New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1864-01-04
,~so, ;r,o cxi..ence BIT we must NOT
.i1NeI ~ npIl"N -. 80 fe-t dnnns. and solne

hardy e1P.' ~. , ,tr 3. -ie prey If Yi ate VS.
ri ,rlicl was b.it nna Iaa, lca 9. '.i.'9 - co
Il Is ~. ~ i -, -, r'r, a l,-l document
ss..irnel Ia prove that tie n-is-Hor !i"N l,
-,oftts gca.4ifry Issued Nt' 100 ...H +..,.. . 3.
=, .r,I,.,re W, can hardly wuntcr y ie names y.
81. 49,. s,in. .H moi r.ure tie i.o,t lvol, ~
so,4 Nv vtich \ ilcf4ca1s CoaIh f''3 Ut. ny 50.
~ avoiccrs and ;ne ci,rclcHes o. "" f'l q, d
ON honest duty. rna'F tle ,li' g., =, m ia
an eI'o,yancc FOR their 'ep.ns 80" 10 i'"Nc ~
&c ,,a, NC were never wiitl paItic tptnerV'""s
'''''' w. cOBDG,; AND THE TIMES.
Thof,l,gwipg is another inSta.lmcntol WIN,
n, ~ calls Tie 'riosi unHcc, ssaIy oe:TcsPOAus"00
ioty.csa Nj Golden and III. De.anc;
'Suo have reccyod lie letter dated eci yourfr
yst1 residence ard bearing your Prone sl-s.i.
yle yoa take on yourself rso1niiy 90 re- S
Of tlc Interpretation pn ~ IHe TINS ca n,, -, We
II M Bright and myscli AZ Locld-c-.ngr' = iis
oroposed division Among trc p- OF TIE i'As u ''
~ yo,, ,rjbg.s 10 ~. ire, deliberate misrep,e.
.e-oiioo e your mea,inf asd thai Of MI n'k., ."
otle means Of rllertuG tAe unesuh az .b,
The land between tle 1ich snd ne poor. min
esrfain passages "a your SPEECHES III! III ~
Ssr no other i0eryleta ton than tat ee!i'o ~ ."s.
- u crave atclsati1n. am told that II pro'cd
.. ,fm,I hing Mr. Bright and myself witAD Inc Iio'
ors ~ ~ . ect SIN George H. cap 10 and render
ns liable The penal consequences 81 tI'hsi 10
,eytu yrs - x-o,.,- p &, thc
,e.p.c; due 10 others wei as yourself as 20 I've 10
5resseC iis accusation to ne uuess Wl'h iAc teIsi
Nj you lave evidence % subS:ant.aie Il.
c'r ol vor e. give ne those certain passages 10
rticS Won refer and which ere lCaly now the only
srestoi at ssus Between YOU nd ne That thele nay
e no excuse OF ground Toy deay accent tio r'lori
shch appeared IA ycug PAL r as On aGc. y version %
-vTpaech and 20 1 sou IN yorr tdsf nave en- RON
IA. Iyges the entire PASSAGE which CONTAINS ui trG
said IN reference 10 the condition o. the W@9.e peOo
The agricultural population. and the land question
In tssrt.cr Bot LEI il lie distinctly understood thsI
a. not confne Won 20 ibis lssast. but thos e'oS
IT, entire range Of my speech. 81, ,ro.a,
which although do hot IN the slightest degree cieh.
IN tAem tie character of evidence may have interest
r is Inown thet an not IN tie hahit o. writing
Sord beforehand O; what speak in pubic LIZ" othcr
,pakcrs practice has given nc "a perfect seiiposses
son in TIE presence Of an audience as II SeTo IA IA!
closet. Now 10y one consan; ara o'sFTuius 'LoIT,
While Bldressng public meeting lIe ore necessity
which tie loDs experience q Ito arts Of coasI0NerAG
ls.s has nqrcssC on NY nnd Is 10 avoid ilc posi- ~
~ Of being iis.ep.esen.cd. end pseyeLi II! opho.'s
from raising false issuc--c iflCk OF cgic as Old q tie
tins Of Aristotle If hive rs some fav0iais cTics
aye r,easco 20 think sometimes spoken WIZ elcei ness
Il is more owing % ths ever csen .eaf ei A.s4vv,v
reDtaiion than any other cause II s anus l1A' ZIG
vet nosions things III lie n cy Lave then nse'
Nhon IN ny speech OF Roohde.e caMc - touch npon
AZ subject Of tho land lie thought instantly flashed
arcugh my Orain-snd none but the pUolc tIeatsr
nOws viii what velocity thor 1T r0Tes when in the
presence ofi,oCJ hsteners-tArt was GeaAn, WIN
tresoa about which there is d superstition IA England
taknown elsewhere, end that TIE enemy would talse ire
ev q agTarianlsa agairs nc and hence NY delunciS
ton O. arrariaa on age which viii be found Ia the
allowing extract. Had been inspired Wit the facn
~ OF sccsnd sight 10 have .Orsccn the editor Of TIE
fines sting bodily penrnc his criticism my speech
You'd ro, have com eiyr llted and couounGed
beforehand the charge how brought against me.
The following Is tie passage referred 10;
at has ecsu hion Of s'e 70 tax q an extension OF The
e a sSasshs sS TO % nS. d o+i1 ~
part in Government and thy P2,ns .. us coray
ID O,ss. es. snS qS'w oTS .Ss not be considered
resostionsry because my sse don't want sIy
T,eisnd Iosy COMPARE very voraoy with cost oiier
eoau,re 4 Won dr tie Ire n scoie'y oieTasy nigh and
ess.ss o. the country, con'.et5s p'Iiin o. ihs
riii classes with the same e'',cs ats2sd. .on 80
800 te ys.g much happier leTe else than IL L.
but when ny oYp2-en'. u.' tn' ~, -. ~ ,Ie
,.onis ~ from their present state 70 tie love! OF o.ef
soIn.rs v i have tssvee3 n.Iof' ciyilizo count e.
~. fc-slr W. ia The of o.er countries - co.d
wish mud In o;her countries greater number o. pope W.
Sou.- In te yc.J .sha. tie Of ae pee 10 sre o. -
,er.te 10 England These ssro BED is' q 'As e9a9or
your pors your mycs !. USE telling X You have
tsmal portion Of your peofls eac.el.ns! Wei. 9f, ws.
with .oIity Of the people AZ O.her coGnes nov ssy
with iressrd to things foreign countries we cont
.Hry h.. no raTsli on the lace Of tie ;esl,s llsrl
You haze other peascn;ry but a Of hnxna when e
rrely divorced rom the and Ter. Is oihsI country IN
lhe word you will not Cad men holding t,e po~ sni
tuning up up0n tier own i.eehod tou ~sni
tbs inj ,ad 1t Il tic col,enl with Aui94n HelI- tal
the cOrcoa u tie people Is r'Lelay pretty
themselves and If y,u lave Class entirely yorced ron %
Es posgeT While IL apoiA'i country tey poser a. hey
greater elvapires ,hey vii be better educated have
better chercs q having property than N country "ee iley
You viii observe IN the above passage frofo ny speech
taken IRON your own report that use tho words. "
change al this and now we must appeal 20 tho ,rbu
nal u tie photographer II you turn 10 "Webater 5
(quarto> Dictionary you VIII ind the word "agrar4An
fnferprC. ed on the authority Of Burke, as MNoTs:
"Reail. 70 l4ndA Dcnoing pertaining TO an equs d.
vision Of and. a. agrasi-n laws Of Rome, wich dis'rs
ned the conquered and otter public land. equally among ~
Again, in the same dictionary, the woTd " agfiran-
tsmis given ian egual division Of lands orprpery
OF the principles If tho-e who favor sncn division
Thus in ropuaioting the agroren system repadigted
IN pure and Cnqresionaole English, according 10
Burke, the principles OF tAose wLo ilEor az e4usi
division Of land; ] repudatei tie aeTarian layB 81
Rome; and yet in spite Of this you charge Inc and Ar
Bright with proposing division ainon2 the poor OF
The lands Of The ricA, and you asssoeie:o IA with
Graceful IN schemes Of sociaistic spOisiOn. will
leave Nj Briyhts cese for The future, you seem 10
prefer II, 10 bis Own good keeping merely observing
Na, his remarks upon tie land question we're more
slighr ard Incidental than even my own end quite as
tacspa1 Of being perverted ~ your sense
mast add word with reference 70 the explanation
lhave gwen Of what VAS passing ia ny nlad when
spOke &C ROchdale against agr3r!an Outrage. in the
House u Commons speaker is allow ed 10 pu. lis
Interpretation and ineae on his dpqted ftteTaDc'
This Is fir in -irc discussions; but decline 10
claim accept tine benefit Of tais practice in the pres
snt There Is no dlspUte IS 20 what said Hc-
een your own version OF my speech IL is marvoi-i
SUsly accurate report and viii abide by every word
Of it in its simples, and rost obvious meaning
And now, having given yOn the above materials
which 90 solely to leave DO ground for prolonged
slondenCe. ak whether You prepared TO id
here ~ tie charge Tat proposed at ROcAdas the
2iih clt TO divide among the poor the lands Of The
rob.' AID Il 30 / caIl you TO cite those certain
passages nom my speech which you ssy viii bear no
other interpretation" l must be allowed 70 remind
you that s now wholly question Of proof; that thero
but one issue before and that any attempt eYade
tis issue by raising others entering or vague and
lrrGley fnf h.