, 1870-01-14
TINE e1ssRrs.
DIR. H. 4. 8sralT0fd Found Nor
Guilty, and Discharged
from Custody.
An Interesting Suit Involving tho
Ownership Of IS, 600 In
, U. q. &ends.
Regiater1 Fees-A Collector for Ga
lena-Another Confidence
Operation.
Police Court Pxpee%diaee.

~@A03AVAA4
Police Court Pxpeeediae1.
Circuit Cont.
TEE ABORTION CASE.
Ths t1f1l Of Henry E. S1auoEdr indicted 70
mGrdGt, Wa concluded yes+e1dAy In the Circu1
Court Tue charge w1s the dsst OF liz lind eye
tried IA It's Stats Of 1llinoi1. It was under It
act Of 1851. snd tn substance that the death h.
been cau1ed OF Tensile named Tneodosia Patel
SOC, roaldiss IN house OF l}-repnse, uuder rh
assumed naue Of Lucy Kellogg, In the perform
anoe OF IA unlasfui ac:-ene procuring Of q Mi
ca1r1hZe; AID that the ogett in producing th
death VA the accused. Tho Presentation Of III
e1idence WIS cone.uded on Wednesday afternoon
when Tho c1se vas opened On the two ndea.
AxorAKST OF kE. TAX AHnAn.
Yesterday. upon the coming in Of tie tut5, MI
John vxu AErusn spoke on behalf Of the ps1kousr
oeeuSrtnE two hou7 and hsu with hl1 remArts
He stEued that the evidence did no nero sha1
prove thai the pntone1 had been called 70 trea
the dhceasod alter u operation had peep, By her
sell OF some other person, performed, and In thi!
conrection he referred to ths ahsept @ Cnas1eY.
her iovtf, whosc anxiety 70 exe1lpsts himself. il
ihss Ife desln migni BE- riahtJ lid u lis doos M
He ato stEned that IN tois czse tue evidence dld
not Prove riih any degree Of certainty TIA: tae
N oocrsaon- upos 4ais H. ppipt p''s'Gs as ursee e:
tho !npoaslunty Of deciding The cause Of deetf
from the Developments Of tue post ns0y1en exam.
He also da eli ps1tictll1,iJ cpon the cotd1uoa oI
tie lidteyA Lot Thoroughly 1nres1galed. bni
Allowing. Ps1nsps. disease, II Indeed & ~Ai pu.
The SPEECH Esa deynted TO consideration Of ihe
character OF The w,tlesses brunght In By The
itEr1fYxF
The cs4e \ u .ake1 up BY the S:A1eta Attorney
as ocock, he n:ss saoMtnE tbs: under the Ia Z
gas y tns 1s,s e'se % Gon'1s1a co. Ios sa
si.ueeter a.y be ionna @ Under tee p,osiaon @
nan renS ~ltnou: ,utenl to XII. but IN tho per-
fcft Atce OF HI lDlAsinl act. Al tho principal
R1st ,aSe s9 spssned osoS e.sa
the eii ne as rent TO- 70 t1eaf carried VIII hlm
ND. upop rescn.ls tie room. htaseS tne paIieas
without u q11J % to her s5mptons. Tbs other
principal poitt Kas t5e Rllecce Of The ph5sctk1a,
OF cealn- He colrended that these matters were m
eolfobotaron cf the testimony of the wltuee1es.
DurkE ile cousse Of III. Reeds rcna.k1 Nj.
B. G. Miller heqcentl Interrupted h1u. conle1d-
lng ttst bis tt1tenent OF evidence wRs Incorrect
Tbeee ttteHuIt1oLs Fele continued uaEl1 tie
Court 'nle1post q, uro7 question put, 10 preTens
II, ~ lLstruttiDR bo.n cpuEsel aud juIy tha. the
jaly were, u my 1oosrGi+ty OF etssernen:. to be
eoVetned ~ tie recollection OF tae ind1s1dun
TIE court irsTuc:ed The tnr5 as hsltp.s. >
o'cloct. and then adjourned until I, Tbs in1truc-
ltons wttc ~ lo.loEa:
FOE THE FE0FLG
!. The Court Ii suuc:s the lasT, n the 1sw of
th1s csse, thai II tney be.leve from the eVldence
beJcrd Reasonable uouot~ sA4s female ty the
wss prrptan', and .h.s defe1dstr {He.Ty z. sttas.
fotnl ~ the use Ct bone tns.ruuent produced the
p,scaIIace of md female for AMI, purpose o:her
: hi r. u nm and
that soth nt.car1!sge caused aud :pfppuced t1e
death Of suEn female, ~ caaraed Ia the lnd,ct-
en. ttea T. y tas duty Of the jasJ 70 nod :ae de.
.. The Couit also scs,rncts the Jury that rea.
sophhie ouubs meacs in Ia Rer4o11, substantial
dencs, md not mere potsb lf7 of q doabi
3 TIC Eon1s ntuacti ne 1a'y tnas, n1oet ma
indc1n est hacn = doz @u.ast, tns laEy U,ay ina
shall b. lteye he guilty Of m2usigug nter iruuj.he
eV,derce- Toe Court tur:her 1nstr1c,a the jury
hnrnn beng ~itnoot any ittent to DO 20. Ia the
comuitalon Of an unlawful act: or lawful act
Which pionaha1 nigh! produce such consequence
1sstruc the lory thst It u An una s.ul oct 70 pro
dnce the 1ue4r.aze Of ptesnautfe1ns:c, except
for tona ~ medical or surgical Iurposek- There.
tEey sh1u tail TO bt.1eve from rne evidence that
the deteoeans Il .fulitJ Of Nu1der, A. charged
IN the lpdtctment. tn. tnan believe 1rou the ev1-
dence that TT defendant Il guilty Of mtnslaughter
In thiz Gaze lten Ia me duiy Of the ie,y 10 od
the de1eudant guilty Of minalsnahtes. And, Il
Trey ahS4 hno min guut5 ot neuslapgntes, tneu
they m1lt, in ther verdict, 6I hia ponishnent,
which cannot be leas than ore 1esr In tne Penl.
tenEslJ, aad Esy be for any nnupsr o! years up
1 Tne Conn aIso lnxtructs tho tory tna. II TIM
dfleuoant comni ted an abortion ia tals case for
to1n dds med1ea1 or surgical purposes, the burden
eucn bona az medical q sarFicG parposet M M
less TIC evicence On tne put oi the people ahpFs
~. De aid Ii foE such oo"a at medical Of cIkical
s, TIE Cour1 further jnstrrctB the tnry that they
have 60 rgnt to reject tne evidence Of Wituess
io1e tae mi5 ean REJECT IL e7tce!ce ~ Of ~ 1it-
neee, {hsY c.Qa, d satlned fram ne ev,a,nrr
tenea 10 Or tns9 ps, nna - sas;sas5
noa. the mai ner. appearance, and condaeE Of the
nas suoea. sas; shs u es,zi3 ea af fse Sa
Lei. ~
&. In III cs1er Of c.!nea pur,shaolc with des,n,
II. coap psiea Ior The tar5 70 Es:urn, .lsh .set
tnat he % inprsoned ID Tie Pen.tsotssiy for i
the teIrs OF hls Iatu1z lie, or for term Or not
FOE 1HE r4lsol RI
!. The Jury are Instructed that they ought not,
n IN cls1 caAe, 10 lid :he:r verdict ia accord.
ihey nxYe rssso: abe doubs ~ Is ,Ie cpis Of re
pr,toler OF Ybe crlne alleged arsinst hit, tntY
anoula end hin not e1tty.
pe,ton Gala God 70 E1tuess Vi nst he i about -
SAY, and RET ooa cas ali Gu IN rroo Iii. mernv and
nS9sss nn9ss: Dsss .na e. a ~. he e.1 ,sssf
ne 1ses e1 e.. . ny az st6st, sase s; ss r.
encad ~ mai 1'ea ~sa q nee ee'
then ihey fuould Ieiect nrr er1nfnee. eIcanr n
e9ed.s therein sue Is BY
8. ltis tue peculiar tro.,cce Of = turv to ia1ne
Of Inc crec,o.i'y ol ~ttes.rs. sd Il ine csinsi
rifnst&ea OF douhtfuJ refx,dtF ana r1a +,rT i, -
ItaeonspIc donos a. TO We IN or itsf ,fa,s.
rot st, III '-A' sA'e'' AA''4 Ane oeaeaaAns
vifaly ts4dea nstru, Is y T1ne I'M ~
shai bavc beeu cor1asorst.d b1 otnes gest5;s
e The dyspc declsr,t,ocs of a n.-+, mo ad,,,.-
aAb3e in et1ueice bros The funnnsition mat tne
condition Of he dec!arsLt In v1sT Of fmnena.
Equivalent to thai i,nrose1 ~ suoo ~
oaih, ard, In R1y1nr e1ert ~ .nrn
testiuony ard IN dstesni,rc its c,.dib,,,.y ~
icre ihtno ui ihero i, sny, inat anecs fne n,opsi
chx1ac,er nf 1ho heciarsn. enS 4a*e ese -, aoss n
mn lte Obligation to lei tie tru,S ~ Het
E ArEoush ne tary anal be,tese from the eri.
csased snd t.st M d.ess.1d s.e npoa 1ne de-
Jet from iii 1nc evidence u the esse tas1 srter.
ton waa o. NJ. rot for B. no 6ds msa,csi n .nTu1-
fendsIf rc1 ufltY - @ -A413 '>'~ 11-
Z AtthcurS ihe ior. .rop,a ha,t.-. ,,o,, .s
eridtrce tnat ine dersaesd ~ 5aS laum nc
eirecsa of m Ahnrs1nn sna sS ss Auu !nc
{etnant persorMed ar "as h,.o;nt haHt lHe as
her Val n re inr. Teon ~ eooIAon upon |
case, cS.cttaln = 1easouabIe doah. a. u va.,arr
emtr o Of osrm ve1s .tnn,ansons - " oen =. tne
~ rnrnnr- -; Th~ Gaea!t ~ 81 iLoEceu oy
osns1 s.n sat tas n'e of
ehou d d, IA tce drfendanf 6ot rn,;tt '" LAG July
4 Tne nresn,nns,nn T. ~ rnn tsta,s., 49,
pn~.rt II *. ~1,1,. emna.1 ~ ..o uEtsatAut Mln.
~ 11svrsT s~cnn., - NV! A.au II