Richmond enquirer. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1815-1867, 1851-06-20

fn'tn The decision the gentleman fro m Mason Mr Naz
ER) appeals. -
! Mr. BOLTS. To relieve the Chair and thu corun4,-
tee from oil difficulty arising from an appeal, Il the
gentleman from Halitax Mr. EDarSps) is determined
TO embarrass my proposition by hi; motion to strks
out. will Withdraw it. i want separate and dis
unct vote upon it, and rs it yet under my control
will withdraw it and let the question Upon striking
out proposition A.
Mr. EDMUNDs. The motion that made / under.
stand to be perfectly parliamentary and Che proposi
ton rf the gentleman from Henrico Mr.: Borrs) is
strong enough to carry, my motion will BE- voted down
My motion to strike out however brings his proposition
directly before TIE house and We can take dreot vote
uponit.
Mr.. WISE. wish to say that the gentleman from
Halifax (Mr. EpMlNDs) it perfectly right his motion
Is Legitimate and the direct mode n the world to
test the question. Il will say to the gentleman from
Mason, (2r. FsnERl that any proposition In the world
that get in easily be put out If it should hap
pen to slip in. Inughter.l So that we do not gain
ANY thing by this means ut all
would inquire of the Chair il there Is any thing BE-
fore the house now; but proposition A ...,;,.=
The CHAIR. That is ALL So. -. :.
Dir. WISE Then do hope that gentlemen will try
"A, and see il they can carry that not. move -
strike out A. the whole Of t-all ALL Rub A Of thu
slate entirely and begin again. moVeto strike cut III
Of 4.
Mr.. sTANARp Do understand that tn. PROPOSE,
ton OF the gentleman from Henrico is withdrawn
Mr.. WISE. Yes
Mr. EDMUNDS. I rise 10 a question Of ordar.
understood the Chair to announce few moments ago,
that motion to strike out proposition having filled
. The CHAIR. There was no motion Of that, kiad
made. The only motion strike out portion Of
it this is 10 strike out the whole OF it.. It Is certainly
q distinct question -
Mr. WISE called for the yeas and nays and they vss.
ordered. -
Mr. EDAlUNDs desire to know what will b b.
fore the committee if proposition j, stricken out and
the committee rises r., -.
The CHAIR. \ aud B will then be reported to ths
house as amended by being stricken out,
Mr.. EDMuNDS. Entirtlyi
The CHAIR Yes
The question being then taken, there were yeaa 81,
nays &C. rs follows:
AYEs-Messrs Armstrong Bland, Blue Bolts, Bow.
n Byrd Of Frederick, Camden, Garlic, Carter Of Bus
Faulkner. Ferguson Fisher, Floyd. Fulkerson, Fultx,
Hays Hoge, Jacob, kenney, klgore, Knote, Lstohsr.
Lionberger Lucas, McCamant, McComas Martin of Mar
shull. Martin of Henry, Miller. Moore Murphy Neeson.
Newman Saunders, Seymour, Shelley Sloan, Smith OF
kanawha, Smith Of Jackson Smith Of Greenhrier,
Snodgrass Stephenson, Stewart of Morgan. Stuart Of
Patrick Summers. Tate Trigg Van Wrinkle. White,
Wiley, Williams of shenandoah and Wise-67.
N"Es--Nessrs. Mason (Pres't.) Arthur, Banks, Bar
bour. Rocock bawles Braxton. Burgess Chamhhss.
Claiborne, Cox Davis, Douglas Ednunds, Edwards.
Finley, Flood Fuqua Garland NJ R. H. Garrett, Goode.
Hall Hopkins, Janney, Jasper. Jones, Leake Ligou.
Lynch, Lyons McCandsh Meredith, Morris, Petey Ran
dolph RILEY, Rives Scoggin Scott Of Caroline Scott
Of Fauqucr Scot, of Richmond city, Shell, Smith Of
Norfolk county, Snowdeu, Southa Stanard StrnughAn,
Strother, TAYLOR Tredwar Tuns Turnbull, Wallace.
Watts of Norfolk county, Whittle of Wingfel1-6e.
So the motion to strike out proposition was decided
in the affirmative
Pending the taking of the yeas and nays, -
Mr.. FlNNEf. on his name being called, said beg
leave here upon this occasion to explain the course
which now intend to pursue upon this question Of ba'
4s and do it in order that east and west may un
derstand TINT do it irrespective of all parties. In
tend to vote no with my eastern friends now, but
shall vote against proposition when the qussti0n
comes up on inserting it in the Constitution.
Mr.. FLOOD, stated that he had paired off with Mr.,
Cook.
Mr. EDMUNDS, stated that his colleague. Mr. PuR- :
kss was confined his bed by Sickness but had paired
off.
Mr. KNOTE, stated that his colleague Mr. GnIr.
was also sick but had paired off with Mr. VOOLFOLK.
Mr. ~ r. H. GARRETT stated that bis colleague
Mr. j. SMITH had paired off with Mr.. PRIcr and that bis
colleague Mr. NJ GARNET had paired off with Mr. Prs.
DIEToS.
Mr.. Bolts. now move to fill the blank created
by striking out proposition a. by inserting therein my
amendment.
Mr. EDMUNDS. In order to bring the COMMITTEES to
direct vote, move ~ strike out all except the frss
section of the amendment Of the gentleman from Hen.
rico.
Mr.. BOTTS When move to fill blank. how can
the gentleman move strike out what is not put In
it must be inserted before it be stricken out.
The CHAIR. The gentleman moves to amend yoss
amendment BY striking portion of it. Tint mo-
lion is in order.
Mr. EDMUNDS call for the yeas and nays upon
The motion to strike the whole of the proposition ct
the gentleman from Henrco (Alr. BorTs) except the
trst section.
The yeas and nays were ordered.
Mr. CLAIBORNE. desire to say that have al
along voted for the mixed basis in every form in whioh
it has been presented Every proposition before the
Committee involving that principle has now been de-
fentcd And shall vote for the proposition OF the
gentleman from Hcurico (Mr BorTs.)
Mr.. Dyed. | shall vote against striking out me
pending proposition but do not mean by this vote To
commit myself To any future course of action
Mr. BOW DEN. As il to be the custom OF the
house to give in experiences, laughter beg leave TO
saw that although nm anxious to compromise this mat
ter cannot to compromise upon the PropoaitIon
Iof the gentleman from Henrco. shall therefore Yoss
for the motion Of the gentleman from Hania1' az
EDMrSDs.) a,
Arrs-Messrs Mason, (Prest,) Arthur. Banks. Bar
hour Bocock Bowden Bowles. Braxton, Burses Garter
Of Loudoun Chambliss Cox, Davis Douglas, Ednunds.
Edwards Hnney, Flood, Fuqua, Garland, Mr. r q Gar
aett Goode, Hall, Hopkins Janney, Jasper, Jones'
cake, Lyon, Lynch Lyons, McCandlish, Martin Of
Henry. Meredith, Morris Petty, Randolph, Ridley.
Rives Saunders Scoggin, Scott of Caroline SCOTT o.
Fau1uier, Scott of Richmond city, Shell Smith OF MOI
strother. Taylor, Tredway Tuns, Turnbu. Wallace.
Waits of Norfolk county White, white. and Wing
ield-dp. =, M. d. D.,
# Frederick Camden Garlic Carter Of Russell Chap
man, Chiffon Claiborne, Deneale, FaulkneT fsr{uso1
Fisher Foyd Fulkerson, Fultz, Hays, Hoge, jacob.
Johnson Kenney Kilgore knote, Letcher, Lion6srseT
uc;, MScOmas Martn Of ssSmo s a
tey sloan Smith Of kanawha, Smith Of Jackson Snlih
# Greenbrier snodgrass Stephenson, Stewart OF Me.
gan Stuart of Patrick, Summers Tate IT 8ss ~
Sle WILEY, Williams OF Shenandoah and WHOSE
So the motion to strike out was agreed TO-
Wr FINEEY. move that the committee 90 now
rise. :.;r ,o+ -;.o no1r
appeal to nv colleague to withdraw his MOTION.
NJ Ir TTSSEY withdraw the motion.
". WISE vsnt to know what is now left before
the corninitteei .,.;.,or' A.
The CHAIR. The first section of the proportion o.
the gentleman from Henrico
[CoMiaued to Supplement No. 40.
OAIJTION AGAINST USING COMMON PRE-
n