New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1863-08-13

.t ihf<e before did; hc g"'s there a,nn' "'c"fk,
~, u TO not yet there un'i about Z; ne prisoner
rvn .ued there after | got tucre until the boar iur
"A dipner, abont al'- i.s: 10, w,ea ne wet to his
d.nuor az! cano back ~ hG,i.p..st I, | l'1 the
shou TIA, mint about tweatr minutes after
oclocX; tle PASSOVER r.rgiEed there alter BIO came
back from dinner until the shop wa OJsed; he a-h
shat up the shop; | live a; lOj Charlton street;
ire prisoner AID went up together IN an EsAth
avenue and Bieecker street STAGE he lives an West
Twenty eighth street; when we had shnt ny the
sIoD the prisoner and came over near The W0TH
building and cav soiae 800 or 400 policemen but no
crowd; @e thea went back and waited some ten
inmates iOr stage; we went up together aod got
out nj the corner OF Downing and Blocker stree's;
LETT the prisoner III the sage II was niter O'Clock
when got ont If the stage; | arked hn 10 Walk up
home but he said lie would not walk because his
foot sore.
Cross-examined-On the Saturday before ne
18th Of July, we remained ia tie shop nntil >
clock it wac liz up with ga, thai gIt and was
down there on the Sunday before the 18th until |
o clock aud then went home and siad around nome
all day; / usually walk ny home; the prisoner
always rides up; after we shut NJ The shop on The
18th ,ye were abont the PARK about five NANTES
no longer; we only came up between The W0rid
Office aud The Tunes Office; we did not hght TIE
gas at all Monday might; We had order from Mr.
| Cnrs,.doro to shut up when it got dark.
! John Shaughnessy-Direc eXamlnatOn.-I know
the prisoner at the bar as " Henry" don't know
any other name for him; Am personally acquainted
with him; have known him for the last five or Fix
years believe; saw him on the l3;h OF July IN
Cbrs'adoros shop, both IN the forenoon aud in the
! afternoon; he was at bis chair at work; SAW him
AS walked along by the door; know LIN TO be an
upright honest man. never knew him to do any
! dug wrong; my business brought me By the door
several times during the day.
/ Cross-examiued-I DO not know whether be went
to dnrer that day; he might have been out from II
10 O'Clock aud not know anything about II;
I ,u. ~ W. RI in the hotel m stairs.
/ Francisco scArdo-DIrcct examination: l work
in Mr.. Crisadoro's, and have worked there for I've
o. tIx years; know the rTsoneri hr WAS III the
sop o., the 18Th Of july. remained IN the shop
nntll nv dinner time which from hslf-p-sl one
TO near two o'clock; when left the snop the
prisoner was there, had returned from his dinner;
bis time was from ~ To ~ Tor him 10 20 10 dinner;
urualy 70 10 dinner when he gcts back; came
hacs from nv diuner at 3! or something Ike that
the mi .oner was in the shop when came back and
| 4 remained there until the shop shut up,
and the prisoner was there them l think he went
ay with james Kelley they shut up the shop;
the prisoner did not leave he shop that raw, from
cary III The morning until he went TO dinner, and
r. N tue tae hc came back from dinner until we
.hut mp the chop; think the shop was shut up
i from : TO :. that uigbt.
Cros.-rAGmiled-We coni see to shave a in
ID. shop on ihc 1871 of July Ut o'clock at night;
was gone to dinner about an hour-thst is my
time, | m.y Ihave bscn some minutes more; u live
corner OF Chambers rtreor and New BJwery.
Alien Hay, direct oxamination-I AIN u black
smith: | 1--we M No. l5i West Twenty eighth
street; / know the prisoner have known hITn ioT
A,e ycaTs; lis general character l. good 30 lar hs
Anow he il an 1one,t aud industrious man, be-
hevc. AID quiet nau; lie has wie and Two
cAilar,a.
Matilda C'ark--l reside in the zane house with
the prisoner. have known him gong on SIX yeas;
know bis general character 10 be very cool; TIC u
leaceabie. quiet aud industrious man. TO the best
81 nv sBoslcd.e the pn,oner got home about IS
oclock on the uishi OF July H.
Robert LDuaa-I 1.-Two at No. 10 Wes. Twenty
ishth street | know the prisoner, cannot ray
VIVA. time the prisoner got home that evening; The
character 81 the prisoner u good 20 i.T "a l Know
Tie defense here rested.
M lhAnn The notorious Alabama rciuycel pro-
cc~ded b. mp for the defense He criticised the
orcdIbiluy oi OF the wltnessea; referred %
ito wfue,s Hall, who acknowledged himself to
b. - flolIy contractor, ant ~ si0ckho.def IN lHE
Tint sI and no doubt TO furnish 70. shoes Tor
%. 90, 900 volunteers that were 10 follow wcl-
/ known governmental procedure. HE testimony
Wa cinii,.l ng, lie fwc,Ts "a ono time Lc was "n
Tie .op II IHE IHfBUNE building, an1 then a.
smother rlIce sScnrs be WAS at thai very time IN
the street. Such testimony shows the iconiou, IN
tent of those VINO have srmiyrci the prisoner
hero 10 d4y. l. shows also IA ici0uous intent IN
U hef qa.Tterr whether from political or meFcshaiy
.iiv.s. % D. not for me 20 Ray. But the mOlVe
cannot BE- good when the act is stained with
perjury GLd ~ open 10 OJi0qny. Toe cOauscl CON.
mrntcl Ilo4 tie conflict 81 testimony IN elercL,e
o. Gle i,.-fA - tic haf oi the prisoner today
su1 on tne lltn al jay, ani argncl that II here
fore followed that toe wItu+-rcr hal reference 10
two different individuals. iio called sue atten-
ton OF tuo Jury 30 tAe te.tim.ny OF the
Wi.uctfes ilr llc defense ~ relation 10 tie good
chlracie- 81 ihe prisoner. ~ That testimony h.d
been uuoIcr,iouei 10 u 10 be tahcn a. true, and,
t.r!,!ore, The pr4a0uer - proved 10 be- - nah 4
gDll character. lLo prisoner l. s.d to have called
fUr ,le,rs for Gen. Mcclellan, Wi, b. in the e. Ima
ton OF thorc who urr4ign hnn h,n', one OF tue
heiuols crimcs that could be- laid 10 his charge
lie could lave gone 10 10 part OF tue DIlcd states
Were snOutH Tor that patriotic General would nave
been more dlsastcful 10 tL0re who heard them .han
tho slol between The Times and IHg IHlHUSL
Buildings. supIo-ing that ho laI done 70. Ia their
opinion, It Ma grave crime TO shout Tor IA Cen
era Who always treated his pfironers lac
human ben,s and who always led his
army like nn army of Christians. But political
prejudice and military iayor1istn should not rule
here although there was perslsIent elon
90 establish that fact which shows that those shouts
are u. ardcd as the gravest crime alleged against
the prisoner nj the bar. He cautioned the Jury
against oonycllng al innocent man upon the tert-
mOuy OF wItuestos VINO look through spccacle5 al n
man IN the distance, and not only that, but through
sprctacles 70 gangrcued with political prejudice,
mat those who use them look ouly IN one diIcc
ton. aBd can observe but one color, and that 40
black AH the ace Of spades.
The counsel continued ut some length in the same
STRAIN " argument.
CLOSING SPEECH or Mr.. GARvIs.
The Assistant Dstrct-Attomey then proceeded to
sum up the for tie people. In bis Introductory
observations he expressed bis regret that the coun
rel for the defendant alluded to politics. Tor the
province OF tho Court and Jury was 10 uoh the
tcales of justice high and even between the people
on one side and the accused the other regardless
Of political on religious considerations. Mr.. Greeley,
whose uumo bad been mentioned, was not even
witness aud no had night 10 reior TO his po-
ritiou or 10 what bc had heretofore said or done.