The sun. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1833-1916, 1865-12-16

r. n aHff~ gFfff -
,.ss ".s s/~~
80 ~ 81 ~,
~ srsS :. - ss 80 y y =, =
80 he - F9e II fsfN 80 -
'a.' =. .,,'"; =. - 20. sg. !.'y''.:s.' 'y''s' -.
- 90 s@'ss > asiff 81 80 Taf
s.'.I s..I 80" ~ g~s... 30. .e' Z. .
u. s'..., =. ,.,.s,ss -. ..1ess
- s,ss~ ~ 80 o,sssse ~. .
ss.uS Fss,a - fssss~ - rsf
;s"!s 49, ',...t. 80. s.,s,~
gssFss sa.i - prfff fesft ss riIaf = ~sife.s
- ssy~lss w - Ha sss assfsreasf =
fssasu ~N sass q Nes 80 as'sps = 80
.,.'. .','., ..s''.-., 80. - -" o. 10. 20.
81 gsssss'tg ~ ssf a.ss Hs-s ass gfN
e.. '.af. gssst bssys y :, - -, y. ~.
ff'iN go ~ slas'l.s 80 - - .s.ss
ssIeig -, isn,s - p" -, 80 80 80. -.
sHi ~ a., so ssssmssss W 90 sesssa
~ tss fsisf eess . n 80 80 o 80 80 %
gls-lsa = assrs ksgiss hsss es ss.sfgg.
ksnf sSspais ibsytr 10 - 40 'o~g'sEssss
s.s@
sss,ss-r - srrsssr ssss-a ~ssr
seo,ssy 0ss.ra sy..f .si 10 ,siassi % oush
% o. csgss'e. ~ sa Ia- sii's~si as
tourt as pss,s as ss.a ,ssprnei .bs rs.
dsrso,.f ne ggumsst rha ssnGsssn Hsi msn.
..nsi ma rbns IN ,ssifios ssns @s taissi
suss. NJ, g.issd o.. Sn en- g1esr n fhs
Csur, -im - asch rsh, v - % ~ hsf " ioso
magoa 81 spapsry ~ ms ~ svssf 49,
ssYs NEE asvy sss . nsss ~ C9ugfsss d,d
~ gfssrts 81 fcspons ior omcs The psu
uons srsysf hrns-if -ifh iboss she eo' auly
srdssvsfsd b dssroy MS Courl, IN, nc 0o.s'n.
lnsni Lett al ,hsrsby essssi - - en- eassf
cYnld no, ne povv ne, msIs os ofhes ds-,roy
~ n ne D s'uos ~ ne ssnnsnso -s eoffect
Judss ssgrs,h, -ha never fsssnsi he plsos 80
Judge n NE Daret c. ~ " aguth Csrpiins, but
sho toos tsr 10 NE fsbslhon, I'll - rssofed
" ne fosaon -hsn s 10 p.rdopsi ~ NE
| Pfssdsni, nui NE pardon -0uid not esytsinly
fss0fs him. fIt' slso The oass NJ poamsstsrs
and ofhcers sf tbs army snd nsvJ, -bo psrii'ip
si 10 We rsbsliob. I. csrisnly would no, bs coo.
tsndsd nat pardon rOuld rs-t0rs w. thsm hsr
once and rsssiis. Tbs proposi.lon 10 ths, - bs
ussson, NJ. GGlsnd dd no, forst his once snd
rs ibssted ne, 90 s,,orpsy In ihs e0urt holds
en- ofhes. No~ here ere public and rrivsss
| ofhcss &c there are pubic snd Trtvsie eorpors.
ons, snd ihsrs are offocs established In tAe ON
| stituiiob and slso by lsr. IL hs position of on
s,,ornsy pri,s,s or . public offiesf la his pm
vs,s pr perry An s,.ornsy 10 ho' sdmiied a
| We bar for shs purpose Of diving him othce. Con
grs.s has SAID ,hs, The Court msy ss,ab oh rules,
| and IN 1879 the qushhes,ion for hs plsce vss
| framed 80 10 now stsnds. Other Dual hoAuons ~
| be requii 81, such % the srsrnipsuon, BY bard
| Of the sypiesnts Cor admission. hr. Speed ,hsr
eouuovsrsed Me other prOposi,Ions Of Mr.. CsrPsn
YER. Tbs place bel by an attorney vas On ofios
but what was The tenure When he accsptsd th'
| offse. did he not know the Court could prescrb,
such rules ~ would deprive him u the office
| Tn, power Of Congress over the quail hoshon ~aI
| known 10 him when he sntored upon 10
The deeision had been made over and oye
sgain Va. Congress could prescribe 'he qislinoa
lions. 0fhoes sro beld 81 the will OF ,hs pows
confsrring them, and the duties may from nm
W time Ia oasugsd. There is nothing lito pen
atty In the Law; II 10 quslitcsuon. A. y wheth
er . qualification 10 . penalty depends on th
stand point. State may say . porsos unde
twenty -ons years shall not vote, or thsI he shal
esllon; aud this Court may ssy thu, man prso
Using al Its bar must have . fair chArscser
and that he has practiscd for three year
| In ,hs hiehes, Court Of his STATE. He would dcpre
es,e any act which would prevent reunion, but, .
the same time be would desire Congress 70 pas
| such laws 90 would keep out OF high places ,los
who have not been faithful to thsir country In th
pas. Tho time 10 coming, but wo cannot say -
vet With Nj. Carpenter, .hat peace rsigns. Tb
President has not yet 30 declared. Those who hal
once under the Government, but who went Int
rebellion, did not so BEEHIVE as 10 entte them
selves W reoccupancy. Was thsre any thing In th
I spirit Of the Constitution, wss II 30 framed that
: pardon arrests the arm Of justice A pario
prevents the infiction Of punishment, bu
, Il In no, key 70 enable the party I
! UNLOCK the Offices Of government rhs pardon
| an iron clad, 90 10 speak, for the purpose of d,
I, fence. The gentleman remarked that while N
pardon says ,he recipient shall not bs punished,
a law Of Congress says he shall: but the Presdsr
. does no, say the petitioner shall practice In III
: Court. Tue President only gives him the night
every other ciNzen. 10 10 the party's own fault
he cannot take the oath. l, IL simply to give O
: surancs TO the Court that they will not admit
q pracucss party who has been In the rebellio
! here is in the s>,h statement Of fact ths, ,h
:, | party has not been in rebellion against n
y United States Nso, he cannot sppear In III g. ~
other legal tribunsls II 10, he repeated fact an
= NOT = test II has been decided by suthoriu,
a which he quoted, that while pardon IL . ptoie
ton Again.I all assaults for the thing done ID ca
n never be the foundation tor q claim. II Mr.. G..
= l.nd's Otcs WAS forfeited, when he became n publ
"a enemy, 10 he not coming before the C0ur, with n
!, PreHdsnts pardon and making 1t tho fou, date
!. Of . claim 1hs, esnno, be done. Il is . smp
prolsction. Not a weapon OF defense NOT
,c key by which ofiics can be opened. Mr.. spe,
n admitted that 10 call q man who has 70, eyed
N "trsitorl' or Scion" is actlonable, bu. suppo
10 "A In said, "you a traitor telop thi, IA ID
n Il still remaius. May not Congress ssy such FAC
n arc disqualih aIions. ls 10 not competent for Co
!, gress - say = mur erer shall no, stand here
.- ! not tn embraced In tho words of the rule
II iair chaTactery Can II be said that man hst
W fair character who cjnss here sfior be las I
"a tempted 10 destroy tue government? Dles .
Ia tnst dlEquAlfy him in THIS Counf
ar II not com pstsn, for Congress TO say the psrd
a. shall not qualify man for practice in this Cou
n, and cannoI Tho people Of State say, through Il
y, delegated authority, that man who LAS comm
N. ud homicide sual never vote or hold ott,
no WHAT more power have the people in Conveuti
IN than Congress has under the Constitute
ct Conventions can prescribe the qialIhcsH
,,- tsadl4tes for oti-e. Congress has power Just
a. plenary. NJ. speeI maiuiaInod "a, u that
ly gilhh.anon IN tns Ia" Is not Q penalty lie iooE
"A upon u as something which Congress may msk'
cs tue duty o. tne Court W embrace. A. or .urIl
en- argument, Mr.. SpeeI said he wanted all tae 10
~ err vi tLe Go'ernmeng exercised for the p
a. ! Poso v. s''He'Ss a'Sut peace NJ wv
ls. mcnt had ever before pLss,i ,hruugA