The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1855-12-13

|
with Ist.r, u must hsve ssrurk you think, the
of trial ind n,c the ices down my
uee, while ihs evderce being gives and witch may
ss well BE- expressed n the isDgu-sa then s-odtnat:
The outr.es perpstrsea BY Poole, previous occa-
si"ns rgsirsl ster, fsses ffend-. h. they ever
sfrscious end correctly narrated, forniah
gl nsnsesuen 81 deiie.Iasy, si'hoat legal yrocsas
state q eye,nee az such this case) they wcold
e.mu'u sifong couoborating circumstance 20 sho~
p'bso" ree nn .t 10 tho mind Of Baker and the proba
-. csrsequcnoer Of such n VI feeling
Aud accote eingly hEd that Baker ~ In the ARRAY
reA' 70 he .he.tie instead Of svoiaas Poole, and re
tlouid have ocre, AT eaht iou the ptos whc. he
a escy witoess'd one ifscs he same evening. fsesuei
in .rt~'re h~r the pfops,rsof had n csoi, given
tice tnat his place closed or tho night a, too
under 'he r'eience, you please vita ihe ba Gis
| otivetf .uch motive under the circumstances,
| eonid he fena fa---of indalping Ia moro liluar.
Can any doubt what hasers fce'insa We = And In
hst stare 4 e,ciremeoi when he inferred stsnwix Hall
the second ,iule that night IN company with ni.
| i've assoeaiss--thfes q whom hghurg oh4r,c-
| tess, all Of whom wore frsh from their
| bsrruom oi cussous, the cnpraiy, may
| suppose. ~ they ocnsidefci Is, iooie's
conoac. three hours ocforc at tho piare
sra 'pvhrce their ritnd Morr.seyi Ihd 10 bis
nnnd, pnnde,n, instantly osmmencinx quarrel with
ooie instead OF interfering good ci,4sa s0ooi
have aone - restore peace, dt hu not ,ooy sNnd by
snd allow tie gfores nsuiss 10 he three times repeated
without even utt"riog word Of semonsirancY Ind he
no. hthtp.h npstihng " do anything In AID OF ptnoe
persist In rsmaising aud Ia indirectly b. a presence
conneusDcpg he outragcs Of his associate Win nh
Ibis rs there any thing Improbable In tho state.
ment OF Aoiorson arc Dean that Baker, ~h,n pdn,'g
apd dscha'ging his ris,i dire y into lode's brosat
shid III put nd Ia thts. ~ Nyou 'tl'U take
you any how or uttered esson OF iiks inpsr
Indicating seng not of oe'cnce bat of whAL he proba
| bly, oonssceted justidsbia resengef
A. 70 the fourth ground the bullet halea msda tho
occasion IN nfooiee oserooaiyoG viii rrcpiee nt sf~r
Tuner comuenc the hrog eight lsehergss
norn him and others ndsormnatoly iook place before
The ain dropped. inoecd, ,ordng 10 the ngaag-
used by Poole, oroaih,ng his lat Lhr ballot
would 20 have alien like tho scattering a ha sia
OF II ~ not ncccassry, therefore, In addition
i Other .ina, e. convict the dead OF perjury In
/ NJ no ugsA lpastt he he
'itnt garment openly exp se rwca1s he oia And III Al
We up"n he ambiguous gyinea Gu, 81 that seoscle'-
compound o wool ami cot which Poole t,na pains
10 conceal, deliberately sojaogs that the dying
without motlye permitted hitnssl TO plunge Into tue
dsih and unietaou ed octan oi srnity With lie upon
! hfe lips aud FeiJufy On hls toof
| ~ tas rssue 80 10 my mind gentlemen--t cannot say
how II may have struck yours hat thi. ioatue IN tho
ccence this effort OF the accused 0lckea the
ne whose life he had taken nnfayor-
ably with the spirit ,vinced by is aroust Ia that
dying ceolhrn,ion 81 blame not Baker m1ch Nor
dssry and Irving" II assumes, and 10 effect ssserfs,
that Poole VIII se daring character hardly he de
plea, In ne-'sfdiy manner. without motive, muiiea
the PISTOL he had frnesy display ed thtfe hour-
fore and hen hA sea.h ed after ten days sor reco-
TIN with No hope for lie, and With a certnn, iaed
-thc grave before him WITHOUT motive again. falsely
swore hat be bad not fred at ali. Ii lalos believed
th version OF ihe ttanssc ion to be true u b.
ortdii.d that be would not have taken so,ne pains
A. iAe time ~ hmse friends, 70 have secu,ed
pistol whose vacant barrels would have told the
"hs I'D he ave the Whole proof ,hs rcin, - the
una'a,ted iaoon u he poels prosecutor Wy, unass
i. n,i,y es'hi hra' sou rom il. uoo,s arbea ean
tents have ce4 4nstrntsd that ball had Issued fom IL
ibsi night am aware, gentlemen, that a. 10 the
peeiJ loaded pistol which has icon produced by tho
potecu Ion snd uace bacs a. the police Oh ser
tie tus received Il a. Foote's but not feoo, Poodle theta
il deifct IN the chain pf evidence 10 .sabsh 81 iicr.
iy. still, thsr. il evidence and what there t,
ai,hoosh irptec' Is strengthened dsee at isast
~ toe nosece 81 .ifor the psri oi tho prisoner
- Toouce The real pistol II u ~ dn.rea' and by his
con, ssmcnt and Night But how y ~ill be- @ssei, 4
ltoie ein tire did Baker ftcei,. bis 3unist Baker
| yoni viii iecoect. II Mitchell aud McD,nough arc co..
| Ieot In 'lelr imp or.ions, WAS to- IN insHat ~
| Why, then, AZ 'has mornent may not bali isc~a
| sh.y, Who iied 'eor tirnes, have pssseh over
tahsr's bead, from front T. rear, pnnehins he
pistol have paarsd through The vest ana pant.lpoEr
sDc shrt (eshibi'ea 70 us ani have spent tsl IA n
den ing Without entering The sursco Of hs abtonons
1Leiu II 10 impossbiy tbi- yho ~ srG Ian 9roba
biiiy~ and 4 L vel established rule, that wbete te.
tmony ern be- nche Il thHl be ia preference in
pu'iDg ieiJury to the rinesses
= 'ten g b. tine That focis, according . hi dying
sios iha he pointed di,payed his pistol tovards
bsler ID amer reasonably 81 create ard Justly
shelter vel founded or not sn aupTehenron ~ great
b,sitls hsrm hbd ntnibcnt aanger caG discover no
such testlm ny ~ ttc eneef there a. Jon viii feoYscs
y Abo wen n there evidence sh,ly ensirg
g. shcw ths, ocle when shot attempting e1u.
nit unlawful act ri, II you sa.sica that TIE
| es'lsme remedy q lilng Wa unneoe~ss'y, Tie 49,
snhoush nnt stne y muIoer, would In t5at be
| rDanslsughter Ia the second deg
A. have ,aid .iready gentlemen the act y Aii.
| be aecused Has he ahosn any necessity, then
suy n.c.ssy which the law can Rauit or whieh
| Vel cfderec mind aypfoyr--for such
| extreme iomedyf HE ooun.cl. 4 edfnonisAei," a.
he ,Byp, and nrott appalled, BY tho magni,ps fhe
tass, be- struggled ably and eoquently - ma. ene
sna Las nitrate Ia he cnntgyer, and tie Court
sud sbh y rtlieve) ron the whole sviafnce taken
t'feihsr and cIesy snayxe1 that all his client did,
tLnt eTsnfin night 70 exercise the gfcag right
- sef d'f.ncn" Bat cos- thir sln.s.g Hercuisan
lstof cary With H. Ass strongly susge at .osst
IMPLIED and important Aiuissions Ins 'fsnsae-
4 npB, Il viii te remembcrei--i mean III. one iane-
di8te IN 'heus-whs but % mNMmnt's lnrAtiln fhey
cnpefed sbo iei and nca baker nred ~lih latent q
1 nd Itcla vNa he Al hail A.
hen rsLtsmsn ttat such tfansaaion briei should
have Tsqpired 10 engthsned AMI 20 elaborate yindi
os'ioBs fhsr nnt hat oreuusance su,gest dub at
| ssst-doutts slenty shayIng tteeselves ussssh not
uttered Ia wcrdswheibcf the ostcEsbls PIE. n logs,
oi ceeDce inter ptsed in t.hA .fe asoused i spo'c.r
Dot be iurArg behind u another witch. although al
| uisfible IN flate u pubhe ~ar, ADD not aDcon.
non Ia eases oi border "a ifs, en- have ~ place ia
| lime OF peace 10 the courts Of justice ~ CIVILIZED
e mUuny. S4srf ispv inter aryst-s3s auEab he
tore ID. eitDon's mouth-bui Wien var IL 1T end
atd order ftgnr l1 preturn@f r~ign. rybt
ayengt injf". real ~ Imaginary, ~ dssHy ~espSnH
csase. spa ought 20 ceas" u l. rsuin right Is b.
persniSg q sar and var onysar " ~ cse..fei asd
~sg.o b, rubDe suthoriissAnd ne, 70 ihaidaas
b. H. A. 70 thssc tho fuie i-ani n v rails en'iA
- gosd ordsr- that hOuirids, although committed 70
prUyocaiep, hg~eyrr great there teen the IL
cspFesset H. sufEeisrt cans time Or passoa sosnaa
md rsa,o, 70 in,erp. .s, dsasfAs 'vvsnse (a,i sss
ofbloscl and therefore murder " allowed
assr,u' Q take tie law into HI. owo haae. Ill. aa,y
o tn. sccisy eabis j. 70 sptes 20 ths copgiisutsi
tribunais ans his eopns hs's no shs 2 arye, naf
hsg. Jon any rieh' toA~uue ihst such sn apgrs
vtuls ~ ia vsin- When that p.ln' hhsN have ssas
r,leEed 4 rsarhel sver - ess,a'ion sI hss@ s,u
csJ sDi govsfrnsu have iTfinirsbf Unfii tSen
nf.ec. tueh ftls oAnnot - enae'sd vgh lmgHn'y
renss q ihs ae'ofr q not al anst y9isihlr ans
| L ~ you % ceicfu.!ns ~hieh ana . ~nAi extent
Mr. Brady ttsn and saids--I sgpt1-A that uls
duty . b performed 'of .4en, -oaa hAre boes
Fefforasd b. NJ ~arrs assoelae sbd sasA sgrA hars
teen eons . yoar Honor t.a ~, given Sssals ssrs
i've v ~ sry, i -ieh eertsn ssets sssense - ~
pfvysd hat ths yery fscia vhich l~ny AL
g.rrs fsy Fpy fegaFd shasvsf th~ Assurpti0as Il
ne CsuFf. Inosyt % hN ~toe = yoar H1u0f ehAfys
t,esass yo - aBon tat teach tssga, Ns4 1
gurtr, sft wifh ~ doe rysfeei eass.1sr fsst ~
N is chAfke b.s Rs~Nfna The uacs of I9r1r
exert 10 youf .t-isnsn. ts' t.fe~ krnsi ns~a vrn
tnfo ftarpx al = rsaB ssl3 he asd 90,
| fAuSstn had gss,al Sas I tiso srsTgf H. y9pf
Borosf ngnry % rty iiey 10, tbs ~ " ~, f
- feres, ~ hsksf sAytssasi a. - caaNrue ~
4 laH u.ss lat teen oysusf y A.. Toaf liosss GA.