New-York daily tribune., 1859-12-26

aTt opinion oa tie 81. Noyember in the clse VI Bai-
sy sid others sl-nit the steamship Sonora, inre1ard
70 ibe +gLts Of ud cabin passengers in Californian
,ie r,slirs The Judge save n hlr opinion:
Hatress ia. the 'sssi waf eosaed wa Plensefs 20 al
ezfeft viieh though uo - sieei a en ~ ~
th.is eom5r, or prsbailS VITA be rIoyoBs ofihe a-
H - .Lo~n thai .or lss second seoia l-..enseTs ony -,
wahbarn' provided ihu' epr'ins i.eE aaf esPeeiy
,re suris, ofite means - ,ecuros rer.ona. eaness ~
maj tcvs OF staniee buuk. running fore aad s
were sIfs'sS on, N iss sso & ,ss he s srs IL .s IN
ed persons n d eut and srauseT 70 eseh
agents fhe Company 20 avoid bot spPess % h1ys Deen
made in iiis n.ienee probably on . ne sy o. PR
cry or 1bS.S. 5ssSi''i . We H''''' WIN -
sged that having foyed thai pyieg ihey have nothing .
m ~ n snd were aroused 10 the morning q, o. a which
tine p1eIarsiioDs Cor washing decks comnenoed
ufovu dow tie htichVay ihe second s5n nateiy or
Iucrs he gIes. g a1d slfs. ron a Pt 2 the vs,e
and hsgfsse piled Up n re pace and that tbs basrase
middle hnd de bebs and dsrtbls degree 70 prevent
that fro there and other causes the Of The
end cabin e such condition render he occupation i1
compabh iib comfort and perhaps wish heath Tact which
IL, ,, 80, sr5 srorg ter soe omen preferred 10 sleep
on deck with bedding and where they were
coz r s ,9 s6 5f Es he slnSr s furnished to The second
cabin during nearly the whole voyage ws 50 ho q e De una
charged cents pound foT the ice they oened io the pi
pose
ants, As showing bTelCh oI tuer contract
Il s. obvious that certain extent Of the dicoforts
conpned OF Incidental 10 vOyage Of this dccpt0n By
paseIee who had only the night 20 second cabin paslge u
could be claimed Or example, that each second cabn pa
should have had wshng basin 9r Dis exclusive use
mrh jnsy be expected that more than two basins would
be provided go That those who occupied the
second cabin should suffer discomfort from f3u ec
unavoidable considerable number Of pas.ensers cold
not placed cabin between decks without being sr
less arreeably situated than II they had occupied state rooms on
the sboye.
Bot hey he'd rs e1gse, that the floor Of their cabin
should ed into taRglge for the hrst cabin
bsegare that should be put in the cabin IN such
hunters make i minnsbabe and that the number on
board he vessel should not be 70 prevent the ordinary
Of ventilation a. opening Of port holes from beng
available
II stande births Of the construction testified 70 were 70 be
women least had ght 70 expect that they would not
be assigned pTomscuously 70 perfons Of dfee sex
That have been 70 arouse those no tept On
the cck very cary hour 70 the purpose Of wssng dees
be admitted Il yasseBgers chose nevertheless 70 occupy
the b. sad have bseu heir choice 70 DO
But this available % the compliant on t
boud appear that other accommodations Were aorded
TO passengers ich comfortable their contracts
entitled them claim, and ch they could have used without
injury 10 health or exposure TO physical suffering
haevcT difference Of opinion exist a. to y precise
character Of the Bodson TO which sec0Edclbn psen
gers are entitled such voyege the degree Of discomfort 20
which they must submit must think be conceded that they
entitled toll supply Of water ht % drnE 10
surely be caned 10 have been fultmet he ron
tract 10 ofer them hot which only palatsDe alter
being cooled with ice which the passengers obliged 70
purchase.