The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1868-10-03

Womun's Attendant at Times, and Her
Partial Cross-Examina alton.
The examination In this case was continued before
Justice John A. Bogart OF Manuel. Rockland county,
New York, yesterday. There was present for the
prosecution Mr.. Henry Daily Jr, while Mcssrs Cln-
ton and Hoffman appeared for the defence, assisted
by Mr.. John Hayes OF New York. There was also
seated around the little court room quite number
OF old women, old men and young ladies' who lis
tened with evident interest to the proceedings.
Professor Doremus not present during the early
part OF the day, but was announced that he would
arrive during the evening to give the
suit Of his analytical labora During the
cross examination OF Miss Mcguire there
was some considerable legal sparring between
the counsel, and at the adjournment for dinner Mr..
Michael Murphy, the deceased woman's brother, had
something to say about Insulting his character by
one OF the counsel for the defence. Some portion OF
the cross-exam nation caused considerable sensa-
ton. The following Is the
TESTIMONY OF MISS JULIA MAGuIRE-CoNrrNUED
Idesire to make correction In the testimony re-
garding my visit TO Mrs. CANDLES house after her
death; 1t was the sth instead OF the 9th OF August;
on Sunday night while was at this house (sirs.
Gamole'sl neither Mrs. Huns nor Mr.. Gamble slept
up stairs next TO the In which slept; they did
not come mp stairs at ALL mean the front stairs;
did not sleep any trat night; slept in the same
room Sunday night that slept in on Saturday night;
no one slept in the middle room where Mrs.
Gamble dIed) that night; the servant girl slept
In the room to the right OF Mrs CANDLES room on
Sunday night saw her going to the room; also saw
her going down stairs In the morning; only partly
closed my door that night; on Monday morning got
up about l,een minutes TO I'VE o'clock; after got up
open; Isaw no one there; observed the bed; there
were no clothes on IT. going down stairs that morn
to awaken me; also saw Mrs. Hujus that morn
ing; she came out OF the dining room, babe
oo % morning. and sa a.. she , was
breakfast; now remember in the matter OF the bad
conduct OF Mr.. Gamble toward his wife, besides what
stated before that he threw tumbler at Ter In the
parlor; when he did this was in the same room;
the tumbler struck in under the Window 1t passed
by Mrs Gamble In Its course; was sitting at the
time on the other side OF Mrs. Gamble; the tumbler
also passed me; said nothing to MIR. Gamble about
this action OF throwing the tumbler he said nothing
before the tumbler was thrown Mr.. and Mrs. Gample
had been talking ..something about" this Miss
Loaisa Bauer; do not remember what Mr.. Gamble
then eaid nor do recOect what Mrs. Gamble then
said about Miss Bauer; while was at Mrs. CANDLES
house IN the country Mr.. Gamble said that he had
did not know 1t; he returned that he odId not think
IT would be done, but II It was there would not
be ANYTHING found;m ] sand nothing else, ese;
went to the depot AT Manuel with me; at that time
SAID that at was too bad that Mrs. Gamble did not
live u lltIlc Wniic longer 10 ENJOY ner NICE pace,
MIR. Gamble said that .'she enjoyed it very well for
the length OF time she lived In Rockland county;'
Mrs. hujus said that 'she supposed her health
that the air was too strong for her."
don't remember anything else being said:
Mrs. Gamble never that i know OF, brought Miss
Bauer TO her house In East Twelfth street, New
York; never saw Mrs. Gamble under the influence
OF liquor, that know Of but saw Mr. Gamble give
IL to her; he always helped her to II when she want
ed IL; never her take 1t herself; II WAS pre-
scribed TO her by doctor when she was delicate;
saw sr a. tnJ Mrs r
In the country, while | was there, Mrs. Gamble,
Mrs. Huius, the German servant girl, the servant
boy and an old lady, whom ! think was the wash.
woman; young lady and gentleman also stopped
there on Sunday evening, but did not know them;
did not see any one else; Mrs Haas did 60 to Jer,
at the depot after going part OF the way to the
ferry, and then babe me good morning.
Cross-eXamined-Wh | came TO Mr.. Candles
place. on the Sth OF August, / did not know OF her
death; no one had said anything about It 70 me;
before; was not sent there: told my mother and
father thai was going 70 see ner; knew now ,n
come down ws' on the al ath 81 July and take
me up; the address was written; ] thought had
handed that memorandum TO me; do not know POSI-
lively his handwriting, as have never seen much
OF nj have him write, to the best OF my knowl-
dunn was in pencil; have not got 1t now; told
them at Mrs. CANDLES, In Rockland county, that
said that I went to Peter Halpln to get
IT, but he had not got IL; after went home found
It in my pOcketbO0k; on that occasion paid my
expenses; they were repaid me; 1t was not at
the request or suggestion OF any OF Mrs. Candles
relations that went 10 Rockland county Irst be-
ago; 1t In the fall OF the year; FIRST saw her to
know ner at $40 East Twelfth STREET New York; got
acquainted with her there; 'sister Carona' intro
duced me to her had accompanied her TO the house,
Sister Car0na Is connected with the Sisters Of
Charity; she Is on East street corner
of IL Al i'm
II is seldom do anything; but when do work IN
the silk business on Twentyfrst street, between
Eighth and Ninth avenues--Mr. Dale's mandatory;
am now employed there; have been working there
of and three four years during that time have
had no other business; during the two years was
acquainted with Mrs. Gamble visited her In company
with Sister Carona only three times: Mr.. Gamble was
In the room once only during these visits; this
the second visit; could not tell how many times
was at Mrs. CANDLES In East Twelfth street during
the first three months OF my acquaintance; during
the nrst six months think saw her about twelve or
fifteen times; cannot say certainly whether I saw
her more than half q dozen times In this period;
/ am certain | saw her the 0rst year more
than six times; cannot answer how many;
Am certain that saw her in this time: WIN swear
positively that saw her as many times a. seven
times, and more than Q dozen times; saw her be-
tween every two and three weeks: WINS not In her
employ at any time; I was engaged by her az nurse
during her confinement; when sle was sick was
there TO take OF her: have spent weeks time
at two different periods In taking care OF
her; this Ia all the time ! spent with
her In this ways there were about eight or ten days
az alluded to; Mrs. Gamble was not related TO me in
any way; am acquainted with her two brothers,
Mike Murphy and Tom Murphy; have been acquainted
with these brothers-Mike about year and Tom
about month; did not know him last summer: it
was during the past month Of September that got
acquainted with him: IL was about the LIST or I'd OF
the month; cannot say whether Tom IL married
or not; never heard nor made any inquiry: am not
married; do not know any other relatives OF Mrs.
Gamble; saw Mrs. Gamble the last time about a
week or 50 before she moved TO Rockland county;
she moved there about the latter. par. Of
Nav last think; when visited Hrs
Gamble | did not him always with
her: saw him occasionally there; think he was
away oftener .ihan there; ] visited Mrs. Gamble,
10 the best OF my knowledge, about hundr q times
or over all together; cannot tell how many over a
hundred; II was 'one hundred and fifty times
more, guess" can't say whether IL was two hun
dred times more; "cant answer'' whether II was
az many three hundred times. and cant an
swerr whether 1t was five hundred times
To the question OF "Was II thousand times ~ OBJ
lection was raised, on the ground that witness had
only known Mrs. a. two years. and not long enough
TO her thousand times. Counsel for the de-
fence said he had right 10 sift the witness and learn
what her recollection was worth-whether II was
reliable not: the witness had not put any limit 10