New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1862-10-17
Jaw INTELLIGENCE.
COURT Oh OYER AND rERMINER-ocr. is--Sefor.
TuE Nh MonOEN cAsE--sEyksrn nAY.


insisncc 10 subs the promised statements therein
aud tho deceased the pasued Every word the
learned counsel had put In the mouth OF he deceased
should put in the heart OF tho prisoner The evil
deuoe OF s deces-ds pefpg In visiting accused not
stropg. bot, the contrary, very weak.
Nh Hal then showed tho amount OF strategy 10 which To-
males would sometimes resort to overcome tao obstacles
which euyronsd them no would not East any fmputa'
ons the The probability was that the anxiety for
marriage and excitement prfoners part and not de-
cd for there was no man, however prePosesus Du,
would DO ered by the mot notorious os,a,ns t1 ~
deceased entirely ncoDsistent WIN TACT. OIL the ca1
through, The pr0babiis, that she took an oa, on
tho decsOgue that thc was earnest and t9a me should o
wife should have this Nh Hall suppose
20 be Ss %'i1 Of Sm %S,a e and
"oaih " are almost Synonymous words. r.f
hsriisse in the Roman Catholic Church was Sacrament,
snd he wished In all the seci There were bad
Catholics ana good Catholics there were sood Prot.ans
add very bad Protetau- bot the Catholic g Ia the
be the 5acrencut her church lie then quoted the in.
ace the Colleen Dawn. and her yielding OF lie er
bo would part with her marriage nes In the present case
10 reason given for marriage. The secret wss
strange secret fog on Tho par, Of The accused she toa
everybody she this mana WIFE Our city was ui oil
claiming TO be The wife OF and c, going over the
alphabet sev.r,l times
snd thousands OF husbands and wives living apart
sud Ai each other under tbr plea OF hom!chl insanity.
tins plea prevail in the u very strange that
dlpnce certificate Of mariage procured for ,uIey 10
orges the house Ia which she was married IL the
,ccused hsd come hin the DisiricAtorDoy at the tine
and related the lpead
he would have thought wonh while locking after Aud al
tho i.h he had hang out bic sbngs ao.
ney Tor dstresed wives Yet there were plenty olawyes
who could have made oJ avery FAIR Gaze TO have presented
qho accused disappointed ia tho desires OF her s, love-
she would et have his name, and therefore took
he sms Of Real II her name bad been ssned ~ Mary
Real to tho letter torn very that decsase Te
secuted by this sboud ined atey have torn It or
md h We ali, IDLY strange that this shond have been
vftt.n IN month that accused said oit
Know Mr. il.alp Mr HAL res,wed her letters Real to
proy- The feeling cf Jotrg and r,ven rne.c e.ers he
:
the prosecution 50 mncl for that branch % Abe defense
n, would refer u The ohrf section Of deenss n.sniy
Mr.. Hall read rom the American journal on Insanity
n.s,iol should rel whether n cle,d
W.. ab 10 h between r:ht and wron a. The time
Mr. lHil said ~es wall, or 70 o. DO
etisr cSiBx ont spology ny up 70 the mouth
captnred biussif ike we-sdvfed Rebel backed ont Tho
.rs .. question be considered Is there nloye"
M llal said be la the way. tor Do scsntly
of AD1.0uist who wished for the ,1u Of S4u;h
.ner Lrpgh,eL In regard 10 Pa card Mr. Hall said he
nm biz icnd hsd iaiimsed yc.sday except that ne dd
opoe act ., Co'nmissioneT for two or three years
Dr. Jsnrs-Apponiei by ,hs Government
Mr Hell ssij yes. llo State Prison Ifrecoy, who
sne" hut tle Of lGnacy COMPARED with tssse who are
M Hall then showed that II srqu,l in Fussud was
siscn e pry the less guilty Of homicide but Only
aid lesser sradcs Of crime The in tho sanch,
together wiki Judge Ceke. dissenting opinion show
a. desffos a tho Will Mr Hall showed sliarity the
a. bar and tie instances he had given to eaCsh guilt
Th- seton Of prisoner IN requesting dece,d to speak
tie igue,i' OF c,ouay. numbering him ard thea comps
~ ~ an corena true vdinsniy sricf never u,cep, Is
the question Of water 1t b Desaond' tas done 10
reisD The minds Of the snsnih. the tea taken to
her iof To act and - fr sucd Why women rover
committed suie!de By hesfm' they nsihc.iToy shrink from
Tic following Is an additional pon, FOR the proireuiou,
laughter tho taird degree II they md The evidence
q tie ed In he beat Il gs''on and without arH to
m clus,d h, Death OF iceelby me di'charr the pistol
With which sh- expressly provided herself
Inc judge delivered the olosiag ch,rss TO The rry;
1871 June Of tho Pe,s; ysaJ Peter C. Rcac iag - h
sath by violence Ninety. y beis hot ~ .ol. Tie
,Isad Jay. b. iusu the hands hsrs,d
iSD.r vao gave her Iame ~ GeEy Rod. A lnic
rr written srcnsaiion Of rers-ns OF cn
u on charge prevented and preerd 70 Grind Jury fhey
have chlfgrd tibet Is dlne oitia lco,us desigu Jag j.
ntsDded to eject bic dsaih snd 'h,; act who pl
'a,tS lee thrown upon he prs.~en,lon he onns OF
s b, ex sv'drsse the iruh o. the contained
In tho indictment Tue poseeoion thsn, gentlemen, must
4 bii he death Of Peter Real
= IRA, iis death b. vo' nee a. Tie Lsaa 81
IA, Il W. done through preu.dts.ed Do ign to eaee.
tcsi o.Ls. woIl tia. she l'-uaci % uinc5rr
him Unc lbs prosecution las adj Gel Dcs ats
tary eyijaco Of sAe srth OF 'ese PoPouou' ias.
oar slItute de6Des murder be biniag human
'crg ~ pIcned'fed oogn, Wildcat no rufloriiy Ct
iw by poison. shooting. ssbDins any other
my oh.r nannor and which !, 10, usoslaasheg e,ct
,h. jusnaabe homicide. IL IA committed n OF less
The hr' one only has any reference 20 hi
fhsi l.. "h'n L & pefpetaied from lnodi'sod des 20
go c,ah o, re t'os hled CT o. say hgaln being
The esl,n's h.. :ami,',5 iha' Yea q dsaa 81
rlsiol ia tie hands Of the accused. tA,y dcl3.
]. Thai "as done WIN p.euieci, .'l.n- n,
.rcu.,d ho1 Mt lie held ToiVonbe LOT Aes bcosar
2 condition q! her ruud such tns. dsy
le Incapable o. distiDsuhius nshI from snd
n i1ual being Ia othty ..ords, Insane.
81 lao knds Of Hsspity--a permanent, 20 al and
NJ ie cfcovclabr - sc' look' manner aud
eu iIlpNls!gs lnaf fpFfFfs
rosr lnabe or every c-terusd iunary snd The other IN
ns on ban eula su6c ana not ai sys blo uni... &C.
e tnd by iece vllegs .mpnlslye saniiy rcualk be
,,nce Of t. latter has recently come under my
a., of celebrated Londpn phy stefan, whose VITO
pugh nted by every naurs mat ealih could produce
nos N the iolpt op OF stoang every article thgt
8 Of 10 able nt'ur rdle, o.. iisue value Her
n.,uty ipt subject as been twicr cstablihd think
IL homicilpl insanity murder 4, committed without sy
motive Whatever strictly deserving ne nome. or 8, MOS.
' "a one totally nsdenus rodues tire Get g. s.rc mind
% is other maud murder 10 never srlninaly niiied
without lotHe adequate to Tie p.rpo.e "a tAe Mind
hit }, .otutsd by H. aid iih TsieIeus a. she victim In
n DO motive may be thrl, promotion o.tion,
te 90 avoid d',e'iion n ds-ce, or it may be ovengc
" ga criminal murder i aways means aeconI thing
sefe ,e.4,n otJse aud j, orn accompanied via
DArl eilu a., NAsIens Win the homcld iugnun.srsc.
uurI,r Is BE oly otjcC, IA view snd l. sccsmps
,d snh afy olhs iupfbrcf &C.. Tho tl.ls ays plins
zoe tLe .r'euiion Of liz ss'isnsi Nwe. u cc All
t.c eonifay, a. 80 sci I.r, tonsu.ts
none ~ o crhycIioiscs %. eFnie u Re usually pelpc-
g'rd sudden, With Ne ncue't objects al hand, IA thu
prsenoo .. rutc, ilhoa ny .aol TO escape any
dr,fs D avoid dt.ac lu llt L. l ought 10 be- shown 20
So uo.h ris. 90 sat 10 have tyAscd ifeIi ia
ini iult.noc cn o. hc q human
nc,rf ~ vo.Ly coaA,gt'i m.ra Who might, ~ bong
Breeding zeal in. slrl " ou, work ~ perverted
n f az 81 haired ak.at n 4.al tis .d.r Ter firLt
ocr lt uiglt rot Ac 80 d,nt'd 20 tie existence
rcrs l.iIH. at Ar bod lv.t's,a Irt At usit lufs
.,rstrr ten. and they uili ir.is on his mind 3,
a. pIoiItc rlte. bat s.i lie wound be Aceoruista tn
Auft4r tnhHnas ~ totally etsssA aslis oolcei,s
Of eson who nisl" mo- b. secorniaee 10 - Akor aud
jet loo p.ueciiy accountable TO hlan t-lbsasls III.
slrrrs a. naiy 10 rot r.ilrlly slutad Ia a.pl IA.
onnai' - I'e's % M .tiiy "A,h rri"'es On re-
.la. slDi a. h,m Ddnri tnl y ousLt .tarf - lo al
uIffa ir'rt RI, rH'i if u sluHu t.it those p4o
reees ti,l la such violence a, 90 1hul's he ine-c
o'i.i ODE 10 auJ Iedsrt impossible i,f tio rany To %,