New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-08-04

,o Of I'll. -... therefor. the engine bad bot nor, than the
rr.n,v ~. va. method Of checking thu dsscen; Of
vsv.. ,nd Of preventing Their slsnnirg oy the devise OF
.-stsr rs..rvor and piston W.
Again. here is vslve gear Used nv "sA quart
Anscdo'es Of the Seam Engine 500, |ol2
Ih> Sf-ren, ws',s valves IeqaIrd ne~ ar
% Of s :. s .rd ,d I've
PFC, ~. placed iheis o hat =. "a, ~hsr.
's-rrs he v,y. ,s. e. :. .s', . SS' ~.
rhkh tr.n.c o. nat ,bud B. s.5a.y shut :, pre-
rsI 80 - - o-e,.o.S ), .ds-n erns Of
va,e. Tbs WEIGHT ther-ste s,s' - ~
psr,e. Of sac eyndr.a each sued ID. TO-
low der N The eeGsrssl p ~ Low ms, .p.ce
{, -hh t.sepds TIE ~- ua ne between .Ia sh
~ih : eov,S b. leather valve e,ns IN ard wnsn ,h-
rqrs', t.i 10, wfsi he puns.r es
.nd WITCH isp.d ms ee~.se 70. rlspsss va ne
re eoueuou which would Be produced ~ " IN
t.p ,oovih references 10 plate giv fal view OF
N. schne Thus find bere the ms hin7 sciu,S nsd
b. Watt fsr any principle = involved c'nsnss tns
"a Identical method. II .f-ctrg the identical purposes
cortupsffd b, the patent Of cckss for ~hico a'c'ra
ire t,h- broader ccnsuuctc Of the comPIanAn's tue
paisrt issued. .... w., .,5
sick.. respective methods for checking the descent OF
the valves bv rlurge and water rvoir Is that Vail
b. g.p the re'srcirg molten 81 point IN the strok- some
hat HER tia scke-s But the combinations ana eject
VS. H. same aud both were applied ~ .ubst ant Ally the
sane rurposs prevent the slsmmng OF the valves
IN closing In fact II may be assumed inst ever ,nce
tbs weight 10 detsch the puppet vsves from
The machine that now d them substantially the ssns
method has been used 10 prevent them sanming on 'n7r
ltsis =,
hob were knoun 70 and used By ptineas Bennett in ls
Your Honor will please notice that Scses before obtain
rg hi. pat, IT. fling bis cavet knew OF benn7ts de
wee yfs'ev.r IL deposition II Phinsss b-nnet PIP
=. S. question % But. moreover the devices known
snd USE are the those Of Sickles Bennets Dep
osliicD. 81 questions = 5 : r. TO- H. See s'so tn-
D,posiron Of Livingston l.. Bsrtholomsw' p 81 ones
ZION to inclusive. See, also the Deposition OF Ezekiel
Wlisus. p o. e,
and tsabsl ed result al their Witnesses show Ben
net. altering only IN mech ,nica arrangement, but the
methods as We see, we're the sane.
And now assuming, according to the defendsnts con
uc,o that ~ pate only the technical necntn
cs comblcaioDs spd not the method or principle rcn
M fnr, ffons a,e not Exactly the same were knosn
ard ued The South Americ 6nt IN l'fo ana ~ oy
Hogs 4 Cunningham. lSee the DISPOSITIONS OF Jas hlsg'
he.Irug at p 20, ofGeorge hsves, - OF Cornsius
II Deau eier "a Of Joseph Be'knsp lo5' OF Joseph
Bill be,k ard - Robert R"bert.on p 1872
Tie ouly difference between ioge od and Sexes
va that ogg used standard If dih-reHt forms aud had
not thu ADJUST BE sicog piece az sckes mas oIi
H. ced The d-ei gagemert II the vslve STEM oy t)!k
that ,..d on the inter- and worked INTO nOtches On the
va,e stem, and drawn cut Of the not'hss oy ssa'on
srv eau TIE hitter assembled and va, pressed OscS INTO
p,,ches by spring the litter rs the inter descended
81 H. M hsni'm Tor reversing ct part 50 A. % cut on
On The lat rar' Of the stroke in winch respttN @e h"t
# Cors,s Bu need not argue thus or toe reason ht
n lompaiuarts nit that llOgg sdeVce Identical "l1n
hat o, Sck,- The water WIS the sane, and
I.Tfe ,econdary RESERVOIR operating IN he same way
VIII. Hogg shows that he made the invention IN l-S al
Re witness, AIMED shos that II sas completed ana sue
c,sfll, applied in Apr. lsfl. Sckeiss patent = dtad
Msy 20 l42 snd the letter by sh,h he claims thar he
,ut gesied the Improvement io osg dated 10 MAY e'
IL i apparent moreover hat 1t the date OF mat .e''er
Sk.s fadno Conces I'd the secondary r-s-rv"rd sr3ed
in his pat iris letter DOES not mentiont ScSei.s
esri'st date for his hvetn"p' IS proved oy "nnsn -
49, -. oil D.rv, nj u ltrI ami
Brown says in July August, ,39- Frederick r. Sexes
80 in cold u-sihsr l-3J.
Moreover tits apparent that Sickles obtained hl patent
uroulh gross mistake ofiacts by perjury For ,he
pai nj r. fu. ed rs the grounf that the inven
H. we're used on The South Amec, loeflr- she broke
down. in April l-ii ara then his partner ifuemsn Cook
sent sul nal affidavit asserting tia, they we're not
90 u I'd on the South America b-iors she broke DOM
COX testfes that the patent issued nat affidavit
N 2 vel II wher,s it is EOS etabi'hed by pr"oi that the
osyres successful operation on the nth America
b.fr. at oe ut and III too i-es'abshedby theiOl
lowii stnesses Peter Iogg and Cornelius ii. Deams-
ter George Rrkbeck Jr steam engine builder; George
Hswes formerly ineer of Peoples Liue OF SteAmb'ts
Robert Robertson, Chief Engineer ct l. NAL steamship
Fahic And, by comparing Robertson testimony win
Sckles caytai IS manitsi that s'cki-s must have OBJ
tanned his ideas of the invention from the SJeh Amsft
Suely need not cwe on the point that the Complain
ant. have not established their tt- by verdict ny
disturbed possession. Their yerdt agsn,' RDdntn WAS
rot the present issue II j. was y = balanced by the
tc The psitut of COr - sterwars granted And IN
rial snce in the Rhode Island District the complain
srt. failed obtain verdict Altogether osog 10 defect
aiding deficiency of proof or errors III tina con
duet # The they obtained verdict .ginst RodmtO
~ 1913 sustaining the cOmplainsuts title yet Hogs
D,lArneier have been making and selling the devices Gov
cred by Sokies patent; and that, too, uumolested.
In conclusion even II ~ have not concldsvey estao
nsh.d oefer have at least established It suite
ieItly euite trial at lag fas- issue. And to
~ iris chsl-Dg- the compsnsnrs Who alone can
give H. he Court shall there 10 orGer H. Of the
lurp,s. Of a.csraniug the facts necessary % guide ITS
,ouscis nee on the final m. riis the controversy
Ituay well be doubted whether the entire course OF
The ouinsirsOn the Patent Lew holder experiment
sde TO peryeI it 10 the purposes OF Justice
sId opor, The complainant Win ut the full title
uih II requires zthOut thai undIsu bed possession
which the lag requires without having established tbs title
10 the before July the law requires and With
out havrg the fact o infringement by the YER
DICT of Jury the Law requir.s-pros-cute party ca
latent which If construed the method OF cut OF
/, friptil the u. syes, III. clam II shall De-
oln att ard II O. n-trued patent Tor mere
otic, was invented msuTed and perfected by two ci,
zeus this State eminent in their business year before
he psi.Itee CLAIMS have made bis invention and whose
elan n. dscOvery sthOuE not presented by taer
the Patent Office sscertaued there and N ide
grouIo tor ,scng the Patent ana were only Sc, aside
snd oytruto there sIpsrts deposition OF al inter
e-.d party proved 10 have been erroneous aud fAlse
To indulge applause 10 such Il would bs TO mpeah
by our doubts he wisdom and the justice OF the tribunals
Of our country,
THE FINE ARTS.