New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1852-09-18

y.rni.aus carriages 'e ~ osH s.s
sss - ,s-. .ss,s rseqtassi AID also
osss ,,st varety eoor "a The lnsnsi's,us "a here
seaesse 70 II ~. s.,D, ctsntt ileA fa'o LII 10
a. a., 90 90 mruseteis ?sfiJ 70 20 It'd hi,
nah.fs,v 81 %, ~ .s ,ns e.s.. iars-t eSay'
made sr..t lss,t,. . o. ;l, IL
ss~rs garage AID ot s s,s 80. ru5ss 10
,ar,s 80 ne dyer Sc.s = ~ Is or h,s
Sept. nb.r 1875 'g 80 r.as II ols rabD.r White
10 iSsnses Eh sDbsf 9 ia "a ai.oo.L.r
d.r,s; :, re - The pr..eai ave con4naei
10 rsssetsrs rbes' 1000. 80 Seb ,. .vs BEEN ID
"a ,sI'.ss ~. ro'i. Phaa.sa s.t
O.sr. ,se otst. ! Ss psar sT Hsrsa 10 ia, sy,,t
~ ssss two s'ifs e.'e' ,of ar ~ ~ :. go.
~ go. we're rubber clo'h AID msis s1tc ur D
,,,,so or wskles hase pats Aboutte samt ufHe
az early 1874, made SahIni osps 1pon '-s s.
lseosd etched SIP q lno. 's,rr HaYWARO
cot sue;eLs1. SAiaANALL nav
Stsen. 30. s1,,ory =, Sow lsA-Ths above a@i4r;
.vor 10 b.s,e ~. FsnLir, JOSH Of te rae@
have pisced before your HcDon very 9iu a4se We
Of evidence Which in my uogmsut IS conclusive uPoa s
ems. I'm that this fse Of rubber and 81 pnnr cued s1a
Id In tba manner set nth Hay ward patert
Of Iye was known far back AZ lSt ana 10 ID -
1881 and 1882 VI. MADE 10 this essonenl e. "a aIlcs
~ constant ,sIe contpusy PIT before the pusi entered
into the psrtet became source Of prom ia -, III
view g pint 10 :uen w'y S,,'se i. s.ce,sis Of oar
proposition upon this Of tscs IS thai inc ,ae " ~
hing patented VIZ, the ruDnef m1eo VIII suP.l ~;
practically applied the only use OF winch II was 20 20
bic viz 10 The ,bspe Of Goth or fsDnc proI 70 i'o 10
priyed Hayward and the plsnth as hn S''e7'' u -"
On he ,eI ode they that putting int? Pu'e
use 10 not such al st or such series OF acN AZ
sbs Of his title patent subsequently taken
"a n, der,tsnd The argument be this thst II rub
her and sulphur mixed soresd upon clotn ano oeo
siII nrodpes rev and useful msnufscture the puhas
of the fabric 80 made without diseos the pro-
By whieb It is made, will not cepve ths @ %
his rfbt 20 patent These goods were nade not Tor e
~ 1ut a
modify sod for purposes OF gem tns srsune.
on h other side IT, that II methods discovered ~ %.en
new fabric can be produced IL ms7 be made aad soo ioI
.smapy wears ., you long A. the public DO rot
discover the mode in shch the eonmodtI - maze leu
nav stock the Market ard still be In time Tor paon
II Is sid that the pubic not possessed 81 the 1ven
ton only Of products Of it. and ath9aeh t1s 81
tor the fruis Of his oc0veIV ara "itnoos
sse,et from the public until be IL sstted with hi faits ne
hiss sill TIE night 10 20 the Patent Ohles ana Obtain an
~ an sy,. be that avoids Detection
may be used for profit nor any lepgn OF tne "o 'i
pairing tie night nj any time aftefwsrd 70 paful ,
Thiss very remarkable proposiiion, and Que NAV "
impossible to MAINTAIN upon principe ~ sg,hol,y ~ Is
clear tat sale OF tue c0mpOston OF pHos quo
rubber spread ueon cloth and dsd ssis or e Of me
thing invented within the meaning OF the Psten' me
u,e OF the fabric IL Of the invention az ln,' the
isnsn.ss ard well settled Of the Patent laws
TO permit inventor 10 withhold his osco'ery iGh Ino
public. use II for his private EN- "a I'm 70
claim the reward Of fourteen years addonst eX u.s.
sn,bo'i,y .Je it, Websefs Patent Cases o.
Morgan against SeawaId hees0n Wesby pace ~ l.sud
on PATENTS, psge g. HOlrs Nisi Pdus Cases WOOD
nv si'soton las been called to note in Curtis p.
t.nts tiop sos introduced by the other side, which II Is
s.nns sd RANGES the doctrine that the dsooverer csn
actually sell and realize profit without prenSloe % h's
rights to patent % long pu.e 90 az. Of
of use and enjoyment OF It. he can siill OBTAIN pa.rnt
have looked into the cs.es contas'a 10 Ms ho,s $40
submi thai IL II 10 net an suihoy which the oeoun
can Ftl, II me- the contrary 10 iofns aVe'y
pointed decision IN favor q H. Seeadsn' u
with Me 20 his profit long as he care putting It's
pro ducts sale and respns the re"Src 10 the'eoJ o''
A,tbe J,.1vpa on the other side ba, cot bosht scss
70 sustain their proposonnow ~ pos-be az 81 lnsen
op can kept by the hSehoI aad used az long -
he eboose and be etiled 20 patent IL would be al on
cour,sement to p,,tss Keep ther disc eii-' ~to then
own breasts In order 10 make them source o. on. 20
tbeus.ly,s fthe sale Of the fab es mad ordns TO the
identical combination patented, be not asse o. me unen
ton, NJ effect abandonment Know q nc s'at "
things which could have he'd that result -. Il.
next proceed discuss the question who was the as
ooverer o the triple compound ard then viii turn my at
tspton 20 that which 10 most impo artwho was the
discOveeI Of the hea"g proess we say ts' US I'm
position and used by Others long eeior, me tune
af the plsrtihs ALLEGED invention whica was IN sib OF
1874 ,,-... $3.50.
TN, branch Of the geiher with tbs other additional
and auxiliary circumstances The INST elsss that ha 70
Ter TO- thai when has been 40 especially attended to o.
Tbs otbei side and subject Of 90 MANY severe ant
caue remarks Their testimony Iela,esto the discover b
Collins in Baltimore In less and the next class refers
the discovery Of the triple compound by very espeeto
man conceded 10 be, named Frat Tssias ~ oge Of IN
Fs.frrn sstss, but these ~itnesesl mean Collas sn
those who SUI port and Pratt aud those who eotohoat
and confirm him, arc extremely numerous In regard
Collins before examining his testimony beg 10 say wor
or two OF bis history as derive II from MS evidence
seems that 10 September lsS he vat In Baltimore, an
there made discovery Of the compound Of lead rubber al
sulphur which h subjected TO the aston heat This %
CURED In Ne ptember 1881 In October asfwsrds ne wen
10 Boston where he taken ,ick he soon recovered
and he who $ now ade tho subject VI - niue
abuse and IL branded an imPostoG early ia 1884
ss,uss ssisSii.hnen,s a, Gsweii, in Eassschu,stt,
uDo;s q invsDos and PSas SB S ne seS
happened 1.-THE was men OF no etute sne q no nent
i've geDiua or sequirenenr-hSSw nspRe.' u NAV thl
this invention hoald IN the Eastern states and In part
OF The country certainly equal 70 any other IN point OF sN
the Lowell Manufacturing Company to put up set on ma
chiuery for the manufacture of tbs new FAB OF lnda
rubber la 1891 aftei having completed tis machinery
Tor the Lowell establishment, he went TO Newton where
lie made machinery for the manufacture OF nois Idoeer
Foods for another company, who ordered macnuey s'sI
10 thst Itch be made Tor the Lowell Company In 1886
be ade tie machinery fo the Boston steam Factory Com
psny In Ptts binding ths, Company to secrecy In refer
nee 10 the machinery and mode VI operating t This
ser who 10 row treated with so much c3ntenpt Was
s iom all New GLAND, and placed at the head OF
o., attainment annual salaryot ~ GOO while
Hs,wsrd as hi ed Of SSOo year Ibls alleged lmpostor
who tecesary nov 20 as asa iaoc A.o Q. p,etsnasa
Nv one Of d princps factories New England, at salary
Of one thous collars yesf, ior apeod Of i've yes" de
onpped IN this position eNsct bouds ~ secrecy from the
company snd scfieeTs un th-is factory busd down II
les sdyer particularly TO the hos C. OF secrecy required
by Collins because everything that falls from the dsin
ishes counsel on the other si3e (Mr Webster) sntite
sthe uhnCst respect and confederation Nhhe aus associate
was Addressing the Cout uTou ms SUBJECT ne declared tha
he can't TO contradict MI Cous In ihe meat that
had exseed bcp6s 70 maintain hissere, and mat ne 0u
.ho~ that Nj Cors hsd 10 Ibis respeet wi1ly perVeite
the ruth will say that my learned Trend wlu MOI .
nbs 10 Acc0n hsh that tesk bot VIII say tla~ DO a0e'
h, will have read the evidences IN very opposite sense non
myurdsrtsndips Of g. Before leave ths bsach OF ID
c.s. will retrt 10 Witnesses called by the other sds, VII
SIy eoIrohorasd what Mg Collins ms 10 this tespeet a.
serted 90 rot to say that IN this mass o. eyidene
there reflect hsnyny nor that ths teeoteuohs OF
these witnesses excnoiaE over long peloSoi time are pI
eisel, the samo bot viii select enough OF them 70 shot
hst that mode q impeaetes Mr. Col ns VII most
ELECTS which we're saved fom the tie were transported
salem and hi, sne III Co!hns wss immediately eng age
by this Sslem company al salary OF one thousand ds
lars a year lie oonduc ed that fSet9ry until the ye:
ISS1 when the company failed. ard ia that resPe,
followed in the footsteps OF almost every other ests
Hshpr nj pSrufastu'teg, mercantile, or mechanics
Ia the country We all remember that portion
the history Of Ire country. when IL was overwhelmed by
sn,rrisl soccN which made everyh disappear before
Inc ow dnNs be fore tie wnS Thus tsSioy, n 1891 sin
ply follow ed the OF ether establishments dealing upo