The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1870-04-29

BAD MEMORY AaLIr.

es$%ssas0 d f. Bank
Owes not that the occasion on which he called on
Es snS dSP seS S
oDdn You give sm on that SScS,lCn letter re-
the best q my knowledge never, o,,uo,,,,,or IN
,sst ocsssiSn %ihss signed good may papers.
No, sri think not - ,.xo
him appointed to- 70 some S SS% oec Ale has several
Q.-un this nrst interview Al think not.
SNs sSea or 70 saving word about any
he motive IN S in Ss g" S '
/ should think half an hour nearly.
n'rARLASD's INTIMACY WITH Mr.. GREELEY.
o-wa. he intimate enough with you TO 90 to yon
and talk oyer hi. domestic troubles with you at that
time? Al should not have talked them over In my
intimate sncSsh NTH ySc SDo AI
Odd you hear with him because he was in great
d;!sis A srsa a't Hno spoke with
he aid ie not cve his wife and wanted give
MP, why should he manifest feengp Al cannot an
SISidns e = cry sH wv NO sir, ,,. .
vaSS Mh ne so Sn %ns e
o1How Iong has you known him before ,n%, Al
,.9-ATc these letters i Your 6andwriiinsS crwo
letter. SoSG MI and the other Dear
cir" on the 9Th Of July 1865 when YOU gave him ths
Al have s's always thought he was friendly to he
protested to be.
DOES Mr.. oREELEr WRITE THE rRurHf
Q-what YOU wrote IN these letters was true, or you
ict,ers o. i recomme ndsti9n Tor once
lee Usually are Laass SeRI'' uo' 'o'a
Ss s"f'S d% Sff evil 81
him before these troubles 49,
not " isS@piSd IN iSO mud the Split Of the man
MIR. Graham commenced to read the fret letter
judge Garyin objected that they were written long
be ore the shooting.
The Court-I think they arc competent to show that
this man had good character at that time.
GRAHAM STUCK ON GRsELEr's HANDWRITING.
Judge Davis-Tnen that will open the question Of
Character 70 us.
MIR. Graham commenced reading:
"MY FRIESD enclose you a note TO Mr. Cooper,
calculator Of dentists. have much fruit IN It's
ep-ephe-rip-"
~ give II up" said Mr.. Graham. Z" This chro.
rr,phy beats me. tGreat laughter. Mr.. Greeley,
will you read these lettcrst"
The letters wer9 passed up to Mr.. Greeley who
read as follows;
oyrlcE OF THE TRrnusE,,
NEW YoRk, July "a, 1865.
My q DO SS have 9es much W
seSsy wrs 50 many eG h1. o Ant Ar ps &c S9
e E 49,, my s!sf with Better
and may &S;.sey yn SslU little HORACE GREELEY
DAsIEL MCFARLAND. Esq.
MIR. Grceley-Ths !. another note to Mr.. McElrsth.
ton;
NEW YORK. Jan II. 1867
nr s aS" Gp . y and r Trsfn. him m AZ
nn,isht woTtnS deacry!ag citizen who viii worihiiy
on any ,ersship in your ant respectiuily commend
"'v"' W 'Vu' "'''o'"' HORACE GREELEY.
THOMAS McELR, ARA, ESQ.
GREELEY RoPIsG DEEcHER IN.
TO The RSv Henry Ward Beechst? H.1-Ycs SIR
w. SS sT s yTsS ns % he
hS . e NJ; I Ssse S;s5, ''
Judge Garvin-Is that competent?
The Court think IL u incompetent.
wtless-l have no objection 70 answering T.
III. Witness. s. Is1'
G s a w CHARGE Go 10 s Grand ay 5
you characterized II plainly and truthfuy and that
@ hsy have sot
! transaction which !he whole civilized world condemns
incy were concerned perfectly innocent and guilt.
f %scy 90f Vie %fS ' ss
s SSS got 90 s se
GUILTY ACTORS THAT TRANSACTION.
Hardly Single verdict out,ide Of those who partle
IN I %as pac hSS en-
lie stand he inquiry ar:t ussc.iea has Ss any
main Eu zoo GST Ss,
maa 'Ssy 90 upon Tie stand 70 tel certain thSss and
tel Ss Ty but yet may ys ss SS9r R
|
syS no Sh yt in .s fqS %o SEs 10 al
DpetS 10 .u our ewes 70 The jnd,ment the vol hs'
pronounced with reference . ths TRANSACTION Have
% o. tins ,n5 Sc hon ROM isss & wit
when he sees hat hrs conduct cannot &c excused sSd
| from hts name? Have not right TO snow tld
me-. GREELEY AND OTHERS
have the control this prosecution and In orde
70 avert that aSIne stain which 4 ,nIe % attach L
gs wi az stoaser motive could pre s npoR man
NJ GREELEY nSliEsnSe ana thai
has received ti0 for his testimony. have right tC
SSo s ne Of sooS 40 f nS S eHe
chow that the fountain nom which this evidence ISSUE
POISONED AT TUE FOUNTAIN HEApf
that there are clrcnmstanec. which deter him IRON
that which he chooses 10 give us9 do not mean !,
mpescn Mr greeley. integrity man 10 any matte
Know how rcgaice viii destroy Tie Conscience IN
Would rssfei While % not " mean ' to %Pusn 'If
want 70 show ina The Jury should receive his test
mon, with very many grains OF allowance.
JUDGE HAcKgrr PROTECTS GREELEY.
The Court-I think the objection Is well taken. Tn,
Wr,S s Tat a,ef xSswcr was to nrsGucc MTt
view? How any Wv Mt. Gre ley ma, hrye had II
"' se6 taw nirs &
was TO DC arned TO this man chardfon, aud he alec
It, and lie Is within legal liability # he did.
Question excluded. Mr.. Graham excepted.
Mr. Graham offered TO show that Mr.. Greeley In
troduced Mrs. Calhoun to Mr.. Beecher, for the pur
pose Of enabling her TO persuade MIR. Beecher 4
solemnize this ceremony, II being well understoo'
by the admissions OF Mrs. CDlhoun that without tn
persuasion Oi Mr.. Greeley's letter, the Rev. Henri
Ward Beecher would take no part In that matter
and the known social, moral, and political standin
OF Mr.. Greeley was supposed to be able TO surmoun
the better judgment of the Rev Henry War
Beecher, and induce him TO do what he would no
| do ior any other person than Horace Greeley.
Excluded. Mr., Graham excepted
| nPARLAND's TRIBUNE ARTICLE.
| ODD You ever examine the manuscript from which
that article printed? lNcFarlands article In tn
| IIrbune.l Al am quite confident s
| Q.-ThC law makes distinct on between logic an
the raco lection Of fact; don't want your
reading that manuscIiptP Ayes, Sir; am very cor
| ndcnt did read II Ms he handed II to me he me {
| me and asked me to let Inn make u statement, aud
| am confident he came back and put II IN my hands
| Q-po you know where the n'anuAcrlpts2 A-NC
| q How Iorg was he gone when he went away TO &c
M lhi' manuscr pt before lie returned wiihlt2 A
/ hour.
OWN you swear that the manu.crirt he returne
H. You was IN his wr.tingP Al don't think kno'
his handwriting well enough TO swcdr u II,
Own you swear That You ever compared the art
ole as PRINT with The paper critically, to sec VIII the
twas cony Of that manuscript Al did not el
amino Il critically,
q Can you swear that Il lie n literal cony OF u
slri cannot swear to HAT, hut
, Q.-Ihats enough, that's enough. When You "
that manuscript what did you do with II? Al sci
II NJ etairs.