, 1869-08-13
THE EXPRESS WAR.
THE msFrhnntA' IEnion and Atucri-
can Express t:ompAnte>-DpsulO
by Judge C:arn0xo.


can Express t.oMrAnsc&-llpsulO
hv .us[rr t,:.ruoxo
rs.m fhe yf,r y-yrk T. :ban., <s,.eu>,,e.
lr the Supreme t,onr1, Ctamherl, yr.tpraiar, be-
fore Nr, Justice Car,luzu the tElta OF McSIcSa1
W. Russ et als Iiu1r,. w. Russ ct uls: WtltIAtys
" Uots i Ct ais IN re- flusklu " Ross 1t ais
Faro Ut uis ys UI..ch,oru cl ;.l. CANE III Tor
iiec,slo1.
IL mny fpa rencn,errt1 that certain OF the stock
l,ut,tr, u In. Mtrru,tt.. ulu,l Exres- LeJpa-
mr. Lnyr.a .,n,, rs :,TO nnu.rd and trotuht Anil,
il, onnn-,tlof Ia tile cGfi.t,lldatlou al rnc Wtr
c!,a1ts l'n1on and American Exuress companiss
and int 1T a L,,er .fuy Mr. Fnrro 1he Prrsfdent
M Inc nut) co,n1atIts cu1uI,eIlcet, ~, utlon 10
tu1,IrI ulI ms. Opuuerts to Unite III stilyl:
n.f ,1,,.rr- e.pn, t,.f,ra ~ Insftra fsnr,;n
~, n potlons IN 1hc n,fferr,,t snifs for mn uunc
t1pn 10 dissolve I'LL 1niunction for q Receiver 10
t,xc,,.,,, IN. n,r a,,,;n,Iir, r,,n,,s .itau Ra
rnynr .,un N sfn NJ; ti.. sfs T,rt.nf iiu iit.T
~, ncT,nn. u..rs II. urvutf1 fn1efher nnh al sr..
now dIsroscti Of 'y .Iadee csfdozo-he no, ap-
r,rf Ior tte yn,rc or thc Ncfcauilt.' Uu!on prun-
trts h. ,io.s not remove Judge Alien, aud only
rctau, the inunct1oI So lar a to prcvyE: the Old
TN. Is thc ontntop:
Ey tar!ozo, jim the tIst three above entitled
t:c ur,urT,y 1' Of ine Ncfchauta Gn,un Express
{uI AN. a;,.t il, Them Q,1 to tho n,:ty7 fou::ulf
an..yr cp,it!ed ! am asked 10 remove lhe Hon
Vim. +. Alien from The position OF Kecelver OF q
ccrluin p1ttlvu u such property to WHICH lie was
arnCltltcJ bT IN ortler nude III the suit Of Ius-
IiE II. 1loEs. etat have concluded 10 delay these
0low!ns Feasons: think that ut THIS stsse OF the
i!,:galiuu The relief songht IT, uuder the circun.
sItlceF unnecessary for lie fuI! protection oi the
l'p.Ettfts AMI would ',e j needless hnrnshlp upon
scEc Of the dcitndauta. The aa1ount Vi Alesen-
tnnt s'ts'k is quite lnco's'aerslle IN c9'npartsoi
t!,,'r-ect IL tie pgIeeuelt ol evneontiauDa; Ana
xhli. Of opinion that dissenting sttc ckttlder
IN these totn, stocs comratfes Ike Retiring i'ult
utr iu au Ordinary partnership, IS not to TX obliged.
certairJy lf ali evrhtr, IN IA- Al,-rnce vi express
aertt1utM to that effect, ~ surrender Ills interest
c..,i,aicd lalGa,lon atuu.Iy escertulncd by sale
IN tnt onIy rnGnner sect:nze1 T., la,s, Tor clo.uE
"; partnerships In the ,''7.Ece OF express stipu'a-
i:u:s Yet the crest disparity between The amount
u struG asseuty 4.st that uiascnt.s, uni tlu,
,G-t -t:ir for The ifttrst u hi TIE parties con-
cesn. Il IN the consolidated company ead lie 70
the tt,f.,iu.tnb that such urucr should, aud |
rA:I.s cail, loi be Ille, without Disturbing The
;1t:tn1 condition oi a:!urs, ~ sill mahe tsest
@ . "5se can x ase aaa sas nh
ienhItely the rights q! tat larLiea- With that
view, while denying Tie mutiur for Kccest1
iar :. to prevent uoy attempt to forfeit
stick Of s1Is ent.nk shareholders. ! Rhah
do n only OH conaI4rn that the defentants fu1-
dl the Justices u tnl- c9Ir:, cua,iI:ionea that
;I6l the nnal Judgment all the piopertt which |
hc!ungch to the Merchants E"io1 Express COM |
ia;4. and which was transferred 70 .he consonla-
led cutnr3ny shall, # 70 required ~ the Judgment,
hc ..tstIed Lilo tile custody of the cuGEt. through
s.lch olccr for tist p.ruuse ~ il may nppotut,
aud also that III cart ~ u=t lapse OF t1Ilt, or
otherwise, any OF lhc properly Snail hasE d. |
uIt:lehc, III value, then to uak.. the sarne by
Islyeul III clah up TO the lull value, 10 1t nscrr
;:.i..ti Us hereinafter nluuetl. This, 1naK,
viii r.ottcf tycr3 body, Without dt;fnE hartn to any
o.t- TIE platntlns have Ao alsuut' right,
tnnug il ~ very common, and, Inteei, most Usual
n do sti TO havc:l salt vi the COMMENCEMENT Vi
tny II, ,;1i,tl-us soU;, ~ the properly has been
la;u!tsi o:cr 10 Il Receiver. Their right II thry
ar. e;tIifed to hare the Torcrts sold ls to hare
il sold when they have rtcuvtrrI Judgment. All !
shat they clai.n thu; tfte property shall bt
t1esurl eli until Jl,lvlutu ~ HAT thet rights,
10 rot understand the Gaze Dt Spcef lg:nDst |
ItIrsce1p, decided y Ju'lgr 11ay Oil the :l!h OF
April, tU Witch Mr. Scwell invited NY attt.tlDu
:I1rr ;llu argument, IL cuLllct With the c+neru
ru.c tEMt ra!c il the 0c!; 1t1hGt OF clo=:Er Up
p3rtns tship II tat laytaeEs cannot Ayret aLAoEK
itrr".!vrr upon a division, or some other meth
ul. understand Judge l'Aiy to nave done sub
tini'.: HEl! hive .itfcsttii't t1 IN here. Lie
tic .'s'!t'n saohid he safc When :inu! tn''S- |
ih!t Haa obtained 10 carry Ht E't"s
if'u tt.ct 'ue1e Must he j refereuce to DUNES
T.. s"sHIst, 80, 10 asce1t'it ahi fsi4ort II! lie
wine nf each Item. which helohted To the Mer. |
t.ll4f5 t!lon EAPfess torna1t HId which wts
trst:ssfrt!' IL t1 thr rnB*ohdafed company, an'l,
EInn tic Lh11lIlE III Hf thut repoTt ~Ils liz tle
!sry !ti,:s; ave Al condition OF returning fhe
tinlL ~: i,.lItnE the llEEHtIUn, thus 10 effect
vi :;':ln. lhuiu Receivers j4Htenfe tte nave
lirs.HyaIy aruiht,i cXFrCrsiflK ANY OriiIIDu on
sh,. n.tlts Or t1l tl. yatlt Questions dlsc;ascd
tnr t.e, beliE. Ing l'at Ill the view tar.. .aken
q! fl4. Ur,syut Tltct4-t.lcs uf the r13r ought 10
lc.:r t:.c To Lt l.stt.e1 Ut uI1Un regular trial.
Il, spi c:1n the :tr,pC..ii ion tu REMOVE Judge Allen
1runI the .,n-t:al f;rCtl;eTsp WHICH he lufds, 1
HUNK II sufficient ty say lint while 10 no, mean
Il, lr uu,,rfuoH us improving The tc1,0d winch
jh, t;,rJi,a tcoK 10 iIFpr,rc tIt:t Kecetycrshp,
,c, IL view Of tie fact that the Ir.