New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-11-01

corr, .g r.paria5 70 the p. q 70 si n Eia.T
ras,, ~ ~. Itb,ttt s,-i-, IS i-ciu,le rs t,si
8rIf lrow batit rnr ar Rlldr frn h' f1nonh'ensn'
st tts uue cl tle Ciairiln Obi.
lame. Cochran svorn- I, Ga elsil.ari vac 90 ~
vrtrt "a tc uefry ClrY he lsy uAer sha wa "a nor
saw d. llllsrging or ila lret tn was n'l Vll,h
u q Jh3 llle te1snl,rl s ytl. Z l - .ne-
90 g. above 0Ie ot ita rs- t'1a-ei''a a''' "-- ''
ln Incl .. e.,
NJ ua0 To. P.ose, a..a wlsl :, ea.' r.iag'i,, p ~
i-Y b low ia may & .-e pa,seaPr ia n'' ~
over bu. magy were tafaA aaa DINERS l''""-' '-
II Iu5so aid .Lo oList OF .aa testimony a. 70 ~,
ini5e orsiboari va - how hat hs ah's,- l.i
ucif duty Re rssllius lta 1ne deieuse aimA'si ~
dl..L ia .usaed ioa. ,ha l.saias q 'h5 l.-'.
Tau also wished D. hoH tia. pe.1na oa shl's 1'sst'i
,aaure b. ID no Gaee g b.. ali a %. ls-I sH1'
ie oMcera hla ai-o a3ne 90 Ahe testimony % ~ -
sie.ad aeoess.l aad The 40 va n,l s's' - f,s,a
:. u closed Tue CASE wIh y sa'1All ~ '-'- 'e''"
oovaI o. coamoa rLEls ssals ilsis; iasaAa'i
sasses. - Villa -Ae.lsa las lil-l ,,...o
ito pialutiu acVCd - ssgiLu 90. 1s hisi "a" 20 10 80
svet ssts Up luattgr Ia anallasAi Tue sA's :"
st i or ne same ,aasa Ia tho IAi,sd hl.ias Joan
Al is Time Vi ths commence A1snI Of ili4 AssH 'p H.
tasons that u dous "e shp" se"u "S'''' , sni
action aud he second that u 10 mailer la AhA''I,'H %
i i.uei til Ua,lar la has Ia the sano nnane, ~
rt -au w g EPs elIaisA % es re- e-.
Ia case ~ lpI aiasieI usafi A,A.ash :.
.ss sis, - s1sa.i, s' s 49, e csa. II assoi
tbAea ;, ~ Code aaa t e,ieaasa los ~. roper ~ ia,
~ 70 ss" IN Il :. az as fall .Ad esaeasiEs oe sAs
,l - al psapgi. 81 Ielaiis iAA defensive a"'
L..s.ss al.,i -hioh dsfsne be ~i fftA,a
.la ia. l.eA Of 'he answer" 'e'S'"'a -" 'e''" mus
a. re eet. 10 abandon th. p,I Of the donss u viii
BE- s,.s-, rp tho 'sHins part Of It la some portions "
~ III ,.,iee 81 he sns~-f clearly frivolous II does not
,.Is r al material allegation ~ the compliant Mtena
aes which rsf' ms prove upon the iriil 70
M. portion Of The answer dnies the god ess
eeer Of the prin On this point testimony regulate 70 car
"A e and denial OF eooc Character 70 inc
material " proper
trial u
reirtnse justine alton Of libel IL must be stricken out
io plaintiff 20 tiIike ont PORTION o the hfi
10 Richard & Wills Whether tlse state aen
wto uo % the, furnished fol the deencsn Pno-
Will or such publication Tie desndli esn1 -
tle iuiic,oD Of the iibe for whcn he Is my
su that potion OF he answer rnss aso De
Tho found fort ol The answer v also ohleeedty
Is the editor OF pubic journal ana A. ln na
sht duty the public 20 ctiei'e the res OF "
made
justified and privileged
and oper duty o. free pres II MOI 20
whether the expressed in this part OF the answer MIN oe
which the "a az heoy 70
go IN .viewing public private character Of an
usl No two cas- pIolAby VII e. AT 2 "a ' ~,
wond proper and probably none 10 te p
val. ohAsactt with pop be made he subject oil continent
unlrs with Gets which the pb are nestea
On, this motion cou-
in BE- defense Jusfinceon
Le hes right claim no should be stricken ont
my opinion does not form any legal snswet 20 Ihr
the plaintiffs demsses II never har o-n 20 %
action for libel nor can pc ufsa .
The fifth portion Of the ropeton OF he eeis Sc 10TH
hiss been repeatedly held bJ Us n
repetition improper ard st statement Of iae IN aeisns
al the. present system OF pleading allows 49,, /.
norii days whistler 20 retain the do
In bsF II s elects the fornf then the
stricken out II the latter then the
ened conformity the views above expressed The Piainn
abide The event