1(04-10425-10004 apn) SECRET 20 August 1985 MEMORANDUM FOR: Office of General Counsel Attention: E. Page Moffett Assistant General Counsel (U) | INFORMATION : Chief, I i iyacy Division . Attentio: U) 23 ; TO via Information Review Officer (U) FROM : Russell B. Holmes Consultant, IMS/FPLG | (QUO) SUBJECT : Document relating to ZRRIFLE (U) REFERENCES : A. Memorandum to James H. Lesar, dated 15 March 1985. Enclosure: First CIA Release to Lesar, F81-0351 (I) (U) B . Memorandum, dated 22 July 1985, from E. Page Moffett. 1. The writer of the memorandum (see reference B) states in paragraph 2 that Lesar called the former's attention to a document listed in three places in the enclosure to reference A as nos. 38, 39, and 55. Lesar claimed that much more of this document had been released previously to [Robert L.] Borosage. (U) 2. The document in question, handwritten, undated, and with the title "Project ZRRIFLE" had been released previously in sanitized form as. JFK Exhibit F-S22 in Volume IV (pages 197- 203) of the HSCA Final Report (1979). The sanitization of the copies of documents nos. 00038-02592, 00039-02638, and 00055- 03471, conformed to the previous sanitization. At the time when this sanitization was made (in late 1978 or early 1979) it was not known that the ZRRIFLE document was one of several documents (81 to be exact) that were the subject of a litiga- tion involving Robert L. Borosage and the Agency. (U) 3. To confirm the validity of Lesar's claim, the undersigned reviewed the Robert L. Borosage Case No. F75-0676. The Agency's file did indeed contain a copy of the 9-page ZRRIFLE document (number 42). .The undersigned then reviewed the computer run describing the contents of the Borosage case file. The entry for document no. 42 gives no date and no subject. It describes SECRET OFFICIAL USE ONLY - When Separated from Attachments
13-00000 SECRET the document only as a manuscript. Inasmuch as the document had been inadequately identified in the computer system, it did not turn up in response to a querry to the computer for any previous releases of the ZRRIFLE document. (U) 4. The undersigned compared the ''Borosage release'' with the document sanitized for the HSCA. There is a great deal of dif- ference, not all of it to the Agency's advantage. The sanitization of the ''Borosage release'' was done in a slipshod manner, e.g., on page 6 of the document as released to Borosage the cryptonyms . KUBARK and KUBARKER appear in paragraph 3); on page 7 the cryptonym KUTUBE appears, also the true name or pseudonym SILVERTHORNE ap- pears; on page 8 the cryptonyms KUBARK and LAURICLE appear; on page 9 see KUBARK and SILVERTHORNE, and on page 10 see true names: Sid [Gottlieb] and [Horton] Telford. To be fair, it should be . noted that Jim A's name on page 10 and COS, Luxembourg on page 4 were left in the release to the HSCA. COS, Luxembourg appears on - page 198 of volume IV of the HSCA Final Report. Jim A's name appears on page 202 of the same volume. (0U0) 5. The undersigned has. sanitized a copy of the ZRRIFLE document as it was released to Robert L. Borosage and has included any information released to the HSCA that was deleted in the Borosage release. The attached ZRRIFLE document may be passed to Lesar. (U) Russell B. Holmes Consultant SECRET
a . . iy . é a roe a +. aa ch . - Ye ws ae Len _ Ppt ZRRIFLE ee Soe Aras frrot2et 2RGELE. HF pe PSU ill | ; . | an Ene Pel AE al Ee doy tne bef ote, yh peepee alt be wpe oped A scpsenr Hii ey, os Tt tod plrarratl ee a be tS : vs Eh tt rae uw ' | ee 'y Ate Fa & ‘ : Sms : . | 7 of . e * 2p a . a . ~ a ee Oe 3. Bathrrend a venue #2 wh Sey Preyer TE
13-00000 a ied ent nose eee ater enn oe oe te ee te mT teem, a ee ee ee eT Pa Oe ee -W) nae 2 Po Ate bande war an Sean OPAL TI parte . Ze joe i Bede Oh Le. He “Septet, Con tina FF . Botan, of Dati . lad eos Bans ref lost fp wee Pe oo | ~ mpg i ~~ S w > - ae = me — a wee ee net ee ee i say ee — we te eT . > SeennemmincennteermaaeEDED
13-00000 esl eat 5 tbs eS eb ta lSEDY 1p 7 cee Pa ee Pee. fare aemetee hg aed — Es Sethe fai : AE te ao. |! eet _d. A Alb maple Oe ei ath oe erihle. atthe | ny a at ee. te A fetetts,. etapa wo i i en ve ee ee ee eee cone ee we ee I I
13-00000 in - , a. Pe Nt eR de ted . Seed cle: tow oa Sito tat . ws ise 7 LB, 1° See eect et ee St <A eet © ve es ee ee me — : |. a) Gare Bay —— Oobite Daa) al ep bthscee__ ~ | te (Cotsen Bootes ven pe ee => eeifeec mene i aL . nw ye de tie va ssoitel), sé ohh. 2. maners i Meech GES Let Bath 4 Ze ett radar Hille bow As abl Ha reat ne Siniieerann. _ _ a Se pew the arn Ageeeiees | te ice focal peri racambitiny «DE abit hecxl{ th ns “Ror ated tae comune fore Aidtbgeepinte ba. ot GUL Attn YUE a { Seated cota toce — ee vee ee cae “4 ‘eos Hage he i: aa j octeed bane - offer | ee sera m8 és iain Fol _. A thee a ff Of a 1 gf hoe we oo 4 ew : . we we ‘ : wee we
13-00000 wait dellipte ithe aa ni iH | ks oy oo US UU U tts a eet txt CC, GEE “Sigh _t, Ele Aeasle ve Lai re Pe aA bo. oe = pe NM MAD om _ | ea _ a ual ‘ aL. foe Tethey, _ wp EE a me newer oe en. Able mericlad aclohys, on _ ee | _ G ube § x pe esas. All auitude <p cargo horny JP havc > ee Spel paw Cele “4 Hors.. ee vee een ite ) Pee! Dower Oe ce punouel a ool libe. ee ee i a oo. gs. Eh cae Ly oe a | oP! bona debit be Adee, "Loli bek Les . 4 OF bos fat ann . a" a ome soa . we ee ee ee ee ee eet ee fe uf venue - oth ae ee _ on pat Te - oe Ve ~~ o~ soe at . i a i : . =: vt a a
13-00000 os Bee rerlorel + Hh Leck merle probit, | | os j y bt Leek. tno la. ae Anes Tlie » Muto . outs Ce. g y. Le Caste, el). ho 7 ae buy prussadater~ ved oe Aa I u . New” t, j j ao hse See Mp eticobisby tee \ _ if ‘ —t. he ee Atnettine,_ N paerat oleae 2. hee, bing . Mackeedl,. ee aeliztic . pre Aone Eis, --—.- 4 Lostd afm of fox A ae vo wat atl at? fork ba Hon ealent i 4 e flee hal Pacts rs eer. can ma =? es ~-e os - a rs { : sot a eo: : io ‘ ic ¢ : pony nae ta wwe ee, ‘ i.
13-00000 : o a te a ¥ , . = | ——— oe = ee er. » t EDO pa oR. pa — pe of es a ; i | ——-. ! cee eee ae ce nie e ee cece ee ene ee | i Po. _ - : es i meee oe eo _ a _ a : i : if 7 — fe ee a ne ee a wee ee : i en ee —_ - - Cot
13-00000 - — Mig iy \ 8 Cog lowe pee re S500 pono OTB ee . Pt. fof Med ge. ey. ZO ged: RR NOECTON otras 5 TOL: oo eGtiyEiiaage Gd fibaes. AS A nd im rad. Lave, ee 7 filS_ Caaetr HE, _ i elt,» oe A GAAL: Loa nn CA 7 ES f i Cre Ataece/ ~ oo. i ceo 1 Were i SRE aT ny ; Se aie ne J bo _ 7 we me = a ~ cod - ° C2 —_—— a ae
13-00000 a a 3 Ay aperttef oh aeuewadk wetoe, ota, Be Vnstel Let, AA pemnbs oe a patil t eet fontaine: eta ws Oe foal nk, Chsadtie sho. ps “4 a” we Lo tlech Za bench tA PAZ hve oe “a cael ao : | , / af f, ¢ earns nent A CAR Anne Lol on Te & be farinn. el wud Se, é “t ¢ “) tetas . “ 2 be? fi E ” . i ee eee be ee Oe ad i . Lied ft Loewe ep Mai: AN es ert a toe BO AA ee is rad ‘ - ; a : ft . a i on Fa ce mo fe othe MpemeTnmal Pa (Per someone bute Pa Fame Pa Cote fos ot aa ba? anu cone Vinton D ana I TEE. Agen 7 ep Por i 7 . 8 ~ s “, ; & aah tt re aie wie Bak ue Peele tel | 7. os vn coe - Fe hk DO 2238 er
13-00000 i Di 5 had ih ~ Misc ji in | | | | j a7 : a ke afte ck saae Loonie, esta 2 eutiah set, SO A eet ed, eh MIA ts franciintet Yip titintnct, Caeed taeda on aon teaduet Wh ts, alt. Whe fk sai satz __ 7 la st ———— ie. ~- ak Et eee oe cote be xe petuial peek sail Hy ee Van ee i i aa, VG he ee, Lt teh ETE | fe Bund htt AT ,- Cetowp OMB ses T be one oe Le Map Abert el Fi FT Math AZZ). tt ! “ye —_——_--- . if ; roe Li ty dni Patan tan, Athatl, of bes it a eo nae | oe | | LU PG 7 none Ci
13-00000 a arya vis . este oil tot LED + 2. DOO = Pre a | ae an pha Cone eet a. 2 i a i ee otk were ee ce he N.S PO fh SP ee ee ee ee | i Hea ¢ fe I colulnune, tmobile a 1 _--~.—.. fe ce ne —_ - pad lb pectin Vol Lethal Bote ly FIO ee ~ ae wee ee ee la if Ar fey nme ee a ee em ee ee i — Oi Dit HIE fu) od ee ---— “te —— - a ee ee _ mec eee a ee ere ne _ i" —_ ~ — _ ewe ee. eee — — ~ 7 af arom — rr : | SERRET _ oo oe oP 2 s on
13-00000 | | d a Bthcahp more, perme ihjvel frblresy pettl nies Af ethyhy ee me 2) lie sea edpsctsach et (exaah) le Mat 224): ae ok. Lepletinacta. 4 _allk hb (Coen, Becdere.provisy Malbler ) > Hone meet i a ) fone soap, wt, w ALL, ed opie. efPbeere. (four an este) hehe. 72 ar _ —_ Ativch ee Ae pl teed, fat sor Fosoihdicn top ba _ 7 As -Aecathee a 5 Be pa auiens 7 ——___ sles joe 28tr Ein en Tysct hy 3 foes wall | & = OUNE-fndn eerie (\ Copp, } cota beoce wth fr of \ a teint (mien Pts) once. Ivonl el putith y Ze a ani Lilac, ope, ay Oe AG ae cor loritinet hf ih id hee fix, a ws Sepmed exter, pred Cane ~ of fecrn t it F Hoi ~&p ofoe (i ns . Dae eee eee ee me meee ee eee Ae cme ee a ee ce meee we ete ees beet oe webs eee ee de beternet, ww othescrbe al foresu_ __... : EN SMM moe int * a fu) yy : ms — a ape - se iy ys it me LibAr: ae Oe bigt ay wet , ve we ae Co ba ses Ee { ALA, oer reenter . . . hep al i , - ota # mye : . : . ~ Uo el ihe e
13-00000 te bot: I a blo Po eS Aaa, BLD, nel § Lage , As te | Berd apes. Cte Nw eval . ; ee pepe: thee Cy ob bods | o Ss PPR dG 7 7 _& he ek a peal | GET 4 ek ies ROR aye a Lo oe _ oie é LNT Ein) — belie 0 Mat val there . ad , Hl ae heen esl. pon Cree ce af Moor. —_ (pronto ter eaeenad } ok fellperincs, | eae Ack ees Ag att are Oe peteceuee pervek a feeecche hte ae 8 Ute mabey whe Aer rrcwny Leatt df crea premix ll pot te Greet op petal Or cee fest AD peck <html, wt Li 2. * 4, eral oan MA joey 26) ARK Z > Ip bachitif i, Ze ee ee 22 ohh. ee — frit HEE, aft Fe ae be cee eee ee ne _ yi ed SEG REF a a | - 7 is
13-00000 » 3 * mye tb ee 2) , fF tA 2 _ “base fort. Site le Bowe}: __.. f¥ nag Ara ar ~ ved wil, 7 C2tg— sibteen FA. _. 2 {i itt th. | t i ae = paces | PME cc, peed oa spe | a Deer ert ! a ee beneen ay Hoof ste a Leeted | i . Ae ~ . 7 Gh a ¢ it linnet ote, ~ ae . be Avs Pete Lary pede te, Abtbyel iisuf 2 Opti? | _ az ee bling. Machel, oe eek __. qe Goat - eobohe en Aout Ln nts , ee i ; 7) anid Aicctemtega wy) 7p frien cama fe sit te Pottiley iis 44 SA Dre ht Sele ety ib abe f * Spin Th te if Piri -- HH ~ -- - --- mrt er mee ee ae } rt € a hte. well prelude for’ a dt $e Ane ee a ee . ° ae . Semetmmmasemmsaed a ' tua v a athe
13-00000 ana. ee nn ee pinion Wye Me ee ULE a a a in 4 - - — _ — we emer | ene ce a ae _.. ee a Be Hi fi Re i oe _ a { SSA) tf RE PROS OTION li; ~~ PRG A QT ER ———= ii ite te mone ee ae en eee iis ‘lie L a ) cre ee meee me ee ee tee ee a ean ee ee wee ee som nee cee cee ee eee ee ee ty sme te es | eee ee oo agen RO OOS Ee ee ee —_ ee _ —~ ee oe ~ _ ~ qf: - feo meee - — - —— ih Series meee cee ~ nine i Sebicl if a a eee ee ee a cee ee ee |
13-00000 | on Te an he Fecspon pRasiire a | CAAA Ma Raa Perez, > 1218 ted eat Cn Agttritte lon Ae : « i) = 7 See 5 Ee Baw As 8. ee - : i Yup: Reta - ~ faheg — —~ 2 aa p ee oo we ae : ar : om; - = . PLi7 tke Gs an PaAsn . c:
13-00000 Faget ew he he aps ee “Ox fae: Sa les HM 500. fase. ALE a _ Muth pt fief Angpecet ete!” Zo oe _ vip mn relat a ee : a i i ee eee ES ENE EN ne ate tenee tte — = eee EER — a an if - = eM BTA) a — me TU ii ie 7 ls - COPY RG. ____-_—__—
s - F . e a) . . a i : : ; te aot re) AN f i wae sos . ‘ * i “} . Nee eet ae a . Ce _ ‘ votes oe : e . - Nassar" ala + HL: yh Ae hae ee ree aie A se Le tahastl tae Pel, WE ooh {eer ht, (Ponte, Yk profi wit ds Le asl 2 apainaY Wh oA toes _ eae tod mM. Oo pn hah i eit ny a XD = bepito tA 07 ae Aig, +8. ss and — uh . f a ’ “ 4 ao: fo = ~ 4 " Ae wt 4 Oo . “= ae “ | | a WEP we i DUST. Copp quae re oy woe ge es nied Bee PIR IB ——— | . iF mand a me . . - - , os _— ane . s. ate | 4. ° _ ~4 Ont fans’ wets Oak, _— ag at Ot ee cnet ~ rocrtesaae aa ee ih 77 7 t oer ee me ~ a marten on tem eS a ee we benersd > ba . . DO C4628 Welle
13-00000 , ee lets Pelle ngeBind | Fovw. mar: . 5 2 Ot? -— oe | we ere re ee aes eee ee nN LY Ge A me = nd An _— - ta : Laeved eff : Eff soph tne. o . | _s ak te Polls 07" oY Jo Be eefibpuere, atte, . “ned. etl, ‘cand aoe noe ty EO —_ - — ee a SOE He aan a ee } LE HoT , i u RG HG } | i I ee __& Ul Ly) metal -|} ec eee eee eee EF cre sere eens mene eee mere ernie ter RE Rk te: ee RT ERENCES Peer er ER OR EEE SS 6 SER 9 SEY COTE _ y i a i vee tee me ee ee we ene ee ero ~- pe ee ae err ~ ti . SEI Joa mi __ _ ow __ - q 6” Lot
13-00000 --— Dy) Jaf athial> var tl, pemiel pn enrea' ) tel apne Ath a a AU oe . __ | a) « Ghar erin sputvice. (Aughrh) Get 202). ae, up Leticte ; —+f fie (Gon pant prey Meller an ae il — a ah _ 4s if __ nt ae Atunputy Da) nnn ———— _ | ashe 0 om pW ed diem net es | nee bawe Ds a far Tres We WO haw agveciees a L _ Aa His 2 real p rot ratuilny Dee ofiialh, sbescxl ? we ee ef oe Mae, she te (areata battle Comanmee L Arpegeegie: : ellen euby ¢ reer pitti wm Haast; y poreilidils, _— wt GUL -frtn Bere (é Capp pe] cottage! hace wcll _brncem (pe ttt) Coney hod g oh wusilh f ew bachfbse, nt Fee oe | nai fore kel) © ae att th, pe mnilspmedearter, 5 prtpid coer ~ off | | ~~ _ hae it on mesh kd OT ok a Gin A HE fs} Tr (0:5. t 4 ar f hf i Bf aL. Br ~ Yow’ ‘ : J oe ' PTT Tee oe _- ~_ awe * ew — +. ne ~ . , “* be les L, as 6% gone \ as . -- - -
13-00000 3) ei Grae fe : ne oti] Ie ify eeriy U fest " Z Lhe D) (hae He, é _ - pfehedes ae het As ae Hoo as Mom as het ~ si ne acleteer | NE _ Porton, Avuhitin of ° oe ee ee es a L Hey He “ieee. he bechade. roped: wile ye 2S ee accent ee db, Acc stballg poss Po ae wiatas en t. #6 Hore esstslued ar lsheos ae _S& Gur s pe iy ahrkl enh, pretense hos | Cee —. Lorie sastittely ie followin, fects. oN Foe nec nce peel & a poecclilite ,_ wf Le meld mbe Bae mewn helt nf rreineisba, re ll pool Lee Gomare of pele. on epee PertD peck ae. wn Btaucl, wet AG MP. a a, Ahsul nh As ou 24) AL Po baschipp Wh Py Le) ow oe ee £ ne ' 60.
13-00000 s} Tete tee Ge av eemeoe afi | (i ; wee eH __avelst ane Dobe os font ves Cj fl oo | pom aay tenia? co ee i 42 ti * nabhrtctee_f iene ov asthe Apart, ape Yar. a ra “a * Z ee chp heer tls... ne a a \ f fs ; ” f ~ A ~ ———. aa Ae dee cee iin ARR ad agape f | i i Ne v N i . m ek fe ay q a _ H hei Coe Cocke Pr SENE if & be ide, hea h He ae ee tte bee ceo cece ment wens ewe i 4 bei nn ipa Orel, Tow ae Le Tet cerel a7. f es i E i Ad. ed on ee : Le ate ei Taed — ee ~~ Vs , Q / O es a =~ PO gemmegmnmentare
13-00000 \ 24) Crticee retqremindels Leck! ered Lose 0 teade ADecotas oe ase = tener steemerener erewrneegrnerree a veers mo _ + — _ | a > ; ne ; | ; j ' | LS Ped | | ovwumegunenacle | =F=. | I ! | | | | ! i 1 { l | i i "> Re egopergy ! Saree ae cme RO age EI ee PM al ee: 1c UT ES I CE ee —— ee es ee - i ve _- - mene me eee ee we eee ee ee _ Ce
13-00000 ( | ed oh pt aes: Ak. Prasat ite TSO OTE 5 ner em —wie Os Cornea 41N7 — 9: Ce ) bacateuetes Coser Asi UCT z/ Wildl C— Fanfan tL fil Aare ~ ao a Jo RGR TER —— Ao. fe — Vie WAAtitde Peed hire, Fabali” 7 “ Canin Ch Anite Ox. ot “ ng td iY oA elias Muy
13-00000 e aly a one: , “oN. . ae H 7 Yo thy Cee te PN uyeyee CIPD 7 etn ce _ “Dp | Hetty __ {5002 ane OIE _ Pht fff hoe geen ete an a os Z Sa ab TB as = a way _ LS. Br. Chef" - — inal Aor. Set _ CALI eee rs VAdr4 (At __. a ane . Cre 7” ze nee/ 5 ae i 2 eee ere ee 2 ae Sem emer ec eee See cet Rete ORR © ee — REPREWETIEN—-—--——- : i : PROGR ny fp Pit SOME ___. — me oo _ - -. = ,- PG Se eens enemereimne COPY RO. J