New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1857-02-12
YOu ,hiul i. possible for them TO be n ,de :, soe'

O. But you Sink il poe'io's ma osy ,;s. ssss
be- nede by tso instruments d A"e' "-s -''o
been s a5e by two iDs'rume1iA Il,
Judge Csprou-Wtil to,i ano1DLs 10 ne sane
Ting because il they eou'o bs mad ~ one ma.
it is fair N ineI mat one 'ns,rqiOsl o.,
that they ere mode oy two !, No1H 'S P'" 'N0H
c.uidui be seiitd.
juror Do you t-Yeve TIA: here was I've iu'-rl-
nep's used or one1 A. can oaiy aa4He IN n- sane
Judge Csprp-Tha, Is an inference am there is
,on. orouI dfr either infe reuce; hats the point DO
that, though didn't put the quesnon. 4.
Q. How eteply did the deepest o. N nc ia
p.Ierrs., | can. tel you; DE' M so' WIN III
fern you about that
O What oid Won e1amioe for A. To asc rt,in the
CT AZ scter Of the voubos, and what tsey nngn save
been given By, and in .ha way he might nave o'eA
Conner-I. vi BE- reoollected that he said me Of
| the sourds decidedly made by snap iu-tru-
ueLt; Other wouI ds nigh have been me'e oy o!un
ifs ypu Mt thst your TESTIMONY, oenVe, DoctH
Indee Cspron-Can ycu tell, Decor by the .p?e1-
suce Of tn. souDds whether II was made by shsrp or
| Gull instrument certainly A. NO oH' "'u'3n' ssy
| Certainly.
Would the ncnion in the garments furnish any
b. Ter 10 de,ermiDe that fact than the wounds
in he body A They might SIR.
| q DID You Examine the CARMEN, The SUIT, Win
| view 10 that J A. Yes, Sir.
| O. What j. tue result OF your examination, taking
| oil Of ,nem whether they were all made with sharp
instrument, or were not a. lhey appA'ea'iy are au
| 81, az cute.
| Q Made by sharp instrument A They might
heve Dten ss said before; they might have all been
| made hy ore iDs umelt.
| O What wa The ch4rsc'er Of the wound IN the
NIX: ass il q cut with O sDlie or stab as with
| oi,kl II was n stab dividing the two corotics;
| wound about 3, inches i'll depth; measured that
| O. think have either heard or an ter'oot there
| Oh The shirt on iho sane slGe va iue
| let side there WIS gance woIna thai nIgot nave
| been riade with ,be s-nls instrument.
| O. Wa il mae az the "a ne time in your judgment
tp he woubd in the neck or might il no: nave beon
| core at an.tber tmel A 1t is not probable tia. /.
Wa. made CT the same tim; it mi4h. have been gu
Effort 10 stike at il WHICH glanced, add then another
| ct succeeded ia m.k'ne TIE Tound :.
| O Yun raid Doctor that the Instrument WAS prob
| Oh triangular A. NJ, Sir stated tnat it might
! have been roise I'd OIL Que SIZE both.
Q Would these wourds appear sharp on the eise IN
| each Gaze A. II the instrument sharp on DJlh
| eoets Il woUd leave a clean cut.
| O. Would ihe not be liz rising Of the skin lett
A There might have been on the Outeide, but 1t WOOD
| have all d'sY peared by the time | san the body
| o. Cur0n+ The Wounds on say, under Tue ear or
TIE cheek were porHiy- cuts wat C ,ll ga'ne5
A. The one on the che k was cut should say, made
10y llapce ,tros the oDe IN The neck diyldug the
two caroids, wac decided boF 81 iocnes In d-pto.
q You know that there is vas; difference bet Teen
| tiab and totl A. Ye., Sir. this instru pen, went
into the ntca nearos, doFn@ards and sneriofiy on
| the l.ft SIDE.
judy Copron-Is there any means Doctor, by
| rbicb YOU can determine whether unds III the side
| were Inflicted upon the sutject willis b. was in
| sr5ndIg l,otiiion were not in fact uutl be ~as
down NJ, SUI cant say, 70 ans certaiaTy.
O. You csnt oetermine, - any certainty A No, Scr.
d Can YOU speak Of the character of The wOuno In
The bet III that relation 10 give opia')u, or Is there
adv uesbs by when you arrive al it : a. eau
| aIrNe al h cOncus IN when Tue wOuud IN the heca
was given by Tie marks OF blood on Tue WALL my idea
is that The Doctor eb ut II O'CLOCK, 10 TX of
Bis OyeIsnos threw aside bis eha H. end sa' dOwn IN
The obsr by the secretary; in Very fe mo Iients
body can in quietly ADD 'urprsed Dim, gave hi n
| Il
cut CT the heck; the Doctor theU jumped ul; being
EaiuIay uuid and bis life having been threatened III
The lOuse bis rst Impulse vas 10 20 toward the door;
lie toward the ooosc tse, sad With his ta,e
io@ ald The door, they give him this tSb the neck
tId that is The blood thrown upon tee closet door, up
wa'd ID always the cass from an artey; then the
neat blow 10 The body he ihres up bis srm to re
ceiye it. aud il struck between the bones OF his arm;
ts was in the fore arm then in his struggles at tus
iine be has the right wri.t by glance sodnt
su II CD an quarter long; he thea, from the loss Of
biz 3D. prUbaby, sonk dOGn, and Shlle be vas yl1g
down those ~oords i'll the hoaft and oreas were it,
| frted by pers standing over him, whils he vas
Vi, Oh his back; thur, the wounds would re given
C.wIwaid, aid sul upward N tie bojy; then there
IT ~ two more wounds below, one ia tie atiomen;
lcu be bad two wounds in tbs axila, one Of which
wntpstts he pleura; then another sad very ccep
wouId peneiIates the ilum I'll, sc evidently tho
ast be received b.carse if they had been the first it
woulo have impossible TO have given that spout
VI blood on he door.
Q Which wire the last If you please A Those
fret while lie sitting down; these wounds were
liSen HIM ar lie ss
A JuroI-A1d these prevent him from crying muir
der A. Thy couldn't.
Conre-Herei. avery serious que.ton.
Dr. Woodwsid-Evtn If those wounds in his neck
wtIe given first be might sn cry, because II wouldn't
| nect ssarily tie fatal imue 0atey.
| O. Th.n you ihDk that if Ihese wounds were given
here in the bo1o before he could get the door
| got az far hi thot A. II might have besn 60; if
I,coect right there was loose paper on the center
tab e covered III bood he mgh have struggled get
ting thtre then there are finger marks on tue door
Which ipd cste a struggle
q. TbeL b. Was III d condition whioh would en- she
| bin 10 give tn claim Ii lie chose A. lie might tt'I
| make q noise.
| O. VIA, meaIt Eas that the eifec, Of the sts5s
wee such not 70 deprive him of that over. a. No.
| TO Ilcopscilale han from crying oct.
O. Would his stab in the neck AVE eau ed hin 10
fall il stsIUy, OF might 10 have s:ooa for some tne
! 4. lie nIght have stood.
| y IL. loss OF blood woui have been 80 CREST
| y. 4 would have taken but few seconds 10 have
| made i : fatal wound.
G. Doctor, there is nothing surprising after all that
thu II, uId hit have been larger Quantity of blood
The floor IRON ths na.se OF th.ve ~ouGds knoSins
ss that ne stab peusiraod the p,eura bid the
II, la b;ilcic; he Create portion OF hs blood msn
hay. gone Into the cavity OF the lungs as The bJd5 iy
I'll he hu0r
DR. Wcouward-Iuto the cavity Of tie pleura that
mi hi bsvc bton the case Of coarse Of there
ats crest io.s Il OvoC his CIches satura'el l.
dts not iv tue, Z cJ,bes of he p.r-ou
WI, mu ceI.c him would have beea covered xia oood
roI0-Wbat want the jury to understln Is
lis TIA, Jol have given your oJiui thai the
gscster poIoL Vi Inc SoGhos we're glsea through tos
ChTOiIc-
Dr. WoodwaId-I say the tRo wounds which we
So lp,te 10 70 tie first, the w In baca, gsol
previous II tle n tie caDud.
COIOLeI-l unoerstand that even though the carotid