Weekly national intelligencer. [volume] (Washington [D.C.]) 1841-1869, 1848-03-25

the other hand had cited the silence Of the constitutions
1914 and 1880 upon the subject virtual denial of the
right To this NJ. Ledru Ron replied that the right wa'
mprescptiblenot be thus lost and ne referred TO the
fact that after the adoption Of the charter OF 1881, Guiz
himself had declared that the exercise OF the right was not
only sau,ay but highly proper and desirable Guizo
himself had belonged to society which held such banques
H. Ledra Rolia then proceeded thus And now come q
PERSONAL matters have been severely assailed reply
these attacks by telling you that there remains with us a
right Wo You ii YOU violate il uproar in the centre
TO You if you invade liberty wo TO you II you oppose
your baitalions Oucry in the cenre.l For then,
Without carrying the to the shedding OF blood, viii
pea to the people, and counsel them TO refuse To be taxed
Lively and long agitation
w. HERBERT [the M,iister.) Thank God the danger spo
Of here exists only in the imagination OF the honorable
member who has just spoken And Is not on imaginary
angers that we are now act hut the law and its quiet
yecuton which has been conded the executive and judi
a authorities He proceeded TO comment upon the cnns-
uion and the law and in reply to the interruptions which
constantly occurred he demanded that the rights OF debate
should be protected The right of popular meetings. said he
granted by the law OF 1884, is granted in subsequent
stutons II therefore does not exist and the right which
leads the results the abuses which
explanatory decree of 1871 sought to remedy Have gnu
done any thing that these popular societies have not done
Have they not toleraon correspondence publication of the
lists publication in the journals of every thing said there
Assaed illuminated your banques, we content ourselves
with invoking OF prevenon-measutes which have
possible Can you deny that these banquets public in
their character ['No, no., from the let. Very we'll
That which you do without right you cannot do without
coming in conflict with The law which forbids Appause
from the cenre-protracted excitement.
III Odibn BGrrot Tin his seat Polignac and Peyron-
net were more constitutional than you pause.
The Lett True true good
Tie Centre Order order
The President. / enoin silence upon the Chamber The
greatest umult prevailed throughout the House. NJ Bafrot
wished to continue The Minister stood ready reply NJ
Pallet the tribune. From every side violent
ordinations Those the left repeated the words Of Bar
Those At the CENTRE loudly and with phrenzed excite
men called Tor orde order This unparalleled tumut
tinued for ten minutes.
The Minister Gin his seat.) will permit, what
violence may be menaced, interruption on the left
however injurious and passionate may be the language OF my
adveaesI will never permit insult to be cast, either upon
my person upon the authority with which am clothed
Tie Ceatre Good
THE ucioL Letf Order order
NJ CURT Disturbances. There is violent
than you.
TIE Centre Order order Enough. Question.
THE Lei Respect the freedom Of debate.
The IN liter. / repeat 1.-THE violence with which my
person ncnaced 1.-THE umut and disorder reached their
height
Sereral roc4y ae Centre Mr. President bring to order
those who make this disturbance
". Emiie II GGardin. | demand the floor
The Frssidat The Minister has the right to it.
THE Minister, (in his place. Whatever may be the VIC
ence exhibited against my person. fresh and loud eXcama-
tons from the left will not permit my person my auiho
rity Minister be insulted. setting forth my own
principles, my convictions and answered BY names
which bring lack unpleasant recolections. [MurmuFs
". Bea0.t How is that :
Uoce tt0a tie Centre They pronounced the name Of
the author u ths ordinance Of July.
TIE Minister, Cunning 10 VI. Odilon Barot) Il is you
who have the signal for these violent ntenuponsyou
who the head Of party, ought on the contrary y have
set example Of moderation. OubursIs OF camor from the
left
Seperal rotces Good good
MN Ferdinand Bnrd and Sieyes sharply addressed the
Minister ii the midst of the confusion
Sererui roices Order order bring the disturbers {
order
TIE Minister. Wen, have not addressed you any ap
peaon which could bring upon your head accusations yo
do not deserve. know IT, Fresh Interruptions Finally
% characterize these banques 10 show you their danger
convince you they tutiona and contrary all lib
erty ask OF all who hear me, accustomed 20 discus
sions Of this kind No, no Good u protest agans
them. Bot understand them too well, and, far from damp
enng my courage they show me that have hit the truth
that have touched the Vaccinations the left
SsCsrai U0ices Good, good Bravo
The Minister. shall execute the law upon all who seek
violate it. Bravo, bravo Cries from the left, umult,
fusion.
A poice on The Letl. That's threat
w. Odbn BGrTot Since is ! who have, by exclama
ton provoked the language you have just heard permit
TO reply in few words repe, at the outset, the threat
which have been hurled against il is only leaf from III
past sucn were tue threat
then put forth is the weapon TO which they resort whe
you would crowd them in debate.
A roice II you who provoked this ,umult
0dLon Bavot While, instead Of appealing to freedom
Of debate you call the aid Of your opposition the
the majority. Boserous interruptions from the left Yes
yes n You surprised that should he excited. Bu
alone in your midst by your side, others VIII
also excited. repeat, here ia my place. what sal
from the tribune your conduct is stain upon Government
whose power derives its sanction from the resistance Of III
TMurmu in he Yes, \ askth hat m
words may be faithfully recorded and long remembered Min
sers of the Revolution Of July you violating RICH
which the Ministers Of the Restoration respected up
the when they overhrown with royalty himself
Take Of what say take note Of what is fact-a fac
be boted out you do respect that which
respected by Polignsc himself [Agitaiion.l
W. Emile Grdrdin. The question is disputed il is doub,
fu demand that you proceed against the bsnquets yo
have against ministerial corruption. yolen, tumult qucs
ton, question
The whole kf side withdrew the question was put, bu
there quorum, and the President pronounced the
sion end Before separating, the Deputies gathered
long time in knots in the Hobbies Of the chamber.
The Opposition Deputies remained firm in thei
determination to attend the banquet and il was fix
ed to be held on the 22d instant, in the Champ.
Elysees. There appears TO have been tacit un
Outstanding between the Ministers and their oppo
nents that, the question of the consttutonality
and consequent legality Of the meeting was denied
by one party and asserted by the other, no OBJ
stacle should be placed in the way Of the meeting
provided il was conducted so as not 10 tend 10 :
breach Of the peace, or TO dangerous excitement
that the party should assemble, but when assembled
altpo h. III