The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1843-02-25

Der 3lst, 1912 coming from Reade street The girl
nave no DOUBT THIS was the woman that came there on
the 2sth OF October Icannot say which of the two
oNsii nave no recollection Of the person Of Ann
Cross-eramined byProsecuon-I cannot say that this
girl called herself Catharae seabold. cannot say
whether she spoke to me not-my only guide IL the
book cannot say that she called herself Mary Heaney
the impression on my mind that they sisters
did get place for Catharne seaeold-absut three
weeks after sent the girl Mary Heavy to Mrs. Hoods
she came my Office and said had sent pretty GIRL
she had robbed me ofewellry THE District Attorney
herself and transferred her right to the place
The girl Ann O'Nen came with her. l can
then called herself Ann ONe my attention wa. first
called the facts relative Catherine seabod by Mrs.
Hood My attention was called to this Crib her gene
witness on Wednesday This girl resembles Catherine
seabold in every particular
By JURoR-Did you get Ann ONeil placer
WIrNEss-No, did not.
By JuRon-would it have appeared upon your book if
you had
By DsrsssB-Did any persen direct your attention to
wIrNEs-No, sir; this morning was the first that
communicated these facts to the counsel.
JOHN SOLOMON called by DefenceI reside at 3s Bur-
engaged !. our Rouse in July last as servants g. her
from intelligence office in Broadway. near Canal
street. Hall is the keeper sent number Of girls, and
my wife liking the looks Of this one, engaged herr she
the name of Ann Wood; my daughter wrote the
name on the ticket from the Intelligence Office; she
left on the Saturday following.
Odd she leave OF her own accord'
WrNEssMy wife sent her to the bakers Objected toy
we were about to discharge her. Objected TOY.
Q.-was she discharged or did she leave Of her own
accord1
WITNESS She was not discharged, but she knew she
would be (Witness continuing to explain why she
went away, but the District Attorney ohjected).
WITNESS continued-She not discharged.
BY PRosEcUrIor- made application to the Int ii
gence one. myself it was in July as the girl who was
laH he cir wi uap Ou a n
rne; do not her last home; have not seen this
girl Ann since the day she left until this morning
The DIsrMcr ArroRNEy asked the girl Ann to turn
her head round towards witness.
WiTNEss-That is the girl
Mr. BRADY here offered the record the 9th ward Court
i'll suit commenced by the girl Ann Murphy for wages
due by Patrick O'Nel in which she gave the name Of
Ann O'Neil; which wa: admitted by the prosecution
He also offered the manifest Of the list Of passengers oil
the brig Echo containing the name of Ann, who came
passenger This vessel arrived here on the 4th Of April
is42 from Liverpool and the report made by Capt
Sill on the 7th of April, before the Mayor which was
Mr. BRApY stated that neither the names of Ann Muir
ply or Aun ONe appeared upon the manifest with the
name of Ann Who, which was there.
MARY GoopwIN was called-I live with Mrs. Field, in
Blocker street; have lived there years Patrick
OK ely lives in the same houses this girl lived with Mr.
Kelly she was then called Ann ONe; while there she
had silver thimbe and Mr. Kelly offered her sixpence
for it, she said she could get more and round the
and sold for sixpence and gave me penny OF
of it.
Crosseramined W as about week
before she left went with her first round the corner
in the morning. and the jeweller not up; she said
know that she sold it to the jeweller; when we first
went there boy said the would give her sixpence
for t told this to Kelly night of the day that
Ann vas sworn; Mr. Kelly told to to Court.
Ann Murphy had said something against me.
Mr. GRAHAM interposed his objections to the course Of
GROSS examination by the District Attorney.
The DIsrkicr AvronsEv replied, and during his re-
marks round Of applause from the gallery
Mr. GRAHAM ain, and asked the Court to protect
its own dignity. He followed with severe remarks IN
condemnation of this continued interruption
Mr. WHrrING replied to the remarks Of Mr. Graham
with great force and energy.
Mr.. GRAHAM followed, and concluding, Mr.. Whiting
said, "Wel shall fight it out regularly"
Witness contnued-Mr Kelly showed me the way to
the Cour he read out of the paper that had brought
liquor in the house to Ann; this was during the last
trial; it in his back parlor his wife, and his two
sistersn. law were present.
The defence took exceptions to the evidence of con
yersasions between 0ksy ara tS Ind .aa tho,
had been in the house only two days. when had been
there month also that had brought liquor in the
BY DErrrcE.-l never brought liquor into the house,
but Ann did twice.
BY JuRoR-Did you and Ann quarrel
WIrNEss.-No, not that recollect have no i'll will
tow ards her she spoke to me in saucy manner in the
jury room the other day told her that she had no oS
casion speak bad to me offered to shake hands with
her. and she said she did not wish to keep company with
such common people, and then she went in the back
Alderman CRoLIus called and sworn.-I was at the
watch house the night of the rape presented Hat
field to the girl Ann that night she pointed out
Dinger first ithen asked her il she could point any
other individual who had also committed the outrage
upon her. who had injured her in other way what
after looking round she stated she could not
Hatfield then observes to me, says he Alderman can
go 2. told him. yes then reflected a moment and
said W ait !" then turned to her and asked
If she had any charge to make against this person be
let him go" she said no. but she had seen him sit
to Hatfield he might CO. Sa. hat he mr. ppssr in sse
morning. as he might be wanted az witness said this
by see
Roome, THAT had committed the outrage asked him
what was his other name and he said he did not know
Cross-eramined by prosecution girl Ann was un
der considerable excitement at this time in the watch
house.
EVENING Session.
At the reopening 1.-THE Court at half past o'clock the
defence called
ESocH E. CAMP one of the reporters eff the Herald, who
QuEsrIoN-Are you the reporter ofthe Herald
ANSWER am one of the reporters
Odd you report the trial of Dipgler1
Q--Is this the report you made7 (handng witness the
printed report as contained in the Herald)
Alt is copy ofthe report made on the trial
DISTRICT ATroRNEY-DO you intend to offer the whole
paper in evidence
By Ga.HAn-No, we do not but we wish to show BY
the report contained in the Herald that Ann Murphy
has contradcted herself in several material points on the
present trial.
TheDnrRIcr ArroRSEvst Still obecting unless all the
The defence. for the purpose of ending further argu
men agreed to take the notes OF Mr. Phillips one Of the
District Attorney assented portions then read
to show that the girl had the previous trial that
John, the accused the first that volated her. and
Dngler the second also that she had taken liquor
into the house of OKeIy, but that girl named Mary
Goodman who had lived in the house with her. had
ron the trial she testified that Dinger was the first that
violated her. and Underhl the accused, the second The
girl Mary Goodman also gave her testimony in the fore
noon and swore that Ann brosght the liquor into the
house herself, and that she did not.
The defence then called Mrs Ruth GRovESoR, who
sworn, and deposed as follows IL now reside at SO
Fulton street; had servant by the name of Ann ONei
she accosted in the street. and asked me If knew Of
any person who wanted servsnt; this a out the
nth Of August LAST she lived with about six weeks;
the end ofhe six weeks she turned out Of house
by the lady who owned the house, the name of that lady
Mrs. Shepherds she is not related to me; was not
present " hen the girl discharged; then lived in
Reade street. at l49; conscious OF tresng this