, 1870-08-25
ecuMEhlCAi COUNCIL.
A the Dogma of 'nfa'libi'ity.
# Archbishop Purcell in Gin
cinuati.

~ = Ths,s arc two in tlio city; one IL
-. In. Cathedral. and the other to
st-H II s.. Xavier. This society is
.tun 10 o,lr citizens, and regret
49, W .;a,aaiu, for them, As just NOS
~" + In. uct bcen Published. wtsli
:r1.,,s;r.l friends, to understand that
..-,r here, not merely to hear lee
s,,,ter hnw important tho subject
~ y, II relieve great Distress ~ntch
~ ,;.ac- in this city: and very lew
S.:i- sufficient to inform yon OF the
= distress that this yon!tS society has
y :ri, i,., mr. of ST. Vincent do Paul has
~ ~ t,,r sl.,,lt forty years. 1t ia nov /
hing condition in many Of our |
IL W Stu iorS, st. Lcuis, Ac.. and it |
e"' 80; :, -:a:.v r.,ics in Europe. Its OBJ 1
distressed families in their dom
ci.t them that cnrporoal aud at |
49, -,:i,1tnal relief that they may
S.a sl.e +, celrts OF thla society, OF
Ia ~. r.,.. Of ,llat obligation. from
~ -, :. %, !.>t year, to August !. o. the
.,.,- ,e!1:cte,1 from among their oEu
.... rem charitable persons OF the
:, ~ II. of which they expended
~ :. T: :. expended this money in bread
80. 1cu,s paid, clothing, shoes and
- fs,y relieved very large number
~ -. :. 80 liz families relieved and visited
II t.. -: +r.r,5t: number Of persons in these
II - i sri the number Of visits made.
.,~c 10 rp>ak of the Ecumeuical
M til. i the subject that I an-
-, +: ,ay answer to Mr. Nelfer and
-. L.- .,trr III lisLed in the newspapers
Ii F. .Yasy- THE .e'rSc1L-
av., .re .ll a~.1e Of the meanlnS o. me
49, ~ II After Ell {FfHAk
80! "a -; m msaos the sho'e habitable globo,
ae; " ~ so;ncii called Gcumenical Is
n ,';,o., member eeGla from every
-. RI Tie l,bisshle globe. 1t must
~. x,,.f,i ,r The Pore to- be a gen
~, ,,.,,ri Iie I,rose-,llngs must he Sane
n. ! ;tr ,ha 1'ope. and its dacrses solemnly
as.,.1.., ,c,] tJr the lppc. These are the es-
II + :. riti,rs of every General Council in
n. r..l,a'ir r,..rtll. Tie Vatican Council is
"a =; from t.iue held in the Vatican. It
IA: .;,tttea;li Of the General Councils coll
ssEis : or Church
|s$Ta rc:r vas exceedingly anxious that it
i: h indeed Vatican Council But We
- il very lnconvenient to meet IN that
~. :,~ a::.c o::r Voices were almost inaudi-
-. III srea: dome cf St. Peter WAS over
~ l.-,I,, and our voices wese absorbed In it.
m .::a :rJ many expedients to render the
- VT AAAh%h1s o+tA0A-
=. :. vcsll have been very unsatisfactory
4 hundred yAzda Of e1nvas. to
-. :. liz I.a7ssc OF sounding bo1rds, ware
EE6 lid oye7 the ambo. as tho pulpit WAS
5Ef,;. a.:I when all these expelients were
m Nh j ati>f1ctUry. I deputation OF Fathers
L aiL i:s-ly,-, ii wLs,ln was one, went too
IN ;,.s a:.,. halls If the Quirinal Palace, to
VI: =t-:ner there the acoustics vera better
+: u: .!4f Vatican. hut it IVES tiusl1y deter
-; n r::hy.iit TO whatever Inconvenience
e. ;, RS i'll 81 Ft.er*r, and there to continue
TO- ,us:,Il-
Mil. xaa also another Inconvenience
M. ,.lo harc been in Iomo know tL4t
N. = j. a.wa:a : certain degree OF heat in st
Ps:r,= Church. OF bitterly cold dar-and
III n i.,rr , lc!l sometimes in Nome-5on en-
Il: la: church. aud ynu Gnd tue atmosphere
cpm!a1..ble: you leave the church, and
81. are Immediately CHILLED by the outside
sr.,l Il, the summer YOU have burning at
IL -,:.rre ols the 0u' Fl lc, and tie moment you
SE,=1 the church you are seized almost with
III. Hence il was not healthy. And last
ffJ...r was very unhcaltAy one III Rome.
n ~ OF our Anepcau ci'izens di.l there
4 S:..eru of our Cardinals and Bishops died
-S:i:::, tic first three months, anti many 9th
r. l4yt since died T1eu in the hall wer
7k:.t us'tuiugs, which otcasionei fre4uen
tk.Srut7 Of air that made s1d Cish
r. -ui!.--- 1 ltavo seen rany 0
af :. ir:;,lH, on st .frs frying to l,o!,tie along
st ii i!rir way 10 their places. that you
H.: u. iill,,Glt one Lad dis.I in tie counci
81 =. .s;,tl,- exhaustion. These oleuingt
u ..,F. rendered il cx'relnelr rnnicasnnt
81 IA. ut!t slanmingnf tlnors coughing ant
6, { .;;:>:: ua!!c it extremely iiaic,llt to hea
II za.us-, hut I'm Ter these i1ieoavenicnees
Id s,t.i,,:lc'! 70 meet.
II FEEEDtN OF SPEECH
.A f..' F"st "aF never present ih the Council
t.sE L. tat lsc-idc 1T it. He did not coutre
4.... ....:;l.. III our disconrscs he left us pei
1,e:'y fire.. under tho direction OF iivo card
xs-;-, viz, Nrrt called Presidents. Of whom tn
1n...,- ~ -ix rears older than the pone, VIII
+ ~ :. lis saith year.
Il We b. Ito ask lsave to speak, and the 1eav
y s.-.ly st.n:el, never rcfcsod. We spok
s-;':. a. wu Thought necessary and it va
y :: "k,n We were in the estimation Of th
=. t!!;rl.c'' :a, tedious that 4 little bell Vi
A.. SID We wero requested to descend frol
n .:.::.,,.
= I!e 'ouncil was composod-I h1ve the lii
s-:r-af 80 Bishops, Generals OF rehgior
':!ts.. E.n, ALbuts- Besides there wei
-".s:: l'ltriarcl,s, aud then 1Fty-cne Card
as Aua sre what i large assembly it WA
-.s1 ahts n full representation Of the East nj
SN~et, North and South, OF kingdoms, NJ
p = 'Ar1. aud territories. aid eut-of-the-w;
a = =, such AZ had never assembled in
s,r:;c 'wforo : because, as sou know, the
II - not single Dinhop from Americ. in n
+ !ai"r Council. Tlsere was q full md Fl
s~i;ercntatson Of Christ cndnm.
THE RIGHTS or SCIENCE.
I !" tho tirst schema, OF which there We
eze@::S'-l iron to discuss the origin OF COVER
aIlss.se-tl,e constitution of the Church ct
4 -1t:'t. the constitution nf the Sta.e-and al
3tar it"is'sation Of religions and scicnti
Xf'-:!:. q! 10 examine into The question whath
s 5tt.~L!itis truth could At tho same time bs a
Et:"e";:t;c to Icvcale7 truth-slether scic
z':::* :ss;il: should be discouraged, or whoth
5tucl RESTRAINTS should be attempted 10 be i
sj,:esd Uroa the pursuera mud students
a. :s:.tc ac would cripple them. or would
'is" them of tlAf free range to ali the I
\ artln'rit. OK ecience without which th
ase%:d :;it ever seek to ottain important l
3"'ts, Tia. rights OF science better VIM
3c-:, its.an they we're hr the Bishops of til
as-s':::::!!!'y. And IN American EIshor, who "
3!:r n%'I f.llow-stuttent farty rears ago,
$eta:ss. now tho Bishop Of ST, Augustine.
Il "a Ia. was one OF the first to speak. he
e'''il"i iileoaogian, and sound. natu
a ::'so. aer. lie taught theology and nAtu
ala:''-a'liy in BALTIMORE; he VAS sent first
r. a-s'n. and. ey his oEn choice, was tra1
'":.' Il tu ST. Augustine. Tic roso At once a
6sT?r'1ci,"d the congregation OF Carlin
Is n''a-:aS the Roman 1nqui.i:ion for hAvi
eG2&e l:.justlce to Galilen. and he cn,phasiz
lea 1soman Congregation; you condemn
i.,4 - t.acslihs. . loctrincc oatrary to
as'E;':::e- when lie taught tho motion OF
ta:e!: ! mention tlis fact to sllo. Il
\ f. ts.;-s their freedom; that tho Car
e. and that they took this r
HI. ::sa-uot they, hut their prcieccA.ors, n
- E:.scd Galileo for teachlug tho dur
=! a'.n':al rotation Of 'l,c earth- He :
A:'.,-=-.d himself to the Spanish nishops :
x"'':' :s,rrr. and their predecessors, for
] t. =. H. would hsve done 10 religion as =
L. !" '::i,ni:y and science ty their unU
1'-En..s.:'s against the possibility OF the
!-''',r Of the Amer1can part OF tha elo
a. :"'ss'. fact that there conll not be nj
4 l<":s-. aud from their vain and absurd r
.I:.:.. :, tEcE concluded it was wild prof
= '"~' Goi;siu!,us Lad in his head, for which
r,''::,~'*s:! aid from Ferdinand and Isabella,
E. :ot mention this rs a reproach to /
= t'::'l1. hut = warning that scienco had
4 t:S.s!=. and III I they should never be INT
II ~: WITH: that scientific men should purs
Il s.'h ts' largest liberty their i,,vestigatio
I :, 'l"F OIL: we're disposed not to reject Ch,
II As't::i- t;entlenien the Bible Is true. G
II i T. a':t,or.
q ny vA::. duty to submit to the Church. I
n II tlarsh will never find fault with vou
4 listing that scientific truth canuot be c,
II .;.: to revelation. G pope never eicr
81 i'-s E:aa1fcsto aeaIust Calico, aud to.t
& :'~ :..'h: mans memory is cycrrwhure
q si.s't'.,'- The Cardinals acknowledged Il
81 a.!!s::s'., Wis done to thar c,ninentiv scient
q ;@>:. al tlH~ il . guarantee that sinlilar
81 F','''' NJ" never lie ;1ouu nsain.
y .':,tF q: oar Disho:s, formerly OF pil
.-:=.'. i:-!lor Domin,ch, made usc Of sim
! :'s'"a- He refutcd the objection IL
r., 80 ~ 'iic- Of America are IN: properly
~ "','. er il they werc that thcy wo
-, 'e's rapal infallibillty, FIR I
.i n'7''H "a- opposed to the advances
J. .s' h:ma. he indignantly repli
t -snicHesn Catholics are better
- ~ tli7' Eolr Italians" He was told
~ Inns, aEd he was-aftcr lie lad u.tc,
70 = = e'-' ;:!:ii. Applauso aud laughtsr.
-; :!' t''n'. he did not consent to yield n
y" Wy Ecan r.thclics-aud Tc.,,t r-r -
F.!-.i. ~ 1nc S7eus
i:N!a& OK nls SPEECH IN THE co,.xct,
"lH'9 Il tanc To m. :urp to snrak ,si
f2s", :1ll il waH granted. I int.,,aaa
\ : E.! IL: t!:c subject that wa. thct, ,,,.
q s:'!-:. t;:c csvi. constitution of socic,E
s:.:..: a..sl origin of government; hui n
"a i.f a {f:.s or f,r, nf+..r I,,j .1,sN