, 1869-01-22
Il 1Es1 CASE.
The Reyenu dc Theory n 10 Inc
Manufacture Of WhhheS
Not Suatalned.
Jrdro Drummord's Charge to REQ
Jury IN the Fur1ons 0ase'

Tim ,r,pev,r.u,. by the comm!sFiorer 9! II. | Il
,.,.al htyetre, it. agent, started theosg nnaes
,,,- Y,rc,uc Law Of lsiG, after an examination ot
~ VARIOUS dlstleries IN the county "nlea vas
,h,, IN t,s.1tli1rE the cis1tNet mingled whh hts
r-,,n ,uch uuaott5 Of vater tnat ionJ Are gal
in, Of the n. II and water combined confirmed |
a, nj resented qne buth bel Of gram. Baaod rpon I
,h,s ,teor5, IN order 10 Ind out the numbsr4of ,
bn,hele rathed in any EtTen disallefy.
the government a4ena We're Instructed 10
meesu.e tie nash-tube, deduc. the proportion Of !
w.,c1, ard See whether the return OF grain wa
uroperiy made. II there w1s sny discrepancy, +
this WIS charged 10 the dist1tlfT on the b1sh
e,ated. Thus. II the dlstiiIer put into bis mash
tub ei1t.Ee gallons OF Eater to the ousacl. nc
was cbsrgaole with bu4hel and 4 ta1 Of gEiin
upt n biz ,tpost. ard an asseteGnenl was made hJ
Il. Attctea. In 4al: ApHl &so officers Of the |
f-Lg cn eaeh cf TN days They tntasufed the
would tevr, upon tie ,heosy Of The government | ,
~h1en Is now Incorporated 1nto the Law or JGly,
lefl5 that tette La1 betL improper rtrngas.
case. as Asied, VAS a4retd ubo1 In open /
cop,s, 4, Re tes. easc- 6sr, todictuettA Lad
a.eA loard, aid ~. t1.ior &, eho had ps.d N
WHO hid served 10 reeo,er tbs md.s5 back: con;
renica to be the parry 10 be trsd ae vas f29td
Los cu:!Iy uude: lhe irstl1cttors OF the court, |
Tte es,euu11t y = clsi,llet II the sprin2 Of |
1867 I be 1sw at that tine mads Il The dutg cf
I
of he lumber ot pounds o. gallons Of massr1sts
o-sa ey ano re r4ooi e tie uoneer
e:nens wl1n .hr nraof tu'reof. rnd the 1auat
md plae- Of pustrest or sts;dence of 'as person
1he Inst c9ant |. the Indictment is that tho de-
fenoaL. EIo a1ed tnrse ploF1:1ora Of The IA" Ia
IA, 2 cen & to tie1 IN a,book Kept for taat pur.
pose lhe uue qEsEttg Of ii. nn4pef Of Eounns
u gsln.s Ut matcria, ere, also. ths1 1e ne!ee:.
eu IL EFT. : IL suck b Oh the Eumcer OF gall"Es
~ ],tt{TS tEeH
the name AID place Q! business CT residence of
TIE perr41 10 Rhufn etfo
on tee first. eleventh AID s~cct1-dttt da} OF each
moi II. tr ~nntn t1e Gays thereafter, 7endt9 TO
htret1 before 1ee.ted, and verified b7 oath Of all
Il taets oc -nr,Hs q e lhe lsst d7J Of tae ae.
o. u nc aL1 w11R hasfrR violated this p1ov:tou OF
the Law, that be n Eaee:aa 70 m.he 10 ste A.,
tss1ty a.ss Days ot esch north, or within nse
cntr ii. r. a'1eT, from tna seventeenth car VI
Apii, 1863. n.ti! the u'es daJ ofA.y.
| TIE l.w also d.c assd that If xoy person re-
sse g, 1ets ass!sa etne1x,se !saa ,n.e
sna e, q as rhs
I tn tne ,u11ctrcnt charces the defendant With
,sa s' e
stris Of these fevszal Items. In 1hs ttst plaee
fhai ne, leeted to make the e1t1 ia his oooxr:
as scqulrtd ~ law, oi the amount Of his Ma'erisl
up. d. ard h. ousntt7 Of liquor h II he dlsillcd.
ard xhAt he had sslf, and the nams 4ud place dt
bu.treas q tho perton to whom sold teeoldls,
1tat In tie particulars tu.t Famed 10 7ti ~ the
o9a: ttt3 Ct Daiesih', sou tie quantity Of spl1's.
] | aLd Of the amonrt sclt, trus retnr.t tVele not
tLe f.e that dittillcd to p!kce other than
& "a = b. rded watetouse
! The QUESTION ia wLcihcr the defendant IL gnl!ty
T. OF i & ny ore oi tie offences CHARGED IL the
ETssS defendant when be Is a1rs,s.ed before
o court Of Justice, Is presumed TO b tnaoccn'- It
.e' ie1pcEmheEt On the prosecution to r4H.fy the
iu.y h., oLd fea. ona5r donat teat ho i. Gussty
OF me,s; teest1ore ss ta:unasens "a she pros
s.'nn Il ts't e.,s ,o sattf Ie1 ee!opa
tt or IN rome one of tte.e patstcRlsts. The lned
OF lion for you to de'c1mtne1. whether he Is Or Il
I'd 10, gull, Of u, OF IN, ona.
nt Futt, stAi hs has rot Hade proper en:sS IN b!
~ books a. TO tho ms1trta! tnat be a.ed, because
'f't ~ .ne Teiss "nsa s} 1e. .at
'aas n Int eraenes s'a''s;,sn FL hs ts'0Ta sa
~ no;e material than he LIS returned. Secon sly
1s g.: ss:ts II sas
that he distilled ncse sptflc than thert appear
10 b.v. been rvturueu. bectnse the nj eIial wh,c
- | qu4y t1ty o distilled tplr!ss.
ia tetehE call yout atteLtlou 10 theac two pee1
<, depce md The CORRECTION Of Tia. evidence VII,
tne quantity Of mat.r,al which has seen reported
I
ke ported and tie quantity o1 sptr1h returned {
y C. urft lhEtc is no .ubt. Tint spo.ars apon sh
an par =: u: aqestsoa y "he:he' taese 'opo''
I'd "a are ,ou ssst.aea srom the eside.ce on tn
Or nt'ticltls AIe YOU sAtt.aed thst shtse :ta1n
w matenhI that was used: IN othes woioe, al b
,ic lse nusr e9tn or grain. n-tne duus!A xn :
Fse itt,eate bcyf nd u IA bic dout', thu, maj
hare n.eu uors cts,s than he a.. 1ssasLet IN CO.
~ / NJ oFtH hx4 ttfr hS[J
e, i.aaipg M ps.t ot .hs sas! e .Sai.
n: b. b.. recrs Cd n o.hcf xora., the te.im 81
tne ness :. en;s, :, = 70 TIT po:nt q, 9th eons
Iaucly thai 'hesc Nss moEc ustaz.si utea ii,
ly1 c ts- ~ led fFon tie 1ssafe. character AZ
ls.a,s NJ, d*ea apan & she
itsusb xe5sbt a. on Irink II oasas I, scce,,
e- pt ared ;sa1a shc Z Esitrit ustd. & mast h.
sd ae p1 sfs4sss lin soenass e S.s scsu,as
sas s !: j ae ie that sh.s the eEdencs hss chiIi
y, teId' q. srd III. tor you % ~ what bsa7rg
Il no. 1he remark tnat would mike npon T.
,ea other. shs, thn cTldcccc must be Of t1eh CO.
ri sestz IL TO exclude sns oh-r 1rfcrnse sn4n tn
aos ttern VIE OF talneu hpEn she ustettl uetd M
and sptnts thai re eceu returusss It must be.
'uis eonsftt:nt with any Other eanc]uK,on than II
and II II Is, then. u eourte. the de.srtAEt IL grl
rial Of The offence that IL cna1Scd. it Il not, II
{ ae NoW. Re wsa. tas evidence, Twill hen, 6
cad % pon. 4I It eoa,is. ~ Il I'll: vsrt
With W.sptssea have beaa introduced Who tare tesut
If ufae,nfe Of tp'rts trom grain, certain amoun
the mai. ITS! Nt eehessliy produce cett..n quaal
fsir .ru,r-. The theory i thss ertsJ bnhel .: nj
5o7 sS spsa ! =. 4sss5 ss.s : e sonfs, -
lares p.ts. cation satisfy .o1 that It i spostsntt
d be So-rec; OF ttst The es1ds1ce e.t.nitshee r.
ely I'M ss.h NO. + iSc III isso..
3 an En,rh tho sn,emmcnt nenscrts, r., :"
nile. aug pom: /. shs!hsf IL atsed.nt % I'D 9.k
. the mra1, 60 fhit ii he asnu1s:,nsea iom The
ssa aos . d asrc asr
,sne a veaa BE- eai y 1f IT, Gcsnee ,s a,s
! By that p{ tie raatcftsl Hhllh he has ua4nn1actu
h.cs; hs his ,aadt sha9t nlnc and hail "a na. IT
Is of j. perhaps sorae diserepsnc1 beiwesa til: .e
ee' isss. :; WOW. il s. = 1.i7 1n.nu.sesafd =
than that, u tt IT u ltt ne QaxEtltJ ta:d tha
# III L. *. & s;asset g
this, thRs pom! ts Of Ea1oas Witnesses, khas the
: duet ef bushel Of material vaics fro a eeTel
oth.I ,nc na1tuaa. The gsaefai t1se1 d
.,4r saretn.nf, tske II 10 .tst The duc usual
& oi nc .tersai - rs. d. ii. tsid sh., t5is pret
last yaIins aecurdtt1 "a c,sc1lntttue~B; that II
a.es1 q r. sa,S q r. FL. seea 4
r the | westn,r. i! vl1tous other caE7uu..accss.
,lsnd -Ypu rt!i observe hat tho prosecution rex
ten 11at il rterYte, y / have ar.sd1 sid, Iaur
if,ss' The rsecsaGr1 and laesstahe inference 'ftn
have s;at VI tac,e, Ito. dA7 wa,satt1ee c3ntius
Ter il ! .hAt Is 10 say.tt @ust neeetssIsIy loiew
reeds the produes une sr The circnsns.knese Hn:ea
etata- lsteo - 11ri.ttrrta In,. X s-e nnr,
.css hayt been a CresItr pr duct: d. fat exam
lar "a. tns .ne d!tsiler! Ut tht detetuant> 'ha
as M eh1uvfY be cpet.ted. the N sfel151 eEat be
& and stf1nR shete together, ,eas the prodnes .
10 bare been Grs.tes. !, :oa taiss r.: ~: y
I'D ,e q e. Sstsas +
rstian nasnos cone 20. tse5, Of eostte tse fnie:
re- au- Vond 70 iR.srst ice defE.d*u.; a. fas eEa:
wiling iflt appeart thst ~ cs.e where rhs satas
r, lie yroouet wss creA.s. that The de:er
theg n.s sho.e tass .,,e pn,ease. ~ nj: oss,
an i ~nea - ss
80 frd fhoxn. azo wn,ca II was incumbent cn sh'
,sn for t4ntsnt to isn srd e ~. zoI cote Q
culent 1risrfee Hoa1c oc asasst nta. n
trc1y u cs1dcree Teict II Is IL TIC power
ssnts; rtn+certlon 70 brig fut xara to Indicate Ii
SSoe !. Il, e. Z ':s 6:
nsa Fo2 e..p .5.4e sets
naF he eItut Et onci.ls ex.rni.ia9 The opcsatso
.ns ma .ss' .s. Nd : aa tss1 - .B
undA Of l r.tt -. .-.,r. rhtrh ~. A.Sa1d~ ~r
filth In ~. ,S ,h,n dnnr - II
cholera, | rf.rr1rc xnnfa In ara,n1t iAc psp.oc
usa lot | The ru,t sppjtes 10 thn ptoeecctiou a
ct them sto The detendant thai U upur given q
Ictt shers arc certain c1ne1aSicak-necete, {,
ound IN esstaea sooel1.ont-se es ds1xn. and Tie,
D. dout dnTe. .a y r.. .as poseI o. sner nt5 ts,.
lind. all .hote eone.aso.s ~ee5d fssev. Il fas7e
tten which would tsnpxR CT adtd .&hose
sion'. md they lars not been produced.
8, stated co1,te ,pe eoeeaatsoas would follow :
subject, sa b. <orv1cssd Whom IN sae oess5aaa: