New-York tribune. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1866-1924, 1866-10-16
CIVIL COURTS.
SUPERIOR CoURT-TRiAL TsRx-ocr. h-Befors jus
tice GARvIN.


CITY RAILROAD CASE
Wilhelm Gabel agt The Thni-aye. Railroad Company =,
This was OF the usual railroad cases, IN whicn
the plaintiff claims that he injured through the negligence
OF the railroad company appears that he hailed car when
stopped for him and that when the point Of getting In one
foot being actually the STEP the impatient conductor saed
the throwing him down. turning his ankle and otherwise
Hurng and as he claims making him him lame for s The
general denial and that his injuries they arose as stated
by him are not 50 severe as he attempts TO make out That
the Court adjourned h 70 today e Pr9f 9Ts his testimony
Alexander A. Besse agt Benjamin Moves
In itself but OF peculiarly unpleasant nature in ITS attending
circumstances having occurred In the presence OF lady with
whom he had supposed be had at the time rather tender TO
lations.
Alexander A. Besse the plaintiff testified that he bired the
The Miss Gardeners He occupied the
house On the I'D OF January ls5 when ne returned az aDu
that this his house and he did not want him In there lie
stated recognized the lady his wife and showed HIN
had been paid by him MI Noyes prang up and
seized him by the throat and neck Miss Gardiner then inter-
ered and demonstrated with Mr. Eoyes He had never I'LL
then received any ntnaon OF alienation the part OF Miss
Gardiner He had heard intimaton that MI Noyes desired
fore The plaintiff consequence left the house and Mr.
took his residences there and now lives with
the hdy Connecticut having married her three months ater
Crossexamned-I was married before this Miss Gardiner
he'd previous this requested me 10 leave the house had
not previous 10 this come the house in Of ntocaoD
had made no threats boardes in the house OF what
II
any inmaton Mr. Noyes that he was engaged to Miss
Gardiner the first thing said when saw MN on the SOFA was
Leave my house - Noyes said had no business there 70
leave the paror he was going protect Miss Gardne Miss
Gardiner told to to my room SAID was the LANDLORD
showed INV receipt she said mind but did not ask me 10
leave the again till after Mr. Hoyes jumped up saa
nothing further her. did not cab her names nor use oneh
ye words she did not request Noyes to rid her Of my
presence don't remember anything at that tune ld 10 M
Noyes when he caught hold OF me said Let me go ne
did not let 20 until Miss Gardiner said LET go him then
my room, the house was boarding house agreed
floor il was very respectable have been in business
in New York for y years. have been about SIX months away
for the defendant argued that the ann was
reality but boarder at 0 week and his claim to be tho
landlord such foundation ridiculous and that the plain
tiff had brought the whole matter on himself by his own Ills
conduct.
dent Of New Haven lie married Miss Gardiner on the lIh
Of February last he had known her four months lie
I'D Of January engaged Miss Gardiner Mr. Bess
knew this had himself told him in the very parlor days
that occasion used some indecorous language toward
WAS epSsred To- @ Gardiner and must hc
the d Of January Mr. Besse into the paor in the
Miss Gardner and himself he was yery much itoTi
Gated and they took notice OF him he came In again about
life and to destroy Miss GARDENERS character saying could
for 800 hire swear 70 matters against her the plaintiff
then stepped toward Hiss Gardiner and the witness took him
by the and told him he behave himself and must
he had been been told leave the house he then promised TO
do and minute acrward used insulting language TO Miss
Gardiner and himself and threatened follow her everywhere
he made step toward Miss Gardiner and Miss Gardiner
quesed him witness thought dangerous
Miss Gardiner Vet him touch her and held him by the col
the grasp his coat not firm enough be used no
force than 10 accomplish his object
1amned-I did last year and knew that
plaintiff engaged Miss Gardiner never heard OF IL
he claimed and Miss Gardiner did only heard
OF what Mr. Bese stated other people, never heard OF his
furnishing her house with money goods she paid her Own
bills did buckets Of butter which he sent In have
occasion examine Miss GARDENERS bills and satisfied
be furnished any consulted Inspector Carpenter before
the 10 what should and acted In accordance with
his directions directed Mr. Carpenter TO send % the
plaintiff store know Capt Young and think told him OF
the Guilty did advise Mr. Young send for the plain
tiff and knowledge Of such thing at the first In
terTiew testified after his return from New Orleans
he while there he behaved himself
well the I'D Of January when he first came in was
sitting the end Of the table and Miss Gardiner at the
about clock of the evening he came IN
again the sofa think was not on the sofa
that evening" think Miss Gardiner was not on the SOFA the
plaintiff sober enough TO require the exerton OF
much strength; as Mr.. Besse came in the room
the frst thing he said TO order me out
be said HIS she had lease from MI Shafe
said II vince this Is house, will leave
the forthwith he SAID he had the lease and took out
paper from his pocketbook which not lease Miss
Gardiner snaichod from bis hand and read 1t with her and
found It receipt for s675 said Mr. Besse this gives
authority power in this house let MI Besse 30
" e promised to leave the house.
Shacr called and testified that when he let the
Miss Gardiner lie understood that she engaged 70
the plaintiff
The Jury rendered a verde; for the defendant