, 1869-05-02
euMsEes!uss 10 jypAlsM.
Aepsy to Mr.. Julias RosenthnL

TAX. CHICAGO, Apatl ~, 1865.
1eAt Nit I"sf n. cAiAaso TRIBUNE:
lvos 1esae oS 'as& Sunday contEias l.tter
s'"ne aaa probably w1.tten or tbs abore na,ne,t
heaNtnsn, 10 which, ~ he result Of ia less
sa'c'cea' !aSFs;'g1'i1a," " he eiains to hsrr dis
'ac slis Of conversions to Judassm- Az
"na Ie3c "hteh Is rea1ly tn4st.r!y he. notB.th-
h'7a''ny h9 elcss saperdci,t loyeatioat on ~ mo-
.szses ecs!rc II bo ioformei Of .tha r.icslazs
II ettccustsncts' Of fna tate ,onFefstona T
IN tEe !tbcrtt, Af. Editor. Of ustpg your col
I'M ~ polnt ont to him method Of obtaining
ssscds ii eieat ,st9masloa 0sed q Which Indeed he
iakt combination 10 ! subject On which 90 f1neh
haa already been aaId. ~
~ ~ nc mat place, leg the gentleman = pardon
hnxeTes, III hts late letter be has confessed hin.
ee1t 10 ne one. acknowledge my mistake, aqd. Ia
peculiar. slers concerning JudStam. hi niWaTs
ttaoo2h- lhat T. be Jew &ua1 must serve not o5i4
- pHn interests, but also those Of hi fellow-mau:
neased aot only Of hts own t1be but Of All tr1tex
anu tAAt le nusi regard his religious belief not a.
= =. G.ess, % " worn aud cast aside pleasure,
setsIed ouJ npoa the termination OF his xs.ence.
tlc gentleM1n descended 1tttie frou that 6ln1.
e.. oi intellectual a7tstocFacJ which b. believes
upon those Je~H who-lf mast Be cn,5rssedS
sEs not tuf3c.enily enlightened to have Aiandoned
WI WI tenS'oo I's h1uons Of Judaism would peth&pa
undergo material change He would for Ia
etanee, discover TINT the sc7iptufu tniuncr,on
Lave tly nelKtbor ~ thync1l ia not s1,Ter{Ti t0
ren,ain an emrsy PHRASE; and also Ii other r.
snecsA' ne Nonld make discoveries auple epoQQn
y eonFnet htm, If be Il capable Of conyicuon
inat the inner truth and eals1torJ power Of
llbei4 Judaism which l. gene1allJ the means oI
procuring chnserts to II lie would perharm
further cease to bc guilty Of tbs absurdlty Of mnr
tn4 an assertion Aud then calling Upo those whose
noaFes he inpugna to adt1co the proof IN III
slpJurt
When NJ. Rosenshal impu,es to "ieAzatd raao,s "
ne publication uf cases Of conventions with q ]
t!e" 10 thclf oNn EioH1cat1op, !" he states what |
y hs lnTe.ttzAtlon has really been Whist he says
u MaA he must know to bc untrue "Learpcd |
fInbts en- certainly not bo held responsible for |
leublleath'ns made without theIE mpWiedRr and |
10 nut even strive for the very dublous honor Of
@SshE an account Of their actions publ1Rbed
lhey leave to other men the pleasure Of bcholinR
Lhftf namca ouce week On tho hist page OF 4
ae*aparer, and feel no ensy 1t such diRu!ned |
smoseMent Indeed. theJ are simple enough 10
&c ooniented with earning the satisfaction Of thetr
aions, ana are quite willing to conecde 10
o1htfa tht merit Of attempting more.
u nj. Ros<uthal cannot aaree with tho FORE
soloE, and does not consider II good Sign Of the
.luea, the learned Fabbt*, 10 whom he repeatedly
'tlat, would, nm cNnvtnced, take great pleasure
4 9e1DR tauRht by him to fofSake tic nath4 Of cr-
'or info which they have ssra5ed, and 10 being
vi az feco0rcnsc, to ocqnntnt him with the
'srGcula1s and circumstances Of those cases which
lass cau.ed him to engage In such a PROFOUND and
'+~ss@t1ul " lnf fe8tlcatnh- E SAPUTALI.