New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1853-08-01

s,.J ,;,o;,lss thS, A.i no foundation IN ruth. and
eou act therefore be made to explain the o.
r. In,,. hat az BRAN Consequence 81 Fhl hh
hssn a.. NV had been PEELED 20 elninsfs Al tns
pobl.r PARTS II ,ha system. and connnt 'n-i.
toe, TO II. m.an.r cne then "a aa n. phe,o.u.
could readily be - lsi0ea and that 'h-y
gr,st system Of sooiAl scierce pesieou! ,I -, :,
~ Ire parts. This was great ro,N 20 ,iy. .,-,.
nigh, have been supposed that r"uil $500 - v
c-,Unt.rsrc. II not even aid, fror he pu'he p,-s AT
freal t. h0<ever. In the f~slrs sesrf lN 49,; =, :,
rubieAior. never cav sngie fS'erftlH -,
a., -, rot have been ~r;:-n By "ussNI
fresh from college ard inflated W.T. -. :.
ths; h@ Rad quSl6sd himself t'r the one " . "a -
ru7 ding hrssf during 'he last term u try'a ~ =
,,ard the confused knd rsrthi-ss system, 81 "-y~
Saw -hich will account 7 ~ f.c,- ana -ncn tus
- rsr,ies arc ir perpeual COZ ct with q. oihe ~
~ - % ,hs. ne !, begsr 10 bs that nv BOOKS
v.r. studied in Europehst they hSd been or "sfS o-s
Translated and r.pnblish eGsnd finally Il. cSMe 20 %
lrcap hist nv Whole system from csnneae-t'-nt %
close hsd been Reproduced by oue OF ,nr Sorse ~
n a econoi.ts and Snong the mos; bTihsn %
vri-ers-.nd tn ana Mt fr4 ls<s ossa" 10 DC
bv our 90 revi-~.rs that might perhaps nave
,.,bd IN nv ynsdp.-. OF IN ih-y a. not even !r
sff, certsn fcr have not YET been incorssd IL
IN. couruy that dictates 81 oar NODES @. uS' s.
- ,;,,, con ns,ert for tbo task SlnOs, sly one "a III
zone N-vehel,ss of s tn reveSers who nave ''r -
usnv years THIS ireSted social science. niAe '-Hss
-, advocates Il international copyright, az t-nans
90 sivs IA American literature ana 20 pro
po,s originality % thought IL may De ta't
fact ould BE- is effects but " - u = measure sSsn''
which our suffers should 10 MAN protest Tor orisniV
i 6esh ~ tb-i bopes Of sne To urnsh origin ii-t-
map must have Dxcsd himself 10 advance ~ MS neigh
b. r. ard in advance. It bis r-Truer-'rd ~ ~ tu-r
srd. himself unable 10 Determine their vus H. ur N IN
over a. b.st he nav and then o4neyo-r'y Disposed
towards his victim he praises him for somshing nat u
CONN ~ himself and dozen others an thus dsnns
him y iih faint praise II other si.e disoosd h. watts
pr, h. can find deprecisiing article by stupid
Eps bnan and reprints that evidences that his cOrnry
man i. An ass AL this il precisely what ha happened 20
IT. NJ natured articles by such Euglishssn ignorant q
The first eunt. Of social sciuce have b4a0 pr te hare,
hut IN single ps,Ssce that nov rscoect has .nythas
oommend.;ory been republ'hed "a being the fact.
would much 10 sAylr "a an sGthor that I be ToGd
have biz bo b to sell he must svod al prrt-ns'n 20 org
inaiity Of n oughtf
som. fifteen years since pubii.hed lt,le book
credit and banking which contains in loo o. 20 pszs
more information thar ne furH in al the Eogh books
the subject pat together ana The tor mi. - that
laid Gown simple princ'Pe:-those Sa'trsct IDEAS
that your reviewer DOES not IKE sud then showed sN al
The fsc's Of the world were in accordance with them
Those ideas adopted 10 Franc. and nave had fer
several years book which e Is shown h0r readily by
their AID al the revson II gland and France coad 20
accounted fer within smon5h have received N -iAbo
rate work BY ,be writer ut from the France
in which little volume j. frly used and = pronounced
10 be de Pins be1ax ourr7ges" this subject nat
hiss appeared Nevertheless hsyiak been ~ unior'
tunSe as 70 cor tain original ideas il received tho
smsllesi norc- here beyond tranpery newspaper
paragraph while long articles were giv-n 10 enor'n 'u'
Epglih volumes written doSn q The level ~ roTew-rs
the authors Of which proved nothing oy ther mln
piy ~ words except that thew had go u etrn tha
Of the Science they had underfak d teach And 80
people talk the necessity Of intern .on% coP!ugm
Mr. Smith has. for the first time, gwen me Tofd
manual Of social science Science ~ bssed on .ws
Laws abstract ideas and yet our resr<sf WIS tNs
ing o science reprov him iDr his sNsir ons MS O'oS
il sn excellent bu' il requires that rs readers shoad
take some little trouble think for there NJ roy ROAD
10 science The stretch o ihough ID t Il requires r. hoS
ever lot greair than might De looked Tor IN any aey@r
COLI g student In scoord lnce with the t.hon OF hs DAY
b. has called political economy and your rsve' yer las
f.iled 10 see In tnst soctl science hs desider>tas
Heaven bep the authors, should originality ever b=coms
the oroer Of the cay among them.
The .liimste object Of .ocis science I. the determine
ton Of conditions under Thch N IN advances mot rsp
dl, toward that perfect freedom Of thought speech, snt
acton Necessary his perfect responsibility for MS &C
tons BET God and mao The slave Is an irresponsible
beng To sch that aighest point IN science i tbs Oo9ct
DIN lat book and TO 10 80 It Wa needed ;hr ,hold
pSs- TIE nh J. gfonad occupied by VIZ Mil IN his Two
Ionoerous octSvos and this il done IN ar less than hus
dret psg. and Ut your reviewer advise. ma 10 DE more
concise TLe s,e 81 pocket encyclopedias has, lnfpa
nsfsy not yet arrived The difference between Ar Mil
and sell his HI has attempted q provo the ru, 81
cCnpe 10 bril- together Thousands Of 'ioaH I1c,' that
seemed ifihey might Go 40 and the r-sl' - that hs
various facts in constant An gOnsm with each o'heh
and his reader Is oeWirrvd H. mas 40 id@A 81 any IN
larged view Of aud IN, sections of tho laws By
which he snd they ar governed and hence tn mapliy
of words have XIV irw Nerj simple pr hciprs cDs-
sriHg n, roe greHqd N'd have called in the chief
ors o The e,h TO prove their ruth AMI tins e't,bl 81
, bightf rfnt H. uh sect9 rin - carr'ef' snd
w. because choose 10 call my book The Save trade
.ur reviewer would have ynuf readers believe IN. t' o.
lat Lad been i',le more bsn 'he t,trms4,n ~ qg-.
NlNt'-u7
could not bur AK myss'f If h. hso r--d m BOX it
seemed for he had he certainly would have
spared him-s the trouble Of r-comm-,0ng m - uiy
sccis science Read yoursef AM then til mr II yoh
know other nat throw, nuon light On that science
Au0fg tre q no science, -i sDouy tho
most eminent writers Of our day, ~" uz1t and ID Toe
Queyie Why NJ they - eminent Because having no
ices at principles laws hey do not Otrtn % TIE
sheraton their adeTs B'h OF them prove th. theY
CO net Know enough define the words about Fnsh
tiev sTit,-CisuzgiOn and Democracy Their leaders,
are beguCd Wit. the idea tnat hey being taught bat
they they b. gsnnoi Ia fie a. vi h. 4cc
u l. mat ne t.0ks hare k1f 50 mum sucres. II II teY
written ~ haas Of their reviewers they would have
been irrrfreVaby los Their books d<rssstly %
fel' books m colleges, tsc ~" my ne rrtA's
GsA g. ne eref foHr Yo2,, Al n1sQenans rec uait5
for surct ), IN tex nook In ny books is view
Of DE- .Queyie aud have ia-t hsd letter rom An
French economist expressing strong desr- that
should be translated and eYroshed that ina De- pl5 ~
France Uist and rrciA'- the raj chtrAcef -
book % popular among up-gt rial men.
Lat autumn when your publishers wrote ne ABOUT con
,rbulous the Magazine original American Thought
Sc I replied II you r-coiect, ny system being on
gina could not wr4 oth-rv ,s but that f hqt rs'0H
nv contributors would them To b. acceptable
Il wouc b. n.eoed. - said, hs should rezrld hA.1us,
kcarao, McCGloch SC az your reviewer ot seward -
iust Low d. he Va. right or or NJ Norit yJ1 t.ve
accepiec review of NJ Seward the author - which
-hold have taken original American ground. ard demon.
raifd d az there ras SCOTS. science by me as u
Winch M wa b. trieo Would nave been c-p.
abb. II which the -Ii-t@ucs 81 science il denied and
u Which We exp-disncy ;h- test while
adetiuns the Nrsr in the face every sep u ns
progress fear Why then talk % orsinh thought
bound the chains VI lntes lL slavery - =
peopl@ tar Inferior 20 our.siye-
few dsys since had conversation win the most &C.
cgrst. observer AID most original thinker, have ever
kLONU the Who, ~ all ottrs has done mHst %
The country for the advancement II ns science n ms
course II he sad he tired Oi lie There sad
h. not ody slk wn % comm llIca.e A
idea esh any hope tla' viii BE- appreciated, even