New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1857-01-20

bought, ye. II does Dos sp2ly 5sexsr. use-. -s
have some lsrger sIpisns'ion msde OF TIE word
bought" .hsll s.s ;h.s you will consider a. 40
Tsn ~ Mr. Ga,chsb's staDdng-a lasyes-prssune -
huy q slave without q bill Of saei Why have they
rot PRODUCED il Why hss not some exp aoaton been
nsSs Of III where is bis eheck-his receipt for IL
Where is the witness, and last though not least,
vtere is Mr.. Oaterbr;dge Horsey Where sre
,h.yl S,lerce answers where Do you suppose,
II Mr. Ga'chel knew that be could DOT sup
port bis possession Of thus BOY, "l.nS SI Tbsv
have tuned out Of Baltimore man at'er N 81
AMER this poor fugitive and yet where is Mr. ont-
bridge Hoiseyl Here is woeful gap IN ther Gaze,
which it VS. in their power to a aod Solcn ney
fe,led 10 fill We have no testimony from the oegio
ming 10 the end Of this Of Mr. Gatchs, me eiier
Can you under the testimony, xth your hand on your
be.r; and your eye turned 10 Heaven say thar tn's
youps u6p IL slave TO VIM. H. Gatcneh iot n,o
Heaven help us if We are 10 be made slaves III nus
manner fbe witness, James w. Brown, says ne
knew hin, zen yesrs previous associated Win hin'
vent 10 parties with him Who else1 No T. ilck''
who cav BIZ knew him some eleven years 40 III VIC
CITY of Baltimore IS free boy. Now, Sir, sre t1tse
yourg men nstattni They have not been c)nua-
cict,d nor jmpeached. l claim for the witnesses on
the pat of the defendant, grester Competency 0,
education than the hirelng iave-cstchers OF Myltnu
men pha are hired 10 hrnt Gown their ieuoSmsn.
Ard net | am told | dare not doubt the com
nttercy Of the witness. Il dsre do what man
sdare do. Who dsres more is not 8 man aPpIy
n
W,tLoop roe and protested against the insult offered
70 lie tfficers) The very name of Bill Thomas VIII
bring a thousand recollections TO the minds o' eSe
men ard now, a lawyer, Philadelphia lawyer s'As
that you should coDsgn to the dungeon 70 tne WHIP
This yours mad We have the testimony OF not one
but dozen that in 1850 this young man was IN PM
sde,phia How are all these fscts 10 be coatra iicted
ny learned friend cannot 90 so-wul not are not
the Sc witnesses entitled 10 as much oeet-gret1er De-
lief than the testimony of the claimant ms Young
man has been arrested in the streets OF Pnadeipha
hustled Ia the Mayor Office brought 10 tal, nessed
with ripor without time scarcely 10 collect ~ own
thCpobis ask bin, il, under these cirumrances be
is not entitled TO a discharge. Sir, am appro 'chug
the conclusion of my outies in this case lhave ieU
have endesyored TO discharge my duty TO my Client
feel great and solemn duty Is 10 devoVe upon YOU
Ore that il TO affect you for veal or woe from now 10
et.tri,y You have in your hsnds that which Is mote
valuable than life or deaih-thst ofhoerty You hSve Ia
your bands the scales of justice, that you must CLOSELY
,crutjnze whether they predominate IN the favor OF
VIM H. Ga.cbell before you cone in this young man
10 Slavery. Ii is a dny you owe to man that you
should dismiss him to his quiet home and send tals
claimant h0rt,ng TO bis land we are approaching tue
close of great weeks labor, and when the Jehovah
had FL ished his work, he said, IT IL good; and
when You close ths week labor, would nave You
lay Your hsnd on your heart and say, " II Is GOOD:
Who HI OWE Sir but that there s some mother IN THIS
city whose heart will be lsceIated by this verdict
Who knows but that be hiss old father whose life
will be br0k en- down by this calamity Who knows
but that there IL some friend IN this city whose ye
you- of God upon you-of an svenglng G)d-who
hes said MY vepgesnce will last forever" Here
Dir PIERCE and The pris ner were boh affected to
tears have in conclusion, only 10 ask that you VIII
stue reesse for this poor young man.
Mr. DoUeherty rose and epoke 10 an llogies oil Dir.
Peirces remarks Of q statements that sd been msde
by the witnesses for the defendan-ot the vilyng eei
hets that bad been hesped upon the opposite sdeand
that Ibis law Of the land the brpherly relation that's
sted between the men Of the North and South, shoud
be respected.
Com. Brown then rOse snd said that in his remarks
be should be brief that the Constitution OF the nited
States made the n after summary one, hut that II
should not be said that be had in any manner acce er-
ated it, He sed that the prisoner had had every fayor
show him. and thst the matter had been presented 10
biz nh in such favorable light thst he should DC
obliged under the circumstances, TO issue warrant
for the safe delivery of the boy TO the hands OF biz m
ter The court then dismissed, the slave and 9th
GERS rtmsinDg behind his person was searched, aud
bis hands manecl.d, aud in that condition was con-
viewed into the lower office
Deputy United States Msrshals jenkins, Crossn and
Officer Graham OF Baltimore put the hsndcuffs the
fugitive although the search of his person revealed the
feLse tbOut him. Toward ii o'clock the fugitive
heavily manac ed, driven TO the ,ltmore depot
surrounded Nth officers, and he was taken 10 Mary
lard by the late train. The coored persons who had
evnced deep interest in the case, conducted them
selves with the utmost decorum after the rendition Of
the fugitive decided upon and under the oircum
stances cannot refrain from saying that the hand
cutting cruel as II was needles.