New-York daily tribune., 1851-09-29
Another View Of the Hungarian Question.

TIE Tablet, Dublin Journal of much pre-
tensions. .one strength. and assured blgotry, con-
teins a AUDITORY review of pamphlet puolhheo
IN London BIZ W B McCabe, 4 compiler OF
Catholic history Of England. Its Chief contents
are reorint Of TIE Coiyi0 and Enqn'rsr'S nun
ps,iar article, The Tablf adopts ana com
ne1ds the principal assertions 80 recAiessly
,r.9e hv our neiqhbor That they were shown to
T. he false m fact and illogical TO inference
neither NJ McCabe or ms eulogist condescenos
to-ofar,o This would be unworthy their ortho-
dovv But what is Of most importance, l. that
while Tie Ta5,ef and Mr McCabe quote The
Co,r.e, and Enquire and claim credit for It's as
sumptlons. they repudlate It's lnierences, and
rround their adherence Of the Hungarian re'o-
luton on principles the very opposite
Here j. the grand summing up Of our ooiem-
poray .,,
- That; as q republican and Christian people;
no have cause to rejoice IN the iail OF hossuH au
should give thanks 10 the Almighty kuIer Oh i4e Ihi
verse that through that proylcentla even. Ir f
graciously liberated FROM bondage nine millions oI
he Sclayonc race and bestowed upon them PERSONA
freedom, and fair share OF poiitical hoeiH.
The main reason Of Mr.. McCabe and his re-
viewer for coming to the same conclusion IS the
very opposite to this They in effect denounce
,ba, Titanic effort as republican and uncatholc.
They do not say this openly. but II Is the grano
ann of tbeir labored anathema Thus saith The
| ToJlo
"The dealings OF the Hungarian Diet or Eccleslas-
tical matters Mr McCabe shows to have a. llltle
perted the sympathy OF Catholics as theh poh'cdi
Directs could be admired, AT least by nations sunei-
| ing under the yoke OF the oppressor
! Lest any doubt NAV exist as TO the true intent
OF the above passage The Tablet quotes from
Mr. NcCabe the following significant and most
| pregnant proofs;
SUMMARY of acts of Hungarian Diet dffer Re roOt'o
! 49, Act I3 Aboshes tithes to the Clergy without
| compensa,ion or, according to the words mace use
of simply records the fact Of the Clergy having vo'
untaIly renounced taking iithes, without claiming
a cOmpeD Satlon. 49,.
| @. tct 90 Recognises the ntaran rell llgon-that
is to saw UnitarianIsm as declared to be III Hungary
what II has long been IN TranYlvania-one oi 'he
legally recognized Christian sects.
- e. Places all the legally recognized fenglohs-
! (Roman Catholic Greek Church. Caiylnlst, Luthe-
| ran and Uniiananl-On footing OF perfect equaly
| The money required for Ecclesiastical and educa
| tlonal purposes to be furnished by the state which
implies that the Clergy OF all the ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
are to be paid by the state None OF the schools 10
! be exclusively cenfned TO any particular sect out
oren To ALI without distinction Bills for carrying
ont these principles TO be prepared by Ministers ana
submitted 10 the next Diet. 49,,
| The which lDeSe apparently lHlpiItdl
! principles for establishing nhdel universities ahl
| primary schools-like those IN trance-"ere 10 De
enforced is, however, shown by the note winch MI
! blackwell adds to the abstract OF this act
The Caihec Bishops afraid that tins aet VIII en-
courage Potestantem which few years "i no donh'
| be the predominant religion III Hungary
This Is decidedly clencher, and must have
thrown our republican friend INTO pIous costa
sy. Before. however, he weeps over the eXtlnc-
ton Of Tlthes in Hungary, he would do well to
remember that The Tablet, and the pamphleteer
and the party they represent, have become husky
from demanding the extinction of Tthcs III Ire
land for the last 50 wears There the system Is
ahominable very hell not alone an injustice,
but an absurdlty. The idea of one man paying for
sustaining religion he does not believe, presents
moral mOnStroslty, compared to which ne
| head of the Gorgon, that turned men TO stones,
was a mere innocent paythng. That excellent
maxim, "what il sauce for the goose Is sauce
for the gander," forms no part OF the creed OF
| these gentlemen, and while Protestant injustice
| IN making Catholics pay tthes, is subject Of
horror. Catholics imposing the same burden on
| ProteStans is matter of plous reverence, and
ary attempt to arrest 1t Is cause tor the most or
thodox gnashng OF teeth.
But this Is not all that "rascally" Diet which.
according to The Courier, "warred IN defense OF
slavery and oppression, and against personal
freedom, political liberty, and equality of per
sona and political rights and IN the overthrow
of which all good men and friends OF liberty
throughout the world should rejoice" had tho
lrreyerent audacity 10 recognize the right of an
ungodly Unitarian congregation to worship God
Al. .,tfh h.,tr
| And hot only were they guilty of this atroclty,
but as a croWning mlamy they established per
| feet religious toleration, and opened the schools
OF the country to all IN fact, introduced the
American system OF Education. Mr.. McCabe'S
| conclusion must strike our cOtemporary as eN-
quisley logical and emlnently Just Because
some one says tha, the Catholic prelateS feared
! tins system would tend to convert their tiockS to
| Professionalism, therefore, he concludes they are
! ''mfdel Universities, ;" and il is an nfdel system.
| We doubt whetherMr McCasc truly apprehends
| Catholic principle. We suspect, on the contrary.
he bellies and dcfames IT, But II his be Catholic,
we are sure ii is not the Christian doctrine. In
either case, we commend his book TO the care
| and sympathy Of The Courier and Enquirer.
| We NAV also be allowed to suggest to our
cotemporary of The Albion, who can find moth
ING IN the Hungarian revolution like an effort for
the extension of personal and political freedom,
that he NAV not have been aware OF the passage
! of laws like those above cited. They certainly
seem to look like al enlargement OF public hb-
| ety
Exports of Specie.
| u, a., El,Sorx IA, Ts1bnHs
! Il -.