, 1869-11-12
MURDER TRIAL.
Eighth Day OF The Case Of ltcv.
Isaac D. Smith.
Arguments for the Defence aud
Prosecution.
Tho 1'rtnl u t,iosc T'o'D"y'

Ttf WeAtHSE H&S cVAt eH1 GHsFbS7a sVh shte'
lss ihl, h sptts Dil H. Ihu Goust ueAss wAa etaSd'
Al il, htar .ht m ptushta IN I'm nasa of Hay, szahn
H. hahh tropts Nts 10 near lh* ap~~ebss u
tueh rases, though Naitf thsy 60 BOT AMaons "
lp,ui. s!lvf lhs tsstImunJ hns tnsn sh hs'u's sha
uutIlt. Tbs euuusut 0n boltl sl'lss wara uh''nH
i4.t ii wuttts tttta tssrnins, whitt lhe1 were
IN tions IL fisspfRs At iha t4Ft, Ths esh'shoa
wss aulnttisd up snd Iaslpwba IN tDsh ssd$a Win
no httls abIllty,
fsAchesi hsrs 1t u n'nlpnk, hth Ifbme1alc'J pro-
xsded lu ths Couit lt0ias.
TaH Juhf.
The juf1 came ID, and theT stisHsfe'l IN l'e't
nsf1,es In low weak tnnek They foot worn 1lit
1l.i1 ttsif wssk = ronansutas. 1heT Afs tIttnAiY
1fisnners faf The Tins betsk Jury 1iis u nos
ss % Tes; ~ .ss 1T c.ss ~. = 'e:ts !: r
Ub bU,h ltts. They ranho! NH 'tt*,a tt" tt'ai
= % r. * s.s'strt II H. sn. II e s8 Il "a. sy.tss .
whore Ihstr IL rats sf* lxhaa III ttvfz.
w. .,, t. ,nsusS, vs,s,sns' ,s'I, ,,, AN, ,t,,ts,
is:Tt,s,, viii rttshrss 10 tna hpssuisa n III awa
ssss H. H. 'ss :sssa's sissaset H. H.
tbsl1n, who Rt,tfras ri hiln pers0nsls, Ats ~
tetIrd psihstlfpll H. b.. yvAssk'.is 9s!lr1. rarn
,esf X al ~ss. esS i,s - ~. 'I 81 aiisetsi y
.1futar rrtstsnca snasae t5 Ms n~N .annset NY,
Nsry. ~ y y! ~! y h'ns ~ az: tGsa.los.
eu;tienee, = hleh eaa Wiling enough to examine
and Rc.uitntx~ ~ r6an.*NAnte+
CONTINUATION on NJ. wlLnox.
My Wlleux rpsun ri htt 4rx,,m ment. EIs set out
cni,c,~a ths casrAesss Of 81. Netzneis speech,
I'D eodessorei DE- 10 10 mulesu tie jary regarding tho
insun amy 10 deoos.t rho evidence IN tho County
E,s,rate to lake enssxe .. the evidence uoauty
magistrates 1o not know ther duty. Couosel vent
on ,o defe1d NJ ni:,ln'on u son.us,ao's
sn eosi.naed lint ias snsu.ac. & Ia I've -
oues one IL IL va Is poor a n,an. xno .aase 10 tsase
nis vile 81 lied il wss proved sass il was al Xfa
o'' o11 il Vss a,so psesea shas sas sop ~as o9 Ike
tuEgy for q long time before the accident rha
prort Ion had d+e!t upon the sta.tme1r Of tbs
smith said INIT he vas eutaeg!ed N The aues.
Another witness sta1ed tnat the lines wese found
tss Ss'1s 9sst # na sas W ss'a mixed
nft ets did nr. snow that he xas mixed up in tie
9ss ~ ea
be explnneti with more probability Oh 'he side Of
Innocence than % the side Of guut. Smith vent
b. bser a!a ien q ID Ign hs insitsa cIsTxs @aa 70 Se
| w1tH hna 10 Benton's- These circumsrAcees
showed tnsi n: snnh dia not presassaa.e me
/ character Of the accused, and tue a1ect,ouase
terms upon which be lived ztth Aa wife ~eru L.
lated upon. ", Aelzuer bad t,1sd to tmpiea'e
ine sss,s. s,tsy Attorney C, caiease g:
ssadb b<oa II IT. od; s9'es ia .ls 10 re aa
ina inas there vas 10 datRer of ns.lnz ht4 good
tne lutnrr Of h.a cb,ldren ,9nat'zeTanud ruined
The trial ruined hin tor ahd staiue1i hts ae,
! TO matter how tzuucent be might be- i hurt hi.
| lie deoorninst,op With vhicn rs va onicialls
| ccnntcrrd. The Kspsecattou Ecyer bae'a ide4
oi TT ::s.a os ne ,G,s1as o. - ~ q
! o. ID spirit Of ptenAAntr~, tioonse1 Concluded
nys ss'ss to the 'u'5 to hoooFao'y ae:n'' The
AxaEXIxr ev UPWARD x 1osEyT roR TIE HtosE~
Nj, Jo.,,n .., tnas e!iios IT, Wilcox naa dt.cnx,ed
and naDKerco. po.nss- l.e tIoslyn} hss enssA.a<-
{, sns e.
could not do X MI, WlcoEfaiIed to e1nlsln the
condition es the horse IN the creek aua The tslrs
atessils @ to 10 s1piar anon ot 1uose poiuts Tners
Has but OF e thing That Cuula clear the pfsootf,
| pn,eh was that ne enofml,y of the cEs'pe % ~.
I Dern employed hy me in.nrau=e co@paus 70 1nd
I'LL Il a ns Wse so,ons g nc ssa L
5o.5n, ~ eup'Gyea By tss q,,.,oe so%paa}
ss,+sa az ,pistsrv s ana Te,tsiop il 81, noi d.
believe IN rercion, and hAd no ena,sy asatnst
bei:e7ed In the Grezt Architect Ct the univerae,
$40 u human accountability. !Asaor aud au-
| 1uaHlty told him tne6a thiuSs wereso. lie had 20
hspoe.tse. I1e ministers aroana then SAID tnt
four four In. Lei them produce Inc irnh lie wou!d
row tpa1 = anger .nsi as e2os1 IT, .,s1a snso
dead asa hare iaa.en ilnm tsing anssl.
se,enee os at toss tn s.0'e epst.r ps Of eos ID
I'd I'd D,unsa ~ ss We .us ! s.,e9 q e,a.e +: :
/ men than f.1litn had falen. The defence could
| not explain the dsmnln9 c.srums'ances tnat sur.
,oosaed ,ee es. Antss 1s,1 Pr 1aSa a. erSs snas
Aen a,nnto in The llssEy OF Aeassu+ Tne ro,'e u
| rtcbtrousE esf did not sAyc Ue1 !fon Inward sln.
| Tne sfgnmept thai minister could not aln snoad
sot nsFss, soe lut7: Ths! .noola a,s not d'o w.,
ccnaen.tt PIC nSe oi the rals 81 sa.an : rsl4tea
Anaelt III, end 20 nd nen. TheJ should taxi
Thai cste as II Smith we'e CO onnoo drawn II
la'orer md is.se nTn<-.,on "od 81 '"ss
aatnister had 10 uofe right tndep,au4 ~ acqatt:a
shar the poorest man who 4uG On ne afee's p
afouud the eoun'r3, from the nlRaeat TO Tue tow
ssi. were h9!stercK up tho case, 40 iiad stst r..
to g rp1 e &c
with levitt ~as tnr faus Of tne countet ior tht
dtfeDce. and Of The pntoner. who tat Al that hal
An resting anhe< auea chasYe. 1iu never x
hsb.ted any feeling Or sorro., Or ahy sstaeace'
rs IL ot TIC n
Nio ID face nrsen. A mJrAl certalutJ of the gpl
OF tho prisoner Ia tnc ra!nGs Of EHe jur5 ~!
.qu,valeut L, CONVICTION. Tbs defence aalu thk!.
WA Eoth..9 IL the lrsurnres. nu: Any .o.9a3 i
| the lzLd, xn0 found cut that sho etoo't fe
s.sen IT, %,p ss;sn s ssA ssss. e.s nus
t3et tleac3n In t'hcsc0 Tho was HsAcoTetoI u =
rnbhfr AID tntet, u.iua h!A plse: - PnstGla7te
- soon+s % nnTdrT W his wlI1 ior aa.al' tna1 tn.t b.
mann. 4 ia~.tr. tasexsuMn. deacon, o. @ ssax'l
vno pats &9.ooo on his wilcs heart and lle, saoa
lr st1t 10 STATE PE1son. Nheu .oulen Est "a
Au1raac. which tney nueht 10 Rtt, they sooaI
IL III M 70 se shai wnc1e M nu.se
soia hs ,c tDr t3oca. lie -p<cQat-t! In Ia @i!s
tf.antel rtterEtd. 10 !" pnept. the m!n:sEr N
n, M:a, 1oSno sos pPt ss sout, :, nsnrns orra
~ .. us,lna saith In getting thu po'tcJ. Vac
MMa VIE - lyaE IN Hogo ~ sae 59nas S1s M 4 ~
IT. house Ebat he might grt '1e PRECIOUS poHc's
!. Eor. b y ,au". Comtne eAcs Evsns spoie Of u
po,ee. aoa a!ssr les'tDg k.0s sboaia an stx
= titIe policies now. d" shnHis9 Tint 20 Ess Arn r.
! EEans snspects's tast he murs. 1sd ~ VIC. w
did smith MI t1c Dc II orofn ~ho Nas tuptrA
:. nuateA and wAa aow tnau1tng women, taal =. !
Z i-utst letpIpg The insurance sec.rs, afraid
n wha. people .aa,d aa.: fhs Insurance was IL
; q ''" p''sAi AfTEaSooS SESSION.
= HIa Honor vaa on time. The colEt waA Gro I'd
I t,~s trh Hus4nE1f With 1FHxf ATE