New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1862-03-11
.vns In me offensive passage 81 the speech to in.
Mssltim to make tia! admission. However, the
,igx honorable bsropet said he would adhere to his
ianousge in its entirety. ben ssked him TO refer

Issssge in its entirety. 1 hen asked him to refer
me 10 y flieUd. ILaushter.l He sid must write
70 bin on tie sgbect, ard did, and if the House
S;ll allow me will give the letter: "My dear Sir
Robert: As the en- lana'icn given by you 10 me re-
rardipg the words made use "f by you toward me
NDonOghue last riot' ia the House is not saiisioe-
tor, and as the mailer cannot possibly remain IN lt
nrs..ut position, request yon at once to refer
me 30 y friend. About 0 clock on saturday even
inc received jeier from tbe righi honorable Dofo-
nj which is very short and sweeI laughter, stating
a.. hs had referred 10 TO q hlcnd. natural
IL supposed tbat wonld have been given
the name; bul 10 nome was mem
t;|oed. That letter though written ri y oelock,
dd not recri:e until lafs at plgh Last might GOT
srotler letter from t'e Ii-ht honorable baIone
grstipc what the hous cs already beard ths' be re-
ss-rsa me to the noble ofd al tire tead o. the Gov
.rpmeut laughter The issuos viii allow NE 90
cav hat there is 10 o,e believe, in le house who
yoUli 50 readily respond 20 anything the Kind rs
che noble lord. Laughter. The letter wac 90 the
following effect: " In Consequence Of cCmniuui-
cation received fr0n Lord Paimertuu very ea'ly
or SATURDAY on S-rlay moruing I referred h.
letter you addressed TO tn. noble viscount, md
Fave received reply from che note viscOunt Ge-
.,riog aie 10 refer you 20 blm" Laughter l dld
ulyselt the honor OF wMting upon Lord Palmers,on
Nj, morning. early and stated 70 him that sir X.
Pol had referred Lin; that came for al eN la
ration of the words Gde of by ne honorable bs-
on,t on Friday night N debate, and that thought ne
would AGREE wit3 NE that such Ords ought not ~
b. passed over. TIE obie lord told what the
yples of tie houee wete and said, 90 Oh nv lOrd,
If YOU take this up ccialiy, IL L. no use NY taking
or voar time sny further Laughter rinolug
o., the whole matter hid been taken mp officially,
AID shat IN fact 1t We reported 10 yOr, Sir, before
deemed Il necessary 10 w npon The night honorable
b.rOnct telt mys u lilced IN very painful posi-
ton. did 0hst | considered my duty toward my
frleud. Hear, hear i had TO ynaictie his honor,
and went about IL IN the only Way understood.
Daulhter. The honor OF my honorable iIienc the
memOe for Tippera,y Was PLACED iu u,y bands. il
Is Row handed TO cu, Sir and the uo,le lord -
tie head Of the Treasury, and l hope You vii pre-
eryc It.. Hear hear.
fie Speeker-T,c honorable and gallan, member
e - erick, speaking behalf Of tho honorable
lnelLcr fr giouertry, has received FIJI latitude,
snd must now rou' "l' TO the HoUse ibli II wouil
no, De proper FOR e cuse 20 folio" 20 she extent
b. hes gone, bccau.e Of the rule Of tie House
&C. if exception lie tlcn TO ANY words spoken IN de-
bate il must be taxi - once ana ~ on the spot, /
and shat 10 wOrcs ~ cone under discussion 10
which such exceptiu ls not been "a" a, aud Wucd
have nos been wn,'cn down ny 90 Clerk at iic /
,sble. The impor, nee and value OF chat rule is
illnsirsfed iu the present. csse. Tie honorable sud
Gallant aertlelsn has nUt produced ID exact wOros
Gsed on tbe occasion. II Is, therefore, my duty 10
inform the boUss that j. IL contrary O TIC rules OF
The Honse 20 proceed TO Discus tie words which |
passed on Friday eve i1g. HE time for discussing
those words has gone by. Now, a breach Of puNi-
iegs has been brought under tue notice Of the House
and it again my duty 20 call upon the honorable
member fOr TpperEry 70 express hls regret Tor hav
ting committed that breach OF privilege which mutt
observe TO him is an otense owe 6 the House, and
% give en- assurance 10 the uoue that the matter
shall not proceed any further Hear, Lear.
The 0'Douoghue-Sir, hore it ia unnecessary
sor 10 SAY that j regFe deeply doing anything 20
violate in any way tie privileges Of thir House.
Hear, hear. / my say inst am almost the last
person in the House to 90 y'hing to wound the
suscepubilities OF any honorable member. Hear,
hear. hope, however the House Will accord TO
ne for momen, that consideration which II lnva.
riajy accords to those who have Terscnal explaDa-
lions 10 make. AaviDg received tile afternoon al
ini.ms len from the noble lord at re head Of the
Government that he deemed it lie duty 10 make, this
evening, q statement 10 refe'erCe TO myself, have
sccordugly attended n my place, aud az TOOK II for
granted that the ststement OF The noble lord would
refer TO what took plce Friday ni,i, oAde copy
Of the words USED b. the rightbOnoib. baronei the
chief secretary 70 tie Loid Li-utenant Of l,elsnd,
which ] considered ler,onuly of.o'i9e. Ia
rising 70 offer few words Of explanation, aru sure
do Dot enormously estimate tie character OF this /
House, when expect from the House ali tie more |
consideration from the fact that the right hon. gentle
Insn did Eli in his pCwer TO txc,e ITejndco against
xne. Perhaps the House will permit ne u read tho
words which | considered offensive Allucing to
lhe alleged prosperity IF Ireland, the night hoa.
gentleman eaid: "Of The Justice VI that opinion, no
more remarkable proof can be adduced than lhat
which took place ibe otl er Day, when there was
Danger Of rupture Win AMsrlct, ahu iIcidnu "''
6led with Anne lean en- ssS,res WHO trleG TO mise
81 in; of d;sloyalty. 4 meeting was held al Tie
Rotupda, at which q few manlkln trllt"r- sought 10
iDisate the eabhage-Ca den traitors Of 1913; but
an GLAD 10 say that they met with no responfe-'nat
shefe was no one 10 follow AID iba. Tiers was not
n single man OF resi- ectaOi!iiy who answered the
sruesl" / felt that that language wa. per,onliy
offensive 10 ne and I thought 1 could n0i
", il psss. ~, that tue night bonorabls [
barouet had come down 10 ire house, having
made 10 bis mind 20 dispArage nv social
position. | do lot ach any LnporSnte 10 hsser-
lions or insnuatiODs made IN tie excitement oi de-
bate or 10 TIE heat OF argument Great al ov snoes
ere to be made for speakers under tuch circumstance;
bur am quite prepared 10 do the rehi hon. Oaronet
she iug ice Of sayD tn lie speee es bear tic marks
O. careful preparation. He 1esniDg on Fnday ilgnt
xsa, quite manifest because his observation drew all
che e. &c Of tie house 0p0n me. Hear, heaf.I what
VIZ 20 dot Could submit 10 tnCh an in utat Oh
TO such aD affout, wih0ut ioifelting my claim even
20 associate with honorable meD, ana without bring
ing disgrace on the DRY Of hose who ehouof an
boand 90 cherish, and without, may say, ensihag
legacy Of shame on hoe who come afieI IRE What \
course wss 10 take am perfectly ware that the
sncieut mode Of .rbiyrslneut has fallen INTO die
IRE, but am bkewise aware tbas those unseemly /
uanners which rendered il slmvst Necessary have |
also disappeared. lIi ear besr Whist, theU, did /
doi consulted ny honorable and gallant friend /
che member for Limerick, ia whOie hands felt 10y /
honor was perfectly sae, and upon whose Judgment, /
4Aured as s by the Xpere1ce acquired IN the most
honorable Of professions could implicitly rely. / /
sonsuiied with my honorable friend, and he agreed
with me that wac entitled not only 10 expect an
exclamation from the night honorable gentleman, but
Aha, was oouud 10 demand, aud il possible 10 Oh
taip su explanation. Well Strive did all we could /
20 obtain an explanation am cure the House will
agree With inc thai theio wac nothing bullying IN
d. tone we adopted. Well, We failed TO OBJ
s,,n l.. and If 4 am forced TO come 70 the