New-York daily tribune., 1858-12-02
M 7WsCkFRAY AAD M. gDvUyD
iAFF S-YWF GiRRICK TLf'R
F,e. "a. I.-sl- h,,,r..ar...

= 90.
cafS "fieh ifoa'sts ~ bc ~ nsi .,..b,e in,,r.
er' 20 He'si! and oas circles arS ~tica ~ilrei =.
- 81 sovel po,', t. b. tried a, oss Of the
y III I'd. ttts = W. stGt..ST. l. Nfi,,> o,,s ~,
li.c Ci,pme teiweer ~ IT, al ersr srtNI, Fi,n,',
ls',s hot, meUber- of tre GafricS Cst -h;cs as.
uif, tie iuio ''ng d.cuuBtsrco-; Under the ,tc II
, Lre'sfY isk, W. Nht,s Published NJ ar, Gle hs -
irA 'or s sO' ,.i Mr. w NJ. rhsek,riy. and thus dc.
Mr.. II. sscry isfus Elk yesss Cd. tsougA from.
/ ihe s,verv wh'e''ss a. his lar, ie SPpoars sope-
~hs, eider re : very tai, siasdiug rps,r, of sn
/ i,rt tVo iuoh,s srd. he walks erect, h, hi sht
| rskcs him cous picr Hs e every assembly, H. fic,
: b'o-lcsa sii Mt p. ticulsiy expires i've bu, ~.
msrksb" ior q frsc'ure o. tie bridge at tie Ios',
The result of an accident in yoNh. lie wears sns
efsy vhiker bu' ol ervse is ctrsr shsycn. NJ one
me,tu hiIs woua TOD 10 iec, gIiSc ia hun gr,tle
man. His b,arug = cold ~ u0n, .,icg his syc II
NCIsaop either oycry cyuical or "A ctcay god
airsd and b. ne,ocrt. tis h1rIl j. f,'cet. his
VII oi,i e. bis pride eas stonchsS bat Lib apsag ,-c
is irvaI.bly FRAT cf COOL swar, vel hreA Sestlc-
war VIE, whatever may D. rark'~- Wiz, in safl m
AZ surface display OF biz emo,ior.'
ALI; i"'es 'hes rroco To cenn"et on Mr..
TTstkeIsys seiius: "H with 't-- pobl .as.ou of
" Tie tird Vr foai'A uumb-r- - Nru,tv Fs.S hat
lie be- an e. dawn tros the ressp p1shc as great
.sius." Tor Hs sarcess cEirnr1ei ~ith
80 T. rfures o. ErslsL nanc-lrs Of 10, shfecnth
" C,rtury wi,:h scrr Vtenced NJ all a., CDd,t All
" tsiW ~ i"u ton. Thc price, wcr, eytrsvag sat;
!" the ,,urers adSls,ion si bnth sus poe'ioa were
" eNirsvSgsn', ths succe~ sas exsgavagars.' Tho
sr, ust 20 le buoSl'jg, oi Dir. rDsskersy, ~ VT to
.o Mr.. Nstes describing the arie - to be- n,s otF.n-
sive ana uuiiendiy merely, but sIaaierogs aud
untrue"
NJ. Th,ckersy con,,aded wRs the tf,Nowing ,dmo-
milton:
II beg rs have sight TO DO that yo. will TO
frsis from printing cou,aNnis upon NV private CON
verssior, that you viii f'rego siscc-srcr, however
buudsTing, "a ny Irvt.e affair. sud tbsi you Will
hnci ih please To- cousider aoy question oi my per-
sonsl 'rnth ard sincerity as qoie ont oi the prov
ipce Cf Nour criticism.
Mr. Ya,es Immediately rcioired lys let'r, In which
be elected Nv Tbsckerays sngr, unds dic,, of
his phrases adding:
II yen, leters sere not slsndercps aud untrue.
stouf readily have discussed the sibisot with You,
0rC avoeei ny c-rue-t and frank do,rc Ia sct right
aiyihirg may have lcft wrnng.
Mr. Thsckcray then suouit'ei the correspon ,enco
which lad passed between M. Yates AZ hi ase IT,
g.trer with the copy OF The article ~ which he he'd
ken eNcep iop, to Ne cOmmse al the Garuck Club.
Mr. Yat.s having heaIj that Mr. rnackcfsy had
adopted this ccmse, wrote to ask the e"mmi'tse Ia
sus I, % th' II judgment until hc lut pspsre HE
version of the case; and sahseQne ~, wrote "a tho
comu ,'ee questioning their right to eutertaia the
nnartsr At an. "The article be- taid, may bo IN
"cxC.ecirgy bad taste, but the committee is not .
" committee { TASTE"
Tie Committee at special meeting resolved that It
was conpe'ebt Ia them ~ entertain Nc. Thsekersy's
coupaiGt, n al the compliant rse ~a, well gocs ded,
and ihattle practice of PUBLISH snoh erte,s hing
ri, ctiors hy one member of he club against any
Other would be fatal 10 The comfort of the c.D, aud
ir,o rable in society of gon'h men. Tho Committee
furtlor resolved that Mr.. lascs vas hoand Ia mako
an on pe spolaey." or re'e from the olub. M.
Yates fco.nod 'er io kotre or to apol gss, and
stated he wonkl spveel to general meeting ~, two
qucsiors-iret whether the case between Mr. roack-
cray apd bims'li was such Case az sh uld be snb-
mitied 'o ile Committee at all : and secondly,
Whether Mr.. Thacteray ha. any right 10 at for n.
apology from ne when lac had 30 auoganuy aud
4" ooaT .el, addrss ID me-
The resut was that Mr.. Iates's subscription wsA
return, d, AID Il mtimeted to ban that c
percA fn m the Club. Ii has therefore instie,ed an
action sgsinst tie Comm'i'ee Or tcspass in rcfus NJ
10 all, W bin 10 enter the Club this will raise he
inn riaDt questioi al. citing the RI sht, " nembsrs
generally, whether the Club had the right to erpal
Mr. Yates not. II is understood thsi there viii bo
a largo array Of legal tal,ut both riles. Tae A..
ioIney Ger era has been r.iscd for the Cam tee of
the Gauick GLIB. Mr.. E1sio james, @. C., H. "
lead the case IN behalf Of tho plaintiff, Mr. Edmund
nil