, 1870-05-17
-THELAWG0URTS.
-A1New Trial Granted in the
craig-SpTague Case.
That esIncuFAbyc and Offensive
DIscnScr 10 be Described.
Drawback 1udgment-Notice Of Dis
missals-0bstruction Of Sidewalks.
SUPREME COURT.

-N~N -e~ Aeet3AAA~AAt VA A~A@
missals-0bstruction Of Sidewalks.
SUPREME COURT.
THE cRA1G-sPRAGuE CASE AGAIN
The one hundred thousand dollar breach o1
PROMISE case Of Amanda j. Craig '. Elisha c.
SpraTue hns come back from the Supreme Court
10 be ret1ed, and this, too. upon very minnie OBJ
1ecticus- The whole cause Is to be heard again.
becsuee sp,ague Vas not allowed TO fully describe
the condition Of Whist the Supreme Cours speak Of
As his "incurablc and offensive disease" and be-
cause the jury may have accidentally been mlsled
by being Instructed only upon the particular de.
fence that was before IT. toWit: the specific attack
made upon the chastity Of plaintiff Slns9lary
enough IN 50 long @ taese %ef s fn me sae op y ei
: isted - objections. The amount of lie damages.
whether excessive or otherwise is not re1erted TO
in the opinion, which Is as follows:
-, EA!xR, Juele4.Th.t is m action q assnlnpsoa.
oqs b sspscs z To 70 @ sr
breach Of eoat.st 70 msHJ The contained
E saaS r.
% 5fee ,s.ss 8 .s esa
and tal was had 10 The lat.er county hefofa
M .9 md q f nS sGsE n rSS|s slian fa 'RsE
+. G: s q sz s.
AID s,. a1s ssa 1ssS saa;' bs% gn 5 me r.
Z + .2.ssIsa xLsthsI ;1p:llec in aas soadas W.
sIps proper sinpl5 asssd fo; he .ppsszase sas
1 + TO Eas sp1ssa 2st II 1wasss; ~
satst.7:tisly. WhethvE ApGs,lsc appeared to 30
2 = Send q S9ae M =
IS iaT only referring to sppeaIanees and mai to ei
nc 5ug shs1d no dsght. b lcft under ordin.g e:s
Sns s q = &
I'll. + t. s t. . se IL IT,
SS e t r.. = 70 s,s ases Ct ssss t.
si Or sSsatea aIyss ~ though she Wss as.sehed
E e. ha M sne ths H. f. s .ssua T. i e s 1hss
eas e3s.e saa shs aSst,op only ~, Sssa e
.stesstasa E .ass av,5;sty q Indy Ss.s
ditl assbe ihe's Il asai IND hsnss ss wins:.
.y ss .1fea d. ,shctss rst 4 pa 70 r. 2, It'd
5sa Ss;s Ssssss =;
iasaI;y i .ssasa = ~ "a s. sastlei
aaissiie. 0' 'oe '''e ano "A'
4s,;s ss2s , IL
ssn ifeps1y hsa Been I'D saS.sausny 70 IT, es:a- @
*. 9 m Si tse Ea Tnose e. no. peaon.y r ,a
APgs|ss H Syds1ss tending
a. ensaeus shc @ I'D i 1as be1
la ZEE sa o 5,,1 IL S5
Fl 81 81 T. ;sssy sss5: ssISss Ssss
NJ - /
IL 5smaf1.t et i tsc iad.Ssed1c jul I'd isiS
s 9n a eef eeaes s9a
eatfs 1as5 in,s Az;
q ih debts .ad ii p @
eE2ss n.e5 e, sp he c e en = ae
i: .iissa Ssash Stdsn;s = Z bai ~
ssts5t 81 i. iadth.saRss; {; 4 ,hs ae
:Ssn @ sssh ssGs!a r 9
ss aE sae aac:siens shen rsIased to 81
H. e sEcn .fer 1e bSEsseh atr mshout sa
ES, Esss;, q dssds :. sn; I XSal bo gFopes; ID
n9Uaf Of or s.sa bv appt.nt or wh hIs
q E hs E you'd afte5 s e i
[hs power o. ndecndsnt II seh eascs 70 prrSeot the
ssIss s. REostsy .itef .6s bssssh I'd oesaasS hSt
aS : tso II 19 @ 9ss That
70 objection to The mode 2. Inasns The proof eee!ns
3Etsenee e s. aSpSe.6isy 70 ~ r the
esfoR f. s ~ b a yh a1 a;e 4
Ssse ssssss al ssSnse:s s es ri s 6 T
faoau,rnt sttsE tss ti@s @ r. biessh
In 70 IL @ 1pd she eGnfe y niEe been
sRsstsd ~ e. s9t IS; fa.s t.
Jhs e,idsnec vss ;Is not @ oteed to shor ds
1fS. q +. 70 t zesTTcI TT TOT ths E1t?2.e = r.
WI sssitsy Ps.es. ~ 9roa ii aises.s ssald
t;h Pszea M = ias:,tsSs snd oaeasvs disesss
ic NM, fh.t ~ t t r;on 80 70 aaEe tGne 70
;5s: Es
= 4 fsiid $ ,as ss1ts VIZ Ss.ss Il. ss:taeny
3 xTeavT fos II sonssancnasi tnns7 hs has thu r
Sss sssS esa.s .ss9 asy - p a.y.
ssaes la. yieid to Tic reaaisemeni. q 5e iaa nad
zns ,ssI p. pv 4. ,nd 81. fR.os ( }ast
@ @ n "a T. ~ ~ onty 2. ne G9u ~
r. IL e "a. s6ssnss e
@sstss se5.tsl M dass ri i5s psis.
3 sse has
81. Z sss Z iaaisssd
snS &c 2sathtsrs 1 naiessd e psqis5 - rfas.;
81 IL pa,tges 'ae A" Ano "o' 'o' 'ae 'nsn3
shssssd ;a.h ss1as ssqeEs.ny .esos. .e
sa 1ssa $ 5s Tsssf
ape aal s. p'iss L sne eses SoS pses
eedssd sss9si shs;.ssss nd a. nst ssSsd
Ioetsun1n. Or n ci1i .eeas, tle ds5enes hsse no
- .ssassa i q = + lsIaasa
s }s:as g r. tRR. Reaa
In d. e T. nd 81
ths gse sstaef IL defepaants ehs1seE nd re Ky
i sspas Ihe :5s5Es A9dEhsa se
& :. 1c a e 1aere C.
S . ts & ~
s5s1t;e5 sss Ehsh.sy; r. i.tt.el
~ foS u st ssan. ddsnd
lz t,sf md & aS s1sS sSnusbp Z ea,a. Tn1 % whsa
a9d.nt isssa Il T. ri.uta e i.ssr sbaad not be
y fSd ths r. e. e
@ sa se1s &c, C !. ~ H. s4y II
1aifiiaK gsG III is4sd e1idsnes Sg1 s:p's'
to be iqo9esa d. sstfr III
fss adas s1snS vi @ se saa.s ii: Gsa +: 5sd
tud for the a. a. o. y s.hs ane
.s tfon o. f,1 Ma. ,,t y nr ftnud partT hss Sen
aetssoiat w Whether i shsn sitgasa be adnitt:d
dor 9uch tcs61etbn1 - knhi1 "0IA " ~ Lev ".