davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
International Cepyrighl.

Nothing does more gooa thah teluhg
certain old stories over and over again.
From the splendid theft Of Prometheus
down to the petty thief in the Police Court
Yesterday, the very old story of the sin of
stealing has been reiterated with every kind
ofemphasis. So every few month some event
in the realm of letters remind us of the
state of perpetual sin in which we Ameri-;
cans live with regard to literary property.
We are pirates upon the sea of mind. We
roam, buccaneers with the black flag Of abb
solute confscation, and every scudding
sloop or portly galleon, freighted with but
single grain of the treasure we seek, is in
continently captured and subjected to our
sway So rich in money, we are yet SO poor
in honesty that we steal the fruits of mems
brains, but protect their orchards and gar
dens with sharp legal hedges.
This old story Of literary thieving re.
ours again upon the pleasant announce.
ment of new tale of Dickens. 1t appears
that the Messrs. Harpers have paid him
$4,000 for the advance sheets. But this is
no copyright. Probably, in view of their
own interest, these gentlemen find it a coed
thing to pay that sum. But it is, after al,
a gratuity. The transaction is generous,
perhaps, but it implies no property of The
author in his work here. The law does
not secure it to him. The American people
do not say to him and to all men whose
books they wish to read, it shall be your
interest to do what you, Of all men, can do
best" The American people say to him
Do your best-wear and waste yourselfin
your work, and we will enjoy its result, nor
give you penny for it." Yet we pay men
for cabbages, and if starving man steal a
half-p@ny biscuit it is crime before the
law. VII some friend tell us what plea
avails against the man who picks pocket
or steals coat, which is not valid against
him who appropriates the profits of a bocka
England shames us in this matter. Her
position is more than generous; it is just.
By the decision of last spring, and by the
recent convention with France, the British
nation Robly recognizes the right which we
ANONYMOUSLY scorn. Do the Messrs. Har-
pers pay Dickens for his booka But they
could print it, if they would, without pay
ing, whereas Mr.. Bentley pays Bancroft,
Melville, and the biographers of Margaret
Fuller, under the sanction of the British
Law, which protects them, and secures them
their rights.
Is there no hope in this matter from Con-
gress? Are we to continue to suffer un-
der this most odious stigma of reputation
of mems rights to their inventions Do we
mean always to submit to this world-notO-
rious brand of meanness-to recognize
every right but that of genius?
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17

How shall Democracy be magsifed, II tried con-
verts TO its faith are not to be admitted to its folds
nor be approved in its choice Others say, he has
enemies 1T home has every great and good man,
who 10 positive enough IN his character to perform
his duty according 10 bis own independence OF mind
and action II he has some enemies, he has more
friends in Pennsylvania than any other man, and
will be more likely to carry maj oriy Of her voices
In the coming contest"
We heartily approve the doctrines here set
forth, both with regard to tried converts" and
TO mans having enemies without rendering
him unf. or unavailable for office How far
they fit Mr. Buchanan's case is quite aaoiher
matter. The forty years ago" is all wrong,
however, foolish misstatement for " tried
convert" need not have been forty years on the
stool of repentance. Mr.. Buchanan was first
elected to Congress as Federalst less than
forty years ago, and signed Federal Circular
appealing to Federalists to rally in support OF
Gregg against Shuttle as Governor of Pennsyl
vania in ls23-less than thirty years ago. About
this time he became Jackson man, along with
many Of the Federal leaders in Pennsylvania
Jackson being then stump candidate for Pres
ident against William H. Crawford, the regular
Democratic nominee, and Jacksonism being
then stgmatized by the leading Democratic
journals as a species of Federalism. Two or
three years later, the regulars took up Jackson
In order to run out Adams, whereby Mr.. Blu.
chanan, along with Louis McLane, 6errit d.
Chittendsn and other inveterate Federalists,
found themselves suddenly transmitted into
Democrats. We don't say they were any better
or worse than those who took it the natural
Wall, Peter d. Vroom, Francis Bayles, Martin
way, but the facts are as we state them, and
their Democracy, such as it is, is the result of
circumstances which they neither foresaw nor
directed
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
B The Express untruly accuses The

II The Express untruly accuses The
Tribune of reviving the story of Mr. CLAWS pref.
erence of Gen Cass for next President, because
we copieda statement to that effect from New
Orleans paper, where it was rested on the au-
thority of Gov. Foote of Miss. Our readers need
not be told that we regard said Foote as good au-
thority for nothing. The Express, however,
gives place to the following extract from prl-
vate letter from Mr.. CLAY himself, for which we
gladly make room. 1t sets at rest, we hope,
all speculation on the subject. Mr.. Clay has no
idea of supporting any other than a Wing for
President, and while he prefers Mr.. Fillmore,
pays hearty tribute to the merits Of Mr.. WEB
sTER and Gen. ScoTT. He clearly indicates his
purpose of supporting whichever of these three
shall be the Wing Presidential candidase-a pur.
pose which never should have been doubted
Here is the extract:
"You rightly understood me In express
ing preference for MIR. Fillmore the Waig eau
didate for the Presidency. This cid before l lsb
home, and nave frequently here la private inter
course, since my arrival at Washington. care not
how generally The fact may be kno w. but should
not deem 1t right to publish any formal avOwal Of
that preference under my wn signature In the
papers. Such q course would subject me to the i'm
puIatIon of supposLg thar my opinions possessed
more weight with tho public than appreaend they
10. TIE foundation Of my preference Is, that Mr..
Fillmore has administered the Executive Govern
ment with signal success and ability. He has been
tsed found true, faithful, honest aud conscrn-
tious, wish to..ay nothing in derogation from MS
eminent competitors. Tney have both rendered
great services to their Countryside one in the field
the other In the Cabinet. They might possibly ad
minister the Government as we'll as Mr. Fillmore
has done. But then neither of them has been tried
He has been tried in the elevated position ne now
holds, and think that prudence and wisdom had
better restrain US from making any change without
a necefsity for 1.-THE existence OF which do not
perceive 1 amy truly your friend,
and Obedient servant, II. CLAY
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
A Gall for Help.

1t is undeniable that Archbishop HUGHES
and the Catholic Clergy exercise a very
wide and profound influence upon the mem.
bess of their church We come to invoke
the earnest and persistent exercise of that
influence in behalf of the peace and wei
fare Of the community, in behalf Of the
prevention Of crime and the diminution of
pauperism and its boundless woes, in be-
half of thousands degraded and being de.
graded into brutality, deprived of reason
and the moral sense, doomed to a life of
swnish loathsomeness and inhumanity, and
death by foul disease or outrageous vic.
lence. We cannot think they will be deaf
or Indifferent to this appeal.
At low calculation there are four thou
sand groggenes in this City kept by Irish
or German Catholics. Who will estimate
the thousands, mainly Of the same race and
religious profession, that at these sinks of
evil daily imbibe poison Of soul and body ;
Who will estimate the irreligion and vice.
the misery, the suffering Of helpless wives
and children, the brutal outrages there en-.
gendered' Who will draw up the fearful
balance sheet of evil! Alas it may be
read but too plainly in the melancholy sta
tistics Of the prisons, the aims. houses and
the hospitals.
Over this pOlluting mass it is in the pow.
er of Archbishop Hughes and the Catholic
clergy to exercise healing influence, of
which 10 ether persons are capable. We
implore them to put it forth. We implore
them to raise their veices, clothed with the
solemn sanctions of the religion whereof
they are consecrated ministers, 40! only
sgsinst the devastating vice Of intemperance
but against the traffic without which that
vice must die out. We implore them to
speak out boldly, decisively and earnestly
On this question. Let them call that traffic,
what it is, accused. Let them denounce
it as trade in the lives and happiness Of
men. Let them exhort their focks to shun
it, and to regard money 80 gained as tainted
with the blosd Of souls. Let them do this,
and they Will confer upon the community
an inestimable benefit, and prevent more
suffering than charity can relieve and more
crime than justice can punish.
Once again, We implore Archbishop
huenEs and his clergy to speak out against
the trade In liquor. A powerful word from
them At this crisis would be help indeed.
And we ask those who just now profess
great zeal for and faith in More! Suasion.
to second and enforce this appeal.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17

FRoh TKxAs.-By the arrival of the
steamer Mexico, Capt. Place, We have Galveston
dates to the 5th INST, and IDoisnola to ire an .,
At the election for city officers IN Galveston, H..
Stuart was chosen Mayor
The State apporionDent bill did not pass, being
seLt to the Governor just ten minutes before the
LEGISLATURE adjourned. He declined signing II be-
cause it was unequal In its distributes snS therefore
VI COZ shtutionsl An ekna session, 1t IL thought
will be Leceseaiy. -
The internal Improvement bill, appropfialins
about $500 OOo failed to pass the Legislature BE-
cause OF the amendments made In the House, 10
which the Senate refused TO asree.
The Indians continue their depTedanons aioag the
Rio Crspce ana Nueces, and evsa within 50 miles of
San Antonio IN O. Pic March 10.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
Sound Dectrine-Buchauau.

In Aeeomae County, Virginia, wherein
Henry A. Wise and Thomas H. Bayly luxuri.
ate, the party recently held a Convention,
elected those gentlemen and some hundred 9th.
ers delegates to their State Convention, de-
clafed for James Buchanan for President. and
with regard to him resolved that
Some say he once was Federalist; il %. he ia
90 much the better Republican now, that he ~
forty Pears ago The error OF his ways and has not
N mat Tune, seen cause 70 recant his couverron'
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
q The Asmonean accuses The Tribun

of pandering to popular prejudice against the He
brew Race, because . recent paragraph In our col
umns, IN hasty record Of crimes, accidents, &C..
spoke Of two persons arrested for some ofense a.
% German Jsws."-0n the same principle, If one Of
our reporters should happen to speak Of some fslon
as "red-haired," We shall expect to have our efics
burnt BY = mob Of red-haired synpathisers in To-
vsnss for the insult really had no idea Of Civ
ofesse By the paragraph objected to, nor do We
think efssss cen justly b taksa.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17

n MIcAJAH KRELlN, a colored Method.
Is, who bought himself out Of Slavery eishsee.
months ago. 10 now appealing to our citizens for the
means Of buying his four children also. We CON-
mend his case to those who believe In the Slave
Trace.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17

LArsR FROM ST. DoMINGo.-By the ar
rival Of he big Clara Windsor Captain Bristsans,
nom Port a. Prince, We have received advicss to
March z. All VAS quiet. The Domiaicans were in
great gss In consequence Of The Coronation Of tAsig
Eupsror, 10 take place April Is, on which occasion
srasd feast 10 to be given, and ZOO troops 70 30
parsAsd under arms 1t viii DO observed ~ great
holiday tAroashsut SAs country. 1t is supposed that
net less than 20 80 persons will b in Prince
"a hat day.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
NETWORK TRIBUNE.
NEw-YoRK. WEDNESDAY, MARCH It.

II The Messrs. Hoe have constructed
for ~. and are now putting up in our Office, new
Printing Press which believe is the largest Press
ever built in this or any country 1t is designed Tor
The Daily and Weekly Tribune the increased circuia
ton of our paper demanding increased pres'room
facilities.
Our new type will be ready in few days
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17

TExAs.-The Brasos Delta has placed at
the head of its columns the names Of Daniel S.
Dickinson, of New-York, for President, and
Thos J. Rusk for Vice President
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17

DELAROcHE's PICTURE.-The exhibition
of Paul Dearoches great picture of Napoleon at
FoAtainebleau, will open on Friday at stuyVesans
Institute.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
NoTIcE-Has been made a number of

times ceEoernJg the beautiful village OF FLAMNERsBURG,
onflushinE Bay Flushing and much pleased
Inform the pphic thas bsildng sites offered for
sale there By our enteIpsine asa ssral friend JOHN A.
FLAMMBR. Ne i37 18th Persons who desire a pleasant
and healthy location for residence recommend call
on him % his Office; VISIT the place make selec
N. e-Ths steamer Island City will make excursion
on THURSDAY nett to the abosenaued village from the
foot Of Fulton. st., at Q A. M.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17

u Col. Shows case comes up for settle
mont to-day in the Assembly. Mark the dodg-
ers,
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
BUILDING ASSOCIATIONS ESTIMATED BY

THEIR BALANCE SHEETS The balance sheet of one
building Association states thai $50 40 had been made
each share. calculation based ON the figures Of the
zane sheet proves that l0ss Of 80 % had accrued
each shars Another balance sheet pretends to show
share in six month"; but its figures prove that the
Association could not it's stockholders much
- thev had paid IT, Another prcehds that gross profit
Of ~, so 81 had been acquired in .r mon,hs although
reveals that all the cash received capital and earnings
only eoese co. of whph sfsr 90 lost In expenses
One balance sheet pretends to show profit of 233 per
cent noeth, and three Others EXHIBIT similar faciOus
pIofts The balance sheets Of four different
chow dehcieneies amounting 10 s. 700 10 II As
soeaton $3e9 o8 10 loan out 81 oO7 Such Information
and more Of the same nature is contained pamphlet
entitled Bulldog Associatops their Deceptive Character
and RuiIous Tendency Exposed. Published BY PERRY
No. 46< DlOadWay
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
W We would call attention to the sale o

" we would ca1f AttehtOh 20 the safe OF
valuable Improved Property TO be nude BY e. LUDLOW.
THIS DAY, at II eclock, at the Merchants Exchange,
consisting Of the thrsessry bIck Houses aad lease Of
Lots the north of Broadway and Clinton
place Also the three story brick House and lease Of Lot
No. ITO Broadway, between Nh aud 10Th Also by
der Of Andrew Warner Esq referee the lot Of land with
the dwelling house therein on the north side Of 2sh St.
100 feet from Lersgton Maps of the Property
be had ct the Office Of the Auctoneer No. ii Wall
tIl8 and 1867
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
TRusTExs' SALE OF TwENrY.oNx VALu-

ABLE WILLIAksRURGH BUILDING LoTs AT AUCTION
We notice that ANTHONY }. BLEECKHR will sell at
ton This DAY. at ~ o'clock 81 the Merchants Exchange
the following Building Lots In WIlismsburgh, VIZ:
ThTes very desi able Bsilcipg Lots situated South
2dn between sh and OH sis. and opposite the Meth
Eiehtesa valuable Building Lots. three of the same
front Dsvoe st. eight Let's Ainsle st. aud
Lots on Powers st.. between Union and Lerimsr-st
Maps describing the above property and further pato
esrs maj be obtained Of the Auctioneer No. Broad st.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17

TAKE WARNING DO not purchase your
English Tapestry, BRUSSELS and Three pl, and Ingram
Carpets Rugs. Oil Clio hs Stair Carpets and Mating. un
~ have the magnificent, most eLter sive aud
cheapest be found this city at No 80 Bow
cry, HIRAM ANDRRsoNs. The great depot and
of trade pricep.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
EsrABLIsHRD l825.-Ia this, the twea.

ESTABLISHED ISZJ.-IH lIIIS, tHo VWCu"
itch year Of 10 The original pro-
Priessis Of the and suecsssfaliy out.
tie idea Of supply Of solely first quality Hsa!y made Gar
sTperisncs not withsandng the efforts that have been
made to equal productions. that we rhl continue to
keep on hand the best of Ready Clothing
10 be "a in this market. winch aid solicit the at
tSntsn Of those who in Of emergency otherwise
REQUIRE Illustrate suit prices which must SATISFY the
dscerning that the most economical If not the
lowest priced goods
usus supply Of the newest and most desirable lad
res viii enable us TO the requirements othose
fsrng articles made 10 which department the
best talent il sEploysd. w. T JENNINGS Co:
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
Look AT THIS ,-Oniy four shiliines pei

LOOK AT THIS Only four shiliings per
yard for splendid and beautiful TALL WOOL Ingram Car
petne At she famous cheap Carpet Depot No BoweLy'
HIRAM ANDERsoN's Also, common Ingrain Carpets g..
o. g. and g. per yard STAIR Gar pets H. 3D. 2 % 3D. and
s. per yard, and largo Rugs enly 30s. each.
r. When Shirts were invented is un.
knowB but for many years past they have been gradually
improved in dt and style until GREEN, No Astor HOUSE.
has capped the climax By his and
plan Of aremsn nsuring perfect fit with mathsmat-
iea precision.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
II Fer Dyspepsia, Debility and loss Of

sppete general felt the spFiae AdveAcss. there
Ne 90 good and healthy htus Of BusRs
RRNovAriNa AROMATIC CORDIAL night and uorans II
csss,es the appetite and r,ss healthy action 70 the
whole sysss Prasipal Depot No 3S Gvesswich corner
Duane ss ssd BY other druggists. Price, 80 cents Per
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
To DEALERS IN HosIERY.-An intimate

o DEALERS IN xIOsiEhf AL ihskuoSo
acquaintance with the Hosiery busress and knowledge
particular articles required by dealers have enabled
us 70 select sleek Hosiery unsurpassed In vare OF
styles excellence of quality cheapnes and adaptation 70
The market We cheeruy open our goods TO those who
wish 70 examine. Ray l. ADAMS, No. 81 Wllism-st.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17

" CosrOR's kxterminator DESTROYS the
Rats Nice. Cock Reaches. Ants So leaves no smsll
nuisance 10 the only ef.etusl article in the csy o.
coua,,y Alc 10 not to sbe human family Goa
rox's Wholesale AID Retail Depot, Nc &st Broadwsy
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
N Union Hall Wholesale Clothing

Warehouse corner Fulton and Nassausts, New YoIt.
ne attention Southern and Western visit
pg this oily h respectfully hvied TO our inme nse stock
81 Spring and Summer Clothipg which embraces all ths
desirable styles of suitable FOR the season.
manufactured BY competent workmsn and sut In the mss
elegant and modern STYLE and n which cannot an
10 rive entire satsfac N. "A Large assortment oil
Hnys ClotAinr constant " ON hand p L. ROGERs.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
EE CHAMPIONSHIP MxRCHANrs AVN MlNERs

invited BARRON BROTHERS. Portable IT
Tunsces fer extracting gold from quartz and for all
other melting operation They the effective Fur
naces in nae Also Barron nros Portable Eorgss Both
Gan be seen In use at the wnereoms, No IS Ddane-E
EoLIAN PIANos.-Great bargains in Pa
need the room. We have Halst. Davis CO =; an
bert Ce.'s; l. Glbe,ts, AVID tho Of several New
A"~ "~A"''' c'.nSe .ianos. Pianos TO Let
-S.LD BERRY. No. 1917 Broadway,
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17
THE LATEST NEWS.
By Telegraph to the New.York Tribune.
ssfar. Tslsms,A oaos. eer~r N Ha.s,sr a.x Bs.,,,

Csnsuntienality or County and City Bends.
COLUMBUS, Ohio, Tuesday. March 10. 1854.
The Supreme Court have this morning ia.
cided that County and City Bonds, for railroad
subscriptions, are valid and Constitutional
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17

GREAT BARGAINS IN CARPETINGs Pa
rtasoN HUMPHREY. No s7s Broadway. corner Of White
st.. HAVING purchased largely at the late large auction
sAes viii dispose Of the ssme At the following lew prices
Rich Velvcts lss Tape tries 9s BrussSls ss Three
ply, q to g. Ingrans, H. to &C., and Nil other goeas
ouuallv low.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17

ar WoRLp's FAIR Patent Tapestry,
Ingram CaYpss preci.ely the exhibition
at the Worlds Fair. The magnificent aud uaQue
deNens, Of gorgeous eolors IT HIRAM kNDERsoNs Ne.
- Bows ths original Dep for those elegant Carpets
N, r. Beware Of luNations
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17

u Thousands of customers may be m.
vitsd at the time BY advertising the best papers
list such sections Ct the eeuny in which desirable TO
sxtegd business PALMER 10 the Agent authorized ~ the
preprietsss TO make contracts Office In 7Ae Tu1xae
Buleing
Y FowLxR h WILLS, Psychologists and
eullsAsrs Clinton Hail. No. ISL Nasssu-st Nsw-Yori,
onA No. la W aahsns,aR- st., Boston,
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-03-17


marx Of the Senator but n had been the iAts o.
Free Soil. wneD IL could not DO mes WIN Ieasoo'
argument, or intelligence, % be puf eowa oy saee
means BOots were great argument against ffee
ao,I Ard we're always Tes0nsd 20 Dy its opponents.
But the Senator had $50 SAID tnAt ~ soon ~ ne nAo
with his boot Kicked the Free III out OF mo found.
alton. there we're men. VINO, VIA iIssn ms!srA ana
torel came and pointed up the places dlsturbef oy
N a Senator's b0ot-s0 with the Free Sellers, thefe
would be pointers always at WORK 70 repair and 81
Nd any breaches made BY their oppooens no
knew that there were more boots tnsn the Fec
Soilsrs, and that boots would alwaJR ousnumssf
them He would take his defeat easily better taW
II in hon eopstbc dO,es, ann the the great shock
would not be 30 much felt. He hat eeen beaten %
fore. he was bea,en when q member OF the honse.
and the principal argument then was the boot. Bat
the pointers were soon at work, sDd t1s deis1
was rsmedied. The Senate might perhaps lose ais
services, ss they had already lost hose Of the non6
able Senator from Mississippi, tMr. FooteJ Ian
Senator on one occaslon said that be expected one
cay TO pass upon him In Mississippi In some Ju,iein
capacity. Now the honorable Senator (uf Focs!
had DO occslon to condemn him IN hs,lsHppl,on
his death nsa been In New. Hampshire. TIE people
OF New. Hampshire said that az mr. Foots was ~
longer In the senate there was 10 TURNER ussh
having bin (Mr Hale) there. tGrea. Laughter
Mr. BoRLAND disclaimed having any IN
tention OF making uIiiDc remnks o. the Sen''"'
Mr.. SEwAP's amendment was teen 'os''
Mr.. DAVE offered verbal amendments
which were adopted.
Mr. CEYrR offered an amendment tnas
reserved sections should not DO subject 70 pnvsn
snTy till after having been offered at pubic ss's'
Adopsea-Yess, %; Nsys,6.
Mr.. BRoDBEAD offered as a substitute iof
the whole bill bill introduced 10 the Tniftiesh Coz
eItss. providing for the graduation OF the PRIV
the pubic lanes.
Mr.. GwIN opposed. He would vote ief
the bill As Il stood and then for the Graduation Dill
. separate nessurc.
Mr. PRArr asked if an amendment v"
in orcer. -.
The CHAIR answered that il was. z