, 1869-05-02
THE TflER-P0itCE CASE,
Charge Of Judge McAllister to the
Jury-The Cass Stated.
A fef1ltt Of Aeasittl R-sd.t>d

7ne'rtsltE Policemen Ds1r, Telyca and Decett
,n lne ma ans'1"ghteF @: the late A1,sa T,.er Nd
p!otght 10 u closu yes.esuas, afler h,ytn9 occr
laea the assent OF Tie ReeoJe-s Co nj. JuJ~,
sao 1orE dot: Is ':te cu- r. = ~ Til" 7-.u~.1
u Counsel was c91ct,sdtl ] OF ne evening pt Fsf
/ uay. Yesterday burning judge NeAll[s.e1
eaarEed The 1uTF. Rn that h,JF rcir. q. 1871 Il
n me charge Of The Court was ID suts,acc:. d.
The charge Ia this case f. the un1svful 1F1,Toy
~ t1ese tcfentlsnsk OF Aaron T. eE. without m1;,
ice express Or implied It + termed ''n4nsla7-1i.
~. and, ss Il ought u he mstnsaine fails within
| The qualancatioa Of thst offence W our STRUTS
nessEpnIcd ~ "!uvuluutary ms1AIsugh' ct, y whlch
I - defined in these words:
tc~ - atsounthty H.H,l'rstcs s1,I eons', IN The +
" foan,t.si,u Of un,.mful NJ. Law Iul ae t
m linla~ful u4sasrs." ~ u.s. I'D
~ ytHi are veil axarr It Ia c1.ucd hJ II.
prosecution laa; Oh the i3ih D1 .,u,bas 1867 ~
otct1sed, who mas = Iunseitur-ai-l4w OF nj,
city. MIS- attending. II a.tcll, II 4 case then paal
inx before Justice A'ltAcn II The ArmoIy, ani
tnat While 50 acting c3ls,ru n ose b-l Hccp the
aecrz.eti and the Justice, during whIc. tic Jas.
ttce ahlutagcd him guilty 0l coa1cmpe nnrl hiu
Eve do!lass anu incn orsiel- i'm 10 il. rcuorci
iseHi The room, M1c!tnPoa Iac defendants prp-
ceedcd TO execute thai eo&ef, md IN 10 doing he
MA 30 sere1lF cL ,>cd. e.ru'k aud ln,d.e i tlat
IN Consequence u il, a,.-rua' !, on lie III day
Gf January 1863, re tl1rt. 1t ~ atso Claimed tha:
anteT these fartt Tue stst ce Ia no power, after
anlhs ios conlcIna 10 otIcr Lin 70 he removed,
o'', Fnu04A nave laoe oHt !tEn"N warrant TO-
deleadants connecting taaA lucy wels ,I!ecE.o,
"e!e unlawful
HK !on1u 'ron the evidence, tht: =: fac:s
are unqnauoedly IS 1,o:e rtAted, then II The only
authority under which tie ucicauauts as..d WAS i
Mels Siues o. tAe Juse'ts 70 tenove dec:asci
to take hlu1 70 tne lueknl BE- N. Then blch al
=. Muulu He u1la"l4l, au9 H. ~ tae performance Of
y, pe!ono teaapnalls aoan: hey Indicted
altcfwarL died then Ihr1c stf94u be q con-
''Gston Il
nat mere e another aeet Of th: ease, The
~ bJ bscsJ peisoa y ~ .Iaa nppr,s .torc Ju:ee Of
It s5y iexsf rrocerdiux betu.e juS,icr .h.i snxsm
lHf i deccnt orety snd rrsEse,f.. msanrr I'll
L s:!ee tss cootemp In any not ,ia1 aye dol
~ ~ .o,,.,.a. =, .t,x
M ,mnceIire M ~ W.. mo .neer % oenao5 r.
" . GoQtL h1 Matte1 M ho1 ntSn ny roaltlon 20.
&C, - ~ u1 ~ te VANS o. nanau
q poverty: Ths power limited, 70 tsr a. u pun.
II m rf the ssne ou; nc Justice has
i iss as'sset saadsts psry sais9 so9 ef eon sa:
sm!I. S'd d ne PATTY sesc about to escape before
onfsr htn intn HInT III. aae 1as,ce might
~ rIA4e M Nc ., were Gahty ol oreach
n n dts,r,se-,- .nsea5 q. aa ~ ~ nay order
Ihe Prsra ,p pssoa T.. ely, ~ ce .emesed Sasnee Ct
10 canir @ H. tns n sae pa"ef a. aay otn;r Court
~ IN ~ tas conuust On cause 20 limit the
~. ana opllcs5fe examination OF W.T.
c@vrst - 5aa. ~ tls {o"el. may o1aeF
~ Tnnrt.~ deisi ~ " " sateu. !os tae purpose
IN ~. =! ~ tSos u SxpE1naiion,
nctsxs Ia scnaG1 ~ ~ saat ne aeesaseA
s1i ,nn rnStica ,1 M 7tesitvstul tnenneF 70
a.a,ai ~ ;nn ~ tns sustsSe oinesea an 70 %
IT ~ - = s~e. , G ,se euu ~ Nuuiu uut coM-
X, 49,, ~ III !loul tae cslaenecr
mt =, ~: ,.ra ~ U s9e c.! ano present.
~ 10 .n ,E ie 1ns vascs otuesed tne ueceaaed
49, ~ - I;S LILY Arp1oscheo tne aeeeased, 0d
e5 t1 ", .s tiatt ~ ~ ~ .ae at Q! deceased ana
i'!s - pe kea1cH Or rave the spom ts1s
~, :, r. ~. - u 1 r. ~ ~ LuS pals ot Nsul3.
49,. - s. ~. tuuht 3olu tuc es Y euco tnat
.t1,.S H,sS ~ 'oarhi nno tnteaaenin&
a+a XIV 'tpuaseu M tMatt, VII ais uano r2sen "
na.a mn /, II an anery. violent and threatening
,1nh ~ 49,, s.e eoasnh8 A1tl, nut y Nitnn
s. ~ a44t ~ tueA oeeEascu MaA Rulfs o. an NJ
ntose ste, 4!s ns. aH pIsAcn " sue Facs Ann
= - s So.uucr !roM as!esk !os Mnlen nc VAS
y! IN a1 ~ T. -,a Mooa
the ststier h,n. = "a bln ..u aAs III "
t tls ssaen uetoM Auu uetaln nlln teAsonole 1lne
~. Huis SuasE ~ ne rlele!Iea ae1.nst aH+ and
~. ~. sts y ss1 n ~ aISo! MY W ~.
- ~ sls .steet y. VIC SiAs noo4a ut u+H1ti.
II LILLE IL nsceasea ieaSted dor olner pouceneh y
otelcoHe tne RESISTANCE soat 6e might
~. m4se 1o ;1 snen aea would e law
= X, h,,, aaat ta"aut u ouG =! tne EkEemeu
ervuu y ~ Sa,y ~ S4Gens " 1as toscc usSesSsIg,
. = =. = - au @ suuns & au tan,st at ,t " Naicn
mnni = snt,t1 ~ oleo' lnen nc
hut, the act Of removal icing lawful the ,uftc-
tion ot sued mortal Nouad would moi Involve tne
cess oI force by The iI!pct coulIuIss!on Of it.
II ID no, suf1icjrut 10 tn thnr onc Or twn of sev
croi 1atth{ barc Indicted the vound but fhc person
who nct1iaI!y did il m1st fn ascertained I,rrnnT
reasnnah]e t,nnht. Tnc indictrnrrt rilegrs 9hat
the defcDdant vaye The deceasr<i a morts3 wound