New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1857-03-31

TIE MOORE AND LryIsGsroS ooSTRovERsY-rHE
DOCTOR SUCCESSFUL.
d. NJ Prioe Moore Alfred s. Livingston aud wife.
Judge Roosevet delivered very elaborate opinion
~. morning Which ,Oot bin nearly az hour 70 resd
b The evidence To regard the case controversy between
Livingston and Moore sasu.ysy and 70 93s GpS ,os a
ase the sacon, now and throughout merely nominal
Parties he proceeded to state the facts and the questions at
.e involves the till. e v:lq.sls property in Broad
Slopsed the plaintiff, bit -hich having put ou' of his
h.nds 5sfes claims Of eedto he cannot 10 law recover
bach by showing some exceptions. crs4m'tances et
snpns him om the cs,ion OF The rule tina, no An defy
The plaintiff sccordasy acts up sreconvrysnce once In
his bands ard now In the d.endi AID IA: sought TO Pove
he AID delivery VII the dsuies And the
question ishe main and only ultimate question to bo deter
oA~, .o,d. w.. there 81 .ny @e such Al or
sny Instrument Of hh. import IN $500 ., nc
which the defendants have Of oei'ined and wronsuJ
Moore in hs complaint, which put in under oath NO,
.ny .s the execution aud delivery q toe AID
Character contents and ~ ending circam',snces 49,
!: ws e.,ed be 'sy On or .o9ot for m
III. wife q Tie d"'sodsot Lvinsstoh the s''ntee was
az Lyin,, on the confederation 600; the premises
ops h. OF Do, Nos o4 Broadway and 81 ulsndt
sir.et v the dmep. # escb he dse Of th- sctoo~
e4spshr and ne ni..soe !, 80" delivered
to oy the d.'-od.n! EN- "a ss ..r 70 70,
nosb. the oousi3eIaOn bAvRs beG tuS settled aud sd
NV. s.,s Of to- psns wSh i. oonovsftsd BY The sworn
AI.ssI Of the defendant, sustained by To- proof
Tbs proceeds uotice remarkable discrepancy be-
tween complsin and bic evidence Th- after
% sm :. I..sd Sy hi.e and sworn 70 win particular. in
derosuOr before the Surrogate rs, than tw weeks AFTER the
attempts 10 overthrow this allegation aud 10 prove
thai Ms Blacks. beid the property IL question not q. al
dn.y owner from whom l[oa.'" nigh, o.gr.y be male
his her (~beh d. been b.bed % Tnf rsRvssl s
nav b. the .ctu. u,6 be heard .ay the
sworn deliberate, f.'e srd such fslsiy
"nio Coa't With eesu hands required By Iona standing
b., wtcs fhe alternatives. t.,b.r :. the one WI.
In question raj sham sac AMI Purchase
- s,tsy1 IT, el.lms y ,rf,Srs rhe Cur, At Il
showing BY siss'imony q Dh' 70 whom Moore ou,rycd
"Gom IN SInowledsrmsn OF Nj. BseG~r whom Ds
ecuv.yed that che bad and from The assertion Of Ls
nltor implied by be Handwriting 70 TIE e'i u both The
% order srd recsip; ths The purchase IN trust
yre,eh.e that therefore TOE snle transaction AHr
"of Livissaon ercssvey In ~hsh thctw Aies merely
tAs CO.., - s... ~. whb ress,di conea.ys =.
hs tbs: b. Ar moore toe only ra pNe', thst no
money pad and that The property ~ss in effect placed
II rested ber.. whatever nigh b Il. moral merit.
would .d1i, Of but one rest No man crs.ios .e--t
sOs' 70 eetsud the SO call upon ihr s~ to % bin
msa. and the between the parties Is
une md The iue f.s p the persn nsned Ai'"" 'aor:
sscs The .odalsni sr.ntot e''OpP d BY bis own &C;
.s ~, ~, e.ns doe. Mt ..i econve,spee hai ~
s.S,S f,sSoi,s sa, R..s:n OF Which %y.Sodsi 90
%.se. Is.Its',on % ugs ds.d -hica .ues.ons in
% e'Ss vel iysndsd les.y ssw,u l'fy blonss to
ha' - ''e' 'peh Increment 10 sTists Gee -
ust.ious 80 d. IN . Ii.oa.
rrconveyancr 'befttr a. Dt ld. GA dulal - Wa,
~ Asfy 20 10 .-i'
To- it ar, .usf,rrs Poe direct ., i,nc. on bi. ut
ls,s hs' iDsuf rc.f g. iyes iofna pNpss
ute. .rapsniei ~ f4l"~l b. st4sl 80
Il 30 fs sHv % fuaA sse oftlntfY
es.es ts 300 fr' er'fene b 20 tbis g.
srGiEAy A. tt'e.~u D.. axe ga Ani N TO- fa ~s'
Ssvr shoWr mT i-' nd hEh m'rs' 90 D mas
Y vlp4f.t, 90. Ky b.us th'a. tth' sHT t'ff-.
~. .G ne tisui a M''te. H. as 10y 3 pm
81 The yfopsrJ. IL ~" mere H.A.f It's ~ ,
tn asss-.l.sI t~~ g. ..s oi t0- 49, '..sf *
me dsap b. s~eu fsfs.ts ' t. - -
bat vi1r,i~i fl.l a. - a. ~ii4
a. Noof, We ,hD "a ',sr.' rc 49, 20 d'lh ''
s..S 20 rton, ~ ths ~Tlrs Toe dors not H1rr tA-
b terts ny 900 A ' 81 O.
suos tsfms tie dignity iu Nv f- 80 D. o~tT -
ed BY r.siorns he Proeer'y 20 :, f-s, u D.. ~, !,
TesSre.d private r"schrry un4-shn@a ~ -
t<oss even & di.in.frstsi PasH- service ~
law essI h0or''' srofs and io'{ 40 ~ 80 - y, nm
.z,.sszys ooupse Of pA,ti~l dersnEsment b.h nor.
aaA usuia- hecomes LivnGsou Shoe snf 49, t9' 'si'
~i,boai ~ sam paistson Z 'si ihrm ~ - %
BIZ ght evi-re. .hood - sl NJ - remove 'nes a. 90
sasssuoa- The 5p~iy hcorvsi LiV1ss'9n Ns rs
hdsnhJ u'ee u honor 20 f~c'vcfy -nsn ~4 49,, !,
W hen. u favor ot hausn virtue th>t u
cetsa Aoo'e ts s~ rreos.sysos -hles Of The 49,
s-..S - L..g s,'o,. Nsr... ss,S.se. 90 tAis poiat
~lusvs e-t g4snis hoash ~sstted spesA 70 q
- from sfldlsd sbsrrJ Of Lvlnssoss tsstiGosy
- ~ ss..sols AID s roisieHdsnfs 10 ia
- soaV~ thas ooneia1vsy fToy-s thsE % instrassssi
-, "A con So eeet To- % Pos'essoa OF tss 81
"A - motto. hst.af t~sr re~u 20 Prodaoe " q
IA 20 production hvtt zoe coo n~a ioi 49,
49, 1880 y, b. ,kefs sI - a0s pfvineuon oSns~2e~ens
a.. ssgse .e1s.tI.s sas. tht ssSst '~sUSsFsJ ""SIs