New-York daily tribune., 1844-06-01

did iu.rest 20 them IL. my letter 10 'he tonrisi
and FnorI-,r i'm, whatever might 5e their oPlnot-
on tie subject any ting ite d!ciHi,oH or "6fift
from any foreign soucce on that subject "ar - b'
me, wi;h ichuk- ard Indignation. nave Ee'eI NJ
tended or taken par; in po!l;ice! meeting or move
nleut IN my life have never voted n ny lie, eX
cent once have le:er made political -Pcecii II
my life aah d-rr Hnr one on earth 10 meet iiie
contradiction oi tbs s;nisI5eut ne Scto"t que
ton j. subject which can he explained IN I lew
word. The Catholics OF ~" otA, Tor slSlee'
wears, mad bcea deprived u lie btne.S OF the I2Nes
winch. in common with their tsl!O"-cit.zens- ihet
had 10 pay 10. education. Thev bad created e"
fra- schools 10 supply. as wei as might be. lie
evils resulting from tins priyaion. The question
Eow arises why were they deprived o' tae risf's u
education And the answer 10 that Question pr
ss1.;s the issue made in the who controversy. lie
Public School Society assignedas reason thai liz
Catholics were bigo;e, eHd iiis theIr priests KEPT
them npar from lie 0tRer caid-eS, lest t3ey Shou
become enl chaaai. .imericanEedi and, n u coi,'-
ouence Proirsfsnis a. -oau ss,hey -rcv M. LIE
Catholic on the 9TH. n7nd, CfrIed 'Gi' aIl' -
!aeet that !:;c s:ste oi tie F'hiIc Sct"o' >"'iC't
was aiaptsd 10 MAKE the Children ;T'te-;siiis or
D;ieis irsf or simultaneously wlh edlcaton
Hcrr !. The co:ltrover>v--oa tlese iwu statements.
The Catholics alleged that .i:F elementary bookS oi
the scioo!s put into TIE hu..ds OF their children
were calculated, it not inteLd.d, 10 po'son tle.F
minds in reference 10 their Teiisioi. az inoh'As
and wears this was denied II the fuh!ic ScHo"l
Soriaiy. That il was truc--they themselves ha;c
~ lcnG.n had the candnr TO acknowledge, by black
enirr cerail portions oil their hoohs, and ih!s ~
their ora motion and not &; any tancc oi Inln
IS All instance ol thuse passages, WIZ 4uoe
among others tie i.!io"iug:
lon n scas' el,',ei 'Gm taP5Ey w %'g ,s 'Y @ N
-1 of ~. ite.a,! centuries IL bold aH reT>cTcre
| The sake"
her friends that lie Catholics should pa. hcif
schcc! taxes ike others (Which ilsy dit,) sa. 'heH
after hayin. paid their tsXe', send their chd:en 1"
lhe ho Is In haze Il..ic minds imOued wa seni
meats like tis, combining at oace, p:rJ"Girc ut'
ct.aii-gh;eness aud witIal, uuHdet:"s istor!ca ~
.ccUr-c,.
tn Csti4oc=. on ;h- other hand, soal'l notaEr, e
IN have ic Zee mes nad understandings their chs
,iren tj~ls !,y -tch sentiments. rs ih1 teia Il! c-
efed TO them in IeiuTn icr the LGtes "';c tie las
required a-.;i 10 I95. THey pet Lonag a. gecd cii-
zan- on M 10 Go under ii.r pressure oi EfeNdct.
rh.y i,.cusscd-ihcy reasoned with ihe!r opp
nsns And iirs lei 20 t.ie results a!fchdF Iti.:r.G
TO- i;ut the ungeuerOuS iric., o tn ir. no. oi tie
Pebble School Spcie;y On discovering that wlt!!f 1:
t!ch fsiscrrd nid misrepresentation weienc m-ica q
lnr TUT, vas 20 allow a. tar as possible 10 one 10
| be elected except such as should t.rst bini ihen
elves IN DEM reGress for he grier1acs compd'F'd
ot-un matter how ju-t or hUw real that sne'ance
| w.,
m. eaction Ian, hi uer!iu@ IN tei!u! lini! ii III
school Question, when the knowledge oil Ih'- tfi'i
broke uun us express, d l!lr -'ni''H'- which !
-ii ,t,s,. D. .iI-r r'-i;t fcp'''i" or mol -
,hqv arr i,iuri IL the Freeman J0arRa htl E0t
;i,. :, arr adorned VIII Ic VAIN. -: shiGcidtS "a
EtiDeu's .ler,.i. Bennett says that t!lr tNo =
n.rfs a:, word 0r w0fdn :. Uerhatib Il ii'eraf512
Inc same" Baane't -aew vii Il "rpta this, last
week thai l- w. wr,,ins ,,iirI was not tue etia
uow lle public SNOW h.l he nnew II. Ny -peeet
at CARROT Hail was not tie speech OF II politician.
II was The speech ot man VIII, has some ieveIen .
for The d.nirv oI human nature. IL was tin speech
of an American wrO knows aat prizes the rights - =
cured by the A,uefican C0n>ialo-, wicil lie oulG
not Isl, tu seq violated III Any DE- nomination OF Ch:--
rlnfs. more than IN i- own. Read that speech a. II
i in the Frssm0nS JonraGf. Is there aay appeal
10 lofeigueIs-io itsr-to Ca;holicH-;o lo!il!cia''
-or ia an, class Ut beings, except 50 ir - pr!n-
cpe of cielr indisputatle rig',i end justice coui
, an appeal 10 tne understanding and the heart q:
every honest man
Turn now -.r | pray yoi:, a.ier hayiag read this
ha tin .urutlOn ot Bennr poCd, 10 tie
nine propositions lad dC"n IN niy iest iEer a.
FACTS. ii iIhose facts true, ask you whether
thrre Is n man smoag Us who present INNS Il at
the bar oi JUST ami honorable public 0plnon, IN
more urrxci;,i,onab!e cilgrucrr Us citizen, as a
Crjstan p4s 10. TRAN do N rr,eing the excess u;
scurriiou ,,l clr," ,c t'a- L. ca ticnPed
upon ne Bat II ytosc propositions are "ot yrut,
/
nett, William L. Stone, and sc Glh drcel'rrs o' the
public stand l"rl!i gmG meet Bishop iiugh"s
\ !cw words more aGd suii close = III what up
pertains 10 NV own vInCicatOn.
In INV le!.rr 10 hi- ionur the hlnyor stated IA
follows in reference 10 the meeting nj Cnrrrll Hall
lit there was reporter OF Bennett's there. who made
speech he thought pcpei-wich was dlt=t"1iu> IS
have j. believe, ,ird up for The purIse OF pfoGnci
If i;eunetts TREMENDOUS EXClrEaESTs nnd making
W, Irt iat tlE zen tins report, having studied
pi DNy,
eltoa comments, all t a0ck srcrg oi which Benaett
i, cnpsIe tie c-a ~ the Re1t In0rRS became the has
- ,',u r iii ;i, yi,u c-tlun raiumuy aud slrnGrf
whcn heapcd on Bsvp Hughes through the
! United states, from that day until tins.
Ali ills was son ne.mJry, end npoiogzed b:
anl:c;puion, If IN qeeSiOHs oi memory had made
am mistake In his attempt 10 reply 10 this, cn the
2ll!i lie states that the Whole question turns IN Tie;
accuracy of the report alone. TINS Is false. SAID
the :. Herald OF the next morning" including boIh
rhe report and the editorial comments, made " iIh
the mock gravity which he sometimes puts on, IN de-
sion o ,iiI nknG. so that here = .hsehOOd both IN
alterng AID III supp!essing truth In that editorial,
! headed wih flaming letters, he announced NEW
| AND EXTRAORDINARY NOV OvEMEHT-jifXTURE or
| POLITICS AND KELIGIoS-.le makes The clergy ai
well Is m, sell speakers, Nc. Aow, none OF !he
! Catholic clergy took any part IN the proceedings
whatever, nor have they III the discussion OF the
School Question, with one or two solitary eXceli-
lions Neither was there any mixture oi fO,i;Ics
and religion that an aware OF, except what Is
|
dea q religion and OF politics, without The slghts 81
consciousness OF any necessary mixture. :
| Words u ;lis k!nd-wrtten inailcOusly-rrad has
liiv-sent forth III LINE u. great party excitement
caught up according 10 The hue and tone OF the
passions-conmen,cd on a. they have been-he cane
urque>, onabiy the onAii ana bGsS oi al tie Vi
tuIeralian iiat has been heaped Oh zc throughout
the United States from ihat day until this. Ait
! hat have said already, the Truth OF one word al
which not even Benneu viii dare 10 deny. ask You
TO ponder on The direction cireH 10 The psJtic min!
| By ,s a5iicle-and it'a% uu viii see iii'I, by ne
ce->i,y ibis an pecvers t,uth IN the Spi'i ot the
a5tic'c-te penefts it IL the a'Jectiye-he Perseft'
i, i'll the noun-in the pTePo-iIion-he rervers II II!
what iie SAYS, and, =r the moral eli-c; coz
corncd hc pe;'-f,s il il. what lac -GPPTesscs. But
runnli spare uae ior tn minute exposure Of hi-
-Iuciiies OF ny character.
The examination ot Jhs question has impressed
on my mind more deep! r!a.a ever The -oundness III
the quotation at tie head Of tlns letter. AnG i
/ believe, that so nf regards ih- things OF this
world. Faiseho0d would be =" almighty Ii II wer-
ot oF Tra.h uione. There arc certa.nly, ci,-
rious forces concealed and mingled with the eie-