New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-02-02
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS.
Before Judges ISGsAHAA, WooDRUFF and DAY..
DECISIONS

DECISIONS.
JadgmCRt rererSed, with costs, viz: Archl-
bald Rouls Oh sst John McCleunan; Arthur Fla ptnan
sgt. Geo A Hslsey WIN 4. Schoheld agt Geo w. Gun
ter and Hamilton X. Huchus' Henry o. DAy'dso ast-
Judgpsni q graed with costs viz Henry Moss, Jr agt
DAvlo Blown; Coukling AIT MURPHY son Resell AZ
Ehlabtth bnhier George u, AndfT~s ssI pug, S"Ii'
aud Seaman; John Edwards aEt DrsS and N3wton
Matthew Beck agt George Winse elmer; Edgar New II
set. samuel Frost; Edward Grdley asst WIN. Ros and
William Patterson akt. Isaac OHara; joan NJ and Miles
/ ORIley AIT Charles Newman.
! Hen, Bishop agt Thos oIver-order appealed from
Banef ast John Coroll- Order at Special Term affirmed,
CIes O. Bsyen, sst Matthew snith-Judsmeut for 80
and the residue without costs Of appeal
= either party
PoINrs IL THE ABoyE.-The following alb
stracts of opinions were made by the Judges them
selves, viz
Edgar Neville appellant, AIT Samuel Frost respondent
Where PerOn contracts with anOiher 20 do wOra for
the done well - the cOntr actor called
tor IL -uch he nor bound to receive an imperfect
rece Of work reduction OF tho cost belo" the contract
lr'ce
Where purchase Is made sud bill aud receipt gwen.
paIo. OF VIA toook place inidnssibo 20 add
g. the term OF tue wi ten contract
Nhre breach Of wfantee Is proven but no amount Of
isaEe shown ~ the evidence the piautd can only re-
SOY o. nominal damages.
Patterson egt O'Haro.
faroi proof 20 slow tC; the under wnttsn leif
Tor lh- rs' year less than stated therein 10 nidnissi
Where receipts are shown for The ll quarters rent each
custeI the due aud which purported 10 b
iu .uch receipts presUuytve evidence that al prey
Gus ret las been pnd although some previous ,ecspts
were ,ytn to- tss "a "a the while quarters rent
HaHnal "a Beeb- at Coyti'.
The Court has power under the amended Code OF 1872 ~
allow "a be W thdllwl on tie ma and order the
complaint 10 be amended BY inserting allegations material
B 20 tie PLAINTIFF case.
The proper paying costs Of term and motion
sud aowns nc cost % plaintiff tor thu intermediate terms
Henry Mos Jr, ast David Brown.
Tns case contains EotAlna INT questions Of mc. upon
which the Ojhe COHt below must be cOncUsye
1t whether the deendant employed TIE p!aflh aad "a
ahetAer the palnun rendered the service Tor which h'
claims ussfon e-e Is evidence tendlng ~ sustain
lie VI both the parties and the uds meat : not
csy agsiHst the eYderce that this Court could Ieye"
tie Judgment new tal of the cause had been tried b..
fore us b. joy would not be granted sud Tor tue
tr finding Of the Jusncs must b. sustained Jads
Matthew Beck sst George wiuehsmsyer
Where evidence u excluded and aersgard received
t-re Is no ground for obsCtag tia. the party h0 hs OBJ
ectsd e1cius injured BY rs reception, when he
/ DO not at the time make the otJectisn.
WLsr, the evidence II cuuictnz as 20 the facts tho
/ Court Wi not review tie finding Of the Justice.
Andrewssxt Buck and Others.
in the Of The d'y .lettsr xach At
Cakl 100 short " admit secondary evidence offs
contents
etter written BY party his adyers,ry aud not
swersd beDgsrr the contract entered n3, 10 noe sd
HaseBs Saith.
In action for tresPsson real estate evidence OF t6e
Il ~
sale Of the land, nadm-s.ble being uncerta AMI
remote rule VI damage
shnislt, at Gustin ( HutchenI
Where the landlord leased 70 lis tnaa'' under seal Ger
tan premises Tor longer than yeaT snd the deend-
ants -retes Tor this sEd the tenant alter
b paroi agreement exchanged with ths landlord
part the prem hired be that tins Was not an ats'
icr Of the original lease whou: te consent OF the sure
tea 50 es 20 oisCharEc them from thar is5iry.
EdvErd Gndlry eat " "a howlan4
The pend rcy o. an action sznln,t me o"nefoi -
nnde tn lien s. for claim aEnst the coa'rictof = no
def nee 10 scon tae r-eor At me sis 'e
proceeding under the hen law - foreclosure % SIC
eurty that Is Do detrnse action saln the debtor
RouIstou. resycncent at. Mcclellan, appehlt.
n, - whom ire IL not bound 20 Keep articles ~
posted With HIN ser h bas offered % denver tns % o
owheI md II the rrses 10 take them a"aJ ne nay
lawfully place hefa Of o. n I,i prsnl',SS e,vton
wsr. ,o.ou % adjourn enable attorney 10 see M
client without any affidavit snow The necessity Of H. was
properly Getitd By the justice. , . -. .,;s - -
srnd OF surpnse except where default made and ads
ILL., Hsmptrrsn AIT. Hslsey.
r-rSer Z notice Es6 Great len which claims tf2r
- ort va. done under contract with th- contractor
-. paiIuH n proceeding enforce the lien cannot
cover Tor wors cone for the owner.
f,nce the contract the psJn1 bound 20 oake out
81. c.se 70 show srnstyely that the contract has been
far Performed that money has been due o. the contract
tlsee he len created
Reilly at. Newman.
Whsre det,ndsnt appears the Court below, and puts
and subsequently, suffers afgnen, BY de-
zult b. eItersd sIsn bin, be cannot sppy 70 this
Court under section SO q the Code for rrial
That section only spphes where the defendant
tails 10 sppea- n he cause.
COURT CALENDAR BAY.
CIRCUIT CouRr.-NOs. 81, l0l 100, o., 20,
u y. ia lis, lls. 50, III, liz. ll9, 10.
L. >. DIsrncl cogxr,-h0s. u 70 u ~s'c&'s'