Daily national Republican., 1863-11-17
reversed and .aDullod, snd III. interference. dis.

10 reversed and sanulicd and the interference dis.
solved. y th fls L
., psssuss the iavcn,aon covered by the ist, 9Th,
and sth cls1ns Of .. q. Wilson 10 substantially
difYsrsat frsn that found IN the patsat and re-
issues Of A. u. Wilson, As an Inspections Of the
models and drawings will show; and because pre-
vious ssanisvioners having determined and &C.
tuslly granted patents to l. M. Singer for what 10
severed " aid elaims, the once 10 now sstcpped
from reversing said decisions, and must abide by
them, inasmuch as the above mentioned claims
cover nothing what has been patented to ]. M.
0u01RsrI-1l- a-sris b. igs-ll,-f
.. Because the Commissioner erred IN deciding
that the evidence produced proved that A. b. Will
sons inventions, or either OF them, were made
prior to the invention Of Atkins and Felthonser.
4. The Commissioner erred in declaring an inter-
ference, since A. B. Wilson's patent is subsequent
in dale to that OF Atkins 4 Felthouser, while the
reissue claims In said A. d. Wilson's patent have
been granted since the filing OF the present appl-
cation, and that, too, without giving said J. @.
Wilson the least notice thereof whereby the office
determined, In the most solemn manner, that the
claims Of the Wilson's then pending did not inter-
fere.
6. Thatthe decision OF the Con ssioner arrived
At are not according TO law and the facts involved
but aie repusnaAt thereto, and should therefore he
reversed and annulled, the interference dissolved
and patent ordered TO issue, % prayed.
Mr.. Bradley then proceed to state that rhe pa
pers and the decision Of Justice Dunlop had gone
to the Patent Office and there were no means to
revoke them. The case was closed. II was 4
corpse and more than that, II was buried corpse
and the counsel who were invited to the foneral,
saw Il hearsed to the tomb II could not be buried.
Just 90 are the accounts at the Treasury office.
The accounting officers who exercise oftentimes a
judicial capacity when they close an account can
not revise IT, This was shown In the well-known
case OF the Bank OF Metropolis concerning the Rec
side Draft In the case OF stockton and Stokes VS..
Kendall
Mr.. Brady, with the indulgence Of the court, in.
reply, stated, In the language OF Lord Ellenbo-
rough, that "the laws were a mass Of nonsense "
II rehearing in this case could not be had because
the papers had. been sent to the Patent oface. II
| such a doctrine was sanctioned In juridical pro.
| ceedings-if successful in this court-his face
might well be shaded with deeper sadness than
that Of the gloomy attendants Of the funeral men.
| toned by the counsel for the appellees. He
thought that II WAS in legal logic, ptiiio prin.
eipii-a begging OF the question-to assume that
the case ended with this court because the chiei
Justice of the deceased Circuit Court had acted on
It and rendered decision without entering into
the merits OF the case.
The hour OF one having arrived, the case wai
postponed, since that was the hour appointed fol
the Sickles cutoff.
Yesterday the court rejected the prayers OF de-
fsndants to admit the declarations Of Cook made
since the last trial, that there was o contrAc,
with the company for the use Of the siekes cut-of
on the steamer Columbia, as set forth in the frs,
count Of the plsadings, on which the former gen
| eral verdict was rendered. .,
Messrs. Davidge and Brent took exceptions tc
the ruling; and stated that they should ask to ofe
other testimony a. to what the jury really did de
| eide by their verdict on that occasion.
Time was given counsel to write ont their bill o
exceptions, and they had them ready for presents
tion this morning.
| nppu Nesr Tulu p,,v,sU - A nnia n0n