The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1858-04-27
Tn. Gaze csSde. C.'ii,.r, E--oo,,cctOs az San
Fsa-.f

Rae CS I'd. eHf1tsr. hS~-talfs~tOr az san
Fsa-.t.s.
erPrEsS cousr--sirgp srA-ES
Asorp.y General, }. $ BiasS sssistAot, Gi'is, Tor
psmD
p.n,.i 4 prssDson and Ohm A. Csahsr 'or de'snssnt
IA, J.i,ed Sasss us Jim.s Cslss -ats Collector If Up
~ Oa,o~rte.-rhs vas 20 a9so. ron the JUG scot u
ne Uelss sates Circuit Court fo- be soa.ne'n daico Of
H.~ YORK DC or Iiln samae seeca, Justice " Vas "a
name Courrsf tho United ssxs-s, aso Hon. S~a 'es r
pete Ds,r,c Judge Now, es5s,a sn''o Gaze se Court
seseed and adugei upon faot found 10 the special
.,s,ct hal,aere xas baascs duo yotse 1sfsassosI
- no 20 xhsch balance they esta ID 10 ns aver and
n. In the jaig sod csruics "oeas toe
p~sapt wesoh found by tue lr, ~ss sto en- IRON the
Dxu,y ooi.sc.us office II dvnssrey, wit DOT nee ct or
Sssun % his part bs part 81 sa'd jane' oher,
80 whch ~es charged assnss hi1- ADJ relu-sa 10y the
R-~ ury Department 10 be paid, aad wneo WAS
n fac, acid into the Treasury Of the Uuitd
ssarp me suH oroucht in May, 1852
1, recover a balsrca sta.si, acd cfnciay certified
b, the re.ury Department I, DC sue, Of hsudrsd
end ppesy bousan1 and ave dollars AID tniry
ere cent? The defendant aapoioled by President
fsyior Collector OF the dwu,et Of Upper Oanovos 81
April ls4e, ans ofiaaied "a saah until l,to Jscaary,
is6t, N which, day Butler Kias who had o-sn 40
T. utd ey,Ev sd. MT ~ m C.ec NJ the d-x,st of
tas FSoscp. the state Of Ocifegna. navira, 70 seq
,s@eer isso been divided lot, ak couecaon ds~,t',
sbch Fan Francesca was oee to,s 90 90 Of the
IosAcm Ba~se there entered ID duties n his
ts A. tn time OF the fsfenHsut appointment. t"ere
Uuned states vt o'gsnizet 10 Cshorpa,
sac jasdc,,sn IN all eases FOR voe,sou Of
lase v,sied 10 the RENE u dtrc, courts o. L,usoa
end Oregon rpers was DO naval oftos
PR, appraiser aod Jodso, district .noro'y
- osbsr lga adv FER VI CAifcrn,a Ad 10 Snoie o<si
pess connected with the ooiiseioo ~ ne 'evs.Se
kt>odsIce The d.fen ant, ana tion DIS so'e re
spessisay The defendant ona"r "mosrrt Sss
sxranr iusry state 81 things hen existing In Cssorn
wb there Is no parallel, collected aa1 received
ntnAy M rfOh
U ss,aud three brndred AID sixsy ave- dolla-s Tn.s
ase.y cf course IN specie, AMI was kep IN he old
rery occupied by Me1icsn autoor't e. and ~hi,h
90 a very unsae building; nr wss the Collector snp
phd With see. and tn specie was tpcref0rs
n-s sss, Nv D! ed up IN boxes aod abt
o boor the cesepd MT and hs assss1 slept there
required 70 be continually a. h poet pas Ger Aiay u
sra. peril a. we'll as responsibility For ell ths, how
ever, The cs,n esrt ASKED no o'her compensation III N
gvec hro BY the express terms Of the Law md
Wi be Was appoipisd--"s sols'y OF fifteen huo5rAt
doars and The fees am commit siops allowed by sw "
and the e. Electors soare OF seized and rfst-d
goods am quors given to h'u by \e Revenue
ks re'e had tees prer :, the tisi o. t,ia csie 6Se
u.rent s'a's mem Il the dsfsn ants sponust IT tue
Treasury DepArin. al fouoded op,n the cup,s
TOO If wbch st ten accVuns we're alike, and widely
ttE., ~ FROM eseh O her thus
l. Usop tho ia OF Juns, 1851 tn which the Treasury
psps,tusptstaed Ens claimed balance OF $751; o6o ~,
4 On be t4th -ep'tmbsT. 1851, IN which they stAied
no eisiaeo q ba,snos OF s7s9,el6 30
On The 10th Dectmbsr istA IN whc they Jtatcd
md c.-rDed q bslspce OF A75o,s3o 90
& On The TN March 1soS, IN sh,ch the C'm missioner
Customs etse1 the balance At 81 6,7l2 a. oat he
atv a the came aaie made ava stated the oasaSe At
on the 22d 4 ptouber 1853 IN which the balance "a
.isd oisued III ga. $50 A. OF which difs,~s:
bAanoes the oeen,apt Was required 70 pay MO tho trei
gry.
RE spscal verdict fsds tina, the esaoces stated
dns from the deep ant In said Gee oIUts
20, due, lees amount, any tn ne being 10 TACT dae
b. me express ~ the sta ute laE Of the UshsJ
pa,'m ut sta ing the uornt due 70 be received
civil but even IN cri n,sa suits under the go usasa
- act peeuu puve evidence tha, the stated bssoce rs
due Abj tbe broen rs imp -e1 upn the seumso della
suentss Prove he Depsive- tbs, n ,t1n q
1pe severity OF this ruIe sDdthe hsrdshc ana TO-
tasrre N Which may subject puo1c Off err STRIKING
IL sbo Va IN this case whore stated balance OF tse
.I. account tbus vsrously stated G5sios
O. the highest arc 10 xest poiut ihao sx huodrea
sboosape toArs spd greatly the io~ss cst
Ys; with al tbsse Cissds sntsges, the de'enssnt
BE sAi4 oriy shosn and established that 10 tois
u OF receipts and osh irsernens dollar
o. be money be! d gng % tn government faithfully
united Tor and he counts precisely balanced
slated BY the d.fepoant and ihat the money stoed a.
krwrey waa improperly charged and exsoed from the
sefepda and too Upted ssSses oouad refund H.
me OF ts exscop sss the more a,psrsat Snso
aDoxp Moater,y where the la~ required
should he Deputy Ceec or's oh,@, $50 miles from
Adnh Strstob be pg necessarily cohti ed every 70
bm aUIrs a. the C-stom 6ouse IN S4o Franci,cj;
end .hen "a o@a.idercd that ny lac the Collector
I'd not appoint but ory non mated the depats,
md suejsot to the approval OF the Secretary
~ Ine Treasury and such depl'y w1 oy Law declared 20
Re IAN ,c.r ~ the cgsoms ADD therefore sAs himself
rs~pog sole performance of cuiiee Toe lr.
san ut eideo ina, dsfeodAut halle for
shs stolen moHey and that he vas ent.d 70 have tire
hknoed.
Il from this judgment that The Unlted states sp
peaed ~ the Supreme Court u the Unred Ssstes. The
e The appeal uguec At Tasonstoo ~ the pre-
ssn. term BY tn. Attorney General, J SACK, ami his
etS5i, Mr. GiDet for The uaiiei states sad Daniel ).
nakprcp and John a Collier fsr the defendznt
MOI day, The lprh u Apr. the Supreme court arm
sd judsn nj 81 the Circuit Court, tnss establish
ns that uto3 the facts oUnd By the sp@s t there
bens truth soo the fsct OF The easel
tns se'erd mt Who had been reported >ni puobed ana
y oscued 40 gresi dtiaatr, ws IN fAaa creditor o.
the urhed States, be the unjust an illegal erscuoa o:
NJ treasury Department (durns the rimore ADD Pier
mib~irspons) 20 The s5soun, Of tsNlo ~ Tor which
tbs o,fepcsnt po~ has 'uasuert in the court o. Mt
r~sc-t, his accounts ooahy sdj1stet upon the
brad principles oobtenoed for and gnei by The de
sseoAnt Unfortunately tor the defcoosnt ts result Il
slty obt~ip,d arter most troublesome aud expansive
N CATION Of several years o. ooet OF ,re insa tns
Tsetry Depar M Mt was wiling 70 allow fos tne de
tsso entire compoon.uob, Apd wha, so1ii 10
bs unequal and uDjust M ms and oil suu brought by
D. unned BATES while the United s,st sncse-yfu
recover aga the def-Ddsot yet j15g pep' ~
favor Of defer dADt be reoovers 20 costs against the