Star of the Kanawha Valley. [volume] (Buffalo, Va. [W. Va.]) 1855-1856, 1856-07-16
From the Richmond Enquirer.
Carlil,s criticism On the Enquirer.

UuYiHC .ClLbAS - - .7I
AS philosophers ascertain the IN
,tincts and habits Of an animal BY q
study Of it's physical conformation,
%. from his mental and moral idio-
,y !, We inferred the exact
junction for which Mr. Garlic was
destined III the House of Representa-
tiyes. While our readers were IA
the election OF 9 person who
would reflect 50 little credit on the
Of Virginia, and were com
that the Democracy did not
achieve q complete victory in the
contest with know Nothingism, we
stroye to appease their qnernlous dis
Content by certain suggestions OF phi
MISUNDERSTANDING them that, 90 ma
tnre contriyed to employ the meanest
and most repulsiyc Of its creatures N
some nsefnl function, so it was not
altogether impossible that Garlic
even might indemnify the honor Of
the State BY serving salntary pur-
pose in the Federal Legislature. This
much we ventured TO predict: that he
would set of the virtues and abilities
Of the rest Of our delegation in the
strong relief Of contrasted character,
and that by exposing himself on an
elevate platform IS the incarnate
representative Of the iniquity OF Know
Nothingism, he would impress q
wholesome lesson on the popular
mind. !.
Mr.. Garlic has not disappointed
our expectation. Perhaps he was
too amiable to convict US Of a false
prophecy. Perhaps he was not want
ing in malice, but in ability to resist
the instructive impulses ofhis nature.
However it be, Mr.. Garlic plays the
very part we assigned him. Utterly
destitute Of dignity Of demeanor, and
incapable Of any perception Of pro-
priety. he is perpetually INDUCING in
in,modest exhibitions Of his defects Of
intellect and character. His most
- S r,;n.n i. r.,no,,a which be abtrnded
upon the attention Of Congress At .
moment when the claims Of public
business were imperative npon every
conscientious representative. This
ebullition Of indecent deHsagoguism,
MY i, P1y.o ss.;asd + &, .D - e NJ
Gou .,;,, IT, ~ -. o 49,, Z, 70 .ta M
e i'a .hn ~ tas . Il e. = S;s. sn u.
NJ M. :. .nr 80 = anlr sr, ohl;.
. ~; Ut. W r,sa :. py 49, ~
H. a,,V al - t:sPoaa u e, 10 a psaaau.s
~. , t 1 W; p1a, aa - ~ antbs'.;t,
srse ilotn S G a.'u ~ ..no I'D:
!: H.. n'ea,'1 S VI oo,.sIess' .n'ta:. : We
nIt; "nu c1.,seq"I u : .; tiIi;s
Nnicn, ''us 'or eul'l e !, ati d ~
tyranny, ,';.h W. n.y.. !" GU 'noiu y '''
| NJ ~ :" r e,n SIn' ..a J. a,..,,;., j,
|; a 1na IL .;t ~; " La. y 800. =,
= thn ps.I III H. elo uno I,
H. w Ia n "asat; PIa H. v' 1880 j.
Sn"a.tor Sn,a,a;op.n i : ~
ueceassry s5r n 70 aro'y an iny;nci
H. ra',,, ,,nance - HI od:ms mi
al, ;;rinns 'heresy Yat stond;no
fpn6S>nnr nos;t;on and accent;no Mr
! GarEle |slown def;nit;dn ofthe DOGMA
|. ,ye NAV easay demonstrate that the
| r{r;nc;nla maintained IL the Enou;;,,e,,
E Identical with t6t nr;nc;nle II nm
r,lar an yera;antv nromnloated hv ii.
/ C;nc;nnat; nlatform sWhat 1 IN.
dnctr;ne Il Snnatter Sovere;,ntv Il
asks Mr. Garlic Ills renlys7fm IN,
E;pnniry i sufficiently Precise and 81.
! ~ rata Tho aoctr;Ia ~ Senate,
Soyereiyntv J, saws nd, ..;s fiat IN
;nhab;tsnt: If . te,r;torv while Il !,
tarr;torr J., ,s,s;,on; !, H.; 1a,;o,,
have the SAME r;oht tbat Z nossessel
H. > sovereign State IL a. apd dec;de
The character Of their domestic ;nsti
| tutions. I, Now. Is any snch nr;nci
bic asserted. directly Of INDIRECTLY. il
tbe platform 81 the Democratic narty
Mr. Garlic Is not particnlarly scrupil
Ions in his assumption 81 facts. int ii
does not venture to affirm mon his
| :ll:I:.- Il /. ~