New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1854-02-28
Id " INTELLIGENCE.

T. s CIRCUIT COURT Second Circuit Of Ort1ber Term 1883
We give below the opinion Of Judge Belts given in the
India Rubber lately tried in the Circuit Court Of the
United States for this District Charles Conor Edwin
n Dicke,on and VIM. Jpdson appeared c,unse! for
defendants and n Richardson Of Boston and e. " Slough
ton of New York for Mr. Day.
Horace A Ds' Is The Nsw.EasAnd carsP!insco
The complainant fled his bill to restrain the defendant,
os viosrs paepti; ld .,O 70 compel hem 70 .pPss ~
Court and abide Ia order AID decree IA respect the ons OF
p,nSf sPeIs Upon The dseadsrts with Of the spPcoa
@9,ed Sn he aer Of he iii The pfemas,y prs5
sufficient pyo a osuppor the Ihey ,'ow Ihst
for pecd Of fourteen years and the S'st Auzl 1885, the
that On te t Jai1 S53 for the eo1dsaoa Of cash paid
him he assigned bic entire iare. IN The extended snt 70 the
the said patented discovery ani had been IN U.s. of for
.sh October OF the pssLt but Inc hearing deferred br
srder 1.-THE Cour o mntua OF ae Of tbs
parties ron tiue to lime until the 5ts J.1unJ last on the last
mentioned Do, the counsel for the complainant to'uPpo his mo
tie affidavit l,Ase Van DoEsa proving the
oiLe Paien by the defendant rhs def,ndle eosn
November 1851 srsntnE them full stsone and exclusive esss
70 use he cured Cbaass ISL.
sIpded patent in he rn.ouf.eare IndaRlbbsT sprns Tor
knotd Cars &c and eo'egI ut sa % use ,Id
Fowler NJ Ray President Of the dsfendsnts
Of Wim udson TO Which sas anrcIed sopy Of .s
s4sd into On he I OF h. 10 osTs'n %, ,e L5"a
BY d Chaee said Jud'on on the 3 sspt'n
is S 80 ~ ' cpv e"asrt or eIe,sa igsl
u c BY Charlie, Goodyets ne sid yad'on Toe e1a1. Of
proofs PUT the Of the denasn the .i.y OF John
the JsnusIy 1881 Of which appended copy Of
agreement bun .nd Ua'. o. a. d an. .al
1850 the those annexed 10 the AaisTit or Wsn ld
cisa.e and w.m Jud,on dated Nov II s5l rho oAe
-,Ppenesd cop, Of The aforesaid power fo n 70
copy Of letter dated sept ls5, written aid Jla.on .
G:s's tie LIE ZANE: t.ted y.s: cop, Of .s%
from Ch.aee to Jud'on dated June n ls53 copy Of re-.
t,uSscn and est:d july us, copy Of he sir.sa.ni
,r Of extended patent BY ch.aes the aa
:ss, OF cs.ae. .t.d January 10 s re
counsel furthermore rut evidence ne sIemp
n. rnest ofe, wuh,ssa dated NoTsmssr 20 1881
, ,ss aat s9 he .s. IL. Of ne
si part ard the Me- EnInd Cn spIns ConpSny esrpor.
ys cns dead of s and esavsy,1.s Of era Ps3. rsas
tie Of u. 1 i pSS ,,.d ss,sSSs &
Fsvler Ray Of the frat AID III. Ca. sprrG
s.i.. T.s.l 1.ss % p,r, ~ Good
e,ea d.,I A. .sInm,t transfer
Ns~Is.sd Car Company rsm Charles Ely and Ed-sri Crane
es &c Coca, ear TO s.@ a.s; ost s1 %
70 ana SCI. ~ TR,oiS q, Ind. .00 70 Ss q.5e
,nr. O evidence ia. othe c!sr Of
u. Nv I,..Rd Car s,ri3s cSnyss! b..r1, Ss. o. s
,ss to e.,: ss, a.S n ss o. ,a .. .n &c
by the esIsu before the license given by Jat
:SP !. 30 a1. 6 $ Is. 81 Safn:y Tom h
1880 and Ch.fee "a tle
giant before made The sgesneni between Ch.Hee .ad
Goody Of Nay 3 1850 ssasos BE- sstuP By she dsf.Odsn,
suypo their title beesuss they By sh ~'nss Ja1son
ssgied snsIleS sad Of ysi after ~ e-e1H
beEs Cbgrss JssIS, Of Sept 1875 sa1 uea
urdhSy would be the esa construction be given the hS N
for the right Of Goodyear iHtsrsss peses n
extended made BY Dependant ssndons
-hiek been fassd By him Tie main in4ay then
vhshe that power astho the snt Jsdson assumed 20 make
vhieh defendants accepted under 10 The license refers 20
tl. Of Jgeson and the defend
AZ aeodngy be held have dsai with kis not ony
der legal sses bat with positive knowlsdge Of the sfsent
and limitation Of his for 10 rskes'ses hat "ChA1ee
upon the eonssraisr and for e Bsp.es therein srrreea
rreyoe.b hold aid patsni haze AZ tosa tssy "a
The provisions Of shat deed they stood 81 the tine
Of OF the eBs the Defendants therefore 20 meas
Ie the lind s holding and eenuol Of hs patent
rhh Judsoa CARED eosd then 10 vii hare
,s sonid whether the terms Of this power OF aftorny
,o, on the exposition given the dep~son Of yadon viii the
~, OF thereto By Chsrec shall rntsn tne r1e
foyerss interpretation respect the parties now Oee. the
Ce,rt Two particulars plaay declared BY The pose rs
thai s6e BY tTue OF Charse and not
az ef uSsor yrnsni 70 yudson BY Gootyex or
the Of srJ ofner heenf OF
dunn the lie Cha9ee The sazsss Css1ee
Ia 40 nominate eorstste ana appoint Sad VIM sdson ny
rree ana attorney ieyocss NO oseF peea hsh Cna1ee
upsr and claim 10 be essss 7sr S
raw. the dsposa Of the trust wise tean IN
the su.sed AID in the Pee. manner pese els "a
,h,se yrord" and n looking trto the
iii h. fuud hs, the be u to hsd the patent and have
hsreof Chsfee has capacity 10 st tn 20
.hs have said patent or o. "
aid extended vths1t the ven eons
~ "a Judso. first had and Obtained Ihs pApapy
,.s over Cbafee and not positive power N
- ~ he psfert rshf interest n or under Literary
oths, persons Who had right 70 ase the
- after pe1soes ~