New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1854-12-13

J1fst DufTls mere erstioD o. ne eftef
20 row Jou b.esDs Possessed Of ths letter
Mr. S.- We nae ;hs I, We. '.s, 70 =. b @sa q ..
awe the u.us lest .r .bolH RAG. in their own -.np
am rot ururs for the socpns even laid do-n in the
Of HOT sst MeKsnxe sih01sb h The Law o. This
STATE for not besvs in tss it.i TIE true
doctrine believe TIA, oogh, = Be souerhs, nooitei-5us
harm woud result Ia c-her. elss The
Couii ~il iroahle itself wth such spTc.tisu.
nsher pretend that Their Interests peeanisy soc,
eue Re furTreson; DO they pretend tst csad ~
We. ne 90. q 1S '. a. wsss T .s
there. that The inunction .h1gld Be d.sovsi
only escaye that BY finding special DO "a;
tia, but 90 .sk you that they
injury persons fenfs social poson the pub
lie. Or smeihbI Of bat srd there no value foa ers
what Infamous scandal circassd
hcw hou.ehod was 10 be broken up ard rendered mer-
notw hisrsrs that moral sud .ocsl evil AID
frsf personal be committed this pabca
ton y.t 70 get found tb, decision IN Hoyt .t AcKsnx H.
Honor obliged fn6 less. he dd nS base hs decision
any other srcuhoj trust There dispute thar this
decision correct one. They did out uus; y
TIE question Of the social and ors evil passed
entirely, 10 deciding The case, I. reeo.eet II.
willing hs, the rule should be further uodiasd . ,zPly
require n, m 70 show On The face Of hs 60 l
u dispute that this Of DO oyy value sofhnE .pPea'
% 70 sn~ .p 80 ~ 80 oy - :.
They tould In their pant such General
70 ,tsi .ee n,eeon.s r iussnee Or resns 10 their fam,
y Affairs or Invention Of their OF thai IL
The next question before the Spgrt t.1d thns this pon,
/, wen AEeL TO- that the sefsndauts Honaa, Cray, and
persecution They bad control Of the letter, had
ofh. T.y o5 ma ca ssts ,.,d % oa Of
the principal brcSsh MS agents or employs bot asy do 80
Judge Daer-In the Broadway Railroad csse NJ Field
tended that ell should be msde parties 70 the SOFT
Mr. Nes-Ys. your did consider that GOOD
.rtumspt even hom the frarnsr Of the CODE. Now
ustrson Suppose were wanted TO restrain the Ethth
treasurer ceneueioi CLERK driver and every Other having
connection with We could never get an Injunction in s1ch
FOR could hnd them out Therefore yo.r
Honors believe that M Dudley Field argued well
order HE ON Code YVES going TO .1sssst where
would this thing end TIE position that they take Is that the
printer Tubher may be restrained ard must be made
party the suit II So must ihey not make the eomPo'o
End ever, other poon Ia that Office parties doEn 20 the very
devil hin II the printers devil" Of couf.e)
case. Suppose there controversy with Adams Co
end you asked eron the running OF the Express
Aussis France and RDsand Will Mr. Field argue before
ycur Hon0rs with any shov Of thai be has Code
Of the ten thousand employed by AdSTs 70 I'VE h
Al the countries the globe, or even in MS cerntry
Be n,de P:Ts. e that S s 70 se4 o BE-
cause all different and responsibilities from the
Of sIS 10 sy v wsRer M field or
tcdy else argued ihs slsd for the cake OF equity and
common ense that His Honor did not sustain the gentleman
in that position. III, H..
Cout has no urd restrain h putfeaton There are
number Of that efec bot have stated only two
or three upon the points for must be brief The Court can
not restrAa crime enforce the performance Of moral ob
cation except it Ia connected with the rights Of opery
Hoyt vs. Mckenzie Barb Oh $50 BFandrsta v, Lance
Paige "a IL connection with thie point. hold that al
though IL undoubtedly wrong for man 20 he utteng dsn
der. @ns & s 1n. there 4% s. ssS 6e
hrnen which the law has prescribed for the violation Of the
rsh Of parties, Your H2ns hsye to sc, OILY 70 th
r. bs,sc,er Of m letter and say whether Il right
10 pnbsh IL Judge HoHmsn admits in biz opinion, that II =
necessary for the Of public justice may be puened
But they sk In advance to decide with ~ wing one
their single tniuf
the circumstances under which was written to de-
fse end. Of public justice % not 5qa,e IL publication
case hey woud make ih. Court me,e censor Of he
uied Tor Of old they would lesst read the document with
out peciion q The document OF snowias one word 10 IT,
thew ak Won allow ts pu1caii9n ssk you where
then would be the liberty Of the p'es How are we % know
the character Of politician who stands up Tor election now
shall know, II the pres prevented from puoshns LIS
ter. OF from publishing bis speeches r there can be no DIS
tneton between words spoken aud wfen what ms pos1h
are What Is TO be the Te'ult o. our Demoershc yneh
Where endifth to run five minas AFTER say
ing writing their flourish aud ask an injunction TO suppress
admit ibsi This not very Formidable .ti'ek that We
hope 10 epe BY giving the whole story But your honor.
Lpew full well that thief concealed behind your door or
nnder your bed far be feared than army 10 the
I'LL 90 Lon and the AS Who went 70 hunt in company.
The sheep having taken shelter n cave where the Ion eeui
while he stood b, TO catch thee. This succeeded and the
coming to share The prey inquired Pf9aa h o S 90,
would have scared me had known you "
We a. simry that may Be msde EnoTa whs,hs, oar as
VI The defendants are morally justified publishing the
The Bible Union he, be IN assasd and misrePre.snei
s friend, ed and traduced and their physical
eonrbsey has been formed between plaintiff wOOl'ey
ard others ruin by false statements what they %
not by facts and the publication wiil ten
to promote the ends of Justice By defeating their scheme
tons 323 and note suppose that there Is no P,etense
The. h; letter wss Of sL pe99.y y,g .asa "a
in the matter; suppose there will be 10 dispute upon tns'
Judge DueTbere may be something of pecun.ry value.
Although worth nothing At all 10 others it may he oil value 10
M Nle.-I admit all that. But there is pre;ense-no
allegation the complaint o any raiae Of any siad % him 2,
moi sell or any thing and think that the rule should DO 50
modifed.
othe they atesst becomes matter OF pure
Equity jurisdiction. They have no legal rshs IN the n.er
this letter and Is not even mixed questoo oil
Jaw 'Ka egsS g.' ph o.is bfps. and The idea Is
lr embdsd in their epreenslion Justice
with andsge and SC .es and sword Equity simply dressed
aes. With motivs. as well As their consequence. Like
Fscbus and Rhsdsm she looks into mems souls TO see
tor her to come With eie.n hands. Justice the contrary
weighs evidence and the lag oniy though the Judge
b, nesses upon the stand he must be acquitted.
But it'll Otherwise with pure cases Of equity Equity az
rue .iS down in tie case Of Hoyt McKen,e the higher
law And when person come. into Court win Lean ssnas
necessary repe that we are not really justified IN pub
fishing OF bis documents, thefe 10 some
JUNCTION But they here Otherwise the Court Will
not when sppers that there controversy "nicn
does not sppesr this c.se prevent from showing the true
sta OF controversy; because will upon these PIT
pes you have been suy Of sAt "rops hsse
made the mos scspdaous and outrageous attacks upon per
sona ehsaete and for what the Court knows necessary
that they show the whole Of what you have been doing that
the community may Judge between you
There pTetense hat answer or our sfhdsyis are
4, MED in sny way that they untrue Our srdsys
alege this conspiracy We alese that this party. who pre-
tends 10 be seps private capacity and who got tins
eopspir.cy with oihe ocer the other Society; that
he.e written in Of al IN
the conspsey and for the purpose OF
n pebe our Society BY ether than facts and .rsu
,nt, because facts aud arguments failed We simply ash to