, 1869-08-04
IT,. BISHOP vs.. RE TOR.
Dttision Of Judge Iamtsen on The Notion
10 Diksolre Nr. Chcnsy's
1njuaftiun.
Tho Injunction Sustained--The
Grounds Upon which the
Decision II Rendered.
An Ecclesiastical Court Of no More
Account in the Eye Of the Law
than q Base Ball Club.

Account In the Eye Of the Law
+ha, = D. no,, n,nh
lHau q base ua44 V1uo.
The Court Declared to Have Como
wfytont thn Canon~ IN ~.
-.1~-N4
ETesonemeo1
--
r,,. ou..,,.z. -,
preine Court OF Illinois.
inc supcro1 Coart met Al 10 O'Clock yesterday
IC1n!tR, PufsEaut 70 adjournment
c1kc Of ~; Iheney7 =
~. 1Ho4fSoS. The cnups1lnsnt'd counsc!
eFs here; ,,-,,,
~. Gold, here, hat don1 Know whether It viii
lie uecsssary u Ha.i
ssS Wi14Hns nAMIS1H hs : pot IT,, se5s IND,
who Is out Of ,o.1, hut think Jour Honor may
pivceea 4 you think proper. -
..;c & st ccamsanees n1eer shca ne s sseas
L. tl.s motion, arose, 91nnsed counseI upop oo,n
tass !nal vos'd M *sd:sysI ! p ssslas 81 r. i
II possible, 10 Us moi to nicrfcrp rith the g:ttiaG
G1 ne Ecclehiaht,cL Cuun puw IL aucs.
,,!oa' !a ea.e m1 ta4gusnt should ;
be dnsoirri. Tnl9 case, although Iwrhaps intf1n-
h.ra,fr OF no ulare difficulty 1hso casea that nre
arising before ne Of similar tlnd eseTs day., 70.
1n1u s. rhrrr has }..rn ~ ntrrh 1,ulTIc 3nfrrrst
u liz car, sna. may ny. 10 mich excitement,
II wnhmt IN II nTfn Enl1n, cyen anTcr1ing IN
thoss, c,rrnnstagccs. 10 lrr,,1. II nr,xi,siy ~
ptsula II tht qutstloF had as1.en ,ttweyn iwu u
t,r Caat Ofacre rjtf7ens of 1xrok (ts1Dry nni VIVA
r,,,,,Ir n5r,s.ona4K rrajIf ai,d tntr1sicslIy IA
lcre.oi i,ru,rr1,. ir.wern insD mi nan
Th,s IL : usutnH in.rrposeh by Tue Reverend
.llput;ch;4 Ia lie tlx+ to dissolve ~ lplunctpn
ia hAx i,ecn siIoaed By thc Court ID Iaynf u Rev
~, ~ ~ "a M n. - ~ Frr..,a.s!rsI t.o'1T We
tu,,c,I,n WA ni,oxsd A. HSye st.te1I a;rcaly.
.si w.. ueee 1oe i,s,i,,'s ~ VIZ. not ~
H.. rnn INT liz ,.y.s,. mi Inr rup,s nj ,hr
nsr7,-s ~. surh .cd tne ~rmu.s INK: ihr,atsG rs @
.ss 80 ssls ~ n e1eee o.etsss ase sacn, LA a
nv insrs mn ~ rrrat ner1l 10 Ih,.t. .ntr
at'd t" @ 1sor ~ Il sbtstne @ coa1t E nndef tho.e crcum
slncc-. Ias l:sst ~ s!Ant ~ lnjuncp.a "a "lluouI
nSMs. enaso II o. sa 1nurrf. f. onnu @ eae ~ s.aM H
thc rcsron1enta hsss come n ana Died l an m "a,
t"et, M 1pa g. ,ne aoIavn aoT ases, not oniy hpua
au, M I lt aarm a .; III tae Ini Iesrsrul I meur1 j.
Wa.tcsoa.e, ia.,op q ia's diocese: j have ieaad
.tse.! nna1.T cqHptie!3 10 Ieusrm u, p1se p;omlse
Ehe f.snis NJ Fnlcn h4Ee arrived. hna sun! @ uos
atseAil - s.sf ~ -. n,9 ~ s,t,m ~ ~ Hsi;
h ~ harr- ~ ~ eon,rI 81 soann n. t. r. cnn'
ta4nta 49,, ,,,s,to,.
BeIufe co1.Menclns, ma! sLase t1At G,4slaSta.
~ ~ tso;,, ~ t.. ~ r. ,n,r ~, ~ y, -
ro ~ ~ ehf =. ~ rsInnnr ~ nr e,ii eurt 10
tiss,ieai sHInai ' II IL ci.,mmH It 70 not The civil
cocsts assc!sina aud sc:c iiscsttn, any power Or
mi conr GrocseL,n9 Fishtn IND nccoft,lnv 10 its
rahnls .hc !hws to1 ItEuas E.ss ~ -. ,ha ~. ,ntr
EstI !ne olu EA1a 43'' shu h r.n1t ~ .th., rsnsso
!ou!,n , ~ h ~ 9nders NJ tho sn,Yt
uns'ty. ano GauFss uuGnl ~ y W. ~ ri{
irtnI1;a! Joo4S. aams1'eu -, =, ..lana ~.
itsGo ~ clfH 1nEA Ana H. - oe4ahe -anhs
u properly, civil f7ctL lnrsalenta, u u!aa tns
I'LL case Is made ol dvll rant tAtca.eoeH n,s ~
The Actnn OF - EccieAsas!lcat Cous. ia. hns ,u.
Gosst Aap.s ~ ~ n ri;nn te Jurisdiction Of
temporal couH-A TEMPORAL !1shL hhtFe ~
cccicsaEfcai o1ouDnlls e92aVeu W. ut t .,iat ~ nv ~
GTcn'eF under m ae1 OF ulsGipltt aHucs ~
rifles and einoas Of Inc Ch1lEnt u u ptoSssa
uccurdug 10 those cahnns Clfll coufl nas ~
right to interfere u II tsanrGfess ~ o~h ruiss
aid rtrulaiaonA aho 1ns tne1t " .s..as si i.f-
gffss'nn o. 10 sef.'y pJa[g TIL sIe cna11s art tns
Itehr, and 1t - tnell du!yt 70 1u1ef1G!tE IT
y LAT tAeu Is Lac wrong ~ LIE LIE
rs<e: suited bneHy. tns s,'po ieSpoaaen.s ~ ~,
~ sn Lcclce!as!cs. Court, and 70 II, ihe Neser-
tna Chaf.es = Enspey, auu t1 ~ ~ ,b.r piies an
lus outside q, A1d IN v1oiaion VI, .ae't .eS t, 90
tcelee!4t1ical couft IN as eUuoe NJ ind
1sitssu, tue M teai l. an ecclessssuca tI'Dana, q
church association u 10 more ~ tos e!e o, Inc a~
tnan Is Al assoctatton for any tempotM p1ipasS qan
1tru page ha1! club \ syceun. Or IN o'BsatzAllon
fur the CONSTRUCTION anc operation Of fMltoaa
and The courts possess ahe r4ht 70 nlese5s u u
these eates 1pon v1oatoa q 'ne ,asian II
is claJctd Lere ser, " the Reverend Challes E