New-York daily tribune., 1859-06-09
COURT or COMMON PLEAs--GESEEAt TEsw-Juus p
Before Judge. DAILY, BEsoY snd HLros.
lie "a Jc>.rh Harrison.


BRADY, J.-Tris action wa. brought to recover
penalties Incurred BY the erection Of four building. in violation
tie ud Fmen, the Court 10 sccorisree ns p,i.oo.
When called the speci., Term p.iutH.
counsel moved il h. tried by the C0u without jury TIE
dsf.ndsnt com .e claimed iral BY Jury Tue Judge psd
ng decided lbs; ,b. scion should BE- trco sy the Court without
Jury and the deieIdsn excepted Tas presents the h qces
The Code sec 25s provides ths, i.sne Of fact 10
tnn r the recovery Of money only or seec or personal
property or for divorce from the marriage contract on the
ground Of adultery, BE- tned by Jury, rrss Jury trial
yded BY sec. 30 III See 30 provide, that other s
sbe by the Court which however may order the whole
S ygfy y st .S hn r. c f spm coa in Gree when %
tiled and which stated the pac.ice under his Sec
proydeo 2S Of the Code II either party should desire
a by jury such party should within ten os7: after issue
thar the Cou Judge might sette the Issue. refer
settlement of them TO Retire.. Tai. /. of the
class Of be tried BY Jury specifically mentioned
rpsS m ss @ a = noa and IL M he h h1'fxy = o ba 1 retrs Ia
violation o law and Dc application was made lor aFy ta IN
toua st Of trial by jury h been vioated defendant
entitled tis in ths mode The Constitution. See
in which been heretofore u.es shall remain iuvola,e
e III EVIL sa il 1 b ss si to y E ySe ,. TG Sy w a c
Sec no provides that the trial BY jury may BE- waived ey ne
with the o the Court IN other actions Ia the manner o
i B, falling to appear ct the tri,L
By person by attorney to be 6ed with the
By ora. consent n open Court and easreS G u the
sered ,ierc,o s jury a., waived In The manner
prG.crbed by law ony To b. considered whether
ihi, vi len ts by jury was in use rIOr TO 'ne
Constitution o. e6 by the sh section 81 nc act Ia tee moe
eaec'g'l Of FIRE. ~ %, cry @ mg" synS s.
house, siore sore-house s.h.be, ssn-houc slrdf q
before in ths sct Which .ha be ercisd blt roofrd'
repaired altered enlarged, built upon Q. lsm',,ai coh
cediug sections declared to be common uuI's9oe ana zoe
J,es' 4 se Sase @ S.4a soa ,a ssa seSey q d the justice.
Of the Court o Geuera Sessions Of The Ptso" "lhn Tue Wy u
New York have ognizsuee u the ohense snd are
10
tk, dl.ention. shall think tit ami praPef and s.' n
the discretion, TO cause such nusaucc 70 BE- aosed .sl
removed. By the soth section Of The sane ae' rt tnt
Of Common Pleas for the CRY aud County u Ne~l3ts
addition the power Of enforcing the Plr. p9.iaa oY
sw and % sy yasS s d. sb IN pr to ra IS aaacon
tte erection Of blidils in al eon 10 Dc bonst - ' rug
In Violation of The shall be taken down aud removed the
imp .ing only preliminary to The ehsTs. o. i g
rys The nuisance it viii tsa. b PSr.eysd 'nf b zoe 'y
md Forfeiture incurred err declared y . would ot be
uusances law PER aud the eoiseq ehee'
brc, '1s'gl s4s ho. ony wics sre prescribed Nae Of
the act. of the Legislature Per 70 tas 80 =. o. ~ ~ ~. ~
only 70 enforce tie penalty bat TO sdadse t. The yoon o
bo.d the Cour.s indictment and conycthn to sgae Anh
IIOts IsIs se ,.' Ae. APr "a isss see, A. AP1 9
is15 Secs Act Maieh a. Isa, src. ? A., My J. lSSt
Ths action iherefe II de,eni cd by ;e jdsmsH. asSed
one in us when The Cons.ut9n o. .ss s -.
ence AZ time Il that the common "a " ise'S ~
Of nuisance was LeaiHes' 'csf,& 49, 70 ~ Ia, preedn1
The Jury Couri oTdrIed cod view the ptrn' lu'
the plaintiff pres Allied he Judgment followed aAt ,ne
y,d ard nat he recover hi. damss-, - IN al a'n
ed upon damages resulting from nuisance .he tnsi py yuS
vailed Thec distinction, h2weyef oeieen eonsoI 40
priy,r ruance account ii the former no seton 49lh e
Iy an individual unless be suffered some I-
teSond the o. he People or some lecu.ii o.
in h. should have iySe a., aeyn 81, -
6 bl coa ~ Lansing 80 s5 ~ n B,aies Co IS IIow.
sro Ref u: HeekeI a.. Sane Ibid "a ..--. Il,
r ssuson designed for the PStecton Of lie ard Pfoesly
sld the psua posed for violation oi i arr gwen % 'ne
ip fs ~ b hSy ptas fhe i1eu,d .y b
. b irSictre, and len b. The penalty be rec01'
s,i,s tie asee1son taken consider how f.. affected
b, he provision ,h prson shA b dpsed
o hs propery Loat du poe.s law a-eao,s thins Z ny
.usre..sd Il aid by a. J. Johasos, j. y WyHea'G-f
s,sn., The rs9ii- q ,hr C:,,io1. va Tie ns
BY jury al cases ia which his herr;ciev ben qsa E
rLb il ia. br,iore been us-i~ Is s-nefc rh.t l. does
limit the rsh; tie i1sAHccs IL vhich L hi4 0een
sf.e snd l.a;.sse: a.' sisw w y ,1 .5 4. % b md II
I'm md can nuisance udrnvsnor sna iuai,sp
!. eeron i.s WLsr-'. G Law. a. b. - ia-sat
"a. ~ rasl r .Ae spsfa Ss..5Ts Re- sat ~ - !
IA - sad ~bsa q aeon ~as S,geth = a. isa ,e p
procr,d-d sroordinz 20 The '1.v .! M lln,-gn AS 80
vas MA By jy r. yo...'9 PM aS o. n N. ~:
rescribd he mode q triaL tn rue aPFlas.s . s. -
\
-yi.,ree would appy nal % rc0vcI peaaY i-lp,II
bv tbe ,,su.r at wsi Tee DEE ndAi would ,, e1-a 70 ll-s
~ Jns,-, Court demanded. lAc. OF 1878 yoL hfiseS
I.w. $40 So as Revised s;s;1'es, ~ - % A. . 81
event, II Court ,of record pocseint ss9aips . ne -
:, tbr ecg-1or sg Rev Sat "a, -rc a. Ihs aii'- --r
rrss-oed a. o-e law 20 rcogve p a,-y o. -
= a silti1r 70 las. = o-s-ss s2t -f'ls ~ Asc&n
I'D s-E-gt ard II which tss mole Ct sill VS. os
- -. .l u AID IL TrcE - 1e Co-s-ior - ief
4, /. No .r.wer the co--lusin t-s errrrs-1 - =. II
ofCasocery had jusiet'oa % rssaa a. 49,. ,t -
.-- I, rsnsrsy fhs power q ~ oolft y . -
- i c.,- Of uss.acs Dc i0ah;si ataos sh . sa'sa
a, AZ eIensu:ary rus :hs. IN many OF ne ess,
- i,sn--s ,orrts II sgly Law % s<s-s
"a ysr- "a Inisac;io-s, 5]l sot l. seems -. -
r,f II ssy vss oouk5et ths restrain u .a;sca Z.
rf,s,c. prsy-r for Nu1ll b- srs O.. to--J
az, ssks Bar 5 l. Rep l57l Ice 1oiEs ~ no 49,
Interfere l. csses l-e Sori y 81
bal Rrx .s, ..ic-. cf D.r., - Ia. -, Ee-sel - is
ara eh ;A- yarty ala F,r.ety e5 iati'ei. -,
e, are for to- 2ufpose o. asestieoAs a.
n tbe Coui oi ChArcey. wh.rr ia in.~rptson - -
r.ses .. a1-s.nce, b.. Ia. heEe ~ss es--
ard D. 1Acces CARA ~ --s
b., conc cin, tia power II of nasaace Pao sa
he h,,sry of ig.dc.ion ard al II sse- D ie-
tTn-tyec 81 sho- TIA. q eEere.sed y
". ssd expressly 6. IT, PlF?-se 9: 0s'a-s sh g"'