The New York herald., 1845-01-29

was greatly distressed and he Mr.. Butler, held me on
his knee for some time and after thar rode sometimes
his knee, and sometimes carpet bag OF his iee
We stopped twice during the night reitng at Homer an
hour or two nearly can recollect During all our
time OF stay at those places my whole efforts were need
ed by my husband soothe him, he beng violently IN.
censed and declaring that Bishop Onderdonk shoaia no
ordan him We stopped that morning about day preak at
place about miles distant. should think, from syra
cuse-perhaps fifteen miles. Here we again rested ana
hs Bshon ssp SeaUy When we lett the last
stopping place, persuaded Mr. Butler to ait back with
Bishop n order to avoid the remark that would pe oc
between the Bishop and myself after changed my seat:
have since seen him, except in Convention until
10 Did the Bishop make any remark when you left the
back seat
He did not did he afterwards remark upon the way
90 Was it clear and warm night on that occasion1
was warm, but not clear; drizzled somewhat about
Did the Bishop make any remark about the state Of
the westher7
~ Did he make any remark about your sitting on the
front seat
have answered the question He did not not that
% Was the top Of the barouche up7
Yes, cir But do not recoilect whether half way or
"a Was you exposed entirely the nclemency Of the
weather on the front seat
was sir but the weather was by no means severe.
% What occurred on the NEXT day
When got home was very much distressed in mind
and body and both unable and unwilling to attend the
%. Was Mr. Butler ordained by Bishop Onderdonk7
He ordained by HIM, though suffering under great
27. Did Mr.. Butler ssts you the why he was
| ordained [Objected to andiiuled sut]
% What was the effect of Bishop Ondsrdonks treat
ment towards y0n on your health
always supposed that some weeks of indisposition
were caused by the distress that went through with that
30. When and where was you indisposed
In my house, sir where boarded, rather, at SYRIA
50. Did your indispositon Immediately succeed that
night
81. When, and to whom, did you first communicate
these facts?
Never infinitely to any one until since this has
been on the carpet except to my husband that night
have since avoided conversation even with hm on the
y. Do you now reside in Syracuse
IS - Where ais red do you now reside
In the city of Bosten.
Since the a0ih of May last, about that time Mr.
and we arrived there day or two previous
35 Did you remain at Syracuse to the time OF your
removal to Boston, and if not where did you 1--we IN the
At Utica about six months at Palmyra two years at
Baltimore about seven months at Georgetown, D. c.
two years and q half and thence moved to Boston.
SO What time did you remove from Syracuse?
The May following the ordination, in 1898.
This evidence is, it will be seen, fatty contradic-
ted by the Rev. Mr. Gregory, who, according to
the statement of the Bishop, asserts that Mr. But
Ter had been lndisposed previously to this journey.
However we have not new space TO make further
comments. Tomorrow we shall proceed with our
review. Thus far we may say, as regards this ex-
traordinary and exciting controversy that the On
| derdonkers and the anti Onderdonkers are about
even-,hey are neck and neck-and new move
ment in this extraordinary moral and religious race
will take place Immediately on the issuing of the
Book of Evidence.