Constitutional Whig. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1824-1832, 1830-01-09

Nf a..
.on'in"da' IN his opinions to- circunsisn, U-h,
IL convention IN, t. thai gcn,lcman was enir,r fr
popaialon; now ne seemed only tIesiruu. =,
protecting the slave-hoiGer, -
, Mr.. Gordon nitogctfer disclaimed npI -ra..
c n"p"' mon cf ID" gentleman from Tuzewou y,
Heorse) which lie chorg cd to be unjust His n,;,I
au S,oueIs9ne no change. Ho had sustained wS;to
pop"iati,h while !here was possibility of ue,, i,,n
~ ne s1hithoueht 1t The true and proper basis re
oiu not pretend to poss the capucity of
'he Hshs ais cnsslon had thrown upon the ,,Ics,i,S
-o' Persfstns IN given course, with dtpved ots,
Macy but IN regard to his conss, ency he I'D ,It
sang stood out against the federal basis of the S
nte' and # he had himself suey ested schspsa mn,
iunced On The white basis he had doue it In
sp'r OF peace and cancellation, and not because be
had reinqiiis!ed his principles. His withers -,
"m~ n lie did not fet the gibe of Tie GENTLE
the snr u lanHwel, though ho might be paiSed by
ar. Campbell Of Brooke, spoke briefly n,nn., ,s,
nlent. .rt ees. IN, :. >-e-A..uuie apPortfoh-
| MIR. Randolph said he should vote for ~. ..;.
resolution, becauscit provided for future nnnor,;n
ment ans,ng The great divisions, without dsturbing
ths prlncipie OF compromise agreed upon Ay tho I'VE
sides Of the House. He denied the tendencr ~,
the resolution to perpeiuate what had becn d.nss u
rpetuaiIon which he as little desired to see IA ms,
! otner;;-ihe great counties of Caroline Chea,,sl.
,e:" southampton, not mention 9th
ers, were placed to Loidoun in regard to now.
or, as one 20 three-a n.onstrpus Injustice wI,cE 10
uiu not asslre 10 perpriuate. lie uttered pbno;c
agansl me csnnty Of Loudaun for being the ofls
one which had voice for John Adams as, d NJ
Jefferson, and another against the new Gons,;tr,;o
Which he undervalued above measure remurk;n ,f,
OF 1t he would not say as father Paul said Of The f.
stitution of Venice perDefua-b ut h.. ,,,n,,, -
that II might have the shortest of all nossbi 10y
ar. lo'gh sud he was mistaken in sa ying tina, tbs
substitute was The same proposition foTma,ly -
isleu oy the gentleman from Patrick (Mr Stuart,
lie should have said that Of the gentleman from, Pit
mond Mr.. Ncale.) ~ 'sfSh-
Mr. Ncale expressed his surprize at the s,,t.
m 1 OF he neman from Chesie rfed (Mr Leigh
nnnf fanf,,~. e
tween his plan ard that offered I'', -"
Mr' MaSsie SAID, that Us reference had been u,ad.r
To the Course of the Ahemarle Di trict and 20 c;a
ges of opinion, he would explain the vote be la,
give IN favor of the original resolution o,I : lu
the substitute. In his add ess to his cous,i,uen, ~
had expressed Varions sentiments but pven but ona-
lPieAge-whirh waste use his best cxertions IN ,rs
tect the East from excessive taxatior = f-SS'H
An animated and acsuliorv debate eus,ed h..
AessrS' hiercer Stonard, Randolph, Georoe. CO..
ao.. ana summers which onr limits would not per.
mt us 10 detail II we were possessed of he
doit In the progress of it, Mr. Cookies ree,I,,
WAS ably sus aired by MIR. Stanard and stor. LII
msh was fought between Mr.. Randolph and NJ
Merccr-he latter Urging he impropriev and -,
evancy of the attack made by Mr. Randainh -,
the politics of Loudoun, and defending her cla;n,s -
the representation given her in the no,.- Con.,;,
o'har ,a.er insisting upon The usrice done "a
o:her counties, and especially, Caroline Snots,,,s
ma Chesterfield and Ei'.v,idde to crafty ~,
Nun IN The House Of Deseea,e,.,
ne wGuin no; instance his own county of Charlotte
'hough reputation, taxation and productive ,ve.i,t
considered fiagran in Justice was done tha, co,iIr.
In assigning her Int one representatives
| The question was then taken on the adoptio, oe
The substitute and i was rejected by the faloynn
VOTE q 'l'''-9 -io"oe
ATEs-Messrs Anderson, CofTinan Harrison vy;r.
hanson, al Coy, Moore, Bcirnc, emth Miller Ra--
Mason, Naylor, Donaldson Boyd, Georye. M,Si;lla"
! q Campbe Byars, Cloyd. Chapman. Motbe'vs ~
glesby Duncan, Laidley, Summers See, Doddridse.
| Cabcll S.uart--38. 'ss
NoEs-M essrs p P. Barbour, Jones' r W, re;oh
> iayior' GILES, Brodnax. Gromgoo:e, AIexnn5rr'
1oode J; sTshail' Tyler Nicholas, Cloptoi,, Bald.
win, }. Y Mason, Trezvant, Claiborne Ureaka :,
/ randolph, w Leigh, Logan, Venuble, Msdson'
Stanard, Holiday, Henderson, Griags. PsndIs,e-'
hoane, W. r, Taylor Morris, Garnet, j. S. Bar,
Prentis, Grigsby, w Campbell Branch q1on,aa,'
Martin, Stuart, Peasants, Gordon Thomson No.
sic, Bates, Neale, Rose, Coalter, Joynes, bavy IT,,
MIR. Poell now moved to subs .itufe thu resn,,,-
ton, by giving the Legislature the power of reonrnr
tlon'ng inc representative power according TO ;us,
10 IN the year 1872 and every ten years thereafter
which was negutived by the following vote. ''''
AfES-Messrs. Anderson, CofTnap XyiIIans
BALDWIN, MC"y' Moore, Berne, Smith, KILLER Rax,cr
G eMznmsn henderson, s,, Osborne, Cooke. PaweR
Griggs, j. NJ Mason, Nayloi, Donaldson, Isoyd per
die'on George, MM'an, E.Campbcli, BY ars Ctovd
Chapman Mathews, ogiesby, Duncan, LajdIey, sum.
mers See, Doddridge, Morgan, A. Campbell. Jyilspn
Saunders Stuart, Upfshur - ~ ''of"
NOBS-Sessrs. p. u. Barbour, Jones' o. W. Leigh
;. Taylor, Giles, Brodnax, Dromgooie AIexander'
eoode J. Marshall, Tyler, Nicholas Clopton Harrison
j; y Maso Trezvani, Claiborne Urq,ari, RandoInh'
w; Leigh logan Venable. Mad son, s,anard, Hoi,
iaaay' Mercer Hoane, W. p Taylor, Morris, Garrett
j. Harbour, Scott, Green, T.. MARSHALL, Tazewelb
Loyal Pren'is, Grigsby, w Campbell, Clayton Branch.
Townes CaheI, Martin P'easans, Gordon, rlempsons'
MSss'c, Bates, Neae, Rose, Coaltcr, Joynes n, IT,
Perrin SIS. D@'S,
mir Stuart said nc could not vote for The proposh
ton nnlcss the basis which it was founded was 10.
CARED ana he moved to amend The rcsou ion by de-
ri rIDr trQnt- !, it,,
tercsls OF the slave holding country GRO Tire same
whv not IN aFportoDing litigation anong the courr
tics OF the same district, adopt Il rule of white pop
s'ract the righrulc? (br. Randolph exclaimed tb.b
he had never admitted it Mr.. Siua.t snswerod tluk
be had not intended to include him