New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-09-18

.s oompoek OF rubber sulphur and Lad mixed ~
bt unde, the OF Richard Collins The other zoe
DENY that Joho Collins ever ard mix the rubber snn 49,
tbai IL VS., Richard Collins s1ne who mixed the eonpolna
propose put end 20 thst question ~ proving ON ns
. OF Wessss called By Goodyesr who ar, In the
6g hostile 10 AZ ths truth Two
worn TO- The counsel read the evidence OF 81 IN
thIey aud observed that this witness bad entses W
with the zeal Of counsel He proves INST COINS
really tho artist IN oil tbese kevEngsDd es,sbs1rl-nn
Its proved by fients out BY our enemies. tpI
to those ount.ns which for we're supposed TO coal.
only wsters Of bitterness II from those PUT = ms
Offer 10 is Court evidence corob native Of Colnn,
viii refer 10 one more witness 10 show tnd ooth youn
and Richard Colin. the mixers OF these 's'a''
III. counsel then referred to and read ise1 OF the a.2o'
or hat need ask were th.se private rooms, which
were sourourstsd to tn. use Of MI Co1s If there hsd
heen 10 secret dvugel Who occupied them Co'.n,
Who we're refused admittsnee EVERYBODY 0as 80 49,.
cana una-r boLss 10 Mr. Collins 10 preserve ms s-crs.
hy then are these witnesses rsmstizsd ~ lmPC
aud ,usrer- whsp the testimony OF ps'op. shsnneo
In plaintiff and crcu instances which cannot o7oe'e ~
firm them 10 oil msterial respects - A.. 49,
Mr. Cuttps then preceded TO comment upon in9 o''
d.pes az Hr Newhsu ard Of Lesnder Mr.. t.rie -.
The LEANED counsel for the psotlh hivo ln9st' 49,
t, shower upon Mr.. Earle sres' sn0onl VI ,I 81.
srd when ] contrast their pesen. 1ne -. s,bih
sxid.rce OF warm ard intims'e friendship vhlen IN.
~, ~ ,hi, e.e .bow hs. until very recently. existed oe
tu,eep the witness and Ons OF tncse les'neo r
n,e,.ut lHr Crooke cannot withhold an ex>ssSn ~
.. IN. sre.t sud ssdden change that IL manifested
toward the witpe., The correspondence oetween l1s
s.d c0ur snc him. discoses the part OF the former
- ti,b rsysr6 for Mr. Earle ne addresses him {. n' oia
fsn6 nsrfess great anxiety concerning the nehtI s1
welfare Of himself and family. end very lively so'luo5
r fheir comfort ard happiness What then IA, oo'isa
oois,oye these interesting lies and 70 expose M Eafis
20 .na5eny TO fierce Onslaught Of Tie Opposite hos
II 4. ony by perussl Of his testimony That the 81
hs .n1niei II .ppesrs then that Goodyear ana nus
friends had sceiteuso tnsi soms years ago hs.s nal
chesed from Collins the secret Of mixing h. 'P0
cn,s ana had Ia fis possession the oEln, ecelP on Ii
t,urtons containing the proportions Of the several
dj-pts sod the process Of compromising tnen sno ~ G
poss.son psper fatal 70 ne paoiln W ~ 80
~ ss ont Dpo tsnce Of the learned counsel -na
- I'D of Esre cOncsvea ~. psn OF orgnz nun nv
tbs cts- q. a. assistant ald co1cuto 70 sssist 1-os ~
j,s.s an e.reeally .uch migh, possibly impeacn
the ,,si cfnrscier q COiinf BY thus assOe'ans nun
- .seot i, vas hoped that the fatal receipt mieht
he kset out q Vi. order more euec 70 OK
ci,e s res. he was Il time pres 1ed with >iuV ana
U - - en-. AZ 6'Hsreu, tunes from the correspond
epce il hpp-ss fsTle sro about the sane uhe DC
eans tn rie,bea friend Of Nj Hsskins AID OF oihes OF
liz aries wnO p:ofrsed ifateTnal regard t0I hH
., ii,t amazed that gent emsn EhO had sooa 80 wen ~
n. client. Of this leaned gentleman Mr. Cook soeue
have teer,e the uhec q III ssvere cltesn' put
fne nys.fv as uuraveed When reflected that upon ms
s,srtion "a witu Sc Ia the he had dsck.ed the
.xstsnce Of receipt from Colns and nae PodOeu e
origipa' ard made II 81 Xol9t ~ 'Le ass ON Ia ~
ment ihs Interesting friendship without Ians''a'e "-
Tie relstan Of Damon AID Pyt las was suddenly as;
solved sno sssius AID his associates not Only broke On
Their iacy but through their council discharged upon
him lie ys,s their wrath TO the uttermgs Gfop ne
cause Of theiT present sumosy arises tOn ms confession
hat he had purchased from Coios tins receipt Tor manu-
featuring India ,ubbef This paper seoed % Mr collins
ana dsv,Ied 10 Nj Earle put BY him in an Old tunf
h.h he opeLed brought the receipt 70 zht IL tls
in he euuiue II be not forgery there 10 not foul
r.uJv coupled with rank forgery effect Of tins receipt
Nut the plaintiff upon tas brsach OF tue case
Tor It's date aud s contents leave no room tor doubt Oh
now wha, are the criticisms made upon this testimony oil
Faie They are these In the first depositiJn tlken be-
oIe he Rad found this receipt be t''he' at be a1 htee
receipts among his papers which be Lad Obtained from Col
us he stated that one.was for eemeat annier "" of
The ipe compound Of lead sulphur aud rubber a. the
other was for compound Of su phuf and ruhbst Sab s.
qeutly he und these receipts AMI turned ont that IN
d iluee there were ony two papers Ih'ncalled
cont ADDICTION But tho fact H. that one OF the two papers
contains separate distinct Teceipts-one fJr cement
without ad OF SULPHUR and the other for the upe com.
pound of lead sulphur ard rubber Now, because ne did
not ind three sspaste papers he supp sed there were-
it..eus there but cOntsibng three receipts
TIL, ns inscouscy affords the opposite counsel ire op-
nonnty 1 ursps upon the Court that his whole evidence
Il To be REGARDED fabrication and 10 be utterly DIS e
esioed Why II this bed been witness who was de'er-
AZ planning asehot d. when he was examined on the
su q before would he have testified t1af he ha1 t &c
eeIpts and eNpsio what they were and then n ne hsd
Manufactured the receipts would lie have TAKEN he p.ios
TO talsiy his oath by clumsy e. as q nave ao
ra ed instead o'three Papcsl Would he not rather
have reduced what he had aiesdy ttsed 70 QUO ne
nave drawn and snufsctu receipts in cOnformty with
his tettInopy or In stikf v,raion fom According
10 nv observation, when you nd witness VINO az the cad
,eh or ten yea, spesk with entire precision Of pa
-rs this And that hasrot seen IN Gil thai length OF
me when you md a Intrepid to dare 70 rely
uron spr-iy memory the purpose OF asserting without
tie least r.henslCn Of msase the contents and the
toc arc of Too much hard hood far me much prefer
modest who STANDS IN some apprehension VI utter
us than actually Ius sud who By some iosccu.
Tury, Ell, ws that lie had not heen hnied.
r kat, round the receipts snd discovered that there
asst variation between the papers and his testimony
her benz instead Of three ltupon such uad-
hat TIE tt impeath these re:epts, and 81 la
due he Cont 70 bsheve they are forssneA AID that
bo'h Coins Fas 10 addition 70 the crns o fOrgery
have srItrsdced that OF itui snd corrupt perjury.
| con,ice, that when ny Collins sapPHte tea by BIZ
tlti slj distinctly confirmed by Ne~ hall and ~ Nj
o n ~ tie prcsctcn # the e!pt the ssnunenss
q iicr thinA as tot been even sg' IL t0uchsa
hi,e mniLed MSS Of evidence that the Court VIII no
D l. ol,Id shattrck, ,e.iirg in Ardover boot al
e 81 1SsS a.. s ,ta hs .so 5a1shs fiona CT
ssrtept f5s compound II rubber, sulphur and whit
rac ~ b. tyes The " portion Of III, white lead usso
t1s con ouon Not whisperis head asAin,t the chat
as.tr % Nv bhsttucs He as peishbOrs aud friends
he OF bad RUE, II could he shown by somebody
Ms We, leT OF boiion prove, aAt ~ lt5i al, heha
Crins lccg,o at hty nlotheTs hoa.e 10 Lowell end On
n saw Colhis mia Iucia rubber dsoived in stunts
turp, Nine AID mia ed with supt aud whit lead and sh
saw him sgIt Rd II on cloth with painters kLite.
NJ Warren White also prOves that IN sSb while Richn
Coins at Ne vtoo falls hs, White purchased from
Eiolaid Collins receipt fora compound Of rubber, whit
Lead ane suI bur- Essnssis snd amPbsok to make ruoSe
Gtogs II Fox a proves u st shout the 81 period h
saw Collins seating compound OF sulphur rubber an'
| Timothy wellington merchant of Newton Falls prove
thai he puTclasea from him, In lBSi receipt Tor com
| pound ot sulphur inois ribber and lead. go
Nr. witness the other SIDE proves that whi
Ri,lNd Collins Of the Salem Factory, (voldme de
ertants riniini ysss SO he qtc cosp1nad OF raDesI
supbur snd lead It's he hi as an ndo
Int man, but ndolente Is not Incompatible with genu.
Perhaps DO, ye'y o,n that the highest order OF intel
| n
MI Stone cousin german Of OF the opposite parties
volume del PENDANTS printing psge ST. also confirms Dill
| Collins
roW refer to a contract between the Company and 81
lrs I'D volume pa1vhs printing appended TO The fam
nation Of Mr. John Wine
Its copy Of Richard Colirss contract with tbs salem
Company, and the Directors expressly engage 70 keep HI
secrets inNiols'e
The bonds eX cuted BY the Boston Company In all proa
bhis tle same a. those he exacied trom the sdsr
Goa papy - 40 . 49,
respectfully subn, that when Mr. Collins testified th'
lie lsd required BONDS keep secret ss knowledge Of I'll
rubh business that he hss OF the mouths Of the wi
e.es on TIE ether side, mainly because the testimony
6nsry came from that side established, boy Dad all re aso
able doubt fact that such bonds were delivered by hi
rieeisey as he has alleged Ii s true man named Badge
lie Treasurer Of the Boston Company states that he d
MOI ave btud But there is not 70 be found among all q
Witnesses who has manifested no;e reluctance to d
close the truth who, BY his want OF re 5oeeCn has mo
clfsey initiated the celebrated Italian whote ans scr h
become BY vcrd, eng sed pom our mother tongue II
were 10 point my at any OF these witnesses who
memories are 90 ifeachsrorsy forset would be
aly aimed s thisiudyiduA Buitis net my desire 10 ~
inyecves or IaTcsus can neither make this bett
orwose BY anything and there eau Be any thi
N