New-York tribune., 1870-12-07

rc ious said he, the learned counsel for the plain
"a stated that ON the argument before Judge Brady, he
s. Trc,aipe) had charged his Honor Judge Barnard)
i,b baviuc made an extra allowance Of $5OO00oo
Mr. Fi,d-It is mistake; didn't say that you said So
Nj. Tcmaiuc-You were SO understood 10y myself and
nv associates.
Mr. F.ld-I didn't say So
A., g,,nouc--Tle learned counsel did say that had
used INV speech that occasion to lie published in
rr,,vsrapers and that would probably do the same
ntps with the remarks that had the honor to submit
Yesterday.
Nj. Field ala.
Mr. Trciuaiuc-T can scarcely understand why the
learned gentleman has lugged in matter 50 mpernent
,rrlr,ant "a trial here and only account for
ron tc suppositon that he knew was stranger here
,d hc proposed to take me i'm, like a good Christian
r,u.htcrl I never said your Honor made an extra
allowance of S5coOOOO. Inever contemplated any such
,bre On the contrary, the very motion was making
his 90 sat aside an order directing the cause 10 stand
over amount Of the extra allowance, and II would
lave absurd for me to that any extra allowance
had been made Now, understand your Honors an
uau from the bench rs disavowal OF Justice
rr rrruft> in the newspapers. As 10 the statement
ttI h cscd my speech to be published IT is just as
f replied that Mr.. Tremaine, the motion to
sasdc Juoev BIrnarIs order, took paper out or MS
+fltat fhr close ~ his argument and read something
rl h. So, had been said al the time of the granting
of th. order oy Judge Barnard. What was written on
a. Isur So. t- uubshcd verbatim I'm the newspapers
IN. nNt ucr ing. The whole thing tissue of false
no n
h. never u.Ce any suggestion whatever as 10 the
9y. 20 the Court on the 18th show what services
L.. I.er rendered This abuse OF reporting 10y making
must ~ srad Il seemed to he forgotten that the per
son who uas "a GROSSLY inaccurate report OF proceed
ing in court s contempt OF court IL seemed 20 De
s t, ~, l'SryeTt eyeryfbinr thar takes place
court ur the purpose of subscribing certain ends OF
I .rcj when ilc opportunity occurred that it would
d. A fa - Ii
AIR. Tcmairc >lid he fearedhis friends memory was
fault u the matter. lie had no right 10 complain Of
leiuc put or the defensive. He Nir. Iremane) stood
D., what he said. He claimed that on that motion before
Judge Blai' the transaction was proved by alidavits
N'uug ildt the armed gent eman lMr. fleIl Was iIe
tut little aId vile his friend Nr Field denied this as
NJ, wi,. should be settled 10y the intelligent members
~ the ha Wto vre present As 10 the reporters, ne
stood NOT there TO vndicatc them Tor they would take
Nj r'ld ,.id &c explanation he had made at a subse
man Mr. Ircma1C was then absent was proper, be
cause wv~ hc inst opportunity he had TO correct Tic
had prt ort1 statement highly injurious and utterly
Or. Tuey-I' was substantially true.
N-. Iechl~u-I recolect distinctly that when TIE
question of o. dismissal Of the complaint was before
yoHr Honor TIE order was that it stand over TO fix nc
aIoaut o al, extra allowance and Mr.. Field then said
20 many WORD lat the extra allowance in Tie suit at
E,uhcsr bad boon $4,000, and that this suit was of %
lr' d.. more Importance Your Honor then said sub
stautay that yoU Wished an affidavit stating the amount
involved m trs controversy ana that you would grant
tie Usual t-trl 90 'loWauce of per cent
T.c Cou-t-No. fo exceed per cent.
Mr. PecSsnn-Nr FIcd then sad that the amount IN
PRO M yl y the T iG en Eg oman T tbe s5eioi
ial~c 300 tu, M lle language used by HIM, Drdhdhts
... .rtou as ta'>., , and nc knows it,
Mr. f,.d-i clre not what polite and civil gentleman
Ah. r ore vl" las lust spoken might say Had been
flat might nC surc had not made mistake as To
@ ati Cd OF te scutlen before justice Biaal u sent
Gd rI,iI rcrarG 10 tiS dispute When has
y
.Ce tu To De of very little importance 20
suybo,y llt lr,'f. never allowed any E5OOOOOO 10
. holy: nut remember saving that should give an
allowance Mt 10 exceed i've per cent upon the amount
br s-o. Iu lniug az Tie testimony have come 70
tt'ohruS'l 'a' - 49,, i . ~ ~ m t Mn ,i,nt
costs. l,ays nc charge Of conspiracy standing against
dl Ficdra thc steuogr9phers notes as 70 what oc-
,.-ed hrfo" Judge lirATd on the hrst OF November,
W.r-,iu % appeared that Mr.. Field lad expressed the
49,, ,iic n = down m the Rochester suit where s92 900
...rrc- -Iart Ga, and That Judge Barnard sald he
-..-... au .li-tt % the amount OF property in
,.cf uu. that Be-" would grant an allowance Of live per
,, I.,r f.I.. T..c was assertion iu the stcuOg-
lpar.. minute riD MI. Field had stated the property
l.,o,.t 20 .I.t"npO. Nj Field submitted findings
o.. ,... ,ir,s.g I'i he'd, to he incorporated III the
j.E-a...I a-.'i.-' laT aud Eaton.
lIt.. -.uaIa- p.SitIOn 10y McSsrS. Temaiue,
,c,., -ta.u. tuaf Le would look over the testimony
t.-. ar. i.r ur proposed findings were warranted by
EAN>sl's SUIT AGAINST ERIE.
lt .-c conclusion of the argument in the
y,
..,fl. -f Of :.u..y against the Eric Company was
g.. .. O.. i....r .ud wished TO know what was to De
t.t, W..lj-. Mr. F.,ld moved the on trial M.
g:-rD.ar ti intih did not desire then 10 proceed
1,t..I. JsD- uat armed from informal sources thaJ
e.. D.i.r .. .r red during the last October Special
directing tle '>e to stand over but no such order
I., t.t ~--,I ou tarin lie would Ike to inquire II IL
Nas uae, trt order nat they sought To move II On
Nr. I.e' Certainty q Is
:.r .ti.t Sal. read behalf OF Mr.. Ramsay recitng
:. Oh, lr,e-in1- TIM have taken place thg9 far and
fIf Il
,I,ltI tio October special Term had been adjourned
'aru,rI said ,hc matter had better stand over
rntI o. appeal n"n. Judge Brady's order lad been
lIr rr.ua Co, ,aI ,y would not consent to any order
NIal said .l.t for the purpose OF seeing what
tlc trncrl 1.rr would SAY Of Judge Bradvs order he
6Ud Ou biz ".h t"i 90" pat the cas- over uu the hrot
NOt.aN co. ft.Hrgsff. Tue special Term would stand
a,oIrnct Uui at .,> and he woud state. IN reply 10
f.I had t,tH -.t H COUNSEL that the OrtOner Special
..I1i Laa ''H -afi, adjourned by lin from time TO
Ekus,l'. APPLICATION FOR A DISCOVERY or
TIL rOoN> OF TIE ERIE COMPANY.
.Iudgr Brady granted, Nov. %, an order,
rciurarle yest,ra! before Judge nrrahaIu, to show
,4.e why discovery OF tine books OF the Erie Company
,ou,l not no aovcd 10 lr. Ramsay in his suit against
ir. After tie arguments ia the other cases the law
,v,ut p.to-, Jud- Iugraliam sitting al Chambers
ttaHr i, obstacles tHi have attended tue prosecution
opposition fora t.y of proceedings until after the
oerisor a oir. from Judge Bfadys order opening
u-l .r. .l. ',uauc replied that would make
h"ttIur. vAc. way tire appeal was decided, as III
AIS event iLr .i.. uid on, and the testimony was
I,sGs- Ilt .t.t U8- .Hutcu and the appeal was not
't... u... Co.,. .o-. We.k I January, there would he
Hu lt. fu prepare between that and the nrst
o.ca' i. ftIff.. 90 which date the trla Was ad
.,r'. al of tie Discussion il was discovered
taf Nf. isitsi,'- petition not properly verified
uadr ir Col .'. ..iuii-soucr before whom he was
seu. hs,IH. neglect t Co. pc on the County aud state
Jdle O. -rtiaIl f'- rf0rc adjourned the matter until
N"loa. nt., ordering The plaintiff 10 verify HE peti-
tH.a aLt -,l., d, U.t.I1 two days.
IT. AIING DIAMONDS.
B. ". PHuh received for sale, Nov. 2j,