The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1857-05-07


no, AN m'sst ~ ~ ~ 'r ~ "u
wboi pa ,h ahtc w. 70 ,es ~ s,a and, mr.
49,, =, nv "ot"'.D ~ ~ w II ""''N" D"1 ~.
az. , VIC 'o'n'f a. iofo Was NJ ooiV'cn a's0r
~ w u a. -. a. "a ~,
~ " lou an MOI mean 10 nave anything sscref A. NO,
N'n ,ys. a., .,
esa ns ho VA, INC d., A. p.cai ws 49,
ann ps me ~pnfs 'aym'ps Them SO AMI o. Coarse
We e9pld OF have gent mon interfere and could not 20
% nS ,1 e 49, ~ ........ us
c,r ~ ' ' ." ~ '"F''u'' IND "'''N'' a. W.
sTo Then u,,, AZ m ,.
an c,htis ih"v ,,ny 80 ~ =; sypk yyu S'"I no. -
b., nr c'i,' a' q. ~ 1'"s ,''o,e, YsptIsys
IDA, ,ios W. san zane n aSd examined tho body while
W." n WI, Az. h, h e'9 80, s'','r ~ -, -,
-, ', al NV =" - ~ n''a my pao. aaois we m
n Al ,ho, rnn ,no 80, !" 'ss Jv.r ,no boy
Nc, der;ieIIy Ill, 80, = % rie,'pS WIN yV.f ~
n IT, 80 go, 49," $3.50, 10, -, "a ani''shs we nsiy'
yon,i moi hsDs anv "',' .'snusna 20.
n" o. ns m, ac,oe, .,, v,,, yo.,,,
": Woo 90 asrsca WIN yoY a. DC wa' not present.
. =, so ~ ~ -. 10y .'n T." ny yoa IA
agTeers a. There was DO asI9orlest At The tmo
q ihen nobody Dut you on,"cl,eY A J sospendei Mo
9. What dld you say 10 Dr. Gilman
cahnot permit repeti,'ons OF evidence
.ou,Gei IoI teience-i nave n% nDtetou MN W sAtS
"nht No Fad
JadgS pay ie'-Ask hin, again No,
Judge pasio. --hc a',i 81 told him that Alter got
ui0aeh nc might conduct hi esh.nnaron."
You on os say 70 I'm Tat me Examination must bs
nid yon t1aeot Tho wound IN The neck. A. did
~, q WI" Wss, SSN ~ "a ho ,oor,
~ % sno a.s %'''H'g o y ~ VI ""oa and oreh.
O. Dr. thl snd De- Rrsh! d't not attend 70 ~ A. They
were ~ INC olher room -.
my ,o sr, Sy s"'f a. '''s e"~ VI"
g They ia not dsseo'n A. They haia knowledge
'bst we 5ii. ,, v--,.
. Iask You Hhether " ~ anu .n' hngns asssctSa
only
nno IT . az Iuu 1T h',as.' anu ny ~ AZ.
a'ter seeing m
10 "hat event az Jon dt'ccs ~ a; 70 sne e1sent
Of taking out about inches Of tho carotid sssyy sboot
external snd internal carotid artery.
mness pointed eu, On lra".s o. ~, .no sna:'my
man hcai now Jar ne han 1s seetsut TINS woAnn
O Wa both the external and Internal carotid ont A.
fes'
9. what do yon mean BY Mo common carOh' A. Be-
And after tho bfurcaoo 10 Is tho external and In
"f ~ T,. q, iw ru or N. 49,, in ~.
EAa'y where was INC GUY ~ INC necn w. aoovo
inc o onoi,aaon OF oeio~r a. Aoov" mo onuFcAon'
nh , Gu. eSus 4: a; !. Yss ~, n.,s 3D. :.
on The right eide, TOO. A. NO, sir.
v lHeh no" 10 you Nno~ 'ne "aecuo1 10 vnson mo
Rh,o wshn a. ~ p,ooe sIa uy o u.rs s
L. ~ s - =. s.,s ~ .s-~...
IN making mo dSsceuon "o oxcoVereo 70" ufscoon ne
To , c On. AID Won sssec, tho vocna ~ Ina usok,
a. 30 as 70 set on s" ,ho S cuH ,n sn
open suhci.n'y 70 SEQ ING oecoon WHICH 'no ~ond ns
taken;
q Then how did you know that tho right cAxodd was
wOnntedf a. Wc Dill NOT ray IL was.
e. understood yon 70 answer mo DHrcs Auorpey thas
va a; NO, .r.
Tho depth Of tho wound IN tho neck you oniy Knew
from nc prooeY a. And dissection.
q Then 10 what extent did yod d1secH a. nmcieruy
TO get a, the artery.
v But beyond that you oil not goF u. Inc roo0 wons
beyond that 10 the depth ri Elk inches
Judge Iaye.s- from the outer surface Of mo woundf
A. Yes, SIR.
q Could you Tell without d.tec.on exactly tne direction
OF M wound III the neck, and ia extentf a. Wa could
q Tbs wound IN the neck s ncce|ariy mortar wound,
iftBosf A. IT'S
q Aud m,s canse dOs,h very scon' A. Ycs, Il hsmor-
rl@ge Dc nc, arrested
q When both corotds are cot, can the hencThags os
nra,uring
y Iheu II Is th u'"rtN sonh" A. IT'S mortal
wound
O. In how soon would IT PROVE rnor'aH A. Perhaps In
thirty seconds
DID you ever Know case wn.ro ootn caiouos we're
cur ~ lesi have seen ssycfni suicides VIA DIM Ca
roin. cut, but 90 nov kho" DOW iop9 'ney nve''
Then y ~ mere matter OF ofinlon a. 70 how Hng .
@ Is generally known by people nos in the medical
profession jest whore the carotid lcs2 A. There are
some people on ci NE fmes'on VINO Know os'tef tnan
others. ! think the Prec!so locality Is not generally
known
" j. there any place N The human system where On
h moro fatal than IN tho c,rotid' A. In tho heart
q L. the heart moro Fatal than tbs caro'id7 A
Death Is more irstantaneor, but 10 place 10 nsors G1
than me carotid.
Ordinary people when they en-, their ihroais, 80 thsy
tiDk they are cuitng mo caronV a. Ihey scs Win tno
idea OF cutting the csroud
=, Judge iayies-whero Is Tho ,asnlar' A. Directly BY
W. tIae ~ tAe chruui. .,.,-,,,
Jndso Msi@--u one CUT mo Juguar wonh 10 necesa-
amy coi INC tmoshf n. Nos hecesafiy; yoa are very
Afs 70 cut inc common cafoi pcof'o seaerhy, Va cut
'lig tmslI throat, cut 10 from. -
:, V win lesfIe no' a.1uM.sea WIN an.'omyl - y n@
'be "r'iEary way % attempting 20 comm" SUICIDE, ono
want TO cut his throat 70 cot In rcn A. They generally
cHt W iroit =
They DO not snemn 70 srlko tne oaroidy A. do
nol kho" whether uey MsmPs " tnaI VIAL usy gene
rally do
Do Won uss tcf mo wound hat Was tmAted one men
IRON TIC lcitnirp.es ~ We did DOT dssect H. we nsa
aureaM
q WHY noV y, We did nOt consider " nec~sry.
" Could you tll Without hs.ccnon tho exact nasns o
The Instrument Nsh which II WA coinmttedf A. coahi
not.
o. Would discretion enable you to dosof A. No. sb dis
Section would help IN coming to conclnson; bnt 30 di
mot think u necessary.
y 1ou en- B"t coSsifrr u nocnf7ary W ifseSs mat
souod OF inc wound ~ ton neck A. NO
" th what sort Of hstrutncot ~ies VIC yodl ID "a"
neck ina otcif \. With a sharp inSltnent