New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1862-03-10


apdy there l. d6nger there hazard OF colis,n ~
hssa the iacouveneneei ' rot only ,ba. which have ny,
tentej TO you ~ trsyelI up and down but to
with Drrchauoise Desd not remind you bore Ce,,lssa
OF ihe Iomiee, hs Brcedeay rom the Battery 20 IT,
square rapidly becoming the street for ss onos
tho io"er pe0 oi II has already becsms 9h4 snon.,
goods daily rscsi ard sold Is enormous Nueh -.
eccuie IN receiving those goods shall De tod H.. 80
goods ker in the aide street, sud that good mar Wy
eksn ~ th. back q, rssr Of he stores Ie i, ~ 70
awe t, this supp al the force serves; y. no
hs sense. wa s-ser tbai "hrie thee block v ,a.,
,0res between street ard sIsst abl book an
stores or other building. IN the rear they sss goods iao ~
corner stores or tho de streets ana carry item through ~
hole ten OF these stoges = gee them 20 the middle sor.
at not ont Of ten of the stores Broadway sss
leh goods etler 10 the rear o. TIE store ts IA.
street,. When good. up BroafNay, they stop IN ~.
Of the stores for which they destined If the TAI Of H.
cart be .Jrned the sidewalk part OF The horses VIII
tbe tidck. The Il even with "a. -
ens method Of travel that city oroioaDcs has been psI
street that can the tail Of hi. 10 The sidsrs
Mr.. JRAci-Is that prohibited by ordinance uoys
| Mr.. WILLIANs-l am 80 informed. The stree, IA AZ
narrow thai l. Is necessary to take the goods from the "a. -
The cart The long ssoPpngs OF csr for the pppose 4 50 IN
oaoiDg would be an insurnountsbe impsds- the s,oo
rhaton OF the street to the purpose demanded by he
promoters ofhis bill greet would De the not
OILY to tho Themselves bu. to the Whale trsyeas CON-
muuity.
sixtbaysnns cars which avsnus /. 10 feet wide b,ss,
building and buitng leaving % feet bttween cub,tons AID
cuo,one that You come upon the street .as
his cart You compelled OF places stop yoar e
until the l. unloaded-that ' " i be teri ed With tbs tai
tie sidewalk aud viii, coacsfts |: inevitable 20 w.
ia sIte of city ordnance though the ordnance hare
referred applies 0ny TO Broadway. because not rse
clble 90 unload in other way aai necessity kaovs
This is exceedingly iucouveIieD. upon that rous H.
though You not often troubled IN this way on sixth aTe1s
the street 4, wide But Ia Bfosdw. where this
of goods TO be carried up AID down every
in the yesr aud caF.s have to o over tier ss
(which takes them tle lorser this fact ~I be s to .hs
ne az no ipuorence we axe laboria ias1 via rdo o.
wslk as best We can But there are ehs Of c,,sDswhs
are not destitute ,swho have caIdlgea to tide snl
vs N zht 10 ride iu them Your bill proslces nde.
ni,y to on5u, who may be driven OF the street BY
the Of this bill But cudrFe OF carriages VII
low them el.ol They have the right. TheS tie
pubic-tbey upon the public highway. You eer4 y
viii drive them off you pass this Till; you certainly Ill
resent broadway from beng place where people q
carriages who should be unwilling or aoeoe 70 - on loot
should be unwilling OF unable to WAX RON 'he cars u
Mr.. ASDREws-We got up Central Park for
Mr. Wl1rrAxs-But, gentlemen, there il moral
Question involved IN this inquiry There question ofdgx
cor ec,ed wiki IT, BY wha. moral ight Va" sHe Lsssefs
Of the s,ae Of NewYoIk ,sy 70 wac bia paid Us
20. lie earnings Of lifetime lhefebst they VA pas
c. tLa will deyeeise hs properly without Pioy'dicz LIN
wish coBpelsaion thcri3rI IL because We masse 'shn
s.se. not one whom have ever spent shilling upoa
ia, ,re. Who have Invested their money L. properyn
~ unless i, be fSr the oetlerl by what
yoa thGs depreciaie the ysoe o. Their popefy an ~
- naef he ihrd poi3t will consider whether does
not the bill does no, provide FOR H. ~ You aye no
r.nt 10 mans property upon that street.
Mr. IRAcf-lt is con aeded tina, Il does not provide
for that class. uBlss le owner Of TIE store ha nie the
middle VI the IL Is conceted mat the oiu makes
roy.ou for the consequential injury 20 the store Hhefe tho
orser does not 10 the street There IS 10 need
aicu.ns that eHcsP, upon the poia you esoose g az
cass IT, that hs ought to De paid tntt man u eDuedn
sation II Ia on the horoughae though
his property nerered With for any incidental dinass
that may accrGe 10 his business. -. NJ,
Air. WiLLlaMs-To that point wish 70 call tho
attention II tie Committee for moment say ast tass
moral question bore The point Eeke Is hi yol s,s 20
liberty 10 damage Gepreciate mans pFoI erty ~isEeo
onoensaiion. This 10 fundamental prlDcpte o. al s
eminent and Of sl civilization IL Is he grand daeaw
m.rk be- H-eeu pa barisIn end civilization
Let as take the Of in Broadway who hss 'psas
s, which he has pull store o' me pesPos.
ri dry FOODS other lawful snrrose Hyoo Pat
,bo. ca. mon that street. You deny sha VII ss
hi. property You hsvc the statement that would irufe ~
.vary occuoan, Brosdwey-sseTy one undertake t9e
20 ssy ha there i, no nan doing 0u'inei' OF tenjns
goadysg who favor OF tits bill OF OF any railroad lack
haeye. being laid that street unless De some oae Sts
hss property the bowery or sifth -Velne' OF uyoo
In -on,rtion az property on Brosdwsy should be
riated You need not be told that cfygooi' ieaef %
1st. N lie were 70 read u his breakfast ibx
bro.day would DC closed ios ss asy Soea ''.e 20 w
woud hsve beuet for a, least one Jay ioa med pos
be oi that Of property IN he oo"e! o. -
street. parallel with Broadway aud when aspire 'a sone
way be the rival streets 20 broad"sy ~ouu M ~
upon the pa sage O! your oii because ss.s
eyue OF property in his stree. in proportion - deSf
etc. property ia bToaiway VI course Le Is 70 it snn
b nos because it belps Brosd"sy Das oecsus u n!aT
Broadway and thereby rsI.e' tae '1,os ,Dos.. .
| scarcely correct IN ssyins tAsi = Wa 800.
figat tske popular vote on the sntect ~ a
sulen, witch oas oten used mas tns iecle y ~
ORR demand tots Tosd s.y that the ea = iae ooNsy
aud sixth aveaue who have property there slea nay
nes ed Ia by any deysc alton o. property on ooi4
Wy ere undoubtedly ia favor OF the bill Nlsihef the Ha
IN toe sixth Ward are In favor or sSa.,i usy
question tetner ne amount oi tei "a VIA f-.oHs
su.6 entsd dinni,hed therspy upon gwen a. ORGY
ecIsy unni oitant con iieIa'on lie nen NaoseN
jud,s II tn thing aic TIE men "A' nave c1iil f.s
"a ID. 5ec by une instincts 81 leass interest,"
their Judgments are Of that iai@oe e-Fa's sna sao1i =
Hts..n5 ulph we qee'u d AZ, He"-' ~ t.sl''Jy
yu rr-efd They arc those Or no pFotsetos o.
dal,asl Auo r1sn ~ho has vested pecenisf nsets
thus question na voice louder thin he hundreds VIC ust
loud you bgicl snG aloud ior beaa om ti tIs..1
b0arf orsir.e yon o. 70 setA Guy thif e1 "a! 80.
% tht pubic sp0us You have no more iats
b. -oyrrrcd BY he voice o. numbers nan rs che Jag, .'
fI, b.uch % ere % decide question ~ nfhs Nn'y
,r.-s whose property Is on the Ska Sfe1srLs
ho 80 busue there Nns pecuniaFy i1t-rc., hs =.
except damage Broa1~syi Mili you listen 70 ~ vs'
hst interest who aoes business q " ~ tsee,
AZ only up and Down once day, % snd fen ~
residence 4weniic'n siFeeti u az sisse h"hs sN
tsl lie hes 30 plol elty broadway. LIS on! .tse"
j. hat II the citizen who akes pId in ihs beauty ana -
ni.o-uee %. he metropolis lie las TIA, intefesi -
coeHdaH,e which f. lie 10y soas-e u o. .'e.
e hls toe Interest lnat AL good men fee WAC desire 70 -
woui rsher The b tefescd-s this iner-'i may ~
De su,hci-ut call hm cut b yo.e an 49,,
given Isn feel N Hsht 20 le-vc !. 70 os ,ous
ot bv ~ "a an Whose property and whose .rn-s are lp0s
ur1a-way N you taea oi.ressd The risAss 4 n ws,'
pfoorit, tee ske loo ear cot 10 u sna oc ini
No., gentlemen do not think IL rsht &c ce.ain yelta
her upon ias question OF deuise " psolet! IN 80.
NAV r.r the petit ,us sad emonaac tnat were .'
IN hoi H. ny aud tire 81 moi- tlaa 10 e1n's
who have against tie passage Of THIS Dill
Mr. WARD-BOw many more
Mr. WMLIAMs-More than 80 names-good 'neu
ana rne whore solo business 10 upon Broadway AID "Io ~
dependent upos thst business for the sup of OF sl
VITO protest aglust tee pA',sgs q 'as OH = Be-
Aer interest. Why injurious a. theit lnseir's ~.
cause ~ lion trlck h. injurious 70 tie Oily u Ss
in use contemplated IN this Dill 't '-e go On
of tie almost incaultb.r au0uuof goods eiiy
Ga, sirest | ,lt say 70 you that have su ~ ,Si
yesfs within ~ iet Of sixth avenue eld i's ever
wagon more th,n hsi o. ne days dung tAs' ss Sys
dive SIX aycugei pass over " tle I'm soI
you .his iusSsuce because sir.l wnsi Aio" i,Jot
,.- - $500, s,gt a. Because kI0T tie "hee."
NV yysron /, r1orr tan scly 70 in'o noe ol 8 80
M or, rurus M taeTs zoe slightest sGiu 81 'ses 80,
[--- ., ,..,,,li..fs OF lls movement may, 80
,Ie de- on nom ,he wheel or ~aoAs 60
, ~. - % h.. ali sippc y sad ne hoisr s.et,L