New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1859-04-09

| that p fton Which hes bcsr The bscSnonei uEhe
fiRtt groove der yte loser surface; Il nsd- muSh
ctep,I gr TIE vuoe upper part OF the body
o. tie lett drey II old rot ore the greet "oi-ves
eel Of She body bot tvo Of The ft kiorey; Old
rot jure the twO great utks uor dd !; VII. I'd the
in'tsrss # tire stomach Il entered tue large ooe OF
the liver; sostonieA'y, II WAS siuin hal sc ine1 o'
the greet vein q the hser 81 ~ IsnsyeTse assure;
! DO not bros that | cen deacriost witnou' lnks
| lite tecni cal lsrgusge; II uansveised the Shoie
til hts, o lbe be If liver ARD ertered the night
cavity e TIE chest without 9Ocnoing tie llbgsi II
brose the eshtb ib All lodged drd tue skin the
lsft soe Of the chest C ntsip-d lsrg- q'suttr OF
J nOCc-s Quart 81 lest; altogether tue amount OF
I buFc sss betwse three eUd four quarts
q. Wac tbht a mortal uourd
Wi'rees-It xsa; eXGu.ired tie heart; there was
somep bst urusus sHoutt Of fairy deposit on the left
nee Of il, but the structure Of tue heart itset was
| hestfy.
o. You have minr,s7 described the course II this
bel passii i.fough the body; sust do 500 iner ss
scerfc g nen or iuu bsye been roe position OF the
! cscesseo EFT . tire tie wound was given
Dir. anton objected, saying tho; sAs question Tor
| iht Jury a. Try.
Tie District Attorney argued that the question was
| proper.
81 Brady deried that any physician was permitted
10 fJp's's op mon OF matter rot pur scieutlo
srd circunscribcc within the boundary snd limits OF
| scsuce.
MI Carlisle argued in favor OF the propriety Of the
Joe. The question is substantially whether from
The Orgsrs WoUbded ard those hot wounded, TIE de
Ct6ttC Htht hGNr hstb IN dLtfrtt ~ IrcuOaLL posi-
uoB. liluk he question is conpsteLt.
Exec ItiOu taker.
DisTrct. AtrCuey TO The wGess-Erom the course
arc direction # the bel, please sis;e shst WAS ths
Io- III tie rcess,d At tie time tie SCOT yas fired
NiIess-l beg permlssloD 10 p'clnIse my answer
by s8yirg that tBe O ps'O balls s al times
,,Iy tUituous and oIh ut 20 trace, bot my op ui1n
fuI % OF the tine il THIS case r. thai the BODY must
have been in Gems recu ,bent posture; 10 other
VOICE. tbBt Sir. kty must nsve been lyiog on his
Iitbt DE, the BODY tuued little over to the right
hId the sbCuideTs 3 tte higher than tue olps can
rot uI der,tt 10 bow the spleen Of the kduey aod the
liver could have been wounded 10 the precise maoner
they we're urtss the bOOy 10 that slilOu; bit
can understand that bal may have escspef the IN
iesIes, and stomach and great artery 10 dh1Iett
pos!tor slibough the probabilities are that lying IN
that posltion go eshst tuIUed TO the right, the
stomach iItestiuss tel fOrssT1, make toe probg-
b.ty u tb.I escape from toe bal the greater AN
Corrected nth the Army OF The United State Ne As
slstsIt Surgeon; ueasursby familiar with gunsn"t
Wourcs; baye 10 doubt that this wound wss inflicted
by pstos shot, bot in our IsGage We cal al Eodlds
| by fitarns gutsbOt WOutds.
q - G. ulo you give opinion - TO the style OF
! pistol With Which tins WOUND was III cted
Mr. Brady objected.
In, DlslIict-Auorney argued that tire question was
! proper.
The wI1.ss cot ut the ball himself, All thinks he
couln recognize it, It marked. Pistol bal hani-
| 60 10 wheel
Q.-ls that Il
Wirress-To the best Of my knowledge and belief,
Il g.: IT has TIE mark made on ii IN ny presence by
| Dr. Store or one eIsc'y he \.
90 VIA: particular c'aesidcstion Of pistols does
| Ia bal CCmLuD belong
Hr. Blady objected. lie did not know tnst ply.
sicab t1per. IN The manufacture OF hfe-arins
District tuusS- Certainly, If he l. physician IN
| the ar y If not, he ceunot dtcbsrge his do'y.
hr BGoy-i thirk he cen d-cbsIgc his duty With
| on dischnrgu fi cams, Lsnght,Gl.
Witness 10 Mr.. Carisl.l- rhs ~ the bali wa eI'
tratteo rom the ngot sdei IL IS tbs Only 0ail "e
iourd; the ball 10 the grOo Psssed torOush' tals
BAL On belpg applied 10 the DcfrOLer pttOi IN CONT
aIo wboh has laIse bore, is found to be- too large
Tor it, that there must have been ttirt pistol the
! bore Of the revolver beng ELI smaller witness
described the uatue of the wuuud 10 th- groin, say
irg, oug other ihIks, test II was rear the main
sIitry ard iust above the largest branch the Only
vess.l woupded Al e1terpai Veln-a he-n "ounf
its severity would depend on after Consequences Of
| dnarlly such wound would not be severe, bat
! II igbt have ltlt l6meDess FOR long tGc.
BY Mr.. Bredy-WitBesss atteIton WAS called I"
Nj Key by the rLOts be Heard no person aine or hi
! went INTO TIE Club.iorse ard found hun breathing
bis last: rot than six or seven persons were
there irclpC inc tao q oed meu to the best OF hs
belief, the Shi,e persons we're Messrs DoyIe, Martin
| UpsbW; WIS ROT certain that he ga" l,dpaIi tneie
person having charge ~ MT. hty, sthc'Iy
sye8krg; wac present when Mr. keys poke we're
searctod, took the opera case irom the left SIDE
pocket Of hs coat his Impression was that TIE case
vac coed empty; be saw two keys, hut coId not
ceutiy those exhibited; IL pulling Gown the pan'a'
oCDs, 10 ascertain the nature OF toe sound, he iet
! some loose money and the keys; he thought every
thing was BANGED 10 the Coroner; he brew no Guar
sct.lst!c prtsented by Itself which could determine,
from the abrasion, the conrse pnrsded 10y bail.
Nh Brady inquired Whether there were indicss
which would iIfalhby determine that al abrasion Was
mace with a ball or ufeaius.
W.i1e-s--Ite holes in the right side coat, waist
coat linen ard far mel SHIRT set.ed the matter 10 bls
mIpd but tals opinion was 10. itiaAlo.e, be merely
that the hole IL the clothes was male by the
! bdp.
MT Brady-Did You ever zee anything elsa that
| could nske such hole
Niine;s-No; iuoge from the frequency l nave
seen cOtbme pierced by shots.
Mr Bfady-Whst is the peculiarly Of hole IN
vest CT other cioth'rF, made By a ball
Witiess-lou s,k'd my opinion the marked peca
| lgIity ] cannot describe.
MT Bracy-Ycu have said that the course OF p'-
to- tall is frequently tar uOus ID tsere any law winch
! regulates euCu d cYUTse
N.tItst- Nom at al; the ball does not necessarily
/ 90 in the line - projection there u Dctniog but
post ort.In exsmu ation 10 tell the course OF 0al
After further uteTrog atCns upon tlrse points tne
| vIu,ss raid he thought M. hoy All NJ. Sekes
were nearly Of the hight hey was, prooao'y
J nye feet eleven inches.
/ Nj Brady-Supuo-e two men are engaged n
scuile u russell each enceavCIDg 10 overcome the
oh-T, struggling for life or death, one stte[hpt'
ny 10 ttIo~ toe other, one dscbDfslpg ps'o-is
there sly possible position Of the piItss "!ch "ou4d
! show q { snot could pTCdncc such 1 CouTse
! WiiDess-Ihe position vi the body must nave beco
/ or the light side with the shoulders little more
81. yated tbsb the hips tho body inclined to the nsht
whether the body supported ~ the arm ara not
| by anythu cse don't sLOw, toe course VI tns baii
NEST have psnot on The position OF the oooy, as
| have descrb,d II.
| Dr. Store who assisted at the post-mortem eIsmi.
ration, testted a. "a the character OF TOE soGlds,
ldei tl'Jipg the ball which taken from the body.
The iury took q reCsss at O'Clock FOR FIVE minutes
After recess Nj James \. Reed, sho sas examined
/ Yesterday vas recalled by the DISTINCT Attorney.