, 1869-02-18
Second NY Of sho Trial Of Roy,
Charles l.. Dafch.
Introduction Of Verbal and Doou.
mentary Evidence.
Hcw Convention Did MT Visit
thu Elg1n Watch Factory.
mir. Ralch'a Connection With
tho Chicago Times Re-
pudlaied.
The Case Closed.


tfeet. .......
The court w.s e,sled to or &c. At 0:.5. the Mod
rstor In tee chair. Prayer wns tGctcd by Kev.
|. II. Sweetct.
All the members Of the court were In attctd
zee. Ms. Balch WAS not present. nor MAS he rep
esented by couIsel. "
Brother Garner suggested tha. the case he pro-
ecced with Ms. Balcn not having aopearrd, and
hey ha,src waited for hin, sufficient lergth Of
inc. Notice was given him the day before that
I would be coEtin1ed In biz absence. He also
moved that the following Affirmation be Rad to
called upon the stacd:
do yon foIemn!J and sincerely affirm hist
b. nr11g IN sIewtr 10 the qne.ants prouounded
to you Aha be tt aInth, the Whoie ueth' AUG
no'hirr bn' tho tru'h:' .. ,
The not,ons were eeconded and passed mani.
mt usly. ........ .--...
Nev. Mr.. Carney moved they take up the Charges
ard spec nca,iops against MIR. Bach one By ons.
Tie motion was .ecoldtd and passed.
TIE TRIAL.
The Chairman ,rad the first charpe aud Fpecsd |
tel1ou, as putlt.htd In TEE TnisuAE yesterday. |
REV, Mr, Cau ey moved that Bro.hc. Van C1re be- |
Invited to take par. in the questioning aud e1- |
animation OF Witnesses, AID to make srsgssuons
in tie case.
TIC mo Ion was stctrd, and carried.
lbe Chairman said the t.et thlae TO be proven
w.e whether Mr. Baleh published thu article re-
frrrrd TO. -..... ....-.
Rev, Mr. Rogers afar red, ald w+s examined.
The Chair. What evidence have you tnat that
article appeared in the Fort Atks.son Herald, and
that M. Ba!ch wrote 1T ...
Mr Horesa cut tha Article from tie UtTdfd Inn
uL eta on the examination ye tcFdaY, ME Bach
c.llrd tbs attention Of his lawyer 10 ID" Article In
Aecrsp book Of his ONE cosr0spor denct; there
fore ii must be hts. hr. 1logess then seaa the
following letter:
"Fr. ATxfxsoN. Via, Feb. Is. 1sG9.
"Icerttfy that Chae. l.. ba ca had xulp:u slmc
10 :, tract any s,aeulnte In his comnnricat On 10
my paper. fhs letter Was In my ro.se.slon
week b. 'ose !. appeared In print n,,,
Mr. vanC1se put in evidence Mr. Bsich's letter
to rux TH,nukK, In which he uses the ~o.ds "m3
report ecr The For Atkinson Herald was carried to
i, sEpx T. 70 D.. To- oxp -
@'ea Uhsarnsn II Tic nssf qne''on Is, did Miss Tap:
III Roger. said MIS- Turp'r affirmed T. him
that rte CID rot e1cha: 20 pulpt!', and Mt Ba.cn
~rusc that his sta'emrn !has eho had reached
The following e1lrac, IRON letter rom AE. 10
s,ah spalul g, or Janrtv.lle .h' vas voueh d foi
b. Nj. HopciR, wss pat III evidrnca:
nj was next turrlitd on reaatn1 = report ol
sa,d rnet.i19. t,en.a =. J.: h9tro, ,o2'sa = IN
IT, u snss sss b.
pr aeItnT u Ai.r III p"I in Janrt7.!ts., =
MI. Hufers trnte ecnta TO ;aY that NJ. b.lch ~ y.
]
/ e4rufe ahuus %riieFs Tor the pFcss Was cot v3lld
q. 10 wsr ~! r1'tcr for the c's, but mln'ste
rhe lhsI.mAn asked II be nsd anv e.licn: % :
to wLether the1e wss .n5 understanding - t.
~, hRprc o. tulptu. -,
ssa ~ Ets'- st n NJ T"nse' -s IL 81 ~;
NY met iath. in stc enr. hei .ecn a. Jan.'.ll;
i BaIcb !. rort A.tin'on. AMI ,sid ths could y,
i tlchstre ~ith him As att waited tho !t'ft.
tnEa'' t," H. h"'" 9e'n"eS i i cs1 rtsn SO ~ta'
y COMMUNICATION II him tiss rot ..su
ccnuuriea',cn. 5n: Tho ;ur ~ 's e., "Fos, NM
j. eonr. d s'sna''''. sna tae sr.,efea lie e,a'
. ID como rhr.e scrrt.Ins wera On Ftlan
efs paS q .s' a. M.. ss
! per was III the tul T.. *ni sster the satvicsa
w.nt m hrt ana 'A1Actt . her IN s '',s 20 ~ ,ata
"e% - i.ax t,tn '..s< o'; ::t: l., r :;
~ ' ia. ii" mivI,t Inv" nal" ns,5 a!tsr,p
VI IT., H,rrtt rssn his 'es,,uuhy n IN 4 toltsf
m M v.nt'I.r. Ills mr.. 1'n'tA'a pssta ~ pro
Il. us' he - mA1v ss estn.'t' eh"uaa III.
t: T. ,"mm':s pn. e .,..nes -, t.,'s,
Ill 1s!Iy ~ h 1tIt rsAcf IA ihR HiA. ..-.
- nj. VI. Cl,t. speak,I" 10 III. potnt andet rt
III ttn, !al1un. rs.d thst lr vsula pa IL evtdrhe'
" | u fu'1 FHcE - aHn - "H"H
~ ustscl lust thsn ~as tn Snrw hT hl. .wn
'er tuis.ion H th,t naIeh had s.npls ,tue 10 recall
.th III i. u ahrr w'e.,er ,s'd he wen. to the once
ess tnt Fort Atkins n Hsra'd, ard vol that e
|ea II n, Nr. Nu'Ghtct y tn icfrncc 0 'hIs u
I'll Tar edltur shtl Dalrh wTots the Latter. stl'
!, ttal be aLd Mrs irpper hal exeeaIrsd.
III y, ueh, flr ttt nI,or Of The Htraid. who wu
ess r1mf IT OF h's soci.iy, ana 4 man OF god n
pes ar Van cius rald th4t the chugo was
but t:snu tcu. ..
The Chs.fnlHn 7, ad tie SECOND sptcldca.
ns. ! heretofore puhlshcd In 1HE rsIBrNH.
Az an, VI. Noxsr.. eal ed; ssia be chi 'ns II,
mo m be r,w i in t:e Bo,ton Car..t.1n Rtgl
rho Ne sAn Bach al the a'tett3on or bic Ia
oil te letter tn nts ssfap.nos whica shoWTd d.lo
'a.s sae Uri,essa ,at STATE opveat,ou. n: m.rttn
4ce, ie!.ed IN the cha: Re vs. die'tuc:l5 Unlv-
uu- at rorvert'oo. Ary on'tlders thsre "ttc I'M
nto Al .nt. po,s t Mr Dp1ch'e reference 10 this
Ter, IN hte Letter TO IuE TArneSR. wae put IN
.h;s 1ne Btothet Ror..e hoped there v:ud b. no
tats tadtet aaa,nr: B:o'tcr B'Ich, and Il th.Sa
siae chs1ce OF treating him with lsr1.ney that
the B:oster Carey said there va, NJ pref:
oba- as1tn-t him tati c1 tho o'h.7 Way.
uch! s,,4ra .afourn ens o. t. s.s neiins 10
vtlle, rcsr1al ele1GJn= n said to HI t.eS Goa
mere sdjourn TIE Convention adjourned m, N.
:h.d lie natiei Of adj51nl1g. was never of1
fine rrouprt IN In tho caun IL. Brother Bile
cd- ak lie meeting to adjourn. Tie c,unt u re,
hay :, W. ~ no yats. tsE1n out oi the CO
yery aises tic .ernen il ths a'ternoor at P~Es 4
, iE rcn. BTo,htr Ba.cn received pcrmssatoa 70 a.
Ehat Ire rneeliI 6. and tEv1 cd teen TO aalo1
such Janessi.le, tut be had mol authority 10 anu
at n she acjou1t Hent.
men, "a IIser e1nors.n ali thr statsmeEts Of BJ
lntry Trre1s.
their THIRD SPECIFICATION.
not TIC WIDEN G was de- md ecnc'usi'e ~
VIC CrE:1man read the third specification. a
pears printed Il THs TRlscss. --.
,ss-n- ~, Hu4 Sa e ~ +1as,,n, ~ VI nt 49, NJ
: n,sl Lot terence, shrr.b giving tut 10 irars
4 the that 1t "ss meeting Or tue U tsaaars sag
{ per- tA.tt:s are tie H~rtAWest.ra.
! pAs. II. 4 gere read .ho tullo wing, received
them I'm aE. Bsc u,,, na..o
ne OF "1-xAa s1a; YIN s1e rsrte tettly t.vit d'o
IL LIB. .;onf in ttis city Ian. 14s, ~
aittle ccllecteu Will bn tascn up t. astisl 10 "
cidc7t ,onf ex;,cnecs. lo;orn nc Al oAce. Anu.
aenf. tne nio1aer Rorez: si b, ,nv,.noa he =
three n,rprne, IT, tse s,stee OF Wiaco.e,n aLd
C per sos, teio :, B:1lin. Wis. The Rev. Mc.
'hly.sn = c.. ago. then frd be -. not member y
easel; cot f,scIec. because he Ga not I'VE ~ ~
tray- @ hltDeso1a. u. rsen w. p,"nn. AA
III The ss1t wien tue toa5 Adjourned II enoa1o
% Tcs to'iowins extract from letter WI,
the &c rttuy Of the above corteter
;.a n; RGfs5. 'si u putin evidence lie LEI
DIN GaoznrE Ros1ss: ~ Iva, !, b b,
Lat. Brother n.ss se1 sent m'n 49, you et
fG,. W..en,. ..asss ycn misunderstood The a,ture of
5:1enee II .tS BE- TIE Gn3:.''eF 3.nF ye meeifps y
gently ard otter L'sesal 1nasnet; Wa co aT'o
rs and H.a1n IL tte an'nsaty ol ia Boaro Of
rly be. icr ral!il . H. .,a,.,
hen 1. 1ne folo"'ne !e fuEsr.Is VII Dsr. Is.
as s,'ns "Esz p Pi1s s. heFfb5; The
!, with, dta1,tion Of the meeting TO- oe e,
r, g.H:n II Il
''u ~ 1'a 1iar ana d. theT LlserA Chus. hes. II
nen& in etce. atuia WAYS tEppoeed, ustt rece
lat the Termed h1 .he sesiet., INC ~ ise.i ~
Isnaper ~ ,3t ane r. h"sA'' ''~' -"
ks ago sc. L. u.
, where The evidence On sa1e Gags ~ e'1s'
u"'"s 1te fhsir 7. I'd IT. 'onr'h fprt lncaslon.
rnpr OF ed N ycst. Ytsy's TRIBUNE.
c crefy Ih.fe w shnn, H.. 1'tar or WIKI
D. ?. vi ~. - tome dcnbf.
estate. MI NoRtrt know ne iete,, a. ~, y -, -
inst his ape ~, H. hs,sa -. d,opre1 a1d /,
against adjou, MD ultl. = =. N. 'or d'4nst.
,s--Wh0 ..,.,., urs,,ov
g part hrr.nr, 70 ,.semoled n $50 .. NJ, t
declare, erssoc In th. etslf. ..,
sly sa1.c Mes t ~ H. s.naci Hill. wets IN II
written i,s, Tie. Varps, VA call. i npun ~ ots
t,ps Sir. which he do. d.~,o~
from r,r tot,ov,.e W.. ,ben re.d " liz Nj
ytelf. 1 Sfsr@ft,tfion f.ffh. That ssid H"v. y
, a rc,r. tir, ! rs 1bcn. the Hn1 tlty Of Dec
my own ttr u, tssu 7,mts. lot tne pufpnas vi /
n 10 70. pasp 10 Viii. lin l:ts.n HAle4 tnmpan1