New-York daily tribune. [volume] (New-York [N.Y.]) 1842-1866, 1846-09-10
Hom0opatky. &.
To the Editor Of The Tribune:

To III. Editor Of The Tribune:
Dr.. Cox's statement in last fridays ITouie i
quires the following reply a; ny tand= ....
The certificate which Dr.. Cox brings io'"aiN .
justification for making the lsa Cry Inspector
tina. physician vino sends II g-estest nu;iloeF VI
certificates OF death is HomaoPaih STOW, -.
haa bee- guilty O. libelous unr-a;h tIee'e IN '"o
HI. original declaration
consecutive srtics definite assertion tAai me h. ~!
~ .,.--,1ares that the who sends the greatest
Tr,sr- Of certificates OF death 10 is once Is i'0''
path
,,a.e officer in the Inspectors Office, simply said 81
,siqt the physician who sent the most certificates vas
Hompopa-h
Now .-l tell Dr. Cox what hank Of MS extraord
ssser,;on and what no doubt every honest man in
his community thinks likewise think this tia: the
nnirrus Of that assertion i precisely the same with maj
OF every untrui whether that assertion was originally
made By Dr. Cox by his tool, Dr.. Collins, ne SNOW
best; ansIauch they have become responsible Tor
one another set them down as par nobils frGtrgH,
Dr. Cox knew 20 little OF what he said that he speaks
of the City Inspector as having made mat assertion
whereas appear ;ha, Ar Fleet was employed ny the
,resen, CITY Inspector. Now what does tins gentleman
say lcaled upon him in company with Dr. GIrod OF
Houstonst in order 70 ascertain the truth Of the matter
and in our presence that gentleman soeny declared
Il have never made such an assertion 70 any man
under Heaven and although am opposed 70 itomuo-
pstlv vet am willing 70 state thattis my impression
} that Horunopa,hs send in few certificates
leave it to Dr.. Cox 8 Co 10 reconcile Mr. Fleets
.yu1s, wiki the statement Of his superior officers.
shall take the earliest opportunity OF counting the
certificates Of death OF lastyear and shall then publish
list of the certificates sent in by the respective physi-
clans until then shall content myself with stating the
following fact from Doctor Wrigh report the Mana
gers OF the Protestant Half Orphan asylum. The re
suit of the treatment of the various diseases occurring
during period OF sixteen months ending Dec. 1913,
follows
Whole lumber Of cases treated i2l cured i3; lett
the asylum under treatment = ded = ne mecca!
treatment in every instance strictly Homeopathic
During the rs years the inmates were under Al
lopathic and the death. averaged one 10 81
during the last three years The treatment has been eXcu
svely Homeopathic and the deaths have averaged only
one 10 m For the last eighteen months there has been
no death OSec Doctor Clark Wrigh,s report TO the
managers OF that institutIon)
AZ regards Dr. Collins npartal;y assert that II was
his deliberate intention 10 admit my article mad
accommodated my article 10 his own views "a can
show from his written testimony can also snow
tina, when he back my article with the excuse that
the matter for his Journal made up nc uttered an IN
truth in as much ms two pages and half OF ms journal
are flied with his scurous remarks on my arti-
Gle and with private notes which Dr. Collins wrote 10
me after my article had been handed to him
In relation 10 he puDHcat'oi oi III Oo''s pm a'e
note to Inc in his journal which purpors to be the
report of our private conversation, and which was
highly dishonorable to publish, beg leave to state
tina, that report garbed distorted and untrue have
been intimately acquainted for several years past with
the gentleman lnaciously alluded to in that note
have constantly honored him Of learning and
skill and have always heard him spoken OF in terms
Of the hghes, regard in the family of my dearest friend
whose life he saved under the most trying crcum.
stances CHARLES JULIUS HENPEi.