, 1870-11-12
THE LAW COURTS.
Value OF a Coopefs AaAe.
Tbs Cpum1dia Mannerchor vsrsus
Albert Crosby.
wh,, the Pngre., OF I4ife Cost Mr.
Schobex. -.
6umsme Court.

4 CASE Hf rEAIA -ftA1I1ohs pAAAoAS
rs E-ara L. Nutray L Mai seson '.
''ne Asl' .. ~ 1. ~. ~. ~ su,t % hrouaS. py The
frs,"s 't1.L .-eW,r.sn ronna, .rho
y n,lr +, tho xtorehousc Of appellants. for the
-,1...e OF delivering his wares, ftu through !
:, rs,.rss,. ,ne rsun OF wt,cn was Ills deata. |
e!u73H! AAeen' aFReuna, W s"v.Seo
d. Icrs. occupying Nos. 1'a aai 1:s North Water
..rr,t I'M. ,xo buildings being 80 atfauged tint,
~, s.cn.atas ene. The nouse. a.e four stories
wv r,sn e..,lsr and sn elers,or runs fn,n
ixn; WIZ ee ~ n,cea1 na s,a,ie. snd ~ snnei
11a,. i si.'rs: .u1ieesaea q r. ~ doors s.
r::s fron tn'cs 70 fsu1 ieet ntsh- oa re 3ssn q
fcrnssat d Murray 4 Mason wan EGGS for packing
M nso H.. M.s 70 ens r. Ia NJ
r nns =, e aoo1 aud ais eries we're nesra a: under
wnsnse ne ra tassp ~ vi .i;eaeI Ms,
- as,s ~ san ss.a u1s 1ss t.ten q es1s 10
HI II. asu,' ~a.r ae dtea vi!al1 .so es .o;s; .n,ss
weeks. TIE ju1. Ia The cou,t bclo. % tsaae aHa.tea
sicn .ae % Vie. 1as sriei *ss ssten. inc tseeg
q srrei.nI ,ha xt:noa1 aatuoty ~ he1ssn s,aan 2
ss.s ne tse ae3dic, i md
!,ags1l, cons:sr5 u 1nt evidence n .es case and
Ees;. taat the death was 1ne ea ~ ~ ~ Ia
Ia, the psna aasak p'{y e n r.
1tErYf, son OF a<sce4sctk's. - -.
stne s!t. 4no not eIe so ,.pt1 R nnon
,,.s..i,,s r,,t in 1sxoe. End 1t WIS claimed
r ep sssyt s,;1 ,h1' 'ae o'a1' '''0" A1a eA0'eo
a intnr nan 4 appellee, the theory zas that tho
s.s, - nss n .ns ths nesre ~ " ,,e ~. -Tes
w, =, .;tn - ~ ~ ,he fu,nrr .9euFrrY ~
co-:asr. " s.s,,aass u t5e pfeSeot aeasesa, II
w ~; ~ ~ nsssinc flnm IN. huisStnv 70
'e Ae'' ~ f''-->'e' %'o-'
AnssttE-
AsNo usns.
a,, ~ xsa..a ssn,,,.sa n.e7,tnc. Ap-
pes! ,,"ta sne, 1T court Iay1g: isss, l'assi,
inf; m*ssa' o'o ~. NC =, Stat. srrrs; fonr
+ar,n. ., o r,spbt 1E.at1.four feet fsunt y
sShy r.; IL se.h e asp a ma d se.s
1nars Il Af,etvnfd he depth OF the bulldiag
Il tset ssan' pf,eR fRs f. f9oa +
=. hsa fxu1esiy been contracted fof.
ms ~.!!. aadsE sae spsaaSsuon4 xs5e s 70 b.
tion ol i!ret {or mt completion Of the EnsA @ wHs
mait necessary BY the ching q oq n1 ae
s's .,sI setexs e. III ,sat teis uns e. s.de van.
VIE up sttnia E5e feet ot the fn11 height Of The
1su.th t,ent a1n 'as tspnt ~ 1as n 70 he top
= wills ~ese Up about sEensytxo tsst ahoye
the point to 1hsca tne stons 1son1 Has
ret. Cpon The fail nc reaf way stoo9, ~ dlq some
the men kEecksa o. Soss 1n Sa1ay n1ac, e'e1S sta
y y 70! iel IT, IT, ,1 aeena.as d tspPese ssea
s0f cAWAktes SoAse1oe.s 1%~AA N~e ~ - s+'S
building.
Arru' p.11ly for appellant, and continued uutl
this morning Tor aPpe.lee
EsroIT11-asxostsa, n L<.os3s ,,a1esss SioEns uor,,5s
ReheaI1nT. Al The Jaly rezm Of The Municipal
Cout1 OF Chicago. 1881. ihree judgments Mete
reIdertd as.nst " + Eaan upon me sa%e !nS, uSy:
1hese wrtr in iasof o. 1oioon . 1e Anvuuf ss,a Sw
Das.> and Que s1SsslsDa Al aat
vas returned 10 part Esuaned. Ea1lT n lsas =
ala. execution was tAsurd and returned sausnst
oy tne ta.e o. tne psensss ~ i n,4S ~ *so nn I'd
acsea, nax e66ma1ea 70 oe Eplsa sSvsa ~ lie mr.
premises we've Tot redtemeo aecosulnk 1SAnSa II A.
TlsoIs OF The s,a1rte. ata N lSs0 =; xas The m,
was e1ecuted 10 ons blaneaasu, ~, SppeJant cIsim
cht4er II The Shet11s SALE 81 r,e r;r - ~ =
TUE rrdcr MIN. T1ls jssd TMs ps.Ssn ;s on p
record In Noteuber. 1ste: Ia dir.stst ssns
BY tht. sa1c The title ~ E3*n 80 n,rte .s1 ~. 1a.
beuGtntfy, IN 1614, Hdotsa1u ou1 ~ T.. :.
it,is bill on tutH tno4susnha a.as; ~ mnS9 =,
they made v1rto0a pNSsx ~ rTassIn1' ~ 4
eludtnc bisneaard: Ihe p5a1fF s,rrisns ~; ~.
nll described II the b!u ol o1"Ttla@aaS Az ~ lnt
bill adecec Has nenaeisa y r. saa ~ 1nE bs q;
tset drs:dhed 80 " he rrrmAs IN 1ne!stna
tnatu IN +eS. auo sue ttS - a1.o.soa
thir sa. were eGtu 10 ,as he,a,n posssLes; -
so. blseGuaus ...st aasash ne c1ont3tnotl his TT
nlrd hs ulu ~ ~ II - asle And Xnpaee sets up
caestsa u! asaa, liz ~ 7s Arrnen nfniIY
3see'u IL ss."p sn41nss stpr AND pEcpKp. ,,..,,
rs Geinans .'n huln,en snaaa,sns to 81 wtt1ea .
Ma Lut = 4ut..rh narhnarT IT the can. NWas !
Transferred HIM. ~ N. m EJlnyr 40 tAN5 70
uun for h+arfnr ~ ~sIss-< <En Gn. - c.G - II
der In crrnr III Az. set& =. .n1utst o. E1o.s ~ ~
The cour1 supno.ei = as :3sc heTs. ss a,,1,,.