, 1869-11-07
y hayh right to bring In this evidence In re-
hdtta OF tno testimony 4dducad ~ to lhelf happy

"old ptux' - >->A ~>1 ''''' :" =" ''~> ''''
THr1xoxr Or oEonaz Hxxwzcx
Nr. AfhntT : have relidtd In Elgin stace ISL
know the place whefo rhis xonnn WAS drowned
eaF the creek The Monday After the inquest vas
Jeats; that daJ measured the Nater close 10 III
morc than IT inchca; mcsanEed the waser At AT
ao7th sidn Ct the ience and II HAS NOT quite II
tptIet deep; thEfe WaS no perceptlble dlte1eoce
ID the depth Of tue Taser at Tho fence and the
bridge; the tcuth btnE IL cot Fety ht91; che
creek bottom Is g1aSetly; the wafer was lol
tn The bottom, and rtaes some dlatas.ce bacevarl
[ did not EeR1ufe ire st. Charles For1: probably
there u not mdch difference between the fof1s 1.
Etoss.tzarnsn-d n c,..:-ess waleox: was ngs
Introduced to The creek IN 1sss; kpow she cscel
up to where Il ttart5 at the ffabnard fara1: VI
there It rul through Low bo;tomi where Jo1.
nan Bofusss ilsea il i ,s hisa Ind; th;oush Tens
lsrn, threeqnaEtets Of mile abova uamuoud'a
farm, It fnna through low laod; doas know snat
IL rises teiJ quickly; I hare seen 1t over ~tte
after The drowning: found II no shere moro than
7. inches deep: cil cot 60 ont into the Ta1er;
hut Eeasotfd It from ths bank.
= JCpGB on 1HK sTASp.
l. s. Judge .uern and er1mjned BY III. Jo.Ifn
Am e year. old. was .orn ii Livingston Co,1a.
y, y. 4. l nas eni!osea for nre years b. the
Of The Turner JUNCTION House, antt tnea welt tnto
the a.u5 tor three JtsEe. | IVES ,aea travelling
agent toT tie Michigan sou:hera Katlroaa: taen /
Nas!5 the lntc1nal Rest nue Defaftmeat ior lwo
Eonfh,: was then t!Ig1eg 70. the Republican
pars!; Kaye concert Ior tue benefit Of stntta 5
church; the net prlceeds we're tsss. was not
Ut iGpseu 10 this couf1. bare been for three
fratn across The continent. expected 10 be back
IN two Hee!P. bat had to remain m extsa week
T. san a,aEr EE.ansttfo, I'd esls asssssa lone
aoou: = mo1th aFer the drp.niu8 Of tbs
Smith: Tas saT Ehen Mrs. Snlln was Irowaed
snd did not hear Of It for three days a1ttr tien
liz isches deep: nsd 10 riea w ~ to Be cs,Isd
- = witt esq. ! ELew SAuh's mare u the Jung.
TIN; she vas Kind aeIalal; naye seen Ar..
sml!Q oIise her; hare seen Smith ddye VIA tns
baFgy top On: do Bet remember any dcnn:fe
uE&e beiorr Mrs, Smith MAS dsOwned when tnr
b9t1g uau top on.
t'e'*-t.ani~::' y ". Ear,s: e,nro: et.e AIRY
Lolhttr parties lar called nv atteesiou to Mr*.
Smith iF@:! liz sniDa! el3Le; san her .1r11ibx
the nhfe s4one onte or tsice: III s1rar once: /
10 TIE ttnci ltnIuk 1t tu tie fore paFt Of the
day; nm nst positive; think It w1s IL Mar or
June. 1Ras ., Wines Defoie 1he grand aSJ,
Nst. Smith dgcre'ti; leser saw the top eT =:r
buggy. nor The buggy oc The lop; thInK tnr TOP
vas Oh ID May o. dGne. ! saw Mn smith onte u
=. DC y IS go,na; sne psssed ny hou.e on tie NAN
street; thc Nhs thea a!ts tod5 1ruza her house. ,
never dfase or rode ntter the aniGa.: don't lcor
ton. The sht nj, sub,'e1aeJ re hetole tue grant
3asy: ~Hs bef6re It ont, oree; VAS here At
The CenEt Hcuse au:!nx the catr eEer, d.'r !:
jury; ~ sotg FOR tos gsaa, 1ars, the ,asI
ta}. Wha not hefe "a company nth Mt.
Ju.1hs White Il aoJ ,tu,e: ea.e "tta Vi: FErech.
grans, js1.. ~. Q: frre x.:n asy one win wtlu MAS
tu!eresi h th!- ,nsufa: CO. Got.i re:oyct 2,,-
'1g 10 ~. ba1r,pg1ou. c:t1E 9: the County. had
tuce him ~ so1e ore n1tst,e STOUT thc cas.,:
df pos 70 TO Bit. arr.cgtou to r.. the Gaze he,ore
the grand JUY, fon't recotiecs hns1u1 a cnnver-
my h-a:. dot.': 'scoarcs teisn1 n. EIenva. il
rIcseEce Of IN. Mccerstl', that tne tnln'ssefa
we're ctfe 3: GENEVA IT. l1E 10 get SGtth o. aas
aout recxhrcs saf!1g that Saith tai I.nt to the
tEd Of LIZ rope. was NOT not!neI, afLsF leac I've.
fGrr tlt fFatd jury. that eoulu be rG1u'rs - .
Aitrtss: va. ruriu,sed INA. was u3:: G3, M.
Anew h ter~ Rp,nx to t'a;.snla,. wna1 ,1.n- Was
stt TOT The '1t"s: was ro- subsae.atd.
CLUE or 1uE rEEsErCTtbS.
Ny. Nvsz-cf. That, II the t*barr please, Is oaT
, III RarrE. fosz Hcnor, the case Of the penpac
las iii cSperteu.y ceule to H close We suprsse,f
gsH Soi ne 81 ass aaa
oef.ea are not rta1y.
The Court. viii allow ha!. Al hoor for con.
sulsst'on. but We e"lnot lose all ,he attesneou.
tecess was takeu.
When the court resumed operations Mr. Aetz-
nc ASKED sease 70 produce another wstrcss
Thc deselce corhenfcn TO aitoF The examination
10 be 1nadr, NLen ihe wnreas WHOM they Wnu. d
FtctGee II aa On the staud-
TIE DEFENCE.
Mis-. BKs7uN'S TESTIMONY,
Ers. Eiitl Benton .cosn, G,d tram;nAf hy Nr
Ttta:on: lise IT Hanover t;ensSe Bentau, the
*!tht:sr IL nj tot. Mt-. Smith wss my ouly ITS.
tcs. III 1nu!le. i. living. nave no brothers. Msa
Qt1 X H4 Trpj1 trRA n
iGfc her axatt; they nseti al Algonquin fznrn Fen
Fnary 10 SoEenoeE. saw them every THO or
three nohssa a. Taen M tlies lssed q. AIRonqua: they
.af,s them 1t Aigohqs,in; the, also lived NJ puu-
oss SseE !Esv ,eats; l used 10
1rterdty teFns WITH her h1soSnJ: he WAS verg
aneentEate 10 her. l recoLtct her ttro ming;
abt'nt O'Clock. ati calling II. err WAS sart Of
akcEeSm o! dNttrs> Aud 1iEa1; be sa!t the tugx
had t!ppet pvtF, aLl te Was siEAid MARY was
ufoTned. We xtfe Ia bet, Ar. benton HeGt uut :
back .oketieT. saE her ~ Eoo1 Is tney brought
hrr 10; looieG heE Clothes, md fet ner neas:,
hut found no beating there NJ all: / Aent for tae
pe:sscos-. sir. sr-,tn was crying NJ tue nou.e.
tncc1lcn Was u'adr 10 The lie Of eaamtuat1nn.
As. Wte4loa coLfelHieL taat they hAfI right
10 th0~ liat tae defendant is.ett 10 reauscitate
Sirs. Etntca pEt uuuLGes LEI deal The KuFtfn.
t-eot hsn fa!led IL prove the hog icltie ana had
EAIlAhEttu ~ rAS iAE ut41lt tp0l lH.s Qh4EQ 1An!
1Itu,.
There vas long legal l;scu.sIcp. Tae C,nrr
sntslLGd Iae pt.1trttn1. Trey euulI asE wn,
lent tnr The phys clAp. hui could Eus 70 l1tJ II.
Conversation
Examination r<sn1nei: yY ron went for til,
fh3 s!es4n Ut ly ttddiLE- Nr. Smith mats the r.
0oj.c. son was na,e to the question what spt..
saul = La stn 'log ios tae phtalcl4n. fac uhtcS
ton 1y su.:aiLcf.
Examination .<zGmed: iad sy user IN IL,
hed sEt: rubbed be. C. e.;-
There Eas anutasr legal bout, a1i tie ez1llin :
GoE 14a E1tCeGuCd win.
N,tatss Sulth sceI1sd to te ye.y wax a,'
Frustrated. a1d h.a Clothes we1c WIT ani tsu,.l7
Ay etstr tad o. 4 bact IL eAs. ! o!zcE and WITT
shasi. aLu y WhLte 61TaE bat; tile shawl was ii
sna~.p'r. ea- heE befos: she vent up " Elxla
lie ..a. Isftf :FAs luabl, her u6uftciot.- nc
t.e tktFtH Of fE dl.Hs ItIc s1len. / lid NOT se
81 II. l.. tit tie ln-ts WIS tEought ID; be was
rte kIrthrn wltttut M tSeteoaI Aatt h:s taxe
c!tts e. W IT vel md -ete't: ne mad on ii .t:
5at; dh: cot sec Lis osertost crttl Eext ,la1
b1ta+t pecher was ELt; sone pspera
tse lower potssts ~tse w.t;, d
Ct ct cca: packets; tee oee:ceas was sandy: sI
| ncs. witch bAw te1t Cay, "ns ~ef- AF h1@nan
| r. r,y ton - - Tor shs UstrcoIt ta.t EIGHT
::ls- u. sn,l MIS- Mer1l1e',l caue 70 lay har d.
Nj anlIh w1a Ia the huuse lien sheY we're tr1
II ~ Ttsukci:a:e her: hc Has I'd f.ueEt d, Fo1asa
| l raw Mr SoIe5 ~ our hcute rext lay. WA n,
| FItttui III nls celsezeastoa with Ar. nth; II
&ns Eas.lk able IL tst tie next day; 1nT ti4re
! eLu Ela!rtd Of tsadacht ta7t Guy Nj site
Vas Lot ssfctS ~a:uaa- lAh HDlt:eIe.sf1.g teKA
i>tUrsLn sstae IL at tbs loiaI talak Df. Lar
a4s II tItioied; he I'D u11 cesnc: he was Aa.ent
C5ssk h.4s Eut tssE Ico~ uf. 'inctorstt for SMi.
E.iole: Ns. nId nj. Sp:sh wer. At suv noaee I
Ar1tl, aN:i tLt 1IY4y up Vi; it xss uir IN ,ta
11s'' aE1 sl>o The dat tl iue ArSlltat: tae we4th
eF tbs: >lt NJ natl tcen vet -oe Of sae fine tlsr
! top u. WAS ruff Hnaed " Toe detept aut
| WSs Of kt!'ItItAet; u5 41e prosecution.
tr's. t1a',:s,! r ~ Mts:'.er: Ny ssste: ~
| lut ,;a.tc tuo .rars: ley wrGt thea TO AI9,,i
quiL. rhet. to L. Junction: sce was never ma
t:e'' tclt'e. vert = nu1ber Of ttnrs to lluai-
eIa'lJ tfaJcti lao Ut three hoars OF hai i uai; *
ti.i ID then t$1ce At Ai1vrga!n; never san thei
| Al tae J4LctioR: tAc1 canae to o'sr hau+e orte
! y "as thele: useJ u,:d 70 stay tiuF1a1 tue d.,
Tte evening t.eJ Nt1s tu E g.n they cane aloti
the st. Charles r)1! ami ac.o.s tie creek About
.,'c.oCt: It ~as Q CLOCK whea iaey cane o4cx
| net 50 10 the c.sek. Mi snu snd husband ,sv,
away 4boui hbit an hour: they brought ii
tore n1t busgy With them: It *a3 tro hoal
Smith vas dfe:stt when &c caltt lOr help; d1
Ios po'me the condition Of the hat Or osercos
onta tie tol.ottos morning. He Eas tasie tar
ctl rot notice tie c0aas.o1 Of lie bu TT, nor ii
hccnd tine: the drss tine tney cane IN II
Mcrhtrr: the teeoId TINE In the Afternoon, whe
eaTe seen It With the top or. hut 10. Shts sor.ns
tayr seen It ktrce thA tr:sl commenced with t;
! top on did act lDoT an. :h1rG Of khe acct4tI
| lusrtsrce before rte Erc:1e.L
| Mr.. FarEse orth objected 10 questions regastIli
| tie .nenI.rcc. OBJECTION suIa:ned.
ESGmfns tsoa 7exusntt: AS kf~ter had no cr
dren ,. rr. sclth; he has :wo caluFt q, i bo5
and d gtf. 81 s
Ee.knsrt: NJ sister was Eot In the habit
talx!rg Ct her dou css.c arairs
IEI1MCST OF D, c KIScA1n.
y. c. htaea11 sEor7s, dnf ezdmiatI b. Cola
Nifrdz: am tcfsrr Vt the Eigll EltehMcn.
anow Smith, and net hts VIE otce Or Lake..
wss at Tie creek ttsee .dsJ7 a1&Er the aecaJet
lt1o*std tie stream through the <as&r; tie val
| 1toehtd the h1b Of tie fore wheel, somewbt
between AcTen:eeQ and twe1sJ 1nched; sn1s Y
ut ILe lord
Gto.~ ezamiaes b. Mr.. Ht,.H<r: MI busW IA
high OF e: the led, horgs hlKs. did not ss
EaIttcElaE notice Of .Ec depth Of the Na.e-. do