The daily union. [volume] (Washington [D.C.]) 1845-1857, 1852-04-24

could be governed BY the action OF The Senate thereafter
the Senate would upon this strongest case and the
Senate by very decided majority, may be seen by
efring 10 the Journal voted against the payment OF ar
For that reason thought my duty TO interpose
hs objection, and remind the SENATE OF It's own decis
i've vote upon the subject u Il i ls..b E. esr t.l#
Mr.. cASS hope and trust that
g The PRESIDENT II a debate arises. the bill will
Mr.. CASS. lido not understand the objection to be
Mr UNDERWOOD. Let it go over.
! MIR, HALE This is not the Armstrong case
| Mr.. CASS L beg pardon. thought il was that case
The PRESIDENT. II objection is made 10 its consid-
GRAFTON, and any disposition shown TO debate It, must
Mr.. CASS. know that thought il was the Arm
strong about which the senator from New Hamp-
shire Mr. HALEl and were conyersing few moments
M UNDERWOOD. I want TO know why we make
different rule here from what prevails in the Pension
Mr.. BORLAND. | will make one remark as a sug-
gesion TO the honorable senator from Kentucky, [Mr
The PRESIDENT. If the bill is debated. it must go
Mr.. BoRLAND | do not wish to discuss the bill /;
but merely 10 make one suggeston which 49, that this is
precisely like the OF lady ia Kentucky, which
brought here by the senator from Kentucky, [Mr. UN
DERwooDl reported from the Committee on Pensions and
Mr.. UNDERWOOD | prefer TO have il go over.
| II was accordingly passed by.
THEODORE T. ELLIOTT.
The Senate then took up Senate bill No 2o7-being "a
bill for the relief Theodore K. Elliott" which read
Mr.. BAYARD called for the reading of the report
The report accordingly read. showing that the bill
was for giving compensation OF $500 Tor keel6oat
which had been bought by United States agent for the
purpose OF transporting supplies to the Cheokees, and
Tor which boat nothing had been paid.
MI. BAYARD. lwoud ask whether there is any evi
dence of the upon the part of Butler, the agent
being recognised by the department IN any manner The
testimony here is merely &c pa's and not acknowledged
by the government would rather the bill be passed
owe mill look
Mr.. SEBASTIAN. made the report in this case,
from the Committee Indian Affairs, and say that
the evidence 10 the contract was penary full and sat
isfactory TO the committee. The committee called upon
the department., but, upon looking at the returns Of Mr.
Butler they found that he had claimed no credit for the
amount claimed by Capt Elliott for the boat That made
it conclusive that he had paid nothing for the boat
/ Mr.. BAYARD. | would prefer TO have the bill go
IT was accordingly passed over, ,..
BARBARA RELY.
The Senate then took up Senate bill 2os-5eing g
bill for The relief OF Barbara Rey" which was read the
second lime. 66su# 42#
Mr.. FETCH. | desire to have this bill so over, |
| II was accordingly passed over.
ROBERT MiLLGAE.
The Senate then took up House bill No. 5s-being
/" Anact for the relief Of Robert Milligan;" which was
read The second time
Mr. DAWSON called for the reading OF the report.
The report accordingly read.
Mr. DAWSON. desire to have the bill go over, in
OtueI tudl we nave W Cufcl
The bill passed over accordingly.
MARK BEAN AND RICHARD II. BEAN.
The Senate then took up Senate bill 2libeing ga bill
for the relief Of Mark Bean and Richard h. Bean which
was read the second iime
The Senate then proceeded consider the bill, in
COMMITTEES of the whole, and amendment being offered
reported to the Senate and ordered TO be engrossed
for The third reading.
JOSEPH coRpEREY.
he took m Sen rasalufan M a.
being "a joint resolution for the relief OF the heirs OF Jo
scph Corierey;,' which read the second time
The Senate then proceeded in committee OF the
whole, to consider the bill, and no amendment being
offered il reported TO the Senate without amendment
Mr. FETCH called for the reading the report, which
No amendment being offered the bill was ordered TO be
engrossed for the third reading.
NOAH MILLER, AL.
The Senate then took up Senate bill No. 220-being
"A bill for The relief OF the legal representatives Of Noah
Miller. OF Lnconve, in the State of Maine and for the
relief OF other persons which read the second time
The bill appropriated the of $1,000 TO the within
named persons Tor making prize OF the British schooner
Mr. BAYARD hope the bill will 90 over
MIR. HAMLlN. The bill has three times passed the
Senate and twice passed the House hope the senator
will moi object TO It's consideration now
Mr.. BAYARD. have read the report accompanying
this bill II is long one, and seems TO me to involve
questions of considerable doubt in my mind especially
the question as TO how far government should go in
sanconing and encouraging The system OF private war
fare public which consider 10 be doubt
full policy Tor such government as the United States.
i The bill was passed over.
MARTHA L. DowHEs.
The Senate then took up Senate bill No 22i--being
"a bill for the relief OF Martha L. Downes !" which
read the second time.
Mr. DAWSON. hope the bill will be passed over, as
wish time 10 look into IT,
Ii was passed over accordingly.
r. NORRIS.
The Senate then took up Senate bill No. 22j-beng "a
bill forhe relief oil Robert T. Norris J" which was read
the second time
Al the request of Mr. DAWSON the bill was passed
over.
LEWIS II. BATHS AND WILLIAM LAcoN.
The Senate then took up Senate bill No 226-being "a
bill for the relief OF Lewis II Bates and William La
con - which read the second time.
MIR. HUN TER desire to have the bill passed over
The PRESIDENT. Does the senator desire to discuss
the bill
Mr. HUNTER | do not know whether will discuss
il or want 10 look into IL before decide upon IT,
TIE PRESIDENT. When debate arises, or a
ator says he intends TO discuss bill it is TO be passed
over.
Mr.. ADAMS. Is ii MOTTO be passed over when sen
The PRESIDENT The Chair must abide by the res
ou,ion, which does not relate TO objection Does the
senator propose 10 discnss the bill
MIR. HUNTER. Well, sir, cannot tell until exam
inc H. suppose II is enough TO say that object, and
want 10 examine IT,
Mr. DAVIS. understand that bill very we'll la my
judgment it requires some notification which | wish
10 propose
u The PRESIDENT. The bill will be passed over
| MARK AND RICHARD H. BEAN.