The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1870-11-12
SHINES LATEST SIT INDY.

Its Examination mt the rOlnbs FOR IgIx A.
snuit OH DIR. Mcrlill--A Confras,--A Nice
| story of Professional Preparation far !.
| Ra5y's Advent.
Inc often adjourned examination OF Dr. Shine for
ms assault on Dr. Merrill. at lying-ln house IN
"rcehWich street some Few weeks since, took place
yesterday al the Tombs Police Court before Justic
lowing DR.. Merrill was placed on the stand ana
deposed as follows:-Flrst saw Dr. Shine nj
ms own door; was standing on me stoop
ana they met there ana talked ,ooetber
lor lew moments; had attended a man
haihea 1ohn Lenahdn; the subject OF the con.
versatlon was that Shine was notified BY the Boara
OF Health TO Investigate the cause OF the death or
Lenahan; SHINE asked MIN what he meant by giving
cerunca'es IN cases OF sudden deaths which propefv
belonged 20 The Coroner; answered that he had
peen Win the man from the beginning or his sick.
ness until MS death; that he had counsclIng pnv
stefan Win nun and considered he had riaht 10
give certificate; shine said he had no right ana
tning'; Shine then ordered him to appear at tSs
SSofoneas Court at ten O'Clock on The following
meaitn replied that he would SEQ aboutit and shine
. ,Ia. eit inc place. was told that the hoard OF
1--we tgatlon. and that DR.. Shine was the nerson 70
MAKE MAJ H.; next saw SHINE at No. q West street. at
ing; she was about being confined: we ,ver,, o In
.ne iylng,ln room at her bedside when DR.. Shine
t zane Amt into fhe adjoining room, staining before
.re noor OF the lylng-in room, ANA sa,n ex-
oieuiy "Wnat does this means this Il, my casa:
answered Shine very quietly, saying that he had no
oJectlon 70 Shines having It, and starting 10 leave
the room, when Mary Collins stepped before him
anu sald ~ on must not go;" answered lone was
enOugn;' she insisted On his remaining but when
MIS-. Muivehlll called for DR.. Shine nc ASKED ner
WHICH sne preferred, and he Immediately left the
room; asked Mary Collins IN the other room N DR.
Sulhe nad Deen there before that evening when be-
lore shc replied DR.. SHINE, rushing from the yins.n
ROOM shouted, God til your soul did / moi
tel you this was my case;' after some excited
remarks on both sides Shine shouted ..i'll learn
you 10 interfere In my business y and seizny large
cohcn shell rom the Inahtelpiece he made two Or
tnree motions 10 strike; the marEs O! Shine g upper
teeth were on his (witnessj arm; <had his hcaa
unuer Shlnes lett arm ana the latter kept poanGnp
MN with the shell; Mary Collins crel ont s.Mur-
def' ana the officers came In; Shine thea went
lIto the other room and he (wltness) told the ON.
GERS THAT SHINE was the man who had injured him:
had loaded sesen-snootcr with him; could
not tell the hour OF the day he NUT
The pistol IN his pocket; ] thought he
made such remark as Ills well Dr. Rhius did net
get shot," "IhatI did not shoot DR.. Shlne:" never
released MS hold OF shine and for tnat reason knew
that 1t not Mulvchill but SHINE who st,ink him.
never asked Mrs. Muvchil in the street 10 attend
her, having notoel that she was ence,nre dl, nor
foley her TO her house ana solicit the case: she
made an indirect application to MIN to attend her:
Old not know what caused Mnlvehill to lniict VIC,
ence on him; meyer solicited pregnant woman in
the streets for efssion 10 attend her: Mrs Mulve-
n 81 nSyer x tSg n ga After The occurrence that
AT this stage OF Tho Examination by the consent OF
ooti sldes. There was an adjournment Monday
week next when inc case Is 70 be connlnded