The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1848-12-17
TWO CENTS.

which interprets my every action making me act in
series, repeat goes further than yo1r thoughts do
not doubt Of your sincerity. / do not Know you 1
have spoken to you but twice; but can believe that
wounded in your feelings, in your affections aud de.
ceiyed In your hopes you have written what you did
not intend to write But you yourself have said that
what you have written Is history and history does not
remain buried in secretare Is printed and put into
circulation Your declaration then does not suffice it
does not place me in situation In which honor
not be attacked. ahall consequently wait K
plantations on your part to know what attitude am
NJ GARNER P.GEs-Tbe position in which we are
placed Is very singular. We cannot prcnouncsa word
that is not by interruption-we cannot PROFOUND
our statements before they interpreted and ira
vested. have been in anothe. Assembly, where
were received In the same manner by the seides OF
M Guizot. II any one have the right Of being heard
here with attention is 1t not those who have bee pro-
vosed into lthis discussion = who have borne i've
months Of attack? II this discussion be unfortunate
lor the republic 1t Is not who have induced it. We
the instigators' How When.we are told that if We
violent agtaton) This Is the language held out to
us, and you will not listen to us. Do you not think
this tribunal to bring back again the deadly days Of
June? And when We point out with regret the faults
ed! We are told that have some hidden aninosi-
ties, soIoe disappointed ambition. Disappointed am
biton; But what share had my friend NJ Barthelemy
St Hilaire in the so-much illuminated Executive
Commission? He accepted functions purely semi
official and since then he has refused the portfolio of
public instruction that you have offered him (turning
towards the seat of the President Of the CouaclJ
Yes nd to also you have offered the Presidency
you, sir; speak TO NJ Marie. maintain my asser-
toDs. We have refused to be your mi nistsrs, and
told that we are ambitious! Ia February were
not place by the people in tho dangerous posts we
occupied! Before you, we're we not a. the Hotel de
Vel Were not breasts there barred to the balls Of in
surrection and were those breasts yours when It was
deemed necessary to offer sacrifice to the safety of
the country? or those who with us at the Hotel
de vile, there are some here who can state what We
have done.
A MEMBER-You have decreed the forty.fye GEN.
times Uaughter).
NJ n ID 9TH rta;or ,vith
some-with NJ Ledru Roln; but there always
railypg pointthe tri colored flag the national flag.
demand pardon for these statements; but they were
necessary to repel the accusation of ambition. You
would now lead us on to ground which 10 not ours
you have shed the blood of the people for your ambi
ton, but that have committed aud we only
the days of June. of the ander ia. chief of the
troops is the opinion of al-of the people of the Ma
tional Guard, of the whole nationa army. 'No, no
vole mt dissent, which continued some time) ex-
peoted this interruption it proceeds from error,
which will explan. You thought faults COM
mitted in the command when you thought that it
was the Executive Committee who committed hem.
New dissent: You deny it still ; and yet have we
not all heard from all sides when soldiers
to arrive "Therei is treason :" The National Guard
credi in its ranks the people repeated At this
the s' Now the National Guard were de-
ceyed, if the people deceived, If you also
deceived we may be allowed to hold another opinion
mission. As member of that commission, have the
right say what done by 1t, and call on NJ. de
on NJ Arago, as M. Ledru Rollin has said the whole
truth must be known. This question must be trsOted
above question Of persons.
VorcE.-Speak Of the republic.
M. GARNER PAoEs-Oh, | shall speak Of 1t, be
assured shall speak of the republic Ah take care
No can say what may happen; but say to you, II
any one, by DISASTROUS mbton, should go
to the Tuileries will go to the Hotel de Vile (Agta
ton) IT, spite Of the opinion OF many OF the members
Of the Assembly, we not pArtisans of your cand
datsship have not the right to say so? Were not
Codefroi Cavagnac, your brother and GARNER Pages,
my brother united in senme is and in heart Ought
we not to go together In the same sentiments! When
you wore accused we to shield you with opn
ION an our power and you, when accused Of
faults that we have not committed did you shield US
the reproach make against you that Of insratitu
You, whom named General Of Division, Governor
ruption)-you think that here l will not brave your
reProsches. will! What did Cen Cavagnac do at
the fret overture that made to him He replied
that he would accept the power that offered him by
the Pslais National Numerous voices. Never The
day before the Of June commenced proposition
laughter) Do not believe that say this, mpelled by
the luminosity Of disappointed ambition. Have not
THAT strikes the
tude of which you have been guilty 1t is most
astonishing , thing to hear IN an assembly which re.
attack the republic. In monarchy, man may well
represent the country; but in republic no man can
have this pIete nsion kn0w.noother motto than thiS
The Republic, the Constitution, and the National
Assembly"
Gen. CAvMoNAc-I have listened with calm to the
rpoVoh
Pages has said that have attributed his conduct to
disappointed ambition. He is in 1t has been
portfolio of public instruction. | never authorised
any one to make such Offer unless it refer to the
opinion Of NJ Barthelemy st. HiIaire as 70 my con-
duet in the events of June As to the candidateship
Of Gsipi s ssss TO .Ss n We may have
not ours. You have reproached me with not having
come here to defend you on the oath Of June was
then minister of war and where then defended
you better than II had been here. (Trfs bien.) It
seems, from what you say, that courted the propo-
stions that made to the 22d June. There
is truth in this and replied to those who offered
me the power, that If they wereidetermined in
peing your retiremen would accept It, It has been
said that some one with propositions to the Rue
de Poitiers. sent no | only M. Adelsward.
IT, In the name of the Rue de Potiers, overtures had
be made to me, should have answered as did to
others. There many members Of this reunion
present let them state If before the 9th June
ceved the slightest communication from them.
Numerous voices IT'S true It's true
Gen CAvAIGNAc.-As to the rcproach of ingratitude,
leave the country Ito decide what owe to M Gar
nier Pages.
M. LEpRU RoLLrS.-I do not mount this tribune to
make recrimnatiops; but It has been asserted that
the Executive Commisson has done all the mischief
There WAS one member OF the Executive Commission
it was who, on the one hand suspected Of
having betrayed the OF order; and whom the
other the people reproached with blood hod aud yet
never ceased 10 demand the most prompt aud euer-
eetc repression OF the disorders Of June 1 thouaht
that, by joining the troops and the National Guard,
the barbados should have been prevented being
formed on all points The military experie of Cen
eIa Cavaignac decided otherwise, and bowed to this
determinations. But, in 20 doing, | always thought
here should have been In Paris 10000, ready attne
first beat Of the drum. remained all day at the seat
Of the More th an ten times in that day.
General Damesme sent to demand battalion-one
battalion only, and this he could not obtain. You
wished to concentrate your troops-be it so but It
apparently to employ them otherwise; II not, this
concentration could have object. defy you to
prove the advantages you pretend to have proceeded
from your system. From three O'Clock in the
ing Till nine in the evening, received, AZ member of
the executive government, 300 persons who came to
say to me, "They are numbering our brothers Help!
let us have help"' And during those long Is hours
you left me alone saying that you would return in half
hour, and recomme nding me not to give orders,
lest they should contradict yours Let this be we'll
understood have admitted the concentration OF the
military forces but tell me, where did it take place
Where 20 00o $1,000, even 10 600 men, An
that Had the man who asked during whole