The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1857-09-17
i''s strss Commissioner Controversy.
suprEuE ouCHr-sPsoIAL rsEM.
Bersi. Hen Juds- Pea ,odv

Tss ssrst Commissioner Controversy,
surrssE ouCar-sPsoIAL rssM.
Bersis Hen Judge Pea pody
ssrr 10 = odnHl Jonooer rs. Tae Minor, &c IF Nex
York a'd 0ho~tes DRIVEN The foo was are r,r
De rt''nosots WINCH elaborated on by cJunss':
trsn ppisu.-tbe plznin hss tile TO the oifoe OF
Scuol
me 1857 prosides in general tas, the
DC appointed Mayor, tae advice snd coosoo'
n he aAyc Of a,rer nsa." (sec l9)
fb~ve aNn,nx In rule N ooostraoaon or in tho
eAscn Of The thug limit tnis ., sa< o. 'pac.n neot T.
he sibs = vscsncy ny t1 Of time Che
~hfe pawer OF sp;On,mcnt Is veseS 10 Tue OF aashcr
ass "sv'r 'leorou Tor .cpon men) - - sopply Va
osncy e,hrr actual aptsipS ed" (Per Savage, j.
Poodle 80 -. st.nt. 1t Won tell, ts4
III The smannad cnatevsmsHae special prrvt son for
vacaAcaes tened ny ssusiy oeo'ivs offices (ssc
aoGs g. ~ Aac 9o) fbs and ihe va,aocy
10 w ever, tDsrsnce vsanred - be allied bv ,csl or civ
authority here neoss.sy VI provitias svecsils
Tor me- 10 OH % hoio ny oi.y xppyntnet Che
appointing o~er 81 ways h's Capaos u action,
b. the Urms OF The ctsrter dishpasly pointed out
~ The s1m,, ~ 'sncfsl aod far 70 one1 cosssruc
uoa u secioU ut interval oes seen ,ha
:nacsn. {. as ne snar'er snd he Isl d January .sss
rom Tie op~rsu OF he ADJOINING provided In
sscs0s 10 thus les OF Q vsSAuuy 10 the
,hefsansh'p Il . "e srsn-ni wholly nnprovided FOR
cep y strained unnatural application Of the n OF
s349y cannot RIVAL
A jorge Pesoooy oenped to sdoos this construction M
v sxpvsse op lille Jlcge DAVIES avoided
sxpressipg any opin u Is Judge Roosevelt uumAtsd
os'nin sssinst J,dse Iag,aosM expressly denied
no 1udse hose'er has 'nnmssed IN opinion in favor
B. the plaintiff construction IL adopted no Commm
0ooScI provided for allowed daring tho tns.rvAi
n N SAJ l. 1887. 10 tn. neAt election
tn insa irarlty Of the law OF ls49, In it, details,
- the Gao u sb ONCE eel b. ,ons@en cencl s,se
.sHnss sAe Ign, claimed onas, 4 BY couovsr - Cover
the sec aoD VI ,h-gn u projected the Street Com
missioner nod ptb-, oesds Of depsr psnts from
Ameut their then sxiarng Of oioe oy tue
npRt8d
termination OF sheir holding before the or rAoo Of taer
.evms So~e n re- aovsd under ssctons ~ or 49, it xss
intended hal appointing 10 the charter CREATED
70, The vhrr~e shooh appoint the case Of People
ConAnt IN Wed, i3. sAx authority for the propo
sititn "tskiog ~hns section ether
IA the IN n vesd tnLs:-'rne persons
ahsG Ihe offices Of Il esi Conmissi &c shall
sDue n nic~ until the aspiration of her er
lees r~unveo from ofse dnriog utinuAnoe ,"
". RE cons'i'uton Art To- Aec Ia ansnprsas the
Legislature v oil vscaaes In office, requires that BODY 70
tscrmiDsse be. Seen sesuve ooes Aod odce. held by
spsripsneri III. Legislature has doc. rne act OF
ts4s Up % 3e) oss for elective offices only Ia
80. " iD0ioe acSoci.s log oy reason Of doatn
removal reign alton &, Ia offices held b, appootu Mt
a. senst al prov except
In cases re etn- gss'ar' or ome urAch thereof ex
e~cises ire s-po'rnba poser or 10 part OFT Il 8
s3a, AZ sno 4S l. as reoessArs 70 provide in
she pecpe and the leg, laive bscie', ,hey
Ia Intervals of poec .urins bic1 the aop ,uras
po~ey he do Ia all Their ,be appointing
20 or 10 ali zap .be OF sstt and exert
Consequently vii bs founc tha 10 Gi NH cases or
h. the etsutory provision relative
Office all VACANCIES, 0~ever sris
ing be be, o,s'h rergnscn removal forfeiture or
81 rhrenos u t~ss
VI re oop, tl'unn rt TO- SEQ 81 'mb,de ahe giving
1 tbs r'-e- to be sovetnment (Peop W Draper,
srocSp PI1r we pt,nciole tba, the title to al oioe
nppo, ~oared INFO coates als and that here 10
odruey d. Will be valid until lat
apppcstins 70 the nresebt case Aud v this pru
c,rle had irfuerce 10 favor o. the isn't plaintiff
iumnary proceedings to possess himself OF the books
and papers in question, In submitted that mis
Apphed
An chcer proceeding 10 enforce hi, powers sg.inst
IN iDdr,aSal can oose in such p'oneedng sustain him
thar he 10 ofioer de Sure (Cnmmugs vs. CLARK rs
Vernon. OF; corprh $ Young, ! ,,buMd'. r, 1853
and nose; Fowler Beebe, Mass. r. 1855; U. s. Dig.
iitle ofbce and oflicer, Q 20 26)
II .ops o. DE-, -e- o THIRD pers'ns one or both hsv
ole de Eac,o sppdes When ,he fser himself is party
De musi sho~ tea' he II officer
III OSe sbo cain. ga pu-h5 oflncr, and on the fare
~ his proceeonss 'h,.s bat he I, not he risotful Off
thai the person against ~hon proceeds Ia
rtgnrful ofoe'. cAsnot oon jadsmsn. sssnst the Ia
Ter.
nv II morrtroas nerv ersion of the las ON this head
20 nay nan,, arer or thres days alleged
possessioa before Justice sh,- thu De mas him
rlga, to the ere, virtually nd mit that the
rarity SCANS has good title 10 an that the
Jpsce take tine books and papers from the
q lawful ocer and deliver them to the ilesia
fosoCc, ree <S not 9TH YER d. jre, could no,
once, DE- sto on De jye's one eserc'ing ,be
functions ~ b. lice vito the pre.umane consent Of the
isguma' appointing power, tne detect 10 wooss
uils he ou b.r ras drcove Tag in the
gg sS ss s't Vs. :. s@"s' wend i aas ~ -
THIRD rhst ID, 'umn a y proceeding booze h
Justice P.ssy hsSe no influence In his case, IL re
s,pecafuy tns,stsa upou ssr tre folio ting ons-
Boes, I'D uet ny tho Quo al agent. OF . COR
oorsu suo l. 10 the rooms bcl,ogrg To- suon corora
aop are net In the ody Of on 'er
erian inx y bia Office, within the sense
and M. Al ma of the .ct q i2s art. 3; Frost
sr,shn 10 SaOd Ia Laval va De Lesserline, Mc'rds
r g. II
H. he statute I, admitted all hands to be applicable
Only 70 ~h're the ON - wa In oo''es'on o. toe
appl car. 10 ail'. x, 6s3 Yet Couoser's orgaal
,ompl.ipt ntther averret fscu ho~ins isg tile from
obi possession m,gbt pre,u me or satei ~ Tact
ha, be Gao sc.s' ro,,es'ion o' inc Once. ,,, -, :.
-fuy sup eo by proofs gwen sussequenly % tbs Is
suing Of The Greer Oevn 10 show csa-e but could
nave been an apad ttea tho sus,eqs ent ai tavs Of
and mpicd adu ,,i ,oioang Devln's acts AID tito
shov ~sain The sss'use, in the folosinS 10
sp~c'ss
Nv Crnovcrs .l avi,- losc the OF contested
sacoosso, and hat legally .r illegally, no was, fact,
aid 90, 81 he ce, an' oeeed the IA ans OF exercising
any by rupdrv asenis Of ihs o'rpoauon
That M, On ao ~i,'in am dsnuton o. mat
Term kpo b s~ AZ ohcer DE- J1eto ~ enc actually
sucrc,sns the ps OF the office sro the Apparent 60
au,s-ospoe Of the appointing power, uneer color Of las.
FOL eiscaiou ~ snrrDierni
A M. i.~ .ni isvi, mate By Conover hi self on the
10Th o. Juy 1887 expressly sAms that al the boots suf
cspcrs &c In ,n,lr rtbul roper piaces ~ deposit
ney could r rgofvl3 ls.faly, or with saiey 70 the
., bio interest, be removed from those psccs aud he
ysca by that, ~hi In their proecr srcs
al dep~s sbey ~ers out Of possession and beyond
ais control conclusive evidence that be W" not 10
poa.c. ~ The fnce
<is sA,uu nevc- Intended 70 esncuon tne 70
ova ~ pueho paper from their proer places OF depo
provided lbeir ,Afety and security b. the public "a.
thorue. NIL The olsm>Dt OF 40 office ny quo TRAN
or o4be,vi. has sq red sctnal control OF thc ce 10
poroar physc2 sense OF tnsA fern, hn summary
remedy can. q, be applied
" nwS In enoed 70 operate a. u has been used In
shs csse "a snnld be confined % booo and papers.
n voud esurd to tho rabbi, seals va,ons other pny
,cal inliemep, with mt which tue olcss cannot sci
void be epenfed 70 the ruoc room desk,, &c attach
I'd 70 thu on q nv law
D. AIo-ipg this statute TO be used In the way oonoyer
hs, employ ~oud oe nve hs public Q, AZ we oeoe
asp dcsls psa 10 doctrine OF olcer d. fdo
hl,st one camsb retained the room, tho public snas,
60 tho o,brr csi ant oy virtue OF samtns-y process
obtained from county lndgc, ~cuio carry on tns ooo
And pspcrs 70 spoher usca Neither ooad thin psrfo IN
apv service for nuolc The Official funca ms would
srirsr tasl and complete vsfa'yss
q In such On Q, rural Register and county Clerk
ouio sau,f y nele Judge tbs, he entitled TO the
oen al The OF oco might DO An Terrod 70
..y,cs IN Msrhreltre evpo~cd tmmu psrl diving