The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1857-09-28

\ "A x~.sat
would not give oAi 81 all, and Mr. viandr-Su 90
Lot Be (sr g. ~ss.wsrs, besides, that NJ ~ na a.,
n4 sesn n ne IsS % AK ss Ss =. spSssr
/ opepios hearing and discnArgng me psrtg sosu.4
E1osins 'hAi that ~sv bis pracs.ce, he lAr. 9) had
Jucse Rasssl--i ho~ ,h.t that nas been Invariably
| the Gscice cf the magistrates
~ s'1sne.-- IL iesaiin however, is Questionable
Jnose Ra11eh-f@, str.ys 0ouoied IL. ltgasy
- csrics Vour hcocr viii rocolieci tn.i Justice
D.vmco the magistrate entertaining tho complaint and
baying lnIis9iyii, N or We complaint
Judge Russen~-I understand, He issued the warrant.
BIT the rs'aie lnts out the ~aion mas
shsi lake, and he mus, follow that oonrse
M ssds ~ick-Jusdoe Fspdresu m Asistra.e who
or convenience, sook the bali bat Jussa Dawson
the impression the defendant N mi. care
reuosens,d oy his council did not want hearing Tina.
u 90 ciemGr' 10 the Gaze
NJ Galsra.h- We we're no. before the ia t,cs ,nen.
Judge Russei-I do not SOS -ba, 1, to DO ssiaod BY
sep, te back 10 The magistrate what 70 be
ssnsa " rot sending Is bssk
W. s., sick~Then why send II bacti
Jadge Ra.~el so far ~ he defence Is Concerned.
they NAY ..n I; have full state OF iAcss sost
asa "a ease goe before the Grand Jury all tue facts
n.y be before them hat right 20 WHOM they are
ie y aE sna s :, ie.Ss gay tue papers 'a'ai'
MY s#ick rhe Gro -e1Auinaiion OF ackles may g
before tho GrasdJuy but OF ne defendanpa
wue es esrr o. be by the Grand JURY for thai
" uid no contrary 70 iAw NV, - 'ne cfoss snAnna
ton - 'esIes, they ~sive tba Al tnep aeye TIA. hey
only want hearing on the part Of sSs dsoaos B.ore
they vouues red TO gre ball sns should have DO
msndee sac examination Of the con, slsinsnt
~ whiting. That u what 20 expect 70 CIV nov.
Jn0gs Kossell-N II the duss OF . msgts1>sa On the
erfeal AZ ayasy, him az to hts rgn sad 70
20 on sad give him the admission prescribed By isw
InEt va tho magSrse's duty In this cAse but he oai
Mr. seae stck-How does your Honor kuoy thstS
Judge RuDei-Tha pspe-s show It The affidavit signed
BY The nss.nse showssa there ~As no examination o.
NJ So that no, required in cas.s Of mis-
demesno under toe statute sili the .ro.eouHon does
uur TO oppoae t. THY want this 10 stand
Other rbey want 1t 70 De considered she defence
fscss 10 Court, and 30 examine sne law Vaey have
bad no time for that parpwe They mfso no o nor de
msnd, rasy do not ed what the lac IL or ~nas the
fs OF she csse are, out Trey wanl time 10 prepare for
bctG
Judge Ras.el-But the diaicul.y Is thai this Is the .I
da5 81 he term aad sha !. questionable yhssaef can
hear IRIS rsouor ~ chambers.
kr seogwcI Tho Court sis asso Ia another woek;
sow Hene', u 90 ~sal can 'en Lae 1oer'
Jaose Russril--l do not onocfe 70 do mat
~. seaR ~os-l am only plAciag mgseu on the Law.
Time ali aak because an tgaora Of ,he matter,
becar'e hAvs got riGht 10 Do gnoraoi Of II In Law
/, spruag upon rns how can pc called upoa 70 answer
The sHdsvt, or even ane or any prcpo vi MS az Law
.Iihou' my having bad legal uotee OF Inc motions nave
nuc polce In iAcl; ou, could temtno ios.i notice
NJ NhnuS-Tne nw 10 directiy me revni 20 Of WIKI
ny fierd SAT- Every man supposed to know tao law
1Foner c,ntsnRed upon ire prinoi lie snsI ha knows
he A~ How macn more is 70 be presumed thIt The
iesfned psv,cs Attorney know. the issf
Mr. ecg nickrhe learned gentleman ecdea voring 10
wil.y. whs said taai am rsierrod ~ PROPOSE
ioAa Of Law witch have mad dms 81 look into
does not reqcie lha experience Of tho leaned gentle
tell every supposed " the iss.
Mr.. WhisDs-hy learned friend vii No, undertake %
dspt.s enc Angle fact bow before the Court nor vii he
the Court his responsibility that
expss r. change In io's any fact alleged touching this
motion Blu, there another objection to ;be agi.trstes
oourse arosber uasy, A1ohor violation q tue las
BY the magistrate himself because Under ,ns act OF lsE
he bad right to tsse the recogazanee II ia renogni
zaooe sEeD without wsrrAns u Las. ~ Benne w1
fond with and TO have the cross exannA Ion OF his 90
oser and ne ougn, DC pat 10 MS deIen,e aod be
PEELED 10 int, and defend hini.er ron
indie Ioent until ha the oppor uEy OF examining
tine pros~outor And showing, In the pralmpNs exam na
ton thai the complaint should DO diamissco BY the ass
uAte He has right 70 the eauDuel hrs before the
mAshtrAte and thus, the case be dism'rsed save
expense. rhs statute says that no officer other
Now here Il csnp,an, made before ono mSsssrHss and
the deieroani ororsh before snoane- magistrate, sho
decb O. " bear the case and csIso, neaT becsuso be
did net sne The waryApt but ~ matter OF form be uSas
this recogr 'z>nco prisoner gong before Axsrale
70 DE nfor med By he imaginable Of Whist his rson
Mr. BeaDev had chosen 70 enter lpto this recogai
zAncs could just Flandreau dSLei Coad
have Dom nsed hinf Certainly not NJ Bennett hsd .
right 70 y, "Jusuos Fandrc~a, request you 10 hear
This case, oner wise win moi give batL" But Tor she
convenience OF the msgsae for the convenience Of the
tuolc, for The Convenience II assce the every day
sDaesrlAadpg thai the preliminary examination %
Afterwards had rtas u what WAS done in thie care.
s,,S sn' , sss oss P'HS0s % be ~ So~ 800 .Ss
q Jest mu n before VOC row a. l.
ron pcepoDed Il Tor an m snths. II es prosecutor
visa 10 % q with the sse 5e heard nj az mo
We have rgnt 70 hs exsuinaton before he case
goes tho Grand Jury; for ga e. ae Graao Jnry
The a9dsy OF he prosecutor aio1s Mr.. Bs.ne MAJ
he put 70 eIpcrie Of defending himself from Ia
d'cmsns which perosre sonld not be ionnd tnsrs we're
. previoos examinsnoo This 10 privnss prosecution
II VI srayo punlio ou~Lcs, but tue iast>,ce
OF private pro1eousor Who make, uze OF the power
the STATE 70 pub'so part for ccram ins libel on om
OUc great Question 10 whether this ibsi, and II the
statement u uheilous .hethef ts rue o. ~ fns de
'cndsn uo plsoed In ,ne roaon u having Inc
baueG, q he prosecrtoEs eIaiaLoa f0f as nrs.
he trial n tho Il /. Al importan ma ter
i'm orsDt sr - nnesl aud perhaps Important ~ the
psos@ocsor-and psrv's rights should Ma be wiiahei
from hin In such case
Juoyc RUSSELL zee no reason ny ihe casa should
iss. . aif rent 6om csner sos Tue ~ sts OF
ssrty ought DO pyssec'ed, ami thux tst icr the
ciiaums.pces u h nv day d hav. tae pspcfs soIt btN
tns yete IN the n,itde the ,srm eyca Ia the las,
zegk CT he torn, -oud gtsa. time 80 that tho Ds
lct Attorney nigh. hsvs al oppouoiy 81 o1nrovertns
ssavA - M Ga bra b. ~ tie ooaid dn % Hat there
POSSIBILITY " deforrins The ms.tr, anu xno s'og H.
GsisIa, well - 90, belsvs -ould he altogether
aficss grant umc for tina. purpose This bIng the ss
lag or n tney 40 before the Dsr tsf aud
ntiuue ,be c..e and thsn h magistrate send the
spers back he tor FUR her acton shall there
iue ordsr drso tse pagers ~ be sent back 70
lie magttsic Tor further bearing