, 1869-07-22

esta1y> TO luussrato The point On which lam speak
and VIII, on -dnA -exA1laauou, -prnsent- It the
be ssle1 ineTeto Is do meantime, aoaeves. ~ % lie
rtqueAt thxS ont 1ctsent Atall within spoaeed
PINE ~ t.s!Ie q 6a{a seisci qns q l.t q psHs
charged Win 1he conside7ssion of Dc @ sSeaed % o.
DO lufeotnn, Of coutse, Of work1nx 1ny grount1 10
object 70 either P1oees1 or presentment tnat may
accused tn- -9aeh cases i cnuEed 70 the c.efSona
! nppcsIznce Of the elelKJmao -homlnsfsd by tae
nishop,. for examination tonontng their colupp-
tency % Ill - az.csso1s to tho end tast suca q
| ntsy eeopeu to challenge TOR c1use may b cx-
| cauned frulu ihs liz 8na the accused enabled 70
select nom sn entire number Of unoo]ectionshlo
70 On The Other hand, thls has been denied aud
the rule tnstated 10 be that- the nominee of the
The eelec4son mnst b made from 1bomsoeTsr 10
! seca 1rto designate. We do lot seek 70 enter Into
I any dtscnsaiou Of this question. The presumption
q tltal Is 70 be .h4d It d designed. to be mpar.
ttal- And IT y submitted thai tmpat1tallsy esn
tunttr, IL some way, to ascertzIu that those Ahp
may be Lis Judges no free from dtsqaal{Jiag htas,
Tna twentieth diocesan canon Il carefal 70
@ - sIaisSsa svs; IL ass prejudice u
Why, simply bec.ase q prejudgaens q the ease
n, the ,s rsns9P: r. 40 ~ not permit party
!
Iust there Ia presumption arising ID IasoE Of .
rreasfT excludes snynody tnxt wss IN to ths
party Tnat wns The Old common law rule, for
s ts a. sn n
- luIpI who vas san 2 = even = so ninth desree
II were tuo that no pfesulnpiion oi
pfeJoaee N9s 10 be lndulgtds
~ eaatss ei a sas o. & 5s
tanst y entertained il favor Of the aoeassd Iy .
| uou In marriage or felhtioD.-
iou perceive that that canon, and the more you
examine En-. ~ IT, 1onpo eoosstens With he pnnci-
oeeo nan OF the rue = that no one Anall he allow
en,e 70 ~ hnl a. ~ Mne na ne ac
~ W. 11c aeeaseu ~ ~ poses .o easneage
WI VIZ ~ e naf Inn mor IN sss ,,,t anna .,n,
! should IL hdented 10 nnereaf nreiice n an ~.
| p0siie cnar.cter III the ssfne fisnr Ee 10 MT
perceive nc neceszsy of dc personal presenee of
smination. E1ch course. We fe4u.iy concede.
Noald ia nroducfiye of tfnubja enfl enense ~
well Hs delay. Assuming the1HeAb5teta nomln8ted
tn thts. instance TO t.s canoalcalIy qualified, II
would seem emlnenily iust, aDd in fact absolutely
reluiste 70 the proPet consideration Of the court
whenever oyQanfzeot that = should BE-. aseet-
formed of expressed IN opinion ~ to the gullt OF
Innocence ol ne accused A. pteJudgmen1 would
essensai iaai aus INJURY @ saosa b made sa ~ 70
MhetnsF exist o. got. Such inquiry We can
donx 10 sol so seWs IN Tson e
T. thai The Dlehop. replied a. have stated-1
ought 70 rad M ftply a matter uf5usdce-1nd
sn5jees.1srs:sahiued 70 se.5 gsss wetsnI ss Tae
% the e
aualnying tias: ! beg to rete. you for my Elews
a
;n1uneston from he Superior Gonrt q cnisaso, o.
nsraf IL 10 IL o1 Ind he b. As' an
DENT has determined, and | snall conrene me
Thndsy mornnS ne1 ba IL tae n.sm ,Se Sa
right o1 eelectlon may be assumed to be stIi open
10 Inc acc1se.."
observe. and ii wns YER, ttndiy done Fm wili
observe thai in order 70 nre1ent the view W. hsre
1f al hs :, qus.on Ct ss,ei'9sd 4 Eoaa a.
e x9o zen soa ~ ~ ~ nos -
2hs % Sssops s letter @ declares .h.. the selection
lepge. The selection Is 81 exercise or personal
Judgment On The part Of the respondent, and does
%R5 ihe ao q M
not sclect be does bot reject foT any known and
EuUtE-QE q
Why It 70 much resembles The comnon Law - Der.
enptosy challenge i Is becaaae he Is hot
SnEs SnEsea l,u.s e Hz1Sn knoEs sd Dc: d
,s,nc can excuse certain member without giving
any y 5ssson under which he can excuse them. ID |
eirlng, reason, and 50 obtain @ eoart oeiorn |
~ s9s,ssissa ssss;s
rst Is selection, choice by the bishop from The
qaa,laed preseyterE Of The diosese-she definite
grefe1enees n fnis T1y. think our
ops s *sG IT, a1 o4s: s ds. Eaa
this respect 4 ve1 ,eroas elSr Is committed.
senfs-no such Thug. Il We have = impartial d ,Fasl
A1sesfoTs, we can have no choice Of pc1sons It
was not srnGd b The a1oa tnat IN
presumption WIS not sudulged that the accused
under such circumstances -onght to Ioe permitted
Is not @ t y meh, Il ss xe oSiees III to pInct,sns
before some Of Cur Jud ges because
IN more intimate with some tnah Others 4
faid 70 D. thc foundation Of Tue provision hire.
Personal preference, in the sense OF wishing 10
might suspect oi entertaining irco OF Ieeei1ed
opinoDsIhat, Indeed, would eHensc- :" Tho
} ~, S,a Of tns TINE
q tina! y ensireiy different from the tne thai the
" n7 e. 1of ne tae =, 1ae
made. md The court thus M cunstituteti heforn
ths nshon >D- ~'-1e Va " HA'A - e''eN -
49, ~ ~ wa ,,+,,o, =, rnar. 1r,.o,, ,,,a, ,,,
,c,It nnu w Luc ~ Hsoa upon toe
{ot4a M 'aae nS ae5 no!uHS Iast aaS.s M noaqlng
"a me eanons pfGsaalne tae stase o. psoeseain9s
a. sho,,is heI 1snn sna. " sIus H mnc1 ~
safsIion ~ 6'e1 nou Gn1n tet so ~
te ~, mos. "' In n hs1monv Wttb oeGM ~
Object ., the po,,ce 10 ye a. oppo.;unitY to pre-
bishop says t. tn so may b. u ade ID aoa re-
Gqeny 4 II p.nosce 81 - Aos H Ssl9se no.se o. tae
,hat ra,,,f ~ ia n,,n,1ea nnS ~ nte
1Ssn i. the rnnr1 sno enfev4a;n the Mini ~ ~
think that TIC pr1ctics might Te5J veil o5.a.n
rade. " lie tben % cite,t W vas1ous canopa which sSa
10 Ic found Ccnerally stated IN Worrinan 81 inc |
Law Of the Church and the canon of New YORK,
which gives thirty days Tor a choice and
thirty d4ys tferea11ef 70 prepare for ual. aud Ia
doubtful Whether, under the general canon IN re-
gard 10 ciianoni siIty DAYS Is not TO be giSen ln
every case Tor trtaA ~ GIned Htend On tie
oheT 81 s1e y teafnea 31 u tae eap9m
crnl convention ms prnEide g thai all ctLstons OF
scrflces Of all CITATIONS, 6Eal be lot sl1tT days
Then THIS authority goes On: The cou11 being
docs not exist until convened BY due cAnopcal &C. |
lection, nor can It ne snnnoned to Q plaee Of !
meeting, except aa the Memoers comprising il
really DO not see why eight pcnxrcmen
could not be summoned 10 Ind here f snch ia
The rropes 1lc,lou OF Tho canon Just Is well
10 pnmarily drsctminate them, beesnse, It he
G sRS e ZEE nsy 1 IT,
rsnq not is6 So 1ns az INV a. 1,Ta .S
lion 10 prpceed 10 thc tisi Of the Csc THere nd
Inc rcn!nIpIpg porrons Of tois aainodty. hut tHeT
-. 49, LsIesS ~ 80 - I