The New York herald. [volume] (New York [N.Y.]) 1840-1920, 1842-09-28

and my object In seeing him ascertain il his evi
| the grand jury room was not introduced TO him, bu
called him on SIDE and asked him what he knew
| the book
Judge LYNcu said the question now presented differ
Ont aspect and he oncurred it'll the Recorder that thu
evidence was not admissible.
The Counsel for the accused requested the Court &
note their objections to this decision ofthe Court
q. by aJuRoR-Are you intimate terms with MIR
Verren So have you ever heard him use the words ASST
Al have been acquainted with him number o
years. never heard him those words never talked
with him in French heard him use prCfane or i'm
proper language; heard him more improper
language than is used by other cergymen.
The defence here rested.
| DR.. ALrRrp c. Posr called by the prosecution and
reside at No. Leroy Place, am native Of this
city, and have always resided here except two years
spent IN Europe, and two years Brooklyn. have been
aphysican and surgeon since 1927. am acquainted with
Dr. Granger by sight, and have frequently heard him
spoken of his reputation for truth and vcracity very
OATH
ro IN
OF him before the Spring OF 1885, One circumstance that
created this opinion of him. was his having presented
forged diploma to the Medical Society cannot mention
any other specific action Of his from my personal know
ledge.
Da. IIEsRy D. BuLxLEY called by the prosecution and
sworn- am practising ply stefan and surgeon in this
city, and have been FOL years past have heard Of
racy, and from that reputation would not believe him
under oath. Never had any dispute with him.
Crosseraminrd.l have heard Of his deceivng his pa
them Obtained nay information from his patients The
only one ! can mention is Mr.. Simeon Baldwin
a sne
sided at 555t Pearl street for FIVE years and al half
9. by BAnxEn-Do you know Peter Formel
o-What do people say about him
A-Nothing good
Odd you know him before he came to New York
ANo, never saw him except in the street, but once,
then he called at my house, and turned him out of
Q.-what is his reputation among people acquainted
Ali people think of him as DO they will not think
O. What do people say of him i.e.
ATMost Of them say he is a good for nothing fellow
Q.-What do they say about his speaking the truth
A.-They say he can speak nothing but lies
| under oath iN fu.i.f.n
Cresseraminsd BY MArwrLL.-wss DR.. Formed ever
called in to see your son when he was sick
A.-Three eminent doctors advised me to send my
to the South he was twenty EIGHT years Of age DR..
Formel called in and told to send him. he would
die at in two days. | called HIM charlatan and
turned him out of DOORS
Q Had you any animosity towards him Z
A.-None. had never seen him before except in the
street
Q.--Have you had luminosity against him snce1
A. never liked him because he came to play the
mountebank with me and extort money. have more
animosty against him than have against you.
You hear the doctors speak bad OF him. or other
people,
Q.-Give the names of the persons you have heard
speak bad Of him
Al don't recollect inames, bit can md plenty who
q, by JuHom-Did the persons on heard speak ofhim
speak Of his reputation as doctor or as man. for truth
and veracity7
A.-They say he is a witness bought upby Mr.. verren
Q.-How long since you heard that
A.-To-day and every day.
QWhen did you rsr hear his character for truth and
verscity spoken against -Ir.
A--At the time of the first law su-mcans the first
trial Of De BoulIion and the others.
Q-iow long since you first heard him SO spoken of
A,-When it was known that Formel was witness for
Cross-era,nined-Q.-Do you know De Boullion1
Ayes; he used to board with me- know Colon in
directly. Chabert has drank wine at my house.
O. by BARxER-What do you know ofDe Buollionl
Al believe him to be an honest man.
Q-What do other people say Of him?
A-Sone say he is honest say that he not and
some say he is more stupid than wicked would believe
THOMAS N. DnouALr, called by the prosecution and
sworn know Granger by the report Of the circle in
which he moves His general reputation for truth and
Crosseramined- heard of his cheating a widow that
lives in Greenwich street, don't remember her name
The Court took recess until half past o'clock p. NJ
The Court again assembled at half past O'Clock.
vALEsrrsn PrLrrrR called by the prosecution and
sworn have been in this city twenty one years and am
Frenchman by birth have known DR.. Granger about
FIVE he has got reputation at all for truth
vefacity I would not believe him under oath.
Cross-eramined-I am importer of French goods !;
never quarrelled with Dr. Granger on the contrary.
have felt friendly towards him read in the papers that
he had false diploma; like him like like mposcr
who wants to make money know De Boulion was ex.
amned at my house on the last trial, when was
sick; know Barthelmy by sight.
Disec resumed-Haye known Granger humber Of
he has given pills more than do good:
don't believe Dr. Granger associates with good sacsty
have heard he ali imposer and made money by
know from patients who have been nearly murdered by
him De Boullion thought gentleman, he paid his
landlord, came home at o'clock at night and was cons
dered gentleman.
To MsxwrlI-I believe what is in hep papers if ii is
Epw.Rp WIN. HosxI1s, called by the prosecution and
sworn-I have been resident Of this city for twenty
years Of the Editors Of the Courier Enquir-
er answe Granger general character for
truth and veracy as do not know sufficient OF his cha
rncter.
JoEL NELSON, called by the prosecution and sworn--I
have reside this city three years. teacher by pro-
fession, and Americans know Formel his character
bad from his general reputation would not believe
Crosseramined--Formel assistant teacher to me
Mr. "nd M speak him.
with me six nine months perhaps year; never
had any fault to find with him as to his duties but always
Mr. MAXWELL handed the witness paper which he said
In his handwriting. He then read the paper, which
recommends Formed a teacher of French, and
Of good moral character. Here portion Of the audience
disgrsc ell themselves by appauding and stsmpng]
CHAsLts CAsDs called by prosecution and sworn
was merely called TO give accumuative testimony, he
having been called to sustain the testimony Of De Bou
bon
The Court sustained the objection Of the Counsel Be-
vera witnesses called by the prosecution but did
nnswer The prosecution rested, reservng the hight 10
coll the absent witnesses at another time
NATHANIEL WsEp called by defence and sworn-Dr.
Granger has practised ply in my family; be-
leve his character TO he good.
CrosSeramined-I have formed my opinion from my in.
tercourse with him.
WIN. C. wElMoRE, called by the defence and sworn--
am lawyer, and have been in this city for twenty
years Granger has been my family ply stefan for six
seven years; believe him 70 sustain good character,
and cannot say ever heard his verscity doubted.
SIDNEY Wv more called by the defence and sworn--I
am Gus House storekeeper Dr. Granger ha, b. eu my
physician years. and he cured me Of the
sumption b. lieve his general character for truth and
veracity to be good. don't know that wss ever In
company where his character the subject Of
sation.
JONATHAN LIrrLr, called by the defence and swon-I
Granger for Eve years. he is my family physician; be-
leve his character is good, don't know that ever
heard his character discussed except as physc II
his character had been assailed think should
have heard l.. ts
Ur,av AIc.r called by the defence and sworn-I am