(404-10172-10292 “* vel Pu Ps Shih J Pg re ret tre et a ne am on ce ct ee eo anne oe ee > ROUTING AND RECORD SHEET e — corr . ; SADTE |e the ebepene of comment gr anda atnan of agape . - Lo fagen The cover sheet of be devtrered whan othe R 1o/ ; Soc yuemes 9 Fdod, . He - RYAN | . COMMENTS : “we ark : ict > FRET q 10 orn — a Seestss MIC ROFILMELD he URN Hie) Ch. . i aaa? sae , * Use Only iif: DOC. MCR. SF 9-13: Ido not feel that Costille'g explanation of meeting arrangements with . 5 makes them any more secure than wd. 2 ad guessed His apartment, his car, jin the quiet of the evoning! Para 7 of dof stil) obtains = RIS could have become] «3 4 oe aware of their meetings & the clandestine : || nature of tha meetings, Also, I question . the security of dropping her off at tHe ¢.e 12.0 ; bus stop nearest her apartment. If thd RIS , . ; has seen any of these contacts, the very : i meeting arrangements would serve to cdn=i4 f ‘ firm[afs as an ascent of Costille = no normal 2 13. aL CE i Aff Mp boy-girfPelationship, i? a social ond, £-/ i oA ‘would go to these lengths unless ther¢ &é 14. | was a spouse in the background; it wold , therefore have to be clandestine, 16, - va Cnr os, able Y ° dee ; ; ’ TEC eee més 7 | Custer as SS fp tr o, a Ce ue Lif 3° | PE] | ace ert: waded, ay Ch a ne ee Sn See Sa e 2° RIO/FE / Ye00U | Oy he Song ae Cer ‘ : @ hak eae a apereact at | fuse di woRe . , ate we. fan? 5 BEES a COR wee Cat eae N! eueeeE a be : gs pL [grnfoss (
7400000 Chief, BO /C? (u-f _Chief of Station 9 October 1959 Cre re oe Or eT 9h _ REDCAP 0% Erna, | MICROP I Lire UP eaters Se morens Costi Lle-AEPAMNLE/5-Golub‘Ccntakt £86 Vise [| ise SS ans Rta BEES a cael ad ™ eee _ a hu5 TEI To feeb ne merece gas on HOG. MICO. FT (orniz2937, a4 Septeaber 1959 1. Reference dispatch has just been received, and we would Like to bring you up to date on the above felationships - . 4 @. Pollow up tol biz During the evening of 4 September, | Golub did not mention his’ previous proposal to have Subject of DIR | 42521 teach Soviet diplomata English. Subjigct on one occasion atated that she was planning to teach English on Finnieh TY and ; that it looked as if she would have a busy season teaching, Golub | did mot pick this up, and the subject was not returned to, The entire evening was quite uneventful, and it was spent talicing about susie. (The Subject of 4IR 42521 will be dealt with by separate dispatch.) Since that evening Golub has only phoned Costille once and this was on @ business matter. Two Americans were in the Soviet Consulate at the time and were applying for Soviet vieas thru Golub, They. had pre= viously been in the American Consulate inquiring about the posaibllity _ Of obtaining a Soviet visa in one or two days. Costille advised thea ' to go directly to Golub and make their request, which they did. Golub phoned Coatille to state that he would give them their visas as soon aa they made advance Intourist reservations, When they did this, Golub immediately gave thea the visas.. Golub's and Costille's pathe crossed once again on 15 September during a Consular Corpe lunch. Thig was a fairly large gathering and Golub and Costille did not have much opportunity to talk, However, Costille gave Golub two tickets to the forthcoming Leonard Bernstein concert in Helsinki, as Golub had previously mentioned to Costille how much he wanted to go. Golub appeared to be quite grate- ful for the tickets, and then stated he wanted Costille and Subject of DIR 42521 to come back to his apartment soon to hear some more good music, Mr. Johanan Bein of the Israeli was standing near by, and Golub extended the invitation to him and wife also. No date was set, However, ‘from 4 September to the present, Colub has not phoned Costille for lunch, which is a new record for him, as heretofore he has called at least once a week, He has either been too busy, his interest is waning as far as _ Gostille is concerned, or he io, as Headquarters suggests, planning to “ttn Cestille over to someone else, ; : : be Costdlle contact with Viktor ZEAL‘; If Golub ds. planning to turn Costille over to someone else, Zegal seeas to be the most obvious. Zegal has had every. onportunity to date to start the contact, but he has not picked up the ball yet. As we have mentioned previously, - ‘Costille met Zegal first at the latter's informal cocktat) party. How= ever, the invitation came through Golub. Zegal was friendly to Costille but not any sore so than to the others at the party, At the second: neoting, a Soviet Dabasay sponsored informal reception for the American _ Babassy, Zegal was again polite to Costille but showed no undue interest: in him. On 7 September, both Zegal and Costille happened to be at the Same sauna party given by a member of the Netherlands! Rabassy. During this party the conversation turned to music, and Zegal mentioned that he had a large American record collection but that records in Finland were | too expenaive to buy, He asked Costille where he ordered his records and if Costille would mind ordering some for him. Costille said he would be glad to. egal happened to be at a small luncheon on 10 September given again by a meaber of the Netherland's Habassy. At this time Costille loaned Zegal two record catalogues from which he could make hie selections, Costille has heard nothing to date from Zegal on this, rk,
eee are sae #5 tart . Ae eee eeemenet Hae Sermatech ett “ite cee eels te CONTINUATASN OF : . + OM$PATCH ona 6 Golkd's possible departure from Helsinki: At the Consular Corps lunchecn on 15 September, Golub once again mentioned to Costille that he would like to be assigned to New York City and even hinted that he hac been offered the job as Consul at the Soviet Consulate in Kew Tork City. It 4s known that Golub is stugying English in Helsinkd from a qualified Husstan-imglish language teacher. He also mentioned that if assigned to the unitea otates, he would be given intensive language training in Moscow. Costille aleo asked him if his wife had returned from Kescow as yet, He waved his hand as if in disgust and stated that it was a pity but she was never coming back, This ®estrarnceent® froa his wife has never quite rung true to either Ceatille . QNor tofAhpsS. She'has never liked the climate in Finland and has been rather sickly ever since she has been here. It may be that she is merely waiting for Golub's return to &M w rather than move back to Helsinki, Golub has also mentioned to’ OSS, te New York and has hinted at fis being in XK scow by December. O2 - d. Golub contacts wen Ys » Foye has bevin seeing [AK/5 about once a week for their language lesson? 5 49 learning Russian, and Golub English, (Golub also has a professional English teacher.) During these - sessions Golub has not once returned to his‘ conversations of 2 Gus in which he derided dAmericans.or has he made lications that (axys on. - might be reporting on her contacts with him? date the pressure seems to be off and that Golub has never raised his euspicions concerning her knowledge of Costille or the fagt that the American Bubsssy had become aware of Golub!s contact with (AE) 5 PZGelub!s comiuct veh § has still been above reproach and not one romantic — overture has been made, Although they still discuss politics, art and music, Golub r@ubdy has made an effort to keep away from extremely con= troversial topics and has refrained from making his usual derogatory. comments about capitalies and the.U. S. when the relationship first began, he did not tyes to bring up these subjects, den A and his wife, who, are SySte rocamate here ago, Golub. invited tars and good frienie of Pe rem Stanford) nivaresty FAB) 5¢g roommate {Iden B}, Zegal.and Nikolay Makeyev or a social evening in Golub's apartment, Gol setime has wanted to meet Iden A, who is the son of a tumusl Loverment efficial now 1i the States, Iden A is here doing research on his father's effect See. The evening was spent in polite conversation, oo drinking and 2, As far as contact: between Costi lle and (A Gas is concerned, it has been kept at a miniaum since her REDSKIN trip and she reported that she had met Golub. There are no regularly scheduled meetings, the date and time of the Throughout + the summer, next meeting being arranged at each previous meeting. meetings have been held about one in every three or four. weeks. . They have been arranged on different rights of the week, On these meetings 5 comes alone to Costille's apartment after 2000 hours, She takes a bus from the University, reich ts in the central pert of Helsinki, to Cestilie's, which — da in a northern suburb SUQEys also lives in the same suburb about 2 kilemeters. from Costille, She, therefore, would take the same bua to Costille's as she would to her own apartment but would get off two stops later, After the meetings, which usually last until about 2400 hours, Costille drives her to the bus stop nogrest her apartacnt, At no or nea {az)5's. For emergency contactlQgEys has been instructed to phone - Costille at hie apartment from a public phone booth mentioning that she has After the - missed him, She never once has. identified cherself on the phone. phone call, she has croceeded to a pre-designated spot in the same suburban area where *costille meets her with his car. ef town. She is dropped off in the same suburban area. The meetings have usually lasted approximately 30 minutes. No surveillance has ever been de~ tected, This has culy been done three or four times. The same procedure is used when Costille wants to s 45 before the next scheduled meeting. Costille has only ‘phone ©}5 twice, and this was in late May during the . REDGKIN debriefings. fa 5 has been with Costille overtly only three tines Ge a rn rn re corner ee oe nent ee yates AC RE 5 EN sete . CAND e Cae | ‘ . @ possibility of his going: 5 etated that since thie About three weeks Costille has never been to her apartment, @ has any untisusl activity been noted outside of Costille's apartment They then preceed to the outskirts
14-00000 me eee boes Sieiines CONTINUATION OF DISPATCH : : ‘(onal 4132 i enn ne ee bt ee cr NN te tte oe mee Oz 94 / gince 5 appt in Pinlard last JU Ganuary,] The first occesion wae in Maren at Eh/3"a apartment. Thie was“the first time Costille net gue Gat roomng ie (another Fulbrighter), and two Finnish students were there (Subject OT (OFHA) 3811, Para 2, line 2; and,Subject of OFHA 3914), The next time was in April wher Costille took § out to dinner and recruited her for the REDSKIN trip. The third time was at a large American kabagsy reception in September for exchange students. Costille talked with 3 for about 5 minutes theres . oa G2 35°2This bringe us to the iesue of Golub’s motives and Sentions. reo garding |AE/5. By Golub's actions on 23 July, reported in (OFHA (4032, 1% seened that he was on the way to a recruitment pitch. However, since that date he has- eased off the. derogatory comments about, ericans completely and seems to be satisfied in his meetings with Aagys discuseing art, susie and non-controversial political topics. If he had any suspicions about/AE/§ z before 23 July, he has not raised thea since in his conversations with hers o lub must realize by. this time that an out-and-out cold recruitment pitch | ‘te AE/5 would be futile, Bven though liberal minded;“A5/5 in their discussions oN been oritical of the Soviet system and has strentiously defended capitaliem, If he is atteapting te get her involved in @ romantic relationship whereby he could exercise some emotional control, he has moved very slowly. As we - have stressed before, he has not made ‘one romantic overture to her. If he did, he would be moet definitely rebuffed. We do not want to turn this inte a "Dear Abby® letter, but feel that Golub may be suffering from a father complex. Golub and his wife have been unable to have children, and he has mentioned that he would desperately like to. Whenever he talke about this he becomes noticeably distressed. Golub appears to be attracted to younger people, This was the case with his former assistant in the Soviet fA Consulate here, Mikhail Lyubimov, who was a young, intelligent, cultured i Soviet. Golub frequently refers to Lyubimov mentioning how much he liked 2 = him, what friends they were, und how much he misses him, Golub's attraction EY5 started when Lyubimov left. So given what we know about Golub's personality, we do not think it too strange that he "likes her for v2 her mind." We admit. that if Golub had the opportunity he would certainly 4 attempt a recruitment or some other!form of enbarrassment; but we alan believe (iS that his feelings are auch toward(AEY5 that he would continue seaing |AE/5o > long after his operational. interest had ‘died dom, We have not. forgot ten the fact that Goltb’is a shrewd intelligence operator. From the outset of Oe the AE/‘5~Golub contact, we instructed her to use extreme caution, that Golub re than a Coneul, and that behind this friendly and gregarious nature, there was @ calculating, diabolical individual, and that she should at all - eosts avoid letting herself be put in the position where she would be suse ceptible to any form of blackmail, She was told that above all she should do nothing to indicate to Golub any contact with any American official. Because of this we have refrained from givi Res eny "requirenents® to elicit from Golub believing that personality data would just come out naturally. wWe have never give 4 f§ any canned responses to political questions that Golub might raise feeling that she was clever and well-read enough to answer. on her own, We did not want to give Golub any impression 4 that she was | being briefed on what to say and to ask. 5 ' ao) , 4e In anawer to para 3 of reference, Costille has never been an to fave apartment and has never met her roommate, Identity B. Identity B was az exchange student in the United States during the 1957=58 academic year. Althouglt@{Azy5 did net know the ys mane before, the arrangements for sharing the apartment ‘were made befor cae Fl Stanreed AB/5 in the fali of 1958 met another Finnish exchange a adent (Stanford Mo was a friend of { Identity B and. pa (ac § dm touch with Identity B, Identity B did not meet Golub until the evening des¢ribed in para l.d. above? AES ‘stated that f ' Iden B is very antieRussian as she was born in what is now Sowiet Karelia aod was forced to leave her home during the war. She has te vary iy that if mr she was ever seen out in the company of 4 Soviet she would automatically lcee >z many of her Finnieh friends. She has often cautionsd (Any 5 about being seen s, out in the company of a Soviet dipleaat too much. Identity B was extrenely x reluctant to attend the social function in Golub's apartment, but finally ce ernie meen po eee ee qeesen 1 OB Me a nt meee vay 2 eee Piste
14-80000 ' perhapa it would be better for 5 to continue seeing Golub, as leng as he ‘she will have more of an excuse to slow dou hen ‘contact with Golub. OSPATCH oo | i Gras : | i. consented to go when she heard other Americans were going to be there. She adaitted that she was curious to meet Golub aleo. There are no Station) or HBFINCH traces on Identity Be il-j & We asree with Heac.ucctera that we do not have much te be gained frog the continuation of thie contact. Our dossier is pretty well A Lied with bio data on Golub as it is, and if he wishes to defect, which we doubt considerably, he won't need her help. However, we feel that to have (x5, completely pull a reversal and stop the contact would only arouse his suspicions that she may be receiving instructions from some outside: source. Since Golub now has stopped his original provocative tone towfd (AEJ§ and the Soviet interest in Costille has slowed dow, at least for the present, does the inviting, until she leaves Heleinki, (Her stipend runs out in January.) Since school is in full swing her free time will be limited, and ) Culley! Gap 8 Willie Costille - Distribution gfe streces | Le ri [AW , 3rewSR w/Idens u.sede 2 a8eS8e 2 . so seeemaeneneneneannasnneenanneattanantn aemmenenaee vd Mies ES eee C Ath aOR SPSL EL Cay ‘ om ComteeeD $F 2 ode om FO Mee AE CO NEE
14-00000 *COKMNUATION OF i . errr rer 5 OPATcH fu IOM-TITY a: (Katert' J. ROLS 1) w FOB nford, California Ages 24 Barri ob Sen of (Rudolph Holsts} Pinsdish | m4 TURETITY Bs (Gisko “Se aA tarjata Sindls bop: (26/12/27)= Senickina, Karelia; . MICRO. Nene addraees 9-8 Stanford Village) oo. f AUG 2 ¢ 1079 ; ‘ e ‘ i , / ae | e foes AE O8t ORS ED HDD Cua AN 4 toe ] cere) BPP al Ft 8 Tew, 308 0 me ano oe Son: eee Ste.