New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-01-20


| took possession rDm US In April, lSi4 he supefln
teuO go for US 20 5lh July 1874 and then pure 1a,e
| The whole esta1ilshulent, think ne Ieis IN 1919
| TINS book vi 20, show
| By NJ Var, B-Nr. Rushton is 10 " ia Ohio, ne Il
| ssudusky remember Mr. Doiy being with nm
| here were ten or twelve employed there auo3e'I
| or Joseph c. Dutcher baTkeeper, dsceaseu,4
| atheT. John DOllner, who was Al Second WaIl 10
| iel THINK have pay.list but not certain 40 no
| Know OF aIy waiter that was there now In thown
| Sli ondeavor TO ascertain. 80
! lanes " Sardsrs0n, sworn By NT. Vt -heeI
| College Hotel. know WIN VI. Doty have known
| HIN all u years have had some business % DC
with him the past year do no, recoliec1 that ever
heard him spoken III Of I'll within lew Gays ouf
ing the period had keen acquainted Win MIN, never
| 1eard him spoken i'll of would have no hesitation
| % believe hun under oath.
| BIZ NJ Van B-Have only known him as genera
| acquaintance when / was At Phllaoelph Sl1 o.
eight Years ago as one IN the same line he used 10
| cail on me during the last summer purchaser 2
| good ceal Of BIN. during the intermediate time
nave met him IN the street. Capt "a cram staio TWO
| or three weeks AZ my place last summer nave MOI
alked any more about this case than other SUBJ ecis
| I has been discussed a good deal at our house
| talked with Capt Calcratt about 1t the evening OF
he day he was FIRST called before tue kiai begun
| fCOk Mr.. Forests s!ce nave been swayed good
deal BY the testimony It IS tang have no. taken
| 4 great interest il recOllect you Van breakfast
ug at house, but DO rot recolect that sad any
| ding on this subject DO not recOhect that l nave
| spoken against Mr Forrest / did not know any
ming against bin as TO his case, have thought ne
| mas hard case DO not Tecol!ect that nave sald
| anything as TO his conduct IN the case.
| Degflr 1. Forcs, sWOrnBr Uy. &c --Keslde al vi
| East BrOadway make steam boilers maze those
fgr Mr.. DOtys establishment, which he set up IN the
BOWery year or two ago 90 nof fnoW thdt
KNOW Edward II Gum may have seen HIM II
do never spoke anything to him against the gem
eial character of Mr.. Doty put in the steam boiler
for Nj d and a creditor OF his hIsi sa" nj n Al
the CIoton Hotel In 1916 have met with HIM oc-
c 8sioHaly in 1916 never heard any thing against
ats moral character or integrity should not
hesitate TO believe him under oatn
By M. Van B.-Was tralsactlng business prlnci-
PAL, as agent at the time OF putting the boilers IN
for Nj Miller he did not know anything about the
transaction he eater twOor three men were en-
pIoytd TO put II up, and paid them had no par
lcaiar occasion 10 see him between 1916 and 1850
vent one time In Nassau-street 20 look At a steam
boiler also on board Collins steamer, also fire.
Quently At Thomson'S, in Nassau-street do not
consider Mr.. DOty acquaintance of mine, nor do
! visit him.
BY Nr. Ven B.-The boiler was put m on credit,
be gave lien on II, TO pay so much month after
the first month he said lie would not be likely TO
succeed, aud for me to come and take IL, but he
wished Il 10 remain a week or so longer as he might
End purchaser / Still held lien from the person
Re cold TO and finally took out the boiler.
William N. c0nLila, sU0Tn.-By slr. O'C.-hneW
William NJ. DOty when he lived at Charleston
shortly after his retIrn from there to New York
received letter from him think he had been Nv
me In Charleston more than year before he re-
turned to Newly ork the letter was dated New
York, Jan. 81, lsii that was all, Mr.. OC SAID that
WIS OF interest to anybody he seemed TO be an
honest upright man. so far all the dealings had
with him never heard any one speak against HIM
would have no Hesitation 10 believe him underoath
By Mr. Van B.-He kept barroom and eating
iOuse'at ChsrleStOn-and there vas a bowling sa-
loon ind billiard table connected Win 1t his wife
lived there | am a mason BY trade, bnckayer |
came in lSi5 from Charleston have been IN Proyi-
tence. Boston, and good many places since then
10Y permanent residence is NeN-l ork-d0 not re-
collect any other places where have been | work
here for myself think Mrs. Doty left Charleston
before her husband.
Mr.. Van b asked witness If Mr.. D0ty lived with
any other woman after Mrs ID. left
The Court assed If they were going to get up
another case of adultery.
ChrlStODhtr Hauk3nS, sworn--By Mr. OC.-Am
grocer In Murray st-Hawkrns Il Stewart Mr. ;.
not IN the City know David NJ. Holhster never
To my knowledge said anything to Mr. IL. against
the morality character for truth and veracity OF
Mr.. Do,y have known Mr.. Doty two years ago
the first OF this month.
Q-Would you hesitate to believe him Oh oath
Witness, after heSItau0n-WhetheY interested or
not, would like 10 know what he Swore to think
there some things IN which should believe him
under oath, particularly If his testimony appeared
QISS Mr. Van B~Suppose IL was an unreason-
able story, would you believe HIM
A.-NO SIR
NeIaclty
At is rather az aims, him, Sir.
Q-YOu speak OF Mr.. HOLSTER did you say any
thing to any one
AS n man OF No. for truth ana veracity,
have spoken against him.
Q-Would you believe HIM uncer oath wheTe MS
interest and feelings were concerned
Alt would depend how much interest am feel
ing he would swear 10.
Q-Bv Mr.. OC.--As 10 David VI. H0!hstef, what Is
your opinion as 10 hIm
INtst 70 David A. HOLSTER, should speak of him
as A No2 "A taught
Jobn A. Brou,l, sWorn-By Ar. OCTAVE kno wn
MIR Doiy a wear or two would rot hesitate to be-
heve HIM under oath.
Bv Vr Van B-Worked on boat as ship joiner on
the Roy line, IN which he was engaged
Hiram Mott, sworn-By Mr.. OC-kno" VIM M
Doty he commenced with me IN 1917 wss win me
some time, year or Is months never heard any
thing against his general character would have no
hesitation IN believing him under oath
BIZ Mr. Van B.-Do not Tec0llect hearing hlm
spoken OF much Mr.. Thompson asked me about
hmm reference 20 place he had to let paid HIM
small balance afterward saw MN on board Troy
boat once or twice, and al restaurant IN fihe-sl
am III the lime business all nave heafd ABOUT
Nr Doty is people he owed would come and speak
about 1t and ask If could secure the debt used
10 Joke Mem sometimes, and ask them what they
would take for the debt; never bought any never
heard him spoken of as talking, blowing man.
George q. Topper, sNOrn-By Mr.. OC.-HaYe
Known Mr.. Doiy since 1918 l am mol now IN the
Troy line my brolherls agent Nil Doty mas been IN
he employment for a year or two am acquainted
With his general character partially Will say am
acquainted with It believe 1t stands good would
have 40 hesitation 10 believe him on oath
By Mr. Van B-I boarded at the Cro,on Hotel IN
1875. when he was steward there have known him
acng ever since nave not been companion nave
heard persons speak of Liabilities that he would not
pay never heard of him as speaking lies
Alfred A PhiEpS SSOrn--By Mr. VC-Am a
ccuns E nor al-laM know VIM NJ. Doty been ac-
qusinted with HIM or 10 years his general charac-
Ter "a good would believe HIM under oaih nfst De-
came ACQUAINTED With HIM ten years ago, as fellow
member OF the Odd Fellows also was connected
with HIM one season in soreeS have never heard
HIM SPOKEN against IN the slightest respect
Etdri0ge Parker, sWou--By Mr. Ot.-ls a poultry
man, Warrington market been acquainted wltn
nun 4 OF Yeas believe his character good would
have 10 hesitation 10 believe HIM under oath.
BIZ Mr. Van B.--FIrSi knew him a! the Croton
Nolei, where he WAS steward ana purchased OF Ine
[ have served the Franklin and Troy, steamboats, IN
NAich he Vas and he purchased Of me have heard
oui one person speak against MI Dosy thar was
John L. Moore, OF the Cro,on Hotel, and he said
rolhlng against him particularly, only ne SAID he
dent like him he never said 10 me that he Iarned
him away.
Charles hfae, sworn-By Ur. OC.-lS Preslden, 0!
rnln,-L,a ,nllane know PrneSSOr HsckieY he Is