Memphis daily appeal. [volume] (Memphis, Tenn.) 1847-1886, 1863-06-25
TIMOTHY DWIGHT
Honorable JOHN TAYLOR, Esq.
REPLY OF 5oHN TAYLOR, OF CARoLuE

REPLY sF JOHN TAYLOR, OF CAROLINE.
SIR Wksthsr yosr letter was dictated by
prJsdies or eiYility, it 2srits az aekaswledg-
msHt for she purpose sfrepaying tie ons By "a
5ssYOrisE to rsmeye the ether.
Au opizisR calculated &c esrrods tba fresSsm
and happiRoss Of sur esuRtry ought, I thiRk, to
Be made a subject Of pEblic aisGussisz, By Gsr-
rendering 6Hr lsttaTs to cszlmsHtaters Esors s3o.
qasis 70 it6 examination. This spinion is lodged
in ysur objections ts ny isas. OF Singing IKE
mar1l gua.ity Of ths States nsarsr tsfathsr, ky
aa exchange Of youths fer the purpose ef edu-
cation.
Yea ssssri, fem ozDorisEee, tsat tha Viz
ginis youths hate sad desPiss yaur manners,
E9-s's, Industry aaa religion; that tho pao-
plg Of Cezneetjcut Aighly esteem the Chris
tisn religion, sad ths. thass yostks dsBpisa it
sRsirsly; shat thess people universally lave iE-
dusfry, whilst these ysaths th.ak Is the busi-
BASS Of slaves and Wrsfshas sRly aad thst shoy
considsr their Nav EEgisna csapanisus as
dssi!ats OF tslsat as well IS PreBsrty.'
Il is evident thss ysu save used Virginia
ysuths IS 5FscElam to reflect ysur own spiu-
len Of the ViFgizisns A yoR.hfal Eisa is in
capable By nstars CT uurturiRE tbs black aad
criminal passions Of malica ard hatred AGAINST
poverty, talents, morals, industry and religion :;
Prsns even to parsoa vice, it is Rsysr sa inezora-
be fee te vigtus. Uabsnding eye, ssslave5 BY
habit avaries er ambition, and bliadel BY auFs-
inc party or fanatic zesl, is thsir natural dwell
ing place, aad their oWa virulanca ssuses shem
20 aseriSe thsic s1R vices % the inneesEt objects
Of thair maleVolsacs. Such a zsel has osenly s.
ssntits fury On womsn aRd ebildrea, and can
with IS ge0d 2 csRgeionce migcoastruo the con-
duet Of bsys, aid alisEopfasslt the character Of
q State This zlisfortans has haBpsRed TO ths
VirginiaEs, amsae WhaR, 3Uriae my wkol1 Die,
psf.iou Of thas msss Of msiEaity teElrd dair
New EgFiaad freksrsgs ege-i5ea 81 thn b
yosr later Ihose whs csas eMoaE us srs up-
3sahsa'shab.s ig5m sarseiyas, because, as Wa
5s not aato taem, We aever suspect that they
hsts us.
Tao Christiaz Teligioa, Whiek ysu say IS 5s-
sFisad BY as and Esnsratsd By yen, has tang be
MS not ts make ogr faiih tie presenter Of oshsf
fsiths; net to kats those Who differ with rs in
srinisn, bscaass, thoggb is raJ please "a am
hiGeEs or rapaeisEE Hierarchy, it viii net please
Gs5; and nol to worship ruch hierarchy in
stead Of tAa Dsity. ia place OF this erasl, ma
lieisus AID impieRs temper, or religions sacts
rnirgls ana warshis IN harmony, ana tha state
sbarnds with Caristisn ministers, Wksgs rsli-
gisn IS not banishea By iaisrmsddLiag with civil
gavsrnment. These defensive 0bSsrvatisss are
not intended 10 izsiagals that the people sf New
Enrlsn5 ara deficient ia a. oquivalsns rdspaet
Ial t4s SA-tls--'-A -o-ih i "'l- ---~-A ~s---A-Aa
brethres.
"Thas we are induced By wealth sad idIansss
to hata year industry aud severity" bsizg
morally iacsrrect, is szIy an evidences Of very
s.rosg prsiadies. What m9ralist las heratof0rs
made idlaaess the cause of wealth and industry
flo caase Of PsvartYl When ne as9uss epin-
ions fron bTeaking the ligaasnts between eaaso
and effect, they must be erroReous.
Parhaps you msy think tkat the partial culi
vstion Of Virgins BY slaves viii reconcile thase
esarYadieGoss. Bat al sesRomists have agreed
thas saea is the lssst Preata5la mode of agricul-
tHrs. If She tsgm slEFery was Prsl8od ini8 SER
vics SIS az additional reProaeh 70 us we aaswsE
that ne regret, Whilst We are uHa5lo ts remady
"a evil forced VBon Us against sur wiz, by a.
biuery power, and that to shaw tho ssssrily Of
this regret By our enmity 70 ths syziaH of HER
sehy patronage and public diet, ioi aakins