, 1866-04-29

sherE rhehrt.r 70 p,1rr nat Ii was not Aa..e,tn
10 lha Prt sner rrnI he fFst srked tho G1set aar4
Regarding tse rottesl ae.rim1ny ne iesfnu'
eorrssl &gast ,tas ,rhA the e1cert:os Ct Pr. Cor
all tts ne1itaI wstrtsfes Jaw him u jill ds,
*sn dr.e,n,ned upen Escn d.setns uss {aaeou
rared ~ fhe ptfacneFe cnunset. or ono of thctu
sed H., pt,tnoFr eoa:d aea :es ins bala1e of tte
their ,hoorJ The eelo-,ou would par. ava, ~o<.
fhc obj Ct OF The csla.toR vs. seEaorsd from hIm
h1i in Ih,t eate, lnn strt hi. x!a hnd htsn butct
*tafea he n*pt,e>,cd 60 eortr.tiou, bas snu ),
lsEorted IL futsffs hih rentsret- H.
TIE counsel. copesudlng In b. sef md eMcibk
Testimony IN the case In liz tek1nz rpon The tsrsi
thss !hH phi trrr ~ar dsu on tan o1en1nZ Of lr1
ton.dis. nd ~ la,pstsd II 'ae dcsats. OF IL.
INSTRUCTIONS ron rIsE FxeYEH.
The CoaEt Instructed thu jafy % nehaii Of ~
ftf rnAt z,usde4 /. the unlawtai killing ot . b..
mag h snr IN the peucr Of Tho rropls Nita male.
afote'herrh: eitaer. xprr.sei o inlHtte*i.
ID. N..'ce hall hs rmr'!+.s when ~ son.tasfsM'
u the killing thoN Ii aha0donrd AID H4h.c4n,
%. The killing being prosed thc burden Of ptny
ins elepusisne-s of Ml'fsstiun OF that justify Of
exetrc 'hr ho1r,e3ds w,ti a-sotsa on lbe acenest
rhltss fbs {xoNs ths part os The pRrseen.u .ui.
auouuia 10 raan,IarEb.er O. that tho seensed wta
jrennrd " esruAed IN to'psatilnx she huppettp.
3se. A REASONABLE donht meant IN hw feftou%
and sahsautiaI donbs- and not see utse Possibility
VI 4 c1uh.
fsh. Hthe jc1y bese.s t:usn tbr evaeenee that the
oetel danf y hco snkT VA uEt orsstlJ skne aud
.t:r, sud IhAi for ) nnmb+r Of seafa prior to the
tl!I3re Of his wIc, he In Ut. Of IN.
t.1icst!on. 10 1tc Violence uJon hsz. snd knon
tbst sch r!c2rucn wHs tbs tL,net ate resul. OF
atn,ies,.op. snd ,ksl. having sIci knvu ctlss, b.
,utn- srliy snsts himteH ntox1tatcd On tba day pa
ms killing q hl1 v,fe, sne y tne tny telest e
lorat = r~7taraht Guuht. tLat eueA killing the
direct retut Of auth tutoxl7tsoD. All sh,i thr DE-
lusion ~rt 10, lie eaaesnt eanta q tne honle.d-.
:t-n the defendtnt y ftsponsthls for thu aet ED
the Jury Phollt hn1 hin guilty.
7ta. The lusY Err ln.erpc1et ~ > n,atter vi l.w,
1hst 5Hsn u ro1 10 t< excnseI from srApons{hili.
" fof cz1n.lEal se1 II Ea has cxpse1ty and reason
fight md wroIg a. to the !cuas se: he I. dc!ps
knosssedgc md epu.eiou.ntss shst the aet Lt 4
doleE T. ~E0rs End CRIMINAL, aod vii Fubtect htm
7trTr'oer, The JuiJ shall belt4re, hpc, 'as ev1.
teate in TIL. tA.r thAt the prisoner. II Tho o&
.ho euusE1i+4fon u The ouEoetde, had sufficient
vt.ns ~ to the particular act he - !hcn aotn9.
III kt 1~tttfhe anf 1o1sne-s y1is al f-a-
abe dt0ha ihsS The acl dol. + mas wrong
tnh tssuntai, 1bct tssr jEsy ought 10 coustct The
pEtsoner
Tu1 u. tk@onef. tho tou1t furthcs Ia. .tIueted tie
f'he ,u.y ran s-< oocsle all the eT!deoee in The
EA!s &endfpe 10 <4ow drunkenness wi1h TIC ds-
Enf. q 'a.snNy: u !. the,r duty 70 DO 70. sad
II lhe fnfy h-l#vF from the Ef.depkr That The
itl.oner u she tItoe OF The killing ~bs s',osrx na
lit .ac6 dsla.!on ~ tic esent esase a. ln rs
:rs then 1! lalte-s cot Rhlt nrre the e1a.s wh.c b
:en TO- Of c,talfd, Of excited epeh insanity. they
>ani,, II ez-enslal 10 constitute eilac, ,pd tha
:nrcen os cst4nltsaIns It II on The stzts, and II
1rs1 b proved s-sund EvaAouan!s doaa1. tR the
ii tie iufJ ~ not abte 10 s,r that the taeory c
scasu!'1 set up SoE 'hs defence t% fAsro beyond 4
tra .or ahic count. The tasy must st4u,,-
ttns ef doing The Act charged. tho pEsuper VIA uo
Of fonnc nilsd. eas adyGted With tn<zulf sud s1et
4s*1lou ~ss !ue eetent esa.e OF the AeI. Rnd thai
r. uuuId nsa hs,- dune The act but tie auectipn
th+s must stqut the p<ts Uutx .ndsn9 the
tr!frse ffotu ahe rvatense that the prisoner bad
he~r ds'nktnx, aod rs uadeE The i0aucIGe O.
3tc1xh the yns, shall bxIe.e from. sbe er1deue.
tat The 2E7toneE eot1u,Iftsd The ret Of houlcdds
1arstd In 'hs tnaie etll f shey shalI oeitc't
ach "a he "as under shs lnaneEes Of an insant
it'H.en In Keszn 10 The chasttty pf ets vita. ant
nit. M - seeh non,ictte, Lea thE fu1y sooaId .pa Is
ar,.Gt5 oct fri3ty.
The yIf, ie,s hz .Aslruefrt Tat u, upon r.
ses esai.s doses y 10 tst r1,s,saoe nd iaa1saes
a3un tie pFt1trr nf sueh te:nxloA At ft1e time
esf7sn,'irnx saea soE,iclas. isen they mast aequi
tho pttsonet.
x=raIc1sn.a OK k1rtxr rxs.1Moxr.
fhe reart ttsttd tca: he hid &i1o hern re
| 'lurtsed 10 inttruet the Euy II relalton 70 th'
At!ctt 10 he ast1Ehrd IN the areEuary ol expe1t8
bu' tbuuid ccciu:e to do 70, pnIen1ns 10 ee.d tn
ftlsoa !nS otlIion uf nrtt.e!ae the sapsr1
4nu of thIs zt3:a, in the s1t.t e44t- daring th
April 'efD af The ets1rt. 1867. t8lst Ill. Htrure
| p. :9d.)
Iii! satd., L. snfty r.y te tim9l..ed 80 na,
ap1 otter te1ltloan defence ~ 70, up to scrren ta
guI1t5. The EVIDENCE II ihu ees. II. ltAt 1t 10 e1
etettpcly difficult to elnuIAie insanity 70 A. Y
xEod dttect3cu II IT. bnt very t3scly :h1t ctNttt
has income sobt-ct Of careful 4cftnt1hc tn1es1i
| gataon. ~atch IA, st2do ADD u making n[pd PIT
| xft*s. Thta turerttcauun eaah}e% t1perts to d.
:sct simulated ir- unity With snuca uuEs eef:al:f
| 'l4n c1Elc formerly he done
hhall 10 Igt.afs kna danounet Z Tt&pls4 oe hu
| Dsn ss1cJ and fe-eRsch On this sat1tct nhiis IT
| :7,cfD acA spp:xud shr sdEarermaJs Ct tcteot
"a iii oihef scrcsEonat leoprts Aa5 ruv.sn a.e.,.
| IN nj ctt1t11ed e1nntlrrs, rreoGulyA theta BY II
erection Gf Tx&l A1yiE1nt for fnese S+t!ottuEate
sttrr THE te.ente be carefully studied By tkos
~ho cet Ole thcss AseA "a tat 1ntesug3k3on of hn-
.unf. r1s, Wfsr~ v<ry nsnF ~ eafrfal tttcuttn
rl-s1ufnt tse srstpstd mi beeouae r>~fal member
:n,essiaz.:0n cAt sea9t.e no s&ats OF this suh:ec
| "hltc lie esue study and tu,ttttzstioa ~tn COZ
| ftsntIy asssssp new Eulh* On ali otht
| .ut:eets would r. dAstre xssEE:p.lon Hppn v bic
! Ne eAtrp+ roofc1t 10 h2rs itlln~ nsAc. It n
line this question VISA hrst bsorxht teCorr th
ours itnAy b lt1t y wss To stGuc Cases lll1eu
| 70 ae.aet tuarsted tHaAnitE. tins the Courts ms
| htv~ hevn trtuesd tn otrfthfrN thu well establtal
Cd tass 10 met The apprehension; hut kti[s danse
| t2m wrn eunrlutetl that We thIrld nahsr. 70 II
Old md well est,hit.ied rHtes Of The tr:nial1 As
ALd that we shno1d zequlrr Ar }es:. a. much cs
I IeEer to convict t51xv man n f1oe Hht.~