The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1860-11-29


~ .ocsed an6 cnsir up AGAINST u, xr. aa,ch
toc o,re not 10 ,Gnr any letters 70 reach Mr.
Bnfeh before - had feen them, am iivinE with NJ
surcn row; have lived ~ his house ever since Mrs
Burnn loit
FsnDy surch recalled II do not remember speak
ing With Margaret O'Hsa about Nj Burcb; 40 not
member sayins that should not DRY y nor that "unce
Asc forgiven Mira Burch for the sauce offence before
Margaret o'HarA recsiled--I reeo,iect having
faop Win Fanny Bur en- on me Wednesday psnt before
srs burcn ft che told tina Mr. surch hSd forgivsn
ARE Bu'eh 10, the same thing three Ears before, cfsd
aer MIR Harch left; Mr. Burcn told ought not 20 osy
or Der, that the guiiiy woman and that ne shoac
et bl Of divorce from her right away tina VS. ~her
Direct examination resumed b. Mr. Van Arpam-rns
aigni hrs Burch ~h Mr. barch ssd oogns =
nave GOA him ABOUT Nj StaIt's waits, | SAL
inst here adisr the house almost 81 tne time
and that y there thing improper 10 ns visit
they wond have iLfo, ned nm; never euseo admit
lance TO Nj ssuart little suspicious Of Mr. ssu1g
after M Bcrch spoke " me about nm; nv smpAtnies
with Mrs. sorch until ate, she left, bot M Burcn
Anpresscn my nina, CONSEQUENTLY tnat sno was guilty
-ter gave my previous testimony Mr. burch neiped
D. DO go; DC not remember Mr. Miller telling mo tnlt
nusi tell what knew op, from my recollection; when
gave my position cold The substAntiAy out ava
Intend the little that renesrred should bsar
tbe put npon them by the lawyers IN the
Jay that Stuart Ars IN the srscsry
saw his arm % her shoulder and Der arm up bwHds
her eonnet; | DID not zee them khs elcn osher OF
ID IRE Of sissing; said that souii no.
| "a 10 oou,, 70 testfy against Mrs Burco;
willing a. a1a testify 70 tne truth; came oefe
| "a wnodsy HI. ht and 6orrG; ~ss sunppnaed
al o.. h h. map usmef =. isou'y ne sai thai the
| swyer, Borch nad sent for me; sss aeasfs
| s,es WORTH And Csuieeid and told them what sne~
about the sssirg testimony Mrs BuIoh Axed t.
me that mat mad tod stories aooai nor
he day thst listened over the bansters tbins
hrs sGy, 'Dont, am tired, bat oan4t
really those The ~ords; she ssid something OF
The smd; rcooect Mrs Buron saying that she vas 80
nsushiy somsr3' hrs Bmch TOLD me TO say nothing
about VIVA, b.d happened Only three gentlemen Ia the
Aeou, IL; wien the deposition before tne
Usgrtrat. Nj Buroh reminiec me Of several thugs IL
si,ng ny ,e,'iuon, srs ghomss sarch had talked e
u she told him the day Of Mr. nrner's
8.a,h into the dipius room, Mr. stuart
are Burcn STOOD near together; had no thought o.
ouosn,n by Mr. Van ArnAm-wnat nrst made you
ADs~er-You did, yourself, when you asked me ques
ois - bos they stood ose'her, sad Ahll they
Mrs Burch bat Aovsed me not 70 do ne has
refused 10 la mo see her lawyers; be blamed IA,
Tor going 10 sr Beckwuh's house wanted t. g, E.s,
aitr had Mr. Beck 9Th and tod Nr Burco
be advised not 70 co. hs said they woulf poison me-.
sna, Mr. Corning would give ever 90 much for my lite
money has been offered me oy either side, 10
| conversation win Mr., Beckwitn he told ooad a.
say1 ~, goo place, that could live IN Mrs Barcn'r
n Mr. Corn family, In any other place 10 Cocasc
o. New York; have never been asked 70 testify IN.
| ruy.
Stuart the evening cf the 2Ah OF December 1857,
81 the fremont House, thai evening Dyer Sage,
myself aao parry Of I'VE or s1, we're IN room No. lao
playing caros Mr. Stuart ihere he got during the
evening AND RAD thai be ~s golg 70 ball given ~ the
employ IS Of the house; oked dim considerably ABOUT
Il, but he -eIi Mr. stuart PLAYED cards With from
seven, pas, ooock for hour ana half;
he the after ne fret left II four dve times
The nrst time be returned ne had white giovss;
when | lett tue card room went into Dsvids
aeon Stua,, wss there; this ~1 eleven O'Clock
DO uot thnk naf Al boar pAssod during the evening
without Ar Stuart coming into ,he room; do Dot
nos far the houae Of Mr. Bdrch 10 from the fremont
House,
.Toss exam bation-i connected with the Central
Railroad ih'ee ago, but not snoe then have peea
II with ar Stuart for years; saw hun last
two weeks fncs; have conver,ed with Mr., OAneneld
about this care, he sss ed was In Chicago
Christnss Day In 1857 did not nrst remember, out
Afterwards DID from tho fact thst my son came 70 INT
on thsi Gay 70 spend Il with me- was first AK I'd
sbe VI tbis some three or -four weeks ago.
Direct exam ration resumedI was employed
ire Central Railroad oy Mr. Corning when did business
with that Rad II wss through Dian Richmond
The deposition Of Frederick BlrnhAm. CLERK Of the
,sup.un,,s,, A. oox.-rhe bali 70 the emooye I, 81
the emon, House held 1t the house the GATH Of
december, 1851 ssked Mr. Stuart II he was soing - tne
bal he raid sYes, Kate who did the chAmber~ork Of
his rocm) has invited M " canoe the nrst SET win oer
aud J shall DO So" soou. hsifp~st esn,
saw Mr. Suat dAcoe win Kate and two three
srlr; the last tine ! saw Mr. stuar. was =, ,welve
rhs Path q noemoer 1851 one ~ tue evenings when
,lre - CHARGED against Mr. stuart aud Mira Brch IN
he bill Of oemI ans
Adjourned tili u. sternoon.
AFTERNOON SESSION.
Gross examip aiUus q rleder,ck Burnham-Parties
were ven 10 me s.rvaes a, the rrenoal House
Christmas Of 1865 and 1857, DO not know Of Mr.
stuart o,ipS theTs gu lbe Chfirtmas eve OF 1901
horora Sc"s examined Tor The defenoe - am llyio.
1905 when orii sent 10 live there hAn Conversation
~ith Msfsafe, OBNa.
Mr. Beos ~nh for the de er o. argued favor OF the
hi 10 ass The question for .ne 81 sing Thai
torce Jtars sso ~ Birch mcteo sasploons against nls
al, thr bressts Of len esics hDas., sci lh.n
~schigE vie whne Mr. stuart, and then sip>r-
invited stuart " The Iouse introduced nim into
his coundenoe and family; maze him the confidential
ueno o. he wife, ana shen impiousy writes ,ne nis
tury ~ the saiu OF his vie
Mr. Van AInam, for the Complainant denied That any
proof bsd yet been farasned proving that Mr. Sarch
had excited suspicons .sspst the honor Of his sic he
could not DC charged With aous simply because he
usd Told servants Ar stuv there - ssy'tne
aoies were out" he opposed the Introduction u such
testimony.
me Court ruled The question out.
Termination o Hooors COX rssnmsd-I remember the
Monday that nr Burch went " Burlington, q, ausrs
cail-s 20 tust morn ma VS. IN the psror, ars Buron
tod me 10 50 up and sil Mss Lize he -. there sne
auAIt there for the neat days did
therei my cuisines as V answer =, the docr root
II. Browns party; Carlyle Boyd caleb night;
Nee Years DAY, .hen srs swcn jsrxed Mr.
or ws playful; abe vas seser.iy playful In Dor
manners; ! rccollsc, the time ~bsn mo trouble
mg, shs tick all bsr meals her rom CONSTANT
~ cryins-scnetmts hard; Mrs Bsrrh ann sinns
Of aoous June 1909: Miss Mary Speeding
uss IN the house With 8urcn
QWston Did you See IN N tosetherf
Van AMMAN, for The claimant objected 70 the qucs
ton ek siib for ine defendant, propscd 70 ak INC
QUESTION 10 show the at cti,o and intimacy bss~e-n
Horvb and Vary spand'nE An~r wrm diskussos the
oour, ruled The question out, Book sxeepsd 70 The
ruling.
Toe en- animation consuued-nr Burch ordercs me
the lAs, Ms Burcn bome not W sey
letter, hrs Bareo, be vss pos In 70 give them 70
Fanny Burco
crossessm,ned--qaves poseu With Mr. Couias "a about
the time -iuart Gated nsu Mr. Baroh Bnringtou
AID other in-s chez the door lacked lee,
Mrs Ba,ch .. a home; suppose any one could have
gore outlrom the in,ide OF tue borse
ExSmue1 by Coulneld FOR the defeooc-When ] say
,ou, did 90, anytime 70 mo; p-rsoo
ina - xss.4 Ia auokt
mony bot the Truth consideration has been given
promiset me o ,oh
The dcpssision " Joe-pn Ibsrsn Iona read he
has known Mr.. B0rch tor tso sesrs kno~v Mrs. Barch
BY sIht, kso-s stuart Ultimately ~ss 81 HE house
~. The meeting a. the H,stor,ca society
Nu Bro~n's there ~cFs present. stuart, his wife and
esushtsr Gated ~ ss'ps h during the e..o0g
fcurd toe ladies rsprued " house 81
David -,usrt found him lying The so's Lslss ~'tn
bAse snrrell, rcmsnet there un lp ccvcn O'Clock;
Stuart pyeseut all IN. time, ~hen hrst heard tns
evening mate point N Bnrchs case, the reonlec
tone ~ tho esenrgs have stated ~ urred 70
.s..- Il f~A.