New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1870-02-23

member asked such permission under the implied assnr
that whatever he might have printed wonia nov no
IN violation Of the rules of the House. much less IN Ho
lat0u Of common decency The speech referred 70 DO
ng on member OF the Senate, IN violation OF com
mon decency II it allowed to pass nnnouced y
The Globe be channel OF personal abse for the con
veyance Of matter which he would be ndieaoie ior NJ
Mr. WOOD Dem, n " suggested that the House, be-
fore beng called upon to vote on the IT,
Mr.. DAWES said he had purposey drawn the preaihpIo
guage which he himself alleged 10 be 100 indecent 10 w
into The Globe
Massachusetts entitled TO the thanks OF the House
for bringing before it the abuse OF printing IN me GOoe
speeches that delivered In the House. IL ongh
TO he reformed debate in the House should
become real debate. and not mere written essays. -
Mr.. DAWES remarked further that to let the matter
unnotced would have been 10 say TO the country
there nothing too indecent or improper Tor the House
TO pdulge in. He thought II due TO the Speaker who
held responsible for the maintenance OF proprety IN
debate show that that speech which was going into
the House and that attention of the House
drawn its character the House had Instructed the
Committee on Rules to inquire whether II was hoI III
MIR MUNGEN Dem, Ohio said that in one sense he
considerably obliged To the honorable gentleman
from Massachusetts for giving hun little nOtoflety'
which he would not. perhaps otherwise have gained
House to be dsrespecu to the Speaker and he de-
fled the gentleman from Massachusetts to point out any
from the Speech declaring that Ting ne should
say had no reference to any act or word OF Mr sue
lie stood here as the representative OF constituents
and he demanded the right of free speech nndcr the
Constitution. He would not permit any one to At
tempt to deprive him Of the right to discuss pun
lie questions that The sDee Sas Mas qt violation
of the rules of the House to quote from the elias,
WssaChusctts or his friend the Senator chose TO make
an application Of his remarks, he Mr MungeD was not
Senator let hiu them He had authority III common
report for say HinS'., D NJ Tf i've
called order If he did As to dsrraceul scenes IN we
House gentleman from Massachusetts, forget the
the last Congress at the counting OF the ires
DENTAL yOiei Did the gentleman from Massa
OF Roanoke. That was Now England authority ana ne
Would tins House gag him in discussing the doctrines OF
an mpertiuent lecturer who was examining his theories
his Illogical damnabe doctrines on inc people OF
the North Had he not the right to discuss then ana To
show their absurdityl That presumptuous lecturer and
champion of the God and morality party OF loyalty
hiz lecture ON Caste he referred TO the hoby OF
ancient Poland as example Of what lie denomnated
Caste" 10 Russia Of the present day as an example ot
pro- ross and civilization. lie Nungch) had spoken OF
Thai IN ms speech What that Russian civilization with
" hch the lecturer was so much III lover III was
monstrous communism in the peasaniry, VINO were
unknown, and among whom there was nothing nuC
moral ideas was the who in love with that mon
aiinded to Euse6ius and to men who lived uuder the
Governments of Constantius and OnOrius and Arcadus
during the decline OF the Roman Empire, ana dnllng
me dirty and indecent Byzantine Empires he
was charged with violating the rules of
tim U ,,iacSnsetts become So fastidiousi why had he
not called his colleagues order when they were abus
ing President Johnson He llr MunGen had spoken OF
ton that he was gifted President, but II he had vlo-
lated the rules by saying SO, he would take D%ck ne
assured the House that he had been respectful 10 u III
that spcec but would allow some new rule OF Ell
quettc to forbid him ctcisiDg the sayings of man VINO
was eternaly trusng himself IN the face OF everybody
Mr. DAWES called Mr.. Munger TO order. He did not
think it proper to speak Of the impotence Of Senator's
public lecturer take issue with the gentleman on
that point, and leave II to the House
The SPEAKER-The Chair rules that the language Is
mparnamentary and out of order
Mr. MUNGEN-Very well, then; WI say that ne Is
not mpudcut # that will be more acceptable lhuchter
MI MUNGEN went on to argue that lie had not been
guilty Of violation OF the rules OF Tue house anu ne
scorned the mputaon of being guilty OF any lndeceney
He perfectly willing to have the matter referred to
MI sCHENCK Gep., Ohio drew sketch OF the style
OF debate that has grown up IN the House, representing
Mr.. Jones OF one state sitting down III ms room hp9hg
pen scratching his head, and writing an essay WINE
Mr. Smith Of another state Is sitting IN ms room ID M
other hotel or observation-disclosures cnuSeIns m Dlhs W
out essay ON another SUBJECT, ana these were
brought the House and read were printed without
being read aud passed IN the country Tor debate. io
doubted whether speeches published IN that way came
properly within the scope of that clause OF the C0usu
called 10 elsewhere for words spoken IN debate
Garsd ones of KehIncRy Voorhec and
Dawes, and then the resolution was agreed TO-
Mr.. MEYERS rep, Penu) from the Conference Com,
the Special Naval Appropriation bill, reported
al $2OOOOOO He explained that the bill as passed the
House gave $COOO9 for the Bureau OF Construction ana
ing. The Committee had agreed TO increase the amount
steam Engineering. These sums absolutely ncces
sary put IN course 0f completion many VesselH low
undergoing repairs Thousands Of men whose work Was
now suspended the yards would again have
employment. The report Was adopted.
MIR. VOORHEES, Dem Ind, rising 10 personal eK
PLANTATION, referred to iIsnuatlon in Mr. Bentons
speech OF Saturday last coupling hun with the knehls
of the Golden Circle and Indignantly denied all cohhec
Mr. SWAMI dem, Md moved to adjourn IN honor OF
The House then went into Com ntee Of the Whole, Mr.
CESSNA Rep.. PENN in the char, on -
THE LEGISLATIVE APPRorRIATIoS BILL -
day appropratng 1880 for The Bureau OF Edneaiion
elected quite long and at times amusing discussion
Cosmttee rise order that he might in the House
The Committee accordingly rose, and the House having
closed the debate all items under the head OF the De
ard the amendment was agreed TO- A.
the discussion OF amendment as 10 Clerks IN the
Departments, Mr. BECK submitted the following AZ SHOW
ing the stages In the "Crcumocution Ohice through
winch lawyer has actually had TO so III coleeinga
FIRST Chief Cek First AUDITOR he stated the
Second to another Clerk in the Office who copied and
Tlird another Clert in the First Controllers oee who
w,s SS o we C i the F U la who verified
the account aud the eo@pu's,oo OF Interest
S,s&. Went bach to no 3 who ar.in Serised il
Sen cent TO The ktgi,ieT CsIE who coP, and reFstd
ESS: " eni to se warrant Clsrl oStarssd warrant
Jealh. Went to Mi W-sitb Chief CLERK. vi signed
Elerenu Hartley the Assistant who signed IT.
Teth Went Mr. Lamb the Fret Controllers Oe whoregE
tered IT,
Ih6eenh: Went to the Hrt Controller who signed IT,
Fourteenth: Went the Registers CLERK, copied
FttfeRh. Weni o Register Allison, who signei t.
Sixteenth Went Mr. Mann the drs room where the dram
Serennn: Went futile Assistant Treasurer who signed the
ORA
EioLp1nt. the Registers CLERK who recorded the draft
Nn,leeat. Went Register Allison who signed the DRAFT
Went Mr. Mann who took ny receipt for the dram and
hHlded
J,rev dr Treated whiskyioddr Loud laughter
After thrtytwo pages OF the bill disposed Of the
Committee rose. -,
Mr. Beaman was excused from service the Com
mttee of Elections and Mr. Hale appointed IN his
m. 81. Ii,,nr mad