New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1855-05-04
LAW LVTELLIGENCE
rr,ryD STATES CIRCUIT ooURr-aAT s-ssf.''
OD"iN~ Ju5gs BtTrs

s'ip .uinst.ss IT, asrlen ssiiIO,d CoGe.rJ
Snis brought TO recover damages Tor s'.osse "a
~brl.is be claims an inPrgveusrt 70 ne s.' ~ 81
sna esns "a I'D has. th-refors been psndaE Or sx
,.a action. relaas 70 ths .see sA'S. .
9onpnJ md obe in as,sehasstts ss.in the tss'n Rail
rosa Company I 4 ued.Dseoa uia' .' rfis 70
use he common ssb ~hesied f@iIosd es io freight 800
pDienfeIs Il $40 la,, 80 m 10 % sc,. ~ a..
srd II he ps1tig scceeos 10 gsns verde .nd 'nos,-
oUsptly "A ja ccn sganN he rcass BE- w'a1 Be s1e =
sb,s from sr5sa eompsnie for TOE US o. the ear
.ev,r.l Isiops more SO bs qltson o. gee lneor
snee 70 rsoedin The Uai1n The pateat Wa exteo:;
ed seven ysrs mailing twenyoas years Ia all Thieh vi
exrire IN Ocobsf next
The vsy u plaintiff pat nt 10 "a. % i..t .ns
hrsno oTiE u 'snto- o DO i9ies Claimed 800 ass Z p
the e.encsnI the sclefaJ ueed 10 To csunp
are suts'ap.iy smm.Ssa N ae cam 49,, ~, ~,
public prior ths date tf be p.'snt Wneher rs panH1
bed isss risht to psten, in isJi ss.. Ill. a.,
Tao s grese1t com 10 1ee1 leors Jnase So
ard ynr, the 5ih 4 lch s1s has a+so 4asn.s
trout g. esyry s1fion sroua, u te n5ty i,s BEEN
tai en- and i;nsss-. examined fs entire ns9y
Of he nynioo IF evey per. ,o9, org ,s "a T,
prior ire fae q psinth' peat lA's, y 80. ', ,o
fuly DfOugtt % h.t- t "s .l at-Al s'iF
si,b bee led esrs and carriages Eh ssve tuess saa-
sy Ike these liautia patent, hh 0sea e,,ii9ia ia
County 'or loss tine prof 10 o.. }, lo5i
The prio Inventions, cbi' ~ relied apn by se'ense z.te
Tsstse 10 RS sishs -hesed aed ~ li<9 and esss
On The oqny s.ssa 40 "a ~ ~
south Csron. Railroad sns o cs ssei ,i ifan.e9rti
1859 3 .fef Far5 W 'aadry other
esIisss exhibited By no'ei % the JafY l1e ae,
fsrdtLts relied upon tn - ere, - eu a ing en-
prinpls eopsuueon 800 operation OF such es' a. are
used ihrolshaut tie county O; me ~ nc 40 eal
that pAlih soeed rothirg n 20 tneu Dut oeo hers}
CHARGED The contraction minor details lr Which they s.
lea Il patent grated 70 him a-d are not in ne eta
TIE psrts On TIE otter hand Gains Tbs invention ofths
8whesl.d whole srd 1on enP t1H these Pfof cfs
ns cid coltsn TIE pecuslts up2a which b. 81
esed improy,n buud-a Ne says thai htsas tse1
.ln 10 MI
m.eb.l operstian. &c # the Baltimore OHIO Rel
roso be nveb-d srd placed ueon ne foss 10 me
that 70 1884 four the Get Que ctei
COMET I'D sJ he took out The patent shcl eyes
The d. tassi, on their pat 10 addition % xhat {. .o'ye
tho1e tb sar es.,rio pien bad seen Pot publ:
use b. pild ath hs snoElss.- ard eoassa sni uai-r
ton lr such Ivenii,a Thlt der ne Of i7s3
which lbs psi,It Is ssnd saeh pnb; use eeatu'sd 80
sbaoonneut Of ts insenton sna that b hs1 n NOT 70
take cot psent OF The inventu SLOWING even th he NJ
made one Also ha tns di,~9 p Il "a aee M sl
,ttuee after the burning Of the Pitit Oc- "es nSt '-
/ Lar 70 the orig nais. 3d.,
damn led s.i,utd .uis q s tine since q Bsiiln5rs
as.ilt OHIO RaIro,d Con2'ny far 10
trtss ,ub.equ,ny suit ssa the s-asne,..y Rr3 d
/ Cornpary in hi. STAT vhisb wsI,u.oessfai
Judss bic charge 20 ihs Jury said hat parry 81
pbing for ptsnt b11ud 10 nske Tie sp--i, i2i -nd
drswpgs 30 clear mechsesl poiot Of We hist ne
ctanc could schiae from p9fu1g said specilca-
ar dswng sso 'hst ne tfa~i y d BY s3ceal
Of TO Re suts isd Or t1oe Destroyed u 80 By
the tufr ib Patent Ose must have be- "a ar ~ -
,ble them se the oHsuii II The inventon d .e-
sub ntisly ike hls 10 use IN Quincy On t1s BAL
Ohio Rsosd or re uanspSr alton ~ sto1e ilu-
Der lie hat pteDd 10 Eog sn5 o. o'crbsi the
books sh nab ne nht have sppiNd me
principe pssfe ssr r-r Il he the Original ngector
OF claims spd he consrUctec sni psced them
otber parties their benefit previous 60 his taxing
patent; be the Invention eerety % the p1be
gsiont hst n Thirty da7s 20
bis nins out patent tho Of his Invention Fsrs 10
bic kuowsdse and consent the baltimore I'D Ono H:
read his p..bi cannot be sustanea,hat Inventor Il
lowed BY time pefirct lie Invention aud can 10y hrs
for ss0rsble tiue 20 complete t. without 'nE ~
gtt 10 H. but n be oispOss OF Or gives aFay IS va
have been oole here others be loses n Claim 20
Patent ard presumed 10 have dedicated % 20 public use II
a. Of psiu.f subfsntally End be I'D not
6eoi,sie he cb'sd verdict, oherwise che verde
| rust be for dsfeudsn.F
The above he lesdiu points ia he charge seai yer
/ d. this forenoon. -
Nhitiug NoiOn and or plaintiff NJ Lsf ab- - fslr
Fl kessni lie sP2s.Tsc flf pls'ndd 40
Eens fstooid sud Binse, snt NJ ho3bsN, " Ph-a4ei
! hi. q 4 defendant