The Madisonian. [volume] (Washington City [i.e. Washington, D.C.]) 1837-1845, 1843-12-11

~
Jo0rpA a a aeWp n neesaits = II record Of Il
couatsJ, ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ - ~ - - assss
plish Ut 4klek ~ - - 49, Vifian1ia wiche
and AK ~ M ii&aA ~ EJA <&e Il ~ HIN = ~
to n ~ oAG ~ ~ 4 m aFaGn naaal
a OBSERVATION-DISCLOSURES 49, nnllnaea hueAh
frareN q - ssalnllen tgew - 3Allotitlns -
righAe 81 At4 - ~ ca n M,
cord ahsa y 49, past 81 ~ Ias1k -
why shaa sneaHn <Aseel
ject1 ~ N 4 &4aipl n 4 tak n
Jaarasi. kM r. ~ 49, - hiQtqey I
the sssnaspeksnanb . 1 - aAeaeasAe 800
cons ellGf ~ N ~ dles1bs - s1c6e
izatioa ef,lhe HQe, - 1Ssl tlIeti4, tef
to vinAiaats apIn ~ WhieA laA 49, &eaa1pd
The motiea n - snl,emas sknA 1oains womeA ~
sfy the JousHdH n should be aAsptsd, and - Aspe,
he would WAaharaV it.
MI. THOMk&ON, q Mlsaisaipp, saia - Va sGE
prised q To pessssssaBos Of the seDtAsnsu lto@
New York, ~. Daraard,) in esdssvoeing to fogo,
this paper upon tie Journal ~ Tor souhdIsap III
gument 4 wesA not Hume ia psah of poseessts, ~
cause it was isiss Y It, coaespsioa. y woud bew
der Posery nom re absurdlty " ~ docetiDes. ~
said member meAt move sAafshs MsE Tesfaneei
be spread upon ne Journal - y wes4 - ~ sheFs
unless inc yeas ana nays we're ofoersd. ne $40 -
cared NOT IS 'or inc ~paPeF' guy % 'ne pFe'
cedent would SCI ~ me iuIufe sesislasaon
Of the country he spoke earnestly and clio
quently in vindication OF the State which ne had
me honor % and earnestly insisted tnat ne
hid committed no fraud in voting for Speaker.
&c sdr HOi4ndn OF South Carolina rose ana A'd
2Anf he E0ah warn the mAlottIy Pct - 1Ne saea'
- daiemma which ~ ~
non aeaans (Aars ~ wese -
II adoPtsd-that Of exPuSgiuB from the Jour-
anticipation. de hoped magpenimots ma
15's"S woold mol place themselves Nd sDss disemma'
Mr. WELLER rose with view TO terminate the
debate, and moved the previous question.
Mr.. =. ). lNGERSOLL said, to remedy all diffi-
Gully ne moved TO lay the whole SUBJECT upon the
table
Mr., BARNARD demanded the yeas and nays.
Mr.. CObb, OF Georgia, rose and inquired OF the
Chair what would be the consequence if the motion
was ADOPTED!
The CHAIR replied the whole subject would be
laid upon the table,
Mr.. COBB inquired if the motion was adopted,
would the Protest remain upon the Journal'
Inc CHAlh replied IN Inc Affirmative
The Clerk proceeded to call the roll on the motion
of Mr.. C. J. INGERsoLL, to lay the whole subject
upon the table, and the folowingis the result-yea.
80, nays IS.
So the motion to lay on the table was lost.
The previous question was renewed by Mr.. VEL
LER.
MIR. DROMGOOLE hoped the gentleman would
withdraw the previous question, because it would
not meet the case and it was withdrawn.
Mr.WISE hoped that the resolution would be so mo
died to make it appear that, when the question
was raised by Mr.. Barnard the members of the House
mad not oesn sworn. lie did not read paper to the
House, but TO body which had not been organized
SO that he might vote understandngly.
Mr. BARNARD here made an EXPLANATION
Mr.. WISE continued, that it was a House organ
lied to elect a Speaker but not to decide upon the
constitutional qualifications of members. The gen.
tlemans Protest was as harmless as aUpcle Toby.
fly"
IA message from the Senate informing the House
thew had agreed Ia the Joint reso,,,;on IN ,e,,,;
the election of CHAPLAIN. ard had chosen one ,r
their part" &c., Gel
Mr. WISE continued. and in in tia co,,se IF hi.
remarks. read the certificate Of the e,ec ar
pr Il ew Hampshire (Mr. Hale and called The
2ten Mr. Barnard 10 the broad seal the S,.t.
Of New Hampshir,, with force and eloouence cha.
racteris'ic Of his well stored mini bav;,, .,f..,
Understanding of the subject he was discussing. He
objected to The proceeding of the member from New
York from the irregui,r m.rre, in ,yb;cb h h J.,
tie subject forward, and forced his Protest upon IN,
Journal in the ni,alory formation oflhe House md
foIe il had been consitutionally organized This wa,
the ground of his objection He believed the Conpr.s,
Of the U. States had the power to appoint the time
place, and manner of holding the elections bu, :,
this case it had not done so il merely reoured III,
States TO do that which Congress had moi done IT,
came into public life onnosed IN IN. od;,. 49,