, 1870-12-27
TIE D0OL1TTLR REFERENCE
.SCAHDAL.

Motion for d RchcartnE OF the Mo-
tton 20 Set Aside thc Betercc,s Ike>
port-Thu Counsel at Dnxgerx
BrnSn-DtaloGue Rosween lhc
Judge and the couuscl--A Drnwn
Fight.
From ne Ste Tori Hfrald, De. 81.
Yesterday morning shs Dooiitt|e reference
case Was revived in Part of tho Superior
Court, before Judge Spcncer, By Afr. Ealr7Lsn,
who moved for leave to renew the motion 10
yet aside tho report presented BY ME. poo-
Little ~ referee in the casa Of Gray againat
Fisk, Jr.
COMMENTS OF COUNSEL.
In commencing the ptoceediugs Mr.. Ehl-
ridge said: lsk to have this order which
your Honor uasde amended in two respects,
that ia ~ 70 their rec;tins the supplementary
affidavit xhichl eent your Honor. and which I
rent tie other ride notice Of, OF TO rscite that
which as presented and offered, publicly
read and refused, and then l ask thst may
he SLOWED to renew this nution on payment
ot the costs Of this notiou- l state 10 your
Lie and we'll fer Ibis Court that this no:,on 10
renew should be granted.
COUNSEL. on TIE OTHER SIDE.
Ar. Dudley Field, who hsd cat with his back
to bis opponeut, not deiguing to bestaw 4 look
upon him. now rose, and: addressing the
Court, eaids IL am entitled to helr the
srourds Of the motion Of eourstl before
aueEer."
AsnASk yrn1C1At Apx1sstoy.
Tie Court. There Was an affidavit saut.to
me by aIr. E;ltilse. which did not reid, /
sent I letter to you to esy would not reatt it.,
Perhaps 1as wrong in refusing to reai il,
and will let him have the benefit OF ii.
1Ir. Etdridse did not ret aus letter from
your Honor.
The Court. l sent letter to you AMI sleo
J to Ms. Field. Did you RECEIVE one, Mr. Field.
Mr.. Fled. No. sir.
The Court. We'll, wvose lins to csch of
4; you. Il IN ro.sib ble Tia let,ers war,, narsr
! mailed. ara re- f5inr among nv paners nt
T, home. lii. EIl,ilgs wroto 10 ms. sending
, sent IN Mr.. F,eld m the anhie.ct than NJ
, Ea1a senf W = iatfrr erclos;ne ona j.. r,n,s
! to III EId1idce m lie subiaci. T,,eu ~
! ,n,.a5 ,,t.,S !, ..,,r- a..st ,,a,,.a..,-,.
,oe,ci, s.r;nc ftst b,i mi rssd ti,a .f,;d,.
II, ~ si,srit; M ra,d = Tl,on .stsr~,r's
t Mr. E,eId rsme into conrt. and thnnobt he
! 1,.1 rot nv ,at+sr hut - .aen. r. n,o "a t.J
not ~ s 1Gs's t.,aa tse ~ ~. 10 onss nsa
I+r1.sits .,st ~. 49, Ef.. - Ir.a T 49, =.
tsas, .I,a,;1, 1,o.s .r.,s.i n ~. ,,rhi, ,ra..
,tn i;IssH -. -;,ts rta.n,e r'o ~, ,i.;&
sn tTts S.- - @ ~ uan I1at.i -, ~ y. tu .t.a
! 1.Sn.,ant - tl,n 1.hf;n sna nnr r,r Iii
I,.Ea T. . n;ratr d.ra: s.snds1 sa.;n ~" ""A
A'"A' :. <..t-s,s. ~ ~ grts T,-xr-r ~ 3
,r- r,d-;Sra Eow ,1c ~. IL ,,n;1ar ran,
i s;jar.tion. u;il .tnfa thxt fT,a-e ara facss
cnnnsried xith the esss that eonld not cat To
o,a H"ne. ~, tis;rt ~ ;,'a6r,a,. ~
ion a.c1ad ~ .i1nw ~ tha fac,s tia s.rre
fss.a w;,,ch brnncht II shonf i,sin, utnreJ ia
Ire f.ce% ptrhsns IL IL = rnsttcr 81 noitcy
w;t,, Tnnr lfonor
| Tie court' Yor e,n pake a motion far a
rehe,r;nc hsfe,re The Ene,inl Term at the Su-
ner;or c,nnrf when NV Judea. si.tinr in .hat
j; hrsnrl, nf III" ro1,rt xiii r3ya ynn IN orltr
sr.in.t 1fr. Fie,d te cnBnaj him n ahug
| csnxa vh,. .ha nation xI,nu3l mt hc ~.
| oran<a
NJ Ela,;3ce. m nn,7orst .na Yopr If,nor
n ..v ,fst 7 Fan Tr,se r,ot;nn f,r \ ,eha,.
inc -N3 =
! T,aH iu,rmlv, I bona ynur Hnno.
ri, - 81 = ar. ~, ,-x,aS
"AAS LA +a'AAE sHs 3oeA oAop@'