New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1863-08-13

G 0yd. Mr.. Garvin ten, i0 paherc
and elOruent strain, spoke of the scenes ne ia
Witnessed in the mel :hbo-lO0d ot The Orphan
Esy lGn duripg the wooa 81 tc not. lht'5 cill
G. ca max Il ns Llsy were lJru, wera TnnniL@, did
i've hundred mcn AID women slcaIing Every NM
tney could Gnd shouted, " "A, kill, h.i thell.'
1nose wsro the klnd OF ieliows raid Air. o.. tha'
wn.tsd to welcome JcI D-vlf ~ tue Ivy o.
New-York--those were the acondreis who would
hold up both hands 20 rec our wives ana 'hioffh
burned ND uuId the flames Of our city. SUCH were
toe unen who ask-d merry o. be Jury. IN speaking
OF tie testimony OF the witness Kelly, Mr.. ,iarvin
pronour ced his statement 10 De IA internal he, and
prcdicted that unless changed DO course ne wohu
soon Oe found IN the state Plson or on the ga!loWa'
Ia conclusion, be SAID that the Jnry had zone tier
duty molly during this tora and he hopei mat
painful IA it wac, they womb pronounce t9e Pr
oner guilty, Whatever the consequence might ue'
Hundreds OF men would yet be TIED III TINS Guy be-
tore honest Jurors; ana be hoped before We mao
another ZINE OF ire, pestence, piunder anu alarm
IN Now-fork, that all these scamPs ana rd''A!s
gouli be brought TO Justice by honest C0gr,s GnC
jnrors Willie be lad the hohOf Of having any
tmn1 to DO with the administration OF Jdsice, he
did not mean 10 let one Of the men escsps II 1t was
possible 10 convict them; and hereafter ne wOulc
tel that he had always done bis duiy against ali
men who had been guilty oi crime, lndeuenaehI OF
,,Otical considerations.
TIE RECORDERS CHARGE.
Recorder Uyims,u in His able and lucd charge to
the Jury, gave "a bret definition OF ne charg.
gainst the IrsOner and remarked, "a the Counsel
virtually admitted that there war AN unlaw iu as'
em1lage il front of The TRIBUNE Office Oh tue lJth
oil July, the only question Tor them 10 deteruins
WIS whether the persecution ma clearly established
the denlity OF the prisoner as The leader oi that
mob. lis Honor reminded the jury that u Wac easy
for witnesses make mstakes In regard 10 identity
AID time, and yet they were bound 20 take Tie eNi
dence ns II was presented 10 them. lie Recorder
coiited the testimony Of twelve witnesses iOr TIE
prosecution VINO clearly Identified the Prisoner d.
OeiuS The leader Of tnat mob, Two OF whom swOfe L.
having converted with HIN whel tue prisoner adj
ml.cd to thnt he WAS At the scene Of me us
tIrOalce the M)ndiyioi toe riot. IL sccined 20
him that there could be no doubt rGslt UPON Sue
testimony Tor the prosecution, aud If that douot ma
been rails d. It WAS created by the defense, aud II
WAS Tor the Jury To say whether the testimony adj
duced by the defense was Sufficient TO SHAKE tie case
made out by the prosecuiion IN conclusion tue IKE
eorler observed that tnls berg the last case that
would be tried this term, they would dispose oil II,
ar he supposed they disposed of every case during
tire term, without any other consideration except
that of doing justice between the prrOLer AID tie
people. What caused the riot, who Horace Greedy
was or what inE TRIBUNE was, or whether one sid-
WAS responsible for the outbreak OF the other,
u question with which neither he nor they had any
thing To do. With what ons mans pohtics
might be or might not be, they had nothing
TO DO Outside OF the Cont, III their capacity /
~ citizens, they would exercise their judgment, /
and do what thew pleased, bat when they entered
the Courtroom they laid politics aside, having be-
come mln,ters OF the law. Tee Jury was
sworn to do thcir duty and the Court was sworn
to do the same, and they should know no differ
euce between men and paitlss. lHt lRB-
USE olce had tho same night 10 protection that
Tae Hrad or The Duiy Mrs Office had, mat
Ter whether the editors OF those papers were TOR or
against tie Admins ration, for against the drait,
or tor or against one principle. livery man mecca
e, require that he shall De unler the protection OF
the las, and they were not TO he put down by the
violence Of mobs or by any unlawful act, whether
done by persons IN or ous Of office. They Were en-
titled TO speak their sentiments freely, aud II would
not do tor Courts and Jurors TO countenance any
disturbance oi tuer rights. The jury would diyest
their minds Of everything thar might b. said for or
against the prisoner on general principles. The con-
duct of rioters IA general was MOI TO be considered,
but they were simply to sny whether or not the
prisoner was eousI IN the mob on that ocea-
siou.
At the request OF the prisoners council the Court
spoke of the good character shown by tue defend
aui aud doug said that one OF tue mos. painful
whcu he had 20 perform la useharsi1g his duty
{ nis term what punishHent 10 would meet out
for oieuses against the not law committed by per
20 - who. up TO the cOmmlsslOn Oi that crime, mad
characters IL was one OF the faults
incident 70 the growing Out OF tits unlawful DIE
"a bance that men, who up 10 that time had been
aS-abiding citlze "a, led TO perpetrate crimes
which twenty -four hours before they would nave
thuddercd TO commit.
TIE lury retired TO their room NJ o'clock, AID "a
IS O.. cocS appeared IN Court, when Jhor inquired
whether the test. .louy ol Nh lia would make any
q! ilrlrtce IN iAe Recorders cAar-e. Tie Recorder
gave some instruction to the Jury. whercup1a hey
pairc1 10 their room, and al sr further absence
o. threc.qulrers Il an iouT, they brought in a YER
ult ~ guilty.
1 80 -, d = al
morning al ~ o'clock wn,n be VIII De- sentenced.