The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1858-09-18
OPINfOs-IN3R AHAM .

supreme Court-spcciaI Term.
oPisios-Is3R .HAAJ.
ls 81 1 sss: a. I've s.s ras rs. N .sssa
6rsrxe ~ the name Of The peooie ana Flag as poup.
behalf ard on s-A.e Il osr I saa sI
psosesdlns. usoa p-.yiss
S scrs BY he MAJ e set IA
city New fot may ee erjcinec from compisns the pur
ss S vo %
s. Ss- c .a '
toe beard Councmen ana which lag.
q ss s: p
smss ne Ss Who
approved thereof and OF The s 70 The property therein de-
The deed vas rendered 70 the Mayor and Comptroller -ho
ousn 'I s.aas q IN scon sSsns he Mavor as
Anc sssr dem ,he amount Of The considersan
% ne sss Ss SouS on upon
s far % saS %srs Q tho ''
The cospi.in lssss vsr'cu. reasons: such van, Of
-6y the resoluoI and moi q The comvs1sr ,h. ne
1S & in % h sssouon f se ensse he ON
Council getty Of an abuse Of trust and uspson In
have sied der answer denying the allegations upon which
BY this II inc
Staying proceednss a-on required 70 he
n Ss Of s as 1s 9ss
since hs order was made the General Term OF this dis
ict has decided that tar payer could maintain such an
Ibis dec-oa would control 70 tins m.n,eo.nce OF
this acton in be pame Of saI pxyer whstever might be
Term Aac SO ,ht this action iae
YOU'D be soona 70 dismiss The 'ae' 'a'
as people s The STATE are ss OneS s =, plaintiffs and the
action against municipal corporation for any alleged fraud
poss. sses BY hem under hsr ohssr H'
froossdinss y way q have brought
% n zee boon. Al zee prossesoss hs's rsos.eai
n vioAt Of s charters from exercising
In Attorney General W. the Birmingham and oxford
Ea.lrosS co~psOy La. NJ r: p 49, ne LORD
poweT 70 restrain publc comps nes from dong 40
ssss ses are :as,s n:sr,er.s y.
w0a sgAr,sd 10 70 e zone that he may restrain IL. aeug
Again where sets are 5ens doae pjusious q the pubic
interest iDasTueh as the pubic inter might o:asr wise
riiy % represent the pucac 7
Is SAD The Court has stirton 70 relieve against sou
are .es.oSs ,,d seGP, =. u,. IMAM
saass CSmEssy !os1 "a Eeg ~ sss 2 h9
doubt
- sss a. sees. ., he oGss p 3 s
mesor sections 42s and $50 specifying IN what The
scope he 1s 4rs AZ anon N me name OF Toe
II must be observed however. that all these cases
people OF The STATE How far action sy be
Dseess.ry for Of
acton rs. &c ia The name tSe .
municp corporations IN have no ees,su In
ned . d. erten. which ia sought n ID tsis
q p5 vs5 ,he r snduI,I !, se ~ rrSsr Il Is.
corpcrse properly snd The doing o. acts no ty
However uswise. mp,oydert. s1ersy.g,nt. uvness.
make lie Aorus Ses9 nor say Ias s.
In my iudsTsst any riss, TO Interfere BY aston IA b. il
charter Q provide ss and r.sui.ie TIE, t.ve me
~
sSs IN csnfe1Tse Al Essesa.ry peer . carr Into
idle grant g the city suhorss confer them he frsE
q he sane e ~sSois he power e prosurr he place
where such market .hoad Be built II would be IN lie
the which they shouh thus essbsA AID yer pro
hibi hem from purchaser e phase necessary for earning
S.f -. ..a 3 nc !, ssu sa ,ss u. TTuccs
the city charter. necessarily with the right per
Butt ss,s even o. power is controlled BY the
.ss ma, hole s s % 5so9os oSs s RS, n,, sss
o. lanes pS s5eeeecns In the whole the clear yearly value
vent Questioned whether, under TIE v.'.ou. acts
q he .sgssg.s any io.cs remains N ,Hs na.sscp The
chsss anss Which r exceed n value and rem, the soGn,
IL ssauied III. provision an rsnss.ed auss,ory The
n Ss M aas oas Isuas q S n
crcss. Which has taken pace In the properly pufchacsi en-
there .ra reasons Why appy % The Pur
rcs Il. Ts.son before stated ,ss, The sh, % e..Oitas
be ORDERED es.ssAse snd erected b. Toe o0nOa ccuac
eree.sc : - N'' '""- " ''1 '''A -
No reveua. 70 he derived from the Ianas purchased for
he cy .ahorilee % re,eve sges ieyenqs ser-fore
Sss s o. :. re- Common Of JRogs Soa: sa s
The teTsa:5re cons mpi, ei the increase Of the cry
the q be Z asssni. Cpasr suss cfe1ms,src..
CITY E,ps tse tss ms,kei. Dsedsd Y BEN should awe
me CeporA deprived them CT the TAO
mes az .q''sss4 y the Of S-:.sgu
s.ry ior ae s,.rsss y n, po.e. .e rpies Tie peser
rsS ss, ss.cs os ensre.sse .srus lsss and here
Tor. ne o.mnon Soasei bad he ,oowsr 2 pr.
ms,, Of nsfiei a.seust IN is oSer pF'vs .,
as q H. s nc 3. We s s s , AM. M
The ,vo proysoss q ne charter be construed
psa d. pSrcs%. II Sis ~ 5. ry Tor Cher ou,ross.
oi he rsh previously conisrrsd o erect sss sa.sss
R.rsr. .as e. 70 purchase Aads
1hsse YES, dispose q ,ss c,jsca,o ,hs y. cannsn
Ss ssa ssesssed he nsos carer a 3
s@osa, q rs,i s.'s ~ -ers assS,,se . hoe M
~ he ch,rsr eSeeuty. business rs nd Be pe o-nca
mens.
wheu; coping % sI.uine he qassisn whs.ar ss gur
se -h'I .. nssrrE Q, ne ch..'r q .hish er.as
Common Co.'S c fgr he purchase Ct els ls1d vp alton n
Ssctou. ftec arnentci charter zae rnaoluuon
hoSErr be purcssse directs Ye Coupvolsr % make
tie p~frhsee he Of a wkrSet, Emiinz him
. price, sB6 defining Dimensions u the
lAnd b purchased Ih- Cor1eoier hsd preousiy i'd
reraec for and received fr hs % he land IN
thAi Srrecoi snd bsd shusee sur5 propcsa'e The
C0u Counni The sslecr from ihoss oTes 81 he lard
ts MgeS for he purposes enp'aed and he hGsnr
a u prize l.gstve sod sKecuive 49, within
ID pcvrce 81 he Cen Council ard properly eKerosed
~ Acn The euy tbs wa erecsve vss mssiDg The ccn
-, * s sss snS nssns 20 an. Ia
far AaythrR appeas before crecUTe act
pe-fornsc y senrted 70 be pericm.d. b. she Common
a. A. t~k4- F~n~. -.