New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-08-20

/ would Bft y ou- if-fr III f'f4A@rt FrNH
he Argument between Minor C. Story OF Pozghkespis
and soms % iAbcTefs among whom as the psa1H i''
Es second fourth and tbs th-se list Io1Es0os o. ne
9Th provisions olcrs; Counsel hen proeseas
the gentleman said tha. no mssr vhetnsr tue Psi1tn
read the sgreeuert or not matter shethsr sss read
c him not matter hos august ia pro sans az isi
bin sncs be :isn-a IT, s e,1a'ns SPoa nm ,a
displayed one could slucs' understand the paradox
Suunszi asszzas tssrea
Understand hs matter very difsrert believe with the
uTis,s, there wrong without reading al here i
sand wrong hcnous niustics and act OF niats III
quty fcT which RE sanction 81 the law voachst Toe
ps ntif went 10 Panama the ith Of November rnTksi
&c days under, broihng fed dsterous food sAs
four or i've weeks sick az Pansnis went iat0 hOip,t
when he came bone, and has ben t,ere since It's nov
rear two months siace be assigned away his labor his
he.h bis blood, Mr. Storey fer which he receives
the nunif ,ert OF els. By the lar TIA rest IL fot'
Most muniicent chairman Of Democrats Committees
nos. humans Law. have Doubt indeed il your honor
shoui decide thst the law Get I'm nsd shs gsn,lem
woulo e1clsim as another sdvocsis did Of cid;
a. Dart, CONE con, 70 sss ss Ss% ~ Yfi gt
Bot The law tins Office the genllsmAn assigned H.
aims at i.tce No matter how strong the bond matter
how sacred the Obligation mstsF thouSh i were .isasd
ard sealed With AL the ceremonial sver iavected BE-
conceived in frAui Il is Of no moro worth than blank
shrec Of dirty paper This not deed Do
bat deed s yoii-i by fraud O.her thlog, e@sie
fraud VII make deco void II the obligation o. 70 DO IA
less ihFg immoral thing or an imp ,ssi Ne hing
void III; bs o5;ai1 BY dggess BY u~nsca ~ By <onS
Of any kind Il "a void II binds hi SELF 10 ps,psus
slavery, by SIMPLE operation OF law he stands Tree msn
wherever he can sppesl 20 Il Ihsre no principle better
knos 70 our jurisprudence hsn this II IS ths great basis
Of the urbroken cuIrert Of decisions ia favor OF msrnes
An English mariner lersie iliterats. signs shipping
article in Liverpool wherein hs njs himself without Emit
Of time distance the ship and forfeit sill wages il ia
anything he violates his eug.gemsrts. He comes hthsr
snd ino the ship is bound TO Panama lie quits and cslss
TO. pfOteciorS,e Of the sv The shppng ar'is 4.
declares 10 be waste and worthless psD-r :, ov..s the
s.n vr., ave integrity OF rseion al which he h'd
irVountfTiy Invested himself sad r.cssb she's 81 hs
ri-hts liy u. judgment tie las, p-nk Of tee vessel rlis
60 - SATISFY liz Need authority be Qlotsd lor "a
here not baH in the Marine Court tia: ,ai ao' tai
yol he would hold The ship and se her las timber though
III whole Navy q Egand stood OF Sandy Hook under
such guert Serh il the msissy NJ The w AID 4
IS not the Law Of Nssl ork bat The law Of Ae cvliz ii
world the expression OF justice st'sred in all the laws on
earth 1t Is whether this is not az analogous ease
Tie first srce OF this agreement, gss, The Sns aad
every q his su,orcinses Unlimited 'sterg over the
ptrscp the heSh, the movements the dst the sleepiago
h. W sman lie sss for the time his very he tie IS
bound not alone work ~ bis trade bat any work no
81 he railroad bat my ard every There draining
malaria swamp or ea csrroni s@episg under he nox
ous cew or breathing ths 10, breath ii dab Aud what
y The sv.deucs-ihe Gncontrsdictsd syiinc That Il
uGn crcwled under shelter 70 "a, his noon neal IN
tropical climate he you'd be ind SO Asrcifal Super
int ndsnt Why II might be- the Whole six months w3ges
~ would be !" rfeit of the bond Certainly Gle Ta
forfeit than that relied on here. The last cl3 explain
by this evde 60 Is abs oltsy void II bound the Fori
O. do ~ ig i act be would not Oug Be irae - DIS
c0iy ia; bound o do B1, does nos bial hin 70 ID
ifegnir = whether legal or Illegal moral Or immoral right
or wforg. sld therefore L IL void Or Il hs not VOID
on tns . XII Is NitlDle, ana tuu4- I'D TX
Nle the workman really bound TO do ald snen h
justified IN refining What has the p datiff il thu case
c'rs! Hst be refused 10 WORK Not h. Has ae gone
aace, lie shelter "f tee 20 eat the hetory o'et
Not Ie Did he refuge sny ny Notke ID d reuse
e. 50 to bed wien tired On tfAw or on the grolni 20
cai 60 - drink, 10 palm sue wlel ordered
Not 80 IN re last Look you - sckenei and therefore
DE- I'd not uS his orgsgagen' Bat hey 40 ny dsoy ne
WAS sek Ia is sick This ia not the ticket they hing
rssiI iortes on. Il wouiI be Seek ous adsed They
90 deny he was but they say be does not produce
Tn. that i-fsu iapfs
Doctor da nov give written ceItIela. Of which Ia SEEKS
20 take advantage Il ei'her was his duty or it vas
Tot 20 give 1t. ii yea then ne can not take advantage OF
his oeB ~rong # nay then We are no. honnd g. prlia's
e. Did the eunsh, juf.t p1ut QUO this eousel Did ne
ADVISE VI Storey thus Dii ne saw Here youu have
''hCD jus tell the doctor not q give the sex any
ticaie ma they trapped either wAyi' When the
d.c'o being SCENT d. sires hem ~ leave they are
bound Immediately 70 qlh' b. the fourth article, sni
ry refuse then hey have faai' - fulfil h'' iupu'rnn
and ny the last csuss & The h article they forfeit all
a9ges AND, again. u they obey and = win lut writ
90 oruuceie ihry tfeu IA F'Ses IN HN7 mtuA-r
T. not ir ofer ontFageou ffaud wrapped up IN he "a
ier Sufficiently dtrnatOry % stamp this agreement With
rfilr ~ m enable wortlssuess TIE LET d'nt tasks
30 Ingenuity OF his einnfnt iufist 70 bad h'se poor
wrecfs thetihsy would be completely a the mercy
q their mssieo call him their w01 b. Ing IN
Justice f,,n 10 slave owners-and by his ftl article, ia
cur work ,hem ald siarys them FOR sx months waiting
week Hycsre II the 5th article he can retain az I'll
lres sun not less thln $50 which means everything
S30 That is The entire Then according % the I'm,
agfu' tells he workman to leave and he disobsyS b.
slicb Dee iofisiis III bis wages and passage homsi hs
aId then he violates 'hs first article and Jriaifs also
Ipt o corhre ourselves - '1e case before u3 Tn9 10
fIse j. made up Il tao fFi-ure3 Firs' thsy say w)
forfeited he wsees earned because 10 rot 01aes tbs
Doctors vrop ortihcgt4, and secondly. Jrf-i. orr
passage Icy NecsUse ID not fnsh on our d n 1l
sryfrcp have proved 10 dlJs So, O-t " tagt -
got SO which leaves sC) SrpDosng tn thai " d a
forfeit our passage homeWsrd still tasfe lns 80. II
fhe coIIyer It the trap - sit N judgment here
cy him to refuse us Judgment for that an lunt II Is not
r. the very naigi ~ Of cunning to refuse There no.
word n tie agreement abOu, written certh ate tls
w0ds are Ill the ply sea1 shall certify W9 have
pos and proved clearly not only that hs certified hat
hat h. actually cred and sent home ald a. his
that va "unft 10 work We nsi.h3r
.-ted nor desired 10 DO sen home, and home wa
we're sent. This the gentleman calls hesyay
evidence Blessings on his legal lore. BIZ
2 learned gentleman gave us 4 specimen Of his NJ
manly 70 veil as law lie tod Is he hai comp Iss)n for
those poor aud 50 had Storey. and 50 must every
man hGyirg hearf" This may be quite true a1t Orim
full q bensN Ole but aay, do MT d4raud %
pshy but be furnished us With proof The proof t. thatr
would be lis interest the g0rkman should oe hsa,hy
strong snd vel ed ard be triumphaniy askedi APO
ssve ny horse, do ovefwoFk M horse do not rs.hsr
take pride IL bis c,nditon and strength r lie will par
con me but cannot hip thinking this rather hickory
humanity to quote plain bat expressive figure used ty
ore Of the vtoesses But - logic is by no mans Of the
stern osbrs As he hsd to the Illustration,
b .ha have the full benef. Of H. think this tral ex
plains IN uakeaty how il would be the benefit Of tbs
ths the plaintiff should get sick when ne did
H. sick before, ard why be not tbs sent home
Bat lust tbs time i, convenient There ware $50
bicb be defendant thought he could make oy the plain
tif finishing biz time and there were the remaining
which he thought he could make BY the absence OF
grtten eertiicste.r That the plaintiff should thus be-
come sick lust th3 value 10 the defendant &C
cord ing bis Of the agrsemsn II would b
OF equal value 10 him thai be should de This brings
to the last Droposion Fist, sntsd TO oar pass
age home the pSro testimony secondly are we ca sd
10 By the words % ths agreement say We ara, winch
|, gEYE a AZ 1. =