The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1849-11-12

with the judges cannot say whether before sfter
or outside or inside; question was asked BY some
member Of the court and cannot rem1moer what hrst
drew my attention to HUFF: | cAonot say whether ne
appalled, to 1t first; alter the question had been
answered be was appealed TO particularly nad he
JONAS PHrLLIrs sworn i am Assistant District
Attorney, and have been since 1913 J know Huh
have seen him write being shown letter Gays he De-
Cross.ssamined Being shown the complaint Gays he
the letter. I judge by orthosrsphy judge from the
character of he hand and the orthography; l have
read minutes taken by him.
GEoscE DEnrisos sworn Il am police sfiicer, and
have been since the spring OF 1889; was 1t the spe
cisl Session: when Catherine Boyle wa. tried know
Huf; rscolleot question To her being there
before; remember IL from the circumstances Mr..
vsnderyoort asked mo Il knew her and said did not
HUFF raid he did, and that she had be- there be,re
he said something to the Court; thought sho Was
stranger there he said The was an old osudsr re-
collection Of faces Is pretty good
Cross-eraminsd i was standing alongside Hun Who
sitting inside the railing where the District At
torney generally sits | recollect his getting up
and going 10 speak to Alderman Stevens; never knew
anything this trial until days Mr. vandrvoor drst
spoke about her being there before; asked Oak
ley aud two three others II they knew her; they
said ne, Hun said" an old ohsndsri" said Il think
EDWARD McKrLEY sworn am attorney and
counsellor of the Supreme Court admitted Janqarys,
lS49 examined on the 9TH know Hut; he Was
amined tho time that was he sat several per-
from heard the ans wers he gave offered 70
show that HUFF was attorney of the Supreme
and examined rs n apddats for admission as an
attorney in that court, and rejected Ut the January
term, 1912
OBJECTED to, overruled and exceptsd) Defendant
rests
# the Marine Court for i've years Hut Was crer part
81 the time he commenced about two years after was
60 keep order open and adjourn the Court he acted
all other cri.rs Hammond, Sherman aud myself
composed the Court during the last years OF my ter
L, gan the 18th Of Nay, 1885, and left in isi3 did
not r-e Tn. article In the Heroid about iuf did NOS
the "illess Bail Case" very seldom read the
H,rad.
Cro..exOminsd i have seen Hun write; (showu .
lstter9 'nys' It may be his hand writing bat tnink
not the signature avoTs his; could not say II it DO
bic or net.
Joas DAVIS, for plaintiff swOrnI am police officer,
and have been since 1857 l recoiet u warrant In
Nov. lssS, Vs. Martin girls given to me by justice
Lothrop
WuNLss-I have the original warrant produces ~
II given at the time OF lts date loh NOV 1875
told him that bad application to me be-
that arrest Of the gis told hin, he must make
application; it was nine months or . year before
to,d Judge Lothrop that the man had been robbsd,
and !. my duty to arrest looked for the parties
bad been 90 their residence nine mouths bofore
Knew where they resided | dad not make any com.
muucation; went TO look for the parties they had
moved | cannot ssy The day thsy we're bronyatls
about night, about shu'tbg-1p urs was present
when they were brought In; was not called GU Co
execute Crosset brought thogi IN baltf - there
pr.tiy much all the time as reporter; was re-
porter Ct proceedings of police; present ~ the
examination; WAS not told by ANY person ehara tuey
lived after had the warrant CrUssman Applied 60 ms
got the warrant asked why did not bring those
| parties In. ard answered, | could not tnd them !
tbougbt they were out OF town. Lothrop ASKED ms IL
| be- . th-u. A9d told nm could net ans them
| SCOTT for plaintiff, sworn
| .rr time John Van Bdren was appointed At
| l, .. General. you y meni6er Of the seusts!
| ...-n 10 ana eKciUded)
| hen did your duty cease ~ Senstor'
. 30 Dec 1874 was State Ssnator from lSii to
| Is have the minutes OF trial OF cath Boye; was
k,certer at that time; Bridget way NJ, tbs hrst
uGueG; thpre short minutes (rescs) -"Lost, two
GOLD pieces defendant snsPped them out OF my baud
hat all in relation TO she charges Macy simp'on
was the xt witness, who said, sas d.rslds1t take
| the raoBey. William X. krosies found 50 90 do
not r.coli, CO sDy thing but wbot have taken ao~n;
| have nothing down rs gwen by them; discovery
op my Jsrt OF any intoxcs ION do not Teeo-ct ally
Thing the Mind; my impression Is thai Ahsaro was
ther. Do not reeoilsct ,hesrn asked tor susPeas'n
Did Huff say anything to you'
| Al canUot say whether be spoke or said anything,
not; IL b. very common thing TO do it, might or
mgnt not; Go not reooiieeI DO not recoiiect mat
| n.ade any inquiry
old in the decision u the question of
her quilt any Influence On the udsmsns OF 'hS coufs
| OBJECTED to as not CON prtsDt)
Att had not on ny Judgment; cannot say IS to
the other httmen.
! Did you come 20 spy conclusion whether the wo-
man IA cid oGsndsr or not!
(Otjtoitd ts, overruieG and ezcepted)
Q-Did any witnes, give evidence that sh. was .
She mish have said so; do not knor; cannot
fay II uG was there ali the tine " not: do not re-.
ctct that soy p.nsiuu sskod All they could
! t,Id out sud bring in wipess-s.
G. Was there any witness ~hs testified that she had
soid coirs
| COLLECTED toy
| G -Oio any witness, gay anything about goia'
| Al do LCt recoil,cg whtther they tAid so or
not; probably many things caue out did nos deem
y.lhIg and good chstsct.r, but whether by Al
! wisuess cannot ssyi no aEdssis was made tu2'
posc held oonfoisiion do pot ksow II the deei;
sion unHEiniGu-: without thsse minutes should
not Iteoi'et any thing about AZ read this srtiel-
-. sia -, ~, M. y,,- ,-t,s 49,. 4,
| vHs 4 w fei,t.
collected TOY
| NnsEss--As to bailinr the Martins (sho~p raaognl-
Fances md order, spd says they are sennlnrJ raj
! taken November 2Hd, perceive; 1 WAS thyn Re
| cofSer Cf the city; there vas a converratoa be.
tween LothloP and myseli in the Court Q. Sea
sioBs, a. the tiwe they we're brought In sherc;
! Jaw them there's do rot know vh,thur they
came BY force not; the Dstgot Attorney suggestCt
it. think LOhrcp Wa BtDt fsr know there was
queion 30 e. tbt bal! aud some perton t.d th'y Ia
dtrbt about it; oouguifstion took pace WIN ths
Dftrict Attorney; Justice Lohfop psinOd OF ire.
gDlGiiy AID BE- posfd 20 Ea5e ~ cptrscted Of
terspcg Of oo.nsa whether he shcuid Is sxsmn-a 81
tie Court 81 ~ the committing masira'e. rs nsd
gftat press II bu-irrF; 81 vas mrfS t-faaic ATTY;
tto JG.tiee toct the fare maa Lr BAL that ID
! The District AttC!utr vas Mt prUsrnt when ban
va iskrn. Gen. rally The District At'orhs, snf The
! parties came APP .omsllmee hs voa'd rsqilse n'oe
aud tcnstimts waved a. h. did n,tas the
hfst tteGtiun ~ taking hail: rCcYlcct shal told
itdgr Lothr.pi uat the Papers rsie out b. Fan
dTNoert; dotos kHov tut used The sxprcs- "a that
| euD '~d lae 10" an Tot We. csfsu / "a Sht havs
tcla LIa - ard might not Dc not rec5llect thst
sid co. 90 rot know ~ stn abs 20 ten AT sons %
uv,s when he W. brought vp thoro ho sail h. vas
~frg TO aHe bail tbCre. Or to 20 ioto tue piss sui
,kc &c; 90 not kn0v Who suggested tSat They sh5ui
eoip'o Tie police dsoi teddy ia favor Off ~ ex,ui-
nsiicn. traufe Lothtop sa1 the proceedings Ssr-
Grbhed, Understood differently; ucut ON aud stated
| 20 him vlAt vas ti.t 20 ne; told hin t5a, hsd
D., IN informed that be had shut his IN snd that
tJugRthies we're csci-sd aad did not went them o.
rnsin IN priscn al -ht 10 did not ~ iil.sil;
t,ld him uuderstood he he'd rot tine sni tbst sa
that wanted wss TO swear the Gitls.s, h. own.
lianed o. go the District ittrnry sropo.si h. should
take hall. the prrtiss brought Into Cuurt
frqusst that Of the District Atorr eY told the Ius
tee old not With 20 them; ct length they h.i
them eNsured saaip: the District Attorney thsr.
sud could waive notice. they went Into the foce ofss
from CCpit ~ Sessitus MIR Clarke there. do not
| kba~ n be accompanied them or II he aud MIR. HUI
we're both there together; think u likely sent foe
Justice Lotbfop HUFF Insisted ~ good ball. and
tiss this mere technically; waited ths Dis
rt Attorney present; " rad been -red between him
ard that they tbould be brought before Court Of Sea-