, 1870-01-04
QUARREL AT THE MANHATTAN
GLIB
A ncu1ber OF the IEoH4c Committee
I.ukiaclY EhNnIl4Gds


From The !se,e Fork 7f1bnne, Jan. !.
The Eost exciting incident Of NeE YearH Eve
was undoubtedly The chastlsemen+. at the Man.
e Se 81 o. tae az an
member. Tne c!Tclmstancea. which are sutn-
c1eDty entertaining IN one sense. are hkely to
10 the manner In which club discipline should
properly be maintained. and tn determining the
precise relations ne. seen officers and members,
ten or diirerarded. We learn rnat the dif-
nealiy originated in c.scamstaace.
ea , asona ornar1 e.
gentlemen, but which, by the nasty indfscretion
Of committees Was IN this Instance Increased
iSss IT. 4 bstenao welInoWn a. an opsrssic Ssasa
manager. committed the mlstake q few nights ago
OF inviting some 9ue8ta 10 dlne ID room which IL
CONNECTED vim the Manhattan Ctnb but very
short time, MI. Bateman WIS wholly unconscious
of thts reservation, and was only made axaIe q
dinner had been ordered, By the abrupt announce
ment that he could not be sesred--an announce
eDt msae p stf5 oote Of NJ ma
II indignant at the manner In which
this intellIEencs VIA conveyed, and smart
states IN Inc letter below. bas aso 10 those be hsd
invited, he BonEht an explanation from Hi. CYans-
ton, but Was repu1sed, With the extraordinary In
proved himself no gentleman. aud vas hot enntled
10 the confederation due gentleman. II Ia al
most needless to say that the usage 10 all civilized
attention to tue tEansgression untl! private or
portun.tJ Offers itself, 10th for the sake Of The
q Tno se s
and Of bis guests Etio ccrtaIEy can have no share
IN the business NJ Ct1ustop, howetcz. chose 10
Of his action was the following note, addressed to
him by Ar. Datenan on The same evening:
NEW losK HoIEi. Dec. q, 1860.
men to dine win nc al tie Ma. hatsu cIns: one
was member Of the club; Tho other tHo con.
alde1ed bad the privilege Of tnsi1'og;
unconsc!ouA15 nave violated some rule: lind 7
been Informed Of any breach Of the Laws Ia
gentlemanly manner, ahould At once hare 70
H!Iec:cd the steward Of the club TO refuse. WITH
cut any explanation, 70 serFe dinner to me and
ny ana 1hs - e q 9aef
ies1tng tic club, 5ou cuiu,nated ,his insult By
esfs aSe4 tost
comes duty ore mytell to demand Of you an
apologs for What deem most unWar1antel
@N'''' II L. RArEHAs.
To this 70 answer vas vo5ohfales1 until the fol.
loK tpE WedEe sdAJ afternoon, HAcn IL nuu[1.ned
misstsc xas received hy Nil. batemau:
Tue MANHATTAN GLrs, % F1fTn TT u .A5y,EES5z} ,Es
II. L. Bat>ran Etl r" <'s ,ofs; I'll IL; stf 1861
SIR: l hare your Eote Of yesterday. In our
conversation Of last esening addressed you as 2
member Of the House CoMnittee OF n csab. u
Jon are aRgreSed (5ic} yo1F remedy Is a. appeal
TO the Managing committee. by whom tne Aoase
Cnmnlitee Ha3 nppo!1ted Ine5 mees me uiss
Friday IN january. Ny Remarks may have been
roase ont sete ma1e ~ ~ 1ep nnc ~ XII spu r ne
club. and in The presence or one o. soaf gussts,
En!cn II 70 os ltelettea. aou SUE teas , .nsa @
asfed you II fou EeEe gentleEer. e. Satel5 youF
memory IL ~ aaua cou,u Hate ashsu ao aeGa
nacless que9tlou+ 1ouI opeu1Snt est Sut,
HlKAA EkASsaos.
fe!eie me deHsel1 Q, tue hoossr NJ. Cfans!oa 1e
stood, y the nlnees OF iesa.xe. Iron ais re.
tnrn, yesterday afternoon. me following re)olnaef
was handed hn at me club: ~ ., ,,.o
NkW ioaA nuAAA7 oee' - AooS'
hiram LfohtEo1l fa4 =,
siR. aouin o. th1s uate, III atanSt ~ tos tu.e @
tas1 nleat, 1eMandlIR aa eAr,Auauou ~ Wy tuta !.
connuct @uu 4Augusee u tue 31a1o0AsA sAa e'u'E -
ttceiseo: ,..uo,.s., mn o.. ,-,.r,,s,
qa sa o e. cu aut
remedy Is an appca 70 tae sxaa saasSS S
Canmittee: aon aiso otn5 n1'gs AsAeI sar an
onsntase question: luz "nsn 'saa's'eo az
eIo"Ry; esr .,,, n +ne eon,.nona an.
~ leTS; ~ 80 ntcr s11 MI - snrsasrs hasnncon
toceLcaa y, 1'1 h,,a 4ts,n,v h.r" c7,.a
scloasJ r., ~ snncT - IN Whirn ron a..
.,ag Hnnr ~ nnna1a,;eie, IN
eGx FIX ~ "anIias,an romnesjtt ms hoIn on
any S!4o VI ~ W tha4 ~ nv snts wno
my oEn a.TounL nua q lnnt e ~ t1;o III - ;,-c,est
w s.v! n y ~. sr.ee ~ .,r,onT
o1 r!,ha.n.e NV nkn - ~ ehs, 4nnr nyenuve
,1nT .1.s hsrs ~ nshcr. he.td. mxsn1f snd
stst neetin. - acce1f snnr dsn1sS
n.n =. ~ I'll. a.ss.t.s ond Trnest+afsr.orr
.na Nv mi, - rNns,drrrd ~ An arv1arnt,nn 81