The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1843-07-19

Dr. seabury here repeatedly objected to the canddaei
answering, and he accordingly declined answering The
ing that il must be answered the final reply was in the
following words taken down by DR.. Anthem;
hos - a me question, which do not know
now 70 answer, out refer to my answer on the other
touching my opinion OF the DEGREES Of the Coun
Q-s. "Do YOU, 10 you not, receive the articles of
the Greed OF Plus Nv. ~
A" So lar they repetons Of the DEGREES of the
Council of Trent, receive them" These words were
taken down by DR.. Anthem.
Let us now see what was the effect of all this ON
the minds of the authors Of the statement II is thus
described by them:-
And here, may we be allowed few remarks as to thu
effect produced minds ministers of the Protest
That effect the confirmation strong and sure OF
previous impressions to his unsoundness and how
could it be otherwise He deemed the differences be-
tween and Rome such embraced points Of faith
doubted whether the Church of Rome or the Anglican
Church were the more pure-considcred the Reformation
from Rome unjustih BILE, and followed by grievous and
lamentabe results though not without others OF an OPP
posite not the Church OF Rome for read
ing the Apocryrha for proof of doctrine not cons
der that we were bound to receive the thrtynne art
ces Of Church in any close and rigid constr ucton OF
the that he knew not how to answer the
considered the Church Of Rome TO be in error in
matters OF faith Twas not prepared to the doc
rine OF uansubstantiation absurd Impossible doc
Urine and regardedit taught within the last hundred
years, as possibly meaning than mean by the
oL ne real presencedd not object to the no ISL
Of purgatory defined by the Council OF Trent
nus lar Tor the negatives for the alternatives He
that the state Of the SOUL after death one in
whch could be benefited by the prayers of the faithful
and the sacrifice Of the altarregarded the denial the
cup 70 me iaty as severe act Of discipline onlyjusti
he did not deny but would positively affirm the de-
crees Of the Council OF Trent another that he receiv
ed the articles of the Greed w so far as thew were
repetons of the DEGREES Of that council And what
were the explanations already alluded to- the record Of
which was deemed by presbyter so important and
which weighed, il with Our nd NJ
brethren against such Of evidence as that pre-
sented the examination, and here To our
apprehension they amounted virtually to nothing. In
suated passages from individual authorities quoted
the bearing Of which was, in our view questionable,
and which, even pertinent could never sustain the
ddate against the standards OF the Church NICE meta
physical, and cobweb distinctions" distinctions with.
out subteties in connexon with
the advice Of subtle poemicreiusal under advsement
to answer plain and Legitimate questions and the answer.
ing them, at last with ingenious and most guarded
serve Could these have awaited ought they to have
avaed against the direct and overwhelming evidence
in the case2 Were not borne out, them in protesting
against the ordination OF the candidate Fearessly do
we here appealto the memories and the hearts alike Of
the clergy and the lay who knew the Church in other
Croft and Bowen-whcn the banner lifted up, and
der which enlisted with all the ardor and energy of
youth and have since been found conendDg for the
truth-the banner of evangelical ruthapostoc order
whether such sentiments those expressed by the
didate were tolerated in, obtruded upon the
Church In our souls do believe that the distinct
avowal oone these and strange doctrines
Of which SO many were openly avowed by Mr. Carey,
would then have closed against an applicant every ave
nue. to the ministry.
The "Puseyite" controversy has now fairly COM
menced here Rejoinders must follow from the
Bishop and the other clergy, who consented to
Mr. Carey's ordination. protracted paper war will
then take place. The discussion will get into the
pulpit. The laity will become excited, and involv-
ed in the battle, and the fame of theological dispu-
tation Widespread tar and wide. The other churches
will, usual cast oil not on the troubled waters,'
but on the flames. Here the episcopal authority
does not possess that absolute supremacy that it
exercises in England, and consequently schism will
much sooner produce its fruits of open disunion and
reorganization. And here, in all probability, the
first decisive step will be taken towards the separa.
ton of the " Puseytes'' and the old light party.
In England, it is true, there are already some
striking indications of an approach to thisseparaton
Amongst them, we observe the following announce.
ment OF what is styled
"a plan girig The Clergy of England and Wales an
opportunity Of expressing their conviction the subject
ofthe Reformation"
ispreposed to obtain by private application one hun.
Dire clerical signatures in the diocese oil London,
hundred In the diocese of Chester and fifty in each Of the
other doceses, agreeing to express in emperaely
ded declaration firm adherence to the principles OF
the reformation, forth in articles embodied in
our ormuaries and developed in the writings Of
formers IRON Cranmer TO Hooker and to renew solemn
protest against the of Rome and all that tends
lead mems minds back TO the doctrines adred by the
formers When these 1900 signatures shall be obtained
is proposed that several clergymen from each do
cese if possible shall meet to draw up the declaration
which will not vary in substance from the above to have
to all other clergymen the kingdom inviting their sig
natures and by the result hope giving courage
and confidence to the friends ofthe Church she is
We will be much mistaken if we do not find before
long, much more decisive, and more openly avow.
ed determination on the part OF one or other of the
antagonist parties here, to dissolve their ecclesiasii
cal connection. Let us wait and see
We gave, on Monday, a synopsis OF the leading
doctrines OF the Puseyites, compiled from the Lon
don Spectator, and other authentic sources. We
have been furnished with large and valuable
package of articles and documents bearing on the
controversy, Of which we will make appropriate
use as occasion may require. The Squash" who
presides over the destinies of Henry Clay and
Charles Fourier, is, we perceive, too busy in recev-
ing the monies and ordering the affairs of the Syl
vana Association, to attend to this important re-
glous movement. Several of the other papers are
also unwilling at present to enter this subject.
We shall, however, as always, give the earliest and
most authentic intelligence in the of this ex-
citing controversy. To morrow we shall follow il
up by some interesting and important details.
IMPORTANT ADVICE TO THE LAplEs.-We have re-
ceived a very important communication, dedicated
especially to the ladies' We would be highly crimi-
nal indeed if we did not give it immediate insertion
in our columns. Hear, then We fair ones of Gotham,
the warning and exhortaton of our correspondent
one, by-the-by, who evidently speaks with autho-
rity":-
Mn. EpIroR-
SIN:
As you were always warm and sincere advocate for
the introduction Of the Croon water into city and
have urged the free OF by the nhabitsnts thuk
you deserve the respect OF liberal and enlightened
mind for old citizen return you thus publicly,
my grateful acknow Judgments As yet the inestimabe
benefit of the he appreciated but the time
is fast approaching when shall consider ii golden
mine such jewel as is possessed by other city in the
world
AS you have also always been q and enthusiastic
odmrer Of ladies' Ibeg leave to send you this