, 1864-06-16

lA8Ek1QA IL ACES u 6dAQ Q1&-
ums wsre mentioned BY them, Ingalls, propos.
nE LEES sun than tea dollars per day, bus Camp
'el inaiRt1ng that four hundred dollars each vas
title enough a. they bad been gagged forty days
nd ferela! EVENING" in the hearing Of the cause.
leponcnt y a. referred to and he refused to ex-
Nese any opinion on the snbJec, stating that be |
F:s .a the arbitrator named BY sald Lsil and pre.
.gree TO- ench sum az they thought tair, and de-
'onent believing thatit Was finally understood
~ enid ingalls, and Campbell that ten dollars per
air compensation, for their services, and
leponcnt Was st TINT time requested by
nc er ooth of eaid arb,trators 70 see said
ns s snnsfs oaes q - aa f
ICES oetWesn Inc ssSond ~ aaa teaa meetn3, that
y s + aacn1 ~ a,d o 1b,1 npr ssn ~ IT. r.
wei Weea Inc ~ 9 ama , IT,, .. saio arn!
sls5ss = 5 iii .aId
ne.Wes1 .1s rs sata seeond ID and third meet
ng, as stated IN the affidavit Of said Campbell on
~ ~ ts thts 5s1nn.n+ t,,,h., s.x, The. .+
r.. s3t "a " sa,, sal9 " Saao sia
- IN. ~ 49, a. ~ Naaloat kn9
n, tnst ,he s.;d shnn NJ s9 aa1 a
ne cause gaaed d saSeesnon vas assented to sy de.
ponen1 ~ J., sau se a. teaas no ooleeuona
sere maae - Eacn saes u3a .! salo 1ngaus: Ano
er Or ] as1eenent as to saia arbtrs
'ols lees, saeopa a. "oo1e sta.eas An9 aeponeat
luftheI eass. ma A. tue aaau tata meetlng
5eno~ent Il bsd sfatea what their ..za9 aaS
N.Y. M na a}oI ~ ese - s1e 0uso, aua n't1
ss!o ineus uau dsau 1is ~ aa9at "oai ne
LnouGnt t9s aMasu o9eut 10 oet i9e salo Gampoel
3 ta'eu " oeponeai anat Ge Waolo s'sa tue aHar9
me oe1t mo1n!ng. pnt 1ha1 ne wanted 70 see and
constlt t1ena oe1o:e no signed X And depo-
nent says mat no tl1ae dtd ne ever hear
the eaid award, Ct that, should be sign the said
award, Inc said Ltl Would pay him 1ouf h1adred
ooilars leea, or any othet sum- nor WAa there
Te1a tta ea 81 Or ,heIr Dy any orc e. estd arb
would make any difference a. 10 the nmount Of
tees they would recelye. whether they did or did
not sign any award Of any, kind. And deponeat
further says that during ne meetings OF said az
bitrStors TO inTestic1!e and determine the canse,
the said Campbell frequently said, wh:n
his attention was called to evidence
Vas not natural. and would make
10 other reply, and he also said that
he htd visited the family md knew them well, aud
be had aeen out to the ia5m with Kaiser. anatast
and that II he Wouid lie would alter his mInd
that they were the ple1santest family be ever
knew: Ind dtponent further says that said
ration OF facts mot IN evidence before them: ana
Ct ppueut fIrtl e. s.Ys that durfnr thef eousnits
t!ona, said Campbell frequeauy stated thai ali Of
csusc was inst right and that II the SAID aspitca
torr could not aeo or thi1k alike abopr lhe f.cts
in the cause, it was au honest difference OF opinion
And deponent further says that the statements OF
said Campbell, in his eAid affidavit s.that OF the
lstt meeting Of the said arotts4tors, the said
Campbell TILED 10 Get from said Ingalls, some epln-
ion ns to the law and evidence In lid cause, but
The arbtsra:oEs Thur4dsy April 18Th, 1854, va.
wasltd in frivolous tstee, lore talx and smutey
stores, the sa1d Law and Ingalls, seeming
and deliberately perform their duty as arbitr1tors
that curing each session Of aaid arbitrators after
the a1ganent OF touoaeI, the said Ingalls, seemed
cidipr lie eause on principlee Of eUuitT Ind ins.
ice are entirely untrue and without the slt.ht-
c4t iourdAtion II fact
And deponept further says that he h,e never Re-.
eel, I'd apT nav OF Compensation whateyer. or INV
p.omiee q! paymcut from said Lii or from any
tlber person tor his services and tie for sery1ns
as ono q The arhtua.ora in this caee.
statement in he afluayit Of tue ri 1ainti ilei in
thir cause, ns fays that sad award IN fact was
contrary to The evidence, cootrary 10 law and cor
tra,y 10 the priuciples OF equity and issticc rud
VIE In fact uadt by Robert Law ana G.orse A.
nom corrupt and Taadul, n: a. motives and and ,h,oasb
9sasst eaaee I'd 1sa. ssd axad
Gircct rc1s onsl pt cunnry benefit 10 one no. bots
Of the taid a5bltratu5s who sl-ued said award,
is 20 lar a. depo5ent his any knowledge on the
foundation IN inct. And depoucnt further SAYS, on
H.. THURSDAY evc1in:.. April asth, 1854, depoaent
il Il said 1nsalls anu Campbell together wGe1 ho
starred fo1 home as5 ten n tie
evenings when said oIbitrators met for detaEnin-
M saio cauee, said ingalls, and Campbell had met
and we're toseiher when deponent srstEed. and
shs, ,hs G oh. evening said and
yeart, and deponsnt neyst had any acaastl;:
sas sas f oe9e eae % a ses
Ano dspolent iartner sa5s, that curing the en-.
Hss fIia o. und sGnse ~ eoa'9tsanon were ere.
asa oet~een eaiG aats .t anu oeponens as TO tae
cslucaCe " n1.te .! ~ eause, os.ose Iae csast
Nae e.ose1 " .ae a.secaeui @ y coun5el. aaa nt
ecnfesfat 1on nstef tEat ant'l th3 aWasi ~as madl
nEg sleEto. cSeept Wnat MaE eoia In the prcseae'
A Ard th,s deponeat tortbeT s,ys that at the tim:
ol 5te Ma9hlEG Q! tslu a"stu oepYEsnt pc.aetC
ano sta penese9 1nat VIZ 6t.eg T. i; y,
sLSS w1n y e critr a md tns,,cs u, o1 ~
rsihsa2'es q cau a1,, 9nu 3osee & NJ ~ -,
cooEse, 3of sne I'a'nua t91as'ca " upoa aas ~
nent 2, the eaee .ns u 3so -, snoa
t Il. isyoF q; M tic M ss;d la n.s:atiG A' s'e ~ ."
raaus rcv st,mn1 io11Hf LAW
1, Gas: = .; hes' StanP,I ut. c.h =,
1 ICss "1o s"si" H. oStotS E,--cn I1e LIT fTa-t
~ ~. Ar17DArrr oz r. 5. T11sos.
Robert 5. NIsou+ a sald county, be.ns d1t
eHoTn, sGye tbs; Le ID cne OF the countel 10
p II ~ ~ ~ Inc 81 ~ II,
ter uetopent and s. Il Dow, ESQ.,, attorney 70
sit agnea taas and II VS. VI asa.
! law suesti0ns vould arise upon the e:f!as-bu
| den6ntpt ard taI S. X Dow had x;ca: diff nit
~ 6a s~2eed to
OF Geo. II. Iufal1s, Esa,, Il he wonld ccus.rt I
sc., G. md de1opeut ard said S L. Dow, Esq
| went 10 the otsce OF said Iagal!
~ ecrs.s "a sre} th,n1 arbitrator. md taen ar,d
theIe informed ea:d ipcal;s tl,at thcy had ere,t i
nrs1,tv In ee1fct,nr nan that would be ssfsftctc
- ~ T.-+trs IN snnn,,ff;n1 t),t cnn.s tn -rhitrs
to.e Was tn have lie sae tficd priyate1y. In orie
rrnrart tfc srer5aI flint 1y,u 9i fn3inu m iii
ane en aa saerS ~ ahnd Sa.u al LII
s.snms ~ cnn.idcrs1 sn6 aoreed nnnn +. s+;d
Dew, Esq.:zna::deponcut for asresae rpon and Sc
nr na r,.s;denf ~ chiraan and hsl esta nl;shed
oi, Tnr inte-;tv aud nr,r,1S NJ s1nrsr
tel. End that he could not be Influenced b
any pecueiary OF outside consideration. raa
sa.d 1nsals then ana tnese ,c consented !,
serve rs euch arbitrator That ds2onen
never spoke to sid ilEalis conceInins his psy
this causf pfetlons 70 t9ai tlnc anui sSme We 9
aiter tbe aWsfa wa Haos, e3eept Mnst ne na y.
MA +, te 14esence o. ali ti1ee Of thc and
naa.n!Ms counsel anu 1sPpno. .P ,,t. hasn2
tnas ne We passGas tha. fc... I.ps AZ
raa .nc ,hs nv inip.o ors| 1s}o on
feeeI.i essnanhss ,a1 shth 80, ~ ~
t1nns atose 1Ron sala asaa. MaiIa Meas tia;
EAIeu " SELL sS ~ ~. - ;aa 80 - - -,
ttas many thfhse detal co IN esosacs s, VI ~ ~ ~
Tome fnleat, anG lnae ~ se. t LIZ
eSIresea ,E7o, ~ Nv ..h.,r
lnt. ana a. ernreseinr their en;ire coafIience
!eess f1rs noei5 arG ~, ~ a4 ~ I,
services rcrdcreo by Sid Incalle. and Tue tin. o
cupicd in the trial, the sum Of four hunared, Il
amount paid ior his services - email comrens
Lion. art les tnan ne onGnt 70 aAEe rec eivea q
dfiorent 50 to!a AIS c,ient, Nm. Lni. Aua =
ronent lI1tae ao nno ~ Nv ennnas
Trial ceaole eat1 oo ~ FL