New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-10-13
POLICE COMMISSIONERS
TULILE IUINIooIUNLFo
Opinion OF RECORDER TILLOU CASE OF CAPT. AcE
ERNAs NISTH WARD.

Ninth Dsrct that On IN ih OF y rs ~ ne
thar which then oeearred IN 9dsoa
Jsy Cart Aetsss. ~ so.2 re. ns Ct o. .1a
sut Of eons1e unbe az 9sf n ht post On
the;s haas. 70 ias esei h' , It M r., .e
o. 10 IL -, 49, ,sesd N. notice thai be ordered he
Policemen then the house oproed for N 20 te tas
ihe q he line there
the g., ntcHs he W.. :. hs s,sonso1.s
o,ns hta, We, ons GO. 2, m 70 .qn 'IT pobn1
thar street boil hst he INTENDED 20 20 70 the sen q rs
ordered the doontn cal the men 'ha be ordered
~ ain room here Lieut. set-ins vas 5.t lieut. ln
tod him htt he TrDbd to 70 ds'uTe's " be s.e not had
thy al and heTupon sTiug wihort ans smother
while Ae putting h. cost came out Of hs oom s9d
Dot replied that h. wanted and tL be wanted
70 sse h,hd n It hs e., @ ,sd nm p IN 5o9
were iesvns ne, BROWN. rous no 90 - ne "a. no. |
iersi'e sp Aos,sn rsrisnea n,i eeioa - As no men
@ IL p, On e t oRi spTta and h time for
him acquire familiar knowledge Of bic duties previous to the
III, proof and establish facts that about
s5 pca Tiev, in he Ninth Dstrie which Trodaesd
end is1 o srd a1si Rs 5o . sa Ss dT5se
The that information being tar there vas hght
ciics ~ts eesed C.Tt GeIrsn and L. sebng the
g. c SG L. ring srd It. Tai tod Actslp ~ hey
severely wth,d 10 90 70 me r,s o. S S ,b lei bs s,rsa
House without permission thar the turned Che second
% re Of dsursspce be the others Dsye the complain
en- not sps S ro ven o. the baii oo where The ordc va
sen was Wism Wallace who had been bat no. then
lend club and he to the not and ass ed q tho
ontsi iA s 'os M, o. . shs hi a a IN st bury
The Police District and ihe Poee Once are On
tero1s iDio he Others that Capt Aeseman
to lie Brought he 6sh Po
e I'd t he vent there md attended reception Of
The prisoners directed tie who brought hem except n
70 return th,t some Of ne pc wie me- s
Toiceu who duty At he Ben Tower vent 10 the
aud riot 10 Hudson 81 AMI the Captain told one
ofhc to 20 to the wsr Police station for help and sei
li. re- q IN ih froofs. 70 who called the men to tam
cut police tha the Captain I'D % Que SAYS
h. s9ted there wAsa tight slys be sat there
dfou not cant say which N hudonst ,ns 'a's ~ Asa
tn, serious riot they were tsAhE aud had attacked
a. d, hand M the doo.n and two f. sar
the Cttsin ed no cay The men Sala,a' C4p.
him al tn aud ihen went IN bis Ca o2 MAJ ps
sdnetr The and told b. m taeTe hgt aud ae
tr,d and fond III, Captain m Goa and hat N ne PISTON
h, svtsiase WHEN gops hsht shfe h1i w4' poi
lie CtIsl have cal he without sindrr' moving
IT, Boil he sssesn confirm ssrSsI q. % MS esns ne m
Of tn hedneld Ven Nof the o q ea
In tia ary he M in the sleeping room and w1en
Mn h es i he ios1d AeEe an the desE police.
,sy threw open the door and said
ihte ira tsht n Huc.0ns, BotA m two
to h1Ir Thai there shi and West re ss toe Cap
lie to nony the tld to uppot The position
tst tie CAPTAIN do not call The men sI 9..as 80 ne
"ai6 h. sel, ~tut cal Ia end h coming oat o. me
sepg be TAFT sieped to The door AID told the men to come
out. n a lele tight
lhs imputed 20 hun WHEN a.
coIry src probably in the hurry and eonfs5n Of
hat lie CsTtsin The fect and
fsh and sudden emreeney ae services n. zee
b. CAPT Aek' ntn deem to be so PROVED not oaiy
notice indicate such emerseny bat m ioi1,'n d
it that theIe fshi hissense
po,d sy bis eareDs s9n 70 s 20 .n and wrd p
that great Gsh cd 9, lie sDhsn t b af7 ms
Of MePh ard others pro. IS h. there vas an
displayed by the eisH son Of derosory epth
.TF'd TO I'm" AEe :, h S .s IL ,:s 81 tbs
CtIttn from impression that n be went az "a
dps ron tn tsuouy whs the witnesses Loyeit and
Ii IN II he enc Of Chisi Of Police Capt
srTouied ApIil the 2t rs LeSt Tag IN Nay Sis
Inns Police on May 9th ii q Second ASSISTANT Feo1'fy
lie Ss section Of Ruls reqr that OF riot other
udd,n IequrD he service o. hs police OF n9ee be
scene Of mot with whole police of duty any thereof
arc be Wal ant IN surIIe@ius the same
me h section The rules declares that the Captain Of
lis ai,iisli' should nySsby rsmn n charge eI tn ss2n
qrrg force the policeman on the beat "a station
vii IN de give noseg 20 '1e nd :. s po.be
Irooeed with BIZ TO the spot tepns the II military oIdrr
.rd pem peous nse with them or place themselves
The d that he IN doub; As 70 HE ability
TO sore eeI q ptseIse NJ Iesee hs vi" 1 'sal
That .Ucas9 eReiseney ofeibsnee or no. requiring h GER
thai such notice contemplated by the Rule.
the statue wts ssn apt clearly
be ordered h oeeueI then in the hou TO BE- called orde,
the mat n AID
did lias AID not there also established nay more
1hst he ohe otce AID men proeecsd without MN not N n.
oIeer trt IL SnSiesr ana Nho1 @ ice 10 Sset
Ios himself between tho aso esAhhsd 4Hd
sI la .Iowse that h. had doubled .fY pressre
Captain Alderman thus violated e tth sHe 81
The Rules 10 ye important Tequb ol o5s.9as MS
justin excuse FOR The dr'lon = It, IhA kals 81 -s'
not ihsn his recollection; ID That h ~ss recently sp
rented and 81 That The deFsrIIe OF the oneef'
aud nen be considered hsi he could n leave ths sis-
tc Hote without violating he lsh section he nr sud sec
certainly amount ny 20 an eies aud nose eat
ccffsr and careful i0n ana study u me rales
he The sueet ' far 70 pregHe SSIe n asi Pc
Of hen and Of hs dE-ies Ehl.
40 roiisuf secio1 which et bHi
If IL ,gh nation be considered thai
bsireaee Of hs psTuni ia,epreistoa saeh ~OaA
IL thu desisu and woad r-c0ncis
doubt would have ben otansd ~
80 rat h. viii esrussfy employ ls besf
krowede L duiis ard n the esse q Cspsn o. 70
lice he understand h duty well 90 na o. n
ioairais of that be ns rue guide ensan
dTtei ard lead then. -, - e..
Tkese Lo~sver excuse IN The sPPtren eonnt 81 "a.
mind vel experienced m ateIPetAs laws
resusts Ia nstsitn iAiy Ins T, IL
~ eaGuiIs tie laws and ges IiAtnt = nc - -
eo iSers th. will think Be rre we'd ta- ias
.h SECTION though EMPLOYS TIE .SlS ~ -, nd sI.ysr
the Of h- Department N frrms NE So
peace and hes reference 10 ornsry occasions and n''
Tbs view Of the rule provision Of the law may saesy
sr,tleS 10 the f having il GOO fsfA gwen sen
eorsuoE he Aeseto Il tkoash suneous By way d eAee
SstS imposed csP;sia Ae~evsr beyOna mere Technics.
% III, By ma s5 5ss % ise oseSs IL Ssa
When siven The duty Of himself ~ ofses "a
Is definite plain simple His order TO the dOofnsa srea ne
men should have been placed the force II military o-der 2
IN tbs ss ion Ped he Ohsr ofer aae
Of tie their ssd thea 70 have MARRIED 80
a ssn police oeerto ninse With the men Wa u express