New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1854-12-04

Nps ~ouj "a. bessss he fEscIs EeAe. 20 'oA 80
and 80 ehoie n hise, Aud .fess - oFrs4.oa
uamSIy the rev coaion the Rel Standard; lnd va
brss, Lo~ y0g that lie dsiv.dAsts haye e. = = rose "a
ibsf vsui DO. rot Ssrs ths pida,1 Bels pro osted
ssnne yon renbsr. bad DO Oissirr snd 10 hssi =
ssapj-rd Of ,ueh Reel rlssel l. was sce.iea .iy
pl.crd behind The uns iastr1eus sni the whole m2 ne
ron % thar il es,y ADJ nslursi TO esce
chine ~ 1884 nprsat one s,1dns Ia rostoa hFs
it inkrfer,i with The rror,.. dividing. aud therefore
plsce tor be fouBd i;eouTar3 "a srch De-
,ic,s wesa usss uPpor' the ais q ne Reel - >E ~
-, sncs Of tn seal would s3s tie Re- fl afc IN
evrr whiis ,he .,,rd.id ,.ef o. Joe N h,'
crcr,Cu Ire same hing Substantially sv b. .li % " ea
words rnJrcsd schine lnd OF 1ore rroeted machine
Al thus nsiiher Bells, Wood srs dolrss
on. deuti'.l with sir 70 the ps.urs : Ires
y E.ehne bad ar uPTrhr reel 'nds copied OF
frur ACofueh paien. ofGI And had r. essx
psIasrts msebne Neither OF thSse taveBtoHs therefore il
hey can be called invent ms, 1ciicsl H. thi gssieCs,
WIS ,Sst o: MCoru-ick in 1875
i, = thus established thai MCeTuek he e7ln.os Of
The ~ " afure. the Reiring Machire patented by him IA
ls45 But CnoUsh Lat ne 4nyslted ,Ac. lacy asg
Be- eI this action ea5r q b. sssineL The Testimony
tprr Z usee LowheTe. The Reaper Vi sj wi,a hse
iss,uTt. Is ased everywhere have 70 d,nou'tao here
with he ADDITION q thsss features II shs scceed ia .hlt
Wall leI spges tss lbe zen, o. 49,, nave oyeh
uni Az fuIv aud a. such ha ards. what VA. lees.
Bstit Due 10 the inventor that h'lld no. leave he
iturent Of Uty to sisDd upon soands 20 peasy clinical
Tlst wsssnove rene whicl he votr wi.ues,I Two or
three ye.s $50 The uousch OF the pcudest knsiou OF
odefn caused palace OF sss 10 D. erected covering
,rv -. 10 The eutsr ~ her cspts and sl invited With
ul,os and other rewards, the inventors o. 81 Va
,us 10 bring thHhet The predictions OF theiL - o
mir them 10 oxsinson IN ord'r that mankind aisH have
Tie benefit o. all that gss PeeSsiy e. oysa oy as Sr
hat edies scene 50 dlcEeni rom tse
fcs BY ssd and which lad theE oioTo marked TIE
meeii1o d Independent Nsi'ous that he9eVoai.s ss
isht have BOXED down ppm with apprlbon ani delight
liberal portion The edice assigned Tor the exhibits n
Fruce % IT, German State Italy to Aasrs Prussia
TO Russia yeis AZ while ,hss res.'sd toT Ctsat
works OF AIT But the large pac' devoted to IT, artisans Of
u Iaxse st.,.: VA. nearly ,lr,.d To- - ., =,
eh the piOdue,ous OF our country were ar ss 20. ed 20
conceal he poverty Of The contribution The Ia.d sites
eeuntN men ia attendance mere Dat ~ ogfes a. hoge
that had been dstance6 and dsFccd Just ths Ia that
experiment Whether, among all the contrib lrs conancd
10 the Uryusl Palace there machine which ofee
tuay take Il Place OF the human reaper n tht hlc cd
Only two nsnes appeaed ON the field ard these were both
u American Invention The one was iessas he1ec. oi
1915 Hnsseys machine ts'led, owing. Is vas Id 20 TN
gecnufss moisture u ihe standing grain NCoImicks,
asHy Nations assembled tie r. sid ths wet sol ned
grAh upon ground leaving not stalk 10 IL pAth at the
An rcsn clipper shrs in from China 70 the whsves Of
London ea,ns far b. nd tism ihc '~iies vessels known
!, va. freely admitted bv the representatives Of Ma
tioe' thai bile EaltSn artisans etesod IN ~ot, wl,,e
10 .HSsT IN st shsVd r n. ptesor 1T
un-ph Which I'll theu tells snd acknowledge
petsona ore than q Ss ona one l. Justly
ssded No General Ccns drawn ehsjt through the
ind bens % srs he who thus vndcaed the Esniu
our courtry g. the Worlds Exhibition All the MeopO
10 not forget bat Iasseys 'hns 40 siulieaed he
and srs OF s Inventor on sCycrL occasions sQs
" md Z, Oicc that It O.sfrs here may aIfsy
American h,cnors uto conflict With each other shall
here els,w here dePcc.te the merit Of Que public
b. i1CiOr. IA order 20 cicy ltc 1uo her
Gentlemen have to the second qut si1n which
consider amgy Have the defendants. appropri-
ne the machines which they have made AID sold with
cerse om The psiLia contain he hss i'uies gwen
th. ina tn Ia ia
800 'ncs i,ncs.c,Wster, LACE ssIl-r Van Tire
o. Cooley need not T-capiulae hsif testimony they
sre all practically well thee eticsy qusli 81 10 testify
on .hst subject and they unOpPo'ed scientific wit
tbi. hempg proof They derosse from s effect
BY stslnaiIrs Ihose v be give G a, Professional
nee coming here TO TESTIFY for eUHpensAon unworthy OF
ofdnee. have the defer dants proved ha these witnes
have received receive spy corporation beyond
that hch The law sanctions They have proved no such b4s
What not proved on trial AZ law d9es MOI exist IN view o.
The law The leaned counsel rscd then without AID
" ithoUt around for aceusaiion
,lopA utneses comir here aid esying oupens iou
that The law not Only allows such witnesses bat
drses that they shall be sumOued 70 gte heir s'tmouyi
end il d also that verdict. D all be ayen aDd judgments
., reoe5 .Iisd IN ns I'D Ans,onii.s
- no sIe udepfs n that lnteiesins department u the
JIs,lpe Art are snmu oned The class Of proei,iobsl
pe open the defendants sell 10 On plaintiff
hy hsv- bsy not ef the pan'h In the market SIC ey
too pco They have 900 stake in this suit aud $500
in Der pocIeis which they Obtained by n lie
der this very patent win winch procure professional wit
ue.es Do they sa.ct horror at resorng to ciss If Wit
rs,es whom The law allows There is an Old ml20a, TOO
eosney exrres.td BE- literally repeated here, but i impe'
thai penot certain description have good opinion OF
the aR under certain peculiar cireunstlnse'
Bat ssntirep shall not leave these witnesses wb0gt
more 6mplste viDdieaoD. The Questions which AZ submit
rpre,tons mechanical laws. These inerpf .,9rs must
h. syep BY somebody who capable OF giving them ~ho
that ny opinion v0s cannot do It, Nor can IA Court DO T.
Certainly cannot The principle upon Which
IL. nv
yeIyades all the ansacops u society You otp have sees
sion inquire what the law allows add what IL lorba' Inst
question moral science You 10 lawyer You some
time. reed 10 know what will eondgee 70 health lou 90 to
Physician You somslimes ds're to know VIVA. your
gi.d IN tn.,ifx IN ea8y,. OF Ju,,lcr On question,
professional wiineses An oath ezseied from them 80
cath esacted Of every other witness snd Of cjody
Gle no engaged Ia the administration usticeof your
sIYs o me Of hs Court sud Of t' mashAs All balAr
bat these professops wnese, are fuVosed 70 be pad
scecrt ~ the sacrifice OF their time and interests which
they make ~ we ALI so We III ought 70 BE- AZ ieas "
TIE rule could be made universal Can you hnd men Hho an
OF IN study The laws Ct Mature 90 as ~ Interpret them Win
out receiving IN way the Of support aud Of se
struetlcn We look luch NJ Wine
The leaned counsel for the deendshts De nsnd IN different
ord om tbs Ottcren you are 10 Psac1ce IN regard
to Lese itne5sss tie same rules which govern Jou in tn,
rrerI coroeTus Of lie Their oaths Of weight and
therefore the law allows hem But osibs are by no ni-sn.
Of claim credit The man who need, an oeih
"a prevent hn nom committing PERJURY will generally testify
sely when sworn You viii receive the testimony Of these
s S,opd. they s,syn for Inc hey Psei 'hl
s. I'm your Judgment 10 BE- sanctioned b. fsa'oa ana
{ nth
The bdants while they fail TO oder PROOF sly ncTeThe
les hs The features Of the rGy sLi ne arrangement o.
Ire Reel standard the machines they have shgrctuTed az
not Identical with the plaintiffs Inventions and they az p
Ia uport his assertion By showing you thai In th~e psrc1
Lars hoe features IN their machines sscE u eu AID 10 ma
tsr..l frc n these Of the plaintiff.
CeDiIeu e. IN mechan form and materials may CIDER
deg while tie sgLsisLSe essence LAS D. The sIile.
& no house neither BE- built Of reeds or u logs
o. Of bos rds o. Of bk Of marble; ~Leh.r be " hs
form NJ wig am constructed AFTER aso, or Gothic
or G,eesh mode. shiP 40 ICES ship whehss Dc PRO
tsIed by Wind OF BY steam II ty wind whether win sell
or two CT three; ard Il by steam whether by the paddle o.
IN. screw Mtuisly therefore, the iaffnser tas eh9ee
whether the inventors form add materials ~ those
hirh sfe different Ii be 10 reckless he will take nos o. me
nj rom those OF the Inventor ne find II Is
therefore clent protection for the defendants hat they
Ire rvtLtor a. the. nseLuity could ceyse. How then
49,. ...- .....L q q