New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1863-02-05
THE BOaLEAU ARREST CASE.
.JndEc Ludlow Esebu:sed.

Al the openinQ Of the February Term Of the Pbila-
delphia Court of Quarter Sessions on Monday,
Judge Allison, in his charge TO the Grand Jury, re-
pudated and rebuked tie course Of Judge Ludlow
in reference to the Boieau case. II is understood
that Judge Thompson, the remaining Judge oil tho
Court, also condemns the action Of Judge Ludlow.
Amer referring to the proceedings in the case, Judge
Allison says:
10 this proceeding am compelled to except regarding
zee wrong in every aspect in which II can be viewed
would be defee. ny daty Judge ofths Court H. by
ny silence myh to sanction Il, aud H. IN speak
us dl place upon it my most emphatic condemnation
wst unwso bcctuss e unnsccrssr the ordinary nDde
Of sgui7sl procedure hong fey adequate % remedy ~
wrong wrong has been oomni..sd aad ta moshod be-
ug "a my judgment shc only proper ssd legal way OF bring
lng he into Court Il was nJudicou for however well
Intended the con,squsncc Of Jsdse Of his own motion
upon more Information obtained IA no legal wsy-ior
tier, was no complaint under oath-wih unnece''ary
and unusual A.si. making OF his official position
10 institute a prosecution strictly personal and phi
vsts IA Its nature Is render tho whole proceed
ing liable 70 nisconructioni TO plaee this Court In
f.l.s position before the country, as anxious Tor
nd q IL. own "a oti0n seeking Of difficulty with the
ov.rnn.pt ani became the legitimate result Of such action
"a ~ rrritst col iiou between the States .Id General
(Iov,nfnen when collision should - al proper me
ana 10 lie lat QoasiDt extremity be uyoi4ed tAAt the tue
I'd constitutional Government OF the agd may be upheld
and hcned In s fearful struggle Win al Infamous ~
bsou which d,hr. IT, authority. trlnpes it. flag mper'
m he erouce ard which has blsd the land with Ian enta-
on aud cannot consent tnst TINS coHt 'hAl even H-
nay be used for any such purpose unless the Hece'-
i,y 10 forced upon aud that necessity that cannot be
AVOIDED aud .pe.srs ny.e here it ,haA 40, br 50
ute5 n by the exercise Of any portion o. OF al tAe sAu"l
power Of N, oni,r, it eau he prevented . = -
Tlefo Is s another reason Why cannot approve OF inc
pro sedug. under confederation and that ~ because pc
hove tns unauHofzpd ~ Ac a" u ihe iand haEis
established principle esla, pio'erai q 10 Ss
Jures 90 sanction sustain them be 20 he
r..,nt vi the ttfoe r1tfsofduty modes 81 intuuns It9
re 20 which have called your attention. "l naA' Ills
not sucs .utineut be made the basis Of any
action by tue TOT Bong aimed ~ individual oHend''
.u4 Al mo spscinc aud dnc oLense a. So'e % .s5
forced only tle pcroual kuowedge OF the ana JNi"ia
the presenaeut question has ior is foundation COM
mum. al made jay Oy tho pfesidus judge anu lue
uf prftes cent before them by A direction. tna
p.-c.,ly what the cour IL CaIpnofs case oecdoduey
h.i ul autHoy 90 d. and therefore 'ian4' ~ e'ivV'
ID IN te law aud exprrtt decision 81 TINS court
ut therefore regard the Issennen as esl'sf aud IN
,shrr does this fell under tLe second cas'lcaiou tho
t.oc.eiIl. ld uot originate Win the nn''' Aoi's io
Wa auy Oh be- own motion Oh o.acI" @'d DC
lore tio Grand jury. r,.,..,.. -, ,
ma.nlg node which BE- wLcr no Iouf OF '4eI own NO
ou cali attention o. tue Ofand jay 90 ana 1ecL o. in
vo,stou Of matters enefa IN thtlI nel.e, i' o. we n.'e
already seen, tnn cah GUY De u'Ne "AeIo lHu o'' o
community, .uI lu no caso who're 1t Ii pe''oiA ana H.
t to be doubted that IN oa,es ko 90 those previously
m,ltI..d such rot nulfances, ana hi i,H b" hai'
au Woes Huch hy.uousy eject .he A'etn ~ onion W
a.. Grand jury w4tuesscs thcir s-tlou but 10
i,cul 90 tno language 81 'ud-a NNs ' ''.',s 70
al.l 81 n cosfr ~ o'an"g "t'' "'n' goa Iy'''
dita44ls 80 would iDFe'e, 10 '.'N -''l1 tne
expression %. 81 ni'n, u5 "st' 1',' , . In,
io conc before Tue courts 10, ''e'' J'us'on a." u
s.tu ca,os prseut oi t-lfu d. so"1 het' i'' '
Ju,uly o.. a''u.o VIA 'no o.ul.-.J C,1'' " tl i
30 Juast 1000. d"eet a" H''.-i $50" ~ 81 '-.' go,
al U l.u,.a. .sse 81 atl god ato alr.t ta ut VI
Ll int.. on 10 70 BE ra-" in' "t'ia ' ~ i' 'i'"'
pr..ona tp4eut then may nr 90 '"' "Ai ''1 ''t"
Doe rr4 ....itH.I Itlse lt u ut.n l4I.A- ia e.. u'
.au aud iu" fe."n. .or e.ey oii-' AA''.h no
o.. r.tld4r .Ioc. DuI ts.'' 'I ','. ,' "''' l',
rl.l iu.,i..A. At judicial uitr -Ad "'.i in '.a'l