The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1852-12-30

PROPOSITION Adjourn TILL r,,y FIrsr ov rruuuAsv
.o.sow wss .n. ns sik s.sS s.ys 70 ..S submit. re-
honcsy Of February next
Objection Was made
yERxp-ExciTISG DEBATE
Mr. sr.SLr (whig) of N, O., offered resolution that
rspotin the Dal Globe as part Of tbs proceedings Of
the Hoyss speeches not made in the House without the
ssys % q he House he said It appeared O% the psv
and conscaiOn BY ks Spanish government sf tbs bark
report to state that Mr. Smart made the speech
sPpelded which occupies four columns In that paper
and the report adds that question taken ana the
resolution adopted Now, not word Of that speech
was uttered on this floor and he mentioned this in
spirit Of personal uniindness Thore was no chance
thertkre, under there circumstances 10 iepy to the
gentle man The administration, of whore manner Of
conducting our foreign relations should be proud
now going ortof power and it was improper TO attack
In TINS way. without chance for its defence.
Mr.. SMART, (oem.) Of Me-. by unanimous consent,
mitcd the resolution in relation the seizure con-
hscaon tf The Georeana and suan Loud which belong
"a to h' sectiC9 Of the country he had srss. icslty
stcmtn MT but inter- u2ted; he thought by the gen.
tsman from forth Carolina himself lie then did what
wac customary In this House during the whole Of this
Copgie ho stated that he would lend his remark, to
the reporters, and hc die lie had to say this thing
He would say to the gentle man and tboss With whom ths
gentleman acts that he willing able and rea1y to
DEFEND What he said in this House 81 her verbally In
wiling He felt himself abundanty able to take
Of himself This he avowed man This adnini.tra.
ton has been grossly remirs in not taking Of the
seized there two vessels without the shadow Of authority
and appropriated them to its two years ago and
TO tins time not one cent of decentralization hes been
obtained for his constituents what is the goyorument
fUr but to take Of rights and protect every ct
zen however humble! He repeated he sent the psech
TO tc published because there opportunity to de-
liver In the House and pnce the facts before the peo
pie. You may say what you VIII about the Spanish
goyernmenthtre is rot iolitary case OF grosser
elsewhere.
0reaDs to Chagrcs-
Mr.. HUNTER (whis) of Ohio caHed the gentleman to
order on the ground of rree,ancy, amid cries OF so
on,""go on.n
Mr. sMART-I appeal to the gentleman permit to
state fact
Mr. HuNTsR-I am willing for explanations, hut not to
travel away from the subject before the House.
Renewed cries of Go on,o 'goonn
MIR sasT then detailed tho circumstances atten ling
The seizure OF the vesses by the Spanish authorities az
tain and at Havana and their being cent to Spain
Government instead OF demanding the reeasc Of these
citizens waited until they pardoned These vessels
should have been captuIea by the United States author
ties and this is the sentiment OF the American people
These vessels worth $4,000 and to the tims Of
their seizure had been in Spanish waters lie
asked whether the Spanish government sczs try aud
punish without ice Jurisdiction These yeusels com
mitted no eaence against Spanish laws nor were they
pirates II he could he would authorse fis government
to make reprss in behalf OF the citizens VINO have SUIT
tered. ana he thought the duty Of the government to
take up the subject Protect a whether rich poor is
the true principle Of government
Mr. STAaIY said he was sorry tho gentleman was
not discussing the proprety OF this administration
re,atipg to these yesclsthe Gsorgana and Loud
about which the gentleman made loud noise
daughter
Mr. sMAKT interrupted by saying he had only done
what Others had done under similar circumstances
Mr. STASIi resumed saying the gentleman had talked
about fibusteIing and lasbcd himself into excitement
but this should not throw him Oh his guard He wanted
the abuse spoken Of corrected The gentleman alto
that the abuse ought 10 be corrected aud he had dis
ciameo all personal unssdnsn.
na~a trato whara
beIs had publivhcd speeches they had not delivered
Mr SrisLs resumed. A habit has been indugsd for
10 make speech TO cay thsy would file one wshirg
u put into tue Consresssiora Globe They would ask
The resolution which he had offered orbds reporters
from putting into tho Dab, Gfoe speeches not made
1r their constituents 81 read them which is bad
nabt they pat in the appendix to tho Globe The
gentleman from Naine said no (Mr 5tanly) interrupted
him sitter he started to make his speech He is mistaken
AS well he (Mr staaly) could Iecollect the gentle
man made no effort The gentleman from Tennessee tMr.
HsrIi:l Objected The gentleman from Maue did not
even say, head and t,l up, Air. Speaker
Mr. SMART (Mr stanly giving way) said he did not at
tempt to make statement The confusion was great in
the hall. and gentleman objected. lie there
porter.
Mr. s1.SyDid you ask FOR leave to Ale your speech
MIR. SMAnT-I did not
Dir slssIY snid the specch maze by this gentleman
was similar to the one he published yesterday The first
diluion Of the latter. He then briefly reviewed
the speech and defended tina Standardization lie lMr.
stsnyQ supposed the Maine Legislature in session,
or tcme election was coming aud the gentleman
wishes TO show how he stands up for his and
rights He hoped the gentleman would come TO the
Georgisna aud susan Loud but he tiir. st.nly)
did think 1t fair to sit s when the administration
assailtd when rot void OF the speech was m ade
in the ball MIR. Fmore's administration is going
Of power and the man who susains it csuaot be
crooiing The pregpsnt hinges of the hneo,
That thrift may follow fsWnng
The outgcing administration is In ite last gasp. The
~bg party was az badly beaten as any party earth;
mt twill -tpH
moa glorious recolecons Of the In which our
foreign affairs have been conducted by the ainnistra
ton lie would tell the gentleman to look out for II the
democratic party should follow the libusering princi
pie to which he had given expression there no
nest democrat but who would rather be supporter Mr.
Fl moIes administration thon Of the party which tri
Mpbed In 1852 lie (Mr Stsny) would not attempt, but
leave fomebody else TO meet the 9oah who had
on ths occa'on ready and Wiling and ably prepared to
defend what he bad written or said orally In snclu
cD he repeated he did not think it fair to send speech
ouse Il was too mart sausSter Vas 'p0Neo IN 'A'
Mr. RlonsnpsoS, (dem of III, ssd this prsctice Of
printing speeches not delivered in the House had bsen
induged for several years and for the first time
hsd been brought to the attention Of the Houe He
thought it waa good way to ssye ts,c aud money.
MI BROWN fden tf Misr ssid that last session both
he and his colleague (r Freeman) had led ard pub.
shtd sIeeches not delivered here bee they related
te stas pohtics and were unintsres,'ns 70 sI one
for the Hou2e TO adopt Mr. Stanlys eolution. Great
embarrassment would result from IL TO have correct
and impartial reports II somewhat difficult He be-
leyed only nsace in which reporters recognized
such except here in the French Assembly in 1893
E94 They set about to have correct reports OF what
aaid by every member in debate without allowing mem
bers to correct the speeches They had reporters
took the ist tentcpce, another the second and
Lysn this failed There complaint of parialtty and
he had no doubt justly lie did not any better way
than to allow members the privilege OF correcting their
speeches
Mr. srANLy said he had no objections to that
MIR. srrrESs thought there ,hould BE- objection to
handing written speeches 10 reporters IL the fact
noted
Mr.. srAsLY-Thst il all want
Mr. eTrrHgSs-Withdraw the resolution and let the
reporters take the suggesticn.
Mr sTasLs objected, saJing the course proposed
eluyal mt to the House the suggestion
Mr.. srrrHrNs remarked, as the resolution stood he
shoud vote against it
Mr.. FREnsfAN (dem.) OF Miss, wished TO offer
amend mtnt that hereafter the rules of the House shall
not be SO construed TO admit OF the discussion Of
potcsl or other matters that not legtmstsy before
the Hows
The srEAtys declared this out Of order
Mr.. FREEMAN appealed ffcm the decision and argued
the relevancy sf bis proposition In the course OF his
remarks he said the country was crying ont