New-York daily tribune., 1844-05-11
oncc Al the conclusion OF his speech the Conner
enEs Pa 1'Jg Ar, MaRrrypALr announced the i0i'0"Ds
-.-'.s;,,,r,an,. for Sunday, May l.:

D.. A., M,RrIypALE announced u'c i0''o ""7
onnointments for Sunday, May u
'if yoRsIxs. AFTERNOON AND rvESis''
oi1strecIl WIN: Y:ia6s6 Il DG5 & i i Gena v Winnn=
y fddS. li. 4 /, sI, io.ner il Sheer
-is5grgW, ,.l,IP T. fi'P5E Poe T. Rabiroa Vi ler ioo.
.Hfa,sg,5.B .Hfas,fe.-B VI Drake J. T. N,e'9!. - ~ : n -
SOM -sfrset-W w Reialal' "
hon. lag.,r,,,-s. :. MOODY. J. Winner J. b Meier
r.,5,,,11..eren.i,st-ee.-A ,,1 Bauu-. D B Randall y
r., Eggsa .,,ee.-r. G. Hbbapl W. Hunter { Bern
Harssl1' 1n1;4 t,, ,reest Vi Glars. T. Go""n' H. ~
ls5s pqea 9i5i4tf' iia5sa l9s
as5e-g Ssr .Ts eSS5,qs Ss1 i hG@R.S E Fmss
Saraa, ,srsetl'', ,,san .af'ei aela S Rysroqq :, r.
..tTrsse,-Gcofse Web5e'. Sacrament H. H.
4-ia@4 @aGFc cnrcaA Adams Hdi} X5GSe0Pf fclicI I SafS
I,1pHf,r5-p : kiHc, {. BnAe'
lsr.gle-J,A Eaqfamall Faaaal. p c;anda, : Elliott
hoassEsaI sEE,-,i,.Gesca C'RS;Ss al ias C. " Brush
~ Drummaad.
sond.-.,,e..w cspt1:. SimasE J. ! s soSNlIa6as Ns.6s.
Ig,srr-J VI ase-g; i,l ; u / .gfj.iI W s. Iafs. : esse
,rry cisI, +; Nyedyea LIDS ,c Il FoYei Y iaatc
fo.9,tt f6o..9l,-tt-N ,lan 4 f,nae, L. Cornell! .hl,
y mr.. Wright. ). Fefsee, j. Vi rioi''
-
Jie,r5. .eGlr l.e-, Ro9q:oq " ); PafS''
Isrssg Ci,,-t b. IIJpeif. J. t. !ioushta'n='
,f,...I Early, \ NfI J i; 7 rhcm25,o2f 3 Fer
Trgnkl,n-s.-T J. Thompson, G = eaipe'''e' " 49, -
c;,,.sss.s..Pp. sa,@n. Morri., Eay Y. J. b Morgan
Iii;55e,5.5SF 3, sarssPi iJs1q I9aq Bear.
Staten ise'@-NV5 N55r,iisa51j 54i5aaEg, KS. < Shaw.
sa$SE fis a.s S5;5; ears = iB,goslyr-G. Baker
Those marked thus are TO preach Missionary
The Capital Punishment controversy
To the Editor Of The T 15NHe; -.;,,
You have been for some time past expressing
yo,,r admiration OF the eoquence and logic oil MI
Hureirb. the lecturer on Capital Punishment
VIII YOU also inform your readers, lmost oi whom
il j. supposed, are Wings, and therefore opposed 10
many OF the ultra-ladical movements OF when So"
seem so londl that this same Mr. Bureisb Is OPP
nosed 10 all punishment riaterer, Us well as 10 that
which i capiral: and does not believe at all in The
s,, nj force ior the suppression OF crime. lie a's-
,inc1lv ayowed the other day in The antl-staFerE
meeting, that man had no right 10 pnHiN man, =
and nil his arguments were directed as much against
anv species OF government as against tcapai p''''s!'
mcn: Will YOU also inform your readers, or s"Hef
me- 10 do it, that this man Yesterday Delivered
specch in favor OF resolution which declares tIat
the Constitution of the United States ought TO De
,r0D,,I2 uYder fe0t and OF another, AIMED NJ tie
destruction of the present Church and State In
short this same MIR. Burlcigh has tor some days
past been warmly advocating an immediate ussoi
ton of this Union, and all this from premises .,'e
same with or similar to. those he employs III 'iie
discussion OF the question OF Capital punsilmeht
Mr.. Burleirh however, can understand, ana so
likewise can [ understand Mr.. Collins-ihere IS
.ome consistency in them although but little logic
unless that can be styled logic which proceeds rom
utterly rotten and improved premises, Win co"I
tinued assumpiiOn OF the fundamental SrOuhos o
,Lr dnspcrate and false views respecting the true
deas fEaw Government and Punishment; but your
course. Mir. Editor | cannot understand. 1T Is Ut
terIv incomprchensible. Why do you not follow
out vour promises and land in the same conclusions
with these men Are YOU startled at the positions
-, which llev have arrived. and which they adVo-
cafe with So much holdness Why then should
Won not suspect the soundness OF your common pre-
mises -,
ions on government and on the grounds OF oDligaton
TO the Constitution OF the L. ;. which he IS disposed
TO cast of 50 lightly have nothing TO do win ms views
on Capi;a Punishment. Others, however, VINO
have gwen attention 10 the GNntteS OF error t'ihh
very differently; and when They hear a man reason
in The manner of this gentleman on the SUBJECT IN
question. they have little difficulty in Judging and
Judging accurately, OF the political and theological
creed or want OF creed, OF the great majority of
his admirers with the exception perhaps OF Il some
uo,.descript like yourself Why too Mr. Editor,
whilst Won are admitting into your columns ana
prpi,iu. the theological and untheological opinions
OF Mr. Hitreigh, and his crude Biblical !nterpreta-
ions. do Won reject, under that branded name all
that Is offensive N reply y.
u Our friend says his say in our columns,
which answers his closing query. We have al
ready repeatedly defined our own position in re-
gard 10 Reforms and Rciormers and need not
reiterate We firmly hold to the right of Society
to prsrent Crime, and to prevent the lntiIction OF
injury, even without crime. Society mas an OBJ
vious right to confnc the maniac where he can
do no harm, and the criminal III like manner.
We hold to Government and Force, even to the
taking OF life il this be found necessary to pre-
vent greater evil, though we believe the taking OF
life is not necessary or beneficial in this age and
country.
Our friend 90 has passion for mixing up
and complicating questions. We Ike 10 keep
Theology and Jurisprudence, Capital Punish
;nent and Abolition, &c. &c. separate; he likes
to compcate and blend them. As to what he
saws about carrying out principles 'coussten-
cy, &c. we lcr it pass for what It IS worth. Lord
Broughan said, in advocating the Reform Of the
British Parliament, that there never yet was "a
Reform made or attempted which could not have
been staggered by the objection, Why do you
stop here Why not be consistent and go far
ther p We prefer to act according to the light
vouchsaied US, and leave every man to do the
same. Ed.
'.Theodore Frelinghuysen STAKEHOLDER?
We are done for, Mr.. FRELINGHuYsES is "a a
used up man. The Emancipator has finally ex-
tinguished the Wing Party! We have nominal
ed a Slave Holder for Vice President And il
YOU don't believe il. read what Mr.. LeavItt, the
Editor OF the Abolition Emancipator, says