The New York herald., 1849-05-28

sponsibiiity from which he ought to be exempt Sup
pose the next Assembly should adopt the view Of
the expedition to Italy the present Assembly has
done how could the President after this letter change
his system How could he work with ministry act
legislature in condemnipg acts in which he had taken
an active part and made himself personally response
BILE? The rumor here to- day is that the letter he
President s the act Of himself but Of his
The nsme Of the minister Who drew II up s publicly
spoken Of and the object which i'll nstured people attr
butte to the govern s IL true not altogether cred
able TO itself or fair to the President It IL said that
the ministry feeling that it, acts likely to make 1t
unpopular with the country il determined that the
Individual members themselves For this the
letter was written to Napoleon Bonaparte which forced
him to return so abruptly from Madrid-a letter which
was rounded on circumstance which Is ascertain
ed never TO have taken place and of which the only
effect is to disunite and throw discred the Bona
parte family while IL weakens their adherents an IL
is for this purpose that the letter to udinot Ia
now pnbhe letter which can have object in the
world but to implicate the President with his Minister'S
"h>le insulting the Liberal party and hurlng defiance
Mt the National Assembly. \ he affair has created a
most painful sensation among the Bonapart list party
see IN th and some others OF the recent acts
OF the government The ruin OF the party but the
other hand 1t reoices the hearts Of the adherents Of
the Bourbons whose objects it well tends to serve.
Ihis letter led to the following violent
DEBATE IN THE ASSEMBLY THE 9rH INST
Some local bills were adopted without dis cussiou
The fRESipENl- The tribune is to NJ Grevy for in
terPeatons to the government marks Of interest
M GREvN said that the Assembly had Monday
night adopted resolution relative to the trench h
troops in Italy The first which was to be noticed
WAS letter from the President of the Republic pub-
lished in the Pdirie OF last night and reproduced
lhis morning in the Monetr. The honorable mber
here read the letter in question: He wished to learn
II that document which was not countersigned by any
minister was to be considered official or private
one He wished to ascertain what feeling dictated
u; ana according to the answer which he might
ceive. he would propose such rs might ap-
pear to him called Tor by the dignity and interests
the republic. (Hcar. hsar)
NJ y. BARRoT, the President of the Council replied.
that the very manner in which the honorable GENTLE
man bad proposed his question dictated the of
The answer which he had to give. The letter evil
d. nty of private character (narks of dissent on
the ef was one of encouragement given to the sol-
d;.annrnb"iIon % on ,h OF gra."Iae Menewed
private letter. addressed to the general of the exped
tion and the very fact that not signed by any
minister proved that 1t was Of a private character
Still, it did not follow from that crcumsta nee
that the government declined the responsibility
which it ought to davow. (Dsapprobatoa the left J
or what there in that letter that could be con
sdcred contrary TO the resolution adopted Monday
night by the Assembly? He would ask if the cabire
had not pressed the committee that day. state
precisely what course the government ought to take
with respect to the army in Italy 1t had requested
the committee to say whether the French troops were
to withdraw to Civita Veccha Were they to
Italy But not one member of the committee was
found prepared to what ought to be the course
follow. he committee had unanimously declared,
that they did not by any means intend to bind down
the government to any fixed line Of conducts that they
desired to allow it every fair liberty of action In
the discussion Of Monday night had been the same
time too early and too atetoo early because the full
particulars OF the case had not been received too
Int because the troops had become too fully engaged
to admit of an honorable withdrawal Even now facts
o,, a,e ,nsnrs o9t beyond any doubt the government
"ouu rum pe IN poseseioh OF the details. telc
EaPne ufPa'cn hao peen received at rouon. stating
lhat letters haa arrived there from the genera-in
t & nu 's. a 'nelr contents would be forwarded with
out deay 1he hdd reason TO beere
mal q NE tree f''nmr1s at Rome two had declared IL
bowxy.r a,d na re .L a,.neh noops tmovement) lie
t, u;u @ o' .uks On hlmselI 70 anirm that as
i"et tince IL WAS only communicated In private let
,d ,ha, ~ ,S h ., iaets' ne consd
iu sa' ~ "ouu DC wses; 10 ADJOURN the discussons
LoekinS now NJ the quesuons OF NJ Grevy ne had to
roy MN iePect 10 the letter OF the PRESIDENT OF the
-. .o n. iuIiy herseu IN the senti-
nnu "i'A i,.ePeo. W .ie resolution OF tne Assembly
""rn,t w s., nc haa 70 oeciare Inat the
od ,% ovnrrnnt ~ G"iy ~ OUT most iuily Al
in order to communicate to the government at home
an Una. passeu maj gentleman nad received precise
US " "na' nc au 10 90 ana those instruc-
'ons nc ""e yuite reaay 10 communicate TO the AS
temoy LOOMING Al the reiations OF the French re-
pubic with foreign powers he must dwell on the ne
sy Vi no' %i,o"s .he iorce anu ihnuencc OF france
W y. ~oaHeneI py n.erhhi DIVISIONS thear, hear) In
ars , nn such gs'"y, al passion ought to be most
.uoy . pu. asiue. How many instances could there
ho pe OF othcr nations when in criti-
cai pos.'ons .ngng away private causes OF dissent
s ~ az hclr FORCES 10 meet the hour OF
u"ouiy ,io uioueh' such was tne course wncn would
a, oe Host worthy oi 6dopton In That Assem-
ply (near near AS TO the 'upposition which some
Peons bad preueht forward, that the President had
INTENDED 10 ADOPT an independent line Of conduct he
could declare that never had that functionary con-
ceived the idea Of acting contrary the intentions
the Assembly (hear, hear) The course to be pursued
al the present conuncture had been debrated in due
course In council and 1t was only after such premi-
nary act that an agent was sent with
IN conformity with the deliberations OF the Assembly
Such being the case it unnecessary for him say
that there was no conflict between the powers hear
hear)
M GREvY said, that as II appeared from the expana-
tons OF the honorable minister that
had been received from Italy he should propose to ad
Journ the discussion to the next day [agtation
NJ. CLIMENT Thomas ascended the tribune but being
met by M LedruRollin gave way to the latter
M. LrpRU-RoLLIN said that he conceived that tho
matter was too grave to be adjourned. As NJ. Grevy
had renounced proceeding with his interpeatons, he
W. Ltdru- Rolip) took on himself to proceed with
them The Language Of the latter exceedingly i'm
pornntj u declared that the writer sympahzed with
what the amy IN Italy endured Loud laughter
a VoIcE ON THE RicHT-Well, what is the harm Of
that
M LIDRu- RoLLiN must maintain that the letter was
not confidential, but an official one-one that the
writer seemed desrous e have read in order of the
day OF he general chief to his troops But
that point might be- the letter in question most
tainly was not IN accordance with the ideas Of repub-
Hcan government. What DID il. In fact, aim att To