The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1854-08-17

f,spe 1 vas behind Mr. Gardens oafA eav Anoooer
go srrsr., IN puli my sister ont Of the ear; MI
s<.n yars,ned at the back Of the car two or three
sr;an,e. after my sister lad reganed her position
S,d not dns ing that time see INN doing anythingi
ssiSsipe 10 p,y sister, and don't mind the restn
krsrd ain say more than once, Come on boys
and that "he should be hung for this" was At
Tsthsrd church Yith Miss Lyndon on sac Wednes
dsy before Mfss Ereanor not there; Oh that day
saw Mr.. Garden On Market bill we were In q pony
carnage; Mr.. Garden csl1e and spoke TO me- he in
qsn for my sister HeaDor; saw four men on q
sss; 10 few ninates after saw carriage behind
Erzs LyDdon examined by the Attorney Gene
sd remember the Wednesday before the ID Of
Jn,x. ACCOMPANIED Miss ArbuthnOt - church on
that day; when returning met Mr.. Garden; tnere
vas no person then with him, but direct!y, when
timing round saw carriage; . nule while After
Isaw isuntpg car; on Sunday MgnA tDe 40 OF
Ivly / returned # IN Rathron~n Churcs in .
covered car; Mr.. Garden passed the oi-;. after
wing he wheeled round and closely followed
he car; tine car stopped at Rathronan, and
= the same moment saw MI !nst Us1S S Mfos
A the car; did not see him open the door,
mt / felt his two arms across me, holding Miss
fssaner Arbuthnot she was above mo in the
>x; pus my arm up 20 prevent him he
was st the time pulling Miss ArbuthrOt after
having pushed him for some time gave him Q
Nov IN the face With my hand he bled In the nose;
AS Garden hfted me out; ran to Q carriage which
Es0od opposite the gate, the steps were down the
Apor open; begged OF the cOachman to come and
assist he did nvT move ran to the car Miss
laura Arbuthnot not then quite out OF the car;
iDmedissey afterwards saw her lying on the road;
Mr. Garden was also down; ran to the cato; there
was man there brandisti,g little stick, with
knot at the end Of it; maa named Magrath went to
The este, wa en- that ma. struck Msgrath with the
ID II the blood rushed ut from under q straw hat he
bad or; ran hack 10 tie car and said to the coach
man, who eat Ut the back Of the car, Stand Dy u.s.
we bave no one to help us;' the coachmsn put his
back 10 the car; then saw Mr.. Garden I left and
vent 70 the gate; the man ad been removed by
RSg sth saw several persons as the time lighting;
iss~ ran named Smthwich struck va terrible
DsCws y a man with weapon similar 70 that hsd
sen with the man AZ the gate went on to the
gate; il was then open; M Cough had got in;
did mot afterw ards see Mr.. Garden.
james Dwyer examined am coachmAn to Capt
Cough; drove Mrs. Cough end the Misses Arbnth-
Nct 70 church on the ID Of July in an open carr Il
having raned brought covered car for them; saw
Mr.. Garden st the church; on our return saw Mr.
Garden on horseback, about half way from the church
10 the house; he was coming from the dire ton of
Esthrosan; on coming up he turned round and fol-
fVvtd the car; when got near the gate I saw
hrsoshHm passing on the road With . man on
eox w. ~ men us me- from wes me carriage
got down, and then saw Mr. Garden 81 the car;
ths man who had the knife, garden knife, pointed
= ct my head, and desired me not TO go foo: fur.
Tier; then went to thu back Of the car; Miss Lyn-
len was out Of the car; Mr.. Garden was halt way
kSo Is; saw man standiDg by Mr.. Garden; did
net zee him do anything; was knocked about;
AaRlatb and Smithwick came to my assistance; /
ssw Mr.. Garden pulling Miss Eleanor, saying " It's
yOu want, it's you WANT Mr. Garden was pulie
hem the car; had . hold Of him by the coat, end
pulled him IS well as could; Miss Arbathnot and
Mrs.. Cough were at the line In the car; went to
he car after Mrs. Cough and Miss Arbuthuot were
yaIed out, and was knocked down; got some
Vows Of . skull cracker: there were six men be-
sides Sm,thwi,k snd Masrath; Rainsberry was
mere; he Was the first man that took hold Of the
hsSse's head; others Of the party, besides tue man
vhc struck me, had skull crackers; Mr.. Garden had
Awnip.
Johp Magrath examined by the Attornsr enc
NIL live at Rath, oman about bali or 4 uH,,ter o.
mile Rom Captain ought gate; oetn, one and
two O'Clock on Sunday the "a OF July, WAS stand
ing N the avenue leading down to atain Gou yh s.;
saw q carriage and three or four men; saw man
a horseback, and another horse afterwards
the carriage was being driven towards Rstl,ronan
ehsxch; II etepped near Captain Coughs gate, and
0se men went tCwardsthe church; they IN. GU,
~ my sight and returned; saw Capt IL cough.
Gar coming rom the church; ga tbs thtve % tour
hen on foot, scd the man on horseback resirning
e&e ran before the Other 70 the gate and he'd 4
k,m then raw the jaHating car come up to tn,
gate; the horseman followed it, and came 10 20 the
ear; he d.smonDted, and saw him grasp the Ia
DIES in The car; saw all the ladies except Mis-
kseaoor ArbntbDot ont Of the car; heard Mr.. Car
den go towards hs carriage and say, "Cowsrtis-
cowards 8hy don't you come 0ni"; saw Mr.. Smtl,
v'ck comjTg from CioDmel and called to him; Mr.
g. dan wss then commencing his work; aied to
SmNhaich 10 hurry on and not lot the ladies be
killed; vert clos r. the car; saw man como or,
Ms.GODeh's car ard 90 % the carriage and set
down; asked inm what they were at; he did not re-
plys then went on 10 ihe csr, and was met by man
vhA skuilciacker, who struck me; Mr. Garden
was at the cas; saw him phi aiss Arbuthna.. snd
Hbey fell on the roa: re, and jostled Mr.. Garden
md Miss Arbuthnot Totup: Twas attacked BY two
men with skul!erackeis ;; they were beating me to-
wards the gate; man with xliite coa' max.
ing at me, and went oS,rds the dyse ,sed
Sp two stones, and struck Mr.. Garden " ia onc :
saw no firearms: heard the 10 lies shriek when d IT
"a ri hSv 4. thpy Ia a
great resistance; raw taer hands showing Mr.. Car.
den back; san Mr.. Garden at the pulling Miss
EeanoT; threw stones ut tne men on = car.
images; there we're tive men hehind; one o. IN ose
bad sten very often in the fight; dill not see Mr.
Garden get into the carriage; the open sid II the
carriage was not at the aide where ! y there
we're about five or six men there entirely; 30 MI
kDos what became Of the horses; was blinded by
the blo<d.
John Splisbwick exsmued by 1r. Gsorgs, Q. O.
Is shepherd TO NJ. Cough; was At mas, Cion
1el on Sunday, the % of iy; 70. back 70 kathro-
nan about o'c3tk; was going By the straia hi ROAD
md saw carriage On toe road and - ne !; saw
Hrs- Goughs car come up: saw man rnH = The
gate, and saw the rar stopped; saw the coacii,aan
Eeruck; saw John ha,,rath; he called out TO ME to
come on; saw Mr.. CArien at the door OF the car
dragging the ladies'; man Mt his lef. hand side;
NV tkolicgackers with five men, went straight 70
ne car received blows from the skucrscker; saw
nan with knife In one haod and skulls acker
II the other; returned 70 the car; saw Mr. Garden
p is; the Misses Arb,ihgot we're then in the OR;
49, MI S -. Say, rs Is 700 wanti' .n",7i
pistsl In Mr.. Gardens side pocket. and bel. around
bs waist; took up stones ana used tlen; did lot
strike Mr. Garden; Magrsth struck by two m %
With skullcrackers; saw Mr.. Garden on tie step o.
hs carr made towards him; he F,trcatsd aud cried
eVt, Murder! Boys, WHY don't you Are ~ /, hi.
Sws boys; was cut severely on the head; did MT
noe M. CarGen get into he carriage.
Mr.. George N Callsgh, sub inspector OF c,nssa 81.
ksry, ard eoae o'her witnesse., having bean ex an
tsed, the case FOR the CROW closed; afser which
Mr.. NaItlcy, Q. g., then proceeded 10 address the
ssiisripg OF his ebert, the POSITION 10 which he was
now placed, the gnieyous punishascut Of fine AM
imprisonment that would awaii him even for the
assanit He observed that evidence would be al
dn ed TO remove the shocking idea ;sas be hal pns-
eh-sed chic osorm IN order to pr1tace inseDsibi-
MY, vi.h the houiolc design OF dclng Ms Ar
bushnot.
r.