The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1858-12-18
Common Pleas--(senerml Term.

Gs"ic JuneeS lhiy bialy auh fitcn
DIFFICULTIES pURirG The RSG AdEMENT OF MARIO
AND dRiSi.
Tee. IT --Nsac ldsk Academy Of Music rs. james IT.
HafIeh Thus brought 70 recover Of the dc.
nan, The OF s3 OOa being three wecss rent Of tne
ktw YORK ACADEMY OF Music durng pes Tod that Gfsi
and Mario lcIoi ned there The building Ut tim.
IN an ondnsbes stat, ana the defendant set as de-
ience breach " the plaintiffs covenant in the tease
Whereby thes egfec To use all diligence in dn,shmg H.
The ~as d before Judse luz raham ami sary and
verdict wss cns,. IN tsvur OF the ,,ntT-, against
tbe del, ndant iur The Of 81 Gal 10 rue
oct, tor tra, spe;iai term, VII On
deemed he then appealed from III. Judgment
genef Judges ingt aan and Isl aLy prTi ag, ani
they borg unable To ag,.e rc3rRau, Mt ordofei.
On the iessEnmtn, before the above judges they al
agreed upos reversing the Judgment, and ordering neg
usl; but "s q The J@ees dtssehed from tue others
Ia the ALLOW Of certain damages claimed by the do
iendant-
The following is the prevailing opinion AZ the Court
kADy, like testimony docs not shu~ that any 40
mard 4 the reut Wis maze. II - alleged u tho cm-
plant that the ut winch accrued the 2iat AMI 2stn
day Il O,tobei aud tho 9th Of November, 1851 b,
s,ne uu., @as .uy detdnoed, bot = amtt'si u. tan
rel that so shoui III neCe,i from the cllulsL
IN q oulaint. II appear what
usy whcn ,i,c fell uuc d.msuded; but IL
ap oars tia, ou tie 9TH Of November 1854 aud nc aboGt
o L. NJ Of tia; dal SIR pJGG n, ariirg h,tp.i
u tic DIRE tors Of the h,ademy u Music directed W.
iuuROl the building, and mot potmn any ger
suD totnter Il without an of0es ifCm Dir fhaen tho
fr,sit III - the Academy or hurei. ana il flthar
ests that Mr. t acted aeoorcies orders locked
tsi ,vis is apparent that, the
Act Nov inter II 81, auo-L Z. H. tln pislnfs
took the huil iuf, WITT the r,-utoD OF ex
sludng e ucienGnns thfersn and thi their orders "
bal tuost Isulose vets tarr out THO Aro,
CuLtadsd prtvEioL as lIt0Ns--Non psytnat Of reut
Vit iasa. Bat Wtdl settcd tina. ON leases con
ta'nnR similar cover at, agreement coudou the
andaios igt % reenter l. act pc, cted un he
ccnleud tor the pyces SIN duo Tor rent ~ the
time snd ace required by law. Tho derand must DO
ade TIE tft nl'sos, INC Gay Il ias due, at
,elhti IA. booze svndown Tho slegatOa IN the CON
pant NJ tic d.msnd toes hat show com piiance
~tb uc INV, hecaneo appears TINT INC
precise sum QUO 1as not demanded. The do
rncat under We - cement was eptL.ed 70 cfsit
81 $"t .. idm ny the Iefg. But ovra Il the dni.n
sas Ii ali rspest IL csup.et, tho -ut1s bah 20 right
tasftsslcn uDl nidnislt u the 4th OF November. Me
cecudan, lao The ~uue day il Vhcn pay rent.
Dbtii tic day expired q not be disturbed Taking
rstetseon a the pr m s.s deliberate interference
Nth the otnA1aAt's Isesessf-a, as rhcn he was 10
ltited a tue iieni.s, tie eviction Was c1mpets, al
touih sucb eesou dit not discharge tho RED; which
had aiesay accrued. The defendant, however,
uild IL The danlsg oucsscned by such eviction,
Violation OF tic agreement o! hiring ana abatement al
tie re- nj his eft! show that representation
ANNOUNCED io tho Monday, Nov q, and that be Incurred
great exponpe by bills ana toerer was
i1uI4siy rcJcic For thu reasons, reference
to- The otbeI ques,4s IN the cause trisI must
ordered may te ne essary however, 70 consider the
aGmRt lhhty cvdenos 70 s0o~ that Mario taken
consequence II the fa4Inis delay hashng the
buldn aitei the d.leudaut TOOK possession The dc
tend.Lt bned the psotnscs for the purpose OF giving
ois rul,c entertainments, wn'cb Marie and GrIsi ap
iacc, they hal sung in this country kept
tbe nlaE ut o tho Defendant, ~ho brought tun Lcfo
IN the language &C Mr. Paine, the plaintiffs, and
the risnris secretary, the great attraction Mario
The hring ulon the 9th Of September,
1901, ami the occupancy was 70 commence the LIT
IT October following. Tho plaintiffs t.
ell dingeLce 10 pnrbing the building, which tue
eftndsit agreed To accept Ia ts unfinished
stale, and tins finishing seems To have coutsin.
p!,od the erection % ntsn ui naces for tue purpose
II heating the bulso. on tie eih 81 October tho weather
NUla, and hut flrraceS were uraeE Mario ami
TIE audience c0nainca Of the codncss OF ths
hu,se. Mr. Fame VS. seen T. about y, aud wcut to a.
c, colo thy tat sung -. Petersburg and TIA
xlrf, hccd suci cola there IL was s-o proved
iat ~, crf number OF men could havo pot "a "a
whole dten furnaces ~ two days; add turth.r hst IN
fInscs completed ubt the 10th oi Nvvcalber
There IS 10 coDhtuts testimony ~ thus subject AM te
t0uCl sen j. Inevitable, on tho eNidetce thst the PLAN
trf Ga Dot al diligence 20 push thc building. The
dci Udant oaTed N conncotion with these iseIs 70 show
tlst the evening Q. tho ltth October Mario vel.
NhCn bc commrrced ha performance, and that during
bm Performance Sss tsk"n with cold aud hoiFsenoss
Whtb prevented BIS pOug through WITH bis perform
snce tlst fUCh cold hos exclusively
hon the Coaicse and darpucr5 ~ the house, aud that
the pattits sh he building ,snd the premises
IN otdr sng tist Nesas Des ooutuued ior soout four
vckp, dufng ~bch time tho dciendani vas ent rcy de-
iaived ~ h. rcrgces AMI bot E'cai sans and prods
cuty In - te rste"uce anoad hAs. been receive,
Tie stFncks u Mario M ducct sequence ~ the
ncegi al t.c plant 70 bnsh the bonding - % ercct ito
fucb Vsb trc otr at gr tht purlusss ~ tlis
hfs a tlR Gth n,Dst nc assunrd IL Urd Munro,
- Nad 10, ihr accn = bouFh,to recover damages
Tho IfgY ~ he deirnaant acivub's Ia driving
81 tLc rAntJf sal, ~ ~hch he vas kisi aua ia
a. ssa ~ egtse The p.tituh 49, frrmdt.d %
recover the oscasoncd h. La wiu's eGyn -,
,tns au,bi nItn te aceidnnt Jntc Nesuu sal "a that
n ~ tho 0anArtf wft clearly ftVed a. i1sa been
~ dnctt tULFtuurncc ~ the pfocfa at tom. ancd ~
aIa CANT wilhn tbs yeii settcd ruu r,alr~Nng
sr,cai caunge. innaRcs actually sustained bat when
% IL, uscs~early irtm the act complained Of aud
Cousfgusnty rp' implicit ~ tue as, tay nevesthc
Ne. ie vercd properly alleged. TIC bene1cai
JOS ~ the plaintiff pft Mlsfs ~ the delenisnt do
lsuued ur-,n 10, aphy ~ l0 utgts ompoyod ~ Lim -
psfto tie dincrelt a. 4 tsrrei them, ana % sos
psa 1teuyci by tbs orlssVn u The plansn- " kccP
thrl epgaet the Ices ahuu1 be borne hy them "
- ~ thai ne 90 MARIO resulted JrcCt tna i'm
a.. dNstr'y fun the neElEtsCc ur wait q dt lice
thr at 81 pi,utirs. and - leaa remote tAn tho
80 kta ~ - the paiua wfc W E0td "a Muafvc
iht tie inGf mrnt shrud b. reversed aud NV tlai
orderca with costa 10 abide tho event