New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-03-30


TESTH DAY
lC--es1et 'yo- s,r5-s Plgs r. i.i' tI,s Tr.'.-'l
B.sros, Fas-r Asr-a ..
A. n.au.es Fa.. e.s7-u acocs Judge h-rrcs -e -
nor o'srs- 'ar 1e prisoner. -'ra-nc7- - 'l-1. sp
t.r re se;e-se
Cl0sISG ARGUMENT ~ M NERBiCK
red ll, .'s-- .l goo. -er---1 90 i- ry - Zee
% e- waisl lse o D. A. -r'e-l &c - -1F
r-fsrr r '- s-r4Ee sl l-e rl-- o. e--- --s-
BE- nav have 81. p-1-er ard ls, e-sci 90 ~ -e--.a-.
and on te co-1rT gea ensl OF "1s c,eaur
-nt corrected 7. 1e d. -. l' ias -i-r IA
Is k-lvl ts c1t resp cte1 - VICE re- 90 k1owr
f-E ID sn--. s-t-eay disappeared a. .ae -ss--h
made which ,re -l-r~ force Cf -h- nlbc il1cuorss
I'D l sol- immunity sal could maze -av sfer
Gay. a. resources ~ei exhausted g.. Al nYs-
.- and darkness suddenly discovery n -snf - -.srs
:. e. % 10 e hi. vss ,ase. To- "a. az an Tso.-4
ne lhac respect i-f above re breath oi SYST
con. -a.d 20 be- lie Murderer. TIE '--os co1mla.y
tc--is1 q. he sane .me ma .1ilvidss .li-
r1irds1 hv me % prison, fre1-.sss ard aone he
vas d-uh-le msd- ro exF sla,.ous-1e sssei 10 sls
20 % . Canaan ere Instances ." c- we .if'" sroi--
IS conduct by .l- r-n..c Tlcc ara -e thousand .l-s
-Hy in when ae ATri tla t--t pfeIicce "o-i n 80
1--WE wsv ald .le --M - ulA break fcr-l DE rested
ID de.-v " -is-ce ~ - pf2HpiN mei s t19~,
verde iol could have k-oFl ...e OF us c--e ssrts-
,itl "1e1 -ol t.oS -c-i -.a > ul. s-n. piss some
ellcr 7a- p 1- facts sleget s-i i lie p-5r
Dumas ~ fscts, some rende1cT a. east yea 4st .sve
bad a t1's mus be dismissed, and yol mus, wee
yourselves ne lei cH o q roV % te a'1ered FROM
re y t1@sses that have hesr examined. We must
he Govern el he issues - be -e1 SRI zee prolf
Submitted Tee Government c-srges Gre defendant wit
me murder 90 Dr. George Parsual with del 1-rse ns ce
Ire issues 20 bee ire- ~ie.ner pr PsrkHan el
1e.- b malice then q rlrrfe.
I'l- mlcs !. NOT proved .seu Be- ray be m,asauet
the .-s44s are LIE s.l. a. t1e H.oIge TIE agent u
ger1re-l occupied great lea. az me. %
.tr. prove IL charges ol- n a. ,lese iar dtys viii
dice ririce of d-ecf testimony. aar gsiuc.s of
proor except circ4usisatl sd ulrec, to prove
r-, proof as Dr Wecs'=r bah any aseleT in The aiding
lie -t1-iy sd promptly adm . hs ae bed A. Interview
v.ta Dr. F1rsual l j 9c.Crs ou tndnf, N1rcule- 3d.
lr sgrcac glIP cse-oeyold ls- D. denied erer 4in-
~ r1 grs.rf. f.st le VAST array ~ ccIr ss1a @v-
r,1cv t1 couvot tie defendant; % So rad lti none. -r
Grs11 Jlr would rot ave "a fr, a-r 1~ would nos
frg- la ..trs winch when examine proves a-t as
ha.ever s.si1-, n. FoF s' thai has been proved Or
fs-fE-an might have oae tis way - 2- l---l ti sa'-
! D. d n ard II never lase seer aim again Sven aim.
1g hai lae remains found IRE -lse % d. Fafsrfg b.
| fo rA4a.1 There 80 macy slcl l ne We vel know
/ la. -.aI re. are often sirsl- ~ f'.al rc....
Lc li -lsrs are aly mars -pou ie bod lrocanE
rave hrel rlrsn,n YET ca JOSH Gale That - Gea,
r13ncrt r VIC elce,te Government produces pl- o.
saul via sc.- AID "a 80 yer on, 81 ne s.le g.
os % p; deat1 ln resard 70 tre re Of 'Sa
nT violence 1e'ofe death because ne fracture j. nH such
i would have been 10 perfectly cac.ned bore be-
fiLss ms, have been broken before cac.4lu1 ln1
ray nave been 1Icstl before d-al 40 i' fracture nav
ave been he csuse OF desfh Blt Or Holmes "a %
Tire sand aLl he hss made qerinen on ne irac'ure
&C. cccacd bores and hose p-rv cslcueo and he nlts
ttf4 laclre o. bone partially cacnea does not d.sr
'r1in isf - served ID t. bone Tue Attorney Genera
49, m II be does not defer % tb- opinion OF Dr Wvusn
man who has made tie SUI eci Of saslony AID esego0
recisr heoues ard be very rroperf sss lai While
e rs.ff v comedies 20 gmau's urrri1r know edge
l The branch 20 which 10 Is devoted he differ ID mars
apuIos ia rc-.I fo ynt.cl tscJ Which le himself
.t.s,ye5 % a. - The med cs tes.riouy rues on
pol ihc witnesses clsacree, and you are e no ,0Ir-e
20 r-asorsb doubt 10 tho clt il he side o Wa eN
sr.ne,i g three distinguished ret cs men, .Ard iu -lf
e-r, WHO have reported upon without conr ldln2 nat
vas made with sharp lsri before deh d. SI0ng,
isflr -sltes Tbs. be regards a. Clean cu b4l te b.
e testimony caves ne medcs. verdict raihef IN
iivor o some cause operating aet dean ana we arc e'
doubt from onseivauon of The remains a. if he To-
sr4ueui -sns mode hy which The decreased came 10 ~
death There are h1lsaDd causes y lcl NAY terr-
human lie. ard In any one n ihe-e ne NfFidla Dol
question msy have been di'psioled t- he Government
my earned associate mss informed You 10 s oruins
bound show thai his hon ia took psce by ne asel
90 q ,tri person. end mat h- person was Ore defend
aafere the Coz eminent hii.ts ats =" eF aence Vhcn
s entirely circumIantA and which cannot warrant YOU
touching drop o. The hearts blood % s dr'ends
Lord Hs-t la41 Gown ilAi 10 amount 'i on lns silt
evidence should INDUCES jury convict unless The body
vas produced Wa msy reasonably doubt whether tois
Vss he BODY 81 Dr. Psi3nisn ard D. "e grant D 10 BE- h
come t0 80 death ~lo1. he --e1cy Of ths de.cnfsni
some robber may have shed h. blood and concealed him
lr while 10 some other pace-lsv have gore IN me sf
aOdr of midnight cad eng access 90 ur Medical Cotgg-
ave taken Advantage 81 the public etci'enen, shout Dr.
Pafkusr 10 place he remains where hev would BE- sup
posed be hi,, Il really they were not his We do u
sav 10 gss 80 bal % might have been Co. potssis
sas lnah Q aad squares well with ms iaacc, lie
or05at.Iae. a. ;ts. the Gc.ernmert has ssslmei w
psI contend that n you fud this be- hr body Of DR.
Pnkns1. and his defendant he sgoui hy waich De-
90 s d-aih Tie crle Is not mulfef. killing viih
deliberate purpose ana ice blt s 81 lth Pr07oca
non snf passion This I know "a ,he ground TIE &c.
-ndani he denies the khng altogether but 81 BE-
ars GUARDIANS - nave not felt A. liberty to zee. bic case
80 narrow foundation W. have taousht wc c4Ehtfo
provide fr the upposuon that he killing Nigh asvr akel
,ac r m l+rr .est u der he r-aions of ne par
yes TIE Government have produced what they would
Gave rerar3 .ha evidence uf De deliberate plan they
ls dserdsn' sedgced be deceased 10 he Ned cal Co.
/ OBJ. H.f q ne H
sud hen .ev lm. rh-v SAY ae did not psy htcagss De-
had not the pav sud ne they undertake o. prove
uy Nj Peee, the collector 20 he icArt money I4ey
slow how ihai al The money lGd him deposited DO
ne Chelsea f y-r Bsnk ana they sccouni for s U.s.
nat al uaimoIey none or not caolsh, remained 1 pay
/ Dr P.lkmau. Wei, gentlemen, hays mined The es
..ure and cOucedo % was 3D. Dr. Webster was u dtH-
,fl ID. Palkfrs1 bic creditor BE owed Money Old
had need Of oil h- received for nc FAMILY SUI We are not
..out some grounds show pad h.s NOR
| .. d. Fsrkrnau which lee sult be paid y having made
lie snew d. Psrknsa Vas iae1orsble and the dsy g.
which re must sete n De exposed io MANY Hu4 4oss OF
ros -vu ~ society vas t"h9 sfpfytcA.n- IT nue. oe
met he prepared himself 10 meet b. eXuaordiuary
! ~ al ar collected Dr. dollars here and hundred DOL.
Sc t-cfc We may De ASKED Wy Goes n'i Or Neis.ef
.fow y nere De- ind hi. money Dr Webster
men no MANAGED BIZ business "ih pfec-on ara iaf-
nal h- soS his definite sum heie and hat here We nty
reci er itai ere one sun 40 i0ry Dol as received
q NJ Feuee which "a. not deposited 70 ihe banA THIS
/ rerv amount iiom New Flgsni barA. hsgirg seen
ns.d io Dr. Parkusn as Dr. Webster it.aes D. Ilst Dr.
Wehser ~. ir possession D. e 10cs and that le
m zee ia. Tie mortgage c.ncerd Dr. rarkuan bet
rrou ssl show ,ar ry ilst be- DID make The pay
l. .1ls f2rer uypOlresls than t a. uf cold
.tersie murder H. gentlemen % he jury. Dr. Fafkusl
id q under hancs n Or Weh.cr. human but
his owe ssw a. human voice huf MS eslf
.1u ie nsnner of b. The circumstances rusf Pc Inferred
/ tom ihos- t ~ know. TIE crime clrfcni, IL r.
ri-ef by fhete circuga-c-s f1 inst ~ mslsausl We
.s- ils feauou of he psrits Dr. FsrAau accused Dr.
Webster at having dcfralded hm. " llun Mr Pet
Gee how be- r.. iossrds him We see FROM NJ shaw here
VIA. seemed cold calculating pressure on he part
] . te creditor alt hers fraffI TIE %
The hunted debtor l. % no, sr slprcsuol. consider.
sHrf an u ~ rf q q
D. parties wss that VcL hey came ogei1er hey rushed
INTO -clfcL ard ty Sudden blow re creditor f-4 T~l
Cd SUPPOSE cod cacu4-n uIfders1 entirety fore ~ 'o
character 81 ilr pa0y-~e nav suppose tat lr ns
oct rlsh boz would aave been f0 fl-l frh
s- Floc.a r. i1l coma dr. the relation " -e DdIes-
IRE 20 i1c Pc SAB seclent co-duct t1 qualify Tie
a re scL e temp Ailou ray have cone ron
rlverfv sud tis s b, aer TIE deed. currez
-aNrg ial-n "a &c slrp, he met 1eces.arv have
.ts-l sroheF-Ae mas ave his been lr-Icec o Go
AJAX tne evidence does not bear Quito tle.e
Ar1ryr1ous i-srs Oh me cliy o. G0ger1ner
n aFtru. iae c-Iert ig - .ut cl-rt charges
IA -ril CERTAIN kni'r Je-- " Webster s.--cs Ccoi
/ fl-kal-lH TIE ieccrc clargss fl = - srcse tY a
f7 h- artd II Of these b. proved slflcent
ru. rrrr- Tia neither u .-ese proved. TIE r-
count -es iJl.l -er - t-e ~ -cA rot prov 81
The fo1l c1l- charges uarncr 80 90 he J-y . -l
Culrt n he vsur ol Which Urv VII llsl-c rcr. tlt
l, c.fIrt i. e -cfFe. Tue Govern &C. Is LoWe-
'or- l-rs-s RAY ard -a1y col--.
please. r-t bound 10 -aie De mes1s - cest. iEs
i-- le.-ucslt Alrw low prepare trss.f flI ,s .
] U 80 . 81 Ia "