Richmond enquirer. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1815-1867, 1841-04-06
The NEW YORK CONTROVERSY.
rErnor sflrarc-ant III Niclmonl III.

|. source +; deep modification and re--et % US
The, lie Richmond Wig touch nothing, which !.
does not torn = pa:ig poison. We nad supposec-~r
mad hoped, ;i!at there any SUBJECT the world
IN which we Of the South NIGH: people
j, was this very CONTROVERSY with New YORK. Di-r
we i.av 2bou; The .emsd--Dite- caano, about the
right But whg should the part? spin. OF Virginia be
addressed :; al. upon this occasion "hv should any
attempt be made 70 draw the line bet@een the parties
IN Virginia en- is svb >c.' The Wing in evil hos!
made ieh: OF the ques,.on-sPoAe q the wrong We
hat sustained a. tTanscen6enal a5srdt:o7- and 81
ar proved se!: a't.sss 10 tie rights ': the South !:
goes irher-adoP;s the former sian, 81 The Ne"
York Correspondent, Q! tie National Intelligence
abou. Calhoun .sn-.nd IN i. yesterdays paPe.
SEEKS 10 throw upon the friends 81 the Inspection
law miserable iacous movement io- me bs1si; .:
Pres.tenii. candidate. Nor,iiy,ag as the Q:
the WIZ tins occasion absur! 8 a.s Is charges
The reasons upon which i builds up these sosPicons
and charges, are equally absurd and uaiounced. The
following extract from yesterdays Wing sets forth
rs idle charges and untoundec specifications
Fiat J9.iitlG- Gre the Dsrii has due.
..The SECOND No of the Southern Magazine. ar
able Monthly Revew published Al Petersburg Is The
Iessrs Ru:in. for February, (Which happens 10 have
ust fallen under observation, II review Of the
New York and Nir-in'a controversy. contains the
Seward, n. denring that the
rul,y persons were within the limits that State, ano
not ob efnr that tc srGerce ri tksir gst ras sHsn
cert tai ct-eG ~ Editors Hhig. refused . surren
Ger I..tsl. tifi.- ~ SeSstaHSS.
sons ior M refusal. The Magazine then quotes the
reasons from Gen Baylys report; which, and r'"d
ori 1t appears have consulted Tor the materials u
Is c-i,,cGe N57r. ,ha, Gov. Seward did no: otIec
that the evidence u tic'! guilt was insufficient IS $
far from being true. De the sery Of truth
We bare not atnanc hi correspondence with Leuie
nan; Governor Hopkins, but he repeats MS oTisHd
reasons Tor not sr-:ender'ng the three :ugves IN
communication 70 the New York Legislature OF harc'
18th, coun,ersgned by Samuel Batchfo:d his private
Secretary, and punished in the wing WITHIN week
We quote these oEglna reasons IN part from taat cocu
'men,:
r ~onid Re manife.y improper that ne fugitive saeaia ,
~ v,r,na under laws asain wne he has not offend
"a consequence q am the part q ~
a.h9'i.ts = sI ssae II fe2sinS . we y =.
f, rsn-e:frliy informed ,bz, Il reference 70 page.
heretofore h,m and his predecessors, VIII b
found nat before The rI9lsiioa io' he sai re'er -
~, F,i, - ms s,,: ,bo n,an. were by eorn,,eH
officer scarred from arrs: upon wii, Of aab-as
winch VII secured bs me Constitution 70 ever! ciike
y III Ear osnss r "5s ~, 4 y,rsia ans ~
Nm IN All r-G1.;on came befsre ta Executive Of hi
decided that the charge wa n fern defective
IL, Is thus manifest that Mr. Ruin Is IN
saving tina, Gov Seward did not objectio the suhcen
cy Of the evidence But as he made The General hi
guide we do no, wonder a. II. for that parsonage
wnoe study has been presen. only such views OF III
matter 9 would intaine iae South asas. !e y OF
Wings, and 70 keep back every v'er winch might hay
tendency 10 heal moi!l;y mitigate. wan Tue cough
" purpose Of creating modcaia o. party caPai iFot
Inc controversy. ne has applied ms we!ec lungs a.
the time blow up the dame ne has represented IA
offence as premedaied the su' q s'laiec inc fish.
of the South waatonly and Of malice afoFethoagh