Richmond enquirer. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1815-1867, 1831-10-18


end exeuv-y Tor the purpose OF sHordiog protector
He sou d not eyre" wi h he gentleman from Gao
ns at The atni scn OF h. power Of protection thu,
limited and re,'rs'~d could be II her drsIow or fa
10 esust; the contrary, eoud 'he 'oc roe as
serted ty The report p.vsr ~oo'de tell ARD com
plste triumph r." sdvoc''.' OF cs's's
b., saia Judge Shooter, " bs' hteu truly ADD peri
n,nuv remarked by the Venerable X pi~mao hcu
New Yort, on, Gal. In that 'bo per 81 me re
Thai n matter as th-te,o aud th.,eby se, tJr end
p,cmuis s,.d wa. or Wa. N, op'hi,n Ct ni' Con-
p,cn, u only given At 'hs o. nion OF "a large
snd tespe siAt,s roron OF the Am rean people" Now
VITO was 10 de rids, who could decide whhocr that
psfcu Of The American people o when aiiu len was
made. did Ia i,s,tod ,b' opinion Of hs gentleman
hoD A'sSana tho gentlem n trcm Carolina VI Tue
= port 81 The somu,t"e-t Ubi..s or ihe o'lsr o
those gentlemen bad es,,er aud mere extensive mean.
Of knowing tho orioicn Of TIL: large aud re'pes',h''
portion Of the Anne al people, hsn IN, cemDt'et
eonsis ipk Of two delegates from each OF fourteen
a,er, and en-, delegate from another, h wou'j OBJ
vieu'iy moi be proper r.jee, The opinion Of n, rom
nit.e. and adcp, thu, Of ii her ms gen'emsn from
Alabama. 81 the gentleman from S'u'h Carol no.
Judge Shorter raid he W 'uid Los cue into an a'eu-
and collect du'ies by way OF rro,.e,iop-su'h arsu-
mso's would no, suit he ocession. ard h d been
s'ujousiy avoided all sidsf. Tie convention. be
said, composed Of members from various pa's oil the
Union ard those emb,rs very naturally entsrtsu-d
dHrsu' views upon some Of The qu,s'ons tv''ved 10
The res'ris,ve system Tbey had all however assem-
wss prePoteIou' TO sxpee, that report would or could
bs made prsciseiy to sui d f. nxsGf rv.iy member
For him'siL he hsd eoi,rsd npSn hs hu.ine's OF The
Csnvsoon with every disposition u eoneliae the s,
tuGs OF ALL believing all 20 be !ris pds Could BE bev
born grai6sd 10 having his own way, he wouli have
bad The shsrac'sr OF the report changed, 80 az cx
pisity decls.s tho eIistng Tariff. in ths opinion o.
the Cocventioc. 10 be uDccnsii u,iopai. He would
have done hs sush was his bonsIt and ceIiber
etc ePDiors spd also the cpoion Il ibose whom
had tho honor 10 part 10 r.pieseni But he had seen
that Cf able snd wsrh tel nds ON The North
ern AID Eas,ern Ss,e', were OF a dfrsu' opinion. anc
dspteeA,sd most -stn~siy such course; he bad there
fore met them halt way a-d he'd been content ha, III.
Ispor should 4psss tho cPinion OF Tho South. with
BIT enumeration If the reason. by whish they sustain
&C that cp MIN
There remaining suggestion, said Judge Snort.
or. that would shew tho improperly of adopting the
amendment proposed by the gentlemen from s. Carolina
or even discussing further friends of the North
and Eastern States have abs aimed from any reply
TO-, argument against the opiuon OF the people from
the South contained in the report and they In
duced TO this course by belief that the members from
tho South would not their pat provoke discussion
The amendment proposed by the gentleman from Sou h
upon which members of this convention entertain
different opinions As the amendment could be produce
two OF no good and might perhaps excite unpleasant
feelings and destroy that harmony which had thus far
prevailed in he hoped most earnestly
that il would not be further pressed.
MIR. Waters OF Alabama. was prepared to take the
Address as came from the hands of the commtee out
OF regard to IN, compromise which had been entered
in,o but he disposed 10 admit the power Of Con-
gress to make such arrangement OF imposts to al
ford moro protection to some branches Of industry than
to others.
Mr.. Stockton of New Jersey, rose he said with un-
fsgnod reluctance But if gentlemen persisted in their
they wished 10 avoid They had come together from
diff rent parts to devise means for removing a great
evil under which the country Was suffering; and they
were Perpiexed with opinions constitutional ques
ton. He not prepared 10 decide that question, and
would express no opinion on it, He had come for dill
fercDt purpose.
amend His object wa' TO screen The addts, from tn
severe siei"n this passage ucult meet. He Md >
personally fulfilled his duty. Ths motion ss accord
fugiy Withdrawn.
Mr.. Ssdswisk Of Maraehu,si,s, wa, cot surp i.,c
81 ibs soieiinde 10 take the question s. haut debate
~as not 10 bs wondered a.. H. was no. ipdssreri in
sdtresos he House. lie MOI behind any xenii, .
man ~ gsU-sous 'ympshy fvp 'h- -oy bern poope: but
n'o'neteio COMM ted most unhappy 'ndisereton. The
opinion IN rein reisrrsd TO, prevs.d in ,ho spu,t but
no' IN Mas-sehuseits. I tsks a higher srouon, ssis
Mr. 'dgwisk, ihso iairpg ment of mar. charter in
my ePPo"ion 10 the 's,H ,y'tem: and | am "n+i IN.
tossrd such hfehrapd among the people. IT,, ts,,a
10 unlus' oPpre s'ive.n abuse CT power An aSu,, nj
what powef An acuss OF greater power than tina,
eonefrsd 90 the representative by his con.,i'u-n.
wr an abuse OF The power conferred on mao BY God
W you io'eTPos- your sbari-r made forty y.ars ago
10 preference 20 The ssnai rule OF rigb, si4bI. 81 by
ihs C'saiof Fy ,osr. age. The principal Ct Tree tad,
was Unknown. Adam Sal then rose az a sun 10 H.
iuninaie the word. When your charter wss fortncd
oil vas monopoly. Many gentlemen had found T. i'm.
p's'ibis % get the arxum- Mt, iu Mr. Ads ca
speech in i79s, in defence # ,hs sou..uop al DOVE
Of Congress to project manufacturer Ons OF The 81,
acts OF the General GoveSnnsn for the protection
- "a
tell the people thai wis, the he en- do
log ever since lis found tio0 hs. had DO power 10
The peopie OF The session, OF the cnunty from hcb
come, W u not uDdersand y,u BIT apps al 10 h.ir pa
I'VE 'Hn's Of jus Ice, and you will DO Lssrd. HAv.os
then hrs sure ground 10 upon wi YOU oii.c, TO
iHlH 'y'ien merely beciu,e "ii not i'm In. bono'
Address iben ~ o hsr IAusu.gs Say TO them, .'Net
IND bro hreD We are d-'ssnded from a mon pat.n.
"gs let oa not sbed each ohsrs blood. L.. u, be ius
a"d sonsii!i"s to one another" Tneir native sense
ot jusi'e will resPood your own 70 elm a. and YOU,
l-st vii be accom- pisbtd.
M'. Ssdgwiek though, here seen ed a ds.irH 4,
some 70 got rid OF ihe sys EN- great bas,e He
besRed them 10 coliec the progress that bad been
made in various countries in getting rid of ,ho tyan
moh imposes, sinse Tho tns when IL was tss,lArIy
established by Co ber IN France. Great part OF tbn
mosos.s re guAii,n' I'D ia tna country been anpuI-
ted And was TO be supposed that Re form in England
would stop Short wi a aanss In the mod, nj ,.oe.,.n
'shon IN PsriDen' Are thDgs re- u iher,I Arc the
sOfD law. which 80 nd macy houssns supo.tIr,, o
bed to con inue In force! N, they must fall and the
suoek WI De 'eii In bic ctuDry. Then what grsa
Poot will be gained by tho friend, Of free trade.
But Jour ara troubling ibo psopie with A bug,i,d|
qarsnoh-a qnes Ion on which the gfes, son.i iona
"yefs ere DIVIDED 10 mat Te,pests the Address Is
sxesa my detes'ive' You oush, 10 have had more
IegHd 'os me sympa,hies II mor. You ought @ have
iold h ~ that you do not mem 10 de,t;oy ,h.m AT
biow You should have told them you ars no, Al wa,
win manufssiurss Manufacturer are Inc eaD,e NJ
shi 'za''op.-From what 10 now done, ws 20 home
pswsIiess. - ~
Mr. s. said, gentlemen must not feel unkind,v n
ward, bin Tor What he had sad.-Hs was The d,yo,ed
hebd 81 Tree trade Il they should forsbIy sxpsl him
from he Convention, and shut their doors on bin, he
wooo si remain The friend ofres trade but be could
not sPPyove t tbS addrey
Mr. Bsrrisn though, Mr. 'dsvek's sp.,.h was
u'Ps,uie ron ne sonshIpory course OF The gentle.
"su rom Nsw York MIR. 5. had gone into hi, rsa.
,ou' Tor not yoipg Tor The Address. He hoped The
Een,ismen woo houghi az he (Mr } ibougb' would
not mitae the exam pie OF Tho ssn,eman Go,, a..