New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-06-23
3yem:21ork Daily Gribane.
BRowYsoY's REVIEW FOR APRIL.


,no.te from the other side Neither reason nor moierA
tor or charity nor christianity did look for or expect
but confess not prepared for the astounding co,
robor.fion Of the Padre ely supplied By col
Issgue and aecomphcs who affects TO oppose him.
The Review contains SIX articles Three Of them are
ossnsbly all Of them really, political All have ons
aim and one idea They frauds their face and fsse
in cir pretended import They purport 70 be reviews
hooks The first is entitled /" The Spiritual not Tor ms
aTsupors Ait- head are the titles OF three books noae
them new of them treating Of the spiritual supre
macy Of the Pope and only that and the third devoted 10
quite different subject. The authors are Arcnosnsp
Kendrick, Hazsrell Italian jesuit, and the Count
MsntslmbeTt Mons Il the three touches the 'do
i.ct .cussed in the srcls TO which they are pfenf-d
Towards it, close he writer ganc=s cursory 81 th-m Jul
only TO say that Of them do not relate Al all to MS sup
iec ano that the Bishop views, on IT, are dianstrcahy
errosd 10 his lie adds however, though ~s have
70 reason to suppose the iustous author ssud object
10 tho ground on which We have put it, OF course nor
sspeoisIl, now that he has had any opportunity OF con
smiling the review But although the books are not re-
viewed their titles not invoked without purpose.
The revi.wer hoped that many would confoand the spirit
us and temporal supremacy Of the Pope and through the
aid Of this trick his doctrine would be elevated by ths re-
mutation Of snguished names. meansr piece OF liter
| ary legerdemain came; well be conceived
But LET us proceed 81 examine TINS article One object
with the reviewer clearly il, cOnfu-ion Is manifest 10
his quaint title Ia that object he has been perfectly sue
ces.fu lie contrives to make himself uninteiSble %
most readers including perhaps himself IL IS only oy
,lov and careful examination have been able TO continue
into sirrle English the above heading think however
the construction Is correct Here It is caegoricsiy
/ WLieh .Laa gorerh--fts Church or the STATE 2"
He answers Of course the Church. He omits' in this
connection to say what the Church s-Fheher the Pope
alone or a council of Bishops acting for particular conn
try or regularly convoked council OF the entire Charch
This howeyer IL imma;erial let the Church be what
tho n
/ bluntly and Enthusiastically;
That II III Chp,cA sLouii direct the Catholic stsi-eH' Of
mis- R,puJie 10 o50li,h Conshtaoa, tn liberty and The
.rE eztsnc Of thetr country, sorereiZH STATE, aud
transfer IT 10 III, eorn # LOss NAPOLEON BoaPart they
are LOHrd6ya DiriHs ordinance u obey
THIS Is precisely what he says and means. No amount
of suberiuge or evasion will avail him to escape from its
reepop,ibty The dogma stands boldly and fully re
ye.o in the very pentude Of its grossness aehOod and
sbsurdiiy
deny it, unrsseryedy, fatty utterly deny it. AMI de-
Dounce it rs uncstholic, unohrisiian and untrue.
Tie idea that the Church and Stats 90 together
without one Of becoming subordinate to the other hs
scouts as deusou "stheisticsi,' protestant and
"benous Their separate independence one OF the o1-
er be regards as an unworthy concession by bOin lie
calls It compromise ano. for the uniucfy cHnoh;
usi accepts it, hints at certain hot place III al nits
in his generosity that some who enter into this snd
"col promise" do it bundly He has unioubted AL
group, sort Of moral Kaleidoscope They-poor delu-
ded lDersls-have hsd experience his had We
w. very many Doe be remember the story of the
key eapng through the three hoops without touching ono
There is possibility FIR very flexible ce"-.-nea To per
form tie feat With an equal number o religions and
like success.
Here t,Le leave to remind the reviewer OF com
nrouise somew Of similar character for which there
is rather high authority Christ having been questioned Is
to tie coin on which the mage of Cesar answered
Give unto Cesar that which is Cessrs and give unto God
that which is Gods This Wa said emph.rc'y sni ON
a significant oc a.lol. Z" 4 con PROMISE hh eonpro
quoih H.. reviewer Perhaps h. would add 10 the
ulpess Of his generosity il entered into rrcoa-
,ciousyr or he may further the Savior on TIE
ground that truth demanded different answer, but policy
is a. and hat be preferred policy to the truth I0ss
not the eIcu gives but the defense he makes frths
Cburoh in not denoancng the prohgse sensual and per
iured King and Court Of France Of which defence word
hereafter.
Again another example OF the wicked compromise even
in our time.
Tie po.ion Of the Catholic Church in the Republic IS
uis She is perfect, free recognized and protected. Mr.
Brornson admits and says, moreover she froer here
than even under Catholic States She does not interfere
in anything with the temporal government Of the Republic
Of her prstes and priests have sworn allegiance to
the Constitution and the laws.
Here is AN undsn.abe compromise : shameful sin
fal compromise according to this high priest Of ntO
erance Ether this. he would have Americans bsh.Fs
that the Catholic Church Priests and People belle their
convictions their cOnsoiancs and thsr principles aud
guilty Of deliberate and predetermined perjury. Is it need
al TO denounc@ go gross a SANDER IL precisely what
Gavazz would charge and h. - hngy zorro 5oraed oy
he reviewer Indeed II called - say which
of the men is the more mischeVous enemy Of the Catholic
religion he need hesitate 20 Nj. Brownson u
Iae IL, 0ieu.
Before proceeding further and in order that there may
be DO mistake about the justification OF the French
Church above alluded o. rsnscribe the words OF thu
reviewer after describing the mnorsliies Of tue klgs
snd Court OF France for ages, he says:
"Tbe prshgacy OF the extended 70 the nobility and
HIGHER ,assr aud th- csrropton of NOR IL. aud II nov
became general CIV tyranny kept pace with the l,ss n
ceceucy sru the increase o vice and what g)uder that
Wien began &, excite the -pnt ot revolt against t-
ermsuf the altar associated win the throne, ant
ssed H. he hos y incurred by Kings anc their
minister, an cCurtiers
~Ais,. poor peop had you been better informed or
lid you been b-tt-- Abe 20 discriminate aid
seen that yC prof gate sters had sirr ed the t-Dn
81 The Church C-rt hey sacrificed yu7r that she Bai
become the victim Of their tyranny before you AMI f the
SAX. ygp Dc cause SUI would profet yOIr rgh- and
Ire.trSt you from slavery J. ne coaaHef d D,.aek .a
= aot 6ec0Hse she aprvo-et M confn
~ tshr vast US. o. - a. WAiA ~ t,4t-t G,ic
ST. sl .nf -otse u'1t.sf9H gggr wIsEsT COURSE"
Exceedingly poi.s and wise withal; and, d,Gb'
exactly What the Ee,i-wer would d. aud BE- Influenced ~
under the circumstances The thimb'rrigng i astaie
well cornyrd vel sds pied periec, Bu, II is th.nbe-
rigrg nevertheless Ard uudsf l4sve BE- Il spoken. L B
very fLse very Enohr.s,1 snd esssa;i.ny Clslthoho
No Catholic could Cor n tolerate the -ugg-s
lion Of derehcon Of duty such A. be meDtoa' AID can