The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1859-08-23
TIE ALLEGED MoRrARA CASE.


-~~~~~~->~>~--
9ne Writ Dfsmissed ~ the Cou1s-..
$500, .s ArchbiSnop Hughes-ae e1~sAy
, C.u,r.a,cts mrs. Hsygerty's sSstsmshsS-
r.mm,ps, ACCOMPLISHMENTS u
C.-..~,-Aadrsss of Mrs. Hsggcrty-Ths
~Doubls-ae~ded Eagle" again. &C., &C.
SUPREME COURT-sPBCIAL TRRA.
Before aon. Judge Ingraham.
August q, 1SSs-Aana J. Ha00srty us Rev. d.. Gum
,u,sOs--rne court room densely crowded from an
..ry how this morning by an ssse age of ~ and
sepica par anxious to he the ds~omen In this OK
srsoromary aase Archbishop Hughes was present u an
carly hour, and was accommodated with seat Rae ne
rails, near the bench.
Mr. B. Fogerty, defendants counsel, then stated that
the esl,mony wac now all in and although they did not
sor moment msgioe there was anything to bs proved
mr. dsoroved on part Of Dr. Cummings, In s'ioA
20 tie matter yet as the name q 'ae Aroao'snop Oh
Nes York. Or Raghes hsd been used oy Two w'oesses-
Mrs Eagerly eonand that as oo'n OF them had
charged oslveIy that and Or Cummings had on one
epe,ed the house ITO East Twenty second street
ON the saae cas- that which the boy Was taEen
and that ,ney lad both left together, exhibiting feeD
D. Joy apd pleasure what had been done; and further
hat on subseqUem OCCASION after she had Called ut Dr.
Cumrpes' house, ana icing Informed that ne was not
b that ,hy prooeeoed TO the Of the ARCHBISHOP,
niefs for the boy they passed cut ana entered
c.rria.e wuhou. giving them any answer 70 their inq
If tns statement mas been made ey Witnesses 10
worthy of creo,t and Inc oAher ALEC halt
sBsve sDd ha fosl- thought It out oue 70 Archbishop
Bugnes opportunity should % corded TO him 70
Say the Court spd through os Court 70 toe
Con unty at large that he had no know leoge whatever
OF tbs transaction ae CONSIDERED, ALSO that
70 Or Gun misss every DON'T OF tns should
he fully explained order the utter fasty OF
this a,ro;ous charge mace agaost DIR. Cummings
Mr. Shafef-8fore lns; rs dooe woaia w,sn the steno
,rf ~ n.rn
Mr. Foger,y then read Srs. Hageertys testimony from
Mr. Jo-epo Bopdss s'enoerspner) Transcript, IN which
sbe STATED that sne had eeen Dr. Cum mipgs and
hiehop eushss IN l7b East Twenty
Afternoon Of the cay the oos as lost, and tna they left
boz ether osp ing lher books and II great joy
judge losrahsoi-Nfs Hasserty, do you remember the
persons n Tue house IN twenty second street,
Mrs Hagserty-Y g. sir tpinx could
@ % you them in Court uoS ~ A. Yes, sir (point-
ing TO archbishop aashes think that Old gentleman is
Who elssq A Or. Cummings there, that IA. man; /.
vse in the srernoon "nen tney came there, and they
kAo their books with them
Hr shaer-she ord not state thst she saw Archbishop
Hugnes and Or Cummings. Sne said toas there two
s~huemen, and that she vas told they Archbishop
Husnes and Dr. Cumming.
Jsoee states that these are the
persons
Archosnop Hughes then sworn ana testified Is fol-
Yeu are the Roman Catholic Prelase Of this docese2
A Yes, cir.
Do you know Mrs. Hsgserty, the lady present hereY
a
You have heard evidence - read from the s,eno
grsghers po,es, TO the alleged rseoty
second street, ana ALEC rs 10 the alleged occurrences
n twenty second street when she and ner met
Aad Dr. Cummings, and that you passed her. Be good
enough archbishop, 70 make statement to the Court
10 the unth OF fsisity Of mis- statement?
Archbishop Hug hes-I have only say tina. all this s
TO II 1t nad occurred Coma reported
that country aud cent TO his never Vas 10 any
pace ss this lady has sworn wss not with DR.. Cum
mugs | not q carriage with him. never re
ceea any message 90 this sucject at my house or else
WHERE sDd in short kDo nothing aoou. IL,
txcepr what may read 10 the De sspapers.
Judge lngrshaDa Save you beard anything OF this
ooS oelor.f Never, Your booo,; never head toe
Kane connected with this matter ueti IL In the
pape's
Q Nay ask II you have couvsrsed With Dr. Cum
o,sgs citation 10 ,his subjec,? A. l never DAD the
pleasure Of seeing Dr. Cummings since this mater oc
CURED, any in RELATION 20 It.
except persous shere pave visited no u,sot ave
read tre aud ASKED about mig
nsae remark; have DOT bao conversation DR.
CeUu,pgs sin e tn,s matter occurred
Cross- xampen by Mr. Snsier-Q Have you any re
collection IT person apply TO ana nesting
tnsTv,ew srh respect iost bog subsequently, 10 to-
>" O. JulyS A. No SIR; no MESSAGE was ever delivers
70 me- OF ,bsS description.
q Do you recosle0ta servant at any time telling 20
es' WOMAN naped Mss asggery desired an uservie'
vtn your A. have no recollection OF Il.
UO you recouoct st any time servant girl ten
you ib.. application made Az the ecor relative 10
loot Chiid, and nat the direcIed eiss
Mr. e B. Sh fer stated that be wished 70 make a 70
pbservaous I'm Ies pee to hs mater vneo zoe Lao
spped to ban TO procure 'bs grit end pressed ia "a
matter he stated 20 tost be OF
lscs that Or. CoDmoss bad OF sne Id,
be refused 10 commences pvocea5oss onsli sne ~o1l
tsts'y hiw and on the oGy Sdt o,tane1 a ate
pept Mss made ny hsr ami Der tnst tots Guild
The po-sess'on OF Dr. Cupniegs private e1,mioa
too In b's oftss b. oen gave 20 Mrs a4z
Perry, tod her tnst person should serve IL
Be was also Informed by Mr. ". ii Dr.
hikel, ~no served she wit, hss Dr. Cunmioss nat the
boy IN bs cha AZ the % day OF ne
ives Satisfied ths. scne n,sake had occurred,
Particularly when bs beard the ev1spce Of the Doctor
add corestcs IN HE house ae oiered % tue re
tpondsn 10 hase pa. sciaos 10 exsmne Mrs dags=rty
ADo II they you'd report coat she mad, ne seuld
drop the proceedings. de led n tos from the
Tact Of Dr. CawnDse' position, ard from the fact OF a
card frsn Craoocey Smaller, winch he considered
TIE Jo1se that such matters had any Dear
Ing in me
AZ. Soaer then proceeded, and stated had Of
fereo 70 sisp the evlderce bat that Dr Canmoes de
sired proceed 10 dc Touid move tnat lbsv be
permit, 10 sItbdrew toe writ, was 90, sur
h;Ient evoercs 10 warTaot them oeedlog further
sr j. B. Foeery ssii be you'd res Jectfuliy Oh
pose tDe Application OF me couoset ste
" umm Iss vas entitled TO decision from the Court
Mr. Soaer sbou'G have been eats6ed OF sanity OF h.
Client befUre he msde charge against gsntIerrso
In Dr. Cum iIg's position. Il would not 10 ID ssan dc
Cunm oss esy Sitn verdict Of proven, aud IA.
Court should give come expression of toe
case. Mr. Foger,y ~ great length opposed spJc4
called for u decision
Mrs Esgserty advanced to the counses table aud
spoke ss iou,ws:-5I, visa 10 speak wofu. | an
uob-i OF thai boy, ana wsh 10 relate 10
yoar do9or
Judge IngfahAm- You have been examined already.
You sert Theses letters, old you noS
M't aasgerty-No. Sir; did not degrade yself, he
mas Gone (poinnng 20 fr. soeeLY) Do you tninx, ne
these gentlemen 90, that An cfazy2 Loos a. me.
Jnose lDsrahan-Dd hot taese ellers In tLe
drug store2
Ma Haggerty-No, sir; know nothing about those
letters.
Q Did you uot know the srugep,9
"A NO, Ell, cont kno. ans surn man; and that au
INF FoPe'iy) has degraded the Lords doiy arit-tbe
boy oe aho niuiseil be has degraded high head
honorable o. hber,yrpe double headed e.ye the ere.t
Bosher OF our Un,op here tnst fellow brought
anu they were d'uoka DIS and prosnes aou tney sa.o
up everything against me- seen IN IN mouse
Or III faue, ano 70 one ever one and II tey
gay 40 toey must DC very low please your
am crazy ToDsD don. protect roy arsz aese yery
decenif ne s oeereotd tue mother of the Uooa even
pe save even TIE Church, preacaers ~i.h
upon iber pecHs; he has degraded HOiy WIT
Mr. Soafer-l wish 10 Say, your Honor wlsn tnis apo
catCn wac made 10 WIS maze good fa.n; ano wien fn
woman called upon zoe tod Innocent and o,f
bsofy taat she nad ios her boy bod was inform
&c tbee Dr. Cummings bad bin -ne dad not 20 on "a tn
rAnoDg way s'eo Sieh TO stae IL has oeea iot
ma. mot secret society toe American Az
feed ne