Lynchburg Virginian. [volume] (Lynchburg [Va.]) 1829-185?, 1833-01-03
ITO IN. Goverpmen, ofbis own State in support Of


this position he referred 10 letter from General
washington, portion Of which he read. lie then
went INTO an examination OF the relation which an
individual! bears 70 his own State Government, aud
appsd his conclusions 10 the relations susiainedey
the States to the Fcdei al Government and insisted
urop the correctness OF the Application 10 the pres
| ent question between the State aud that Govern
ment lie denied that the States had any rfsh, m
onpostion 10 the Federal Government, other than
| The vigh ofrebrilton. He applied the individual
right of Benedict Arnold, when he betrayed and
fed his country TO illustrate the right oil State 10
| res Isl oppression seas rebcHlon. lie sad that
the States when they entered iflo the compact,
| bound themselves TO obey the laws 81 me hheo
| States psssed III pursuance oi Tho 3onsFia1io'--
and thai they had 40 more reh, Ia Iudgeond drleF-
mine the oo.aitufiaaaihp Of the iaY.s Nlan M M
div dual has 10 determine aron tr eonsntatenal'y
! Of State law.
| IN REGARD To the consequence dedHced by the
Repon from the doetrne oi secession. lac of course,
could not coincide lie doubted whether t'sasoH
could be committed against state At a'L lie did
| not think that such offence could be committed
against the United States. lie defended the Pies
| dss,i from the attack made ~ the Report As he
considered He thought that the President had
acted correctly in the emergency nnd that the prih
e,ples upon which h. acted, were correct and con-
sti,utionnl lie rnid ho should not be deferred nom
the expression of his opinions, from fear oil the
charge OF Federalism lie knew that he should be
denounced as a Fodcralis while The Ofd Hffoi 10y
the same men, would he clappcd upon the back,
and called Republicans lie would leuye such
gentlemen to explain the reasons OF such ae6ursc
/, was eloar that If these resolutions were adopt
ed. South Carolina would lnfcr that We are p,c
pafedfo sustain her, ifsbe would only pui The word
min oil of AujtfBrUiIp1. l.
! Sir, THIS was ~ ident--an1 the two words meant
the sainc Thug lie adycrted 10 the time aud rir
cinsstancos under which were called upon to
adopt these ineasurcshe shld II Indicated dcttt-
mutation to tal.e sides with South tarollnn- lie
sad TINT thus House might do rs II plcased--that
fhey cannot carry the people OF thus State Will
them IN adopting these Resolutions. Sin the mo
mcni Dat the Star Spnnecd Banner, Is raise.5 tF-
cay hill, wood mountain AMI valley Wit shout ia
one voice, and tuilyius a9aoi = VII bear II We
toroasy against the treason contemplated againsI
the Federal Government.
In conclusion, hc pressed the NECESSITY Of utlclt-
ing tn substitute offered
HI. vote hsn. taken, stood Ayes, 50 Noea 81
Sothli The sub iituto was adapted.
Nj, Brodiax rose aud and, thai BE- presumed the
whole Of the Debate WIS out sfoidrr. 1t was al
ways allowed Committee 10 petie1t rs basin' -
Ian, amendments OF Substitute were offered. This
WINS the rule So far as ms experience extended
But IN this ense, the House had departed from thr
rule.
| A dcsutory debate arose, IN which Messrs
Banks, DHde, Watcher and Moore took pafi, ON lhr
question ns In the poprleiy oldlsems ng the merits
Of the original Report, on motion 10 rinend sub
stiiuie offered to that Report
On the question, viii the Committee adopt The
subAtituto as nmenied. the vote stood-Ayes, -,
Noes I'll So that the substitute, as nmepdeo, Was
rejected aud the question recurring ON the original
Repor
Mr Rrodnax moved an amcndiaeni,o the fourth
Resolution Of The Commtec, TO VII. hctwecn the
words are unconstitutional insolt " believed
by large majoriiy Of the People OF Virginia It
he =
Mr. Camrbe0 nlAyad That the worl large i,
thc amendment be stricken out.
Alr BrodnnA objected to the amendment was
a mere matter ofopinion, and each member woul,
vote aecording 10 his Union of the fact stated.
Mr. Campb 4 repl.ld, aud The vote being takcn
the amendment II Mr. was lo4i
Mr. Gmef opposed tie Anlan1mcnt offered ty
Mr. Bolunx, and assigned his r,asons for SO do
+ ing lie thought that w should not undertake t,
express a matter Of tipt. OF winch hrto might 10
some doubt.
MI Broduax replied and thought It imrortan
that the amendment slIouidlr adopted. We spul
US The representatives, of the Pcoplc.--We COM
changed with lheu wishes and opinions, and 1t j
our duty 50 express them
The amendment vas last, II voting in the a,lit
NATIVE.
Nj Jorcs, 81 York, moved the following amend
i meni-bctwcon the words "aie coNfJatB2 IN III
g Iin Resolution, lnsclt-=7 3ir,otlV'-ozi
Mr. Brodnax moved other antendmcnts To llv III
and elh resolutions wh.eh being chiefly OF vel Ga
dalnre it Is useless To designate
- Nj Wilson moycd th.t the Committee now rise
rerott progress. and asi. leave to SIT asaiagytee
e ite.
II On motion Of NJ, sherfarj, the House adj jourr
ed iill Monday, IL O'Clock.
If
Il From tte g. } 'p',,t 80