Daily Richmond Whig. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1828-1831, 1831-02-11

House. -.
Mr. CurLroS was opposed TO the motion. Tie
bill was done with for tins session, by the consent
both its friends and enemies, and no in favor #
letting the report sleep with the bill. The report
contained an exparte argument on the subJec,
which Mr.. c. did not wish to send among the Pcopel
with even this indirect sanction OF tho House. Th
country now in state of excitement, and ever.
member ought to be willing to allay that exctemen
instead of sending forth what would tend to ncrcas,
it, However untenable the argument OF the report
argument fallacious that any school boy couli
answer 1.-THE order to print extra number wouli
give To it some degree of importance. The repor
was presumed to be the production OF an individual
of the Committee of Manufactures and if the prac.
tice to prevail IL would become an easy matter
for any member Of the House To have his opinions
sent forth with this sanction. however obnoxious
they might be 10 the OF the House. II gentle
men desired 10 distribute copies OF the report. Let
them do it at thti- expense, not ut That of the
House
Mr. WILLIAMS moved to lay the motion for prin-
ting the table
Mr MALLARY requested that Mr. w would with.
draw the motion, to give him opportunity of re-
plying to Mr. Chton's REMARKS; but Mr. w declined
! yielding to the request.
The question was thon put on laying this motion
on the table, and was decided by Yeas ana Nays in
| the negative, follows:
Yeas 80; Nays 100.
| The report was then ordered to be printed.
| Mr. Craig asked leave TO submit resolution pro.
posing that the House should meet at o'clock in
! House refused the leave.
Mr.. Craig then moved that the rule be suspcn
dcd for the present. This motion was also mega
! lived.
SuuPLUs REVENUE.
/ The motion submitted some days since by Mr.
JARVIS To print goo additional copies OF the report
Of the Select Commute appointed OH 50 much OF The
! Presidents Message relates To the Surplus RryA
nue. ofthe Government, again taken up foi consl
derati0n.
| Mr. REED demanded the Yeas and Nays on ;h
! question of adopting the rcsOlutlon and they were
ordered by the House.
! Mr.. VANCE moved 10 lay the motion on the ;ahi,
And on this motion Mr. lGAMMnNs dcmauJed IN
Yeas and Nays. and they were ordered.
Mr.. VANCE then 20 save time and trouhl', til
drew his motion to lay the rGsoaton The table
luton, it was determined in the affirmative as fUl
lows:
Yeas-Mcssrs Alexander, Allen, Aston. Anier
son, Angel, J. :. barbour, Barmwei Baylor, B."
Jas Bar, Bo,kec Bors, BoulJ.n, Brodead Buch
anan, Cahoon, Cambreleng, Campbell Carson
Chandler, Guilds. Claiborne, Clay, Coke, Conner
Crocheron, DGvenpost, w. Il. Dvais. De WIT
Dickinson, dayton, Duncan, EARL, Finch. Ford
Foster, Fry, Gather, Gordon, Green. Hail. Uasev
llammnns, Haynes, Hcmphill. Kinds, Holland Ilnif
man, Hubbard, Jarvis, Richard NJ Johnson, Perkins
King, Adam King, Lamar. Lea, Lcavitt, Lccom9ie
Lent, Lewis, Loyal, l.umpkin, Magee. Mallarv
MARI Thomas Maxwell. McCoy, McDufiie ncln
tire, Mitchell, Mcneil. Nuckos, Ovrrton, Patton
Petts, Polk, Potter. Powers, Ramsay, Rcncher
Roane Sanford. VIM. b. ShcG ard, Aug. III. Shep
perd, Shields, Spcight, Stevens. Taliafa.To, Vile
Thompson, Trezvagt, Tucker, Verplaack, Wayne
/ Weeks, Campbell p. Whi:c, Wilde, Nanccy-o9
/ Nays-Messrs. Armstrong, Arnold, Bailey, II YES
BnTher Barrngcr, BARLEY, Bates, Bceklnon, Joh
Couner tBu,man, Chiffon, CPRakyGGttt CrePn
ton, Crowninsbicld, John Davis pe6erry, Denny
,, Doddrdge, Dwight, Eager, Joshua Evans Horac
, Everett, Forward, Grennell, Hodges, Hughes. Hunt
Huntingdon, Ibrie, Ingrrsoll, Thomas Irwin, VII
liam W. Irvln, Johns, Kendall, Kennon, Kiucaid
AIartndale, Lewis Maxwell. McCreery, Mercei
@G MGasafg es6ee s I 6eea sn ca
Strawberry. 5 andefer, Sterig,re VIM l.. S.nrrs
Strong, Sutherland, Swami. Swift. Tayior, Tcs
John Thomson Tracy, Vance, Varnn,n, Vlntor
Washington, Whit lesGy, Edward d. Waite, vii
ians, Wilson, Wmgn,e- TouBg-79.
The resolutions h0refore sIOmtted by liessrs
Drayton and Ellsworth, calling upon the s5ecretar,
of War for certain information. were cun ,ldrcj ana
| agreed 20.
! TIE JUDICIARY REpoRTy
The House having taken up the resolution submit,
| ted some days ago by Dir White of New N,rk II
print 5000 additional copies of he rcpor, of the Com
mntcc on the Judiciary in favour OF repeating tn.
18th section of tho Judiciary Act of 1880 toGe,he,
with the Counter Report Of the minority OF the com
m!itee-
Mr. BUcuANAN said it might be supposed that h,
felt some interest in the of this motion but
really he felt The question on III. reDeal OF
the 25th section had been settled by The House
settled 10 Mr. BIS entire satisfaction Tins Iac;s,o,
/
purpose 1t could answer TO send the two argument.
OF the Committee tagging after it through the coun
Try. lie was therefore opposed to prlntin: any adj
dItinnal copies.
| Mr. HAY%Es of Georgia, was in favor Of prin,in,
the extra copies. The report OF the committee CON
tanned fair exposition OF the unconstitutiona,v OF
:he 18th section; and as there hnd been no opp,r:u
NIFTY for discussion OF the SUBJECT lh. House he
wished the argument of the committee to be exinn-
slyc!y disseminated No man. Mr. r.. said was moro
attached to the union OF the states than himself but
he did not consider the proposition TO repeal the
ton as any attack on the Uuon on the contrary.
beng satisfied that the section itself unconsi-
tioDal, he was In favor OF its repeal and wished the
argument OF the COMMITTEES printed for the nfJrml
ton Of the people,
MIR Chiffon moved that the motion be laid on tbc
table; but withdrew his motion at the request OF
several gentlemen.
Mr. DoDDHrDGE, Of Va. remarked that much had
been sald and many illusions had been made TO a n
expression OF his. on former OCCASION thst Inc con-
sdcred The proposition to repeal tho 2jth section OF
the Judiciary Act equivalent to n motion tn dis
snvo tho Union. Such said Mr. D is my opnion
II IS my opinion repeated Mr ID. aud hope no anerv
feelings will be produced bV INV nvo,viu,, =, Al