New-York daily tribune., 1858-10-14
GENERAL TERM sUrREME COURT.

Be,.r, J.dses strong. Eu.0it aui Brown.
Tcln Cs.!v Re-. o,deni cat Cty of Brooklyn Appellant.
O. and T. Stevenson for .ponGeLt Samuel T. Johnson ~
Bytle Court. EuoTr. J.-This is an action against
the pref. Brooklyn uIon juogmcrt recovered 't
the iorr City Of William GA TIE del' 'adiut demaifra 90
lie cy cour, oyrred the demurrer .ni 'hc dendan aP.
i r. s.d leave of the Cont -hond haze ner 9n'
taut before bringing Le suit e.c.Iams 70 = Ih on - M & &
rel,,s the oelsi iadsment el sssin n /" iai,y ~
wlo. -r tAi.iecr {. lir -. , , G ~ y. - ' 4; ; -. N H.
erfo.t Ia lie Judgment, and therefore liable 10 D. sird
gp rmeut winch is evidence o that deb, The next
la fle prescul dtfrudan ifisbc G, bo
sued Judgment he, rght 70 meet tue qes's ~ o.ea
on the will be- suiccni - decide III question y u
should arise uyou the trial hr after lii were 'ey rfe
US however should have n' iy ~ aP.'- ol u. s
s.b Of tie alner Ciy ~ Wlansbursh The only gaiion
which material 'hrrrioi' Is "u5h'5 ~. OHs " y" ,l
burah owed this debt That ma been Determined ~ an s1n
btv n, plaintiff aid that city aud see reason Why th,t
yit aud parties l. is laid hat statute which the antirs
coueud imposes upon the conocsied Cry Of boosyn I'M %
i.son snd liability be- slrd or the debts Of the
- sf - " ~ i,c,I lin including udre than one subject
and hos. not expressed in th title. fesr matter Of dr.s
Of city or tie con-oldston OF uun P4.e, into
one subirct" within tue uoa,s oi ms al.e Ci iIe
Csti,lo there might be something IN th, Objection II
Iii ii.i t ld be pretty efecla baui. 70 any legs
son ~ha'y'e' Tire wa s WIN We see,Sa - Ds
has been clausei ,ui presume under he recett authorities
in The Couf. OF resort Judge would wsiusn t1at
the ogsu ofbd the regulation IN city charter oi al the
matters over city 70 have Jurisdiction or in az at
saw prov iors s6.tilr al the various rights Interests of
obligations o. the corporations 70 he corodeo y A aeh
wi'ch rnsy be involved.
p,S cor ,hs the plaintiff mistaken his remedy
that be should applied the sap-T ors AID C1mon
OF Brooslyu, which included IN 'he former Cy OF WI
n infer that this APPLICATION wrre REFUSED ne
counsel ht maudsinas should Issue Tia; cn ony be
If there csu BE- DO other remedy.
ulaudsu will he granted where sl can BE- brought.
this pre ssive WI; the ordinary process for collecting
lie question. therefore se whether ne psesen, City Of
Brooklyn by 10. 80 { consoda;io s de liable = rd9e'
If ,le former City Of WamsbuigA, aad 50, whether ai'
liability he enforced ty init in he ordinary ay ~ nhrarr
any aode NiDted oui 10 iho.e eredtoI. aaa they 'e
uiited mode Of asserting eis rights Il Is noi easy 20
how doubt exist upon me ms o THESE 9ls'L-
The act consolidate The Cities OF Brookr and Niirs
brgh and tie Town Of bushwick Ac se Lave el lg2i -
ssa y of Tide Xi, tp s2l euast' ,nat al Liabilities oi
either thai is ,iiheI tae former oics OF bo9sl1n ~
WhAusburgL Town Of Bushwick II l-'f - hiTi p.,ts
Lsl be t-ued b. and Insy B. erorcsl s-a'' me NS ~
Brooklyn hsrrtv ncorPora'ed iue'" so..e, als ~ on.
BE- assumed but enforced. Ano may D. ooiNd thN nc
rrrs,u city s,aucs h. the place o. hr CITY OF NiansoHrEh
lust the former Cry o Brooklyn Ihe leAny o.
tsue usA,s difference; tie city j 20 Al in;ens the
lu,r Of Wiainsbagh and Blsa~ick /: . That Oi ne
Is ,ali tlai exist fnd Of which m de
udsn csu pas t ignc. aEaus, T. lretc, es-oT az tAi
il can hardly supposed TIA, the Legislature would place
Mirirsl CoTorataa srch suatru - 20 ueccs tate
s. 80 =. MN. nv by She-a 20 pay deb;s II
, frsabc TIA, the L-gislEfrre would terminate ihc rA
.n- Of Muural Corporation, by blending with others
~ tin sud leave is creditor. wiiiol; any rrriy ior
h~r u., detts would other them - ssi ne -rn oi t
,i;,;. of tb- new Municipality before they obtain
n ~ citv .rli- the debt. of ,s
,-es..o. which has ABSORBED ard must e to provide
-s, 70 rav lose debts would 10 own whrii ney are
vi.on la. y, been usa, Tacre nothing in the Charter
eonfnin III creditor. the ey 20 o pees4t
or Or 1.a ,. >, ,Ss s S!Stlh h va. ffey City
the ccn.ahd..ioa ha Dis,rt has no lonset separate
rnunisir eAs.ence. The -, tis A. l. Per.- sits com
Iaeneea b,ru the conso,on % ee 49, & "a = " =,
ei,ltr Of lien, But that /, r- Of procsdsre Iae
db h.y tecome asss Of .he Lew cy and B! ;ss g''sa