The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1862-07-19
Reply of the Minority.
gfuh isGsu - tie t1EasLD v yestefj'sy.I
Reply OF air. Maynard.


Eo,sR ~ KEfRE>srrsrI,Es, Jliy ie 1872
SiR--rle magnitude srl..ty al the ptoplsst.on
srbntisd hy !oq TO felrese"tatives rom the s,4
ste,y Il opaion. You viii not, therefore be sGf,,sei
that have not beea aos 10 c3ucni IN with tns
rty Of HEM THIS - attributable oss cly 70 the tact
that tny ~tc IL not border state. properly - ~
taat ny i'nmedia,s constituents mol yet
III a,iaa from tie hosiisa Of Tho rebeil9n rss
fsat - pm seal Obs the way my nos $40
Utg TO tbsr . nsiaeEstion ths or any other prppos
Il oosne t. pnht,cai tian cs ecally such ia ms
Case w5u.d require chang ~ ihs organic law y tue
-tAle
But do no, infer ina, am insensib!c your sppea
You surrounded with difficulties Ia greater
than havs embarrassed or your predecessors. You
neei the support " every Anne &c n citized, and
ought IL have IL active alo and nest. Tbs
every uuion 70 arc you il preserving the UAion
thp daty ~ Tho time. Differences 10 policy anu
rethods mus; be subo diaatsi ~ The purpose
IL looking for the causes o. ths rebellion. II Is natural
that each and each party should aserb litts
baine poss 10 itse and u much possible
opponent section aud sarty. oasiby you AID might
Asrss com. arson Of yiews Thai tiiers
should be difference OF opinion to the Of
conducting cur inAy operations and the best men 10
lead our armies, Is egNiy natural Contests snch
9sstions weaken ourselves and strengthen enemies
they are unproitahc AMI possibly unpairi7tic. sone
bocy mus, yield; y We wass our strength in oon.
tempt bic ST. ggle amongst curse veg.
You Appeal IT, the uyal men o. the slave States
Tie SACRIFICES they have ALREADY made aid The
they have old rsf give the bcsl that the
peal viii not n.yo been made in He WHO
really is all bus iIatsfk int ss AMI foregu
cherished and opinions for the 81
VI his country although b. may have peril
lie the battle field IN her defence, Is hut half "a
not Among the loyal people thas represent
half patriots
Already the .sosllon has cost much, even to our
rnd.ing conlet mead be, to give up the rest
10 suppress We have rto,dby you from the begin.
Mag u ths struggle and stand BY you God
willing, till he ed os IL.
did not vte for the resolution to which you al do
solely fr tie that, a. the time absent tie
capita Of my own Ssats. II Is right.
Should any II the slave States think proper 70 terminate
that institution az ssvera vi them. understand. a;
least o: their citizens propose Justice and gene
comfy require that the country should nte pose
10 ad u in lessenng the BURDEN public ani pr
csoned b! 30 radical change 10 Us iausI W.
relations.
will not now speculate upon the effect, a. hme or
abroad, Of the adoption o! your policy Inquire
action VI the rebel saders h ree1 -omtaiig VI tue
kind imp. tant. Your whole administrator gives tho
highest assurance that you are mevei Gu rom
dcsI u sae all men everywhere made lree, from
ar higher desire " preserve frse instutcns n The
bseh Of men Already free not 10 make Il free en
but 10 prevent freemen from being made sayes not 10
dcstoy an Institution when portion u only
sider bad, but 10 institutions which AL alike
consider good am satisfied you you'd not FROM
any & yoar fellow citizens sacrifice not In yolf u dg
ment. i'm sgatiyely required D. The SAFETY of ihs
country.
This is the spirit q your appeal. and respond 70 ~
the same spirt
Az very respectfully, your sbedien, servant,
HORACE MAYNARD.
- 49,