New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-04-08


W IN The moguing found that car shoes were very
much WCru- ! went that night % Ms Harrinstoas
house Trey hsd al gone 30 bel | knocked Al ne
door. snd she came down and les me IN. tod Der
wanted % borrow IS soi tod her RaySn owed me
$50 She gave ire TIE Is and then went back Tas
nsxf morning gave g 80 my son. aud told him 10
20 srd buy psr of shoes Cor hnself sos the dr'aks
at MAgcire's. he wens and when be cscie back ne
gave me the change then wrnt out and sought my
sef pair Of docs When | sSsiR became ittss
short Il money, wen. 20 Mr.. irds and borrowed ~
from hnl--he SAID he wVud lend me Il with pleasure
On Tues isy night was out Of change and vent eo~a
% borrow some fm Ms. shaw and abe Esd not Il 10
vt her 20 borrow I, from lynch Nv oa was with me
Nothing wss said about murder. When ~e 20, there
were les n hy Mrs Carroll asked tor Ma shaw.
We wrnt right up stairs Lynch VS. lying down the
bed lis wife swOke him introduced myself usa
never scsn them before. Lynch ct up and went tr
liquor, and brought Il in Mrs Lynch said he hsd bore
drinking TOR the lss ateen days she ssked me not 70
let bun drink II, aud said If shc he'd told me before hs
went for The liquor would not have lee him gone l
gave him half dollar 10 &c, H. Mrs shaw made some
punch hut would not drunk any. she took my
her lap and kissed hun. and said she bad narsed hs
when sn infant She told him We were sons b 90
married We eot up and went down stairs with Mrs.
shaw and were introduced 10 Ms. Carroll Went into
the front nom with Mrs shaw and gave her quarter
70 set some liquor She did and made fcur gisssss u
punch. We drank H. ard then GOT up and were about
goinc ont when we met Mr. Carroll in the eatry He
struck his wife because she hsi the door fastened
him Mrs C. called GU, Spring me. said, here am
l. Carroll ssked VITO was Spring ! ssid. am the msa
He walked up and struck ne. and followed me to the
stairs % strike Sesin. ssid doat strike me again,
for dent wsnt to strike YOU in your own house. Hs
brother took him OF. Nv took hold OF him, and
wanted to strike HIM. HE thea ran out in the yard
We soor made friends and went into the back rom
and sat down. When we started % go two men went
rsrt OF the wsy heme with After they l,it us, my
son sand father am glad YOU did not ssk Lynch too
money for heard that he had been paid So asd An
bour have that money in the trunk 70 EroS night
said am known there: don't touch L. for I'll be sus
pected NY son said. there IA more than that IN tho
trunk. because Mrs shaw told mo yea were goins 10
marry her and 20 into business m NSketst it1d
him not to do a. or would separate from him. lilo
said That Is what get for lesviT INV little sisters In
Washington. and getting you ont Of sing Sing
Ideried about Soing to be married told him had
changed hats and wanted him 10 take down. lie ssd
he wcud net bat he would 70 down the next night 10
take the money | said | would 90 down then and
change The hat On "Wednesday night. man who hsd
carried large business in Potsyile. came to No
guires be got very drunk. and took him down 20 MI
Toole'r IN Moysmeusing drank twice with him he
paid for one drink and the other. | afterwsrd came
hack and then went down 20 Carrolls 10 change my
hat | GOT there about o'clock Mrs. Crrrou came %
the door asked for Carroll and she said he was MOI
in told her hsd wrong hat did not want 20 ses
Nrs shaw but Mrs Carroll invited me In and .ad Mrs
shaw in bed hut she dbl not think she wa
very drunk She went up stairs aud called h~
up When she came down stairs, abe sat on my
knee | went home about liz o'clock and did not 50
INTRO the bar room went through the bakers becsusc
had black eye. and did not wish 10 be secu My son
ga d 10 me when in bed, that be- would 20 down the
next night the CAROLS were going 20 ball. and
take the money-thst what he wanted. snd he said
he would have H. | told him that had been many
wears in business, and been an honest man. said my
son don't 20 for won't have any thing do with the
money He said he would have tt told him that
would quit him, II he was going to do tie
told me % 90 up stairs a. 10 Del ana VIC
handkerchief around my head, ami he would como
up and see me. and then go down and say that lad
gone 10 bed Did 90 to bed, but my son was not In
bed all night He came 20 me about the middle oil inc
Notch af hf..kH IN naf
money in--he ssd he had got some sni his was too
small; gave him mine he told me what 10 tell Ns-
guire When got up In the morning saw i'ne shiIts
or the table and asked my where hs GOT them ne
told me he had bought them Ilesad here Is sl note.
au5 told nue. he bad gwen Mrs Mcguire o. The shirts
that were on the table rolled up and put them under
A. but did no. take notce 81 any blood on them the.
went Down 10 the bar room and found my son there !
took glass Of ale ~ was In trouble. Ny sop staid
there only few minutes. aud then went out Whrs
he came back his clio he's were wet asked him where
he had been. lie told me had been down there nobody
heard him tell me this he then said Fries had been
rested for H. but he did not tell OF the murder till
then. A short time aiterward the officers and
asked for Spring | said was the man. They took me
bu, did NOT tell me II was tor the murder did not do
H. nor bal any hand In H. did not take the money
Ny son did not tell me he had murdered he two
men I had nothing TO do with Z, did not 90 Ia
Ollsuas TO commit murder. did not 20 10 Fagans
% commit murder or robbery
! did not 20 10 Lynch 90 DO 40. arm Innocent oi
the crime know nothing about the matter These
call God TO witness my innocence. II Mrs. shaw had
had a. coo she would have given Il all 10 and gone
With me Had Mrs shaw or Mrs Lynch here thoy
could tell who the murderer and prove my nD0
cence. / will go back 90 New York, Il you have no oh
Jectons. snd will let me go.
All the latter part was said In very excited manner
with hs am uphned, and his eyes turned upward
JUDGE xELLEYs RkPLY TO THE PRISONER.
Judge Kelley remarked, that he hal great many Oh
jectous ~ his going back o. New York AZ you have
now done and a. I have listened 10 your staisnsnt
consider proper that should say lew words In 70
ply. You have now been convicted u ths crime OF
murder sad your days upon this earth numbered
Those days VIII soon have ceased 10 exist You ssked
20 be heard before and you have again asked H. Theirs
are reasons which make me regret that granted your
request and there which make feel sat
s6ed that have heard you
FaI,efood can serve you nov Truth should by ey
cry manly impulse prompt you yiadicste the chsrac
tfr Of your soD, you value your peace and safety
hereafter. You are man under conviction, whose
penalty DEATH and your thoughts should be turned
upon preparation 10 meet H. Your son "a destitute
orphan with the world before him. who Il the only one
20 watch over your three little destitute female children
IIn words have not told this. His hps have not
spoken the words But there are those la whose eDi-
ploy be has worked-toling for his nte sisters They
have watched bis course and that he had but 0ns
Object IN the world-their welfare He Wa who pre-
.ented binsef foot sore and heart sore, 10 Captain
Stew and other gentlemen la New York b. be assist
cd in getting Albany b procure your lberat0n from
prison lie gets there and presenis his letters 70 Gov
efnOr Hunt Of the great State u New York. and la the
strength Of hs Ougushng affections, tolls hls tale and
pr5cures your pardon and Cor your prison Your
charscter u recorded IN this cry at an sery day and IN
New York subsequently,.
Your sons character stands recorded every foot Of
thewuy from Washington 10 Albany snd viii be perps
tusted Your statements all eOntradcted. HIS all
confirmed. Whoever killed Mrs Lynch and Mr. Shaw,
carried with him the traces OF he murder upon his body
whoever inflicted Al stabs the former and IL gaping
wound. upon the latter not ma cOBdiuOn % be
sesu INN ediaely serwards Al about qlarper " 10
o'cloek d. deed yssd0ne.
Five witnesses Say they were with, Or saw the boy
eli hat evening UP % II O'Clock When he arrived &c
Nsguires having just eit lad a minute two before
be was free from stains Of blood aud excitement lie
had rot little before slew two strong -oulen Your
story u eharactezed by the highest state OF iprobs
biry whether viewed a Vindie6tlon OF yourself or
erirninaton your 1 feel gr1eyed mat should
have 90 ro address you but also feel that q duty
Those two women mly have BEEN slsughtered with
our the power or the tune b utter prayer tbsy
may have upon their bended knees, implOred mercy
or iorgiyensss while being slain Take for an exam
Die the latter II such were the esse and pend your
lat moments IN preparing 10 meet youf 6od sod notn
deyis.ng ~ ure those WHOM ,ou suppose nave
Injured you Look your God, AID Whatever you nAy
4f.-a f4rrn ertV La mn