The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1853-01-06

Mr.. GIADsrosx os.Adsred thss the speech which ths
committee had Just heard ought 70 meet With rspay
and reply 1t tho moment; and he snimadverted With
Dsrss had used ana hs phrasss he had sppsd 70 the
characters Of public After cosdsunng the course
proceeding adopted By the With refersnos
to the resolutions he ohsoted he SAID 70 the resolution
before the committee whether WAS vote for House
tsx or a vote for the bndsst He enumsratsd specific
objections to the house for which he would le
pats until Ill these questions had been fully ds-sd
He showed how severely the additional direct taxse
would ate ot persons with small incomes some OF whom
Including the clergy would come thu rst time within
the Of the income tax He objected to the addition
al house tax, because i was connected With the osal
OF half the malt taxa measure which profess.
eely for the immediate beneH. Of the consumer,
whereas it was sacrifice Of f2Sco,oOo for . rsduc-
ton in the price Of beer that would be scarcely spprec
able and the principle Of reproduction would
~ bs dormant The imposing tax OF one kind 70
peal of another kind was most delicate op Grafton
and which would attract the most Jealous scrutny The
question however which lay at the root Of the whss
discussion that of the income tax and its mod6cs
tons Nothing could satisfy tho country upon this head
bur plarnot abstraction, no. something seductive
which they who proposed knew could not be carried
Of Commons would forfeit duty il 1t consented to deal
In the abstract with matter respecting which the theo
nee were endless Passing to the budget g.psrsy he
ducsd new principle subyersive Of all rules OF pru-
denee by presenting budget without surpus for the
borrowed money and no real surplus That right
honorable gentlemen he sad complained Of being oppos
ed BY coalition He (Mr 0'sd,tone), wanted ts know
whether minister Of the GROWN vac entitled mako
such charge against an independent member OF Fara
nens AND without any evidence lie vo.sa against a.:
grounds Of its principles bat smphatissly because 1t
his Arm conviction thai this the NEST perverted
budget in Its tendency and ultimate effects he had
and il The House fheu,d sanction It's dclusivc
scheme the day would cons when 1t would lock back,
with bifttrMIa late, though Intellectual repentance.
Ar co,oLL, replied 70 somersmsrks Of Mr. Gladstone,
amidst much interruptisa.
The committee then divided
.'...'''''...'.....s
Majority against Minister ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 10
The House then adjourned at twenty minutes to tour
till Monday next
The Liverpool Chronicle gives tho following era.
phic sketah Of the scenes which took place In the
House of Commons on the occ Aston Of the ministe-
rial defeat
sCRsGs AT THE DIVISION.
The House has just divided, amidst . such Asit
would be difficult to describe. went down shortly be-
fore O'Clock just ths Chancellor Of the Exohequsr
finishing . three hours speech He spoke under
great and amidst the cheers supporters
was informedfor could not speak Of the fact, and
write ct least two or three hours before the morning
pspers are pubished-that he made very coarse aud
uDgentleMaBly attack on Sir Charles Wood the late
whs Chancellor Of the Exchequer and that he was
TO- coalition somo,hiug that doomed In the futuren
and which would to be most disastrous to the best
interests of the country But this and the other
heads Of his speech tho morning papers will COARSE
be very explicit Mr. Gladstone iMmedistely rose and,
right member for he University Of Oxford and
the brother OF your to~nsman, Mr.. Robertson Glad
STONE. u evidentg favorte with the House Mr.. Glad
stone IL Of great mental power and his reasoning
strong and consistent. his illustrations happy,
his dicsion eloquent and flowing and his At
moment calm and digHnsA ~ another assionsd
and eloquent that late the hour was, no carried
the House With him. The applause not vooiferous
was iene1 OF tns speech tIe u prssson Of msn VINO
oesd appreciate ths very hgnest orosr OF forensic
eloquencs combined with the most enlarged political
philosophy. The psrora,ion disappointed me in fore.
and power for although in keeping, 1t hardly sKceed
the beautiful and finished address which he delivered
to the House. one Of those things which those who
ds.ssi, crowded judging BY IL appearance should
have uBhesitatiDgiy declared that tho government
friend the rsjonder was All you forget me mbsrs
who not in the Houfe Depend upon IT, the govern
nent win be beaten by :. lea.. score The refsshmcnt
rooms tie fmoking rooms, the library, all full Of
members, who listening for the division bell Mr..
Gladstone down 1t quarter past three After him
some Mr. Connolly who was asrailed ~ the most tor
rife cries Of divide, vdc but still ho proceeded and
several sentences whah he uttered distinctly heard
Nevertheless be srsen-ed TO be rambling from the
pitch that nobody should presume 70 occupy their time
q that hour Of the mesning and Mr. Connolly liter
ally roared down 1t understood that il any Of
mark had followed Mr. Gladstone, Lord John Russell
would have wound Up the debate bat 10 did not speak
At length about twenty minutes past three the question
put and the Ayes" and Nces" &C ,tended foe the
mastery. The members then went into the lobby to
count nosee and In eIacty hsn an hour aner-stte
minutes to four-the result vas announced Ayes sso
.p.Sts ''1 $3.50 ~ s.,...;"n IN. .x,.,-
AZ MSe., .o; 80. ~ -so - ;t ~ nv 49,.
nSsd OF Inc iesding miniseeAl PRINT Wno pray u 20
ssnu WHeu Jvu Gu. tne oPPUs.sou-1",uPMe~ VI ~
1vees oo D.ss psnu' .,e .ule. Sn1 Wy ss
A.,
;s one oendns he0a, . t No s
tnsv tne osys OF sofJ government As Ao' oVe1 "e
sn4l ese. sp,,
h..--I ..d ,.o.t h.,.r .I<oL,1
.Sl 81 80, - nj. ,o-d.h;n ", sbs,ms. C.s.ford
Glsdrone's spesoh With his nrrs Occasionally folded
acIoas ohest looking In . temper the OF