New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-07-03

scriptiOn OF boot shoe Driven from suspendefs,
they could not Drive Mr. Dav into desertioD
of the settlement He still adhered 10 his duty,
~ his right of shrring. Although they had com
nelI.d Inn to abandon the old form Of il, still he
dd pot love at once 10 repudIate the contract, re-
coolized it, vnlidJ, a. an honest, hbpofable "any
and said l., ms, u, II cannot make Shfrea yooos
in the form contemplated b, fhe pnTt'es,i ~hs
come ~ near 10 It a. ! can w 'ne 'o'"' ~
sLi,t.d g.ods in another appcHtion Ana tnis
man who il said To be inhui need by menta' re-
seUnt,ons with IN intention - cheat-tnis mfn
whom the licenses have dr0OuDced III sue" tD''n"
as the Bench mpy employ toward those very
censes a. having cummings and Taihuieh'y 'o'"o"
their own c nriacts-,his man, whom they coHse
with mel tai re-, eratIDD aud intentions 10 coea',
] cay. when driven from that form on cOrfu aoSo
manufacture Just took another. nope ue IL
cehs,s let HIM alone, and that GOODYEAR projected
him IN that Other. But let Us seq. NO; ne en-
cnunterd IN that new field n competition more
cunning more shallow, more Dlsrhleyous, than ne
hrd met on the ii Id Of the suspend r. andon that
ne~ feu OF competI'on instead OF having merely
the licen es to combat with. he mad Goodyear him-
self by his agent and associate, Mr. Judson-
his agent, c -adlutOr, aud ass Iclat- for many
ye,rs-Mr. JudsOn directly aiding aad abetting
m the competition which NJ wa now beginning
IL euier. Now, may II please the Court tha
nroof Is exactly This: thai cerJtu Hr. Richard
Soils from ZONE time in 1913, or, possibly, early in
the year lS,9-the time Is a II c midst nct-Out
inst about the time Mr.. Da, disappears as sus-
uebder maker, ana emergts as maker Vi congress
ioots-nlst al out that time, this Mr. hIchd' oohS
mhk.s ii- appearance in the market as the manu-
tsctmeT and yrBder OF d form of shrred or CORFU.
gated GOODS which THY called d-lcately bIasseo
ooodsn and he piocreds ~ The manufacture OF an
a,rlcle cuuniugly made aud little different ron
Goodye ar's corrugated goods, b I the meTese ANU
shallow est niIiuA euent ON GDody ears patent ever
attempted, winch he was called on I'D prosecute AS
IMP. haa nsskl fsll
shirred or corr ugattd gOods-rhe same thing that
Mr.. Day had betaken himself ton article oil
shirrrd or corrugated cOJh made elastic 0y
uni, n with India rubber cOids united by process
not different from either Of tncn-an article known
I'D eyer market ~ the world aS >hirren UT CORFU
gated goods. % seSsing every property as Day 5,
,ny not quite good, elas &c rs his was elastic,
although nor unte So elastic, aud made - by the
same means | say 'hc testimony proves tnat
from the yral 1913, thi~ Mr.. Richard S"I' emerges
;nro competition with Mr.. DAY, VIII en- he continued
W til an appr, cabI, Irj Irinus influence upon
NJ DAYS business, and from that time tni nc
abandoned cOr,ugutiun III every Torn, an1 oetook
hun eff 10 o. business, III which nope ne
is IL have Mt last the prUtecron oi this Court
Now, We have d, zen Witnesses, by whom
thes, facts tn the part of soils n ave been estao-
h.htd beyonn a doubt. rney are; D00oughtn,
Dodd. " ard Met n. d, tR,bert aud ID ivld,) Town
send Boz arou, Carlton. Kent, Colh 'un aud Bliss,
AMI there Is not h pat Ir Ut cont ad,ctory ev-
Cencr he other >Idt, ing 20 create tdpuDt,
! trt+pdIrg 10 shJ~ that that WIS not the course
! OF Mr.. SUl,>'s usDess. I'hste Is controversy
as To- vi ether aud 10 what eACent Mr.. Soils was
all Inventor but the general fact, mat just ABOUT
! co Incident with The tune mat my client was ex.
! ue led from the manufacture Ut Suspenders-stlt
UNIV lIag 10 desert the yer of the license he nsd
! suhsstrO under just then, may IL please your
honUr-, b\ one OF those colncideuces tnat shouio
! not as a feasonrr on facts, undertake To exp am,
/ u.I. lrI ns. AT
| ostIt, and ayo~mg purpose Ia pursue MI.
! Ia, let INN engage where o. III what form OF ln-
| dia rubber manufacture ne might Ju't then MI
Sol,s is found largely engaged IN tne manufacture
ni this new rm oi sbired goods 80 thaC AFTER inc
lst Of Jubunry iS49. ne got de tdcto no more pro-
! tsct,,n thnn before. Nhllr his cOveaant IS,
| TINT he il not Ia work outside Ut ms license
while he - protected there has not been day
| or a MA MT, week day ar Sabbath, raiay
day or dry day, from the time he made IL
TINT he has had the forms even o. protection I;
tl,et he has not encountered the snaIpest anu
dlfectest competition that he has not ielt
| ever, tne h laid down at night ana rose up III
the mornn that he had squaldered all that ne
pad upon the forms OF IL SettieIn-nt that was
worth ess | say mere Is direct cOnnlyance IN
SolIs's manufactures and only ask the Chancellor
| to put that ore Jury IN The proper cou sc Of
| tblr tribunal To LAY whether or not that ~ not
| couni ance with Sohs'5 infringement. Now, IN
the fret place il your hOn0rs please, we show that
C s-uy, III ORDER to min iidcture these corrugated
| goods for this Mr.. Richard Soils to he supplied
! with the yulCaDlZed inple compound rubber
| thT,a which ~ man on earth was permitted 10
consume-~hIch nobody could sell but by the
consent OF GOOdy ear, aud SUis could not have
prosecuted thai competition Tor three quarters Oh
all hnur-but by the uId Of rome 0i that vulcan
lied Triple cOmpOuni rubber, which no man can
! sell but GOOdN ear. Soils applies 10 the Newark
Company, oil all the world, for his supplies they
SOLD to hm u httle wnlie, aud became afraid lest
| they shou encounter Good ,-ar, on whose pa
tent il was Undoubtedly direct rInge.nent,
! md then the, decllDrd to sell 10 hun any more.
| The proofs on your bret Will show you that he
thereupon proceeded make application
through Ger ain Mr.. Ward, professional bro
ther. 10 Dir. JudsOn himself, equally interested to
tie extent OF one eighth Oi every dollar oil every
tariff Tor liz hinsels rhe general agent Of Jodyear
--fglts mr. hts his adviser, slJs by this table
to-day with mluie han tho feelings OF "A counsel
hr, with biz heart palptatlag with all the trenor
OF an interested PARRY. Mr.. Judson, on behalf
of Mr. Sons, apples To MIR. Goodyear himself for
De,n,issiuu 20 sell india Rubber threads ~ SOs, to
break down LAY, ami he sold them, or authorized
him to sell IN, IN, and It directly enacted
through his agent, Mr.. Judson, by their license,
with full aud perfect knowledge OF wat ar. 30.
liz was DONG with those threads, with full and
erect knowledge thar il was TO lDJuie and com
pete with Day. All OF this SIR. Jndson and Mr.
Goodyear did do. For gam aud hire they aided,
abetted ami comorted SOILS in the enterprise
of competition, aud they supplied nun, for money,
with mat erals ty which he competed with that
man, in his last rxertion to raise revenue Tor ms
fanny ana yet keep the letter Of tne c ,,at nS
Z Il, nm that evidence. Here IS nOC merely want
OF rrotection, but direct, active, most intense
I'D ,narrmI7l competition, in the face Of the Gov
ensnt. that uood, ear, by no argument, ny no per
! ,,.s;,,u will lend hIs ad 10 no cohPe',op, wiz
, , ~, ,, y,nce and contribute no ad or com
Syt II 10 To- ANYBODY Tho undertakes 70 d'place that
i nncs Ell, now, that being 50, ,anthey talk Of
an estoppe 600 have mere, On %s ma court
u.sd,, - Ali. r.. they can get II. Can they talk
| - - of a mans proceedings when he ~