, 1869-04-05
not ne supe1.isom' duty to do Il This cses1t

jurtsd!etion Of tae pnited states Circuit Court
lIwful!J aeqolred. No one can deny tha1 - ~ :
my scqni1e Jurisdiction. These court, tnoTpfFe,
hare concurrent tarisdict3ou- It u Obvious tGas
both, nj the satnc time, csnnos exercise turtsdie'
force II and the other deny It There can b 20
conf.ct bert, for ths law provides ~ opeo noo
III IL. xben q sse .sa
haze concuHen, tur.siisaiou, and nc State Courts
mt Acqulre Jurisdiction Of the subject natter In
e,omplsts1y deps1ses the FEDERAL Courts Of Iars-
I X pdrts Ros<it., 1s. 1nsa,sod !:
Taylor ct al ea CarryL ~ How, E93.
lhH 1es been referred . ~ adjatbeaaon In
ene esin1e IL lie ssste Or fedezl Court. = ~.
nine casea In Fede,ai Courts and several b the
State coa1ts n SUPPORT Of thts docts1uc. II u
ides 10 sussain Il Il csnnnl be denici - '
Which Court &equlrsrl Jurisdiction of tho subject
matter OF the sah dHtf II Is Unnecessary to In
ton Of tho actions Of p1slnu6 therein upon tho
eeopon1 o. new % suit m ! am clearly Of opsnIissn
queat}on IN The view tha. ii ID but continuation
Of the action Oh the coupons
The earliest Of these hctons was commenced On
The injunction suis IN the state Court vas COM
menced on The 18th day OF December, 1857, tnat u
n Appearance Wa entsIsl Y tho suit 90 that daJ.
mtnecd two yeats and four months before those u
the Federal Court: and, II the State Court &c
ag5en iHasq ,qs r. sso Gous d a
qulrc Jurisdiction. win consider that the iD}unc-
ton suit MA commenced On the 15th day o. De-
ceMbes, 1876, and not MFdrc whether It wes
continuation Of nnotner Rait commenced IL 1854
~ claimed hy plAtntinA
Ihe petition 1nmeieat IN 70 t9rm ~ sn1 h,ars oss
ter. What wsa the subject matter Of Mhleh INC
court thereby acquired lur1sdsetous TIC PETITION PETITION
eniene 'ns snd from @ eonec.lns ny
for The ol csrtain ~ npn ,na ~
"1n ,ts ~ HhSt ar ea aa. on1e she SUB
jess matte. consist o. ,l. o. The ss following: ,a
= The d1ty OF the county aa'aoF'ues 10 'e'5
II tho county authorities had no poTcr 70 lerJ
the tax Tss not thef aat! 70 70 no' tuS ~ ~ ~
poyen 1sS1s II ,i M conictel Win tho awful lsats q
| dnty 70 1cTJ The tx z.,..x =, nm tn
Junction and mandamns ac,.ons wss tas s1mo; :, 3ns
r1 rSasohinG 1na1 n1f1 H. {rnehca as atcn Ths o.
@ ~ pe in a9 10 nrcssn, the
anN coltrcton Q! Lnc taAca I'VE M aIse,tar.
Intended to en1oFee tne 1esH az ,nies 1onSesaGn u
| tnefrlofe, >ac ea1ne suplee' nAtsa = eA'o'e 49,
| both suftA r.,,,. A.. M. nav. ,n-
nfSe1 W. tnal tae ~ inr Fu Ho.rd nI' Of supr
ason q ne ,nsrefo, Mh,e he 4 Wss comsnt o.
lot tn1t SouEi u nIQuSc ~ ~ " ts ~ 49,
matter 81 me asuon. w. g ,, y sv, - a1
NJ meneed aad appearance made while. the County
Judge u!senAgco III tns LaASs1vas anra,-.snrs ~"
performed ny Lne ,cnu ~ ~ ,tTrs Tne
! among ntnefA tne lcFJlA9 " s S anS
action vas entitled Q! ~ name no. !. mo ana
etye Of once nna 30 conanoeo enute1, pu. "1s -
AGAINST hin ometay tna1 rsnS. s W. souXn, snHo, a.
appcats thai the superssora cnp1o{eu eoanseI 70 70
asfena tnS Snse Wy va ~ + rrrnv:
District nna SspIens ,h.t a,4,, ~. y
tnoash ri speaf!ns ~ si{ e 1 tns 5seon. as
sss Nd poSea psna!nias e sesa,, @stssss i. ;ns
s5nz q @ vhTa sa1 ao Ssf9T r. tsss Se
they were required TO assume ail dntiea 2ert
tanning thereto, before belonging to the once
fns Hs asnnst Sth the County Judge oiseia1 ID mat
should employ counsel and through nun dsssna a;
therein even though no change should be made IN
Its title Our code Of procedure 1sots o substance
Cd I On nccount Il the want o1 form IN proceedings
Revision, e7a4, provides that no action Shall
ahate by reason Of ne transfer q ny lntessal
. ! thtre!D during Its pcnueuty, and thAt the 4cdor
may be continued ag1tnst the original parties
This section may not Be complsiely applicable C
this case, nas = e!seu As an lnaS1a1'oa u ou'
, | general system OF procedure nrc,,4
II Is also urged that the decree is void becanss
the holders Of the bonds Whieh bore the COUPONS %
ton snts have no diflcut{ here,
Under the Constitution q lowa these bonds and
coupons we're prohibited tae county nsn no na1no
nnnlttes suth = the eject Of the adjudication:
Of the Supreme Court Of our saate, and 40 cous'
soa aes rssa fee eei see +
daeTently 70 case Nlthlh tner !orsaiet,on y
not Pretended that thsSs decisions arH n e9naac
With the lnws or CONSTITUTION OF tne untea atalea
: fore, review such tsc!zons l am nos, thersfose
Courts Of this State Tor authority upon this point
These bonds and coupons ars anso'9Isu 'aa' anG M
] we're 90 ron the % nea7nn!ng, mag !ney a'o 49, no
I INST Nov. there % AZ no dsgrHs 49,. Il
me Ta.tatEy .. nauW @ .sd.,,s M u ns,,,,nent ,ns5t
r sannot s arscie ~ In measure Wsa nrasidty
nor Can oS N aeH!ee sa ..a, y nav III EoiG ~
Ea and 1!naaa sateIy ,eHai pii 1pu y ~ WY
all toF cause q anotneI e! i ast Is waatn; u;
IL onapH ,%tee Il doe nor 1 srcaIn nn1 deptNsJ
ofa of eou1se oo1 " zone csn % e he ra
{ ing from hand TO hano o. tne ssahs!e9 ot tne n
ssEnment So debt psssss sna ~ snas Is wnat "
ws DO not mean .as paps. Wn!sh asl ts,1 Is sne Sy
eIer ., " tsg sc M nsameu, ssauiIss no shts
I ail aIH'e' " sa'' q" 'A7'' "'''@A'> ''S''' - ~
q psIties that theif riadts night haze been pm
i HshI nut Il i replied thst ~ onkas to nase
day II eou 70 Dc neau n npGn -, sn 30
h aap Sor a6s naa su
brought Hat btnsas Moea ae s1 aaI y h7 NJ e. e..
tlem. ana sha! 1uess;yn ~ mn3 ~ tn n Z,
ssa1on 1t -, H.,i, t1f M hnnas voss smns
pIemc So@i = u usstvIA - - ~ ,.~,-4Tsr+ 7 a'
spoKe the MnRuaSe " tnss w - t,at tr1,
lnt nnss sq ~ ba, no 81 3aI IN coutt pSi tas b
anneaiion asos 70 aaddcstons Of facts not Of av
&c 9Ppnts. " ~ go, - tor-.S ~ thn s1l,,
EJ dazen al ths Ssa!s y = oeu ovs sssn iaS y +
supPee coals sgs - o sse state There nut
! q i e t5 G ne ssop q Mnt
N t1efE Nah, or CUuau uNte uSu ~! SsAE- AuG ~
ae been issued oJ Lse Ioaass sa.st t IL ciatI
g n from ne nature o. nc case aa1s H., steii
I'd the only fact necessary 10 he aandleassd IN o.i
y. 10 determine the quesIoh 9! IaM, "a'eu MAA -
IT. these bonds were pEoMn'tea y toe ia
N and Ii should 80 appear, That INC snpetEsoEs
90 thlA county pau Esusu NJ tusH ~ SoS s.e.sni X
te yooo, opon "4Sh t1 =, ,s5 IN n tn III ~ Il
re Amouut OF monc5. 70 De ussu ~, ~ =. tus ~ ~
81 Czstans against tat InIf3 ann maj n1 Is eo 1eo
Y 70 ne eslen to rav ,S nIeS pu ~ Hot1 ,s1 ta
Seno1 teauss 1ne sfp 1o,aGs ~ ,s Irvr ~
III be naae pAI.! oGtu!s a .h ~ sin " "
sc. A1T feL W oAte seen tnets 9Ss ts.s " ~ =
Et gtcea IN The validity Of lostfune14 aese , ooa
Ho9a @ ~ 1so's na nnn ~. tntsd r. H. ss1
nc nghts ~ noiaeS 2. = oa,sse1. .t,ta ~.
Illustration WI maze ne 4osaloa INa AAsu'n q aS ~
6nGns St1o t11 hS09 nn{.Iiui Iii no r,ss,
VT what ID r1ohnon o. ~ 11gaI* W Hniea ne
~ no otnet refaSaI. Aitet tae dn1ahe1on = II ~
d. Wa TIC only one 70 be benefited BY BA unlaw
the nets. and Waa not undc party 10 me setioa
ne THIS u tne precise csse before ne; me nosass
mp ton against the county authorities 70 restr'
m them from leyytnE taI IN violation Q! laT = '.
us because be, the only one TO &C beneoted oy
sou tax, WA not part, to The suit
hy II II be necessary thni The holders Of aneh v
n Instruments be msde parties TO pr'eeeding
10. resrain 1he collection t, 81 nas 70 Pay des ~
NJ nnF rmedy. The United States