The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1856-07-15

whoever connected with the Committee.
Mr. CAMPBELL Of Ohio said Mr.. Orr had maae Charge
which involved his integrity as member namely,
that the Committee had sought by this report 70 make
political captal.o
Mr.. ORR replied he did not impugn the motives Of the
gentlemen his associates but the report itself looked
II they hat gone into the investigation make Presiden
ttal capital Hestaed expressly he did not intend 10
feet personally on the gentleman.
Mr. CAnrnEI expressed himself satisfied He said that
up 10 this morning he had not only been Wiling. but
anxious that the gentleman implicated in this transactions
should present their facts He argued that the ques
ment whether the people shall have the power to
govern, or whether the constitution and the laws shaK
be on side and freedom and the cudge the other.
The House then voted the substitute OF Mr. English
that the House declares its disapprobation Of the
probation OF the OF language in debate personally
Offensive to ndve ua members of Congress or State Of
Disagreed to by a voss of s5 against TIA.
The House now voted on the substitute OF the minority
House has e Comm hs sa ' SS
Mr.. Breoks on Mr. sarDsr and therefore deems it i'm
proper 10 express any opinion the subject"
REJECTED by yeas CO, nays l45 as follows
YEAsmMessps Aiken Dasdale Bell Bennett Q, Mss Be-
Eusis Falkner Florence Poster Greenwood Hall Iowa
h'Hs sss Isss' I4n aes o.
1srr < su M R o
STsndrdge sn Seward shorter Smith Of o.
atkins Wheeler wnsow Wight wight %a of
Allen Asen BALL Barbour Bsnns. e
w. Ba hsnn %
Penn, Campbell OF Ohio, Carlisle Chaiee, Clarke N. "
D
English EherSs Gsssway Cid
Ian, Harris Of Maryland; Harrison, Haven Hickman Mof
SSs1ss Ssrssa, Olives e New YORK hissss Pafsss.
F:ss ffsy sss
e. ssS sae sa
9 Ts T %ads w. rsa W
bridge, Wadron, wash5arne q wisconsin wssa5nrns Of
ney williams, Wood woodruff Woodwork, zolcoaer.
Tie House next voted fast the resolution Of the
jory of the committee That Preston s. Brooks be and
he forthwith expelled from hIs House representa-
tive from South Ciroina.n
The result was, yeas, l2l; nays, e5, as follows
Of SnsGs Sshf &
shaw Brepton, brown, BS,nxok Bsrnga%s Campbell Of
Con- oHss q S Sss e. Y
Du4ss
Ss SSss f Mosn H g ho0
Of S oS MoT ssss nnf Ke
Miller, n j., Miwsrd Moore Morgan Merrill Mott Murray.
Peek Sssse SGs sas
Gen.
Ss'f Ssssis
Bowie Boyce, Branch, Burnett Cadwallader,
SSso SE'ss
ISIeqgs Foster $oods SrssSwSGd Hall q IONA, liar
% A III ks knas
kws LAKE aamPtp Mace Nsr,s
ORR PSsp
kIssSs RUM, Eds' ssnss ssyass sssSsrd
MaEns Wheeler WINSTON Wright Of Miss, Wright Of Tenn
The srxaKER-The House Las rcfuscdVo agree to the
resolution, there not being twothrds vote required
by the constitution, thereon.
Mr. BROOKS (aen.) Of S. c., rose to question Of pr
vege saying he felt that the rights Of his Constituent
ard the rights Of members had been violated by the
Mr. Clippings, (niggcr worshipper) of ohio-I wish I,
know what the question OF privilege Is.
Mr. BRooEs-I will state Il.
Mr.. DrSS, (nigger worshipper) Of Ind ask by th
unanimous the House. that the gentleman iron
sou.h Carolina be heard
Mr.. GipDHcs-For one, shall give no such consent
tbject 10 anything but order from that gentleman.
The SrE,KrR Tho gentleman from South Carolin
siates that he rises 70 a privileged question.
Mr.. DuSs.-l trust that the House Will entertan INC
ton for suspension Of the rules
Mr. Elc1lotA (nigger worshpper) OF Ohio deicacy ma
lave prevented the gentleman from speaking heretofore
il was proper he should De heard pro;es, in Ii
lame Ct truth and justice against keeping him silent
Mr. Frslrs tx. NJ Lat would be a gross vol
tan courtesy snd decency TO deprive him Of the priv
lege.
South Carolina had risen, and stating his questic
withoa, objection II was not In order for Mr.. Giddins
The srTaKYR 1t was competent for the gcntlems
from Ohio, TO raise question OF order.
Mr.. GmpNcs-we have voted add done duty, az
ought not TO listen TO speech out OF order.
Mr. CAsrB,rIa OF Ohio, earnestly appealed to N
Gddings 10 withdraw his objection. Mr.. Brooks,
said, ought to be heard, he vitality Interested
Mr. CosINs, (nigger worshipper) Of Mass, likewise
pealcd TO MIR. Giddings TO withdraw his objection.
Mr.. GInprSGs yielded only on the ground to satisfy
friends.
Members now crowded round Mr. Brooks and intense
interested spectators in the galleries leaned 10 he
Mr.. Brooks said Mr.. Sumner uttered SANDER on
state and venerable relative who was absent No; ca
tent with this he published libel on his stite aud bloc
Whoever nsulted South Carolina insulted him. and
ftcod ready at all times, huInbly and nodestly, as
con, 10 perform his duty. He should have forfeited
self respect and the good opinion Of his cosn,rymeu
Rad permitted the offence ~ pass unpunished. II was
personal affair and in taking redress into his ham
he meant no dsrespect 10 the senate or the House
Of he personal responsibility He incurred H. and
prepared 70 meet u. He Knew he was amenaole 10
laws which offered the same protection TO every citiI
whether member 81 Congress or In the private wa
Of life He did not believe he could be punis
by Court Of law and by the majority o.
brtsch Of privilege he was answerablc TO the Sens
which had no right to present him 70 the House for
nsbment. The question not only involved him and
friends, but the whole House. II the consequences
confined TO himself he would be prepared 70 meet tn
here or elsewhere. Others must not suffer for him.
lad felt for bis friends--Ncssrs Edmgndson
Kett-thsn himself. They are blancless. Zach
proved friend who stickcth closer than broth<
when he remarked, the people Of the great North 80
Of me a. bad man, thew will do me the Justice 70
that blow from me at this time would be 10 lowed
revolution, and they Know Il; Applause, seemingly
nncd to the ealeries) but no act of mine shall +
revolution. am not willing 20 see the constto
wounded through me. He would say 70 the House
The ave applied him may tall on them. lie
only to say he could retain his seat consists
with bis self respect and rights under the coostiin
During this very session member from PennsylyY
charged Q colleague With attempt at bribery. W.
the proceedings In that casef BY passing
silence the House has declared bribery excussbc
simple assault and battery 10 not. lie spoke OF W.
ohusctts a. being in rebellion against the laws and
sttuton Of the United statcs, while sitting v judgr
on him, and demanding his expulsion without heal
He had never been called 10 order, nor had he ofef
any officer yet q vote has been to-day transm
him 10 rosterty unworthy Of . scat here, bee,
Of disorderiy behavior, and In this connection he
OF Mr.. Pennington, the prosecutor, rs tho ''thnmy
per- the tFastaffan member &c, for which,
Speaker sailed him 10 order Mr.. Brooks sail thar
Pennington charged that the assault murderous
that With bludgcon attempted 10 kill Mr.. SUD
My friend from Massachusetts, over there has ~
"a ef.x dgs9L fhaul i'm N rails a