The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1867-12-11
SUPREME cuuar-spscIAl TERM.

" Little rcfsrred Ia Register nv,sht
- '''>' =
.,.nr.. .,,., c.,,,., -.
Suphtmt CuuhI-SPtIAl ltHm.
-, ,,,
The boora o. HenUn ma tne bntcners OF
New Y0rk-ImpOrtant OpintOn-The Rights
'"e i"''n p",s. ,as',o. s.. ~ ,"e oo"
, ,,-. =, -,
Ine ifope 1e. g 'eh, 'dwsn a. &C. a. me he''o'
pblitIn Board Of Healh and John A. Kennedy, Superi
t,apf se The following onnion IN tb,s hing ,gated
$50. ~. 1880 .,~.-s,. 80 !.
case wnich mas oeen decdoo adversely 10 the board OF
Health, was rendered by Judge Barnard yesterday
n. r.,r,,s .re ana h.va he.n .,nc. INC y.a, 1857
~ 80 49,, ~ s'.s' w =. 49,
engaged in the business OF slaughtering cattle In the
city OF New York at Nos. 25s 200 and 262 avenue d,
- So r..,.,h .,.n.. r.~. -. - III. -.
anu oc'o" ro'''ssn suOs" lucy a'or 10 ther oon'-
paint which Is properly verified that their business ID
"a n NO. ,h ~ not ad
10 no such and that thew have Invested IN said
-; ar.etsn r-o,ar hansc .r =, ns, ~ M
a ak o hch "a o1s,tsd ana To-. ~, sha he he
sh or ths or5insnoe hsr,, si sS
~. .an,s;n, s,,har che-ras ~. aha,s 81. tssaa
nsrsons enaaged IN tbe san hnsn"sa ar. smarv
p',a,nd snS ard sb.. mi. s.rs,o homsa,
- wsn ,s The n,antGs have hasn cosaa * h me a.
- s WI =" =, s as ,s s e ~ =, lo s NC
~ ~ =, "inoa, ,ei.i
enro 20 ~ ~ @ sna WIZ view 70 .ns
"a no r ~ Will s0y ~ nuIIn
o. forhesn s.ree' me complaint Alleges tnst me en-
q ssa Tenc Ger vaueess propery
o. .ne es.matea value O wnen hot useu ior
VIC purposcs Iol Wnicn u Is huaplSo me pisintns
a,s sas .ea p,ensss se Aaps sIean anu WI mn
tiatco anu severed ana Ihese eiegatohs nre verned
and supported by proof Tho complaint sets iorh the
oiulhaico oohp'1ucu VI. a.u WuiSh 10 - Ioiom..
THAT on and after the 10Th day OF June 1851 neither
t'e ssugu1erhs not ne urving q enl.,s ss ne yer
nued or ocnanctod a. any place. ia we Guy o. Vow
iorx SCUM Of roretn street nor snsii .ne sauserng
VI caIue oe conuuctrn ~ any paco IN tnc CITY VI NC"
YORK norsn OF sag street nor AZ any place 10
the city OF Brcoklyn: without a special written
porims from ms boaru me ueienaah's, in Ut
answers controvet tue aiieeanons OF the complain,
and claim that the business pursuit OF saughtenng
ca'ue ~ nuisance and DANGEROUS 20 NE and neaitn
They clam that piaintins premises nave been 80 ad-
judged pursuance OF the fourteenth section OF me act
hereinafter cited they also clnim power ana authority
70 pas we oTdinance IN question: humorous anluav.s
were read oy the defendants tending 70 sustain tnef
aeicnco ana alao senang 70 essosn sne' ciam wa.
cattle arvng ~ dangerous 70 ire. inc painuns aso
read aMoaslls showing thai we pa.hsns business Is
nota nuisance, moi aahgefous 70 ne ana nesi'n ana
zone wi,nou DANGER 20 human ne inese ave A. .ae
nnsor. arisins n me ,s ~ ,s@S ia re
~ ~ s,s a a c'sr ~ nv ,
M, od ~ ysIsS ~ al ~ .re & esra.
"a o, nh ~ s upon r rur' d,s
LAYS OF 1899 ,. ~, vol J. sections Z and u
c.Sen,s ovr,rs;,, ~ a,,,v ia ors
posse ssa by certain boards and Officers within me city
oha ~ cxs,c'sss ~, az Wy o
y,sea and ~ bsrsn os set or,b rar The nnrro.s 81
,ras.r,rr ~ rra.oc'in Weo - .,,n wy 49,
aissass AMI ecr Inc rrasor nroscan and secp;,v ~
ssa NH se ' ~ az cs Il - h vrsro ~ h ~
SETON ,hsi tha "a Va no o,hor,,y m ma
~ rr ,.s ~ as tn 80 ~ =.
% a., ~, III ~ - ,v :, 80
business pursuit matter Or thing b in = condition or
taro and ala among III ,ccorss wba, !, raj, r,, a =,
saecien, proof 20 thcrze ~ declaration tSs, thc same
!. y nhir rns.nca ~ ian,sroaS -, ra ~ sam. "a
s,, Hoard nav tharennn ana, ~ ~, re"orJs tba sas
as a nnssnce mud o,ie, Tho Same 40 he removed
nd s. ean ~ o, ns"ra
| ia execution "a be served ON iba owner Tho
satplo thon proyides for service or noiIee Of ina
corSsmna,,op ~ his or nronev nnsu ,se mar.
son 10 IA aectra also Tor s,sasnsion n 10 order ~
scn,sncs NJ for hafora N Hoard
and for rea,lrma;Iou or recession an the same or ne
eys,,on ,bereof and thsl no Hoard M, rsaoirc Inc
roi,~s A. arecrsc no esctrncss az ma
ib,,lv s,st sson NJ hi ae makes comics ~ IL record
AZ he proceedrs Of Inc BOARD 81 liz rules resulaous
81 e,ea az tha farfs ssIemSst ana rsef,s,a tnare,n
ronsa1raa and az nctor a. IA ia rcarfos M
apc 70 10 treated as primo e just aud legal The dc.
fenant claim in Their ansxer 10 nave condemned the
pa,nt nr,,nisas and ansiness nursoIf ANA the prcm
sse and hasinss. nnrsn Of tho persous similarly alta
ated soatn 81 s,rso, Ly yrse 81 tho prov isons
~ 80 ar, is,,o e MI. 9,,s.ssn Of ~ scfenI
| anita enssar IL controverted nv the plainiIlIs.
who dsny ina. ther premises were ever con.
mcpI,ono, IN ihe act anr, o. Iss- tho I@cislaturs
passed an sct making II mia v,I 10 drive any cattle
&c. in the city az New York except at such times and
In such manner az the dsfsndnpts might by ordnance
or resolution prescribe I. further provides that 20
long as tho defendants shall permit the business OF
saughterng animals for food below Fortscth street.
this act and 10 ore The abortion OF the ordinances be.
fore mentioned the Basrd OF Health adopted ordi-
regulating the ,iae and manner Of driving cattle.
| claim that the ordinance preventing the driving and
NJ OF CATTLE &C. south Of Forsth street Is
void and ask that the may be adjudsed, and
that the defendants dorcy tho pending OF this be
| restrained from enforcing the same
Ira SAafer. jams H. Coleman aud 7hoss0s J. Crumsr,
ter Pc'nhgs; ~ Eaoa aud George Big W. Jor Ds.
charge tba, OF 1866 and the ordinance comp
Of deprive them and tho persons whose behalf they
sue % ss propSy without doe process q law and
United staies amended article g. constitution or the
State article ,, section O. by tho enforcement 81 the