The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1870-08-11
" that you saw tais instrument n year ago. h.-No,
Or but Afterwards Thought that that was not
THE SANE INSTRUMENT,

in the room At ais head
you had seen an instrument ike i Gdfere h.-,sooe
coz sssG up a and held cid { Sf hs Hand ne o0 S O
h-lhsdc the ns,tumcnt That saw Wa. - ing nsdc
Q.-lou attention had not been called to " since
from anything you mad ,ern OF hcarl2 A.-No, sir.
NJ; S h va M rSord,gV i ion 3 w n, s e WY
had seem h.-Ycs, err.
when You ,aw ina! nstrnm nt, wish og Gonld be as
nc mtg Soad 10 hS saue3 A LSrdy think IA
"G-Ht Tic time Won saw The instrument lying In the
| stable. were the doors ouen on sag - MSi,y econ
stree e,iSl Al thn& tLeY Nere' l thhk ut coach
Q-%as L ylng distinct by ll'elt' AaYes. sr.,
No sir. ii was lying BY itfci against the wall " the
| Q-Dd you stop at alp A.--No; glanced at itas1
o the only impression Won had rcgar linz hs
s1nire md tuch a. you iorud IN walNii eh4sty0y
g re certain ,laI It vas that ,hPPe and sac.
IIrrlE HEAVIER IRON.
M5 Es'e 1, s"& &, you to say l The coach
siit that tho coaciuan must have re me in at TIC
DO 1og Srow WHO the coachman WASP A-The
o Gan ySn ~ nc date Of seeing tits Instrument
Q.-C'h you 6nls your mind to hear upon circsm.
stttc.s that occurred wniie you were there Alt
was sole time IN the ncshboThOod of September a
Q-isggposc ry your charges on your books for WORK
c5NI rot Tx tic i9te vas passing tlTonsh and fsaw
@ sn &sg s.e s ef e3S a AZ 9S date by the
way exposed S o. M ANY part eosi SSI i1" e
c.-you could sec the whole oft. then2 Ayes. sir
Q;-Your attention was not called to that aitcrwaid
nm.l WE mtgdes Tas1 ing Cog as ,hown to you q!
At Mr. Nethans Oh the day OF the murdsr but did not
~ on arg certain mat yql say m article ~ I'M,
i rcceleet distinctly that saw "a ns.fa@e eGo OF
Nj. Ficid'-wero there any men working there eS
| sept tue men in your employ Ayes. tir; othe,s
o eDo YOU knew what others had been there besides
the plunpes2 Ayes, there were carpenters vois
q DO you snoT whether Mr.; Mckenzie had the
QNDo YOU know what pIsnSes. tnarc wcro A. the
sTie, , vas, II ny McETS6,, who Ia, tss,ncd2 Al
% ssE All GSs ynE r f sssf
ne nj ,ha, y9p had seen near the stable door
o-How soon after You bai seen Il. did you think Of
s ~ sS% TrS 'fS z Gse% SoS oon scI
The hSu. ep rn s 1 Ssr +, s %ssD
seen an Instrument similar g thls one2 AL asked
oa, ,Sy had Sa not saY se sn., q Tat an
| hf A.-No, SIR, have not spoken 70 them
| sIScE ruE MURDER.
o1whcn yon saw the inssra .n last ssptembeS
y9n were paSslng through the asSle
you 70 discriminate between nsirnn,cpI which yos
4, sSsh SSu srs s ser A a
,o-stii YOU Do not swear distinctly that that
o%D,d YOU spcSi to Mn. Kelly or her son before You
lott the house. on F,idayr A.-No. sir. don't thIhk
yS1 ds TO h% as,g g,
.Q-Dd YOU 60 to the house expressly TO sneak ABOUT
" Ais epped ia there TO know whether there was
,QTDid YOU have 1t on yonr mind to speak about III
Mr.. Ra.sel-HSvee ypp seen the Instrument used for
c,.Do you think that tina, Instrument was used py
| lawyer A.-NO they generally nave them n
heavier than hat 6uis lor holding
ws S, S %s saw b IN ss sS.ep ,oe SS
lie men Lao iCrg otiea some u their lois.
Mr. fslo~smDo you Know ynst sind OF work me
sVnie new paAkng, / th,nk, on the loos Of
Iux STABLE OR COACH HOUSE.
o--was there any work going on that would have
neeessitated the use OF such an Instrument? A-No,
o-Do You know Mr.. Williams OF 70 Broadway A.
Q-Mh,, is his bu.inepp Ale is a LAWYER.
o-Do you IsnlenGsr whether YOU saw an iron poker
o1Dii yea a any ii@s
CD You remember laEac up the roser in your
murder i Was cd Vas S65ii ilat .zsi H-Y,s,
u-Wii sou please tat Whether this conversation
occurred nc Assea ipy GS ge"t Te d 40 s %
YOU sw n he 1ele IS,iye mouth, aso; and Gu were
ibS q re4tmb a. TS' lay M Tees oa,
was used Al a,d 4 looked sT,at deai hAe Il
At Ma. NAIHAS's HEAD.
| OF rcseu bled that ? Ayes sir.
Q-You observed iGis toicraby osely. did you no,Y
| Showing the insuumyntl A.-No, s"' tic on'ci
'o,Sbid yoa lSok at il VITA much care a; yon cid
nc n,,nlgineO! lying near tho ''4'e doori A'-No
Q,1,sIaie whether Or not ySur eommG9e a.
him 10 believe that ms llstrmenf with which Nit
| Ia the stable Twelve months ago. A-Wel, yes, Il
Coroner RoIlus-what were you doing in the stab'
last year. A-lTel'y much ihs sans isil p.
Yo.Dld not you cement tie stable aO0r2 Al do
put uP SOME NEW BRICK;
the carpenters were laying down the door; did mol
see any Instrument OF that Kind used.
81 the Dod sEEs IN sTaBLs.
Robert Newton, another OF Mr.. wiliams's work
men. was next called. lie had never seen tue dol
before, but remembered that Mr.. Williams had too
| him " 1t had seemed like dream to him civilians
that be had seen that dog IN the stable long tim
Mr.. Field Ito the Coroner)-The Jury would lik
| 10 have Mr.. Washington Nathan recalled. for tl'
purpose OF aseerlainins tne exact time when 10 mrs
| saw that the front door was open
: WASHINGTON NATHAN RECALLED.
Washington Nathan was recalled by tie Coroner
and testified to discovering that the front hall doo
was open, as he reached the hall OF the second foo
I, | Two STEPS before he touched the nOor-ookin
= down from the sGir-. lie also testified That tn
coachmln row in the employ Of the family ha
cen with them four or ave Years. and on the morn
y | Ing OF the murder lie was in the country.
t Nr. Frederick Nathan next called TO tn
: stand and sworn by the uplned hand. He is
taanly compact, snowy, handsome, userish-lookinl
| Young nan. Ills emotion was almost oyerpow erin!
= a. he detailed the shocking Appearance OF his lathe
when he disc oyeTed him on that terrible norm g
bat he steTnly repIessed his leelnge, and gave h
evidence with ease and precision lie was hrst e'
| amlned by the Coroner.
f. gHR TESTIMONY OF FREDERICK NATHAN.
, Q.-where do You reslde2 A.-No, IL West Invent
| tara street.
at the Al elt u Nnh NY father a0out twcni
or tSentl -hye mnutesl pact TX We walked dow
4. | MN avenue 10 the -yuaHpEue aud beheNe' We We
- up stars together 10 the place of worship VIC le
ID, | tie synagogue, l believe little after seven-nay
y | twenty minutes or quarter past seven 4 believe
- went in ahead OF my father 10 my adnts rename
. | there some time, having the house about twentyhN
y or twenty minutes Of eight leaving my ntheF lHlkln
with OF his sisters, and saying " him. &c ID eye
v | ing" .--.,--.-- 81, .
| Ale was there, too. lie lett about hye or ten nl
- utcs before DID. Amer leaving my aunts, walked
- to the corner Of rwentyhrst street ana FUN ANenu
W on the southwest corner debating whether should
| 10 20 and o friend. Mr.. Cooper residing IN u
~ iarse boarding house the corner OF BROADWAY AZ
| Twenty nrst street. There were
TWO GEHTLRhES,
think, sitting In the doorway knew they were
~ quAlutsd with Mr. Cooper, as met them pretlol
nights ~ his rooms one OF them was lnfoducel "a
~ don't TecolIect II introduced TO the Otner the
NJ told me NJ Cooper had just left ana gone 70 Broo