New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-11-17
NETWORK DAILY TRIBUNE WEDNESDAY NOVEMBER II. 1852

down nom him think he dill not stop there ~, N
utes 81 tnst time; always heard tina; he was a cal .,
pesceatle nnn, and an honest man
fdr'ek Crfaes recalled saw prisoner have tn hov-
Eofs abcuf three years ago when be boarded with
he fell out bed in the night and when struck n N.
eno went 10 nm ne shook violently and took ho Of me
press nC me hard.
EGa.i nd Lore syorn-Knovy Doye. bav, known hin,
about yesr; he bo~ried with me saw him sar or "
days before this occurrence in Rector s. ursr Wei. h.
assed ne 60 and drink with HIM smell ire louor
On him, AMI then sSii, Jim YOU have been drink NJ,
ycu broke the Tleige-you know you have done bal
thing: He asked me 70 drink. which reused ami BE-
seiG II would 20 AMI take drink with him be wol'i
take the pledge again told him il thought h woudI
would go with him; the tears were running from his
eyes he then intoxicated always heard tat he
was a cuie'. houest man.
Professor Gfmea sorl-IIavc been a Professor at The
Medical College for ten twelve years a onetle
OF Try lie a. phys.cian the City Prison, great many
cases Of doliTgr tIemens have heard the testimony
tlis iCrenoCn cannot give decided opinion a. to de
irun iremen> from the testimony; the te-nnony OF the
witness that he trcmhled and shook AMI pcrspret the
nhi beiorc-that think pretty important a. they are
Indirect syuptOns not Of intoXcarIOn. but Of deirln
treUer- II the was ST hsbitusi drlnkar snd hRa
attack before he would undoubtedly he kelyto nave
another 6ttsck the fact that he tore open his wound AZ
tie Hospital would Indicate either that he Insane or
pretended 10 be i does not follow because man ms
been drinking for ten days that be would have dehfum
tremens-one msn might have g and another not II Is
certain that while = laborng under thai disease
he is much deranged by as be wcul be under any
ether orcum tances persons laborng under arc very
sensitive 20 insult and rational upon one subject but III
sane uTon others would no, give the act OF his tearing
open the wound after being sent 70 the IObs from the
Hospital o. an explanation Of dCrum tremens; think
thai Whist the testified b. could not be taken for or
sesn-t his laborns 81 the time under the di-ease
r.. CcrcI sworn.-AIn physician - the City Prison;
rcColcct the prisoner beng brought 20 the puson he
remained there for couple OF days he was placed N
tie hospital when he irtcame IN hi wound was closed
no laid him tie bed and desired hnn 10 be quiet;
told that h. hal
q ourd open ! went back and found hm bce ing;
lacked him why he had tom 1t Open AMI he replied that
be wanted 70 Kill himsc-tha he wanted 20 die he was
very much depressed II struck me- that h was despcr-
ate and wanted 10 commit suicide bound uup and be
acctme calm; he went away IN day or two alter
ward.
JOHN IcaTy, Robert Haskell Robert r Asdc,soa,
Gorge Rsiand, TAomas ~. atkinson. and Richard
4ii,oH testified 70 being acquainted with the prisoner
nc would 90 on sprecs occasionally; quiet and
n. Sckrc,ley recalled by Mr. Cliuton-waenI a,kel
deceased who cut her throat AMI shc replied Jlm's
DoSle asked her what he did it for she replied he
did 20 because would not give him money 20 buy
she then .wcld over aga that he would take all her
money from her and her h,tle boy
The District Attorney insisted that nc ahoud also state
her tr-wcr es 60 whether he drunk sober az tue
tine but il objected 10 By Mr. Clinton, AMI over
ruled.
IT. Dar'a Smith syorn-C on-ider tie testimony given
~ Barney Toy t. indicate d-i.riun rcmens; should
Judge from the testimony tina. The party was labOring
under Gelun trcIuens at the time of the occurrence
Tie couti ued Of bad liquor would have tendency
produce It sometimes the party IS violent and some
pa si'o sometimes tcil violence VIII Be dircctcl
against those they are most intimate with.
IT. Guernsey swCrn--Heard the testimony Of FOy
consider Il to have Indicated delirium tremcnS; and.
from the te timory, think he might have had deriun
troneus at the time of The occurrences he might Or
might not have had it think the testimony showed he
war ject ~ dCrium trcmcrs.
Mr. Clinton said with the exception Of another medical
wire tle defence is closed
IT. fcrst0v sworn by ID. A-Was n attendance ntthe
Cily Hospital when Doy was brought IN i; am not
much GCCus.u,od with dclir um ttemcns; did not OBJ
serve anything in Doyle indicating deiitium remens
nv yhIts Tslc and 10 short, however, had no
opportunity OF observing.
II. Coop1; svou.--li resident surgeon AZ City IIo'
Iital; w. theo when DOYLE WE hrOu mt in dressed
his wound; attended him atterward uutcr tn super,
imCuGtLCc Ct Dr. Buld at least twice day; ms WOuni
was about inches long the 'front.' OF hs throat
It cut several Of the smaller vessels nnd small artery
aud entered into the winfpipe; observed symptonn
thst mi.lt be referred TO deirum trmens, but made
up ny mind ot the time he went out that he had not
tlcu he WINS net trerteJ ior delrVm ramens: he may
he lteu dcIrous when lie came in, but 10 not think
II ny time lie had deirum ucmcns; tnat might |
think have csused by TIE wound.
n Mr. CIni0n-l c3nnOt say whether he had d.
liGm trcmeus when lie came IN, as had not seen hun
tc,cre; !. two three days after nc came ths.
made up my mlu0; do not remember saying 10 M
Ilpin. bic associate counsel, that dit not form any
opinion a. b. prsoncli disease whls he was there;
M between - cnd - yess Of age the synp 1ms OF
nos q tic nbs, wdnesl OF appearance a. OF horror;
caLnotssy DCs lively VIII ther or not vsitct MN every
Cay; Judge from my general habit o. visiting Pttiena;
lad nom 80 T. 10 patients under my charge az mat
tine: did not devote very long time 10 each, mat
would depend upon circumstances; remember som :
iufo Ward OF visiting do not recoiecE
wfrt medicine gave him; It 20 long since ami gave
linn 20 little. gave him some brandy and water.
Thomas ~. Higgins sworil-ls Counselor at Law
had conversation with lat witness as 10 M opinion OF
the .,e OF mind of Doyle when he came 70 the hospital
he lsrld q at be had opinion, that his attention was
called plIticulary,to the wound he sl the nurse 'u
b. much more able to inform ~ 70 The steO yies
mind than him.
Tic tertmony closed on both sile- and the Court /
;ol.tned 20 this forenoon