New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1846-05-12
I. c. Hin in Reply TO seuhor No-onhn.

To as< sGi.rr Of TIE Tri5-re
Srz- Tou- pa7e- a-via5 keen maize he Instrument Of
cael nd inous asperoa upon y ca-racie, aad Eeqa-
sasoa Is 81 ar:is AID mar. Zee, III; your ofrs
ice cauuot 1s.e ne rooGs Tor tefeatrg r.ysesy ;ains
re ;-h REARING TIE recsc: Coaeert OF AZ. No-onhs
arI ny connection with It. This viii 60 ;he iewes;
possible words.
n the ars: place. Senior NoFonha for IRE 20 arrange
abou; his Concert. called him Or times
his NEUTRALITY-SUSPICIOUS. What he wantel-enaced NJ.
Tnz-saw Miss SortaAn. ,wfose services could net %
o5.aaed)-c.ed ca Madame Otto aad engaged her-lna
also engaged an Orchestra fov whose par responsible,
As informed senior Nororhs his vie, ard which they
wei understood then spent no little time Aad ;roaDle III
running s5ou, the city. making his programme GET.
ing i and hts posters printed &c. called ,he
lob printing otE-s three times 70 HAT every thing
was properly borrowed music attended
with the Sand =. N!oo's or Wednesday Ao- Ssh ard
los. me whole venins Ihe night the Concert wss
postponed attended, slso. rehearsal wiki Sand
a. the Apollo the jil OF May. and again 10 The
nz $50 took trouble 70 ootatn psro OF Mr. Prison
Tor the Concert without charge and again assured every
body engaged ths there would be no dIih:Gty aboa,
the psy.
s receipt. would be sufficient pay toe rent OF The
saloor-to sag nothing OF the orchestra and iHc assist
artists had been recently sued for the expenses OF
concert under very similar circumssances and the
ja5 sment, obtained a2siGst me lew weeks ago is now
incuosng in OF The Courts. Has responsible for
the expenses on this and did feel myself
able 10 take tie money OF my own POCKET TO pay
;hem Atthe Sacred Music Socieys and other concerts
II the czsio 10 pay me orchestra the evening oi
,he performance aud considered tia; tuty 10 set
iupcied accede 70 tae making OF this condition On
the present occasion. Whether hSd already con
trbu;ed mr. fair proportion 10 tic concert considering
thst nothing Suta plain reslden! musician and 10
pretend be distinguished foreign arstsnd that my
wife never Wrote line Of poetry in her lite
Leave 10 the candid judgment OF that public among
xhom I have spent my lie. aud Were hope TO
be permitted 20 end ny days IN peace and bs consigned
20 nj last with tfe respectful! memory OF tbos5
who know me best.
Nv own services as well as those Of Mr. rinu. would
have been cheeriuy rendered Ind they been avail able
Iesircd but did lee that ought either 70 pay the
Orchestra and Madame OTTO myself or 10 solicit at their
hands fyor which coa9 not AK for myself without
breach OF professional dccacy which Senior Moron
h -. ms 10 have 30 strangely forgotten. Il seems
that an artist obligations TO MS fellow artists we'll
A. 10 INC public and that ii circumstances force him
position OF embarrassment he should distribute tho dis
appointment equally possible between the audience
and his Was it Not enough that the Ier had
attended rehearssls lost two evenings, besides some
OF theu having RAD substitutes, and willing
10 fre all remuneration for their time and actual less
on condition OF being permitted 10 withdraw especi ally
the audience expressed themselves satisfied WITH Mr.
Sallsnechs explanation, and the Concert went on with
their entire APPRECIATION, and positive saving to Sc nhsr
Noronhd of hundred and tweuty-odd dollars
But srlver matter than all these 10 discuss ain
Senior Serouha-
NJ HUI 10 i've Climax 10 the whole, addressed HIM
self 10 the people Of the Concert Room pn gu the ghI s.
suppo.iug base enough 10 a on all points of my ei 70
gsgsi1J- those " DO nsi done ne the honor OF beu
pre,rnt lh, uahgFpy occasion
TINS i. .imply untrue pronounce it deliberate
fal.ehood and one that Senior Noronha Gf he knew
what &C. sisned) must have kHo~n 20 be such.
Again Senior Noronha says
th4ns al.o the thee ilar musicians who wished to
accompany me. Il Mir Hill would have consented"
No suca oder made 10 my knowledge; but have
since hid reason believe that this statement
from an offer made for the purpose OF iniurDg by
IL tctf,z bad
ously stopped IN the Sacred Music Society account;
OF his insuenton. He and Others welcome TO all
the capital that be made out Of tho Circumstance
But 10 the inure, SENIOR Nuronha say g. IN re-
gard to his next concert:
true artists
l would not be impairment would ike 20 inquire
by wt-; standard this gentleman from raz intends TO
judge and pass sentence o death and execution upon
the three four hundred obscure musical people In
New York who have presumed 10 take rank lwith the
appreciation of the public true artstst Does S-uhor
Noroaa ,ty'e nobody true art!ss those who
willing play for nothing II will he answer, upon
his conscience whether ms ohjsc, In giving Concert
make money! II he disappointed never
heess be tried 10 accomplish his object and how dare
he thus sweep into tho gull uf dshonor oil those
fortunate horn blowers and cagut scr-psrs who tried
make s. apiece the way "a h. ear--~"rnd
pocket his hundredsby the exercise OF their profess
oua ;aents Can the senior translate our homrsy OLD
Yankee saw" Sauce for the goose Ia sauce Tor the gan
dor into classic PoriusUesel His Printers bills &c
sc. were all Cor of them paid in advance Why,
pee: alma from his assistant musicians
i word more and have done. Your correspond
ent x, in commenting upon SENIOR Eoronhas letter,
has permitted himself To the following language:
A. those Persons who, having engaged him.
and being The spOt 10 T.adness Ian in.u aud in
fure unable 10 SPEAK word Of English
lend himself 10 any way. ana fehnej gentleman who
{, "a tn of nj. letter only with
utl ie and the chances o! ner professions
5ug back 10 ihsif memory IN lhs way they
deserve"
will not upon this writer by invoking upon him
the rewards which euueoty deserved by those who
venture cgiumui4te and iniurc their fellow men In
print simply because they nave heard ono side OF
sor; in which friend is actor and resolue!y shut
their cars against the possibility OF listening 70 The other
Te writer .e read this rsply and Whistler or not his
acutene.s viii enable him 70 detect in it, the
OF 4 ehned gentleman take the liberty OF assuring
him tbs. II conceived and uttered, every word OF y IN
spirit OF truth and sucerytha ia written BY man
who scorrs base ngssrdy ungeuerous actlon more
tha he does any thing else ~ ,hs world eScc? the Vi
terer Of fasehoods and the contrver or cfcua.or OF
L. C. HILL.