New-York daily tribune., 1858-07-08

wen M,s ~ cA-,.u d-c~ 1. ,er As.s Ike a mud.
;ui;,s. He essa te-e tie ssGc chsrsc.
ter. Ibe Rsv. M. job ecu sisoisdl,s Mr.. DIcknsn
Charlie c liver, o'rs.l II Irs Brown, vac hAd hsed
Will het slre iile bos-te-, "a ,r-red o,' of
Yer h.rse Eten she discovered ts char csr acd tHsn
c.untrced bis sbass ei ter, which wss ths red
ten Csai'ss Co'ssr, s'st'rs that be rsves vet TO
b. ard left Judge Culver here; irds-d tee Judge
ne, er there sfisr 10 oelcCk Hs ha5 osver heard
sryttirr pee teiw er the Judge Gri 5 Brcwr
wiich wee II 50 icrproPer character or het ~sen her
arc aIy body else. WesteEve.i cane % htn sod VS.
aIx - q - sOcs. Lex 81 AKA Judge Culver. T.tss
Jscob' testified that ChsIl.s C9rvcl.s s'sersr, VS.
scu.n ofs!ro1g pregd'Ces, scd soe" her as 20 bs
ic Dice. T. cctclGsicr, Judge Gu Var ssksd lis
Council uot orly prom unce IN tee regularity OF tie
rIeos.ciIgs, hut sisO on TIE uoiits of tie c'-e. .
- n,fes e TIE ms ~ were ny fec 10 peak, 7
they hsd s-ght to say. There rss serce, sc- an sc
iaUIfE.srt icr ies.
II tie evtriug there wss srss; d,l.y s6ou: set,oz
Tettter; tte two G-vsIccrs wee pr1e'ui; A'es
rsitir fsr more Tran II OF hour the C1urc o-gan.
iltd sId Jusge B.KtR of butiao moved that the
REV bTs % tte church Ireson throuEa oee 0, * oi
thtr nun br be requested 70 sfs'e ~nethsr tue csse
lad beer fsilly pftserted TO the Council
Er. NALTSTISE sisted ths +, Eos member s, N,
IN " TIE disuisssl cf Jrdgs Cuve-, bu' 81 the trs
restirs tberesfter WITHDREW. He hsd been surprised
ths tie could be presented 80 Clearly snd fuuy
arf lie rtCustt f tier. hsd teen suy uleteke 10 pre-
,tlrrg tte csse Judge Culver had erred IN not pre-
sertirg il IS blsck g. II Fss IRE Council mgQt tally
Isy upon the statement which hsd been msds.
Gov. BRrGGs-In Your opinion 'he case sssus
Juoee Cciyer ard Ms. Brown tss bsen stated nsre -
stlcrgly ss it sppe.red II the Church mestiags
NJ. NALTSrlSE-Quits as strongly. IRE oLy eN
frerce Is lat Judge Cover then manifested coHscer-
she wsrmtn a. tines wEicn perhaps was not est'reIy
Chiistisg IKE.
Mr.. Wells co5roborsled the ~.stement Of Mr. Nal-
sn. ne. He stated that rot word wss ssid 10 rels-
ton 10 tire cause of Mr.. Brovas exclusion iu ths
minutes.
Mr. NICHOLS eaid that Brother Culver had no.
shown much feelrg IL giving hi sta'eusr, 81 the
Committee il making ia report 20 le Church, or the
C.urch IL sctfg upcp tee report.
Judge Culver then stated tha. he desired 20 suS-
eest fual poi,t ~ the Culci the procuring caaae
e this extraordinary procedure He had felt thst the
real cause was rot put forward. lie nsd oesn nei
with the obi, ctcn ihs he dstsrded he csse not 81
Christian hus LAWYER. At the last rae'irg ne de-
marded ar irstsrce. deacon seid th, he hsd de-
msrGed copies of TIE papers. This ~ then showed
10 be Ia sccciasrce with The Church ho,k No other
instaTce giycn. The Hrst difficulty shCn ne ever
had with IT, pss'or
Ex-Gcv BRIGGs-It seems 20 ne that Wa have
rotbrg 20 30 with the motives If tie church. We
can't Try the church st ALL We s'e 20 judge upon
the fscts pIessited whether there is ANYTHING winch
stou.6 c.use ue 70 withdraw fellowship from you.
Mr. RICHARDsoS Of Albsny thought the Ju9se
might De permitted 20 stow the motives for so extra
Oldirsry pro ecuti0n.
judge CUlyFR-Ihere wss 40 TIC talk about excud-
irg n for seeding I'd ksrsss notice 70 oe read
Gov. BsIGGs-I hope thst We saall keep ksnsas
out We aave nothing to do with the motives of the
Church.
Mr. Gum hoped thst Bro. Culve would be al
owed 10 state ary facts which would ierc TO exPlaa
this MISTER
Gov. BRIGcs-We cant try tbs obu, ch. II Br. Cal
Yer shows tat the proceedlree egsrs him are DOT
81 ficert 20 lead us 20 xthdrag eilo <ship We
tsy So We lDust proceed With ths utmost caution ana
precision.
resolution -tsting that their judgment nothing hsc
Tudg VA q n
then fellowship.
Judge CrryrR I'd that be inclined u waive further
hesrirg. lie added tact which ho hst omitted.
Deacon Story attempted to face him down on 5 i;ct
IN his evidence and would have done so, had not ne
hed four witreases 70 prove Il. He submitted ths
whole Gaze asked the counsel espec,sy 40, 20 %
rcS SS1 s seds e etuMf M al no believe that %
6ividrss were TO he eersursd and church 10 escape
censure entirety because y was church.
Mir. HoLDKIEGE, AZ aged member OF the Church,
Of whose fslnily ten were meubers If the C5urch,
etesteo the Truth of Mr Caivers s.stemens, most of
which WEIR, indeed, resd from dOcumeuts, ana Gov.
BkIGGs followed o An able ststemeut oi the Srongs
which Jrdge Culver had suffered at me hands Of the
Church under tie hypothetical form.
At tits tine, shout ~ O'clock ?. n Mr. THOMAS
GILBERT. cne Of tbs majority sppea7Ad and ssksd TO
be heard. A. he had 10 suhon'y to represent the
Ctu .b The Couf eli declined g. l'sten 70 him.
Alter sore technical Discus ion ths Council went
into secret sessop the Official report OF which Ie 81
i.lows:
Gov. BRIGGs offered tbs following resolution, which
wbs III animously adopted.
Resolrtd By this fGre Cornell called By JtGe Cayer
sr6 62 oksr f1rnbers Of IN. Ft hsp. Church e WILLIAMS
bush that by the evidence pro iucd before by said C1se
there has notscs sFpsd IN opinion assins tte Chd",1
oar,c,tr 0. sale Culver Of Ms mary Brown tho. should
deter prevent other BaDts Chl from '1E or h)d
r7 fell ship witt hsu Notwithstanding their expulsion from
the First Bspt'st Church of Wniawsoulgh
P,oe,d Thst 'be Hon Judge Bsser ofBuflo Goo fetehe
and Gov Briggs Of Mass, ee COMMITTEE to pre-
psrr report the eyeIc. before ard te ocsedngs aid Rs
suits OF toe Council RYLAkD FLETCHER, Chairman.
6 RESIkCToS, Secretary