New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1847-11-13

One e Mr. ken1as after houghf comp sirts t. that
there are more thsu one Company g. a. tha, one -,
# nsnsgers DO not cortrol III the lines from Phsde.
pfia Up Chicago. Cleveland. Cincinnati 81 Louis Sc
All this Re knew and asfented % from the nrst And
what Of u Let ihs Psieltees come Ia and .sse their
stock. convoy a. patent right sri enable u -se con
csruad o. rct On n suhoritsfvey Temporary orgsni-
zlton viii III be fully resa.sed What would IL benefit
ths pstentees 10 have bat one Company They have
70 Buffalo. 10 Boston, snf enc q Washington.
are no, each Of thefe long enough Under ORelys
contract one Company was impossible.
On June 20. lst5 Mr OReiiy issued rom Inc Aba
nyArgus press Telegraph Circular under bis contract
m ouy thirteen days OH which SORT - Mr. Ken
DAN In Il he set 0at proposing separate ComPsnies
WHY noti tie said.
THE route between the Atlantic and Ohio wi sonsti-
tuts the Ff SECTION tLst between the Ohio and The
Lsses Detroit the Second Sssf0H thar between Wheel
nE and Cineiunatfhe Iiud Ssciie' and onw ard "a
tie poiolslti0n ofhese and other lines o. The Nssssr
pi a. S. Louis ard elsewhere which combinations uN
~ d.ridrd mo srcfsoni of proper extent Sc.
The ckhosrs 0i each section viii have an Jade pendent
0rrenfr.ffon ~rrn-rts1 only hv general council for
adopting rerullf0ls Nc Persons taxing either
on he hrs three sections will be c1usaeed entitled Oh
preference in extending the lines che extensive
sions included within the range already indicated
Macy more such notices were issuei there visa
n ither couces nent the hand complaint
the other. Even Smith and Case propo'sd 20 arrsrss
their separate lice by Company. In August lsi3,
Kendall rea0y 20 bargain for The Troy and h'ntres
an Buffalo snd Erie routes with any Association hav
ing means build them a. = per cent, being the sans
terms 50 O'Rciy had agreed for.
What error As to the temporary arrangement OF his
associates could - what's his contract rs 10 convert 70
into trap for picking the pockets OF bona nde STOCK
holders T. an the golfers off. o. J Smith & Co Are
bubbles Ike hssa stiicy IN keeping with the worthy
Professors essay on tho morality Of the Telegraph
Were in his shoes, ] should be ashamsi - nnding
scieoce IN such shabby company az be has got into
In February last the complexion OF Tho line % Pits
burgh followed by prosecution on The para OF ne
paten;ees applied O. Judge Kama oi the IT. 5. Dis
,r-t Coart Pniiadeiphil for special junction against
OReiy and hls associates giDs thai bic contract
hsi been forfeited. For Eve days wss the whole MATER
argued there The Judge In giving bis opinion. stated
that The exclusive ants of patouee arc specially
guarded from Intrusion nut the contracts whcn hs
share them with third p'rsons ar' Interpreted
snd r0rcei Just a. other gal engagements. Hs re-
susej the Injunction but remarked. IS he had been -.
qHfstfd py pafu.s 10 express - IN opinion tfV" lhH
MERITS or THE CONTROVERSY, that h. had seen
nothing In ihe facts hsl had ncea developed % CAL ilr
different conclusion from that 70 which abstract priuc
ules had directed him 10 other words ihs' Nr o.
Reilly had the rs ht toe question aud thst Mr. j.
Smith bad had cause Of complaint whatever
Previous % t-is yexstous aut costly lawsuit Judge
Selden Of Rochester went b Washington and proposed
to compromise In frendy manner all d'ih,ulues -
SIR Kendsl replied by Offering 10 organize toe Pitts
burgn line II Ar Rsily would sog Il - con
meet only with a line to Cincinnati, 10 be built by r. .
Smiths brothsrinla~ Ephslet Case, exPostnastsr ~
Lowell Editor OF the Portland Argus, and now Editor
Of Cincinnati paper. Mr.. Case Y seems was mus u
profit by the pil-ge Of ORcy and the public MIR sell
den A once declared b. would q accept hsndss
proposition for the line 10 Pittsburgh with this condition
should BE- k 10 three dsHfrr,sed persons % dcciae
NhffhT u Ru Case hfd ne 0fst rflh % C0nsFht me
line fs Of that cy Csse having mai assigned 10 MIN Boy
the pstsutses Ill their reserved rights KENDALL AND
his EMPLOYERS DECLINED TIE oFFERl They would no.
thus oi,rate feti ruth mat the contract which
smith s.hec throw into tbs hands OF Case was not
ons whit more favorable o. the paeuiees than key
Alter the lawsuit decided In favor Of OReiiy,
Mr Case and Judge Wright Of Cincinnati asked hin l.
hf there snd settle all difficulties. and IA nmei
stely went GA the - OF March last Mr. Smith elso
wrote bin. that
with regret that all difference. might not have been
IN nH
for the future aud as, under ne ta5s c9heyanee other
parties have ght shall leave them AID YOU to measure
those rrfs best may be done each de-onY ihf
wish distinctly be understood that act NJ snJ party
be considered affecting my individual intere or
rights sanctioned by me, unless accompanied oy
special authority under my hand
Mr. OReilly promptly agreed 10 compromise wnen
would hsvs settled III difficulties II once. Smith and
/ Morse's trustees. who w,re Hon. John q. Wright r.
+ Case c. g. Coe 4. g. Thomas sni L. WorthnelOo. iu
/ ly concurrei with him. Surely said Judge Wright
'thc Taientees sH not refe neir aifni 20 an arra.g
and ~ he ad sfmsHf Of lar sni equa 10 anything they
/ give Mp effect the settlement"
Alter tanisiizing the Western people Tor some llhe
however. the patentees Smith, Kendall aud More
VETOED the compromise OF their o~n SCENTS wen
might the Cincinnati Ga,eus excAim, Hitherto tn,y
ttha patentees) have shown no disposition % eNpto7
the enterprise In The West" No, heir disposition wes
10 amuse delay and embsrrass Okoiy snd retard ma
/ operations.
But the Western folks were 10 esrnesl-lhey wanted
10 20 ahead Il was their 10 do Morses trut
tees therefore azain met OR-iy -Hho Obriaed every
objection of .hs pseniees 10 hs frs. compromise by
agreeing to another which settled eyesy difficulty upon
wha, was IN reality their own terms. This also wa
sent 10 Warrington, with strong expression 81 reefel
on the part Of Messrs Case Wright Worihngt9n, C)e
and Thomas that tbs former settlement had been au'
! pupd and trouble and lit cation thereby preferred
The pAlentees hsd had wsh for fair settlement,
and they showed IT, They again vetoed the settle
ment made on their own terms ~ their own CHOSEN
! a.. The Cincinnati Garc'fe said, June -,
1--WE very much regret hat the Patentees' &c. have
agsa refused 10 iy the second compromise made hy tne
Trutees here with Mr. OReily lnnsmuch as TINS seccna
arrangement avoided all the objections Aefetoo.e usso
fully expected that this controversy 50
90 the public interest, would no" be terminated. sucn
however has not been mo result AL tue ~
Mr. smith have ACKNOWLEDGED ihemseves willing 20 faliJ
the azreement-Mr $. holding cut 10 appears now
a. We learn. that Mr > hss become somehow possessed
of the control of trs estern line and interest would
sesa nsslesf Hat take az ancabe arfangenef ~ ne
nlffsr II appears, however ihai hehly with pas.
worthy spirit atfensined net % Be spIenoed but 70 ~
ahead and early possible, hs W esiefn Inc
| swrrH ALONE HELD OFT against both sides To had
soi hold Of the Western interest OF the paenlee snd
/ neither law arbitration, compromise, contract nor N.
public good could dispel the dazzling visions OF euor
nous lin 10 ba msis out Of the Western folks. hen
dali Ia lsssrted was retained Ia his interest for cou
/ sdarston. C48 thing u clear Kendall wheeled rolnl
His letter T. Mr. OR a tie 29th ot September. l-in
plainly ininatrs ihst Messrs Case and smith had C. m
bued 20 breax up bis contract Let u DO compared win
his move recent epil.e 10 Mr. Wharton Of tbs H'."s
I Tins
10 Aueus,last Mr. Speed an agent for Smith called on
Mr. Ely ard Judge seien n Rochester add tho basis OF
an arbitration Che fourth stempi) was settled VIZ
that Daniel Lord. Aaron Vsndorpcel, AID ID. 3 Ogden
arss should s' abifaor on the question Of the "a
hdiiy u The ORely contract ard rs construction gen
/ orally After ORely hsd sssertcd ~ his. smith con
rvei 10 eei rid ~ i BY Insisting that Until the froi
I traitors should give In their award he (Ok) sHorir
I SUSPEND ALL OPERATIONS OK EVERY ONE o. MS con
TRACTS % speed had previously ensured Mr. r. J ina
be know or could not DO that and Smith had write
10 bin. March , The whole hs'i s 10 be contested
and the sooner commenced the there will be Of u
fit be 10, sooner ended ihereby
Oa the 18Th of Sept last Mr. Oile.ly wrote Professor
More that he and hs associates then sud 1~ay
bad beer ssdy sssgn D. hin the share u stock VI
other erest required By hor contract which he sSai
ssxed tins Professor 10 fulhL Ike notice vac sent y
smith But as 10 former csies delays aud non inier
course order On the Boston line wers the only reply
O'Relly toll Smith that be VS. ready At any hour I
meet the holders of the patent ags'n IN Court and 70
INTO THE WHOLE MEATS OF IHE CASE taking 20 ID
vantage OF lszsl tsclnicslIties o. DAVIS. NewsPapa
abuse was the rrl1lnier
When this nstlon found sself Involved In war With
BriiAn in l-2 ev,ry possible Effort vas made % inEen
add organize Efficient lines Of telegraph and the cer
btaied Chrstoyhsr Coles WbOse early Efforts on benz
Il the Erie CanA are warmly eulosizst BY Clinton
delivered Lectures the telegraph IN Or that year
~ing audiences 81 the Custom House Of ins CJ
With What feeling Of ireffAole contempt would Cole
and Franklin II sgsn permitted 20 visii former scenes
regard smith Case Kendall sud their assoeistes who
a.. =