The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1854-10-05

FIRM mo 70 Mr. 0cosor sbsut aneen er srrtee, feet)
@ Understood you ~ say Won had h'h' gid by too
h.na, A No; II ue boy came from tbs i'aiog roam
with tse rbia; soieg ssAs qoink c,Q'a
Mr. Rsqsre ga. I'D o. sseso at ne; he eft ,ha da og
stout no 'sme mes'snt did git cut al uuS
lit be ttsstet 9th hs htie BIZ; hio
turning from tho frsyste say he hs1 itdY stsh
bia has pAs-ta tss oa ara ret irnsd appc
o. ne Doe q re s'sss woea got % se heA o. tsa
sfAus trst observed tao g.o'i-ueo standing m ths
gasawsy they we're Shading taoe 20 face Dot torng
~ss fscisg sr Gfa~m, h fss-d tosssd. he cioiog
rom; az 'hs hesd thee s'aIs there Is iarsa mfr
ro which ppies spoe from ,ho foar to the Gel as
As Jot LorSbg not f.cicg that nirror he stnoi
very % the orik Il he STAIR; tue bees
OF he shtes stppsrs { tss edge II tn s~ri,
and The tss II his sspgers sh he he
5000 esther sios oo~ ing a. toe ,au from % a.
wey not to.sids Il; DR. Graham stocd with hi fac,
toasrds Col Iogug; tnFy b,th stood face 20 iac. .
lid 'bsy OF Then .tant THAT ire mirror would have
s.twn bo h OF their boob pisa t5iok there IS
a httis g tnsre. Y Csuls DR. Gr.h,n Etsndog that
~sy, fsce 70 CD Lorsg ions i,ro tns pi r9rP he
could. Y Rev ~ss IL ~ttb regsto Col Lnripgg A. !
Old not think he could z. at -nat disttn;' did DR..
Graham stand fr, M CD LAiegs We short distance
about ak Or Eight inches When sou oo'eeved those
geD'enen standing there then you made up your nina
10 60 down the eft hand start A Yes sir; the aurss
lats for breakfast and told to eat much
she coula and ~oV take the chitd had gone any
steps III stairs before Toe up tok the
child xi'h,n few in hes Of the bead Of the stairs
So ,ba the next sfep wosid h. We taken me dowa NAT
gor past the raDng aud then at the
gyeT; could oct reco lect what hand hli tbs cold
by; rs Lear l rec.l CT h.ld Ire CHILD by my
laft hand hsc bait1d about ,is mid lie Of the
fscitg bi osd soy, when The up took the
chib; she right down he stairs tmns6iaety dill
rot follow them Q Up to this line had tnere bsen
any word those two e nt,erpen thet you aid
attsb'itp tor A. No cir, rh-y talsny loud
at he time what the words &c at that time DO
rot know head col LoIink speak at tue time Q.
ID ycu hear Iol Lorpe make OF term like this:
.'You are a loaisr." A Nos Q ny thing Of int
kindly md lot hear Col Loring say 80; he dill not
speak oud enough At = At time q i'd you heat Col.
Iorng say, damn yoas'' A. No, sir 2 When dill the
words rsc loud snd srqiys A When the
ms Dol q cir fbfu hta So ak
loud but did understand them did aos hear any
loud cords but those have tod 2 There we're load
words then, that did not understand? A. Yss; they
were speaking ,hr for minute two, as far my
judgment g3es; had motive FIR lis enal.
passed BET seen themy No I only gay what did
hear. Q Was here not loud talking which You a not
.undeystsrds A enig say did not hear tnem Q DID
you hear whss words Col LnrBg used when Ut GRAHAM
said You lisg' A 60 net understand tae quss iba.
Mr. Whiitg-lhea wen pass on - something else
Q Before lr Graham ed the csne had the two
gentlemen lett heir potitiors No, sir, thsy
standing III the same place according as saw, within
head Of the Air these Two gentlemen whom they
Prapplsd each olbefS A Alb ut as far as that desk
dour or bve feet) Col Lorins visa going sideways to-
towards the mirror A. They both togetn-r
they took sort of circular turn 20 can jdige
rrecolect Whereabouts ia tho hall did Coz Lonng
fall On bis aces A. Directly In front Of tue mSie SLAB,
The Cour,--which Slab DO you msanf
A. The one towards Broadwas.
Mr. Wh,ing-lo you mssn to ELL this jury that they
came together 30 quick you couldn't tell -hich took
hoa h,str a Yes Q Can you describe the manner ia
closed in 70 quick. Q You have described the
way pr Graham rsissd the stics: did you
Colonel Loripg rshe bis hand before that ? A.
did not. Q. Did you hear aay noise like that
(slspfiog Of the hanes together) knock or slsps
A. No O. Did not Col oring seizs that stick when DR..
GRAHAM raised tY A. old him @ Could it
have haopsre without your feeiug ~ A. should cot
have bought So but il mighs ooat wantto say any
thing that did @ id you not struggle
between those two gentlemen for the mastery of that
stictS. A No sir, dc not. Q Where the bard
OF tbet zane when Col Loripg felR did not SEQ t.
q Lid you bot see it in COL Loring's hands did
rot Did you rot it that morning apart from the
Gamer A. No, sir, rot 70 my knowledge Q when yon
the stick in the hands of DI Graba a, and both
hsnds Of Col Lorrg up, cid you whether he pnt his
bands on the stick or On Dr.. GtshamY a. did not SEQ
a When the tosslo could not tell Q, Vas
Colonel Loling large or small MANI Very
A. Yes, three ieet ia Ter than am Q.ughtsr) he
avery tai, powerful man could not Judge how much
be would weigh, sa. Thick about 2co los Witness
here gain descIiped how Col LorDg beId his hands up
not quite As high as his head but as high As his
shoulder Q AFTER you ,aw The hands up in that way
stick, any part OF it, after tina. men? A. NJ, sr,
Re direct esamin.ton-Q During the whole tine Of
this which way you iook,ngt A. My face to-
wards Eroadway. O. Did keep your face in that d.
Tes s during NE whole q the he. ssS, Yes @
eyes away II ON the partys a. No, oia not q When
the cane was raised did ther Of the parties adsaoceg
the Court said that the witness had already testified
that subject
O. Dic you notice that ksjor Loring had hold Of Dr..
Grshami
This question objected tobe By Mr. 0'Coner a. not
arising out of the Mutation.
The Court escuced the que hon for the
The Court then wanted to know what the witness
meant by sayirg that he Dr. Grstan struggling,
iut did not think it sword until he dres i. oat
WitDesa--1bere fHssle; did not think the Boc.
tor had any weapon; did not know until Col Loring
exclaimed 81 sm stshbed-he has kaife !"
Witness-I supposed the knite was in him Col L.,)
at the time
struggling before the witness lost sght OF the cane and
after he had II ed in the way had described
Mr. O'Coper objected to tho question, as going back
over the testimony already gone through.
The question withdrawn.
Q ~ what point Of the difficulty did the struggle you
have stated beginY
MI OCoror again objected and the question WAS ruled
Juror to witness--Frou the time you saw the two
at the head OF the stairs what elapsed before
the struggle commenced A. Not than i've minutes.
Q Did you any anger from the time yon first saw
say he raised the arm horizontally with his throAt2
A. Yes sir, Col. L. raised his hand about high
rs bis shoulder. Q Tnen Dr.. Grahan's hands must
have been somewhat lower : 4. Yes.
Another juror to wness-Do understand you that
he put his hand against the cane a. Yes, his and
Chas. H. Rogers examined by the District Attorney
Whist was your busir esq on the "a OF August lastg
s1ner at the barr A. saw him once or twice; I
know him by sight. Q. Did you kn,w Col. Lorins
or ten days Q Lid you SEQ the prisoner at the bar
and Col. Loring together the "a Of August A
did. O. Whereabouts A. At the head Of the
stairs, the laadipg the second floor.
There the wtress pointed on. the place in tho dagram
went from the dnicg towards Broadway: / saw
Colonel Lorrg standing there, and Dr. Graham facing
him.
The Court ssdI understand the witness 70 say that
COL Loripg stood aA ths nearest to Broadway
To VAR
, the witness az he came mp.
The District Attornes to the witness-At W 81 point
we're Jour A. was directly bebiad him. q At what
distance you from birnS A. About four feet. O.
What were you doipgY A was In )mpany with lady
from the dining room and taking her to the stage O.
Lid you notice shat they doinsf 4. What brought
my atiei ton to them vas that they Speaking
loud heard Colonel foring say. I" my wife, which
appeared to be the enl Of the sentence. O. Did Dr.
Graham make any reply A. Yes. What dill he say?
A. !" don't care o dsrnn fer yosr wifa you" O.
What ncxt took placer 4. could no. cay what mex.