Vermont phÅ“nix. [volume] (Brattleboro, Vt.) 1834-1955, 1858-08-07

~ r. " ~ 49,
s'oiees m su ol 'le inoineht
'i! W Nho''c uocS bIv"t iyuS,Vo W 'ilV W.
publican party when he lays TINS irreIerenee
ior iG inc past 10 .hcir rhaiBe' as nc seems TO
!hihk that nc aloiie mas reau DOCKS anu stuu-
lc1 '',c leSspns vi un'llui'!, he VIII oe Pieas.
Gu 10 lcarh .ilul therc uLc persons also III 'na'
pur!y VINO have not Hegicc'eu uii tnelr ,opPor-
.urtles III that kliu' me OBJECT oi tne hepuo-
Hcuns ~ W o,i.'S p"oN '"e Poho! anu Pr"cuce
vi 'uc AcPuoHC W SUM- heuieI , agreement "
Ine IN tfau,uohs Oh elle ia'hers: lhey also nave
Na'io'.n III luc1' soiile oi cleii arc caPaole
oi disungushing "a phrase from an iuea; OF
w UT Ohoatc "ouiu hhu II easier 10 convert thcm'
lhey propose 10 create Na''ohal nehtimeht'
IN IN 'he ohiy way that Is PosSiole under c9hulnohS
ike ours, ny clearing the way ior the ueNtlope-
meht OF natloh Wnlch shali be- not only IN the
rour'h vi yuil or"t'onS' oue vi, ever! VA! ln'nc
year, ana IN the mouths Oh al peoples, great
ana WISE just anu oraNe, ana whose iuea a.
1'6 ",'u NenelITc' .! .ulliS loNeiy anu
olllpie' snaii p,u US al ~ common iulioiinl-
c oA va; o!"! ~ Ti.a' Is iu1' oui
lol what N Boou, oul wv 'oI Hn't Is oeuu.lui'
nv NV oui so",o Vi ooOui.I ~ VIZ. - ins
i'e - :nc t'' NiiiI" ,Hr lasiielS oon'c
w. anu 1t .a: Ml;I u llit iopN loi
% NI''L s,'i
'''' O''i 'i"SSa0''"'v',S "n" N"io'i'''' ~
'n' ne'ItS 4i InoSe VINO eau 'ncli mother "ltl,
'.i I'sG V, n''''i'i'! ~ o"oe 'i"ie 'e""ei "'io
''"r1 M n''yo o'.'. c,., n,,
ng'e s pus' iol W!nch l'epeollo"'s nave
no IesPecou' 1t Is one VI receliS uHte
.n .".lo - 'iis.oi! iro"i Which .noi ieiuse u
'ia ''. I. ioa "',| "'e u,.''i,-
W. It - ",S'oi! "H'oii ~ no' ie' w'i''e".
ien .L'c i'itule n'5'or'u" sii..il S'uu! lo past
anu Sn'nc' i'''eIinis ioi "r'tihS 'h"t hIS,ol!,
'n't lu'io'i'i '''c! WilCI, ro'I "itns'oiu' anu
survive not the enor's OF Nir Nhoate dreadful
rcioriierS, out oi an administration Gaming u
sen Democratlc, winch with the creed OF the
OSlcnu Maiillesto ior itS lorelBh, anu inc NAN
Sas ior lts domestlc pony, could yet hhu
Schoiar ana gentleman IKE MIR Choate TO de-
lend IT.
Mr. Choate charges the Republicans with be-
ing incapable OF generalization. They can,
at least, generalizc so far as this,-that, when
they lind number of sophistres in an argu-
mcnt, they conclude that the cause which re-
qulres their support must be weak one. One
OF the most amusing of these In the Grafton be-
fore us is where (uslng the very same argu-
ments that were urged in that coalition in Mass
achuSetts, against the morality of which the then
party OF MIR Choate exclaimed SO loudly he cN
tolls the merits OF Compromise in craftsmanship.
In support OF what he says on this subject, he
quotes from speech oil Archbishop Whately
passage in favor of Expediency. ltis really too
bad, that the Primate OF ireland, OF all men liv
ing, should be made the abettor in two fallacies.
In the hrst place, Mr. Choatc assumes that there
are certain deludcd persons who affirm that all
compromises III politics are wrong. Having
stuhed out his man OF straw he proceeds grave
~ to argue with him, as ii he were as cunning
OF fence as Duns HeotuS' One would think
from some OF the notions he deems 1t necessary
to combat, that we were living in the time of
'he ruin Monarchy men, and that Captain Ven
her' with ms troop was ready to issue from the
saIrets ol pat'er! !-iharch street; 10 ma Arma-
SeuuVh IN Dock square ana the beast oil the
hcneiaIiohs IN the Chlei OF ronce' mere Is no
man VINO oelievIs that inc sn.r oi state, any
'' '''S an o'uIi.! Nessei' can oe I!aN 'galen
G , ,,o Wv ies'I'ir:l. ":oiie pI' "g,LneT VIII
."..:,i so ~, " wi 'iaTi6 ~ dooHiu i"o VII
o''' IL was ~
-, Nh Iu"iii'eu " al; e!c " ,'lo ni"i',
,b"s S,', '' ',,'', w ?.'''eN
Jl W 'oii' .'i'i ioi''iees "'' necessary a. VI
ue' W e"ii oh ileu eiiiiiieht put uiis lS
ol''se tlieit,9ic 1t II necessary mere
- .'io HIS' iaiile!: lhe o'ncr S!lo9iSm runs
-Ape.'ieio! - tssolr'.'i III poi'ieS 80 az
=, rnrt'iote SUM pdrrou.ar
,rhn ata,'t iS,'a.! tu',iUti p wv
s.o.;.. :. - =. -
oi oi"'on ~ VI oou'Sv, 10 con'ProniiseS On Tue
SN''eif ques.ioli we agrec WIN NM 'hal no
lia,t Ji seist WIN uei'! lnat TpmPfonse Is es-
sy.ai III politics. ana eSpGeialiy IN our poiites'
"i!h sinsie exception al tlat ne says on 'ils
.Ipie ~ expressed @ WIN mastery iorre ana com
Lietche:s' put wnch we come 10 the apphca-
MN ,iIn VI ~ 'ne matter assumes aho'her ace
hc'i Vi sellse may anu uo' ciher as 10 what IS
u eo.pio;iiiso vi, asreelns IN tha'' they may
uIilei IS"ir Us 10 Whe.her II pe cApculcnt' f9f
Example, IL HAIL having 'aAeh anolhcf ei0ak'
"A .ilsis. oi 'aNiiis ms ooaI "isp 'hI uchuuce'
:nousn he hiisn' eon6rasuia'e himself On nay
ny peen sGt iol"ui4 u 81 iur oh MS wa! t9w"ruS
l'e ma. Vi "oulu ntruiy can
.no ",'"i' oon ionitIe on .ne Purt ol r,ic oe
.: nuuei. vi aga,h, II ms ofother WIN ostend
Pilncip'eS si'ouiu oher 20 coinPromise auout tne
coat Dy tahih9 ON! nan Oh IL, nc woulu oe III
cohsiuerao,c uouot Whether the arrangement
were eAPeuicHt' NO" there are many hoheS'
peoPie, not as eloquent as Mf on9ale' not as
S, seno,ariy, ana perhaps NOT more iilogleai' VINO
atlny olleNe 'hat our compromises on the 9u9s
eion ~ siuNery nave onercu eNunpieSo oi oo'h inc
SP9e'es uooVe ucscrl1cu.
~ Is NOT unnatural therelore' that, wmIe they
assent .s 70 ms general theory' they should pro-
, ,esI "salnsI ms hipue Oh applying 1t 10 pari!cu
mrs lhey may De lncapaDle OF BeneraliZa-