New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-04-06
SUPREME COURT.-EssTERS OisrsIcr.
The Delaware and Hudson Canal Company ". the Pen
sylyania Coal Company

BLL ~ EautTY.
Lewis J.-Ihe special prayer for relief in this
p.S. dated 2s,h day Of Juy ia5 be delivered a, 20 BE-
cancelled aud that the Defendant be restrained from bring
under them We proceed at once to consider sad dispose
o. the urged in favor Of the relief thu. specially
desired
IL does cot appear tbs. The defendant In a proceedings
before the supreme Court Of Ne~-York obtained in
Junction. ucs-r constucton Of the agreement which
20 the Of the statutes and sub
vesive OF the rishis Of the plaintiff Nor d. any
thing IN the Agreement 20 JUSTLY any nch construction Il
" true that temporary anctlen Wa obtained nom the
Suprere Court Of Newi ork BY which the Canal Company
vas s:,siP ,s SG 9s os s;aS 1 S 9
de- LAC are. TO ere sssd a s Rsp M hs
disposed OF the final hearing according the principles
Of equity and law. The Tribunal having coguzace OF Il
quite competent 70 do justice a. the whose authority
= nov invoke We haYs Eesu nothing IL past prOeeS
bss 70 create cnub IN read 10 TIE Ef - Of 40 hns
acoa In the premises IL = clrar that valid agreement
cannot Be rendered invalid by temporary o. Court
Of one Of the parties an eN Founding It.
IL NAV be that the agreement IN qnrs'"n might prevent
the Canal COMPANY from infoScns the maximum
tolls SLOWED b. charter Il va. ~ dspo. a. anl mshs
Glso prevent a Company from dividing the profits
from before they are eciel The charter prohibits
the Comp from char.fg hgher rate than that spec
td, bot II vas not nt,nlsd 90 proven The Canal Com
psny from ohsrgiBg less rate the contrary the lower
the rate OF tolls the better 90 the lvsnremnt Of tho pub
&c interest end moth indicate thai hcse
stons stand in need Of legislative i1iicls seton,
Interests.
The ss1eensnt. ABss'd 20 BE- uacertlin and without
~ Tie CONSTRUCTION 81 g. but - itr - ~ perceiys II -
quite sgsceutsC construction hv which the amount Of
toll per tun well a tac lime Of payment b. reduced
10 reasonable CERTAINTY There u no want Of mutuaty
the provisions Tor enforcing performance The Cana Com
psny bound, BY the Agreement, % furnish the OF
C1ns 70 the Goal Co tue later required 20
the tolls ACCORDING the rule pr .r5-d b. be D.es r
the plIpnse Of sscsTfAutrg the amount Tn rrusv fJr
tie Collector Of sos under the c,rtar a, ~, t ,.,v
by the agreement athoush hs nfbts modified i-sar
O. amount and time Of payment. This summary rcntdy
for the collection Of tolls om the t1e par -
The ussntude OF ths ktcEcsis nvols andhe endrhe
public nd pavste jury which ishs acrrur from rs sblsr
Lust sfIy be subject T. the cOnhol 0f Tire tour5 ~
tie exercise Of their cbshcery powers In sttrou " he
sufDu4Iy remedy referred TO- sfe Jf clilon that
acton OF be maintained on me coa.r so 30
recover any tols which msy become due under Prov
sous T. Tor coustrcton0. l- tg--euen- - thl- there
Is ooyeIahs 10 psy the toll accoras ~ u sar. pee
eTih<d ~ the part Tor Asr-rtarlls fhs ln0sL-.
C0ncedrs that tie rresd-t sn hiinsgs, CT tie Penn
syNsHs Goa COMPANY si rH- uHs - enleIilE afl 'he
contract veIs resident czehs o. Nrgf6rk end no, r-
dents o. crEass OF fsnnsyvs. md tss tasy tier
ioIr inteinsibie' dos not follow hs - rr =
lot bius upou fh- d~fenssu- Ths oacer nav ave
ben int isbe b1 this , tLlsn idsa.sss ~ 10
and I'll third perron. thst tbeT La-e ass- n r55ifl
With ~ 0tcers ee fasf II .hts ths Az tn
sci. Of the y,T'ir- uldsr the ag-e~a-E l-
evidence OF faflcafon ~ % pre--Ie Court VI ~ ty
iron lencng ~ eyucoroicy en- o. t-Lrov r1 -lu-rsc
o. % PFcveut ths parties tom aa-- lltsr submit
cssI 1' o. KS s- 'nls'' ~ 70 IT, ae 'o' 'i
A.r ihAucus he dsf--t Az g. sxr-i very i-4- -.
u money tas c0Gst-ucfoa o. To- ruf8al rHa In ll.
her ne cesar bUsr o 0 az G-d s10rt.s coal -
market up1n lf fsta a q. 1..le1t a s-or tae
plEnnd 40 eLttsd @ base DO caaes.,ed. sp5n ths
.rouIds slrgee aFs4rst q l ~ app eaton bad been se-
e5rFsnlfd VIII a. Jrsy o - T-- bsnf.f received
csr The sf~crsut tud - pat A- o1post- part - ts
.1n1tlon . va "a before tie c1ufIar- ra- l Oh,
have viewed % glil 1'orr favor A - s-nl- there
- nc ess ~ Vlateser IL Pll.ii's AL l4r
cards TIRE rec lr "a. 70 t-Ila.asL-
u remains CO. lnq1fFe Whe-4rr 0rsar sef.. .-a -
frsniee anc eE the srer r Iae roll 70 b. rrazr-
uncer ihs Irav-r mas lct Ju.y p --gr OH %
sper &c re..t d@Ilari-t brt b. .gsrs1-i - tt-
case mae " he tl and toe si-ls-fo1- I'd l-.r
-gs rOf cav b. srfk sl-1 gro1 "a o. ~ p sf
Eaht- Ia thy rlasf spr-ar o. nave t~es
ttc - b. ~ - p1r,c-. aEd for re- purr0se
- cc1rolcl2rEz - sf-ilas Er.r - 90 sfeIlc
tef F-aJet; ctteTwe tie CO ~oJla b ae.-rd-
ant ~ rsyrsf, which ooEFary % - ynDrp-A Tne
t3cts stOue ~ y s-ztsd wiz ,gfe.-a. prsc K1n c.
saa1.f tie tolF. ~ nske sI--.r dsrsce, =; B..
sch Es1.El terms O. fnsA- ~ C0r-- msrsly o. d.
de .hs-Tzef Frr-cpl-- In 81 tter- psrr.-s To
5l IL Gen-snt IA its rOt stated Eg1 sg1- &C.
re-n u saAhe the C0ur any dsc-ee 1E4-- ~
srD1Es Prayer The yrcs-- sEn0rt o. 70 sen..se az
~ Feroc stAfes u tfs hii .pisS 31r any fe
alleged res ~hich th@ pro7er kr' - csicazsel a.
cOrdrs g to t-fIs RI tor-sT ACC re .eza.grs
= heb zs1e App-s- have s~-G fra merely for
IT, serrUs- ~ sITrt.ls r. srcic rraysr u ~ ~
fyecl3c persruzuss Of .Er--r-r. -taz-r-f resr-
.isisar VI sFplcssoE r hsEs aefigs-s % % b
tsnos4os AZ Hul and H0A Ib~ 81 1zg ;As<esJre "a a.
Ilise1
Ii .sr.r.e md s-,,es "a, i,s ~ e tsrs.,e 4. tie
Sos-s 81 Tie YA-Euf.