davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27
MsILs FOR CALIFORNIA.

The steamship Ohio. Capt schsnok will leave thip
port for Cbsgres. via Havana this afternoon Her
mails ~i close at the post Office ut two O'Clock, P.
n The Weekly Herald. containing the proceedings oe
Congress relative to the admission Of California ane
the from all parts Of the United States and
Europe, ~il he issued ut nine O'Clock this morning..
Single papers in wrappers be had 1t the counter
for SIX peuce each
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

FsoM H.rAevrr.-By the arrival OF the brig wi.sa-
biekon from hay aguer. July L. We learn that very
heavy rains have fallen there lately rendering the
reads 20 impossible. that produce could be taken
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

LATER FROM Rio JAsnRo.-ws have received, by
the bark Maryland from Rio Jsnsiro nlss Of the
Jornsi do Concrete. to the 10Th Of June
The House OF Deputies, on the nth Of June, vas
engaged Ia discussing about the maritime forces aud
the soidiers who to compose the next army and
navy of the empire.
The English government has finally treated With
company Of steam packets tor the transportation Of
the ms ais Bra zil and Rio da frxta.
The Engli-h steam msn.of var sharpshooter
rived In ~ port Of Rio Jsn~ro the 10Th Of June
Sr Joso Caefopo dos santos. distuguishsd citizen
Of Rio JsL.iro. died the lSth ult
The Enghsh packet Petrol arrived In the port the
18Th alt.
There IL nothing in nies about the fever, which
made ouch havoc IN brsxii.
The President at the provinces Of Rio Graads do
korte Jo~- joaquin Uunns took possession Of his
ONCE CD the B,h of Nay
Our nies nll-d ~ith reports OF the discussion
about local matters which TOOK phase Ia the House Of
Deputies.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

GrkrLEY ON THE BOUNDARY D,srUrK The phi
lo.OPher Of the F,burs is highly incensed at the
proposition made in tn, Senate, to appoint comm--
son.rs to settle the boundary dispute between
Texas and New Mexico, and regrets very macn
that 1t meets with favorin Copgress. This Is all
very natural, and he precisely VIVA, might he er.
r,ci,d. The philosopher Of the TStbuae wants
bloodshed he wishes to- see Texas aud The Unrrd
States government in open hosuity; h wants civII
war. We bope, however, that he will b- di,.p-
pointed. There is no Necessity for officially Of
tuch a character az Is desired in certain quarters.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

FRos Posox-P R-By the bark John Colby. Capt.
Hatch. nom Ponce. r., which place she left tho
l2tb July We learn that sugar Vas very scarce aud
owing To great petition prices hat advanced about
81 per leo lbs The crop nearly finished Amsri-
Can provsioos and lumber we're plenty aud dull. No
political q worth repoftin1.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27
HALLS FOa ROPE.
THE WEEKLY HERALD.

The steamship Atsntic Capt. West, will leave this
port twelve o'clock this day, for Liverpool Her
ms liz will cl.se at the post sies at half past ten
ociock, A. NJ The Ws,kiv Herald viii BE- psblished as
o'clock this morning. Single copies, in wrappers,
sixptpce
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

Dressing Cases Complete. and ready for
arrl" ai,-o being Of the very best
qnsliy Pe,soas travelling, ~ sns this article
bin v-neDoe utility Toiie, articles Of
every de eriptior pt 53h Broadway. IN. QUIMBY.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

InFRoyIaEsrs Mr 4 Bsckhnus- Esa IL ms.
hing sa. rsh- i'm ut in tina AZ the
corner Of Concord and Briag- streets ON th- s,rnsr
there stood formerly old frame building rais has
be. moved some distance up Concord street by the
celebrated mover. Pst.r q Berry IL has also ben
rsis-o one story and neat oa-. m-nt added thereto
In addition TO this. ts- foundation walls OF thru. sub
stsptisl buildings to be used stores with dwelling
spsrt Dts above them have been laid The housss
when pl.ted viii bs four stories hi.
he bas-m meats Three of the ssres will be thirty
s'x FEET dep the corner one thirty sine fsst Tue
masops Nessrs hmhrns. Il usors Carpsut.r
JO.-ph Esssrds. The buldinxs will cost 5000 each
and 10 be completed IN n couple OF months
kUKoIARs.Tns city is infestsd with;s daring gang Of
burpHrs who committing d-predstions VII bout
pumbr while at the same time. Effort ID made 70
cb. oh their movements The watehmeu be
found -b-n wanted aud il has became almost a pro-
b. that the persons who should be- guardians Of the
night are WHERE hut In their r<st place In
IA. Tenth ward the dwelling Of Y. Child ESQ va.
entered on lharsday night. and quantity OF chill
or.r's clothing taken and made off With We are
ttant hariDS OF various hurgsries 10 different parts
81 h. CITY and the authorities OF Brooklyn appear
b. osinelined to one inch Ia the natter Let q
reward b. offered for ihs detection OF these scamps
thrn the citizens feel that their property Is safe
and rot before
ve,anct Tent. Tpd-osndsnt Order Of Rschabitss, in
tend eel brstDg their Fifth Anniversary tse Sud
street church on Monday evening next The
cises Will be- an opening hymn by members Of the
oroer' prayer, reading. music and fpoaktng.
LATE FROM Bursos Es-By the arrival Of the
bark Jsmes Anderson, Captain French, from BuenosN
Ayres We are put In possession OF dates from Dusnos
Ayrss to the LIST ut but they bring political news
OF Importance The House of Representatives, pre-.
the public oces receiving any longer taxes from Gen
ROsas. wi o lad uniformly ortinued to pay thems
though required bv Law To do during the dis
custom az which DIR u. Garcia aumadverted in very
semby concerning the conduct Of the Argentine
forces at the battle ~ Oblig ado
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

PRorosEp STATUE OF GENERAL TAYLOR
great talents Of GABRIELLE, the sculptor and modeer,
are too well known in the United States, and to
all the admirers Of the fine arts, TO require any
eulogy from us. The fidelity, elegance and deli
cacy which marks the work Of his skilful hand,
ard which follows the touch of his alm.st msgic
chisel, have excited public admiration in all the
productions Of his genius. In none of these is his
genius more respondent than in the famous bust
Of General Taylor, the only faithful one in exist
ence, which the artist went to Mexico to take, and
in the execution of which he exposed himself upon
the field of battle. That famous bust, the model
and prototype Of all others, is due the genius of
GABRIELLE. As there is now a talk Of procuring
marble bust, statue, Of the late President, the
national expense, we are sure that no person more
proper and competent could he chosen to execute
IL than Mr.. GABRIELLE; and il is To be hoped hi,
genus, talent, and the faithful bust he has already
executed will not be forgotten at the present time
As the author and modeller Of the best bust Of
General Tay lor in existence, he now richly de-
serves the preference and We doubt not the
family OF the late President will be foremos, to
award il 10 one whose talent is unrivalled, and
whose genius, as q sculptor, is universally &C
hnowledged.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

PROFESSOR WEBsrER.-We understand that this
unfortunate man says &c is too much of Christian
to commit suicide II would be we'll for ban if he
had been too much of Christian to commit
utde
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

The STRIKE OF TIL JoUKNEYsAs TAILoRs.-
The jeuTDeymen tailors maintain the giound
which they assumed at the beginning of their strike
for higher pay TO- their work, and seem deter
mined to hold on to the last. We are glad to see
that they are combining themselves within the law,
and that there has been repetition of the ille-
gal acts " hicb were committed by portion of
the craft few days since. The sympathy of the
community will be with them so long as 10 pur-
suing their own hts they do not invade those Of
others. We dsuht not that but for the teachings
Of The socialists, the occurrences TO which re-
fer would not have taken place. Violating the law
will only tend to weaken them and the cause in
which they engaged Let them pursue their
busin. S. peacrsbly, and, above all things, pay no
heed to the doctrines Of the dsorg anizers, who are
ever ready to such occa sions to their own adj
YaniaQe.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

LIE NEW COpE.-lht Original onJect lnfn1ed
by the introduction Of n new code, was that of
clearing up rome of the myst,iicarions Of the old
law, ard simplifying It's obruse rechnic slities but
how far this has been effected the frequenters Of
courts have had ample proof aud opportunity Of
observing Il is, in fact, " confusion worse con-
founded"
The forms in plea ding and in practice, under the
new system, occasion more delay than was ever
experienced before its hapless introduction, and
the expense and uncertainty in the administration
Of Justice have not been dimini,hed; the snsres
which endangered the path to justice have not
been removed by the legal reormers Of the present
day, but u system has bsen introduced by them
which, instead Of proving more simple, is more coz
founded, and its efficacy is manifested by the fact
that liz ncomplefsness impresses upon every liti-
giant the necessity Of appealing against adverse
decisions, and thus passing through the various
courts to the highest tribunal ia the State whilst
an enormous and ruinous expsnce is encountered,
with hope Of at last obtaining justice-a fair in
terpreistion of the law.
by the union Of law and equity jurisdiction in
the same tribunal, under the new code-which en-
tirel, shroga,es the old form Of peadings-a sut,
thoulh rendered easy in iis commencement is
douhy difficult In its progress Instead Of there
brhs simple issue OF fact, there are now seve-
raj and the jury are prrplexrd by the questions
upon which they are expected to pass. This
charge has therefore proved embarrassing. but no,
useful
Thu new code will not, IL cannot, stand; IL must
be- repealed. II is imperfect, uninteigibe, iucom-
prte, and vague. More time in lost IN eodeavor-
ing to comprehend its legitimate constructions; in
discussing whether am, ndnents should he permit
ted and in dispo-ne Of other preliminary techni-
cslitirs than is occupied in the actual trial of the
csu~e at issue.
We have carefully watched the operations 81 the
new code. and can that II neither diminishes
nor chespens litigation; nor does IL make il more
useful or certain in the efrciuaiioa of justice On
the contrary. the desire for law suits has increased
because Of The facility Of comm, ncing actions, aud
the 1vdry with which a "crrtain class" ~ mem
here OF The profession seize upon the sghtes, pre-
text tor entering suit on nsmeless and unprofes-
sional conditions
fct, there are many mco Of strict probity, high
honor, and great legal requirements ut the New
York bar; let the task ~ remodpliug this precious
code, this gsngrspe of legal my.tHcationS be cou-
signed TO them. Let them "reform II altogether
foI u has originated in the wild aud reckless. fancy
Of socialist democrats and visionary wh,gs; aud
nttesd Of being modification or simolfic,tioo Of
the rntrcscfts Of the law, IL has proved labor To
the bar, puzzle to the bench, and an incubus Tn
the community ut large.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

nsu IS ct aud eemnete each article
uess among which is the Netal, ablet Strop for
ke iTg in rfeot order msnufaotured at SAUN-
DFRS va Broadway, Of Liberty street, and sSZ
Broadway
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

sBieI uilss fora 20 the tiy Hall. the uufron
ts st very low fare nearly every hour
Httottu hear comparison With this Delighted
variety 20 g. offered nt Keihnrers
hsrtr lons'-ts, pms. quote. .hpfe boards swings se,
Els FURNISHED - moderate bsnd u
biestres whose melodies Ia, al others in tso GAads
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27
q they could and that they believe their health and

VI trty ccuo, they believe their health and
lives Er. endangered
David Kerr John A Van Ripper Archibald smith,
John fa!ior webster and oth~rs lin all twenty two)
nsnsg'Is aud osersers ia the Powrr Loom Carpct
fsct'ry unite In an sfhoasit Ia which they dspose
that the contents ther.of are tru. rh.v fur.
ther drpo'. hat they have had great difficulty in
retain their hand, in the hot season that mum.
btrt have LETT III tn. hot in cos.-q
stencil and .fuva arising from III. bon. bsiiing snt
bone grIndnR Embellishments They verify b-li-vs
that th- workpsu In general suffer 10 thrr health in
cons'qu.nce OF tn. vicinity of these
ana That drponentr are frequently obliged TO close
th' wdo~r o the factory in the not TO avoid
the efiuvix.
Such is the appalling mass OF evidence. Yet the
Board OF Health appoint con mittee TO inquire
whether thes- establishments really nuisances
or injurious to the public healta and they defer
action I'LL perhaps cholera or some other epidemic
isupon us. Property is ruined in the vicinity ofthese
nuisances. The inhabitants fly TO Brooklyn, Will
iamsburg, ana New Jersey, aud thus New York is
injured. The taxes, too, suffer materially from the
depreciation Of property. in consequence of the
denominations described and We understand the
commissioners of taxes are ready to prove the
fact. II remains to be seen how long the Board OF
Health will shirk this question or palter with the
public health. the responsibility is thrown upon
them, and they cannot escape from II. The fall
elections are al hand.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

Ex.MANAGER MITCHELL AND Ills FAMILY Az
TAiRs.-We wish that ex-nlanager Mltchell Of the
Olympic Theatre, would 40 settle and arrange the
private affairs between him and his wife, as to
save that lady from the necessity of calling so
often at the newspaper offices, and soliciting aid,
paragraphs, anything she get, in reference
to the suit pending between them for divorce. We
have had 70 much trouble and annoyance recently,
growing out of the great divorce cases of Forrest
and his wife, and Bgelow Lawrence and his wife,
that we cannot conveniently find time or temper to
pay much attention TO small matters, or the small
divorces of the day. Mr. Mitchell should settle
his family quarres like gentleman, and allow his
wife something 10 live upon, and dry up her tears.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

rhsIn s. Suits, at Odd FeliO WIS Hall, oer-
To- consist Of Cloth Csat, and
Ca rim Pans and Fsncv Vest Also variety Of SUM
hing 81 To- S. suit Also l36 Nassau street.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

Fts"o rorser,-A nne nss0rtHnsnt OF sspc-
rioI Pianos with withsu oiian seoomp imon.
FufactLted b, re celebrated hoIse OF 7 GlLBExr
IT, N'stcn may be found 81 their New York Wareroons
go Broadway isrgs supply Of good SECOND Hand Pianos
r sale C. cap or 20 rent.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

Fine Boot, shoe, or Cater, at . very
modsrn'e price he found at ~ eourtandt street. under
th berchhits Hot. whore will ind Young ready
20 furnu you with fine French Calf Bocts At - So worth
g. and 81. TIE DOCrO&.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

Er' tfins Ut " cnlec lon ~ Portraits Of
a. tia. uisiec irdi,fuss in tie United states. No
Wet fail ibg nth ss-rai fsmtnsr faoea
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27
Tn. s...ehers nnsr science, aud Seekers

ait e ervr. taylor engraved appeared in the erst
Ne - tho alter, ~ flius'rius Amsrcss IL " sold BY all
Bcctscts sps alec b, BRADY 80 Broadway, who're tho
nrrirai b.Eusrreotyye v a he seen.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

y
ssleeier ici,t' Ures '-mhs in york scroll And
sthsr styles isss We oh Comb male order
81 ~ sfy drsiFn. fuInishe' at a. l. ]. SAUNDERS ~
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

'.'''y' ~" Snssu -
tee D. Thu sae b,itod To sTamine the styles,
With isrv and varied jus, received per steamer,
,pp~'s ~ rrsnch roube uperor anA
b.sutifui patterns Comb, ~ wtot s.ls. by
y I. QrtNPy 500, Broadway
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

beer wn batcheor Tor beat Wigs and Tou-
Fee III. slls invited insect his uev style for
iSi. ~ pAT'HkloRs celebrated Mig Factory, 4 wall
street Vie keeps the largest and Ssss sorsmsnt In ss
etN C.kv ~. .dfrets
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

Soap to~esr niost Anrirahie article as IL er-ctuAiU
do With the fe Of washing dA in
,uens he sbr AID drudIery that has hitherto eharao-
arrived 10 u accom- shes The wuk thoroughly than
the n and 10 at leAst hundred per
cheaper. For sale by EARLE x CO..
asa 20 Wsshinftou street
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

as,r he procuf,d at the factory, Wall
street The prhlic should suard AGAINST limitations See
v'rieus aTi1us Pe-sons whose hair has assumed
tss lor rcn the ~ the i alton dyes 10
sorretted by calling - sA"ve Cepv tho aaarss>
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

sdvertsipg eormns cen that the steamer Joseph
B-tns makes sr usual eSoursion 70 ksvbure
n.ie places Tomorrow leaving Chambers pier
5AA N.
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

GO0rsud's Italian msdicated Soap Will
trcchl-s saliuwness Poudre Subtitle
for -rsaieatin ssperosou hair from part Of the
BODY aoia RouE~ fer pal. lip. ohsska LILLY White
for rod 'h~ess ~ walker asst from
Rate. q Co. rrn Washington Bostsu-
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

WfKsf " iHs I-s ItiEens AID StrnngerS arc
iBve. nrreei PHALON's style W wigs and Tsu-
he kseI The largest and hest the city.
his celebrated waiTr Hair pvs Faotsry lN Broadway,
eerpev 80 Dew str-~, "opv the address
The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1850-07-27

-hst.rs tho moment applied withous
injury the h-ir ssn II eau he washed mediatsly
vie ds'nrbrz TIE color and hes bad door II is
pso s"ld ., pHALcs's wig and Teupss Mandatory.
nrosd
The Camden journal. [volume] (Camden, S.C.) 1836-1851, 1850-06-21

larly such as relate to this compromise bill pend.
ing in the United States Senate, though none are
in favor OF that bill unless it be amended in con-
formity with our resolutions, or in such manner
as shall satisfactorily secure to the South the
rights assertedin them. Until Congress adiourns
we cannot know what it will do or will fail to do.
We must therefore meet again after it's adjourn
ment to consider the final condition in which it
will leave you. We recommend to yon, and ex-
mort you to send delegates from every county and
district IN the southern States to meet us when
We again assemble. h.is no ordinary occasion
which has assembled US together. The coustitu-
ton, and the Union it created, 80 long dear h,
your hearts, are to be preserved, and your liber-
ties and your institutions maintained. e
The Camden journal. [volume] (Camden, S.C.) 1836-1851, 1850-06-21
The Southern Prsss

Is on our table. 1t is large and handsome
sheet. Elwood Fisher and Edwin DeLeon; Edi-
tors. G. H. Sage and Her. H. Heath, Publishers.
Their debut is strong but temperate firm and de-
cided. 1t should be visitor at every mans fire.
side in the South. The great object fthe paper
is the defence ofa Southern Rights" The Union,
Intelligencer and Republic are devoted to the North
false colors have been thrown over the true
state Of things by those Organs-while the South,
in the minority any how; has had not one voice
raised in her behalf Terms, Daily, $40. .,Tri.
Weekly,5; Weekly,2.
The Camden journal. [volume] (Camden, S.C.) 1836-1851, 1850-06-21
The Southern Address.

To-day we publish the SouthernAddress. It's.
an able exposition Of oufewrongr. and points, DE-
cidedy. to the remedy. We are glad indeed that
so much unapimity prevailed-and hope, at the
reasse milling of the, Convention not one Southern
State will be unrepresented. The day to decide
whether We will be slaves or freemen, has arrived
let those who wouldbe slaves, opposed South
ern Convention, and favor degrading concession,
miscalled compromise"
The Camden journal. [volume] (Camden, S.C.) 1836-1851, 1850-06-21

IT will be seen that this distinguished Senator
has offered an amendment in the Senate, provi.
ding that the Territories shall come in as slave
holding States if the inhabitants so decide-which
was passed by large vote. With due Difference
to the man Of all others in the Senate, we would
say, this is dangerous ground for the South.
Facts stare us plainly in the face. California will
come in on those grounds. The dreadful Wilmot
Proviso threatening, will be brought to life again
by the North, in order to frighten the shareholders
away from the Territories until Yankees enough
can get there to make another California constitu-
ton, aud thus will they eventually accomplish
what they dare not directly. Is that our best
hope Isit not then, at least the best phlosophyio
see tha worst. They. will pass, BY these very
means, the Wilmot Proviso over every TERRITORY
admit them as free States-and then legiislate to
suit themselves. 81 ...s 49,,
Tie Washington Rnnapays-t is supposed
that the large number of slaves who recently es-
capped must have gone off with Dan Rice's Circus,
and that they concealed themselves in the Wagons.
None have been ecovered-Sduih t:arotinida.
That is good-we only want this distinction,
that those who patroni2e those Northern nuiissn-'
ces-whether they come as Circus players-jouy,
neylnen preachers or school teachers-n -notionyen-
ders-or elsewise, should be the ones TO losethe
negroes. We like the course pursued by the. E T.
isto Islanders last week. A yankee youth, came
down and offered his services to teach the young
Edisto ideas how to ehoot-his preference howev-
The Camden journal. [volume] (Camden, S.C.) 1836-1851, 1850-06-21
TITLE JOlURNAIL..
CAMDEN, S. O..
FRIDAY EVENING, JUNE 81, 1850.

U- Hon. J. L. Oar will please accept our
thanks for various public documents
The Camden journal. [volume] (Camden, S.C.) 1836-1851, 1850-06-21

At Boston, on the 18th, the Court refused the
motion for new trial in the case Of Prof Web,
ster,
The Camden journal. [volume] (Camden, S.C.) 1836-1851, 1850-06-21

Oeen lDree ulneS rejected Oy tne NOIul. TWICE
she has proposed compromise by which she
consented to leave it to the courts Of the United
States to determine her rights. Instead Of requir-
ing sternly their recognition by Congress, fifteen
sovereign States have consented to be carried in
to the courts of the country, and there to submit
their sovereign rights in territory belonging to
them to their final arbitrament. Their humia-
tion did not win the respect or confidence Of the
North. and the proposition was twice rejected.
The South, in our opinion, might accept one
other compromise, not because it is co-extensve
with our rights, but because it has been twice
sanctioned by those who have gone before. If
the North offers the Missouri compromise, to ex-
tend to the Pacific ocean, the South cannot reject
it, provided distinct recognition of our right to
enter the territory south of 36 deg. 80 min. north
latitude is expressed in the compromise. We
should take this line as partition line between
the two sections of the Union; and beside this,
nothing but what the constitution bestows, AL.
though the Northern States would acquire by this
compromise three-fourths of our vacant territory,
they will have renounced the insuffershle preten.
sion of restricting and preventing the extension of
the South, whilst they should extend indefinitely.
Having thus, fellow.citzens, laid before you
statement Of your oondtion-your rights
the remedy which, under present circumstances,
you should accept we leave you for brief space
of time. II Is proper to state to you, that while
we are unanimous in approving the resolutions
which accompany this address, the delegates to
this convention are not entirely unanimous in ap-
proving all the arguments contained init, partcu,