Lincoln telegraph. [volume] (Bath, Me.) 1836-1846, 1841-10-28
J7The following concludes our long medical
controversy. " Sic tropsd,' &c.

GJ'The following concludes our long medical
controversy. Sic tronst,' &c.
ron THE TELEGRAPH.
Medical lia---Foison--
Death, etc.
Mn. EpIToHYour remarks at the close Of The last
nun cation If eRtanico Aledicrs mas lavd the gor-
dian knot the discussion brtween that writer his niles,
The part, aud myself alon rhe other, is now 10
iyyour edict, be have no tlams upon your
indulgence for further continuance Of the controversy,
but the sake Of brevity, win "look" al the
much talked If sweet spirits Ct Ate" Is there Is any
difference between the recipen given by BotaniCo Med
Gus" and the Irregular d0rcd' formula fr manufac
turing this article throughout the u States, from the "ra
Materials not this difference enough to show that his
views ae Chased upon daa" If obtain chem
cai product, finn rGD materials" certain quantity #
heat required in the process, does necessarily follow
the product "DIsTILLED compoupd IL the 'rau
rls" put together at the ordinary temperature Of the
atmosphere would The same chemical action take place Ii
not then the views Medicus this pnt are
CHASED erroneous data? win ccH water in Guan
promote sweat is 1t not from urge quantities only Of
this fluid and its ready absorption into the ccuaory
ment blood that sweat is promoted induced? so, is
Of otlnco aiedicus in this pect biased
upon datai Does net Nre Sa Petre) and the
SWEET spirits If Nitro promote sweat wiont copous dilu-
ton If So again the views Of "BOnnco Medcus based
upon crOneons data Does chilly sens alton come
US when taste ~: Without prff Hther than the
Of 'Boianc0 Medious" TO this effect, his
views upon tins point are based upon erroneous data" Is
it ergerani VI no says so What authority? None other
than ''Botanco Medcus'' shceihe Chemical Physiology
cal Pharmaceutical herapei teal authority? Until he
knows the difference between satisfied Compound" and
choa.ca c6dat0n shall so far "tramre upon his 'coM
MON sense, as o. u.Hs - oeo' - et'seiah powers IL
kick' hIc no.,'C ~ tntu'"s ~ ""'io'" fP0@
anu nt re-, his up? 80 ,o,;. -, .,, -, II, !,
u H.io ,i '', NV, niai a'u , sIow MS
elItieous uitL u" u'T nV"osa neh,nF pan. 20
I}nG" dass'' Hustt'> Ia" htPois pieJuuoa diDofy'
IL hui nave We i't ~ - Pt, 'ot no a "oS
i4ohala in doses, until he died Was Loyeu ''n
r last Stages uisedse, anu hau ne 1eeh a'uuea ana
aball 5.d u! me oeIoie 4hoisoh was sent
iof''! where's ulc PROV istnc mff say So VI boGHn,
1edcus prog positive when facts are wanted' Had
Thomson "a ellC 10 ioNe "9uiu II MOI naVa
been tonslnsIeo sS % uedt ny P0tS" l lact oi me
po SON ana Ge POISONING was Pooe0, lhcohu"efupy
prord but honson was acquueo upon the ground, ana
the ground oy tli nc u" i as.t0I' as am ntehoadag
beforehand tic dedh Of Ezra Lovett his Is prof
from the ta1 htpoits ttsffeuto anu "pud seem mucn
htue Tor 8Ct1hie9 u consult 'ila. autuott ana
deny mi he can, than 70 cam on inc po"i OF facts oy
s'wndy contradiction Nheiesuie eJ'PHyls "ahleo!
II pr0red before jury OF good men and true, that
ovett died from poison and that that poison was Lobea,
administered by the advice ana directions u thomson
his stands as PROM according 10 WIS HasSachqsels La~
Reports, vol T. page l3i, CuinmohWealth U. lnomson
Gainsay It with prOf but not assertion, nor long Para
graph upon the crciiiNon Ct 'our shyOm'!
Did not quote from altht MY techs Medical Jnnspu'
been killed from eating this plani is 1t not poison? What
says the L. :. Dspensatory which botanlco Medicus
patesn much about! It's effects IN doses too large
frequently repeated, extreme prosraton, great
anxiety and Distress and ultimately death preceded bycon
vusonsn zee last edition, p. 4l3 Is from the doses
TOO FREQUENTLY repeated which renders this plant poison
GUST Was not from doses too frequently repeated to EZ
Lovett which caused his death Dr fully Of Yale Co
The U. s Army, may have given in large doses with
perfect SAFETY. But did either Of them ever give IN doses
700 Jreqgenty REPEATED nty may nave lisen iSe'
IN, thet are moi IGNORANT nreenders nor consmmate
enprcs-thereby hangs a tale, which If should tell,