davidaulloa/AmericanStories huggingface dataset:
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-02-11

o. The Memory n tenacious Of Imperfans
facts especially WHOM hey have direct reference W,
pocket; and hence he man who has purchased par
Boo., Shoes, Caters here ssvu sorgsn ne way"
IaxIeIA a AzrHe
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-02-11
FTRTHER FROM EUROPE.

b Bf;s's ge-c.IHS TslrSyspA
E.l1FAr TELESE4rn OFricr
Saturday, FEB :, ias@
Toe Europa e1perisBced heavy bead winds da-
r.nz 7 OIL q Der passage.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-02-11
Steamsr Falcon.

HALrrsK Saturday. Pei. O.
Great fears ar entertained here for the safety o
m steamer con- ro days over due Al thi, port from
NeTf1und aui
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-02-11

Tho General Bond Account mas been reduced ei,l9
during The year The Rsa Estate Bond Account lac
increased $4,000 for lots tie Thry -ihlfd
. SOD Fo0dhsy No Resi Estsis has been cold durng
tie yesr cra"y money borrowed on Real Estate
The business u The present year viii probably Afford
considerable Of receip,s $40 and wou, say
material Increase OF service Al many points le iIa
establishments commenced % about 70 be under
taken the populaeo Is rapidly ucreasng, and the auen
OF manufacturers and producers VI ell Kinds constant
ly turning toward the line Bot great Of enlarged
win be found IN the freight rsns about 10 be &C.
tablshed by tie New Haven Railroad Company, whose ar
raDsenso,s making Tor the transportation oflfegI
10 and from interior OF New-Eng and, ~ u ne
numerous railroads extending from the New Haven Road
lnD very centres Of hose States The share VI this yas
business which viii accrue the roaj VIII be- earned ~
ANAL expense u current shsrges due 10 the crest cost
aud uneHsnped facilities afforded BY shs Harlem koAf'
ron ne position IN lhs 81 lhs Guy OF New fors
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-02-11

a~xSrcAx MUsErN-TSs arse Of iae Loi,efy 60 =
- 80 .hak IN hCussrcs Of siaes n "a day, a-d IS
p.-,--s-se no convuisve. Of Deeheisus@1 ~ =
- ,i.v,Ss th.s afternoon ard evening Tbs Two S.o~ps>
= n go tAe RAvels made such tremendous D :
- sS,eh the M.ranesus DO equally wei sle sso 81
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-02-11
CATTlON fOTHF PUBLIC

~ The gresf popularity Of LYoS's Magnetic Powder.
for tCsrctnn % Bsdbug- COckrOsches and I'll other
insects has prompted cesin parties iO manufacture spn
nous artice and onrT 70 Tor sale about The The
pr0yeiO vi the srA and genuine article has agents
IN tie city, and car purchased only ~ DO depot ~
Brosdway where De obtained PHI. for tie nsaL
isneous destruction Of Rats and Nice Both articles are
warranted % coutain no poison ~ 3tO6ltW-
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-02-11
CITY ITEMS.

- For 4 great number OF City. Brooklyn " "
ss5urgh, Hobokeu, Jersey City Snt Newas ieIa' see
Ouiste ant especially The SuPp.ezsnf
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-02-11
HOROKFN lrEMs.

CONCERT Al Sr. P,rLs-We learn that thi-
concert Vas iay Successful he proceeds reaching ahou
$3.50 From acquaintance wih several u he aides WI
10 Tie money promise thai Il viii be JUDI
cousy AID carefully expended FOR nc relief Vi he poor
children fog HON g va. ra--t.
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-02-11

Mas B0sTWlck's C0yCERr--Our rsa1cfs WI
reco-eci hat . Coneer, takes place tonight .he =
mae Academy She viii have he assistance Of Mesns
Tlmm Kyle and Dotwouh and 9fcouT,e VII have lara
audience
- DAILY, the stage dri' er vas baiied on Sstur-
DAY In Gee 10 apossr and such etAlgs lgt. be-
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-02-11

PvpoLKS, W.~rsn-wssred about - more good fu1-
-rs 70 70 Wes where they VII receive st Per TN snt
steady employment Taos- wishing 70 90 oct VIII use
hs.fe - the furnaces rAPdiy ang Up Enquire 81
Icg~ n BROWN Co DRY Gosd Merchants MArke', rear
y,.,-.s., Phrsiep Phi. Passages PAID cut sflv--
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-02-11

For TEX RrtIEF FryD-The German Liedes-
srasig assisted b other musical societies proposes
20 give Concert Wednesday s., The Tabernacle Tor The
be@s, OF sufferers by the Ilsguest calamity THIS j.
good opportunity hear good masc and contribute 90
GOOD ohiec
New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1850-02-11

Tuly more disastrous accident has Dsver Ane1ed GU
CIV nor one which strongly calls for sympathy a9d -
.istsaoe 10 he suffering fisnes Of he Wounded and ~
Dead
FOR various notices incidents 3e eou1ecsed WIN IA
sd tsr we refer Ire reader oe poruons Of or resu-
ar sheet and Supplsmentl
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09
l32,O66 l2 1
$3,O92,9y3 81 G

The total amour. of the State debt which
would have become due on the 3lst of De-
cember, 1850, payable in the city Of New
York, was "a, 1886, $50 76. AS no means had
been provided for the payment of this debt,
it was deemed desirable by the General AS
sembly, to extend the time of payment, by
issuing new stocks for the redemption Of the
certificates becoming due.
Accordingly, under The act 'to authorize
the Canal fund Commissioners to exchange
certain certificates of the funded debt Of this
State" passed on the 2lst Of March, l849,
and the act amendatory thereto passed on the
18th March 1850, the Fund Commissioners
have Issued $l025,O 900 90 of five per cent.
stock, payable in the city of New York at
the pleasure Of the State, after the 3lst De-
cember 1866, 81 ,5l7, ,468 AZ, of six per
cent. payable after the 3lst December, 1870,
and 81 100000 90 of six per cent. stock,
payable after the 3lst December, 1875,
The premiums received upon the new stock
amounted to more than three hundred thou
sand dollars, after the payment Of al char
ges and expenses. In additions to this pre-
MUM, six hundred and twenty-five thousand
dollars of the six per cent. stock; thus saving
in interest nearly an additional hundred thou-
sand dollars. ....
The foreign debt Of the State on the first of
January, 1850, was $l6.680, 1882 so. This
debt on the first day of January, 1851, will
be SIC, $3.50, 773 So, being reduction during
the year Of S3l4,2OS 81.
There is now in the hands of the Fund
Commissioners, and in the Treasury, subject
to their control, surplus revenue, sinking
funds, land funds and other means, exceed
ing seven hundred thousand dollars, which is
tothe payment ofithe balance of
seven per cent. stock. 1t is not therefore
deemed necessary to make any further proyis-
ion foT the, payment Of the stock becoming
due in j 85ls ; The means alreadyin the hands
Of the Fund Commissioners, with the reve-
huesand resources Of the current year, will
enable the Commissioners promptly to pay |
'hc bplpnceof tIle one million five hundred
,Ihlcd Tine, and 80 .tlio mater kfup0s.- =
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09
R. msining in the institution, Nov. 5, 80. 424

r maining in the institution, Nov. 5, 80. aga
Upon the subject of the prison, and the ad-
ministratlon of the criminal law, i feel i'm
PEELED, from sense of duty, to remark that
there is almost a constant throng of appli-
cants for pardon. These applications are
not made and signed by friends merely, but
frequently by the Judges of the Courts, Jurors,
Sheriffs, Prosecuting Attorneys, and other
county officers. n alaBon teJs
These petitions almost universally set up as
o reason for executive interference, that it isthe
first offence; that the offender is young, and has
been the dupe Of more artful adopts in crime
that reform, the object of punishment, has been
effected; that the ends of public Justice have
been subserved, the supremacy of the law vildi-
Gated, and therefore the prisoner ought to be dis
charged. All this leads to the reflection whe-
ther the law ought not be so amended as to re-
duce the minimum length Of time for punish
ment giving the courts greater latitude accor-
ding To the circumstances Of mitigation or agra
vaton which shall surround each case Again,
as the object Of punishment is two-fold, the
protection of society and therefomation of the
criminal, the question arises whether it would
not be better accomplished by a. graduation OF
the length of punishment by the number of con-
victiOns. Would not the offender, KNOWN .
that the second offence would be more severely
and more certainly punished, be more likely "a
be deferred from the commission OF itY. The
whole matter Is submitted to the wisdom Of The
General Assembly. Nt1 q fiis1AGi ~, n
The great object Of punishment, which is
the protection Of community from the depre-
dations Of the vile, may be batter accomplish.
.ed by preventing the commission. OF the evil,
Than byenacting laws for Furnishing The off
endar after the crime is committed. The
State Reform School Of Massac husetts. estab-
iished lor that purpose, has thus far exceed
ed th3 most sanglrins expectations of its be.
lneyolent projectors. The building can ac.
conmodate three hundred, and are now ,full
of bright youth, who perhaps from penury
and want, had violated the law; who, per,
haps were driven from home, to stray tbron gh
the lanes and streets Of the towns and cities
without protection or instruction. compelled
TO beg or steal or starye; and who perhaps,
had never heard the voice Of pity or friend
ship. Here they are cared for, and instructed
by those whose hearts are warmed with the
hope and prospect Of the good before them;
they become contenied, happy, and .anbi.
tious; and who in most instances, max fail
promise Of becoming respectable citizens. -
~ From the condition OF this State, the time
is not distant when necessity and policy.
and an adherence to that enlightened course
Of benevolence which has heretofore charac-
ierized our legislation will require forors az
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

states Treasury: because it attemptsto make ex
pafte testimony, taken in another jurisdiction,
final and conclusive in cases where the, effect
may bet0 enslave man and his posterity for all
time, aud commits the decision OF this question
Of civil liberty tooficers not selected for their
judicial wisdom or experience; because 1t at
tempts to compel the citizens of free States to
aid in arreSting and returning to slavery the
man who is only fleeing for liberty, in the same
manner as they would rightfully be bound to
aid aman fleeing from justice, charged with
the commission Of high crime and misdemea
nor.
Finally: In relation to the mode Of trial and
other particulars, the law is contrary to the ge-
MUS and spirit Of our free institutions, and there
fore dangerous to both free and slave States,
and consequently ought to be amended OF re-
pealeds But a forcible resistance TO this ornny
other law, is only rebellion, and is not the way
to procure the remedy. Let there be gener-
Gus confidence in all parts of the nation, each
with the other; let the evils be plainly laid be-
fore the law-making power Of the country; let
argument and reason, and love of country be the
ruling principles, and the constitution will pre-
vail; let law bepassed giving to the master his
constitutional rights only, based upon common
principles of evidence, adjudication and execn-
ton, thus being consistent with the spirit Of
our Free institutions, andI venture the assertion
that i WILDE fulfilled to the letter and spirit,
IN all parts of the Union, and the country again
settle down in harmony and peace.
Once more the interests of the people are
committed tn your wisdom. And again would
add my fervent supplications to the Supreme
Ruler of the Universe, that providential care
may still be continued to the State; that virtue
and the love Of country may be fixed in the
breasts of the people, and their liberties beper-
petuated, SEABURY FORD;
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

CAsslus M. Clay, delivered the intoduc-
tory lecture before the Young Mems Library
Association in Cincinnati, on Tuesday even
ing, to a densely crowded auditory, His
subject was The Theory of Morals. From,
a critical notice in one Of the papers of the,
Queen city, we judge the lecture was characc z
teristic Of the lecturer, bold, independent;
and reckless, representing theethical opinions
of the individual himself, rather than those
established upon the foundations Of inmuta.
BILE truth, orderived from sources Of general
and recognized authority. ia5ora,.oS .,s, IN
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

SENATOR FoorE.-The Mississippi Legis-
lature has passed resolutions censuring Mr..
Foote for his support of the compromise,
and inyitingh him to resign. It very certain
that he will moi accept of the polite invita-
ton. He will make his appeal TO the people.
who, we have not doubt, win sustain him.
The people will censure the Legislature far
more efectually than that body is capable Of
censmtng the gallant and patriotic Senator. !,
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09
90 09l 1893 50 6

~ EXPENDITURES:
Paid General Assembly, Judi
: cial and State officers, State
Institutions, claims and
incidental items 1891 1856 4S /
Repairs of public works 329, ,596 90 0
Repairs Of National Road,
&c. ~ 47,242 &C 0
Interest on Domestic Bonds 1854 66 0
interest on foreign debt l,022,3 95 0
Common school fund dis
ributed 100000 90 o
Interest on special school and
trust funds 97,272 81 O.
One per cent. on surplus rev.
enue $3.50 Sc |
Three per cent. fund paid l3,246 81 0.
On account Of next January
interest l43,3S2 AS 0
Fund Commissioners on ac-
count of State debt 657,866 "a 3
Claims transferred to the At
torney General for collec-
ton 1882 o. 0
Domestic bonds redeemed by
the Treasurer $4,000 90 0
Miscellaneous items paid l,709 80 0
Total amount drawn from
the Treasury 1850 927 68 5
Balance remaining in the
Treasury on the 18th No ,.h
vember, 1850 .,..4 l32,O66 l2
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

/ The EPISCOPAL CONVENTION, of New
York, assembled to elect a Provisional Bishop
in place Of Bishop onderdonk, adjouroed
without making any choice.
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09
Portsmouth, December 9, 1860.

OHV b. PALMER, the American Newspaper
Agent, is the only authorized agent for this
paper in the cities Of Boston, New York, and
Philadelphia, and is duly empowered to take
rates as required by us. HIS receipts will be
regardedas payments. ,aa
OY Our publication day being on Mon
day, all advertisements and notices orpub-
ication. must be handel in on Saturday.
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

OTMr. Paine gave an exhibition Of lis
gas light, at Worcester, Mass, on Tuesday
!ast, He intends 10 send an agent TO Lon
don to introduce the gas at the Worlds FAIR.
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09
A Knotty Point.

A list has beenmade out of $50 pamphlets
on Baptismal Regeneration, elected by the
late Gorham controversy.
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09
Endowment OF wealth.

The appraisers of personal property Of the
estate of Mr.. McDonough, the New Orleans
Millionaire, found the value Of his entire
werdrobe to be thirty dollars.
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

The police Of Philadelphia have been
furnished with revolvers, which in future
will form part Of their armament.
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

GooD.-lt is said that the Union members
of Congress have agreed to vote downat once
all movements towards re-agitation of the
compromise measures -
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

Os- During the week ending Nov. l6,
there were lat interme nts, in New Orleans,
Of which 80 were OF Cholera. The cholera
has broken out at Placuemine.
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

OThe steamer Gayoso was destroyed by
fire at Memphis the other day. Insurace SlS
600,
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09
Good!

At the election recently held in Georgia for
delegates to the convention, the Union party
carried the State by an overwhelming majority
probably $4,000.
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

The population Of New York it is uscer-
ltained is nearly halfa million. m
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

thousand dollars seven per cent. stock due on
the 3lst December, 1851 a 4
On the first of July, l645,
the,amount of the State
debt as statedby the Fund
Commissioners in their
report Of january, l649, f
:, was S2O,Ol8.5lO So
The total amount of debt of
the State on the first of
January, 1851, will be as
follows:
Forgn debt $l7556,773 50
Domestic Bonds 493,6 90
ISeh'l. & trust fas gys.Ylg
funds l,6ss,99e0O l VI ts
A1G rAA pEA %
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

Amount of principal paid
since LIST Of July, l845
Add to this the funds now
in the hands OF Commits
sionefs and in the Treas
ury set apart ior the pay-
ment Of the foreign and
domestic debt as it be-
comes due lN nt
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09
GOVERNORS MESSAGE,
Gentlemen Of tRe Senate

NGateMtH oI thc pcNdtC M
and House Of Rtprcsentdttvts:f
Another political year of our State is adj
ded to the past, and in pursuance OF the Con-
|stitution, the people, BY their representatives,
have assembled to examine their affairs and
consult for the common good. The fact that
from year to year The people are thus assem-
bled to look after their own interests. and that
administrations are peaceably schanged by the
self-renoyating and propelling power Of the
Constitution alone, is beautiful and striking
illustration of the srlperior excellence of onr
free institutions. We NAV with oreat nro-
prety first direct olr attention 10 the c;rcnno- :
stances which demonstrate the goodness Of
Divine Proyidenee on whose no2ver I'VE are
dependant for all we enjoy. and render 10 Him
that large measure ot gratitude which we
owe for The bles sings Of The mast wear. In a
few places, that as vet mysterio,1s DESTROYER
Of maI--the cholera--has prevailed with its
usually distressing incidents, but with this
exception, general health has prevailed
throughout our borders. Much more Than
usually abundant haryests Of al kinds have
rewarded the labor of the husbandnan. Com
merce, the mechanic arts, and all the various
branches of industrial pursuits. have steadily
increased. Peace and order have prevailed
The administration of n,stice has been duly
regarded. The projection and SUPREMACY Of
law is still felt and acknowledged by the peo-
| ple. Intellectual and moral instruction nm.
der our present iudicious regulations, have
been extended generally TO all classes, and
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

RECEIPTS:
General revenue received du-
ring the year 1850 $275,902 OF 0
Canal tax, including $l25,000
Sinking fund 968,443 20 0
Canal tolls and water rents 72S,085 70 O
Turnpike and canal dividends 29,838 20 0
Canal lands sold 1851 AZ 0
Surplus revenue repaid 1928 85 0
School and ministerial lands sold &c. .664 81 s
,,I,ccocl 3 s,I,ncol s1,;a S;;;. ,.s,sss,.--ferred from
taxes collected $4,000 90 o
Interest upon surplus revenue
fund a1 59,74l se 8
Tax on Banks and Insurance
Companies 56,42S 95 0
Tolls upon Western Reserve
and Maumee Road l2,043 SO
National Road Tolls $1,000 IL
Miscellaneous items 1925 13 0
Total amount Of receipts du- b9
ring the year $2,536, ,558 40 3
Balance in the Treasury on the
18th Nov. le49 555, ABS 40 3
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09

.ll'|
AsMpDERE TRLL.--The Meredith Bridge
IN H1 Gazetteis responsible for the fol-
loving story ssl,g5,s .1s,
Ma Nathaniel Whittier Of Lake Village,
thecalebssfed Sharp Shooter, made two
capiial shots afew days since, with bis il1etflh-
tucKyR Rsfle, near Province Road meeting
house in EilWanton. The first murk was
ihs boW loiu llayPipe held BY tbesem oftbe
same ID gfnii, mouth, which was
hit bgfic ball and quickly dispatched a a
distsilee of So yseds. The second shot, the,
sameiismpce, wasahan apple. lain upon
The head of 3 genileman, which wssa readi.
IL dispstrbed. This is mo- fctionso Seyerai
witntsses Ktfe "a Attendance. Ehoare ready
f6osl fQf thrs9hosG assertion
Vest q dlnlicf. fref iyi ielf II
The Portsmouth inquirer. [volume] (Portsmouth, O. [Ohio]) 1849-1855, 1850-12-09
PORTSMOUTH INQUIRER.

FRANCIS CLEVELAND, EDITORS AND
ALEX, PEARCE, PRoPRlEroRs. +,
The national era. [volume] (Washington [D.C.]) 1847-1860, 1850-04-04
VIRGINIA AND OHIO.

A few weeks ago, we noticed a ridiculous re-
commendation Of the Governor Of Virginia TO the
Legislature of that State, 10 consequences OF the
refusal of Gov Ford, Of Ohio, to surrender GER
tain person, charged with inducing slave 70 e.
cape from Virginia. The Ohio STATE Journal gives
the following history OF the affair
"A black man, named Buck, once slave In
Hampshire county, Va, had, by the last will Of
his master, been set free. He came TO the State
Of Ohio and settled Amer some time he went
back to his old home, but soon returned 70 Ohio.
After he LEFT Virginia, the Grand Jury OF Hamp-
shire county found bill Of indictment against
him said bill contained two counts. The hrst
count charges Buck with advising certain slave,
named Nelson, to abscond from his master The
second count charges him with furnishing Nelson
with copy Of his former masters will, BY which
be (Buch) was liberated, for the purpose OF being
used 10 deceive others This indictment was
found In June, is49. In December last she Gov
erDor Of Virginia sent special sgent here 70 de-
mand Buck a. fugitive from justice lie brought
an authenticated copy Of the indictment NO OBJ
The national era. [volume] (Washington [D.C.]) 1847-1860, 1850-04-04

lection was at any time made to the form Of the
requisition. After careful examination Of the
documents, Gov Ford called to his assistance the
Attorney General of the State, Henry Stanbery,
and the papeps were all submitted to him, with a
request that he would examine them and report
upon their sufhciency, &c This was done, and
Mr.. Stsnbery soon after submitted to the Govern
or written opinion that the papers did not
make out case which authorized or required
the Governor TO grant the requistion asked. II
assumes that the intention Of that clause Of the
Constitution requiring fugtives from justice to
be delivered up, did not cover minor classes Of
offences in the criminal codes Of States, but had
reference only to the higher class, such as muir
der, arson, &c. IL AYERS that offences charged
in the indictment are not offences in Ohio, that
no such crimes are known to the common law ;
that neither the common nor the statute law re-
cognising any such offence as is charged, the Gov
ernor, in accordance with well-settled and long
continued practice, ought to decline compliance
with the reQuisstion These views correspond in
all respects with the views Of Gov. Ford in the
premises, and therefore, on the Dist Of February
last, he wrote a letter to the Governor Of Virgin
ia informing him of the result of his deliberations
And thus ended the case, so far as Ohio is con-
cernedn