The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1865-09-03

IL n,MZWl y Eu1M RHyaA 1sos ppepss
- ~ sre.csj .e$ 3st shs Ss.det Hswsy vas thsa
eon and could never consent 70 patronss IN enter
N 10 that dlrssarded the laws Of morality and dsss
ed the finest Of the hne arts And in letter. substance
cts!aforesaid set FORTH and intended DO taken nom
70 twenty-five 70 folio twsntyfour Of the complaint
Is~tA-And these defendants reteratins their denals
manner and form aforesaid, for separate and mrsnes
renee aver that each and every Of the said pupsned
Amt then and there and true in al particulars
that they true In substance and effect because
ese defendants say that before and ~ the sme on tne
ppening Of the In the said alleged Deous pub
alton, well hereinafter set FORTH II was the TACT
I'VE The facts were At the time mentioned IN the com
Fton the revelations defendants made in their
I'd newspaper would be and was description Of the
;Iactsr Of the audiences VINO eqasnsea me academy
Ach description would have been furnished by defend
corps Of reporters aided and assisted by the detec
Fes which M kennedy, the Superintendent Of Police
the city or New York. did then and there detail nightly
guard the premises Of said Academy That the plain
Strons would have been thus traced to their houses
n haunts, whether in the Fifth avenue or the Five
hnts In Mercer street Madison square, and the de-
adants would have learned In what feculent soil aud
ephc atmosphere the social toadstools and the fungi
shoddy did most luxurantly flourish and most did
lgregate And these defendants do justify the same
letter substance and effect and the facts aforesaid
rth and intended TO be taken from folios twenty-four
twenty seven Of the said complaints as true.
IA-And these Defendants reiterating their denials
tanner and form aforesaid for separate and further
fence aver that each and every of the said published
legations got in the fourth of action the
Amt was then and there and true all particulars:
defendants say that before and at the time Of tho
opening Of the events in the said alleged bellous pub
ason as we'll as hereinafter set FORTH II the fact
q the facts were at the time mentioned in the said
nplaint as follows 70 wit-That tho plaintiff then and
ere was performing certain man@uvres, and that the
ayr Of the wicked then were and are still hard, and
n It
nd either the participation by the said wicked in,
nnivance at breaches Of the high moral tone Of social
which ought 70 be maintained by those who set
emseves up as caterers for public amusement land
~ such catering s the greatest moral responsibility any
sce sooner or later does overtake the Wicked who are
ecrbed Aforesaid and that In vain could such wicked
An 90 aforesaid seek TO evade the responsibility and
reaction always takes place. and that the scales fall
,m the eyes Of the previously unsuspecng victims Of
inning and dupcity both Of heart and purpose; and
= the fact does stand before them all it's naked de-
I'd that the plaintiff did at last discover and the fact
- that, in spite Of the proverb to the contrary,
ere ID such word as fail and that in spite OF the nom
alant erontery the realization Of that ugly fact TO wit
there being such word as fall did cause the plaintiff
culver with alarm as the grim shadows Of confidence
onsibes that he had evaded, arose before him and
at he the inevitable result which would follow his
4 attempt at managing the New York public BY pan
ring TO its worst instincts, and moulding the venal por
'n Of the press to his will. And that after the COM
encement OF defendants structures on the operate
Academy Of Music tor the defendants had dared to
eak out whilst too many Of the defendants contempt
sympathy with the course pursued by this would
leader Of public taste in the highest realms
arD the houses had fallen Off rapidly; and
Ct any one really would have supposed, from plain
re antecedents the evident Partially he displayed
corporal grossness in the human form divine, that
fore he quilted his beloved faderland he had en-
that had any one traced his managerial career back
ehacer would have found that the plaintiff had con
women and fat men, when their talent was mediocre
draw his admiration and that when fat was combined
th any approach to merit the plaintiff became ecsatic
bat the plaintiff the admirer of Stehanani, the fat
did give the cold shoulder TO- Bosio, the thin great
|nger that she was land the fact is she was great
hgerl and that the plaintiff delighted in Marini, be-
aginous Savi did look II lard oil would exude il any
squeezed him, and that Salvi was the plaintiffs spe-
pet and that the defendants could have then and
multiplied instances Of the past taste Of plaintiff in
~ respect, which had found its climax at the time al
ne nGu sh n wn a
dsd another Of still larger proportions and truly pom
weight and that the leading tenor and baritone
gers Of plaintiff were both fat and were fast verging
that wheezng condition which attends gross habit
body in man or animal in the race they we're running
emulate the size Of poor dead Amodio whom the
continually fretting and frizzling their love
Aim that they had time TO reach the standard Of
ssr o. ef q shem That The Defendants had 'S ar
ssd 81 the conclusion that the plaintiff could not forget
~, ss, M c.,dis factory IN Ststen Island
ssch GERMAN ss,ahl;shcd A. .so that with an eve tn
numerical well AZ musical business the plaintiff
- y, ~ % ~ scre Sn,nro ncrsnJ N nroat and ad
|...- "a sns, -har the sir~ers If plaintisT were
s.n .s ,s "a ~ ~ S,vher ,,.s N hmsaiS ~ anv
- 80. shss ,hsr ~. n,aintiT comS melt them down
~ rn..s ,hs,n into fsrcv toilet soans each haar;no
-, snrrnryssc rsn,cs vhicb vonId doubtless and
- - s,nons The n,sntisY,. patrons of the demi
-. ara the Sefsndants a. instifv the same in
49, snhssncs ana effect and The facts aforesaid SET
"a re- asscrasrs. re;tarati,o their depials in
s,r .n so, sforsssid FIR senaraie and further de-
- aver ,hsi esrh and every of Che said nubshed al
.ss,ns al nm An the ann csnse IF action in the com
800 re ,hsn ma there ana are true in ali nartcuars
- ~, ,hsv 40 srne in substance and effect he
sn... dssena.r,s ssv that hcfora and NJ the tina
~. h.rrsnnr ~ ~. svenss in the esd alleged libel
q purlassion a. well a. hereinafter set forth il was