, 1869-04-29
the 1YLER-Pol'cE CASE
Third Day OF the Trial OF the
Five Policemen.
The Testimony for the Prosecution Closed
and the Defence Commenced,
Discharge Of Officers GALLAGHER
and Beebe.


Justice Milllken's Eyidenoo.
The trial OF the I've policemen indicted TOT man-
slaughter w:s resumed in the Reeersfer eouts III
10 O'Clock yestert!ar morning. The attendance
Tas yer. large throughout the sesson "u'co laS'ed
Until clock Many Of the personal friends and
comparIpps Of the accused Nerc clustered within
the railing, and fer'st' 'fscp's interested IN the
proceedings 1hc fsfe1 "fncss put upon the
stand wAs
u1Ii4M HAEBOrH,
vho tcstIncd as follows; am alawyer, practising
IN this city; knew the late Judge Ty3er; WIS pres
cnt nj the rd.ee Court On the 18th day Of Dcce1p-
he:, a!en MI alteration ensucd between deceased
hl Judge M!Illlen; Tyler was contluctnc the tle-
cnce Of Il 1nan charged with keeping ;lIsorier1t
hrEse: question arose On the admss!bIlity Of
tr':an evidence about the character Of the house
ltfi by defendant; young lady was being exam
Inei t@ Tyler, who repeated certain question
several times to witness: Judge Mulikeu then said:
- Nr Tyler. yoa have asked that question several
,ra ,cs don't Ask !. sny n,ors lte answered .
proper. Judge s,iliken ihea toIa hi;a i
~ciss ;ea S nna yn, to aS
INT TJer refused to occupy II, sasing thtt his
ptAcc rms where defendant was, when The Justice
lin 10 he removed after Dore wnrIs had passed
between them: three sn'ticnrn took hold OF him;
h. said tile, would 'sinart lor thls; lie held on to
the railing bnt did NO: serm to use any resistance:
think nnr of the officers chukch hfEa severely;
there wr's. fous n:lecrs who had hu1d Of him when
outsids u The b.s: ,h!ns that et1!cer ,wearng
badge No. n wIE thc matt who rhokest him, but
cam positively Identify him; he IL either the nan
Or there II a oiiccr us the pocc force who Rrcat-
II tt:rthlcs illul; never t%Inre saw the men tn
kEnr them; I noticed no blood on the stairway
leading INN the Police Court. l SAN hone Of
item Et,ke h:iz,
ttats-t "a IL. inafio. raw Tyler atterwarg; per-
hai's All haur later; he looked ralr, and ono Of
ht* eyes was much hlsco1oEri; sar no bo'h1 on
the s1nri; .hfnk tsa: tic nlsn who wears hs'lye
NJ. - Was tue uHc whu thnled Tyler, but am not
lea,. uau: i MAS Present vt the Police Court
on r'o't ts1ona1 business: there was large num-
ftro Of FeTsnHs present. at the time Ut the atteFca
t'nh Was sitting near the 6snyc. perhaps ahout
Ei!'tn feet ANA. fn''n Judge TslHE: there were
uefs answered the question in her own WAY:
r. cplcct the witness protested aypi,lst the r:ps,
t"n u';,t Of nc ,,', eonsc: aas,'on heard aass
N. qnet1ions hrh he ii,uast we're ,awfal % al al
jus, .II.lgr stxp1l nrI.5.r1 him Il, .it ti01n.
did not hear T,1er griIisc the second time to take
= Feat; heard jG.i.:. Mlxcn flrc fItu A. fur cnn
temp, !! court lr ,i'l nut pay thc anc; Tylcr m
t!4t hr naui t3s, 20 II :, cha!- wns ir,rht IN him
cnr n+.rr nlrr.,<cllr Ty"r drst. fh"rl ohrrs jnii
l"ld "' Inn. ,ftrr ttr Coun crrirrcd him IL he
III. rln1 f.1lr ln'i fn n him lt,sie thn tar.
rr .sIft.l IL" Railing, ami In that way offered re-
si.!a.lrr; th,r then fnn,ri hin, npflv he ,1hlul
ro -,h,t.ar;.: hc pushed IN. Officers un This il
lh, Ihrd liar In .r testified In ti4 rase DOM
rcrs,4,,t tiat taw 1fr ta,,, al',s tf any nf liz.
trt.r4 tr;, down ,ln.i-,, .ryIrT Hns ,ns,tls thr
r4iI|r, wmn ta,irrmuu ia. III nv thm;vt.t. a,,.
,1,. il, !, i'm Ills ..,rr t"A hin r ths ii".,, :;
t.s M him l., ri III. ~" s, ~ If tn, 1nl IT, u 'Hs coA' ae
a. .jitrr.. Aiirr t1u1sr r,1.r xaa ,atcn on,
pnr,r ii the af'l"rrs rsinrnt i, thc tirt sson,'
au Itr ,,,,r u,,, ,irn w,u,. la,lt.. Nh Nj n,,n,,
lhr,r WIZ ,hr ,.r,,, thiuk, wi r,r,,rf, TTl"r:
ms s,l. liz, lnr vi t, fi,,,.. IT the nl,rr2 linn
anl hui /; y.s,I ,r,us!nm:ty in s,r ali thst ',..
cnrrrd: di.l m. ~, !, !, ha,r tu,,,ri +, jnavr
'r,lrr: | u,,tcrrloe1 Inn, n rem ,,,ttrc VIM M.
ts,,, Mt n l,ar tnr',,r r. me- .:!",,r ,hn ~ i
irr ,pw Ts,cf hres tnn. r, wrsn tr n" linz NJ ~ ",
7,..fl,tn.v fv .tt. ! ,,1-.ny
-. u. .'ntH""u, srt,,u mn II !aw,rr mn, rrAr-
l!' Ili III. r, Nm. present 1T shr Iluc uf til"
'ulI,: I ~ns atIir.: IN frnnt Ut tiln .tu1ih'r r
af.s: 1tt1r' Tskr NM examining n ~tnr.a. n,.,1
t,t"ht'i anrhtI,1 nr.rra1 ti'tt.a, x,Irtl i,tgt.
Mia "a ns'irsrs h". 10 strip: r'E"r n't",,Iiu1 In
'"sn' lhng: i'nsn LulAu MH:Lk.n Or.
t,t iuL4 III pIl .!uHn: thrre w,'tt'
la ct...h, r,nss .,:'r nj llst,1. .t,Ah
a ill., h r W 'o:.t. ,u,: u ",i ] is' Ia nn n'.''n WI.
r'I:s'a; n'nr" ""''n nrs'"i Whit ttIslhr MI
~, II nF,tri. tn 10 i'nr: tl'' rr!Gs"i: srsrsh
.6rF, "s't'' ''.ll4"l; tH!'rrr T.,":l tn,s ln!t III
I.Irt' r 't'lar hut t'r-r Hrsirs 1uuk trll uf hi,
ann; t'"E,''h" T,liys.t n,n, l'r'rs. ''rt none I"
u. "!.s iin' l,.F. t"S Inn |" IT," EA;s. wnI
iEk +" lEls: r''.s1r"tn >ltnrifr nftrrwart: thinI
t4" h"nt h!.H"l -iat4 IN HE hlAir"ay: Ty!c
W. l''rdlt freely Tram tin. !l1'a', lld thfre Nd
~Ar ii. h,''" there ~, t'!rta Oh hta shirt-col
iai, .n! s:t, fatr n:La shath r"useM; ltsGry a1,'
Tt..ti lr1Itd to take Tsler Oil VI !hcrouri-r0om
f''.~@I.!Ms" fith n: one that nsst III
:afraehei l:Icr %aA le1Eyea Wien TIL: officers 20
lstn +, Tie r.ilt':s ~ fr:4rts! hln".ii nyalnst
Win his ftes and tlr1t s@'S holl of II he strns
Eta soinr"hat ~Eil btli1s s.'niuctc'i to The door
sa" !nl''' fhn mss .a' ~ N rrHE:-Foo;n VIII
iEG lnsoher a,a ~, , Mot ios4u'e 1'An more tha
Nv" "t'Ht o'1 III A.tn. ,,
!--a,1's !Gtntlis t"o Pe!ife!nfH IS Ha:ln
,at.n II ~ ~ u u ssl%t-ii.1if5 Afld leu5ea;l sa1
nah PITY ~ Ish,ea !. t:s th. fs ,ner ta,oIE !;
on: thty walked fast; short zine a'teEwara til
1''o nr"tfs re- uraef. 70 ihe con1 room u VI
l,; r. s.;.ls ,se thi'4tcs; aid hoi STE Icu5ea
TE-T1AosT Of vA- ErcELET.
'tfG*Tt i L.. .7'ern: am ""i:ccman IN
lots-iI' Aec., =, tc :i1nory. wien the difficult
was in ,tserattes last, Htirrr Dccce l,ruu2h
r.ls-F ti'ra 'rn'is Tia courtroom snfo the ONCE
;ae :r r ,sn iSa tsw sreeks .t beo o,s
oili'.:- "ih E.:4i. -
T. ~-.smi." i'm: Only one officer brought hi,
Lay u II. ne %s re Tier ~ vas ast not H a ,!
::!na e Il: ste w:.s there :s';It tseasy minutes
II: ..::islr told me n TAXI thu Prisoner anu kee
T.trc say .*Gnsi A-n the Sons Of b-S; the
e.n,s hrft me- ANY, hg ai.lnt say hs was hurs-
1iie c.ise for lhc l"riiis wis he1e closed
John Va, tr1ran, I.ss., .as .; the counsel Il
1ar dct>nce, Then 'rs"ns :tTs..'l the jary, CLAIM
ft..c, Gear explanation cf tlc ca,,scs Of ,jIig
Tt!eT'* s!c.ti st'i:!d ac given. It., oGl hc show
liz sail, that death pr.4accI s,y q disease 6
thr t!tt,1 With hpl existed itertur to tue tin,
OF thr difficulty: that he hal suffered fenua thi
Ccinrlnnt. which vas produet4.c Of t3e-tr!cttu
~ tie tar.egrs CT tae throat long ,imc prrytou
n1 1t. occurrence uni priur .l,sl,h he hal ma'l
,or":nli.iui II l]i:ltsi Ineet.'ing from his t1ea
El'14: nj Tie P.!i Cu,sl.
Il. t. A.ll,r, l>tl.. sups+d that all tile defendant
cSre,.! p,Er. anil TtllyvH, liz discharged.
This 1uotrn WAS objected to hy the counsel II
dsrce Il Cfieer Deerlle having hal charge Vi it
prlsnaer previous to his delivery into the hands
~. .''"s.nr ks"rtr
guilty = concerning t,T1cers Gaashe. aad Dcebt
7ssso were accordingly discharged.
7E*11Ao>S ur JUSTICE AiLL1EEs.
Chicago; have occupied that ullce for twel'
Yeas; On December II, 1S5s, Was Police Jnst
at tie Aruu1y; saw thr lat+. Judge T. IL. on Il
AFTERNOON: OF that day; he appeared u counsel
the tlcfcncr In m action brought by the Ct
against Hartman -ad Oat!uan, for keeping q d
q. prosecuting w1tucss. Size waa examined
mt and Judge TYLER aftecTnEl cnoss-examn
.r.t.rtt1 l.t vfrn her ami t}afu,au- hc asked h
several times 10 rcneat the answer: she respond
10 thls Anal she had a1rrafF answered I
t.i1. stlun: | SAW m variation In her stat
5"nf: ,he oue.tton was INT T,r Il
lou III lime hv Judge fy!er. viii
s:.f 70 hro You hare nst "a t3,,t = 1rs,on ~.
..,:.! ,trr.. You have rs,carl 10 ti,ts rnonrh
answered ai,s7tp,ly thst he would AK thnt nue
1vl, Ut any other question ii often as Dc r!ease
c:.nI rfu,t. III th.; !r sail: unslr / t.Sd mn
tahc q SEAT, hui be- refused; tic then sa,,i
would do 10 il chair should le got for him; q 81
1Tus ,aca,e1 for hitl, but he al,aiu refused 10
down. aid tnel Tin for contempt ul Court:
s,t,l "Fine away:" uskei1 him II he wouli r
MS tItir, :l,;i he sail he wii ,tn:: thru urlcl
Inn Il, ivavu ttlc col,rt-y.Au: te wouId not:
<lcre.i the officers 10 taxi, hir, out when he s:
IN them s:1f .nu tnuch me- ri ,narc you SIN