, 1869-06-21

Hernandez the Ert lr e1ttsrlss heS zone to Eatc
Pr!.1n tos A,tesnlains Hi his wiic- Hi sui.ar
:sunmtEs euf tv EArc cent bin ththet year ago,
ttt 10 esatc h%s cntcrrd
~. P},,n \ h,r ,hc. 81 sn1r ts ~. nd1n.<.
.....--.
eapef1ef CoafL
Judgments were ren1ccrd as Soll1T9;
john ueracher :. ClF1stoN Zimmerman 1,y
confession for Q2aA
Edward c Ryan :. Ma.tia Arcrs. By conies-
sion for fa4
Ann Jane NIner ct ala. e. MIchae, Hx-nea ~ .,s.
Decree 10 allow complainant, n Ruar1iisp Of de-
ieufa,lta, who nrc mlncrs, 10 borrow money On
mortgage on the ndrth half Of Lot .. yloct "a
School Sect!on Addition
Nrw SITS
Ann H. Payne =, William Il. paype ct als.
lllll 10 neffec; tt1o 10 Lot D. UIocr sd En1Ies Ad
dliiUu.
RAILRoApcAsk
Patrick 7. Clifford :, I1ttspuyeh, Fart waync
Chicago Railway Company sad Pcunsylyaula Cen
t~al RAIlWA AZ Coiupapy UIll Com aIajnant vns
contractor on the ROAD under the Pittsburgh 4
Fort Wayue !a1ilroad Company. He recovered
Judgment against that company IN the Circuit
md seets to recoTett froa The '' pfssent
organization, The defendants resist m
the ground nst the sale OF the roaa nrdeg DEGREES
ot foreclosure In the District Courts Of the limited
states tn Ohio, Tentls4iva11Ia, lndtsaa and inols
has c1ls OF the creditors Of the PITTSBURGH ron
Wayne Railroad Company CuQorI claims. In hts
bill that The foreclosure prucced,n1, Werr anntc,
bic, In pursuance Of an arrangement between lie
bppl and stool khOlltTs and t1at IL Kns ontT a cns
ora1j1e uan5ser the st4,ckh itra nj The o;u cnr
poyatlop receiving IKE amounts OF etOce IN tne ~
Organized curnpanf that Ihsy lad helI IN Inc oid.
xnr, that th+rrforr The nrw cnrn,ny fnot rhr,
nrooertT 5uhfpct n tnr Tfchts n re ere>,tnrs
tic Old comoany. ~
'1s ~ 1ssErtSry ,cr,~ srnprr,p~
t,nr ~ ThS.st-,u ntri,e = - 49, - 4hA si't.
same e tartan ! Jnnes
S.ne = II + D,,in
same r. 4 anderson
Samn < chsrina ! Taotu 1oz,,h n Hail ,ra
I.eAc ISwis - ' e"N
Samr e Cha1,rs u,nck,ry.
SAME = 1:a; I1nt'.r1 = u
ss,ne = Ei,a,,, ~ I3pa ( G-,sn - w.
samer = = n1ca
salnc =. isrpNn i SSars
e,ame " r. T. Mii.ef
sane '. Nooru sseyenA
Same '. Hunt 4 t;.sn,g.n.
Same '. Earuun 4 Weiles.
samey arne y p..is = ,iiAh j.msa T. nnnt'oea aa".
same T. James l. Knss
same ', llplulc, $40, Co,
S4ne :. i rradway i HendrcEA
sar.e =. Ihass / ueyvood.
s:Jnc r. itaae ! trw3.
Sane '. usxsn. vi. HsTru,
Snmc =, Inmca Van Inwaor5,
SxIne y Iew1s ltsnct1,ct anI Tnnp1ss n Gra.
haua.
viii damages nycs,u1p. Yrom une 10 aTisthon.
sau,l tiutafs In eacn casc. ana acl1onk hrnHrht tn
recover III, I. n n4r rr,f ~ ur.mirns aIfhnTi,ed
r fhr ttfy rhnr4er ~ ~ cnlcrred froI1 the n-rnfa
al fofrirn Iye.rnuce rou,nanics
Some r,r,c Since a blI WIS died ar.tn.t Arthur
G. Eucat, on the chancery side o the cour, csii.
INT for m acfount,uR s,n r.Yntrnt ~ thr tv ~
cr5t.ax That nlt SaR dss1niss,d IL heinr hcit
b, the Court that II the nct auihuxtx1pg i6e tax
was constitutions, there v as an adequate remedy
Iron this the c,ty xued r}ucas m the conm m
law side, in az acton u uvnL and onIa,pea ImIs.
neuL i1ac carst vas then taAen to thu Suprrmr
Iou:t, where The Iuuzmtut vas afsrme,t.
Tnt ot,L,ou uf The 5 .treu,e Cour delivered by
Judge HEec>t.. was, In substance, as toliows;
Thts Eas m Acuou OF debt brought 10 the
q! rse Sy q
IS agent Of fonr several insurance companies
created and established Ia the State Of Sew York,
bT virtue Of thg IxNs Of that state the son or II
upon tTe17 S{Uv Of urtmjums. he as sacn agent
had r-cctycd on policies ts.utti hy aid co.unanIes
sereralty, whilst they were doing bualneas a suca
cumnalies IN tne c1sy OF Cn.caco Demurrer II
snecanl plea hetnx sustained, Judgment Was rru-
derrd for Is 7s& - a. the debt dlc The npneal
Is taken to sx,erse tbs Judgment, assigning Is
error thst the dctnrrrpr u The encrtni rIr. M
sustained. =
The clam OF the city is based On the nth sect,on
Of The city charter. .ss
pow e. Of the LcS1slatarc TO tnaEe discF1sraa,foa
between foreign ald domestic insurance co.nra-
nies by taxing them on the premipuS rrcetycd
and letting the domestic cpu1psues no untax ctl o1
The Aane, tho farmer having complied Win the
laws Of the State permitting tncfr to exercise
Appellants take TIE ground that After this stAte
has authorized Insurance companies to e.tI,ilsn
Agencies AID DO business here II clanos tax the!r
property tnorc or dtf!ereaiiJ than tic property Of
c!tL ems nf tic State Is taxed
The Coar-, nfter ca1r1u! consideration Of the
Gases and arguments, reached the conclusion
that corporations are not clttzeas within the
meaning OF Section OF Article ". Of the Cansttu
tton OF tne fttf1t St4:eA ....
Appellants proposition q that corporations
created hy the LAWS OF ScT fofk are, to the IN
tents md purposes for which they arc created
citizens oI NeF fsIS, aal as such cutirled to Ill
the benefits Of the section cited. thai the ct.-
fens Of each State shall be entitled 70 al prtu-
legrs AID tnnunluea Of clttzens IN the several
StaseA
1he Corrt corl,f not nnd II had ever bccn de-
cited ~ any ccnE that corporations are citizens
then proceeded to eiucuxte this pndlnc py m ey-
atn.ust on u th. authorities
The eas.s Of The lout.r1lle c and c. R R ca =.
bridge CO. :. eheppani, 81 Mow15d. al, do NOT
establish the proposition OF 4,laintn. In both
eases ne quesaon ~ ohs o. la[ssueuon. aha no
constitution, nherefutc they are not declAse OF
tic ro:nL In &h1 last named ea&e, c. J
Ianey sad I'M IN The case u the I,faystte @ n.
<nl, '1he declaration ststet thai tue corporation
:t-rl1 y ~ q citizen OF lnd.soA No~, nov one,
ing Created ny a oct or incorporation could be
citizen 0, STATE In t1e tr.lse IN ~hieh thai voni
Is rsel IN the Constitution ol The Cnited ssaies
lei sverred ~As simply impossible.
bJ referring IL The case in Is Howard, COX
It Ri,r cals tic opspiop wxs delivered by Justice
f,Ifts AMI he zs.s: .Tne aysru1cnt tnat ife nr1,,
,sn1 n = r1tisrn ii 1udlsna can hxye M sen,tnir
mrsn1nc ATTACHED to 4 This tour dnes
;'ot ho;t ,nsr eifh,r a yntunt1rE nSsnciat,on ~
s-x ~ ~ an sssx1atIon inin a NOD ,,oI,t,c ~.
~, hr',aw IL :. lf,1rn of the S,si, within IN.
1n..,1na i; -, ~. ct,n.sirntinn -.>
~1sank " ~" H. rs as-,tss rotht,o n,,. ~, ,,
,n.t ies a ~ ~. nn,r.e. oi sSe,n. aa utns sc,
~ - r1so-.Itn c-rx,ed n, and tltne hussnsss IN
I.rususr st.,ts i. .uistant,xllr c,ttIeu Of xnr
s1,usu,nt,Sn M ~ >, .S,ns--s e'nseHnc M ia,
s.t,lIction nv ~. cnrts ~ tnr Initei staIes in
cA4es Between s;t1eas OF dircreat States.
may, rvorrri, - r,ns,n.r,z, rii1sn nG ihc s,alx
Of i:s c.cat,cn. for ,hc sm1no.. Of brtnr.ng sit
Int We trc,lnet 70 think the concess,on n. ~
unfortunate % Gus
WIS tho Case Q! llore tnsarsnee Corurauy '
poa7dEan, trancn u. Thr noint wss mad,
that corporation neyrrratr ron|d mt te clt11et
ol any state aud there va. nj, ,yesmrnt Of c,ti
xenhnlp IN the declaration Of thr ,nft1dn ala wh[