The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1857-10-09


npossssss Il slaves IN loiS save eooalsssaH taken
b hn owner fson x.yAaa e .esk ~ ssasry y w
= vss. sss ~: &
D.. ..1s ss. nom kss,sasy No oass 8 s::s. ~.
dave Ha's viii her nastsS did boa nass hsr . slave
sgEn. 1855, the Supreme osass Of LosisAna bald thAs
kuhiaDs, became nee In 1915, NE cane Court hsid
thai psEson Ohsd - slavs by bin of sale sxsoatsd
me q ss n oss Of The sac could b a:
ined BY proving him 10 DO fugitive ,lavs Bsfcse The
sos Of itl6, the courts Of Leu,sana always hsla ,ha,
sas taken mo frae Sta boo free; and that he
supreme ooais Of Missouri hold ia. me sou. rs,ds.os
Also, that slave taken Into Illinois on bis route hissou
ri bri hired b. resident while toere, became frse Toe
weeks In Illinois And whore an Amy OH ser took
Save 70 n posi- IN hs North sestsrn Terrtory The save
rona in an action for the vaue oi sssc recognised tho
principle that save bar ding in free State bsoa free
In $780, The General Court Of vrsiua held that s.ave
INTO Virginia. was entitled 10 her freedom. (Bety Hoi
ton In this case tho Oou1. held thar this
slaves coming there In issa, Ohef Justice shsv hold
that slave mpciniy brought BY his owner inso kAsss
Third Point -rhe provhioa In the federal CONSULTATION
relA.g to faeue sAves recognises ihis principle 81 uai
.Sos sns % On y: free 80
were recognized - property un1ef she constitution, this
provision wouo be unnecessary.
free b. the express ansnt Of the Lsgssture OF this
State 40 person held a. slave shaI bs imported In
whatever every such person shan bs freo" HEvery
psrscn orcrghi into This state slave AhAl be ree
ho Of D q
cite en- the Argument before Mr. Justice Paine are-rhAs
relating 10 fositves from jooe that flu fs and credit
u every oher sae that the citizens OF each Sae shall
be eatd 10 al privileges and immuniies Of cazsas In
the feversl States hat citizen shall be deprived Of
life, liberty, properly, without duo process Of law.
None Of these have any reference 70 this CASE
oii:r STATE We give FUN .SS and cred. % TO the s ac or
vigr!s, sha: made sGsse perons ssve there. We allow
na sac &c has nc: been deprived q properly By
there proceeSirEs TIE appellant hsd no properly In
there perE ns i ceased to % property when he brought
HON Into hc State tf Now York e cansttuton OF the
Unea GATES Is grsa Of powers to tho General govern
non 70 loes, 5y neceasasy conseq cacc that What 10
enforce u2on New Yosk the obss:soa 70 alo ciz.n
CT slave sse to bring his slaves aad retain tnem
tie general government h,s no. the power; and t,e rg
DO nc does lot ext New York having prohi5nsd the
So. has .os % 1es.ss he 81 nssrs
htr ol Ct sn owl that exists only IN violation Of pasurA
,eh'--,o maintain, IN prasioe .. we'll . nea,y,
| the asaec rights OF peryons and per soua hborty.
Een in conellng She IsolaE.sion Of fugiuvcs fro n
service abe dos The Law Of slavery She
nature OF The duty OF sersice on tho part Of the fugitive
Whether slave or Al APPRENTICE bus 70 remit hlm 70 the
D 4 her d0y Her bcad extends no further than 70 tae
fVgve AZ 10 ri! ciher persons her laws protect their
Psr,sn. liberty sg.nss all csiDan.s l. was no. conss
VAS 70 be pesnans nj institution OF The Unii.d aacs Il
Ia Inconsistent with tho principle that lies Al tae foundation
o. !. u In contradiction 70 The Declare
cp o. penoeroc snd 10 the preamble 70 the eopsu
sn All he provisions az that Instrument and oontempo-
rncors history look 10 is un1se exnos By the less
lacn and ao,iSn II tho a;o governmens In incorpo-
aing the fugitive Asge provision Into the consu.o the
p, sse or .svsrg ~ !. nroyan
Isporsd By The committee seps IL 1857, road illegally
held seryce and was amended Sept l6 BY snlEiag
lava tas. ecfn The xsrd "serviceD vas suotu.ei fr
'Tervuec," On mellon OF Edmund Rancolph the later
oeTg cefcripive Of Alaves and the former
-ish Po5-These peTsons arc nos 70 be held IS dawes
under any iupned covenants between The States OF the
ped ongsion Inc paIi Of New York 10 au,w . slave
vhhin her borders in any form or under crcum1an
from ersie, Is tho ony possible case where saon a. obi
CATION CAL arise Ana BY Incorporating hA provision In
.oe oonssaSaon, every Ssnsr oAe s.claded sas
savo ssie slsht sn DO held n escaping inso taken
into ee state IN cH',u the cor.tsutiona provision =
70 tuea.vss would be scperfuous No oomy 3iAtss
quir,s Admi. slavery INTO ais In any form. Ia
extending comfy tcwards the laws Of other states 4. 10
can be no such comfy here, because the Sale has
made express ssAuie declaring hese pe 70 be free
but oeur cry allowed BY The party assuming tse duty
In cectIs hcsher ni requires any al, We lsok b
Gsrsr q os.rsee - vo,s,on Of cur S.: No cnmV
cqoirts 10 TO allow an sct here BY citizens OF an thar
Bale ual done By cur ovn cz ,ns would ss felony.
Toe comfy OF rail ne bastd principles that dss
roy al rghi TO bald tneso peoas Slaves The laws Of
moral rgt. tho yeoogrton Of personal liberty by the IL
tia or Italy, ihvc TO tho law capros be reclaimed.
serf fem Rossia or Barbsry slave, brought hther BY
liberty By any law 0, conay TO discover, says vste
In bis PreinlEAy Dseourse The rights and dulles Ct M
asps We must 1,sso The sss'.I sa. and duties
only natural nnnts OF men applied 70 M Ions. If lhe
srct Of personal liberty sas ~ much regarded In prac
oss-n courts ard less a.ares declared In IA p.rtcc
care the .dnued rcr erslhw, oogenl argu ment may
principles OF the law c. nations, dcveopsd ~ ,he high
ess authority.
seyen,h Poln:-Tbesc portions came, be restrained O
ther Lbuty, shstever may have bsea thor 10 vr
GINA IL rtriraned Of liberty hero, must DO ethe
Tnder and y viiue Of our avs or under me laws o.
be- and cor ed In ccrsin house ia This city, ass!E
ihslr will The answer b, they arc slaves. oar A~'
Iergsn claimed refuse DO deanei fhe question her,
10, teey be cetA'net7 Certany not by lsss
Of Virginia are no: in rec here II the s.,o resss
hos CAB lie be compelled 10 susjsaio11 n The mssle
r., ne power 70 enforce oees,ence be Cal moi invos'
lows ihs ocr avs In This respect, II hsy remain neug u
ave he PARTIES 70 their natural rights Thl
bcug so, the slsyc IA free Or authorities only
osse The niB Sc and those OF another Stae
Hshih rO.ns-Fhc are rec oy The common Law. Tt.
Easbh coroncn law, aJIGic&ied Defsrs aud snce
Re- sueoa sjnGs' thoE to be free. ~ u, princ ola
u he az OF tshons, a. srpsunded ~ re philosopher
Hsa ss .aa neos.an ~ =
Jsed ttaes docs D1i by any ca Va rms, aelve
hem 10 ssvery. No Implies ion be d'sun from sny
pFcvicn Of that Instrument 10 rexnd them 10 slavery
lie laws 0, tails state declare than Il 90 In bshai o
thtu iftecon urge The cnmntn t1risprudesce OF al
laHcns-ino principles OF our common az the doc
rines o. hc founders OF government 10 cgss on
cur safe, TIE pubic opinio7 Of the vcrla a1d deny
Tn Tie Fsri OF The people Of NE state Of ker York,
there peroas claimed slaves can be deemed a suci
IN oar tosru Ct jssaoe.
Personal lntriiigcncs
Jsuor crawford, Esq, Her Britannia xsj,r,y's Con