The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1854-01-13


fomsd Part of political '.ntrsl Americaf ar Campoa
had erlisd 10 him frsphly stating thai hs was not ad
vtsd officially Of what the view Q, the govsrnms
but did not teeIe II in,srde1 10 he undersoot
mesrirg that 1opSurss was in Central Amerc o. the
contrary he believed the Belize IN Mexico Ia the
aInded to, he thiDss II thu int ion
use the term Central Amercaasa general gsoxrs al
aeoou Of the central p,rt OF ths conticsa al. AMI
s trne political sense Mr. Cramr ton he has
son believe hst the gosernm mt of the Uat.i s,ass
conceded with him in this view He, Mr. Clyton u.dsr
stood the Ser stpr as conter ding that Csutr4 Ams
risa, as rttd in tbs treaty, must be- taken in is
geographical sense. He examined this point aN
| Va ch and lie thought that hs had shown by ,utn .
rites and argument, the contrary Sill notwithsandisg
tha Senator had had tsn mcnths In which to examine
h matter he appeared to De rs conf lent ns ever IN hls
error The serAtcr had rot pretended r.ply to or
etptroyeIt he suthortes he had thsrs exhibtsi hut
sim ply cor fined himself to rspson OF his postuate
1t was rne that SONS gaze teers and ALIASES de
| fcIited Central America as embracing the Bszs; Ia
deed, some Of them put down the limits of Central
AmTrcs So fnfludn2 Texa and sfornia oftha ma Do
published by III, Socs FOR the Dusi n o, Useful Know
ledge describes Central Am, ric, all Mexico
rsS' and o,lfo'nis and positively sscu les Costa Res
and it vas on su ,h map that thai tne Senator AS
staemap, relied. this Senator "a on such ma "a a.
hat, to show that the Belize included Centr. Ams.
Ia, be must semt that the geogra p,.l l-sr poa NJ
Centa America thereon Il correct ald ha saws h.
voted for tie treaty because it Excluded the UIt.i
States ard Great Britain from co,rizluy. oc,upyia.
or fortifyipg any part OF seosraphioJ Central
America, be must admit tina, he voted foe
Unn hid any Senator vote for the treaty under sush
81 imlressoDS Did the ma ors from r-x,s In voting
or IT. suppose thy were voting to pns Texas ensr.csd
|
uoh . map WAS en- error, and altogs.hr unworthy to
b. ,elea On By any one protesting to ne a
fer rot to fuch this but Whist consdsr
edby this government as the true political C.nrsl Amer
lea this he found laid Gown In treaty this GOV
ernnent with Central America ITSELF and Ia that treaty
teniral Americs was defined to be nsuded within
hss states constituting eestr Aneri,s IN the trus legal
poltssl and diplomatic, He read the treaty and
said that when ths political dsfniton OF Central Aercs
was abandoned then they would bs st he search
for tire ore. He regarded tao Senator from Michigan
pacirg himself the British side OF this question
and s. seainst the position OF the Amercso gov rnmsnt
He Is sseumrg that the Belly. was excusei from the
treaty by the exchange o, raridcaton, hold that the
Belize ia part Of Ce.tral America The Senator ia mis-.
taken in posing that the British arrea
with him D this last particular Take from the sss,
tors speech the assumption that the So snt at tbs
Belize clussd in the Central named in the
treaty, and he (Caytcn rght Afford tn allow the df
teen columns Of the speech go uuans ~ered even fun
Of errs as thsy were The greatest p,rt OF the spseca
British government admits that the g. liz /. ncu led in
the terms OF the hesiy deso ibns Cent 81 America Let
cretsry of stste-Ist him produce ths authority Of
Wfsm Marcy, TO sustain the position that hs sstls.
men Of 'he Belize is included by The treaty, aud he
&c aytoD ~sud abandon the controversy and I'd the
Senator to be victor He referred to by srst,ry
Burhsnsn which be found recorded in depart
msnt which folly sn' tained him in declsrng thst
the gentleman thousht a. he cid on this suhjscs
The tendency Of tn. first twelve columos of hs Sna-
tors sIsech was to Ircoues tfat which E. gland
hs ,ence to all the im porsons of tn. British cabinst
10 that end refused Tie lie to Bezs by Grsst Bitia
there which fhs held b, the same tenure as the
gentleman did his farmthe rigbr 70 posses. use and
oreuPy; but without any supreme poll io,l pover do
minion The title to RoA'an different There,
she was potsessed of absolute political dominion,
s.n1'or from Michigan woulc psrsist in viewing
Roatsn a. one OF the dependencies of the Belize.
With IS much propriety might he call J.macs dspsu-
dsrcy q sore private sensman's aes.iemert. He de
crbed what the depecoenc:ss OF the Beze wers rnoy
consisted OF sn Island calico Georges KY. small
cluster OF islands where Eogi.h shipping conh BE-
pa red &c at TIMES when ire main la id could b.
Appr ached TOR th.t purpe'e These d-re ,dcncss
nan 81 ard d. ecrbed 10 the treat OF Loado. sad 10 hi,
counter ttsement TO Bulsers eecsrstion he conansd
ths er'rdenots 70 more par ocular The S,nstor
IL his desire male hin vreny al involved MIN.
srlf in absurctes whiah might hereafter p-ovs essr
Tafirg. II he fat dowp, ths Senator sid hs was too
,io, II he stood up the So a,or though. him tall.
In he exchange OF rstf:atona OF TIE Bal de-
ella ttat the Belize and its deaaudeocis not ia
sd D. He snswered that Central 4me.ics ana is de.
hss here by either psrfy9 He put 1t to any
ero IS question e ,.w in controversy.
and says claim al Black srd it, appurts a,ucs
Neiler psry rights viii te affected by their declaration
W the into At the tms he received
Bulvers dsclsEson hew as mu h annoyed BY ani said
that he would not ex9hargs ratifca.ions With him
tAe treaty but reeds finally persuaded hin that he
would be doing wrorg and wou ID be greatly blamed IL
be permitted tuch mater be loss of the last
chance of Gett clear OF British influence in Central
Anerca This eons sIsion induced him to receive the
dec arafioD, and to ATE couater Informing Buwer
that no Ia be replied to- In this declara.
non be stated that tbs treaty VAS 70; 70 bs con
wer further that he (bulws) had po~sr to pro.
Ioss any chsrgs in the treaty, al Of which BuSsr
70 show furthrr that Great Britain before the treaty,
WIS made thoroughly to un3erstard that che to
agree rot to colonies occupy fo-iy pAr OF Cen
rs America he quoted from the report OF In erye1
between Lord Palaertton and Mr. Lawrence IN 1919 and
from corespondepce bstTesr the sss Since the treaty
Great Bfi'sin hiss made like declaration and he was
sonerhx surprised to find Lord Clarend,n asserting
tbs right CT Great Britain to continue her proeo.
tcrete over the hosquito coast BE thought tia.
m. 81 I'D
tie full force and wight Of = precedent which
stood In Biz psth but in respect to which he had said
The Mexican government regarded that protocol
restoring the heaty to what 1t before amended by
tie Senate ytt President 20 did not send 1t to the Se
nate did he make 1t pubic for year after, when it
sent to the House Ia to call and Aooomps
MED BY his reasons Tor MT esaTdns II az valid Polk
dfried the validity OF tic Protocol ts badny
OF the United States, ss Cmmisso had power to
charge or Alter treaty from uhats was wnen ratified
detni PresN ert Pok and Lila Corm,sioners from this
charge By the Mexican nsnt OF wan. faith In
dsregardipg that protoc Would the senator venture
the assertion that that pro,eco changed or ssred
Kelican r aty from whs' 1t ratified oy the Senate
or ab,eyei Mexico fom obis.ton TO Abite BY its stpu
laons2 lie made protocol with Rulser-he received
a declaration from BulWer ard made q codnter one.
Could they Affect the ts.'y2 oa tae oh OF January
interview with ". + ri & who denied hagin. made auy
such s,aitmsn. 10 hin (Jlaytlp,) as va, coniainsi
Ii PLACED him n l. represen ed Liu ~ having m,ds
a ,rlse statement In grave dipora'is despatch he
vss a. rome ct the re Ard remote fou post ON,
and heard nothing Of 1t until he Friday ter when he
els PHI, n the Naosa fngeacr the words ussi by
Kns to him, vhish VAS p1blished on saturdsy. oa
Monday he pec'ed the ienats would have him JUS
c@. but that day lie into the Senate AMI rser
ated Lis thst Col King derisd having written
such note Should nos tae senator have Cone hlm
ukicef The Senator stys lie did not ssain visit Riag
but ought he not TO have dons and have relieved that
gtpt also from jusiiee' How soud he yepeIt in
Ire 5eiSe the Sioa that King told him he had not
written the note whsn the n7ts pab in this
ity without doirg King great ustice de has repeat
| I'd II again and again, and asser $ 1t yet
| Mr.. CAS-Of course do.
Mr. CLAYTON then read aud commented upon Jrdye
B-asss publ cation in behalf OF Mr. King what took
place between him and Case and denied that Cass had
done justice either TO him King Ths Senator's csclA
ration that the Senate, In rsing the aty, under
stotd it meaning gesr sphsA Central America, doubt
| less embittered the dying hours OF Mr. King he
| thought to have Mr. King before hts depar
| ture, but did not. He then read . letter rom
| Hr Rodney. Cont ul at Esiarsas, vhc, At Mr. Kings