, 1869-01-29
THE NIAGARA SHIP CANAL.
2.
Speech by, H., 3. Judd, January Is, 1869.

The House.. according to order. resumed
Inc consideration OF the bila 10. \. 10. l.12(
20 provide lof ths coEstructton Of sup canal
around the FAILS OF Niagara
-; ar. JuIn. Af- speakeT' tns p.oJect Q!
sup canal around the Falls OIL Niagara has
neen Before the people Of tais country ior st
least quarter OF century. y has gathered
sessnEtn by me discussion Wnlea me qnes'
ts9 Loa nas received and oy tne neeesslues grow
ing out ofthc increase Of commerce and bnsl-
neEs, aud the creation during tnat tlme Of
GSoupatatiye1y new nation west o. Inc lakes.
- nacosaoie tntsnocf8 WILL Ieheet iof Que mo-
1nsut 1poh Inc nature o. Lne p1o)eci as con.
TEssteo Hnn tne nasiea!lon 70 "n'ca tne
thar e ,,id VI Hlaeaia cous.l'us onc 1uis.lupilon
~; ta ~ ~ 10" 1npofLan. ~ sae n4taoa'
ct..,,..na na "Sss; ~ tns tsuosal u tni5 oo-
1'..1 ~ ..I..' ats ne ~ alo e9an
NJ q. - eu'LM MGscS t11o4en AaAg sapeIlo', nas-
y r. Ss' Asly, Lahe MlSMgaus p:s LaAe ana AaFcr
uto1s ~ anu Lka w.. nnu IN h'fel e. elalr, Lake
=, 49,, aI4 .asa outa5.o ~ % tne
cnntti,n,c a6,,T t.ro tt,ons.nd Tn,,os "
so1na ao'ns t"o ,uo1Sanu ~ 15.'c9 ol nasl
sao,c - "a1tts, aau, aua lo II luc -. lawrence
sWt-t, n9aia aoa yon naVea total o. aoont
" }ax,. ~ nncTic,n WEI East nm ITHACA ,;,u.
an,f i,ra 49, suast I'LL " sae:e 1ivefs
a. ma .es,n - ;s,a aass anu tals,
Jot,cJ xiii ,hr,r,n~ ond sa"r;shn, - ,t,s ~ uas
c',iss isse ~ "t.a tuaE anu anullsan! cltics
cnlti-afton ~ ~. sa1,i,n tas ~ .i aao
upvn nnst n ;,Lond Al, donsndan+ .nn. oprue luz
|
1o:,, ,no;S mutss7 lo5 .As transportation oi the
h,'t tha - a, ~, ~. onll Msrlsultueat,
ors +n;-a - hs eesuS pso:uaSts ol uumes-
fv.fiTn =. -. +; 49,. 'r .., .ue last !"en-
duc,im;' ar nrnnire ,S;+f,;g i1sa'f ~ pto. a
shnwn rastaria g. Jg'f "'ths" ti nssll. AS was
Wcon: IL Mr Faipe eyep us taiIana II from
Die in f, Of thosc Snr.hw..trn " peo
ilcna,, ~, 10 hoz1. ~ ~ sstssn s.ates NOW
thr i.n1,ati Stotas en1o u =, t.e s.oEetntut OF
ro,,ot;on ~ ta.;r s,r',,s .aS, ius
nnetsio ~, U enom noa, eh psouucl'ons 10 Tue
Nr. sntater nItI Il 1es eain. iae, s,,1 n.,o
man fTan Ncs WI M HA'I ~ tns sso.tG
connection viii ~. ',,N,r. ~. III ~
naw VI tha4 IL. s;a'n1s =; lo' tnc state ~
nh,s,t,or, H. 10y ~ tne,. =? somc Gonssttn.enat
IIu,,sr sr ii nun pG.ui. III, enc
1heir ercs nnnn he ,nn1 ,har vs;i, " Iaa p1hss
from tGe HAL ~ Io1 1t,,o.tSS- orHS 49, az
INV a,;o inI aSnu ~ 81 a4e 20 Like
Win; ~. r.;,,s,' ~ eoales
r,I H,t.-nat;n.. ~ o.tts ."tSG nalu-
,,is ',,t,o 1--WE n IIeSa..3, !h eaist ~
Sic. Tare sccnni, the g. f1aie. II 1,ts an5
fh:rd th,s rhsfrnc,thn II tha Eia.,asn 80 aia
Tha t,,,ro-1nt ,uS 49, -, ~ .ae .slasa1A M1e
hr a. n1 aona1o.s ,nnnI 4 4a, ~ hat
1va o1str,,c,;ns a., tho ~ nt t,, aue
shall Ills her e.iccnt nncr ,nto-ca ~" n,'nn "a
ttr rin;ercst ~ rnvnmrrcc nrG I'M ;nta4"st ~ ~
= Ia rao .on.,n ,hn .nu tnc tntettes =.
Whv NJ. ~ 'ESs sncaEcr H1 d. vc hn,,5 ,,ob+-
1,om>,s M al, H.. totoss 6 Thr - ~" ~.
1nnvs rncts f1o1n tEa hnrh,r ~ ~ ~ 49,
Whr ,s MA an.,,.,n,nar1 tn-sar a. ~" a,aIa;a. au,n
~ r,on.r ~ r.,'a., n,..,.ot;as aPenulS
ira1Ion Z, M. W;ss;ssinn > WIZ t. VI, !, 1h 1hat
nororr = ,ont hne snort ;ts y,,ii;,.. T. tns
Gtrna,inl Go,stinent ~ spfts s .n!uous "a con
se.assnS s Aa'po loi ~ pluLtc.lou Vi COM
te.'a -, snen' Nv EosctnoasnL eau r.
1m}1S ha,ho. ~ Hntt"i" oan naruo., ra1, GU
s,t,,e,I,,,s T., H., ~ Mis.I.s;r,, p.o ~
oran LII. ~ .a nanst,..,.; .i ~ aeeoI-
anSc NIL .I iao eoun.tut.vn, Why Is toat ID.
es.ulaens u ;h au.h"n ~ a. Us ~ uen VIC Propose 10
e,ots hara ,aar;,'a a,E.ng, opstsuGoM on Tue l'ne
thems W. ~ nnt nrnnnsn liz ii'a 81 h,i1 " -.
nea1n Nv " .,s,1 ~ H.. ill.,, - ~ liz m u!' ~
e1ea'e all5 W" ttue. 20 nns oeeu atctseu' VI
new aSeau: o1 eommeree, hat SIMPLY 10 oo,
s.usS @ ~ Eutur1a ea onstsuct9a ta 10 tnls eiana
axchus r,', q, eogIes 20 1nat IT. my oe USED
W. Mnn s,a s1GaaeT .,. aaeiy ef a' @ Eoxesnmert ana
1AG ieoPis .uan :. naa oeeI n3tns!u'
4: ~ say tnc government mas not constltn
1 ..o1a. ln"sl " ~ !nls Holh Is ~ oels Lne
suLaI u.sto, ~ 80. .ntn - apou tnese
H.,,;"r ths, rianss -. ~ ~ y1st;.,;
''" .4."s s.,na ."I ~ "a.a
Iun.sts . uua ss,t ne Po"e, o,o ~" seSu Ky
aa.e 4h aerarni oc1 hi,a uat'pns ane
n v.lI.s I.1 .u sesrI' ~, @ oea pa'.i natptfs, y:
l'sut-nouses, anu uGacoas, ana ciesica the
.ssat sna.e ha e' e,tc,i " .ns '1el "ols n
mus. oe o1 natlonat Gnaraetef' 40 aot
eonasna, ~ mt. hnpeaaets IN. taeIe IS power 10
mnen ilse. usa1s u lnarkst the c1mnl.tce !
~ Satloas stntSs, 10 sane ufa'i VIII oouhl
ins power y. sonsssss ID Tug premises pn1,
III Inc language OF another, great and wide
Spsea1 Ee ~ my enterprise M
lloLai chalactef' ..
Ing sent,eH,nn , t, i!om Ne" iork seems %
Ultimate that The Governmtnt OF the United
States cannot enter within The territory Of
state 10 interfere VIII rs SOL or us sover'
gu.S ns eASo41o t5,1 o. rue sne7G tb pp%ehs
Why, slf, nave shohn that from me pcSin'
nlre q tnc government 10 1h1s lthc " nas
been inc uh!foFm Practice OF Inc government
70 ehtcl "lInln tne tcrrltors OF states iof the
pu. p3sG o. n'ahtns, luipro.stnents ~ o. 2 na
Iona, cuarae,el, , aId the s.ase o. New hoss,
efano aoa nopae ss sue M H. eannot s.aaa ~ tne
Way o. tue demands OF large portion Of the
pegple t1a u ,ne county. III 4h,.
LIZ Seutte.nau. eetIe ~ Iuat LUIS - y scueG7e
and l'c repeats IT orer ana over a9aiu. h
can Aara!S 'na epuheis ht[ons enonEn &c
eaa4 actellze lne me9sn1e. Wh5' SIT, 1t n
had 4oukea ~ INC btll nc Wild haye seer
tnat tne1e Is no scheine ~ tnc sense that In
gentleman uses that word. II Erauts NJ
ftixAeEe. y cEeate6 10 corporate powers; /; nj
nol'!oua' T rhtsles. is sonneelga Mna tnc en-
!srptiSe' lnGre Is no aphsopfia,l9n m y ~ nons t,s
1nI!e y ~ euus!ls p!osaVsu t ~ toi ~ tuc oilt
II y 10 dlTess % %appllea5'ont "a ~ inc GoseInmen
y. -ot 1eot 'a,hI; st 10 1uoa ~ ~ h,f Iy
sllues E1eat puphc Mosk Iol the puoll'
oenyn ad l.. usa1s ~ aa;S t;s H., W tos
80 o'1eN uenou9ceu oa tu!s no1. ioE aspictnas
'ns poses Theis @ can Be- no pretenss andsr der LII LII
Wy aa4u w. - ,a,nhts y, ~ Tho sh Honse TIM
. thls il simniv n nncstion Whether he Con
rrcss al thp IN i,et States viii remove a,
obstructiou ttnt stands in the way Of tn
nrospcTity Of a larrt portion OF the people q
/, th;s co,,niry. If IA n1f. / merriam; cannnt TO-
Inc of trapsuortatiou or channel 81 com
. mcr,.e. That il the distinction between
onI1 "nr nther ntnicct for fhe altered dc
!, vrionrepi | Of our resources that has bee
!. nrc.entcd Ior fhr consideration of Congrrs
) / say, theu, that when any gentiema :
= schrmc or proiect he has nci rad WIth car
= the hi nr kr drsirns n leave an imnrcssIo
.rh,n vnt G ~ rov;s;nne ~ ~ ,he Xii dn nnt Ta
= rant
/. The aentleman from New York {Mr. Hun
,b41r,S nae sid that this canal viii not
= ppref;ahlc II Constructed. and he gives as a
T. arc1,mcnt lint # II wonij he nr,,iltaIle cap
sat;s,s wnrIt hnre seigrd Il hefore fh1s LIN
and cornoralions would have built it. SUI
nnse It ri! moi. he PRINTABLE. that is The yci
sasgh ;n{;as-ast ~ ec 4to Taan3s - denand Il
S. .ns ~. .uu W. pvvp,s psont,,,.,on+ ah,,
= ,, tn'Hiorsosn., ,s tnof ~ .io,, thon ~
N e,,a,t .nI - sdarass ~ ,b .nenhars ~ III
" ,4n IA - oan;tai;s,s wnnti ~ nn;a, NM
y noue va: s"Fh; .h;. t.;nd ng D., t,,o..!p ~
. An entel ptise ~ tnis IL, A!.u ous tne.e
Ct another tcatnse o. ta,s MSS suejGct ~ WHEEL 10 n
IT, lninu Is easonEsi iuaa ~ otoet1 !" ~ .
:" 81 .ne current h:s.o ~ 'us ia
+. incfe IS 20 man Hllhln inc sounu
% my voice who, look at public transpottati
= and at tue organization and concentrations
80 ! raih onds that Arc now going on but Woti
,c ,e say that II there Is an avenue that Tue Eeoi
y demand IL should bc Kept tree from any 50
= OF posltion in which these a1onopolists G
te grab It at the expense Of the People. 1
re me tell my friend from New york TINT II
Il | Is In the hands Of a private company, prot