New-York daily tribune., 1858-08-02


ktssassC HEeRNC ASD VALENTINE BrriLs
UENTLtAIX: Your sspar.ie chanenses vos tern f1f~
of July ~, have 20 nJ notice Your ehAspse' M
ring b unasI op,n and Dc,6u,, and evidently ineno7a
BE- uLcer yCur immediate control ana 'uPer''s -
say "Ipil put Up s2S0" kc Into whose h'nes an "
whom spfontsd yos appoint them, sns evidently -
ssh. next that A Committee 'bs be sPPo'n'eo y 'po'
intesd tie tIisl," Sc by Dho11 EVde1'S "
YOU i.sio the power AID thereby e1ptc' 70 .oUe %
Your eal,.p.e Mes,rs Valentine Butler I" ecnnlcs e
so,. rs.nins requDz Safe d. not pretend b
mai. a tee, with ss yon do not manufacture you
Admit ib. y.por or emitted from your hnz o7 Hcn
the contents a e SAFE preserved IN case Of hre ln the s
uns "The saf, te,tsd be free from dsmpness The
b.Ie.,. 10 made ard virtually withdrawn II i' simply
,8ps,on a. 1esaton Besnrns boldly, ending oowsrdly
gepceuen your challenged vii badly your furpose to
stos dedge the proposition made you hrorsh The pie" for
,e.t Of SAFES That proposition fair practical AID entirely
beyond lac reach Of iricksry svohtsm lsyns 'und
tion ,rceIty bread for all sBEETfRos SFE MAHERs and
n,,s1 10 ssud upoua propoion has been fsyorsby
by the pubic published nd commented upon by the
prsn hrouiboc. the country with uniform Terms o sppio
bon and one easily disposed OF yo1 msy sppeaenc
se public eye is upon you and has already discovered
vor inability prsys alton IN eyading the eit you are
nj With your lofty son and the assertions made
daily ycar Offices that my Safes not feproof fox this
were you would sep propontion obge me % put up
&15l vsDqush me- and money 70 proclaim my defeat
Ceutsuen the public patrons and have tight to
ssDsnd equitable and dseire n' Of respective SAFES
They have unDsak,by ssined my pro3,sition You m1s
socep. it. you will b. held responsible by discerning p'As
your acceptance your du7lieiiy aud evasion
Tbs, misspprehens0n may exist a. 70 ihe meaning my
propAition, | sgsin reppbish II:
"TteHsyors ofhe Cities Of New York aud Troy anal ao'
sree upon Jurors be c mechanics aud thrse
men bsh scientific attainment who shall have u Po~efo
nveasate aud se this ques son They shall examine the coz
strucon respective Safe. and Locks in use a2d In store
ts eu, by FIRE one they please IN Tr.cty p'
yse 81 test burglar proof qualities s. will best eso
U.b ,sir merits or dems examine the construction OF all
csses or degrees burglar and fire proof combined aud their
ANNUAL vre aud decay make out their report
in fu eabsg every mPos item Of Information ofintersf
to TIE public decide dcy ard unmistakaby 0ho makes
tie be.t
BURGLAR AND CoNGINED BURGLAR AID FIRE PROOF SAiLi
from which decision neither party shall conrovert or take
any exception Five thousand dollars shall be placed IN The
bspds said Msyor five hundred dollars by each
marty desy expenses except the Sfs tested which each
shall flemish required, and the balance II any shall be
expended publishing said repoI; IN the principal ces OF the
United States"
Now Sir, in my former iep,s 70 you, Mr. Herring have
shown satisfactorily your Safes hare failed rtensrey in
fires to wits at Troy Ws,eItown Green Bay, and 81. Louis
How msny Of these Champions" is unknowp, but probs
BY most Of he the Wilder patent according your former
pretensousl would not have failed generally have also
shown tbst the Champion poorly stood the FIRE at Es'ton
and WGsmpo Pa And the latter place three out Of five
permitted b. opened publicly but removed
and ner1 or hto,d from. iou admit by silence that
your ChtmpioIs out and become worthless both
against fire and theses Also that your Halls Patent Powder
proof Lock Is Orhess against Burglars aud only the
purpose Of button, and that your Safes afford security
sgs thieves except made order You continue to publish
that proof Safes have failed In accidental fires Let
tes the evidence Of your bengs. will forfeit 00 pon
your furnishing legal proof that of my Srs
sold have failed 10 preserve their contents through the
hce. fe evidence be taken before magistrate Of aud
city Troy my presence who shall hold the money and
decide 'be question.
You closng be Mt Herring exhibits substantial evidence
M yorr Tricks smother sxpedert to draw ne OF in part
from original purpose Your Safes must be tetted with mine
Oh their merits the nformson the public want
Now Sir e, in conclusion to you and Al my Shee'
iron Safe opponents abandon your special pleadns join
issue aid come directly Trial. aud submit the case to an mpsf
tisl ury a. proposed and merit will have its reward
T,oy J,ly 90 1883 LEWIS LILLE.
LiltIY's WROUGHT BAR AND CALLED iRoN BURGLAR MD
FlsI.FRoof SAfEs ana VAULT DooRs,
fastened with
Iutt.,s tNrENrTRABLE POWDER AND BURGLARPRoOF COM
BNAIIOs LOck,
the only .ecmity that will stand the scientific and before
an applied by the bugls e the present day Atu
ss.oitmen; on hand a. my ssency.
FMRBAxxs & Co, No. lse Broadway N. Y.