New-York daily tribune., 1858-11-02
SUPREME COURr-GESERAL TERM-Noy. l-Before
Jusxes CAVES, IsGVAaHAa and SUTHERLAND.
THY BROADWAY RAILROAD Chss.


II. complaint in this cause filed by the plain
as stns Eat they Of lota Broadway with
buildinss -rcctri Thereon, sud doing business therein
That defendants about construct railway theren
without legal authority And that SUCH railway would be specially
The Jud,o at srera Torn before whom the tried
found matter Of fact:
buildings UPON said street ard Of the o,. o land npn which
d budna' erected as particularly Sc. forth N the CON-
os and Tor several
seorStTst tho establishment Of rao,d in Broadway
aforesaid will DO special injurious T. TIE sais property Of me
nn ,h finding gmont was entered p-rp.u,ly snjoia
!us anl restraining defendants from entering INTO or upon
.sd street. Broadway or purpose Of aging or es,ab
fishing therein the referred 10 in the com
from ths. jut mont .ppes hss been taken BY the defend
Dayi Du1ey Field for appellants o. C. Bronson aud J. Van
d, ne Cott Dari-, Pyesiding The only question neos
.s, 70 this appeal whether upon the hcts found
the plaintiffs can maintain ss action and If co. are entitled ~
1t appear thai both ponts have been settled in
P.mer sst these defendant. bar. Tns Mayor sa Of
New YORK. IL X krnan 5S IA sait r-issing 70 thi.
that other questions proseuttd aud
case. ard decided BY the Court but IL seems 70
that The points yessntec a.o prssn.ed
Denio { j. In delivering the opinion Of the Court In that
c.s ss,s i. vel ettled that where Chat
ru2oc-l likely occasion special >ifJ
to one individual which well be compensated dan.
ares equity will entertain jurisdiction Of the Gaze At MS cont
authorities % sustain ih,, poston "sht
j. delivered tbs dissenting opinion Of as Court y
ooncgrred in this view Of the A" Tor De a,' FaIe P;r
con. o.ud Interfere except thr act sthr,d tended 20 th-
creation Of public OF pra'e nuisance specially inJaIi9ls -
thea and om which they sPPFeheuded direct special d"
la tia. eA.e It proven thai the plaintiffs tho
Of o,s On Brosi~ay and as sup of Court ioid a,
of fact, shat the railway would nos be nuisance, or
specially injurious ~ the plaintiffs ,-
tn appearing she plaintiffs the ot lots on
tie Of Special Term On the authority OF na C"At
Of app Al. n p.'. .Hd Palmer as Inc same dei"ns~H''
Jud yInenS affirmed with costa
Meyrr H. Meyer AT L.on Var coaen =. al HenpF
Turner Is:. tEs same Fsp FFsnkenAeiner ct a. .s 'ns
Jupos svrHERIAsD.-The complaints in these
three raay b oon.sred int IN looking At he qa,,
to1s raised By the tsuuers = the COMPLAINT Eaca c"mP'
ne-l.--aess Eola LIZ ha ol Ds iou1z Ne'mAh
s. hrG. 20 the pa n.a ,2ntfi ,e. Ut he Jsn c"n-'s
eTs5n o. ,uch indebtedness AID .ss, fol 1dne-l 1f s4c IL
all the defendants TIE complaint. l9ea alleys
certain :aess sho~ Ven Colen liable general Partasf
sho 60 osnsy BY The terms of tne pansAp lie "a' ~ %
-E-clsl psitner only, AID il-tls only IS such. -,
The complaints .so sege vcret oous!,e and ifadu7a.
eonies'on ol judgment By Dc Yogn- Nsgasn ssaa.l.@
Van Cee yI tie Pg;2Se Of hndeFia- dcsyas AID assa
he creditor, 4 Tie t that tic driralsa rierg. s.h
IN. a. tis deaisht. from a.'snns Or q .a ps.ssi
t ssy sts E snsa ,Ds T., :. src,sa s re-
.tranE Van cos1 on ef.. on Or ,5osI' "a . -n
II lA- hand, 4 lie sh-.lf, aud for Eeael'.s
The grounds Il The demurrer are; s,.. ,.., -
-G. la. -rvsai casse. Of .e.ioa have ba Improperly
seen II the Cod- defines en- action b. ordinary 2'
eeels n eeaf u justice " oss p.ity '-a.4' ' or ~
prevention 81 -rons So e.ase Of acton De dshard
70 be tie TAt wah Ys;.y Ia. ~ a-ie.e - ce'J S-s-
ssch proceeding. -, -.
Tkr e. r,pl..u. sa,es he facts showing this rght
Tie UNITY "a. ycEt enforced or Of he cro"9 |" -
redrss.ed cor n.ttutss tie unity % tAe sctSo2 -,
The ~ u .ou yocs4ins depends on re naif- u n'
enforced 20 De IeMecl-f, c ne LLa OF
uu.roun-ss II The pf3ce-dals tn an s;lDa Goes ~. 49,
unity tie s.a which De ends -osJ 90 'a- aJ y s
10 ,s:ey enforced OF "a wrong - oe o'PeeJ
rstr,ssE.
L. actions IN collect isbs the se d-ts-'oa Or ro
rs,aeut II =. .ebt. and the vrorE ta- been eope-y -
dressed has got lis MONEY; az otA4iAy
action or tie Lection oi cro s-es "iIA me
iuczuler and execution for osr sy judgment nd .s n
enforce the collection payment Of tns onsy o' eJ 40
not then tie creditor tsvIG acquired AZ adfnonsi nsn, OK
sacnc len on tie concealed property 81 ais DEBTOR can com
other proceecrfs acton II ad oi as u1zsns
La cro ether Tor ne Yf-- o ais
cov.rrz srv properly r-roviEs sdssns A
st-.ctioa q way of bis .Ssov,on . - .x
Wiho.t .ch Judgment aid uxrcutic., h- has no r<r
Other 4v.e Of accu AID no greater better 20 Hr prop
err, of n, debtor proceeds ereof issn asJ os
tor u Ike position Nov in thee sc.oas me corr
forth are inc.ttednes and scts 20 sao~ oa; ssn
liable o.hrr defendants, ard claim Judkenl ~
io- The debt The facts stated 40
sf,ci.rl 10 make Van Calem haele. The o'nps g 80
therefore sevrr~J cot tain cssse VI sclcn si- II
ordinary j1dgr1ent remedy for ths recovery q -
Fret zru1ri therefore. ssu ,s1 81
cars- ,be eomrlaiasns OLy AK fo sndn.,.
Junction, and ir effect 70 -. So
iud xn-n confessed var Caiem-reuecre ,s-sr I,I-
clearly eu.t.ed % bsore they 80, !. .io
meats fFi-pt~.fs axt Joei k-rnsD -. - - an.
ma Tie colisia nly o.eer VI ssaon 90 's. A..
esGse of setoni Cert.1ly aot ssesa'e '" -"