The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1860-11-22

This Jnry Fina . Verdict OF Guilty.
ColAT or oYkR AND rERAIsER
Before Hon Iudse tSould

Before Hon. Judge Boald
Nov II This case, which has much excite
among the '.fancy" and the public generally
continued Gay Contrary 10 genera expectation NO
witnesses called for tue defer ce and the sum
ming up OF Doth sid.s was proceeded ~itn
Mr. Rcharo Bus,eed, Of the Tor the prson
err the summing up HE Of the defence
AFTER some important preliminary remarks, he pro.
cesdeo 10 es lain the care 20 the jury IN which
he claimed that II WAS not properly the people o.
the state who were carrying On tho prosecution,
Dul tina, John Morrissey who had doae Inc
wh,le lhing, from personal dislike 10 the prisoner
he glanced The Of dr.. Iaigan, and
.iutout aniavoraole impression tna lac paoc on
To- laaed t,waros him entirely osing 10 tao pablo
pr,ss, aud severely commented apoa toeir rePifss he
Nh explained the indcsuent, and Inc phAly Msacpsu
W tie crime, agd maintained ahat the pfs3u cbsfsea
must be convicted o hhu.tne or ala-n afs0B tpe peV
DC pJos,n DRt no ass prove ting saa esa poor
ARD be ton OF al luJary ust Aso be poe'
DC IheD pfo 10 spe.- y pe o1tes q hs Jlofs
ate ttcessil ther sen Vega Is the coaAoslls 7s
GgLce that there thops psesa uprFs eslre1csi
ii, heueut DOUBT should - an times DC Il 'en 70 he
dc cont.DGeo mat The evidepce asansl W.
nam ALsnn fes "a entirey ap.n ne evidence " 4ss
cted ei0a, and that vas JeIb hssfsse! ihslsB
10 ,,,ncf esrebee VI g1it 10 tnis case. No auugan
sves ihe ui aorrnsey, gaasoles loses ne u bey,
ald r,lurLs retrieve no aoes Mp'rssey
uunteos o she house l1iorms s.i Dlks Ina.
kunlaL creating stnrpah 90 Ia nls house fnis MAS
fsa be order captain Dix his uilces W pro
to IA Irlesey house, and Aatleaa eagAsei
dslgi haAce Or breach OF ire peace 70 brlns am
back oser proceeds 90 she house AID hniiog aagAa
peIiect state peace pIucteds 10 arrtst nim ,nsA
Aonifrey ala Olvef ssore taGt pistol ~s W nta AZ
over and 10 make matters worse, horf ssy ststei tnal
PIE self cocker, while tncre 10 ABUNDANT eyi
a.lce That IL ~ss 40 such hing Hogs s~oro taAs ae
e Iouse, aud saw tie whole tnAg, oui ala ho1
a1y pIio ralsed UNsal ais9 ssose p same mus
CAPTAIN Dllks sSore maj Oliver, when he came
back, very much excited, and fuitnef states
| that HR@es told uim tat Onver ~a se'los
.il0, aud officers should DC seIt thervi not
arrest Maaan, but 70 take care o. oifer He con
that bpLtiul caInot be inferred, ba1 uast oe
proved "a ID The Il dcinen There ~ tust
lhe pistol IL question VAS loaded aud the nticmsnt
ttalts tbal here evidence " prove thai
as,sult toos pace AID tho charge II a.y saoaa nave
be- made ,ug 20 oe Tor oosr acting an oser 10 dis
fne gentl,rl an here closed ard District Attorney
Nilsson Vat. bury Then sunI1ed Up for the prosec0
Hs coAtend,d dat the majesty o. tae as mus pc
ma ptsiLeo, AID this case as one OF fhem The Ia"
could no' be Upheld the shcers we're ao proie, la
siih hem John Morrissey VAS not tic heal o tnis
prosecution, but was he me CHOSEN representative o.
TIE ope Nho came orwafd 70 ok then 70 punish TIE
d. ner vie lawess reckless class exists amols
us, but he hoped that The iag would alSays have
HE power 10 wresue with them overpo ser tnem
u bad nothing to DO wh the past character Of Sagan
iho JCIy uust Try hln Gu Toe merits u the pesen
case AQlag@n vac oae u shcst persons y Sa'm no
h.o re,r.o, .hose poser 10y oheay In the pisoi or
thai ta.y earned Taere @as bui one qdestp1 DID
she pfforei - the tempt 10 stool tne ON err We
have ssssea Who saw tne pistol potaesa 81 tie on
Ger He then proceeded " shoS slight dscrepsn
es h the evidence u s'me ihe aisaesses &c aeid
got without hit a,iua discharge Of IRE
Ncspou rs lar s beg loaded, II wa5 apt Lsces
sht That officer Oh yer haa done No more inAn ms
da,y the nisht Of he 2oh, ao5 ~As oesty
proved that ohya Ma Sos iasasca ~ a. ne
nor in srrestng hu'gsn For what Constitutes
oisorderly oooouct entering into nao's house
ioaaed pistol Ia his hand, oeloaing hra abuse
aud profanity notl IAN ihe law be deaed il gam
bnut loase, ana draS line between gam
bnng and the nous OF The citizet NO AL
mLst Lave the protection OF u
Aro both ,ides bad closed their Arguments, Judge
Gould NJ oce proceeded 70 cnaso TIE ary IN
clear and moat eJpiicit manrer. tic said;-
n orott approach the case properly, II vii be no
csssuy throw things that have been STATED
The law that peison comes into your anusc, arm
med, that you have riga. 70 exp nm, a.
you Call IN N oacer Re Is oni, aoias his duty " ASSIST
you Il makes Gn-rslce ahat tns cnarsctsr VI tbs
housc ID. Everything Gums before You aere dpon simple
| facts. hDrrlssty ordered Aalisan TO leave
| tho hcuse, before ne got an officer, and inAs
| ope gase him full power 70 EJECT The party
WE1t ht stated to he jury 70 bs Considered ~ law
he mace mistake, tnSi DO affair OF theirs, there
vas higher tribunal that would set thai r.sat Iney
ouly had 70 with the Ia LAID doSn briore them
The Grst part to Auigan remaining In the house,
aud he had referred 70 that IN uAG.sr tDAs YOU'D su
Ace Ia regard 10 the testimony Of the witnesses, yoa
must weigh that yourselves; every one allowed 70 tee
NY, their testimony supposed 70 be tue, but with
are 10 Wy and reconcile ali The evidsnce that
| mpossole you must decide which 70 Throw out It Il
and 10 supposed that party who s~ears that no say
certain Thing entitled 70 more belief Than several who
Of .So pevss O'S peoa aoaa 10 &c:
have Doshnf TO DO with 10 only wnetb.r ne iAtend
ed 70 commit The ect no matter What might havs pre-
vented him; and this 10 matter " be decood by
! and on you ress the responsibility.
After the Judge haa concluded hn charge the jury rer
cd being abent about quarters Of an hoar,
returned with verdict Of guilty The proners counsel
not being present. Al the fenoerng OF the yedci each
Juror slated that that n individual VERDICT % ~ 10
| prevent any misunders audiIg
The prisoner did appear be at all ale tied by the
courso Affairs bad taken Sentence was deferred until
rf- Act IN
| nor ihey might please
1 SENTENCES.
/ Before Hon Judge Gould.
John Y. williams peadsd gully 10 mAnsltughtsr IN the
/ Crit cegree for kliiDe Dis wife HIS counsel, A Ash.
mead, nopsd that Tie court would DO merci,u " MIN "A
WAS certain taas the man ~ss NOT W ms right mind,
aud wa sborng under The aeuson shlt soGle obe Sss
going W murder aim, ana ~As not conscious o. wasi be
ala
Williams, In answer 70 the usGal auesiloa why
tcnce tnould be pared 1poa him. sad that Il ns
boaor soaid look io his heart "a me Goa oil merslos
| could, he would ply nim. He had always loved AMI
cherish his wife, god would resent siln indguaiin
i1ss hat offered T. her. In hr oteas. there hai
never ranked thought u ma &c or hatred lie coald
| socouat for the deed he hna oommit,ed.
Tue Judge remarked that The as Geld meu accountable
fer consequences Of ln.f Own WI NJ, AM u maa
out Of his MUD b hi osI @cts, u 1ss a. excuse
ihe Ju0kc Eaia tnAt Tie prsoasr sas ~ o" tAAte
health, sncash, iaa' lev se..s o. inprsesasat ~oa
he ut paa tie Tail pcuniiy TIE teafencs 81 tie
prt0usr be tsas 70 silg sng tof nfcsa
4 yIkrE ard ak mtnths.
1lar.s Aaursitts, very bad look e yocug fclJs,
pltada guy e muresr p ~ stoo-a dlsser, ias 80
kJas klebafpsuh Grey fae ffe0ner, in 'e.y 10 sac
uSgAi qut5tilG, icpea at rs fag n1talg ~ 80 4ha
Jutgs q oFht ttlt na 49, TIC 80 = fsa ~ slcd rGr
sue and iuattntNy Eavv ihe prisoner az seaca
a. the ~ With Nas lMrsJr aegt - aff thf Tor a.
9Obu ald5n an Jars,s Earahi souvc,ei for ticket
tKEcNug we're To- BIZ. skt fri ara 10 seatsusg
txRscroor smiin sa'n tbat n tae case IL Earlg1t
Tie, ~ouG lot oc so.e = prease VI q excepsoas al
saturday. They wrua rsk cNsy 10 tha' time Urocf
iuat they might prvPne viii q Apply for
! sisy o. proceedings