New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1855-09-11

fIe soffh s - ssay y
&, E,ss V-.,-rS' |b F"v"A. ~, a, in'''se Fe'f
io,. isossss fJpir ssoss'vf f"' NJ p-'' ~ -.
~. 80. .se.s.,, I. -. Ga,. NJ ~ i,s @sa,
4,.bsf 81 s,'g ss - ,' init so1 hT'cs - mp
80, 10 pst,sss ,ga Inns ~ f@'Hgniss5 n sp''s n III
ecu. ls he Ds,n sod bs "siuoshon sot 10 o. '-s
,A,e, a. srhs, oo''.s, ds' h' 'pss 80 ge1 - ~
,s ssG ~ py,'f - he Union vhel did Mt PRINT
's,b prs"y 80 ~h'h o'', "i gish efs" ~ ~ n. q
ssis ~. w.. thosght oo hsfsb crue n f-sp's'
" A. sn, ns 10 p,arery ~ GsrG, nsgb broshi nor
,,,sa in ahs sists srds 5's- srs BY he gsDs him
H. ssc.pss there ss'int h' cans ut ana often i"fh
" ,ib rufsrod IN ofdsf 10 H. reclaimed ...
Other 'hortrs might De- quosd 20 the SANE eHse b1
ssry for u e no' 81 ar t1 one voana nv b'pus'.
90 vii We thss Tor hr ,sss II thi. Jidc,l
pfssunls that thsse slaves 80 NJ Nh-rlsf resP9d ron ~
sini. INTO nylvsni when no sucb alteration va nSie
H. n.son Nben IL h erpf-ssy stated n the petition 4 Mr.
M mon verified BY ha sHrmA ION that they wsr. brought
ounsy b. heir matter end when this iict "a SfnaD
conceded by the judge Of tbs District Coort u b., oa,o1
Great ny rereet for The ads aie rites ~ me fesra
Government. cannot e7n'ens 70 .niuy ny'i "a oiloI ~
sustain their unauthorized judgments, md more particularly
where before u.s. II would BE- e. tho expense
OF he liberty of citi Ien Of thus Commonwealth
The only naming griund upon Fheh this Jurisdiction ear
different states and shall dlsiss this branch OF The case
sin ply BY afming- that the proceeding BY hADes' corpus
J. Il IL were to the CiTclit Coud alone gwen th'.
ron For the correctness the m position refer 70 opinion
tI ndiS 70 "A Peters and TO thar Of Judge Be. Of the Cur
cut Court Of New Yor Berry Mcrcen al reported in
JrSici.py Sc, pa'.ed o. The 2,th September 1888
Ny view ofbis had been committed to writing before
Fsvns head i, hastily read but once may mstsSe Us pu
port bit % ae" the eqs OF the naec,
srpaaie ceelLs the Dis net Court had jur
decision Or As II ear, from tho record tina, the prisoner
In cu,cy uton contempt we are powesess to
ding the numerous hat cited to sustain
this ro.op appears TO me to be as novel as MS danger a.
a, % couit ,or contempt Caa possible that cit
zet rce committed for beyond the nope OF ree
oyn housh the shows that the alleged contempt wa
In efOWe
pcse The Judge Of the District ut sloud send 70 PRISON
On editor u newspaper for contempt OF his court IN com
f ting urun decision ia this would the prisoner
b.y6r6 resoh Of cur writ ct hsoeas c"rpu II ne
al sd our guarans and srts Of right
ropes sand But il me Of he aw aver that no '1
IL attempted 20 be exercised, There modes oil rehei 'a
and pie Tor the .Nigeocy OF the &C son. ., III 81,
hive al either time opportunity 70 examine al
te c..e, d but have sminod them they decide
this nothing morethat where court OF
usict OF contempt another court WtnoIsp
rowe will Xane the case TO determine ~heth
ID en- ar conten rs e coufs, and the legislative action
thereon both il I'D Union IN an unnistakab man;
80 ,ond the pmptne.s which unsuarded has been
followed by legislative re'rct0n 4 Is no longer an a9Iena
OBJ Of the citizen the mere caPne OF inc jugs OF
court, but has It's ooun 80 s ia - 90 in
In Re WORD. e the set of Congress Of ID March 1884, The
never Of The several courts United States 20 issue at
fae huens and nict summary punshment tot coneuptso
court lie construed 10 extend 20 any cases except tS
of any person or persons the Of said
conf. o 40 near thereto ob.iruct the simiu alton Of
,ce the havor any of the officers Of the said courts
th,r official transactions and the disobedeDce resistance
by any ofoer the said jurors witness OF any
ether peI.on OF Psi,on' 70 any WI" ''O'
New Psssmore Williamson convicted OF contempt tor
writ OF habes' corpus comusneins % 20 Pouce
before The District certain persons claimed BY Wheeler
as ssves Wast lawful writ Clearly not II The Court had
riJe,1 TO issue Il; and It had not think Is very
plain If unlawful the person TO whom 1t was directed
bound obey it, and in the very words OF me statute
the power punh for contempt shall not be constructed 10
" extend to it," -. ...u,..., 81,
Roo ,bs contempt was committed answer this oy asserting
that Won nuot the conviction Wi bout seeing e cause
o., he pettion, 2 the wit and the alias wit OF haoes cor
nus; the retnrn end T. the Judg ent 49, .L .a p,.s
II is ordered and adjudged by the Court ha the 'a
,a iamsf be committed to the custody OF the Marshal
Without bail OF msupnze for contempt IN refusing TO make
bT al he instance " Mr. Johh H. wheee" As unde'
stand the opinion of majority Of my pe.hen as ,COn h 90.
instantly .eaed to the residue Of the record - ms
commit must seems INST presume ~ INC We y e
NJ he these runaway slaves aud second
we must be only portions OF the record e we
should find that the prisoner was committed
rsrnot bes the expression the opinion that the rule
aid J in This case BY the maj y Is augh with crest dan
aer TO the most cherished rg1 The citizens Of the State.
While involving the hight OF property merely
re me we ay sill these judgments Of the niied Staes
within their uri'dicon as Du,.ei yet
gle kinks proper 10 determine tn one OF our c
zeI ba guilty contempt II such determinsto
ad is foundation upon which The Judge had no power
10 pronounce and most nanesty IN direct NO
l., oemu EFT OF the very legislative agtoory ts otst
the which the Judge pesdes 1t seems hat see
pTorounoed by Court OF cou peeht ao'"S ~
the sdmitied Sphere Of its constitutona powers. ~ -
Nay We confess ourselves Powehess 70 protect our
zus from the On Of Court, 90 ioregn from orr
stae government in matters not IN nitte to ITS jurisdiction
az The Court II Bench Eng and and I'M, upon tue
authority prom unced IN cases not At all Analogous
to the one under ctsnra n believe t9s 70 Dc tne
the prayer OF cizen for the witt OF haoeas corpus 20
inquire into the LEGALITY OF an hd,s 70 Wit yid
for OF juris dcton. ..-tt
will conclude by recapituatps the GROUNDS upon Nn'"
link his an be
l. A. Common i.w and by our Of 1885, the writ Of
bsbeas eorpu. ad .ufcenduin Is writ Of right demandable
whenever petition in due form asserts what II true would
Thai an ale CATION IN pstitioo that the petitioners rs
ed of his liberty by oder OF Judge Court without
ude shows sreh probable cause as 70 leave L 10 longer
made wheher the writ shs or shall not issue
That Where PlsIh : tpd ssie for fesns to sawe
ofhsbess corpus be entitled 70 De a'onaIsea rom
such in prsonmeD II the Judge of the District Court had no
T. Thst the power to issue ws of hsbe~ corpus BY the
Of the Federal Courts Is mere suh.fy power ana
such writ be Issued b such Judge. wneie ne cause
Of complaint be rrmedied BY I beyond their ufisacoL.
lin ited on the Constitution OF the United
hs Of Congress under the Consutuon aud hi
IL pursuance the Constitution ii does not exist
g. when does not appear BY be record that mo oout
h,d udlction In under our hsbeis corpus act 20
T,ityd from illegal Imprisonment want oi Juisd'eou "aJ
b, shown BY proving he facts IN the case -, co,
arise, upon rule for habes' corpus al The e' SCI Ss's m
the petition teDdh 70 show want o. Jurisdiction are 10 % ''"
q Tbs ~hen the owner slave voluntarily bnogs his slave
ON slave 20 Free state without any intention OF remaining
The gbt Of tho his freedom depends upon the
lsw az he State into which he Is thus brought
g. Ttst slave brought into Free state escapes Hon
the euody Of his while In said state, the sht Of tho
ster 10 reclaim him question arising under th Con
uto Of the United State. the laws thereof and there
fore judge Of United States cannot Issue WHIT OF hsses
dire who IL Is alleged withho 6 the
II The from the maste COMMANDING niu 10 pV"S' NV
h Is II th. slave before said Judge. - A., -.
~ That District Court VI The United states iof tne
District Of PbusyyaDa has Jurisdiction because con-
trovsr, ciizsns OF different states ana tha'
cseers by h.b.as corpus ga sense controversy DO
tween private psrties- -, ,,-..-. s,.,..
m That the power the several courts OF the United states
49,. l.rr lAnfnn