, 1869-12-02
THE COURTS.
Conclusion Of Srit Of Importance to tha
Commercial Community.
A Kew Question tHere) Raised Under
the Patent Law.
Tho Police Courts.
UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT.

coNNkRc1AL CASE
: Churchill Cotl,ug =. Jesse Ao1t. Assumpslt To
recover for alleged wrongful sale Of corn. csCse
tried, and verdict rendered Tor defendant 1ntae
early Pert Of November, 1st1, pa'nsn. resident
OF Ie1u In this S:atc, wss tn Cnlcigo, md, fotI-
ipg the opinion that the price ot corn would hd-
vrres, copclu led 10 make = considerable Invest.
ncnt In thst article lie parcsased b:.weea
"a 600 and s. Coz bushels, =: bayers tp.5n 70 thc
1stt Of November. HAVING thus r1rch tsed ne
copclrdcd 10 Eh,p, and ai'er proper inquiry ne &C.
lcctet Mr. E. bruce 10 be hts a5ent. The 1e-
euit OF Eeverol Interviews WAS An agreement W
nlCcc TO 1or a sri tue cnfn l, Se" iHff. II oe'uS
,udelatooa that he ~oulu be sccountsa!e fer tue
Gum Of eIen,5 .1yc cents per bushel the palatn 10
mike VI at5 u!l!tfruee ~ price- Coru fell 10 Tue
lnntLct. 1ud It IL ns uautss.o3I there miHnt os
necessity 10 n1u to tie niF4iss Huu aI4uEs'
The cvvst .kourtt u tucn 3 state Of case that
CERTAIN cnn>ts .at ln4 grew Up T.. ~ conup n ~
prsxt's. F.5cS4a l', .r, M p&a ras Ia .ecnne
ttc.rEy or The aivant"s InA!e or 20 ~ Fa!sea =!
E1u1e, s;.a tax tie GFoir riy would he ae:a
q a.oau'assr. AID thl' II II weat fns Natu 70 Sew
Stfr. It uelt ulth tie overdue belonging aO It,
:, lur1iea OILY tu u: got lid u h5 IN a~recmeat
arfs lhucc. "F "fn -" p,',y 10 waon tne sofo
pf which 1ae cora = a. IL be held ior q time Ger.
15r, or 81 q .ptc.uel prlce, or npoa the coudiioo
,ncc L ,cSo,v on pla,ot,1 10 zee ihas the ishli.-
" te.i:og u;su1 thc tTpp:rt5 WAS discharged
il: II tL.fe va, kuch an a3frehent, y .as 10
cYEyasii on Bruce 10 call on taB rlalatl1 before
tefr and that there was ouch ~ sTsccDcat
should be J'suCcaIy made ont by plaintiff. or
caurs.:, tsc rla!n 10 must haze unuesstood tsss
Ihta tusden !. sted on and followed The property.
Ihu Court Ieele the correypondencc be-
tween the pars,t., IN rue course q when, from
tauce II a4le i,ence, tie defendant. In Hhuse p,S-
te, son the ca1u vas, Fa% made ATnEe that plata
IN nat eette RS. IN she nrops;1{; q tae 1ssa
hes !, hn1cft 4 nv corr lbIpkipx the price would
csr1e ut,, bui. 70 lar, hare ts.tn Disappointed "
- stated tn:;s ne NJ SHIPPED some @ Of MS cata t9
whttber plalrt'r Eoull lite 70 &aip some Of hi+
corp, I'VE hare bell 30 long l.ls dt11!cu:t to
be- nsa T ase9os .siDs oe:t
there Is coa-ce Of iet,c1irg oae conittAon by
sntrp,r 10 Liverpool. lup. yoa Will ship etln.s
II hope Isl. svu wlli ~ ahse 10 mAte
6. .ch a a.sp.sl:,on as Will sa-e at
esst po,toa q q seS ,,E aasnass." = ~. 4 n isE
he'll - long u l cotld in hopes tue price Tollj
70 up. III ,A,s hare been nis1aten- TIE uIar-
k.t las been .n: a!s win1er, aid canpot ARRANGE
ln have Tits cprr he,1 aty longer, and do nut
kLow st 1t much use IN shipping. as the mar
ket Gu The uine1 eiAe lecos Reiats doHn-" This
caa, hut ~ I, Tue coud,,ioa Of ne pfoPeri5 AMI
ptrhaps !, couil nut tie expected that lht coin
thDnld lie lone.1 hell roi 81 tae advances Iacu.l.
ranger fcr. 1hts iut':nu,tpn being g,vcp: tae
t'ouIt Atught re Eta,i'in was bound to Sec 70 Il
Tint the iAFupra.s were Cadt good, Eh!ch, NOT 10
:nr, te ecp1l Lot rnH'pls:n, iii the as>cuce
OF a.y net u h., that tnc corn should Il
sp:d TO reimburse tee a1eance4-
,,au het 4 @ ,ip.e G. ~ the cnrn. THIS p;esnpno.c.
right to tcs, aud although tho letters express a
hofc that tie con would ot rcId. mono ol taeI
relation Ia the corr. DESCENDANTS firn, on n.
9Th OF Apr1f, trt1rm1 d Coming OF the Ra!c Of the
isas Il hal ,rsn eoi', iai II u.li - lous witaou
NneLs, tbty III: 1sst's could lot ho!d over.
The corttsrauftr@cc csApe!ici TIC co1clnsfon
tEa, wte1A.r Ntuct AS the arrnt 0t The defend
mt Ct not at the TIN. III. urist.al trar,.ct'o:
Nas 1raa+, the plat: tlI 1L,!eSs:ooa lhas the coz
t.rneea had n rtrl1 10 'sI-lm'e Of tan c"rn, au
that he cuCir nnf legally clA!5 TIA, 1heJ IIu.l =
fBIn the cum, uttsA he Li1.s'f lid suI+' act b,
which ther h.. lie faculty Il RETAINING II IN oiLc
male On the c.rn 4td t:a; i w..- htll iur ,1c,t
1nd 60 tttlrr inf-tEl.i hui Tar c9IH could not b
further htlj. bu ). ae Lot dot?s a5t1e nj he coui
not com ri slu <It = FATE tI.nt&r 10 Eoll fattr-
The cate then ira lefu It-tlt tltu Inlsti0
whether Je.tr 1iu.t K III hsve x!sec a true \,
count Of <hat N'ssn"uc = -Hs th- raru. anl Hhtt
ef or Got the! urtatt II. Etr1l ata ta making n
s1le. The parties haylas the tight To .ci, II the
acted IN good Isttb, ,u.u lheiF ch1r1es acre ju+ al
1easonslle, 'hrt The cuts thu1's'!t rllinttf coul
not recover, utles- there was u ttpasAte sud di
tlhct cors1acs. th,nn t,s rlsIhuT, wh.ca No1
cnargc the 1ixilts ci Eht parties att bid ilott
il there ~sa wsrt OF good faith, {
faise accsu. 1l.S, 't:rn tnr1e ronld be
recovery. IT, wsud he no nlsKcr
EQGu u CHAINt 1ua t&1EIELtAIIk ~d3 tk4N.RQA ~ III
plalu'IH q t:Eht', t'E mad tist ciAiu to whs
eyer surplus ihtys. ut.ht lie ulas1 All honest az
teIT snle alter pa}ts, tae n.lvaaec. expenses ~
cpsrHcs The were; haEsrc.. surprised OF b
Itghtf fsat.Tl.T Ct4ILs thRs thu testimony tcn:
10 prove bad faNlL tuO' r u hrr tnluv., 1t Il 6ai
that m rutait eb,fy was Eote oa tlefeuLsnL
l,oolt, As corer to 4 fictitious transaction, or !
conceal resi- tthE>actiIh. The sgehts wei
bound In this IL 1srt tp s:fct honesty, NJ well II
tie ibttrcst 0t the taF:tes who hal made a.
yAuceF, rs fer TIC !utcfc4t Of Ii:1llti1- This,
contse, IT, be Atcsarti unter the evidence. u II
sale was Lot TINA E1f, zo6p pfasottn could no
defendant rct;Nn~Inls. Tor the hlRnest marx
value OF The col n, mad 10 Ttfay the c0n1tss'O
charged ind II. eIrst 10 e-.-- H. however, the
wns enttre cooh fifth, dcftrdaut had filled I
rpt8Lurc og y, ':A'a1'ts, u t1e ahAtnCe OF a1v I
Of platEtin NJ Which lcitudant conI be eu1 1ted
ao1 loi kcf.
vn,..ns = 3sEGt*Ii&G rAIENT SIT.
This IN an action II tth. ~ r. c5rcE thc fenat.5
S1Nt, Ersc2 Nv The rs1h trrtGH OF The act OF &C
gIths ol AuE,ltt -, 1S'2 inr l1atkng AZ attclb
Lrtrr patsLtrh. t:-e elc'c relpR uhrttcnte'1. 7
. utfCyallco is Ih4' ti~iru,lant having prOcafed
pst-Et Ill .Apsis l,4i', fsr ratatatug strawn.a
tnlusattd with tar ,nt r-lEts houses and shea
irG purposes. u3 IN a':tcc Of m4nufactarc a.
ltMr, NJ u ace stfa sN,2-s r:atn t~ith31. ta.n'
tton} anc I,uf m 1t fnr e'aEn, l1teat4rl April
1eG9 BY Htp l.r,ia I. Fthi. f'r tho parpoac Of 4
cev.ng ln- pa mic Funitd Gl i.'la the ps1A.t
tor t ii rul. at rIsin kl,an tcartl so marked. Al
OF, rel frr snIr tn Jut~. l>+o. The ncl yivet OF
ratf thr r+f.ats r.r-y,ren, ~ iac patent fAe
and c7fe llr'f 10 tllr t'Hrfy tNioc- Tho he9rc
rElt IN q rtntrAl cGhIit. hut II eetma 10 r
ut4,E tte Ia I.ef tbIt It s:4n he brorCd th1t
s,caEi PATE WA ~ n.sadyere esnca placed M
TUE a1;iclt, nnt tina. sne1c wod Al entire want
CekI&c or ip;eylun 10 deceive.
NAV SEtTss
Julsa RrGoks aAn'E sstratttx. r. 81. =. John
Nccosntc- A.sunrssl DtInaot. sla,te0.