New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1846-09-03
NETWORK CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION
FOURTEENTH wEEK-LXXvII1n DAY.
Glorious NeWst


AIsASr Sept ls- l746.
t. tie Edi;or Of Tx Tribune:
SIR Mr3rown proposed thatthe Convention should
finally close it. proceedings Tuesday Oct 9Th which
was agreed 70 with l;tc opposition
most uaportan; vote has beea gwen FOR the good
OF this fine country would fan hope VII be sustain.
ed Mr Murphy this evening made me following mo
ton in the form Of an amendment 20 very different
by Mr. Brown:
'sl2 The 1871 JvsTIcEs or TIE SUPREME coraT SHALL
BIZ ELLcrrp 81 TIE ELEcToRs or HE RESPECTIVE 1927
SENATE DISTRICTS Al SUCH TiME As NAY BIZ PROVIDED
BIZ Law
M Murphv's proposition delight TO sag it; was car.
RED bv the large vote 30 70 ~ and the judges
be appointed by The people in reality. This Is party
triuInp-iti. the triumph OF american principles ;ree
elective institutions.
For The section and an Elective Judiciary by Senate
Districts voted
Messrs Archer Ayraul, F +. Backus H Bsckus ssser
Bascom, Bergen. Bowdish, Bray;on Bruce, Bu. Burr,
Csndee, Chamberlain Clark, Clyde Cook, Crooker Dana
Dodd Dorlon. Flanders Forsyth Graham Harris Hsrri
well, Murphy, Nicholas, Parish, Patterson, Penu!msn
Porter Richmond. Salisbury, Shsver Shaw, Z spencer
ca.t Tain!adge Townsend, Van Schoonhoven, Warren
Waterbury, Wiibeck, Worden, = Virgin, ". B. Wright,
fawger, Young-6o.
Against il voted
Messrs Angel, Bouck, Brown, Brandage, cambreeng,
R. Campbell, Jr Goneiy, Cornell; ClddebaGs, DUBOIS
er, A. Huntington. Hutchinson Hyde, Jones, kemo!e,
Kennedy, LOOMS Mann Morris, Sels, N!co. o Conor
Perkins, Powers, President Rhoades, Rker, s. John,
Sanford, Sears Sheldon Stephens. Steteon, j. J.
Taylor, w Taylor, Tilcen, Tuthl, White, Willard, Wood,
The following
AsssxT-Alen. d. D. Campbell, ChaideId; Danforh,
V5nt TeIo1 Rnyres Rns.ei Sbanard Simmons smith
Vache, Ward-l9
Mr. Brown evidently much Disconnected with the re-
suit, al minutes past and gave notice tnat he
would reconsideration OF the vote just gwen
confess enjoyed his distress. He aspires 70 the oce OF
leader the party, and must say that Il they
can ind no better Democrats among the Scotch here
they might try Native next with advantage. There are
some bold and and manly souls, who arst the
light in the Empire State Mr. Brown might resign with
great proprcty The cenxals are al fault this tune
Election of the Judges
About hafpas -four this evening the lawyers sounded
the legal trumpet on the question OF an biecuve udicla
~. The weather is hot the Convention Chamber iu!,
and the dog the gun, and the highland heath OF Aud
Lang.Syne are again among the pleasures oil memo
"" No one says word OF d system OF Official SOmina
tons and yet cannot how the People can eject with
out IL batch OF Judges may De nominated at Albany
Washington, Undertook. Syracuse or Hcrkner. and
the people do what the Senate now doesso Win 'hei'
party leaders. but popular election is quite another
thing 1t may be real in Senate District without an OF.
fetal nomination Can be so in state as popu!ous rs
Scotland
Mr. BAowS Of Orange, (yho stuck with anxiety and
10 lawyercensng and Masters in Chancery9
and proposed the Convention 10 vote ior the elec
ton of the 81 Judges OF the supreme Court By ONE
GENERAL TICKET throughout the State, each party
nominate 81 candidates at it's caucus or party Con
venon and the people divide into two armies, each
man of each army placing in the ballot boxes ballot
with 80 names 81 OF whom perhaps lie never heard
OF before and If that is voted down, they would then
get the question OF the appointment OF the Judges by
Governor and senate AS heretofore. or thelr eectt
by Districts II he could not get these judges elected by
general ticket then no would go tor their appointment by
the Governor and Senate in preference 10 election by
Districts
n hope TINT when Governor Wright takes the field
with his army patronage by self and party fappointcd
in the old way and by self and party if dictated from
Syracuse, that he will remember poor Mr.. Brown. If
he has sometimes forgotten Orange County he has
proved 'rrishi the ncedeto the pole The
very though, of such politician and the quarter he
comes from makes many converts 10 Natyism.
Mr. MURPHY said that unless he could have his way he
would go Tor the appointment OF the Judges by The Gov.
crnor and Senate He would propose that they should
De elected by single Senate Districts, and should that
fail then he would 60 for the old way OF appointing the
Judiciary by the Executive and Senate. The people
cannot Understandings for the judges unless they
know them II elected by general ticket Will they know
One.tenth OF them No The party politicians nomi-
atc them, and the people take them on trust by the
party.
Mr. BRowS said that these Justices were the. Justices
oil the People at large and not of localities.
Sois the Senate Of the State though its members
elected by Districts and yet Mr. Brown and Mr.. Muir.
phys % choice is an appointment Of 81 Judges for
years by Senate elected by the people for but two
wears the - said Senate fix the salaries OF the 81
on the - benches at 5000 year more or less I'M
changa5c Tor years. Drol Democracy this Messrs
Brown and Murphy
Mr. STErsoN spoke next. In his loudest, sharpest-
mos; unmusicM accents, he fairly and boldly followed
Mr. Brown for the general ticket the party The Demo
crazy. Mr. STRONG followed and then NJ. BAscoM. X.