, 1869-02-27
THE JACKSON sfREET rRAaE9y.
Thcmex Stewart EOund Guilty
Of HurderinH Henry
Herbert.
Iupsiseurnant for Life the Penalty
Of Els 1rext Ofiues

Judge Porter continued the hesstnR Of tbs elss
sratnst Tnasnas s,eFs.3 and Eltsa MteJ for the
1nrrtes Of HenrJ Herpe1t- II hense II tu-nue
On 3Aeatan street. ~ ttn conclusion Of shs n
Ersct The Cczst tuftrueted tho jury, stating tho,
ssstu;orY dednit!ur IT sts crime Of murder. Be
tbep ftkted 10 thea that It troaa thu e7tdenca,
shcv b+ilevnd, oeydna 1raaoakola daaht, thAs
the ae,enaaa,, stex.s< killed Hesbs.t ~ttt malice
afnre,hone ht, u eh1tee3 IL the au4ict.ueut tn4n
ths. should ind ttm ssllty oi murder. although
no ro,tru Ind bscn proved IN the exse He thea
exp}aintd that ! rrasotAols doubt IN laS IL : *
.tors, fphstantisi, md wtH-foun1ed to1hk zed
no, he pesr poestn...sy OF doubt nor ! racsa
txeulx&tvs OF eAlE,eise<l doaes. Fos the laT
rrrsusaes pertoui 10 hare iaitnded the nA.1ts1
sorsee1saee q u. .sts; 20 ~ ~: y = ~. os.
A,t zniaxsaIY Ard deliberately ahoe snd &Illcd
Herbert, Is charged. tteu The lay psesumkd the
g. ept er nsiee uoe u
formed The ]ufy ,hks ii detcposts formed ths In
ettrn 10 ks! the deceased ut tnA tta-kat he ored
" ia,sl tfot then such ~ in'ent' N would con.
p7eee 70 eeEy1et SitWart that ho tnurtt nAvs
formed The IN 'ent!on /, kill Tor 1otr peFsod br-
mssicn u - isitr,,oa Is III taa. nees.sar1 10
to comply With the provision OF the sasa's Of
Eurder
wese Es1uetsd tott I saninlote ooual, tae
ra.1rt ol which tId teen x'reAby expl11ne1.
hcqE1Lttd, aud to1t the ouftcn Of proof ~As Npar
ant Il nliy thls proof coDt.zts5a OF n, ses sv1-
Ae1cs In Tic oae. which beng tAktn together
tauat co1v.rc- tho sd.d, b-yoaa 4 rfafocanle
saf se ss 81 ~
1Arked. it'd tea. SC wfs tu appasc1i n:eeui and
rrrttalg danger Of seccinrg E'eas ooo'lt nnm
rranaea 11s5 Ia eeif III soe,1y III i1yar1 ~aa'd sut
70 him ntless be SHOT The dscelset- thcu ta re
should be N ssqai:.sl; ", atsa, II the 3nf5 ".
s;s from .ts z oo -, ~ 10;
put Of IL baek cooz. In ths Att OF d. eatnihK
= toxnict with tho ctcestec. I'D tnlecdshR
nrd:r etrru5stspcss hssct-satc ss.tea, tns shoot-
31R ws2 dane. then Toe bo rtetdc wA 11sfifed :.
re-, oseo, Il the defendant Wa inep!ted a1d pro
pusion ii reASo1ab.e pessou. aad unues the 10
Gntptc II lhis tbs shooting Est dole. Wfthoa
tnaiier. her sA- grade ct tue 6 iear sts ou1
10A:s auRh'er- IL NJ event. ~ e'.osnee r. u,d
he 70 et.puS ~ 10 txeludc Ecaaonsec mp p3theala
osstnec.Ten.
On the psst Of TIC woman prisoner, MeI, sht
iu1y Il the 3ndSe bosh uf lhs Law I'D uf The ntte
anu II II EscetsRry IN c1Inirat eases That III th4
xnAt:rtsl arEs.lLcs should DC ea:sn fstcd. ~ en-
dcLee. htsoz1 scAaosao'e auubt. ID ofoct &c
etn1iet. IL .h,s cass snere hs 70 contc
t1on II less khe Woms7 s!tc1 CT a1aisfcd t1, oI
ahct,eo the esinc, ef ttat. not nean presrns, tdt
1h. ,usy retlrea 1t - nina.sa past II 4
the bA1losirE nhleh toloHea, 1t II nEtetssoot
1tHse WsA nd d1s1Rsttmsnt on The Qn:Attou
Grl.s or iu1ccs Ecs, int tnty Il to th- measure o
the pea1't1. E.Ets 5uzets. It u tstd> vot fv In
pr.souuer: fos NE I. 70 atesk1t SUD tour 10: tn
tn Ct On {! The ex+Et1tst pensl:y OF tbs law
Al AS tne 3n.oss had lsrgct At {43 Tbs prlson
e7s 1rse Ees11n:d INTO court, 8neu fhe Terd {
waa re:urted 10 III. nAVltJ. The -io:k II &c
emitted TIE ~oEoa1, Riley and found SkHhl
guilty Of nusIeF n sns s1aooEE znt fpta1 e1lkgel
l. The ,cc1ctme:t IN d1c3 The {cnL L:y y IN .s.4
cuto.Lt IN The fenlt4n',4-J lot n: tesn Of HI
naturst il:r. ..
The priacnes received tho Knowledge Of th
ceral1k as1icrce With pt,n joeu1Rrl,J. dc ~
4, tic t31aa 6isuoc opposite to Two Meo who
1a{1 ute later wtrn ordered to be " etnt down,
e4ea II thtfa toe *eycn yeHEF. Tactr zen pres 81
tusper4c prestpsea them. prooaatT. from totntI
u hls nu cctnlJ 1tr1ne0t Toe prisoner was :,
nAttto, ue.sol In a:tes. ot Judgement bsiu