The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1858-05-30

lamacn itself Ansr noble aod usnly deo.raaia a
be Doble hieud (the Fart OF Eeaporouxpl TIssf.y
ne tnst DC alone was respoas'De for the pabca on q
tDe ossPAtcp us no LORD CnaSCc had thJugat tdSS
asuss geserous impnlse would have nOols
mover (the Earl OF sn.fesDufy) have abandoned h
the 0uoe said the people or Dude
lay prostrs before the BrtHh arms the auesnn arose
how they couc be tfesod sta veil a. jussics IL
necesssry doubt, 70 make terrible * a.
the mass Of the people, who had sclaa ed b.
tome o, tce strongest passons which cou astss the
human heart allowances ought have been aae
These feelings were shared by every member Capt
ret spd tbey ls bound 70 Dediatey wsea Ii ~
all the pr cp winch they Rht be ought to so,
Had they received ntmsti;n thst Lord Can ainx IN
would have been GOOD reason Tor toe sosw 20
It. right honorable gentleman fHr Smith who
hao withheld from government tho Wedge Of tho in
tended explanation sorsbo for tho despatch,
which would not have been written had that right hoaoss
bic gen'lem made Communication vita noble
tbA. noble earl hHa taken upoo himself the oy
of publishing the despach and had resigned, idle
70 ohooss that question He believed that such discus
sion Was wholly unnecessary, and that tho m0oa coad
not bstes be net haa By moving the previous qussoa
(Cheersl
losd had by his remarks with reference tho people OF
Dude, made cover. cefence Of the rebel army. Ono,
He would nat enter into the ssoa Of the divided
respous riliy Of Cabinet because perfectly
that the present instance the the act Of the
whole government and not that OF the noble carl (tns
Earl Of Eenbor0ugh) alone. This fully proved by
What had been saied N their places ia ParAsot, bsi
by the noble earl the head OF and By
sns Cn.ncslio, Of The E.Sheqass assr hssr Nothing
Canning The government light have remonstratsd with
him, and II they thought his proclaim nos indicated
ing him. No one could have blamed th,m for adopting
either Of these csurses but they had taken saoh
n,sres, or their oouriry me, had sent dsscseS which
was inr uitDg IN its TERMS and regard 70 which
with any seose OF personal honor could nesitse the
course he ought tn pursue (dear hear He would not
the question the mests or dement's OF the
Inexaiion OF Oude for they had mot Sufficient data
this sifsed wouls be found thai Lord
Canning tended only 70 claim the suzersinty
territory of osds ana not TO cenasca,s the property q
the great IN Asses of the people (aesr hsar)
Lnrr HOMOGENEOUS briefly opposed the motion.
Earl GRKr while declaring his willingness to effect
Approved Of the puhlcson Of ths ocspatch and OBJ
that the resignation Of Lord Ellen borough could
not free from responsibility the colleagues who hsd mot
rbe Duke OF NawcAsnE also reluctant TO daspse
tie preent ministry but felt impeed to vote for Lord
the Earl DsRBr gave Lord Canning credit for Having.
mp to the issue Of the proclamation, displayed
sa he Ssa Sees oaaosS v snv coosiSsrssss
TO depart frcm those principles. With regard ~
bs noble friend Qhe Earl Of EenborouShs)
despatch, he entirely cOnc0rred In he sentiments
In It, but with regard its publication he had
bad DO wecge OF it. BE had not beeo consulted
preclsmsirn Itself b,e uoon tho face Of an appearances
Of conasears the entire territory Oude and In such
n,ept II said that not intended 70 de-
pve the Inhabitants of the land which they ba1 horeo
fore possessed but the prooau alton expressly stated taat
mission to return ehoaid not be considered rs
ersta,emept in territorial rights. Under such circum
stances, the government were bound 70 IC' 1t
piaSs,oos we're Intended to be seui BY the Co
vernon General It impossible 70 account for
the conduct Of Mr. Vernon Smith In ~hhoding tho pri
lafs ~ vnrsi Nv n
IL appeared that had been submited the xsonlr
received 10 Lyd Panss7 so toho thOusM cs proasise
pd,i oI at eps unnecessayy 10 acqaint u: 0oper-
ut 'cih he iare faa that orphan aiovs cos,sg
lonse.s was 'ngos,ac to soy ysnt other asy. asa
than tvo MOI bs hao elapsed sncs as prcc sms.oo
forwarded not single word had been received BY NE
government which could 10 aoy WAY explAo the reasons
which bad ,nsuced the Goserpor General {, prepare
proclamation OF sweeping character In the absosos
OF al infor the government bound upoa
In which they had read Il, they thought thoco
was tot mon ent to be lost In returning daing
swer 70 It, In giving that auswer they felt that Ian
guage could hardly be TOO stoUg 70 their spprs
hersops OF ts queuoss and their dsspprovu Of
tone IN r. neral (Minsteral chees) they were, how
ever fortified the they By
the copion OF several gentlemen. amons others OF Sur
George Clerk, ultimately acqusioted vita tho Affairs f
India Nevertheless, " oic ne voocaed the sentiments
contained 10 the DESPATCH be regretted that the whole
nceed any part Of the despatch mai been laid The
"a le OF the House OF Commons at carly period He
thought, however, that government ought not DO
hele responsible for the act Of subor innate member OF
the 20 nment under the directions OF minter whe
hao admitted his sole responsibility. He begged "
mind noble lords opposite that 10 June 1885, tue noble
lord the member for the city OF London at that cs So
cretAry OF state FOR the Cooass sent On mssion W
Vienna In his capacity OF nipoteDtary he entered
into certain for areay which, when brought
home arc submitted 70 his colleagues approved
Tho noble loro however, did not resign; out
matters until . motioa introduced tho
House OF Commons, when the governmeot re1uda,sd all
responsibility, End ihrd John Resell resigned In COZ
cipsiop the noble earl epreaed their ordshps cot By
sfi' ming Of the resolutions 20 place tie g1Ugpmcnf
feeling that might De most disaros to ne intercs Of ss
Earl GRssymix den'ed that thoss who supported the
irsnuaton should have been thrown out against the
noble mever Che Earl OF Snsesbury) in consequence a
his borg realive OF LORD pamerstcn. II no IL.
cned 10 permn ire debate " sink low he might call
attention 10 q rumcr that In cchsur,g lord Gaming,
and ndueirg him 70 throw up hs Office, the noble carl
at tho bssa OF the sovcrDmont not entirely us-
Influenced by personal combinations. (Cheers The
noble cart then p'cecdea at esgsh 70 exsmas
incouss ncies OF the staeneos With 10 the pub
lcaOn Of the despaicb contspdpg tss tbs govsrnmeot
had ample time W reconsider their PROMISE aud that Par
lament voul1 have aoquicsoed they had honestly stated
that be detrimental public service pus-
lkhk An u wac published, the whole government
responsible for IT, He eotrcstcd the Hooss not 70 pat H.
self isse position BY asserting 10 tho previous qus
ton fer IA occasion would have the most fatal aad psrni
cious u1ueoce In India, whore would 20 forth taat Ne
Their ordship pa then divided the motion that the
Question be now put, when there were
toIsebG- fIttcnt....s...... sss..s.s. "
ffoNies %
Total contents ...................... LIS
Non. oopte Present. lis
Proxies. ........................ 10
Total non contents --lsT
Majority In favor OF the govern nent .......... o
The question therefore, declared carried
The announcement OF he numbers rcosved Win
much cheering from the opposition, account q We
smallpcss OF tho majority.
The House then adjourned.
Mr. cARDwyLL's MOTION IN TIE COMMONS
In tho Bousc OF Commons on l4tn instant, Mr.. CARD-
WE'LL rose 10 move the following resolution
Tia. As House. willis. in ia Of Information