The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1866-01-01
Disagreement and Discharge
Of the Jury.
FOlTY-rOUa HOURS DELIBERATy0N.
HOW 1HH JURY STOOD.
THE POINTS OF DISAGREEMENT.
THE ISSUES THAT WERE ON TRIAL.
&c. &s. &c.

Yesterday inorhing between and eight O'Clock
thsJury IN the SirvnS Jvorce aso comngn 80 the
oheer N char4e Request for ue picsonce of Judge
0arNn. IN ssengor immediately despatched TO
bis resid for hrn, also Tor Mc.srs crs,u aud Gerry
OF the opposing counAoL Toward lsc hour 1f nins
O'Clock the court rvcpened 70 Judga tooA hls
seat on the bench aud III c TX eaod he tho
jurors.
Judge Garyin then ssked II they had come TO aoy
agreement
The Jury expressed their unan nous belief ,ha, was
impnsSiois 10 any agreement though tAey had
tbought previously they mlxhs be all, obtain md
ipg, they convinced they could do
Judge Garviu ilsn formally dischaI sed them fro any
further consideration OF tue The crict adjourned
ths court, tho Judge, tho Jury the nsc and the few
sps ts,ors loft the room, and ended the
the drama of the Strong dlvorce suit
now rms JuRr STOOD rus FONTS OF DisAoREE-
Tho following statement from several of tho
jury Will Indicate the Io,nta Of their Asrrouen aud ds
Agreement, -
had agreed upon verdict N favor OF tic pla niin
issues relating To the adultery of tho defendant AId
the ssucs rsaiing 10 forgiveness that adult ~ by
the plsniH Ia say. ". have all asrved thai tho
dienisnt hsd been xuy of Ajuiry and iat the plain
uH had not forgi,ea her
On tn rsn,AiaiDg question, the charge Of @dliiSy
against Mr. uoug, ten ~ for verdict 10 his ia
aud the roinaning tso juror, Jaucn huIas NTH
And Join J. seirs refused thor A~sst IN tnis and
upon the dsa this posnt lxl tbs Jury
sore dlschsrsod THIS uvrnibs
~ IVES, Thirty seventh str.st
JOHN y AUksTELL,
Garner n ssptb .y and fort!tth o.
hOBERf AAcKlE
x37 wss w rh street
JOAN r wiiLErIA,
~ We, rhs,y 1itL street
rus ISSUES on TRIAL
Annexed are tbs points which lad beforc the
Jury. They s~ss TO ds-id. each ssgssst.iy The
ssps " W. Jury In ssh does srsai Aa0scr
bus n tho bsas for b~auent nston for dserss
| divorce from The oouu
!. HAs Ihs dsfssdsA., since her marriage ~ish Ne
pains, and ocforr tne comnsnrsmcet u th,s scsiss.
| oopnsaistsd sdal.ry ~uh yS~ssd N sGoug,
Did tbs dsssdsni la ,h,s sc,'ca comm, sAuitsry
Apr 10 the yrsr isuo ~ ,hs ,o~s Of .es,own Qss~ss
| oanniy, hsw Sost,
lid .i,- SID d.fsoSAs, ssmm,, sasi,ry ~ssh .s.
Ldwsrd N. sfvng ~ AewtDss, osesss oDvnsy, View
YORK os,.~ days sAid mouth os April isow
l = nA thu sa.a asfe~is.s esssma sa.s,sssy ~ah
A~s'd y. .ssons 81 hssio~n. 0sssns s.esss n.v
Ysss the ssvssi days aSy dsy ~ tbs ssssss
" NAY. June, ~ md Asxaa, tseW
D. D,d th- sad assssssa s.nsms sAsiisry vnA said
Edward n. s%sons ~ ks~sosa slss~sAad ssssvus
dsys any aay Aafsas moashs " JsssAsy, sss
,s.ry, Neg. Joo. snd ocssrsf sssi'
bsd sss said svusssa s1s)s~vv wSeh ~
:--.-. .-l =: ssiS a; > bss-.ss:, ~ -.
hrrt street. VA ssld .i,yf
J. Dd ,ss sad a~i-sdan, commit sdspssy 9th ssd
Reward n stsons any day In ,Ie month q. JAY,
at Aaga.i IN ths yeAf isoo ai the house huosn No
s5 niascksr street, atio sity vi Nee tsssf
Wa tie piainin Isbof<Dt o sscs sdsit1sy ~ CON
niedD until tue 9th dsy oi Jss1sry l-si aud such
adultery "a eoDnu-Il ~t,hVyt sis cop.~nt ,oub~sses.
yr,ny Vr prosaruusnsf
A. tie dsts of Tie eOnmeEesneni of this sSilsn
had ,hsD hyo ysss c,.ps snos tha fact q sash
sdgltsrus iniercoLfs- c.ae " hs snusisdgs ~ the
yiahtiuf
40 NJ ths ,l.ntir vtth kaosla-tgs of the 'sst of
such Ai.ltsIy forgiven The naE~ ~ s-i t'i'-iistson
vita saf desscant, IN .n0sisige ~ tbe oscn.s
~ Hss tho pl.lstH, ~Ith bsO~i,iss of ts- fsst "
sacb sda.tsfy, fwgssa tho s.Hso, ssd Each foslvs
proven ~ sIvfvss pfofsf
~ nd tLc piABls commit siai,sry WITH "ns VI u
foater - aaisi ia the De- snoa ssisssi ~ the o.
fsndaut thui sCtsys " L~r ssgsismfn's sns~"
"a this .Ctosr
- DID the p,aintr e0mms siutrry With ous tlscta
Putisf stated 10 the dssncs sissea by tee dsfsBd
Ast 10 ths fosfh of Bof ssplsassla! asA-ef %
tLis sctlonf
"a ND tic psnn commit sigiiery With sns tlests
Po,sr aa,Si tbs d~fsss alleged ~ TIE csfsoa
sat ths nih scciiVa % her saIlisEsuss sns~" ia
ths sctiyr'