Richmond enquirer. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1815-1867, 1851-07-01

il ,hrra solitary westerns ::.I? *g." GRE Tia; VIII
say that lie rrciers il, ;i;% IL VII! vote !vr It. il it
ONES before him b" Hs~li I" DC voted Iai:: Is therea
nglc eastern man, unless i! he tie en;'an f!o the
,pnn,y Of Hcrr;co tSr. Bo!1sl WHO viii vote lvr il
A not know ui enc, east or west. havr heard tic
.yrrc.si;us of u.any c,;t.elen both from lie and
the west aud have not heard me fit vel who
ns dc.lnre,i that he wou!. IL. it. w!r i.uvc
heard very maav declare they VII! Il" &. i. Ev
WIS i not then wl!.cld. WIZ AZ least, vas " no;
before it brought here, in ccc anl IN
conference 10 the cast. l!cu ha"!: IL. oil: al
;na urity iu favor IF osr.Lt r., "sit: II isis to
me ~ odd mode 81 getting GpI ccEp:,:i+". INC gen
,,.r from Icare0 (Nr. Bo11sr -p .:.ya .ha: !: j,
measure OF rracr: t.a! r viii ar:cc 10 s..c re-
presentation TO property lie puts Lis o'; "a liz: lie
AMI he GENES forward here 10 aaHn his sccc ..I i:
mi; his pro position dr!ece ii he RIGHTS Il pvrn
:ur the purpose I" giving the a>r.,J!n2y i;t they
rttl. to- aud that he sill Sever "oe L. f'i"c Fr"prlt
Representation AMI Yet. w"ir;iu - sta; Sir. Ciir
.an. lis proposition accomplish: lie v,:y is %cA
lie VOWS il was inielJed 10 Cci,qt Il j: a'co.u fishes
INV thing NJ all except TIE d.:=; If The east. il rav
Be that il is measure ri lrEcc tl!: ta: i other
wise. sh: cndearer 10 sho" II l.. tia: the peo-
ole viii say tha. it Partakes nore Of ;.", rc.c5rlr.
Trojan no. ( "inStnr .a.";is 'g..sM. w!.' Der. ,cah
md armed enemies within is how re-. iraui;it
with Infinite l:i>che:-, if il <la IL a, I'D ard Ey!e-
after when the S:ate Is grnaig udc. the misery II
dc;s by it. lie s.li be cai:c hy ic.li 10 i've
history Of this day, h. viii xc!o;in IS tie broHr,-
tunes arising from Tie Introduction q that i@se within
lie walls Of Troy. and tic to"t:! u ia. Inflated city.
"lnfandrra, sccas jules g;ssc q !o,cn!.
Trojauas u: op"s t. alne;,a..c srzntln.
E.uutlnt Dlna-
Quorum pars magma !'i
He asks ne to translate; Will. hen he shall bc
asked hereafter by ANY 10 give account Of il
horse he will say you call upnn ne E.r friend 10
count tale of woe how eastern asia lid Ill ila
was dear 10 her were o--how thu; an'rIied so",:ii-
mem If hers uverthrown. III which sal wvi: ! Wis
prominent and principal act"s. gt"c lie gentleman
= humeiy prose not the poeic', tr;.si:t"I. ...y il
rrcr there was proposition %!::t, . can >"a! wor!"
t-in, mischief the cu.nlry, A.. ~. :.!": Il which,
ii hereafter called upon 10 give "c:,;.n 81 As
country should reply IS c u FRO II liz! i, is is
with tbs difference o!r, 'i" III, Nir is s OF II"
a.l-thc gift under which: ITO" !.. vas IA. q" ~. #
REX Here the author would lave nan. Tue :,..t
n>sit tina tie injury, iac:s =. -:atila: he been
al lid the .ur by itIli ...n- :..cas.!:e viii.
mad the government he m"at cor.rt and t.c
.:e.tae Of ;ny iii eX;>;onr" ana j; wa III: work
What i; it! Why, it is All arbitrary G:s no. the STATE
Into muities Of 5.nI 75 bl.eiUpo 10 isias:p.s repre-
-eutaiiun at al, either OF PERSONS I: ilopcr:y, and u,
ti.ici maintained AMI at."ucrJ u. tie ground lInl
is based upon principl =; al, Bat :ide, equally
the representation giving c'.ati to each side aI it
accuup panied by the declaration ts.; there i, III the
breast Of the author OF that prGpo,i. determination
nal,crblc and fixed ncvo: 10 re pr'ptrl: represent
axiom. And yet Wien you co:Ir ;"!oc iitoit. tlt uy
gives property representation, bat ives II more rce
.ctaiiun thu it does ~ persons; for II 70" lake person
the standard, the majority ought 10 Dc il the west
II take property II. the st"a;rG TIE Gaiur Ough,
- he in the east II you brin; the east Up i, the
thcu to produce equally oi representation, you
give property JUS. muc!: Iorc rc:c ca: q! ;lal
curds to his s,and.rd:ur he .aa it - cJ;cu t"uc-
t il entitled to, us tn make II bear Go"n tic MAJORITY
If the people in the west - tGGa vi i the mor
it; Of the people in the ,!n.- not call rce.
,cntation of property it is truc bat is !. r''t 81. Kc
presentation must rest upo" icr-l., OF ,mrr. or
both We'll there are 10: WAS pc".ois r!i'!sn III hc
tn ctic tc.n TO cnc-it u: tie r:vc-r.- .i:o1,
a:id if property Is not entities 10 v:esvtt,I ina,
he majority in the west is "iI! .c - r!ty t! ic
representation. Ii this excess .: representation Le ,i
representation ot property, u wiI i Il rerescnt.
atun II must be Representation ol !:."nas-. IL.
preventative representing nothing. !- j. t:::c--. tome
ontciva5le. inr have a".ig, huy,,ei :a: l:u him.
rerTc>e nted b: authin III! .i.t III !trstaadhow
nothin scn be represented u his The very &c: OF
announcing the proposition! III; The p,4 ip!c whic!
the author Of i: t.eies, ~; ;c syo;, lin pic witch
his proportion rcp-.Iites. inc ,-en .cnan, ~; wiiu-
sta;ld aluns .!, uf Marshall f,.o;i, Leigh s:,!op
Scott Stanard .her, Gic- ami al tn, lcu OF tat
lay, to stand above them Ir"c.a "a al.
panacea for all the evils complained vi here lie dee
not it is true say that lie vii! -;a:l above lem ci
that is his position and the mv:!.: al lis language.
cause he be will pa: lis foot cp uii.e 3.iufiD'" they
announced and advocated. dat properly i, ci led %
Representatives." tnd nyows his !crh E:'-t.iv 20 +.
Well, it strikes me his proposition Is ike I'LL the ulhr
rauacc, that have ever heard Of Tor /; cures all kin<
of diseases ur II Is no piacca, AMI Ut Course MIST
equally we'll suit those al the Opposite e. .racar.
1t is utterly Inconsistent with the professions of Ike in
ventor and if it cures one, i ul4cJ ano.hcr IN. in
reality II cures
Before proceed further to ana,yze this paaa,ra.
however, let ask what connection there is t wees i
and the principle OF ad rs!ore" ;aA;i" winch i in:o-
laced by the sc,cma.i, ana suggests ,:-tinuch he
;lar,cIt-por!pn "t his argument dG!c,cr Of III,
prom:ct What has taxation - do wiki scircm ni
Representations which il arbitrary and regardless of
.tlion But that thunder belongs rather rny fri,d
from Berkeley (Mr. FAuLKNEE) than The grlIcii. from
Hcnrico, who has introduced i. apar Of his congo
Mise. And believe there is anolhrr gentleman ram
the county of Marion. (Alr NEEsoy who will ,gnlu.te
with my friend from Bcrkclr: tMr FAcLENLEl tor he
palm Of having Introduced that trupo!tiun. and i in
truth entitled to il, aud committee Of tais
5od have actually reported, and the report is ROW Z;
ling before ME, in favor of the s,lcn -: ui gG!
iatio. And the argument o the Gentleman from Hel-
rico upon the effect Of taxation ii MILL
tenth of per Cent Is the argument before lie
print Of the gentleman from Bcfsciey hr. FArL.:GG)
who haa preceded him. III ;!t pect settling its srrs
us of the guarantees upon which he means 10 rcl:
His western proposition upon tie sub;ect of taxation.
brought forward IS an eastern pll.cc:. for the If
"rr diseases aud part Of this peculiar compro:nisc.
Mr. Bolts. regret utcrruptng the gentleman
nor will do with regard ay Of his arguments
an VIII he aIUlucu Stage
of the discussion to some Of the rcntenals
propositions. All wish to do now is 10 set him +: Il,
in simple matter Of fact before he proceeds f4rhe-
In relation to this question Of al atpfenl taxation
take occasion say that believe it was the very first
proposition that submitted to the COMMITTEE in tn
month Of October last and | am informed by til.
gentlemen around me- it the first submitted up
ON that subject. The proposition referred To the
Legislative committee aud tHe up for their ccisid
Grafton was invited 10 appear before them and pre-
sent my views upan the subject Of the system Of cd RI
iOrem taxation, with which request | complied The
committee adopted and reported I'll: proposition which
had submitted IA gentlemen have informed me-
Mr. LYONS. Ii | am wroa. in nv sta:cneu Of The
paternity of this proposition with great pleasure will
make the proper correction. 5" far lis am concerned
The gentleman will have the Justice and re he i, emil.
tied to in the presentation OF TIL proposition and he SHALL
receive entire courtcs, hands But nv impression
that the gentleman iro: Marion Mr. Nrisox, was the
irst gentleman who submitted tins PROPOSE ion to the
committee. Whether he ar not or whether the
gentleman from Heurico lIr BORIS was The first to SUI
sest it, here is the report Of the legislative committee
which has adopted the proposition If that ecrticnan
he sa:s t me concc!c that the committee adopted
it his proposition. Lc; concec that it was sy-
gestcd by him, and not b. the gentleman from Marion
Mr.. NEEsoS) Aud ask again. VIVA. has ii to do with
the compromised Does he propose 10 base representa-
ton upon it No. The gentleman from Marion tATr