, 1864-10-19
TIE McHALLK mURDER,


The inquest upon the body Of John Mcyatlv.
who wns killed on Sunday mornibe last unaer cir.
cuustsncea previously reported In The TRIBUNE,
WIS continued LAST ntsht at the North Market Han
betere Coroner Wagner. The deliberations Of
the jury resulted IN vtrtict implicatjsp h,th
Bolen and Dcly. In the minds ot manY thrra was
10 moral doubt Of the guilt Of oae OF the-e men
tufictent to convict. The .ce1sed evtdeo1l, died
from the effects OF the revpleer shot. Toon,h
b u Bolen urd Dot, were imp'ieste, 10 the our
r.; sna In. though En- both ncoouetudly assaulted Ne
prove which OF them fEed the fAttl bul.et. Tae
evidehce as 1t Stands may be thus briefly SUMMED
Esrly in the evening Bo,en and Dotv ve,e st
the Jupiter ss]oon concert room, on Desrbora
Rueet, whtre Bolen acsnow edged the o,sesstnn
Of revolver. BY thteasen,ng TO shoot the BIZ
Keeper A'ter*ards be affirmed tout bis weaoon
had teen stolen by Dosy- Later in tia evening
the men. or At least Bol. were seen At The saloon
q Barney 9 Riley, ii the vicinity Of ,he murder.
quarrel, and afttr the firing Of the ehot both ran
11em the tceDe Of death. went through O'Riles'a
eAlocn INTO his backyard, where q revolver owned
The men then 4ired to their boardi1e bouse and
rested. -
- Tn. n ist t5s syt5ense points Individually to one
h,lity Of deciding which ot the two Tas ,hs mur.
duet may, cause the d1.eharge Of both Tbs fol.
owing Is the evidence addueed list n'ght
TESTIMONY or TIMOTHY M"cARrHY.
Peter Kirwan's Melodeon saloon, on Dearbnrn
street, know Do1en hy sisht, but am b. nd
me.nt intimately acquainted With him. saw him
man named Doty. I did not notlce Dott par I'D.
lsE1y, hut saw :hst he Was intoxicated. BuIen was
Wy sIunk: When The psrtormsncs at onr place
thst be had lost bis revolver, which be stat,s hsd
heep taken by one OF his friends Doty and B1]sn
let In company. The Gan Bolen was also w,,h
thsm u tee eal9on that wa.s had
nire be told me that be woa1d shoos me He
ateruarfe tnid On the SIDEWALK that his revolver
hsd been .toltn, and hAd t'etn taken by Duty. I
d1d not see any other young man with The group,
npt ouIg man afteiw.fda came to me in tue
South Side. In q restaurant and tod me thit
C.e'eland Jack had been ehos bT Doty have
rot teen the young MIN eince, but would know
him II eaW him. IA man csptnred By the police,
Jrtterday. was here procnced, but Tue witness
stated dec,s'yely that he Was rot the man be hsd
teiettnce TO-
ETnEHcE OF BArNAnD SHANNON.
Barnard Shannon aTorn.-4m sailor, but LETT
my shtp Two weeks ago. Oo SnLday night I was
y Barney o.N es'a ealoon y hen rome men came in,
o'clock. After drinking LEFT them. ] did moi
hear Of row or know that a man had beeo kllied
unn' next morning. fwas not at Davis saloon,
Un The SonA Sloe, on that night
EVIDENCE or nAnHRT osnuEY.
Bs1uey O'Rlley yre-examned.-Saw Bo.eu in nv
hnuee On Saturday night somexhere about twelve
o'clo * Shortly afterwards be vent out with
come other men, and shortly Afterwards there was
Sight ouselde. There sas = man with Boien but
stoulo not kLow him again i'll saw him. I did
not eee Sksnnon in the enoeB, but be may have
bee there. When Bo1eh left think all tie other
men vent with him. heard the fight as / was
shutting my door for the night, and looked ont ind
cav number on the sidewalk. While there
heard s ths rspoft Of pistol just ahyr~atds two
and cjored the door. One OF the men who ran
thre9eh ny house va Bolen trhts witness eyi.
to tell, but with Hlbernian obstinacy he DECLINED
to say anything decisive and eyaded every qaestion
that he could Possibly efcspe.
TIE VERDICT.
Alter the atoye Witnesses had been examined,
TIE jury rttirtd aid determined upon the following
verdict:
1--WE, the Jury and that John McNslt, c.me to
his death trtm the effects Of revolver .ho fired at
the hAn6e Of Wafer OF Watlas Baleu. on the north
sIe OF North Water street, between CLARK and
Dearborn stteets on the 18th Of Octoosr, aud thar
Charles Doty WAS an accessory to the murder.