The New York herald., 1865-12-23

We here NAV Know that The "mal ont nj Scnaors' arc
probably only actaated by iqns al information or power
withheld, from desire to avoid pecunarv OF other
Investigations at have been gitimatey called for by
tho regular goyernm Mt Of the motherhood seems IN
the passianale and earnest 'men in the
gap" who strain their eyes 10 US from aiar that
these macont n 81 only be acting In the direct
interest Of England, and " tn view 70 break up
the Brotherhooda eat for which England would doubt
less be glad TO pay to-day less than million pounds
sterling il less sum woaid DO it, To ,he in Ire
andtho men who have ther lives and lib rites, and NIL
question Of detail or petty grievance can seem
admissible justification for such an outbreak they
raging in the Fenan ranks. ''who began its'
lie thcircry; not "Who is ri2htwho wrongs" The men
who began the quarrel they regard as traitors in the pay
Of England for to motive Of less cogency could they
the Fcnian S and sh cause Wo the s. q
stone in the aIraya' will be the only demand Of the
nation and already have enough OF
written and other evidence to convince us that
not President O'Mahony either directly or indirectly
He bore everything in silence for the sake Of the causc
upon public press OF the United States and clse
where, by the action Of few recruits, deraulting
ana and who ana % no as hey
tors through trick, and actually by trading on
9 Mahony,s popularity At the late Ph adelphia Con.
gress; and who ROW have set before themselves for
various selfish reasons Of aggrnndizclnent or es-
| cape from just responsibility the task OF over
throwing tho present orgaizat on Of the Brother
hood, preaching faith in It's place. themselves
sezng all the pecuniary and other rens OF in
sbstancc-has already said II substance-we have
proof beyond question, also that he will say and
already said much more than to repeat beev-
active OF the malc0ntent Senator's, as traitor who has
already betrayed the secrets Of the Order to the British
government thereby directly causing the late
Mr.. Stephens himself. and placing all the interests
Of the D. in jeopardy SO far as his power extend
case we know; and that such must be tho view Of all
the Irish brethren, who in affairs OF such kind,
only see through his eyes. But the CIV is q wrong
hold and therefore do not give II any further
publ ctythc gentleman it being well known to
us and sincerely respected; and estimate of him
being that he may have committed and doubtless has
committed many bad mistakes OF pique anger and lack
s os' as either ea' ne Is 5 as m nsaTabe Of @
selves, and that no is tr and warn patriot as
breathes, although in his present Of beilion
against the regular government OF the Order very grossly
mistaken in our judi nent.
TRUE MOTIVES OF THE PRESENT FEElAN rRAoAs-
THE pIsTURBERs MAY BE HALF TRAITORS, BUT
ARE WHOLE FOOLS. -.
1s 1t not rule accepted by the sense and po-
eal experience Of all Americans, that quarrels or
ganizaton shall be fonh out long any liberty of
discussion and act on shall he left within the organ "a
ton IN which they started? And should this
especially be the case in vast conspiracy, which,
though perfectly legitimate and peacef here has the
lives and liberties Of many thousands OF true men dc.
pending on its successful execution Irsland9 DO not
the who rush into violent measures of subycrscn in
|Grch movement, dragging all the dirty linen hcy
md in the Broth rhood out Of its proper buck ng
,ask :, and insisting that 1t shall be washed in
pubic by thc'r own not over clean handsdo these
men by snch course give nconestbe evidence that If
*' Y pay Of the British government, they richly
i
interest OF the cause they profess have at heart 10
.heir me- own most miserable vanties. jealousies,
ami SICK wisbcsthe ambition OF demagogues TO
obtain personal prominence at no matter what cost or
the skulking desire Of some dishonest ignorant and
tellgent officials such ore The motvos truly al bottom
o. his Fensn revolt, and motive yet trust and
s,ss .a ' G and gEaisA a rcschefS @ which
! compelled 10 see or 70 suspect ia it.
PERSONNEL OF THE ''aALcoNrENT sHNAToRs'' AND
THEIR yFivArE cAusks or GRIEvANCE-LEr THE
TRUTH he TOLD N TIE SKY FALLS.
The suaTei confessedly originating On he side OF the
'maIcontent SENATORS" and the frst stoIe The INT
dozen demonstrating been thrown by Their hands IT Us
next look AZ how, and with what weapons they are
pure and credtable one and The quarrel Necessary arc
di S ns sas e f s4s s
Of the Brotherhood and hopes OF their brethren IN
Ircand' TO this wc shall reply BY proving that .hcr
weapons are poisoned arrows shot in the dark that
Ia their mad rage against the elected President Of their
Order, whom they nnd themselves Unable 10 njupc
itself in an effort TO ruin what they ruo
smash that power Of far seeing Integrity and rcsoute
S u E s Tss1 @ attack as make ss
regular govornnni Of tho Brotherhood with bitter rid
cne for s titles Of President Secretary of tho
having its headquarters in palace on Union square
Let Just how honest in the mouths Of these NAL
content Senator's the charges made All tho
titles created forced upon the reluctant and protest
ing acceptance Of Colonel Mahony at the Philadelphia
Congress, under constitution which majority OF these
mscontens forming the old Central Council bad
specially prepared for their benefit and tina. OF ther
accomplces. O'hahony was, as be has ALWAYS been
bent work, not show; and well enough content
with his title Of "Head Centrc aud suite OF small but
sufficient Offices the top floors OF building In Duane
tra Council, who wished the title of President for him.
SELF and the constitution framed for his benefit
that when OMahony should gn tas tho macontents
expected and have since labored 10 drive him to do) Mr.
Roberts should inherit both his position and the coveted
.sSc,eiary or ns ,nn Tseasury @ was uen NV Mr. r. P
W. Dunn, distiler, Of Peoria, ILL.,, who arranged
tho terms Of the Office TO sut hs own views when he
should t and Of the rounds OF quarrel the part
of tho senate s that olrnc 0Mahony has pers tcntly
refused TO place this person who owes vast sums TO she
United States gyerDmen In control OF the finances OF
the Bro herhood So too, the Office OF ':e.rcsry OF
War; prepared Tor tho special comfort and TO graft
the political and all other ambitions OF Mr. Michael
Scanlan, who is candy maker Of Chicago and IL Is with
such men, together with Gibbons, old ward polt
elan OF Philadelphia, Fitz crald green grocer, and
simple and unrducated engineer in the J,it@ne
Office and 80 forth that This revolt or the smaIconicnt
Senators has orig mated OEourke was treasurer
der the old Central Council, and is in arms becaus he
either cannot or viii not account for several hundred
thousand dollars intiscd to bis care, and which he
claims TO have lodged with amenbcr ol The Tr b AsSo
caon Roberts was pressed on Nahcny for Secretary
o the Treasury and wanted 10 issue notes and bonds
without numbering them any other system Of check
Mr. Patritk Aeehan OF the Irish Anic lconthc nblcst
man oi the crowd, and the only one for whom
VIC feel any respect and our respect for him arcere
though believing him to be misfakendcsr d. IL g said
to have been made the AGENT of the IRISH republic
America; While that Mr.. +. l.. Carey had other
object to graty-though forget precisely what II
wsswe well assured. Mr.. Roberts has belonged TO
the Order about months and yet Is The bogus
president set up by the malconten,s against OMaho
ny. sseDaor' Carey has belonged 10 tho Order somo
two three monhRnot more, so far as we can learn
'Senatorp Meehan Joined the brotherhood last Fe6rl
ary and yot these the at whose bidding 'tho
Irish home aud abroad requested-nay, impers-
lively ordcedo discard the trused guidance and tried
and unblemished faith of John on ahony OF the Come
raghs, of the two who-Jamcs stephens being
the otherrst ret this snowfall o. bate 10 England roll
ing, and sped IL forth until now IL has become
lanchc OF revolution, puneing and crushing forward on
It's resIstless way.
THE PALACE HEADQUARTERS" ON UNION SQUARE
rRUE HISTORY OF THE MATTER-soME WORDS
ABOUT MR.. xiLLIAN--wHO HE ~ AND WHAT.
Az TO the palace hired for headquarters In Union
square and is having been taken for eighteen months,
the answer is yet more crushing, II that possible.
These "malconent Senator'S protested against and rd
culcd hahonys humble but sufficient Offices in Duane