The daily national Whig. [volume] (Washington, D.C.) 1847-1849, 1849-03-19

~.
hv cayanis f,ape., ~ M n, has,no hss,,
nss,en,ad 4, ia,anS e. ions ~ Nj n snayr
Moranve, III. ~ - - ,,J.ayr,nb; ;rc,,U x
msrtina he ,,n nar ,,as NO, nsr
,hs sa ~ .in ha. hsf, X id NIra
aNsi,bar ar ,n uo'S'e a.,o ~ an, ,,v :;
the nboye e,smen,sl tsa,,res J%s i,n,nfo, ~ ,os1
,ros ,noSS ~, az ~ Gr.s .an,L;nsJ ami Inc sdvan
iagcs clai,,ssa y ", ha,. 49, ds.os,ed no aach e.,
thesa con,h,saa oas..,,e .nra iSa,,.aiy (, $3.50 -
hem ,has W." ~, o, na,en,,h ~
tben sovas ,hora - s,hi,a ,,sn,ahI ~ nv Wor.s's
claim lef, ~ he in,ssf.rs tD,h sxcen, Ms claim NJ
nnisnt for 10 n,iar ~ ,ha mnch}nerv descrheJ
chns,v and ,,,,.ar.Is ~ ~ das.r;hsd ,hereir rhe
caim Of earh annlicar therefor Il reduced N the
claim a. ~ a,ns; ,a,, rzaacb;n and mat,r,Is
which he has imvan,sd IA doss no, inchde anv of
the ma,sar" ca,,osd i, his sneci6ca,nn which are
No, now ,,.,.nsahI. - ' '' !
These comhjna,ion. uaam m mo IN he FAR from
Identical NJ P;, Sno,,Jsa in bis con,bin.,ion the
use III ,he na,,ora,ad anar a. com no;,,g he com
m,nication. and If he s,va which masses ihs elec
trio cnrrsn, ,hromg, Inc neyforated naner and ihe
maehinerv lar irs,s,n,,na The came comm,nica
m sevay.l d,tt.an, ,a.ss y, ,ha s,mc time i, 10
said thnt tho avis IL mt new.bnl ne makes Il an
Ingredient in bis comhn,,ion5 and IN ihat ,esnect
his combina,ion di6rs irona ,h., of Mr. Morse and
II Il d verv i'm nor,an, iem In connesion Win, the
nerf,rn,ed nansr IT, ,ncl,,das IN lie comhIna,,nn
new patentabe matter with oil matter. not patent,
able and thereby makes new naieninble combina-
linn This new mater Ting Introduced into thc
new Communications ia a,in;,,aJ "a ha nn,en,able in
i,sslf T. i,h ,bo n
matter and indeed n seems 10 be a great improye
mant IN The ,rnns,oIssion ~ ,elesronbic Information
M, i, IL sad ,,,as Ne Rain IL nnlv amIhari1ed n
attain senara,e M lar asch If ,hose nven,ons
and cannnt claim = nnien, frr his new cor,bination
Of the old and nav t6yeiher, If however III new
combin,Iion az ali ma,erinls he nn,entnble (which
mnst hs admi,,sd or h, ,vonld M, inierlere with
Nj Mnyse,s c,ir,1 /, saems 10 no M, The lcss mn
enable because II Includes The now matter IN con
naxion win fbe IA nh, od motter NAV moi In
i,sslf h na,sn,ab,e In, ;nined ~ M nav ,oatte,
non,hino,i" ,,a ~ for,,ad ,hich NAV he na,en,,d
Ia Ia NJ, nh,aad ~ ,.re sensro,e na;ans far each
nan na,an,o,H ,,,ar II an,s 20, na,, ost a.
,he pha ''a, ha ,.,ninn - osI oni, fnr J, ,i,lted
,,se n ,hosa nav m,,ters ~ ,r;f h eonb,at;an and
M, s,r n exn,sira ,se n ,hsn er every n,rnnss ~,
which ,hav mav Ia annlic.ha N'S'' fNt
At, Ga,sa.' ' H. :, ps.m aa,s g.. .oo,h;,.,;on ar
NJ, mousom ~ p az ssys ~ naona "
,hcrcof new ecct IL nrodneed nav be- ,he subject
AZ na,a,, Thia aipc, ,na. .an.s, e,her ~ ,he
nrod,c,nn ,e : s,,, ar,;c,a ~ i, n,nLins mn ali one
4, " ha,,. a, az " ta.nsr 10 4 .arhis
mannE,ctnra nav =. n,ade n Ji,lsren, snbs,ances
minaleJ ,noe,hety. or of d;,,sreni machnes formed
. ot ~ ~, ~ os,,ae,,, ~ ,ann III nnnhi
mi on', ~ VI. ,, a, =, =, ha o'u
na.,os. pa. y, ~, ti nas,, ,re,,i,e
~, ,,, "a as;h !, = rJa eSe 49,. Lana a, inna
tpo,yn and ", ,hs mannfac.nre NAV he I'M ,ronar
snoMn, anu ye. ,ne anaoe nay W ',ao pao ~,
;a ~ pe NJ l ~. ' III u.s., pn, nv ~
% , pu, ,oi .e nem h I ha
,nlne nus Proaucea * coioInall1n 'lt ,ne g,anl
/,
known, Win somethmg then invented, SO os 70 pro-
dnce an effect which was never before attained
Inc counsel OIL mr.. Morse IN argument, SAID,
~ y obvious and isadmiiied oy our aaveIsaries,
mat Morse instrument is very uinereht hhg, ~
Its form and structure from Bain's" But Jorm ana
structure are very Important matters IN machinery;
ana u 'hey ehaoio me operator 10 90 inc Work IN
pe''er manner OF WIN more euse, OF Tess expense
or IN less Tine y y no interference; out IS an I'M
provemeht LOT whicn Inc inventor may nave put
emit
when me application - Tor q patent ior compi-
natlon OF machinery ana maIerais FORM anu str ".
lure Deconie shostdhce t,ey aIe =, e essence u te
invention; ana an ADMISSION mat Morse instrument
Is very dflerent ting IN its form ana structure,
rom paih ~ an aa'ssioh - lucy when y prana
laeta evidence ~ leas tnal mere ~ no interference
oetweeh Tue t"o anu 'fo"s INC oufue'i u PROOF on
me olhcr slae. c,.
lhere was no evidence 'iaiu before ,ne Commis-
sioner q patents upon lne q9es.Qn OF ntererence;
50 liia' We must nave wy upon
comparison o. me TWO specineauohs' Possipy
Wnhou' eonsideiihs tha' INC ony patent winch
either could ooiaif, would DC pIlent i2r ms own
w., W. =, MS,i III
co,nonatoh consists oelhs OLD ana mol no" patent
ao ns; ,t -, NJ,
me question - No. NV, Mue'nei 'ns siaIns o.
Mf. BAN ana Mr.; morse ihterete as 70 mallsrs no,
now pa'entaolei out Mhe.hsf .ney .h'ena,e % 70
matters non pa1sn'e2le, sha .nu oniy a.sl now
patehtaoie IN Mr. nSs speciHra.lon, ~ ms T own
eoilS si =, .;.,n anu .u.e..i,s lna'
cbne IL adm,,,sa 10 he very Iilrsn ,ing Up p a IT,
Srrs :, ,r,c,,,rs fon, NJ pin' .iWs = ~
ior anu s.,aG,ute ~, iso' ;t,.,,, na, sr oIh ma
cnhtnn,inn cos;s,s 4, nr, Ana .i,,c,,.sy ona ,,e
ns,ant II ;aaneI viii nresnrns i've issned far ,ho
fc,r,, snd s,.,,e,,r, nr,be in a,,a,nsn, ~ '''
T, heina adni,ed ,hat the foym md atruc,,,,o nc
NJ p,. inar,,n,s,, "a ysru dsrnrt rom orse, -
,horo ca,, 10 M intcrierence In Inn rcsac, ami II
snrr, oni s,rnc,mre cnns'nie ,he dsn,i,v ~ m
nhnor, ,tsra ~ M ,r,a,fnrsnce IN ,hs ,uo ne,r
and # tbs in.,,,,,psnts nrc the comhn, ,ans
m ,be ,esnl, oc hn combinations far which M
RI nu cain,n5 hsrs Il M intr,cyepce h thc ,,ro
IN raanr "a onv ,nai,sy NV, nn,en,ohIe
Rni II T. not nesessarv 10 rely none mon ,he al.
,,so - NJ Worss's council n show rba, ,hera i
raat a difIsrsncc hatwcnn rhe nnch,noru ,ssd he
~ an,endno nnnIican,s 70 ef,sct he ohisct
nv ran,d ,rn .sinn os n,elligence h. In nn.e
nf he eIsc,ric current anv one who win eomnare
NJ w ,,vn sn.ci,;nnnns and dau;n1s and NAIL
,"il ~ am once narcsiye ihe Al iI.rencc "'
4 nalentable improyomeni d moi nm interference.
m "REMINISCENCES IN his yr,,en dacisom .av.
+, nana.rs srs,, ,ia ra.o,ds ~ ,ha nt.e ,5a H.
onnlina,on 10 aa,d sleyander Rain snbect Of Grea,
Rraia ,vas ~ mazda hnrl Ia lsas md unon exan,.
i,t IL mIai ,as fond ,hat H. hssarn
a.,,,nd Lat, nnd hs c,5o;ts~ ~ ,a,,nt no r..
,.,,;a " ill., cInrac,cr amncarin,, in ~. nnh,ic
rs,arJa Of H. nor in XXI. nrinied nblicaon