New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1846-08-28
n Unknown tac:--:hs jiaiEe % adIniai:.e. KNOWN

an Unknown :ac:-ihe judge 70 administer KNOWN
M. Holman declared ths; the lsv was no; known
az, March n Ms e,--tna. there were shout Two MI
ions OF rules many OF thera very doubtful snd that
code was wanted.
He would allow the Judge who mad tied case TO III
and -c on an sppeal whether ne mad o. hsd not EVEN
written opinion according 20 Judge 2usgles prppO-
s.-.or /: adze TOO ildoieIi opinion re
NAY vote on 81 appeal fror1 i:i: ne writes i ou: he
The Convention refused &c strike OF; written 5y a
vote Of . % ,.
M. S-ow-Seein- thai are 10 hold out tn ;e-ap.a-
ton 20 & Judge not 20 write out MS opinions. must
vote against me whole
For III Rusgles's amendment q asains; !, % ab-
30 that nall ;ae Final Appeal Court may De the
whole Of TIE Supreme Court OF the Ds;ric; who tired
Nj. MokR-s wanted an appeal Court o; seven men.
ber= 20 % composed OF three Supreme Cour; Judges
and ioUr eleciec members
Lost-Ayes - Noes -
Mr. NtcoLL proposed Judges having four years 70
.a-ve IN the supreme Court should serve il the Ar
Mr. SALISBURY presumed tina: this new Cour, o; e
,o- would not 20 employed quarter Of the tine.
l. would be good -,,r0t tat Comfortable place ioT
-srred Judges accept NTH pensions o. 5000 20 SiUOv
M R,rHmoxD believed that this new appeal Court
va intended 10 costs 70 -uJors. and be
merely ~ ECHO OF ihe Supreme Court and ne wanted
inc sIch Court altogether tfsry ne'T move N a."
demanded q DeT iee from the client
Nr y RES proposed mat the Judges OF TIE : P
uel Cour, who we're - lc elected should % elected
on. ,acn 10 o. tour Districts composing Inc s"''
To-, sve- 3--NOeS %
Mr. Bnowx proposed 20 elect Two OF the ApPeai
Iudges every four vears-tyo 20 20 cut M ne END OF
four ycar-tvo AZ ne end 81 t-Al Tue TENURE '''-'
" ART proposed 70 add 10 the section mat nc
INDICTMENT decree order decision OF the supreme Court
sbal be- reversed without the concurrence OF nj eas' q
T,oiu- n minority pi tn" Court OF Appeals Lost WIZ!
ONT even a record OF the Ave. and Noe- Mr. Brown
explaining that il not to D. expected that all the
Judges would be present
the nature powers His a'He ndnlen' was instantly
Mr, BAscoM proposed 70 add to the section. that
q. ,ior of IN. said court shall held ofi"u once
IN two wears cach OF Tie d Jadcia DISTRICTS OF 'he
Ave. IL Noe- g. Lost
Mr. Harris and Or. HARRISON made propositions "hitH
NJ BIscoN stated his intention to strike GU,
section atosciho--butil The section was 10 be adopted
and Inc Court created ht wanted 20 aGd 20 = a. Hbo'e
,,rovo.,o- was next made strike out years a.
the term tor which the Appeal judges won4d be elected
and insert hu, met httie favor. Inc Aye were
Mc.srs Archer Richmond, - Johu salisbury sheldon
Morris Waterbury. Wool. \ q " T. " r'slt hat'cd,
F Backu= Mann. ani others whose names could not
hear bv reason oi the noise. Ayes = Noes ~ Lost
The, end s. creating appeal Court from le supreme
IL
Noes -
= There shall he Courof Appeals composed of,ie'
Judges, of whom four shall be- Elected by re electors oi
the Sto.e eight years and four selected from ur e-
of Justices of the supreme Court having the shortest TINE
10 serve Provision shall he made by nav Tor desi suats
nm, of the number elected Clrt JudEe ana TOR strcn
.Icl II.ti- p the supreme Court from ne 10 time and
for classifying those elected thai ono >h" De- et'ed
every second year.
Mr. STRONG moved a reconsideration, and as there
may be proceedings hereafter winch vii more clearly
;ndica;, the opinions Members This most import
ant subject oIii; the Ayes and Noe
Section Sd was read establishing supreme C"urt
with law and equity jurisdiction
Nj SwAcxn4MER wanted more clear definition OF
the meaning OF the section
Mr.. Brown proposed 10 add
subject 10 such additions limitations aad regulations a-
may be- prescribed by Jaw
4 long discussion about County Courts followed Nj
O'Ccnor called Judge Ulshoctcrs Court " the ehiri
icSel OF the County Nh Richmond thought that ti'
peop. would want an array OF - County Courts,
and also 36 Supreme and Appeal Judges Mr. Cambrel-
eng wanted the Supreme Court Judges 10 preside IN
the County Courts and 10 save the country from 50 ma
ny appeals as some seutemens plans INDICATED.
No wa taken --a-,-
In the Majority Report il provided that there shall
be four Judges in eac: OF eight Dsrict-n all thirty
two-Mr Brown wants forty besides tour - be appeal
Judges by general ticket Mcssrs. Chatield Harri-.
O'Conor TAYLOR. Morris. Nan Schoonhovel, Marvin
stow &c tel u that the simphrcaton OF the practice
in the Courts would greatly diminish the business oil tue
ludiciary-some OF them say Il would take away one
half OF IL We have now Chancelor,2 vices an As
sistan, Supreme and Circuit Judges, with Superlor
Court judge in New orN-l' IL all The aS practice
is To De simpi.cd and the army Judges doubled
,rebed and some OF them introduced by general ticket
as pensions for party politicians. It 5 true the
Judges will have to do the business, now a5suriy and
extensively done by the Examiners and Masters IN
Chancery and OF the County Judges: bat the latter
carve, out much work thu higher Courts or the most
part at rast) and the work be done in lieu OF the
Examiners and Masters IN Chaucery. VIII surely not
coun;erbalance work be saved by all the reforms a.
regards time.
The Majority Report provides tha; any additional
number Of judges may be aer"ard appointed or elect
ed for the City OF n York, that may De- required
Whv not allow those who had lt;!e TO do III the rural
Districts 10 attend ;hc Courts IN Ne" FORK Forty
Judges eight Clerks and four other officers, glve ~
diy-rwo officers az 5000 >lJoUJ year J0r salaries
dgn, -Four times the expense OF the Legislature 10
salaries with G Members. The public business must
bt done but ttytwo officers. elected tor eight years
armed with the judicial power. and most OF then 10
travel k, tue Methodist preachers, al! OYER the state
mot Dad tina, arrangement neither Is costly arrange,
ment n