The Caledonian. [volume] (St. Johnsbury, Vt.) 1837-1867, 1842-02-15
8 D H. r G. III
OFTHE HON. CIIAlLEs mUnsuFJ
{ C0NCEuDE ~.

80 "a VI II
OFTHE HON. CHARLES mUDSuE
rooEGEUDHu.l
Tia geutielnurI from South Caruina Earned
thar ali protective duties were tax upuu a "a PEG
pie, he paid as a bounty he nlrusts,ns, srs.-
u has aszarred, agaIn ana again. ial CRISES witt
rise Just propurtion 20 the Ineruass uf ilrY ---
This. Mr. Speaker. IS tar from halns te ca Sol
FAR IS this from using truth, that lha opposite
is frequently true. There b.. { lansil uo
saiuta Ixad rue in this CASE VhaE Is trus of ore
arrIeis may not ba iruc OF anuIner. va bat can hn
shown 10 be the result a duty 30 ono uiHe- may
not TO produced 70 the same extent ut uI"tHer.--
Huca must depend upon lae supply lna demand
4 viii also be touud than small eLIclanEy n lla
supply viii raisslt PrreB of the ,gao lssanIlY
IN the marser lar ahove me whine ol lie dei-cit-
Aad.1 the ether lzud "a suFis. l..on1 ruii. Wa
reduce te prIcG tile whole coufIuusiilV ir eyu
the vutuG uf the snrui'lz. Il surplus WORTH 8i0001
would frequently produces ara ag=rruals -eauctloE
ia ti.e tIarttrt 20 tine lrnnuut oi $50 600. rims
7riuCipie Is 50 esssHrufI 90 tua lrltl larzraaIus
Of this subiGrt rhatI .raE shaft la Ca r1rsG 81
1ttempi u mere tuil iiIuatratuu- hFJii suppose
that there are tee shops In sins csrv- usrUa by
uluny IaliIviduaiz, ana that SIU0 rrr quarter q
fliE rent eaeii oi than. Blf Iaa nuu5er ut
deFE wishing OCCUPY tEoSa aaups 10 uuG acne.
tiIerehy :eayIng Z ssETnrs OF aanu. Now. sIr-
what viii be rhs praelisaI afaet 1f fAis state oi
lnngss Nine souz VvIii be oeelIplcE ,aIti
ae vnraut- The o,aHer 81 Iaa varazg aiIss. saetug
s1il his nefiIbnrs erioyire faruusi aF 7l00 DER
quarter. wnIla he rocsivgs lotufrw srsara
FOR $780, on ihG WISE prru11uis rlss to h1s 1uErsr
take rhul sum than uosllIng rlia oder .lduuns
one OF the Iraasrs vino p@Ysnz iU0. 10 ault i1z
shDp ne occupies. ana JaSa ana i,sE
SEC. This chance Iouvus aau1Hur sa0u utaptys
and lhis induces par aAG AZ $50 per
quarter; TINS induces au8tuuF rgrnuve, ana
a shop ut sue. Ana s1uv WA 10 liirassa vrItt
cac1 snuu. tliI ali ara nraEan1 $50 here
has heegl rs-iuErIou OF $40 sillsp. uai4az
an aggrugutn of Igg, heinz ist ee Hui to the vauo
of the surplus. And how standa he n1itci. nDEr
JVbv ,sIr there Is umpfv snop rs nf me hczru-
ming, and this same process uf rs1IctEun viii 90 on
It'll the urfre Is BrouaiIt down ioT rs 70 ruauGn
sumo person slahaEiz ruha- $780, unaer oti1eE
circumstances. would taIHE Z suEaEIug ~ TINS
sind OF business
This prlrrIuie vynIEz cvurvr frzEtlca man lsisl
ackaowtedgs, enters iaEgsiy iuin o1r- commerce.
both 0rufsn and dorae=tic. inns aii-.IaRaE-
tant bearing upon pri-ns. 1ssntug sang prIHuIpae
view, lat US inquire into EIct ui tzrifs
OFFICES suppose article Saw uaFtDG a aais
Of ~ per sun ccEali - par cent rluru
tdHty; acGoruIH tina grntieElitaa fsccErfne- ne
price 70 nsrccEE- rIuEtzcr 3ut Co
act-this witt NOT &c The sAa1erBran E1gr~
chanE- ~ 40 has "a llsI ga taxing isa ar
ficie OF On EufIs houae t 1ln1uut "a ss~4@1-
writes his Correspondent tsseGE t5rrfufp- lhaI
IN consequence af tire unruu4 OF uutv, nu can Sow
ra1a out 81 900. unirzz RRalEc4-EEE ggt'l So
d1ce lars prrcc. rle BrluAh manufacturer 4unvss
ing full thRt if $1,000 Sr1a "a ass i4aEIc be
thrown into ms hoIlzu lnari-uI vrlfi r~nuon ts
price uud lsssau taG yztrla li hs EnDEg sssGs on
hansi- Immediately rucuCEa il88pFlcs4 ana sup
plies his Old customer gEiin he azuG4 1uEutE1Y %
the article. Eha uulu-ut cd be rccacIi1H witt de-
pend upun tina of ina iEErizst- solEufIues lt
gyTii be ana gou8umEa less the uyeEgsl-
aernHps- would be h4l4 -lla lliz-aN'2 El.fst
The foreign manufacturer paving -luti 30 we
ndditiUuai duty, The actual dUky palu V tue iluur
vvuud be so per cent-iusEeun OF 4l4 sII as t1e
the iHcrezssn duIY would nEoteet TIE manufacturer
cifTzsus would embatk with yaukse Zuai ~
this specie ul Manufacture. This would pruuucs
composition ~ houIe. ANA tha Increased qiIUntEzv
of the fabric thrown into market. would have
atendeHEv produce suruius. ana IslIz vvuuIa
serve to keep down the price. Here would be
dOubia competition. Z competition between the tor
eigu ami domestic manufacturers ANA compeElou
hstwseH the duInsstIC manutactEsres tifeulseiVes--
Lie auEuEnt tendency Oh tuIs 1TOuid Dc 10 reuucG
prIcns Itz operation yvoGld be or Tess sud-
den. according the character OF the HlUuuactuEs
IL il a COSTLY l.lTu ct mHuut2cturs- or one
aci required great experieuce or skill, u wuuia
take longer to bring tins reduction aDouL Lux u
tha manufacture were OF SUCH nature as 20 re-
qtlirs but little capiIaI iitte sxperencethe COM
petition and consequent reduction WOULD De nors
iuureaiale- Alter mixing All allowances for due
uatiuns from varIouz eauaes4 las u down Is
geuerai princinie. whiCn with hold good tatae a
number sicCessIgH. isSt dHtes io0lziEIz
pruteetIun, If taeyfara IudIeotsIy iaAa 'Yii re-
duce pFleEa.
This only appears eylIieni from the atiire 81
the casa but sustained bv facts aisaH from tfEI-
ciuF documents Ehes facts viii present Tor tia
consideration OF the Houss.
TO- q