, 1869-08-04


f.-- - -.
Was It n inevitable conteauenee that there wonit
b - injury oomnitsed 70 the propeny nFht, q
! OF the cGnPl alnAuk II the court Were a1o~eo u
PR cetd: .......
The bill sets ur that Mr.. Cheney has for mAn!
,eas. been pseshJ ter Of ctE1At Church. In thiI
ctty Connected U1t4 the Dlnce4o Of Inino!A, tpa
hc wns edrcarcd lot The bustieaa and pursuit Of !
pastor Of the Episcopal Church; taat he II In tli
ir, aud ahaa Of efnoume eats II lilo shape ii a1
! 4eonscr,' 'rctit nee. ftbn the nalIth..
Nov, what would b tue coraooueuoe at m,
court u Iais .nstsacs proceeding 70 IL, Il i
e1ea ans osSnfao1 on neua e. b Dc
hrci. M view Of that poias Is ;its: eo5n M
cetdlng IN violation Of iis own canon.. ontsi.s n
liz pwn juFt dlct,op must - prexnrne7 - fnt,na
All That may beial ii tue prosecu,too ar ths CO.
tvep the worst that mn betafl Thcy .on<t =.
trEuued TO iutend 30 faF A thr ouesti6n A. t,.,e
Is ctnce1re, the depostt1ou OF 1nts nasty heisn.s
ton And the bill NAY 81 .ay, " east @ 10 fr,tses. tx
states Thar The l,1thor hss made fhrraf orvh.i S
Las been taken and understood to he an authortv
that there shall be depos,t1oD In Ihn casn md
Ina, the question shall be cal7ed uutll deoos,tion
te arrived at. II il true, ihc p1anop. in ii,
.sdssts, denies thss. but It Is mott s!gninca1!
only deicndants to he bii Ia ;Ger snswer. Do noi
deuy II They make no. answer whs,ever 10 thsI
hlszsdon Of The bin npd % far as these respond.
rot denying. Having. a. eay. 10 T1Tlt to y nroo @
cted II all The p1csun pttop nl xx Is ttlas ttef in
icuc-!os the purposo Of eir1ng Jurisdiction 10 =
court 10 put stop 20 &bc{T tlle0al pyuceetftnos-
t,sat they iutcpd that which nay belaiL I'll that
may fc1ait IN the case, The wors, consequence
under the canons Of the Church.
Us, whether there Is such damage 70 tde e,sli md
PROPERTY rights Of this complainant AZ that court
has rtGLt 10 Intervene AMI protect him 1rur tito
AjuTJt nud PET stop to fae action Of the court.
Tie Ejuty must te trrrpaIa,,le- What ID m iETr-
parable injurs In TIC irgai sclsc OF the Term; 4
u!an may hare re different est4ces worth yl1o COO
apiece excerpt the 1ftt, which 1uay tc worth hut
l4,ttn. and be has a perfect right under the law
tn 60 ibtu court nud allegs
Threatened irrrparas,le Injury to the
fur from Threatened, ar from N it,urT such ~ "a
renurr Inn bankrupt. Thc rrcIvIai,le IniurT n
Al ,TyunrxtIe tnr.,x II one snst tnvrsstn., "a a..
s,rpT ;bA In t6o catsie or in Tia thing Or enhtect
IN h1orrann shetht.r r 1e an her,t.ot ~ .vstfs -
Il ~. m es;n,r In iant fha, rnnid nsstroI
,lst In thc cutat, Th!ch ia .,f nrcuniar1 rn, ~
Tie oWpcf II tho injury he xuch ~ 10 THREATEN to
N yhai ntesrss m tp-a1zrssaa ~ ,ntorx -
An irrrnars,le innpr fnnst ,.e r,thcr dt,cc,,, n,
,ndtr..tfr& II ths 1trcc, ,nS ttnn1n. ~.
" ns.,,,s ~. n.s.,s ~ ,r,a-,,,M t.a5,,v *
scna,ai,! u ~ - sncn 1h.t fhc ,,,n,r e1,m5,,rn
n rnlS1 ~ In. Ennin trcncn,,s ~ .ytet,.nrc y
mtS A., ~ ,H. n'nt secnt, .,,s =, da,,.r' ~ A.
rv ~ ~, ~ ~ ..,c, " ~ :"
II il then tnt,,rrcuy insrpa5a1ir ami tilo Law TIi
uirr IN nuI ,T.rrI, ,ni,ry '
~ ~ ~ pstsI ~ ~ ny ~ ,,, ,.,. ..
I, &C. & nase sa,o e. .ha .ee G, m ne9n ~ 2aes'o
= ~ -, - r. 49,, ~ t, -. i1 ~ - ~ ..s, " @ s..o
t,nuc IN a le uufsni az us,or Of CHI, nn,, - and
-, rasn, 70 ~ @ u rAn,o ~ sra1sn 1ai ~ .h1 49,
.t;on :! .1 ne sIans u t5m,. i6nt " n 1ua
esii ~, ri ~ ~ 49,, IN, irn' ,..sn,.11 ~ =
Church vim ~ rhch he Is It present % conns,e:ss +
c a,rnH n,. , n;,.t tsp >us .1,sa y, =.
etnrThs Ao' 'oooee' D'As4s'4 "'>A oos'' "~1s'
tr1 ~. oncs,,on bc,c I, m, 50 s,nn,r y, that
f4I tth IAt ~ ~ @Oh 81 FsiAtftC ~ eA+e.
.t nr.sa - ~ d,. ~ rsn Irasnn,te,r ~
co1sl p,tsra 70 otpoN' or G'en en- loceantey ~
+1 ~ - - ~. hmhn ~ W. sTa a.nartn 49,
irofn T. w. 1dr enntene1 m q 11e sn9 e,.rh
r,tt., T., ~. trnntT ~ - n Fnr1nnd nroir.hl1
oir1ste NJ nettnr MS carrer sna ,,,r..,,t. tx
~ en ~ 'e ann n, x ne,oso e y @ h1a.
il II L. 70 far AZ Il ia tsn,poral nstlts arr con.
c.1Srd, c. NJ very maca M a. taongh 6is arms 1 were
tlis ssonrt or A. thouen HI. 1Iame Wer. na,nsyzed
nj ,h.r In n ~ nhrS h. ,,aa hesn ene,,,ed ~
ran ii,tna ~ f,1nse,f and nts farr,1y wrr. nj
ne,.. snr,ht,.t.d ~ 1s,n,r,-i ~ ~, ~ fhe ~
I'M 81 hn,tn, ,h.t me te.non5ep,s nctin1 n
rinIa,tnn ~ Ihe,r own cannnS1-If ti,r n.sf!t n
tisrr prnceet,Ine would t,c Of mlgn, BE- Tie depo.
D thry tnrea.isn hS tne very nc: OF prpceedirg to
~ t,,m. NJ, win 1nai nsf tn adysuce of hin isay
tlat IN, Ere threa,sntuc him with an trTrnarabls
i1tur, to iis ,enpora! nshts and 10 hls pecuulaIy
u;s1ts;s, IL has teen holden In heycra: cases
Thai tQe function and business Of mlnlstcr Of tic
Gospel or OF LAWYER Is th.rs-,t
L. VAltntlG tliDV INDEPENDENTLY L0$
ttts and etnolamrn1s that may
beia1t,' aod upder5r2nd thai TO be distinctly the
butt t:utc Of two decisions In The fourth OF HA-
lacc1 Gnl1ed States Renorta ttAs went up 1rnm
. the 5t4te Of Missouri, one OF which Involved the
rRtt at mtu!s'er OF the Gotpe! 70 preach. and
lie nthel nf = laxyer 70 practise h!s profession
without hkthR certaln oata ihat MI hcen PIT
stt1bed by The Lesla1ntuse ~ Alssou,a nhu wnien
fLtJ could not take "l1h stApfet - Laels coauGci
dat1ng Tue var There s case also cttea 10 1ne
Alo&urna IcnortA-the folume nas escartn Met
tltt "
the same effect
Now, nay he said, an1 Viii be sald' and Was
so npon re aIgnms; taa. ho .p]nrs Ga9 sa1 ~ n
rnl,net and Ensn court u law. In eon'ri,s-
t.aetson to . Cnut OF Cnances5, 1Gtntsoes 90 Aae :
qtate fenea5 ioI tnAl NionS ~ LWE. anu :. -
c'aln th hf1e 1oal IN cAst % MI+ Ioss.
beng unaer engagement " Gh51sI Ghurea parsa
10 Iteaen lol 1stn'' ,,,,s MtonsInu ssnpr.rs.t
ona nave s. Iae ps1s the n,aues n s
sAa5 and It Is undoubtedly true @ sant ,s ne 1L sp6
or, should he choose, ne coold sue ouL q WIZ o.
na and Te 9nnsf 1Gs 1 rse,nn nae ~ ,s n
s11ion IS nlaistei Of Ch1st Church. But how in,
adequate remedy of that kind! Even inc VII
OF sHnn6TMus coufd nor undo tae eehtenco o. TUX
tribunal IN thls case. ". cheoeg, the sonpIan
| RQt here, would be al the ume dtposea 4nt1isse
! Of the Episcopal Church LIS conQfrgat'on-
| they must and they would, IN CONTEMPLATION Q
IAw, obey and fo!low their Rlsnop. Al
though Mr. cheney might be 1e|tor1d ~
i
: 1Ec xrar fur winch they had engaged him. and he
n,nht IN m arfion ri law recover lIts taI1ry fo
! ~ haisnee NJ he tcnr-stl he would not he III,
a.,oe ~ nor ,'rsctico, sarse ri that chnnrh ijt
Ia19 Inrs n9 II ne.r tn 1f1e1 cnnih mi hra,
49,. rhsr - nnf sn En,sronaj rhnrrt1 in tI1e ian,
niEs W. - ~ ~ ~ st,h,, ,e1t,nr ,h.nsaire
iat coGl1 usat 1 " ~ nnsnre m, tifrh the1
~ tne luPutat.o - ~ .1.d - .n,,a.,et ~ ~ri-tf
NGulo De ilante ~ ~ 'L.uu' ~ ~ pH ~ !.
Gal csnhu1c bf lug hianop ~ Goastsileuee =.
tluf there Is absolutely no snc'ent reusa} o. ~
when the Term f29 expired LOT WHICH iis u cu
| eaEed. Where Is hla pursuit. hs career, hls oisl
| Etsa IS minister OF the Gnspe! lie 10 driver
forth like Cain, with nari upon h's lofehead ant
| u IL 1he duty OF at good CAnrcnEen 10 shun hu
Nov, !h)u7y Of ,niS kind |. scfJ fnr from being
sight injury To the ten pufal tnietesis or Hghts
properly CT the party, II am correct IN Suppoe'n{
ilsai there Ia such thing az value In The right
| pursue ones calling - minister Of tho Gospel
Without gong INTO other questions which hay'
| treu rulsGd IN this Case nD prepared 10 rest N!
Judgment upon thIs-of course understanding
very ptll the falltHl:1 Of my Own judgment Az
| t1ai l nay le IN c1rIE II u my duty
! hoRcyc1-tr has txen made my duty. With
| out my own choice, may eay-to inter
90 80 eash a r. a s 'Ir Ti. ,s frs,fui ia
1t Is ny pleasure to 10 vcstsJuan q thc Etleo