The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1857-05-18

oe.yne ga, from spy the.
Y what paisrs did Gerard sive your A. don't re-
member that Gerard CAV int any, think remember
that lssssiere ga, u6e come bni / sure: am
~" sure wtether to pspes now befo' the Oart were
handed me 10y NnOu, Tsss Dtere or ne ,nhO'on:
o. G'st under the impression nssancre haded them
me on reaeoaon tell whioh handed them TO rus
HSys oS e Ts ss SeTs s S Ss Cam :" %
have man, books papers brought this country b.
erfo.t The witness now in ny % ses, ioa thsse re
,srtsly. by cur ONCE neen nlen's ,hitk nave
Other papers than those Included IN my last An Ser n,
before the C,omiesner In some say refe ring "a the
blsipe. here Tcu brief ths, i, all: have also -eps
na..rs In cy,, sum. have MOI any more: got thea,
paaeys al yarous tunes csut tell when tie drsi; pre-
. me bette.p the bennpc Of Sepem Der 1886 and the
ne they were laid before Mr. Betts
O. Wh,oo Cf the pausre before the Commissioner can
wa dessnate az having rec wed in SeptemberS A.
cant rsc,nze thai received aay Of them in September
can o, t- a. IN Ia, time or reos ,t of any by in ir
dates ana then showing for ,e ne u their ming over
csnp,t reco,pize any in Uo,ober can't tdenufy the
month No wo,rh any were rcce,yed nv memory Ia about
sy~sae rather bad. -
q Ara there or vrre there nA ta.srs thai we're use3
IN The O. Sc that are MOI berc ana OF which YOU for
,,yne had ,s,asfestn
one s.si 70 as irrelevant
Bu tesd intends 10 show the ttuthrnes OF theory tbs
thr,e ue, othes pspess used IN le case AZ 10 aus
tan thsr CAGE which have been abstracsed that 1t Ia
malicious prosecution and improperly coaduued
Objection overruled.
A There arc tssrs when bsys recei we'd -htch g.
Dc. be ia the CASE va have NOT pdi ths
Case
O. STATE what they are and state them allf
Objected To- Ober,ioo sustained Exception
q Are any runers Included IN chr AIT answer priya..
r~per, Of yoars
Otae<sei TO- Oblctica Sustained
Was th,re any Presidential for the
trAicn accused than that before Mr. Betis
Objected IT, Orerruled
A believe there was; I believe l am quite sure
November, b.. can't sal for certain.
Wa y presented TO any Unlted States Commissions
member, ~ am swsre Of
y Wa presented ~ Any xhcer o. the United NAlee
A. NUT ask what sou mean by prese'dedy
9 Imean WAS II eshib'ed' A. J think It WAS sho%a
Mckeon he VI Ia this case,
cis rult by The Northern Railroad Compa agans,
NJ a f,,s ss,, SIy az e.Gp
Mckenn yocktg at H. Pillow had custody OF |,
then, believe; can't ssy whether In Pillows McKe0ns
or nine, OF Do Monthoon's hands.
Q. pout ycu know that il vas exhibited to Commits
sionerP A. don't
io1erY A doar remembps TIA, be did and II he dd i,
would be only heAxsay,
Q Was nos il exhibited to any Commissioner besides
d. you Know wiser sny United sss,es cmm.
ooer or either United a,a officer issued any vsrraDi 10
ams,ton a these accused or sny OF them or TOOK s.v
step y Whatsoever thrreundors 4 I don't remember. I
ns. hs. wss form Of xsrr,,s drsSn ~" eo SasS 0a
rs1top vhe,her i, y-sa signed ana I,snat ~
The CSnmissousr or not Mr. rioo drew !, ap as Wen ~
aver Com missioner va. 70 scs hat DON, Su," ,hsi ~
u,ep led for any psrtcusY fomssIoner. n tho as, NJ
my recollection read the form Of warrant drawn up
oeAeve TAXED WIN him a. associate Counsel about
NJ JAcAiussen moved 70 strike Qua all evidence IN 70
ston TO the private acts " Mr. Msrrosh ~ counsel In
fererce 70 and az TO private couservaoa between him
sen and private Counsel IN regard 70 u Mr.. Mckeos
argues In support Of the motion
MARCH I2-Au present AZ 70 mouon OF Mr. Joachms
ssn granted on the ground that at and conversation or
he counsel with witness are priviieeed-as TO his
private ac hey cann0t DC inquired into wout proof OF
relevancy.
q Dfd you ever see thai dram warrant aoer w&s
shown 70 Mr.. Keen "a you hsve staedY
Objection Objection sustained. Exception
M B<eed gives notice 70 counsel for The prosecution
10 produce thas warrant
10 yoo Know ApgusH fArotf A DO from seeing
rim here IN Court don't remembes seeing him anywhere
che; nave seea 0odard; sn0w him BY sight;
versed with nm VI his exra0n case 70 the best OF my
recohectsoo; ne mas oeeu ~ Tuous ofnoe when was
mere
ootccuon 70 ev'oence OK Godard'S acts toer0 Oojcc-
Hon sustAned
NJ bu'tesd oaess 70 prove ~ witness I'M be was
Pre-ens In nisoos 0ce and saw eodard give 70 Iue1
portpho-a pockesoook which was taken from AugSste
fnroi AND wncn contained 60 ip "a OK NE compAny and
osner papers OF pecunr vAae; ana mat toey have beea
a ppro NOetlNrn n