The Caledonian. [volume] (St. Johnsbury, Vt.) 1837-1867, 1850-11-30

"N 'N'
aCnoOL nOORs.

.'t. .lia uofirs Thoa5h unjust toward ihr
s.gurTs 81 tho recommendation ni. lnHhs h'gif n
r ] Hunil hNi lNINh ii .il'H- ~ f-liI it-,.t a..
. uaf relate tD 20 mot Important Tutiit i"t-'l-i M
/ tendency. and obviously 10 hriWlf Dr. =" N''N,'
. tls confidence NJ fhf community ln ihH eNl"' ~
trlIgr.ts of tlf County, lrarrpt Those VIM lhl Ni
F. ,.--rf.sUf a6augiI ~ perceive the superiority "I
I fiIudrFl.r's llrldrrs,I aHi lead people in Hfi'.
4 tlrir recommendation n- unworthy NI "7' .
. HpIrHi- 20 ur nhf rh'l"N' 'll4 N''t' 'N'i 49,, a.
l majority ul hr NlIuW lprIiilnNN'Nl. ''.' iI.'
J il.l aamf rhlrrrs which Doc brings HfAINrl 20" %"
+ u1u. "IIs0fsinfuF ani tending 20 lri''l 'N' 'N''
/ IA Il uag,asuias because % Represent u.rm ns
/ t4rrrrHYrg mon WHO can he t0Hgh. ftsil} lnHr N'
having uu opinion ui ihgIr uHuf Hul l'' F 2" t..'
thr.r uHWrs Hinu 'sHfnldi lN Hl"lN' "
dnt,uu. IDrrur superintendent illus 9" l'Fln'Nt
ll. t.IIHn.. uItu Uu hrili. IFIruu fhuF Dr. Uu'NNl
/ bv tho uct complained " aos seem usFrnei'u'rA"'
n /. sa,asf locause t iasiaapi,s that they we're
BrLri yffarfd p1Bf 10 lHg Hh-rurr ui ihH Huihur
uame DO is hard % believe fHi ilr-l'N llr'hHi,'N
I contained Boo ihr question: i.Hi l'Nnhi Voc H'~'
affl pqnuci by WHn n hnuDWhle feelings HhN
I rnrrrft pnugpr- one especially having ihAirhhnt
a. TINT iuphrih no evil 49, rg ihr 'lFurf1 o" ll'
Report, uFruis inr ihr ueN booker u ih'Ir w, VIZ
lb, sacfei HI0ieal Ga the lowest pf1uHift~ ~ $40
/ luy OF u0u Ca Upp1s0 the rnruWWnudhil.ht ~Ff
Htii believe Il,efr hfr puiie HnnnT lhure c"n"'Nf
uur bnfri, who would ullueai wiz WeuiaI 'rln
| aim contempt iAH ortr &C % prrtnlHrY reward lur
RS Az biz unma trim recommendation ~ NJ nook
/ ~ our slhupls, u - aupaPILendoni kH'as nat
HAT the town Whlrh hHs appointed 90 uuRuuNy
man mas uuderstfnn b., aud appoint better II
gao don uur i-u1W - w. must hce % o. wyHI gnn
I tlr contrary. / must sly du Hut believe uUr ~
those who tlncl thr recommendation ui Towns
bDpks sa5 nu"HFcnl fig tlrin' nf nrri''l anN'p
ruuary uusldru.tluu" tur hs signature, IT, HRlt
he accommodated hls bftH mH,, ANY ui tliem shnll
acc be- agents a. bring the huok Go tho notice u The
public and ufuHucr thrin a. ihr rch"plsi they VIII
De- no moro than they would have done Cor Muuir-
D.. had
than DO b. understood Ihr minority drt doing Whrih-
er Huy rrrr lhry rrDcINopIy mr iWc-iAus spent,
-'s''r~r'--Ti y r 'iiiFrr M 40
great concern. M, manner in which ihe sigma
WrUs trtAe IrruIu'drHlliI}u ui iuHu'r hnphfrNrfu
obtained b. uhrrird CO. hF "a supcnbtraiuut "-
tuprr.ntcuiruis ~ Granville. ui Which Vaudeville -
Reader. WcTr u.s. y-slllOrudri, there seemed hardly
time iu gdl uu'pIrf uWNfnll"n llh snlhslrn' -
wee, 7rf publ 10 eflf1iuruIH'i"h Tao ue hIHllrl
Nv thp winter schotN The lnfcurfs ~, the season
required immediate ur'fHl, What alternative WHh
ltn huf private consultation Accordingly Fuiur
of tlr Superintendent, uCiupirl rulrlN by The "a
forrest 300 thr prosperity otuur 'rh""H undgl'r"h Nae
sk ul going oyer ul, gYuli iu gHp-.'.i ull lhr o-
cu, The htta were pr,srnl-l. wid iht .uprnnirn-
drufs 900 of 81 huw, Wo believe SIRE capable uithnk-
iup Too tlsm-rIt,s puI hHsr tlfIr DWu opinion. even
ifuut mo hc' Judges oi hpuks having Zoe many pl--
B.. yr,raaaIy examined tlr book, With gIrst unpu-
unity ana frli'nr'r, Expressed lA'r preference
for Towns ~ "HR'uil rNrrpi in one "r w." TO-
sfuurr.. hui pHhnig 20 do with getting signature,
uuI chem, ua Nv nrv Cold, only ult.fupuutlu fu.
p.rui,udrUt mud not directing urhdtisiug
lhr Ntalhb " hr msuHr,, T. another strong
objection urged hy "rupruufCuututs' Let uH
weigh 10, and scc hlN much consideration % merits
Ia the hr,i place it important 90 h' borne Yea mind
that the recommendation ~ Nuprruirudruh lu
Vermont urc utly 0arisurW they have un legal Hu-
uunty,, Boo N,v Hampshire mud Maine fo prtf,rils
tbr huphs that rAa'l hr used, The law make Do our
duty iu tNBmiuv and recommend, and our ,oUrcIou-
pr, hiud e. 40 hc faithful lu t- matter, hul when
we hHv- recommended. the i'-uTir Hrr rtI'rriy M
NHrriy GO adopt "r reject Tic law iucs uui pre-
scribe the tuHuUur Zoo which Wu shall perform this
Iutyi. of cuur-u, then, private cuu-uiiu.uu is ,a1
i.l lle NJ 49, t'f-
iuHlutf complained uii iH mot lir9nl. roe meeting.
held n' pnu,'llc, Spring aud Fall, though attended
bY iiniuurl,. Negr not e- i.pl ll4a "liii~i,-
dUfiuns th'fr lut iurHt, Nui uduiilL. i--!ftii'y
-.ftl 4lg'-gti 4i'rrrT, | uu The suggestion tint
their uyfluu tukL 10 they WlIcl 10 sl. Bind 100 thr
MINORITY n'sh Go stand Doe tri attitude hgluo the
community AMI assume ito tes pIHa.Al!lty ol h.Bd
Ing the majority against thoir willsf
The community, in order a. know how much |
weight O. attach io % Recommendation, ought o. hc
informed whether made hy majority or minority, /
Md moreover 70 seems "a ~, That when made lay q
minority, the H1uiss 81 ~ iHdriiatp making 10, /
should accompany 70. lhc objection tu the action .
NJ t'1uvi''0 q. uul ilnl n Wu. "vgi bat that so
small Il minority should presume io act Cor Che /
whole. and publish their recommendation that ]
of the Ltlrd ef Sy,ft isrlfnts. nothing appearing
Ca the contrary, and prrNpI, the same objection /
might hr iIlpdo to the action ui the fret convention.
hNI ll'' Nlll'lfll recommendation NlNf iIlfHN Va
300 such frT'uruh'c til,Wmn ASH supcrutct
would rvYU.cuI urcd of foreign aid 'U hr help
~ -4.il t.-l+ --.,-istti lfrr 10 tNHW
how the cA-o -tuudr, aud thew VIII know how e.
act The objection ui ilrwliy b. wuundlussi mad
the matter ut recommendation, 300 ur a. relates Co.
kriiur 5ulhs, stand, thus TO upurinicndcut.,p out
of the 22iu the CO.. met no n1uvc. aud a maturity
81 them, LtNorur MlntcVillr'r READERS, RECON- /,
ucnaHtiuu ot Thorn wins published, Subsequently /
Recommendation of Towns books appeared, .igti- /
cI hy hr.Hfy -upcriutouduut. three .igniur.u out
I'D nf e. LAD 81 N.rrfH ~.
ThyU unfortunately, now before the community two
recommendation, OF superintendent for different
,vtt- of reading huok.j one uf these y the RECON-
mcndniiun u t'co, the other Of hrsHfV supcrintcu-
Jcnt,. II remains for the community 60 cay which
they viii adopt.
lmay sav here, that owing 10 sickness. did mot /
attend the meeting duly notified ~ Dnuvic, hut
had previously expressed favorable opinion of .
Muul1villc. had not then examined hir stsi,rt nj
all, bat only looked over the selections ntlcr nmor'
careful rNumphiiun, wins compelled to tccl they /.
were not az u adapted to the wants OF our schools
II was not, then, IN my own case hHay, hut most
de!bcraic aetion that led 10 the result OF which "a
superintendent complains And think. IN rrncr- {
al We have followed the caution hC wisely gives.
"lct nothing be done wshly,"
In regard Is thc merits uf tho two sorlc, Il r. lmrE
IL necessary here 20 say a words good men and /
wise, IN regard to this we'll other matters may
entertain different opninnsA Superintendent gives
the names of three or four worthy men whose o. |
pinions are worthy OF regard and tho names OF
wrrtry- mon who have Oppressed decidedly an OPP |
posito opinion might Ice multiplied our prcscutStnte
Superintendent he says MInr- ManleX IllG.-alE
first state Superintendent doe, not Aud by the
WAY, va cannot help wondering 1t did not occur to
~ superintendent when hc "a significantly ask.
cd "are amy OF the smcrs Of the Report agents for
the new books, that nns of these Nl,-e tirrriuS nc
gives agent for Muudcvilc's
Prof Vaudeville loeiared before the Professors
Of Bowloin college, and sci forth the merits -pf his
system; they examined H. and "reUrd IL with deci-
dot ds1jYro58fian,' AZ two or three Academies IN
thi, State the books have been examined, tried
and condemned An Agent for the books got mp a
reading class IN st, Iohnshurv Academy, and, 80
far ~ could learn, there wis general feeling Of
disgust toward thn hnnks, si)er trying them. 9th
or instances might be glvcn where they have been
tried, and proved failure.
Bo-do-, Is there not some objection to be found
IN what Vaudeville says IN the letter published by
90 superintendent" lie SAYS he has made many
changes, and intends 10 continue 10 make them from
ume 10 Times aud that "twcnty-one" Is less than
lhe number lac intends to make" Now will il not
hc source Of great Inconvenience to have success
i've changes appearing while the hnol.A ara ~, 49,.
earnestly hope, Mr. Editor no nhstncles will be
thrown IN the way Of carrying out recommended
ton made with 81 much Immunity MS Is that in
hvor Of Towns Readers. aud that no one will take
AHNa WAN ~