New-York daily tribune., 1853-12-27
SLAVERY DISCUSSED.

snd rebtfulness Of Free Discussion Ony few years
since the discussion Of certain great social evils ws'
resisted b. Conservatism rcendisry criminal peril
ous now those sane evils are freely discussed b. sl
psr.ies and b. none more readily frequently tasa
by those who 30 lately prOmP; to silence objection
BY tie bowieknife and pssolby breaking up printing
presses scattering type and robblng mails Thus Ia,
Noble Register (Als comments on s,u1e rece1f cha?
ter Of extracts made by Us from sosthsro prOsisTe
journals as follows
aF.cTs OF srsvrEY u nder Ills iHs t. Asr York
Trune arrays before its readers long is. q s'ross
OF various kinds which have occurred II The slave h01 ng
States and which have been carefully called from the
Southern pevpapers gems 20 set 10 sn Ab J0l fans
This en- old trek o. the enemies OF Ias S)lih and Is
c mode d c7gnmeni 10; he aoTe insenous t-F a11 n'l
est because 0f L. frequent repetition II e1sTers ~ par
pose be sure, Which % keep sAye an1 excited the
anti SiGycEy feeling q tie country nsi oolllera l-
tr.ious. Bat confess we have OIiel wondered a1F
Horsce Greeley could -et the consent OF Ia c ~
anu rhlosoTlc mind to make var in his shss oa sEs
ten even abaorren to him that Of slavery n tas
Ssrth lie l. enthusiast 70 b slre ut Te hevs a.
wavs given him credit for bein; homes. in h convictions
and tie best evidence Of this. TO our ul1 has oeea the
consistency and peEnaciy Il which he sites - his
crnou. ard YuTo-es Nbenhe takes Gl ira - never
cycs Up bat Gies N the las. ditch WITH a. Bal De-
sid ten. al enthusiast " Greeley is nan Oi power
f inteutCt-nay We look upon b n a. the g1 H. par
c,sEcs Of :te Abolition Press By hs anaded resources
o mird and C3sTgy he has attained to an influence dai
i--4pt
TlI.es How then can an hon & min aad nan o. ss1,e
cai. ls O. attack any s.em on grclAs a. YIN
srgrucni- h,1 however my nay e4s.ie Pass.1 pose
robin tac TessOn and nf OF eu N Ai l'1s a,
90 taxes the boi tie brF and TIE cEiT ard sores Of
stem -cd cal tie wOsld io ccuem Il on Gcco1nI Of
them l. II fair and wish Mr Greeley w1s answer
IL for IN this subject usually discussed viii pru Ice slt
heat both sides. sh0uli Ike TO have le quiet
tall with Hr Gre ley-we ak Is this fair For|WAa Is
the conclusion Of The arg1meI c1ce2: ihat slavery
human inst tuition and, Therefore subject 10 human inpsr
fec;ious There lot Institution t1e globe secular
moral charitable religions which eann't be oondeias1
teioI III ~ % ne paDIc OPINION Ct ManAhl o. iS,
moly plecisey similar. The parallel cases are oosiols
But take Al extreme cleT-ymsra or q )d IN
narae but scfsh wo7ling at hear. who has stolen
he livery Of Heaven = serve the Devil in falls from
r. sh estse. .lg adv ants OF hls clerical zaro and
The confidence b-lolC - his sacrc1 ON -. lie stea le
GIl leaves dcsCla-on and pollution N domestic CIRCLE
WccIe lie commissioned 10 leave oli Blessings parity
and holmes. Mr. Greeley has doubtless read ol sI,a
oAssshe New England papeTs furnish as frequent BIS; D.
trd no;hn. be strOci0usly tsbclcsl t1sE sleh
conduct. ask now Il because fL--s such mn stes
ii tie gospel shah the gospel religion De dis,rsd.ied a-i
abclsh6di To ers Is human M Greeley knows, and
Cn eli things humsn-hOvever Humanity may ai,empt 70
scar tewsfd tie sri mount TO hs upper ether os
e0oGD.ss and g.cilncss ia IL s5nls yesrnin{s and
s.rainifcs Gier tie Spiritual All DiTiae--Sstare
has ST its iFTovocabls stamp of imPsTsction. We
know well the Abo.ti,D.sts that Sevsy shares tbs
Coz n and hes lis impeTteccus cnd is evls Bat has
Freedom noDe tbs s0asiea Fseedsn Of tia Nora
cen not condemn by daily occurring Instances Of M
monstrOsiy snd eslreviis, Without rs'ltrng - the
days q drowning and burning wicaes lWJ inst.Dces cs1
becisi in the ees Il New YORK and Bosor which inh3r
To and coo aid hes1 deyii. hsve never been paraed
know ieig. in the history Of ayeAoiiing people
Thcy ;Eo cases Of SseTtf anlrs L. oas c-s t1s
Of Colt tie murdered pssked up scn a. lise
al y ed 20 some distant port and IL tno Oiaer ID
Up Lis Gesh cu into snail eces lis bones eAarred ihe
yeTy gold 4se srd false teen IL BIS moZfh sozrei to De
T. ed ana decoTose by the acfion 81 IRE and sds, %
hide the Internal deed from the Light Of m,E eys sap
.rs~ rfrra ah11f III
iy oi New ENGLAND freedom. and the virtue Of NeS E,g
LAID ercef0n and Institutions c-- point 10 thess acts
the fit -nd rrocf Of AID Just this much sDd
Is Proved against the Institutions u ae s5u oy T. Tri
itEcs Facts O. Siavery We aver t.; tbs enemies o..
S,very At the Norh eherdo noi ui1rstsnd wat slave
~ les i Or Ley are uncanct al -heles In ei,aeE
cesc the Do tie South s1os injustice We shAI speak of
tl-s IN sro;kcr article.
Leaving 90 much Of the above So Is psrs0nal 20 ~
swer itself we proceed 70 deal with tie resiiue pre-
nisihg TIA; our Facts Of Slavery" DO po exhibit
merely CT siee Of the systen bat em5edy ard
sciderts witch exhibi. iis better aspects well But
We propose TO deal directly and thoroughly with Tse
Resis'er's esdpg proposition above quO.ed-aauely,
Tia; Slavery s essentially good bat through tie imper
.ecticns Of hug an nature ard human Circumstances
subject TO abuse ani sc4ndsl-Cvhch " the way. il
Substantially tie sentiment attributed b. Mrs Stowe
IL Uncle Tom 10 lie Rev joel Parker snd which tLat
hs character damaging il to tie eIten: Of S-J000)
Judge Hkether We deal with tbs argument !airly:
That zen DO wrong, bc;A .: the North and s, tie
SCuit, is poia; conceded al hands that there are
irfuesses e1fra-eoas to themselves which sometimes
irciie them 10 DO COVE very ready 20 admit We
say shai SlaTery. wherever IL exits IS among these
sfusnees 10 which Te Rsgster Ie.orts that as grez.
crues sIe committed under tie sway Of Northern
Freedom IS under that Of Southern Slavery. Ye. we
Dc Lot uz1entzn5 OuE antagonist IS nG1t4isng tLat
either Freedom or ChrsEiAnity Is the nPei8g cause
Of ihe eTief he instances committed the North
and if not, how does bis logic tPply We never cisel
the askei ac. that crimes sre committed g tie South
IS IL argument aszins: Slavery bu. have sirnel %
show ik.t tics, eTiss ~ers i4cte6 or ec;,d ty 85rs
~ II Re Al p-Ove'th.t the murders OF Aisas sni
Ps1krAn were melted by the essence Of chse Slavery
where they Oeegrrei, and would not have been com
ritted lad tie parties resided in Slave Stste then
hs facts o'nfIori ours sd our mutual readers nas.
Judge which should prepoaderate-
Is 10 lis other cAss-ihst Of c.ergy1nen who prove
wolves instead OF shepherds 20 the lambs Of their
ioeksvs sdEt that s1eh have occurred snd 10 occur
L tie Free sts.ks-n0t frequently We believe bat stil
ofsn eno8gk 10 give emphasis to the warning that :
ssneiinoni0Gs cezesn0r and cody professions are
never to BE implicitly trusted, bas skoala GO f0r
BoihiBg unless baked By Pzre ard blasaeess life
Tie maiden Hstrcu who tolerAtes 5erties IA oct or
lpeeeh fson clergyman which she vOzli ressn, sni
rpel IL sr0ler Ern OF wk0 isol.tes herself from %
srTson With elsrgt nan under circumstances which
voUld stamp riiscretion similar inserviels With
sEosker Gees wAGi Religion never required WIS;
her OF prophet! should co.. iemn .n5 what
70 ccnsidsr.;e al r-rs-minied ele-rs,,s, WI rs-