, 1866-03-18

"
CAL Frotoetapn.st* ii particular. But, eiaee
yoa r:y mo tho compliment or thinking
.l.as what Il aaia in my Fct.de's y fozatrs'
EtchosAs u rad and llsteLed 10 by some
tne1ieans, ! beg to recommend 10 your 40
sice tie further explanations which | bars
added to the passage quoted hy you, In tho
list published {lhe Peopte's} edition Of that
work. lhxve directed the rnbilshet 10 sen1
Jou a copy, and II tie important journal
with which you arc connected h pleased to
attach euy yalus taytur opinion ca tho tub
jet, thai opinion Will S1r 'f6rua' mach uure
completely slated, With. additional vplles 10
rsottesAanlat arguments, In pp. SO 70 Us Of
TIC rcupiera sd,lion. a ;. =
NJ am, dear sir, yours, !a'thfally,
4'"J. s. MILL"
IonS a1rAuT MIL OK PROTECTION iH .Er
CouNrRIEa-
The folioaIns Il ths extinct 10 rhlh sr.
AIN cslla xttenllaa :-~-- !
..la eunpt1.os tu HbFt Tic sysisn Of presrchon
is yn:ttl s.Ats.. Insssins II. s.sass lnte aoee
Hhteh II toss cd ecaaptomtte be,~ue1 froe u7de
and ersslt unn. tAutrlY: tLss protoe1ton for pro-
sue onreiio. ahle d hivtns II maca protret,on u
lnxr 4, Eaet:s!ly re1slt fFt.sn 'nrsd tanned solely
tsr r~tane, E'en ~ En.t.na, r.=Nt Il s.aassasaes
=
reEvsa m cre.. aeeuult ot tue ttSeuue w0ukt
Jie!d. 3-dsFe1adenty. howe>e4. OF thr Srrh:al In
policy ct taiss OF lie utot.>.e~ u ise. ,al. Goe
Etftc s1lo&ks tbA ke1, l:xt E1trnur !. rrcrsrtd
tnty or the qualify Imported. bot tsal tlr TAI IL
rad On Tho enitzu Guat:ty Sun,utae1i ~ ntzlt
W. pseae Esy much r.: .hs Es..g sasys's
lrtcpuc. In The ezss Of ntznn'Aetusca articles tia
turut1e tnvolsc. 4 ralpAb|e tn<pp.iaahnr1- The
ssitttt VIA u aaors.irx. even iaesdsa'tl,. sny
projection, 1t can only rtrFAss rsQtsct inn IN 70
faf II !. ltsyrnla tppd1 md 10 wsa!e+sr T.
.r: ssgs + 7sr'<al' 'a'o''1aaa ii .a'fs' ~ rev.
Her follows the paragraph commencing,
AsThe only case h. whicn, On mere pdacsples
of IS,lItlc1l ecuroHr,'' e., quntcd by your
coy.e4pondcnk "I'rutestion"; sud Ats. MM
thra c4ntluEeas
..7bo onp vr,tet of s:y reputation - pt,1.:setl
ceonomlst; who Log adaer. 70 The i.rn.trasoat.i
dottin< AF. A. =. Earey. scrI* tfs aefcnce. Ia N
] tps fs III % s9sss sss,p: n eo.t u esni.st, s7ss
sreur on pftinc,nx cfa1ratGi1srs Al " ssfr nsat
iAe E.sase ~bsre thtT nrs 10 b~ cou .unpd- The
ttle. .hapoft<d and ~ tho~r t1po+ted In e1csAptr
fv lhrri, lie Ersxl,t. dtecs hu1ihen on lhr pro-
dneeE-, 4Ea Eos, - Ia osEltaaf. ,he ruth % she
Gun. Etutff- tn hIn1*ue1tr It falls: II u wtE1nuf
de4hl. h1rIhtD the Industry Of the ~1ttd. Ent
II Il otslcu. tun t:st Mr. tasey co-s aoi "cr It. u
sne Of ths m.n. tsPtl.'ns ts1es 10 BIZ hook that
a1sentaxrs Nsh. ttn.tn c43isy boukaf ta for
ti9n cuuufsJ VIII dnnestic nroou uce IN spite nf tau
donblt coat q: tA<Ace. the laet eso*es that hksrJ
thst eorf n,ay te. The ssvtas In cert Of sfo61e
uaf, oht~ stxt1 u. ard the ro'.~cl.E atos u The
rr4ntsy u 90 lka rhole htttet rs:ncesated th,n
eF vantlgr nta.s, psn:p:un< aE,3. which Isre
srsde bas 10 powS 10 ahsocAles sbn unass A'neEa-
q eatn*a NOR ', otis:nln4: hrr E.anrfastasts
though thn uaesssn 1t h~r coru E7d cotton. ttsu
els !os.. IN cp<I u eataee, H. e4p.t.. emrlot ..
IN rtptadnR earn III toflo, in annnalsT ther.*sed
| QUsttttles iet The trei.E fra,tef aaVld turn y
trr.inf e,ods Of l4iustsJ IN ~lieh th.su leta
eort o1 t1riryr 10 ~. esc II nAt b. only t.tt-
teatpE fer ttrapo... .nd suesex ter'As:st pro
ttessar- The etp-rs4s et peoinet.oa t~1ne al~ats
rrta'es: =. efrs. MS. happrn tt+a tho ts1,e nc
d,ettou. sherct rsEyts r,u.s s.ra1tae+o1s- Euay
nos tetc.,e ~ unsa feer restssr ac:x'snn q p.
cGh'r7y .ots. hhch II > 1at Ia k tKTlssr1 tfat
pr, sl~ s{ccHl3tnts shu1k 1ruf IN aScf tnat t-tr
setvrt+o7% tnav t~ t-ct.aand hy thesz rE.r. aavA
shrsvtnrr conceded 'hE 10 a~w eonnis{. ten,-
ea!J Eefrnsfbt eoss:ltioR, howesrr. th1t II he
cn,irtty f,o1td IN pHr. 81 fsE1r md t3russ.!aa he
Se % r1sSaasss tssrr,,str sts:s. easa ,ea,,ar.7j
p1uet11nn II Of tLe k4n.A nasnsr - paieo1, nod
| fhuaA b sGss7prd ~ tknllst onudiaoos.
of III eSosotse 6tneEts pscs Il4stu. sp3;iss op~
y to conatries to~e e1Ierts cons u a1tu!st
! psct.sess. Ee x-1aea saathY s,4ae ofth., As-Sst
scs1as s pes 4S: ass u ,ae isss Il H. ts es9n
II, ~ brsue ccnsuraxrr sanhi do, lhr ft-dx!nx
e!rsaeufs ~h1ea they at+tssct hun II, Inls s-Hu.
! L!fQk f4tEE1tES bS Q i1C
| truth or winch II fl fon.te:-a :;rth wtkh has
1e!y !a!eiJ en.ao - 1t rtdsr~tood. aH. with Ii
heocefcsth Grst,tet 70 tt Parliament cement m
the tto:kk:s of ttAessntE Il sur1l sIwasl tAte
ht<n IN The 5e.'aatet Of raf1zs. To tae qas.ttnn
u ps4s eettao.trn, tpxere1 1t ;. trreesaut ThAl
tc tslrrense srp* III ofssx bss:sa, In Aaa-rst7 to
s. ss & sse Z + ,se oe1
era eA.ts, &n1 that t.,h Ate alErsly tt teee ptt
dacisve u a. fofr.trlf. ssr4'ett 10 ntsA sssn u
alresdy fstd fesp'e1inf eQ.t Of cai.ssr~ T. the
aess sss esase. Assrasa tc x.gess saH:
her .d-sntsre. -, thea fas noa:d Us: pss1tst n
! e1p~tss NV p,tcurr Rsd:uFcsi:aR nAnraetufrs,
tnI itE<tr Ihan The isner sne SD u doug 70.
txceeted ~hst the taHn<c esAt heE; n. ahea t:
tecaase AEr3 1nr beg to stpats fh- eot the
rieraenl. Of fsttiltJ rhicr .as hsd rtci aesy, II
r. r. ta,1n.: T. ~ so.t y R"at1.a ~tss r ssase c
! are taSethrr. E.As1ee 1an,d r. tneRt<,a. Aed u
/ Ett, III ssrcrt Of rem ~onH reAse, l. c.sdea1
takra p.se-. il ,arse aas 30, h~eu i,-sr II bfn1 =
eo1etsat tas<xssoa u is~ to''. nr: ~ s1t1ns" ~
ef ,arh fertility, tae euI.tratcn q Witch eaao:.1
aas.slo:a ot zssss;s I. so1p a. !. !, 10 atStr 40 10
axex f~'tet 10 htrak up utN ea1is lAu to 1,xpa Z.
the old. America Nln t:Eles t~s.or.s > teGE.v ira
porter ai nazrgzr. vii vtlhtf: t-pse-1as tE,k1
gro~ efHn ttsr eese.t onsf. C13 manufacturing ~
lefreE. ~tn nnsAc t+f nhnasx, ~ ~, cAtsI t&ifea
Fer ,n-<e cb.tor. :~.,ons eo:a Mr.. cast3't
etonoa1e s,9usuerr for i1us+t ,h4.I-Ea 10 " totsJ
lnr1ltd Tfse econpnH. enuetar- Il fsl ie1a, brtna
ssettts o,.cs teesoa e1sree,sts u, aatt u "A IN
sred Es.:. 9ron oo:a!n: ssp=sar % ~ roasoa,
mo.. 1,r >un~ dsfsssea ~ The higher sn'et-.T. 0
haEan's{. than hI p11s, eeono+n 1-A.oas l-J
ard ~ lacy u stet i1ssi- ats1a II nrer.sas
ttnc1c s.oucu that 1:4I should eu+ne:ce tbe,
istxas. ts rassn4 q ir.trrhaae- ul'n thrIr t-Ist
h11.I..tn rscPIc o. ra,s a.,' ea:.sa,if. II a,1
l etu+~ u haId he rutus1 rlafI-ttn- U ~1'sa aSt ~
tArxtaF et stsas-uttes thaa ~&th {ses?is % Il
cppoeiie stae of ,ar tfos.. Ioey ecasevs ,hst ii
pnrpp;t--4 usttGa zG 4rTtss::tas.1-car1ht stsaE
| hsRt sts'e u ets1na:ioa AID eetsasr- .And ID
IT, ,hs7+ .,.,,t T. rsa, svanass:sa .. r7'a, q
Tns.fd st.se.. sitA us.11 tse sar.l,s.'aa,. i: =
| rhisxrai +..&o<41tne. 4na tne1f own tsan.t..--~1
pos.isie ot noa. i iii psaiI.s,. 70 H. koxese.
u an Object 10 sseet The etcc,st'p d.sptsio
ofth* population, Nj. Wafrsest aa> pots;rd cs
d, posing q its r1oceprs+i .aa.. h! rfs.i.r lie
prsee; ia+tFsl ot INV etfng II. Or ptttcc asa! I:
! .a~. *rssnltorA:s> n l. !arxesT Ssp~ .tatr =
t. Mf. Es,ey, il. hiun, M trn:rc1ort,E i: -nE
. I - nre~F~a1y thu: Ohio sd Ntthcan ttoold
,, | rfu!efiet A:&rtst Nairnc5c*ts ~ urn a. af1rs
tnare u,an tnose Of th- oil country. A~t-,ncn
. h!s ctt.dc1afsia u fl!tag1nga tarItsetutios pos
}suu:: 10 tk:e doozs Of Ire W>ttetu tIE,es. bo.tt
AQA -&RV HO N0t fHPfI{ AAF AEuAA Et ttk
+. :smns 10 tae Western psstd-t, tny testes 70
Ma1kLester; snd It u ~ otTc7at TO get rack i
Entnuft trura lat ra,e place. ~ t1rEa lbs otnef.
FaHE 1aADt aSp PROTECTION IL TUE CssT]
svAIEs.
Tlc d}seusslan uf Ills cucttioo In the calEln
! Of tho Chicago TI.bESx H. beginning to q
! clte gFtat aNlount Of interest On this sde
4 TIC Atlantic II would Ii we'll for certain
T your correspondents to know That. in :.
i. | cr!nIoa q. rs'lIiieat economists In Ills coz
T. try, cot ore kinsle esEamen. has yet ceca Z
:. sxEsed sfslnss tho adv liability Of ssee tsas
b which hcsrk the mcsit u originality
: ! their ot}ce:1ons, excuses, pless and !at1ae
!. ! have been Csci by ihc1u II second hand fl
! E1rppe; and rttea not zdd thAtH bcco..
~ rather a.apsInS 10 dad tho rlaycd-ou! slso1
= I !,!cs Of the Old World located and heptal'
! III The Cnited States. havo lstd telorr
h jpr C7ne1Al Thompson, Abe Frli known
It ,her sf the "Casechis1a on tho Corn Laal
y = tic following two propositions Of your p
r tcetlonh,s, two which, By then, Ic rrec1rt
q 1s fundamental aud indkputs1se. 5as i
=. s.,l h.. r-e..::....i way Of summing up =
x .mashing Ah4urt1ltiea: and Ills lscouisns b,
" pr,vsd as elective for freedom In this cc
.ry ~ the eloquent hxstugpts Of SScs'
=; Golden and fright, And The dcepIy stIa
= arguments u such economists - John Stu
Y Nlll, 4n such trllorn ~ Foublanque. e
Thompson has written The following lGtt'
II my request, for The columns Of The I
=. hukE- .....
y. | lEf1fx& rRpx MAJOR nE~~NA1 rnokt%oN. nr
10 akrtssn AAxf. II KtctI ~ t-Fsofser1os'.l
l pTHEEs.
E4ot VALE, EiArkuEAru- s. z,
re- letras.y ~, 1a6
rp-&E hat
aAn trpcs. on fore1en manufactures that q
m eonp-ttstou 1ilh ihe hut.e nsste cef.cs.
| .9rAse1 lhe sslue oI tha tssness proAueta. xnt
=. va.s~ ot uechaa$cs. In = eo-tss poDdfnS eatn
~ the tntreate in roe poec ot tbe rotcctsd guods
s1- The an.kef tpps1ts to BE- thai
:nzt ..An tnFost 11 bsvtEa masuh11srs 1nt.c
ptpGs+ xrd. r+-ta2', ataes IN lhe isfpt~e'td tn
1as and esuarns.h,s them II tht trsdar wteh. Ia
nc Of :+redotn. UouH he u.t stcT frnss of vast /,
I ep-ni on The tEtsTed trkde- = h,ca Ea,kcs se1
II loss Ia tha Aggregate 70 tsads. And tla hns
Ia Il Ihhi the .at. n1fhirr