The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1857-08-16

Ihe 1oyR, &C., OF NeU f0vk ~ C,Se0u< 0N0 CtATt -
mo pail nsG snsk ooo ,lsius ID sined en- ~ ~
nr ssmpoNs hjuncss n, rssrsrung ths deisadsna,
Oonoves ard ~ne from vin< tho books ana paoe "
herewith and Devhn nom cslseriDg the anne 70 Q no
ven or one on hs oenaf aa order FOR he deead
N show CAUSE ~hy saoh jooa,n should mot be
',oueo rhe alsini shovel ihss he books and Ell
refer cd 70 see toe rxcusive property Of the plaintiffs
rnas Tsv Iov ~ho St ees Commissioner, cd and Ia
acted in bi ant -bie % scpg 0ad I'VE Cnarge N
book ami pspers That De- H. sp doted by the
ssyor ia 6ard OF Aloe men, and eosared uooa ine
ut 90 OF The office and wasn ossson ri arch ooos an
Apers sno sacn officer smzed ny tne psi1uh.
Thai the defendant. Oonoger siaiuDs 70 bs Street. oa
mssiober bal cmweDoed ~oSeedlngs against Deshn N
obtain goss-son ~ such books, aad that tbs Judg
Def re hom Tho proceeding ling mad made az
thai DevAn deliver over the sane O,novsr
warrants acre a'o 70 he isus N snfrce suoh order
Thai the seizure ana removal NJ suoh BOOKS 30 would
be- ,crious interruption OF tho OF the dsoari
DeDt, and e esly msede INA ~rf FINANCE a ~ dl los
oy the Corpo alton " the p,bl and might nvovs he
ola nlins tabde. and lnes,tb IN IL too bo,a, NC
we're v.hASle and me pam i r-qned The 'orsaos use
III hem % naoe hem 70 or tastr cor prase ale
anc hat NO ooot be ssed hi soaid for
ali sdequae ion for the iujr, occioned ny The
taxing tue O. piAnI Ask or To- ,asaio0 r. sraiu
'Ds inc 1ef bdsp's from taxing the sid 6ooxs, &c.
C.Dsi6e, Abie osuussiJo has Iaxeu ace the time
hen lpju, Alio .so prsv,ous pjaG ,U 70
hso been ~pvt Tor Aod obtained during The previous
wecs which sas ro&arned TO aud casceaied the
surpotia g. the ooup.el sSed Ih~s me Ao OF
oePuoua reDdevsa TIA UNNECESSARY. After ~ard
aeoono " &iss Submitted mo and . ne iujulc
ton asked for, ~hich sigued The day Vnic =
toA ia'e me oompsp ooat4ns the sAsen resard
N the crrtiovsr which rendered the anona soesssry
The pr OF the PLAINTIFF ,ntsss.. nat men,
80 thst The ~ATAn1 were sooot 70 be ssaet Aod
The property DELIVERED u o, yer, ith~tsndug The a.
o~spos ~ the oe'norar Upon such application every
hing CONTAINED In the mi cstou hob 90 Id be oon
.troed ~ relating 70 lac proceedings before the
Court or Ar. Jasuce Peabody ~N a1ickeu out
and be oder VI injlDc lon soey directed t.
the defepcanu hr the expr purpose OF ava1ipg Al,
tos' Ju re r " bis scon 10 NE p1ooeedug before nim
has, no ever been The Gust Courts of equity, bosn
iD Eoend and this country % =, proce iinsa IN smother
couri ~ inr ncuoD me 0ks arc full OF Of
charAx apd the Int 20 do 40 he's pevor bSsp qoes
u~ ed. With moon moro p-opriesy ms"t such srd-r
wase o. oour Who, in he ospscit. 10 wt-b he "a.
acting. uao no eq Thy powers snd ,oud gran relief
.bicn -. .@kea for The right OF the plato i upon "a,
eAe OF facts nrceed 10 the compiant sppeaed 4, ~
oe Gle enutns lbe the reher ronght Il there
any thing IN the fudsnts' a6davis changing that
exolasiss popeH Of the pasiod ana ihis IL denie
other bAn ov Allegation Of he defen I'd
wei and bsesss the oo ks, s. are nh the exclusive
property II The plaintiff, bus are ubhi reooris, ~ni,h
,he pApd- have NO right 70 take from the stody o. she
street ,oumt-ioneS. Tue de'enia,t also rignt
70 the OH be denies shs pA,, OF Oevno
70 execute The dutes ii the ooe an oonnt on these
papers 70 Arume hat the booss the pr perry of
PLAINTIFF rnn fact IL oosiu civ On their behAf
Am alb sed to ING ire beIon tho oape,s, 1 cirs
there can be 10 dou6i that very many Of tho boiss
the e1Oo,ve property Of pAipIfs pat for out u he
Treasury and not BY ases ment, while greas Of
the books and Apsrs necessary for the ectoa y,
money! due 70 the y the loss OF ~hich would os,asioa
great, hot rreS aoe, scunAry Damage 70 pa ,ru
interests The ve~s entertain or defendant Couovsrs
claim 1, hold ,oe ofse bave bean IDLY ssted by me ia
he matter Of Dew I'm hAbsas corpus, refer
oppl.a dvive I'd therein with the bare sateueut sh ise
up. onsnen under u5 cliolei 20 bold the olce
i sd ,os sSs 40 20. "f
seasoo OF The books By OcnJver = u tres
psss, and - snoh y iii not inierfsre nut that the
parry IN possession had right tn rs'i.t D. Sfce Aad
tecs that night 10 ordinary cases Of uespass suoh Q
rule correct Equity does not, and ought n 70 inter
perry Sessesn xhsp The .ssr 10 ooot
Y ANAL In Mount, or can be ped for BY damages In
action for that sspass BAT do not oonsder that rub
the injury would Do grea shsre ,he properly wa Of -,
cuhaI value the DAMAGE sucn mai thoy 10
osS e, y any IL J. or. w
ordinary cases the remedy Of resoAs been 'oand
amply sufcint for the oteoaon Of props'ty ANT do
not think adv sabie to ntrodrc- the chancey remedy
t substitute. e,cept 10 strong and aggravated
whore the mischef 10 rome iucse." Again ne 50 ri
90 uo know Of where ipuncton ~ ocen giant
Cd merely because the defendant -tshout
shosog that the property VA ptcoh vai-e and could
nos admit of due recou oer'e In Ordinary he do
uagca asessed by Jury ~i bs adequate FOR check and
for recompenre" In E,pst in ". Borg and onsrs rs
HowArd % Judge Davies snted an injunction more
% restrain the sale OF some fur ture 10 he deen
We tod that this beins mere ves,As the plant s
shouc be le, to remedy BY h~ or 70 cscnd thsr pos
Why an scten q. ID j, no remedy Re value o, n. Sc
books and psrs 10 the cry o,nnot be e-tiusfed TIE
large GO cunts doe them on ase meps svi1ca,e Tor
which 10 or y 10 De found 10 them ths sias <nol .xi,
real estate 70 - essmenu AMI tho evidence Of o.
ands for long period back, the re,rrds Of which 20
city ard voiyus other matters -nch .s nox unpsccs.
sSry 10 rcsor, ccnclusvey ssabsh the great Of
these bo,ks aud p. es {, shs psia,d' pscu ,isr, -
well - 70 me public % Goa aiming evi1ence .,
fleeing The rial estate Of This CITY 70 very
graf sxient the complain, also sho-s thsi he rc-
mova Of them ON he Office ~oih graath inoeie Inc
u y
be obtained Tor tney loss desvucon TIA, the plain
TITS are called upon under such c'rc nsaocss ether n
resort n acton 81 h for damages 70 csi-, ID,
taSins OF them by force caopot concede 70 Els sopa
rent, from ~hs already stated, that action 81
OF oompehns tue ainurs N resort b force " defend
their psesson instcaf OF ASKING ths aid OF tho Oour
ItDink ,hc,e be hesitation Jadse Rope oil, says,
IN tho opinion delivered ~ him, 'ae plaintiff being, n
they aie~e porscs,i W defend 10. m elves IN he
oroioar' oour,c Of Ing again any Illegal distu,os
They resot criminal Magistrate o 70 Ii, sno-
rin or hs deputies, II he are night .xx II tbs book
60 sre The prgs1 fspe'y OF the plaza = hey nd De
protected oy ne zane means, remeois on egspuve ~
uespas.c- d q nke nature" 7 Can hardly suDyoss
that learned Jusri intsnncd W be und-rss, d ss
order 70 retain ihs pos,esioo Of AIS p-opsny Red
by the Ordinary forms OF hs vunj be ira ten Ne
oh, uld be very un~iLins 70 ho1 tai aoc .usnoa
Ties would be l1taeo 10 Involving ths trtb
ssch have seady tas plscs gard " tbs 3,-se,
sion OF this once We have already "a. eTec1 0.
such attempted employ mcnt Of 'orcs In tue aAntensn
oomr Aiped o. be remcdie by tue ain a.
oour. qurtiy and ssoeas'y i,.Dsi sod enforced, q
rsolvtpe lbte'est, 90 irnr7ri-nt ssef IN
TIL, properly ibinh there sh3li talon
The cyurse cd ,ptef lib 4 % oni "a hat tolls IA
juncson is an inter'eftrcs ~hn Gu OF abotb -
tribunal That decision -a-c h.s - her parus.
TIE plaintiffs bad rgnt 70 deiooo there
n could have beeo peousht IN i.s.e b., uos bsias
parer, have no rsns Of reviewing the decid n -
uszsuase, anc they are ir t9oxiss besnd ~ tat -
csoo would be iujasfics 70 70 . psr,s csinus
property ~bich oonotded 70 belong ~ hi a. ihs r'g1;
OF third person 10 tnn p-oocrty ha. cecd by
msssTaie In prcce~ding bc~ cea him and oshsr- eni
tneef,re you have prasoaon rom the rhs
prcsenv this s'ae OF aoe;-rhe o,Aiotns amips
10 DO the o~pe, OF properly Of vsloc the os,
deuaciion OF shch could nos be r. sired r,r mic
N adequate eneny he Obtained ron q c11rt o.
equity al order OF Injunction 70 p-ereo hs defsu isot
Tom skins tina, prop ny from the place Ia -ncn Il
has bcep depssied ana from their vsos a1d GO.
trUl l zee no reSon vhy such relief snoud % be
grsp'ed tpcer ne CT cum tan So rtsted 10 the
There 10 m qntsiioo y,t rcms ming 70 ~bon have -.
,ct referred nisb The yer ,i,h me defendant.
up 70 the grazing ~ 'hl' mo,'n by Of - al
lcsed q iioiosunD b, Judge Ro.cvet Of s-
ton befo-e him 90 the oompsint died ~ the Sips
Court praying for . similar Wi ocsIon rosi
rtn . a IN Cur. an. N