New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1855-04-23
NR. ". H. FRY'S REJOINDER TO MR.
PHALEN.
To ns Ed,to, Of 7NE y. TrtbUns

To a< Eeiho, Of TA< n. y. Trtbuns
SIR: Allow me, with brevity pushed to the ut
mott to reoin to the answer published to-day by Mr.
Pba.n President of the Directors of the Acsde ny OF
Music to my commune alton which appeared in your
columns yesterday 1t is the last time shall notice
tie subject shan answer his statements in due
order:
&c ida not ..s.i Mr. Ph.lep simply published my Ph
letters addressed to him officially and stated wh.t tue
Con miree Of Dscon did he representing them In all the
II Mr. fhslen .sy, Nearly month since, M. Try 81,
an psr. Of bis heh for mspifold declined
b. ..s eou Re pisyed 10 an hour and qaG-I In th.
Mr. Ph.en mistaken He contracted with me on TIE llts
rot until 2ih March that tn. proposition p'odaes an op,r
made him my nCts % a% O. Sss . not bot
proved to be about - Ny statement then to 10 length
III Mr. Fh.sp says. consested make bis s,rbat Mater
the second part Of Concert 70 be sven At the A,admT
,,oro. hs 10 usss nv Stass xIsr, oew hlos the
second part concert Of old ttisg' was no, 20 me-
OF It would have been Indignantly rejected Mr. Phasn ed
say would hours only omethinse'e mlht
II Mr. %sIes says. The rshe.ra, bessn. bat, .her
the chorus and orchestra GENERALLY eompsi 1ed OF tns
70 no on 9th IL they obliged neglect the Opera Of
Wsm Tell then under rehearsal For this string nI reason
The peculiar ps,ure or difficulty OF the music all entirely
Of subject TO h,t eosse sud al oatorio
,,s,on tb.p an t.i,n 0pers II I'D no, dee my
aimed and Original effects and Of c'al'e more
difficult th.n old aud ped foDs should eolster Il
unworthy Of the Aessemy As the Interference OF the re-
hesfsss Of the Saoqt With those Of Nin is sa h
had been orchestral rehearsal whatever OF me oIod
trsI r.b.s.s OF m, did Till sever. days
.erwnd or Thosy Up 70 tbs. T ids ore tSsS
bso been rehesa ind out II there weis sny ana -
,eoai,ps alteration bot one part that Mr. 81, which
chs. sed his sntire satisfaction Tbs other s
.a Nth their psr. after h.d
Of them able chorus seemed 70 m"ter their Pars
witfo any upususl effort
Mr. Pbaen say, that, as an evidence Of good will he
agreed t5o toward the expense Of copying the music
and hat OF hi. paur period; he
s ri ouIns had then
tie Academy for daring 10 promise TO perform the 30 "a
OF their intention to perform It bad been made
a. small matter as by the the
become the Of these when the Sdo was
Choose stree then breach Of contract to awe pa.,
sha impose upon tn. the burden Of paying the 50 N o.
$lS for the only snal work they have had an opportunity
Oh v ~ r, aa When he mi W n Fry accuse.
Mr. absent reueas8l Tuesday morn
ns 1.-THE NIL he unteneros.y res'ecs to STATE 9r ne ~s
aware ofitl that Nr naretzek too al 70 conduct made
no nccu.a ion .galn. Mr. Ms'ezek though he VS. in the
Academy Tuedsy morning and did not even render me the
ply statement in letter Mr. Phssn VIII oh biz condaet
toward forced TO publish that the leader a nats
in direct Violation Of The written contract ordered hs
be the last and although the contract in terms
hat there should be general ehssrsa on hs ne ias
day evening to allow members hom the Harmonic So
ciety nd. and who bad had NJ opportunity what'
' tody 70 We wes suhed BY Mr PR.sn and Colt BY
hss toe oSO 20 ,sem 10 tnd The Mo.ca Director
or Conductor the head Of the orchestral the
Insulting me 10 propose The performance OF orsoro VITA
,uch orchestral rehessss the two brief ones rven H.
would have the public TO present. Work 80 ouchered
An the orchestral and general tshesnas under NJ aretzsk
demanded by including such puflly brief ones
Mr.
s1 in humber But to Mr. Phslens s;atsnent that M
Try fu.ihsr ,hi De did .s.ss
Tue,dsy morning rehearsal that Their. seemed tns % ~
break the contract Dec VI
the influence OF The Nee is Herald which ha1 lew i.i'
pr,youy connected refusing 70 advertise for the Opera or
pint bills stab0i vas to be performed OF 70 notice ihs
Open or to mention ny same ~ an "a no ~
with h leader and many Of ne me ts
sboud be carefully rehe.sed and that would force tue
usrssemen 70 leep th.y a,d 20 have 20
OF 10 rshess such had been sven H. expose their con
duet tbrsusb the public journals and have tsp my word
VII Sir Ph.en says " deem Il only Just to express.
~, .,oSe i.,or COED on the a,fas. a1d employee
Of ACADEMY who 81 ugh ~ornou oJ eight boar dsuy re-
were called study the oasOriO Of M Fry 70 ~h'h
one ara eli ehesriully eonss nted" ,,,.
on. o. eli tie the Opers house ~ers .eaa1aed
With lees ard which ,. studied ID PERFORMED NON
csTe ard pTiGd orchestral part having h.d toe sd
.uase OF uutuduou perrmsaees Ia Esrope before e.os
P r.n.ps,s .i.ht hour. az, Of rehearsal aud ia
-es rer.iy.d either az or seven ful orchestral r-he4F
But ny Staeai. SIS work not printed. BAT eo2i7d sha
hey Of shout two nSus eaeh "a the 1~s't4h Ae
uy o! Mu.c Ard the Committee eHpr>ss n on % M
P6slen their profound that my WORK snoed nave
received hat sno0ai o. attention ,,.. -
VIII In eorcu.ion Mr. Phsleas denis, that be or ne
Committee Ohefs 10 the Academy we're inhasrcsd oy
TIE York Herafs thf-ss BY 10 r-fess - .avef-
~Lx their motives Psreothetesly ~ond Iemrt,
apologize for soss paper with the Tame Of
lAe Herald 10 spe hing Of It's retsss . sdsefs7 mf
any Other woft Win n.a. mas. ,S es ssa-
h.yiDs wished for advertise ent or noe a. o-
lanes Ct inisny deem i' am happy 20 s.y % mag
senenen n this comnuny sssfseefa 70 si'stsc IL
or i've .uy uppo % that lama. though Mr. Phsl-r
h- d-.ir0> have 80. support 81 'Af Nse
Isrt Hesld" f-apors! 10-e'' shsn- Of 'o:n7. o1
tse krowE influence tn loEEipded and 80
p.Siav over " the theatrical iod m1sc- p-ots+
.icu e.nsnt The pntinf Of q. the n IL e .. the
tbesrs Ct Ee~ 7ork bseHusy given 70 N, Herald oie'
in CIDER 10 coIci.fe the orriEn fuso WIS o~ns AM con
tros sheet would merely state that Ia a.. az inter-
cour. With and Of seateFs .ec opera houses
hi. city h.'s s.s..y fsSsd iten osssf %
in self witch might brig then the III viii OF TIE sa
tor Of thai shee-kuOwUE tha- be Alone Of 81 tle
editors Of Ses fuk u vile snou.s . as'a se 'os
or private wcub Ia the psrsg VI hs o<n magatnt ana
sysreous Ry chance sale the sc.esu eof
St8ba By management Of the Academy . IH
HsralS iosersscbU Mr. Pa well tso-s tht 90 ne
ordered Of ia cosDts and n,s shce
that ouD .rd the bill pions OF the uprs
deci,.o therefore believe that the dsEsce- CT taS
Academy alribat.be 70 IN Tact OF tnH
deteuins;Or nsnssem.bt y sscrnce ne ofo,1-f
American order 10 uckle 20 th.; soca esi1 "7o esA
bt.rs he Of ire Sable hofseSbipptnr
MI Pbslsn eonnsesates me 1psn nv cssppSintD.ns
assure him music " rhnresin.f snal ost
As r,suss morals Infinitely lase for tad tha. pe'soas e,
s.rd for their honor but whistle promises even wit AID
.fpS dov wind provided thew pscste Tue iOoes
villain Of ihi, benspt,r. epoch fcur osecsnt ssyn
Neg i0rk, Saturday, AgrE q ZOE VA nhAHi rat'