New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-08-23


The next point is whether the contracts their f.,s
smourt ,th.r IN law or IN ecuy 10 say agree Snioa
binds her Cbs-e fxes the hts Of the def-pisnts
Were they, u cir fsre alone Lease or pesm'ssi N -
these parties 70 then Nos, Sir these contracts have
s The weakness amount that There ust
shy hey don't amount 70 t. th-re whY ,hs
rtoi.as IN the do amount 70 evidences Of
hcps. or of smother sp..r.ent contract Bat 81 IN
20 sl the objections b-'su.e hi. - putt OK
them rDdsrssnd the gentleman 70 'sy, and 10 . q,
they be put. whether they pu, them ~, sni
De examined by the Court, - Ehsre the Con
tnd thing about which u cntrsct-wh-r- there -
area contract between .ny body Now there conissH.
here undoubtedly, and for the pur ,hoviog WHISTLER
gives any re ~ 70 Hsrshorn il is necessary - what
rights IL does give 70 whom they are extended and
what consideration. Here done xb itais,
cept for purpcs. Of cen truotion Of the instrument itself
and for that still; titled to take r.cts bat NJ, by
way q ts,cppa or !or Tie plpOe OF fading snecedon
contracts The reciss only n b. used now 20
What the contract conveys ard - whom conveys say
! hing
Now Sir propose in the first place 10 shoF precisely
What these eoniots % convey between Judson aud
Chaifer-wheh,r they r,yocASe not and whether
we have revoked ih.m. think shall show yOIr II nor
that II is perfectly i'm material for HE purposes OF the
but vta night thu had crested or may not b. inns
t.risl the purposes Of seeing sh-t er they created
hcerss themselves by force OF 1er eIitence for
Hsniliou to work under this patent OF ChsiFees
Before, boseyer, come 90 tbst have little usa 20
make c hst part Of the case which WAS pa, in by Mr.
ludson which ably and slnqu-nty presented by him
hst CO net feel oisposed To say word ab a sslb
ssb'ive ground of these bu. merely
ty way % illustration. sm looking 70 what ths
birsts did convey snd 20 whom they conveyed t. W.
have disposed Of the matter OF thu r-ciss most c,na
syey The, recitals about o.h.r matters aud chsr
CouiTaris 90 ms5e upon their face NnV wish IN x
The papers and eIsnr them discover Who thu parties
then relation Snd condition Whist III, talking ab,u,
srd vhst sort Of contract they hsye made Tina, is
potsnt upon this question. tn5 tnGt purpose then,
say the shows that VIM Juas'o then tho sg-ut
attorney Of Oh flee Fer the Durp of The conruc
tit of these contracts, propose g y. thN by virtue
arc by means OF tLAt att rney ship took mos; y
adv suisse Of Ch4se in the making Of thcn do ask
f Ia .l.sIf /. L.
CoLtrs'f prop so merely To shl ihA WA Jltson
Jrocutd peculiar crcum t,noes, contract 10 BE-
see by Ciafee vhich Chsdes in hi and in his
ssiilts mace, which wss eniiely subversve OF hrs
rights i,h To- sway all the rights he had by that
tension. al ~ ,h entT,ly destroyed hsosn s'es, II
that CONT u enforced propose - shDs "a lsrs
CERTAIN pGrpos-s. 20 NIX A. 'OuirI'ti that Jud-o1
hus, bad drasn up this contract in ninaer perfectly
uncou cioI Sbr fair 1T 4hi Intended - bene
e. tucson slcn sud 20 Cnse. snd thai T0ad be -
.8,at # the gent mans ut uotinn l. 10 be given -
tai It will LOT as between at rley and cl@nt gig7
crIstIICrCl 10 = paper or Il ail r0lsteu 'nO1 Ia
q equity the purpose 81 r. B:er cOa'r set
which pits h,he the in, enor and The only msrtorDi
man saci rely in the h,nis of Jud,Or,
hat he play the dog 10 tie mTgsr snG nsber Let
CLsfee tsk- any advsrt.ss from he contract nor take
fer him. Say toe contracts Undertook - convey -
irreVotsbe right % iceuse zoe 'pdy-sr cDnoint
iou uuGtr certain conditions and h.' conusnrss md
clcseG The hitse nth twenty SIKH lines o. aa
second coIts,t Jucson uss- am ni-fteke - iv-y
give in revt cable power - c--se The GOO y7
combnson cernil oondni Il, during TIE who- ~
i,ictd term without liuii hn, St al 20 ios mgri
a. should payoIy ifihey u psv c-ttalq HtcHtit
tbu they 10 receive License Turn ypu p@ se -
~ ffst cOnirsct That cOrtrxct und-ltiaes 10 re,tri .
Ch Zee fr' licensing any body else but the G'odyer
censees.
Then Judsob undertook attorney, toge into IA. ntnns
TIE power fT-t upon certain co1o us - Ii elss q 'oi
Year and bis ceIs'es md second, - r,sc. On flee II 'm
IsiIg yboCy Else 10 C"ttc; With them Thn he m
cert, Ok 70 hold or bot As be pleased nat patent wi,1"l
heusmg Goody and bis H. eI'e4s, sud biting MOB dY
vok under T. 70 icen-e them a. nis option unfer the
terms and rdious of first contrast Nov what Is tn
eject c that ttst the uc'ior upon Chsse tnd
row SIN addressing tho Cocr- entr, ~ matter %
tween Jues'u and Chaa 81 The 'f,ef upoa Chaf-sis
this Judson hid merely 10 play NE d. Ia the Roger
,I ply say-ltecsu your Honor vii r-m-mb-r the
construct Of this contract Is to secure Judsln for the
enhancement OF .one -" Cbsaee aas knJ 'edged toe
debt tic face of these instruments 81 e. in s-ut ~
equity BE- maintained evidence nialned IN then
Juiscns ps;t against hun tor ta,s adsancem-nt"
Judson holds Chsf, debt for tho adv IDc- sat
whatever was He ssys-I can, II please, e,th--e
licensees go On without licensing IN Is cal
hold rp@ts ~ and gr-It liz - MT, dy and get
pay cen hold your pa'en' 10 m end Of tho time You
hCen.e n"bOoy Else IL ultlcsnss the Goodyear
"lit fusefs a hdGy debt on you. # choose, til tbs
"end Of the seven years and then II Chsfes is worth
dollar in the world, be- may collect 4 ne best may
That Their construction between these 1es IDs
tracts ad- betgee0 lawyer ana c.n and thy
rot to be sustained 5y Court o: Equity, between the
parties The msely,s.
say then Ctsfee can revoke upon the ps5ment % Mr.
Juoson # th- that the ,tt-r made,
that the by confederation where any ater-. c,uoei
Jucs all The powers attorney Watcher able
Rot they nay b. ked the will Of thu parry They
revocable IN terns, II they not coupled With IN
i.es that Snds 10 the way n our thru party IS - be
Injured, aid the attorneys else - done suy
hing thess which ar-vOcatiOn will IBure 10
uCIds ibt moment the Interests se # the parties bs
placed IN stt 1DO the parties can be pui Ia the sltiOn
hey before the power grated and 10 injury
from their revocation the revocation always ia
made And ref, thu authority story or agen
os 10 which geI ,tmln referred 1hs doctrine there
is that poser conpl,d WITH interest cannO,
rev ktd long that Interest r-msins pO~sr
yteb,r coupled with inttr-t or not II acted under
TIA u0 affect the acts thai have been done
Urctr by third parties canno. b. revoked At hs sIl of
psriy lui if parties placed m the same posi-
ou whore hey before and the interest then
b. revoked
Then bi.corfrsct a. be.wesn Judson aud Ch,f-s cal
be revoh.d because The only 0t.rest Juds under
tis amount mOLey be- ADJ ancsd % Chafe snd hs
hodlose p,p-rs cOntsnpg terms II the
for security Itgas nIig.ge or len upon the ytnsnf
and he nIsii IA ID 10 secure hm,, Tor ths moray sd
ySnced Hen GIT lcen.e Ger cstAn c0nd tons Good
year bis c,nsees bu wi'hOutthes- pnduou b.. could
nt that is he Of he paper between Ch.- and
JUdsoD. Itvas giving To- jus in terms
power OF attorney csnse the Go cys, licensees Ter
certain conditions t. uihst they shout perform certain
things tti're hey could have heel IL dons tor
he ptTpose Of securing Jud.On, AID for other earthly
purpose Thai JuisOn only interest
here object, bat that does meet this
part 81 The az AL Tia. vas that ludon col
let of TIE censees the money for the -nscs sud he
Old not he WAS 10 pay over - thsi-r the 800 syeT
That such interest Jutce Story talks .bou; in
bis realise sg,ncy II take power OF attorney to
ell mans tose for bin and pay the purch ..e
money hat power coupled with an Interest bIf
take power II attrL.y 90 sell horse for Ger
tain and pay over the purchase money tbs considers
rCn am 70 - 81 Interest with Which the
coDIleo ard he revOkes my power that moment he for
gives aLnuls ny liability 10 pay the askGty.
Take oct The interest tia, the debt created bewsra