New-York daily tribune., 1858-12-24
Or. CHURCHILL AND HIS DIsCOvERIgs
Il The E6,to, Of T1s N. v. Ty,s.ae.

To The Jdhy Of Tls ". Y. Trtb.as
SIR; My attention oss lnst been directed N a 49,.
uyrics,'oa from NJ J Wincse.ierin THt Ta''oaa "a
VI TIE 1rh ul'., N which N ehsrged With
fUN enhrg = pr ority 10 whlcn sm o., erii,..
Second ttirs ibooTance Of waa, d.. Chareh Ia
views rsslly are.
TRrd: lrcorreclress IN my chemical s.sa,nnto,.
propose giving brief ex.nlinallou of TIE ps,,..
issne p I'D by DR.. ConrchiPs American Aget,
FSn: A. regards the question Il pri Jr,y, Ia =.
aIiicc IN ne Usst,rH L11c,t of lsj4 pro.o.si a.
Hli-ternc, IN g, nect',n eitl other fems.ae. ~
p'orns, rih he pprpo.e IF iacreasi.g "a, -.
frocft0n = ozsg,H. gas. Or. Caurchils sheofy .,A,
ttr' ls al, nc.c y e pA >iE'rls IN tie system !.
"sn '1yrtntbie shape, 20 or sr softs dsfcieDr,
o' Pb'spn'ios ~ state ep2>e Of efiraeii'g or,ss,
gas. lie prop u remedy tAis efficiency bT y,,o.
one PREPARATION Of phosphorus. / big anotb., Ls
be ides ls ,orDmon to o',h ,f us that pho.ohota,. .
Gs ncl,It and c"u-eQQrLtl, ID. attraction OF 60
detective. Dr. ChurCnils vicss w-rs 1T for,,rs
p6ger preselted 70 tie \ q ,emv - Meieios p
il July, 1876. Aile, as atiestsi ~ yoarsel n, psS
tor w,fe pub. shed 10 Ausus' 1891. or ,,co ,oay, -
SecoHd a. "a ny i-rorAi &C. a. Dr. c neal 49,
csD merely say that ] took them from eir.,I.s
pubust.c by .Ll- sane Mr.. j " u6 lie stsf sbr.f =.
siraCI Of which pr,srut: "Ptosphoru, esr.S 50 so
systeu, bat whether ~ p0ospho.ic acid AZ -
" lower state of oxsda'loU, and ~ such csos,s =
hseprs W the SLOW combustion which cos.lass.
ole Of the principal pheuo ena # nfe chemist. a.,
"lbysolog sis are unable to iecice. The crLbr,,-i
Li,b'g stating that II l. iupossibie T. decide "a
quesuot, willie the lote DR.. Gregory IeMg'. 49,
clscille, declares a ctssrd 70 suppo.. tia,
phosphorus can exis, iu the saigal frame IN a.,
"Mer c0ha""7 nan a. gtosO' 'orie acd.' I
Churchill, osrvrr, afles stsndiuy I.eb,.
assertion that e tmposSsaie 10 aeeJ,-iae the crS
u,n that hos?hOr0s 'Nsts The system that hek,.
0u,rcont Tie .mPoinbsry, and IL drec. coutr ,iic1oa
70 ne ia'e pr. Gr-eoTy,is guilty ot the "a5sa,f1f'
q asserting g. 81 u so-s eXs In soHs ott,r ga. 10,
fb.n Jh0splorlc ocd. New, one woall ,upno.e ,b,s
/ ~ ol pcslrg such authority as liebg and Greyorv
some proofs Wou be adipcvi 10 snsan his poe ton,
/ but u he .as lott'ned iuis-if, hls agent Mr. n
Wirchos.er tss not sch f. t. .iye tneu pub,e,v
brt cal. o., ~ toe Amen pubic 20 swallow hhsds
tlt rssut,f " d.. john Francis CAarcains lol p.rA
seri-s ot s,itni. d=cu,tiuns
Ikrd, | docUfed of an 'nrreo.ness in nv ebsni.
cal Assuoi lions on the gro,ud t1t bypophosp aorca,
acid s ysblr c)Lver-iOo irto )h 1spAorc st snS
c,L.eou.Lrly exs, in the sysrem sllout oeu IA
..t.o by anol ss al n,ti TIE cspabhty o't,, eor
v,Is o. 0 the bypophosp pt"fous 10 the paos )aos,.
lst enit part oi tn y TEN Go, tnis hypoyhoshs
r,u- aci0 .xis. NJ. Wiucaest,r tseitl, sdn hnt
dnes rot CNlst in bOle ss.ue. Iervous matter Ne
iu, does lut polft oOt lie lca uabt,uoa bsfu. II aa
0,rsoe. y n,tamofphose. NoS, l contend thai l. hss
10 e.isterce IN the Crgsr ism, au', IKE second
Mrerys mas its annual ofi gn nrely fro the u,oh6,
Drain Of Or. CbHrcbl. IDe sns ysls Of chy ne does
not give Il tue analysis OF chy ye destitute 1t, and
ID fle, hunOr ne secretion, 10 excre'ion and 10
soho Jether Osscou-, hbrnnus, or OF uhatsyer es.
IL eute /. may be formed exhibit IT. cad upOo Dr.
c. Therefore, his Ameic7u sstut j. N.ncaester 70
Jet o. have the de oRs OF ID. ChuTcalfs series Il
i,rentitc dtdGctiOIs.'
Mr.. Winchester t.lks / an b b, "rabuked' fs
dsrifg 10 Cout e. the pals # puOrly with an "em.
nett man. l eau nefey say, that inherii tha
Anne rcan peculiarly of character 81 stand ip for my
rights agfirs 1fosvever intfinsfs upon t1em, how.
ever sni'e1' isey may be, sui shsll always en-.
deayor t. combat error, however Z" emlnert' the
source, when consider the eff-cts OF that error -
reiutiri, T. the health Of society and the atysnos-
m,It Of r ience. WV. GvILFoRD.
rL Ifs