New-York daily tribune., 1844-06-07

:, b;cb hec been in successful and most benchcent
ooera,ion before Yourself and large portion oi me
audience YOU addressed. had any claim even TO ii's
protection Of the American laws. MS Is 'or
.ophs,n which runs through both your letters, and
which trns, elsewhere more fully 10 e1p"sc-
Then. Sir. again repeat YOU did oct in operation
, ajn of eau s which -. 10 The o The od'ois co"i
ayr the exclusion of the Bbe from our Common school
assurance tn r-ve tba.c VINO by ;i at nj nor ~
nci.c;ec,!y and wronriuy. - beere eh!e4tofed 10 ~
tended should removed uui ;hsy had sccnp ,n- =
yor I'D cor!I,Ty court is favor OF political pay
le,sinr o CAUSING ~ p'e-ei the vote 81 your Hus
t.ai side winch should md IN tn accom hiien "i :; ~
-hcfnc4-. barssin which was mot ruffiply co4'uHmhi
y Causing your qo., wh9' ~ 10 f.in.a une, nae re
aained field. la y'ed the GROUND % your ae ne ne!
non; the neyy va, received that tie bill " the mos. ic =
had been pas;g7 leH ~. nave p. "a isn 10
sigcr which yau buas; OF possessing N ts 1} ini vi" N
,h, notwithstanding your denial. you ga in
., 1orh - c<rie the Of intriguing directly raG
gg7ay W % aag, ,s here done both abfcy aad ya,e
nch the Obligation OF .ce ard good W" 10 Az men
have haG the poor Of ntit" SeuuiE-ne-s md .Dc-f
irery or osed Eli those meek, and kind Gat :en'e.
asd ravas influence, wnfn you "ou'd As'e u 'e'e ai'
g; as pause moment eniesyor to bring up before The
, tho s-c,e> @; that remarkable e"ent-h- SUBJECT
noscrtet-,i audience gddre.cdhe nUd hccompalnertS
II nore and trmu VIVA; 10 be decided 1t was ~.
,.t which u Tin. the question OF questions
the r,ode Of conducting pubic system u eincaiion, si
The g-a, principle. w 1t should be iounded-a enenn
which o an others reu thorough and 'e:ul
f mo. i-s, ;r. which lie ut the foundation both
..ila'l G ~ I,.npbve oreS;ion sr-rounded " M
new and necila; tfcus IN il, ronr-cur ,y;h LIBERAL
us,ituus Of fou county, Gton whose decision vas T. E
50 nde AS 70 ecape ey of nrdelty the fand.aud
Of on & 's S yG,k X, be f i 3 4; ] 's IN. ie @ ;
ssnzulne hopes hat tnoe had been iolni Eh bas' on
which ths, dec could he piacet-a Gucs;.nl WIN.
needed M. eepe, reflection al the p'oiuunGe m1d Md
;h-ir cnrte,t ierd and m tef ctIne>t nu-s
And who composed the audience 10 whom you ndIf'7 .
ynur,rlf1 If II cons, Of the OF and-orf -;
writers. prui1unde TANKER our rt9 schaHif' :
The ia :hst from II possible Nou nede your iIhamma
mscunl, ppl,Sh.. uIu IL b. ", s,.,,ucy H.
ces'lu: ind the FnEn: % Sh ielaIs on G'',su "a
gues-on, heated and struggling pnIcal paij,
willing grasp Hnytng, and 10 offer nnF pfbes 70 Obtain
suc,ct. m charter erc,ona winch whate'er might
be IL. value Itself. sunk INTO Ut;er rcance when ac ri
o1 IN. re wh the gent interests involved the qes
winch wss thus bnse made su'erv,ent To uiiei
Hf political hacss :he interests oi Our tnmnon schools
to buy with the priceless gold Of National ,uca
ton " hat pen adequately describe the unerb. tEse
res OF purs connected IN such 81 infamous ,raihc
and Feeinn Journal let The candid reader Judge "tetef
and weih-: ,ot you have :" olenny Ie ie u re
celtye-yeu deceptive warm professions OF Dem
..:ce arbitrary rtual mud temporal dspoi I'd
;h. most determined Zoe free be found the
world YOU uGmlt and Eel N great degree the force oi tte
POSITIONS your nnNous attempt t fepudalr That report,
~ lssocianc WIKI the nGme o Bennett, thCs indirectly
that deserves the cthe's by Nc. u
r ,,6y teIye II ,i f.thfi - well Il. r;I;,ic r.
yr So tai both wnfds AID Let however. ~
the > place. before forgetting Hdy Ell ;O cAtT.He
d IN Il e cciGcu;G OF with that Of Ben
G.I, i here - such OF all !ce here such fb.
u Jcsu;isr It wss proceeding 80 becoming ~
and cy OF pous Cir;s,inn Bishop ia II
cannot be much niured FOR the eSiitnn Of those ddr-
able q1 Lite. winch yGu great clam ;houc chuui
am not gu.n. ra Bennett, 10 express indignant
tiiursne Il, ie association ,ei It iorth u u sneciei OF
wn OF your friend, hav@ styled a mos; calm tid :
n fed appeal instead o the pa"u and pfcjGtcr
rcn Your ruSe this respect, however, exhibits about
much refined TASTE 10 say h,hihs o. ts iEuith'; s u
should couple nume wh That OF the celebrated Monroe
WHAT rev. ;r loyou shrnk from the as'oc@tioa Wei
you lny VIII make Il. Bu; Monroe Edwhld ~
Iko n.tts ltsCt
ned man. nnd Ike yourself has lie ccn4laned bitterly OF
the attacks upon IN Ia the newspapers, Sul WI net p.i-
>ev. - ~ the n,,ocutui, although this community will tie
,.bc a ,',,e offensive 10 you ,huu YOU supprt
would be- 10 NE Icullnt connection which ptc>et
ed my name the ubc. should even represent the Gar
ru Hall orator aud the tenant oi sing respectively the
Rn Tor ,he reasons whrh had then, and hay now. for
rnrdns that report fruitful account OF what was sai aid
Carroll Hall. 10 the rs place. was IN perfect Keep
your course for years previous 9ad :'us p'ec
B adapted 70 'ie e1 rencc q" your "vofre SeHeie, ~ e
before the public. And here cannot help expressing Is
concrsy Us ma! be- iew ,honshs on nplec' ihe ,.!,
uf when might well require volumes hiqe 10 tc
pnGcpo hch system oi public eucaou should e co-
iuce. A bret statement OF them Is tar from beng foreign
argument although hu Indirectly conHecieh Win our
Carroll Hall speech belongs soto any present Office ~
your attack OF bat three theories that Tins
country be held relation 10 thus SUBJECT and OF but ree
m cti In each Gen"mruon bii.t ans and knuy not " y
the ,idcipa euCi sect philosophy should not lie
udc app ih"'e funds ~ aSceflanei proportions u
the support ct thar respective >chouis.
Tne second theory, which may, by oi detnc,oa be
y led the iHfdeI would be- utterly baush Nil religious
ucon whether ol positive or negative knd: {" c"urse AL
moral cnchng beng necessarily founded upon rclron
and on the saue pnc,pe c"ni-ion'y carried OUT, n 'u
ec,s about which there my he dissenting Snce u any
the smallest portion. s scheme, rs could he shuw
had time md space 20 co INTO such dsctYn instead "l
beng merely negative would b direct ttdfhs OF ift' IT.
eon mode which, although o!e:a'lns silently would he
the youthful mind the highest auh0riy has told Ma,
there neutrality this warfare, influence merely
gatiye he That not Tor Us pDSre!D nguSt U.s. ANA hs
cathere;h uo with schtter-t abfond s scheme,
thcn although roes,'nc L" be the antp2des oi 'eclafan
tuN the kN1T
nicAG portion u the community assumes That we nave
Nr,i"nn Innrre no pTedGmnan; Naonnl resloa Us t,.
trcused from established Church that we have no b0WO-
winch the perpetual lIlux of kindly INDUCED Tor
esners would impress supnn our institutions that, other
gathering MI tribes and TONGUES; without is being possible
erabe TINT should pu>ses> that homUccne y
which essential not only to Nat"nn CHARACTER but Hi>n u
NatonG existence (which Is absolutely necessary 70 cons te
genus, one o the families oi the EARTH ltcOnssicn'-
Is a>,Les therefore TINT OF the smallest fragments III u
Heterogeneous mas thu, refusing 10 cOGSce with the iedum
National influences, not simply entitled |" ioerioa
and prolecun but hns rch,iu rco upon any thing IN
uislruc,qn which may be offensive o themselves
however acceptable, however much desired and yGughc
te, not merely ,oa mJut'y but 10 the p'edomnnf-
| II may appear O superficial mud who cannu, how
closely intefwined are the roots o moral political and c
truth, this scheme has been regarded by the
iourdst thinkers irauhl Will! the utmost peril 10 our poli
| cal existence
The third and 10. hi, country the only plan public eucl
tion which had prospect OF beng successfully carGed ou
II eds the Theory that ine'e! scientific education l
exclusion ui m"fnss SIMPLY necCtirY deficient. hU
foot endar. unless regarded aS unded on pnnc pie
OF cligo,-thut have dsICt national character
,houl havirs and rso national language ais;
have ea !egiOu.thai this rei:l though
iahlNhed IN particular farm or mode the creature u
the nw does matter OF fact mode hsheriEai
the laws-ihat tie head the informing pl;t of laws
the snul ut the natonthat Tits religion the CsrISGR
other words, that CiStiGn nation. stnctor
irn an nnde M4home'an OF Pasai-tha' therefore I
raj education should be built upon ChGisauy. that
in;idei the foreign Teson suppo>Iug hm Ia
r.nieute, yield IN The p;eiomnnn, religious character
the country ;uuy tht the SACR Ed BOOKS, IN whics
taS religion contained, should be The standard moral
!Giuus instruction. be Taught the al
which be Il; alt consistent with the preservation
you yourself might PERHAPS Theoretically, practical
y and IN second letter. which directed by
aSe, suppose. instead ui real antagonist you
language very much like t.at which have supposed Ice
ploycd by the inide wheu you ta' there sUci
hing tiiS eOnrv predominant retsiOp': although
eau hardly believe meant that CHRIS
tisn Pagan, Ahhomenan iiiJe nation that tbs
fact >uud be taken INTO the account system O
tionai education
There h however another pom, this third Theory having
maintained! all the previous principles sacrificed. 4 version
vttAc Holy Scriptures TO be employed and here
necessary iu consider that Christian IN dl>tacou
nnde or Nnhumetan krw we've
of fact Protestant distinction from Pnp> tbs
couuiy had Amo>t without exception been settled by Pcie
ants. aud from l'tute>au. countries
Oar butch and Anglo Saxon ancestors Were PrD'eait
Nine people. nutwi,h>ardin. annual
off p .ft si