The daily union. [volume] (Washington [D.C.]) 1845-1857, 1850-08-16

he
soa. and ,avs I" as' Ss same result apprehend
y,ld sasms TIM ns"sr 4 no snread unon the journal
h, Y /; pmh vav tba, If NAV be identified
,..h ysys hi asc.,,s;n ,hs acs,;an M the Senate " Il
VIZ I.;rs y - as0ea ~; ~ sah, Nat Il Il clearly
~ h;.b w ap 49, M III ~ he d;scretion The cour
and ihs ~ the Senate The senator from
W;y;;a sha ~ ,, ~ - i;a,,on M h.oan hv disa yowing
Claim ~ ~ ,,sr ~ rr;rh, ~ he recenon ard enter.
ny ns ~ s ,; [ a !, ~ an,naI i an appeal 10 the
h - w af ~ 49, Wy sh;L N a N dr,, ~
hs ca.e and ia, ~ ,e gtsb House Of Lords
,h 4 ,; @ ~ ~ ,,h M 10 - ~ annlicaon the nreirjce
na, he sana,o5. o Az seeking 10 have Their
nat inc i'ua se.asos w - ~ . ~ ~ avail
!eas.S - wv" du J.,ia J.as - ~ ~ N
IN m pn, y w ips;5y disavoy that al
together, - n z
,ar o he obect Of the reference 10 the arstocrac priv
anos - ,shch rxs, in ihe British House Of Lords does
No.. a,s;, e h, ~ enter nroest ,pon the journal
Th smut II draw an analogy between these two cases
a,t n nv mind no other nIerence than that il was in
tended 10 attach 10 this the prejudice which would result
rom see to obtain higher privileges Upon thar sub
c desire IA say that lie aspect In which consider this
question is moi that it claim upon the part Of indyid
bmt claim n behalf OF the States which they represent
agree most perfectly with the remarks OF the honorable
ana,nr srom Mchi,an TMr CAss that in the absence
If ali nreeedent lhs h a case ii which there is degree
smat y aay Sy every concatory means. II is mere
p p ~ ~ a93osa n tbe d;scre,ion Of the Senate and
cannot annrehend danger from the precedent at all
II hs so, sba occur ara adopt
he language o. Inc noole sesnI q cc c aSain
shcn @ n aa.. nnaar anncafion shall
\ hi ha nsrfectlv wiling mysef to exercise The
J;t ~ , h.n % IL : Ssoa}a shaii M called moon to ex
ISL a,an @ ha,her hs naner shall or shall
S'su Nm - he ;nrnai IInnuestonaby The Senate
viii have to exercise its discretion II viii have TO ex
aine mmee M N @ an T, ,u INV scara 6at no paper
ao =, as ~ nner intended to encumber
VS. h 80 arm nstall be entered
ae journal WIN ths Y Observed and if
upon lns jou'hh ~ Nh; er do mi zee thai there "a any
b;ng n ~ temoer or lang uage or Tone or in the spirit
OF thus paper wnea "a y, o those aeaemeD that
10 - and Il be So upon the principle
which have sated--if it be unexceponable, then,
IN, IN tha assertion Of established right but in
nal 10 ihe cour,esv Of ihe Senae--made in spirit to
aIIay ra,her than 10 increase excitement-upon what
ailay ,a'ne. ae ,s, uaa', r.s,sa g. ~
Nny M 6a ying said thus much in relation to the ap-
nlcaton of he senator from Virginia in behalf of him
ali ana IL the granting OF whose request
ha cbssrnllv rive nv yote4t is proper that al the
time shoud state why as southern senator, my
name does not apper upon thai paper have state sim
i ~, M ~ ~ ,hs State of Georgia having pre-
py pyhd ,hrongS ,s fncanares te action which is to
~ ~ m usn, of lhe nassaee Of this bill and having
sad ~ ~ d 80 M Sale n i5e pogress Of this bil
, ny III W W,h,sd hu anv act 81 mine a, interfere
- ~ n.y. ,h, & sia,nr and he action which is present.
ed by The constitution
III H. - nm, a. - snable every senator to vote accord
W. MN ~ II M; = an,;maa,s and views hone the question
viii be mol merely upon the reception OF the paper Sen
mentarv y,noian NAV he made afterwards which we do
~ h =, IL go;ad nnnr hone the Senate will not
; ~. ~ - aLa Il out ~ The nossesson of those
- ~ ~ @ aasnad Il ami then have IL in their power to
anpus NC ns + atoreihsr hope therefore that when
he vote is taken il will be vote decisive OF all that is
d;J ,ba, ,ha onesion NAV he nut upon the reception
J ,a;a 80 naont the ;onroaI ali In one vote In that
@ @ ~ a s an Ia aaceiyed Every senator will under
saae sa , ha, ~. NH II ha accomnI;sheJ by that
s III % DID SInENT IFS The parliamentary rule that
he oneston shall be upon the reception OF paper II It's
receon i objected To- But il is the pleasure OF the
senate the question will be- Shall the paper be received
and spread upon the journali r.
Mr. RAIDER Mr. President, desire 10 say one
varJ unon the subject In the first place, wish TO
correct mistake into which the senator from Massa-
cbusetts before me lMr WHTHRopl has fallen, in say
ng thai the Eoesh House of Lords is the only para
menlary house in The world n which the privilege OF en-
ering protes, is enoyed as matter OF right The con-
s,uon OF North Carolina expressly that priyi-
asnre IN nv own state although that privilege exists
and has existed since the year i77o when her consntu
lion WAS framed there has not been any 10 com
Dlan of any abuse OF the right so conferred thnk
n probable that not more than half dozen, Ger.
tainy not more than dozen instances OF protest have
occurred during thai period AT the Tine Mr. Pres
Ient must say have ieli il TO be question OF very
impo whether, on this occasion 'he oenae
Of the United States should now authorize tne recepuoh
and putting upon their journal OF paper OF this cbarac-
ter say this, not account OF any objections 70 tne
contents OF this paper, and not without very serious
conviction thai this occasion is which, Al any occa-
sion could Justify such departure from the usxes oi
The body would seem TO warantt But when we consider
tat after so great length Of tune, in which 80 many cues
ibs body. and decided against minories, deemlng that
their mos important rights had been taken from them,
deemne that constitutional privileges and constitutional
Injunction, had bet either denied disegarded-when