New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1851-05-09
LAW COURTS.
Superior Contradictory Msys.
Before Judge Oakley.
Mp. WILLIS rs. ED WIN FORREST.
IL A IL. 4 n

r J
80, s oh,as tier r'sP'ei "a c0uase s5ns ladies' Tss o
II. compliant state nat on tie i7h Jus. 1850 III. s.sia,,.
aha ssai he psuuf ihst plant diT aofssas
~, p "a'tgon A. rear his rs,i'srcs ~hsa TIE ds's
~ ne plan IL sac-ns and vo.nty assaulted
The 1st lae plan Il bat II. ssai,siI At Is. ,sn, ne
.1a 70 ls trs up.i a27a lst -, n pan "a -
ne sr2sta vhh 40 bst.sry 10 u-d
PerebssId hat so6aut ac1upalsd By 0hsr sf
30. VIZ" Ehoa defendant h,s a. toe Puauf af'n.i AT b.
ecui;sc al ts .bss AN, ,t4 -. si5s, ,ss sb.s ~ "a.
ph1t any weapon Of dssae other OF
sau except The a o. bysaae The sac 3s sai
~ Pss fora oas tins prevented from readsrlg
Aod hs PIuts ia, BY saa. Of sal .,.au
ese hs hs rHsrsi sr-'i bodily ssi en paa az
NON attending % h orinsy pursuits and mss
s-S. ne leleaasat o tes n ~ sioress1 and MAJ Ne
sssneaa, sy = aleFso 70 The PAni Corporation damages
Is. sGup amt signed sy Z F.rehsr attorney M p.af and
sshso essrH as io", CITY ast Coaay q NsT for -
Wills. Of sad City, To Patd Tbs actoa osns
EBoEsors .1csp a. % ,b -hs A.. ihr. .a.. On h
BE- irus NATHANIEL ?. WILLIS.
defendant Eevn Forrest admits that the
compliant he inf csd several upon psa
to va cons without provoeauon and ~ also GENES hsi
son persons eoapred a. tccomPhces 70 assist him BIS caEa
cssraon and ~ has nv ss1 al .ub -, ,s n N 49,,
bodily or uensl or other I'll Consequence Which tally
9ssa y SAD plaintiff - Just punishment for hs previous
denies the circumstances Of crusy and sggayon alleged the
complaint any the blows
the Psrth and he AYERS haiti took pas the following
to fs c6sr,eis srd psss Of mind As .rsnasr .s.s a5d i
with resentment The sad Eans. srcOHntsrsi the p.nf
the and place sa;sd hs npa1 and coming front Of
him before bis face The defendant With n, hand oay
plaintiff ground st d.enfsa; ss1ns
Of The plaintiff iufihsr indicted t. With
Tua percha which the ony weapon bad D.
several blows 90 ts shousrs bach ani s OF the sd PaiH
and the defer expressly that the tbs
and place unexpected BY him that The sad blows
SAID defendant aons and we're entirely nsus1t % 20 severe
orpsrmsnent injury - th. Psrln Of ld plaintiff and that
be r,sa HI. haze 70 he breast with tue s7parsnt purooss -
ins weapon ahd ha; whole the sad
1'sndaht wa' .,hoat any ass ta1:s a s -. - .
ls4t 40 49, ~ v.yy Ts,s5t ..psc,ly dunn ~ "a a.
the pt pua,d .vs,en ci ecrst sis ,.,y v hi
defendant accepted e knduss and hospitality Of
guilty mind Toe plaintiffs compelled dssiias,
March apply the Legislature Of Pennsylvania or divorce
Charges made a. 10 hs alleged course pahI Previous TO
Application, sad before he as edge TO What
charged hs application for divorce dssndart wansi palH
sgnst any ntsreence "a ne dpm'tc EA ~ Apsftnsnsd
ohers ard expressly ptoh tei him M dong uadsr
penalty Of Ps''ona saa hat r-sard', 'aeh warn
,s, ns s.o oy ,s & ~ - y 3. ~ 5
he Hone Journal pub she'd uSat pup0rtei % b oths
al shb ,rs va soa.susJ .s,s,.na,. g. he eoassi
that the casmen' dsss'd and that damages should not 5s
sEaIdsdaeairst hm. &c Toe sas~er i'a.so 7sfhst
Or the Ja mpsnesd s5eepton vas taken By cuae for
suspected as ions unvora5s impression a. % Mr. p AMI
another Juror led in his slaes
Hr ssudoe cpesd the case 20 The jury Thai al assault
ds-d athssgh regard
10 Circumstance and pantH y - ea'd 20 oe d'nas'' ~
% ,rs b,,.r, 80. AZ. Of eoest ccgrres bat rare a, 70
raes ooCupylg the poson Wlth tale sustained Iley
both measure public msnMr Willis distinguished a.
suthor Journal Mr. Forrest by perseverance,
had ned houosbe position another sphse NJ
5 'ueed to ths great hys, s'Esash Of NJ ind At hat m'
As the defense SCI paaton o. .1ease The ,- ~
admit show at the TINS but does not allow
psly 70 Dr9c "a llGn ,.sY ~ 80, Of &c az Ps
gard 10 N. charge that Mr. Wills has t cosvsrsaon v III ME-
Fouslnd that which caused t.isrdan to apPl % another
State for oivoTcst singular fact that The mans Of Mr. Willis
Mr., hs compliant that
the Of another gsntlsman II the Court will permit The
mol shrnk from i snd " y show GO 70 himself and family
that the charges respects him and Mrs Ahhosgh
that controversy Be ore ne Cous n an2hsr snaps and the &
most deeply interested the case and vho's acton VIII that
absent from the cy Mr. W will b. l'hsd meeting the sus
and the Court viii permit IT, will 90 AZ TO the other mattel
oI plaintiff Introduction. Nothing pal
late case Of hat Ind unless happened 80 recently that The %
was made by M w 10 BIS own lstfcsior. strong
rsmsTts referred % the ,ees.y Jury showing
defendant who depend psca strength aat great wealth 70
and as:; S s6 snSas a &c. oG way to nsi.
him feel vii be through bis pocket Il VII be an admonoa %
public.
After the opening which occupied considerable time Mr. pro-
4nn Morgsr ia young iady) ia Bs.cksr ia
three standing TALKING scDouga 81 tao square,
S , , AZ roIs1 = o 80, 49,
observed eusmsn snsr the gate from McDougs ST. va, Mr.
Willis Mr. VII passed the three add going toward UniVsry
place when NJ Forrest w'ksd Alter him. and then ran or walked
IN down tbs blow
~ be came up % hum they we're 90 parallel paths and Mr.
crossed the hr WI cannot whether he vas AZ s side
Of Mr. w h. struck the blow as be
I'D thing 'ad Mr. then took the -nca
Mr. held cut Of hs band sn5 struck hm OF TIMES Be
about he head shouisrs NJ atsmPsi
P3Bybe, Of psops cot round saw pors.u Their. .t.r
hey rad taken them away no one nersred 0s~een hs that
u the police could rot say with What Mr. Forrest
struck the fs oE M w fell the ground With his lace down
Cron ramred By Mr. Van Brsn square cor.
Of FOURTH It snd Up's Pses us srss s'asm'a sh.
square sre osrbs more when observed them Mr. willis
when he entered The hs passed me passed from as Ph
Forrest cans up 70 him; stopped after Mr. NJ W sy
passed short distances, then crossed The grass
.rsh 80 l.s from where stood The d
Guilty occupied looing all ne time
rscoet tho Police came could bear What
sad.
5use' soOs, - en-. 81, ...-.a ~, a W
sitting hcDuga AMI F9nrh Streets
~ t,,s " es Nd ss Foa person sE to. s,ts
you'd not roucs him w. Fourth b
tween Med Sixth A. a51u; taf block from tbs
Foarib Mr. she tas ~ behind III, M W %
es5s Mr. " bad passes u. .s asJat IS lris
hr ~ He behind M asdk,oeisd BIN
ii. CO h ace Mr. wsscssi from gr the cane Mr. w
h' arc ue him With = % aS 9aHS , de nee
. more than once roles1s can. Up &c 20 %; @
tsoihn down Hshad hold Of hm BY he collar Of hs coat DID
sry company With hr p ~asa BE stood BE-
Ind the tee Noticed psrsoa uisors 0s1rs the Police
up et.usn X by ntsrersc a. he ume-hsfs vas oa
lsrs-coud not@cognze n)W sai %
sg tie bsrsh vita ne a. the tins "tasfss
6shin ard un right up.
Con eraptrsa-A yourg nanet Arbefle With ms
The Tree v.s rot "a large Mr. Forrest she aa
age near ssnch sitting theirs a1nsag
sei ~h eads there several hsrs among them
ny srosr they running around The Parads G'ouai
tuug holding the watch 80 not kaoH E5a paf
q e square they running when NJ struck mr. '" %
hsvs running; cannot how ar M S from ne
Vheu be .truek w bstEsen ana M !" could Dot
W. down I'D not EnoE that nr ,
gong stt.ek Tiers nothing o cali ttsniol
ID NJ W down thsre Fer- O-hsf
person., suppcss passing The SAL 10 Mr. hn9 coz
tds gutta ssfcha Whip ioioEsi
he Polre ocs have sut0rsd tbs % ssvet never "
NJ Wis except ny aiaEt two or Tires days a.
.rvard he Pc csusa arrested Ar. Forrest asket lad
sny gcng ". Wls sad Eas Wiling, .nd
NeLt 10 M W. house M W wrote tbs aiAfi made - nm
previously rspTsseLtau0n 10 resast % =
havg testimony tas Court a. ufusa
~ The day The JUG natrg 20 The jury GOT % permit any per
on during recess ssak thsm relation % The case
Unltsd States Circuit Court. Tax RsDAY, May 3.
Bslor, Judges Nelson and Belts.