The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1852-07-04
The Exsrsdition Case.
UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT.
Lefure lion. .judg. Belts

July SIN the matter Of Thomas Kaine claimed
Fsgitire from Justice in Ireland Mr. Edwards
for the British eovinIen sp Ike ut c d. rabe eng'h
In 10 the argument of MIR Brady and urged upon
The CO. ri the us The claim OF the British govern
meet n their right to the return Of the fugitive
crin from justic. lie ted he condition Of Tho
prisoner wb that Of poi icai r,fugee and alluded
tie total atea OF motive the part of Kaine
nit the CRIME with which he is charged. The circum-
stasoe out Of ter with which had earth
interest Whatever lie not tue party dspossessed
he not connected with the party dpossessed he
lived oistanc. from the placebut became the viii
ing instrument of another aud this the forsooth
for vi on this sympathy GIT up and whom tho sympa
thxcrs ale ~ xious should Dec me citizen If the United
States Upon he IN wing h. il Fugitive from JUS
at this un.iy I ku that .rics never VII give
political fugit venor Will England either; bit here
j. no pttcl oheuce but cr uinal act ana it is rea
B0nab o enough to think that wlen county sends
tbftr THAI aud mile for man there nut be some
founc alton FIR the oh rye hat t. laid dust him II he
gs back he will have all the rights Of TT al bv jury of
his all The justice Of the courts OF Ireland (iur-
mnrs aud ner,si'e expression' ~ oh onD
The Judge (loosine around the lobby Of the court
which b, his i'm very much filled by the unnIe
ella Of Irnh) said " here aoy repetition Of such
ct the Mar h.l hould be directed 20 clear ne
Marks Of di Apr, baton approbation could
rot be TIED In he halls of justice IL coun
ceed bis mts. the Court sill reprovc hun. but this
intfs3cr there groupdr for the interruption.
2 he Untei States harshal (f. u rallmadse) ad
trcsnR be people IN be boy the Court, said You
on IL IL he IL 70 give his oders the
Mar, bal will O. rtainly carry tn IN out
3hr Juhg.-Apd Mr. Mar hal. IL you can designate
any person who makes disturbance bring him fore
the tUut and lie will be dealt wlb the law permits
MI. BWts,n, Ia ADDITION 10 wln Ills Honor the Judge
yad ttaLd, begged TO cay thai il there any such
} aDiie-stion again he counsel for til. accu. ed
sello leave The Gaze Without any further defence
MIR tdsnrds then continued hi argument uninter-
ppisdly and sad iAat II this man (Na'ue) returns
surope there crenm. tanc-s thit he m. ght
bring forward for hs def II innocent; and od knew
BE tMr Edvafdsl siDc rely wshrd that II" might D. anle
81 do AID clear hms,lf Of hr crime hat = CHI rged
against him But TO tbr eyd aldace1 bci re the
Conpsfionsr he commended that If he alleged crime
p,rpersed here ana that Balfe rub '.qisn y dei ia
eyid No. OF 1on-. Mragher uld nen sufficient
10 have kaipe committed flr trial Meaghrr 0,cfr
be wtbi" short diIance & che place aui he he ard
ef The outrage he zoe, 10 the won Iri man anl see.
bm ard ha (Bsie) HANDS him this prayer book anu
hun a. pursuit OF Kane SlpBjse h,t Btlf ton VI
sppesr the magi traeth"t tmouy Il N,aghcr
tufcisDt prima fdse eyidenc" 70 have the actu ed
committed for tria lie (Mr Edwar1.j WAITED 30 n rs
the Court that this naked uh!cn O. did
bsve been ett up BY MsaRotr He hss come h,rr an
officer npJ h. has en- ahu "a rs blood 'unt and ie
nounCed an iniuTmef Why II he every hal
deputy marsIal longing 70 this honorable court T. n
brood hound but MenRher n constable will not aud
cannot toDch penny Of tn- reward Iies iniormer.
the .iDfofinalion OF haines wnrrrabOuts could not
me bom rum nay have e me from some
Of the 1teds acquaintance miserable wretch
from tIe part OF tn country. Blt M.saher il
che iDfnlDlsf he cunos here as an Ulcer OF jGs ice
Then with regard 10 the objection OF psouers council
~ 70 the warrant Mr.. Ed yards tubmitted under
the etcoDo section a the there nee sasty
10 produce the warrant yet he had IN add ion the
testmopy 81 Constable 1esgher. produced the original
warrant Cuubs, shen Tev.~ed the testimony and sub
piitso that there eufcirDt evidence To that
rr Pea beTstOuphaugh who grsut.d the warrant.
Ju,tice OF the Peac. ~ Ireland lie ben referred Let
Phillips Evidence $50 and 4ay Cowau AMI TN
END 20 Phil ~ i4S which states that IN he matter of n
foreign 0ncun.nt untr the zeal u he court MI that
viii b. nc"stsTy 90 prove the ipDature az the Judge.
In This there H. sufficient before this court in the
tseliu,cby Of Constable Meagb.r. 20 snow that Mr.
Yeai b. Iftons baulh has Standing magistrate. II
tbsrv any doubt 20 tn. crimiDaty 81 the sc Of
shooting n with loaded weapon he would rter 10
BARRIERS Grim Nv. TIT ana 7S2. The British act was
psseco IN 1StS-the American act not LaSsed TIL
1y5t: and act, II would be hsdbesn copied
from the British act Mr. Edwards continued at cansi-
deubbe length 20 argue In Of rbe iutness ~ the
cism. aud thi undc ub,ed ,Rht Of friendly power 70 the
cKuaditioB of n Grim nal fugitive from Justice.
Mr Busted piled bebaf 81 IN. ed Ia a very
shse and srxumeDtstive address, which occupied the
bdurs
re,he cspciusson the Judge iptmstsd that his dc.
-lo be delivered on "Wednesday next