New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-09-18

Of ths con- pouo, y,r n hs Court TO the evidence o.
EI,b. Pratt TO whom invoke paftiea AZ If
gentleman of unquestioned and und0u0tra lniesY -.
sN,r a. bs. lived many years IN the world aia -
LnovTn a. early 1854 pstertee o. a.
- - ,snes wi be found recorded IN the ~. sn ~ ~,
g. ..{nysrtOr,i IN that, thea, rev Of ~ 50.
.,s-t,on ,o ne business Of rbhr, ard max
M en- invent H. which be deerned 20 " S - u
peent for IL srd an e. aoi.i ~. rr H. ri.bf. aad
,,toeHect He scld ouf for coIoerAois s.'H - -
1890 10 n. Il uncers estsolislulrht sn9
nert covrnsu'ed no longer 70 use ~ - a.
At nat time discovered the irp!e con 800
80, 80 s,-cov.-ed tie effect q hat upon rHpDHi TO-
Ne then went 20 the CRY Of New York rhere
si.-iop VS. 70 Re led t7r TIE p1IPos :, $50 -
49, Sbrs: he then entered into 50 srsn2eIsI
VII Known firm Of haiers IN tnat ~ Ia ,bs r..nlt
r. 80 e.t.bhshnent n Cans y, ana tne L'l'
,b.t INV mid rooms for him IN the neishp1fhos
10y were very na apartment. o,e ~ t 80 10
g.. y, length AID breadth with very lsrEe li'-l tlos
- ~ Trnon one cccgson, his hat bodles were lung
10 re-T tie stove. ne s1pposec az ne - -
70 - ,be hat hsf ruined them. lie menu med ms 70
srrs Mile & Co. III m'shsp ihat hah IA'Ien ~, -.
5tv however wolk the hat loies up snd % ,ne
at, isbmenf tha they were " Pc. s t . 5-r tou,h
| ,,s,rfsrtured They exc -dinKy HsH- - 80,
- yeTsrk Div f@aile AID Il accident ianit ia,t n.
$50. ri reat npor the rubber conpJunf used IN
- "a, f,d,e. at had wrought the change. Ihe's h.t
t5ss were c-ver-d with composition OF rDoe' slYnl
ard esd-the trp.e compound ne Subsequently ep i.e
h. exfcrr1 erts Among othr tess, ID. ''Aeu - oJ
- y.t,r rlaced some egfs IN the water, ana nHeIhs
,. bessd 10 red bat he eggs were coot'a ala
onthy egiiee lie Ts 80 und 70 hsve been only
rot areeed, hut the compound OF tuoDet y -
| he fact
s 80 .sor Ten months when the witness re uraei
| IL Caubrdse Having Sufficient heaute SppaIs., 10
unable there 70 IsP0SSs Ne YS1s sef out
IN Of the history Of his remarkable 10 he nlsy "
this fsnc For the present. va! Eser 0.y 70
n T erson o;ser than Goodyear DID not PRIOR to him.
invent PIT in use the trps eonPoana ,. or,, NOR.
Mr. Cutting then proeesaed % ~ os'Oe '' "'O'' wv
| ,iors Of the tts,imony Of Nj Pfait 10 ., =. -.
The Iext vin-.is Mr. James stewart Sh9 "ps N oe-
curaLt sf the building In Nsw-l OK N ~hGn ~ a.
NED on hs ope sn1 Re erToboTates In SUBSTANCE 'he
IL tie rn.n who mixed tie compound,
ard o,Lerwe aais.sd Mr. Pratt IN his manuisetop' 10
New Ytrt Mr. Ed ard ear you ne .d7iendsnI' pant
qt,,sb ven 10, and severe examination. an
us6c saving that bis ,e,'iuong upoa ,n'' pom ~
w sh keu Ju think VIII be verJ 'al'aotoEy
ne ne,t wtreu to whom refer is Mrs H.dsy,
ufrse iestinouy is be found 10 yonme J. deiend.a
,itrg rae Size knew Mr Pau in 1888 aud speaks 81
E.fxeenmeats a, The bottom Of psse J. Question ~ a.
M Cutti5s also ssrred the evidence of Robbins
~ 81 cnnh Mr Greene. aud a number Of others who
confirm ID tie testimony Of Ar fistt -. -, a,
not s.CT lead II contained the oxide OF ead but not
e cad be found hat this did not eXs'tiy answer snd
H. I h. inv, MED he com position # the tdPe comp. und,
"a an ,rpofiors not yarJ "a very essent aily fo those
refeed to b, Mr Goodyear In his patent In 10 ne 70
turned East Csmbneee aud while cIf' ns On INC e..ao
.Imsnt lie performed the operation OF iSne ne com,
nouTd Some Of tl. ~srkmen Pae pard Ia the sci, and
oil Of them tsso in annef net SEN, 20 lsAs no p,
by that upon ts branch oi the esss my iraneo
- 81, lie otber .de ave totally absained from max
ig anythng ike an stts Pt 70 supply saisis 10Y ekPA
son: While they eudesyored 70 be,k the force Of the
te.nony In regard 70 the curing 81 'h. trple COMPOUND
v ss-ItDF that Pratt could nut have salned 'uclent
of b.st bv stove or furnace vgcan1e raober,
th.e ,Hor made to seal HIN IN reference to
| A. Il. early use of al q Triple pound 1900
stI,astoI NE that this banch Of tbs csu,e fht be
r-,t'd upon tiistssmony a, an :. ' 'uF
sniLg 10 ~ the author Of the tnPe COMPOUND n ma
fled ms t against Pra tor an NV eoo, or nsd D'9l a.,
A. u ct ctargirg MN Suh intueen eni' anu MI
PA had proved Whist these respectable wtn'ssi
| He O
| Past ii. eeut Tor the trip compound
qb,,c - s another csss o. Witnesses, who prove Tat
r. rre OF lead sulphur and rubber. known add
| u,u i. L. ie1i I'D 1855 Nr Nathaniel Stocoard en-.
phNed ttese ir,e utlees, IN combination WIN largely
ifu.acufed fabrics OF Tu0hrr TINS iac Is attessl %
No. en-, a., by Ms s,oddard tlus wiic,l by Mrs.
Wlire, who wo he'd FOR him in "a IS, and who ussd the
u,er,nh end hy Mr. Chase, who proves the exact sci
tr slo supported By Mr. TiIetJn Thtse psr'on' are
heir,r If COZ ctoec fespcctaiity Mr. Stcdda-o, b.
c, rasts d evidence appears 10 have been employed
b. its. interested the other "ee be bad beee their
',,usn ec scllsi ard one OF the hes, opellvcs
ttty employed lie u hee iom 81 rep 'ech eer
M ar GuIus, since la 1nne elton WIN them
ur pn,c r w. TO conclude this ranch o. the in7estEa-
fifr 3, rts witue-ses ia Other s5e-ther hay
WARDS ttei hun ph-ey and Cutters WI make up by
them the ruc the trpe pound .oog PRIOR 20 tbs
al estG oscoNtfy Il by Cody end II their eyIfecce
| .la uP 10 what suppose II VIII AL uninterrupted
| Nv, part b. B. tie pIaiL;iii WI cons itute Ptr
~ then proceeded 20 eNaulae the deposition, 4
lie 1e witnestls shsl inv ke and draE IN to t.s-
rt s..rs in ald his eoscjatsIs and catc Ani
J
ns'usc lueB tie has ha7 be goo J'taoe - nave &C
aed, ,ut Of tbs Tua-ttT ,se ,r hsit nov the
o,f-f II fourth 81 the UaywsTd Rather Cou0'uy,
al Et h.s cash CAPT at Of 5oo'o tie Is one u as
oh Antt q tarin. paid sJIoiss insnufa-,1e
a rt+r RIA Tire lIncs Of general tress1r-r 'o
,urt,. OF sucuuelt aud o' meeting the expenses al
III It,r 81, a1d r conducting ~ the general success 81
tetvn,ts,f 40, psterL snd by means OF which vcfy
vefla e,tfen ely We organized aud discpio I'd band
tsrr oi . .ltl,a,n Sch being The pos'a ot hayTaff
D. II eo 10 meet Interested 10 not dsdors t7@ Pho
ue of ils c.mlopnt. Con es,ors eomine ton him aoC
st,t ls piesL Interest entitled n controlling iuh
,ue IN he sccOId o psintn printing, page -
y, srss er - ninety fourth question. Hayward ASKED
use stale mo- mlfy" Nc Mr.. Cutuog here went int
N he Court please Is the ting itself Ii you ool
AZ H.,wsrds ps',ni you WI Ind The proportion
ulrui TO that qrsu,y Il rubber dissoed snb.tan tally Il
lhe way IN about Ike proportion o. white lead
The Court" And patented in 1899 :"
No, sir, the triple compound itself wa
rot PATENTED until 1874 AID the identical eompjuni
ustd 1881. Il the yeuabs thing the genuine Article
Exhibit q, 81 the end OF Hsywarcs eNamin.uJn, volum
ysiptn 2 piAting PAGE 7s6. Is more foil and
ascc,ure BY hsywsId under oath OF the same fact
Tins at 6ayt 10 on the 9th OF November 1874
cate Sten his memory was more accurate than when eS
| amin dlnltH.
Nh Cutie, smother witness the part Of the plantia
an Associate Of hr Goodyear and contribute Of the fan
ip qu sieu teshes substantially the thing Pa
If5reII sstness CD the other SIDE, who establishes III
same prup sit.Or Mr. Stone, extremely zetlOus
part o. wines. plaintiffs hrt vol, page So exhibit
NJ. CctuIn ", l. question also proves that tbs VET
compound forth GoOdy, taen was In actual pu.
| lie ne BY Hay ard IS early As 1870.
| hr William Beers, OF WOourn, suostanaly reiteEate
8 | the facts.
have row terminated this very tedious ard unin.eresn
e1auIbson Of evidence fAr IS II Is applicable to "a
THO pound and cannot ieist the CONCLUSION tina
whther DEF resPectsbIy OF the witnes.es
, manner 10 which they supported; ths dsnitenes
pr.c with whel they hsve spoken IT, numerous cro,
e1amr which 81 lori Intervals they have w1thsoot
tatwe rave established upon ths branch Of the csss
most perfect defense and # thefe auJ thing len
IS ub y cur have entered the camp ID
enemy ard have invoked leading witnesses aad the
| h..
net Cneiuoe this part Of our defense IL entirely
n | pfensbe -
assuming that M GO0iy
d pstelt other respects valid 80 cesbs ~ GJ0dysa
N s9e susceptible Of any pa-csl usel rest; Ia
pToouc Of utility g. q al IN po;E Of fac
manufacturers employ the process or compound
An .srbsd by Goodyear IN The patent.
Bis rscdesin in describing the process By which q
~ cmpoon Of mst-r 10 be made Is % defective tbs, u
l. .-a..a.- - .. 4. 49, Il =