The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1852-12-31

t~x---~--.-> s.-r--rsssgs
n..snnw0munn.
n@szuu ssansl. - s.sssur1 !, S.ss.ua
=. "a 3 q = e 49, 49, ! = 49,
-. Z = !sivasss' I'D tAas Beard das n las y
Ass,s1.nt A,ss~n nA,.Arr.-rhs ssnf,eu.. tA,..&
- he Deazd but think they dass - A fhs q
- ccncrnsA have No oAsetien - rssslvag ~ pro-
,.. =, = 4 s, ,ss. -: but sA',E h
Assistant Adsrnsn ReDNAu.-TAs gsstinsa's thzests
AL q the snsw sgainst walls know ny rights. 1
have msdsa netaoa 70 ay tbs protest upea tie table
Assistant Alderman BAaxra present this protest a.
question Of right, and WIN ask tAs CHAIR % have Is
The PnrsDrsr-Any member Of this Board has : risht
to have paper road when IL b in relation - the subject
Assistant Aldsrmas RsDHAs Il object TO It, en- mot
tsposed TO take advantage Of any gentleman bat viii
The PsrmpESr ID the pleasure Of the Beard In
relation to this protest.
Nh BAsxrR-I VIII withdraw this protest The quss-
tien was put and the protest withdraw.
Assistant Alderman MAN-Now then for the motion
totake up the Broadway railway affair move thst
with the action Of the Boaad Of Aldermen in adopting
the report and resolutions In regard to laying rails In
Broadway notwithstanding the objection Of his Honor
the Mayor.
Assistant Alderman BARxER-I have to review this
oOUutoVlOQ
NOR the Mayor and had hoped notW ithstanding the
excitement upon this subject from the very fair and
candid objections stated BY his Honor the Mayer that
some who veted in favor Of this measure might have
been induced to change their opinion circumstances
have occurred shiloh in my opinion render not only
for have been stoned from fa.ber DrScssdna by an
injunction from the Superior Court. We all know and
every member Of this body knows-for we have been
served with inunction-that proceeding has been
adopted and suit instituted In the Superior Court
in the CITY Of New York. 10 which parties have com-
I %or an ' an
commanding us TO do nothing IN connection with this mat
ter and resolution In relation to the same Now, under
n and shall obey implicitly the words Of that inanc-
on and take further action upon the subject either
by voting or speaking believe however in connection
with this matter, that have right to protest against
any action being taken from the fact that do not think
Independent Of that matter that the subject matter 10
that offered this protest signed by the minority Of shis
board In order that might have the right before
denied in any legislative bly, right Of protest by
the minority. But as gentlemen will not permit this
protest to be made will read 1t a. part Of my speech
The undersigned, members of the Beard Of Assistant Al
nSo ZIP sna %
the broadway Railroad and The resolution oonfering the
Railroad through Braawsy nssmuoS a. Tho undsr
signed are Of the linton that the same not legally be-
1852 BY reason Of action had said and
November ls5s to the eighth day Of sovsmSs 1854 which
s:s
sAs Ana s sy q sss
n; % S are Of The op1 that the said
RifiSn s EMERSON A as a Fifteenth zenith ,:,$
ThoS s 0DwARD A Ar r Ala; Seventh ward.
IONA. TRoTTER, Asst. AID. Seventeenth ward.
wash my hands Of this business will have nothing
more TO 90 with It, either in voting or in any other way
ter, have conducted myself in such q manner that
feel entirely relieved from any chickering's OF conscience
and also feel that my hands not dirty as to need
washing at ell. have acted in concert with the muo-
rity Of this board 1t Is true and it 10 also truly gratifying
to me that have been able to make my mind harmouze
along broadway have no sort Of regret for having
acted as have done, for find, in my dstly walks
through this city that the people with whom have
ton Of this railway In Broadway, have dwndled down
to IN Insignificant minority, just such min rity and
than the minority who have signed the protest pre-
sented to the committee by the gentleman of the Fiji
to this paper here that the gentleman chooses to dsno
inmate protest. it protest ut all but quasi protest.
Deis tmar alton Of crazy brain Where is there
schootoy in this city since the Introduction Of free
schools who has been for six months to one of them
who and understand the truth Of what now
test sespst voting here who dare protest ssisnst
my voting but my own constituents! What should
say. If were to 60 home to the Fifth ward and say to
them there is NO more use for OF the City Hail. for
judge Of the Superior Court, whose name believe, ID
CaDpb has decided TO state the aye and for me-
IKE to 90 back to their constituents washed Of ali su
tbority given to them by their constituents am not
disposed to home that way to night aud stand here
my capacity goes to them to protect the in
terests Of the Fifth ward II there any lack upon my
the business Of the Fifth ward the hands OF Judge
Campbell. Others may do as they choose but shall
not DO CO. win make few remarks In regard to the
then l will cay something respecting the gen
tlemen of the two Boarss who arc elamorous
y give my op'nion in regard to the motives OF the
gentlemen, however may err the latter point The
subject matter Of the Broadway railway all pretty well
understand and the community will understand it.
There were some gentlemen in our city gentlemen Of
known integrity ability and business oapacty-who ap-
piled for right to construct railroad in Broadway who
presented petition TO the Board Of Aldermen, aud
upon that special committee raised for the purpose
OF examining the subject matter referred to them.
believe there is no gentleman In this land who will
question the ability Of the committee thus appointed
decide between this city and the petitioners that
the petitioners in favor Of The broadway Railroad we're
notified to appear before them Those pore1 IL we're
also notified to appear before them The committee stated
70 the petitioners that there serious objections
granting that right; and among the most serious
that Broaoway too much ctowded with vehicles 70
admit laying tracks or running through that street,
spd the committee said to the petitioners vs. cannot
give you grant to through Broadway unless you
makettome arrangement whereby the omnibu@, can be
taken cut OF it, That was certainly wise decision for
that committee to to. 1t was a wiae conclusion
that Broadway 20 much crowded and such do
c6ed Babel The petitioners looking about what
might be done in oroer 10 carry their design In regard
to the railway and TO make money for themselves
edto call upon the omnibus propresors. They stated
the portion Of matters TO those people The very people
who were opposing the action Of the committee, op
poeng the right OF the committee TO grant railway,
called upon in regard TO this matter The omnibus
propetors stated that they had objection the laying
OF track in Broadwsy except that IL ntererred With
their I'M erests whicbtf very natural objection for
should ell object to that They continued to talk in
GARD to the matter and bargain concluded between
them they se eeDg that railroad would be preferable
to stages Themselves and waving their sctons the
road partly for the benefit CT tho city and partly for their
own bargain was concluded between the petitioners
and the omnibus propetors and the petitioners the
railroad took upon themselves purchase the stock and
the entire apparatus 81 the several omnibus lines thus
saaclng themselves with debt OF half million Of dol
lars (Which is considerable of money, and would