New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-08-23

the 81 the parties ta purpose
! ir- construction TO their acts snd proceedings.
On to- 3si of Argrst ls76 Mr. Chsse took patent
fer Or, cess Cf msnrfCtung india rubb-r BY grnfx
Il viii III OF solvents sud so-- dirs L. scr hsv
ing nix !. with clorng matt rsvp'r coih and thus pro
GrCrs irds rubber goods Bat ~ tie year issS al tue
ia rubber used in aAnufs ur,s ia this coaetry and else
wh,rs fr>t drced q liquid - pss'y urn BY tbs
s q urpef tire cr other solvents 'rhe purpose
I Of berg sPresd upon ccth Tois Vas very expensive
rrcce.s bscsue the solvent required vas gH N Sno1nt
srd costy aud an immense MT - labor as lsrsd
for the purpose Of Gorg the work Bat was folai fht
these solvents produced an 10 ma rubber sn1 so ms
process sought or 20 msdy hN defect Mr. Clsfss,
he man in whose footsteps stand the Al und-r VII
We esin ani really the man whose rights heias pc
rented 70 YOU 20 day went 70 work ~ Il his ranlity
cculd contiive ne plan BY wh,h be cpui r-nssy tbs
defect in he anuf,oure And sh1 eid ~ do Vie dis
covered process or means oy Shioh fuooet " US r.w
state as came frcm Peru could be reduced ~ prty
form ard spread upon cloth without the use OF sAvenf
AZ very uch less expense ard pro1uces mach o-tsr s
Gle than urce- The old process lie discovered .nI ,s
Na coulo he done aud patented that discovery sndth1
i IT, first clsm in bis pSen-t1e invention OF process
BY sh,h rubb-r could be reduced 70 pasty toIn sn
us Of solvent sud s,resd upon cloth That dts
covery 81, benefit 20 tn trade L ds'ressed 20
thirds II the exp Of su uScture Srd <hen say nA
ken within bounds The co immunity may no, have DE-
rvtd propcrion.is sdvSntsge from the discovery and
| all show your Honor the reason why has not rhe
men who get hold of this nveu;iCn held il Tor tonr'sen
years: 0rr years they held monopoly 10 this III
vtnon and nov they come before your Honor 20 tas AN
tide Of besga.s fe riul hat hs gsutlg Of "a ojrn uoa
WI brig upon them utter ruin
Brt NJ G. Zee invented 'nahirgmDr We invented
srd rsttn,t6 rchiHe BY which he Yrotuoet thS result
That pasit has been su.tnsr sul WHEN y hes been
s'ec Il j. g. I'd 90 b. z',d and valid for tarteer
10 wear, thee very deie,d ,nts Iartshom co, AID
n-.tr ms o.i,eo.y "A tai. couair, They
RAJ &c nd po,k hundrais 90 n ussnds yea millions OF
drlsr. 4 Their wa benefit. iu Ing that rne ', soods
rors'r u monopoly Upon 'he public ard TIE niA inooer
t-ff, for fourteen cng year, aad every patcle Vt that
l.r.ff Ifg-se vi th- ut-msu On the other side vas
e. ioyed an p-oktsdb y HUtshorn Co, aai other par
Ia. " 10 - Ere the ii'eusers 90 'ody.ar
And Dat lr.rgs u. rpto tle point The peten. vas
granted o. ,h a q paced IA VI .hsas,' hmis under
nsscIt Of contract hrorsh vaTon' cher P9rsons -
Chas .odjear sri al fcrthe ptfil sun ct e's thsn
sfco Arsfyou look into these Al 'aviis aud contracts
Ycu ~ find that Chahsf up - The 3st Of August $780,
lduyrreaz-d hundred dollars ss ina result Of this
vItn. Up 20 ih7t ,ue the iavenf r bad gone ucre
vsrl,d AID happtirg ry,o 20 be- Cor the rsi time on
trovarsy. I csu be permitted - say spn-thlag in
iior o. y inventor ofths process lh.ve heard from
gtneten o The other side of This caepsrhafs Ut those
pho have been arguing Il heretor 'hs last two years
since lave been connected win ina, controversy one
general ~ e prote, n 20 inventors aat 4 giving thsn
u.tce II sv heard Charles Goodyear heli mp tsa per
hct nat,r his hind sho must have risht snd Jusrce
W De Horace II Day, with everybody else sc'ing win
him. uust have the strong Of Chancey and ,s upon
Inn 10 matter what the ruin and desostion that must
.rsue 20 protect hi, Goodyear and ia, combination
. 80 o. th.t IN ara aid not receive hundred
dollar out Of his nvesron and he got bis ex
press'y upon The ground shat the whols OF the profits OF
til. wonderful irv nou had been P,cketed by speculscrs
by and licensor and not one doisr beyond
tie mis- rae pin ncs that he had obtained from them nsd
gore in'o Chaes pocket That ths position In which
stood 1850 when th kuee applied Tor thS
t,lsi,n na made one Of the greatest dscoveres-ous
wli,h iii We are stopped in petition, say the de-
f dsnts will work rrepTsbe rua 10 IA, the discovery
being necessary 20 tho prosecution OF our business and
nali our IN mense tstAhli'hmen's must fall Eds NJ
ChnGse brougb, 10 light this great improvement and
witt having received up 10 1885, 800 cr IT, We una nim
con eDCig tkey sly % contract win them 10 give
thin licenses
Noa sgree ore 'ep further with the geutemln that
70 that time Iiarfhorn was one IT the hoen ees l
nsy The Of ny argument can them by thefent
usIle for the purpose Of dstrgn-hing them lie vas ons
Of h,, famous il nei Sc india rubber mpaaion in this
courrJ-s monopoly that hss made mere money IN the
lss lou yar than any Other comoi lati'n OF nhyid
usls do either IN ads OK commerce IN ms United
- fes 10 he IN 81 time We start With our oi.
alleging hat Iarisi orn Of them II was put N
there by ny suggestion 20 brother Jtnckes We .md
by t. Not only lutshorf, bn' the two hyssrds oe'
Md 20 M combination End they make the three de-
fauts in this case W. If the Goodyear licensees by
virtue ChaIee IN this case have got licenses OF hs er
ca because sdmt that these defendants Of these
ncrsees All the admission Is for the purpose Of enti
Isl the paru,s we admit Il All they can 81 dm for hts
r. he trYose Of Identity NV let be remembered
iha Haffshor Co have been not from the Inception Of
the business but for the last dive or sH years prosper
Gus Manufacturers under that comb nation as any set OF
IN IN this country We admit that Hartshorn Co have
pookeed se0coO net profit for the st i've years ou, OF
tbs Iat,A They have that louisson and 1t Is fair and
VI Cbalse conveyed his original piert-becsussI
do ot ye, approach the tine OF the e1tensonwhsn Chat
f. lad conveyed his original patent 10 the Rorbufy Com
rai y who af,rgard conveyed it to -, and 4 u. to
Gcocyssr he DID not convey the extended term Nov.
| not
prtemen on the other side whether extended term
he conveyed not. found myself In the position last
wear discussing that question the other sid' wh"n
was the side they now, IN other words they
were on the side that | should be IT should say an
xeuted patent cannot be sold before Is obtained.
Therefore do not intend in this controversy, thought
hay got this tide whore asking the aid OF Chan
csrv In an Injunction ~ cross my own track. IL 10 u
all material in this whether extension could or
crd not he conveyed whether n could could not DO
fraud uoon the Patent Office By ths inventor before he had
got extended term the ground hat the entire policy
OF the law that that extended term shall be for the BEN
Eft of The raifnee inventor Judge story In the case
OF Edward S1emsn decides That point IS PERFECTLY i'm
material II il enough for Us that IN this case whsu IS
conveyed The original patent he could not convey the in
,eIor The gentlemen will egrse With ms this point.
because IN 800 tbs time when the orgind pa-nt wss
granted 'oC se and no made tbs original conveyance 70
a. Ro1ouTy ConIany 70 ngh' o. extension sno.so J.
In g or vas known the lay Ct the land So At that
9e H. could have conveyed tbs extended term there
being no ght extension knOen in Law. The psten'es
fso only hs original tern. ard the law which grsnts
stances dated subsequent 10 the sale Of this ps;ent
bo,r N the ginal sale end the sale 20 Goodyear Chat
fee undertook convey the naked patent alone and could
coryev no more and the very case have cited dscdes
th. Lror 20 the law which grants extension, no such
er,erdtd ter c. I'D BE- conveyed.
Then Il the tins tbs application made for ertsn-
sion dyear AID biz ensees bad no csn to this ex-
t.dsd term By law They htd pGrchased FOR single on
g torn AID made their fortunes out Off but they we're
not en.lsd by say aw Of previous contract 20 sZs upon
he Term That 10 Ired ouly ard wholly TO ne
b. nett Of Cbase unless Chs6se IN point OF fact parted
with il At subsequent time 20 they claim be Ga do
not here touch the point @hler bs parted VITA II eithes
by cenfe Eas % J11sCn or MS nee pSe ou' ~ virus
al Biz znai sls be- id not part With the extended tsrm
no 10 the eEtsus1n and Whsn iauref l. Injured % his
tsntGtaone We made The very declaration upon the IN
s'ruueDs hemss wee and were Jud60n party here and
were We to bEDz eel aide lhs Pogsr Of attorney 70