New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1851-07-04
- ,.;oined, "Does your conscience
= " n"., ai.obey me :" lgreat hilari'y on 'ne
rnaea you ,,ember left the hall.

- se ''. 7, ai.OSey me :" lsreas hilari'y on 'ne
sna ,s;eh the member left the hall
tjsa WIZ sceaker--Go on. Go on
I n Is1 in the midst OF the confusion al
.ame words to the speaker ,.., my
| - '0ns The President reminds nae 'ha' my
-, contrary to the Cons'i. ~ ,h;s Assembly,
go - ,,pce, that member OF 'n' cons,,,u,iop
~ ~ wor,alembert said, that u any no Great
! s' shouh infringe on either Oh !, ~, aroa St
sis'sse ,hs family, Of religion, or Oh p'op''"'
rSaples" " would be null and void IN ''sen,
| ~ Consu Ne was right. Gsmiles ana eAcia"''
,-cn,eal applause on the Le''I m,he
!! rrs n0" The case is serious one All Wv
,,n, are called to serve IN 'ns '', rrn,s Ispeak
,rmy and ough, to kno" 'nell iisn w.. n.,ps Of
y" oply in my own name, but III inc IAN .S;.n
s' no. ,s.y tba, il law commands an ac' WIZ
ar one Of the rights prior to ana aoo''
seaa , would not obey it. IhoSen'e @.,,,,
css'ilu'''i' ~andS an act contrary to the iauAny
Fneip~' w.. -o,s a., act which would be VIOLA
=, n nv religious faith, or II II s.o,. What,
IONS fsi,h OF my brothers whsi,
might be, would disooe' IT. .. ,hoD..
~a ,"' co,o,nands me to do violence 70 'iie h''
II -@a ', reonIe. will disobey 1t. lsenss'oh7
tonan'y q on me Left And If you please
L"ep oPP'1-' n 4, example from recent e'ei'S'-
WI man an all sides.l When the expedition 70
, me- ,,ss determined on, my understanding "s
''" I'D AZ an honest man told me 'ha' 'hiS a0'
'''''. -ol.,son of the Constitution, an outrage on
rSa ,sn~ndsnce and nationality OF people Hahl
-. soldier, should have disooeyed. I'ioie"'
ION or the Right. Applause on the Lett
~ AZ yocrE-Ths rs an instiga'ion 10 revolt
ss,,e. Of the Right, Order Order constantly
increased ....o, - Tho cam.
- of the Roman Expedition IS an insult 10
he army n...,..,.. .,
-. ,be Sneaker, but could not be heard BY the
audience. -
" .rxup-The President does me the honor 70
- Cha, should have been tired by "a Council Of
-, and sentenced TO death. reply, should not
49,. Asserted like coward, but would have broken
49, .xo,d and said to council OF war, Decide upon
rs- fAppause on the Lett The council OF war
!, ooaderonng me- would have done MS office, for II
!. me organ Of the law And |. should have done
M duty in obeying my conscience, which IS my SOW
,,sn Judge Lively appreciation On the Lett
The PsrslprSr-I called youto order when saw
fla, your doctrines were an excitement to rebellion,
10 di.obedience. to anarchy GOOD Excellent on
,Ae Right Energetic protests on the Lett
The Assembly remained for some lime in a state OF
area, confusion, until at last the PRESIDENT was
sustained in calling NJ. ARNAu to order, and he was
obliged 10 leave the tribune 4 heated debate en-
sued. Messrs. De, Flotte, Bedeauj Charras, DEFY
rammoni and Piscatory taking part in It, VI. Char
ras IN his speech revealed the fact that in the days
Of June Gen paraguay DlIiliers refused to take
command OF division even after three Generals
had fallen and there was need Of him. That Is to
saw. he had violated the principle OF passive obeii
ence the Right were contendng for This produced
a new excitement with interruptions and exclama
tons in abundance. Finally, the Assembly was adj
iouned, having the matter unfinished.
Theaixussion was resumed the next day, and ter
minated in the passage ofthe bill, after several amend
nSnfS