The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1860-07-11
The West Washington Market Case
s.rR2nE couET .-Sfnc1AL TERN.
Before Hon. Judge Iograhan.

-
s.Nohk corT.-srsnAl fh"
Before Hoa. Judge Isgrabsn
JuLy 10 I'll, POM, q, Ne Rtsatos Of TsNcr ard
-. - 80. ,,...,..y.. a, Of Nre YORK.
c'e7'NdN Is me Mayor e"'"P'0s'' az, ooo.u,.d
FIX Judge Edmonds the part Of the REALTORS occaped
'ne Court the greater pai' ., 80. go. hu ~,
arguing his points lie s'uded 70 vac oA' 49, ~ ~
lor and Brennan TO open these Judgments against
A., - :, -, however that the Comptroller
nl ~ ~, =, - having the $50 900 received by
the REALTORS returned, and the possession Of
tbero us alsarneement and the case proceeded The
M Jeseuceoi the judgments is that il was versay
csdat ,t t time az Tie trial and the reference that
@ it had no title and that thcyefore the hen Ccgpo
ration Counsel acted not only without fraud but
rnentably IN the course be pursued is dinghy part
OF the argument fSr the uaaintis that that course
OF Mr. Bisteed was Justified by the Law OF the ease
The lands in question did belong 70 the state on the LIST
70 the CITY they con, ned Ia the ownership Of the State
where they were when the hrst was formed
the prosisons AZ arte ton 10 or the
OF lS MI Of artcie of the Consultation of 1919 and
by the nt ralpsLe and evident lece. sty they thus fell
wthin te oerr 81 the sloners OF the Land Once
to disnose Il tLem All the laod then 10 New York made
and rd in. oliside OF 400 feet below low water mark
TO the power Of the Comm ioners Of the Land
once to dispose Of There is but one i.misa,
thai is where the lands have been already .resetved
Appropriated to pabc use eeded to the United States
ali lands not thus ecdcsy reserved appropriated
coded are therefore subject to the disposal Of the Com
mssioners Of the Land Office Judge EAmonds proceeded
IN nd
Potter and before the referees were regular and legal
He was at loss TO know where the collision and fraud,
rssed and concYaed an eioSuen, argument by submit
,ns III, The motion shou,d be- DISMISSED -
a. syo,nr s svnaoss ~ The noints made by Mr.
Sasns sbs psusss his il is ths duty
81 he Ia anpiy 10 the court 10 set aside anv
agn the s wnsn sn % ss Of
20 him authority go 10 do Thir al has been re-
peateiy decided to be constitutional and under luds
go M .,,enn,s he Tav,or prsnnan to obta,n pos.
es, ~ ,Ss nrnmse: in oneson beso-e and without
60, - H. ~. e., ,er ,xsrs sraudulen. and illegal So
ira 70 'ne IN .sn sh ,"so, ~ tho civ hv DO
s, d .st ho1es st,on~nmen was fr3udl
u' an" maes ~, h has Ger sinre con
Ken. ana lesa ana saca possson mas The late
ue oe haa No authority to tate the city
a. ae'euuahl IN he e'esae ~ 1870 ~, md ~
ga. Az "s, W., ~ ~ ~ he Isth snI Issa
suspend tne execution OF tne LIN su! a,v",
restoring tne pos,ess'o 1,, ana ~" sn,s and
10 pa! osu 20 "s Wy - A. .:nr,h,,r Lv NO
prohts received D, him, or 70 40 an! talhs oy wa!
q Tylns oauss aleaa. eee ~. - ot VI ,s 49,,
Noi ma ne au'no ~ -, ~ rS -, NV crr nv
men su :. ~ snd us sucS .;ver and ahsnSor
men' were coiiswe hfl l.alaen' NOT nae ue ,,
10 appear or TAKE apy Step N ne name 81 'he CIV ~
the aetloh orousnt y! Asyio' assst ss s s ~ %,
the rents and prohts from Apr - 1907 70 vceoea "a
1892, inas'nuch as no process haa veen serNeo anu,
besides ms appearance ana ae's IN wa. evh ~sse 81
eolns We ana fraudulent; and designed only 70 adysnIe
tDe "snes ana pr tnose .e u "u -
prosen ~ we s, " ~ cesdng on the mart o
Lvor vas Iacna,eo py eonse ~ anu ~ tue I,s
haste py wn'cn al e procee inss anu .ns TIN. He,o
CparHteTzeu. NOR Aau nc An! ausuo.ns "
appear or taAe any steps as counsel ior tne Guy tue
WI a p Drvus on e ne Sno ~ H. s M
w - 81 10 sIsos ant ,hs rcnts snd nro6,s G,,r,
session VI INV plrnhse> ev Wy ,eso 80 Pnr - -.
oe,oper -, tos W oSo. - Ia, %;s -
FEvvsss ua .sss 49, s u III m;n IA S'd
anaae.. na aesen we,e a.. a -. , ~ s a S
sea snu We S r W W sht 80 80 ps
ino,e .ne VI lss 'r o. ens ~ s,a. s1. ~. ILL.,
proved IN IKE manner oy ns consentnS 70 y: m~e.
aa'e reference a'ouen y WAS no resi aom ss'su, ~
MS conserving 10 everything ,ney Msuee, AM ~ .Ae
\
ment mas never peeh larry aeeaueo nor ve ue Lao's
relating 90 the tte 10 Tue properly ever oeen
10 any tFlouna W su.h Wcisu. a'u uiSu'! vi a. SUN
manner mai .he sl.y autnoriues ougn' W ea.e.an
douO aooui ne 'u; OF ner toe, o 30 40 ~ Proyeul
Their hay ns new ana iair ana inpuIsai uaL me
dismissal OF the counse. VINO haa sIccssu,y aeenoea
the action w 70 the tm, W tue ua, yus' oeioi. w
nhhuea sonethinE 70 nle.a'e ne ssnianee, AUG snss
fore another leading counsel t!adge lean) was retained
but on sb"r NOVICE anu unuet sucn WA.
ia cas- 90 uucu in,r.es.y au" enen nls
acknowledged apity cou,u not save .ne c.y " y" tne