, 1869-10-29
SUPERIOR t.OCRT.

~ t1'FssklHlG CUltkI.
OS HEAkISa.
catsssn, rlrte L Co. Y. Ru!prt n Freeman, Tro
Sfr tGr tic recovery Of III. value ul ~llk4 ETC. al
ItEcu 10 havc accn etolcn irosn pla,nti1. sui OF
hearing.
TIE 7ELECRArttG IMrgM;tIo,
Atlapfie Pacific TelegTapn Company '. Tht
Mississippi Valley National Telegraph GompapY
Ir. r. fsc,1c At2I's Ie,ex1ap,. Coapauy. oi tds
1njttct1on Aua;alntl Thu decision Of tho Cour1
WIS as sollow1: "
,h.s t.. az tc,.n .tMrsn 1As esnss.p.as aad the
s..d ,ns r." st ..ssr; eat,nf,.
TS1a' tic rrtF.e. NJ n"" ru'-t.tias Is Iu.iowr:
t It 11s sts,ss' s 4. ' {. ,s aa,.s' :s1s IL
~ ,Eettea1 ea'aH,rti,u Il Isvvts each IL ths
uhsf u ii 1s l. =: .a q
Al tlst; 10 5eeInnt .i.:e M E':.c sHd t.u,a!Ay
,L,it s..s.t mutually esehaase al .'asIntss
ss osT IT, ~.''i ;ise se'fn Gs M .f
thr.nsh cbieas?,o Lcsansso.t. tor twenty scsrs
;T IT, H. s d S.;,s n;s,se s.'a Il Il 'Es,
sgt1turit tts tht' Ht+ .f til txy c..,u,a
n-- ssd in care ii ttIri peTtva 10 h
sr.ns y i t.,a :, II vi t .as M 5ss 'a.ass ;,1
;si. a. i: l. !; tN s ,s ;;i r. .bi
es,r Ih-y ss~r ist Iii. etrs. ~. in is, z 1rna m
tr tine ri IT, f1uat.n until III. present t,r sud tha;
f..:s until atsut s* IN" & si:x ,ir ta II aesc,
ist slIe deentant thr Mi.-I-.tpji vi vy tnItu1sI
tH's rsh-, Ia: .r*-d T. sa,se r.~ III il tsrr ri.
@ .1s;,r Ir,n All, ',,*t' Il i, = Il i ,,
s-nrr. santL AID tn,s 81. r.ul mi /, ST T. M.
saH xsr As,s 70 1usas s es'F, HI = T.s III
s;5sid T., tL.s e.urs, Ills sf.ss:ss vi" l. csE.is Lilo
7hr, tst.Etzl .essttnr. in ~ .;i a.:dc.s m II,
arr th.s Tic tn-iutrs II thir stitrs'iss Valley Tets
;s, :. ais";Is s!.s - e = inu ctEss viii
sat Il IL t @ : III 4. s11n N, @ e. 3; S
thr,n = r",.s -. }."nt md s' rs.st' ~
a .h:+t ii1s ii ht r.es, l.. H.. cy.ptainaat nsa
:4Ia4x. at Lore of Drots t4. vuii IL fEonl
Th;s Id l.- tes, .rnc,d~s % 4, to ~. ac IN aaaL
:n.i aIsua.ta:rr I:sh t,rtuS h.ns ;hr eA.e some.
.re.t'tdnn:a ' th. dtt-nd.tt. u effect iii Lie md
s<:i s ss :: ss's sss VIII IT i;iss 81
tns sha M TX, s,, L ,b u nt u ~ IS ,h ~
ls11at ~. To snurr III; ia wig +'ui tho Ahtissspi
III detsnaant. ,he Pae;ne l. Atlantic u,nr.uv. in
iis snsa ~. h.s'. zss'tt 10 tie e.'Fc. suAle
III f. nss Z sns.as
Tie ~ a thu M.s-1 H. tpsSs
Ad 10 eHsEa to rusp &c thtte y aIJ .n.a a1i~uee.
c.nam. Il s., -: hsssvs. - .tates ~. s kae1,
tratlou between the t~o PARTIES that there rl,a
;ion 4 intTs! tntct hanfs Il n1r.. aud IT bu.ae.t
adsas 81 psisle.l.s adsslt4eso"s slIsaseas,; = ~ Il y
tttlsI u Tie e"npanet. AID Itlte N.Aou thi. fact
t;.n.a., IL tessi is.th III 14s".he csaaIe.at, 4,
.s.; s:; N aa a;;r az ., ,ns.Is . = .s
!hit es tatth; and claims 1hi. ente dtcncA u
7!e csher detcadarte make aa.v.s. but It i. mt e
rtst.;5 10 aiase I! 'he = = u au~si,s' Al thu
tf.s - bs:sps; ssat,s; i s
st shs Il. ~ u IL Ii lii
e!tltr to ieuy o! eLt-t. to eT.,e u. ,<nnlanee q
ssSss Ii :a ~Isa IL I
~ 1s 10 sasr sn i III t .s na =: m o
ti-ss:nf !. .s.ie s..s1 shf. '7,iter. e ~. kpi
I'D. nr.cr ~ ST it i, n1,ne s X" % X ts
,'l -, ns rusd- the rute'.e. IN a!.ti"a, hat FL u,
~ 50 i.S at. = s s:5'' s:.:;ss ass:s :;
II :. TT "a es aser
our 4tautr. here nt,de ~ l1s4 lsc ,hs 10
!.S;s s,m q, ra III ."'o E'~ as1e" A' wi.ssr is
7le ,t.tus T.. ut y. sn E:i.'u r:a III.
:!it. tne nia5e.4i A.. ii. nj c.:rs;s:t5u II
t.st i ths il ast::v- III r.<..
II thr d,ttiEa silt has nn-Nef lhc bill ur ~,
..'~t. I; :, ste '',sl,s :. 7" ~, ~ wlusa he -
/, in sa"vg in /, = :. ] ..,: - ass.wsI ~ sa'tS j.
IT,. l', :" f. =. s..'. ,s' t,' h.t ths INJUNCTION
v..i. sI'.tskn ot thu htt. nm, ,h.t 'sed IL di.-
iii. ,,c. tx,ips tetn ew. IT, 10 in ds,. fern think
1t! is,. ,ss!., I" IL .r. :: ii: iii. Ap,a il
;'..ten e + ;s .:fss s:;lST ~ .
IT, ."" s,st srI 4 " ~ ~ IF c1y n, "1ers.a 70
r,r1 III Tsaatiu itMr.s th!t t.a,aia vi md The d.
A;s IL s;a e i: a..;s ": x: .suf % :ssus s5 III
It'll l u ,a.s m snTs sss. H. ~.
I'D !t,c ars wif. .aa :is.r.sa. q, H. A.;.itd?e
L. Hs,,S z sst a. III. s HI M b,
tsavsrir u. siax X Il; n III,
have lad lt-t w-tat than new. Hrre sre sse 1xs
IT, IT, .. ~ se % . sa s S.sss IT,, 4ts5a 4
fhl1fr Vas F1tft s1HtE n rH+G
athAd 1xsees Inyns n. orr Il =, eoursnses- In
Il aaniss TIT /, in<@ IL. r. - ~ ,,,.ou
Of bu.rees bes~ceo tn, swu s''urs7rs. Sow. .a Whit
sA Il a1s est It. l' aa1aas s !:
III M I'll sd 2. one :. y. IN
,Sis s'isT5!;s ;s[s
T aSest
;:s;a,.. :, sssSss: sss ,ss i ss:s:.sa as1 =!
1lstanee est u Uhsssa rhsasa l. eanrcied vaea
T. r.,.T .aa 'saT .as !. se @ :" VI i e se
.s ~ s Sas 1 tas '; Ut !. IT., 81. to - % ri s
ct ssl 80 10 t,d that tt.- Plea il IL ren.
aSud ie Ia .so:ians VI Wh ,aI!e
'z : IT r s..a,ss ... y: -. p.
o. III Tie , a sh s - I'll q ss Is; qsse
1ns GI a. hs.S ..td .f't1 t!il;s o.t liz eaus>+
by ht>h It hAd tte.ui.! ists 4 s.trd it tGs
e-Etinc: a7enten,ea, fAtols!, to Il: Aad Il !,
ward u 70 rrtsrl, ternrr ii ii thr.- aTs. sses. and
ale" ~ntta Il I. sca>r ot.t nsilt thn app
ncta t. ;n.t .Iee L, ii s ss ; xhieb Is - u as ~
iAia slis itjnnsttnI H.. Al. sI.Ar-. .slsit: T1.ry
!, +; ;1ins X. X .e f. s. tsrr: ~
d., n: E:sa:s WI + ls1ss, aal .ss thty car:
r.. err'''f . r'+ r. i~f .ci r:iyt, IT, pn,at
tu' drsd L+s T., thr hr.u,. sva< t:a' s.i;n;aain-
~. : .r.rs e;,4tt:'s u rac *esr ior e.t1 fl =
IT,: it, ,: n VI: t. !. en eI q tstsx t. ~
t1s,.*r M 'e saA' a,5,af sas
ssa;,, ~ ,n.., , :'.t: = tic 1i.s yeaE s. o
.asA H., t., t., te' ~ = Ito Of boS I. Iaes
..r1:, sSt v:iea sn:: s,..;t9, ot srez, ,io9 ny
~: H.: & d. III 2 n. @t,d .a.s.snss i,
taas ins9 rsr rn' rrs+etive pnhs. ahieh ~ :,
u! Z: ~. 80 s4t rtu ,, r. ,e1a:
iss i; - =. N c eas a,sss bses, :,
T't r,neirkl a5.e7,. hnts,s,. ~ I; hsItJa. t,|t5
tn~r ~ IT ,Sm't ,s ,s lin ~ 81
ir ~ r. -. as*se aFy i: u. = IL
srn't'1s' ties may n:t. The, s. g. IN fr, III r. u
a1a rho tsulv eone7er1 ,s,,, !. /. ro n., ., ~.
sE = FS..e r. M ts .,- {" r. ;r,. L ns:tet II. III
s;T.as f. T rsre ai.sse ~ y'ns:n. u'ss ,se
:.a. sa Esa III ri. c: rc
fer ny II b,i fe f.s L ,a :. atsE sss Ssa
AZ III L. n.is :Gsia .as 10; i+ss.s: E e.ssn sa
G l., !. !:., ri 1 Ii I'll. z.:.i ss, .s s
rS.s' Il tsfo5 9; :nt es::i..... shi;h il
Little t7aa p.ns s.. j. tonsF; rvtJ ' f,a f.sSe AZ
i,'sc "a ~:!eht and e~Lsi. -tan H,th th- Ca:t