The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1858-03-21
TEE UNION BAhK DEFMSiTIcS CASE.
Argument ON Mosscr 60 Discharge Jacob
III. Motl-Doci.lou Reserved.

1vi.h thars. lin "A
60, . ~ 80 :" ~ ~ N
iaSuAe 9'e Inioa BANK Oh -aS CITY, "ls commenced GA
NJ, Cam, co,,s.I r., al, .,o,.os ..,,.s 90 80.
r.. - 80 80 WV A''N'0' A7AoN "a 'A~es
'' oSN"ss ~ '-o o~1N' uPol "aA" soc"'ens Oh '0o
statute he relied ~ hold Mr. Mott ~ which query the
learned counse arer oonspno ,ne .u,nOr,as ran,iaa
ur,r ,,o pov,sas e,.,,,a. 80 or, ~a. 20. -r
utN1 'De ne'so" o~A'a'eS page ooi sec Do DO, page
So. sec. 6, o and el; do. , page STA, sec. 3.
a Raaraar intoai III, Ia uva. ~ I'm on,r,on I'm,
40 N 'N~. No " " 40 'pA 'A~'
so oay otuoo iof WHICH nI' no" e'aiu DC neio "As
conspiracy " eabcz1e but he had examaed the sub
ice. 90 carefully as he intended
:. 60, :, -,
'H' """e" snen Ffoceeuoo ~itu n1 sfgn"ent On "
motion TO discharge the accused the ground that the
av1denca vas tnsufeant n boi6 him Tern was m tcs
49,, - :. -.
sA5 soAe W sA'" '1A" "a"uoSo AAo Soe~ o--De-~1o~
,hs con sequences could 70. attach TO mott Il was
..........s g.. ,,-..s.. :. 49,. .,.... -. .,.
n"s F''su"o" ''"' "'o'Aoleon oiN'eN"' 0-0' "aN
od 80 and uAns sfTe0 II W hot tAe0 Inc ACCUSED would
be guilty. but there yvcs no evidence Of that Theye "a
- .I.... a. .s... ,h., ,h. vvs. any, sn~. os .s...
no Lae,esoc ~ es,ues'oe s"Ss saefe 81. ' ssres
'oes' oes~eeo sott anu hto.oefSva .oSs oo' Nh W.
sx,S ' :. - ~. ".s ....s.s. - ss.s.s'
~ ~ 40 " 90 az ,t' ccna sarsr -. th
WV uicI - N.oa.a oienII ~ W wig
=, ,S ~ .., =. ~, -. =, - 80 So
.o, 1880 =, IN, n.y. 80, $500, ~ r,rr. crS, - tc
49,. .ss 800 80. S 80. 1r,o. a,.,,
~sS MOI rr,,,sa n ~ nnrsi i,stituo Il did ra
WIS nv piVrc" ~ oo /" -" P -, ,N, ~ 49, Wv ~
come ~1no ."e sss'uy ueuos"I VI 'N1 NJ.
&1o neace 70 PfoPet couiI % loss. mneh a.
Pe'H - 80 80 r. - an.ar, Ala -, 80 h1.
% 1891 rs ~ AAo 49, i,a,.n.~ ~.
Hs* tl0 Oni. . D~ " e -, 60, 80. .s Nv
~ Wy so"y 80 - axsn,.s Co., oo.s- $3.50
Uoeoi " ~ go. ssn.,,s nssr. "a
49, as t.'1 RI n,,n;, -. ~ ,,s,..hSn, h,a
standing IN tne community were i,ieprgscusoie hs
~. vs Wills VIZ lie $50 :. s".-,o- ~ ~
M.m Ut ~ ,bs 100; h.os 800 sad ot I
...on Ds-A oNe~..As' 10" 0 80 -, -- s " So
.. :, S.,S,t ~ ~ ~ - inv..d" -. .,.s.sra ~
n my =, wv nsu weOr S oi 49,, s -,
~, ~ s - - :. = - - -. 80
a. q sIs"y aId toaiiy unfchaoie ne inuma'ca ma;
Ni Af NJ Wss l p n1., a ' I@eoo : s.0a
NM .hs cn,s ha. az ~ ~ 81 ~ -
,. - -, :, 60 80 o5y.,,,~,od nro .na, =.
r u u S "Dco ,,a s.. Ei.sa WI evar bsarc "
s nus ~ 49,. -, !. -, -r,,.,.a ua,,,D
sucn etAse Oh 1ss \ IL, .os aa' . '' I
noh rs ~Ss oisooss IN su.s ..su ~" ooS 49, ono
n~1A e,"o " su'S oo" . vi IN, NO. ,, a. . 90
ssrns Ncul ID ',,e 49, 80 . ~. s pa. W
sAIain .nolil n, ss.u ~. hnnG, " ~, o
oa1X we're pIoseoa.ng iof tho pehe ., tne nus
coCiee MSnt ps Jus.tlea. a. y, 10 ~ w. pam
S.aaest VI ~ AZ uI ioaI 80 -. ,ha 80 49,
nain s.s ~ W.. ~ ,s.,r a, ,n 80 ,,nn h. "
Wa NaAoo u! U'o Sii VI '1 Hi- nv" Sooe
II HaIsn uat W. wei. 40. i ~. W usso q
se1eIa u ' " Vv III, ~, ue ueo .i. y. 20
zee ~nere ira"os nao ooon .cuni"sej Jus ~oo oia "
only look Aso me secvant u JACOB u alOs. ~ whht
ni'iHe sasuo''y vi ~ .) NC e-iai i.uto, .iu nc
snos uisn WIZ, aoooanl '" Pu. Las nneei " ' ueSo
frauds! lie arthur Knew m re ABOUT tho anars o. this
nstuVoh ,nao nah! snPpceeu hae Iotos' "a .noso
.ee ni.iv"o uay ea - -. , 49,, ~
II 70 ee- 10" has charge OIL 'her funds Ino Only iesa4
evidence against BIOL. were cneeks sno cse' Al" ney
wore not orered Ncf were The poos esa' sne
"ee e'ue 1t ,a 'ne! n.u 10 ouen SoioI-| hop toi
NUMBER OF years iEe tesunoIy u AZ 'ne attaches W
the tsbh MS "a sch nataro Rs tnst DO an OF common
wcuid rely upon IT. 1t old not follow that because
cheeks presented purpo TUG 10 have sgnoi BY
jacob h MOI That ne "Ia VI % ION,
the soscsna Ing ce'suea' VIZ n s VIZ ea5 nase
forged MI Mctts name Inc cicers CT tae pan1 were
Instructed BY counsel 70 Prcapce the pot1s ou' uey
osre not 40 ~ They Know nom al a.oa-Ahu
krow from moral evcehse ss.d the spesSe.tual 1 'n'
checks were not Jarob n meua
The suooio1 20 nts togetner WIZ e GOoVe uos'ract
hours argument
cocNss' tck nv pttsNpS'S foN's ,,,
nths case as loses any offence ses.s' .ne ct nna
laws CT this STATE the prvc must sow Boou reason 70 De
Eeye that money persona, properly or o'net Vaueoe
thing has been obtained from some per5n or pody IN
cuded by the . stolc Within .ne dehstoo OF Pefeoo
by sone fAse tken writing, or py soue oher Iac pro
tence, and thst there io the evidence COCO reaeu 70
believe tnat me ce,cncant MOI. ma su'n &
fence either duety OF hfousn notne ssus 70 as
Knowiecge anu utfvuen nis oo n' Ss, s
- o rid.rce N The csss shox,rg thai apv ',per
soI h, s anins ot tho statutes has been Cheated
- 49,, ,,,,a"s :, he ,aa tan. MI timselr
vi TIL ~ ~ -, ,onv ,h. Ms, n, ~ o.ner nerson ever
-. az rsr-csan,s,;on ~ ,.a,emcnt 10 The bank in re-
,o. ~ ~ scconns s,hcr verbL or m wr,,ina OK.
.. . =. 7" - 1900 - 100 l,.-I. snJ here ~ 10
p IN, 10, ,ha te,er ~ the bank or INV parson
os'nony , . 1 20 s 1920 - - ~ ,r q, ths i-iSa, "r
,hav toor az u,,,,n, IN the bank 10 sscertan tho
conSor nj Nou's account, or that th. prstcndeo over
ss oi Mott wore ua,d py reason OF any deceit or fraud
eneasS oy Va, &c ,e asnL There is no ts.,mooy
thai INC having teller ever had recourse 10 the
hoort.ecey ~ knex row Mott, .ccount stood nj lbe baak
or ths h the oycraraf,s we're made as alleged BY Mott
,he s.m. were mnoe by reason OF any deceit effected
Inv IN. false epir. Ia the Iodyrr Tho facts and crcum
.snc.s u,.a which the nasIstraic .ouncs his good
rssoos,, 10 hAeye an offence mas bcon committed ana
ih. he accused Is suiy OF such offence must DO es
tabshsd by legal evidence The summary character oil
thesn nroceedup does not dispense legal evidence
sr 90 oarh e,narn,e fact. IL ouiy reuuirrs A lc.ss
% w - iL.i s..oor 40 caumu thar 10 oonv,c,
amount oi ieSa ptvoi W N'lainN 49, -, -,
The proofs sdauoed against ue ocie.o. oo. - uos %
received At OF justice 10 support cr ior inc re-
coyery of money in q cvl sction. Much lees such
n,cofs n. accorded here a. evidence Of crime Those
1900 s,s ohs.Tsnv, stsem.nls and tho statements OF
xo f ,be bsnI clerks OF The result OF pretended exami
nation by them of the figures in portions of the
hess In other words tho bSoss OF these two clerks
of min, n,o,peea ara mace 20 sneak through the
ccrEs who have no RECOLLECTION Of faca except they
nppcar corded in ouch books The vos OF Brotherson
hols Of tho oe,o.t evs and paying teller and thoso
book shov that no defacaon has uscn place There s
r rssn y, ~ ~ p,Vc cn.,nr,o~
=, yudy. ro, resuopded On behalf OF the TYSON Bank
lie said Il wss manifest ali tina; this money drawn
by collus between Mott and BTcthcrson ana that was