New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1870-07-04

o,s, mark and the absence OF title in the oa"a nd
~So settled IN the Valley before IL was surveyor '
oISp sCESCX (ep Ohio) expressed the dei t9a, o
me squattrs or prctmp, ionss u any lien, for il
s trrn over tu them the hand on wllon VIC! vi ,soi
successors might esa hush lasrp ,d :" he
thc beauty which It was desired to preserve
Tnc o Vac hg3 fo6 J los Nae, ST.
~ ~ NC Then urHocc1cd t. nc co. GRAFTON OF &c
Ly fn fine Couiu tee on Iatrhts tie Guest ON hehg
pn',S % on To- reconsider tue vote whereof, 'n' hnlse
TrfIG lc.t,tly y, TO lay o. tne ' y 1' VII "
the wIv 63ITTGIIiDGE Ucp- Iova), who had made the
, %i 10 reconsider wi'hdr%M H. Nave 40
Me- MT0okE RcP T.. C93 , H S3 Of da tnsol
rort d tue dill Tor t' Atens.H o, ic patent VI '''''
sot,tb fTr inn royomCnt an loNS t"sN'u. c,,,,it,cc
NJ yERs M rcnn) non 'e f ,SIo STray Of
repcric mn io 1V itS OF Of tic cgs,r1n p.oW
J;,a9 Id o. order made by Mr. NsiER az p, MOI.
t1a, , , Committee Of tac Whole tie bill was
ref rae 20 s't ten moved To- suspend the rules 10 bring
III il before the House ant pa 10 upon n
The sPTAKEE dec dcd the motion 10 ne IN or unr
thtIue winch authorizes mot2oS 10 '"'i'"" '''''
Inc t"S N ssT iiJrc Tic motion for the present with
n updcrs q dag that hc would renew u @" "nO'"'i
&C SIT REP r. H. from The Conference Com
mi ~ an lie bill To revise cohso aHU an i S
Patent and Copyright laWs, made report Wh'h Was
""'N'' TIE INDIAN AUTHORIZATION BILL ~.
The sPEAkER informed the liousS ,hI t t I in,a"
Appropriation biit had been returned ~ III u e - -
N9 request for further conference, the eouteos OF
tho Two bodies having failed to agree.
.toted the grounds OF difference between The tvo bodies
The senate he said, Insisted upon specific appropriations
nader The treaties nadc since Juy l'5' add AZ InoS
t.catics be recognized a. the salItmt law OF inc amt
IL claimed the exclusive right ot det,rnnnE t.C P"
IT city making treat, inc terms OF S'h a a.! Nv
Tn whom IL might properly hc haue' Hl1 3n, 80 ~
not open to the criticism oF co'' 6 S 1"' f
latlyc power. The senate 'OHi,i nj ,ii,,t,,,i,
ever, offered to put clause III tnV w. s nr,,
ing the President o TO named in the treaties in his
discretion with tae consent OF the lhqias , inc
House Committee had refused 80 Insert IN !he OH any
thing which could be taken as oP -, ~ ,i
sent TO- any Indian treaty made since tDe 'I q.
Indians are not independent nat oEs with whom Iedto5
can possibly he made that SO I'S MS
on the Government aud Injurious 10 , taT
Indiaus that the ne" Ie%tSS G1 MI A. cInditIIrc
of $40 100000 least ami that To Concet lhe oSahu ol
ana any arpouIt whatever coad be taken from the
Trc.esy without the consent Of the peoples r. SchIa
tNtse her as to tie amOuHtor to The usc Nlch1t should
b,Icd that tie object Tor which tue moncy was t. be
tie treaties were, IN Great l'n.asiC
useless; that re r cent lnn deieEatls mao 1o
n0u.ccd treaties fraud and surprise on me
Indians, and tuat the Government IA9 liiu 70 r "a
sPcot e. them so idt as tTI! "a I h,i ~
Limiting privileges ON the Indians. As aSl nope OF
-. rec HcHt with the desire OF preventing an lndah
war and securing tic comfort HnL ,.Nd a tu r,i
I.us the House COuCTres had proposed 10 alpIoTF-
ate Tn nun amount which the Senate had inserted IN
gros, ana TO leave to the LAecutFe Ic uuIg auu
responsibility Of tNptudng the money Ia u !3 vi
the question not Of money, hut of principle Inc
senate confCTees. however, refused TO ace TO that
Mr. BECK Dem, KY insisted on the right of the
House to say whether 1t would appropriate money 10
aut 10 any such Or position that. the Senate had
1igbt IN make a treaty with 100 Indians any one Of
whom might be hung for stealing COW, and pay them
uOo,OOOGlO for the Territory Of Colorado.
in his Judgment. the rse was not bound to carry ont
the Indian treaties made pursuance of the act of July,
Congress reserved To Itself the right to determine what
lands should DC set apart for reservations To- the Indians
and Therefore treaty could be made binding Congress
TO appropriate money until these reservations mad been
express ~ approved by Congress; second, that money
ia pursuance of law-that is, law enacted ly
both Houses aid approved by the President,
Third that the Indian tribes are not independent nations
in the sense Of international law, capable Of making
treaties that can bind them o. the United states
Mr. WASHBUkN Qiep, WIS., asked MI. Lawrence
propriations T. carry out these treaties.
Mr.. LAWkENCE-Uudouhtedy. 1t is very well settled
that the treaty-uak!ng power can NOT make treaty
when onos ~, , e1ir pt5 tr@atV which is Ca
pablo OF being executed without the consent Of the
Mr. WAsHBURN-I understand that to be the true doc
trne hut the opposite doctrine is held III the Senate.
Mr. LAwRENGE-We , are under her me sHSh Obligation
Mr. TASH5BTE- hope pee 50 I nCSer shall render that
further Conference Committee was ordered, and
MT EiSGaHM dep Ohio laid before the House the
request Of Richard III Merrck counsel Tor P NQodswho
Vr,inia that he McIric) be heard at the bar of the
HIse 10 argue the al the hearing. He argued that
United to the House ana denied.
A MIMBER ADMITTED.
The House then took up the Louisiana contested elcc
tOu case Of Darrell against Baey-the resolution OF the
minority being that AdOph Bailey is not emitted 10 the
scat aud that G. b. Darrell Is; and OF the minority that
Bailey was duly elected, and j. entitled to tn" seat
A fter remarks 10y McssTs STEVENSON and SHELDON
of Louisiana in support Of the majority resolutions, and
OF Mr. KERR against them the resolution OF the minor
inv vas Jed Sc t. 81, and that Of the majority giving
the seat MI Darrell, adOpted-iea~, g. Nays g.
Mr.. RANDALL dem, PENN made "a motion 10 ac-
iourI rema king that the question was important ana
a
Mr. STEVENSON N;ep., Ohio) offered to allow the vote
on IL motion reconsider to he taken at O'Clock on
"Wednesday next.
MT. RANDALL accepted the propos ton, and it was
agreed TO.
Mr.. CULLOM d,ep., III, by unanimous consent, re-
uoTtcd from the Committee Territories the bill 10 III
rorp0rate the United States Freehold Land and EmgIa-
ton COMPANY aud to confirm certain legislation III col
orado Territory. Passed.
Mr.. MYEisS (R p, Peuu.) from the Conference Com
mitt,c on tie bin 10 establish an additional land district
In Kansas, made a report, which was agreed 70.
Mr.. NCCRARY Rep Iowa., from tine Committee on
Elections caiC4 up the contested election case from
Kcr,urly with the resolution that MI Adams the sit
TIM member, i, entitled to retain his scat
Mr. DICKLY sug 1ested that the House was IN no con-
ditiou 10 consider another Gle tiOn case.
The suggestion approved aud y was agreed That
the matter should 20 over as unfinished business.
Mr.. FERRIS (Bcp ~ " reported from tine Conference
Committee the bill granting the right OF way to ditch
and canal hrldcrs over the public lands.
without dispUsiDg of the bill the House adjourned TIL
Tuesday next.