New-York daily tribune., 1851-09-30

uese gayms.t.n lerluce" We re3'y th1t. u 60
ric0, = = ll.pi'Cs- 10 such remarks we've maze lF
An because = ear oy Eau. .nfr iaey would e. udY
have .,tn hesr4 b. ruo>on sni ye' Hudson dii
un' aeu them fle.p>S part OF tne dialogue si>
fufr0se.v sQukeI su 81 los voice. sxren- cue or
csiCa-Wor1 uttered LOUDLY for the esl 0r Faulkner.
The meaning of Cor"g'. ana Nyer>'s replies te-
u,rd, Aitost taer upon ne nature of tnc remarks
wb. called them i0rtb. see nothing cNtr1Orli-
cInu' IN C0~ils contribution % Phelps SpenSes
and il> operations 90 ftNtl when Phelps should
return. euTc.ee bv he receipt ot $500 20 De 90
tanned r. IN tn state OF Alchiga-.. 5Y payment
from hiS pretended debtor Massachusetts. OF 0y a
fortune 10 &c secured oN The partial favor and assist
sLce OF his distinguished friend, tie Governor Of
Minnesota.
Geutcmco. 4 + scarcely Necessary 70 remark that
u Phelps's narrative $ ial,e 'he relation gwen b.
Lake cannot oe true HIS concurrence lends ~
confirmation. There are however, cross readings
by these witreSSoS which require moments 40
tee Phelps isStlhes thai Williams should Wl.te -
tGe Railroad Company, through an attorney. and
offer TO take thousand dollars year. FOR htc years.
f1J letting them OF Lake on the contrary. attn
butes his generous proposition 10 CorNiu. W htn,
however. the counsel ioF the prose cu:on Indicate
the Ta-ance Lake IecOHcleS tfe CoIllct OV >dk lis
he has card Williams the same thing. Il IS cK-
uaorcIndry that Phelps should have forgotten thai
1orwI made the remark. ana equally 80 th,.t Lake
had not, the hr>t instance, placed the remark 10
re account Of Williams. where Il belonged. Lake
informs - that Fitch sand. on the piazza, a. BaS
CONS tavern. IN JACKS N. hat lt CeSt lm COW a.o
SO - ourn the Old tepot-,hat he had pald $50 10
was to pay $50 more after Il should oe Ourned.
" tina. - We would burn the Niles dcpns, We could
have 5000 IN money. OF the twin oxen n $40 ant
the balance IN money. Phelps. who was present.
gives Us no such details NJ that conversation but
presents the same neiarlonS statements A. having
been made by Fl;ch. AZ The bai-alioy, on the occa
SION ot his ViSli there with Mm b LacOcA, which
occurred before Lakes engagement began. 1t II
manifest, therefore, that Lake mas blunderngiy "a
len from tie common diary what was heard 5y
Phelps alone, and produced II aS a confession oi
l,.~ L. D. inns.
Although Plep> had stated that he WAS 20 be paid
= expenses IN case OF failure 70 5urn the Niles
dtyof. Yet he Wa, leaving the stand without sHow
lIg that be haI received or even demanded ms eN
rel>es. \ Juror pointed cut the lncongruy He
Immediately replied. "They pad me before aad
afie, Z weu. 4hout sixty doiafS. on account OF eN'
IeuseS. OF this sum. Fiich paid me 'ghl hall dol
lars tVO gold dollars and one quarter eagle. MAKING
tIght dollars and fty cents, besides seven dnldrs
paid Lake By Williams. on the same account.
Lake ON the contrary. says, that neither Williams
nor any other person ever pad anything T. MN on
account Of Cxpeus e. nor 70 his knowledge vas any
thing ever paid 10 Phoip on that account lie SAYS
further. thar ne was present When the clght doutfs
and a half was delivered and received rs spurious,
and that = ~ fact counterfeit CON. II viii not
surprise YOU gentlemen. 20 find that Phelps and
Lake hamonze IA their account OF Farnhams IN
iemal machine, which tncy saw at MS gate, Mhere
there vas 10 other witness present m the night
time when none but they and such as they could sea
any thing Nevertheless, u u strange mat me en-
ginncer who fabricated The matches produced here
with such profound philosophical knowledge and
eNqu Shil. cannot describe the mode % opera
ton OF Farnhams Internal machine for blowing mp
the railroad, although u consisted OF two common
tn hons, bound together 1t the naIroweSt part oi
the tubes with clasp. d. fantam vas 'dAeu
flOm his house IN the night tune, without nouce, ana
h,e dwelling was then exposed 10 the most scEutiniI-
ing search of the police but neither the mdchlHe'
nor any of It's >uperluous materials, nor me in'fu-
ments employed IN the construction OF H. nave oeeh
produced.
pass on 20 Lakes account of The Transactions OF
April n he spyS that Phelps and himself arrived
atfllleys together about noon, ard inquired ol hnii
the boys were there. You know, gentlemen, thaI
"ihe boyS" lived al Leoui, four miles eds' o Michi-
gan Centre. and, according TO Lake. he ana Phelps
had iust passed LeOni where they could nave Deeh
found ard had come down 10 Michigan centre 10 IN
aure for them where they were sure not obc found
lake SAYS they told Fillcv We have come 10 go to
Niles" Finley replied - am glad We are ready iot
YOU" Lake says, " Twas un@ell and LAID down al,
Ter hing hour rose again, came down STAIRS hhd
found FllleV We then had talN aOOui preparations
for Niles Filey went to the barn and DrouRh' me
match / examined II. tiDey put II INTO the ooS,
nailed il up, put II into the SoTe-Toom, and SAYING
is ready for Niles put the key ln his pocket inns
ingenious narrative was. unhappiy, IN conflict VIA
the testimony OF Kane and Allen who TOOK fiiiey 70
The pond about hafpdst ~, before Lake arrived AZ
his house and dc.alred hun until between and
o'clock Lake removes the difficulty thus raised
Will he gives conclusive answer 10 SecOrd thc
Betmans and TAYLOR, who have tesiihed 10 ms tfaV,
els on loot with a match IN a box ted up IN req
handkerchief lie was SICK before, and now. 'Ae
Don Juan In the ehlpnreck, he falls seeker. and
euafges the per0d Of hs repose u me upper cham-
Der from one 20 three hours. How could dmdn, "ho
was obliged 10 sleep three hours m day, walk iour
miles oppressed with the weight ned up IN IN" feu
bundle
Geo.l,men. have now shown YOU that the test.
mony Of Phelp, and Lake IS unworthy Of credit oy
reason Of Their depTaSity-o internal evidence Oh
fslsehood-of conflict between themse!Ees-oi ma
grant ayowas Of deceit-and Of collision WIN ticE
Ipcon,e.tbN established advert briefly 20 some
prgt
nrincIpally by Me,sTs Van Arman and tlfh Ke-
vert Al YOU please 10 their account OF ine disclosures
made u GAYS house Van Arnn SAYS clark was
Standing too far OIL 10 hear Phelps Was taking
with Gay Phelps gave us the sigma I" approach
They were taking about burning the depOl- NJ MICS
and Detroit Phelps sad he would go out 70 SEE ti'
frI.nds a: the Centre and let Gay know what time
thev would be- ready Al Nile. Gay SAID they "ouih
be ready 10 make strIke here al Ne same HiIe
Who does uot see that THIS conversation Wa con
trlyed between Phelps and Gay lOr Tie purpose ol
corroboraflou Again, Mr. Van ATman. describing
the transactions AZ the same place on the loAoNhs
ulpht SAYS &C lare being present, though not "II!u
hearmg) Gay talked with Phelps about Oafnhs
the new depot and with equal care, a'oIdeu conies,
ing anxthiug about burning the Old one. NJ the
same tine Phelps having had priya'e CONVEX
with CAV told Van ATmdL that Gay had s'en leave,
and thereupon Phelps went up s'aTs ana eAhiDieu
the match 10 Clark and Van Armah Naat Va.
tbere mn All III but "a uggle between Pheips ana
Cav to impose upon Clark ana van AIiidh ~ lvI
have "a ,hird corrObOratOn ID the iacl Nal The'Ps
I
phene but Il y deprived Of all ~ alue oy the ldet
iDat lark had been apprised that the money was
lent ana was sent INTO ParkeTs 70 request MN "
make memorandum Of the sale. FouItn corfoDo
ration Alter setting Ere 10 the depot Al Mes ~ltn
ibe fu,e end OF We match, Phelps, Lake, cafk ana
Van Armsu returned together IA the ar to"h'
Detroit When they arrived At Jackson, illey vas
seen there and he i0oked as y NJ tas aafig,sy e.,
D,rf,pg son,b0ap. Phelp, concerted WIN I IAN hd
Van Arrnan that he should draw FA!sy in'o con-
,ersatoR, v lie hey >h0uiu Hs.en - PIe
IS ln a sderot Oh the ARRIVAL 0l tram VI cas- he IS
y.r,snt 10 look a. 4 he vas expecting ,omeoody
Acon!er-a;.on. Of course, occurred, OF which IhIec
versions are gwen IL, d., 80. go,
FIr,t. Phelps. version FIilsy-Ilo" nd ycl se'
along Phelp>-i set he Depot on ire but made a
faIluTe They put = out have not maze more
,ban r-ne t.fues aaye BONE my expenses ihere
and back Fuley--GO up 10 the (enfTe ana see me
COWS they vii make Z all rght
yan Arms version Pheps-l did not make
NOR. nan me time. Filey-lo Oh had better 20
u,mecIately 10 the Centre The boys are waiting for
you. D.. f.
(iark'e version. Eiuey- Plelps-
tIIle,- or wh4t value - a concerted
,orroboraionike fhis. which all that = necessar;
l. 80. ...r.HH "