The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1859-04-21

"a IN lin
bad been ccmmupca'a 20 MN n ,a.nco was eonpetsn,
nj; pia! s,sS1nav IN his 90. ping had re,researei
Ih' itslos As~Dy a. m,rv and M Kew as ta,pp
Nr sich'es M S $500, - I'm. hs w 40 u.yrnoat
urh' meo nnp ' 81 ,sas n, sho > that n. Ksv In
s 20 ibis very subject, bad made &c s,uo AMI
ehpIestion ,i - 49,, w.,nop. in an, .or,sion that
pose ps w'ap, had no,hng IN evda ,ce ahon, Tho
uFhs oceu.' up -, na,.aan ~ gev - u. S,sr,s
ns. men ~, ~ W s ond tam bet en- TIM ana Gov,
sxeep, wa. 'p.. ~ Us ,s. rs,,.,n Ia ,.ansns.
SCI siepeo 'na. ,nc y, .h ass,er 80 r,, %
Of Mr. Key IN reference 70 'ne nA'e' were pe'ec'y co"
Ps~l, s ,o,ovea an a.o .,uos ,as rhsv
,u h ,Snca oSareA a., sho r,ns an acpno
e. @ v. 'u W" ~ ~ aas,:s e a,,,,sS ,es a
s,a ~ mv, ,,s as hch ~,dencs rouiJ no or,red
e su,! on ssS, pO no s,aea ,n.s M Sea
lps,h.a" =, e, ~ ra..a,o" nas AS .,has me
~ n os s,h;,p wssa,,ns nreoarsa :, rene,
% - ,, ~ Tho hrshaoi 20 n,nish the In
ivy Nv ~ .a W. ,s,s WV rnav ar ,sa a.
NM weo,ser ,yht thea IA =, sns,,ln
yn sne,ns. tIouna, ia. W a., su t ~, I'd aecara
,hs p'.feouuon t.o"s ou. J: .s 49, s,,,oa. az.
,'ons ., NY ,n.s o NV a ' ,,,s had wn, ~ on.
@ IA VI " ~ as or ,ns sovernmeot ,bs defence
ulin o<,ue VI 'uo p~u " ~ w. ,, 90 sny ,hst no
nso It". " .n'w w. ~ s'y ,r,,n q, the n,oneo, N
was 40. opy oa s hn -, w ress he doc
e hon'a. ous lpss a' y, * aSn,tsrer Ware moi
mnon IInls o.o.s' " a.. .ns ;nrv ,n ,bs mini as 70
H.su s"ons ,s.sS " a. n..a. ~ ,ne g,vernmeot
wSsn no wss s,anY The evidence was imp Srtsut Also
Nneh ne ~ w., ,, Of ,ha n,osocntion m ,de in the
az i'e t as , s ~ ns,,,c, stwnev Hs verify be-
oPs ~, ~ ~ az nj ,n,vnss Of his charac-
'Neu ".s a., a. a ~, or the has b,n5 They n al
e ~. or This "A ina M es M NOM ent 10 Al
lens t ~ az he .ssa or Mrs H,ytnngl rhs svi
N.s rs,re n,o,S. no, only on the rroup of the
ar inrsysrca If aneer 10 the husbaod bot bsc lnse
+, hr rar,i.nar case Inc aduerer al armed himse [,
,se,s, ,be bnshaus n he Win him in his amour
1ns TOO uor,d no rem,rksi was m ia IA
e,,o souare in view Of the bo,se OF Mr. Sicks and
NJ The time when Kew was contempa.iog the perpetra
,ion or The wrong for which he vas killed
Mr. Carlisle argued against the I'D mission Of the evi-
aence He wou,d rst notice tue pom OF and
Divine vengeance which it seemed as IT his ou
ersood M have by prevons ratings in this
case he had moi So uuderstood his Homo rulings But
hs Honor had ,a.d that the evidcnce of adultery AZ
admss,bie ms Tending 10 show the INSANITY ouiy
wh,,h he took io be c,ear exc,us,oa of
the conclusion that IL was admitted far the
WIG s ~ sno.;ns mo, M,,na wsnaaarca was
purpOse OF showing .aa msae TVS veps s,susd p,u
90, IprsdrH hsd moi d;.sinc,v ,h.t M o,s or
The Sronnss on uh,sh he rebe5 and ~ Tareel " as Gu
80 - 49, -, ha hon,ht ,r ,h,, ,r,;no r D,yna
vengeance He (Mr BfaGy) had argued that il was al
nssiole because we are DOW inqrng into the <ct Of
the previous aouery ana because ths evdeace pore on
that inquiry AS 70 sne iaot OF aduseIy ns aonor raei
against the onecson OF the prosecution out win ns pet
Ter Judgment Oh the Jaw "efrmned taat tna' matter was
nj suuect OF inquiry nere out ex'ue,vey on sne sag
geton lnat Sss TO De connected WITH osaer proof 20
show the INSANITY Of the prisoner CERTAIN PORTIONS OF
the evcence tendlng 10 prove adutery were a'muei
the prisoner At the time Of the homicSe dc did aot,
therefore, deem necessary to trouble his Honor with
The are omeDt on MAT pat OF the proposition HIS Honor
bad Constantly refused to recognze the doctrine OK voe
vengeance but tns or OF evidence vas based on another
ground, which be deemed worthy OF consideration II
was offered, first, 10 show that Mr. Key WIS armed; Be-
cond)y, as tending to Strengthen the impression on the
prisoners mind that Mr. Key was armed aad thirdly, as
being something natare Of threat by deceased
towards tue prisoner. These were pertecty ntes 0
grounds and he proposed to discuss them a. be thought
they were ented to be discussed Ho" then, did these
the tine the homicide tooS place, on tho 2Ith OF Febru
APPROXIMATIONS made ten or twelve days before thar
He submitted that that did not tend n prove that the de-
ceased armed when the prisoner INST aim Whether
or not be was armed on previous days was totally imna
as 20 as he haa no he,ra
ton that the conversations between witness and de
ceased were never n the lifetime Of the deceased
communicated to the prisoner. Admit that the CON
veisation took place, aud that 1t might be inter
| pretel to mean tia. the deceased then wore arms
1t neither proved, tended to prove tina. the de.
was armed Oh subsequent day or that the pfi-
soDer knew he armed. Bat whether decelscd
was no, armed was wholly jmmatersl the question OF
The ptnoner's guilt innocence. The "a .stiou
whether he armed, bnt how ne used whether he
used st ~, the arms wncn ne was supposed TO have
carried IL was urseo ne,e .nas Inc arnuon Of tine
deceased smoue Ted 70 an aamsson 90 ms part OF su
sho 70 cecais'on nh, GO as IoPareu W We, eu! as
whsre he facts show the homc e ana where ne deeefs
cans INA. sne lohoee ~as 10 u .,,r s,. =
saeaoa OF .ne osurss ., e ,h or Tn
tufus.h Vi Juns'ee III .ne ~ VI s'o W. 20. ~.
oec,A ALTON o the wat s was p.epued io Ivy
saon a,AcS az nas .en.s " sun" suA, ue
made the hrst assauiti ,nst ne torea.oed, IN SUP
stance, the prisoner. Unless that be the use male
o. IL, ! suon'l !. Cu ns~ NJ use. Duos ,0u
Ia any uegree 70 .nas emu ,ns., Nv my. az n
smpy, oas'rsy cs w. h ,S II1 VI sa, ~ -
spewef 70 warning ,n ne wou,n Te assaa ss',e
mehs Mai lie Touu arisn' himself n,o.o s,ss y,
ipDu hhs Ioosolaoy ineI .no aos W Plovo wun ~ -
ohe'eu TO suon ipe,p e'a..oa nas oeea eussIseu'
none sun nas oocuIrcu 70 me- ihi rloak, pesn.p
IN gay ng tna. 10 tucn mas oeen
IL pas peh tuAses,su III .ne sIsu,n' )" .ue esh.e
on ,ne o!oer tae 'ai oeceaseu nso ue.snoeu, or na
oneiea 70 oeenu MS ne ase ss 'ne prs 'uor
as the prisoner was 'a' ,ue uecease9 Wa al
woud nave peen 70 pace ntnseit "a uenasce ., tne
law ana that, ne ntd sihn he prisoner IN defence Oh
MS I'VE, would nave oeen eqoivaeat 70 Staying we
sherh on .e scanou, s'1nuns .as,e W eAecuse tu'
mannA'e Oh cue s" seea usouss ms ms sapp'se uo,
me seuuen. .at, 60 soo, as sis y, isoper, s'sp
III yuosmSh. W uc hc's vi u's wpe auu vi, usyeAssi
ieaohea Me cuuciuson, !ns.hsu oy reason ana IN ,le
ther'Ise VI Iesso 'ni' 'ncy were suy as aiu'oItr
sna s'u., s, n0 wa" -, "f Ei ~ eaus 'ne w.. ~
oese', " mn NC .iss nm, as oae nos III uis
| pseaS y. ~. "eu "a VIC onsse ''asos, nv. e'ir'
VI .sen, .na'' IN .ne nAs@i vi law, ne mis ~.
| "a rue pesoo VI w. shu VI sue onnol o'A'es
ts, 90 rs 49,, % @ ue III H. w. , 70 W. y,
s VIZ ~ h ~ - s, - ~. 1 Sly uo p' ~.
.i :, we usi ~ ~ s :. ~ @ es nun, WIN ..e
=, ~, ', .fus nay ns' Ia W
p pun. ,. y , s ~ s ,c p nc no " spy gu
da We W. ao ' v~n ,'T, s ne ~ he.i as. o ,
,x, -, ~, 80 - s.S ~ - .n ss t',s e.. 500. uoe
u'o s y. e 49, 49, ~ W. a " wy nh'"u Sues,
. ~ y. ~ vi a pooo y, !" 10y supp1ss'
~ "a" " 49, ~ -, a - ~, ~ - nv, ,1u :.
% 49, W 49, =. ~. ny 100 VI Sou ~