The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1852-03-03
Supreme CDur,-sp-o,nA s'ss@.
bstsre ilca jrdes h0o-rts!t,

DUriaEnos o. orssfoS gsgNrsr ICpa-a
N.rga 2 - Uttiiarv T,far Caas n, giay and sfisys
In yesterday IsRsrp, gavo . rspor. OF csckslos
Judgs EdlD tt9y she Of J0dvo
Roosevelt rendered 10 this cas-. In Japnsry last Txss
dag judge Roosevelt expressed great Gspsasure tAAt
application should nays been msss % another Judge
- aside his dsci.loD being bat appeal roz
sin2is JuGgs 10 another II. e. at tbie q very
graVe md important msttr After eJs tie proceedings
had In the every thing dous ey susgr or ths
csri. sitting under the constitution aud koai9g term
~ law ana announcing judicial dcciSn as required
h; law is,ns OF law having been made up, that
issre tfad and grave constitutional questions gassdv
nciusiye pToet offered and the Court having h0aaA
counsel both sides the plrsdpss and tina Drosfa,
sli holding as soj before by under tbs Av u
The sr Il ard II there oi.ar before tho
court 1t the la boh the direction so1gnS
to tc imprgpsi VAS given by Judge in open co1r., IN
r.t,ercs oi oil rsIiies eys,y tnng examined rs pre-
,cIiN>d and decree in writing drawn up 20 b. snssss
by the Clerk and Jet after all tnis beins core judge
/oi the Court Appeals snd DOT Judge o. thus cours
without any appeal TO him has directed TINS dsossn
to bs from ths records OF the ccurt and what
Ia nas delivered lecture to Judge Of tss eoart
who. X sssn, dorr not know HI: busnen-thAs H. hs
hss not msds his .snature ACCORDING 70 Law This
Jn0g- has betn told his morning, ciioasly
throrsh ne newspapers, that hs did not know
Lis business; that no did net sign his dsorss.
All this has bera done by chst Justice Edmcnds.
although do not believe thsr- j. any sunh psesoA,
Chief Justice Of lh, ut s-but Ssst of all 10
hr Chief Justice Of IT, Ne /, Judge Of ths oeurss
he is Judge Of the Court Of Appes. And is IT. -
be endured that he Judge Of ths latter court sh osxd
sit Judge CT tdi, ccust and in collateral way Aaa
without any appeal % him saao seat this bench,
the uaicn! praers Of tnis court ssidcs IL chs
that ought bs frs, ATTACKED 1h~ ssction relied upon
by s parties who complain q tile orscr a1es eos apply
open colrtit only aprusa 60 orders made our
of term Ia corclusson Judge Roosevelt sd he was Uee
e he subordinate 10 auY indiydUa Jucgs ne~hs ony
able 70 the general tsrrn end re tH6, tcer, r,ai s
uid always bow am ss4l he q opinion, TINT rd&s
Edmords cannot in This court while DO nsa sest In
,h- Court 81 Appeals 1h- two .udic,l oaces sss Ia
compatible with each ether Hs ha therefore, Iavs
dlctc n this court by Law snd 0cntf@i oyer iss pr
cssdials J.. thought thrt sJge, DC. d this CONT
could take seat It's bcpch. ans IN sur,nsay way.
aetsn gNaA oAe1 NJ aXb
would he brought to rpsedy ,ermHe.ion nAyc ooa-
suit-i With " N, colleagues end IN orees th&t he9
matter shall receive forraai discussion shall IN
tire Is, place declare that tbs oflsr of the 18th or Eeb
tary last IL incperstye. ana tlr: is enal b. qcahs
and yxcsted the parties hsye opportunity TO
Rpp4sl 10 tho general term, yich VIII t SAsurisp
nst give dscops and that IL then hnvs rr,fatesce
Ard have tho Qus.iiea aily hrsra aaa iuiicit
rasstd
Bssor. Hon. Judge Edwards.
HAsCD L-Dgrel j, EnyrA Us. Csas. N S,uvSk -
Motion change place OF trial from New York to ne
Li7Ggeton county lsni.d, without prejudice u
any sppjsson which sSsll % rasde tlsrs s1Aoud
to dscrss Tor o. account.