The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1848-03-06

The MINISTER JUsrIcr believed that he had proved
that the government had always carried out the law
he had explained It But several Hon members who
had spoken seemed to intimate that they inclined
to disobsy the Law
n DuvxseIrH DE HAunArSE-Ws do not speak, for
our parts, Of disobeyiug the law
Tho MrsIsrER OF JUsrics-Surey It was Just ~ pru-
dem t. submit to old Law whom allowed to be in vgor
after having been contested, a. to new voted by
the chambers and promulgated by the King (Approba
tou FROM centres But every hing prom ounce ed In
The heat Of discussion Was not to he taken literally and
no doubt those Hon gentlemen who had spoken 90 FIRMLY
Of not submitting to tho law a. II at present extsd
would on cool elaboration the wisdom Of
th.ir liberalization (Agltation) Between words snd
action there was room for reflection resh agitation and
noise on the left Ia the midst OF which NJ GARNER Pages
NJ Chsmbolle, and Others gesculstsd vehenently and
pronounced some words which could not catch
TITO MINISTER OF JusrIcE Undressing the eft) Whist
language to be- used rom this tribune to Won in order
% obtain partial hesringl Were to say to you this
law In our fAepr We shall CERTAINLY apply It, aud we
shsl then sss whether you or the will YIELD
you would be right In declaring that spoke In man
ought to be permitted to declare Without any danger OF
Interruption that time should bs given error to per
eei,s when Il ia in tbs wrong Not to be satisfied With
such moderation OF languageto out when call on
you to redect-h to pass - much DO done from
menace to executon-and, wherever tho faul. may is
Hon. minister then went to explain Why the govern
ent had not put tho law in force Some persons had
soou,ed tho government Of having de:snsdiy held back
In order to allow the agitation to- gain csrtsu head
and to lead to disturbance and riot He ia the most
formal manner protested against such idea to have
acted In that way would have been most detestabe
toc, unworthy of every man of honor, (hear, hear
We should prefer said tho Non minister to fall TO.
morrow rather than keep ourselves in power even for
long years. at such urce Tho only reason whv the
government had no. smplsyed tho law was that laws
which interiors; Nth fsssdon of opioion- which
touched on poltgnA Questions rarely well under.
ssood at hrst Hear, hear fom the csntres) But at
present public opinion formed; the daugers which
consequently the execution OF the law becam.
ssry Tho government would not fail to do their duty
tmurmurs from the lsft) What the government had
done for the bapquets 1t always did Ia every OF
prss'on 1T allowed the hrs faults pass over bat II
h-y psrsevered in then interfsrsd and put
down L.tit not be supposed that the was
urged by sire to give heavy blow to political
sdvsrsariss, or to use reprsss No such thing When
tho majority had bssn violently attacked in the ban
quss aud accused Of being corrupt could the govern
msn be justly charged with u.ng reprsas when IL con.
tented isslf with only osllipg it's hostile
trs That would BE- but feeble biud Of rep isa, What
the goverpm.nt and the majority desired that what
bsn clearly pronounced by tina country should bs also
proclaimed BY the chamber. (Grsat sgitation)
M. F.uiLLADE.CHAuvH declared that ne could not
help bsips Moved by most painful feeling OF surprise
when he heard minister of tho Crown supporting in
the tribune fraudulent and lying interpretation OF the
law loud dIsapprobation from the centre TIL. ban
uets had taken place tho number OF upwards Of
II thSlsw was efficient to prevent them why had not
the government applied It! Because there was no law
in existonco for the purpose sna from the
The honorable deputy continued for time dwell.
ing particularly the fact that the liberation accorded
to them by she government was in fact an implied
NJ. Lxpsu RoELrN denied the statement Of the honora
BILE minister that no public assemblies could be legally
held without the authority Of tho government where.
al, the fact that every lawyer and every man Of
sesss in that chamber knew that theirs were natural
rights which could only be restricted by formal law,
and suoh law, he commended did not exist had
ad that because the charter OF 1880 did specify the
right Of ASSEMBLING that consequently it did not exist
but to that argument hs could not 10 was
less for him to remind the ChsIoer how that
had been drawn up llntsrruption from the osntre).
The PnrsIprNr--You have sworn fidelity to itsuch
1t is, and you ought to respect It.
The Marquis D. RocHrJAavGLEtN--Read the pre-
snibie OF it--here IL ID
Tho PREsIpENT--It 10 not your turn to speak
NJ. LEDau RoLLiS-Heres the preamble -" We have
crasi.-d aud do crdsn fellows The charter OF 1914
suoh ~ 1t has bseu smsaiei by deliberations" &c IL
therefore evident that the charter OF 1880 was no
thing more than that Of 1914 amended The charter OF
1914 made no mention Of the right Of meeting; that
might BIS readily conceived for it was Of foreign manu-
fscture and did not seek its principles In their old
solutions daughter during which all eyes turned
towards NJ d. IL Rochrjsqusieio The charter Of 1880
could not reproduce what 1t not nd ia that Of 1914
but the right meeting was SO natural and mprescrp
tibe, that NJ Gusot then Minister of the Interior and
who WAS well acquainted with the charter Of $780, de-
elared the loving day that the right Of meeting
WAS both egsi and desirable The honorable gentleman
then rscapuatd the clauses Of the laws OF 1900 and
l194 relative to popular asesmbles aud concluded by
saying "f your faults the last liberty that of speak
ing in common SHOULD BIS taken from US IL you cause
Jour battslions to march and blood she'd will sp
peal TO the paops to obtain refusal Of the
The MiNsrRs OF JusrIeE said II was very safe eou-
rage to contend against imaginary dangers He
psed that after seventeen years enjoyment Of the most
absolute liberty such protest should be raised from
that tribune against violation Of right and Of
tyranny, whom the only question the refusal OF H.
een'e which for " years had never been admitted In the
country
NJ LsDsu RoLL,s-Thsre we're i'm prescriptibls rights
Nj. TAILLANprER-rhen yioabity OF domioils among
the number
The MIsnrER OF JUsrIcE--Ths inviolabiity of the
deputy.
Gle. cloud Of g. Order, Order')
Til. MiSUrSR oS JusrIcE would merely add that
the law did not recognize any assemblies to dslberste
On pubic affairs and against the government What
had been hitherto dons had been Illegal and II l.
TO bs respected the parties concsrned would ind them
selves opposed BY tho law. loud applause from this
N o BARRor suddenly rose in his place, and ad-
dressed some words to the part OF the Chamber where
ths ministers were sitting The act was done
psctedy and the burst Of uprosr which followed
desfsning, that We could only each the expression :
Polgnac aud Psyronnet more constitutional than
you!" (0rest tumult and cries OF Order order" fol
lowed from the centres and were responded By loud
lasrks OF appreciation from the lsft)
THE PsKsIDsrr Honorable deputies should really
respect the dignity OF tho chamber
0<eat tumult again aro,e M o Barrot gestculatng
and apparently wishing to continue whilst tho Minis
ter Of Justice and seemed anxious to reply Dur
log all this NJ Pallet had assembled the tribune,
aud looking down TRANQUILITY on the confusion
The tnmue lasted at least ten minutes Atla
Tbs MIEsrsR OF Jusrics was heard to say what
ever volencs may be displayed (tutsrruption on the
lsft)--
H. OBSERVATION-DISCLOSURES There is no one violent but
yourself
= Ths Mrrrsrsa OF Jusrrex.-whatever violence hon
gentlemen may display towards me- whatever Injustice
and passion may b exhibited against me- shall not
allow the authority Of minister Of the King to be
absssd In my person (Uproar the leit stand here
to express opinions which my own profound convic
ons and AN replied to ny names to when src attach
ed the ssddest reooll,ctions! such accusations are
oious (great noiss), aud cannot conceive that you
tturnng TO NJ y. Barrot), woo ought to give al ex-
ample OF rssrrve-you the head OF party Gan thus
give the signal for such violent Interruptions! Loud
cries on the lett responded by loud applause from the
crDtre) Bat however you act learn that your csmors
far from forcing to reco will only nerve mo 70 the
OF doing my duty they prove my deter
minstion Is most Justly, most fully called ior-tnat
nave put ny logger the sore! continued noise)
shall cause the Law to be executed against all who act in
to IT, loud cheers ren the centre, and
uprosr rom the lett
NJ .. BAsaor call on hon members to pay full at.
t-ntiou to my words, and send them With every
sbls publicity through the country Ministers Of the
Hsvoiution OF July, you are attempting sgainst that
liberty irOn which you issued most odlous act
yon are prescribing right which tbs ministers OF