Rutland weekly herald. [volume] (Rutland, Vt.) 1859-1877, 1870-11-17

~
Chase shonld have been allowed to vot
as well as othere, and that his case ha
i not been considered at all. II this Hous
= is to decide this case intelligently, W
must have all the facts before US, in re
gard to all the disputed voters. H
thought that TrueWorthy Brown lost hi
residence in Brunswick the moment b
crossed the line into New Hampshire
where he remained until the day of elec
tion, when he rode over to the place o
voting in Brunswick, and Immediate.
= went back into New Hampshire. HI
hoped the vote would be reconsidered
for he could see no difference from wha
/, cause he left the State. It can make NJ
difference whether q man sells bis farm
or is burned up by IN act of providence
if he leaves the State, that is sufficien
for him to lose his residence.
Mr.. Grout desired to say one word more
in explanation, in regard to the intention
of Trueworthy Brown to reside in Bruins
wick in the contingency that the mill.
which had been burned should be rebuilt
There was no proof presented TO the com
mitteo that Brown contemplated chang
ing his residence, permanently.
Mr. Hinckley OF Chelsea said ne had nc
doubt that Irueworthy Brown was legal
voter In the town OF Brunswick. He had
no residences elsewhere, and could gain DC
olher residence so long as he remained IN
Brun9wloS. lie thought that the impor'
tant point IN this case rested upon TINS
fact alone, ana that the decision OF the
case Is correct as IL no" stahds, and c
should oppose any RECOMMENDATION OF the
matter
MIR. HQughfon OF Stamford moved the
previous question, when was seconded oy
the House, end the main qnestlon was
! thfh put-0ha'l 'h0 To'" by which the re-
solution reporter ~ too sohtl9ll"n 5ro,ii On
Barton was an"p''n o5 recorslDeIea rI,s ou
that qneHtion MI I7n' OF iihInou'h ue-
manooo 'H9 yeas ana 6d nays "nlcn were were
| '"Seh' yeas Ilo' nays w: 60 me moVion
| 70 reconsider was HEietu To-
lhe question then r fTcnrTod-ohHA the
reSol9non oe aoop,Gc ana on that ques-
/ Uloh lar' 0iaoe OF Nhluoleoury InoVeo the
previous qneslon, pehd'ng "nlch'
Mt. hei'ogS OF benson moved 10 lay the
resolution on the tabie, as IL was evident
that we cannot complete our action on it
before dinner which motion was agreed
to.
In the "t5eruoon after The routine bust
ness of the House was disposed OF, Mr..
KELLOGG Of Benson called up the Bruins
1ick contested election case. Mr. Slade
withdrew the motion for the previous
Question. Mr.. Kellogg said that to his
mind We should now lay this resolution
on The table, and take up the motion to re-
consider the vote refusing to adopt the re-
solution recommended by the majority of
the committee: md on his motion the re-
solution was laid on the table, and the
resolution Of the majority was taken up,
the question being on the motion of Mr..
Ballard of Fairfax to reconder the vote re-
jecting the resolution.
The motion waa opposed by Mr. Bisbee
Of Newport favored by Mr.. Slade of Mid
dlebury ; and adopte d-yeas 112, nays 95.
The question then recurred-Shall the
resolution be adopted
Mr.. Kellogg Of Benson, asked for the
facts in regard to the right of Charles
Chase 20 vote il the town of Brunswick,
which were given by Mr. Henry of Ches-
ter, as they appeared before the commit
tee, and thereupon the several dePositions
IN relation 10 Charies ChaSe was fead
by the CLERK from whlch IL appeared
that ne h2a maze ms nome WIN MS
oI"e, ~ ID Jus " ioA !oi 'nS Past teIce
y'8i' Hi7 10 POI ils oi nis
W aS"'i Ii uol'e "lao !. 20
&C.,. ~ Sl '''' -
NJ ~ -, .:.,.,,. ..;,,,t,,.:.
"a ~ f;,,, - - o1aon 80 - - 49, 80
i.-4antia, af C,b.,Ios Cbasa - ro.';r, ~
,1a,,IsiI, o,,a rioh+ - ,-at :, 49, to1,,
~ P.r',,;ai-. ,hae ~ v,a, ,,lte- o"d
", n,.l.I,t - ~ - g.. NJ IT,
1- ii.+ --;i1 80, ,D;as 'oa o:,;.-
49, 4 NY -
W.; p.., ,--. 80,
80" PoI', 'atu 'llt9 Ha We
Ch's ra1iIs,,la 49,, lIdorir ,,' N NJ
TT.-,:-, 3 ,I,,+ L., ,,.,, ~ .. -.
i1 PtYn.wioI, FGa vas eonaIIv cIesr
49, T,r,,e,.,,,rrh,, RI, ,,-s,. y,,or j.,
10 +,-,,r ,f Tr,,-svr;ol- Lr. rI:cL +ba
an1,4 - a3l,,rl,, ,,,o,4,+
NJ Rrn,,,js, of p.,,Ia+ ssi3 thor j. an.
.,,,-1ra,7 Irn,,, 30 +as,,r,,,,,, +I,at Cbsrlffs
Pt',l tP5I. i4.;,., lr, aio,mir, - $500
80 nr,1,,sr,-iol- a.. 30 had
raf,,.,g4 -, r1,,,,-,, ~, +r,,Dt, So, 80
-. :. ,'}, nm e. -;
3'.'.iiIth ~, Tg h-9,h Co. ond ~,
Ii- r;S,,. ~ ,-,to = tha novt Froa,,a,,;,
1T; s,,r,,,.,~rtt,. p.or.,,,,
na1,. 'f..,' ,a. a,,, ;,,5ra r,hatkar Va r,-as
.,t 40 ,r,,s. I,,,or- ,-,h.t s..,o.
y, ~ " ,n.tn ro,t ~ +b @ oiriI | n,h"rifv ~
ra,ar3 ~ his % ;ntontinns n tho ,re,nisaa "
NJ S.a-,. a< - 5;ao.,gsoa 49,,
matter further as to the right of Charles
Nearly all other matters were mere rub-
bish, brought in to embarrass the House
in the decision of this one question.
Mr. Bromley Of Pawlrt read from the
testimony OF Trueworthy BROWN, from
which he came to the conclusion that he