The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1853-12-15

his publication 1t ID not diAeult to draw that lice Of
distnoios, and y seems TO that it line dictated
good eenee And lair dealing. This rule has besu ap
Pisd, have remarked. In various Aluson has
been made TO sroisms upon the proceedings Of courts
!%sne Ma t sns publisher Of .swsp.Isr may give
Of justice and many things often sad aud done here
which may injurs individuals Counsel may accuse Wit
offences which may be calculated TO inurs and destroy
their standing in life Yet taers free liberty in these
courts of justice But person. In to give
an acct unit OF what takes place In court gives
ons Of his own calculated to give to thsss ssssr.ons
the weight OF his own personal vsrActy he res ponsbe
In one word in any statement Of matters of fact in rsa
item to this principle as vol every other the party
responsible for the truth of what states and ID not
sponsbs for his opinion and Judgment That arises from
this opinion should be es to test il By
any rule The critic may have honest opinion book
Nhch is 1ni.vorsss and may have an unjust opinion
book states fact contrary to the truth he responsible
not for the criticism Vbich he Makes but for the false
sre u.s. all the parts Of these bsls which rsfec on Mr.
Fys want OF judgment and skill either 10 the selection
Of that lind is opsn to critics
and Mr. Bennett not responsible opinions be not
correc but ali those parts Of the hbss which charge Mr.
Fry with unjust tyrannica and oppressive conduct in
reference to his dealings with his artists do not
within the rule. You have therefore. to aualyzs
Mr.. Benefits opinions in reference to Mr. Fry as ths
OF An Italian opera and those which charge him
Ery wisn sOonaas' 10 ms employees ana with seek
Is responie,e only as ne has succeeded In satisfy.
Ing you thSt ~ IL SUBSTANTIALLY true. Inc
Of the statement should be literally proved true;
the truth OF the libel must be Proved
psrt OF any kad Is 70 Dc lett imp ovet For in
has been guilty OF steainapfrom another man, and
o. M.n .especs 70 nootnss psrson 6osh
perchsnce be able to prove that of the charges
was .rSs pus II wGSi1 not JUSTLY the libel because the
that doctrine to this case too legal iusae app
S o, ba t asehot, ana .ns lsry ma tnat
anJsnt a nr n nothsr .as GUY .uen 20 nn or eas de
@ - a1o'n S a,pcos ancompists PROOF OF ma
" AZ re ~ t tae tsy W 81 ampoianee
So.s net oma ~ IA rauass;o 'as estoe nee
nisin+,g S' 90 'oas Up 20 Tue hn asans. sns
lei ;n,+,soa+;nn ~ ~ ",;t,.at;s =, ss.a: 100 :"
!, iS ~ @ 70" ~ . Ing vi si.g o"ms.ss
inv Now ,Sa tes ha,1 o me
~ e. ~ inSo TWO CLASSES. nave menonea
tG a. ~ nSors rnsna th~ sa ~ sn pin
srsnst him pf =, ust snd rased
n not n,a .t;.as IN rs,.t;on ~ ~ ; - &
h.ro hesn nanssd ~ u.t 'e hP u.son wI WIZ
Is,sr ~ ono fsa,us ~ tha CO.'S d, oSos tr. - VIII
ht po .oH ~ 'h' oase ~ erue. lHss you sIan
L"a -. ~ -, W, PAi' u .ue osso nas
se,Ia Tm :. es w. ~; ~ ueannss WIN Woman
nna rum seens inns WOMAN was an Naan opera
a. ~ pn. go, ~ M. ~ a. APpeals
I'D TIA aaaa CO. ,h g. ~" aTeS.i9sns'
stana ~ T.; ~ u ~ sy ' Sh as u au
~ ~. ~ 1919 ~ ts ono o.oAo u .va
- 40 Soaase y. NaS ~ ne ~ glorm snss
carabor o;Ur s ~ ;nm n,st. nv. puy sma
tiff write To his friend Ana Ssrs Stating a. under
~. ma ,hs sv;dsn.a hat Trui "a AZ. Nor
MAJ do not understand that any explanation was given
A. to the Of that breatno down the fact rua
that she WAS nnsb to 90 ON ri,h her mart Tao alleys
ton then against the paiut s that he took
Of sck ness If TrnA In make fh viz;
r.snac. 10 hsr hrsaLjno DOM and toot Us;s h.s ~
pnbshed which the dsfendant ssvs ~ inst ons ~ tbo.
Instances bs h.s CHARGED mon him ~ bsvrn Mhsd
his emnI,ves and caused famaIas r.rtieularI. -
be abure5 IN The nublio nantrs On tbs nthsr
hand the plaintiff savs that he ssatsd nothing
40 the nIaintiff vonla NOT he ohnoxious tn tha
Charge but IL the woman was In fact sick and fisd tn
narfor IN That crourd and that orIv ard tha
was aware Of IT, and he made such to bis
raris hera M lad the nnhuc 10 ho;ava that sha hroha
down hecanse abe was To narform her mart
then q would he one of In the dsfansant
.ueoas a. ;ust;scaton ~ hs oharra Trarasasa AZ -
snsc, IN tba vou iii consasr wb,t .rs the chsrctr
IA ,%a aTa.,, -, a. ew;s.r.a 49, -, Wi.ass
snota ~ nor hair. nv shs s .;o, so -
~ ,;rno.hst .Sa -. s;ch cop,ot =. donhtaa NJ ~
Ing Fne ~as a.. s .a canuo' % aouota cutN
:. ~ .;a n;,L ~. as,s.,,aarsaa ~ 80 " 49,
tho n,.;ntitr was awara of n csrtainiv w.s
co oS nrs.t ;n;rs,;"s md brdsh;n .n +h;s wnn.
~ :" n,sse slows hsrs Nv os
M bot sba ,yas In ntant =, nartorn, IT, nart
rbers ia anahsr rrcumstsrc. int strncl mo ne hsn~
go ran,areah, 49,. H.. tha ~, n.T sha.I, -
des,;ma HI own artists in The .ves Of the nnhic
those yerv napson. 10Th men and WOMEN mn, ,yhosa
capaciy ana 1sacston his own success as an opsrs
rnsn.cs, densndsd must saw that Was a. ,ois To
;scnysr apv motiva adeausts tn .cconnt for .n.h @ In
nrohsse tan,ast IN and that vou will take into ,oasi
ggsi -; ;s ~ mi; $1,000 ua ~" T NV ~
90 co ,bara h.y nm a. am~t ,od ~ az nnon ;s l;r
tin charges of in;us,ica towards thoss nersops IN
bia emnlov He has been chsyoed with sesh;n, N
camel rhsr contracts Sb;cb n s in.im.taa no fnpd
to he inind,c,nss or Too numerous for bis int
rests NV aysiIino him self ~ circnmsta,cas vhich
authorized him prohahl tn do so The,s sra tina
chsIves which Won are 70 t.be into cSnsi,er.tion
and n tbev h, be.n nrova5 u, ha trns IN
unnr thcn the wonld Ia ent;t3 tn
yopr veraict n on the other hand Won come tn the
oopcuson that these pubi re not fair crtei
to the lie extent mon Mr. srv nera and
n AZ those marta 40 not coma that ynl ara
no, drty no
tbe ps,n,f ana asses. aamsssa WITH rasnsat tn that
matter I NAV saw that the law alrays presumeain
cases ~ th kina that some ha bean an
n nla in here has mt moved nv loss In "a
ca, IN his I'm sness an onsra inased n you'd
Ss vsry 6cnlt for IN. man IN NOV. IL bscsnss n void
- sf .nIt a. Nov. th., =, "a, aon Ala 80 % q, tna
on.ra ~. rs,nts ccrrsa Nd h.ar crs;ed snd
90 "A nop ~ ~ aaSsndsr+ r., ~ sst;.stins
a.. - -. q. ,anh =. A.. ,h.r..,a- 20 80 :?
., n r. tyr~ss ~ ,%a ri,n,g nt =, vaU -
~ ,an ~ n,a;na;na ~, 81 ,;nn,r -.
Az M. 49, ard On dra ~in x,r ,oSaroa,a "a