New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-11-03

The Buffalo Commercial AdrertisU makes response
to a recent article in this paper wherein sought at
the request of correspondent to answer single ar
gument urged by the advocates Of the scheme which
| they choose 10 designate as Canadian Reciprocity.
We have no space to waste in returning the personal
| compliments, which the writer The Commercial is
moved to bestow upon us, but his objections shall have
the benefit of such circulation as we give them,
and such answer as sulfces. Imprimis. The CONNER
cial says:
"The position of The TrJpne l. that the repeal of the
duty Canadian wheat would by augmening the supply
in market occasion fall OF prices and operate to the
disadvantage Of our farmers Now admitting all this to
be true in The full extent which Tie TriJHae claims reel
procity would Notwithstanding be great advantage TO
PEOPLE and promote the prosperity of every class in
the community. The free admission of Canadian wheat
which only OF great system of measures seems to
be treated by The Trsbune as though it were the sole
feature Of the arrangement, though il embraced the
whole cause.
We knew this dodge long ago, and in a preceding ar
tice had taken occasion to put upon record for use
when il should next be resOrted TO- the distinct almis
sion of The Journal Commerce TO admit the Canadian
wheat into the United States free utys heessential
feature of the proposed system of Reciprocity" The
friends of the scheme generally careful 10 keep this
fact in the shade as much as possible yet in all the
stick out 1t will not serve The Commercials purpose
to talk vaguely Of great system of measures 1t
must specify, and furnish precise bill of particulars,
OF it cannot escape the effect Of the incautOus admis
sion made by its coadutOrs We know, of course that
the free admission OF Canadian wheat is not the sole
feature of the arrangement" II is so much the worse
that the arrangement includes rye oats. peas, beans
and other products Of agricultural industry We were
content to deal with the essential feature more espe
ciay as the same which forbid that equally
valid against the subordinate ones. Secondly: TIE
Iribrae opens its TRADE by denouncing the transit
drawback law by which Canadian grain is allowed to
find its way to foreign markets through our internal
channels Of commerce"
Nothing but bad temper and violent inclination to
use hard words could have produced this statement
We said not a word in disapprova of the transit draw
back law with which well enough content, aud
in stating it's effect in facilitating the competition Of
Canadian breadstuifs with in foreign markets,
We copied the language Of the Canadians Themselves
aud OF Mr. Seymours report in favor Of the Reciprocity
bill II was entirely pertinent to show, we did that
during the last six eight weeks the competition Of
tie Canadians for the Of canal and boats had
raised the price of rcghs and thereby diminished the
otherwise have received from the rise in the price of
grain in New-York and Liverpool. The Commsrciai
does not dispute The fact but inmates that no citizen
Of this state should find fault with it, Well, we can
not help sympathzing with producers rather than with
iofc who fetch and carry aud exchange products. Ii
this De rcaron make the most OF H. u is part OF
whit The CO4Dt"ai syles our peculiar political econ
omy which We nclcr expect TO see very popular on
ilc docks Of Buffalo or Of this City but which never
lclca lies At ihc foundation Of that protective policy
which The Comm,re,ai utcd to al, ocoie bcogc took
~ MON swing
1iiidlj me Commtriai rc.teratcs the assertion
nai since tho repeal 81 lho rrish Corn Laws In
ieic ths pnoe 81 Whoa England has regulated ia
pire in Ibis counify bat n oilers proof nor does
- deAg proposition that. general thing. tho
tise o. impnie diners hom that At Newiolk by
MD,a u.aA iLs aosi ~ transportation. by au amount
.qsai ~ iLs duiy sfi.9 ~ Tho freight Ws nssi thai
- at De- eha ~ 100 Dibai be- D'ie, ~ aya1s pa atru
sam u % MUM imfAssllls iLal his,h lana ahuuii
BE- tpit h",..sa 4sd fsAsiia" r.i.as a"i that rana
9i.t t.i.as sLsYi1 ts graduated w ,hs Ar.a,ip.n
e1o4. Hsieb' cad aais -llah stab i--~ a.se .pt
% fts aEtDn+e1 .fat,..'a ~ 'I4.4a4 saf lta, 'hp
ilist D. ~. i.Alh AAl % b. -s.s .sl-Hata.f .a..H.
3D., nee .,sAia qe.4s ill ..rlsi - ~. aAi, u la-
t4hsi4 ls4+.t. .-+- ~ lA.ii.aa.l lil il COO az
-Htt4l tsefA8 4iNui 90. i4.A