The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1857-05-06

fore obainabe may be obtained under the provisions q
that chapter The language 10 be sure 10 Affirmative
pregnant with the suggestion OF negative thas other ~
medies not generally TO be had Hereunder Oesr
Of the u s ns
action, strengthea the presumption that neither this
the other provisional remedies nsenAed 10 b appoa-
bic TO except where they expressly declared In ter
to be soand on the whole am satisfied that Is not
horized by that system (See 43S providing for
anOrds many other evidences general provsooso
actions do NOT apply to the action treated ofn this chap
said thai some Of this reasoning does not apply 70 csss =
which the validity Of the Offices q in controversy. n =
not necessary thai should for this Is not such oasa
The existence Of the oces admitted necessarily in ~
suit and the title Of the defendants 70 them alone in a
ton. Ny conclusion H. thai injunction restraining -
authorized BY law. The oonsderatoa Of the other poin
made by defendants becomes unnecessary in the yieW
have taken The injunction must DO dissolved.
SUPREME COURrLGKNERAL TERN. \
Before Judges Mitchell, Roosevelt and Peabody.
ARGUMENT UPoN THE coNsrfrufIoNALxFY o. I'm
METROPOLITAN PoLICD ACT.
MAJ s-fAe Pnpe On Dc yeioSom Of Fdvsumdo W.
~ SIMEON Dvupr, d aL-k was agreed BY the oou.ssl,
before commencing their argument that each one wssd
only occupy two hours In speaking
Mr.. oConor on behalf Of the od Police Commissioosrv
opened the case BY giving q sketch Of the proooedisg
thai have taken place regard tho Metroposaa Puos
before the gesersl Of the Supreme Court upoo =
appeal from the decision Of the special Supreme oouss
he considered the only question before the Court was he
one In regard 70 the oonstuuonalNy OF the aforcmaa
toned police BIN He then presented the points Of bis e.
gument, which are as follows,-
complaint against defendants IN the nsure on Os
;,a, e, setting d.c.. hersnaS stated
va. me sn s The people
anita o. ne "a 2, ARsil lssI ne dssssd.ns oo@nz
Is 1851 had they n,s. netting and orsansed Board Of 70
hessupSs assumed DE o. de police orys q Ned
YORK IN case presents snse question. wSesher -
ts Por The Metropolitan Poi,cs bul In n. whole ssops
pea,ns clauses. %aaesy resasnsn o sSs IseS - "a
rsss ~ %s W ss s. .
sss s and rs q ss
ssex ss. esries oejec, Of hs' 'nsrmen 20 red4
CConv.n.iOn Journal D. i.ss!S
os pc . q s.,s 5s a. ps:
s made sss ss. 3 <. cse q s .:d
c ON r. Joarns, P ls q
hsi this hghy approved principle o. decesrIaoo wss en-
,spSsd 70 oc power IS ws a 70 psonHse aud THAI ey
TO the isrihess practicable limit One single for spec
reasons wa. excepted from the general rule. Erss-
l. The Senatorial Judicial and Assembly districts ere.
departments any sense ye such Of As ns wSin sss
s Nsss W. ,sss s ana
sos q s q aa ssun sas A'
The Legislature Is allowed 10 al.er even those merely
he return each pssS snd dn. + =
ssoo arr s. sec 49, Il Is in,ms.a ' Sa s ns.. Sor
would eooorn 70 the spirit OF the constitution BY oonfevng
POWERS q local NO ana. and s%os.sr.
ssS ne mater q e as sy s be- nS y Of
nate districts single Assembly dis,cs and small juasi
and yIascs ,her elective occrs elected b. ne 10
esd font me proposition 90 which the se,roporaa 20
es e s sousn % ss .seseca s s es.s der. 20
pPo:e. 2, CIV, lawfully erect sod
~ W. s.S;S; sssss
render n,s.,o the most mpors.., features Of
The consuioa recognized al the osvl governmental
d,,. ct n. s1s thu. irving them gerpsu,y ~ co..;
e'y,-e ms. Of 1 sss. towns .s,. Gs VILLAGES. o. sc
vssts he people S. s s, .s
Jog ~ esa.y s,y Own o. village ocer. vested me
We q: 80 m .s...sS SS ms esc.s .sss ne q
sahor.y" hereof sons fascuoasry or r.sssons
sf issssa S n 3, slss s,. to IA. central No.
would ssss ss ss SES%sss s . o
iii Patrons could Be- IN M o,ser var ,s
~ es"s e, the IscY o. ss sSsss sss o.n. s
yss.s rc'Ihe constitution. BY necessary Imp,e.,.u,
eiv,' government dsrcs unknown the fsndsmesa2
flha, power eris,ed In NE r>sislsure our oies towns
I'M ana r . .sa rsons ss ~. %Fs = .s
~ The nswiy formed e.rcies mrced~sem.nis depart
1Saass Of justice judges Once. az and oSesss .o ss
Ss ssS ssso,.s % .ed "a ~ Rsc,ss
rs e ~s sss g . Srs %s..
power would placed hands q Ss o~srp MOI ssS -
eyp.uEoas ,ssss,ars = The rsv.rd % hsr asarps.!
q the ss.e escep, The Judge. Of me Cou q Appe. sad q
az ,src' Courts wifh-udgs c.rks other ocers