, 1869-10-12

tuC VI LILO E1t0 NoFOk III QX Ey6. kltks
oouEd, snd me inner, ~ s!thn,ek; tSe;r sccouut
"a ko1s1y NHh cbroth' and the pnhtc't account Is
NEh tnen |'!tt 40 !. s!tn coso'n onsy;' oArn
YI;HEhiKTHopIsT BoQK CoHGERn.
- - ;DE. Por$er,s peseneo.,
IL NE Es.a1ri u ~ 4Ns. Yerk r. s,sfns Psss: -
Rrtu1nihg: hDnt ua:: she Z. entnx " The ssd
uirtnn. xxs tu,Etsed 70 fnd thu cry sbszt Win
lie aenoai.t soot coueeTn. ii IL pdansed d "a pf.
Lzusntn u the dlscovertr, md OF eaufso ths
source o. fntorust1or. and seyelN of them In /.
lTags, horcFrr. tTeated tno report a. another
sensational hua,uu1 poutttn9 the train d all the
tac Tsu"e 1f 9ns : 81 ~; a. eslslnx npon b. lsna
dlscoteted xp1 lots wha1ever, hut though ten
made. The Chrtasaa Advocate, however, which
ny os rsEsr,.a. psrh.p. - a sea9i;st'ca s.ys
va dssTa pto sas at,s.r 1if ~ ts estdens paf pe
pose 10 tujure !" ne, Thtch there 10 no rcnon to
uuubt But rtops,se ror to yindlcate n,ys.lr,
advantage d their origin or object, AID Ioave the
matter until further oetteo NAV secn necessary.
:, no nssps e r. e. her nas any
Tre SubstaDee Of these ruMorn IN their worst
iun. 4, .hst having cnsrse q supplying Tho BOOK
s Il .so dwe Sm
eonmt'saon shared win him, or Them whereas
anse terms. tsee kss~tss Pess Of September ~
To tins reply:
bo1 Tsss IT, p..T M H. :Ss @s 2e; aq, to
ment het ween Dr.. Carton aud Ey salf Nor va il
apS sssas a's io 81 ss tpe
city much Of 'he 1lme4 Besido6, found another
msn Of locg experience and unqueattoned xii
nbd tnteRnig occupied with thai work wnen en-
'eI 1 1 shesetoto % psrer bought . pound Of paoer
during ths whote sws1ve years. Of my connection
j. Nos did employ my 500 to pazchase paper,
or nlo~ him ao, conn lssion w1.atsvcz. great or
small Ntthtr 4tn i aEAfa that ha Kas euploJed
by nay other parry 70 do tina ~ork.
aaen.; rs 7sss fosnd H. q ]. ooodsnoasa, ' oe.
Of paper for. the printing depennent, Of which
he Vas the hon0red foreman. lie did thtB work
1on.s Tho ssoef. sepsr,'on q s's sssats dr.
ior ihe printing os1ca xaers 10 could aes them
pse.r ass z e.:
I Goodenousns stsentsou to The TACT ana said that
II was moi tlsetJ THAI be could furnish us with
Should no bs ablt 10 do 10 ia any case, would bo
Fiad 20 have hin ps.rvnioe h!m nn thought hest,
| buy iut <isswberrt - and 10 tAf n Know Of
Junction 10 ,he ,c.tsr. This was tho utmost oi ny
~ H. e q o 5ss E.;
Of his Lnstncss than Of that 0f AuJ oshor hoAlcF.
e -, IL ~ 5eggsas Gae s1.s .iuee
1nsnd lhs wtalt prodoo.1ou of lundry mills and
thu sRenoJ ar ocrAln uanus CIan - of paper man.
81 II 'a' tss s es asSS%
dera,ood Il tha tuna, and now iulloye, u I.w ii
Ia combination af shls t.atcnrnt. which viii t,e
a.trstcd .! tath. j. nrtetsaF. have tho p1i'tlugo
Methodist Look CONCERN dutIu0 tho entire eruHcY
p"e @ q sspprs ep liz Tor esia'Sa III s!n a.
! never khew Of pr. Pottess purchs1na any
paper. Of apro.nsing b,s son TO DO 10; nor did ho
allude 10 ihs snbtccf except 70 nay Il could huy
ngy1afpR Of him u low n oonld got II oi any
e. f. Rs'2 sSae a vsS p s e. S t. st nh nj Do
act,nE UP 10. The Doctor 5 lnstruc.ion. i further
s1se1di snptrvnon Of Df Porter III tin branch
| my duty, and ! therefore consulted with both
AGENTS from ume 70 ntpe. ~ c1fc1nastanoes re-
u this peEs Of the business, must be halo rrspcn.
| al0Ie. nnd not Iii. Porter; and am ready 10 40.
s.sr for @ 4! II M3anGement sa AZ rsspests .. The
'"" ""S1W Yosx, te,ober !, 1862" o'OA"'''1'-
It has also been aasened mat had the spec.a !
e q dssa sspfs .na ss
in 1854 ! found Ar. Hoffman ID charge o! tnIs
bEanch Of tae business a foreman, en5oytng the
who preceded ne He eous!nuod 10 purchase hts
snrpa!c1 during ny stay in tho Concern, and left
fann1n' on1cer, II my nssoctste and myself fully
bellefed. | never bought dollars worth Of
atos1 tor ~ department. though ! OCCASIONALLY
paid BY the iaIgr.t binderes Of Now Yorf and
Boston, d we'll Al The prices charged By honAea
sere pasine a fsasaa.Ss 1ass @sss IL
90 toe same thirE Ni.n regard to the purchases
Nov. hess beng beng tic fsots in the case tsna
hnve 10 doubt thai Or. Carleton. my superior on
G. for the Snele t.ne: ~: Denaam, our excellent
Nd can eoonsm them By Tho books Of tae house,
these being ths facts, sAy, whele could ny a.
q ny tuhofsd "1aaa IL collision @ rits M ny son
AM guilty, OF not guIlty- Gen"Mmeu have
5,S ,ne 70 ne I'd 20
moted II waA nothing, as Il u q common prac,ice
IN commercial e1clea-" However thts may be, i
Lei /, De proved that took one penny Of CON-
Of purchaser made for thar Concern, directly Of
3ears' service as agent, and vii CONSENT to 10
branded as tnirf and rcbber. hut ns man
sll attempt to prove It; And no man Who has
Will believe It TOT one moment Or. Lau1-
a5es aa! sss1se = s 1as VIZ i;
aud III rot Nor I'll any man whisper such d
susp!caon Hho does not consult intx4e.t<t parties
Of MT dotnga m1tead ht defraadln4 the Concern,
= N1ckedl tnsinnAted, dld thousands OF dollars
xoith Ct e1sra l1ef1s1 md other service, tol
il0 II least taonAand d4lars yta+, for ksvcra
| Tea1s, OF mr. prtyste funds learned before I wenI
And did tnts 70 aid In ltftinE mat <1bsarassed
Concern out OF tts more fh1n ote HUNDRED dai sre-
tnfr fhou*1rd dotLdfs {Fatbt<dHeAs, OcGaSionel by
| 1lE latR ufT3E$fn of The rHnifHI
Clutch So1tn, IN whlca We found It, and place il
o. ne tol.d foundation on which nad tne pleas.
After ~ this, and mnch more ot the saue kind
OF nteh The Church kunwk titr1e ami the pubiis
les. 70 he summoned tIom the quiet retirement L
Gaming the turmoil Of Church responsibility az
ncsinets, atd q doing little good,, y de.ent
secret Toe, - aoo g1tevoua TO Do borne without
erotion- And 10 De sllowsd 10 lie under thls vilt
,@aa4no1 Tor twelve long days witaozs relief
70 Justify II, and might EindIcate me beJou1 suspi
con " single dash OF his pen, IA more er!evou
f. Il. 1s Il ss a., .seI
thst as nas % 1essoo "a ai1sFoss my integrity II
Il sSs i. % lie Injustice which he proposes I,
fnaIe out 70 aU who staod Implicated BY hts -
sun ed diAcnrss1ea ~ and ahou. that time hon
ss ~ %: sFs3 ;as q ~
seeas is7s Il fuy j. ezea1pse 1ae q
| n1s-4A
whom hase long differed In great Church cues
|, lions but neser bad the nrsi unpleasant word.
/ kindly fncotuced hfd to my vacant chair, ant
| tende,ed him any Information he might need II
The tusioesS, Of which be has taken sone little
! peShspe useful Advantage, but he has never men
tton&1 the 8unIect OF hi discoveries 70 me in "a,
| mALpef whatever.
From whence, ,ncu. Il Eul be asked, cane al
l these tuuory, aId wh41 Is thu Iufptr1liop Ind Oh
! iect Of lhem4 OF coursev can gI7o no pos!ttv,
! aoAEef. They hear llteznal evidence Of q spectnt
| origin and object have traced those sgainl
use 10 ! personal source, and have written nj toe
oU of the caee but A,thhol1 1t fof the present ths
! mJ deftlct maJ rot be embarrassed bg col8te.a
lsentx- The only question 10 be nov settled u
Did pE. Porter do *hat Is alleged II haye proyct
that be- did MOI, to the katisIactton Of those xh
| have rAtE1xrtd The scandal Tor eight or ten JeArB
a. tlutntuNy declared by The papers that SOM
have dong, trust theJ tin Lake pains to re1ac
the lalsehood and repair the lnj1s,ice done me
and hope that e11tors who hare Slvcn patlic.1,
| 10 TIE Fuupre1 lmr}ic1tons, Will do ne the jus
t!ce 10 puhllA1 my defence, and otherwise seel
TO rspar the 0amaSe unwits!nrly done.
LIE afsistAns' Agent of thc Methodist Look Con
c+fn.
HIw ToK1, Oct. :, 1859.
Il 4 Monument to Adn1us
| a. Frs1a h Irort H,.rI5