The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1857-09-12

New York He wss here 70 say that II they made that
nomination they might look in vain for 40 600 OF majority
rem New York cry. BE would vote for him hini elf II
nomip saed bat would be inexpedient, mpoiuo aud
improper nomination II was . nomination not NJ 70 DO
msde, and they would presently have resolutions present
cd the Police BILL Bus how could they 90
fore ihe people with these resolutions on one side and
Judge the oher He should give hs vote the
Convention against him. because he did not consider him
demCcr he understood democracy, and be hs
nomination would be IN insult to New York city.
Nr. NoRAscH spoke few words amidst confusion, and
was understood To be against Judge Denio.
TIE HswsBoYs CONVENTION.
Rrrus W. PscKHn, Of Albany, nav mounted the plat.
form and oomnsnced speslins bu. the bays entered with
precpitae dives towards the boys crying for the NEW
fosH HERALD and nterrupDg the proceedings till Capt.
Ryndes in Ht Of generosity, threw handful OF silver
into The boys hands bought up the whole atock which
Mr. PrcKnAs then reviewed Mayor Woods speech,
That gentle had by declaring that he had
the highest respect for the judiciary and before oonclud
because whyi Because he had given judicial san oton TO
Law which he Mayor wood) did not spprove-
Mayor wooD Onsenupting) said that he had made no
M PIoKHAM coutiuued-He did not think ho hsa mis-
represen,eo the gentleman He had said that Judge Deaio
was unfit for the bench; and why un1d HIS Ito
extoed his abilities admiited-but he differed from other
democrats In the res ults he arrived upon
mated sbi.y. Who because be failed o come up 10 what
the gentleman thinks the rgh standard OF democracy,
was 70 be denounced ~ NO dcmocrat a man unt to se
on the benoh and unworthy Of the nomination Of this
Convention This hAysh verdict to render man,
for political o1ce, much LEGS for judicial one
He had acted With Mayor Wood most queeti ,ns which
came up before the Convention but could in hs He
did not benevs the Convention prepared TO cast
Judge aide because he differed from the democracy OF
The Slate on 0 question Of law. He proceeded 70 argue
tina. the question Of the constutonsly Of the law had
reson 20 IL meriu saying that We might - well attack
for ns judicial opinion on N his law. indeed, The
decision given asa.nat his osn friends, and with the
knosledge that would excite their opposition, was :
- hss nd tutow vtfw ha hn
eved were mot prepared regard the independence OF
The judiciary iu such Light - TO ay 70 the jadgc,
iben you all right but you decide against the
Police bill, and nov yon are oil wrong Der bench can
never siand such be the tes No man with self repeot
would occupy judicial olce when told when you decide
With the democratic party you are worthy, and when
sganst you unworthy Yet this waa the character
!h.. Mayor Wood would give 70 We M Jude %Judicy; As con
way honorab o and at 10 be made
nR. HcKIm pKHNEs POSITION.
DANIEL T. sicKIs then took the PLATFORM he said he
would de tho Convention cnly long enough to explain
the motives that Influenced him in voting for the candi
date for the Court Of Appeals. II was not his !n,en.
ton TO follow tho gentleman who had preceded him
Every delegate occupying . place In tina. hal
had two fold posuona position - the exponent Of his
individual Wishes and position the exponent Of the
wishes Of his constituency. II the question before tnat
body, presented In the nomination Of Judge DEMO-
ques Of endorsement Of Tho wisdom and fairness and
room for nsants hesitation Their platform would de-
nounce the folly u dice and wickedncss Of tho principles
Semcersc, % repssi that hs and place the heel Of
reprobauon upon H. Bat he, ~ spsking for himse did
not undssand that any such issue was presented here In
tho person Of Judge Denio He dill not pass the fair
justce Of the legislation IL was the Legislature
that did that The sole ISSUE presented 10 Judge Deno and
10 oorsdsr 5. aw impsrsIIy ana ry ana sSstsor The
ccnstisutlon, By III terms and letter, denied 70 The
LEGISLATURE NE power % p... . .uch 70 i. statute
OF COURT sad the consultation did NOT prohbn In this
be differed from many able and erudle lawyers and from
ed hs every man would ooposce nss Judge Dsno reach
cd tA decision through pure heart and bright intellect
He may havo been In error In hs opinion, - what
may notf But say that for dinefing In opinion
on single question WI Political friends 10 /, 30 co.,
sidered /. fAilhlsss 70 his w party and alien %
sso prior % NE convention Of isss, Judges we're
appointed by the Governor and Senate, and was
beard .ssa or S:.%sS S,. q s
Political qusssi,n against bis political friendss No, for
such act would have consigned Tho party thas sase
win eismiss upright Judge from power because he
commits an error OF Judgment We called
rOr..d By IL. 'SoV Go1srnor n@'s and seo.s
II vas due 70 The Conycnsion ihai be should declare,
Representative Of New York constituency as an eI
tesres and fesnes he could not support The nomnaon
Of Judge Den6 He should pos fairly and honorsbly re-
DO not wish Judge DEMO = their candidate In this be
differed with them He had said 90 70 them ., home ana
might say here He bad Iod his constituents when a.
reoicd 70 cast bis vote for another candidate that they
bad committed IN act which aimed . bos n
The very heart OF democratic government, be-
which might fall. He said 70 ,he Convention
thai here - his own Representative the vote he would
give for Judge DEMO would es the prousss. Of a, e but
other person. (Loud spplause)
JOHN cocnaASK's VIEW.
Mr. CouRASs next took the stand. He said the main
question whether democratic principles would sufcr
In ihc selection rejection OF Judge DEMO for the Court Of
Appeals. rhere was wide difference between The do
nuDcisiou Of the judiciary - exists, and the
selection Of noe candidate for The bench
He held lhaa Judge DEMO should be Withdrawn tho
questions would be in regard V the oandidsiss he
capable and sithfulS 10 he hones,7 There certainly
pertinent In rsaon 70 Judge DEMO- who was sos 70 be
oestnusd In otios but 70 be renomina'ed for . nov
krm since The adoption o. NE new constitution p,
nical parties bed recognised the rehi 70 eleus can
didaies for .he Judiciary upon party considerations,
and could be no ialhcy 70 say tnAi Judge Denio's
fs argument vM designed to provo ha mo democratic
Party had always recognized the principle OF in9urns
inso The ssnccrs,,o s0gsoIs'' o. candidate Tor The
vas seecied account Of his acquire nens and demo
cratic priDclpes, % should udgss be selecssd He en-
shost Of judicial independents. II was not present
hero to-day. He desired 70 sdd bis tsumosy
.,rss ss ma. as.s .e,e se' po~ aass1 sss.s
baby brightsv iumnasy nov shines In the
udicir ar nAnsnt. but called on noe 70 selscs
candidate ths Court cf Appeals whose VIII bs
proper and expedent 70 yesent 70 the people of the A
for supTcrt tov his dDtyct New Yoit) he nigh cay
there diGtrenoe Of opinion AL unanlmsus 10
desiring . oAn1dac vho should present Q dirccs
With The q the last IHgiasture, the iron Of
which he'd enisred 20 deeply Into their souls.
rm srRAi pnSGArE GROWING Rrmvp
Jou KELLY rose 70 speak, when . delegate from The
rural dsrics suggested thai The opinion Of he New
York delegates tolevably we tnovp BY thI, time,
might be well so lake the sentiments OF persons from
osher parts OF ths HAsa
Mr. EnIr proceeded 70 say that Judge Dcnio had Do
used ihe streets OF The oitT Of New York blood with
regard 70 these very laws, and would be fot he
Convention 10 nominate him and expect The people OF Nsv
York support him. He had Tear In ylns that you
can peruade the people Of Nes York 10 Judge
DEMO BE thought the time Of The Convention had already
been sufficiently consumed this subject, and moved
that they procces by the method before
CO ndic ates for the Court Of Appeals
Mr. Lrpnw objected 70 the of making nominations
bersioore adopted BY tho Don venion He desired 70