New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1867-12-31

the Vintage OF a eIalIed mnd." WnHI VI
gold" may be have dictionary at hand sufficiently
comprehensive 10 tell u.s. yet, suppose II may be gs
strives to show at his point and bis astuteneSs:
Mn. w.-"AuJ like dream Of beauty g5des 0r0y"
Mr. B." Aud mingErg With dreas,s bears me eTag'
But TO continue our inquiry as TO what Is or what IL NOS
plagiarism according 20 the Hssges Of the pGet we eS
anime h. poem OF M!s @hi,a Giorv sScV airs
these phrases long ago set IN the lanSuageot
Shut wings" tot bee property sufficiently nsiPd 70
escape any vehement desire to coyet or to claim aud may
only serve, by contrast To recall the grim ""has
But whore the pOetess sings;
o paader through The woodlands hoary-
Is there not an echo Of Carlos Wilcox:
To To s ss5&cT 5 5q5 20 The S9so ss'ss
Or OF Lons BLOWS " In the Woods"
90 could lutg.
When 10 her eye the hunbeams battle the hills in mel
aDchoy gold We to hold Ler responsible or noat
The bright ssrstin<s gorde, hu1
Bgl<d the sIil frozen earshr
anu "s'''-' The sylvan floor Il oaAod IA goar
Or both paarsts because Rufus Dawes wrote before
The hills bottled IN food QrgoryT
Or is It not very common fancy Of the poets TO see
things Lahed" the light Of tie suni Aud thGn poor.
| a plagIaist Of Mrs. Whitman when he speaks "
each sense OF his gad s9a. IG1'ed 90 geeng| Doa
connosseur IN poetry which he co cooly arfogatesi
Ike fond lover lo.tn TO say farewell"
had not Drake already said
Lis n ring friends Who linyer While iheJ seVerr
Her bees dropsyaie echoes Emersons bees drow,p
time" Her little brds'-what scores Of poets aPostro
doom TO those Of Duchess Msy-"Gh nosetess'y RON
ey g aud - tscy 60 IL bear 10 5cb i , .,
era eTSSd old SITss oTcgst Hymn lynn
Indeed. Il is plain enough that she catches tones and
echoes abundant y from Bryant as an artist may Dor
row master, features aud eolorngs ~ landscape.
sba GUS The Hinged ee!inn nods Tic gentian
mods, IN dewy umbes bound III" Iringed seiiaa IN
fact - the mos uikinsy erect OF 81 ho"eIs: Ne can
tank of none In tho whole Catalogue, WIN stem so
straight aud eoroa, Ike cup 50 absolutely loslinsu9
II Old idea Of the poets speak Of flowers like tho
daisies buttereup- and eoianbne, as noudhg-ro ihs
violet but IA 10 sense can the term he speI 70
the blue eentan We trace me misaAe ~ WEI nsS
Gli he blue geutsp sower ,hs breeze mods leuslr"
HoIe is without doubt, slip OF e1pres7on '1as
Maser OF American pasoris abnnqanty J''. .. ns
own correct observation OF nature IN tho poem 'ne
"lhsu doh isy ,Fss, asd q' ,s! ere,
Tf 1885, MT ou IHS Of %I iaS 'S %nS
sinSs' "Yet ss,i tho blue-eyed g,a.,n look
through fringed LIS 10 Heaven
w. have one moro illustration sl nearer homo Ths
critic himself in "s0ppng up Whole Ines isolatrd
btetatuie Of Bilngsgate viii This bid him adiea
We have said that tie Aker claim gives not shred OF
SoS Ind bssfea TO Introduce to your kind attention
witness who signs himself Major WIZ Hnney 81 Lumer-
W
i'm he army TO discern fancy straps ON here 10 Albany:
IL is the singular fancy OF army officers to be shy Of
eSsions But II We must have our wituesa in
uniform be H. There he stands, IA tho fu pahOpy OF
war; two shining rows Of niue down te iFohl straps
with the golden leaves and between the leaves enl-
brodered E d. Probably he may estimate lls a Gun
the world for the frer distribution OK us houor does
repeat the opportunities OF greatness " 0Ho
It is pity men viii not stick to their buttons THIS
Major may bo master OF boiiscEehoe' ou 10 Is hat
Truly Mrs Akers may eyclam. in the language OF the
Too mnch iSR penty The zeal Of witness is too
much He tesdes that he was in Bradford, W. ~ lSG
Chase, aferward Mrs Aktrs that IN February Of mat
year she produced the poem Rock me- TO Sleep III SIX
stanzas and that then IL published over her nom de
plume That there may be 10 mistake III the uate NC Eo
This ia fearful And that he should have "beea and
gone and done IT, after she explicitly says WAT cue p"
duced It in Italy in May 1870 ~ ,or ora and exne.
rid nee In the writing Of poem which j instinct VIA F
turity OF experience, or Us W. says OF after
Me- S 40 unfair as 10 embarras her with such
laundering as inns UE VIJy 30 the prrirdce Of Mr. Bah
I'm the Islander that lie sent 10 paNf poeln
o. Mrs h ~ nrsdce S Mr. Balls case In tie public n
and make sentiment In favor OF Ms AhsS I bch
! thingenever has courted pdble Ieputatvrn ~
having any thing published, and j. ony sI""h' " N
character who could imagine II 10 De tluI. ,t.to- =.
This SANDER We now this Lumber-st MAJOR AZ
Is source; this Albanian hero THIS ns,rous' @ b,
Wines {, luz viii hardly dull but that they buckle TIE
badge around his tongue. We send II Lome 10 A'- ~
| TOOst! . -. .ro ho,rded nv the narrow
thoatcT of his age but those Of scholar Viii DC ieuN
In ages yet unborn when the cletal susli NC 4V ng
There remains now the more serious N'.'' inr,tnie
those whose standing in the profession on ht t.,e
admits OF no excuse for vulgar mistake or udt 80
The dignity OF reviewer SITTING IN consiiNN .tr n
clothed n q robe OF Ahenlan grace prea'ni'e, 80.
classical fragrance mature in the nice estimate VI an
gunpe and its nice use, and prOnOu cE J. -
we're the d1neuts Of al oracle, uuS''"0 VI '0 F'F
one may lashly HsSail -. ~, rioerasea - IN adiudcs
ubsttey n wrre IA safer inspiration which slouiu nov
frou the claug OF brazen canldfO III the oah 49,
Dodona OF the click OF hleAeI IcI.Vt, lie one
market of Boston But antiquity may suV'.i9 ,hr 20
i,h Soary seemness while truth cOnfronts tue 9net
| ia disgrsce We aTraigu Ihe Ahdmo "VtI
| Tho organ Of the same publishers VII, seaIs
.pook me to sleep" to float it-ind whO IN lhc Euiss
| impartial reviewers are only defending eo''"e
' ReIiewer raves in the same style OF argument WIZ
which we already familiar, railery III lhe ,,,s %
Vei '.with qups aud sentences, aud paper Duio.so
the brain 10 awe a man" lilo has the same stare p,,.
ology. hopeless poetasunE ahu ,an seepers" Nc.
There slight difference nat III he ,ns ston'och
",rain whr" n this STRIKES cold on inc s1.i ,,
which Ia probably due TO dlnereht Tie sies trIia
hrs editorial char OF state 70 i''S sha ,ace of
basketful OF waste paper mo 10 .n no ,,dprnlouS
Mr. Ball The staple of his cTy ard Vet agnn
ridcuious and after that all out OF Wnonplngrr
OF the same spirit with that Other VI 4"s 80 "a
arcades aBbo-he strives 10 cover " NV u"l,es for
The iTuosiflon of his readers. trusting that iol ns
MIR MorSes pamphlet III their hands or hhte W y" tth
10 compare they will rot detect tne Miuh Ar liv,o
For example he says OF the testimony oI Mii rss"J
tbnt he MES the tme when he heard Mr ba LeI 10
"PocE ma IN Seep" by tho date of paper when 40
Mifs le called " draw up ut Mr. Balls residence S0"'