The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1849-09-27

n
z; H. Judson, George Douglass,
Inomss Bennett, John Norris
1sr Met'heMs, bugn Mclaughlin,
Ae1ander Hossack Thomas Green,
Dsniei "A. Aor1ance' James O'Nen
l. Joseph BrowDer 7e6 Green wich street
6orpenns Dewitt; liquor dealer l35 Amos street
psud rage, public house corner OF West and Ho-
soAen streets
Iatrck Downey tinsmith, Ss1 Grand street.
robert w sterhouse grocer, 81 Pitt street.
Sh" buckftone grocer, 10 Amos street.
4 VIM Browning Ss< Washington street
Alsnson IL Scudder dry goods "A Hammond st.
o. Jeremish Hswley fruit merchant 10 Fulton street.
10. Themes Cooper, grocer lo3 East Broadway.
II. Sorbsm T. Taylor grocer lz2 Monroe street.
~. Dand Newman grocer 81 Broad street.
counsel Tor the Poopie-Messrs Mckson, Whiting
AND fnilnps
Counsel TOT the Defence-Messrs Smith, Bustsed
SHERWOOD hiorrison' bisnckmsn, Cornell, Scheu and
boudnot
THIRTEENTH DAY.
sept. 2o.-The Court was opened at half past ten
O'Clock, and the summing up proceeded with
MIR. scsElL addressed the Jury in behalf Of Thomas
Green He faid that In order to convict his client II
must De proven hrst that riot occurred before his
client was arrested; and secondly, that Green
90. IN .nss '. ne claimed tnst nad
1;yesn IS arrr.s,sa r. ~ uu.,s ri's'
.iart IL ,,a,Hy , ro" re...a uis s W MS
On The t.stsw"nu ~ na1;s" NJ w uua St
~ rao.;r.a LII ~. 1870 '' a.. -S ~ ~ nus
10. s wiz I'm, A., oau.ioo MT Scnen occupied
MIR M.ss,sor connssi sor Iamas 0p,N.u v..,,.,.x.
20 sdarass sh ;" ~ Ia n "a e' wa sas s,
~ $500. -. ~ 100 10 noA W qusiiei WIN
~ ths n,ssS;na i,Ss IN M, ~ su Soa,ss
Quarrel with the prosseutins counsel He c,s%sS ,h,t
S;s c,is,t hsd nnt hssa ,rov.u -. r. 49, Wy ,es
n.,t,.;nsnt a. r. go :. - L;.sIs s gu
baisf ana mads bsnH."m Tar.. '.e ro'' hs was
NJ S ~. ".nS s .s . ru.rsss ,..,
bn h;.h ~ honI" b. .u .ns. nc nAS POM
hsan na,fsc,iy ..,isaaa ~, spa,S ~ 1877 - @ c
be besv ed himself to be- IL would be- x.sts Of tims
80 rrrs,s ~, ...- <..h "'~iu 70 s"~S'' vi 'il'0
AZ MKrns Whs, a. ~ .o,,
Nj Sm,In"To ons.b o ~ yo ;n piopusv,
NJ y y. a. ~ sne ,nu ,uiens ,.,
,nn,,"r -, t e :. 70 msNs
hrsn two tb,qa. romn,.t.n mS .sr .ns case nsS
had actually summed up.
,hs Conr. h .I was Mtosssner IN tne discretion OF
now near .ns on motion 20 arrest Judg.
thst xrai, 10 .aa % vas ienoereo Snouio
nAas h snss ns wSulS near Ine Aigument
LILA - .nu r 40 49, snouiu prove sooo'
M s,-. I'LL ~. ~ ~. ,o,n,n r,...
SMin ,r s'ou n'S Po'n's' 'h'-Ahs' tne IN
"iI 1. .nr M 70 oe,ec.ss-
,d, ,h,s IL aoes not $40" iof VIII" purpose the
fio.eIs sssem ~, oiso.
second, Inc Indictment 10 DEFECTIVE In not averring
va. ' ac wers cons 70 .ne terror OF inc people
ton ''''" -""0i''i'' ~ 'uPpof'oi nS posi-
"on
Mr.. McKEor stated in bis own Defence that the in-
dctmeDt used was blank form flled up, and that
wells District Attorpeyship, (some twenty yesrs)
Mr. SMTH's authorities are to sustain the nrst point:
sustain the second point The su,bortirs y. CARING
ton Paine. 1910; Russell on Crime, 222-8; ]. Hsw-
kins' Pleas OF the Crown5lS
The Court overrued the motion to quash the indict
nent Mr.. SAITH took exception to the decision, and
the summing up was resumed by Mr. Whiting
Mr. WHIrIro said. the time had come when the prose
cution to be heard The counsel the other side
had supposed that the defendants to be pursued
: victims appease broken law Some had even sup
posed them TO be pursued by private prejudice In
community where law prevails-where the bowie knife
Is not made the resort OF persons seeking to redress
wrongly you, gentlemen, are not excited, not
excited the Court is not excited. who, then,
cited! Why, they are the defendants here The pub
lie are anxious to zee this matter certified II These de-
DdsDts guilty IL would he said be the duty
Of the jury to find them apdt would remsn with the
Court 70 Pr.seribe the Punhhmept there should be
doubt OF the guilt Of the defendants or any OF then,
~ would De tbs dnty, rs IL undoubtedly would be the
pessos' OF .he Jury 70 render verdict OF not guilty.
was me ou'y OF tne Jury 10 dispose OF prisoner,
w,nout regard 70 rank OF poilon according TO the
EVIDENCE sooueed. we nave after several moiions on
ire part u f smith VINO appears here as the counsel
Tor the piincipa the rpgieaders OF these rioters
come 10 TINS point ih,s dount thst nave tpoks on,
q; n's,, o ~ nnas s"a 'nu sha.
~ sppsar mat bese o.enaant- are every enc OF them
euiy. hey IRE Ina,otea LOT iloe no" ,ne counsei
Oh .ne u'n't nos ma. go 70 ior M nus sumo
100 - 80 ~ ~. ~ 1s ~ W ",y .o.A
,ohe ana my loIo soreooey eiso why genuemen,
you VIII ara cry oI your oli,ufsn Nns' TO. vs. .hey
WI sWs you very cf,ec. ueunioou on tns ~oru rlo.
hr '. h'irg 10 simple isnsusss oise''sa OF law .erms'
mere pfoe-s1ed 70 ts, what wss Atot livery tnmuIu-
Gus y, 'hs s"ss.s; cons''',ns y, 'nlsa .,
more persons ne tsid- hsVing oennite OBJECT
81 lnNsN nature 70 aeeoinpRbr sho !o'nmg'
70 sec'nbnsh mat ouJoe., .Dey were rioters.
Wy lii sel IN e0hysr. 70 1ceonpns, oes
oweet, ~ tuihcient mat th.ir acts All tend
70 'hc "c.o"phshihen. VI $50 otIece ine 90
jet must be oi IriVe,e nature, because. ~ II IS
n a...s
~ "a 70 VIZ Sne" pIoues ~ ongui1e
lh's ne s'oehce ens. l.' me sp.ss ., sns rensra
NsuS ~ ~, , ' .u''e. ~, Wv u.ieno' ~
nv cshs' 81" UNITS " '"'se roor ouys wer so ,ne
.se,,tc.s VII, w." Iss' rns,ssos,I VINO W.T. sso
I''blupt party leao'rr WIZ n'.nNeu W ~ ~ i",ts,
mo,s grofh ,aum'y cou,o hot oe u.efea ny ,ne Ups
oI nunhh usipH' ni "nl',pR p'ie pe-sos n i'5n
,ui Euin ofon ~, ~ ~ y, puno
Iostcuor' ouEn, paID W ~ i ~. Nv
"ue We bs ,i hE 70 "Ihs,'ns P.Il'icSi Pn.Ies;
put ~ We noe aii n'ioDs 70 ohs .ouuDsy'
vi 10y va ~ p',y :, a.. I'm ~
sbo nc htu hth, 70 pay ,n,rs, sou .r rorre,. or
~ I,nor ~ ~ - W n.'ei'.I' :" "
~ l % ~ ~ Nh" 80 " w Pu . "ni
NY I'.st DC tus .y ~ Huu ,cu"'v,"s W ~
Nr ro.'et' or nis h'.nuS' La'e ~" w. y,
Ihi ID we h'le.t neA.u'es tutsu'a 'htbf' the ~
ny gu ol,a'h huN' -, SOY h't ~n''n ~, P.ose
,hen hslun'h,s"y tI'y ouEu, ', mANe " snosn
to ,se floPo, oh' Vl vac 'nibs" Vppp
hcn,s co. eaito ..F nrcIesoI ",ul.s nis
ras IN tsd ,s'te MI nacresaJ loVta our Ia itnonsi
no Nst sDVe, 20 oiltb ~ Ia'niJ 49, =. 'u.-
ess un TO- nsrs ,, -
Nticn causeo IN. o'ah ~ 20 mspy henAn utlhgs nna
QUIZ tnete'rny OF slSh'y persons elestsa on tnas