Constitutional Whig. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1824-1832, 1828-09-24
From 1f4 .Iotorqj M!.,.gs,7,...
COMMUNICATION.

f.sTHA
upon the occasion of his announcing lis int.nen u
re[ring 1ron the Presidency nj tl.c United States
hAvfflg " my possession book, en,i5l,.d The
Iiercai senator; or, copious and iInl,llli H.pog
OF the Jebates in the Congress OF the United Sai1c
duriLg the Second Session of the Fourth Cu,rrcss
by Thomas Carpenter | was Induced to rZa,nip,
IL Tor the purpose OF possessing myself OF the r,so
OF those WHO opposed and voted against that address
among those who so voted Is the name OF hHpRl.w
'AChsoN' VINO Is now cunddute for the Presidency
OF the Cuitcd States. 1t does not upr.ar mat tnna
n Jackson delivered his sentiments the subject
bilt Well rocui!cct that, soIe time dun iUr The nrs,ut
summer, Mr.. Senator EAro> addressed et4a, ,,
Governor GILES and hpw ARD LIVINGSTON who zyer.,
ALSO members OF Congress at the SINE skig vi them
e reasons log opposing the adoption OF thai alreHs
a'h shat ne published their answers il the uapar.; :
CONTINUING The reasons which influenced the t,ir5;. ii
fceTat 9dciisnr on the qucs ,--tus ayuIl!lIr
'l' hne'r sentiments were those lenaral J;teAS3li
ana expressing Willingness 10 abide by inc same.
olon examining the volume, the title OF whici, I
nave given, ind that on the t;Ir Dec 1886 PACE.
70, Nh Giles says, lac really wished tie uGs,,ss re-
connitfed is thcre were m7ny oisctioaa5|e d5ls III
Again, page 10, Mr.. Giles say, "It, ysied T., ,c4
US respectful TO the President as any gentleman b,t
ne "nSer"ed many parts in his [thc President 81
ihhTcsS, winch we're objectionable. Je j; 97.niarai
an" n'e'02!'9 IN as, SAYS Mr. Giles, 10 ry7,;t il;
our superior happiness. light CT wisdom Il IS MOI
as all necessary that we soui e1cu IN ,rr atlyapfa
gt"i and thus reflect the unhapiv situation al
nhtons IN tIeir tFoubes; t is Insulting to iTen Il
thut We slio!ild eroy !iapp:cs; but les Us not
hoast ct IL 70 I'll the world. rs 70 Hose oaJfs Of N,
.6LreS 'etch SPEAK Of tie lcSoOfe ah fnesy e,Lae
Fr%ienf' he mast oiert 10 thcn. On refcction he
could see want Of wisdom und ;iinegs III the A.l-
tlstIatiH for the last six years. Ilav be sinu1Iar
'n my ideas, said he, but Ihejere tta. orr llnnfsi
t'oo hos BEEN neittef rise nor 7iz9. L beliets sir
,oaot y ''l'd"n1 an Inrne&s has J|oHghtMis couarrl
INTO me present dt7aig Situtti0d. live 5aea yicy
OF our foreign relations we shall see no reasn, "a
est IN the wisdom iifnl,ess ofup ion
Noshng so hl'tch as want OF Wisdom and trulsess
has brought the critical ,aton i, which .,-
'new stand 1 must acknowledge that an one 6j
those apho do mt think n,rE If he pilsiant -
Others do aoisb hin 10 retire and ftat {fg 3ro y,
'@"ment Y ms retirement. He Thoughts tie Govern
'Lnent could 60 very wei Without him s}tro,T,T
much had been said, and that by seazy nsooie an,
his intended retirement, yet he llt ro aiic,1S,ttJL
SnSot'o1' o5oia it-lc was Periccty easy in oresDn
'of The event" - -
However these sentiments NAV nsf,,;sE, Ito l,ao-.
ut the present time they Of small account in no
itlca! view, when compared with those which foI,-w.
=, hms' make some observations (sitI &Ir. CsIxEs
on me last paragraph, hut one. ose address, ltcr.
we cali ourselves the frcest aud most emil htcncdn ma
ton in The world. Indeed the whole OF fIst rIars
Graph Is objectionable. dsappToyc the whole oft
II am free II am happy, if enlightened more
,thah others wish not 70 proclaim It on the loa!sf
top. y 'cf HFaffec, 1T IS not PRUDENT 70 rr-cI rs
!y II enlightened, inJt tlr d;a al tbs fE2Dc :,
riinPesit - the Worid-lI No LEGISLATIVE: t-,I-
Germ
--- I'''~ III itON Ni respect TO tf;CGn
El'Rt5 Is 20 ask, what would nov be thought o. :
member Of Congress who should ris in his NJ, W, ~;
say, thai the tree dom, the happiness, and tc c,
enimg oil the People, arc no legislative Concern:
That DIR. Giles was extremely avCtrse that sn -
ample of General Washington should be foIIov,r6 h,
his successors, is apparent from What follows:
Tie says: Another expression would NOTICE : :,
the last paragraph OF the Address. Wherein It srys
thai yUU1 example p'1y be S,vidc to7o1H. s.cs
!Whosoevar he may be (said ATr. Gisj tito-e is r,
doubt he will do his duty to the best OF his ability,
From the violent and unceasing opposition t:liel
Mr.. Giles rade TO the administration Of the suaccs
sor Of General Washington, it is fair TO infer ilat
did not esteem hmselfH prophet in this jr,.1e
! The observations of bIr. Giles havry ,ivcu ,iso ,
a considerable debate, in answer TO scInciint ard =
Mr. " Smith Mr: Giles rosc, and in a short evplana
ton, observed, ''lIG HousdG Tire Prcsid.qt a. roo,
'mcT'ping sort IF n man, but 4tfcn R,is!tG'
! In subsequent par; Of tie dcbutc M Giles .,,-.
'I Is not wonderful t',ot tic Presidents pnru1,r
should be introduced into tf:e debate ,rf,a IL I'M
done but he hoped the influence Of +. -oI3 bc9e,
'gre3t Gcntemen have sud that Il w Ike out r.
the Adfressl the expressions Of our sense Of the Wis
dom and irInness of the Administration crc PES
dent, there viii be no ground TO complIrcr ri him
so [said Mr. Giles1 !, for one would not 10 wiling
7 present an address Of all lie could not consent E,
acknowledge the wisdom and iirnlnasr cr his Admin
I tTation No influence p,iGlr TEcgreo cr,.,,, ;,t.
hi5a IN oote for He .AddJess M fssi2 IT,, 5;,.i ri
nrttocc has measures. The reason wish linn fran
his present Office is from k'o,vledeo that lie viii h.
/ more happy at Mount Vernon. ] know; tie Pcoplc
can do without him. lie fhot,rht fLore wa ec6n,
enough to compliment the President, without writir,
'Scou1arcP On their oTchea9s, Ivy expressing approa
ZION 81 measures to which they were opposed
! AGAIN, says SIr, Cfcs-''Per1aos think rs h;rh-,
! 'of the People that gentleman, CTr. AYrsl dons
nut II so, Isls not becoming in rae 70 express it.
we are the most free and enlightened it does not c
come us TO make our boast Of i-ucitFey do mini
~ rtS.t 10 te" The People so. The gentleman eait
some individuals were opposed 10 tho C,nvnrn,oert
~ the Erecuttre alone rncaH5as the Government
ne thought tfGt rms CtHsuj05ie--howeve- he couI
not call nat the Government although Il was psy
>ot H. lie was sorry he said, TO find this part Of tn
Government, 1.-THE Execufivol haa a-Ir-! >. !, e.
49, clsagIsc9bi9 s..,1a ION