New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-10-13
drowned No missing persons were inquired for uP to
midnight.
LAW LVIELLIGENCE.
Us. CIRCUIT COURT-Bes1rs Jndss SrtsoT
IMPORTANT PATENT CASE.

9. Lib pv T.vs, =. John Preaiis- james r. Prents Wn
H. Ans Henry Moulion. and Laas1s Hopkins
Tbs was motion for injunction 70 restrain the defend
.n from any usseHns o. letters patent sr.nid p n
We snd sshsd To tht II va -TsSsd IGs7
Keller and W soush'oA and Daniel Lord for
HsIsos J-The BIZ h. hs. been fled b. the complain
sssDses Of h A Wells the Psienss sr - inpe,s1-at 70
gsd nfFemcni Of the patent ihe psi-nt wa
s eorr snsri. have heretofore fled bill ThH ce1t
Cov Of the United states sssnsi persons ee.Is.a win nnEns
ton granted afterwards directed sue % TT the validity
e. re esg gsi'S s' .ns en On io Nay 40
emp upon which the injunction previously Issued "S
he improved machinery Of the ps.enee COASTS ssing tn,
fur after it y picted to rotating nrssa bst~..I 20
coh sove the oiheT the o~ef horizontal ne ohsr
S no. = no os. bib r.sy ehaBsed toward
Al the other purpose Of concentrating the lying
for ard directing on % cone heh pscea Ja.. in front OF roe
rforstd nsd Of aud the air beneath eHh.us'ed BY
~ S N. sr S Win tss podSeed b The seos Of
the r.vovnS tru more Esy e me 0.ns sSIf 70. ~
produced the wires By the exhaustion Of the air boE
where The fr Is dscarsd resaste sna the
correspondents tho parts requiring less
Amer The Bat thus formed On it removed and thl.
eeSt aebtsics 10 admit be removal subjected hardening
Asd iss s1. lh Tsns s ssS over ~b pi.e
fored metallic to ITo.es 5s.'ss a9og me ,,s o. e %
rbb Il ined HARDIN the bat preparatory 70 the tetingi
sns In rs ssG 90 as 70 pres
sure Of ss u as Oee dep0n the m
es part. Of ne nasehnsT p,d ~, @ WE s
uneersnd The paentee claims among other thnD l. The
with the perforated cone front Of the aperture
Of de, oi s o. ana pIo ids 1.-THE h AZ spe below and
Of the lTh FOR the Admission Of current OF ar 10 ad
.h ss t sns Ssn. esns %
perforated md atoI TO lie removal on heron BY I'm
ne Defendants deny originality Of the invention and also the
italy different that described in the patent OF we and fur!
Their Their Of hardening The bat materially direa
lyon the question Of originality the have ooand
ira in snoheT circuit shs deem to examine
thtn The gsn been between die parties m upoa
this reln mary motion ioI sp ~ nsn he xdpc rdaesd
NJ On Il ta parties which constitute par Of the proof. IL
and h been referred . in The argument by tns learned
sides and satisfied that the clear weight OF
Tt main sourd the trial Philadelphia for the
PgIoe OF SaSns me RW j o. in FnrsnS fo sprf,ets
he bodies End respect which great deal Of evidence wa'
also the ground sssin relied upon here to resist this
Wanst took Outwo patents IN Englsnd-one IN 1883 the
He too on, pstent this country in 1870 for the improve
Tiese ttter or DESCRIPTION m4ehnery and improvement
% The aehna were fore The Court Jury the trial
Ard tie ony which there be pTeenson the novelty
one this country 1870 and the weight Of the Proofs
before k that ibis machine OF Williams ne Yer "sn lno success
lad ade ser to make bat bodies ard here
Is
according to the evidence Of the present de-
pn Istente Wells Of an earlier date than that OF Williams,
lie gssted ard red 10 Hopkins 49, soon aer went
England end on hi. return in ls the h machine yves oa
chine Mr. su Ivan in London IN cnbef - . SpPeAs
thereto that the present. paentee was not only the h Peso 80
he has tsind patent also the fret construct machine
1 has ,P @ oPsIaSa Of S VIII pP S b. en-.
INTO successful practical use IN making bat bodies by ma
The Ssrdnts have a,O relied upon patent Thomas Bsnch
n 'nh' ~ ~ 1is 90 clns Invented Nv Mr.
lie vel known ingenious inventor OF the maehine Tor turning
prior that time; and there no doubt b1i th h
vbeb Al these achnes for ring bodies would Be useless
rshe would hsye been thought Of lie rH sested tAe
9th bS The operations Of whch the dbs Tho when taoa
io the ar viii be drawn down TO he wire sheet aud mere formed
INTO h1i T web Tor ha' bods OF -1s p'Hs oi n
instead Of bowls acoofdns TO the od ntihoa MI mio"ns
The iupo,omen Of wells the suggestion Of peroaed
we cone 70 bOdy hs in III shape desirable
AID adapting h machinery produce required result ami
tie eonr'ng the means Of ssing the web ur nom
ssu, and although the ingenuity displayed
compared the idea struck ont By blanchard and which
lies st The tornaon OF me proyement a' De aa
dies are By hand when according 70 tn old
mode of bow not exceed twenty thirty ee0ee right
Th next son is whether or machine used tn de-
infringement in other words substantially the
Iron IBIS question the experts usual da,r have therefore
been under the necessity Of examining the machines for myself
Which %sf o,0is 10 On me ss ~ sHs b OF
ih empsnt. Thew have The tunnel or chamber INTO
BY making per through the centre OF We the hbre
oh through each apartment 10 the point Of hsTge
other wards they duplicate Of Wells tunnel
call contrvsnce They have also conryRnce By
which they the exhausngtox beneath the wh the
aperture and thereby increase the Of
the tunnel important; though for aught that up
eqUaliy well wi'hOu IL
They perforated wire larger openings
then Wells and finer of gnscoth over IT, They also
nsac ad hsifbrsh for throwing
the fires into he tnn chambers aud finally instead Of
ncrsu the bat formed the cone warm water 70 harden H.
be readily removed they discharge jets OF steam upon
the bat - Il i in the process Of formation.
been examined the Of the de-
udaI for The showing that this Of moisteuns
while forming the products better hat body
than when hsiG ned by immersion IN But admitting
this he pEoyemnt CO.'S not necessarily absorb the process
Wells claims hardening the Tat by the Of water
ifthst original with him
Upon the whole without pursuing the examination further
the machine
hi making hat lodes and OF the Of
preparatory removal OF IL from the
def ndGn md mode Of making tho hat
lody substantially tie and that the compnsns enti-
lied 10 tie Injunction.
CIRCUIT COURT-Before Judge MITCHELL