New-York tribune., 1866-12-22
CIVH COURTS.
SUPERIOR C0URT-TEIu TPni-Brc 2l-Before Justice
MCCtNN.
RIGHTS OF THOSE WHO PLAY FABO AND LOsE-sT2Icr
PLgADryG REQUIRFp.
John s,dDaTi mar Dol,S aet HeTy Eytinre ct al

complaint upon Ec ground hat did cot contain iacs !" coz
ftituts Of Ah"r The erImclts o. counsel
] adge MoCun rendered the following dcc,hi3ni ...,
This acaon IL hnsed on The l4h section ' hf,t we p
chapcr - Revised Statutes 1ae section IN i' words.
L,ey person 40 shan. p AyI.s az a.5 tso, - % & ' t
stinR tie suin or value OF 90 or upward ana ' % &
liver tAc any part theicu. may within t,e en'H-
months ane- suc Payment or do' eJ sue 1I az r'' % 'S
money or Yalle m tie things 80 iosi ana pau OF o
the winner thereof Tic complaint contains no O.. lihl
Tint Of Tie money ~ lgLi 10 De recovered 20 or upN.I
lost az uMc OF sitting lAc drttlo.tl' Sl uls y nm ,
zion aBd accordingly 10 ai,la tHe hc.lo o. f pou
raised by the moiiol apTeIb MOI 70 nave hegA lla s
mined IN any reported c4ae nave bestowed
upon Qu stuV ana the result Of ny dcycrOl J, h 'Aa
Gecncants assume tenabe ground and tnnt ine cnaA a
hhits no cause OF action II u lnrdhmrhiA hnu '' @
Of peabg lat ever! substantive lac hec t'ij h h4 70 ~
maintenance Of the action must be- covered by IN arWe
svcrnent ~ thc declaration or complain ,lneoa Con-,
rncnt Pleas s. Gouds Pleading 49) Tho supreme Col'E
Of the United States thus pTopOunds the principle '-c aJ
feet necessary 10 be found On TIE le, ~ oIei p ~ ~ ,
plaintiffs night Of recovery the deolf ijn or e'mst Wu''
fact" Ganko the United States ag Smith u hcf'on ~
In our practice the rule is not relaxed uat u ! 1v
prove and which the defendant has rirat % conorc 90
bis answer musAe distinctly ayercd IN pn, concise Gad d.
Crimsead 10 Barb III Bridge uft payson. Sgna. -
SOdaAd no.; OuondaRa An Conference, IL Barb 35) ITO
Now in the case before it viii mol he denied that The loss ui
s2j or upward at time or skiing Is essential TO thc pain
sction or recovery Of cs srn - siugl' sitting The
only allegation o los ~ tie comrnu is a on % ABOUT ne
i3h Of September lrj the defendants won et gaming So
&c ~, r. ii af time md "anrSi d, col tined as r1ayacnt
10 m allegation that the ainu lost g. upward ai sitting
Hence tne cen nllai4In esseanl ayermcnt and
- ~ G1v dctprti,e Al cnmunn law no action laws fIr
money lod a. gaming. The sp'h Cf that geltlrnany
system of uSsWuocnce would not tolerate Tie idst ht
a after tahas the chance Of vhhihg fIoai9 cone
excluded from the benefit Of M process by The maFn N pen
delo potter cooto o!'TdSnS. I4 eliy M Che reign %.
Queen Anne statute lu,e tie psernSg %, nct'n ior1f
money; and tnut the original OF our Own Glgc.
,nt I'm few crr drr obi law are reported ir tle Elsh
books for that few persons have peea wiling 90 eN
pose themselves tp odum OF cudca'c-HE 20 reclaim ~
arur ybo ey had nir, ,.t on an eQtm hazar howe7ar
IN > NU BlUkAtuue -. . tiN E.n.f.
stone 80 and IN Ncsev J4. d@ hud cac. arising urscr
tb otue rt In none - coutvoyr.trd 0t e-iccantion
should contain an o. every ic, which . -E uSkes
esscuato the plaintiffs night Of recovery. o. ur contrary
the ncccsy OF uch ayc1raut is assumed po.'ae Ol
reason nud authority then Che complain, ir t5 action Is
mi, 1artu,s- fc code invests TIE co-'s With very liberia.
Gscrfon bn. il prc.cribe, one restriction which hg ihc
amendment must De in iutlcraHr' ~ justice cannot aer
how Justice would be- promoted by oulJn-n person recover
winner b, wuu.G ildi.pu'ahT iochet hs gam Wl al
paintia h,reis cicar cnri.cd 90 10 udulEoee
4HE vAL'l o. -ieiT coNlEJ, %; =. ILL, Al.
The pairfif bad of.f Of N'. l- 'srt w..e tlefi'-
lcrdant al. hai '.e upper a.". Tac D. lt" So. GO ou
tuI 10 h., ba'ut., i .r, im .l' 70 's' 'al ,'H.c Of
tie iiaeree. ia q, asG Inc - gi. m tl, onro 5p
prr- cn-le through fho sLA o. e- Oc and Oh, ''ir cuft
ihcqshAIon o.. lol dcoa owing t. 4cr', .rhegoe was
indrst tie p!a. M y',lcts 81 up ,ba q. ~.
no. tlc prop.- par' TIA. 10 light, v- really eo,'aiya
r,, i.r- r-. ....,f o y--i.r' q. rl,.r'f fr ,ra
siTJI~ Teiai-rrc .i--.a,Irt &- Ja't..s Ho.'lr-.N
lIc-yo",.
August C. Do'vuaa ae'. F7.ds G,.aI-e.-J-.ie.
vacated a-i -. .ta'-'l with s., .''it .,-.
VII. r-. d. -Y... n ic-r.
Saua. sa,n a NOM. T. ars.-S .,o- F-.,t.-. md
Aif. ~r'r'.- ss James Igrrt sac.f-2io-on
grl 80 a.t .-'rr.r. u.1.I.. i'- '. -l.'. ...
ss.- y '..g 90 'a' ."-i --.'.'.H 1'.''..
...--N' F.,...' H-,r.. .........,
o,ar,... l.s ,.ei e... = .ar..
o. 3D.. - ,...'- t..-,. ca.@ Gaze b.. '1 -
r.-r.r..u. H.Irr-r.
gas. F... r- a "a.e r-. rf
d. l -.' .-- o- - "
Ha. yy,c or. g.t- I MO-. r--.'t ,-f-.-.
tra- G. -... s-. o.s- l4.--',-... .....-- aI
?. .s. ..-.. ,-.'...tl. ...sf.
E,-5..r. .r,r.n
1..re-N MOO.
s.r. ~. c7-ar-ar,---r--l. ..-.~.s, J. lie.
u..'sTISa.
M.ar1 er.. - ..r-'. Vol H. '., 'd.
y ,f..-' a. a- % ,il,a--'''..oa ...a..' Oh
ir.1I .s, 4a 3'le.. s,-li. .os s...-. a...
,,..q.. q. ..,..-.,.. .. .'.s 70 g.. ... N,,,..
r1rA. ,,.-.a,l- ,-zA1sm" .oN'v.. le.' oaiio.
I. o. 2ll '-" 81. "-:. .'''.t 10. +'-' w. ".-'I. aa!
lrrs--.a.-. - s.' f-a,',a.s r.. - h".a Hr"1. b.,
u-.- sr'.- hy BE- '-. .tocAn. '' '.. al .i
,'at-- .'' o.. a''.-.. ~. UT. 2, p, 80. - . ..
Jr-,- &C.,. ,....l c..f-rrF- 'r te et -.no '-at re
4o. ,it.s COMPANY rendered o.. u. ly .Ic hode.s
so- 't stock rut r-u..r' .... i-r 'i'- rt"'
o. th, isr,,-. o. tsttoDr1 o,afI ola sae. aol v..@
g.. holder, Dr." 5-s1 lcr d ilc right nj f1" t.r ~'7-m
Proc. AM lrslust n license have oo ..- ..' 'n oi
i.r .our duIu1 he week. r.' fH .- hlrH ig-
,o..-., ,ssy ITr a,rrosi' vubc oose- fr vr a-ny BY
i'.yc vera c'abors,ry rrcard bv Mr' ar-4o Fullerton
AZ st~adgo Emoti y the applicants aad eA Judge ""oau'
Ciacrr.-nzr 2L--lrioTc Sir. JrslC EucoN.
Az ALLE1ED NuisASaE-TnE orEsrros of sUISAYcEs-
PRETTY wAIIEE Girls" &c, &c.
Pautig is tenant Of az aut gho ows cogsidcrabe prop
cry the northwest OF Mott and Chatham sis Pain
tiG hired yc large basement on w. eo-l rom defendant
fof the pun pos' Of conducting billiard and concert snoon lie
had ason 5ooiing gallery on TN rcm,rs 'nu employed nearly
ycars IRON the st oi May. s15 Ancr being there few
months he alleges hat his saloon bccGm partially flooded AZ
account OF econieHs Of espoo next door
ia Moii-,L aud sInsd on property belonging 10 doendnni
cracks and creyccs IN saloon that tue stencil no
cradle driving away his customer and pretty waiter girls
and rendering It Impossible tor him ond hs family to reside
thcre tcy wsr! W ' TIE purpose o saving Aouse rent
that.e had called defendant attention to te matter, but Ae
Ieultd l Ntli nc ai"" P-4lh 10 ItAeug ~
al has own CAp"Asc
Ar Chauu .v schaer counsel for p1i1f said that bis
cly was OBJ take tig I.rfh0l Dt Obtaining redress
under existing circumstance appeal 60 the Board of Health
woiI b. E,t,ss tie .tc tai 10 one could be found 10
nbste nuisance and then tie f.sk Of cg pnd by the
owners Of the property when the nutucc cErd According
the nOIs of the oard oi ih TIE oA ner OF the prop
crv where nuisance is u1aed must TIE party nnfng IT,
but as they generally refused DO il unless compelled BY
law and ns the expenses o law sun Nti' oeh mtc tA1h
the expense incurred IN nbsHg Tie Nuisance would DO
%. oh saS Ya ot ~ [ lis client for The pos,ti,
oud indirect damage had sustained H expected
. O 10 e OJ damages 10 this proceeding and would
then npy for Injunction 10 TcgtIun defendant nom
tlnuiug thus nuisance which Ar Scaler snd, II defend
ant interest do rs continuance would amount paci
cay 10 on eviction OF pnth and defendant could then lease
the promises for double the present Tcno 30 per annuD
That ia af1l