New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1863-10-22
(uVd from rfr. (.nr,in.

70 "a Edifg. 81 TAe y ! Tribsae.
SIR: IN an article headed " Rattle for
Judgcshp. forl Play Ia Drawing The Lots. published
In I'M Tribune Of to day 1t Is stated " We learn upon
authority which be questioned that the friends
Of tao Of the spiranis for seat the bench Of the
Superior Court met lat Saturday IL oiioe
not far from tie City Hall who're the! decided by lot
the rnmmany Hall nomination.
The Judge vns draw los toe friend OF Mr.. ; Il. Gar
siu and he was accordingly nominated b. accama'on
last Monda, the subsequent subacr,icni Convention
81 Tammnny Hall.
This is serious statement, and shall receive a, riy
hands the grave consideration il merits. have no
hc,ta,on IN saying that II 1t IL true ought 20 De
defeated and moreover pledge myself that Il It eun
be- ,ubstanilatoJ. | viii "a, once withdraw from the
oauySs.
claim to have been nominated by the delegates
elected to represent the Democracy OF tue City Of New
York. and that the statement IN youf paper is al M
nit gated and atrocious iasehood.
You state that you learn What is contained IN the
article upon authority which cannot be questioned
Now respectfully demand the authority and
ask that the statement charges shall be made spc
clhc, that 1t may be specifically met and promise
forthwith TO take legal proceedings before magistrate
who shall be- Kepubhcan-that taotc shall not b. any
impuinton OF part. lusAip Dad will bring the ISSUE u
trial within - hours.
Twill examine tie " au,hory" any other wliRes,
whom she authority OF any other person will name
audcr oath ard II the allegation is pryycn repeat
viii at withdraw from the CAMPS as cand
date.
L. not this fart The article IN question treas tie
subjcc, in strong language speaking If this nriaf
III 81. .f.- ..s.., a..
IN speaking equally vlthoa, mud would ash
II the statement referred to is fabricated frva whole
cloth-ho simple production Of csnspcrated deprayit,
without a single fact TO justify III is no, the Do au
hori,y' you quote Il scoundrcl and should not tie au
thoriiy' DO branded such In The public plory tia
all may know hun; for he may again deceive others a.
hc has deceived You by equal atr.eiy You have bee
imposed upon by having been made the medium .
charging aggregation Of gross untruths and Aa'
been injured by the charge
Now we are Jointly interested IN bringing the az
thority" who has done this double wrong and who
evidently rogue TO justice. | therefore ask You /
common fairness 10 give rue the numc Of your uformai
who strikes the dark and To present the issue tia
| can meet the grave statements yon make and refa'
them In n court of justice before my fellow oEos al
called on to vote On my nomination
have stated the penalty | win submit 70 it II IA
to prove the charge IN wholesale nj detail iisehoo'
claim to have the sclfrespcct Nhch belongs Ia ma
hood, and AN incapable OF being candidate beiol
the people oh nomination obtauei 10y trckery irau
| OF chance.
You have made the assertion that my nomination VI
so obtaiued simply ask you to give me the "ppo
tunity to prove the statement also aud for tho name
thc ,uilt, author that he may receive the puniSlmc
| he deserves.
also uSA that this note be published US conspicuous