New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1855-12-22


tugb ssked for By the prosecution hsd been
c'eumssIc vhich the counsel for the people urges te,
ftnse that the Of the CT IA the ysrd the
&c men was Tie ssssor hn the d.cesssd very Woe
f1 weeks afterwards that sor going up the
.ss1t and .hi. dOnr he stIusi hs held By df,ud.
fca shet 70 be dschsfed These theories
septsd b. yeu .nsa Tss Jary ~oss enss., %
Gle az tee imo1y wherever and ~hsnever esn be
unse evidence on so.S Ode. :. @ Civ. er.d.nc. ~h.rs
version that given Of ssms affair BY both snd th.y
only vary in the Of telling the nIry tia.
s or ths Cher ere corrupt ssd not entitled to erei..ee
only Ia ms'ers point. thar the yay bound this
thing nellie ia this l. your day
where the 70 i've eoorns 70 crime w.rs he
greatest There much Of The testimony what rsnsprsd
cep. during the ar. the prisoner prssen what oscusd
avIr that tire s Ct the Utmost i'm poLtsnos bis eoadae
,asy he present. f the puIposs q insssting he
hesmsfer, to stack tie cid ~ would sppeT from tbs
Dotetman" On tie PSI. Of the proseeutOa the 6nt and
mat myittn wins. brought forward ". the deceased
Dyke decsucn testimony taken lesy and Of cred without
sSS chance T mutt stioo Il !: testimony % sQ.h
p.non mssios Dying declaration is equivalent to tn.
po.s iaGence can sway them and l. 70 Be- received
nhue Witne was living pe'ent and sworn The jury has
ssticn Sd: the condition Of mind c,ntsmp.,sd By d.
law If they conclusion that she was NOT in as
i've s Should be TO as s
care have bieIe you the testimony OF three Witnesses from
should be o;,ed upon as dying declni .tion.
Firt Coroner HGon stated that he would h,ys
dition according to her statement to th, effect
ScOnd The Interpreter stated tsst ,he hs; told him cha. abs
believed abe wcUo ole som tho wound.
Third: Mrs Hsf, whose Testimony his Hon'r oss.rysd,
Soush ID. t6. n. recover
up to the time the Coroner attended for TIE ding
b, tts witness 10 ted the truth she h.d another
he thought ID. ee The e.n.d Recorder sid h
ese' the sissi
theIeoie be conIued this etenens made under the
ce:epce Il entitled TO- She stands before yu "a uulm.
peach, witness, and must bs considered such unless I'm
The Recorder here read ID. d, dessoa Of the deceased
ard commented thereon. The contained
Gp..on Did you stsits me 1i cub when comm, up
sts ?" with importance He did not ask Did
aro there is not ca. soid he .dsd
i ds s. q, When S u s ao
alton and the theory offered BY tn. defense The
fssy we the only present when he fat, shot wa,
fired except Ptnson The Recorder here read the
IS. ps ss sne si
spd Dtxt Did tie wound IL sed cause death We have
Dor ant ana from il there appears that there no
possbe prayccaien that would Justify tho use OF deadly
sr ssy deadly wespon 1ns ss soa.s doing
be 70 UPON b asSs ss
be at the Zine on his premises be bosnd rees
II room v stick G
did justify the t,ks Of pisto and shooting that
her sid eoTrobosted BY the eviene. Of the w.nc.
Half who stated that the two men had bod Of Fur in
.Rsw W1.. ps sp1s1e teoi in the sa. aud the
o mind e Fuis ana his wife. ar they were e th.t
hsy .vlcefce big dsushteI the Cd IeoO.e
q the words 10 sufficient TO render 1t ad usbe testimony
~ h.p he Che rsoner was present aiding and s..d9s
and he stood & Sd BE: Shs stare While the was,
say the leas-hs Honor obeIved-on hst occasion brutal,
s Ss s sT md
wbst 10 in tyioence What would good citizen h.ye
J%s impctsnf .uohsr point Of V.@ il he stood b.
cOncedsd be cid By the defense he mut have seen th.
acted 5s; .sS aaS ho :ss b ss
yard aid render necessary draw adesdy weapon and shoot
@ e .ssss:s.s sSss ss::: r:
F%as bsa mite; had IL Even though be hsd
IN. violence ssou be bscsuss tber.n
6s srTssu. and b. wife under he inhancs Of iqum
oiesd, vi tie cODIsy We. shown to be the .rp'
Of he e@si lst the Recorder ,,id was collateral
e ~ ps that English sDd whs ts.
WITCH & s5Pps Ss @ 1 II
exhibited solemn ccca,on At al events It did aot
a
ssses Browr The witness Blown ,ad thu her mother told
5 s q: :n 4. p vent a. id %
into re P.Gn.' Io'm for the PSP;,s Of .hsI pro
ia tie discharge of Legal duty and any attack uposs
Der urju.t. Ths other witne" p hD,to1 aid aid
on The hess and thai while getting up from ii. sHsc Of tbs.
,S- I'd :ns bs S rS: ts:moDy eoa1
..id was IN arso s,sls ..a ss fa'::n Tor you co. 5.
vosnd be inflicted fouI the sIampa-
ticn down. ard and b.cfwM6i II .ss hso q the det;us.
the poseeuOn COmns those t.O theories and
The physcs eydei which Ia In your power to you
viii ba enabled arrive satfactory conclusion.
ARCHER inpor witness the Ksrcher who red IA.
Der S0% Ma,, '9 Pt Up -. S bs a.osss
was struck and fell upon biz bds and feat Won that n.ke
the nos described By This wA' =. IA. s.,sd %
the spot Did be tell the ofer that he blow
or O. them the mark r., o, .a.ne. n the o. II you
believe that the bl'w on tbs head wa. hced and th,
ussf, The use Of dead, weapon; the krs tics
thetefom murder the prs nsr .h,n ni1s me po N
ue that time this blow inflicted the pfis1nss wa.
ansI Of roes. ss bodily harm aaS n,i 2, dd ~ .
homicide became bound 70 wait till the deed cone
bus . bs % ne s. 1' p ssu ss
tess Of ard res1mee that vend have pee
have been zee whether blow ouch described BY the Wit
res Pilp; wooa have CAustd to be Discharged sad
sS hs a.Sed vs.. Sss Ss.t .heh
was IGsd months st6I' or on tue s:.n 10 the one
there show that the mind was &C ns and n IN
5. "a s .s SG ts s SS party o
ps any inquiry be put his boots and cat and 10 two MIN
utes after the be pto the room OF the oe
msi. p zee be GA. never befre and there srrsstsd
The Court submitted the csse TO the Jury after bav-
In, ,s.n stated esaly the different degree, Of crime that nigh
them particularly against sner;snps any deuei su saTs
iI Of the sys.Ies &C thai even those ~u" ''' o.
zion tie conclusion Of the Recorders charge Mr.