The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1853-02-16

in reg,Td to the record Any resolution offered o. o
luton which Las once been considered by the House
aced on becomes necessarily part q the journal ana
benot be be srassd p the Hous whether cceptbe to
character 1t is net intended to rspresent the views Of
party merely but is to be full history OF the proceed
Ar F9RsiIn, dem u Albany seid there had been
100 700 much tak in the fsosse tine to
me re- oiutiont If Mr. Lteiohn were irreeylt, and
ought not to have been entertained II one tie,nbef
nSht spread his speeches upon the record all >thers
sa ana the Journal would be diverted rom its aopro
Mr. cnrr (whig) OF Erie aoped the m sority W, ,u,d
pause IN their course of tyranny He wshe Fto enter Ma
proestagainst this of the journal Me maiorsS
naa acted IN the most Oppressive manner here, aud lie
@isned the whole history Of that oppression parS
o the proceedings OF the House to upon Journal
that what had been done might fairly apper there
Inc rights Of the minority IS scored these Of the
majority and should be scrurulously rospe ted II
was the right of his constituents full OF
~ he should do here No part O. the proceeding the
Louse should be obliteated 1t youd be an ou,ge Of
\ th Q most odious character.
MIR Looms protested against ti~ complaint of yrspny
aadc by the minority. Such charges were untruo.
nira 'rity treated indugently while pursu-
ing iaetons course than the niiorfty here 1t
NOT proposed to strike out the stateeht the jour- a.
th BIZ ttleohn had proposed to place bis protest
the record; but the protest itself witch insult ~
tho konse had no business the record There muss
be anit TO- what goes the journal II must conta =
r,cord OF facts and not Of speeches The fact that M
iAtsejoSn had made motion for certain purpose ought
togo upun the ourDa but his reasons for this
here oouh not 10 there would open too wide door
or the gdsnisson of extraneoss matter.
to reflect pscuratesy e procesdi1gs of tie .Horse He
had tplsted the Dritr would return to OF JUS
no presedst or the proposition 10 utilate the journal
HE had voted sganst the resolutions of Mr. Loo:ns and
,naf vote was eensure to shemwer the rahor vote.
account This would be changing nd modifying the
journal 20 as to answer the purposes Of party nyolence
Nj IlTiEoHS Md not ask is rcsoi., ms tc goon the
rscord as matte, Of courtesy he den andot t-!t as
r'tt. Tie resolutions brief--thc, contained
expression Of opifion all other ,uticAsdo and
must but they were much entitled to plae e"on the
rec 1r' as any other which had been offered
Mr BrRR0uGIis saa the Constitution ret uire y jour
nal of the proceedings of the House to he ept and not
merey cnrnalof the proceedings of Il 'e ge tenan
froI ', Herirasr. It not to contain iercl. what
mig be approved bythat gentleman but it tocon
tain ,he whos truth i only the iou rnal ofler
OF every other county Are resolutions to be ased the
eiddisg o. Heimer county Is this the cha racte md
journal is my journal. l have resoll ,tions and
voting there and if they are struck out, viii sacw
why, nd let tho people know why The lo Of This
LesisE ture are ot to be destroyed In 1851, when ths
nine million law was passed; the minority made protest
aAd aslisa that be plAcea the record 1t was dor
without obiectioa He coudn thousands of ecedet
Mr. LOOMS sadprece dent could be found for all sorts
of bad lisages.
Mr.. BvnRoucHs-There ioon thing precedent cannet
be found for since the days Of Queen Anne and that is
for the arbitrary arrest Of member of deb eratiya-
body at the will osthe presiding officer The gen emar
from Herkimer county had doered certain rcso utions
here in regard to- the canal and financial policy of the
State Woudit suit that gantleaan to have his esolu
same rgat be permitted to the member from Os vegot
He saw there disposition to move the pre- yious
MS silence He had somoof the spirit of the found.
the repubic. He would not submit to tyranny any
where He would oppose any oppressive act wheneve he
could, and as far as he could
srI MARSH den.) of Torzphos, said he had thought
Of moving the previous question before the gentleman
from Orleous addressed the House and he sorry to
such unworthy of this agnanimy, in vilify
ing the majority The House has the power to correct
modify and amend the iourl at will The proposition
proper to 60 upon the reoor There propre
ty in placing ta argumen. and speeches of members
the iourna that record should he statement of the
facts and actions, and not of reasons.
r. CArP sasd he had Protested and would continue 70
protest against the tyranny Of the majority.
Mr. lNGAI1 sdem) sait he nnust repel the aspersons
re%d nh eat hndness and ea enency
There have haen constant illusions to the leadership
10 follow that leadersha ii i. was right but no one
would follow him against his convictions Tho charge
any such charge against the majority He would sane.
ton the curse of neither mojorty nor minority unless
it. met The apProval al 81 his judgment Inc I n
that has been heaped upon him, but Mr.. l. not viii
ling to have it uttered here without repeling it, The
journal made to te, the truth and not to be
voir Of all the sanders that facous minority may
choose to pour ont against the majority
NJ. SESSIONS propoaa after the entertainment Just
had, the House be divsrtsd With a song
M O'BxES (dem.) Of \. " said the resolutions Of
They had gone theournal without the action OF the
House They were no part Of the transactions Of this
properly placed tersand should be erased part
Of the proceedings Ct tis House.
colleague QIr lngas,. He had not touched the ques
ton and Mr. b. could not therefore, be expected to dc
His colleague had sur endered himself body and SOUL
to the gentleman fre,n Herkmer Two gods are wo,r
shipped herethe gods OF party and of the pocket Te
independence boased Of here by his colleague only
an alternate worship Of these The minority had rot
abused the maiority-they had only state facts.
Mr. A. c. HAir' (aeu) Of Oneida, called Mr. b 10,
order.
Mr. BEMAS said ia was fully as muck in order a. !e
gentleman who Lad preceded him. His course had hsen
ness often against him af the maioriy.
Mr. INGALLS, rose to question Of nriylege and pro
hm to order ferrpesynncy Mr. insslis contnuei. Int
Mr.. KENNEL ecallRd him TO order.
The SPEAKr sustained the pon. af order made ~ Mr.
Kennedy.
Mr.. BuRsrresid nothing could % gained by sspapg
ing the ytion Of Mr. Lttle IN from the cara,l Of
Yesterday st naust necessarily 90 the record today
Mr.. HASTINGS, iwhig) of Mon, &c, wished to present
few consid sratioas to tho after en Of the mefy Il
have advsad him to withdraw his resolution Enough
has been aia the subject C Saturdays Proceedings.
We oug t. to drop this sub "a and take up the general
orders. Tia Journal Is TO xhib nothing. but the pro
ceedng q tie House, and rot of individuals. There
s e. rom rone That Of course goes on the ourna
Then ls snnalber makes speech in support Of his
tons thai speccatog 60 anon the recoG Not at all
In tn ssvay every Syccch made any notion word
there. Tbs motion, and ,ot the spscc a belongs ca the
jour ial Ar. Lt,j ejohr cannot con ain If an usual
course is pursued in th' ssase This should be admo
nit.op to- memlss 10 aot again attempt to 60 their
spa ecifes on tho recolt,
b. IT, LTTIEIog. said is rcsout On rot E. speech
J. vas on ths recor,r that certain. Tho question
r,w is, whether II lpld be torn fom IT. Mr.
fhe ayes xnd nays were call 4 on the meson OF %
laoSd TO tha resolution Il Mr. Little ,an Ay
fS: nays 81 SO IA motion pr aailed.
MR BUESEr Eea that the -ssolution of Hr Kenney
adopted last 7ng be stru * from ounal, ii
tancd impliad censure &C the Speaker, by asserting
that his bad not bee actuated by good mctves
leaving II to ~ inferred IT, his conduct ba. Mr.
Burnet then withdrew his motion, ana tae ounaiwas
4 approved
After the reception ar.l proper disposition OF several
communications, the bcdy adjourned
The LiqVsr Law La vermnNt-
| TPg oFFIcIAa VOTE, SO FAR A KNOWN,
| BSaIINGroS, Feb 18 1853,
The oowing IL he official return os the vote upon the