, 1869-07-22

- - --------
~ =. :. - =
,axsnd ,.es.hicn ,sa s,;S5 -
EhT. s,se1 sTnntH -; s e ~ s<t,v.nxosE feason
stss sser b.. Esa "a ns n!
ses y e. s9 osnob A. e r
sasee % o.
Il
10 nuiter Of fact involved 10 mat II To1Id re-.
4ut1E evidence the palt OF the sccpsad to rs.
ese M 9as i: ,f ;is. tom
pies6Jr. o9 deop ss . fS5sta s d
! ssJ word i lnlioased to Inc learned cpunsei.
~9ss ea41a o4fs '0n e ri, .1
question On tSst nov pending7 ' ~"
MI: THOMPSON. i intimsted when We called
WA 4 question which We could lot with propriet1
then preseDL. s,nce ye h.d neTer seen tkls iocn.
ment, and which Ne would Teserre ua,ii siter tho
pape1k! Sou reoollecs t, =; =
nj. THoArsoN. an not going to iustss upon IT,
mlng ter osnG @ question III nrss t.' ts'''l' o''ef-
Judge OTIS think We nadhetter taks up these
hing II o,de1;
the question should have come up lrae Tor It goes
to lns jus,sdeton, However. -.
JUQR& tllA GO QtE KNOW IuA[ i u&TS 6MVH0-
lection 10 your presentipa il now. -. y :
Nj. THOMPSON, ] think 1t would be more con-
venieut e tne seu1.
questions % a. soon -, - We &C. caa. I'M laias You haa
,aS. aS 7noaSof y S.sn IN do a. I1s esaaon
" 1TfIfrIS isnnno.a + :. rnnstSsrsd a. IN
Judge OTIS q, IS, q course, i l ii d.
IT " ~ epasse maasGSes " 10y iet,s ~
sala aeif ne ~ 70 me m 1,taoa s.1
Mlss ano as 10 W a5s nos 70 pe eon1.oG is ~
sar. narng 9 ytei1ya ~ r. H. wsa
ssasict, j ~, : commission 70 TIC persons Eh0
4ass iounu Ioi5 psentnenL N ~ LIE .s; 1st p,aes;
!, eYt.n, sa' ~ reao iue rom " M snsuat ~
ido ~ not Isaa sonec1iV q 1se Judge WI sorsect mn.
she @ B.shop to prcsept prsssJ,er @ for TIL ii fead
llpM tae canous ot uat a.oe1as M NJ ue sWenueLa OF
sn1 q sr ~ III saTp n, 1ea M !s -
main nsIs II nnrnbcr az IN restrT y an, ehn-rS
nshrttrs n the oeese ent,tea N os,1s ~ tSs
rnnrEnrInn ~ frnm nnhi1r. TnTnr ~ ronse mn,,red
IN Secilou :, Canon Ii oii,le GeneTzI Cenrenton.
thnt anT cicrrynau ID undcr imnuiation al
having been sult5 OF offences. be- snail
proceed" The position that We taEe here y that
this pre6entneut does not come within elhfr of
thGse three nodes y which presoytet can be
1eIred 70: sRye minister snall pc iishle o Pre-.
sentneni ana utai iot NM CRIME OF etYoa IN
noianty Ia mi6aslI 0! ithls G64sEa 80 s9au ne
c!se o. he ministerial onlce wiihout taNful caqss,
Or o. M,,os IN laF pe1pe.aM alsase Of puna'
91aap 1,a . yo, are mn,
SV.gu O1Gs auu S1e teA111s 1s9o0 LIE Saapn
l1At ~ LIZ a!4InsIAsH rS1i4 IstN'ea1 ,,oo,
hit IL sot mnee tSc eitation cI The CO eoa1I ~
Sucss uaia = W. -, ooHs s o. NE Ass eeoerA
% TiS,sfps1iv Ivni GnIs an.Her ,m,oo,a
1uss Us vel t has been bee Changed II IA easi seSerai
Ms, ~ -. 80, -, ~. t.i,n..t.1
1rtne. ~ 1Iss ,,nnn,,tv. saeand for nn,dinSS
and teaeans pnnssJ o. ps;'ssslyh - and a. adslssd
e.. EsiscouI Cautsh ~ ID tpe W United Il ii ssssss Of
Arne!lea o. Course !. Is not ela'msd m that ta!s
on T. shy suT tne ton.th o1 3e'.t,o .. ,oe
o. tne eonsusuuon s ano Sas 1,s 9! sne d!osess 70
HotSn 81. Is uUs9. auu NV W. ~ essSSn I
ae Y seSoa ls NH mnster & HE tSa.tS
6nau 70 aeSaseu " p1puV tutnot o. olsconln9ln9
a!l exercise Of nc 1anistestai oMSe without ~,
public vorship or Of tue Holy Eucharist accord
q my q other Of the offences enumerated d tne
+ o,ss JSdRs I,st5g1; oTIs rna, i, ,be nav one
Mr, THOMPSON. stnpG read thtsfo the pnr.
pofe Of show ng that 1he Esaor must either il, The
vestT. secnnt Jrnr, 'rnrca nr..h,t.rs. ~ thfrS
pobIic 1pmoH The1o arn Ia, fhrrs mod. m l.,
Wn'en lals t!lai can % set IN motion. We called
ooL ms commission !or tae purpose 81 learning
surr snnI Itou Il uets, harH tsa az los
nom ,ais e1e e NC ~ ~ aop Wneser
a nao o. sns sesuF, OF snfo3ga iafee
papeF Ess prduced IA speusa io y Ell I'll tas s
indicates ne manner M II which this Information
when thls tIial VA SCI n motion. q Ia other
WotnSs ne IuIlsole1ou /. ol WIS case. ne lnloIm
been "eTedtsI5 informed '.se does l not ~ tsas
aoss not that a, Vas ss aoss By tsee
coma connection IN ihlsmand am not so!ng lu!o
ths matter 70 that nc pres6yter aud tne tadse
nd @ Sc Wsdm rs u ~ fna a reaa t'o aseMGa o.
ii III. case real IN hate ssr.s precisely IS iEls
Iead from u Is eo1taned u tne ansWe5 o. the
tap bisanp N tnas case@n Has1n& tssn cIealhy n.
This IS having been Informed ia! tae neS'casa.
= = iSosney, Sy, eae.Iney sln pfseiseiy snke. ~.
proceeding Al thnt trtal, and TIC case was very
fn]ts argued BY one Of the mos; eminent lawyers !
ne hud tn tee Northwest, the late Judge
before nc Iion. JOHN ". Wilson. one Of the moss
eminent OF our Western Judges, ONO Of tae mos.
smlnent O. our American Judgcat before the |
the Judge npon the sesy point which 1t seems to
e Is conclusive OF the Point as to The want OF 1n-
risu1St.oh N llis case:
~ ~" o. tne saafea a. east 80 1aE a. thcy ISSUING
-, 10 !etistte ulon any hpeclnc suN]ccL ano u y
- - a.r n4esaei - " InsJ ups!aE ~ St1ul OF
- n,dienS ~ - .. ou.i =. poNt.s pc4ute
on,Ia h.,,a ~ Ae' @ uancesssaIY " ~
sdts"cin,ine ~nt 49, ,Iwa, W. Ipo saoleTs s ~
and rcs+ru,S ,bo poHe nsEo,, !" naa;
ns pishons In thIs cass Of eases. In. ~ c,ne
mi anhsrr,ne n Jhe Gne11tne confc,isY ~ ~
rcsrondsnts counsel ina. the ishon can nrctnS
in ease no: nrnyisr Ior n ,sn rn5nns * nern
con structiun nrou the conntis that hsjTip RAJ
lLly lDfornsci al in tils case "a n 1s..fer and
nnre saf,1tactor1 rrnnnM of nroesed,nr % 1,n ,h aa
IL rrmoE II wns contente., IN ths t1ia, fnHt
i being cIcd1b]y informed" was pe,tcr and morr
serious ground than "ruolc fumof." bat The
answer to this position to sar that the Legislative
ranch Of The Church hare gtyen no rover to
proceed IN sneh cases, and saat it
tic canoIs Y they deem It c1pcdlent II q well.
rue Il const1actuu that the speclfca.
,ons Of q mode Of procedure exclude by impIica-
II Jurisdictions 1,ut the view We have tasen rea-
leIs further discussion 81 this question unncccs-
saSy,
,a NV ~ e. las G - .he opnMa o. me coal1 WEich
on FL IT. isat i = dsrsr " T mere y aa aues
- * r1,o ~ ,sdn =; ~ ta s9at
e ~ ~ ~ su 19n 70 ue aaopsea oy Iaese nfesoy
nv. - M noes1 tIS Wa qogs'h ~. ~ coafse We
that IS whenever :: eeeS@ss @ : court. { Il
ever does.san take no power BY implication that
rs sa qss apn npoa Is fne saGs 9f
shzlen rns these esanine1s il 9ouoa 70 state nov
ne 1tTo1matIon came 10 tne khow'ense 9! Inc
blthoP. goes 10 me Jnttsdieaon o1 tne pIp-
ceedneF ihat Goes nos stag nI.on the tace o. tae
Eanon We cannot II iet teaf any other mode e5-
ttS and hence We eftn9 u within the decision Of
JIlge wilson and the CONT u bang ttcte, and ask
aud not INocecd father with this case. / will not
enlarge Eron It any further. 49,