New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1846-08-19

Cd Ee:icr and qaicler in It's graphic execution
writing,
9Th More ANALooIo!lL N the Phonosraphic formation
OF the signs with the Principles OF Phoneucs, as
understood 10y Mr.. Ptman and his disciples
9Th More complete in Sounds Authorizations Nasals and
other component elements of universal language.
1;h. More pathological IN Us theoretical composition,
and more Philosophical in its practical construction
Sth. More comprehensive and more adorable svs.
tenn of Pare and T1e Photography TO the universally
o! human languages
9th and finally more communicable, and much more
speedily ccq.;rec and understood by the ucophyie
Now then II tine OTTER o; proving these facts, IN the
manner proposed. do uot suffice 10 convince the
followers o! Mr. PtnSn System OF the necessity 10 put
en- end 70 all extr0neoUs personalities and anacpat
ed controversy this subject by fastening the pfopos
cd I's instead o! pcrpeusly dissenting and raising
eoecuon upon objection, 10 avoid H. II posSlHe,
and the final issue We shall! persist III believing maj
they promoted IN their diffusion OF his system by
views very widely differing from those dis!n;eresed
desires OF beneans the human race sc so often and
emphaucaiy repeated to The public, by either speech
OF pint, Tor the last eighteen months
Il - well known. II TACT that pecuuisry considers.
tons OF minor importance TO those immediately
cerned the teaching OF that are al stake the
result OF this trial and hcuce the OF this continual
incarceration from dsscnsions' and objections" 10
Inconsistencies OF the most bcwilderns nature We
are aware therefore have hitherto been taught oy
experience thst al imaginable preeNts however trvo-
lous and inconsistent in themselves Viii again be
ed 70 and actively set forth 10 counterfeit the action Of
the Convention and evade the pctcinp'ory Verde; OF
the select urv II. this issue vet whatever insy be The
wsys and means adopted by an Interested opposition
10 carry such plans - nc wa H' 'oFS u; 'tSS
tcke place We are determined 20 concentrate al ouc
perseverance snd energy e:;as abou; the coniea'
hated ISSUE ths, The pS6c and especially those con.
cerned in general education may ana'ly S2l' without
equivocston whether Mr. P.tman's 80 much vspn'ed
system of Phoaography Is, IN reality ne ian ,yor-
thy o; universal adoption, or wheiacr the Ne"
System" is not al that we have said Il WAS
We Will also Nix Editor abide literally % Your gen
eral proposal formulated IL yoar accompanying Ec'
marks 10 my letter OF the 18Th u!t Wul II shall hSNe
been overruled BY the Convention II its members see
fl 20 do So for q better substitute Should Nj NJ
choose 10 persist in dissenting and decline acceps
the basis OF the ial such they may De voted BY the
Convention and accepted by Us, We kaoo OF other dis
cipes o; Mr. P,1sn adopts OF his system emf
nently qualified 20 illustrate it Principles 10 the fullest
satisfaction OF the members of the Committee !, mat;
tiers any way to the public, and those Interested
this question lcko shall be the deicnsor Of Mr.. 5
system provided the dcensor shall prove himself as
thoroughly ncqusinJed and conversan; WIFE II RS Is au
thor himself may be
With the hope that this marx of our profound se,
spec, Tor PusLc OPINION may be duly appreciated snd
indugen'ly received remain dear Sir. very respect
fully yours, FK's F. CD.
See Tribune OF September 10, is and ls, ls.s