The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1858-05-30


SsIrpess had seat copy 80 70 the honorable neooeS
for BrDn cham ,Mr. BrshO, Who he'd given noece On
sIslosy bst~etn Me cssss Of Lord Aberdeeo's goyra
pep and Of the Csbne In tho former Case nSy
refused allow the Duke Of Newcastle TO r.sso
The question which Affected him was ono sn'o Tue 20
hey Of tas Cabinet Bat, In the present. DssAace
IL not question Of policy bat mercy V sno y" mos
Borough would take upon himself As 70 tae snsgs.aoa
made tina. gcverDmsns ought 70 nave recAeI Lpra
Canning, tost Yves an alternative wn0n even nsd saSy
wished 10 do &c. which they di not they could
net for msu,fett reasons have embraced Zoe govern
ment moreover justified in hoping that the ooaasels
and otbsrs Who bpew the spIit Of the people Of
Dude would the Governor 6enera 10 ms
proclamation, and that although ne ms Ut wnnaraw
su that be practically mitigate is effects (ohssrs
Bad The known that an expaDanou ush, have
beep frou Lord Canning that would been
eood delay the mission Of the
and even the writing OF it. (Cheers) II Lord Canning
hao had reason compao OF any It Of bis friend
and colleague ar Vernon smital who mad ~tahelo IRON
the know ledge the government Lord Csnnings osenasd
explanation OF his prOcar alton. Cheers rhe right
honor Aole gentleman Mr Vernon Sm thy still could
imagine believe thar the words In Lord Canniogs letter
OF The slightest IN pofsnoe (LAugh'er sai cnoers)
Whether ne conceived them Of imporaoc6 or not, hs
deemed the letter sufficiently important - consult
the noble lord the member for rveston upon r.
cloud cheers) So Of sufficient mp0 lance 70 SHOW
10 the late Prime Minister, but not - tina President Of
the 3 ard OF Control rhe result sas that they nser
csptea The letter cloud chsers) Hs (tbs 5,licisar
GeDers thought the charge Of the pubicat had fallen
to The ground. The right honorable geat.emAn bad 40
csmston but he he Solicitor GcDera Appealed 90 them
TO and 10 let this subject ne slurrea over by
cap ous aud catching molten D prepared , ~ o'o1 70
cbeers lie APPEALED 10 the House ty dtsnc ce to DE-
clare 10 the people IF India thot the dynasty oah zoe are
about into that cosy not 10 BE- Of yec
less and ,ndiscrimnate clidtso'' Cloud and prolonged
cheers
condemn the government for entertaining different
opinions from those OF be Governor General ont for ex
pressing thoee opin in offensive and mpolisc terms
1SnpN
mtsed That the Kiig Of Dude was sti entitled 10 The
crown. II the despatch easily 70 be defended,
Why vas nora Eenoorooea srctncsm ne sneC1 o. ons
that If II had not emsnatAd from the Ministers OF the
Grown he would not have hes ated 10 Call
document 1t Was not An official blaoder, bat political
Mr. LINDSAY strongly objected N the policy OF c,ons,A
ton, and must therefore, oppose the mo,oo he c,ad
support il party Measure, for Al advanced
beral, be had expectations from the ~hgs add had
more 10 bope from the ministry nov IN office
LORD VANE TEMPEST SAID tbas IL vas air 70
discuss despatch without IKE discussing the pro
claIoaiion The policy Of Lord ElenDofoogn MAI always
be- that Of mercy.
Lord STANLEY said the government had desire 70
avoid inquiry into their conduct but hs bad 70 CON
plain tbstue right bosorshle gentleman Mr Card bad
upfsly limited the inquiry which II Wa practically i'm
possible 90 BY excluding the merits OF Lord CAooDgs
policy The charges sgaost the government we're two.
fold Fret there was the pubhoAsoo Of the despatch;
and secondly there the qnsstion Shether, surprising
D, was not published, ought 10 have oeeo written
at all He approached she first charge VIII great
pusa,ion of excupatog oneself al ihe EXPENSE OF q
colleague, and undouDted ability Aoc
He c1ud say that Who tost Den ;h h ID
hesrd Of the promise 10 or odaoe dssoa ch until men
toned 10 the House. and they then Learned 9Th
Il asked Why they dd not refuse t. give IT. hut the
promise having gwen ths pos ZOO VI che g,vero
nent wss altered Although they ought to have aooe 40
the public interest ia danger, could toe have ead
iha, the despatch which had been sent o,otained dc
clsrstion ther policy, aod that essential tue
safety of Iodla 10 Withhold ny Sacn poi,y M hsH
disclosure and half mys'ery would have oeen far wor g.
-tnf. "a
infinitely alarming than Il really vss (Coeers
He the promse nut o. two pabhc daogers the
govern ment had ch toe lesser. Cabinet Vas
spopsbe for ire coaouc Of ali ts members as long As
acquesced that conduct bot no BODY OF ,oIif be
b.d responsible for at which they regretted a. soon
a. they heard OF IL. and ciavo~sd (Cbeers They we're
charged the hope VI gaining popolary an1 svodias
responsibility He utterly denied the cosvge b, ~hai
language woud have BE- he'd If they hsa givea 40
irdstensbls the conduct OF eonent aai soI
leagues without deiberatoDf sucn not me ndoct OF
pubic men, and required DO defencen they hat allowed
tTinpg delay elsg In conterins their judgment
(Cheers) With respect TO the publication, although they
might BY arnces have prolonged ne Soild
mat nc eoveramsn, ives Jssnaso IN sa,n an
acted, but have kept their counsel -och course wss
simply impossible Publicity belonged 10 our ~oole osu-
tutons bse its advantages and is svie, which mus,
be osetter He toto tbey ought 70 have wa ed
and spared Lord CaDnngs feeoss But ~ss nothing else
10 have been cotsdeedf He'd they TO consider
effect OF general ascscon ave mioos OF osle
who we're armed Agairsius Delay ~oulo bui have req
dsred them more inns acaoe IN Their revenue and every
empire. (Hear, hcAr.) He regrettsd that the ps.
sages having reference to tne King of o de had been
Inserted M ire dcspstch- (hear, heAf but hey
written for The obvious reason OF polas,og out in.
partially the distinction between the coniuct OF
Sepoys and that Of the revosed population 81 DUDE
With W the condsca,on OF property under toe
proclamation, sAid vas only Intended u seixs the
rights Of rebetous eheftaine but they bal thsn Tor
uesses and we're surrounded By their armed rctAners
they not the clAse which should be driven o
despair. (Hear, hear But be had on the highest au
tborty thai the larger portion the Ouds
held by small osuers al OF whom would ne Affected
by n proclamation. IL said that voud have
been carried out 70 the full extent but still boz we're the
people Of Dude know that and what vonld be the effect
upon tbemY Letters had been received iron persons !,
India high In military rank, who dreaded vnAf the result
OF the proclamation would be. (Coeer) dc disspprov
ed Of the policy OF Lord Canning Indicated 10 the drs
PATCH and voad nos shrink from his share OF toe resoon
sbility OF snch drapprovA. (hcsr) Whatever The Vs.
Of the prescut debate might ne the government you'd
thanh the right honorable gentleman Eve Gard
WE'LL for bringing forward his moton for BY oong go,
be bad placed them 10 the poi OF the Oh ampDne of
right against ropq and fayer Geld fall q