The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1865-09-03

nd
p injured aud damaged by the said lbels printed
g re- nyybIshed by the defendants
s wbbsrecore he demands Judgment against the defend
" soe the snm Of twenty thousand dollars damages
essides the costs Of this action
JUDAH DICKINSON, Plaintiffs Attorneys
Mr. and County, of Ne,C York -
MAJ Maretzek The plaintiff being sworn says The
above complaint s true of his own knowledge, except
TO the matters therein stated on information and be-
st and as 10 those matters he believes il to be true
'' MAX MARErZEK
sworn os'o'e me 'nS Soa ny Pu,rr Notary Public
City and County Of New York
,
THE ANswnn.
EpERioR COURT or THE u[ - ~ ~ sosH
Mar Aarl;ek a9am9 mu'am 0esa% S asI " T =
Whitney The deiendanIs appearing ~ a. o. iappo"
their attorney, ior answe, 70 me Somp.Ins 10y
hrsf deny any knowouse y. I'm ,ha
Gent 70 Iorin osaiea e ~ s,io se % ,
complaint from ioho one 70 io'io steven are uus -.
And the oeiendants uI.uo. oeuy, snas .ney " ha
ing and publishing tne maeI H eu,rye
or wickedy or maciousy or otherwise intend 70
either the piaintn OF n's BUSINESS 10 any an - sad
snd H. hnsnsss ., "Psr or any manner
contvs OF ineno 10 aua aoou. sno sal The defend
or an Oh tns oongs anu ao.s seseu r The Complaint
ants al 1onos tnirteep ana iouIteen " .nv vwisa
ana they oeny tnat inc paln.u n ,h;na In ssid con
injured or damaged oy reasou VI H"''Ae -
plant contained .,.. thar, in r,,rt;rg
And the defendants further aeny .a y cpd ~. re
ana pupsnng the prineu a;ns sscondIv set forth aid
Soeous ana N tne ,;c,ousv or Otherwise intend
contrive, or wlckeoy o. 80 rs ,s;rsss in anv and in
70 ntpre eitner tne plar . ~ sstd cor,nlaint con
every OF the respeoss snd HE business or eher or in
corning SAID paInn anu ,..S a. - .hcmt IN. said
any manner country VI VI ,h do,nas md scts alleged
premises any y. a., " % ,I;ns savontaen and eioh
against these oeiendan.s a. hooS .h. hs main
teen OF the compant anu .sey SsrS smd G Of
mas Deen IN any a. y ".s~ Contained
anythhS III SAN .H dassndants re,terang their de-
Secona-ana d form atorass;d for q separaie and
mas IN nanno, ,ha, aoch and averv az the said
Further 40, mn in the ,rst cause Of Action in
the compliant was saen anu m an% h a a.
tcuars, anu t hS d a. the t,ns ~ hs honren
az S nts IN the said alleged beons publication
shg oi 'nc eveuSa ~ w r.i 81 as re s.rt and th1
as wen do nee, t, %. III Th.s tho s~h;h;.,or ~
.ac's were as da m.racssn, nS the nIantT was
tne opoia, uae' ~ -asnoc,ahs yn.n,hor ~ The fair
eucn ono 10 ~ aesLe .n..eao 80 h,,h ,.s,a
eek couiu pa.'onalo "s ;,bo, rSnni~o ths rst Of
and modesy, anu wmnous aunn,ns h 'a .ha ' twas
coming in contact with the characters wno AZ sne smes
Ieierreo W III oolnpains, iu "a 49, az sad
svsnts ars dissraee 70 the sad operaand these de.
Iehoan.s 10 JUSTLY 'no e"'ie' " WV ~ ~ "
forsn as True ,,o,..,., ,o;,.-.,,no THAR dor,o,s
Ihud-Aho tne oesenuan.' .e.'oa.'.s se, t c
IN manner ana toim M - t 80 dIu
oelence, aver una. ao -, ord carsa ~ ac,ion ;n Tho
complaint was then anu 'nere ana Ha rue ~ az ,
= b daSand.nts "a tha, hefora and nj the time
OF the happening Vi ne eveIs. ~ W. o ~. e SS a. 10.
ious puoncat0n as wen - .h .o so =, re
the fact ana the were .ns Th % .e
SAID compliant as 70 w II , .no AGA ,h; ali
Music was under cloud SIN IN nign PAGES anu 'ha' az
these @ naa Heen s M @ No; suc
cessful under MANAGEMENT Of tho plaintiff as place OF
public entertainment pecuna,y .n' W 70 W .nc oe.a
As ana was iasnouaoio anu 'n ' Ia H. ,s
cover muitituoe Oh SINS " our sooaou ocss o'ovn
and that whispers did oegln 70 circ9iate tnat tne
Academy OF MUSIC was haruy tue psce Us oae az anu t
house or Tree ckes naa been iurnisnea 70
people wnom no uecens 0aeu ~. 'uu ss s " Peg S S ~"
sae MS ~e or Sham om narnne
forth IN ai tneiI glory anu is nt H. ,h
Hobbies thereof became INFESTED WIN rePresenaSe I've
from sne woss o. ,e Ty ysre comna,ied 70
Keep Drsns lookou. ioa se S To- III rs ,h,
on h U tr e st.s uho was given nrominent
one OF tne Iemae artstes viz ~as sen p voons "
pace 10 sno ps ;,iT % ,h, hs. nr;ro,a chsr.c,or
.ne troupe o. Suu m % m evsrv v;rmors "mam
was SUN .nA. :. wea ~ AZ .sna "a ~, ,hn ia
IN the mouse 70 $40" nel on .as M u a 1 S SS
irequene,s Vi sno Auau'y 49,. a. sS ~ ~ =. s
tended that said pantn snoud no. nave TURNER tease
ol tns p,c . anu a.. &c, srsh AZ ,rvs ' ''
anu .ne iao.s a r ",rher ana ssnar.s de,snce
.,I an ,h o rorons aon,ais IN nanner and form
h psso;S rIaadad Tho daronasnts Srr
% tney nave oeen a. p,.sa.u s.T ;s & al
m Soy reym scoS cansa ~ senarais
the matters IN tner foregoing se.ouu eau. " sIpa
oecuoo anu uo asa'n ~. ~ ne;,st ~ ,has a.
PENDANTS. ''' ' '-
fNhIAnu LOT s,, ~. a ro a. .ha
hsVe been sforesad pleaded these Defendants further
answering say nat they pead ana w ,
the matters tue y, u mr. ..e ~ %
cunstances against any damages claimed of these de-
PENDANTS .. ..,o,..,,s ,.,,o,.,,,r ,,.,, ,rovo,.
""N ssa..,.,d1 1900, A.. a,
nenias 10 manner anu 'o,, a. III .h ~
further and separate defence aver sna' tney prn.e%
ana puousnea tne sao , s s ,ho; h,ns ~
action number one ,he cSussS o. 'ne as sarsc
public Jonrnasts, ana sney naa ueUh, u, ,,h S
Of the editors referred 70 IN the complaint ana
from motives OF pubic Poncy, n,o!eS s ~ h anu
that they peeVeo tne same W os s.ue su H ~ "u,
said capacities rs public JOURNALISTS tncy nad oeen re-
auested by the panh 70 SPEAK Oh ms opera ,hs Ur
the oes' aavanase y, sne puu,,., a. ~ .hc NIB nh
believed It was Tor the pest advantage Oh inc pun
lie, well as OF the plaintiff. to know ana
he
they had in doing as in this cause OF defence men
toned, no malice towards the paintin, nor IN VIII
towards him, nor intent TO injure MIN or MS DUST
ness and that the said matters were and are
fair and legitimate matters OF public news and items
particular and general interest to the reading pub
lie, and we're fair and candid commentso on place oil
public amusement and were published for the purpose
Of dssem the persons subscribers To their
said newspaper information which these defendants as
aforesaid believed to be true and such as true ought
20 be published for the Information aforesaid and
they therefore plead and will insist upon the foregoing
averments In mitigation Of damages.
Seventh And these defendants, reiterapng their pre-
vious denias in manner and form as Aforesaid pleaded
n f,rtho apAo