, 1869-04-28

me Of Inc men WHO puk ouk Tue IudBe "as |
DISCRIMINATION BY Judge Nltrr: Am sales
nan at 40. '6 Randolph: been In the city for two t
VAS ut the Police Court with him. and who went !
10 see Mr. Hartman, defendant In the case; WIG
out Of employment III December; VAS at the court |
half or three-Quarters OF On hour; Ar. Tyler was
In court when he went In; witness had been to 1
Police Court before. but not from curiosity; case
lid not recall anything except The squabble: Tyler
was standing near Justice Mulilen at the ttme;
witness was outside the railing and thirty feet
from The Justice: thirty or forty people we're
In the room and there were many around
the dock: some gizl was examining; the talking
between Miken AMI deceased lasted nve min
utes; DECEASED did not SIT down when asket, to:
did not sec any chair handed him; did not hear
him tefnse 70 SIT down; he Wa ordered TO leave
the court room before be WAS 1ned; did not recol-
lect Miliken saying that 1t MAS necessary 70 pEe
serve order; some Of the policemen took hold Of |
thc4 wss one eses s sp
pulled back and said the man who laid hands On
would pay for It; saw him, struggle anu push
Witness % 81 tept bis seat until Tyler was out Of the
roou; when deceased Was outside the bar more
policemen came up; one came ~ behind and t'ok
hold Of his shoulder and neck; did nos know where
the hands Of The others were eaT Tyler struggle TO
Keep hack oll the WY to the door; did not see |
mn ns1 tness ans en Sen a down ss
cause The case had ended: witness, hls ftlen anu
Hartman left the court room togstner dih not
recollec, seeing blood in the pssssse; saw II arst
on the ba1usters three OF four steps down; the
blood went nom there all the Way down;
The policeman had wiped the blood an from tWo
OF three stairs; had no Idea what sort OF cloth 1t
waa; had no pail: said to his friend TINT that was
shameful; was positive the blood was spoken OF:
went across the street to the corner, and waited
Tor Tyler to come out; DID not see Tyler after that
day.
A. Van buren, called and sworn: Knew Judge
Tyler and was at the Police Court when the frolI-
bic occurred, saw him taken out OF the room;
identified Dry an Ie9ea tsa1 " Iso ~ %n9 . .Goh ef.n
ants were present Witness went on 20 uescfloe
the court room, and the relative position Of The
what he tal seen Of the d.trcnlty between Ts!er
md MillIen. The account Of this witness was
substantially the same q those arssds pqoisaS IT,
ier:s removal was ordered Onicer Dsury took hold
Of him, and Tyler shook his hand ot1. and At tas
i; seized Him p5 the arm, anl got him towards ING
Entc ID the bar. THIN Officer Tel,ea took holh Of
HIN near the throat As they got HIN ont ct the
Struggled and held on to the railing He WAS then
rushed ont ol the room. The witness vent down
9e fened hs e es ,ns n
did 10. Tyler WIS blctsi,rG: there Was . Snt over
S;. ns eisses M s"'sR Wns
asked Tyler to he allowed to pay his anc. lie ?,
Inst refused. hut finally agreed, and It was paid:
vcfs much n excited. nc looked bally about the
IL I'D no not 1s shea Complain @ Of any particular
md When he went hack in the court room, he
acted as II tn ing to get the names Of me poSe.
swollen. and SO was hts nose LAWYERS at the
Police Court universally stood. The witness saw
Tyler day or two afterwards, and the deceased
| cornplaIned OF feeling badly. .... ~
Crokatxamination by Hr. Ma*on: Witness saw
Judge Tyler next ,lay in Ills oalcc- He did not
yase o e fooWnF sy Mr Gord and
Nr. naggett were there. Witness next saw Tyter
on the Sidewalk near the entrance 70 h!s ot1ice.
Dr. Hlake came along and commenced speaLans,
noticing the appearance Of the judge. The three
we're there hut few minutes Tylss was r. r. III r.;
or ow oue yer IL
not anlc to say positively how often he saw T5ei
TTer Tenestcdly asked the elri at the Police Cout
aud which she sometimes did and sometimes az
!, not answer, was In relation 70 her paS ne dis
protection. i,rury lid not take ho!d q Tyier rio
iently. The latter told him to Keep his hands Of
it little M way but NOT pushed violently back. Il VA
only tFo or three feet pIary again seized him
The witness .ltd not hear Drary ask the deceasct
struggling and had hol,l OF the railing. Te5ea mus
: : | have FeixeI him hy the coat collar. Itler VA
asns @ e a @ s ana % GDf aas hax .
nnk nn H At III tic % time Of the alteration lie did no
4 recoect stating to MIllken that Tyler must nave
ssw Tvler nhage 60 i;cfore lie would not awea,
! thas he did not say that TSler vas d1ana, ~ IN .
4 witness had made 10 JUDGE ~ Mate stalencnt aa y y
, dnceI to writing. What It Was to be nseI for h
did not know. lie might have told Alsen @ tha ha
= iaved 50 badly. The witness went down stai.
within nye minutes after T!icr was expelled: an
was below With him two or three minutes Wnli
I gu!ng down be did mol fccollect neelln8 a1} PEI
y son On the stairs
= Re-Jirtef: lie saw spots Of blood On the stairs o
aa asfe ms @ 10 ana
;, = T Re-c1o~11amination: he sworc Drnry went oal
y slle the har with Tyler: Ic was equally nositv
Z hands we're torn. .s--..-
~ DR.. John n. Ptllsbury called and sw0rn: Hat
m rtactised medicine for nine years; Was called
intend Judge Tyler, who came to big oI1ce on u
afternoon Of December IS to consult n sesa1u Sa
vas cut over the left eye. The eyes we're pa
tiniy closed. There we're marks ol injury Gno'
"a the throat He sled at the nose and splt plo9 9
to stated how be received his injuries Vitne
=. again examined him ut e. aud found the nose pa
" tally fractured, and much s"elanS la Inc talo
i: in lis lunes, Just below the collar bone They osa
III SPOKE Of how he received his Injuries Extern
Wnees saw " i'm On hour iater, when be Te
rs to bcd. The weather Vas very pleasant "
~ next morning I!les came down 70 osesG's; t :;
OF swelling outside had much gone down Wine
advised him to 50 to bis family physician and q
tC not see him uhs SIX oa}s 9e!o.s ~ ussst. y l. !.
nc swelling In the throat continued There We
;st signs Of m abscess forming Il gathered 81, a
no Fnday. lie spit ont the matter through !
IT mouth. The afscess broke OF ITSELF Tuesf
evening The swelling heKan to @ Increase .e, low To-"
I'D witness saesesIed . Mr: Hbbari tne ptsp.1ety
nsve sm up, "a eryspe!a,eus SYMPTOMS we're 8
sly ling IN. he grew worse an day Ne4nesdsy:
THURSDAY be could speak Tn. ne "a aits5n0e 51H
ny received produced Inflammation ending
o. death; the wrenchin9 or twisting OF Z
paIs 4aortem examination. It commenced IN
!ng rharyn1, and involved the larynx ana . fIacn
COZ The ahscess was Ia the love! part OF tne pnass
1elr &C Csp..xransnatsor, BY ". Van Arasan: With
completed hs studies y 1sa Va H. ~, she AT az
lily & eteesG eefeca 1ss7, % he cane here lie nsd kno
her Judge Tyler Intimately boarding At the 50
.a n9t s.sassa Ut fass SsS a5 a}en
oy. ins ns ' On the e throat, Just below sne ADA.
The tf1ne had been pressed there. 1t looked IS Il
ken va perhaps IN inch IL width on each g
Get three inches In length. e1ter3inG 1p
cen down. Il ras very slight abrasion. He J
ne not then ueat bin an % nout s aseS eeFn1
'ng- tnterps,iv. it was somewnst kwolten- He CO
ard NOT esy where the blood he spit came nom-n
oAt- or tp4sa Ha thought It came from ne n
Tnere was no internal znfos1on Of tne tatoa&
lasss lassfy Sseaf infean dsedns d IL aassa
ling terpaf cirrum stances md what Tyler said II
pre- was aftez wards abrasion In the taIoat-on r. y
OF tsT. eix Of seven days before his death- WIFI
lten+ did not Know what he did dnring tue PERIOD
the iorinr the 1rst prescription He ate bis NJ
cur pretty regularly. One OF the seETants came came
the witness On Monday morning. The swelling
,less increased inside and out There Was great +,
the and fnfness Of the pQsteor part Of the Ill
e1tendipr @ in the iar1n1e Both vocal chords =
: Of involved. The abscess MAS 1uss aoofe, oaf
sre VolVtng them II had not t6sa 59fe qfa sots III
win | oiottia ana lower portion OF phats
le is Te Point Of breaktug vas neas ne upPs1 :;
a. chord. The color Of me po11d; q1;.rea 1hst Il
sert- 10 IA not recolcct- External appnca!lons
IS At croton oil werc ordered me ansceSs &c o.o1e @
om s tro Or Tire da53 !, a tanpaia Of swelling 10
arc AVN: he Was put under general sntiph!og!
treatment and saline n'!s ana aasoqa H. aat @as., 1a'
@nat tne1 were; the ne1t daJ he began to
nn. wnrn It BROKE hts breathing WAS much easier;
ss q he ~
,,,or nad changed ct s1pelatous symptoms npPeare
2tne5 tie outside Of the neck; the sktn vas pated
rse hea sais St IL VS. X
nv day night; from thas time he gradually sunk;
reT Salcqg Of ores.11ng sea311g lesTs7s
ds Or Cartons OF !eaa la,,s to,son, d.. d.. ,,o
one the o1ulna1y treatment. He used d sclutle
ID or the breaking Of the ahscess The pressure at
seemed to be between the sternum aud the lar
ma From The fulness Of the swelling be Judged It
With below the laiyn4 and ID ne uae1ea Ine M "a
esad Was tnF0lsed lhe lMIueuiale causo " -, sne
d By up the 9dema Of the Elotsta The witness
t. gnlatlon, and yet before he died there was
any fuse discharge from his throat Of thlck L