New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1856-04-04
La " LNI'ELLIGENCE.
THE CONTESTED CONTROLIERSHIP.
SUPREME COURT-Befxe JUICE EnorI.
TRIAL OF THE CASE or JOHN s. GILDs 81
AIARIAH @. FL tGG.

TRIAL OF THE CASE or JOHN s.. GILES sgt.
AZARIAH @. FLtGG.
The trial Of this case was RESUMED yesterday Judge
Emott stated TO the counsel that il the not
closed by Saturday night be would be compelled to adj
ouin il until fortnight from the following Mon
day. a. his engagements in his own District next week
were Of imperative character and he could not pro-
tract his stay here long enough to finish the tre
less il was hastened to a close by Saturday.
Daniel W. Fitch, sworn-Am q cauiage-pantcr; |
interested in the Of Joseph Taylor the American
ticket ~hSb voted Grst knew Mr. Gies four or I've wseks
$50 ST the OF the votes in the Is, District
The Nineteenth ard from the C eneenent unn the close
orandunI Of the vote whue she canvass was pro-
ie,. eoen,S took in little common bound BOOB in tn
book had previously kept accounts between myself and Mr.
couple Gays AFTER the election; have searched Tor IL
end csnLo md III kept note Of The aie. on the Controllers
rtlsGs, think so this from nay book and from Nh ke'ch
uu. kept the vote by toes the has
been deebed by the other az to the manner OF keep
cro reside at No $50 Forty fourth FIR
weeks before the seetisn had been uSemPoyed sf the
book spesL Of at NJ room IN my "iies wokstsnd thnk
los, there taies Of oil tho tickets were taken in my
book heard that there sase was one day
ID the following when some perso. called on me- and
asked # kept tally to that lire did not know there
va, any m.sls Sir KetchurD called od enough in the
for az, to hear tpew at ne time tasy es'd
exactly Mr. Ge- aod Taylor; was amsrn otae
Do that thing passed pedgns the Association to
support the American ticket was not engaged az the polls by
before but rot city interested FOR Taylor because
be had been pesOnsl friend Of mine did not know anybody
Direct e1su resumedT remarked at the Announce
ent OF the Giles being mri ahead Of flag
and Mr. said that he much esd In other dis
ncts. Flsgg would be- badly beaten NJ,
cn a, the tine Of the election employed the Comfy
Clerks Once bad been smSS,a ' es S% Of Ss t
present the whole bIi ma have gone out tor
sose' s S Two nI ,nU, Sut No" so bar e the vote Wa.
fbaI
manner OF ing which substantially
1ns p y Eas 'f for Pt Conc
oer belong the Banner Association; happened
NJ Brsd,-i .h. not ak YOU Low tbs, happened Laugh
tel How ws,,be vote for Giles aid t..s A NJ Ge. got
cult standing behind him he suLouhced cor
rec,ly stood behind Mr. ketchum during tho whole OF the
canvass and rs'ehed him coss at the time o. thS annouce
the called ou thGt Sr Flag was an
- there he would be hee made note
Of the result immediately alter the announcement TOOK
from the y Lett the PAPERS here form the tally st
Of the spit tickets AID tie paper from ~nca made tns mem
orandun; he meuOaf~um Oh this BOOK aet the can
yass eomtetcd tho tickets Iu IN tine oNes SOME
kept out s.r~srd taken out 10 put IN vita the pa
refs the tired To cor. one Of kind but here many
We could 10 j.; do shink tne1 box was locked
after the ballots ~.rs eanya,sed; 1 tded to lock It,
reilly but could do II; saw ST. GILES unul three
after made the ali lay spckeu OF yesterday FRIDAY
after the election met Aid Herek be said there AZ "a err
tie return. he bad il,t they did not compare wiA me
there IhusdaJ the evening pe'ses he said that
Ccrorsr the returns Ia had then be said he
Clerks Office Of the Common Pleas and the correction was
hat there any alteration made in the vote Tor LOUIS
~ Glover this erTor eNc'ed ny suspicious and oa stasy az
That NJ Flag accorded SIC yote' said that cant
be possible remembered the remark made AZ he time the
announcement madei took out ny aemoTaud BOOK
compared with the memorandum there aud found tue re-
trns vronsi he entry in this meorandS1 BOOK va,
Immediately sft.rNasi why h,dnt ss;ed tas return.
Immediately after ihsy made SAIL wished hal never
sued them had iouId the Giles and Flss trans
Iosed ek,d him to sive the returns % have lem coz
lonset hm be ssd 10 could not part WIN the fets no
hee net wa. NOT awiai o. sosSs 70 CT
vsh Hniek OF the po clerks 'LAt Afternoon " ae
sI3Y som 1"n tic Tweaas,h Wafd no. in thon;
told Hugh Hencf l vsnte, to 81. the tally ',i be
sb.pt error and he said be 'hovgA euor; sod
interest q but wanted see every man ger as
~ Srty oS &c baez The returns for co,r-c
Rosh sb0e tie mistake and they et 10 70 have y eo.tsee
made Nj Henry Banks sfasys tae frst was not
AID he tore up and vote sHOh9t Zen went W -
ard went 70 have Tim make - ". loo he o'i
so when welt to n KeiehIn. say y z RA !eaIs
showed them their Tally list heteAhm sitd he "a -
tia, their earning out H. his writing DO no. kn2s
What Mr. Reh said gave the bAlo.ot eon',a,.s .os
Hou-e either "Wednesday Thur,.y psh aud never ..w i
tbst the law eqgHsd then 10 be e.sio "a ole ~
leaned TIE fact 81 Mr. ke,cht n.de ne nz.s On s
Z: thought keoh1 Anerc ticket az TIE 9ie
wben called cut he ~a:os=d DO act kno" AZ We So1
ne clOse | aid him. .Or WEIGHED nm nss'l e'-e
ILausbier knew Nj Fisgg peTsoA.y he1, and nal oco
vo;-d c hiE KEEP bu-ese'hoP " s1ih aytLoe optGse
the Crystal Psiscs an slore ~ psEt.e1 t.e ari
uenofasn made When disc 5feTed the mistake aha t"o.
II fl from tie returns
Mr Brady les n. r.t spoken Of IN eStsree
is read: Flag, - Cues. JIG.
eros. Of the boxes coId BE- locked az
oe ed ed 10 ock the City .nd County box a. ~
t-rdee lave he yotes eaysissd sSan - Sc ny Fere
correct weua eAve done but shenr hi!st uoa -
Tkuis6ay that ~,ud not Be Legal, ne 'k
hsy ,os sui Of rosssson r.c.nNa-et tae C9.te
vote AID G.cov red mistake and th led ae 10 %
re- the City AID County took 81
voted for took particular inteFes; u Nj Couae'!
County ticket prsfsrTed Mr. 70 Flag 'o9k no n,e
FssE 60 recollec that sApes.c
that kely to be beaten applied 70 ePet 70 In
Tat # Cd Flsss beaten i~'efe - * n -.
b tOWh-re kDOw John Esxsn - Lot res"sct q
In tas Sou.c rs'her {. Ht-s-r 74-
the habit su-h q. se slt 81 nc
Cd Thrrsjsy sfterroor told Mr. hss dion 1ns nc A ~
At tie s.iionHes- and that L. could there .nd eIane
he vo clerks ~ d lot know VI ~ PIN =.
b. Known Bols-s before .nd Jl Dot ssS~ Is A-oe
wher s~ore hE; srs n1ebte1 10 Ny Ae-spS.o1l -
ireeb.edses Commenced eigseen Eoh.ns ago. 70 ,afel
ne the 70 Commerce TIE t7iehsr-s ya'i Ss
60 krUv ha' Ncspedcon 1,ef ec .s4-, M Is
duri. The ,tion DO Think Wa stsent = AZ ou;Ils We
cal q " the City AID County vote VI 40 "a Io' 'eea "a
OF three Gays ssr tie election WIEN ~ Re lsis Saa hae
Htrrisk te cieIG 1SEtttiak Il pSste said VILE a. oH
TO MI KetshEm, When M. R!eh b. ha, wa Cos -
the returns altered tAs uoT=1z dr. HE ss. - &c
He bruibers believe Alderman Herfk Ss 90
Iosed Mr. FLAG tbA election present . &c nee
ng Of the Hsfd CaIsAsssrs signed The retsIns ee
voted to Seventeenth and Llshieenh nas - Va 80
roll rron Web esdsy; 90 TOT reeole' o ~
% hun The Gay sf-r the - coriIetc u.s.