The enquirer. [volume] (Richmond, Va.) 1804-1815, 1805-09-06
IaleaNlsin8 IF 9rolnegi,
ON THE
IMPEACHMENT OF JUDGE CHASE.
SATURDAY, FEBRUARY 2s.
Mr.. MARTIN, in lcut;uua.;sv

IL IL
charges made agaira Judge Chaf,, as they re-.
late to Mr.. Hay. the Other courf.l for CaIen-
Ger. Mr. iiiy Unified thai TIE indictment cc,Iiid
| no' be ipppofted. becauge the title of C,,l.u
GERS publication, parts Of which were CHARGED
TO be iae''nus, was rot Inherited i'm the indi9-
meEt, to wit, beCaufc it was not GateJ in tbe
indictment that the book, which contained tb.
Lhe'ous matter, was called : The profor,st r.
| iore u. And to fipport This objection, he
went on '" prove, thar when an indictment
tates iioelI0uS writings in tenor foIoying tha
lieeiious part Of the writin, let forth. and on
winch the Indictment is found. mutt lie fet forth
verbatim ct 'iteraim ~ 1shere WIS no al
tempt to flew that AIRY exorefTion in tie ind;,a-
,ns"t, was not Rated correctly both verbally AMI
literally, as pu5liihed by Calender. TIE in.
d'ct''ient did rot charge the title OF the hook
| belng l!he.!ous. 1t did not notice the it'll. of
inc COOK m any manner. IF the title OF the
9o'k wa, q, neclhary to have been inherited wkea.
or inconciuive argument 70 iupnort the Doiti
on than that upon which Mr.. Hsy reIi ii md
the Judge ihewed great temper in mereIv exp,
ing IL 10 i1dcuie in the manner ne did, nv OBJ
f-rsinS, that as he infited the The)lous matt,
mould be ct ont z,erdniin 1T Etergt;u, h.. y.,o-
dercd M had not alio inGned II ri,oaIj ". Get
| foi!h P'C!-t~att1a. All obirryaion, by the nv,
winch perhaps contaaed foil a. p,uch of sooi
words written or printed, viii be iiabI. to DIFF
fe.ent contributions, and convey vsrv .lifc.r4rt
meanings as they are punttua,cI. NJ. !Iay,
1t appears from his "wn teitimOny, rs well as the
te!uTonv OF the other witnehcs, was guilty or
| very improper conduct to the court. lie iTfa-
cd trdt II the prfioHcr was convicted UPON that
indictment, hr might again be indicted for INK.
'ane offence, and could not defend hinfe!f 90
tine convicuoo OH the indictment then before the
couft. When the court aIured him he was
| tnItaken IN the law, Mr.. Hay Till periited and
declared that ne ihoutd mot be more furprifed,
even II Eir. Calender fhould aeair be indiStst,
for the fame offence, and fhould be puni(hed :,
(eeon6 time for he iarne offence, IN AN he was
iuipTiied at the indictment then before the court.
ana TIE attempt to nuri1 Calender IN COME
qilehce OF that indictment. What language
pray you, conid be uled 10 the court, hut in re-
atty addrefledt TO the Do0uiaCe, more derog,to-
ryto the then naturalization. as being unprin
c'piedIy oPpre!iive, or containing a mere d,reCt
ATTACK upon the integrity of the Judges, holding
them up as the 7csal fools OF the thea adminjf
prcGion
VIVA: was alfo TIE anal conaua Of .U,y.
! %hen naving repeattd y attempted 10 argue To
F'e ,ury againit the direction Of the CONT. and
71"iHk as repeatedly hcen in. erfupt.d and (too.
ped by the court RE took up his papers to
withdraw upon which the court told him. If
ne pleased ne might proceed Ills anfger was.
| qVfH mt" When the court further ob(ery
cd you will not MIR. Hay, be capnous, 20 ON
| u you pIeaie IN any manner YOU cnoDfc, and We
| "i'i not interrupt Won. Even then when n,
! my opinion, the court bad, AS in Fries's cafe,
made improper conc ions, what was MS an
! ! or 3" an not cao''ous, Int I zDU mt trs-
cesd." And he folded up bis papers aud wit >.
drew.
How cane he thus to al? Is to Calender,
NC acknowledges h. deipiftd the wretch, that
! h's O'Vttt was 70 ieryc the caufe. not Calender
How WIS tc tn ierye the cauie Dy giving an
/ inpreliion to the pubic mind. What imprec.
! ion did he wifi TO sve BY holding I'D the HE,
OF oppr-ii!On on the part Of the soyernu, n, .
/ land corruption on The part IF the court nus
/ finding himief tilus foiicd in his attrr,nf Ly
tie hyperion a'iIitisq of M honorable client and
! his hyperion knowledge Of Mankind: fnJing
! that, iritcad 81 cT.i'rg irGignation araioe ,7,v
Client, my cieut ncG fortunately hai s.,ci..d
arainit him the jaugh' e. and riiicule of The am
ditprs, he went out ~ pnfi,a. Al tLe f,us
tune ever The manner in which he laft shs rcrrt
fhewed his viii 10 impress TIE rut lic mini. ne
fli Us P0Gibe, with fcni'1ents d;fllylntsveous
70 the court. ord a. ju the rntrruotione NJ
I Hay received. th,y ave clearly proved "a ~ =,
conteGuence 81 his pcrtirscionny attsmn.ir. ~
( ACT contrary 10 thc CircctiUH az n, court. and
! 'r that cai. iht oily quofion could ne ,vhr,ter
TEE court or M,. Hay had tie como, over ,U.
! p'|cr.
! Bat, Gr, t6cre IS another CHARGE vt;cb hoo
been made agaitf roy honorable ,..,ct. .. :,.r
/ ';y TIA; part &C the article vtj.b s.,nf + ia
! II T@de'Z5 IL Is & ii that fpealiue Of Chm.