, 1869-11-18
MURDER TRIAL.
Sixth Day Of the Healy Murder
Trial ut Ottawa.

Trial ut Ottawa.
Argument for The Prosecution,
Ereetsi uespa.eh 70 The chieaSo tribune.
tf1iNA, i'll. Nos. It.
otkHtfs AhstHHHr foR fRA fHvskct1tuF.
The te%ttnuht t'tIns closed. Mt. tluneh tto-
+..d.t ~ s't:les4 thu iafy t7t ihe ptosscu'lot4
IT. Attk* u h. rta.e t"'bthsiti1tt tut ~ttshed
sf*h h!fts44i Ahd I'M hihet e'tHi.ef tt mo essHt
Htt thef lis tttsHHts shHHlh IN tih&t hy 4 t~ftrs
NJ mi GH't'tl Whsihnf hs shHit ta sst,t n tbs
|stl'thiIA1l ht lin 18TH 1T kts HsIHs41 ilit. ~
Hktihel hh ahsh. stitstf ~ tsHHhtiHiHHs h1As4 M
tlts shsHt,tt, thAt 4pHl IHuthnf had hasH rssFs,
tath IN nD's hauhlad, Il wss Rlstt iIatbl attI
4n~ataiJ #ltsdtt, snt lhs nAsallnH IL lii ,tsi'lrt
HAH Nhtihtt Ihlta lihsls MAJ The mAH Win tAHf+
s'; r. i, .*'t . % = h. n.;"a H. t:.'". nc %
in.s !. Il S :i|,'l cf /" Isis;."ss i, as1 H. t
81 T." & tiY .sss l.'1Is' ,Ites,!
%a s tns ., ' H., ,.s. u !f t.s nv s,.t, Ts
lhk n thH cta!n assi .een tnrpllst AMI #sery uih
'.isr ~! ,ss'.h,,ns ~ n ttsia tat
18th FfHtet, atl,l tha IaauHrf lH whl,l HIAhH MAJ
stlt1 = n aisa l~ntIsp't, y '.sA'l,ss!.r'I ..nsn
.l,as ;: t'' h.ss b+es shos shtauEh A. lsw win
ys'.f: w s;s ~: .eA ''' II ::::
!:; ~ s~s,.. Il. .:.;; ..; ,ot et TT IT, ,f!"t s
ah nl 'he t'frninsehrea l'oltfetl lliprtly 10 Ind
r. " n t!s.'%t ,';,,n "f ~ r.. ttt st e. IT, ula
4t'iiY ~ mi. Attsk.lpt bill iest. .liais., i'5
t4At'.t| tnl M lsfsha. II tas iat4 III Al4aa hst.
;ts t. ~ 'E:1 II III IL:
s s " .an*s .t i. CUT ID s.t s.s. IT, s f.,a1 f.s IT,.
stA"A Aatl +al aay 'ttl1'aHy WIN lu t!at t'aIaef
'hst s,t."a4sea =. NY tb!nx. ~, .auu4at
ecu IHiilHtr III iitAsldf ttn!.Ayi 1al II Wa4 asH
tio'en Iha. taa tLaa u ha NM lIttuta'l with lin
~ ar,la!'e'i ", s... Ia hlla.esi. hA.' nesss
an~h ti,st H'Ann had iAcnrfed Ills Viii Of pe0
Ite In TIN nt!8hboFh0od Of Rockwell, ~ having
uhaeTtBken anhhFy cnhtfatts III ~ ser prices than
*ers GlsTeht: hut tho pFtsnE xAA ilfaa:fiy 10 tue
cOn.saF5. Counsel for tie defrafs mud suugh. to
tnslhl inso llit iL!nsis of the Jury tho lca that
sn, u ~ ~ nIn an1 II T. VIII
That the deiead4nt should haya tbs bened, ii
AK tor cshscton: bQt II guilty, II wa4 tue outy
OF the 1aEI to say 50, md let HIN au1er The Just
penalty Of h,a hcts- There was discretion sc.ked
rt!soner. i Iouhd guilty, should te dealn on the
lcarolh OF 1nnTf onmenl in the Penitenilary for 4
Term not ese than Il yeart or for the duration OF
T., th nT as e ss = ~, .ns
ssss !; ;Ss 4 s0;sa.1s tas
am.n xare fnna ,1t1 1oos ~ 10 taa. ., ume,
rut for he oaIs tS NJ n1snes
uf deHta; but DOW tlceu Was no cIpita! offence,
thas ~ ,,s ~ y. a. ~ ~ H. M1s1s.cea
VAS mt nrsssnr for h1nt s,fSnooh 10 Ge
tous!y believed Heals 10 be guilty. He did no.
nntI =. 49,; ~ " ~ nnt ht ~ to out tnes
IS h@ to thc rea sT1 or ill., 80 s'a ~ a9o 10 oge
,sa no1tngs r. ,33 oas1se o. nc
nT Iot e4aI. iney "91d Ga os tola NV taat la;J wets
!ssrs e -. ve1e q ressoasele w aeaas s q j
n3s s1ilt IeaSousn!s douhs xas snsn ono =
rss'lon 10 hs oMn asr. and Se
n tnas ~ euGI 1casonsua aonot gag heea faIsed IN
~ s s., easg, nAt w 1ae prooa tnis case: Flrss
Healy sna MIN laI ~ ie ;,n. ~
eSnR!t.ea7 ltV.s pso.ed taas he; nad Tepeas.
~ tnrhi br b.s on 2, snc tset saa. ey
ne nt,, "opld ,ss Nteas ,.a!., by vengeance upon
s.iaesee q. e tss 'sa% aislr VICE. @hsa ueals as
a.ssn !, isa Is ~, You'd o!eSe .hstnsi iies!;
W. W. s mnn Of saca nagoFe1oaeIs PASSION that DC
nae e3alnlted aiWse!t N condition Of irenxlea
s1sr the ~ petose ne Tss as5essed ne had gone
!
| lot tnat pfetons onence. uusl such time as he
eou,o r. AZ. na'l aaa ad'isH win him a. 10 the
sos e. .h;s oe snopla pnfsne: Mhat VA the proaf ~
| - tn1 a1tAcA Oh St1oo In tae Held: There ~k5
| 1s.., ne were charged wtth q a.ssalt Win
si ses ses apoa 5 taa e cosa
rn1ch he law directed IN such : case: Then, u
70 Gle tLe oiosr m attanls. Which occurred On the day
~ 81 sss .ss; s1f h sdns ne
Up 70 tae place W1efe me @nod Fa|, and that
1ps1 @ = qaa a. 1eeh ZONE ons loaaing wood out d!.i
| mothes alte!Nafds- Heaiy and hts SOU went up
70 the place where Lont1 Fol!tsa wea loading hi
oed ;',nt, une BOY stated shas Loah Fosad sAd be
ianefs house. They got uron the wagon
eng rode down - far a. Mr.
M1on a. ,6a oonse: I1sn there was discrepancy
toE @ re Ge9pls snowed that loais s.ated that tue
H. H. ,oaa tnas morning .as 10 60 to Mr. Nixon.
oaa ~ ", % 2, H. e" Hs.,. soa tsat me r.,
ZINE u sEas tns ditnculsJ occurred, Mr. Nixon and
ME- aoong posh ses;'nea that Sxon ca Eos hase
n'm ssoop to nict Up stone, but he al not PICK
saas 1on stone; H. Ihe toy % vas contFaac;ed @ y Mrt
;;Sh.nt ;;aunt Atf. Ao9n9 anu LOUIS Folirad.
Tht! ts'd iii! l1esly mined tnse pi.tol I'D als.
W., S S e IN. +, 1.,nsr ass @
re te:,'mony q ,ne oo, Il preference % hat q
| sHte: 'stsS "'tue.sea A!u suef brHcFs tQas 1ac
re,hcr t't'teye That lie ha.i tetn ulln9 10 tcil 4
eiory 70 accurate 10 some things deemed to h
~ hsi 1cea .lc isa!aet oi the eoy, Se exn,"1tc
sGhe!asts pioes OF nnsinQ been trained ii u
What he tn3ula taJ. Nhen he Aad gut 10 tht
eha 0! h's lesson ne Msau 10 CgT
ana nnA0y eAld ne would not tcs:if5
sn5 lu!sne1, hnu ptfsEed ~ II a. hc nhti prcsi
ou.it cone br!oFe me efnn4i tney. When he wal
thsru iefure ~ grand Jury he hal mol ieasnet
] nl& lcsstns OF II nc nal, II H4A btCnusC be bhOulL
no. icstuJ y lore The gfnni jlry for fear hs Test
nonJ wonii . ne 'atcn .'orn md brought here It
contont hlM on the trial. liz father wa4 shire ~'
euopan 70 kto~ the eH!s't 0f thMt. md therefore
hs ~ not a ao*Si o. 81 to tc:slty: There we're oths
RI examination he lid Inc rt.toi Va, Ia iaAcr @
rom w. !atac1 Y h's mother when thry rcturoe'
ome n,itd ATT 'hc 1Fs saoolS a1d 'at sae pn
ssxan,tn.;ien he aid taat 'ne d ar.t ~ ~
'hc r!s!"' On the bureau ana Tint Afterwards III,
sa, thst rhe Mot!i tut Il ", nsrsn.r: rcrnnp'
~ II mt the time i1c.e mea wont to mr. ~ ri,
,rG11 'n: 'o h; T. nsT E5 s .s 81, er
slsep,n9. Ih.t Sfsla ;oli hla father nc was
tns"ntT: IMa. 9a. ~ tsther nsver assc.i what b
esmc mo the Kitchen: AMI tint K-yc
kn'sI, - os ;ho.. ilt -, ss',, the+o xere q
"Inat T. = .'sa!a a.n !oaoeeat oi.' Thc boy IA,
as 1Atnes Ifsav utter Inc wos'i. - 10 not car
H&nn, knnT f'nthlhR atnHt ~ nf F." tiotl'
Rise tamn. - hhow nothing With FrxArl l.
!. tut taat sheeo Atc tnc wofAa MI krJra tat
n,ru; ne souEs1l aaa !t1ea 70 1T NJ. ke,c
| ~ 4hHl1 mat !tra5 hk1 nail: "t}tss hc!r mr.:
h.,c ,,, hsd ait'lenlsy w1.h ". NIXON. md the
~Il enatns n,n Win ha1trs fLe.i hin. :" tI' krsr
| sA1t Hr leAu nQtHth9 0I sRat 1ihL No cont
| uenfc can hc placed Ii tho testimony UI &his lUJ
rnrh Nc Hhn 10 fstlt cottrAteitA ~ s!tHeaA'
IN fchtfou 10 efery tnrg which he hhA sr4t!hc
"a hiA rhtsr testimony md h!a appearance o
tnc staos't clearly Indicate mat hr hAti bCcu IL
ttt"rLrd u ihr trausnOnJ hr mRat gttc. 10 ~