New-York daily tribune., 1854-07-10
NEwYoRK DAILY TRIBUNE, MONDAY. JULY 10, 1854

.le ,ouId lot succeed III me- ii'nninS her pv.pH -. -
;i ,Es Il, eiosting any further euoroacamcn 1pon fha
T,kish territories cnnno feel 'hrt we rec have ay
r,cst alarm "a TO what she may a;:enp; ngsn- AusTa
Prussia France or Encirnd TEE, however ms neen
,,;.un.r.too6 and told that /; il supposed thai
yc cor,csod general Incredibly OF cny dagger OF Ras
.;an eecIe..ion Now, my Lords, have shown ycd what
Il n, sr. of aggression which afraid Of: and what
nv, rot afraid cf desire, however to confne Eiyse a.
ru.h 1s rosshIo these explanations hu cor'i ~sn
10 y something ubou those extraordinary and sbsurd
n. renal isnpu.aiODs 20 Which have been exposed MY
f,,s srrriv none Of you BE- 80 dril 20 Jn
,,eL,rd the motives in which those accusations have
oririrucd They arc however 50 lidic-ors!y anu ao-
Ills cnIuuniou- that rLoali almost fee il would b-
~ oiiy OF the position now occrpy-anwory OF me
memoir of those with whom have acted aud unworthy
of v own character if could conde;ceni TO enter into
ery iustifcaon Of MY conduct against snci prepcser
eaiumuies Ministerial cheers. Ny lords i true that
have perhsIs then any man struggled 20 pre-
serve state Of peace. have done becsuse thought
II was nv duty the people Of this ecuniry-y duty I,
my God-to exhaust evoy possible means of maintaining
peace And the OILY Tegre; feel T. lest-n'hough my
ror science acqu Of having done my u'mcst-le
Inay possibly not have doae my unost-e't may per-
chance have lost possible means Of preserving pence
fan iron;cal laugh the loss Of which consider the
greatest calamity that cen be'sl any country for no 4
iamitv surely exceed that Of know may be
scd that If am such lover Of peace an unfit 70 make
Ny lords, wish TO make war in order to Obtain
peace And know that the only mode Of making war so
es 10 obein speedy peace is 10 make with the NJ
most vigor and energy. My noble friends me know
well that have slrunk from any for the
prosection Of the war; the contrary. have always
rre,sed them forward believe may sey have per
sonally been more urgent than any other man in the
cover yneL. in exhornc the speedy advance ami con-
cenrann of the allied powers on the Danube in order
TO support the gallant army OF Omer Pa'ha, anu 70
operate against Russia. My Lords except under pres
sure Of tie vehemonce of which speaking perhaps
this is more than ought to cay but il il truth. and II has
been the course have universally taken Faint minis.
teral cheer. My lords, have now 10 more 10 say l
with TO confbe myself much possible to plantations
10, entering into questions connected with the general
rocy of The war or the which have pre- eded or
followed it. have wished to DO away with the impres-
WI il
ous-ns TO what said in your lordships honse NAM
tain that far fcm my endeavor to preserve peace IN
fitting for undertaking the most expeditions ana e'
fctua means of restoring peace thai my love Oi peace
will induce that war IL entered upon IA war "oic
consider and declare TO be perfectly JUST so long as l
have snv concern with its conduct 10 carry u on IN such
n wav as NAV be best calculated 70 secure safe. a
speedy ard an honorable peace. Feeble ministerial
cheers According 10 the report Of The NorReg Her-
go fIorv the noble Earl sat down evidently iIshenrt-
ened by be almost dead silence with which his speech had
been heard by his supporters the cheers be re-
ceived even from his nearest adberens being few ami
faint and almost all from peers IN the inediate vicinity
of the Treasury bench while all sides there was oiten
heard the hafsuppressod laugh OF irony or audible mur-
murs of doubt
III MARQUIS oF CLsSRIcAIDrs REPLY.
The Marcus of Clanricerde said he glad tha; the
noble Earl had upon reflection thought it right aud neces
sary 10 reret well as TO explain great portion OF the
speech which the noble Earl had made the other night;
Although however be the Marquis of Clanrcardel was
happy that the noble Earl Aberdeen had thought neces-
sary to retract-
The Marquis of ClanricardeIo reract explain away
great portions of the noble Ears speech the former
occasion Hear hear The question which the noble Earl
had now brought before their lordshps OF inn
elv wider scope than ha, of the precise terms the n
mediate effects of the treaty of Adranope Hear hear
Their or,lsIips understood the noble Earl by his notion
ard still more by his speech TO state TO them his views
not merely the present but on the past end perma
nent FOREIGN policy of this country 10 general the noble
Earl had gone back to s2s and had more than once stated
had done all this lay before their Ordshps grounds on
which they might consider him enttdt TO the confidence of
Parliament and the country in conducting this war 10
termination and negotiating the peace whichmay follow IT,
This was great question. and one which undoubtedly he
the Marquis of Clanricarde would not have mcoed HIM
self But as il was mooted he would not shrink from it
and while he admitted to the noble Earl liberdeenl that
through his public life he had acted with perfect conss
ercy he claimed credit 10 himself for similar consistency
Because from the year 1899, and even earlier, he the
MARQUIS of Claprcarde had differed from the noble Earl
on almost every topic of foreign policy, and he thought
tie sentiments and opinions which throughout that peri
od had dictated the policy Of the noble Earl Aberdeen
had been The principal cause Of the war into which this
country Rad been led and which, from what the country
could Judge Of the conduct Of the noble Earl he was ut-
terly unfit carry be the chief adviser OF the Crown
in carry ing Loud cries of Hear hear Before
going into the subject he could not but complain OF the
disrespect with which the noble Earl had treated Para-
ment in regard the dispatch to which the noble Ears
present motion referred. The noble Earl had stated that
e late Lord Grey had desired its productiOnthat the
late I.?d Melbourne hsG aesreu IT'S production but ttst
lie noble Earl considered full of peril that il was not
produced More lately however il had been adyered to
and quoted by the noble Earl himself and then when an
honorable member Of the other House, very properly
thinking that any public document from which minister
OF the Crown quoted ought 10 be produced, moved for
its production, in February last the answer of Lord D.
Russell was that he could not lay whether It would be
produced without consultation with the noble Earl That
con sultation held and the result was announced
that the dispatch could not be produced; And yet
now after all The noble Eerl, from purely personal
motives for his vndication and convenience
produced this very Dispatch which lie had for 80 long
refused the reiterated requests OF members of both
par hparl
the that its contents were OF so lnammatory
character that before war had been declared would not
have been prudent produce it, for the noble Earl had the
other night smaripg under the effect OF that extraordinary
speech of the noble ndleaed Lord yndhurs, tauned
the noble and learned Lord by saying that This philippe
against Russia as the noble Earl called III might have
been Of some service few months ago TO raise the nation
in alton for war; but that now when going
on not wise that such language should be used.
Hear hear II clear therefore, that this could not
be the why the dispatch iii question had not been
produced and it plain that If it could be produced
now il could have been produced i,ng ago. Hear hear
lie the Marquis of Canrcardo would now adv ert to that
reference which the noble Earl had made 10 the period Of
The noble Earl had assuming the position which
he now occupied declared that the foreign policy Of this
country had not varied for thirty years past however It's
execution might have varied lie the Marquis of ClanTi-
carde differed from the noble Earl in that statement, and
considered that the differences met foreign policy during
that period had been fundamental and differences of prn
cple: and that from the rstfrom lray when the noble
Earl was at the head of foreign affairs down 1892
when again the noble Earl in the positon-ihe
noble Earl had been the consistent most Jealous, and
most earnest supporter Of arbitrary governments.
The Earl Of Aberieen-(with angry ironyD-Hear hear.
The Marquis of Clanricarde-Ihe noble Earl Inc re-
pea;ed had been the supporter OF all the arbitrary power
of Europe and al all tunes the advocate ana adheren oi
the Emperor Of Russia.
The Earl OF Aberdeen-langrlyl- hear.
The Marquis Of Clapricarde.-ies The noble Earl
had every possible occasion berended those arbitrary
The Earl Of Aberdeen-Nol
The Marouis of Clanresrde-The noble Earl cried no
IL. E.rl. u.