davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
WnL1AMsnELD. Oct. Sd, 1864


DIR. EDIToRs:-Enclosed I send list
of names of soldiers belonging to the ID
Ohio Cavalry captured in Virginia up to
july Ist 1864, who were transferred from
Richmond TO Andersonville, Ca, about
the last of the same month. Having lost
my diary, l am obliged to write from
memory alone; however, think the list
embraces. at least, ali the Trumbull Co
men. I suppose all our prisoners are to-
gether, and that they have been removed
from Andersonville to Savannah, and
that those among them who are sick will
be paroled soon. Maj. Melford our Asst.
Com. OF Exchange, told US that he was
collecting transports at Fortress Monroe,
sufficient to accommodate ten thousand,
and that he expected to start for Savan-
nah as soon as the necessary arrange
ments could be completed.
Ifary thing that have sent or written
is of sufficient importance to the friends
of those noble boys, you are welcome to
publish ii
Very Truly Yours,
NJ. C. COWDERY.
Serg't Joseph McElroy, Co. D, Mansfield
Ohio.
g VIM. D. Hickox, Co. D. Bristolville
=" Gaylord Ozier, Co. D. Richland Co,
D. S. Dancer, Co. D. Richland Co.
Corp'l John A. White. Harrisburg, Geau-
ga County.
Corp'l Daniel w. Myers, Mesopotamia.
{" Edmund E. Rinear, Pennington.
&" Wellville Porter. Ashland County.
Saddler, James EdVey, Bloomfield.
-- PRIVATES.
Charles Adams, Bristol.
James Matteson, Pennington.
Frank Proctor, Pennington.
Faank Hine, johnson.
James Young, johnson.
Porter Barnes. johnson. HsE
VIM. Epherson, Dayton.
Myron Lane. Holmes County.
Lawson E. Pooler, Summit County
Conrad Shesler, Darke County.
Frank Ronaburn. Urbana.
John Saxton, Larain County.
Kimpton Ogier, Richland County.
joseph Firckbiner. Richland County.
- Cowles, Richland County.
John Mcconnell, Niles.
Charles E. w. Tanner, ST. Louis, Mo
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
S3084.4O

The army sentiment was well express
ed by soldier in the Vermont election.
A copperhead ticket was thrust at him
as he limped up to the polls He took it
and looked at it musingly, then threw 1t
away with the remark: What a thun
dering fool 1 should be to go down to
Virginia and fight rebels three years with
my musket, and then come here to stab
myself in the back with piece of paper
like that"
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
The Boston Transcript, of Friday. sa,

The Boston Transcript, of Friday. says:
Four rebel Generals-Jones, of Virgin
Ia, BeiIs, of Arkansas, Trimble, of Mary
land, and Frazer-arrivedi in this city yes
terday morning, from Johnson's Island,
on the way to Fort Warren. General
Trimble was the instigator of the riot in
Baltimore, at the commencement Of the
war, when the Massachusetts 9th went
through. r.-s.-
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
II Is SLAVERY PERrrr uArED.

Could disunionists ask more than this'
Can traitorous ingenuity more artfully
contrive doctrine that would at once
denationize America, wreck its Constitu-
tion, break its Union into formless ruins.
and prostrate it into irretrievable an
archyY Could any devotee of slavery
invent more perfect and eternal safe.
guard of iti ''The Constitution as it is, y
unamended and unamendable, is slavery
as it was, unmoved and immovable.-
[Cheers. And to that the Democracy is
pledged, and for that it struggles Down
with the Democracy, its candidates and
its platform, now and for all coming time!
Enthusiastic and long continued ap
plause. a..3 .-.al..lsr.-
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

Rev. IL. W. Beecher gave notice in his
pulpit on Sunday week that he would, on
Sunday evenings, until the Presidential
election, preach sermons which some peo-
pie might call political. He gave the no
tice in advance, that if any did not wish
10 hear these discourses, they would have
opportunity to leave their seats for
those who did. --..- ...... ...--I
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

A cockney tourist met Scottish las
sic going barefoot toward GLASGOW
'Lassie," said he 81 should like to know
if all the people in these parts go bare
footr' "Part of 'em do, and the rest of
'em mind their own business" was the
rather settling reply. ---
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

"Let every enemy go to the front says
Jeff. Davis.
"Let every man go to the rear says
Gen. Mcclellan.
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

TIE MANUFACTURE OF CHEEsE.-Mr. John
Douds of Boston, has sold to Harmon 4
Root, of Aurora, the cheese Manufactured
at his three dairies during 81 and 6S days
of the present season. as follows:
The Orson Cook Dairy, Al cows,
81, cheese, 6430fbs. 90
The E. Terpenny Dairy, 80 cows,
6S, cheese, 4138 bs........ ...--. SO, 60
The Home Dairy, 35 COWS, 68
cheese, 1904 fos.......-........... 96O,SO
Total, S5Oo4,4O
If any Dairyman of this, or any other
county, can beat these figures we should
like to see them.-AEron Beacon.
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

There is a conductor on the Louisville
and Nashville Railroad named sipy
His wife il Of course Mrs sipy. 11
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
~. ss1rE. W. sNITE

p roduce. Commission and Forwarding Merchant
DeS Ter, in Western Reserve Cheese and Butter
. Il c.12sPine Street. ST. Louis: Missouri. Particl-
lar at ention viii be paid to the sale of Western
Res orve Cheese and Butter. Win make liberal
advances on, and render prompt returns for any
t4ls Parties under the styIs Of MecoMSs *
Hf$Rs Hsrsn ehse. 1ElE5 Il
~ " - s.ss5 ,sgfss
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
y tIses. q HINa k.RRorHER.

Dealers IN Watches, Clocks, Jewery. Silver Plated
and Brattania Ware, Lamps Fgncy Goods. &C
No. y Main Street, Warren. Ohio. All kinds o.
Clocks and Watches carefully repaired and war
v-ssntsd.-7-r - -rTT TrT E7-s-FF
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

JEFF. Davis tells his Richmond army
that they have "the vital issue now be-
fore them. Perhaps he means the vittls,
issue.
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

A rage for red hair is the epidemic in
Paris now. Some Of the bellies are dye
ing for it.
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
RON rrAss OF rA1LuRE. =
The traitors platform proceeds thu

The traitors platform proceeds thus:
uFsat this Convention does especially de-
slars, as the sense of the American people,
that after four years Of fdilurs to restors hs
Unior by the experiment of icor, = o. :"
justice, humanity, liberty, aud The public toEl-
fare demand thatsnnmediate efforts Be made
for q cessation of hostiiites, i0itA vist0 to an
aEtirats ConUentien of tie States, and other
peaceabs means, to the end that at the edrti-
est practicable moment peace may be restored
o,. the basis of the Federal Union of the STATE.
And this is what they say about the
war whose thunders from Mobile Bay,
Atlanta aud Petersburg, were even then
reverberating over the land. Not one
word of cheer or encouragement to our
noble soldiers and sailors! Not one
breath of ofoondemnation, or even censure,
of their ruthless -slaYerslL Not one sylla-
| BILE of any sort Of purpose to yindicate or
defend the UnionI Not one Thought for
their country in its mortal grapple with
the aristoeraey- of slavery, Only a fetid,
Isnaky hiss at flour years or failurel Fail
urel how? whens wheref The rebels had
Norfolk, Yorktown, New Orleans, Port
Hudson, Matches, Vielss6urg. Memphis,
Columbus, Nashville, Chattanooga, Allan
! Ia, 4dfo -lH01 gu thOlA hOn . i Ia SleAh =
and vociferous cheers. They had Lou
isiana, Mississippi, and Tennessee; who
has them now? Repeated cheers, l.
They had the Cumberland, the Tennessee
and the Mississippi; have they a drop OF
either nowf Cheers and cries Of mo-
They had open ports in Albermsrle and
Pamlico Sounds, and st Charleston, Port
ROYAL, Savannah, and Mobile; are they
IopenA nowf They Shad Forts Pulaski
Morgan, Gaines, jackson, Henry and
4 Donelson; have they them Row2TF (''No
lnot") Failurel,, Cali .iyoul 10 a-failnre
when the rebellion has been shriveled ar
like a piece of sbfiveled leather ano
Sherman, Sheridan and Grant hsfe got
it in the FIRE, and will hold it there till il
is burned to ashesf tEnthnsiastie cheers.
You might as well call streak OF light
ming failure, because it only knocked
down three quarters of your house
Cheers. Hiss on, setpentsl this is you
time to hiss; bat the ligbtnings of thu
peoples wrath are gathering. and Their
I will be no failure in their Kissing strati
upon you on the eighth of November
W. SSo' S ee;l iii balas .s7sGluoi II
Y = p ~ CESSATION OF HosrrLITrEs.cTigs. I
!, But ..justics, 1iananit, liberty, and ths put
kc t0slfare, demand that the immsdidls for
Be mads for a eessatOna af hostititiss' Effort
--by whomS 0fcourse, only by our Gov
+ ernment. That is, the nations Chief .
!. the very moment its armies have the II
balliea tArsttiS<. snd are 3askinG "a
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

-,Ifa man only has "duck" of wife, he
Is sure to get along ssimmivg.
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
GROCERS,

wholesale Dealer m Saddiery. Carriage Hardware
eaddies Trunks, &c. Warren. o. FEB 3 "a
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
@. VI. MESSER,


Dealer In Fashionable Millinery, Rooms over Nc
Combs and Smiths Store. Warren. Ohio Al or
aerspronptly attended 20. FEB q
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
WHAT 1T Is NOT MADE OF.

Very few words will suffice to tell what
it is not made of; for you can't find q
single fibre of patriotism. courage, manli'
r1ess or honesty in it. Cheers.] And il
is so singularly destitute of common
sense,iTf tteFly ignoring great.and Vita
issues, and prating about matters which
can never be -dignifed into issues, and
which the country cares nothing about
that it might well pass fOr the production
of an All fool Convention, if it were not
that a man can'tsvery we'll be both 8
fool and a -knave.. Great applause.
That will do for what il is not made OF
Now, as briefly as possible, for what it i
made Of. 80 n tL.L-i /.
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
LFrola fis Ra.Iiaston Pa Reporter
DISSERTATION.

Thoughts say9e.,ei By .eeizJ tbs ABerSoaA Flag oai-
,Hg yrol, a HicsoT. Pole erected 6y Coppsrhsads
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

8. g1UTRoT. - ...-- Tx rAcKLEY. 4
oEkI5E3I5. 5.sFAUrROF & co... Y 20
Importer of Gold and Silver Watches and Deale
81 m Jewelry. Silver Ware. &c. Market Street, w
rem. Ohio. c-- --1- ---
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
DEMOCRATIC UNIoSIsM.


1t begins by saying. That in the future,
as IN The past i5e pilk adhere icitk traslrsrrin9
tfdclity 10 The Union, .s t
I'm the future as in the past" Does
that mean that they hare. in the past,
adhered with answering fidelity 10 the
Union" Ifit does, theAdo they speak
flor the Democratic party. or elsethey do
not intend to adhere 10 the Union at all;
! for it was Southern Democrats who at
tempted 10 break up the Union; and it
yvss-a- Democratic Secretary of War who
furnished Them with the arms of the
Union to fight the Union with; and 1t
was a Democratic President who looked
ron. without moving so much as his lit
tie finger to savethe1 Union. And have
we not for nearly four years been fight
I ing Southern Democrats. armed for the
Unions destruction? lGreat applause,
THE UNION AS IT WAS" RULEDBY SLAVERY
The Union under the Consolation. Why
did they not say, 1.-The Union as IL ,0ds
under the Constitution as Il i2f' for that
is what they meant, but had not the
manliness, courage, or honesty to say II
their platform, as they do in their speech
es and newspapers every day, sll ofeI
the country, Why sid they net ~ it
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
) a Hlrxox. y D. FOLSOM H. R. f.
HARMON BROS. & FOLSOM.

-, e fSuccessers to E. z. Hoyt & CO..
nea1srs in Foreign and Domestic Dry Goods. Dress
Goods Gents Furnishing foods. and silk, Shawls
= Hosiery and Gloves. All kinds of Gents Cloth
inr gotten up on the shortest possible notice. kp
Il River Block, Main Street. Warren, Ohio
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
1sFs, PaRKs / wENrz. 4

Dealers in Fore:gn and Domestic Dry Goods, Crock
ri. cry Boots SHOES and Leather. CarPeting, Paper
Hanging. W indOw Shades, Ready Made Clothing,
= kc, aiYf<s cheap for ready pay at the New ork
"a Store Market Street. Warren. Qhio- -, -
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

1rrRKRR $50 J Il SMITH,
FREER 6 SMITH,
callers IN Groceries and Provisions Wooden and
Stone Ware Market Street. Warren. Ohio-Octla
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
now necLELLAN TOOK MANASSAS
NJ OLD NAPoLEAN.

Heard re how the bold Mcclellan
lie, the Wether with the bell on:
He. the head of all the asses
Heard ye how he took Manassas!
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
DlhCS. o. NO
IDDINGs 4 MORGAN. !

pealers In Staple and Fancy Dry Goods. Groceries.
sa1 Cfockery Hardware, Carpeng Sole Lcsth II, DC,
81 At the sign of the Empire SIRE" Mari ct Street
Marren. Ohio - II = - : Il -
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
PECK q BROTHER,

y holesals and Retail Dealers in Foreign and Do
.smestic Dry Goods. Silk and Straw BOnnetS Trim
st nines, Varieties, &c. at the sign of the Warren
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

~. y. PoRIER- ". p. PORTER.
-, ,se W. NJ d W. r. PORTER, =
Dealer in School and Miscellaneous Books Station
cry, Wall Papers. Periodicals. Pamphlets and
~ Magazines, at the New York Book Store. Main
street, w sTren. Ohio. ~ = - ----@-
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

wholesale and Retail Dealers in Foreign and Amer
- ican Dry Goods, Groceries, Croekery, &c Corner
-us51fs haiHand Market Streets. Warren. Ohio.
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
n. IA. nkRNUm,


Wholesale and Retail dealer IN American and For
eign Hardware, Iron, Nails, Glass, 6e. y an Cor
der's Block. Market Street. Warren, Ohio.
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02
z would AMENDMENTS DE RATIF1ED7


What, then. becomes Of the Chicago
project of a Conventionls 2 The South re-
jeets it with scorn;. the North rejects it
from principle; end there is not a human
being on earth that has the semblanes Of
authority from the South or the North to
propose it as measure of peace To pro-
pose an impossibiiity; and to propose an
impossibility in the present strained and
anxious condition of the public mind
was bold imposture, a vile cheat a 1y-
ing delusion, and a cruel and dsvilish
yickedness; and every 1man in the Chi
cago Convention knewlit was so. and was
intended to be So, and knows il now
| [Applause.1 -..-,r -,..r.,1 IT
"lN ULTIMATE coNvESrtoS"-A JAek o'LAS
TERN. ~~
Bat, my friends, wehays not yet reach
Western Reserve chronicle. [volume] (Warren, Ohio) 1855-1921, 1864-11-02

81 c. \. fURkER j. .t--.- SO - D, G. PEcA.
ss- -of .ars- TURNER d PECK
y. Dezlers in Mems and Boys Clothing. Hats. Caps
Il Hosiery. Gloves. and Geats + furnishing Goods Ol
= every description.
4 No. Il. Mebbs Block. Main St.
-. Sent 2l. 1864 -Iyr
Daily national Republican. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1862-1866, 1864-03-04
nonntIss tll April First.

The Joint resolution extending the time for
paying bountles to April LIST was passed In the
Senate yesterday. Senator Wilson presented
the following letter from Secretary Stanton on
the subject;
WAN DEPARTMEsT, March 2, 1851.
SIRi Your note Of this date, requesting my
views regarding joint resolution No. Al, Of the
House Of Representatives, to continue the pay
ment of bounties, &C., has just been received,
and In reply would havothe honor to state;
First. That, in my opinion, the requisite
troops can be raised moro expedltiously by con-
tlnuing the payment Of bounties to the LIST of
April than by any other means.
Second That, at present, great exertions are
being made In the several States 10 raise their
quotas by volunteers, so as TO avoid drait,
the people prcferring that method Of furnishing
troops.
Third. That Gen. Burnside, Gen Hancock,
and State Legislatures and Executives arc earn
estly requesting the continuance Of the bountles
until the list Of April.
Fourth. That, In my opinion, the Joint reso-
luton of the House OF Representatives Is wise
and judicious, and that its speedy passage by
the Senate would greatly promote the public
welfare, and strengthen the military force more
quickly and eiTectually than can be accom-
pllshed in any other mode.
Your obedient servant,
EDWIN NJ. STANTON.
To Hon. HENRY WILSON.
Daily national Republican. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1862-1866, 1864-03-04
From the Army OF the Potomac.

letter from the Army of the Potomac, re-
Ceiyed last night, says that a captain, lieute-
nant and ten men, deserters from the rebels,
came into our lines yesterday. They state that
they have been receiving full rations since
February Let, including coffee and sugar. A
member of the Cd Virginia cavalry asserts,
among other things, their pay was s24 per
month, each man furnishing his own horse.
That they had received no money for some
time past, their authorities waiting for the
new currency which is being prepared.
Some Of the prisoners captured by General
Custar affect great confidence In their cause
and say that everything looks favorable fol-
them, and that they are bound to secure their
independence.
Among the spoils brought in by Gen. Gustav
was a rebel mail captured at Stannardsylllei
consisting principally of love letters and other!
of business character. At that place he found
large quantity of bags marked 90. NJ. d. o.
Sax in kind" which were intended to re-
ceiyo the contributions Of citizens OF the vlcin
ity towards supplying the rebel army. All Of
the bags were destroyed.
The weather yesterday and to-day was mucl
more favorable, and, If IL continues day Of
two, the roads will be as passable as they wer'
before the late storm.
All the troops who accompanied Ger. Custa
have returned.
Daily national Republican. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1862-1866, 1864-03-04
aatiuual Gspublitan.
uyIoN NArIoNAI CONVENTION

The undersigned, who, by original appoint.
ment, or subsequent designation to bll vacan-
Cies, constitute the executive committee ere
ated by the National Convention, hold at Chi
cago on the 10th day Of May. 1850, do hereby
cali upon all qualified voters who desire the
unconditional maintenance OF tho Union, the
supremacy of the Constitution, and the complete
suppression Of the existing rebellion, with the
cause thereof, by vigorous war and all apt and
efficient means, TO send delegates to conven-
ton TO assemble at Baltimore, on Tuesday, the
7th day Of June, 1854, at 10 o'clock, noon, for
the purpose Of presentlng candidates for the
offices Of President and Vice President of the
United States. Each State having a represen-
tation In Congress will be entitled TO as many
delegates as shall be equal 10 twice the number
of electors TO which such State Ia entitled in the
Electoral College Of the United States.
Edwin d. Morgan, Of New York, chairman.
Charles ]. Gilman, Maine; Laurence Bral-
nerd, Vermont; John z. Goodrich, Massachu.
sets; Thos. @: Turner, Rhode Islandj Gideon
Wells, Connecticut; Denning Duer, New Jer-
sey; Edward Mcpherson, Pennsylyanla; Ma
thanlel b. smithers, Delaware; James +. Wag-
ner, Maryland; Thomas Spooher, Ohloj Henry
8. Lane, Indiana; EbeneEer Peck, 1llinolsi H.
NJ. Hoxie, Iowa; william ID. Washbun, Min.
nesota; Cornelius Cole, California; o. II. Irish,
Nebraska, Joseph Gerhardt, District Of Co.
lumbla; Austin Blair, Mlchiganj Carl schurtz,
Wisconsin,; VIM. A. Phillips, Kansas.
Daily national Republican. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1862-1866, 1864-03-04

Major NJ. 2. Turner, commander Of the mill
tary prison at Richmond, reports the names Of
the prisoners captured at Smithneld, Va, Feb
ruary LIST, and Of the killed and wounded, al
follows:
Capt. +. A. Rome, 10Th New York; Lieut.. I
s. Harris, Sd Pennsylvania artillery, both
wounded. VIM. Chambers, captain command
Ing the Briggs; Andrew Hopkins, chief engi
ueer; james Booth, second engineer, same yes
sci; AdIutant A. Crumb, 21st Connectlcuti prl'
yatc A. Rockwell, Goth New York cayalryj pri
vate J. Kirk, Sd Pennsylvania artllleryi pri
Yates NJ. Vaughan and W. Taddles, 10th New
York cavalry, all wounded. Prlyates Charles
DENIM, Charles Morris, and Mike Clark, o
the Sd Pennsylvania artillery, were killed.
Daily national Republican. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1862-1866, 1864-03-04
LOCAL NEWS.

PENNSYLVANIA AssoCIATIoN.-Ata meeting
OF a number of citizens OF Pennsylvania, held al
,he room Of Hon. Mr.. Mcpherson, Clerk OF the
House OF Representatives, an organization wal
formed Tor the purpose OF promoting the election
Of the candidate who may be nominated At BAIL
more on June nth, and also for the purpose OF dis
semlnAting information among the people OF thell
state, and especially in order that the distrieti
now represented by Opposition members In Con
greSs may be enlightened on theBreat issues Of Tho
day. .,.,
Hon. ]. X. MoorheAd presided at the meeting.
Hon Amos Myers being calledupon for speech
expressed himself "hit or miss,n In favor Of Abra
nam Lincoln TIL the meeting of the Union Con
yention in Baltimore. This Allusion to Mr.. Lin
coin was received with tremendous shsutn o
applause; .,--..,. n,
The following officers were then elected! Presi
dent, Hon. J. X. MoorheAdi Vice President, Col
John W. EOrney and MesArB. A. d, Gosh and J
Holcomb; Recording Secretary, John sullivan Cor
responding Secretary, John p. Jonesi Treasurer
Mr. II. L. Fahnestock.
The meeting thtn adjourned to meet next Thurs
day evening, at such place as may be appointed b.
the committee.