New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-08-23

st tie third party to 90 CERTAIN nhereoy ne y ~
b. benefited IN order that i. Il rd party nay come
AZ receive the benefits he must sece9t the terms OF
trust in b. II be r not ps'y ne must m axe
himself patty IN order to tave u osneu' ., oe
tk.,. n rd parties .ccsDt-d the terms 81 the ras;
Thy up this contract aud If they have piP--s - sho
n N " pied th- terms Of tho ru,, they
~ in their bu' they can procuce no -ydeac
/ OF il whAtSyer
two coptrs together and UPON their consr1rt1G pr
pose 70 look cha. is the recital 10 th7n- 'sy
II j. recital # such contract Is would p-"tl -
sfsct Ills case You ALL keep in MED. hop aa 2.a'
Jrptoe IN relation 10 ts mater the opsetks u doe.
reote my oonfrsotti wonderfully. passing srInge asy
have po' PR cpcfd j; 10 show what il IS.
! Tie frst rectal il;
Whereas Erwin NJ Cha9,s have lately Pre- cured Al
e1ter sion Of nv ps'eIt-
So far is lssr and oi.tinet-ihere 10 sort Of do 10,
about IT, II qures legal logic nor lice trimming Z"
reasob % uno.T-'snd H. II Is plain. straight i1r Ed
recital andtd upon true TRANSACTION a: showed the
| cCnmsnosH ent my Argument
TIE next point is
AID where's fsid Goodyear agreed With me-
1hfy nay have used hs worc agree Just "a the genie
n ofer 10. sys hey sgr-e' rPoriog that the
r;e il Their the sane as though
! ifvss sa.d BE 2 n'rscted With me
g. for ii Ell and others u'ing ny Sail patent under
! TAati.-G oo5yfar's Licensees undoubtedly
iba, u ~ would brt have tte expense ci CO 1plsng
NV ssid .1t.n,iou - rid pa'ett.
TLat wss the arguTeui 10 doubt. II b. yst did not
fsorus with thu pr .rn ofhs paper - have in ths
po,i.f We would kn " it Was the fact
trey WoE.c TIRE 1persts t1tnctd
VS. that sa'ei No. sir II reci-s simple agree
tf1fcrory in IL character % be c)nsunm@ed A;s-
esid II hey would P-y he .A2*Dss.-h toy "oa'd
make allow arc 20 IN ior sieTvarc t1fy wee - sage
n. benz " r. h j. hsd shoulders aud All, and give
TIE gfniie - tie bfnef Of tina. re1it.-tsSe il 10 rs
Igih bres ~ - thickness We AsA no iTers upon oT
/ u, r it, 90 ustiuc'isB
TItn con @ The recital q tho amour be paid to Caaf
f srd /. the payn.Tts 10 be made That recite
SEP c. Tirso'-sn aeTet~fnt ANA here might ask
you Hcr Z" believe hey r-ce lsgusge 10 tn pspers
Al ch not trJe Bat tuCh il not 70 b. supposed They
MY have sds sste giving e1sc recogniti N Il
TIE th Bot it.Tc j. something more in Ills contract
T.. r. hvc II whole u ing and give them tue bcnei OF
IT, H. argued II Good, ar th.t If dsesr would pay
he nscs ct eAeIsion, and 90 certain other things
ie .hou d ave he p4iect.
IIri-ht With great rroprey here snd ask il Good
year ever paid tla'V eli there 20 tbs paper, and
liz lac, douse ihrwn out Which thu gentle IN wants
hive 'hroTn OUT sh' with pr'priety stop AZ mat
contract by "a, ChafFee DID BE- do i By *
tr,tber e1eruory rtrac that could 90 IT, o. i he
iro that Gsvpsy itce SJpeufes huf sv the for
(hbfce 20 Iayl The sfni.eu ~ c05d have shown hlT
hat by he pr ducio oftese p~per. aud tnen the
facts voulr have been clear All 'a' there - clear
.ca' il this paper that he bad contracted vito 1opd) ~,
Nat If Goodyear would Go certain ;.iugs te should
have the Idcut upon dose co'drt'oIs Where IN
tbs paper u there any evidence that II ~' ever
d.net Now ] want The ro-t + that paper - snow
aud there is vhc-e tie selil-nan pu-t TAX oar
lire Of argument iha; that paper on tho fae Of i
slows that toe coLtrsct never compiled With The
lsptr j. el'r,!, bssert with Hstlf The paper is
Jtly con.i,irIt with ii.eh After Leave that clause,
? OthfT Csu.s IN there two from Alpha TO
Omega snd How them dnFn l'ne oy re, anG they shoF
Hat GooGy oomJ with BIZ eoD'r ct aud, there
fore hey TAXI ihs rade with Ju1s n Iha' - pre-
" ;fe ucint m n. cas- which the g@I- dare
tptr ath. Ii psrec " evidsBoei by h, false .oki'
rssorinP nd b.ggiog cf the question aa. he saw IT,
l. perfectly e'den: HAT h. had BIZ cler gi al mind
uyon IT, feared sppryach II. Bu there il 49, and
u us The isp.r b comes laS The Two papers stand y
geif-r or they al together Don their reci'as nov
SPEAK ard Tie subsequent rect in this concsc. do most
CCLCiuy ely how that G0ody-aT never did dopt H. aud
nevei Old csIry out thsi .xtcu0ry cOnr1cs he never
pdife fxpfrse3 The extension, eNp-ted 10 pay
~ d. sn5 ht hey were ut upon Chaaee himself 70 pay
! That Why find him c0I tracing With JudsOn Why
tucson IN i II that contract was not carried out
What IN a Of common sen-e You bringing in
this lawyer 10 make him truee of a trust
fr the pun ose Of giving tucson position, when II
TIE CoItsaCi which was originally made bet sren 'od
ytar srd ihsfee lad b-ea carried ont tbs right Of
ihetC Goodyear ii tIte5 uld have been established
! lave TO doubt GcOcyesr went Il CO te- who was
poor s ndle-s and homeless With whatever TO
procure his extension. snc said We Will pay these eI
pen,.s fer you aud c~itain sum besd-' and you shall
"hkve he Of tie pa'e II for yourself you Will as2n
"lie p.ert 30 Us, Sloh doub; WAS the contrast 1t
was miserate contract f Ctafee-s gre. sacrifice for
in 10 ske II that contract had been carried out by
Go,cytsr Goodyear might have made ahundr-dtaon
dnilNs Ii il Rad been carried cut Chstee would have
ser iced Ia. would have net Lin hundred or hun
crto thousand collars He had DO meaus OF recurring the
eSteD,ion es2pled g. ana Judsc vent aud
ur6cured i. Now who a.vanced the expenses hope
your HorOr VIII 'ske note OF that poil. Did Goodyear
ard lis iceT advance these expenses cid they not
Ny position in relation - this ma t-r might seem little
and your Eoror cii not Constitutional is II IN ev
osnce in il csse-the general e., that tins NIB naon
ths oropOly has grown rich-uot Char. odyeAr him
sei that he siancs eide by eide vita Oh se SIN poor
RAD though inventor, and tie money has all bssnnsde
srd pookeied by this combination Who pad Chstes
Did Goodyesr venture to SAY il that contra" couli bs
produced, II would be found that 4; a contract Sh
Goodyear alone Judson Sh-n he g. rscit- It here
careful 10 reci;e II being sde BY Goodyear fr tho
benefit Of these parties but venture 10 say they had
ICckted that COntTGctt would have turned out 10 h4gs
be.p ot for Coco ceI but Goodyear himself
Bur 10 mailer for hist simply rect.- such set
come pw 10 the inquiry upon the face Of the papers
cidtiey pey the money FOLLOW thee papers fro IN the
iont 20 tie ED and you fno distinctly I'D unlu,li6eiy
s.serteO tia VIM tucson paid his money viii ind
there that tlafee Is und r'at to WIN Julson
or ii AZ Identical money which JucsOc paid Ch aee
The very next recital is that Jud,' paid that money for
(hse AID that be shall be secured by these contracts
for il.
Now sub nit that you shall assume that Judson
one OF the lc-Isers They do not adm. that in the bill
The gtDlentn Go lot starr With that That he may have
attorney for these licenses thin; 60 Mt
oeDy but Inst he If the icencers not true in
fact not admitted in this bill claimed the ali IA.
VT. io The defense in any other form IL is al ned
~ he oil proved the sidGvits attempted
proved hist Jadson sppesrsd ard acted for these india
rubber people GeCdy licenses getting this extern
zion sdd their gents in making th contracts. IL
tor JaGoD, and JudsOn sOIe that this contract IS made
and Is rot shown ~ be scted with hOs.
Chsfee, too Then k, r the resais Of These ap-r,
SID they have be- recisd many times htre thaI viii
not the hen Il is said that Judon aid tan
n,y thai he seeks security OF CHAT IS there s0y
that itess parties did comply with the con.
citizen pretec upon their part make them trustees
INA bring them in under these contracts under the
benefits ials None AZ al and that conclusive
= The sce of q papers hat the contract With
| wi read enough 20 show that right about that
&c q al the gentleman may bot ssy th-t lump