New-York daily tribune., 1842-09-05

aettba; Governor DoTr prevented by cteums,ances
beyond Ills eoaaol tro TO exercise The functions
State o. ma these aeIs inai which were a1d
tgntu az The uae fcaano for the reasoas assigned,
Il may however re said that in complying with the
80 section torrts aricie af the EGnsation Of Tie
unte5 STATES, Governor OF any Sale, wborn qE.
sun b. made. Is ca.y 70 irqare who Is he acting
Gerl7S a. IRE making sBrh rrduiSitioD. Tbs cs-
t, cssoupt H. such the notorious u-pser
sho should happen t. gel the eort !or t'pie 2i aHy
ta;e be recogsc by The Gosereors Of oter State,
lnd thus hey might cceae ils insuHeiss 10 aid 10 Ke
rnn bis vengeance agaist iinsr VINO ha1c tad 20 OPP
oos bis r7iio. and who have f ron tie Stale TOR
afeiy. aa ,hal among independent power' GOV.
-rnnsni de fgcso y recognized a e,etiHE ne mai
for the iirss -ipg This uriBclnc sc necessity al
tie case spd ground naot s ri:ht u de-
-dc Whether the lveruleIt OF 1uthfF not ont
opinion different rpie mus; apry 10 The states "hich
~ confederate republic Ti@ eIre theory OF our
yssr.sts t prncpi a;a'l authority ist be figani
an ,erivef ios Is peOpehr acknowledged se1Fee OF all
political 9ower. Ay Iret=D,lea Gosernmeti IN any cne
Stale derived tro, Ills source ft &oytrtheia at ah
,n canisos he reeonnzed either by The federal author;
des or tose III oer States The lanulnrSs or rlehdGineSs
f polca owerjB his country be separated from
ne existence OF such power. I be ghUl II doe not
exist So la b~ Constitution OF these United States
has required The authorities CT one STATE DO act 10 pur
nance Of rec,uiSt OK the authorities Of another State
mposeSu e former the duy Of deciding who are the
rirhtiu authorities ofcach State.
have further objections 10 compliance with your
qucst The provision in The Constitution Of the United
states regard requtnDs does not, in my opinion EN-.
guase Of tha. par OF the secoud section OF the ur article,
q the Constitution IS ps,sgn eg.a ,n a, %;
United Sta which had been defined in the last secon
of the preceding srt!ce-ahd felony and other crimes
means offences kown such common law and excludes
the idea Of pol.tca ofeIceS Would not the con-
sequence of applying this provisioa to political offences
have direct and inevitable tendency 10 involve one
State in the controversies of Should happen
faction any State, bv fraud or violence should
yet possession OF the Government in papable violation of
Cons tuition and should pass arbitrary laws making
enal and capital offence TO call IN question their au
!orityand should their opponents fire for refuge 10
neghboring State. and oCd requisition be made for
their surrender, would be proper 10 comply with such
requisiton and thus aid in carrying into effect the pur
poses OF such faction. thak unt We were near Wit
nessiag such STATE of things in Pennsylvania bu! rev
years since. And il NAV happen again whenever IN ths
country attempt shall he made TO sci al nought th
voice of The People consituonaly and lawfully expressed
suppose The minority in State becomes SO ex:sperateo
that in period of great excitement they pass laws
s.ain tie opposing party, who escape persecution fec
10 other Are they he surrendered upon requ-
,on and that upon Executive OF sovereign State IN
whose jurisdiction they have taken refuge Can this be te
meaning OF the Constitution OF this free Republc Can the
liberty of The American People rest upon ssch prlncpe
think not can give on countenance or suppor, TO any
such doctrine.
Ii canno, be that the supreme Executive OF State when
called upon exercise his authority 70 remove person
who is within his jurisdiction TO disregard the essential
principles ofcivl liberty That he not 10 inquire whether
be another Jurisdiction be punished
for actual crme or merely for bis opposition to The will of
dominant and successful party think il is not only his
right but his duty 10 inquire il is the first and highest
liberty, only in his jursdicon but in ether States
far he may be called upon do any official act that
may affect them or their people cannot tereore WIN
regard 10 the Constitution and the Law which purpose
crupuousy 10 observe surrender Gov Dorr upon your
requstion, for the purpose of ha~ng him taken to your
State for trial uponthe charges made against bn IdeepIy
regret the unhappy controversies which have for same tune
past existed in the State or Rhode Island and earnestly
hope that the time distan, when there shall be
restoration of entire tranquility and order among her peo-
Dated at Chariesown this 10Th day August A. D. 1872
HENRY HUBBARD,
Governor OF the State OF New Hampshire.