Richmond enquirer. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1815-1867, 1862-01-24

in tna ra7 oi sai=.e...
&om, | sm in fa=cr c: tie views :11Ttssst
~ tns ge1;;sasa from 4 !sasts Mess
! STUART ed j nssaS.) nu ~ favor G
having special Court OF App:ait; fDc rfoc:s
CASES, out das &c tiist c1urs t. b CONSTITUTED
rs il nas bsan n tirG5 past. md nat h:.s hcer
whr1e.s: sn li,aa Of the Si2"enis C2rr
vera disqualified FROM dccicirg 6ny osse. h;
L Slsla:rre had the power 10 orcaa |: specia
Coars Of Appeals 10 sct for ibe;n. Ny ohio
Is 10 preyen, tho creation By the G1r"T4 A.
soDbly Of pew and UNNECESSARY chi:o?s.
propose 70 p,r ne Jliyrs Of lae 3aP'em ard
| Circui: C,urts li62ral gs'ar;o5 sai wE;ie
d. so shall rcql'rs OF them tia. ,tey shall
| perform their d,:ies. Why. sir, how has .hi.
bssn composedH lIa: it no. always been coin.
posed Of toe judges Vi iss CiTcut Courts?
| dc not desire to d,;s:n the ConrsnIioa
further than merely To submit ;a:s proposition
!oT their consideration.
Ar. pEIoG There are two II jdes 81 c1nsti
Iu:!ng the Special Our: Of Appeals adcr the
Law az il now standI. F:rs', Z special cur.
o; sppe.is c5Dp5sed in part Of judges Of :he
court oi appssls sad crcu:t jnd;ss. That waa
= aass vixen so'u- .: ice I!,cs Of th" court
80: ae.-s A:'ce;.sa. s.s,l i 34i6 .nroy
D: ,ac,u to c)ns!;a c qrcruu were Ijrad IL.
competent TO Sit upon the hearing Of anJ caso,
fn this state OF things they call il tho aid OF
tTo or more circuit judges. 50 as to oonst!:up
e court Of i7s-part Of the judges of tho cour.
OF appesls and part of tho c.rcu': cour: jujs3s.
Ar. HASNosD Il will modify my acipa3-
msnt 80 ~ TO make it resd. "i,r!1 ID cf circuit
oeurt idgcs acd JUICES CT tao coari Q! ap.
pesls-"
Ar. PlIcz. THAT wonid MT do E=rs,c.
fors thsrs hGye been tpo c,aria Of Ep3eDl in
sc=al0a =: thu sams tima-tha suoreros cour;
ard .ao specisl oour. Of sppc.is, composed of
H7a cireu: j,jgra. sad 10 .nst way tne husi-
as: vas aons. E:cn cour. did e. ipucL bu-
siEe's without tie o:hsr as ii only one ~ss ia
sessi2r. My il you adopt the smsEdment
proposed By the geatleEl ,n from, Marion, (M7
uArX,So) You destroy ths court Of appeals,
aud you ,usse ihe special court consist entirely
Of circuit rauTt idgas. NV, | npprchsnd
there :s TO peocssiy CT appointing iiycs
spNcn(y rs special court :d.cs. :hiLk ;i!.;
tic Legislature viii exercise T;s2 d,3c:e:!3:i
IN i!o: appointing persons who'ar: 10: .igr:
10 constitute this special curt g! 4.n@aa.
II. SGcAxr.-t sm SURE il T q Joa the pur
plsa Of The ,thG,i!.ea ;, au'n;T1: siT ;E!T:;
ike II. has econ ind ~ the gentleman
from Nuiou-
D; rcf.rarc. 10 tue CLAUSE IN tbs Coa=t:tu.
lion AZ K 70 = cE:sta, nc :2.d, ta.i: Zee H.
3iisti :.7:sr ah:li Ga ve.!sd in + su?I.:ns
cur; :: p2:s:., .c The o::aa;t o,ut;s and ID:
i;a. aY;2f IN II, a3nHiY aGG corporation
yagr!e, in he ,sGlcc3 DI tta Jesnc, and II ih5
us::iai-a,=s :.Iu r;as hnicnS 80 G1T.ora.2
t.,,-
i.ui5 sr3:,ai a-uci:i tf g! y al, ia clcI:st ot
a1; less ih"a three H97 iuore ;hsn Rss ind ie'.
10 r. ali; caeea thai mEy 5s CT E!;I d;,.lat I!
Ii Sup-ru. court" 81
Nv, in order to caTiztc .i,s OF :c:!on or tbH
,sa!!rInl2, ] viii ,227s Is III AN :n3meaI -
.s.ss .f;ret by n'ul, tl= ioi:o o.ils, 70 =2ms IN
at the 7oin: NJ wtc1 hc pTn91se1 20 insert his
.lc=adnenl nsui:!v, =f!sr the vord ''ar2eal,'
TIC s,X,a ItGe, formed Of the judges oi ihs
-lp:gIa: o5n.i Of appeals, spd ~ ia ci!ci:
courE, a. .ny Z: thril
IL. HArS9yD.-I Icce2: .aat s:n:nc::sa: IL
lieu d ~ cGn.
The auYa irgaa! Ss5 thea "a ppsad.
ifr WocDs.-l OBJ eTva upon c;T1.ni o51I-.
p:S;s Il ol :eis section aad fJf:nc. s'elions,
thgre is tcg sTi.; ilT -rsnc-, - WHICH JasiEs
70 call Il. es.r,.s:oa. IL to- E.,1.sa.;::1-
will -sa,: n: s:c:ion from tho 1,l ;lcas;i
tu!i'n - peat cut the d'h.rencc:
"l2 S,.c;a! Courts Of A9pe,!I 20 consist OF
10! les lhan .!:rsc no- n5rs G;a judges ray
40 iai :osi Of n. judges oI ifa SoPreeis Cour;
of Acsoti: I'D 81 .lc Circuit C5urt5, c: :ay
u torn, 10 :r;- any tiss1 fs;l7n!cS O. tt:a
i1csais ci ;i:e r:Is q. Curt ~ Ap2oais s!sen
he Ji1 Iss :n?rcp: Case % hoii :tls!r n1is g;
.. 10 trv .nT e..cs which ,nly 10 oa tna d>:k
e:S Of tho su2salio CJnTs 0! A2p:al; cst2n-
,.i; d by -. CONSTITUTION, in rsapec: to which
! IL; 't!tr 0f tn= J@d so ui siid Cou-. nay De
- sf II IS 20 maize i! improper for iAem 10
:i: en- iils hestnS lhaFcof."
TIE Grst se;ten G? tee 6.E .rtici: 10 .h- re
Dor; CT Ice Committee, reads:
:.The Judicial powe- shall D, gca:ed in 4. su
prcme Cur: 9! Aepeas iu ths Circuit CoD.;s,
.nd ihc jijse2 ;.,'eCi, i'll ihe cr%a;y cn1 O.:
1oretion court, IA the jg5'icas o. me p:scs
and in the mrg:stra'oG cho MAJ 0e!cpG TO
coroor1;r h-d.rs. TIE General Assembly
nay slSu Constitute special Courts 0: Appeal,
10 oons's: o! set les; than tETeo :07 :co:e IAs1
Ave ID ;es, 10 t-y .ay ca:ea :5G; 0iaT CO on
;he do, lut Of IT,? Suo:ems Gau;! oi App ?a!a, IL
respect 10 which = rif;orit: nf :l.G jllgts OF
that Court RAY &c 80 siu.tea es 10 mike it
improper iar .lsm to Sit I'd the .'ra! ing :nercoE
ard aso 20 ~ any Gases Oh the said cnehe.
shich cancot o;L.r:ica o, iispised ct with
convonieGl d,sua ct.
Mr. TotD i propose t, Strike cut aAor
tbs syri "canes," ia ;ag eleventh. line Lte
words "tnas rnay be-" Dad lrseT: tue ~3rd
".o1,r 81, mt ih5t par; Ct i:'r se::'o2 u! tbs
alae adr4n, viii read ''The G:he!a! A:scutiy
G.ny sis, oonssitu;" SPECIAL Courts OF Apfsa'.
to oonsis. OF not lcss Lhea 'hfce nor ii cTo Il Sd
f7. judges, t, Try any cases nU% OF Inc dlcket
Of the Su,rsIo Court OF ApPe=ls," &'.
vfr lie auisI G..eI.: for Ito purpose cf
preventing tic peru.ntnt establishments OF
s7cGn3 Corr: oi Appeals. Cart; u:cerEiaR6
,ls reason vty no should ...c7a in he E2:!si
tu.iGn one Supreme Court q Appeals 80: the
:ral 9! sll important c6:ts re;tncd 60 It, nEd
y; ;hc ezne tiua autEorizs the Lrsis!a;ur2 &c
.;s,a tlish 5:5idis ]; II Court Of t9ual aL6 CO.,
ren.rl jurisdiction. and suthoe &c Ire Court
Of ppc: Il 70 ..ansitr to It I'll suea csses IS i;
rnas ,n:nk pIoD:r ~iisnr7ev ;Gat Co:rt calir o.
disuC.e ut ,hr,n Eith cc"ctnit!t 4 sgs'ct-
Tha nrc;ssity of that rc;=f nG", ii. ;hs
p.eaeut sc:umul.tior ef business, ,nay make
1t raas soaab:J hat, I'D sh3r; time, oc G7sa for
Series Gf Jcara, such Epeclsl Court sh)aid
have such cor c.rI1nt i!,sc:ctior; b.: c;nnot
understand tn: necessity o. prGrrielJ Ct ca--
l;GuiHs and prCvidirg III tnc Constitution !ha'
That Gcu,t MAJ 10 cppiir pel fer Ill futurs
tine.
Think it ia q more Importance that c,sas
should DO pr3np,lg decided. 'hsu h.; ne!
shcuid be aiws,s decided exactly 1:sc. !
nsyc 10 dcubt list Tie occunuiaIi9H oi tusi.
scgs in tha curt CT aYp.ais h:a otca csu: cd
Ia gest degree ty re siueire:s Of the
amount necessary TO S.ve it ju:i:4lc;:on. Il
wouid be better @ pre7!ce in subsequent
part Of his ssetioa ltss lever cassa sioulc
Hnd Il cir vsy into 'fs ecurt cf sIrcals, Than
10 tud up ll,E St csEd ccur, Of appeal. wi:ch
will have just ~ much au:ieIity, sid Nhc:e
iurifGic,ion will be ezsc;ly COT Ico7rtLt y: il
ltrt OF tie court # ,uTsea!s- 1t wor'd BE-
better 20 liu:t ii;c prut her II csscs btt would
hereafter knd ,htir Hay into tbst ccurt. iot