The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1870-05-03

with ts.t understanding and arranrement thcse Rar,
RETURN II, s, and came q tss f. Tt
Mr.. RFARLASD PUT MS WIFE
under the instruction OF Mr.. George Warden
TSe t9r e ScnS such ths they were not able
to Mr. %sE @ sr@ s sSs M n
pstrGelon MIN Win NE e eTT f. rsM nSSpohm.nt IN
me puficcpt 70 support ii, family that time
s going upon Upon the STAGE was erecrar New
Ter, orths lady BY other y,nc.es ma, ne letter,
which written by i; ny now o on 81 s nng am
proved by We prsogcr II the var nat when he h;
home, generations were had on thc SUBJECT.
THE LETTERS or mrs. CALHOUN
read g or by him were VERY " ice
SANCTION Of her adopting that MODE of supporting the
.mv After her return she dd go sPoh ho 'pe epressn
taons IN which size was .ed criticised and com;
RDG9 SfF S@G n ads ow
M ? nSa az 81
no dress whatever at 20 wear npon the s,sgh IN nn
Esrs and aq Prepared Tor se
parei Mr. MeFarland on seyera OCCASIONS 9e9g PPni
arprovlnR what done, We propose 20 show al
heartily spPro1od the fact that hc himself received
TUE sclSr sauSrNos or THAT WOMAN
while she thus employed on the stage ard arrlied
pSs NSd % 90 p fsf 70 ow tn for two purpo
hrst 20 dsabuse this to the jury of all this precN
degree e9npeced sth her LEAVING her husband throw
%sPSsyS
f9nSy Nat on. yldsnss clsaFy oo@pGts9t we gro
parade has been made in , written py this lady
now on the stand were written out Of the kndness or
hood Tor AZ ma time. simos dcsiiiaie family tina,
| sought the proprietor OF the Winter Garden,
Mr.. STUART,
and made an arrangement with him. with no motive
nothns oP any e relation eusSe hetrsn Mrs MeFar
and nT n o6 h. Sr s ssn Sc
pures kindest charity that actuatcd womanhood
70 THIS evidence for either Of the purposes have ind
The court-I am not aware OF any evidence tending
show that Mcfarland ever objected to his we going
on ~ pacNo there none pGt there 4 evidence
ey TO get her on the stage for the purpose Of getting
for the defence Is Tia, tbs iaGy with others Combined
Td 81 5n i e9n o. Mas mS
Of the expedicns used effect that purpose. That
M, DAVIS And that The first step to get her
the stage for that purpose.
WHAT JUDGE HAcKErr WILL ALLOW.
the issue "a ,SS enc 70 Mrs MeFaTasG
snd lei ssSd S nsT c G s nGG 3 her
o &c M heT IA, 20 p s , s a
man n very good circumstances. worth $4,000 will
Mr.. Graham-Now, ~ your Honor please want to
be heard ] MAKE objection l want t9 sec eKictly
testimony into this cascat all events. of serious
BEEN furnished Sy her own Pe That Is p' matter S Of
construcuon when we come 10 sum MP this case 20 the
pen Now. the question for your Honor Is this Is
WIPE OUT nER PEN WITH HER roSGuEP
CIaughterl.
Mrs. Calhoun. Runkle looked admringly AZ Mr.
Graham, whom he male this point and seemed to be
thinking what admirable sentence. sis she TO
wipe DOT her pen with her tonguet" would be for
one OF her own cpigrammatic letters. Mr. Graham
continued:
To ask to state how consrue her letters would
is vii the Court hen her letters showing parieulsI
STm S Ssr E e ado he those By
nj rule O. s esspes an q
Ga DO not Be Sa Sdaed
60 90 upon the ,tage they prove nothng Yoas Honor
facts which Gis.ssd Mr. MsFsseSa INTO mental Sena.
=. everybody else win read Them suppose he ihonTht
his wife went % The stage with his consent and when
uye OF him aid meant 70 deilnnce OF him, was
not that Just Us much calculated
TO MADDEN HIN,
a. though he had not been consulted ut a9 Suppose
hts wife h put him under the impression that she was
consulting hun rs to her c0ur'e and was following his
| he discovered
MRS. CALHOUN WAS AT THg DorroN
Of The whole thing and that he would haze been is
exprc sed 70 hs wife have they right 20 90 into that
c,eg Thai wa. just as much eseSsoG to
hun though he supposed she wen. on tho stage with hs
between Mrs. Calhoun aud his wife Your Honor Will
S seems to oS @e win ali respect 6at . c0arse not
Soper , S aee me SSs hecn Your Honor
cannot have forgotten the fact IN me face Of ms oner
theatre, the moment Mrs Mcfarland went upon the
| THIS MAN RICHARDSON.
| WIZ Admit het husband 20 there with her return
with her2 From that moment tnis man Richardson
he was her husband a favor allowed TO those only who
sustained privileged relations with he ladies who were
~ Time how 1 far qI these cs are gone INTO bit arS
Sa sS r s 70 BEEN S sd fS S
90 certain extent % 20 nto ihe cause Of hrs MOI
70 her husband that may nave arisen out Of the
SaSs e., SSSS syin s on PS
9E SS,Gonsye to our pr9 S9 ss, Sai srs
AniIy street. When they went into tnat mouse thcl
peElisd, and i any sh%nse came SycI M Sit,t
erng hat house In January 1884, anu TIC 2lst Of Eco
mrs. M'FARLASD ABscoxprD
M N her husband twas not une years that pro lucet
this sSgnr9on va sSmst.InS , at
bS enST sren INNS an Sn,as ever Occurred
justify this course on The part Of Mr. etarlan1 I
summit that tnis should be restrained wthin h'
lmt at have eeen already moGl6Sd ny the dee;
te pen.rs lenseres, that acted npon the mind Of Mr.
|
souADBLB SuMngR TWO.
Mr.. Davis rose to make reio!nder. NJ. GRAHAM
said:
, had the closing II was my objection.
| MI Davis-Yrs; hut had not hear the ground mo
| which the objection nut, The Iunse sia. u rl
| lectcd, without stating the ground.
| The Court Vel, MI. Graham, The Affirmative %
fence up by Won h That conspiracy was formed b
Mrs Calhoun and Mrs sinclair, ana others, % induc
Mrs Mcfarland TO 90 upon the STAGE and l'ave, or d
her husband. Tint was yonr defence and In Vie
| ten by tins lady 10 Mrs. McFnrand, 10 Indicate thH
cnnspracy II 20 Ter theso circumstances
there is M departure FROM the rule Ihaye mahtalne
| throughout this case that The prosecution should b
perm tied show In point 4 fact there was co!
1 | spirncy 80 far rs inaucug Mrs, Mcfarland to g
urnu the STAGE, hvt Tint II done with the know
ledge sanction. ana consent Of her husband, for
or pro to the OF their separation. II seen
10 me to be equally fair, this lady hcnr Nt ackod as IA
has been by these letters her motives lmuu2 ned IN
an opportu unity should be Afforded II there are c&pt
atoy circumstance. to vudicatH her rom the chnrg
made agaust her But thcrc should hc no VIOLATION @
the rule that tho letters must speak Tor hemseNc nm
ghgT>- -, -, ,ses ~ u ssr- = 49, ~,
throw nght upon the subject mstf,r II those ltiter
Ii strikes me- n Eir ~ rrcs--t- t-S N go ~ ~
L Mr. Grahanl-YoLr Honor VIII give Us an exception
, TnE wITSEs,'s sToRr,
O-Stae what you know Of tho sghl 'ct nrlor 70 70
n going 10 tie White Mountains, Of Mrs, Mcfarland h
" ing accust nmed "a give rcainrsp Al attended ur
| given nv her In New YORK. go
, | Mr. Ciraham-An that cyid'nce your Honor win