New-York daily tribune., 1865-11-28
LAW INTEI.I.aGENCH.
81 PEEA.E COlRT-CbsssgRs-Soy Z.--Belose Jusl,e

M lax oON8IsiuSTKs CAsI-


IN TAX ,ON.Is,iuSTRS CAI.-.
The Feop.- -. James Donn sad 'h'I. r. Dods- peP
.ty TrS Cemaiss.oncrs, aad "'h'i' aS.' hai.hr"
Ipon tie coming Ia of the return Of ihe Con.
ro 70 tie alternative wFi O. nsnenu' sAe elsior aiosed
foI pc emr'oy VT sudus tie Controller 20 py the
!, .oed adl,,ed upon he return o, Wiuam'ou sfowa
,rs Ain .puf.,gcd he only l.sai Dl,ri n' 1aI Cauls
sofer fhs, ,d ryi.teJ eler the law o' lhi tho sp
poiuis,eui o. rsIcs wo0drvh snd q -. m the place Of
,.g Conn! .suucf. ig January, Ij1 xhout Sr-.n,
~ Court ws. tIesps.. ppou rights o.! tho tolams
o.sT. trsi fe or IDLE 0spos.csnon o. he sl. Ioinms
,opor. by llrr Woodruff end Allen sot 0 ns.rpa.
ton co.3-fcd Tigits upon 'n p.u aly Isf,Op'
appointed ~ thcm that the rrior' IfpcuFly ~ the'~
.itona were iesJJ aipoiHted by !le s
never been a@iuS removed by i'd ,4.inge to De and
~. ,ficos l.a Hay lad. dnrin. All tie yeli4d thsi
oaee spd t,,,es b-en rosly snl 6,oas 10 perform hsr
T..,cye da.ie.in I'D oae, "a wef. o1lJ pc,,r,sd iron
doinz by tie acts ~ te Controller rd lOss rpp l'@d By
biu s,I tsr Lodin. Office narf hisI Tie Cor .o ~ Ia
ofHc-r, Lolinr 10 der ls slurpns Con sol'is lad no
rEt zach o csd not entitled tob- pad any .sl.
or other c0le Tor thr .~fylrr- rendered bv them la
said ,hce@ Yet 'he e'1na sloN tha nile such Psfaons
wese hg'ilz d. .ad us4pn. toin' nrfs no Ps'e'
in 1ct p4d d. srie, suAced 90 thDsr o-, Tcsp'.tyoy
by the Controller u 49, stood een.d b. The reuIus ei
lawr Comm Onrr, the f'liorshst discharged - dlfr, m
peron thong. 'hr Controller I'D Paid The s,lafe. 70 the np
poinees Of ie urirpny Cormir1olof. she drug that
peiod hsd d'.'iiured no duties ~iuicys.
ln tiS 81 bs one 81 tho f,iors t apTe,frd trt h,
ir1' rflsrf ifff 20 the from the
ofc~ r.nfPux tomniss.oroT ana thut hr I'D bold
IA. orr sni performed h- d1trs under 4r rtpot
tnrn tn ~, tef, Coinis.ior~s since 'h"f mum e.
onl-e npty.ith.tandng THO -si-fy ~ office iad
boon paid o r-rto8 Who i1d before lsrr ap.
pointed 80 oics by aid mapping 'Onuis,i1nes, n
ough rrson he'd rot profn~d an, ofc dn,es Of The
ssi sce. E fIhl appeared s duns c Who'll, period ir
witch the CouOer h., pryinE The rssc- Of aid occrs
the sproiners of ssd usnpins oomm,ioncf. 10 ws.
moasi, notified m WHY By tbs .egsi hat ,uc
not The lcs hold q, o such Gces respectively
n,f ra,ed 10 tie ssihrs but ti lin c0s'raIy tho sad
Tcs3r Icspecvc we've t ,s. hOld,. " ,i 0h!e- sud
a. s.rh legally entitled no s.riof tLru,l Trsp,cugnIy.
Tbs iogvin. - The olpt Of the Court before whom the
aid cagssi vefs heard;
Ci.Rxy IL think umi the d-f.nd,, W.. iu,,lhrd in
PAVING the salary demanded bJ the Irca 90 ihr sctus
incumbent ol tie J1e during TIE prfod ~ qu-sion Ibr
special and Geaori i O.. t, tut decided that The Con-
who appJi-i hin wIrr themselves appointed
Befor;h; decision rcycs by ihe Cont of Appaas
and wLs II Osef,'iy. as tho law. ard consequently
binding upon him. tle de,int paid - the Incumbent IN.
oney which tn ln tLo tre,snfy Tor snrh pssmrn n
h. lus,ihea n j1int his he cnoi h. compelled p,y
rssios ont oil the pubc money under he control ih-r -
no appropriation Tor such payment AMI conseieaiy hrrc IL
40 mon 81 The treasury for th, specific rnfpos". T. would
be o alton of l,~ or tue 'onorr 10 tatr appTn
pnsIsd oh.r rufvpss to sppy 10 t.s. c..Iist
Arsi uooh l,s coippr hiE 10 DO hai would
r., Of he dny ani Of 'he ss. Wns".sr other
e- iic. the iy have II he hss suv s, sppeinn
esrno, ia opinion be granted ho'ion pa msni,nus
denied
DECISIONS.
= fi,f.fe s1t t,e, IA If..t. If