New-York daily tribune., 1854-07-14


zcuia 6< tcsad 20 ee<y
u.o,s noastrous tyranny prOposed-a more
ti.spheInors fasehood never uttered. Bat saeh a. II
us. Il vss presented ;. the Amcrican people - wat
ff.v wee 20 exrec: ne hands OF III Caioors vbas
.,.rs .,e.eb TO act, by orestes A. hrownson. And
;.g;h lay . h,is ~des ihat 4 az, prosoH- ,ne u
uosr II. cna,or The Americans wVrc be unworthy OF
tl.;r ebsrse.r ard hsiefy they ~"aid ce degenerate
ana craven they I'D epe with naughty seorn evea
The IDEA of 80 odou. a-p..sM doctrine :. false a. II :.
foGliregiou- it = Disgusting, and unt ,ho'c - 1t
is odioGs. ,
fr-t cite D. Dole re wa. ve-y modes, man. as
ureh Gsrnsushsd fot p.tv and vrtss as i'f Learning
aid cenas. The Church ireland u lens; as'er Pr
cuceG 50 grea; writer or i0ore s"nchhsh m'"' i'e
wrote thus: -.
slS ir. Il sI-s. Of ssb'snss AID bsSeAssa the s.@
sIsw rp .a ..nsoa' sy p-sry 81
~ III. ~ r.i % i 81, s-f S ,s Ss of e c.tbs
SASrs bot mt 3 'T po, 49, . 2 =. a. % e. s - s--c,-s
an 5-r@rdrnt-"
His ornion 81 the reviewers King.lom Of God on
Earth WIS rot very ra;erins. He rather thought i,
more Ike another king,oni--the kIngion of pride and
tad passo.s. But; un.acsy the good Bishop Ind some
cr.st dsdy arieses First he had not drop Of
man az even AneioSsxon blood in bis veins in his
hear, Secondly he did make wares OF religion.
st i in packages at een,s per PseAsse and
the Catholic Church and had no experience. outse IL
now arpeaI 70 Doctor Hughes, where he c,esS rhom
Aquinnas and Snarez, IN his e''er 10 "eh ass nc
says: n, ~ r,.,,. rich, Of K,,,.
III ,,p or I.r n .n .o.rIn unen, human rsntS
scan turn 20 poc,or Doyle. In his exa;nina'ion on
oath before Committee Of the House ~ '"m"oes in
lss5 re saws. IL answer 20 tic question; So
Can the pl- sl.oiVe 'hs sn.''aees'' 'ro' as
Q !. ain t- E~~sr,od pr's the King Of hs s0sd0n'
bs bv an, me.n. excuse C.hoc from hi. allegiance p
No, undou5,edly , no,7
Again he is asked .....,.., .a,,,,,,v
srro.se 70 Scripture and trs4i0a'
Hear the Right Rev. DR.. Curtis, Archbi-hopof Armagh
In the SAME examination and in to the same aes
ticn he ssys: .,
eTgosed bc eeAry he las ssssd nc such power n0n
Heag again Doctor Murray, Archbishop Of Dublin. He
says: .,.-, ,,.,.
M FBi i '1S sss. o 5 ~l s.S SS'sf ~ % not s..
~erd H .Ta power dc. not sos hia 20 astaroas sas'
tmr :! that spd .ssd consider ssuus 70 >eHrn'e sad '''
Hear again Dr.. Kelly. Archbishop o; Tam:
adm 'ta IS Of ,h cA;hoe csa,sh that
I have cited these authorities, and dwet upon them,
no. because they were needed Us to the questions IN
volved no, because sny doubt Whatever eAss os na'
existed in respect to them in the mind o. sny we-n
formed Catholic but because the position cf ne hcri-r
il such iha, naturally makes impressions on the nis
Of even intelligent Protestants VITA view OF oIs-
abusing them have deemed il expeisnt To produce a.
testimony the written wocons:de-ed nay. sworn opin
ions of the eminent dvine- and scholars OF the
Cahoc Church Itf Re,"r' TaHt.nE "Sa O".hone .hn
DAINTY prove could ma.tipy them one thousand fold
coud cite far stronger opinions from all hese bishops
from Doctor Collins examined a. the same Ine sap i,ou
Daniel Ccnreu, Sne, BiGke ana hos's o. o'"es' VA"
enough.
Having thus delivered himself, and then span ont
through several pages the idea that the esnnpn"n ot
foreigners-oi the Irish-rcuses native feeling he con
ciues thus: ,,..
fer. ,.msrss,s. mem :. wei Z. t.aoics
Why, of course Tae present party ae only ono there
j. or likely 10 be- io not go far enough for hn Insy
never hin, ahou; dsgracng the Consultation Ihey take
ss he says too low TOO narrow view oi the qie't,n
Tbey are not of The eenaine Catholic stripe nor Of she
true American s,smr A. II one contradiction was no'
enough one subject W. have the following; -.,..
We cs,hoc iTiend. h'. ~. i'nn,ni rna
stn IL the bosom OF American ftoiss.aa..
rostes A. Brownson. in the raagnaniwisy OF his nature
ard the generosity OF his sentiments az will be seen by
reference the first quot alton from hm above WIZ aloT
the children of Irish parents born here to be con-
siered ~ natives born Prodgious' ~ poua'e ssmp-
son would say. Thus he ioveth Us
Reject his iIs men seG ssie. "a 'a S S"a,'n @ & -
-elss sg.iust them tacy a. TOO hnrt'n,
70 h. m.seed-oo .qusrog' 10 be dnssn lIy "s s,
10 make heta bend' 7yss rae a. 49, N m & &
,or viii he ss.nis,ed nsivr 50 srer ali with @nlsi
fcrbearsnee. the evil will gradually dissPpear'
Nagn.n;mous indeed He hopes ms cointrymes -
those he a moment before called foreigners and affected
10 despise-"have much sefrespect 10 convert the
"rrish into bondsisves. The pious baoosn ne hopes
The hone s sugges.ior.he cousCmmntion OF that wsa
Ia the British heart. The bond slavery depre-
Gated not bocnuse /, IS wicked odols cruel ana an'i-
republican, not because the Irish deserve any oeer
fate but because enforce would not rebound to tbs
self frespect of Native Americans. And ths Is the man
who Tvss Rourishes on the poor pasnce OF the hsrd-
worked illied ill.cad Irish-he who coins Their pre-
udces hard cash The Irish reject bis appeal they
scorn and spit him and the mercy he invokes. ihey
have for the part been loyal true devotei cilens
OF the Republic. no reacbery OF hs can ever weau them
from their undyng otion to the flag of liberty They
have never proved themselves unworthy oil American IN
.,,uons They aspire to real brotherhood, and il they
ak 10 share the liberty Of the Republic they also ask TO
share in the dangers its defense But il attempt be
made 10 massacre" 'to drive them oat, !" reduce
them bond saves then they will defend Themselves,
and let the result be with God. His booas," his
tolerance" his coward cringing for them, they ding
hack upon him with contempt aud utter defiance.
MICHAEL DOHENy