Daily Ohio statesman. [volume] (Columbus, Ohio) 1855-1870, 1863-03-14
supreme court or Ohio.

Hon. William v. peck obief Ju,t,ce and Hon W.,
liam Y. Gholson Hon Jaoob BrlnkerhofT, Hon Jos,a
gcol. and Han Rnfns Rannau ynd0sI, nun '"'a
L. ]. Critchaeid Eaa Reporter.
| Tnvsn.v M.rcb IN 1870
| A"Ar' "a'oh ~ 'oo''
GENERAL Do0RET
| No no wn,,u, yu,.-.o,, : xu,,,,.. o. . -,
| paS Mo' os' Wina,n m, mbwen v, Wipam ureen et al
n1ssIveu IN thS Dlstnct oourt OF hamilton county
| a I,.;,,,g T., ~eiu ~:
Ia claim hss hss ala M 20 coun
A. a.o Deen ,vu vanno, u,,ss .ne actlon.
drawn vblcb cnnts;r S nn.n uny VI inaIunciay
Won contains INC necessary lactB TO warrant ar
.onns, ase, 10 70 .nS aesnean., vii be treated as
a After x cssa ,s res.,uaS >, shis Co... ,
ioined and an asrssS s,a,emsO, ~ st upon ssue
ibe niesdIngs matinS issuss 80 Io y
evidence vii ha aiIwL Is. =, a. oIsinB M urine \.
w,,hont I, ~ Ia. ~ uni.ss " maue ciear thal
pam LID lnJusuce uone. rl. D
=, Mnen the answer is that OF church corporation,
msmbsrs "a b & osi Wy m ai S' s
s,s;y, ~ sHPeS ueIu " De nieu, s1
al an extIa msetpg conysnsd withont srT;t n,a
and bv n a,raii nnmber.oy the mamhers iiI n, ~
lowed 3''' " ''' -''"'''''' WIZ no' w al
g. NV sucb corno,o,;or a,,so,,n,
sale Of church propertv and An SppronTstion NJ H.
proceeds must be taken an whole ana no sale will br
allowed unless the anpronration The nyocsed" 4, is
cal ''' '"' aPP'oPiia'oh Vi 'he proceeuS ID IT,
g. 1t is the right Of apy msmbsr o, The corDoro,,or
to prevent by Injunction breach Of trust bv tbe ma.
jorIty. - 0 49,"
z. euch sale and appropriation NAV he iawfr,Iv ~
dered al the regular annual meeting Of bs
without special notice and for ibis purpose adjourned
sessions OF such meeting are but lawful gaton
OF it, Wv 'N' ""'D' rio'OnsS'ion
g. WbeYe thp ,,obt N ,o,o .,,,Dor .,I ,,.,,o .,o,
ing the interests Of The eornoraon s sesnred bu The
chsr,ar 10 .aaob rnanaha G ~ , seSIeu ~ He
nam o,Dners tbe nrIvisa, q, siv,ng 70
strict The rieht pf votng =, the Sni 4, Sn 70
every one admitted into the socetv bv aori, oS bo
~ yTh W ~ ~ OoIpoLaupn.
court Of eauty will not cSntInus ~ msEe
Injunction altar he canss sr hb a. @ ,I L on
been removed and danger to the rights Of ,he psint
no longer exists ~ 'AN ''e"'' " INV Pi''"''ii
no. A truatee in doubt M IN b,s Dowors has ,ho vh,
to apply TO couTt Of eonitv N dsana hem and gius
judicial sanction to his acts but in such case the ceut
will only define the trusts and will NOT order aae of
property where no adverse right ia asserted.
ii. Members who seosde from n hhn,cb oyuanization
thereby forfeit all right to any part Of the church prop
erty. N1' f' - 'N' P'0p'
u. Whether there has been n aacsso,o, ,,,;,bin ,h
meaning of ha rnIe IL mixad onsS,;n W i nS
fact 10 be decided nnon ,ha an;derda g;,S io =. I
The crcuunstances ipeludno tbe acis ~ Ihe nas nd
the motives which have nrnIntsd sUnh 49,, anu
IN. A cond',Ion"I pt.IPp,e promP,eu sson scs.
two bodias g;,b ,ba sps. - " .no memoets INTO
ioritv and fonndsd ,noS ans sPp.oyai oi ma
the church pronertvtbc romhsuP .;II .an, VI
TO exercise their rights In The cnrnn,.t;ar =; ~, ~
cesslon. :" -"' ~
II. Where the charter az cb,rch cornnration Uives
the power NTH the consent M maioy;iy 81 i,s Nam
bers TO ds ne of the nronertu tiSor ths nrrnnse =,
promoting ths eneata n tbeir cbrvcb - 81 Oh , "
ioritv dec;dkes9lt a. ,,o. i o1uuh anu sucn ma
nronotsS 10 d,vi"'on e ~ Oh sne cnuIch VIII De
ecclesiasticai bodiea and an anr1ahIa o ~ ~
chuYch nTonertu and Sor .h sluso.e @ uss'on oi .ne
division OF such propertvHeid. thst oh 1 nS
division Involved no volation NJ ,hs h s",o anu W
breach OF trust. " '1' 0nS'''i anu no
Motion 10 diamisu anti n ova,rr,oa Lava .. m,,..
answer and file further answer rsfussd and ,uSvnsnt
entered dIssoIying inuncton and sanctonng az anS
distributor in accnTdance y1,,h rasoInt; 1 o on
1859. va" '''O'"'''N' VI "SS ~''
Gholson, j., did not sit IN tbis case. .l
scott I dissan,sS W. ~ '"s 'a'e'
No
Error N The 6on,eaI pI y, ". SnIIstIan huchauer'
served in The DistrIct 6onri huSkhgnm county ne
Brlnkerhol, j, Held:
puIchase of real a:,.,o =, ,,,,,.,,, al.
who At the appraisement undsr ,vbjch snoh 80, ~ was
~ Sscta a.. ~ "a an s no under the provisions
oniv. aOd viii on e s.cy vo,a Du Is yoldaeis
onlv On an internos;tnn ~ nSoosaaI S al snu vv,u,
interest tiirectlv foT The nnrpoSe m avo,S b ala
Judgment afirmea 'e 'NNA '"'-
Rannev' J.. dassnted
No. q, John GaSlev At n, y rbs ao,.vo,,,. soo,a,.
of Zoar et al Reas2ved n ,he n,;",p pSs IUuey
rawas. ''O N'''i'' O'1'' VI hN''A
Peck,J:
An nn;n,svnor.,aa4 .n...,., Ill, .,,-.,. :, =,
grated from eTman1 anS ,Uiy caea separas mi
county in 1917 In straItened c;rcnm.toncs, s S hs
membera purchased Iarge rat 80 dS 80 o VI ", a.. n
taking deed In his own name and S;n hi;
notes and mortpa0e to aecrre navms, bt ,,h th
derstauding that each Of tbe members bouid hava h
portion OF The land as he bonid @ 20, "t s
yate means f"' 'O' '"' VI LIE pr
In 1910 the pl.n of sevaroi ,n,a,os,s vr., ...o,
bv The members and tbst ~ .n,ns,s, was auanuonsu
adopted and In their articles Of assocation ,bst 1aa
the members renounced ali aanarate ;ntaras,s a., ,h
nronertv and devoted The san,s 20 ~, ss IN .ne
tons IN n common Srnd - ,hn a.. isaIe @ aoausi
eat Of the society and under tba mansusnn az ~
recora Ali the membe ra nart;cnatinrr aSraIi, ~ az ~
Of the Joint propertv an long as bsu continna y, %o
members and 10 labor for the socjatu. bnt ,ha tbt
spectlye interests In the same and rgbt n
from shouId ceaae unon voIun,ar 20 ~ H.,
expuisIon from the secatv and Sor,d nas NJ Sus'
mssibe In case of death 10 ibsr resnective bsrs az