Kanawha Valley star. [volume] (Charleston, Va. [W. Va.]) 1856-1861, 1857-05-26
d EANAWHA q H. VIRGINIA, TUESDAY, MAY Rd, 1857

II v
ealsanetlon Of the Am4riaaaApeople, and
all subsequent REELECTION has but satisfied
me more thoroughly that the interests 81
IourI people, and the purity of our Gev,
ernment, ifnot it's observation-disclosures up.
on its obsefs ance. + sishhe Public Lands
fare the common property Of the United
States, and the moneys arising from theil
sales are "a part oftfe public EoYenue."
Farther on, Gen, Jackson also says;
tiff themoncy 3 tie United States
cannot be applied to local purposes,
through its own agents a& little can it be
Ethps expended through tile asestcy Of the
State Governments. ..
New then, if Gen. Jackson held Il
Unconstitutional t9 divide the pro,
ceeds of tile Pablo Lands among ths
Estates, would he not have held Mr.
CarEle's measure equally unconstitn;
| tiqnRl, which DIVIDES the yerysLands
| tlatSsell for the prqeefds2 VI
4 Following Gut Mr.. GarlilG's pfopo
sitiof, could not THE States sen tAg
lands. and pocket tAe 4.very proceeds
(which Gen jackson ,feclarAd it+ un.
constitutional to Divide atpdng THEM?
EBetweeR the two measures of4liyilling
It!ic proceeds af the .PRblic Lanls d
dividing the Rublid Lambs tlteti>$elves
SO faftas the constitnti6naItf #of. thc
matter goes, there Is, actndllyf fo dir
I feferite atsall, .lE HIM.
.WeseA then, tltAt se far irohl AIr.
1 Callile'sI4anl Divisi orlSeheihe Agree.
ling W-ith Gen. Jackson i. 'Sfie,tB. q
4 tic G5nstth2tioas" tte#- t~d afe Wide
/ APART as the polls I'll =. t.F@ 4
/ NdW let us=enqlile how, the#5s,tio
Of distfibdfiollKW Which III emhfaced il
! Mr.. Garlilels propositi4n, Wonld haye
4 correspondent with Gen. ] ackson's
E''yieWB Of sound polirYlana tic right
IQf the respectiFe Staten
In #Mr. Garlic cirenlar, page n, b
1says THAT after eqt{alizihg the gxRnts
OF Public Lands, iheI PROPOSES Nto
i diyidG. theTe$ilRe ionSaltlie StateE
! sssaccdrtling 10 theit iespectiyef and
usltath}rol29rtioll inthe general ellarge
and expenditure, Iere WE perGtivt
\ he quotes 4 line from #the, Virsssinii
Ideel, hi cessi0n. Bht What does Mr.
1 Carlife understand Ii theA ''resltee
I1tiYeapd usual pronoItiI1n. iils!t he Zen
n Elseral charge avid eSPefi2l Itupef lily
Turning to his speechslh1de HIST lies
n sioh inr-t lIQRse ofE ReBfesell tatIyes
4 which, wiliSbe Round IN tAe 1Aaer6at
If Ofqda of' Feb 2GIh.I as 4 Nellltit Htai
Il IN theE Gongt,easfoalI lfLo6e, We4fnt
H stthatIhe proposes tptliyidethf Iiap(h
| ameng the States .ae&orsling ste: ttllkkeil
II Congressional thtttIis ttheir lNettra
!. Y representation. a. .5.4,
il Nov itso happcsisEthat the Fedora
or CONGRESSIONAL ratio III Distribution
] whichsthe Bill beford spoken bf epf
, tanned, was another III the reason
! why Gdn. jackson VETOED it. Aitte
!, giving pne7pight Of the5 proceeds. g
i tIfesP lblic Lanlsstd Vile new States
II H. s 10 81. Ifl +lS+ Alt a
. ~ l14 'lYN;'isSt ea's's r'hs ~, III H.
Eq l Il ~ ill., III
ss' fta t u N9'i We sse lT H.,
etol! n e''Salt4 1,'01 NH 4 1 e f Ta
.fsSt L I u ~ II 4lfl NJ, &, aI,
IN ss Il. I'LL H., III P ], n E,ta
III ILL., o, ill., t,a, ~ lh;,f Min ef3,
fY Ill., H. s3 S,1, o HS.n, ~
IT. s,ft u ~. : / u,
e }lf a D " hp II ''te Hth;
sii, Il / t, 5ha,! lisg,,;sed u
IflIa1ates t6e'eon1ifiohs, apoh whicR the Ilfni
tsd Statss- ACQUIRED titlB na ths foede,
ssIland. Abandoning altokether thaE< r,&:tti
! lofdistfibution aecordihgTo gsnersi dharg
land eSpenditure prorileH hg TILE com
Fpacts, II ddobts tiat little Te;as1at ~
! -iConqressionaf re6feseatast,e pepkttdttQa.
.Ni Here. Then, We fihdR Mi. Gallild'
tt.tl prouo5sitian conflicts Il dire5dtfN witl
% III of,,s syi,,xsI If sound poli
q s51 fbn r;aI,ts III t]se ,;s,,,spef ! /,
Il &C.,, 80 S7I, Ga.1;1 bas xxx I'LL
ola.e XII "a. Az p,. oas &, fydf,
qneInitl use % t!e aeests S II ! u
tlte ataFes as aSelfYlltS lt7. = ~ Iioins
(thougit indeed ohtSa Yefy sil1 !, PIT
f1of ting pubic DOMAIN FNas sellitls !, 81 81
-dfliFed. III the same f Fn FISH
Z a X, n n. II