New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1859-04-30


yrv.d q N. bsb,s, ppu, ard Of ns al
.oa d.iiysr,d 70 slavery y Some,.' a.r VINO have =,
eevsS couse oonpen';on ior % es
Iosvs and tie temple. asios srda with chains The reco
,y s . sn 4 m, os s 81 SIZE. a &c cos
er.cy for any oaere asxrst te or he laws Of Ire
sspopd,pos Win ierds ., b,ae or with the pres.
States expresses. their dislike Of che slave ystem the sh OF
related sernE fact that & under ~ OWL observa'n
Can H. then regarded matter - surprse sstonsh
.n accumulated and oGtrsses should excite
men st they should appeal Legislation. Of the
Stat. q b. pSss to, S S OIL , sa'os NJ s.s
Of Free State What, though they ask more than we
or sss o,der Our denunesons sbosi be Erst hurled
those real foe, the publ and 20 ne Cnstuon aud to
the Union who armed with power snd filed with insoienoe
roudy mpe In very principles Of the popular hb
In he.s Petitions may pardon something 10 the ''a
The majority Of this committee arm ~ heir report ,hs; the
parties asking Tor The passage Of h m we're not sens N sno
well known and 700 generally discussed 70 t.xs room o'
IN. ss HePy .Dy e az noraSe senator. who
have sneton 70 TIA, report 70 assr most adj
di,ssree upon be meaning Of the Constitution, s:s:ue
strange bet Such Engagement arises In ouT "a
miller discussions such subjects in legislative dsbstes ..
the forum and the occupants the highest seat OF
justice That these respectable petitioners should dnsr on ucn
the members OF this COMMITTEE unressons
BY be expected
There are several legal psoposoDs oou.ined in the majority
report which the undersigned totally disens dsstnins
them s'ossy gneontuons thar any proposition to Be
brsoed in the following extract from that report;
The nsnege Of the Govt in one Of me case: above sd
secure the hight reclaim fugitive slave. against State esi's
pat. III; question Upon ~ 1e TSun a, no aI.
srerde slave it is the law Of The state where 10 created
4" with which alone this responsibility
from the opinions delivered in the bred Scott by the
sve Of the hsbrs States and Of the people than this 1t
tb. doctrine BY which Slavery eIpec TO be carried By u
thine by which threatens force herself the Free States
Judgment in the heart VI metropolis
IN
State igtation mark these words-AGATsr STATE ILSLA
without even the the Constitution, and that d9onss
legislation The Constitution tbs be true seeges that
light in other words sanctions that night cot b night which
outside Of the national compact Consequenty STATE ess
son could the constitutional clause were not 10 eI
prevent BY all It's court executive forces,
the entry State limits Of the master 10 pursuit. OF bis
Against Til. doctrine the undersigned his solemn protest;
in his in the name Of the Recubhesn party 10 the
Of the Constitution.
The majority report also contains these words;
o. tns ohe C rS that ~ decision become. the law
T0 9at then o a. his S .rsS. to overthrow any
provisions Of laws Of Congress held By the Supreme
To 90 much Of the preceding as as.s that u.
eone, Of the land the undersigned totally dissen's The
eating parties ends their lawsuit and execution follows the
judgment rendered but decision beco lag beyond such
extent judicial proceeding whatever IL will be regarded
BY the profession and by the public stronger or weaker sn'
dence whs, the Court would be likely 70 60 IN ae cs
does the Constitution anywhere declare u 4 the deGon OF sas
v Of @ land the Court could not decide other sssn..
H. because Cou cannot alter TIE lag JIs dieys non t
In The case before them make the law Court ~oke
desiOn but does not wax. ne H,D g., nnr,.,ou.
rsesed their solemn dec'on, They have ae
cded one case one sna oSs1 The s
wrong still the law to the paT'is before 1e Coun
Ss wSen Th. s !. what declared in the Constitution
This Constitution the laws OF the United States which
Which shall be made under the authority of the United States
shall be the supreme tar Of the dnd'
ton that Judicial decision between and or ever wac ths
law Of the land T w99d and sss II. s%pn TS". we
dcon the iron code Of the Medes and Pesn' that chsnss
undoubtedly true that the Fugitive Slave act has caused
neat III feeling in Northern mind There many people
sDy other. who doubt the whole Of T. These opinions BY
confined aymen, but are entertained py ven eoe
that IL uspend the wit Of hobo, corpu The evidence OF that
feet contained in the majority report Of thu Committee IN the
And L is further declared by said section the such eerf
TO the e.asa,. oi ~ ns bs rsb
person in whose favor granted 70 remove 'nca
,bs peycp all moIssson Of such person any
prOe, ,ued by Court JUDGE, MAGISTRATE or any per
Language could not be made palmer than this 10 pieces
reach person thus held asa ~ any os S"ush o
reSason On III. obs, hand declare, a. follows. The
privilege Of hsbeas sfa not b. suspended
when Of rebellion invasion the public safety
How then without violation Of the Constitution in time Of
peace when rebellion OF inysson does not @ can me PnN
iege writ be suspended and totally sbrogstea'
There ST another unconstitutional and most dangerous aoe
,ne advanced majority ~sch 10 this, that the
the disposal Of the President as MS ordinary
means 10 execute laws This boldly asserted In the report
90 established authority On the contrary The army ana navy
cannot be thus employed the States for the execution Of jo
Congress have su
tborzed the them The friends Of republican government
may permitted 70 hope that the time is ts distant when ns
es shall be allowed az the Presidential nod
within the State Jurisdictions for such purpose
The supple Of two OF the Committee closes WIN
certain marked quotsuon: An nrepessoe couc.
the North and the South and the public from that
with its evident snuson 10 distinguished hses
man NAV be enormously led 20 attribute that expression 70 him
The two members Of the Committee however mistaken
themselves this respect The irepressioe coaniot
by him between principles two systems OF spof ana
he ssd there epessibie conflict between 'ne
North and the South.
The the subject in hand far greater
sn dangers threaten the Constitution OF the Union On
the contrary popular elections which are an index Of puonc
enment furnished recent proofs ct satniacory kind,
both the Union and the Constitution are screay
y the mas of people the Free Sses Obedience to the
Constitution and the Union do not demand OF us any
sacrifice of those sacred personal ha and liberties which
hobeds corpus iGI BY jury part o. ne Coa,Iss
ton preservation and careful protection OF the peses
OF these two Of eeaom do not evnce any
want of feSy the under whoh 1t our fortune "
live. ..u.-.
nends their passage:
Rs.osd That the bill be recommed With power to amend
and complete.
Reso,d That Liberty bill ought psss containing
the Aabea, eorpS and trial by with other ana
securities and liberties q the people 81 the
All which is respectfully submitted y. " bANoN''
SLATE-CATCIyING- DjPENS RE
PORT.