~ ro,a;,r antsnrleI h;rssit snf5sr, n
AS as Sn,,ht T., =, viva hn5srnInn,,en,an ~ n
uv @ es = T.. ~ Lii ste,~ ,,a ,,s... ,ei.;n1r III
!, US . r,shr.t;ao" ~ ~ Nv s,r1re.ssfn1 II
To esc.e' .! NS :. " s'49 :. -. 80 ,n,c
use mauo 14e1. sH - H ~ taas ~ H IT, IL
Aem- lliussi A.tSt a.stns ss - NJ " h..d -" Iii
,aon, be can post1h's earty On ~ nsl1, - ~, -
aAnA nouCn " nsseo, 6to W ~ ars.t.@s4 @ =.
h{.ck.art. and daxx1ed the oye Of both II
and foe.
In this connection, lsye omitted to !
uteF. tiop, also, the faef that General DoyeE.
VA to sce the Eppcrpr, In England, VAS,
.., yicus 10 his being intrusiel, bS Dazaine.
sI1e1, thc,a rn;s.;ons. oninate,l = General. hy
10 oe l.t,ar-.11 the otber f}rnnrafn l,ayinr raj
ptaee tc.rt n ths m,tte1
ltus1l T1,s ,,.cst ra7-@e,r- th,noz IN nv mind
'Aa ,,a Ecnr5s ivc,, IN pr,nrs Frf.1er1cf an,
n