, 1860-12-05

nartic1e of evidence n s,,nnnrt lit ASSERTIONS.
when hc knew that thr record in thr c:,s,.
was weighed down with The dispositions of
ChicaSo's best citizens. showing The contrary. !.
Tic counsel should be held accountable for
this. He had no right to Introduce this str:,1,-
..cr to you in this manner. WHY did lie read
to YOU That deposition Of Sir. Tishe, Wien he
knew that lie lad not offered tu MAKE 4 sjugl:
proof upon that point, but to make xo,ital tur
the iury. To ST ow the spirit that las animated
him. would call to your notice tlle question
10 Nr. Layton. "Did you tr,i my one that Won
left Mr.. Hurch because YOU had rot tired of
driving him around with faucy women," when
thc counsel knew that thu answer would b.:
mo" Did he do It for YOU, or to have it
sprrad abroad and read by millions Why did
lie make Ills statements or what lie could prove
when he dare not introduce it, when tle juf:.-
lots, BECAME knownY Wly did lie assert that
this trial was commenced in a secret manner,
when lc knew that it was done 80 Us to keep
the record from The pub]ic .r;tzr. ut IF rc..aru
for his children and the mother Of his chill
dren, md that he has constantly sought o1cr-
Jugs to do this without spreading everything
abroad to {r read by millions ls Il MI
enough that his home has been made lcso1,t,,
that every earthly ho,,c has withcrctt and dictl
around him, without these ,tnprutessional a.
tcn,ts to biacken his cllaractcry
ouly desire. gentlemen, that YOU should
regard this as YOU would any other case. IT,
gard only lie facts and look with NJ .ayor nr
disfayor upon the persons wl.o*c rights you
arc called 10 pass upop, l know t!at wtct
prejudice once insini,atcs itself into the mind,
the Judgment cannot fairly 1sass upcn the sub
iect. DisDct that from your minds, The
question here il simply wleil,cr tlr tlefiutl-
ant has been ..uilty OF idultrry as charged il
the hill of ron,Dlaint. That which h:s been
hrou.rht hcf;,rc vn,, IN show .h,i she has. or
Things outside ut these are 10 be .c:.,t aside.
You 3ra mt tn try lin, 1uoral ut1nlit;t* or ttu.
,,ar1;cs whcthcr ,.;tl...r hss .rIcl viii fnd;s.
t.rct;on' nr as yon ,ynutf have done in Ukc
casc rrhrec t{1;n~s r. c,.ps;der,.G hv vnn ran
mil, ecrr" IT, d;2oot ,nnr .n;n,Is fr,n, that
wh;cI, you ,,ov,. ~ rsss ,,,nn The simI,I,.
n,cst;nn f:,r rn, to d!st.rn,;n,. ): whether fhn
ttho-,,o - ,rn1 ~ c1so w, ,,,,st n,,t 41,tr,.
tho, r ~, 1s,,d ~. do,o,sm+ .,';1t, .so H.,
w.. IT, 1919 @s S.s,.~' H., ~ e.
rhn 1,n;t of vnnr dntr IL r. sav .v,,,t hrr fror,
thc c,;a,ca ;.o, te,;tv. .ho ~ 1..,.., .,n;it,.
IF od,,Iter,. Van Iut, ~ .;,nn1r NH ~ -, c,nrc:.
t,,c ron,;ct;on ~ ro,,r .w,, m;,,I.
Thc ,.i,arrc ;s = scr;ous nnc md v.u shou,1
cxcrri,r cScry md INV r..,,,,,;bir canfinn,
Ynn s1,,u1G ,;'o,- ~on-.v-,,1,atb;.. ,n xt.,nI
tovards hrr hcfof'. von decide n...,;,,st her
Snwc ~ - IN .i,;s co,;rt ron,n In. frr". sy,n.
notiv tar tI,is nnf;,rtnnatt 1,dv In, III,
~. .,,a . NY ..tI...s ~.
nms snou'u no' uA.enu ai;.c ~ i''1 40 to h ha.
6oa,, ,r,,;i,,- a.Id 49,, ,.;t,t.. ~ -oti1e ~.
,,rs,o,,,,: ,,,r .ar.,;nt ica,,." = ,,,,,st ,r,.
tf,,,a ;.r,,,,;,,,, ~ ~, rr;,,r.. ..:at;,!.
r. ~, ,,,xa IT,. r,,,;,,.r ILL., H.,
cn,,src,,",,r.s Til. ia of IIr,tri,nnnv ia ,r,t
H. co;'r.ncncc ~ nart;cs i,,t III. .st.i,,ist,,
in.r of f.tnili,s the Erocr,-iio,, If otTsnr1,~-
III thosn c,,m;iv r.atinns ,yhirl, liz ~ H. I:s
NJ II, onr I,ar,1,in.ss md civ;;zs,for If ttu,.
t1urs iiS, ,nis w..'n,un:s il 1r ic 1,aS.ctl mar
t1.,, onr G,,n;,,. r"l,t;ona .rc ,,rr,T,tr,; All
thc wt.iT,r.. n :o,;st~ ~ s,vc,H fr,, r. C,nd.
.,son . u 'oe'e' s"'p' s'''' 40 '''s'4'1'
T,nc stn+,,tc },os ,,rnr;1ed that Gn~ ,,,,,,,
1irhfrr nf{;nces than hrr,. charre,l. fhr family
relation tan he dissolved. hui t,nr statutcs and
tl iow If cyrrv mace. ,,,l :t1 a.,c,. liz, b:elI
that for adultery the marriage relation ,nl,s;
hrbrt,kcn. II must always h. ~, ar tf. hi..y1.
est interests NC have On Garth will 1T d.
frat,I.
Sov with regard to tie proof, II is mt
nccrssary TINT Ia hive. rrot,f s,n,l lie 1,r,,,
ducch /, IL a,n'nst nrc,ssar;Iv t' in .,,.,iv,.,,
fro1n n thousant ,n,,ltjt uduu,1s circumstance.
,,ror,y u,;,,tinr mil And iii. tlu.. 1T tc>ti
rnnnv * stru,,;-cr than nositiyr nr,nr ii,r nj
ma;,; fact, m.ri,,rcI t.sf,mony ran Ii. .,lyru
hut this caunot he dong with circumstances
small minnie. t,ittcrin~ which, ,rro,,1u,f II.
grtI1cr. ,rlyr that i1n,,ress;on 10 tLt. 1nint
which ca1noi lie derfycd from any siiuu,c. nos
tive facts.
Mr. Miller read from 4M Euc{i.A E.e}fs;ts
ti,,d H.n,,fx n. ana. a d,,.isitm ur Sir Nm
Scott 10 tic effect lila! adultery was prcuJia5l,
M nct donc in tlarkIr,s and mor,. tl,au ::u,
o:hcr act ,,te,it IT, ir derive, tro,n s1ri,, RI
cnn,s,onccs
Wr W;,icr ,7eo rc,,, IN Tho ;urr nort;on. ~,
The ,,s, IF Eu,,1cx. ~ H,y,nss Ir.,,n ii,t. sam,
rniumc of Ecnt;1ts =, ~ as .,;y;n- The narr,
lin, of rori,;n,,;nn ri s;,,;i,
10 thosr in ti,t: rlsc at lar sn thc mr,r"ssi,,,
tIcy LETT uron lie mind Of il,c cI,,icEt iur;st
Sir Iym, St,,tt
Mr. Miller nlst, rcad +o t1, iur.: from, III,
,.,s,. of I,rr;s ,s Jtts,;x u 1,;S .,t ti,. xau,,
vo1umc f;,r s;n,;.ar n,r,n,sr
NJ sfiiin- .is" ,.., -. tt,, ;u-,. from, IL,
c,s,. or Nra,a,sW r.. .,r,,,.r,y * 'rn~ r,r,
RI, - ~ irvine, r.. ;.;.,,'ns NJ ilr 1n.h
;n1 ~, NM, ? cn,Sh;,,,i;.,u ~ r;rc,,msta,,,,
Wr Miller r;sn rca,, f., liz. iu-y frn,n IssIo
m 1L,rr;nnt o,.J il;,nrr. ~ t:S t],.tailinr th
elements ;,ttr;nr ;,,tn ~, ,,t NJ a1lnltcrv m,
| thr ,,rorr rnou;rcsI
Yr,, viii ,7fu.. Understand. Gentlemen fha
IT is ynur dn,, ,f, take thp,,. circumstances al
to.1;,"r and r. ,S~ r.. ..,,,,s;sf,.,,t viii, he
;nnocrncc to ,,nd her i,nnc,.,,t. If thrv ar
!: ',,i,. r"cc.sarS ti,; ,1,c nar,;cs Inv. dspo
s;.;nn, .. .i, an' ,.i that y;
r.o! ~ co.itl 'ae ~ '1na 'ii '"u
~ ~as,-,;nn', e.'s, T., ,,,n,,.";',,, , f:'r =,
nt .rr ntInrnce T., t1x;n~ cxcr,: s,:t.,c nm,
Al o,,,'i,v IF ih,. :" nrt ;n,st h., ;,tSr1nnci II i.
sho ,1t ;is.it. ,s,cr'e ,.rs;'s sn..i. fn.,.. s,t
;rtrE;cws &c., @ octs ~ ~ ;nnronr;csv s;,u1.-;u
thrr -c,t 11r4h.r sr,,,n n1cn" tl,1n 1,han !;
.h. v;c,r ~ .,tnr. W ,rs;s, tl,,+ .,,,r1 tr,,
a.r '..% " ILLICIT IT, .slsa .mat t,.i' ai"
a;', tI,.. S Lae ,.,,, .r,,;it, - ~
snu" tA,1 ~, ~ , ;, 14e "ssu W. W -
.e ~ iHt'"aueu ~ t're =; ~: ~
"ess vM. t,a: w. r.", i.,n ,..,, m 'nIl
,e',a;, ..'"s. tt,a,. i,,'.t.i,r
~. ~ n ~ se,.1 t III !, .,s t' fs t s,,,,
",nrni ,n,nnar ~" -; viii. !, ro,,i., 1,xa % 1;..n
~ io,s. t1,o" ~, ~. Iaa -, ,,,5 49,, ,r,,.
th'. En.,s nt,',,,, IL s,,.,,...s,, ~ th'.,n
~ ,,'n.,, " -,a++;o.1an "'r;r;:,s g. - a'+..
Waaa-.t ;itarra IT,, ~ e,..e 49,,
,.. ...s' ~, ~" 'os "'
~ ~. ga ~" ~" ,,,st.. -. ....,s; ~. ..ns
~, s, ,,i1 ti t.o,s 40 srf,i,. , a..
.e s,,s. tcu III .e ~ ~ 10y. ous
.at ,", ". na, W., h, 1.e ., ~
.n:n .nvy nase in,ea u5 aa Ut . itcoaiee'n: @ VI
~. ~ W ~ n'Aao e'e aoe0 no' vary nef 'ac
&c ,r,. re' ,o.a,,,,,e nail, ,;-,,,,,,,4
,sts icr :. fsd t,'at nr ti,t ,rx .,,, my ~, ~
,,;.;o,,e y, ~ ,,fS,os su,,s-.. s
tn '.;,., ~, ;nnrn,,"o ~ 49, 1.,. -
h.,s ,,t ro.s tho ,..,,taar. ,,t;,ra,', =,
~ .s ti.. 'a.,,' ..Iros s11I,~ ,rn. E.s,iIi ~,
TO- ~ WI 49, ,sar-a,',c'i int ~" 1s-,,a, t
..s aIr' ~. 1a.ar, III nar 49, ~
"n u sttuSEts S"..s ~ ~ ,! nei Hill ~ =
saw It. You hcari hsr bnfst ,, @ in:o tca1t, rs st
aa.;!c - H t..t H., "u'n ~
.;na e., ,a4oi H. ,r,,, ~; ~ a =,
~. ".,,ost;ar' !. ri ,.I'' .oo s'E ~ ~,
~ rai -. w ~ :. f,,a ~ i,;.a 80 ~, va ~
iS ,r;.,, ~, ,.,re,... ',e ~, ~, a
t,nt r., e a,,a so.v the;, damr;nc ..,n".. ,r,i
t,'a .,.;ds,,'.n ~ i1onor;n EnnE, s,.nl;,,-
the he sa,nc m,s,t;nn ~ md sw,vcd ton hr th.. ssn